SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL MASTER VISION FOR SWANLEY …
Transcript of SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL MASTER VISION FOR SWANLEY …
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X1X
Prepared by Lake Market Research for Sevenoaks District Council
Date: December 2016
This report complies with ISO: 20252 standards and other relevant forms of conduct
SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL
MASTER VISION FOR SWANLEY AND
HEXTABLE
PUBLIC CONSULTATION
WRITTEN REPORT
Appendix 1
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X2X
1 Background, objectives and research context 3
2 Executive summary 8
3 Consultation response profile 10
4 Agreement with the Master Vision 12
5 Summary of all agreement with Master Vision 37
6 Younger age group mini consultation 38
7 Appendices 39
SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL MASTER VISION FOR SWANLEY AND HEXTABLE WRITTEN REPORT
TABLE OF CONTENTS
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X3X
1.1 BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES
Sevenoaks District Council has prepared a ‘Master Vision’ to be used in the
development and regeneration of Swanley and Hextable. This ‘Master Vision’
was informed by the results of a consultation carried out in February 2016
during which a number of priorities were identified.
In order to accurately quantify residents’ views and opinions of the proposals,
a further public consultation was undertaken encompassing an online
questionnaire and self-completion postal questionnaire running from 7th
September to 2nd November 2016.
As part of the consultation, Sevenoaks District Council held six drop in
sessions in Swanley and Hextable and various other events throughout
September and October engaging with different stakeholders. This gave local
people the opportunity to see the Master Vision and understand its place in
planning policy and also talk to SDC staff about the plans. The public
consultation was promoted throughout the area and public participation in the
events was encouraged to enable people to understand the vision and ask any
questions before completing the consultation questionnaire. It is estimated
that these sessions attracted over 1,000 people and additional consultation
questionnaires were also distributed to attendees.
The questionnaire was divided into eight sections with each section including
a detailed description and images (where possible) of the proposals.
Respondents were then asked to indicate their level of agreement with a
number of proposals within each section.
The primary objective was to ascertain and understand the views of residents
and business owners in Swanley and the surrounding areas on the proposed
improvements to Swanley town centre and for the wider Swanley town and
Hextable Parish.
SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL MASTER VISION FOR SWANLEY AND HEXTABLE WRITTEN REPORT
1. BACKGROUND, OBJECTIVES AND RESEARCH CONTEXT
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X4X
In order to achieve this, SDC commissioned Lake Market Research to manage
the survey process including distributing the postal questionnaire, managing
the online survey, processing and analysing all submissions to produce an
independent and impartial report detailing the views of residents.
In addition a smaller scale consultation was undertaken to reach out to and
include views from younger people. With support from the Head Teacher at
Orchards Academy in Swanley, a secondary school serving the local area, staff
from Sevenoaks District Council and Lake Market Research were granted to
access engage with children on this topic.
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X5X
1.2 METHODOLOGY
In order to ensure that all residents had an equal opportunity to give their
view, 9,800 households and businesses within the ‘BR8 7’ and ‘BR8 8’
postcode areas were invited to participate in the consultation via two
methods:
• A self-completion paper questionnaire including a pre-paid return
envelope sent out to a sample of 9,403 households and 397 businesses
in the Swanley and Hextable area (addresses were provided by
Sevenoaks District Council from its Local Land and Property Gazetteer).
• An online version of the questionnaire was published on the Sevenoaks
District Council website for completion.
• To reach the more rural areas of Crockenhill lying outside of the
specified postcode areas, the consultation questionnaires were
distributed with the copies of the parish magazine by Crockenhill Parish
Council; questionnaires were also made available in the Parish Council
offices.
SDC encouraged multiple submissions from households so as to not limit
responses to one response per household; responses from young people were
also encouraged. If names and/or addresses were not provided on the
questionnaires the submissions were excluded as stated on the final page of
the questionnaire. If consultees completed both an online and paper version
of the questionnaire, the latest submission received was processed and any
previous submissions were discarded taking into account that the respondent
may have changed their opinion.
Following a review of the data obtained from the main consultation, a
secondary small consultation was undertaken to engage the younger age
group at Orchards Academy. Staff at the school selected different classes
from years seven, eight and nine (age range 11-14 years) to attend a
presentation given by Sevenoaks District Council and subsequently the pupils
completed a consultation questionnaire on a tablet supplied by Lake Market
Research.
Parents and / or guardians were advised in advance that children attending
the Orchards Academy maybe asked to participate in the consultation.
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X6X
The original consultation questionnaire was adapted slightly to use more child-
friendly terminology; however, care was taken to avoid any alterations in
wording that could change the meaning of the proposals.
Lake Market Research was on hand to assist the children with the operation of
the tablets and answer any queries in relation to the questionnaire.
The survey comprised questions based on a rating scale from ‘Strongly Agree’
to ‘Strongly Disagree’ as well as a ‘This does not affect me’ option. Consultees
were then given the opportunity to submit comments on the proposals in a
free text area within the questionnaire. Lake Market Research has quantified
these by grouping them into common themes.
All research conducted by Lake Market Research abides by the Code of
Conduct and we are a member of the Market Research Society.
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X7X
1.3 SAMPLING
The confidence interval (also called margin of error) is the plus-or-minus
figure usually reported. For example, if you use a confidence interval of 4 and
47% percent of your sample picks an answer you can be "sure" that if you had
asked the question of the entire relevant population between 43% (47-4) and
51% (47+4) would have picked that answer. The confidence level tells you
how sure you can be. It is expressed as a percentage and represents how
often the true percentage of the population who would pick an answer lies
within the confidence interval. The 95% confidence level means you can be
95% certain; the 99% confidence level means you can be 99% certain. Most
researchers use the 95% confidence level.
Confidence Level 95%
Sample Size 1,816
Population 22,485*
Percentage 50%
Confidence Interval +/- 2.2%
*We have assumed that the majority of pupils who participated in the
consultation at Orchards Academy reside in the five wards of Swanley and
Hextable.
When we put together the confidence level and the confidence interval and
using the worse case scenario where the answer is completely divided 50/50,
we can say that we are 95% sure that the true percentage of the population
(22,485) would answer between 47.8% and 52.2% (+/- 2.2%). Therefore, this
can be considered a robust sample.
1.4 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We would like to thank all those who took the time to complete the
consultation documentation.
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X8X
2.1 SUMMARY OF RESULTS
The following summary chart shows the level of agreement and disagreement
with the 27 proposals put forward in the questionnaire.
Some 20 out of the 27 proposals were supported by more than 50% of
residents with 10 proposals being supported by three-quarters of consultees.
Two proposals received over 90% support, namely retaining leisure facilities in
Swanley which achieved the highest level of agreement at 96% followed by
maintaining separate identities of Swanley, Hextable and Swanley Village
through green and open spaces with 93% agreement.
SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL MASTER VISION FOR SWANLEY AND HEXTABLE WRITTEN REPORT
2. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Base: Various for each question (Not relevant & not answered excluded – original base size 1,838)
Summary of agreement & disagreement of main points raised in the consultation
unweighted data - main consultation + Orchards Academy data
63%
50%
81%
51%
61%
84%
72%
59%
96%
50%
58%
35%
42%
22%
50%
79%
71%
73%
93%
83%
76%
49%
53%
68%
77%
77%
85%
37%
50%
19%
49%
39%
16%
28%
41%
4%
50%
42%
65%
58%
78%
50%
21%
29%
27%
7%
17%
24%
51%
47%
32%
23%
23%
15%
Agree Disagree
1,485
1,146
1,349
1,435
1,179
1,333
1,663
1,671
1,747
1,725
1,732
1,456
1,748
1,712
1,653
1,670
1,766
1,708
1,725
1,714
1,763
1,732
1,673
1,715
1,662
1,664
1,648
Base size
692
403
659
353
489
505
175
167
91
113
106
382
90
126
185
168
72
130
113
124
75
106
165
123
176
174
190
Not answered
/ Not relevant
<Q8e> New spacious family homes in Hextable
<Q8c> Landscape improvements to Hextable village green
<Q8b> A new Parish Hub at Hextable Park and redevelop current Parish complex
<Q8f> New homes and accommodation in Hextable for older people
<Q8d> Limit development in Hextable to small scale sites that don't join Swanley
<Q8a>Improved Oasis site with mixed use development, including new housing
<Q7c> Better access to Swanley Park
<Q7b> An improved Swanley Park
<Q7a> Maintain separate identities of Swanley and Hextable
<Q6b> Small business units included in Bevan Place / Working Men's Club site development
<Q6a> Restaurants and retail included in Bevan Place / Working Men's Club site development
<Q5a> An improved education campus at Orchards Academy
<Q4g> New apartments built in Swanley town centre
<Q4f> A new hotel built on a small part of the recreation ground
<Q4e> New/refurbished public/Town Council facilities facing the recreation ground
<Q4d> New public/Town Council facilities built by the recreation ground
<Q4c> New health/medical/leisure facilities built on part of the recreation ground
<Q4b> Better located leisure facilities
<Q4a> Leisure facilities retained in Swanley
<Q3c> Improvements to the Asda block
<Q3b> Shops and restaurants open into the evening
<Q3a> New shops and restaurants in Swanley town centre
<Q2b> Public transport links between Swanley station & garden village
<Q2a> New Swanley station built closer to Swanley town centre
<Q1c> Homes and accommodation for older people
<Q1b> New Swanley Halt station serving the Garden Village
<Q1a> New Garden Village with family homes
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X9X
The proposal with the highest level of disagreement was the idea of building a
hotel on a small part of the recreation ground with 78% of respondents
opposing this and 22% supporting it. Almost two-thirds (65%) of consultees
did not agree with building new public / Town Council facilities alongside
open space on the recreation ground while 35% supported it.
There are three proposals which produced mixed results with 50% of
respondents agreeing and 50% disagreeing, these are:
• The development of a Swanley Halt station serving the new Garden
Village
• Better located leisure facilities
• New apartments built in Swanley town centre
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X10X
In total 1,838 people responded to the consultation. The main consultation
comprised 1,731 submissions of which 1,399 were paper questionnaire
completions and 332 online questionnaire completions; there were 107
submissions from Orchards Academy completed on a tablet. In terms of the
main consultation the majority (99%) of the consultees were either residents
or business owners within the Swanley and Hextable area and we have
assumed that the younger age group who participated in the consultation at
Orchards Academy are residents of the local area.
The respondent profile below shows the breakdown of those responding to
the consultation:
SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL MASTER VISION FOR SWANLEY AND HEXTABLE WRITTEN REPORT
3. CONSULTATION RESPONSE PROFILE
2
Gender
Male 41%
Female 54%
Prefer not answer 5%
Age
Under 16 6%
16 - 17 0%
18 - 24 2%
25 – 34 7%
35 – 44 11%
45 – 54 15%
55 – 64 19%
65 and over 33%
Prefer not answer 9%
Disabled as set out in Equality Act 2010
Yes 11%
No 69%
Prefer not answer 20%
Sevenoaks District Council Wards
1%Incomplete / outside five main wards
Hextable 22%
Swanley Christchurch and Swanley Village
27%
Swanley St Mary's 15%
Swanley White Oak 23%
Crockenhill and Well Hill 6%
Orchards Academy 6%
Profile of respondents
Method of completion
18%Online
Paper 76%
Tablets at Orchards Academy 6%
Base: All answering (1,838)
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X11X
The respondent profile below shows the breakdown of those responding to
the consultation compared to the demographic profile of the local area
according to 2014 population estimates (Mid-2014 Population Estimates for
2014 Wards in England and Wales, Source: Office for National Statistics).
3
GenderConsultation
ResponseProfile of
Area
Male 41% 48%
Female 54% 52%
Prefer not answer 5% 0%
AgeConsultation
ResponseProfile of
Area
Under 16 6% 18%
16 - 17 0% 2%
18 - 24 2% 8%
25 – 34 7% 12%
35 – 44 11% 12%
45 – 54 15% 15%
55 – 64 19% 13%
65 and over 33% 20%
Prefer not answer 9% 0%
Sevenoaks District
Council Wards
Consultation Response
Profile of Area
Hextable 22% 18%
Swanley Christchurch and
Swanley Village27% 26%
Swanley St Mary's 15% 20%
Swanley White Oak 23% 28%
Crockenhill and Well Hill 6% 9%
Profile of respondents vs. profile of area
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X12X
This section of the report summarises the level of agreement or disagreement
with each of the proposals. The following charts show unweighted data
(N=1,838) with consultees indicating their views.
The charts show the level of agreement and disagreement with each proposal.
The ‘Agree’ portion of the charts merge the consultees who selected ‘Strongly
Agree’ and ‘Agree’ within the questionnaire and the ‘Disagree’ portion of the
charts merge consultees who selected ‘Strongly Disagree’ and ‘Disagree’
within the questionnaire.
The respondents who selected ‘This does not affect me’ or chose not to
provide an answer have been excluded from the calculations pertaining to the
percentages used to generate the charts. Therefore, each question has a
different base size (N=various) which is shown adjacent to each proposal in
the charts, there is another column which shows the number of respondents
who are excluded from percentage calculations.
Following the chart illustrating the levels of agreement and disagreement with
each of the proposals, there is an additional chart summarising the free text
comments made in question nine. These charts have been created by grouping
common themes together and quantifying them in order to produce a chart
representing the themes. In total there were comments made on 1,036
questionnaire submissions from the main consultation.
There were several comments made that do not relate to the consultation
proposals so these have been excluded from the report.
SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL MASTER VISION FOR SWANLEY AND HEXTABLE WRITTEN REPORT
4. AGREEMENT WITH MASTER VISION
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X13X
4.1 SWANLEY AS A NEW ‘GARDEN VILLAGE’
Plans for a new Swanley ‘Garden Village’ are described in the consultation as:
The proposals are:
Respondents were asked to indicate their level of agreement with the above
proposals:
Swanley needs a variety of new homes including private housing to meet future needs, whether
these are for first time buyers, families or for people in later life. This means new housing should
be planned in a way that responds to these needs and is supported by a wide range of services
and facilities.
The Master Vision looks at the potential for Swanley to have possible new housing to the east of
Swanley as a new ‘Garden Village’ to reflect the horticultural heritage of the area with improved
transport links and potentially a ‘station halt’. The government has launched plans to promote
Garden Villages. For Swanley, this could mean:
• New spacious family friendly housing
• Housing supported by parks, play spaces, health and education
• Improving green spaces and access from them into the town
• Improved transport links
Q1a - New spacious and family friendly housing (garden village) with play and park areas outside of Swanley town centre Q1b - Garden village to be served by a new linked ‘Swanley Halt’ station (in addition to the existing station) which would aim to reduce congestion and provide an alternative means of transport
Q1c - Homes and accommodation suitable for the needs of older people
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X14X
Almost two-thirds (63%) of respondents agreed with the idea of building new
spacious family friendly housing located in the proposed new garden village.
There was a mixed response to the proposal entailing building a new Swanley
Halt station serving the garden village with both 50% agreeing and
disagreeing.
The majority (81%) of consultees were supportive of the idea of providing
homes and accommodation suitable for the needs of older people.
5
63%
50%
81%
37%
50%
19%
<Q1a> New spacious and family friendly housing
(garden village) with play and park areas outside of
Swanley town centre
<Q1b> Garden village to be served by a new linked
‘Swanley Halt’ station (in addition to the existing
station) which would aim to reduce congestion and
provide an alternative means of transport
<Q1c> Homes and accommodation suitable for the
needs of older people
Agree Disagree
Q1 - Swanley as a new ‘Garden Village’How much do you agree that the Master Vision should include the following?
