Seed$availability$ for$non GM# cotton%production An# ... · Seed availability for non-GM cotton...

!!""#$%&%’(%)’(’*+$!

!"#$%"%"!"# !cotton production!

An ! !"#$%&’()*+! !"#$ !

!

#$$%!&!#’()*!+,*-!.’/0$!

1/2,3(0!4’55’3!6’73%!+,8)$!!

! 9!0’)),8’/,5(’3!8$5:$$3; !

3*5(575$!

3*5(575$!’@!1/2,3(0!92/(07)57/$".(=

+$A,*!9&B!92/(#FC6!

=,D$/!4/’G#0($30$!

!

!

"#$%!&’()*+,-$.&!%-/01!$%!,2!$2.&2-*+13!4!5$+%-!,%%&%%6&2-!*5!-#&!(+*7)&6%!*5!,88&%%$29!*+9,2$8!%&&0!,20!-#&!8*2-,6$2,-$*2!*5!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!%&&0!:$-#!9&2&-$8!

6*0$5$8,-$*2!;!$2!-#&!5$&)0?!@/-8*6&%!*5!-#&!$2.&2-*+1!)&,0!-*!#1(*-#&%&%!-*!7&!-&%-&0!$2!5/+-#&+!

+&9$*2,)!:*+A%#*(%?!"#$%!$2.&2-*+1!$%!,2!$2$-$,)!%-&(!$2!0&.&)*($29!,!6,%-&+!(),2!5*+!%,5&9/,+0$29!-#&!

,.,$),7$)$-1!*5!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!%&&0?!

!

4((+*’$6,-&)1! BCD!*5!+&%(*20&2-%!*.&+,))E!$28)/0$29!FGD!*5!*+9,2$8!5,+6&+%!:#*!+&%(*20&0E!,+&!*5!-#&!

*($2$*2!-#,-!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!%&&0!$%!0$55$8/)-!-*!,88&%%?!H2!8*/2-+$&%!:#&+&!!8)*%&!-*!FGD!*5!+&%(*20&2-%!5&&)!$-!$%!N0$55$8/)-O!-*!N$6(*%%$7)&O!-*!

,88&%%!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!%&&0?!488&%%$29!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!%&&0!$%!8*2%$0&+&0!(+*7)&6,-$8!&.&2!$2!8*/2-+$&%!:#&+&!

Seed availability for non-GM cotton production - Seed & Soils Task Force, OCRT, Textile Exchange

3!

!"#$%&’()*(+($,- !

"#$%!%-/01!:,%!8*66$%%$*2&0!71!"&’-$)&!Z’8#,29&!,20!9&2&+*/%)1!5$2,28&0!71!ZHWZZQ!MHJ^ZY!,20!L,1&+!K+*(J8$&28&?!H-!:,%!$6()&6&2-&0!71!-#&!J&&0!X!J*$)%!",%A!M*+8&!40.$%*+1!!,20!=,#&%#!Y,6,A+$%#2,2!;4+.$20E!H20$,>!:#*!#,.&!#&)(&0!71!,2%:&+$29!a/&%-$*2%!+&9,+0$29!5,7+$8!,20!%-,()&!)&29-#c!,20!!:#*!(+*.$0&0!/%&5/)!5&&07,8A!*2!%-+,-&9$&%!5*+!S&%-!45+$8,c!,20!W$&%)!"+/%8*--!,20!W$%,!Z67&+%*2!;"ZRId>!:#*!#,.&!(+*.$0&0! -#&!*.&+,))!%/((*+-!5*+!-#$%!(+*‘&8-e!W,%-!7/-!2*-!)&,%-!,!7$9!-#,2A!1*/!-*!"&++1!^10&E!"&’-$)&!Z’8#,29&E!5*+!(,-$&2-)1!&0$-$29!-#&!+&(*+-E!,20!-*!=&-#,!.,2!L+/99&2!;WLH>!5*+!-#&!),1*/-!*5!-&’-!,20!5$9/+&%?!!

=*%-!*5!*/+!,((+&8$,-$*2!9*&%!-*!,))!-#*%&!:#*!#,.&!9$.&2!-#&$+!.,)/,7)&!-$6&!,20!*.&+8*6&!.,+$*/%!*7%-,8)&%!-*!5$))!$2!-#&!a/&%-$*22,$+&?!4!%(&8$,)!,8A2*:)&09&6&2-!9*&%!-*!-#&!7+&&0&+%!:#*!+&%(*20&0E!:#*!6/%-!#,.&!%(&2-!-#&!6*%-!-$6&!5$))$29!$-!$2?!

!

Z0$-#!W,66&+-%!.,2!L/&+&2!

K#,$+E!J&&0!X!J*$)%!",%A!M*+8&!

=,+8#!UGCV!

!


4!

4’35$35*!!

H! >35/’%705(’3! I !

"#&!K#,))&29&! B!

L,8A9+*/20! B!

@7‘&8-$.&%! B!

=&-#*0*)*91 ! F!

"#&!J/+.&1! F!

"#&!Y&(*+-! F!

J! 6$*7)5*! HK!

[+*5$)&!*5!Y&%(*20&2-%! CG!

4.,$),7$)$-1!*5!@+9,2$8!K*--*2!J&&0! CC!

K*2-,6$2,-$*2!*5!@+9,2$8!K*--*2!,20!K*--*2!J&&0!:$-#!


5!

.(27/$*!,3%!+,8)$*!!

!"#$%&’()’*+&%+"&,’-.’/0&’-%"#"1’-.’233’%&45-16&1/4! 10!!"#$%&’()’*+","-,.’-/’011’%&.+-,2&,3.’-,’4-5’&0.6’-%’2"78$13’088&..’3-’.&&2’".! !! !!"#$%&’()’*+"!"#!$%#&%’((%)*$+#!,*!-$%#!%$*)"#.$!*$$%#&%/#!-’0"!’1#!%#&%#)2’!"/%/#3#!%

!"#$%&’(! 12!!"#$%&’()’*+","-,’-.’/00’%&1+-,2&,31’-,’3%&,21’",’-%#/,"45’4-,6&,7-,/0’/,2’89R!"#"$%

areas!13!Fig!"#$%&$’()*)+*,$+*$-.#/.#"$/+/01$2+3+*$0"#0$-)11$)*2"#0,#4$"#50)*$,/061#$+"$7#2"#0,#! 14!!"#$%&’()’*+,&-.&/’-012#&3’"2’456$7&3’58’,$%-013&/’92"30&/’,%5/$-.3’:;’

!"#$%&’(&)%*+,-.%-/*0&+,*12,-&1-&/3%&/%42$%&5"$6%&73"1-! !" !!"#$%&’(&)"*+,-.&/%%0%/&0,.+&102,-+"3+&13&-%/4*5,3&,6&*,7,3&81%$/! !" !!"#$%&’(&)*+,+-,&-./%%0%/1&",0&."/2%/1&-,&2-13&+2*-/3",3&*%131! !" !!"#$%&’(&)*+,*+-&."#/*01&2"/+!!"#$%&’$(&)%’*+,&+,$-%.! !" !!

!

90/’3DO* !

L-! L,8$))/%!-#/+$29$&2%$%!

KHKY! K&2-+,)!H2%-$-/-&!K*--*2!Y&%&,+8#!

KHY4_! K&2-+&!H2-&+2,-$*2,)&!0&!),!Y&8#&+8#&!49+*2*6$a/&!(*/+!),!_j.&)*((&6&2- !

K=" ! K/-E!=,A&!,20!"+$6!

KYJ! K,-#*)$8!Y&)$&5!J&+.$8&%!M$LW! M*+%8#/29%$2%-$-/-!5k+!7$*)*9$%8#&2!W,207,/E!Y&%&,+8#!H2%-$-/-&!*5!@+9,2$8!

49+$8/)-/+&!


6!

CA$075(T$!#7OO,/D!

