Sewage pollution and extinction risk: an endangered limpet as a … · 2009. 11. 11. · and...

21
-1 Sewage pollution and extinction risk: an endangered limpet as a bioindicator? F. ESPINOSA * , J.M. GUERRA-GARCI ´ A and J.C. GARCI ´ A-GO ´ MEZ Laboratorio de Biologı´a Marina, Dpto. Fisiologı´a y Zoologı´a, Facultad de Biologı´a, Universidad de Sevilla, Avda Reina Mercedes 6, 41012, Sevilla, Spain; *Author for correspondence (e-mail: [email protected]; phone: +34-954557100; fax: +34-954233480) Received 6 January 2005; accepted in revised form 9 September 2005 Key words: Harbour, Monitoring, Patella ferruginea, Patellogastropods, Pollution, Sewage outfall, Siphonaria Abstract. The mollusc Patella ferruginea, endemic to the Mediterranean, is the most endangered marine species on the list of the European Council Directive 92/43/EEC and it is under serious risk of extinction. In spite of the low abundances and restricted distribution of this limpet, important populations have been found in the harbour of Ceuta, north Africa. The main objective of the present study was to characterise, for the first time, the effects of sewage pollution on P. ferruginea and related limpet species, and to evaluate the potential value of these limpet assemblages as bioindicators, using univariate and multivariate analyses. Physicochemical parameters and limpets were sampled in nine stations located at 0, 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, 32, 64 and 128 m away from the discharge point of a sewage effluent in Ceuta harbour. The stations closer to the outfall (0, 1, 2, 4 and 8) were characterised by higher values of turbidity, phosphate and ammonia in the water column, and organic matter, faecal coliforms and faecal Streptococci in sediments. A total of six limpet species were found and studied (Patella ferruginea, P. caerulea, P. nigra, P. rustica, P. ulyssiponensis and Siphonaria pectinata); the number of limpet species increased with increasing distance from the outfall, while diversity and evenness reached the highest values at intermediate sites. Siphonaria pectinata and P. caerulea were the most resistant and abundant species, while P. ferruginea was the most sensitive species to sewage pollution, only found at stations from 32 to 128 m. The distri- bution of this endangered limpet seems mainly affected by the pollution gradient, and not by the competition with the remaining limpets. The results of this study should be taken into account in future programmes of management and conservation of P. ferruginea. Introduction The limpet Patella ferruginea Gmelin, 1791, endemic to the Mediterranean, is the most endangered marine species on the list of the European Council Directive 92/43/EEC on the conservation of Natural Habitats and of Wild Fauna and Flora, 1992 (Ramos 1998), and it is, presently, under serious risk of extinction (Laborel-Deguen and Laborel 1991; Templado and Moreno 1997). Although its relative abundance in Palaeolithic and Neolithic deposits indicates a former distribution in the Western Mediterranean Basin (East coast of Italy, Mediterranean France, Iberian Peninsula, Morocco, Tunisia and the Western Mediterranean islands), today its Mediterranean range has progressively con- tracted to a few restricted areas (Cretella et al. 1994; Templado 1996) probably Biodiversity and Conservation (2007) 16:377–397 ȑ Springer 2006 DOI 10.1007/s10531-005-3014-3

Transcript of Sewage pollution and extinction risk: an endangered limpet as a … · 2009. 11. 11. · and...

  • -1

    Sewage pollution and extinction risk: an endangeredlimpet as a bioindicator?

    F. ESPINOSA*, J.M. GUERRA-GARCÍA and J.C. GARCÍA-GÓMEZLaboratorio de Biologı́a Marina, Dpto. Fisiologı́a y Zoologı́a, Facultad de Biologı́a, Universidad de

    Sevilla, Avda Reina Mercedes 6, 41012, Sevilla, Spain; *Author for correspondence (e-mail:

    [email protected]; phone: +34-954557100; fax: +34-954233480)

    Received 6 January 2005; accepted in revised form 9 September 2005

    Key words: Harbour, Monitoring, Patella ferruginea, Patellogastropods, Pollution, Sewage outfall,

    Siphonaria

    Abstract. The mollusc Patella ferruginea, endemic to the Mediterranean, is the most endangered

    marine species on the list of the European Council Directive 92/43/EEC and it is under serious risk

    of extinction. In spite of the low abundances and restricted distribution of this limpet, important

    populations have been found in the harbour of Ceuta, north Africa. The main objective of the

    present study was to characterise, for the first time, the effects of sewage pollution on P. ferruginea

    and related limpet species, and to evaluate the potential value of these limpet assemblages as

    bioindicators, using univariate and multivariate analyses. Physicochemical parameters and limpets

    were sampled in nine stations located at 0, 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, 32, 64 and 128 m away from the discharge

    point of a sewage effluent in Ceuta harbour. The stations closer to the outfall (0, 1, 2, 4 and 8) were

    characterised by higher values of turbidity, phosphate and ammonia in the water column, and

    organic matter, faecal coliforms and faecal Streptococci in sediments. A total of six limpet species

    were found and studied (Patella ferruginea, P. caerulea, P. nigra, P. rustica, P. ulyssiponensis and

    Siphonaria pectinata); the number of limpet species increased with increasing distance from the

    outfall, while diversity and evenness reached the highest values at intermediate sites. Siphonaria

    pectinata and P. caerulea were the most resistant and abundant species, while P. ferruginea was the

    most sensitive species to sewage pollution, only found at stations from 32 to 128 m. The distri-

    bution of this endangered limpet seems mainly affected by the pollution gradient, and not by the

    competition with the remaining limpets. The results of this study should be taken into account in

    future programmes of management and conservation of P. ferruginea.