Base: Various for each question (Not relevant & not answered excluded – original base size 1,838)
1,662
1,664
1,648
Base size
176
174
190
Not
answered / Not
relevant
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X15X
The following chart quantifies the free text comments made relating to proposals for a new Garden Village:
19
74
68
59
54
53
53
48
39
39
31
30
27
25
25
25
21
21
21
9
45
Garden Village free text comments summary
(number of comments made)
Base: All responding to Q9 (1,036); Total number of comments made about the Garden Village (437)
Other
More property to rent needed / quality rental accommodation to be built
Support the idea of Garden Village / more housing
Proposed designs should be high class / innovative / energy efficient / in keeping
Private ownership / owner occupied / avoid buy-to-let
Concerns about length of Master Vision / living in a building site / how will development disruption be managed
Don't want Swanley to become a commuter town / suburb of London / encouraging outsiders
Social housing needed / must include more social housing
No to social housing / town has enough social housing already
Need to attract new families / young professionals / a better class of person / wider range of people
Family homes / houses with gardens / prefer building houses to apartments
Must have adequate parking for residents / more housing will need more parking
Housing for the elderly to downsize / bungalows / supported housing / accessible housing for disabled
Limited development on earmarked sites only / use brownfield / redevelop existing buildings
Pollution / environmental impacts / concerns for wildlife
Housing for locals to stay in area / current residents / young people
No to Garden Village / no more houses to be built / Swanley is big enough / non DCLG compliance
Infrastructure would need to be in place before any development starts
Unsustainable increase in population / too many new people / town overpopulated
Must have affordable housing / starter homes / shared ownership
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X16X
4.2 TRANSPORT
Plans for transport are described in the consultation as:
The proposals are:
Congestion, particularly near the roundabout junction of the M25 and A20 needs to be
improved. However, Swanley is very well placed to make the most of its transport connections.
There are opportunities to improve the quality of, and access to, the railway station and its
connection to the town centre and while improving public transport alternatives to keep more traffic off the roads.
Q2a - A new modern railway station built closer to Swanley town centre with improved pedestrian links Q2b - Fast public transport routes between Swanley station, the town centre and the proposed garden village
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X17X
Respondents were asked to indicate their level of agreement with the above
proposals:
There was a mixed response to the idea of relocating the railway station closer
to the town centre, however, a majority of 51% were in agreement with this.
Fast public transport routes between Swanley station, the town centre and
the proposed garden village were agreed by 61% of respondents.
8
51%
61%
49%
39%
<Q2a> A new modern
railway station built closer
to Swanley town centre
with improved pedestrian
links
<Q2b> Fast public
transport routes between
Swanley station, the town
centre and the proposed
garden village
Agree Disagree
Q2 – TransportHow much do you agree that the Master Vision should include the following?
Base: Various for each question (Not relevant & not answered excluded – original base size 1,838)
1,673
1,715
Base size
165
123
Not
answered
/ Not
relevant
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X18X
The following chart quantifies the free text comments made relating to the proposals for transport:
20
66
5
8
9
11
13
15
16
17
17
22
22
30
30
32
47
51
53
57
136
145
158
198
Transport free text comments summary
(number of comments made)
Base: All responding to Q9 (1,036); Total number of comments made about transport (512)
Second bridge over the railway lines to ease congestion / improve access over rail line
Better rail services / improve links / to London Bridge / Cannon Street
Like the idea of moving station / new station
Other
Modern transport Hub to be created - buses / trains / interchange
Overcrowded trains / railways already at capacity
Improve cycleways / more cycle routes / secure cycle parks / links to London
Improve traffic calming / introduce 20 mph zones / traffic enforcement cameras
Review parking restrictions / bad parking / Illegal parking / commuter parking
Access to Oyster Cards / TFL Travelcards / Freedom Pass / cost of travel is too high
Bus links to and from rail station / improve access / park and ride
Unrealistic to believe new residents will not use cars / that improving public transport will solve situation
Halt Station unnecessary / not convinced would work
Existing station to be improved / updated / more investment / improve access / parking
Improve road maintenance / pavements / paths
Town has to absorb M25 overflow / rat runs / cut throughs
Existing station not far from town / convenient / easy to walk to / less traffic congestion
New access roads in and out / ring road / review issues at M25 J3 / A20 / M20 junctions
Better bus services / more buses / more affordable / more reliable / more and better placed stops
Improve overall road infrastructure / review traffic management / better road layouts and circulation
Don't move station / new station unnecessary / money would be better spent elsewhere
Traffic congestion will increase with development
Roads already gridlocked at peak times / congestion / issues due to Dartford Crossing
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X19X
4.3 SWANLEY TOWN CENTRE
Plans for Swanley town centre are described in the consultation as:
The proposals are:
Swanley town centre has potential for a greater number and range of shops, services and
facilities including new and improved public spaces and streets. There is scope to improve
access to the town centre. Potential investment in the town centre and the redevelopment of
the former Swanley Working Men’s Club site and car park in Bevan Place may provide early
opportunities to help achieve this.
Q3a - An increase and improvement in the range of shops and restaurants on offer Q3b - Shops and restaurants open into the evening Q3c - Improvements to the Asda block including improved, possibly decked car parking
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X20X
Respondents were asked to indicate their level of agreement with the above
proposals:
There was a high level of agreement with the proposal to increase and
improve the range of shops and restaurants available at 84%.
Almost three-quarters (72%) of respondents were in agreement with shops
and restaurants opening into the evening while 59% of consultees supported
the idea of improving the Asda block.
7
84%
72%
59%
28%
41%
16%
<Q3a> An increase and
improvement in the range
of shops and restaurants
on offer
<Q3b> Shops and
restaurants open into the
evening
<Q3c> Improvements to
the Asda block including
improved, possibly
decked car parking
Agree Disagree
Q3 – Swanley Town Centre
How much do you agree that the Master Vision should include the following?
Base: Various for each question (Not relevant & not answered excluded – original base size 1,838)
1,714
1,763
1,732
Base size
124
75
106
Not
answered / Not
relevant
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X21X
The following chart quantifies the free text comments made relating to the proposals for Swanley town centre:
22
93
2
5
6
6
7
7
7
11
18
21
26
3
37
41
43
44
44
5
51
91
94
95
225
Town centre free text comments summary
(number of comments made)
Base: All responding to Q9 (1,036); Total number of comments made about the town centre (480)
Support town centre redevelopment with a hotel
Improve street lighting
No more shops / more retail unnecessary / current shops struggle
Relocate market away from town centre / negative impact
Other
Negative impact on town's businesses
Support town centre redevelopment with new businesses
Need another supermarket / better supermarket / more competition
Business rates too high / expensive shop rents / independent traders put off
Support town centre redevelopment with new shops and restaurants
Competition from other areas / Bluewater / Lakeside / London, etc.
Free car parking in town centre / encourage shoppers / visitors
More car parking needed in town centre / address bad parking / illegal parking
Better standard of restaurants / higher end bars / pubs / greater variety / family friendly
Litter issues / fly tipping / refuse collection / clean up Swanley / more litter bins
No to multi-storey car park
Concerns about increased crime / anti-social behaviour / vandalism
No to more fastfood outlets / all night eateries / town has enough already
Asda impacts negatively on town / puts small shops out of business / litters the town with trollies
No hotel needed
Town centre needs regenerating / facelift / looking shabby / needs updating / tidying up
Town will become an eyesore / unsightly / slum / inner city feel / concrete jungle
Lack of diversity in town centre / wider range of retail / small businesses needed
No 13 floor high-rise buildings / blocks of flats out of place / detrimental environmental impact
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X22X
4.4 NEW HEALTH / MEDICAL CENTRE, LEISURE CENTRE AND OTHER SERVICES
Plans for new health / medical centre, leisure centre and other services are described in the consultation as:
The proposals are:
Q4a - Leisure facilities retained in Swanley Q4b - Better use of the leisure facilities encouraged by locating them more centrally Q4c - New health/medical and leisure facilities built on a small part of the existing recreation ground with the majority of the recreation ground retained as an improved public open space Q4d - New public/town council facilities built alongside open space on the recreation ground Q4e - New or refurbished public/town council facilities facing open space on the recreation ground Q4f - A hotel built on a small part of the existing recreation ground, with the majority of the recreation ground retained as an improved public open space, to take advantage of a relocated railway station Q4g - Development such as apartments in Swanley Town Centre, to reduce pressure on green and open spaces
The Master Vision sets out the potential to make the recreation ground the focus of a new and public space with new health and leisure facilities. There could also be potential for a hotel. The
majority of the recreation ground would be retained as an improved green open space that could
be better used by local people. Any development would be built on the edge of the existing
recreation ground and close to the proposed relocated Swanley station. Any of the recreation
ground used for community facilities would have to be replaced elsewhere in Swanley.