K&+-$5$&0!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!(+*0/8-$*2!%$-%!,-!‘/%-!/20&+!CD!*5!9)*7,)!8*--*2!8/)-$.,-$*2?!"#&!5$.&!7$99&%-!(+*0/8&+%!*5!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!,+&3!H20$,!;l\GD>E!K#$2,E!"/+A&1E!IJ4E!,20!",2b,2$,?!@-#&+!(+*0/8-$*2!,+&,%!$28)/0&!S&%-E!Z,%-!,20!Q*+-#!45+$8,E!W,-$2!46&+$8,E!Z91(-E!H%+,&)!,20!K&2-+,)!4%$,!;d1+91b%-,2!,20!",‘$A$%-,2>?!!

L1!UGC]E!\fD!*5!-#&!9)*7,)!;8*2.&2-$*2,)>!8*--*2!,+&,!;U]?F!6$))$*2!#,>!:,%!8/)-$.,-&0!:$-#!?!"#$%!$28)/0&%!K#$2,E!H20$,E![,A$%-,2E!=1,26,+E!IJ4E!=&’$8*E!K*%-,!Y$8,E!K*)*67$,E![,+,9/,1E!4+9&2-$2,E!L+,b$)E!4/%-+,)$,E!J*/-#!45+$8,E!,20!L/+A$2,!M,%*?!

"#&!*7‘&8-$.&!*5!-#&!$2.&2-*+1!(+&%&2-&0!$2!-#$%!+&(*+-!$%!-*!(+*.$0&!,!7$+0m%!&1&!.$&:!*5!:*+)0:$0&!,20!+&9$*2R%(&8$5$8!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!%&&0!,.,$),7$)$-1E!8*2-,6$2,-$*2!$%%/&%E!-+&20%!$2!8*--*2!(+*0/8-$*2E!8#,))&29&%!$2!8*--*2!(+*0/8-$*2!,20!*($2$*2%!*2!:#,-!-#&!N$0&,)O!8*--*2 !$%?!!H-!:$))!,)%*!&’()*+&!-#*/9#-%!*2!:#,-!A$20!*5!8*--*2!%#*/)0!7&!9+*:2!$2!UGUV!,20!:#,-!%*+-!*5!%&&0!(+*9+,6 6&%!%#*/)0!7&!$6()&6&2-&0!$2!:#$8#!+&9$*2%!-*!&2%/+&!$2-&9+$-1!,20!9+*:-#!*5!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!(+*0/8-$*2?!

42!$2-&+2&-!7,%&0!a/&%-$*22,$+&!:,%!%&2-!*/-!-*!,((+*’$6,-&)1! FGG!%-,A*)0&+%?!"#&!+&%(*20&2-%!;CGD!$2!-*-,)>!:&+&!:&))!%(+&,0!-#+*/9#*/- !-#&!-&’-$)&!.,)/&! 8#,$2!,20!,8+*%%!,))!6,‘*+!8*--*2!(+*0/8$29!+&9$*2%?!

"#&!2/67&+!*5!+&%(*20&2-%!(&+!8*2-$2&2-!:, %E!#*:&.& +E!-**!)*:!-*!,++$.&!,-! %*)$0!,20!%-,-$%-$8,))1!%*/20!8*28)/%$*2%?!"#&!+&(*+-!5*+6/),-&%!#1(*-#&%&%!-#,-!%#*/)0!7&!8#&8A&0!,9,$2%-!+&,)$-1!$2!+&9$*2,)!:*+A%#*(%?!

@+9,2$8!8*--*2!%&&0!:,%!8*2%$0&+&0!0$55$8/)-!-*!,88&%%!,88*+0$29!-*!BCD!*5!-#&!+&%(*20&2-%!:#*!8*2%$0&+&0!-#&6%&).&%!,7)&!-*!,%%&%%!-#$%!$%%/&?!H2!,+&,%!:#&+&!

!


7!

*5!-R%#$+-%!:$))!0+,%-$8,))1!$28+&,%&!,20 !-#&%&!:*/)0!(+*7,7)1!2*-!+&a/$+&!6/8#!)*29&+!%-,()&!)&29-#!-#,2!UF66?!"#&!$0&,)!8*--*2!0&%8+$7&0!$%!, !/-*($,2!*2&?!H-!8,22*-!7&!+&,)$%&0!,%!-#&!8+$-&+$,!9$.&2!,+&!$2!8*25)$8-?!"#&+&!,)%*!,((&,+%!,!6$%6,-8#!7&-:&&2!-#&!0$%&,%&%!,20!(&%-%!-#,-!7+&&0&+%!5*8/%!*2!$2!-#&$+!7+&&0$29!(+*9+,66&%!,20!-#*%&!-#,-!:&+&!(+$*+$-$%&0!71!+&%(*20&2-%!,%!-#&!7$99&%-!(+*0/8-$*2!8*2%-+,$2-%?!M/+-#&+!(+$*+$-1!+,2A$29!*5!7+&&0$29n%&)&8-$*2!8+$-&+$,!:$))!2&&0!-*!7&!0&5$2&0!$2!&,8#!%/7R+&9$*2?!!

4)6*%-!,))!+&%(*20&2-%!;FVD>!5&)-!$-!$%!$6(*+-,2-!-*!0&.&)*(!%&&0!(+*9+,66&%?![+&5&+&28&!:, %!9$.&2!-*!2*2R!,+&!,00+&%%$29!,88&%%!-*!7&--&+!a/,)$-1E!*(&2 R(*))$2,-&0!8*--*2!%&&0!:$-#!%/((*+-!5+*6!-#&!


8!

H In!"#$%&!’#(!

+?$!4?,))$32$!!

K&+-$5$&0!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!(+*0/8-$*2!%$-%!,-!‘/%-!/20&+!CD!*5!9)*7,)!8*--*2!8/)-$.,-$*2?!"#&!5$.&!7$99&%-!(+*0/8&+%!*5!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!,+&!H20$,!;l\GD>E!K#$2,E!"/+A&1E!-#&!IJ4E!,20!",2b,2$,?!@-#&+!(+*0/8-$*2!,+&,%!,+&!$2!S&%-E!Z,%-!,20!Q*+-#!45+$8,E!W,-$2!46&+$8,E!Z91(-E!H%+,&)E!,20 !K&2-+,)!4%$,!;d1+91b%-,2!,20!",‘$A$%-,2>?!!

488*+0$29!-*!-#&!HJ444!+&(*+-!71!UGC]!\f D!*5!9)*7,)!8*--*2!,+&,!:,%!8/)-$.,-&0!:$-#!!$2!CV!8*/2-+$&%!$2!5$.&!8*2-$2&2-%!;o,6&%E!UGC]>?!"#$%!$28)/0&%!K#$2,E!H20$,E![,A$%-,2E!=1,26,+E!IJ4 E!=&’$8*E!K*%-,!Y$8,E!K*)*67$,E![,+,9/,1E!4+9&2-$2,E!L+,b$)E!4/%-+,)$,E!J*/-#!45+$8,E!,20!L/+A$2,!M,%*?!!

H2!,00$-$*2!-*!E!-#&!IJ4E!K#$2,E!(,+-%!*5!W,-$2!46&+$8,E!J*/-#&+2!45+$8,E!L/+A$2,!M,%*!,20!(+*7,7)1!-#&!:#*)&!*5!J/7RJ,#,+,2!45+$8,E!

!


9!

B $5?’%’)’2D !

42!$2-&+2&-!7,%&0!%/+.&1!:,%!8,++$&0!*/-!$2!*+0&+!-*!8+&,-&!,2!$2.&2-*+1!*5!$%%/&%E!8#,))&29&%!,20!*((*+-/2$-$&%!5*+!-#&!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!%&8-*+?!H2!0*$29!%*E!$-!:,%!,2-$8$(,-&0!-#,-!,!7+*,0!($8-/+&!*5!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!%&&0!,.,$),7$)$-1!$2!,))!6,‘*+!8*--*2!(+*0/8$29!+&9$*2%!:*/ )0!7&!&%-,7)$%#&0?!

