Sharing new information from CCS projects around the world - overview at Rotterdam Member's Meeting...

GLOBAL CCS INSTITUTE

WWW.GLOBALCCSINSTITUTE.COM

SHARING NEW INFORMATION FROM PROJECTS AROUND THE WORLD

Sean McClowry – General Manager, Knowledge Management

10 May 2011


INTRODUCTION

Framework

We have created an advanced framework on which we are executing

Content

We have valuable knowledge to share from projects, content partners and the Institute

1

Platforms

We have developed sophisticated digital platforms to enhance dissemination and collaboration

Engagement

We need your participation to make this work


OUR MISSION: share knowledge to accelerate deployment of CCS

Identify Needs

Collectand

Create

Register and

Store

Analyseand

Verify

Process and Add

Value

Advocate

Assist Projects

Share knowledge

2

Measure and Review

knowledge


Rotterdam CCS Network Project, RCI

• Storage and shipping studies

Getica, ISPE• Feasibility Study

Project Pioneer, TransAlta

• FEED studies

American Electric Power, Mountaineer• FEED studies

ROAD Project, MaasvlakteCCS

• FEED studies & execution planning

INSTITUTE-SUPPORTED PROJECTS FOR KNOWLEDGE SHARING

* Letter of Intent

Tenaska Trailblazer Project

• FEED studies

Tenaska/Entergy Nelson 6 CCS Project

•Development studies

CarbonNet, Victorian Government

•Commercial and Planning studies

Callide Oxyfuel Project, OPTL*

•Transport and CO2 injection studies

Chiyoda Project, Chiyoda/Tokyo University•Shuttle shipping study

3


Feasibility/FEED Case Studies

Project

Cap

ture

Tra

nsp

ort

/ In

frastr

uctu

re

Sto

rag

e a

nd

M

MV

Fin

an

ce a

nd

C

om

merc

ial

Po

licy,

Leg

al

an

d

Reg

ula

tio

n

Pu

bli

c

En

gag

em

en

t

Ris

k a

nd

E

nvir

on

men

t

Rotterdam CCS Network Project ��

Romanian CCS Demo Plant ��

KNOWLEDGE TOPICS COVERED

Demo Plant ��

Trailblazer Energy Center ��

Nelson 6 CCS Project (Phase 1) ��

TransAlta Pioneer ��

AEP Mountaineer ��

Chiyoda Project ��

ROAD Project ��

4


FUNDED PROJECTS: Examples of recent deliverables from RCI and Tenaska Trailblazer

Knowledge products – Trailblazer Tenaska

Development History of the Project

CO2 Technology Evaluation, Methodology and Criteria

Public Engagement activities

Report on Steam Turbine Sizing

Carbon Capture Plant Layout Integration with a New Coal Fired Power Generating Facility

5

Coal Fired Power Generating Facility

Deep Saline Sequestration Study

Knowledge products – Rotterdam CCS Network Project

Detailed technical and cost reports for 3-4 storage sites in Dutch sector North Sea

Historic Case Study on the Rotterdam CCS network

Methodology report on the Independent Storage Assessment


FUNDED PROJECTS: Upcoming deliverables from Europe

Knowledge products – GETICA Romania

Permitting Report

Summary Report NER300 Application

Financial Scenarios Report

Public Feasibility Study Report

Knowledge products – Rotterdam CCS Network Project

Historic Case Study on the Rotterdam CCS network

Overall supply chain optimization Liquid Logistics Shipping Concept

6

Overall supply chain optimization Liquid Logistics Shipping Concept

Report on Rotterdam CO2 hub safety – including port and offshore infrastructure development, along with a range of CO2 transportation solutions, including shipping

Report on lessons learned from the feasibility study of the CO2 liquid logistics shipping concept

Knowledge products – ROAD Project

Special report on CO2 capture technology selection methodology

Non-confidential FEED study report

Reports on permitting processes and public engagement

Report on Mitigating project risks including handling of business risks

Report on the Execution Strategy of the project


FUNDED PROJECTS : Upcoming deliverables from North America

Knowledge products – Project Pioneer (Transalta)

Report on the Regulatory gaps for implementing CCS

Case Study on the socio - economic impact of an integrated CCS Project

Special report on the Construction execution strategy for the ProjectNew developments in MMV technology

Non confidential version of FEED study report of the integrated project (2012)

Knowledge products – Mountaineer Project (A.E.P)

7

CO2 Compression report

Report on CCS integration issues

The business case – financial modelling and local impacts of CCS

Non confidential version of FEED study report of the integrated project

Knowledge products – Tenaska Trailblazer

Building a Consortium to Develop a New Pulverised Coal Plant with Post-combustion CaptureBridging the commercial gap for CCS (ERCOT base load power and EOR market factors)

Financing a new pulverized coal plant with CCS.

Non confidential version of FEED study report


FUNDED PROJECTS: Accessing key deliverables

8


Key Findings

Government commitments towards demonstrating CCS between US$ 33 and US$ 44 billion

77 projects have been identified and an increasing number of projects are moving to advanced planning and execution stages

Around 30 CCS network projects have been identified of which more that half involve extensions of existing EOR networks

Australia, Canada, China, India, much of Europe and the United

GLOBAL STATUS OF CCS: 2010

9

Australia, Canada, China, India, much of Europe and the United States have made significant advances in national and regional high-level storage assessments during the past two years

Large uncertainly and variety around up-front costs of CCS projects

The cost of moving from a desktop screening assessment to a fully assessed site that is ready for development is high

Increasing number of Knowledge Sharing initiatives are underway nationally and internationally

Consistent themes around public engagement are emerging from the limited case-studies around the world

Significant progress has been made in the development of legal and regulatory frameworks at regional and (inter) national levels


� Best practice guide for government, regulators and industry to testregulatory systems and permitting processes for CCS.