    Introduction

    The limpet Patella ferruginea Gmelin, 1791, endemic to the Mediterranean, isthe most endangered marine species on the list of the European CouncilDirective 92/43/EEC on the conservation of Natural Habitats and of WildFauna and Flora, 1992 (Ramos 1998), and it is, presently, under serious risk ofextinction (Laborel-Deguen and Laborel 1991; Templado and Moreno 1997).Although its relative abundance in Palaeolithic and Neolithic deposits indicatesa former distribution in the Western Mediterranean Basin (East coast of Italy,Mediterranean France, Iberian Peninsula, Morocco, Tunisia and the WesternMediterranean islands), today its Mediterranean range has progressively con-tracted to a few restricted areas (Cretella et al. 1994; Templado 1996) probably

    Biodiversity and Conservation (2007) 16:377–397 � Springer 2006DOI 10.1007/s10531-005-3014-3

  • due to human pressure (Aversano 1986; Laborel-Deguen and Laborel 1991).Although the species is threatened with extinction, important populations havebeen found recently inside the harbour of Ceuta, Strait of Gibraltar (Guerra-Garcı́a et al. 2004a, b); Ceuta harbour is environmentally unique, differingsubstantially from other conventional harbours, since it is located between twobays connected by a channel which increases the water movement and ex-change and contributes to the maintenance of rich and diverse communities ofmarine invertebrates (Guerra-Garcı́a and Garcı́a-Gómez 2005). Little is knownabout the biology and ecological preferences of P. ferruginea; this species has avery low growth and reproductive rate, reaching sexual maturation at 2–3 years (Guerra-Garcı́a et al. 2004a). It is a protandric species with oocytes of142–170 lm (Unpublished data) and this limpet feed mainly on cyanobacteriaand the algae Ralfsia spp. and Rissoella spp.In the harbour of Ceuta, P. ferruginea coexists with five other limpet species:

    Patella caerulea Linnaeus, 1758, Patella nigra da Costa, 1771, Patella rusticaLinnaeus, 1758, Patella ulyssiponensis Gmelin, 1791 and Siphonaria pectinata(Linnaeus, 1758). Patella nigra is also an endangered limpet, however, unlikeP. ferruginea, P. nigra is not suffering a clear regression and populations seemto be increasing (Templado et al. 2004). Recent morphological and molecularstudies seems to indicate that P. nigra should be transferred to the genusCymbula, as Cymbula safiana Lamark, 1819 (see Ridgway et al. 1998;Koufopanou et al. 1999). Taking into account that there is a sewage outfallinside the harbour of Ceuta, the present study explores how this sewage effluentis affecting the limpet assemblages in general andPatella ferruginea in particular.Due to their ecological importance, as well as sedentary life, molluscs have

    assumed a major role in monitoring contaminants worldwide (Boening 1999;Feldstein et al. 2003). They are abundant, sedentary and easy to collect, whichmakes them ideal for biomonitoring (Bresler et al. 2003a, b). Furthermore, incomparison with other marine environments, access to intertidal ecosystems isusually easier, and these ecosystems are more amenable to management thanopen ocean and sublittoral benthic habitats. Additionally, the composition ofsessile communities is particularly useful as baseline for ecological monitoringbecause such organisms are unable to avoid disturbances in the marine envi-ronment and thus, the composition of the community reflects their commonhistory (Fa et al. 2002).Differences in physical and biological conditions are the main cause of

    variation in marine communities, both in time and space (Pain and Levin 1981;Dayton 1984; Sousa 1984), and, consequently, environmental gradients areimportant in determining the structure of assemblages (Bishop et al. 2002).Some of these gradients originate as anthropogenic perturbations. One of themost serious, and increasingly common, sources of disturbance in marinecommunities is the discharge of sewage effluents (Gerlach 1981; Gray 1982).These effluents are often discharged via outfalls into shallow subtidal habitats,and can result in significant effects on marine biota, involving changes incytology and physiology at the individual level that are ultimately manifested

    378

  • as alterations in the community structure (Littler and Murray 1975). There arefew studies describing the effects of sewage on macro-benthic assemblagesliving on hard substrata (Terlizzi et al. 2002). Furthermore, according toUnderwood (1997), some authors have analysed differences between an im-pacted location and a single control, with evident problems of pseudoreplica-tion and consequently confounding in the logical interpretation of results.Additionally, along the Mediterranean coasts, despite a large amount ofdomestic and industrial sewage discharged to the sea (UNEP 1989), there arefew published accounts of the effects of sewage effluents on the macrobenthos(see Terlizzi et al. 2002).The objectives of the present study are to characterise the effect of a sewage

    effluent on density, size and assemblages of the patellid community inhabitingthe rocky intertidal shores of the harbour of Ceuta, North Africa, with specialattention to the endangered P. ferruginea, and to explore the value of thesepatellid molluscs as bioindicators of sewage pollution.

    Material and methods

    Study area

    The harbour of Ceuta (35�53¢ N, 5�18¢ W) is one of the most important in theStrait of Gibraltar, because of its situation relative to Europe and Africa(Figure 1). There are no river discharges directly into the harbour and, unlikeother harbours in this region of the Mediterranean, industrial activity adjacentto the harbour of Ceuta is absent. Consequently, the contamination inside theharbour is derived from the sewage effluents of urban influence, antifoulingpaints and accidental oil spills during the loading and dumping involved inshipping operations. Although the sediments are moderately polluted in theharbour of Ceuta (Guerra-Garcı́a et al. 2003), this harbour has a unique designwith two opposing entrances and a channel, which increases water exchangemaintaining high oxygen levels in the water column. Under these unusualconditions (polluted sediments but oxygen saturation), the communities of theharbour of Ceuta are characterised by rich and diverse macrobenthic com-munities. The number of species is unusually high when compared with othermore conventional enclosed harbours of nearby areas which do not have twoopposing entrances or a channel (see Guerra-Garcı́a and Garcı́a-Gómez2004a–c, 2005; in press).Inside the harbour there is a sewage outfall located close to a leisure resort.

    The study was conducted during summer (August 2002), which coincides withthe maximum peak of tourist activity. Raw sewage is discharged onto the shorearea through a pipeline with a rectangular section measuring 135 · 75 cm.Although the outfall is discharging throughout the whole year, it is especially

    379

  • active during the summer months, discharging every day. The outfall terminusis located in the intertidal area, composed of sandstone artificial rocks.

    Sampling methods

    A total of nine sites were selected for this study. The first station (Site 0) wasthe ‘outfall site’ and the remaining stations were located at 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, 32, 64and 128 m away along a transect (see Figure 1). The presence of the sewageeffluent involves a gradient, and sampling is usually conducted in spatial scaleand regularly (May 1985; Foe and Knight 1987; Lopez-Gappa et al. 1990;Zmarzly et al. 1994); however, sampling at regular intervals from a disturbanceusing a single spatial scale is not necessarily appropriate (Bishop et al. 2002).We used herein a logarithmic scale (log2) to explore more carefully the areaclose to the outfall since communities inhabiting this area are the most affectedby the sewage pollution.