42!$2-&+2&-!7,%&0!%/+.&1!$%!2*-!-#&!$0&,)!.$8)&!-*!+&)$,7)1!&%-,7)$%#!,.,$),7$)$-1!*5!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!%&&0?!"*!*.&+8*6&!-#$%!%#*+-8*6$29E!+&%(*2%&%!5+*6!0$55&+&2-!%-,A*)0&+!9+*/(%!:$-#$2!-#&!-&’-$)&!.,)/&! 8#,$2!:&+&!,2,)1%&0!71!%(&8$5$8!+&9$*2!-*!,%8&+-,$2!:#&-#&+!,!8*2%$%-&2-!(,--&+2!:*/)0!&6&+9&?!!J/8#!8*2%$%-&28$&%!:&+&!5*/20!$2!,+&,%!:#&+&!6/)-$()&!%-,A*)0&+!9+*/(%!+&()$&0!-*!-#&!a/&%-$*22,$+&?!"#&!5$20$29%!*5!-#&!%/+.&1!,+&!a/,)$-,-$.&!$2!2,-/+&!,20!8,2!*2)1!7&!/%&0!,%!,!%-&(($29!%-*2&!5*+!5/+-#&+E!6*+&!a/,2-$-,-$.&!%-/0$&%?!"#&!+&%/)-%!*5!-#$%!%/+.&1!8,2!7&!/%&0!-*!0&-&+6$2&!,+&,%!:#&+&!-#&%&!a/,2-$-,-$.&!%-/0$&%!2&&0!-*!7&!8*20/8-&0?!

^*:&.&+E!-#&!%/+.&1!+&%/)-%!0*!9$.&!,0&a/,-& !$2%$9#-!-*!7&!,7)&!-*!0$%8&+2!$%%/&%!,20!&6&+9$29!-+&20%!,20!-*!6,A&!+&8*66&20,-$*2%!5*+!(+$*+$-$&%!,20!2&’-!%-&(%?!!

+?$!#7/T$D!

" #&!5*))*:$29!7+*,0!,+&,%!:&+&!,00+&%%&0!$2!-#&!a/&%-$*22,$+&3!

¥ H25*+6,-$*2!,7*/- !-#&!+&%(*20&2-%!,20!-#&$+!(*%$-$*2!$2!-#&!-&’-$)&!.,)/&! 8#,$2!

¥ 4.,$),7$)$-1!*5!*+9,2$8E!8*2.&2-$*2,)!,20!


10!

J ! !"#$%"!

V/’@()$!’@!6$*G’3%$35*!

:%)("$; $4-9’*’-/$’/$*?"$*"8*’("$&%(5"$6?%’/$"#&!a/&%-$*22,$+&!:,%!%&2-!*/-!-*! ,((+*’$6,-&)1! FGG!%-,A&R#*)0&+%!5+*6!"Zm%!0,-,7,%&?!J*6&!FG!%-,A*)0&+%!+&%(*20&0!:#$8#!$%!CGD?!

",7)&!C!,20!M$9/+&!C!%#*:!-#,-!-#&!+&%(*20&2-%!,+&!:&))!0$%-+$7/-&0!7*-#!9)*7,))1!,20!-#+*/9#*/-! -#&!-&’-$)&!.,)/&!8#,$2?!VVD!*5!+&%(*20&2-%!:& +&!&$-#&+!5,+6&+%!*+!+&(+&%&2-&0!5,+6&+%?!"#&!+&6,$2$29!fVD!+&(+&%&2-&0!-#&!(*%-!5,+6!.,)/&!8#,$2!:$-#!,!%)$9#-!*.&+R+&(+&%&2-,-$*2!*5!-#&!+&-,$)!%&8-*+?!"#$%!$%!2*-!%/+(+$%$29!,%!

-#&!6,‘*+$-1!*5!"Z!6&67&+%!,+&!+&-,$)&+%?!

W**A$29!,-!-#&!*+$9$2!*5!+&%(*20&2-%E!Z/+*(&!,20!-#&!IJ4! :&+&!:&))!+&(+&%&2-&0!6,$2)1!-#+*/9#!-#&!+&-,$)!,20!-+,0$29!8,-&9*+$&%?!"#&!),+9&%-!2/67&+!*5!+&%(*2%&%!:,%!5+*6!H20$,?!W,29/,9&!7,++$&+%!6$9#-!#,.&!)$6$-&0!+&%(*2%&%!5+*6!K#$2,E!K&2-+,)!4%$,E!J*/-#!46&+$8,!,20!S&%-!45+$8,?!

"#&!2/67&+!*5!+&%(*20&2-%!:, %!-**!)*:!-*!,++$.&!,-!%-,-$%-$8,))1!%*/20!8*28)/%$*2%!(&+!+&9$*2!*+!(&+!%-,A*)0&+!9+*/(?!̂ *:&.&+ E!-#&!2/67&+!*5!+&%(*20&2-%!$%!%/55$8$&2-)1!),+9&!-*!7&!,7)&!-*!0$%8&+2!$%%/&%!,20!&6&+9$29!-+&20%?!

!

!

!

@’A5."$; !

CC?VD!

H!,6!,!%($22&+! V?BD!

H!,6!,!:&,.&+ ! G?GD!

H!,6!,!K="!/2$- ! C?FD!

H!,6!,!:#*)&%,)&+!*5!1,+2! ] ?BD!

H!,6!,!:#*)&%,)&+!*5!5,7+$8! \ ?\D !

H!,6!,!+&-,$)&+! UV?GD!

!


11!

9T,(),8()(5D!’@!1 /2,3(0!4’55’3! #$$%!

B.A%/’6$6-**-/$9""#$’9$#’,,’65(*$*-$%66"99$%66-.#’/A$*-$D;E$-,$*?"$."94-/#"/*9$C?-$6-/9’#"."#$*?"F9"(&"9$%)("$*-$%99"99$*?’9$’995"G$H/$%."%9$C?"."$12 $6-**-/$’9$A.-C/I$JKE$-,$."94-/#"/*9$,%6"#$4.-)("F9$%66"99’/A$-.A%/’6$6-**-/$9""#G$H/$%."%9$C?"."$-/(+$6-/&"/*’-/%($6-**-/$’9$A.-C/I$LKE$-,$."94-/#"/*9$, -5 /#$’*$#’,,’65(*$*-$%66"99$-.A%/’6$6-**-/$9""#G$

"#+&&!-1(&%!*5!8*--*2!%&&0!,+&!,.,$),7)&!*2!-#&!6,+A&-3!*+9,2$8E!8*2.&2-$*2,)!;-+&,-&0!:$-#!8#&6$8,)%!*+!/2-+&,-&0>!,20!?!

488*+0$29!-*!%-,20,+0%!*5!*+9,2$8!8&+-$5$8,-$*2E!*+9,2$8!%&&0%!,+&!-#*%&!-#,-!#,.&!7&&2!(+*0/8&0!/20&+!*+9,2$8!8/)-$.,-$*2!;5*+!*2&!1&,+!5*+!,22/,)!8+*(%>?![ &+6$%%$*2!$%!9+,2-&0!;,-!-$6&%!,20!5*+!,!)$6$-&0!(&+$*0>!-*!*+9,2$8!5,+6&+%!-*!/%&!/2-+&,-&0!8*2.&2-$*2,)!%&&0%?!@2!.&+1!+,+&!*88,%$*2%E!(&+6$%%$*2!$%!9$.&2!5*+!/%&!*5!-+&,-&0!8*2.&2-$*2,)!%&&0%!$2!*+9,2$8!8/)-$.,-$*2!(+*.$0&0!-#&!%&&0%!,+&!-#*+*/9#)1!8)&,2&0!7&5*+&!(),2-$29?!


12!

H2!,+&,%!:#&+&!

!


13!

+/$3%*!(3!R/’:(32! 1 /2,3(0!4’55’3 !