� Takes a CCS project application through the approval process in a

CCS REGULATORY TEST TOOLKIT

through the approval process in a regulatory test exercise.

� Suitable for national and regional governments.

� Produced by SCCS researchers on behalf of the Scottish Government and supported by the Institute.

10


� Exercise preparation requires:

o Resources and governance;

o Stakeholder engagement;

o Regulatory analysis; and

o Preparation for the event.

CCS REGULATORY TEST TOOLKIT

� A one-day workshop allows stakeholders to test the regulatory system using a selected CCS project (real or simulated).

� Managed follow-up to communicate exercise findings, agree actions and deliver benefits is critical.

11


� Effective Public Engagement is essential

� Each CCS project and community is unique:

o Every project requires an tailored engagement process.

o Regions may have vastly different approaches.

� Consistent themes are emerging on areas of importance:

SHARING KNOWLEDGE ON PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT

� Consistent themes are emerging on areas of importance:

o Establish effective levels of trust with local communities.

o Communicate the case for CCS with balanced information in an ongoing dialogue with local stakeholders.

o Ensure that outreach activities reflect a partnership approach involving joint decision making.

o Understand the local context and identify the social value proposition.

12


� Commissioned with CSIRO and the global social research network.

� A practical guide for project proponents to plan their engagement .

SHARING KNOWLEDGE ON PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT: Toolkit

� Provides a range of methods and activities for addressing social considerations for successful CCS project deployment.

� Built from real case studies .

� Will improve over time as it is used by more projects.

13


The toolkit provides

� Social data collection methods

� Stakeholder identification methods

� A project baseline survey

� Independent steering group model

� Citizen task force/advisory board model

� Example role descriptions

SHARING KNOWLEDGE ON PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT: Toolkit

14

� Example role descriptions

� Example media products

� Swot analysis worksheet

� Example engagement plan

� Example project timeline


� Pre-Announcement

o Information Gathering

o Initial local contact

o Public announcement

o Legislative Briefings

SHARING KNOWLEDGE ON PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT: Tenaska Trailblazer

� Stakeholder Identification

� Jobs

o Information Gathering

o Value Proposition

15


� Community Outreach

o Community Representative

o Project Website/E-mail

o Civic Group Presentations

o Earned Media

o Open House


o Open House

o Advertising

� Air Quality Permit

� Water Conservation

� Legislative Outreach

16



17


� Global Status of CCS Report

� Tenaska Trailblazer Report

� Communications and Engagement Toolkit for CCS Projects

� Case Studies:

o What happened in Barendrecht?

o Carson CCS

SHARING KNOWLEDGE ON PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT: Learn more

o Carson CCS

o FutureGen

o CO2CRC Otway Project Case Study

o ZeroGen

� Towards a Public Communication and Engagement Strategy ... (Scottish Centre for Carbon Capture)

� Best Practices for Public Outreach and Education for Carbon Storage (US DoE)

� Community Engagement Guidelines (WRI)18


SHARING KNOWLEDGE ON PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT: Campaign

� Reports

� Conversations

� Opinions

� Toolkits

19

� Toolkits

� Methods


� We’ve launched a Japanese knowledge sharing network

o Involves about key staff of ~15 major CCS-related organisations in Japan.

o Collaboration is face-to-face and on the Institute’s extranet.

o Facilitators include JGC and its partners (Quintessa, AIST and McKinley).

� Focused on identifying decisions and sharing knowledge on

o National energy portfolio changes after the earthquake, tsunami and nuclear

HOW WE ENGAGE: Japanese CCS knowledge network

o National energy portfolio changes after the earthquake, tsunami and nuclear crisis.

o Role of CCS in a revised national energy portfolio, e.g., enhancement of the fossil power stations.

o Risks associated with earthquakes and tsunamis on underground storage of CCS in Japan.

o Risk of seismic activity induced by CO2 injection.

� Will publish a public summary report in August 20


An open and collaboratively developed CCS methodology, covering ...

HOW WE ENGAGE: OpenCCS project methodology

Power CapturePower Capture

Industry CaptureIndustry Capture

Power Capture

Industry Capture

Identify ExecuteEvaluate Operate ClosureDefine

TransportTransport

StorageStorage

Power CapturePower Capture

Transport

Storage

Power Capture



22http://www.globalccsinstitute.com/openccs



23


HOW WE ENGAGE: we’re building an expertise-driven approach

ExpertsHow do the economics of CCS stack up against other renewable energy economic models in meeting climate change objective?

CCS Market and Economic CCS Market and Economic

ConditionsConditions

Required expertise

� Strong experience in energy economics

� Peer recognition

Motivation

Willing to publish non-confidential information in exchange for greater access to information from other experts.

Contact requirements

Wants to be notified about any opportunity to contribute expertise in field.

ConditionsConditions


Framework

We’ll continue to improve on our approach based on your feedback

Content

Our library of knowledge products and expertise will grow over time

NEXT STEPS

25

Platform

We base our approach around knowledge platforms and will be making many improvements

Engagement

Success will come with your participation


www.globalccsinstitute.com26

Sharing new information from CCS projects around the world - overview at Rotterdam Member's Meeting...

Technology

Transcript of Sharing new information from CCS projects around the world - overview at Rotterdam Member's Meeting...