    Limpet samplingIn each station, the density of limpets was measured by counting the number ofspecimens found in a 1 m wide transect located from the zero tidal level to theupper level of the intertidal in which limpets were present. At site 0, coincidentwith the outfall, no limpets were found. The size of each limpet was estimatedby measuring the shell length (see Guerra-Garcı́a et al. 2004a). The species

    Figure 1. Map of the study area in the harbour of Ceuta, North Africa. Arrow indicates the

    sewage discharge point, and the gross continuous line the 128 m transect. Sampling sites from 0 to

    128 m along the transect are indicated.

    380

  • were identified ‘in situ’ when possible; if the species could not be properlyvisually identified due to epiphytic alga or fauna, the limpet was removed foridentification in the laboratory.

    Physico-chemical analysisIn addition to the limpet study, several physico-chemical parameters weremeasured in the water column and sediments in each sampling stations.Water samples were taken in the nine stations. Free and total ammonia,

    nitrate, nitrite, phosphate and pH were measured using colorimetric methodsbased on analytical test Seachem�, and dissolved oxygen using the kitD.O.Azoo�. Turbidity was measured in nephelometric turbidity units (ntu)using a turbidimeter Hanna HI 93703.Sediments were also collected at the nine sites, at 4 m depth and 20 m away

    from the coast. Analysis were conducted using the finest fraction of the sedi-ment (diameter less than 0.063 mm) (see Guerra-Garcı́a and Garcı́a-Gómez2005)). Sediment samples were conserved in sterile containers until their arrivalat the laboratory where they were frozen. The organic content was analysed byashing samples of sediment to 500 �C for 6 h and re-weighing (mean values ofthree replicates of 2 g each) (see Estacio et al. 1997). Phosphate and nitratewere measured using UV visible spectrophotometry followingMétodos oficialesde análisis para aguas residuales y suelos (1986). Hydrocarbons were measuredby extraction and FT-IR spectrophotometry (see Estacio et al. 1997). Thefaecal coliforms were measured as the coliforms which fermented lactose in amedium M-FC with production of acid and gas at 44.5 �C during 24 h. Formeasuring the faecal Streptococci, agar m Enterococcus at 35 �C during 48 hwas used. The results of microbiological analyses were expressed as colonialformers units (cfu) per gram of sediment.

    Statistical analysis

    The total number of species, the Shannon–Wiener diversity index (Shannonand Weaver 1963) and the Pielou’s evenness index (Pielou 1966) were calcu-lated for each station based on the abundances of patellid species.The affinities among stations were established through cluster analysis using

    the UPGMA method (unweight pair–group method using arithmetic averages)(Sneath and Sokal 1973), based on the Bray–Curtis similarity index for thelimpet species matrix and on the Euclidean distance for the environmentalmatrix. Abundance data of the limpet species were double square root trans-formed so that the ensuing classification and ordination were not determinedonly by the most dominant species (Clarke and Green 1988); environmentaldata were transformed using log (x+1) (see Guerra-Garcı́a and Garcı́a-Gómez2001). In order to confirm the results of the cluster, Principal ComponentAnalyses were used for the ordination of stations based on the physico-chemical data measured in water and sediment, and a MDS (non-metric

    381

  • multidimensional scaling) was used for biological data. To test the ordination,the stress coefficient of Kruskal was employed (Kruskal and Wish 1978). Toexplore the relationships among environmental measures and the patellidassemblages, a canonical correspondence analysis (CCA) was applied. Rela-tionships between multivariate biological structure and environmental vari-ables were also examined using the BIO-ENV procedure (Clarke andAinsworth 1993). Percentage of similarity analysis (SIMPER) (Clarke 1993)was used to determine the species involved in grouping of the different stations.Possible differences in limpet abundances and sizes between the groups

    defined by ordination and classification analyses based on physicochemicalparameters, were tested using Kruskal–Wallis test, since normality (Shapiro–Wilk test) and/or homogeneity of variances (Levene test) were not passed, andconsequently ANOVA parametric tests could not be carried out.Univariate and multivariate analyses were carried out using BMDP (Dixon

    1983), PRIMER (Clarke and Gorley 2001) and the PC-ORD (McCune andMefford 1997).

    Results

    Physicochemical parameters

    Table 1 includes the values of physicochemical parameters measured in waterand sediments. In the water column, a clear trend could be observed fornutrients. The concentrations of ammonia and phosphate were at least oneorder of magnitude higher in the stations located near the outfall than in theremaining stations further away. The highest values of turbidity and pH werealso recorded near the sewage outfall. On the other hand, oxygen showed thelowest values in the first 16 m, while in stations located at 32, 64 and 128 maway from the outfall, the oxygen concentrations were higher, reaching9.0 mg/l. With regard to the sediment, both faecal coliforms and Streptococciwere more abundant in the stations closer to the outfall; the same trend wasobtained for hydrocarbons (Table 1) and for organic matter (Figure 2).However, phosphate and nitrate did not show a clear pattern, and concen-trations of phosphate were often higher in the stations more distant from theoutfall.The PCA plot obtained using the physicochemical parameters of the water

    column reflected similar gradients to the PCA elaborated with the sedimentvariables, although the former showed more clearly the gradient produced bythe outfall (Figure 3). The first axis of the PCA ordination using water columnmeasures, explained 59.1% of the total variance and the percentage of varianceexplained by axis 1 of the PCA based on the sediment measures was 43.4%.The PCA analyses, consequently, confirmed the trend of a pollution gradientfrom the outfall point. Cluster analyses also supported this ordination andshowed clearly that stations could be separated into two groups according to

    382

  • Table

    1.

    Values

    obtained

    forvariablesmeasuredin

    thewatercolumnandsedim

    entattheninesamplingsitesalongthetransect.n.a:data

    notavailable.