VDE$-,$."94-/#"/*9$C"."$-,$*?"$-4’/’-/$*?%*$-.A%/’6$6-**-/$%6."%A"$C’(($9*%+$*?"$9%F"$-.$’/6."%9"I$#"94’*"$*?"$4.-)("F9$*?"+$"/6-5/*". G$:?’9$C%9$-,,9"*$)+$*?"$MME$-,$."94-/#"/*9$C?-$9%C$%$#"6(’/"$’/$-.A%/’6$6-**-/$%."%G$="94-/9"9$,.-F$H/#’%$%/#$3?’/%$95AA"9*"#$*?%*$-.A%/’6$6-**-/$%6."%A"$C’(($."F%’/$9*%)("I$C?’("$."94-/9"9$,.-F$Z+.A+W9*%/I$:%[’P’9*%/$%/#$\"9*$7,.’6%$95AA"9*"#$*?%*$%6."%A"$-,$-.A%/’6$6-**-/$C’(($’/6."%9"G$B&".%((I$."94-/#"/*9$,.-F$ *?"$T!7$9%C$-.A%/’6$6-**-/$%."%$"84%/#’/AI$%(*?-5A?$,%.F".9$*?"F9"(&"9$9%C$-.A%/’6$6-**-/$%6."%A"$."F%’/’/A$9*%)("G$]-C"&".I$%9$*?"$/5F)".$-,$."94-/#"/*9$ C%9$(-CI$%$,’/%($6-/6(59’-/ $6%//-*$)"$."%6?"#G$

=*%-!*5!-#&!+&%(*20&2-%!;\BD>!:&+&!*5!-#&!*($2$*2!-#,-!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!,8+&,9&!:$))!%-,1!-#&!%,6&!*+!$28+&,%&!0&%($-&!-#&!6,21!(+*7)&6%!-#&1!&28*/2-&+?!M+*6!-#&!+&%(*2%&%E!$-!8,2!7&!$25&++&0!-#,-!8*2.&2-$*2,)!8*--*2!$%!&’(&8-&0!-*!0&8)$2&!$2!$6(*+-,28&!$5!?!

Y&%(*20&2-%!.$&:&0!-#&!6,$2!,+&,%!*5!9+*:-#!$2!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!(+*0/8-$*2!-*!7&!d1+91b%-,2E!",‘$A$%-,2!,20!S&%-!45+$8,?!K)*%&!-*!BGD!*5!-+,0&+%!:&+&!*5!-#&!*($2$*2!-#,-!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!,+&,!:$))!$28+&,%&?!Y&%(*20$29!5,+6&+%!#,0!,!6$’&0!*($2$*2E!&a/,))1!0$%-+$7/-&0!7&-:&&2!9+*:-# E!0&8)$2&!,20!%-,7$)$%,-$*2!*5!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!,+&,?!

J*6&!+&%(*20&2-%!:&+&!*5!-#&!*($2$*2!-#,-!?!

!

@’A5."$L


14!

V/’@(5,8()(5D!’@!4’55’3! V/’%705(’3!

LSE$-,$."94-/#"/*9$,.-F$F%[-.$6-**-/$A.-C’/A$%."%9$C"."$-,$*?"$-4’/’-/$*?%*$6-**-/$%6."%A"$C’(($#"6(’/"$%9$%$."95(*$-,$6-F4"*’*’-/$,.-F $F-."$4.-,’*%)("$%/#$"%9’".$*-$A.-C$6.-49$(’P"$9-+)"%/$%/#$&"A"*%)("9G$MME$-, $."94-/#"/*9I$F-9*(+$,.-F$9F%((".$6-**-/$A.-C’/A$%."%9I$,"(*$*?%*$6-**-/$A.-C’/A$C’(($’/6."%9"$#5"$*-$%$F-."$,%&-5.%)("$4-(’6+$%/#$F%.P"*’/A$"/&’.-/F"/*G$

"#&!a/&%-$*2!:,%!,%A&0!,%!-*!:#&-#&+!*+!2*-!8*--*2!$%!%-$))!,!(+*5$-,7)&!8+*(!-*!9+*:!*+!:#&-#&+!$-!:$ ))!7&!+&(),8&0!71!6*+&!(+*5$-,7)&!8+*(%E!+&%/)-$29!$2!,!0&8+&,%&!$2!8*--*2!9+*:$29!,+&,?!

4((+*’$6,-&)1!fVD!*5!+&%(*20&2-%!(+&0$8-&0!8*--*2! (+*0/8-$*2!-*!0&8+&,%&!;%&&!M$9/+&!V>E!:#$)&!UUD!:&+&!*5!-#&!*($2$*2!-#,-!$-!:$))!$28+&,%&?!!

"#&!+&%(*20&2-%!:#*!(+&0$8-&0!-#,-!8*--*2!,+&,!:$))!0&8+&,%&!6&2-$*2&0!(+$6,+$)1!%*17&,2!,20!.&9&-,7)&%!,%!-#&!8*6(&-$29!8+*(%E!-#*/9#!,-!-$6&%!&.&2!6,$b&!$%!6&2-$*2&0?!"#&!6,$2!+&,%*2!,--+$7/-&0!-*!-#&!0&8)$2&!*5!8*--*2!,8+&,9&!:,%!

-#,-!$-%!(+*5$-,7$)$-1!$%!/20&+!(+&%%/+&!,%!,!+&%/)-!*5!+$%$29!),7*/ +!,20!$2(/-!8*%-%E!8*/()&0!:$-#! ,!#$9#!)&.&)!*5!+$%A?!4)-&+2,-$.&!8+*(%!8,2!#,.&!,!%#*+-&+!9+*:-#!818)&E!%&&!+$%$29!6,+A&-!(+$8&%E!+&a/$+&!+&),-$.&)1!)*:!),7*/ +!$2(/-!,20!5,8&!+&),-$.&)1!)*:&+!+$%A!-#,2!8*--*2?!!

Y&%(*20&2-%!:$-#!-#&!*($2$*2!-#,-!8*--*2!,8+&,9&!:, %!+&0/8$29!*+$9$2,-&0!5+*6!-#&!IJ4!;"&’,%!,20!K,)$5*+2$,>E!H20$,!;=,#,+,%#-+,E!=,0#1,![+,0&%#E!E!d1+91b%-,2E!=,)$!,20![&+/?!!

!

@’A5."$S30/$,*(32!

.)7057,W32!

M’:3!

^3-**-/$4.-#56*’-/$?%9$(%.A"(+$,-((-C"#$C-.(#$6-**-/$4.’6"9$)5*$C’*?$*?"$%#&"/*$-,$6-/*.%6*$,%.F’/A$C?"."’/$,%.F".9$%."$A"**’/A$A’//".9>$9544-.*$*-$A.-C$6-**-/I$C"$%."$9""’/A$F-."$(%/#$6-F’/A$)%6P$*-$6-**-/G_$

!-5.6"

!


15!

B,(3! . ,05’/*! 9@@$05(32!4’55’3!‘ ($)%*!