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X23X
Respondents were asked to indicate their level of agreement with the above
proposals:
Leisure facilities being retained in Swanley achieved the highest agreement
level of all 27 proposals with 96% agreeing. By comparison the view on
whether to relocate leisure facilities more centrally was divided with 50% of
respondents agreeing and 50% disagreeing.
58% of respondents supported new health / medical and leisure facilities built
on a small part of the recreation ground with the majority of the recreation
ground being retained as improved public open space.
8
96%
50%
58%
35%
42%
22%
50%
50%
42%
65%
58%
78%
50%
4%<Q4a> Leisure facilities retained in Swanley
<Q4b> Better use of the leisure facilities encouraged by locating them
more centrally
<Q4c> New health/medical and leisure facilities built on a small part of the
existing recreation ground with the majority of the recreation ground
retained as an improved public open space
<Q4d> New public/town council facilities built alongside open space on
the recreation ground
<Q4e> New or refurbished public/town council facilities facing open space
on the recreation ground
<Q4f> A hotel built on a small part of the existing recreation ground, with
the majority of the recreation ground retained as an improved public open
space, to take advantage of a relocated railway station
<Q4g> Development such as apartments in Swanley Town Centre, to
reduce pressure on green and open spaces
Agree Disagree
Q4 – New health / medical centre, leisure centre and other services
How much do you agree that the Master Vision should include the following?
Base: Various for each question (Not relevant & not answered excluded – original base size 1,838)
1,748
1,712
1,653
1,670
1,766
1,708
1,725
Base size
90
126
185
168
72
130
113
Not answered /
Not relevant
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X24X
Just over a third (35%) of respondents agreed with building new public / Town
Council facilities alongside open space on the recreation ground while 65%
disagreed.
In relation to building new or refurbishing existing public / Town Council
facilities facing open space on the recreation ground, 42% of consultees
agreed with this and 58% disagreed.
The proposal with the highest level of disagreement was the idea of building a
hotel on a small part of the recreation ground at 78% although 22% agreed
with this.
Development such as apartments in Swanley town centre received a mixed
response with 50% agreeing and 50% disagreeing.
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X25X
The following chart quantifies the free text comments made relating to the proposals concerning a new health / medical centre, leisure centre and other
services:
24
72
3
4
4
6
10
11
13
18
21
27
29
38
49
64
73
83
123
Health centre, leisure centre, other services free text comments summary
(number of comments made)
Base: All responding to Q9 (1,036); Total number of comments made about the health centre, leisure centre, other services (348)
Other
Support redevelopment of recreation ground
Ice rink
Free and adequate parking at Doctors' surgeries / health centres
Support centralised leisure centre / moving leisure centre
Bowling alley
More facilities for the elderly / clubs / centres
Revamp and reopen Woodlands Centre / preserve for citizens of Swanley to use
Cinema
No new Government offices / current facilities are adequate / refurbish existing sites
Moving leisure centre into town will create more traffic congestion / requires more parking
More facilities for young people / clubs / centres
Already long waiting times to see GP / NHS lists closed at current GP practices
Invest in existing leisure centre / rebuild / modernise
New leisure centre unnecessary / no need to move / easily accessible where it is
Need to build new health centre / new surgeries / increased healthcare provision
Negative impact / strain on existing health infrastructure
No development on recreation ground / land donated to the people of Swanley
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X26X
4.5 EDUCATION
Plans for education are described in the consultation as:
The proposal is:
Respondents were asked to indicate their level of agreement with the above
proposals:
The Master Vision recognises that the Orchards Academy and St Mary’s Primary School are key
education providers. The Master Vision could enable them, if they wished, to improve their
facilities through relocation and redevelopment. The current Local Plan recognises the need for
additional primary school places to meet future demand. It also recognises that Secondary
school facilities should be rebuilt and refurbished to ensure that they are fit for future use.
Q5a - An improved education campus at Orchards Academy, potentially incorporating an improved building for St Mary’s Primary School
9
79% 21%
<Q5a> An improved
education campus at
Orchards Academy,
potentially incorporating an
improved building for St
Mary’s Primary School
Agree Disagree
Q5 – Education
How much do you agree that the Master Vision should include the following?
Base: Various for each question (Not relevant & not answered excluded – original base size 1,838)
1,456
Base size
382
Not answered
/ Not relevant
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X27X
A strong majority of 79% were in agreement with the proposal to improve the
education campus at Orchards Academy.
The following chart quantifies the free text comments made relating to the
proposals for education:
26
33
6
18
69
74
74
Education free text comments summary
(number of comments made)
Base: All responding to Q9 (1,036); Total number of comments made about education (210)
Other
Support school and education proposals (Orchards Academy Campus / modernisation)
Reopen Birchwood Primary School / regenerate / don't use for housing
Reopen Oasis Academy Secondary School / regenerate / don't use for housing
Extra schools will be needed / more school places to cope with increased demand
Negative impact / strain on existing education infrastructure / schools cannot cope currently
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X28X
4.6 NEW GATEWAY TO SWANLEY TOWN CENTRE
Plans for the new Gateway to Swanley town centre are described in the consultation as:
The proposals are:
Sevenoaks District Council recently bought the former Swanley Working Men’s Club site in the
High Street, having owned the neighbouring Bevan Place Car Park for many years.
The Bevan Place Car Park and Working Men’s Club site is designated for housing in the Local
Plan. The Local Plan recognises that this is likely to be best provided by residential apartment
blocks.
Q6a - Restaurants and retail at ground floor level Q6b - Small business units to encourage and support new businesses
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X29X
Respondents were asked to indicate their level of agreement with the above
proposals:
Development of Bevan Place was supported by over two-thirds of consultees.
71% were in agreement with including restaurants and retail at ground floor
level on the former Working Men’s Club site and 73% agreed with developing
small business units to encourage and support new businesses.
12
71%
73% 27%
29%
<Q6a> Restaurants and
retail at ground floor
level
<Q6b> Small business
units to encourage and
support new businesses
Agree Disagree
Q6 – New Gateway to Swanley town centreHow much do you agree that the Bevan Place car park and former Working Men’s Club site which will include housing, should also include the following?
Base: Various for each question (Not relevant & not answered excluded – original base size 1,838)
1,725
1,732
Base size
113
106
Not answered
/ Not
relevant
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X30X
The following chart quantifies the free text comments made relating to proposals for a new Gateway to Swanley town centre:
28
34
5
6
8
16
Gateway free text comments summary
(number of comments made)
Base: All responding to Q9 (1,036); Total number of comments made about the Gateway (61)
Other
Support proposals for Bevan Place / Gateway Development
Bevan Place should be family low-rise homes / 2/3 bed houses / not blocks of flats
Bevan Place to be residential only / no shops or restaurants at ground level
Horizon House development - negative mentions / has been unsaleable / should have been left as offices
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X31X
4.7 GREEN AND OPEN SPACE
Plans for green and open space are described in the consultation as:
The proposals are:
Q7a - To maintain the separate identities of Swanley, Hextable and Swanley Village through green and open spaces Q7b - An improved Swanley Park, including the potential for a new outdoor sports hub on the Birchwood School site Q7c - Better access to Swanley Park from Swanley and Hextable along the Avenue of Limes
The Master Vision sets out to improve access to Swanley Park, potentially including a new car
park on the south side of Swanley Park. It includes possible plans for an all weather path suitable
for cyclists and pedestrians through the Avenue of Limes to enhance access between Swanley
and Hextable. It also includes a possible option of a new outdoor sports hub on the Birchwood
School site.