    Sites

    Watercolumn

    Sedim

    ent

    Freeammonia

    (ppm)

    Totalammonia

    (ppm)

    Nitrate

    (ppm)

    Nitrite

    (ppm)

    Phosphate

    (ppm)

    Oxygen

    (mg/l)

    pH

    Turbidity

    (ntu)

    F.coliform

    s

    (cfu/g)

    F.Streptococci

    (cfu/g)

    Phosphate

    (ppm)

    Nitrate

    (ppm)

    Hydrocarbons

    (ppm)

    02.50

    3.50

    0.2

    0.10

    3.5

    6.0

    8.2

    35.42

    416.94

    268.36

    12.50

    3.50

    1.0

    0.50

    3.5

    6.5

    8.2

    15.06

    9134

    5.35

    7.13

    76.67

    20.50

    3.00

    0.2

    0.10

    2.5

    5.0

    8.7

    10.69

    3119

    4.89

    20.37

    78.82

    40.15

    2.00

    0.2

    0.10

    2.0

    7.0

    8.0

    5.19

    18

    230

    5.20

    3.19

    119.78

    80.15

    2.00

    0.2

    0.10

    3.0

    5.0

    7.9

    2.19

    2108

    9.24

    6.35

    85.69

    16

    0.01

    0.15

    0.2

    0.05

    1.0

    5.0

    8.1

    0.85

    015

    8.38

    8.59

    23.51

    32

    0.01

    0.15

    0.2

    0.05

    0.2

    9.0

    8.1

    1.10

    015

    17.02

    17.92

    32.64

    64

    0.01

    0.15

    0.2

    0.05

    0.2

    9.0

    8.1

    0.86

    07

    14.53

    14.26

    52.70

    128

    0.01

    0.15

    0.2

    0.05

    0.2

    9.0

    7.9

    0.88

    1n.a.

    9.40

    16.77

    70.69

    383

  • the physicochemical parameters both in the water column and sediments. Onegroup (from now on referred to as near sites) was formed by the sites located inthe first 8 m of the transect, and the second group (from now on referred to as

    Figure 2. Percentage of organic matter measured in the nine sampling sites along the transect.

    Mean values and standard deviations are included.

    Figure 3. PCA (left) and Cluster (right) plots, based on the physicochemical parameters measured

    in the water column and sediment.

    384

  • further away sites) included the remaining sites (from 16 to 128 m) (Figure 3).These two groups of stations shown by the physicochemical data (near sites vsfurther away sites) were used in further comparisons between density and sizeof specimens, as well as for SIMPER analysis.

    Biological data

    The limpets Siphonaria pectinata (Basommatophora) and Patella caerulea(Patellogastropoda) were present in all the sampled sites, although the densitieswere significantly higher in the further away sites than in the near sites(S. pectinata, K = 5.4, p

  • in sediment, according to the BIO-ENV. Including extra variables the signifi-cance of the correlation decreased, although the values were also significant(Table 3). Taking into account that eight stations only were sampled, themaximum number of variables which we could included in the CCA analysiswas seven; consequently, we selected the seven variables which, independently,showed the best correlation coefficients with the biotic data in the BIO-ENVanalysis: turbidity, free ammonia, total ammonia, nitrite, phosphate, organic

    Figure 4. Number of individuals and size of each limpet species at the sampled stations along the

    transect. Mean values and standard deviations are included for size.

    386

  • matter in sediment, and phosphate in sediment. The first axis of the CCAanalysis (Figure 8, Table 4) mainly correlated with the organic matter of thesediment, but also with the concentrations of total ammonia, turbidity andphosphate (both in water and sediment). Axis 1 separated Patella ferrugineaand P. rustica from the remaining species. These two limpets were associatedwith the further away sites (32, 64 and 128 m), characterised by lower con-centrations of ammonia, phosphate in water, organic matter in sediment andlower values of turbidity. On the other hand, the axis 2 separated the stations 1

    Figure 4. Continued

    387

  • and 2 -and the species Siphonaria pectinata and Patella caerulea-, from thestations 4, 8 and 16 -and the species P. nigra and P. ulyssiponensis-, based on theconcentrations of free ammonia, which correlated significantly with the axis 2.

    Discussion

    Physico-chemical data

    The present study showed moderate concentrations of nutrients (mainlyammonia and phosphates) in the water column close to the outfall. These

    Figure 5. The relative contribution in percentage of individuals of each limpet species at the

    sampling sites. See also Figure 4.

    Figure 6. Species richness (S), Shannon–Wiener diversity (H¢) and Pielou evenness (J) of thepatellid community in each station.

    388

  • concentrations were considerably higher than those measured in other areasof the harbour of Ceuta and adjacent waters (see Guerra-Garcı́a 2001),which indicates the urban influence of sewage effluent. The oxygen con-centrations near the outfall (5–7 mg/l) were lower than in the sites 32, 64and 128 m (9 mg/l). Several studies have recently pointed out the impor-tance of oxygen in the water column on macrofaunal assemblages (Saı́z-Salinas 1997; Guerra-Garcı́a and Garcı́a-Gómez 2005). Our data are inagreement with Littler and Murray (1975) that recorded values of 5.5 mg/l

    Figure 7. Cluster and MDS analysis based on the abundance of patellid species.

    Table 2. Average abundances of the species from sites located closer to the outfall (N) and further

    away (F).

    Species Abund. N Abund. F Av. Dis. Ratio Dis. (%) Cum. Dis (%)

    Patella rustica 0.75 18.00 9.13 2.18 23.40 23.40

    Patella caerulea 11.00 94.00 7.77 2.49 19.90 43.30

    Siphonaria pectinata 17.25 115.25 7.01 4.59 17.97 61.27

    Patella ferruginea 0.00 5.50 6.75 1.64 17.29 78.57

    Patella ulyssiponensis 0.50 2.50 4.23 1.13 10.83 89.39

    Patella nigra 6.50 5.75 4.14 1.10 10.61 100.00

    Species are listed in order of decreasing contribution to the average dissimilarity (Av. Dis.) between

    the two groups. The ratio indicates Dis/Standard deviation. The total average dissimilarity between

    groups is 39%.