‘.-5A?*9$C" ."$6-/9’#"."#$*-$)"$%$&".+$9".’-59$4.-)("F$’/$6-**-/$65(*’&%*’-/G$a"%,0956P’/A$’/9"6*9$C" ."$*?"$F-9*$9".’-59$4"9*$4.-)("FI$C?’("$9-’($)-./"$#’9"%9"9$*-44"#$*?"$#’9"%9"$(’9*G$:?"9"$4.-)("F9$/""# $*-$)"$%##."99"#$%9$*?"+$6%59"$A%49$’/$6-**-/$9*%/#9$%/#$’/6."%9"$*?"$.’9P9$-,$A%40,’((’/A$C’*?$12$9""#9G$="#56"#$6-**-/$+’"(#9$C"."$,-5/#$*-$)"$%$."95(*$-,$"8*"./%($"/&’.-/F"/*%($,%6*-.9$)"+-/#$%$,%.F".>9$6-/*.-(I$.%*?".$*?%/$*?"$."95(*$-,$,%6*-.9$*?"+$6-5(#$6-/*.-($956?$%9$6?-’6"$-,$6-**-/$&%.’"*’"9I$,%.F".$4.%6*’6"9b(%)-5.I$%/#$9-’($,".*’(’*+$F%/%A"F"/*G$

Y&%(*20&2-%!:&+&!,%A&0!:#$8#!5,8-*+%!,55&8-!8*--*2!1$&)0%?!"#&!+&()$&%!(+*.$0&!,!/%&5/)!$2%$9#-!$2-*!-#&!8*20$-$*2%!/20&+!:#$8#!8*--*2!$%!9+*:2!,20!:#,-!8*20$-$*2%!,2!$0&,)!8*--*2!%#*/)0!7&!,7)&!-*!-*)&+,-&!;%&&!",7)&!U>?!"#&!6 *%-!$6(*+-,2-!8#,+,8-&+$%-$8%!:&+&!8*2%$0&+&0!-*!7&3!0+*/9#-!-*)&+,28&E!,0,(-,-$*2!-* !/25,.* / +,7)&!+,$25,))!(,--&+2%E!,20!-*)&+,28&!-* !(&%-%!,20!0$%&,%&!,--,8A%?!

H-!$%!$6(*+-,2-!-*!2*-$8&!-#,-!6,21!+&%(*20&2-%!-#*/9#-!8*--*2!1$&)0!+&0/8-$*2!:,%!0/&!-*!&2.$+*26&2-,)!5,8-*+%!-#,-!5,+6&+%!8,22*-!8*2-+*)!+,-#&+!-#,2!5,8-*+%!-#&1!8,2E!5*+!$2%-,28&!71!8#**%$29!9**0!

.,+$&-$&%E!$6(+*.$29!%*$)!5&+-$)$-1!6,2,9&6&2-!,20!$28+&,%&0!),7*/+?!H2!*-#&+!:*+0%3!5,+6&+%!-#$2A!-#&1!8,22*-!$6(+*.&!-#&$+!8*--*2!9+*:$29!8*20$-$*2%!,20!,+&!),+9&)1!0&(&20&2-!*2!&’-&+2,)!5,8-*+%?!!"#&!6,‘*+$-1!*5!5,+6&+!+&%(*20&2-%!,)%*!$20$8,-&0!-#,-!-#&1!*2)1!#,.&!,88&%%!-*!,!)$6$-&0!2/67&+!*5!.,+$&-$&%E!,20!#&28&!:& +&!)$A&)1!-*!/20&+&%-$6,-&!-#&!(*-&2-$,)!*5!.,+$&-1!$6(+*.&6&2-?!=*+&*.&+E!:$-#*/-!8),%%$8,)!7+&&0$29E!2*!


16!

:%)("$Y! ] ?f !

W19/%$Qa+A59$&-99"(".’R! ] ?G!

46&+$8,2!L*)):*+6!;]"(’6-&".4%$%.F’A".%b]"(’-*?’9>! U?f !

J&6$!)**(&+!;7/-F’9$,(%&%>! U?f !

o,%%$0%!;7F.%96%$)’A5*"((%$)’A5*"((%>! U?U!

=&,)1!7/9!; N?"/%6-6659$9-("/-49’9!;"$2%)&1>>! U?G!

[$2A!L*)):*+6!;N"6*’/’4?-.%$A-99+4’"((%>! C?B!

J(*--&0!7*)):*+6!; d%.’%9$&’*"((%>! C?B!

W&,5!+*))&+!;!+("4*"$#".-A%*%>! C?B!

!

C?B!!!

K*--*2!%-,$2&+%! C?\ !

W&,5!:*+6!;!4-#-4*".%$(’*5.%>! C?P!

J#**-!:&&.$)!;7(6’#-#"%$%,,%)".>! C?V!

Y&0!L*)):*+6!; ‘’4%.-49’9$6%9*%/"%>! C?f !

J($21!7*)):*+6!;d%.’%9$’/95(%/%>!!

C?] !

sC!t!2*!(+*7)&6E!U!t!%*6&-$6&%!,!(+*7)&6E!]!t!$6(*+-,2-!(+*7)&6E!f!t!.&+1!$6(*+-,2-!(+*7)&6!

!


17!

:%)("$L


18!

H-!,((&,+&0E!-#*/9# E!-#,-!,!%(&8$,)-1!6,+A&-!$%!5*+&%&&2!5*+!]UR]B66!%-,()&!8*--*2!(+*0/8-%3!0+&%%!%#$+-%?!"#&!%(&8$,)-1!6,+A&-!8*/)0!,)%*!$28)/0&!5$2&!7&0!%#&&-%!,20!#$9#!a/,)$-1!-*:&)%E!7/-!-#$%!2&&0%!-*!7&!$2.&%-$9,-&0!5/+-#&+?!",‘$A$%-,2!$%!&6&+9$29!,%!,!%-+*29!8,20$0,-&!5*+!-#$%!%/7R%&8-*+!;"Z!@+9,2$8!K*--*2!Y&(*+-!UGC]>?!!42!,00$-$*2,)!,0.,2-,9&!5*+!-#&!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!%&8-*+!$%!-#,-!",‘$A$%-,2!:$))!(+*7,7)1!+&6,$2!,!?!

>OG’/5,30$!’@!#$$%!V/’2/,O O$*!

‘"&"(-4F"/*$-,$9""#$4.-A.%FF" 9$C%9$6-/9’#"."#$’F4-.*%/*$*-$JSE$-,$."94-/#"/*9G$:?"$."94-/#"/*9$?%#$%$9(’A?*$4.","."/6"$,-.$9""#$F5(*’4(’6%*’-/$4.-A.%FF" 9$,-.$6".*’,’"#$/-/012$9""#G$f%.’"*+$9"("6*’-/$%/#$).""#’/A$,-((-C"#$%*$%$&".+$6(-9"$9"6-/# G$="94-/#"/*9$,.-F$*?"$T!7I$\"9*$7,.’6%$%/#$3?’/%$?%#$9’F’(%.$-4’/’-/9G$H/$H/#’%I$9""#$F5(*’4(’6%*’-/$4.-A.%FF" 9$,-.$-.A%/’6$9""#$C"."$4.",".."# I$,-((-C"#$)+$).""#’/A$4.-A.%FF" 9$*-$#"&"(-4$/"C$/-/012$6-**-/$&%.’"*’"9G$$

Y&%(*20&2-%!:&+&!,%A&0!-#&$+!*($2$*2!*2!-#&!$6(*+-,28&!*5!0&.&)*($29!%&&0!(+*9+,66&%!-*!$6(+*.&!,.,$),7$)$-1!*5!2*2R?!

4)%*!,%A&0!:&+&!a/&%-$*2%!*2!-#&!-1(&!*5!%&&0!(+*9+,66&!-#,-!:,%!&2.$%,9&0!71!+&%(*20&2-%?!M/))!5+&&0*6!:,%!9$.&2!-*!,2%:&+!$2!,))!8,-&9*+$&%!,20!M$9/+&!B!(+&%&2-%!-#&!+&%/)-%?!H-!8,2!7&!%&&2!-#,-!%&&0!6/)-$()$8,-$*2!(+*9+,6 6&%!:& +&!%)$9#-)1!

(+&5&++&0E!5*))*:&0!8)*%&)1!71!.,+$&-1!%&)&8-$*2!(+*9+,66&%!,20!7+&&0$29!(+*9+,66&%?!W**A$29!,-!-#&!,2%:&+%!*5!+&%(*20&2-%!5+*6!0$55&+&2-!+&9$*2%!$-!:,%!5*/20!-#,-E!:$-#!-#&!&’8&(-$*2!*5!H20$,2!+&%(*20&2-%E!+&%(*20&2-%!5+*6!,))!+&9$*2%!#,0!%$6$),+!(+&5&+&28&%?!