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X32X
Respondents were asked to indicate their level of agreement with the above
proposals:
Maintaining separate identities of Swanley, Hextable and Swanley Village
through green and open spaces achieved the second highest level of
agreement at 93%.
Some 83% of respondents supported the idea of improving Swanley Park
including the potential for a new outdoor sports hub.
Over three-quarters (76%) of consultees agreed with improving access to
Swanley Park from Swanley and Hextable along the Avenue of Limes.
11
93%
83%
76%
17%
24%
7%
<Q7a> To maintain the
separate identities of
Swanley, Hextable and
Swanley Village through
green and open spaces
<Q7b> An improved
Swanley Park, including
the potential for a new
outdoor sports hub on
the Birchwood School
site
<Q7c> Better access to
Swanley Park from
Swanley and Hextable
along the Avenue of
Limes
Agree Disagree
Q7 – Green and open space
How much do you agree that the Master Vision should include the following?
Base: Various for each question (Not relevant & not answered excluded – original base size 1,838)
1,663
1,671
1,747
Base size
175
167
91
Not
answered
/ Not relevant
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X33X
The following chart quantifies the free text comments made relating to proposals for green and open space:
30
17
21
35
45
78
118
124
126
Green and open space free text comments summary
(number of comments made)
Base: All responding to Q9 (1,036); Total number of comments made about green and open space (366)
Green space is badly maintained / Council to improve green spaces / plant more trees
Preserve unique identity of Swanley Village / no mention of Swanley Village in Master Vision
No building on agricultural land / farmland needs to be preserved
Other
Maintain separation of Swanley Town, Swanley village, Hextable, Crockenhill, Wilmington / avoid urban sprawl
Preserve Swanley's small town feel / rural character / sense of community / heritage
No building on any greenbelt
Preserve green space / parks / open spaces / play areas
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X34X
4.8 HEXTABLE
Plans for Hextable are described in the consultation as:
The proposals are:
Q8a - Opportunity to improve the Oasis Academy site to create new mixed use development, including housing
Q8b - A new Hextable Parish Hub potentially at Hextable Park and redevelopment of the current Parish Council complex Q8c - Landscape improvements to Hextable village green Q8d - New development being limited to smaller scale growth on sites that don’t join Hextable and Swanley Village to Swanley and with supporting infrastructure Q8e - New spacious family homes Q8f - Homes and accommodation suitable for the needs of older people
The Master Vision identifies Swanley and Hextable as two places with their own communities
and social networks. Green spaces and Swanley Park act as a green corridor between Swanley
and Hextable, which should be retained, with access across Swanley and Hextable improved for
all.
The current Local Plan already recognises the need to improve infrastructure in Hextable. This
includes the provision of Primary School places and a single healthcare facility which is needed
to provide capacity for the existing population. There is an opportunity for the redevelopment of
the current Parish Council Complex with a new Hextable Parish hub and Hextable Park.
The Master Vision identifies Hextable village green as an attractive space affected by traffic in
the Dartford Road with some areas that are fenced off, overgrown and unusable. To the west of
the village Hextable Gardens provides an attractive open space linked to the parish office,
former Horticulture College and village hall. This forms part of the wider area of green space
between Swanley and Hextable (including Swanley Park).
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X35X
Respondents were asked to indicate their level of agreement with the above
proposals:
There are notably lower base sizes for the questions in this section of the
consultation concerning Hextable due to a larger proportion of respondents
not choosing to answer or stating that these proposals do not affect them.
In relation to improving the Oasis Academy site to create mixed use
development including housing, 49% agreed with this and 51% disagreed.
Over half (53%) of respondents supported the development of a new
Hextable Parish Hub at Hextable Park and the redevelopment of the current
Parish Council complex.
12
49%
53%
68%
77%
77%
85%
47%
23%
23%
15%
32%
51%<Q8a> Opportunity to improve the Oasis Academy site to
create new mixed use development, including housing
<Q8b> A new Hextable Parish Hub potentially at Hextable
Park and redevelopment of the current Parish Council
complex
<Q8c> Landscape improvements to Hextable village green
<Q8d> New development being limited to smaller scale
growth on sites that don’t join Hextable and Swanley
Village to Swanley and with supporting infrastructure
<Q8e> New spacious family homes
<Q8f> Homes and accommodation suitable for the needs
of older people
Agree Disagree
Q8 – Hextable
How much do you agree that the Master Vision should include the following?
Base: Various for each question (Not relevant & not answered excluded – original base size 1,838)
1,485
1,146
1,349
1,453
1,179
1,333
Base size
353
692
489
403
659
505
Not
answered / Not relevant
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X36X
Over two-thirds (68%) were in agreement with making landscape
improvements to the village green in Hextable.
Over three-quarters (77%) of respondents were in agreement with two
proposals, namely new development being limited to smaller scale growth on
sites that don’t join Swanley and Hextable and the development of new
spacious family homes.
The most supported proposal in this section of the consultation and the
proposal achieving the third highest level of agreement with 85% was
providing homes and accommodation suitable for the needs of older people.
The following chart quantifies the free text comments made relating to the proposals for Hextable:
32
49
3
3
6
10
13
13
14
15
15
16
2
25
33
36
67
Hextable free text comments summary
(number of comments made)
Base: All responding to Q9 (1,036); Total number of comments made about Hextable (174)
Support idea of proposed developments in Hextable
Preserve the Hextable Scout Hut
Leave Avenue of Limes as is / no cycle path / no all weather footpath
Improve traffic calming measures / increase 30 mph zones
New Health Centre for Hextable / improve health services
Address illegal parking / bad parking
New schools for Hextable / Hextable needs a Secondary School / schools expanded
Encourage more independent traders / shops / butchers / greengrocer
Address Hextable's traffic congestion / HGV weight limit
Improve Hextable's road infrastructure / lack of capacity for proposed developments
No development in Hextable Gardens / no to Parish Hub
Other
Respect Hextable's heritage and history / needs sensitive redevelopment
No more development in Hextable / leave it as it is / big enough already
Preserve Hextable's green spaces / village green / views
Preserve Hextable's village feel / rural character / unique identity
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X37X
5.1 SUMMARY CHART FOR ALL PROPOSALS
The summary chart below shows the proportion of respondents agreeing with
the proposals in descending order of level of agreement. 20 out of the 27
proposals achieved majority support at over 50% agreement.
SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL MASTER VISION FOR SWANLEY AND HEXTABLE WRITTEN REPORT
5. SUMMARY OF AGREEMENT WITH MASTER VISION
16
93%
85%
84%
83%
81%
79%
77%
77%
76%
73%
72%
71%
68%
63%
61%
59%
58%
53%
51%
50%
50%
50%
49%
42%
35%
96%
22%
Summary of proposals in descending order of agreement% Agreement (Net: Strongly Agree & Agree)
Base: Various for each question (Not relevant & not answered excluded – original base size 1,838)
1,712
1,670
1,653
1,333
1,748
1,708
1,664
1,715
1,179
1,766
1,714
1,673
1,648
1,435
1,732
1,763
1,725
1,663
1,146
1,349
1,456
1,662
1,671
1,732
1,485
1,747
1,725
Base size
168
505
90
126
185
130
174
123
659
72
124
165
190
403
106
75
113
175
692
489
382
176
167
106
353
91
113
Not answered / Not relevant
<Q4d> New public/Town Council facilities built by the recreation ground
<Q8a>Improved Oasis site with mixed use development, including new housing
<Q4g> New apartments built in Swanley town centre
<Q4f> A new hotel built on a small part of the recreation ground
<Q4e> New/refurbished public/Town Council facilities facing the recreation ground
<Q4b> Better located leisure facilities
<Q1b> New Swanley Halt station serving the Garden Village
<Q2a> New Swanley station built closer to Swanley town centre
<Q8b> A new Parish Hub at Hextable Park and redevelop current Parish complex
<Q4c> New health/medical/leisure facilities built on part of the recreation ground
<Q3c> Improvements to the Asda block
<Q2b> Public transport links between Swanley station & garden village
<Q1a> New Garden Village with family homes
<Q8c> Landscape improvements to Hextable village green
<Q6a> Restaurants and retail included in Bevan Place / Working Men's Club site development
<Q3b> Shops and restaurants open into the evening
<Q6b> Small business units included in Bevan Place / Working Men's Club site development
<Q7c> Better access to Swanley Park
<Q8e> New spacious family homes in Hextable
<Q8d> Limit development in Hextable to small scale sites that don't join Swanley
<Q5a> An improved education campus at Orchards Academy
<Q1c> Homes and accommodation for older people
<Q7b> An improved Swanley Park
<Q3a> New shops and restaurants in Swanley town centre
<Q8f> New homes and accommodation in Hextable for older people
<Q7a> Maintain separate identities of Swanley and Hextable
<Q4a> Leisure facilities retained in Swanley
9160065-01 SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL SWANLEY & HEXTABLE MASTER VISION PUBLIC CONSULTATION WRITTEN REPORT GM 12.12.16
X38X
6.1 YOUNGER AGE GROUP SUMMARY CHART FOR ALL PROPOSALS
The summary chart below shows the level of agreement with the proposals
for the younger age group in the consultation carried out at Orchards
Academy.
SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL MASTER VISION FOR SWANLEY AND HEXTABLE WRITTEN REPORT
6. YOUNGER AGE GROUP MINI CONSULTATION
Base: Various for each question (Not relevant & not answered excluded – original base size 107)
Summary of agreement & disagreement of main points raised in the consultation
unweighted data - Orchards Academy only
84%
82%
96%
78%
91%
93%
93%
78%
92%
79%
79%
52%
68%
50%
72%
88%
93%
78%
89%
86%
82%
79%
65%
74%
75%
89%
88%
16%
18%
4%
22%
9%
7%
7%
22%
8%
21%
21%
48%
32%
50%
28%
12%
7%
22%
11%
14%
18%
21%
35%
26%
25%
11%
12%
Agree Disagree
99
94
91
88
78
92
93
98
98
91
101
105
97
98
91
89
99
102
104
95
101
105
98
99
97
94
101
Base size
13
19
29
8
16
15
14
9
9
9
6
2
10
9
16
18
8
5
3
12
6
2
9
8
10
13
6
Not answered / Not relevant
<Q8e> New spacious family homes in Hextable
<Q8c> Landscape improvements to Hextable village green
<Q8b> A new Parish Hub at Hextable Park and redevelop current Parish complex
<Q8f> New homes and accommodation in Hextable for older people
<Q8d> Limit development in Hextable to small scale sites that don't join Swanley
<Q8a>Improved Oasis site with mixed use development, including new housing
<Q7c> Better access to Swanley Park
<Q7b> An improved Swanley Park
<Q7a> Maintain separate identities of Swanley and Hextable
<Q6b> Small business units included in Bevan Place / Working Men's Club site development
<Q6a> Restaurants and retail included in Bevan Place / Working Men's Club site development
<Q5a> An improved education campus at Orchards Academy
<Q4g> New apartments built in Swanley town centre
<Q4f> A new hotel built on a small part of the recreation ground
<Q4e> New/refurbished public/Town Council facilities facing the recreation ground
<Q4d> New public/Town Council facilities built by the recreation ground
<Q4c> New health/medical/leisure facilities built on part of the recreation ground
<Q4b> Better located leisure facilities
<Q4a> Leisure facilities retained in Swanley
<Q3c> Improvements to the Asda block
<Q3b> Shops and restaurants open into the evening
<Q3a> New shops and restaurants in Swanley town centre
<Q2b> Public transport links between Swanley station & garden village
<Q2a> New Swanley station built closer to Swanley town centre
<Q1c> Homes and accommodation for older people
<Q1b> New Swanley Halt station serving the Garden Village
<Q1a> New Garden Village with family homes
91
60
06
5-0
1 S
EV
EN
OA
KS D
IST
RIC
T C
OU
NC
IL S
WA
NLE
Y &
HE
XT
AB
LE
MA
ST
ER
VIS
ION
PU
BLIC
CO
NSU
LT
AT
ION
WR
ITT
EN
RE
PO
RT
GM
12
.12
.16
X3
9X
SE
VE
NO
AK
S D
IST
RIC
T C
OU
NC
IL M
AS
TE
R V
ISIO
N F
OR
SW
AN
LE
Y A
ND
HE
XT
AB
LE
WR
ITT
EN
RE
PO
RT
7. A
PP
EN
DIC
ES
Base: Various for each question (Not relevant & not answered excluded – original base size 1,838)
Summary of agreement & disagreement of main points raised in the consultation
unweighted data - main consultation + Orchards Academy data
63%
50%
81%
51%
61%
84%
72%
59%
96%
50%
58%
35%
42%
22%
50%
79%
71%
73%
93%
83%
76%
49%
53%
68%
77%
77%
85%
37%
50%
19%
49%
39%
16%
28%
41%
4%
50%
42%
65%
58%
78%
50%
21%
29%
27%
7%
17%
24%
51%
47%
32%
23%
23%
15%
Agree Disagree
1,485
1,146
1,349
1,435
1,179
1,333
1,663
1,671
1,747
1,725
1,732
1,456
1,748
1,712
1,653
1,670
1,766
1,708
1,725
1,714
1,763
1,732
1,673
1,715
1,662
1,664
1,648
Base size
692
403
659
353
489
505
175
167
91
113
106
382
90
126
185
168
72
130
113
124
75
106
165
123
176
174
190
Not answered / Not relevant
<Q8e> New spacious family homes in Hextable
<Q8c> Landscape improvements to Hextable village green
<Q8b> A new Parish Hub at Hextable Park and redevelop current Parish complex
<Q8f> New homes and accommodation in Hextable for older people
<Q8d> Limit development in Hextable to small scale sites that don't join Swanley
<Q8a>Improved Oasis site with mixed use development, including new housing
<Q7c> Better access to Swanley Park
<Q7b> An improved Swanley Park
<Q7a> Maintain separate identities of Swanley and Hextable
<Q6b> Small business units included in Bevan Place / Working Men's Club site development
<Q6a> Restaurants and retail included in Bevan Place / Working Men's Club site development
<Q5a> An improved education campus at Orchards Academy
<Q4g> New apartments built in Swanley town centre
<Q4f> A new hotel built on a small part of the recreation ground
<Q4e> New/refurbished public/Town Council facilities facing the recreation ground
<Q4d> New public/Town Council facilities built by the recreation ground
<Q4c> New health/medical/leisure facilities built on part of the recreation ground
<Q4b> Better located leisure facilities
<Q4a> Leisure facilities retained in Swanley
<Q3c> Improvements to the Asda block
<Q3b> Shops and restaurants open into the evening
<Q3a> New shops and restaurants in Swanley town centre
<Q2b> Public transport links between Swanley station & garden village
<Q2a> New Swanley station built closer to Swanley town centre
<Q1c> Homes and accommodation for older people
<Q1b> New Swanley Halt station serving the Garden Village
