Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in...

46
Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading Dongwook Yoon 1,2 , Ken Hinckley 1 , Hrvoje Benko 1 , François Guimbretière 1,2 , Pourang Irani 1,3 , Michel Pahud 1 , and Marcel Gavriliu 1 1 2 3

Transcript of Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in...

Page 1: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility

for Active Reading

Dongwook Yoon1,2, Ken Hinckley1, Hrvoje Benko1, François Guimbretière1,2,

Pourang Irani1,3, Michel Pahud1, and Marcel Gavriliu1

1

2

3

Page 2: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Physical Manipulation of Objects

https://www.flickr.com/photos/craigmyranphotography

Page 3: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Proactive knowledge construction tasks:

Supporting Active Reading

https://www.flickr.com/photos/cityyear

Page 4: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Supporting Active Reading

https://www.flickr.com/photos/difei

Proactive knowledge construction tasks:

Nonlinear Navigation

Page 5: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Supporting Active Reading

Proactive knowledge construction tasks:

Nonlinear Navigation

Cross-referencing content

Page 6: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Supporting Active Reading

Proactive knowledge construction tasks:

Nonlinear Navigation

Cross-referencing content

Working together over a document

https://www.flickr.com/photos/pennstatelive

Page 7: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Supporting Active Reading

Maintaining the Flow of Reading

Needs for effective UI

https://www.flickr.com/photos/stemonx

Page 8: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Embodied Interactions for Active Reading

https://www.flickr.com/photos/fanz

Page 9: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Embodied Interactions for Active Reading

Turning pages

Page 10: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Embodied Interactions for Active Reading

Turning pages

Lifting for a closer look

https://www.flickr.com/photos/28032587@N06/

Page 11: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Embodied Interactions for Active Reading

Turning pages

Lifting for a closer look

Multiple document layout

https://www.flickr.com/photos/34038246@N02

Page 12: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Embodied Interactions for Active Reading

https://www.flickr.com/photos/frosch50

Turning pages

Lifting for a closer look

Multiple document layout

Orienting toward others

Page 13: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Micro-mobility:

Orienting and repositioning physical artifacts

Page 14: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Grasp in Micro-mobility:

‘Hand grips’ coming into play

Page 15: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Grasp + Micro-mobility Interactions

Page 16: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Grasp + Micro-mobility Interactions

Page 17: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Grasp + Micro-mobility Interactions

Page 18: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Formative Study:

Competitionmemorization /

guessing games

Presentationreading and explaining

infographics

Cooperationdiscussion over a shared

infographics

We Know Too Little About Grasp + Micro-mobility Actions.

Observing Naturally Occurring

Grasp + Micro-mobility in Document Work

Page 19: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Formative Study:Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work

Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital bias

Acrylic tablet mock-ups (iPad air or mini sized and weighted)

Page 20: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Observed Behaviors:

Lateral swing for face-to-face handoff

Page 21: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Observed Behaviors:

Bimanual symmetric grip

for immersive reading

Page 22: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Observed Behaviors:

Bimanual symmetric grip

for immersive reading

Thumbing indicates

locus of attention

Page 23: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Sensing System for Grasp + Micro-mobility

Interactions

Tablet (11.6” Samsung ATIV tablet, 337×197×16 mm, 1.4 kg)

Capacitive Sensor Array (Back and Edges) (44×26, 50Hz)

Inertial Sensors (3-DOF, 100Hz)

Page 24: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Recognizing Multi-hand Grasp

De-noise

Segment

Classify

Thumb Left Edge

Thumb Right

Page 25: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital
Page 26: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Marquardt et al.’s

Micro-mobility

Interaction

(2012)

Designing Interactions: Design space

Single User Multiple User

Sin

gle

Dev

ice

Mu

ltip

le D

evic

e

Page 27: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Face-to-Face Handoff (Multi-User, Single-Device)

Page 28: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Face-to-Face Handoff (Multi-User, Single-Device)

Page 29: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Face-to-Face Handoff (Multi-User, Single-Device)

Page 30: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Immersive Reading (Single-User, Single-Device)

Page 31: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Immersive Reading (Single-User, Single-Device)

Page 32: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Thumb Bookmark with ‘Tip-to-Flip’(Single-User, Single-Device)

Page 33: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Thumb Bookmark with ‘Tip-to-Flip’(Single-User, Single-Device)

Page 34: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Fine-Grained Reference + Hold to Refer Back(Single-user, Multi-device)

Page 35: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Fine-Grained Reference + Hold to Refer Back(Single-user, Multi-device)

Page 36: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Evaluation Results and Design Insights:Familiarity of Natural Grasp + Micro-mobility Interactions

Page 37: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Evaluation Results and Design Insights:Context sensing vs. Gesture interaction

Page 38: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Evaluation Results and Design Insights:Capturing flexibility and diversity of behaviors

Comprehensive recognition technique,

or

Not recognizing it by design

Side-by-side hand-off

Page 39: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Conclusion and Takeaway

Capturing Naturally Occurring Grasp + Micro-mobility

behaviors provides a Mutually Reinforcing Signal of

User Context

Observational Findings from the Behavioral Study

Handoff, Immersive reading, Thumbing

Design Space and Interaction Techniques

Single / Multi-user, and Single / Multi-device

Combination of Grasp and Micro-mobility

Not just about grip, nor just about movements

Page 40: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Supplementary Slides

Page 41: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Related Work

Micro-mobility: Orienting and repositioning in collaboration

+ Grasp, + Individual level micro-mobility

Grasp Sensing: Bezel, Back-of-device touch

Entire back surface and sides touch + inertial motion

Grasp Applications: Handedness, Screen orientation and virtual

keyboard,

Grip-dependent functions, Front + back gestures

Active reading contexts

(Luff and Heath, 98, Marquardt et al., 2012, Greenberg et al., 99)

(Kim et al., 2013) (Wolf et al., 2012, Noor et al., 2014)

(Wimmer et al., 2009) (Cheng et al., 2012, Cheng et al., 2013)

(Kim et al., 2006, Taylor et al., 2009, Wimmer, 2011) (Wolf et al., 2012, Noor et al., 2014)

Page 42: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Observed Behaviors: Grips

Thumb Left grip Thumb Left-Edge grip Tray grip

Page 43: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Observed Behaviors: with a Pen

Page 44: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Recognizing Multi-hand Grasp

De-noise

Segment

Classify

Stabilize

Classifier

TLE

TLE

Stabilizer

TR

TR

Sensor Signal De-noised Segmented

Result

Thumb Left Edge

Thumb Right

Shape + Geometry Features

Page 45: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Side-by-Side Micro-Territoriality (Multi-User, Single-Device)

Page 46: Sensing Tablet Grasp + Micro-mobility for Active Reading · Observing Grasp + Micro-mobility in Solo / Dyadic Document Work Capturing naturally occurring behavior without digital

Preliminary Evaluation:

Assessing Reactions to Grasp + Mobility Interaction Techniques

Procedure

Instruction and demonstration (total 5 min)

Participant practicing (total 10 min)

Tasks (total 45 min)

Interview (30 min)

Tasks

Reading and navigating a document (single-user, single-device interactions)

Archiving information in a document (single-user, multi-device interactions)

Cooperative discussion and markup (multi-user, multi-device interactions)

Participants

16 people (8 pairs, all right-handed, 4 female, 25-48 years old, M = 28.5)