Sharma+16b – arXiv : 1606.08688 Sharma+16a – …Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham Escape fraction...

16
Mahavir Sharma (ICC Durham) & Tom Theuns, Carlos Frenk, Eagle collaboration Sharma+16b – arXiv : 1606.08688 Sharma+16a – MNRAS z QHII 1 0

Transcript of Sharma+16b – arXiv : 1606.08688 Sharma+16a – …Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham Escape fraction...

Page 1: Sharma+16b – arXiv : 1606.08688 Sharma+16a – …Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham Escape fraction should evolve Any study with escape fraction 15 to 20 % at z>6 is in the right ball park

Mahavir Sharma (ICC Durham)&

Tom Theuns, Carlos Frenk, Eagle collaboration

Sharma+16b – arXiv : 1606.08688Sharma+16a – MNRAS

z

QHII

1

0

Page 2: Sharma+16b – arXiv : 1606.08688 Sharma+16a – …Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham Escape fraction should evolve Any study with escape fraction 15 to 20 % at z>6 is in the right ball park

Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham

Reionization 

Photoionisation rate (Observers)Post-reionization

Ionised gas filling factor (Theorists)z>6

Should reproduce the evolution of ionized filling factor andphoto. rate post reionization

Electron scattering optical depth (CMB)

Crucial parameter, poorly understood

Page 3: Sharma+16b – arXiv : 1606.08688 Sharma+16a – …Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham Escape fraction should evolve Any study with escape fraction 15 to 20 % at z>6 is in the right ball park

Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham

Escape fraction should evolve

Any study with escape fraction 15 to 20 % at z>6 is in the right ball park(e.g. Robertson+15,Bouwens+15 + + ).

why does it evolve ? WINDS

Haardt & Madau 12 -->

Page 4: Sharma+16b – arXiv : 1606.08688 Sharma+16a – …Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham Escape fraction should evolve Any study with escape fraction 15 to 20 % at z>6 is in the right ball park

Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham

Ionising photons escape through channels created by winds

● Linked to winds : high surface density of star formation – winds –

high f_esc (Heckman 01,11, Borthakur+14, Izotov+16a,b)

Starburst, winds -------------------------> High Escape Fraction

Bo

rth

aku

r e

tal 14

● Threshold for winds

(Heckman 01, Murray+10, Scanapiecco+13)

Page 5: Sharma+16b – arXiv : 1606.08688 Sharma+16a – …Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham Escape fraction should evolve Any study with escape fraction 15 to 20 % at z>6 is in the right ball park

Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham

Starburst – (winds) – High escape fraction

Wise et al. 2014

Time

[SIII]/[SII]

Zastrow+13

Page 6: Sharma+16b – arXiv : 1606.08688 Sharma+16a – …Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham Escape fraction should evolve Any study with escape fraction 15 to 20 % at z>6 is in the right ball park

Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham

Escape Fraction : Model

● Star formation histories from the EAGLE simulation

● Capability of a burst to puncture the discdictated by the local SFR surface density.

Schaye et al. 2015, Data is now Public http://icc.dur.ac.uk/Eagle/database.php

For example, if 5 out of 100 star forming regions satisfy the aboveCriteria then the galaxy-wide escape fraction is 1 %.

(Heckman 2001)

Sharma+2016a,b

Borthakur+14,Izotov+16

Page 7: Sharma+16b – arXiv : 1606.08688 Sharma+16a – …Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham Escape fraction should evolve Any study with escape fraction 15 to 20 % at z>6 is in the right ball park

Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham

Escape fraction vs SFR surface density

LBGsIwata+07Nestor+10

z=0 galaxies

Page 8: Sharma+16b – arXiv : 1606.08688 Sharma+16a – …Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham Escape fraction should evolve Any study with escape fraction 15 to 20 % at z>6 is in the right ball park

Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham

Izotov+16a,b

SDSS, z=0

LBGs z=3-5

Nearby galaxies with high f_esc

Heckman 01

Wind Threshold

Page 9: Sharma+16b – arXiv : 1606.08688 Sharma+16a – …Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham Escape fraction should evolve Any study with escape fraction 15 to 20 % at z>6 is in the right ball park

Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham

Sharma+2016a

More than half of the ionising photons emittedBy the galaxies within the current HST limits

Page 10: Sharma+16b – arXiv : 1606.08688 Sharma+16a – …Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham Escape fraction should evolve Any study with escape fraction 15 to 20 % at z>6 is in the right ball park

Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham

Escape fraction : evolution 

● evolves with redshift

● Winds when

Threshold for winds (Heckman 2001)

(Heckman 01, Murray+10, Scanapiecco+13)

Page 11: Sharma+16b – arXiv : 1606.08688 Sharma+16a – …Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham Escape fraction should evolve Any study with escape fraction 15 to 20 % at z>6 is in the right ball park

Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham

Escape fraction : Evolution

HM12

From evolving [OIII]/[OII] (Faisst+16, Nakajima&Ouchi14)

Page 12: Sharma+16b – arXiv : 1606.08688 Sharma+16a – …Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham Escape fraction should evolve Any study with escape fraction 15 to 20 % at z>6 is in the right ball park

Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham

Reionization 

Sharma+16b - arXiv:1606.08688

Page 13: Sharma+16b – arXiv : 1606.08688 Sharma+16a – …Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham Escape fraction should evolve Any study with escape fraction 15 to 20 % at z>6 is in the right ball park

Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham

Reionization 

Sharma+16b - arXiv:1606.08688

Model with constant escape fractionoverproduces the photo rate at low redshift

Page 14: Sharma+16b – arXiv : 1606.08688 Sharma+16a – …Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham Escape fraction should evolve Any study with escape fraction 15 to 20 % at z>6 is in the right ball park

Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham

Fossils of reionizers 

● Fractional abundance is higher in the low mass galaxies.

● Most of them live in the massive galaxies.

Page 15: Sharma+16b – arXiv : 1606.08688 Sharma+16a – …Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham Escape fraction should evolve Any study with escape fraction 15 to 20 % at z>6 is in the right ball park

Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham

The Milky Way, face­on(fraction of reionizers)

● Reionizers have a shalower distribution compared to normal stars, ● High fractional abundance in the outskirts.

Sharma+in prep.

Page 16: Sharma+16b – arXiv : 1606.08688 Sharma+16a – …Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham Escape fraction should evolve Any study with escape fraction 15 to 20 % at z>6 is in the right ball park

Mahavir Sharma, ICC Durham

Summary

● Winds pave paths for high escape fraction and drive theevolution of escape fraction

● Most of reionisers today live in the massive galaxies.

● Low mass galaxies have higher fractional abundance.

● High fractional abundance in the outskirts of the Milky Way