    389

  • in an outfall point located in San Clemente Island, California, and values of7–8 mg/l, 30 m away. Mean values of turbidity measured inside Ceuta’sharbour are about 0.62 ntu (CEDEX 2000); however, the values measuredin this study near the effluents reached 35 ntu. These high values of tur-bidity, due to the presence of solids and organic matter in suspension mayhave direct negative effects since these can clog the gills of marine organ-isms, such as limpet molluscs. In this sense, Marshall and McQuaid (1989)compared the survival rate of a pulmonate limpet (Siphonaria capensis)with a prosobranchia limpet (Patella granularis) in the presence of sand andlow oxygen concentrations, and found a higher survival of the pulmonatelimpet possibly due to the different breathing strategy. This fact couldexplain the presence of S. pectinata very close to the effluent outfall in thepresent study. Furthermore, Branch (1981) pointed out that siltation may bemore important than salinity in excluding limpets from estuaries.

    Biological data

    There is a lack of studies dealing with the abundance of patellids in areasaffected by sewage disposal. Bishop et al. (2002) found higher densities of the

    Table 3. Summary of results from BIO-ENV analysis.

    k Best variable combination

    1 Turbity 0.871 F. ammonia 0.870 T. ammonia 0.866 Nitrite 0.828

    2 Turbidity 0.944 Turbidity 0.923 F. ammonia 0.893 T. ammonia 0.893

    Phosphate T. ammonia T. ammonia Cu

    3 T. ammonia 0.946 T. ammonia 0.929 F. ammonia 0.907 F. ammonia 0.907

    Turbidity Phosphate T. ammonia T. ammonia

    O.M. Turbidity Turbidity O.M.

    4 F. ammonia 0.960 T. ammonia 0.951 T. ammonia 0.946 F. ammonia 0.927

    T. ammonia Nitrite Nitrate T. ammonia

    Turbidity Turbidity Turbidity Phosphate

    O.M. O.M. O.M. Turbidity

    5 F. ammonia 0.956 T. ammonia 0.953 T. ammonia 0.945 F. ammonia 0.939

    T. ammonia Nitrite Nitrate T. ammonia

    Phosphate Phosphate Phosphate Oxygen

    Turbidity Turbidity Turbidity Turbidity

    O.M. O.M. O.M. O.M.

    6 F. ammonia 0.950 T. ammonia 0.944 T. ammonia 0.943 F. ammonia 0.937

    T. ammonia Nitrite Nitrate T. ammonia

    Phosphate Phosphate Phosphate Phosphate

    Turbidity Turbidity Turbidity pH

    O.M. O.M. O.M. O.M.

    Phosphate (sed) Phosphate (sed) Phosphate (sed) Phosphate (sed)

    Combinations of variables, k at a time, giving the highest rank correlations between biotic and

    environmental similarity matrices are shown with the value of the weighted Spearman rank cor-

    relation coefficient; text in bold type indicate the best combination overall.

    390

  • Figure 8. Graphic representation of the stations, limpet species and environmental measures with

    respect to the first two axes of the canonical correspondence analysis (CCA).

    Table 4. Summary results of the canonical correspondence analysis.

    Axis 1 Axis 2 Axis 3

    Eigenvalue 0.11 0.06 0.01

    Species–environment correlation 0.99 0.99 0.99

    Percentage of species variance 58.3 30.8 6.7

    Correlation with environmental variables

    Free ammonia (ppm) – 0.72* –

    Total ammonia (ppm) 0.79* – –

    Nitrite (ppm) – – –

    Phosphate (ppm) 0.89** – –

    Turbidity (ntu) 0.76* – –

    OM sed. (%) 0.98*** – –

    Phosphate sed. (ppm) � 0.89** – –

    *p

  • limpet Patelloida latistrigata in sites further away from an outfall; Tabladoet al. (1994) found significant lower densities of Siphonaria lessoni near anoutfall point. In the present study, for the six limpet species recorded, thelowest abundances were found close to the outfall, and sites 1 and 2 weredominated by Siphonaria pectinata, which was the most resistant species to thesewage pollution. On the other hand,P. ferruginea was most sensitive to theeffluent, and was absent in regions of low oxygen concentrations, and highconcentrations of ammonia, phosphate and turbidity in the water column. Thislimpet is the most endangered marine invertebrate in the Western Mediterra-nean rocky shores. It has been traditionally considered a K-strategist, associ-ated with clean waters, a long life cycle and a lower reproductive rate (seeGuerra-Garcı́a et al. 2004a). Although several important populations ofP. ferruginea have been found recently in the harbour of Ceuta (Guerra-Garcı́aet al. 2004a, b), the presence of this species on the Iberian Peninsula is ex-tremely reduced; the most recent cites of P. ferruginea in the Iberian Peninsulaare reported by Garcı́a-Gómez (1983) who recorded several individuals inAlgeciras Bay, and Moreno (1992), who found two specimens in Cabo de Gata.It is especially interesting that other species, such as P. nigra and P. ulyssi-ponensis were more abundant in intermediate sites. These higher abundancescould be due to enrichment effects (sensu the Intermediate Disturbance andDynamic Equilibrium Hypotheses) and should be considered at least aspotential components of community structure through e.g. competitive effects.It is also interesting that P. rustica was the greatest contributor to dissimilarity.It is an upper-shore species, usually found well above the other limpet speciesstudied, and may indicate the possible influence of dessication pressures alongthe vertical gradients.For the dominant species, S. pectinata and Patella caerulea, the specimens

    near the discharge point were significantly larger than the individuals locatedfurther away. A combination of several factors (such as the higher inputs oforganic matter and the lower intraspecific and interspecific competition due tolower densities) could explain this pattern. High growth rates in areas affectedby organic enrichment have been recorded for Patella vulgata (Hatton 1938;Fischer-Piette 1948; Lewis and Bowman 1975) and S. pectinata (Voss 1959).Bastida et al. (1971) measured a higher growth rate for S. lessoni inside aharbour area. Liu and Morton (1998) found larger specimens of Patelloidasaccharina and Patelloida pygmaea in polluted areas in comparison tounpolluted sites, and Tablado et al. (1994) recorded higher growth rates inspecimens of S. lessoni placed near sewage outfall than specimens placed innon-polluted areas.Multivariate analysis showed that turbidity, ammonia and phosphate in

    the water column, together with the organic matter in sediment, were theparameters that mainly explained the limpet assemblages. Recent studiesfocused on marine communities of Algeciras Bay, also located in the Strait ofGibraltar, have shown that turbidity is one of the factors negatively affectingthe distribution of benthic assemblages (Sánchez-Moyano et al. 1998).