"#&!H20$,2!+&%(*20&2-%!9,.&!6*+&!$6(*+-,28&!-*!*+9,2$8!%&&0!6/)-$()$8,-$*2!,20!7+&&0$29!(+*9+,6 6&%!,%!8,2!7&!%&&2!$2!M$9/+&!F?!"#$%!6$9#-!7&!$25)/&28&0!71!-#&!5,8-!-#,-!%*6&!7+&&0$29!(+*9+,6 6&%!5*+!)*:R$2(/-!8*20$-$*2%!,+&!,)+&,01!$6()&6&2-&0!$2!H20$,?!

@’A5."$V!%’!3’5!-3’:!!JX!

3’5!(OG’/5,35!!!LX!

!


19!

!

!

!

!

$

@’A5."$J


20!

L !"#$%##"&’!

H2!-#$%!%&8-$*2E!-#&!*/-8*6&%!*5!-#&!a/&%-$*22,$+&!,+&!0$%8/%%&0!-*!(+*.$0&!,!8)&,+&+!($8-/+&!,20!7&--&+!9/$0&)$2&%!5*+!,!5/-/+&!%-+,-&91!-*!7&!0&.&)*(&0?!

M+*6!,2%:&+%!-*!-#&!a/&%-$*22,$+&E!$-!7&8,6&!8)&,+!-#,-!,88&%%!-*!*+9,2$8!,20!&.&2!8*2.&2-$*2,)E!2*2R!*5!-#&!8*--*2!%&8-*+!,%!,!:#*)&E!$28)/0$29!(+*8&%%$29?!"/+A&1!#,%!,2!,0.,2-,9&!*5!#,.$29!,!%-+*29!,20!0&.&)*(&0!2*2R

!


21!

S#&2!+&9$*2,)!%&&0!%-+,-&9$&%!,+&!0&.&)*(&0E!-#&%&!$%%/&%!2&&0!-*!7&!.&+$5$&0E!-,8A)&0!*+!,-!)&,%-!7&!-,A&2!$2-*!8*2%$0&+,-$*2?!

#$$%!*7GG)($*!%(@@$/!

"#+*/9#*/-! -#&!:*+)0E!0$55&+&2-!%1%-&6%!*5!8*--*2!%&&0!%/(()1!,+&!$2!/%&?!J*6&!8*/2-+$&%E!)$A&!H20$,!,20!J*/-#&+2!45+$8,E!#,.&!8*6()&-&)1!8*66&+8$,)!%&&0!8*6(,2$&%!-#,-!%/(()1!5,+6&+%!:$-#!8*--*2!%&&0!,9,$2%-!0$+&8-!8,%#!(,16&2-?!!@-#&+%E!%/8#!,%!-#&!M+&28#!%(&,A$29!S&%-!45+$8,E!#,.&!9*.&+26&2-!6,2,9&0!%&&0!%1%-&6%!-#,-!(+*.$0&!5,+6&+%!;%/7%$0$%&0>!8*--*2!%&&0!*2!8+&0$-!:#$8#!$%!(,$0!71!5,+6&+%!:#&2!-#&1!-+,0&!-#&$+!8*--*2!-#+*/9#!-#&!9*.&+26&2-!8*2-+*))&0!9$2%?!

@5-&2!9$2%!(),1!,2!$6(*+-,2-!(,+-!$2!%&&0!0$%-+$7/-$*2!-*!5,+6&+%?!"#&1!;6 *%-)1>!(+*.$0&!5,+6&+%!:$-#!%&&0!7*/9#-!5+*6!%&&0!8*6(,2$&%!7/-E!,-!-$6&%E!,)%*!%&))!%&&0!0$+&8-)1!*7-,$2&0!5+*6!9$22$29!-*!5,+6&+%?!H2!-#&!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!%&8-*+E!-#&!+*)&!*5!%&&0!%/(()1!$%!*5-&2!,%%/6&0!71!Q*2R?!

L&5*+&!&67,+A$29!*2!,!%&&0!%-+,-&91!,20!$6()&6&2-$29!$-E!,!8)&,+!/20&+%-,20$29!*5!-#&!%/(()1!%1%-&6!$%!+&a/$+&0?!H2!-#&!8,%&!*5!H20$,E!-#$%!%-/01!#,%!7&&2!6,0&!71!W,/+,!=,+-1!;UGC]>?!"#&!7,%$8!$%%/&!$%!-#,-!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!8*2%-$-/-&%!*2)1!CD!*5!-#&!8*--*2!,+&,!:*+)0:$0&?![+*0/8-$*2!,+&,%!,+&!*5-&2!%8,--&+&0!*.&+!,!8*/2-+1!,20E!-#/%E!-#&!(+*7)&6!*5!%/55$8$&2-!(/+8#,%&!.*)/6&!,+$%&%?!J&&0!8*6(,2$&%!%&&!$-!,%!,!7/+0&2!-*!(+*0/8&!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!%&&0E!&%(&8$,))1!$2!8*/2-+$&%!:#&+&!


22!

3-**-/$4’6P’/A$’/$H/#’%$’9$#-/"$)+$?%/#G$7$C-.P".$C?-$’9$4."9"/*(+$4%’#$%)-5*$Hg=$YKK$%$#%+$6%/$4’6P$%*$F-9*$YKPAG$N."9"/*$4.’6"9$,-.$.%C$6-**-/$%."$%)-5*$Hg=$YK$4".$PA$*?59$?%.&"9*’/A$%(-/"$%)9-.)9$YKE$-,$*?"$’/6-F"$"%./"#G$‘-5)(’/A$*?"$&-(5F"$-,$)-((9$*?%*$6%/$)"$4’6P"#$4".$#%+$C-5(#$95)9*%/*’%((+$’/6."%9"$4.-,’*9G$$!-5.6"

!


23!

(&%-$8$0&!,(()$8,-$*2%!,20!#$9#!,6*/2-!*5!+&,0$)1!,.,$),7)&!5&+-$)$%&+>!,20!5*+!-#&!8*2.&2-$*2,)!6&-#*0!*5!8*--*2!8/)-$.,-$*2?!

"#&!7$99&%-!0$55&+&28&!7&-:&&2!*+9,2$8!,20!8*2.&2-$*2,)!8/)-$.,-$*2!6&-#*0%!$%!5*/20!$2!2$-+*9&2!6,2,9&6&2-!*(-$*2%!,.,$),7)&!$2!*+9,2$8!5,+6$29!8*6(,+&0!:$-#!-#&!&,%1!,(()$8,-$*2!*5!2$-+*9&2!5&+-$)$%&+%!$2!8*2.&2-$*2,)!8*--*2!(+*0/8-$*2?!J&)&8-$*2!8+$-&+$,!%#*/)0!7&!5*8/%$29!6*+&!*2!%167$*%$%!:$-#!,!),+9&!2/67&+!*5!7$*R,9&2-%!;&?9?!=18*++#$b,E![#*%(#*+!J*)/7$)$b$29!L,8-&+$,E!&-8?>?![&%-!,20!0$%&,%&!6,2,9&6&2-! ,)%*!0$55&+E!+&a/$+$29!-*!7+&&0!6*+&!5*+!6*+(#*)*9$8,)!-+,$-%!;)$A&!#,$+$2&%%>!-*!6,A&!(),2-%!)&%%!,--+,8-$.&!-*!)&,5!%/8A$29!$2%&8-%!*+!&99!),1$29?!J/$-,7$)$-1!*5!-#&!8*--*2!.,+$&-1!;0&.&)*(&0!/20&+!,2!*+9,2$8!7+&&0$29!(+*9+,6>!5*+!6$’&0!8+*(($29!%#*/)0!7&!-,A&2!$2-*!8*2%$0&+,-$*2!,%!8+*(%!)$A&!(/)%&%!:$))!7&!$2-&+8+*((&0!5*+!.,+$*/%!(/+(*%&%?!"#&!8*2.&2-$*2,)!%1%-&6%!7+&&0!8*--*2!5*+!6*2*8+*(($29?!