<Q1a> New Garden Village with family homes
91
60
06
5-0
1 S
EV
EN
OA
KS D
IST
RIC
T C
OU
NC
IL S
WA
NLE
Y &
HE
XT
AB
LE
MA
ST
ER
VIS
ION
PU
BLIC
CO
NSU
LT
AT
ION
WR
ITT
EN
RE
PO
RT
GM
12
.12
.16
X4
0X
19
74
68
59
54
53
53
48
39
39
31
30
27
25
25
25
21
21
21
9
45
Garden Village free text comments summary
(number of comments made)
Base: All responding to Q9 (1,036); Total number of comments made about the Garden Village (437)
Other
More property to rent needed / quality rental accommodation to be built
Support the idea of Garden Village / more housing
Proposed designs should be high class / innovative / energy efficient / in keeping
Private ownership / owner occupied / avoid buy-to-let
Concerns about length of Master Vision / living in a building site / how will development disruption be managed
Don't want Swanley to become a commuter town / suburb of London / encouraging outsiders
Social housing needed / must include more social housing
No to social housing / town has enough social housing already
Need to attract new families / young professionals / a better class of person / wider range of people
Family homes / houses with gardens / prefer building houses to apartments
Must have adequate parking for residents / more housing will need more parking
Housing for the elderly to downsize / bungalows / supported housing / accessible housing for disabled
Limited development on earmarked sites only / use brownfield / redevelop existing buildings
Pollution / environmental impacts / concerns for wildlife
Housing for locals to stay in area / current residents / young people
No to Garden Village / no more houses to be built / Swanley is big enough / non DCLG compliance
Infrastructure would need to be in place before any development starts
Unsustainable increase in population / too many new people / town overpopulated
Must have affordable housing / starter homes / shared ownership
91
60
06
5-0
1 S
EV
EN
OA
KS D
IST
RIC
T C
OU
NC
IL S
WA
NLE
Y &
HE
XT
AB
LE
MA
ST
ER
VIS
ION
PU
BLIC
CO
NSU
LT
AT
ION
WR
ITT
EN
RE
PO
RT
GM
12
.12
.16
X4
1X
20
66
5
8
9
11
13
15
16
17
17
22
22
30
30
32
47
51
53
57
136
145
158
198
Transport free text comments summary
(number of comments made)
Base: All responding to Q9 (1,036); Total number of comments made about transport (512)
Second bridge over the railway lines to ease congestion / improve access over rail line
Better rail services / improve links / to London Bridge / Cannon Street
Like the idea of moving station / new station
Other
Modern transport Hub to be created - buses / trains / interchange
Overcrowded trains / railways already at capacity
Improve cycleways / more cycle routes / secure cycle parks / links to London
Improve traffic calming / introduce 20 mph zones / traffic enforcement cameras
Review parking restrictions / bad parking / Illegal parking / commuter parking
Access to Oyster Cards / TFL Travelcards / Freedom Pass / cost of travel is too high
Bus links to and from rail station / improve access / park and ride
Unrealistic to believe new residents will not use cars / that improving public transport will solve situation
Halt Station unnecessary / not convinced would work
Existing station to be improved / updated / more investment / improve access / parking
Improve road maintenance / pavements / paths
Town has to absorb M25 overflow / rat runs / cut throughs
Existing station not far from town / convenient / easy to walk to / less traffic congestion
New access roads in and out / ring road / review issues at M25 J3 / A20 / M20 junctions
Better bus services / more buses / more affordable / more reliable / more and better placed stops
Improve overall road infrastructure / review traffic management / better road layouts and circulation
Don't move station / new station unnecessary / money would be better spent elsewhere
Traffic congestion will increase with development
Roads already gridlocked at peak times / congestion / issues due to Dartford Crossing
22
93
2
5
6
6
7
7
7
11
18
21
26
3
37
41
43
44
44
5
51
91
94
95
225
Town centre free text comments summary
(number of comments made)
Base: All responding to Q9 (1,036); Total number of comments made about the town centre (480)
Support town centre redevelopment with a hotel
Improve street lighting
No more shops / more retail unnecessary / current shops struggle
Relocate market away from town centre / negative impact
Other
Negative impact on town's businesses
Support town centre redevelopment with new businesses
Need another supermarket / better supermarket / more competition
Business rates too high / expensive shop rents / independent traders put off
Support town centre redevelopment with new shops and restaurants
Competition from other areas / Bluewater / Lakeside / London, etc.
Free car parking in town centre / encourage shoppers / visitors
More car parking needed in town centre / address bad parking / illegal parking
Better standard of restaurants / higher end bars / pubs / greater variety / family friendly
Litter issues / fly tipping / refuse collection / clean up Swanley / more litter bins
No to multi-storey car park
Concerns about increased crime / anti-social behaviour / vandalism
No to more fastfood outlets / all night eateries / town has enough already
Asda impacts negatively on town / puts small shops out of business / litters the town with trollies
No hotel needed
Town centre needs regenerating / facelift / looking shabby / needs updating / tidying up
Town will become an eyesore / unsightly / slum / inner city feel / concrete jungle
Lack of diversity in town centre / wider range of retail / small businesses needed
No 13 floor high-rise buildings / blocks of flats out of place / detrimental environmental impact
91
60
06
5-0
1 S
EV
EN
OA
KS D
IST
RIC
T C
OU
NC
IL S
WA
NLE
Y &
HE
XT
AB
LE
MA
ST
ER
VIS
ION
PU
BLIC
CO
NSU
LT
AT
ION
WR
ITT
EN
RE
PO
RT
GM
12
.12
.16
X4
2X
24
72
3
4
4
6
10
11
13
18
21
27
29
38
49
64
73
83
123
Health centre, leisure centre, other services free text comments summary
(number of comments made)
Base: All responding to Q9 (1,036); Total number of comments made about the health centre, leisure centre, other services (348)
Other
Support redevelopment of recreation ground
Ice rink
Free and adequate parking at Doctors' surgeries / health centres
Support centralised leisure centre / moving leisure centre
Bowling alley
More facilities for the elderly / clubs / centres
Revamp and reopen Woodlands Centre / preserve for citizens of Swanley to use
Cinema
No new Government offices / current facilities are adequate / refurbish existing sites
Moving leisure centre into town will create more traffic congestion / requires more parking
More facilities for young people / clubs / centres
Already long waiting times to see GP / NHS lists closed at current GP practices
Invest in existing leisure centre / rebuild / modernise
New leisure centre unnecessary / no need to move / easily accessible where it is
Need to build new health centre / new surgeries / increased healthcare provision
Negative impact / strain on existing health infrastructure
No development on recreation ground / land donated to the people of Swanley
91
60
06
5-0
1 S
EV
EN
OA
KS D
IST
RIC
T C
OU
NC
IL S
WA
NLE
Y &
HE
XT
AB
LE
MA
ST
ER
VIS
ION
PU
BLIC
CO
NSU
LT
AT
ION
WR
ITT
EN
RE
PO
RT
GM
12
.12
.16
X4
3X
26
33
6
18
69
74
74
Education free text comments summary
(number of comments made)
Base: All responding to Q9 (1,036); Total number of comments made about education (210)
Other
Support school and education proposals (Orchards Academy Campus / modernisation)
Reopen Birchwood Primary School / regenerate / don't use for housing
Reopen Oasis Academy Secondary School / regenerate / don't use for housing