    392

  • Effects of sewage effluents

    The results of the present study, based on the limpet assemblages, showed a cleargradient of environmental perturbation from the sites near the sewage outfall tothe further away sites. As pointed out by Pearson and Rosenberg (1978), theeffects of a sewage effluent are most pronounced in the vicinity of the outlets anddecrease progressively with increasing distance from the discharge points.Raffaelli and Hawkins (1996) pointed out that most of the small volumes ofeffluent discharge have ecological effects in the first 10 m away from the outfall.Littler and Murray (1975), in a study conducted in San Clement Island, Cali-fornia, indicated pollution effects inside the first 30 m from the effluent, andnormal communities from 90 m away. Terlizzi et al. (2002) provided evidencethat sites located about 100–300 m apart from an outfall located in Apuliancoast, Italy, were similar to each other and they differed from the site locatedin close proximity to the sewage. Lopez-Gappa et al. (1993) found pollutioneffects on intertidal communities 50–100 m away from effluents from the cities ofNecochea and Quequén (Argentina). In the present study, natural conditionswere completely re-established at 64 m from the discharge point.

    Conclusions and environmental implications

    The physicochemical parameters measured both in the water column andsediment showed a clear perturbation due to the presence of the sewage effluentinside the harbour. However, the effect on limpet assemblages is restricted, andfrom 32–64 to 128 m from the point of discharge ‘normal’ conditions arere-established. From a methodological point of view, the use of log2 can beuseful to select and locate the sampling sites in this kind of study, focused onenvironmental gradients.Furthermore, limpet assemblages can be used as a tool to evaluate the

    environmental state of the coast, without the need of using the whole com-munity which would be more time consuming and would require higher costs.In this sense, authorities and government institutions are increasinglydemanding quick and effective environmental studies in coastal areas. This factprecludes developing series of data based on complex matrices of varioustaxonomic groups whose identifications requires great effort and time. A short-term spatial study dealing with only several easy-to-identify limpet species canyield similar results to those obtained with costly physico-chemical analysis.Although further studies are necessary to investigate the ecological prefer-

    ences and responses to pollution of the endangered mollusc Patella ferruginea,this study represents a first approach, showing that this limpet is sensitive tosewage pollution, specially to the increase of turbidity, ammonia and phos-phate, and the decrease of oxygen concentrations in the water column. Theseinitial results should be taken into account in future studies of management

    393

  • and conservation of P. ferruginea. Furthermore, the present work showed thatthe highest densities of P. ferruginea were measured at 32 and 64 m away fromthe outfall, coinciding with the highest densities of other limpets; therefore, thistrend indicates that the main problem for P. ferruginea is the degree of pol-lution, and not interspecific competition with other limpets. This fact should bealso taken into consideration in future programmes of reintroduction orresettling of this endangered limpet.

    Acknowledgements

    Special thanks are due to our colleagues Alexander Roi González, CristinaHuertas and Aurora Ruiz for helping during sampling. The present work wasfunded by the Asamblea de Ceuta, Autoridad Portuaria de Ceuta, and a PhDscholarship FPU AP-3556-2001 (to F. Espinosa) from the Ministry of Edu-cation and Culture of Spain.

    References

    Aversano F.R. 1986. Esperimento di insediamento artificiale di Patella ferruginea Gmelin, 1791

    nelle acque del Golfo di Arzachena (Sardegna settentrionale). Boll. Malacol. 22: 169–170.

    Bastida R., Capezzani A. and Torti M.R. 1971. Fouling organisms in the port of Mar del Plata

    (Argentina). I. Siphonaria lessoni: ecological and biometric aspects. Mar. Biol. 10: 297–307.

    Bishop M.J., Underwood A.J. and Archambault P. 2002. Sewage and environmental impacts on

    rocky shores: necessity of identifying relevant spatial scales. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 236: 121–128.

    Boening D.W. 1999. An evaluation of bivalves as biomonitors of heavy metals pollution in marine

    waters. Environ. Monit. Assess. 55: 459–470.

    Branch G.M. 1981. The biology of limpets: physical factors, energy flow and ecological interac-

    tions. Oceanogr. Mar. Biol. Ann. Rev. 19: 235–380.

    Bresler V., Abelson A., Fishelson L., Feldstein T., Rosenfeld M. and Mokady O. 2003a. Marine

    molluscs in environmental monitoring. I. Cellular and molecular responses. Helgoland Mar. Res.

    57: 157–165.

    Bresler V., Mokady O., Fishelson L., Feldstein T. and Abelson A. 2003b. Marine molluscs in

    environmental monitoring. II. Experimental exposure to selected pollutants. Helgoland Mar.

    Res. 57: 206–211.

    CEDEX 2000. Análisis y medidas complementarias para la gestión del material dragado en el

    muelle de cruceros turı́sticos adosado al Muelle de España. Informe especı́fico, Ministerio de

    Fomento, Madrid, pp. 1–52

    Clarke K.R. 1993. Non-parametric multivariate analyses of changes in community structure. Aust.

    J. Ecol. 18: 117–143.

    Clarke K.R. and Ainsworth M. 1993. A method of linking multivariate community structure to

    environmental variables. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 92: 205–219.

    Clarke K.R. and Green R.H. 1988. Statistical design and analysis for a ‘biological effects’ study.

    Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 46: 213–226.

    Clarke K.R. and Gorley R.N. 2001. PRIMER (Plymouth Routines In Multivariate Ecological

    Research) v5: user manual/tutorial. PRIMER-E, Plymouth.

    Cretella M., Scillitani G., Toscano F., Turella P., Picariello O. and Cataudo A. 1994. Relationships

    between Patella ferruginea Gmelin, 1791 and the other Tyrrhenian species of Patella (Gastro-

    poda: Patellidae). J. Molluscan Stud. 60: 9–17.

    394

  • Dayton P.K. 1984. Processes structuring some marine communities: are they general? In: Strong

    D.R.J., Simberloff D., Abelle L.G. and Thistle A.B. (eds), Ecological Communities: Conceptual

    Issues and the Evidence. Princeton University Press, Princeton, pp. 181–197.

    Dixon W.J. 1983. BMDP Statistical Software. University California Press, Berkeley.

    Estacio F.J., Garcı́a-Adiego E.M., Fa D., Garcı́a-Gómez J.C., Daza J.L., Hortas F. and Gómez-

    Ariza J.L. 1997. Ecological analysis in a polluted area of Algeciras Bay (Southern Spain):

    external ‘versus’ internal outfalls and environmental implications. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 34: 780–793.

