Sheet Metal Example
Transcript of Sheet Metal Example
-
7/27/2019 Sheet Metal Example
1/16
Creating sheet metal parts for your beam in SolidWorksWhat follows is an example of how to build and analyse a simple sheet metal beam in SolidWorks.
Your structure will be longer and more complex, but this example should give you a good idea of
how to go about using SolidWorks to help you in your design. Remember, only use SolidWorks if you
are going to use it dont just draw pictures for the sake of it! There are excellent tutorials in
SolidWorks on sheet metal, finite element analysis, spot welds, etc. and you may want to consult
these too. You cannot use the COSMOS optimizer for shell meshes, which are used below. If you
want to use the optimizer, which is not available in your home version of SolidWorks, you will need
to use a solid mesh. An example optimization is included at the end of this document.
A basic folded sheet part
Select Base flange and sketch sheet metal shape:
Exit sketch and define thickness:
-
7/27/2019 Sheet Metal Example
2/16
Select Edge flange. Note Trim side bends is selected and radius is set to 3mm (naturally, this will
depend on how you intend to bend the sheet):
Add two more flanges:
-
7/27/2019 Sheet Metal Example
3/16
Note how the final flange overlaps the first two, and is offset by 0.1mm so that SolidWorks does not
unite the overlap with the other flange:
Select Flat pattern Unsuppress and Suppress to toggle between a template for the sheet
metal and the formed part:
-
7/27/2019 Sheet Metal Example
4/16
Analysing an assembly
Create a new assembly and add this part and the mounting plate. Use the Mate tool to position
the parts. Here I am positioning the two joining face such that they are parallel and very close
together, but not touching (0.1mm).
Further Mates position the part relative to the mounting plate:
-
7/27/2019 Sheet Metal Example
5/16
We need to spot weld the part together and to the mounting plate. The welds will be positioned
using reference points (add as many as you think you will need):
-
7/27/2019 Sheet Metal Example
6/16
Setting up the COSMOSWorks analysis
Things get a bit more tricky now! We need to define what type of analysis we want and what
conditions the beam is under. To begin with, open up a new Study in COSMOSWorks and choose
Shell Mesh Using Surfaces and Static:
Right click on Shells and Define By Selected Surfaces.... Select all the surfaces on one side of both
parts:
-
7/27/2019 Sheet Metal Example
7/16
Right click on Shells and Apply Material to All.... Use 1023 Carbon Steel Sheet:
Add the spot welds by right clicking on Load/Restraint and selecting Connectors.... Select faces
which correspond to those you selected as shell surfaces above. Use the reference points as created
above to position the welds:
-
7/27/2019 Sheet Metal Example
8/16
Right click on Load/Restraint and add a restraint to all the mounting point holes (select edges on the
shell surface):
Then add a loading force:
I have added a force to a 15mm hole. The actually load would be applied in a small area at the base
of this hole, but for simplicity I am applying it to the whole interior surface. Only 10N is used,
because this is a very weak structure (you need to use 200N):
-
7/27/2019 Sheet Metal Example
9/16
Now we need to tell the analysis what to do where the two parts meet. Right click on
Contact/Gaps and select No Penetraction:
Now right click on Mesh and select Create Mesh. A coarse mesh will give quicker, but less
accurate results while the opposite is true of a fine mesh. Here Im using the default:
-
7/27/2019 Sheet Metal Example
10/16
Now right click on the Study and Run. Here are the stress results:
and the displacement:
Clearly using one spot weld to join to the back plate is insufficient: there is large displacement here.
-
7/27/2019 Sheet Metal Example
11/16
I have used four welds positioned as shown:
to produce the following stresses and displacements:
-
7/27/2019 Sheet Metal Example
12/16
There is now much less displacement near the welds. Notice, though, how the mounting plate is
under considerable stress obviously an area to add more sheet metal.
Because we are dealing with sheet metal, it is likely that buckling will be a problem. It is therefore
advisable to run a buckling analysis too. Open a new study and select buckling. The properties of the
previous study can be copied by right clicking on each property of the study and selecting copy and
then paste when the corresponding property of the new study is highlighted. Here are the results
of a buckling study:
The load factor of -0.027 means that buckling is not predicted. Look up buckling load factor in the
COSMOSWorks help to interpret load factors.
-
7/27/2019 Sheet Metal Example
13/16
Optimisation
(N.B. this example uses a solid mesh and slightly different geometry than above, but the process is
basically the same)
It is possible to optimise the dimensions of parts in an assembly using an optimization study. We
need to define the objective, the design variables and the constraints. Our objective is the mass of
the beam:
I have chosen just one design variable: the height of the beam. Note that I have added equations to
other dimensions so that they vary with the design variable (recall that these are derived
parameters)
-
7/27/2019 Sheet Metal Example
14/16
The constraints are that the deflection should not exceed 5mm,
the peak stress should not be greater than the yield stress of the material (~300,000,000 N/m2),
-
7/27/2019 Sheet Metal Example
15/16
and that the beam should not buckle. Here a safety factor of 2 is chosen (the upper bound is set
high so it is inactive) for the first mode of buckling:
The optimisation reduces the mass slightly by reducing the height of the beam from 50mm to 46mm,
whilst meeting the stress constraint. You may want to include a factor of safety in your stress
constraint (though the beam will be heavier). The other constraints are easily met. Note the slightly
increased stress in the beam below:
-
7/27/2019 Sheet Metal Example
16/16
The optimisation takes quite a long time, particularly when lots of design variables are used. You will
need to run it overnight if you want to optimise the whole beam. Try coarsening the mesh to speed
things up, or just optimise individual parts.