J&8*20)1E!-#&+&!,+&!$%%/&%!*2!-#&!6*+(#*)*91!*5!8*--*2!,20!-#&!:,1!$-!9+*:%?!"#$%!:$))!8),+$51!:#1!-#&!N$0&,)O!8*--*2!.,+$&-1!8,22*-!7&!7+&0?!!

K*--*2!$%!0&.&)*($29!5)*:&+%!,20!-#/%!7*))%!7*--*6!/(:,+0%!;%&&!M$9/+&!CG>?!"#&+&5*+&E!0&6,20$29!,!8*--*2!.,+$&-1!:$-#!7*))%!$2!-#&!/((&+!(,+-!,20!*5!6&0$/6!0/+,-$*2!$%!.&+1!(+*7)&6,-$8!,%!-*(!7*))%!:$))!6,-/+&!,7*/-!,!6*2-#!),-&+!-#,2!5$+%-!7*))%?!!!

!,20!h,2!_$‘A!;UGCf>?!

!@’A5."$;K


24!

N !"#$%&’("#’)*#+),-$"..-#+*/("# ! !

"#$%!$2-&+2&-R7,%&0!$2.&2-*+1E!8*6($)&0!/%$29!-#&!+&%/)-%!*5!,!a/&%-$*22,$+&!0$%-+$7/-&0!-*!"&’-$)&!Z’8#,29&m%!2&-:*+A%E!#,%!(+*.$0&0!-#&!5$+%-!*.&+.$&:!*5!9)*7,)!,20!+&9$*2R%(&8$5$8!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!%&&0!,.,$),7$)$-1?!4)%*!&’()*+&0!:&+&!8*2-,6$2,-$*2!$%%/&%E!(+*7)&6%!,20!-+&20%!$2!8*--*2!(+*0/8-$*2E!,20!*($2$*2%!*2!-#&!.,+$&-1!8#,+,8-&+$%-$8%!+&a/$+&0!-*!6&&-!5/-/+&!0&6,20%?!H-!$%!$6(*+-,2-!-*! A&&(!$2!6$20!-#,-!-#&!2/67&+!*5!+&%(*20&2-%!(&+!8*2-$2&2-!:,%!-**!)*:!-*!,++$.&!,-!%*)$0!,20!%-,-$%-$8,))1!%*/20!8*28)/%$*2%E!7/-!%/55$8$&2-!-*!9$.&!,!5$+%-!9)*7,)!*.&+.$&:!*5!-#&!6,$2!%&&0!$%%/&%?!"#$%!+&(*+-!#,%!5*+6/),-&0!#1(*-#&%&%!-#,-!%#*/)0!7&!8#&8A&0!,9,$2%-!+&,)$-1!$2!+&9$*2,)!:*+A%#*(%?!!

!

l$D!@(3%(32*;!

¥ !"#$%&’(’)*)%(+,,-(&+(-&.’/01(1)($’’,++($’’)"-&%#(1)(234()5(",+6)%-,%1+7(!"#$%&$’#()&%!"#$%&%’#()#*+%,’-#./0#%1#+2)3%’42’5)#16$24#3+%7829)#6$$2))(’*#%+*6’($#$%&%’#)224!"wh!"#$ in areas where only conven.onal co/on is grown, 40% of respondents found it !"#$%&’(’)(*$$+,,-(!!

¥ !"#$%&’#%("#)*+",-.&/)0’$1)23)4"5"#)0.+.).6*.+ !"#$"%&’(&)*+&,-&."/0,#%"#1/2&Those producing organic co0on in countries where GM co0on!!"#$%&’#(!!"#!"#$%&%’()*!"#!"#$%&’($’"!#&)*!&+"!$,-"./()01$2-")$#3($45(0+"!!&*-(6$75-8(9$&!:$7&!;&!*&$0(()(:$!"#$%&’($)*+%,$%,-*&./$/%0%&$1,%23/#,4$!"*!$2%$&%!$5(!"#$%&’!$&()$*+,-.!/0$12"3$!"#$%&’#%("#)!!

¥ !"#$%&’#(")*’)$#%("+)$%,$%-&"##%("..+),/")%,#%$0’%1,2"&%-,3#’%"4%-")$,1+),/")5!!"#$%$&’(&$)$*&+,!!"##$%&’()*’!"#$%&’!"(#)(*+#(",#-./#012#3+!"-*#(-#*//,#3%&4.(*/,#5+!"#$%$&’#(’)*+’,#-./’!#)*0#1’2./’3.$)#,4$#% !"#!$#!%&’"()#)!*!"+#!"#$%&’!""#$%&’!"#$%"&’(")*("+",&’*-(.+(#$! !!"#$!%&’(!""!"#$%&’()*!+,$!""#!$%&’%!(&%!)%*+!"#$%’(!!!!"#pure organic seed.!!

¥ Co#on, as a crop, is under pressure from easier to grow and more profitable alterna8ve !"#$%&%’!(&)%&%#*+,)-!!!"#$%&’()*&+,-.#/0,/%-&%12/3&%14%&5#6#/&4+,4-&7281%&+,0$5,9&:%&!"#$%&&’!()#*+,*#*+-"-#%&!)!(,*-#.&%/#/,0%%2%(#3&%451!()#1%5(*&!-"#!"#$%&!!!"#$%&%"#&!"#$%&’($)"*+#,#$-#,./+0#+!,$1##2$!"3!$!"#*-$4/5/+$3-#3$6*22$#7.3+0!"#$"%&"#"’()*+,"&-"! !"#$%&’$#(!"#$%&’()$$!*+&,-.-"&/*-01,2"3&,-1"#*2!’4!!

¥ !"#$%&’%()*%+*,-.*#(,%/)&%’*0(%"10*%(&%.*,2+31*%()*%!"!"#$%&’()(*!!!!"#$%"!&!"’!&!"(&!"#$%&’%&()"*’+,’-+.+(’!*+/%0’1(-2!&’"+’3%+()45!!"#$%&"’()$*+),-.&"($&"’(/)-.,"0"’/)!"#$%&’#$(’)*’(’)#(+*",#’( !"#!!R!"#$%!"#$%%"&’(!)*(%%+"$,*’-(!-"(,&"./-!-"#01%&"2’03(3%+",0."!"#$%!"&’$()&*+,-"!&./01*"&*",-/)&/)0,&23’’4&!!

¥ !"#$%&’#()$*+,+-.$’#/*0&1#’$12$0#/3+-’#-4/$&/$($54+3&(-$+-#6!!"#$%&&’"#()#%$*+),)-#.+&$)#!"#$!"#$%"!&’!"#$!"%&!"# !!"#$%&’(!$"%)*+,-.%.+&/0"+&11.&%0+$"+2.+&+3(03&$!-+2.$4..#+$-.+!"#$%#$#&%’!&($#)#&)*%)&+,$$!$,#&-./0#&.’&"’&)*$",&+,$$!"’1&(,.1,%22$#&%’!&)*.#$&)*%)&!"#"$%#&’#&()"*$+,$#")%’-*"-.)$/)$.0"$+&11").$%#’*23(’-$3’-).#/&-.)4$52#.0"#$%#&’#&.,$!"#$%#&’()*(+!,,-%!"#$%&%’()!*’+,-%+,.*/,&&*!%%0*-)*1%*0%2!%0*,!*%.’3*$41R!"#$%&’(!

!

!


25!

6$0’OO$3%,5(’3*!

J-&(%!%#*/)0!7&!-,A&2!,-!,!+&9$*2,)!)&.&)!-*!%,5&9/,+0!-#&!$2-&9+$-1!*5!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!,20!%/((*+-!-#&!,.,$),7$)$-1!*5!*+9,2$8E!2*2R


26!

!"#"$"%&"’!

_$‘AE!W?K?=?!.,2E!UGCf?!J6,))#*)0&+!K*--*2![+*0/8-$*2!$2!I9,20,!R!L+&&0&+%!,20!M,+6&+%!L+$09$29!-#&!