    Fa D.A., Finlayson C., Garcı́a-Adiego E., Sánchez-Moyano J.E. and Garcı́a-Gómez J.C. 2002.

    Influence of some environmental factors on the structure and distribution of the rocky shore

    macrobenthic communities in the Bay of Gibraltar: preliminary results. Almoraima 28: 73–88.

    Feldstein T., Kashman Y., Abelson A., Fishelson L., Mokady O., Bresler V. and Erel Y. 2003.

    Marine molluscs in environmental monitoring. III. Trace metals and organic pollutants in ani-

    mal tissue and sediments. Helgoland Mar. Res. 57: 212–219.

    Fischer-Piette E. 1948. Sur les élements de prosperité des Patelles et sur leur spécificité. J. Conchol.

    84: 45–96.

    Foe C. and Knight A. 1987. Assessment of the biological impact of point-source discharges

    employing asiatic clams. Arch. Environ. Contam. Toxicol. 16: 39–51.

    Garcı́a-Gómez J.C. 1983. Estudio comparado de las tanatocenosis y biocenosis malacológicas del

    Estrecho de Gibraltar y áreas próximas. Iberus 3: 75–90.

    Gerlach S.A. 1981. Marine Pollution. Diagnosis and Therapy. Springer-Verlag, Berlin.

    Gray J.S. 1982. Effects of pollutants on marine ecosystems. Netherlands J. Sea Res. 16: 424–443.

    Guerra-Garcı́a J.M. 2001. Análisis integrado de las perturbaciones antropogénicas en sedimentos

    del Puerto de Ceuta. Efecto sobre las comunidades macrobentónicas e implicaciones ambien-

    tales. Ph.D. thesis. University of Sevilla, Sevilla, 346 pp.

    Guerra-Garcı́a J.M. and Garcı́a-Gómez J.C. 2001. The spatial distribution of the Caprellidea

    (Crustacea: Amphipoda): a stress bioindicator in Ceuta (North Africa, Gibraltar area). PSZNI

    Mar. Ecol. 22: 357–367.

    Guerra-Garcı́a J.M., Gonzalez-Vila F.J. and Garcia-Gomez J.C. 2003. Aliphatic hydrocarbon

    pollution and macrobenthic assemblages in Ceuta harbour: a multivariate approach. Mar. Ecol.

    Prog. Ser. 263: 127–138.

    Guerra-Garcı́a J.M. and Garcı́a-Gómez J.C. 2004a. Soft bottom mollusc assemblages and pollu-

    tion in a harbour with two opposing entrances. Estuarine Coast. Shelf Sci. 60: 273–283.

    Guerra-Garcı́a J.M. and Garcı́a-Gómez J.C. 2004b. Crustacean assemblages and sediment pollu-

    tion in an exceptional case study: a harbour with two opposing entrances. Crustaceana 77: 353–

    370.

    Guerra-Garcı́a J.M. and Garcı́a-Gómez J.C. 2004c. Polychaete assemblages and sediment pollution

    in a harbour with two opposing entrances. Helgoland Mar. Res. 58: 183–191.

    Guerra-Garcı́a J.M., Corzo J., Espinosa F. and Garcı́a-Gómez J.C. 2004a. Assessing habitat use of

    the endangered marine mollusc Patella ferruginea (Gatropoda, Patellidae) in northern Africa:

    preliminary results and implications for conservation. Biol. Conserv. 116: 319–326.

    Guerra-Garcı́a J.M., Corzo J., Espinosa F., Fa D. and Garcı́a-Gómez J.C. 2004b. Extinction risk

    and harbours as marine reserves? J. Mollus. Stud. 70: 116–118.

    Guerra-Garcı́a J.M. and Garcı́a-Gómez J.C. 2005. Oxygen levels versus chemical pollutants: do

    they have similar influence on macrofaunal assemblages? A case study in a harbour with two

    opposing entrances Environ. Pollut. 135: 281–291.

    Guerra-Garcı́a J.M. and Garcı́a-Gómez J.C. 2005. Assessing pollution levels in sediments of an

    exceptional harbour with two opposing entrances. Environmental implications. J. Environ.

    Manage. 77: 1–11.

    Hatton H. 1938. Essais de bionomie explicative sur quelques especes intercoidales d’algues et

    d’animaux. Annal. l’Inst. Oceanogr. Monaco 17: 241–348.

    Koufopanou V., Reid D.G., Ridgway S.A. and Thomas R.H. 1999. A molecular phylogeny of the

    patellid limpets (Gastropoda: Patellidae) and its implications for the origins of their antitropical

    distribution. Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 11: 138–156.

    395

  • Kruskal J.B. and Wish M. 1978. Multidimensional Scaling. Sage Publications, Beverley Hills,

    California.

    Laborel-Deguen F. and Laborel J. 1991. Statut de Patella ferruginea Gmelin en Mediterranee. In:

    Boudouresque C.F., Avon M. and Gravez V. (eds), Les spèces marines à protéger en Médi-

    terranée. GIS Posidonie Publishers, Marseille, pp. 91–103.

    Lewis J.R. and Bowman R.S. 1975. Local habitat-induced variations in the population dynamics of

    Patella vulgata L. J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol. 17: 165–203.

    Littler M.M. and Murray S.N. 1975. Impact of sewage on the distribution, abundance and com-

    munity structure of rocky intertidal macro-organisms. Mar. Biol. 30: 277–291.

    Liu J.H. and Morton B. 1998. The impacts of pollution on the growth, reproduction and popu-

    lation structure of Hong Kong limpets. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 36: 152–158.

    Lopez-Gappa J.J., Tablado A. and Magaldi N.H. 1990. Influence of sewage pollution on a rocky

    intertidal community dominated by the mytilid Brachidontes rodriguezi. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser.

    63: 163–175.

    Lopez-Gappa J.J., Tablado A. and Magaldi N.H. 1993. Seasonal changes in an intertidal com-

    munity affected by sewage pollution. Environ. Pollut. 82: 157–165.