Extra schools will be needed / more school places to cope with increased demand
Negative impact / strain on existing education infrastructure / schools cannot cope currently
91
60
06
5-0
1 S
EV
EN
OA
KS D
IST
RIC
T C
OU
NC
IL S
WA
NLE
Y &
HE
XT
AB
LE
MA
ST
ER
VIS
ION
PU
BLIC
CO
NSU
LT
AT
ION
WR
ITT
EN
RE
PO
RT
GM
12
.12
.16
X4
4X
28
34
5
6
8
16
Gateway free text comments summary
(number of comments made)
Base: All responding to Q9 (1,036); Total number of comments made about the Gateway (61)
Other
Support proposals for Bevan Place / Gateway Development
Bevan Place should be family low-rise homes / 2/3 bed houses / not blocks of flats
Bevan Place to be residential only / no shops or restaurants at ground level
Horizon House development - negative mentions / has been unsaleable / should have been left as offices
91
60
06
5-0
1 S
EV
EN
OA
KS D
IST
RIC
T C
OU
NC
IL S
WA
NLE
Y &
HE
XT
AB
LE
MA
ST
ER
VIS
ION
PU
BLIC
CO
NSU
LT
AT
ION
WR
ITT
EN
RE
PO
RT
GM
12
.12
.16
X4
5X
30
17
21
35
45
78
118
124
126
Green and open space free text comments summary
(number of comments made)
Base: All responding to Q9 (1,036); Total number of comments made about green and open space (366)
Green space is badly maintained / Council to improve green spaces / plant more trees
Preserve unique identity of Swanley Village / no mention of Swanley Village in Master Vision
No building on agricultural land / farmland needs to be preserved
Other
Maintain separation of Swanley Town, Swanley village, Hextable, Crockenhill, Wilmington / avoid urban sprawl
Preserve Swanley's small town feel / rural character / sense of community / heritage
No building on any greenbelt
Preserve green space / parks / open spaces / play areas
91
60
06
5-0
1 S
EV
EN
OA
KS D
IST
RIC
T C
OU
NC
IL S
WA
NLE
Y &
HE
XT
AB
LE
MA
ST
ER
VIS
ION
PU
BLIC
CO
NSU
LT
AT
ION
WR
ITT
EN
RE
PO
RT
GM
12
.12
.16
X4
6X
32
49
3
3
6
10
13
13
14
15
15
16
2
25
33
36
67
Hextable free text comments summary
(number of comments made)
Base: All responding to Q9 (1,036); Total number of comments made about Hextable (174)
Support idea of proposed developments in Hextable
Preserve the Hextable Scout Hut
Leave Avenue of Limes as is / no cycle path / no all weather footpath
Improve traffic calming measures / increase 30 mph zones
New Health Centre for Hextable / improve health services
Address illegal parking / bad parking
New schools for Hextable / Hextable needs a Secondary School / schools expanded
Encourage more independent traders / shops / butchers / greengrocer
Address Hextable's traffic congestion / HGV weight limit
Improve Hextable's road infrastructure / lack of capacity for proposed developments
No development in Hextable Gardens / no to Parish Hub
Other
Respect Hextable's heritage and history / needs sensitive redevelopment
No more development in Hextable / leave it as it is / big enough already
Preserve Hextable's green spaces / village green / views
Preserve Hextable's village feel / rural character / unique identity
91
60
06
5-0
1 S
EV
EN
OA
KS D
IST
RIC
T C
OU
NC
IL S
WA
NLE
Y &
HE
XT
AB
LE
MA
ST
ER
VIS
ION
PU
BLIC
CO
NSU
LT
AT
ION
WR
ITT
EN
RE
PO
RT
GM
12
.12
.16
X4
7X
16
93%
85%
84%
83%
81%
79%
77%
77%
76%
73%
72%
71%
68%
63%
61%
59%
58%
53%
51%
50%
50%
50%
49%
42%
35%
96%
22%
Summary of proposals in descending order of agreement% Agreement (Net: Strongly Agree & Agree)
Base: Various for each question (Not relevant & not answered excluded – original base size 1,838)
1,712
1,670
1,653
1,333
1,748
1,708
1,664
1,715
1,179
1,766
1,714
1,673
1,648
1,435
1,732
1,763
1,725
1,663
1,146
1,349
1,456
1,662
1,671
1,732
1,485
1,747
1,725
Base size
168
505
90
126
185
130
174
123
659
72
124
165
190
403
106
75
113
175
692
489
382
176
167
106
353
91
113
Not answered / Not relevant
<Q4d> New public/Town Council facilities built by the recreation ground
<Q8a>Improved Oasis site with mixed use development, including new housing
<Q4g> New apartments built in Swanley town centre
<Q4f> A new hotel built on a small part of the recreation ground
<Q4e> New/refurbished public/Town Council facilities facing the recreation ground
<Q4b> Better located leisure facilities
<Q1b> New Swanley Halt station serving the Garden Village
<Q2a> New Swanley station built closer to Swanley town centre
<Q8b> A new Parish Hub at Hextable Park and redevelop current Parish complex
<Q4c> New health/medical/leisure facilities built on part of the recreation ground
<Q3c> Improvements to the Asda block
<Q2b> Public transport links between Swanley station & garden village
<Q1a> New Garden Village with family homes
<Q8c> Landscape improvements to Hextable village green
<Q6a> Restaurants and retail included in Bevan Place / Working Men's Club site development
<Q3b> Shops and restaurants open into the evening
<Q6b> Small business units included in Bevan Place / Working Men's Club site development
<Q7c> Better access to Swanley Park
<Q8e> New spacious family homes in Hextable
<Q8d> Limit development in Hextable to small scale sites that don't join Swanley
<Q5a> An improved education campus at Orchards Academy
<Q1c> Homes and accommodation for older people
<Q7b> An improved Swanley Park
<Q3a> New shops and restaurants in Swanley town centre
<Q8f> New homes and accommodation in Hextable for older people
<Q7a> Maintain separate identities of Swanley and Hextable
<Q4a> Leisure facilities retained in Swanley
91
60
06
5-0
1 S
EV
EN
OA
KS D
IST
RIC
T C
OU
NC
IL S
WA
NLE
Y &
HE
XT
AB
LE
MA
ST
ER
VIS
ION
PU
BLIC
CO
NSU
LT
AT
ION
WR
ITT
EN
RE
PO
RT
GM
12
.12
.16
X4
8X
Base: Various for each question (Not relevant & not answered excluded – original base size 107)
Summary of agreement & disagreement of main points raised in the consultation
unweighted data - Orchards Academy only
84%
82%
96%
78%
91%
93%
93%
78%
92%
79%
79%
52%
68%
50%
72%
88%
93%
78%
89%
86%
82%
79%
65%
74%
75%
89%
88%
16%
18%
4%
22%
9%
7%
7%
22%
8%
21%
21%
48%
32%
50%
28%
12%
7%
22%
11%
14%
18%
21%
35%
26%
25%
11%
12%
Agree Disagree
99
94
91
88
78
92
93
98
98
91
101
105
97
98
91
89
99
102
104
95
101
105
98
99
97
94
101
Base size
13
19
29
8
16
15
14
9
9
9
6
2
10
9
16
18
8
5
3
12
6
2
9
8
10
13
6
Not answered
/ Not relevant
<Q8e> New spacious family homes in Hextable
<Q8c> Landscape improvements to Hextable village green
<Q8b> A new Parish Hub at Hextable Park and redevelop current Parish complex
<Q8f> New homes and accommodation in Hextable for older people
<Q8d> Limit development in Hextable to small scale sites that don't join Swanley
<Q8a>Improved Oasis site with mixed use development, including new housing
<Q7c> Better access to Swanley Park
<Q7b> An improved Swanley Park
<Q7a> Maintain separate identities of Swanley and Hextable
<Q6b> Small business units included in Bevan Place / Working Men's Club site development
<Q6a> Restaurants and retail included in Bevan Place / Working Men's Club site development
<Q5a> An improved education campus at Orchards Academy
<Q4g> New apartments built in Swanley town centre
<Q4f> A new hotel built on a small part of the recreation ground
<Q4e> New/refurbished public/Town Council facilities facing the recreation ground
<Q4d> New public/Town Council facilities built by the recreation ground
<Q4c> New health/medical/leisure facilities built on part of the recreation ground
<Q4b> Better located leisure facilities
<Q4a> Leisure facilities retained in Swanley
<Q3c> Improvements to the Asda block
<Q3b> Shops and restaurants open into the evening
<Q3a> New shops and restaurants in Swanley town centre
<Q2b> Public transport links between Swanley station & garden village
<Q2a> New Swanley station built closer to Swanley town centre
<Q1c> Homes and accommodation for older people
<Q1b> New Swanley Halt station serving the Garden Village
<Q1a> New Garden Village with family homes