Self-Correctiong ‘storytelling science’ methods correcting storytelling science.pdf · 4 Tests...
Transcript of Self-Correctiong ‘storytelling science’ methods correcting storytelling science.pdf · 4 Tests...
Self-Correctiong‘storytellingscience’methods
DavidBojeandGraceAnnRosileCabriniUniversityDoctoralSeminar
2
4TestsofSelf-CorrectingMethod
1.Refutationtestofself-reflexivity,self-conversations,orinautoethnography,toquestionassumptions,2.Storytellingconversationswithothers,3.UnderstandingthescienceandprocessesofNature,and4.Doingexperimentsandpracticeinterventionstogetclosertothegroundedsituation.
3
PHASE1:TestbyAutoethnographicReflexivity
Whatisautoethnography?Whatisyourlivingstoryofyourdissertation?Whatisreflexivity?
4
5
Self-CorrectingInductionMethods
1. ForKarlPopperitisZigzagbetweenintuitivehypothesesandtestingtheoriesbydisconfirmation,notbyconfirmation
2. ForC.S.Pierceitisself-correctinginductionbyfourteststogetclosertoTruth
3. ForHenriSavallitisself-correctingby’Agile’interventionusingPeirce’sAbduction-Induction-DeductioninScientificMethodofunleashinghumanpotential
6
Popper(1972:243)Self-CorrectionFormulaPS1èTT1èEE1èPS2
• PS1=Problemsituation,initialresponse• TT1=Tentativetheories(conjectures)• EE1=Erroreliminationbytesting• PS2=Problemsituation,theoriessurvivingrefutationprocess
7
JimSibelDissertation
9
JimSibeldissertationexample
10
AnOntologyofIndustrialWorkintheDigitalElectronicAgeThomasE.Kleiner,Jr.
11
Phase2:TestbyConversations
SoundoffootstepsDavid:Ok,howcanIhelpyou?(Softlyasked)GraceAnn:I’mgoingtogivehimhissecond.Sothat’shis(pointstooneplastictub)David:OKGraceAnn:Andthere’sabowl,outsidefornow[morefootsteps;soundoffoodbeingpouredintothebowl]SeethatbowlthereDavid:OK?GraceAnn:Wekeepthemseparate(scufflingsound)that’sallright,lethimgo,he’sgoingtogowithyou.
12
SoundoffootstepsDavid:Ok,howcanIhelpyou?(Softlyasked)GraceAnn:I’mgoingtogivehimhissecond.Sothat’shis(pointstooneplastictub)David:OKGraceAnn:Andthere’sabowl,outsidefornow[morefootsteps;soundoffoodbeingpouredintothebowl]SeethatbowlthereDavid:OK?GraceAnn:Wekeepthemseparate(scufflingsound)that’sallright,lethimgo,he’sgoingtogowithyou.
DavidisinhishomeofficeinLasCrucesGraceAnnwalksintheoffice,interruptingDavid’susualwriting,withSparkleswhousuallyeatsthereinthatoffice.ThenewpuppyfromtheRescueShelterisabouttogetfirstmealinourhome(Before).Thenewdoggetshisfoodsecondtoreinforcetotheolddogthatsheisnowtheseniordog,sheknowstherules,andthenewdogshouldrespectherandfollowherleadDavidagreeing,toshowhehasheard.Thereishistoryhere(Before),sinceitisabouthowSparkyandHoneyhadbeenfedinseparateroomsbeforeSparkydied.ThenHoneywasalone,andthenlaterwhenSparklescame,Honeybecametopdogandwasfedfirst.AfterHoneywasgone,Sparkleswasaloneuntilthenewmalepuppywasadopted.NowSparklesistopdogandgetstoeatfirst,andthenewpuppyissecondinrank.Thisis(Rehistoricizing)thedog-to-dogrelationship.(Futuring)Givingherplan(Foretellingbetsonthefuture)forhowthefeedingwillbedone.(Grounding)DavidistofeedSparklesinhisoffice.GraceAnnpointstoSparklesbowl,inhisoffice.
13
PHASE3:TestwithScience1. Taylor’s(2007)three-yearethnographyofanimal
sanctuariesraiseschallengesto‘animalpersonhood’intheintersubjectivitybetweenanimalsandhumans(theanimalworkers).
2. Petstatisticstellamultispecies-story,onerelayedinsocialmediaaccountsofhomelessnessandeuthanasia(forwhichtheliteralmeaningoftherootwordsis‘GoodDeath’),andpartofpetcapitalism.“Eachyear,approximately1.5millionshelteranimalsareeuthanized(670,000dogsand860,000cats). 14
PHASE4:TestingClaims
15
MarkVanderklei16
17
18
19
20
UntoldStoryofFashion,PetEuthanasia,andGlobalWarming
PICKONEVIDEO:Overpopulationhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ye6-8ZCMJIgHomelesspetshttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gp5gwioRyGsPetsandGlobalWarminghttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sJGw_rR6RZk(UCLAStudy)It’sabizarreinjusticethatthisuntoldstoryissweptunderthecarpetduetothepowerofthepharmaceuticalandagriculturalindustrylobbyingThemorethisisastory-told,themoreawarenessraisedthebetter.
21