    Marshall D.J. and McQuaid C.D. 1989. The influence of respiratory responses on the tolerance to

    sand inundation of the limpets Patella granularis L. (Prosobranchia) and Siphonaria capensis Q.

    et G. (Pulmonata). J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol. 128: 191–201.

    May V. 1985. Observations on algal floras close to two sewage outlets. Cunninghamia 1: 385–394.

    McCune B. and Mefford M.J. 1997. PC-ORD. Multivariate Analyses of Ecological Data. Version

    3.0. Mjm Software Design, Gleneden Beach, U.S.A.

    Métodos oficiales de análisis para aguas residuales y suelos 1986. Tomo III. MAPA. Dirección

    general de polı́tica alimentaria, Madrid.

    Moreno D. 1992. Presencia de Patella ferruginea Gmelin 1971 en el Cabo de Gata (Almerı́a, SE

    España). Cuadernos de Investigación Biológica, Bilbao 17: 71.

    Paine R.T. and Levin S.A. 1981. Intertidal landscapes: disturbances and the dynamics of pattern.

    Ecol. Monogr. 51: 145–178.

    Pearson T.H. and Rosenberg R. 1978. Macrobenthic succession in relation to organic enrichment

    and pollution of the marine environment. Oceanogr. Mar. Biol. Annl. Rev. 16: 229–311.

    Pielou E.C. 1966. The measurement of diversity in different types of biological collections. J. Theor.

    Biol. 13: 131–144.

    Raffaelli D. and Hawkins S.J. 1996. Intertidal Ecology. Chapman and Hall, London, pp. 356

    Ramos M.A. 1998. Implementing the Habitats Directive for mollusc species in Spain. J. Conchol.

    Special Publicat. 2: 125–132.

    Ridgway S.A., Reid D.G., Taylor J.D., Branch G.M. and Hodgson A.N. 1998. A cladistic phy-

    logeny of the family Patellidae (Mollusca: Gastropoda). Philos. Trans. Biol. Sci. 353: 1645–1671.

    Sánchez-Moyano J.E., Estacio F.J., Garcı́a-Adiego E.M. and Garcı́a-Gómez J.C. 1998. Las pra-

    deras submarinas de la Bahı́a de Algeciras. Evolución histórica y planes para su restauración y

    conservación. Almoraima 19: 173–180.

    Saı́z-Salinas J.I. 1997. Evaluation of adverse biological effects induced by pollution in the Bilbao

    Estuary (Spain). Environ. pollut. 96: 351–359.

    Shannon C.E. and Weaver W. 1963. The Matemathical Theory of Communication. University of

    Illinois Press, Urbana, Illinois, pp. 117

    Sneath P.H.A. and Sokal R.R. 1973. Numerical Taxonomy. The Principles and Practice of

    Numerical Classification. WH Freeman and Company, San Francisco, pp. 573

    Sousa W.P. 1984. Intertidal mosaics: patch size, propagule availability and spatial variable patterns

    of sucession. Ecology 65: 1918–1935.

    Tablado A., Lopez-Gappa J.J. and Magaldi N.H. 1994. Growth of the pulmonate limpet

    Siphonaria lessoni (Blainville) in a rocky intertidal area affected by sewage pollution. J. Exp.

    Mar. Biol. Ecol. 175: 211–226.

    Templado J. 1996. Patella ferruginea. In: Ramos M.A. (ed.), Inventario de las especies de inver-

    tebrados no artrópodos incluidas en los anejos de la Directiva 92/43/CEE del Consejo. ICONA,

    Spain, pp. 11–15.

    396

  • Templado J. and Moreno D. 1997. La lapa ferrugı́nea. Biológica 6: 80–81.

    Templado J., Calvo M., Garvı́a A., Luque A.A., Maldonado M. and Moro L. 2004. Guı́a de

    invertebrados y peces marinos protegidos por la legislación nacional e internacional. Organismo

    Autónomo Parques Nacionales, Ministerio de Medio Ambiente, Madrid.

    Terlizzi A., Fraschetti S., Guidetti P. and Boero F. 2002. The effects of sewage discharge on shallow

    hard substrate sessile assemblages. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 44: 544–550.

    Underwood A.J. 1997. Experiments in Ecology: Their Logical Design and Interpretation using

    Analysis of Variance. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

    UNEP 1989. State of the Mediterranean marine environment. MAP Tech. Rep. Ser. 28: 34–39.

    Voss N.A. 1959. Studies on the pulmonate gastropod Siphonaria pectinata (Linnaeus) from the

    southeast coast of Florida. Bull. Mar. Sci. 9: 84–99.

    Zmarzly D.L., Stebbins T.D., Pasko D., Duggan R.M. and Barwick K.L. 1994. Spatial patterns

    and temporal succession in soft bottom macroinvertebrate assemblages surrounding an ocean

    outfall on the southern San Diego shelf: relation to anthropogenic and natural events. Mar. Biol.

    118: 293–307.

    397

    /ColorImageDict > /JPEG2000ColorACSImageDict > /JPEG2000ColorImageDict > /AntiAliasGrayImages false /DownsampleGrayImages true /GrayImageDownsampleType /Bicubic /GrayImageResolution 150 /GrayImageDepth -1 /GrayImageDownsampleThreshold 1.50000 /EncodeGrayImages true /GrayImageFilter /DCTEncode /AutoFilterGrayImages true /GrayImageAutoFilterStrategy /JPEG /GrayACSImageDict > /GrayImageDict > /JPEG2000GrayACSImageDict > /JPEG2000GrayImageDict > /AntiAliasMonoImages false /DownsampleMonoImages true /MonoImageDownsampleType /Bicubic /MonoImageResolution 600 /MonoImageDepth -1 /MonoImageDownsampleThreshold 1.50000 /EncodeMonoImages true /MonoImageFilter /CCITTFaxEncode /MonoImageDict > /AllowPSXObjects false /PDFX1aCheck false /PDFX3Check false /PDFXCompliantPDFOnly false /PDFXNoTrimBoxError true /PDFXTrimBoxToMediaBoxOffset [ 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 ] /PDFXSetBleedBoxToMediaBox true /PDFXBleedBoxToTrimBoxOffset [ 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 ] /PDFXOutputIntentProfile (None) /PDFXOutputCondition () /PDFXRegistryName (http://www.color.org?) /PDFXTrapped /False

    /Description >>> setdistillerparams> setpagedevice