!


27!

@’A5."$7M!,+&!&’8&))&2-!(*))$2,-*+%!*5!8*--*2!,20!#,.&!7&&2!5*/20!-*!8,++1!8*--*2!(*))&2!*.&+!,!0$%-,28&!*5!BGG!6&-&+%?!4)%*!7&&-)&%!;M$9/+&!4U>!8+,:)$29!5+*6!*2&!(),2-!-*!-#&!*-#&+!,+&!$6(*+-,2-!(*))$2,-*+%!*5!8*--*2?!"#&!6,’$6/6!0$%-,28&!-#&1!8,++1!(*))&2!#,%!7&&2!5*/20!-*!7&!,7*/-!VG!6&-&+%?!"#&!6*+&!$2%&8-%!(+&%&2-E!-#&!),+9&+!-#&!8#,28&!-#,-!8+*%%R(*))$2,-$*2!-,A&%!(),8&?$!

K+*%%!(*))$2,-$*2!$%!&%-$6,-&0!-*!7&!,88*/2-,7)&!5*+!,7*/-!CD!*5!-#&!8*2-,6$2,-$*2!*5!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!;^&/7&+9&+!&-!,)?E!UGCGc!@J


28!

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

H5!,))!$%!:&))E!7+&&0&+!,20!5*/20,-$*2!%&&0!$%!Q@"!8*2-,6$2,-&0?!"#&!(,+&2-!)$2&%!2&&0!-*!7&!6,$2-,$2&0!,-!)&,%-!fGG!6&-&+%!,:,1!5+*6!!,88*+0$29!-*!%&&0!),:%!$2!K,)$5*+2$,?!=,21!%&&0!8*6(,2$&%!,+&!&’(&8-&0!-*!5,8&!(+*7)&6%!$2!6,$2-,$2$29!-#$%!$%*),-$*2!0$%-,28&E!&%(&8$,))1!:#&2!-#&1!,+&!,)%*!(+*0/8$29!

!


29!

!

@’A5."$7L%/%(+9"$#5$F%’((-/$l$9"F"/6"$m$F-/*."$c5"$(%$9"F"/6"$,-5./’"$%58$4.-#56*"5.9$#"$6-*-/$)’-$4-5.$(%$4.-#56*’-/$9>"9*$.n&n(n"$%99"W$6-/*%F’/n"$%5$F-F"/*$#"$(%$(’&.%’9-/G$N-5.$("$4"5$#>n6?%/*’((-/9$c5"$/-59$%&-/9$%/%(+9nI$("$*%58$#"$6-/*%F’/%*’-/$"9*$n("&nI$n*%/*$#-//n$c5"$(%$9"F"/6"$"9*$(%$)%9"$#"$*-5*"$4.-#56*’-/G$Q7/%(+9’9$-,$*?"$9""#$9%F4("$*%P"/$9?-C9$*?%*$*?"$9""#$4.-&’#"#$*-$-.A%/’6$6-**-/$4.-#56".9$’9$6-/*%F’/%*"#$%*$*?"$F-F"/*$-,$#"(’&".+G$@-.$*?"$(’F’*"#$9%F4("9$C"$%/%(+9"#$*?"$("&"($-,$6-/*%F’/%*’-/$’9$6-/9’#"."#$?’A?$A’&"/$*?"$,%6*$*?%*$9""#$’9$*?"$)%9"$-,$%(($4.-#56*’-/R!

!-5.6"

!


30!

j_7)9-(5*"(+$5/6-/*.-((%)("I$C"$/""#$9"4%.%*"$A’/9$%/#$#"(’/*".9GG_j_KE$6-/*%F’/%*’-/$’9$/-$(-/A".$4-99’)("_j$

J*/+8&3!+&%(*20&2-!-*!-#$%!a/&%-$*22,$+&!:#&2!,%A&0!{m0*!1*/!5,8&!8*2-,6$2,-$*2!(+*7)&6%imm!

!

^17+$0%!,+&!9&2&+,))1!(+*0/8&0!71!+&(/-,7)&!%&&0!8*6(,2$&%!/20&+!8)*%&!%/(&+.$%$*2E!-#&+&5*+&!-#&+&!%#*/)0!7&!5&:&+!(+*7)&6%!:$-#!8*2-,6$2,-$*2!$5!-#&!8*6(,2$&%!,0#&+&!-*!&%-,7)$%#&0!(+*8&0/+&%!*5!a/,)$-1!8*2-+*)?!"#&1!*5-&2!*/-%*/+8&!%&&0!6/)-$()$8,-$*2!-*!%(&8$,)$%&0!5,+6&+%!:#*!%#*/)0!7&!+&9/),+)1!$2%(&8-&0?!"*!:#,-!&’-&2-!-#$%!+&,))1!#,((&2%!0&(&20%!*2!-#&!%&&0!%1%-&6!,20!a/,)$-1!8*2-+*)!%1%-&6!$2!,!8*/2-+1?!!

^*:&.&+E!$-!$%!(*%%$7)&!-#,-!(**+!5,+6&+%!(/+8#,%&!%&9+&9,-$29!MU!#17+$0!%&&0!7,8A!5+*6!9$22&+%?!H2!%/8#!,!8,%&!-#&!+$%A!*5!8*2-,6$2,-$*2!*5!*+9,2$8!8*--*2!%&&0!:$-#!!#17+$0!%&&0?!"#$%!)&,0%!-*!8*2%$0&+,7)&!%,.$29%!$2!(+*0/8-$*2!8*%-%E!7/-!,)%*!$2!#$9#&+!.,+$,7$)$-1!*5!-#&!a/,)$-1!*5!-#&!)$2-!,20!)*:&+!1$&)0%?!"#&!+$%A!*5!9&--$29!3!’5?$/!0’735/($*!5?$!),:!%’$*!3’5!G/$*0/(8$!5?(*Q!C3@’/0$O$35!’@!5?$!),:!(*!,!*$G,/,5$!(**7$Q!

!

^="95(*9$,.-F$*?’9$9*5#+$95AA"9*$*?%*$6.-4$94%6’/A$6%/$)"$59"#$*-$(’F’*$5/C%/*"#$A"/"$,(-CI$%9$X*$6-**-/$,’"(#9$oVSK$F$,.-F$*?"$"#A"$-,$F-/’*-."#$,’"(#9$#’#$/-*$%44"%.$*-$6-/*.’)5*"$*-$-5*6.-99’/AG$]-C"&".I$4-(("/0F"#’%*"#$*.%/9A"/"$,(-C$.%*"9$C"."$%(C%+9$(-C$’/$*?’9$9*5#+$Q’G"GI$p;E$-,$9""#9$%*$*?"$,’"(#$"#A"RI$"&"/$’/$F-/’*-."#$,’"(#9$*?%*$C"."$/"%.$X*$6-**-/$,’"(#9G$:?’9$95AA"9*9$*?%*$94%6’/A$,’"(#9$?5/#."#9$-,$F"*".9$,.-F$*.%/9A"/’6$6.-49$’9$5//"6"99%.+$,-.$6-**-/I$"&"/$’/$*?"$d5.-4"%/$T/’-/$C?"."$*?"$(%)"(’/A$*?."9?-(#$,-.$%#&"/*’*’-59$4."9"/6"$’/$6.-49$’9$KGJEG$]-C"&".I$*?’9$9*5#+$#"F-/9*.%*"9$*?"$4-*"/*’%($,-.$9""#0F"#’%*"#$A"/"$,(-C$*-$)"6-F"$4.-F’/"/*$’/$9"**’/A9$C?"."$%6*’-/9$%."$/-*$*%P"/$*-$P""4$%#&"/*’*’-59$4."9"/6"$’/$6?"6PG$qjjGGr$

H/$9"**’/A9$C?"."$9""#$45.’*+$’9$#"9’.%)("I$9""#$4.-#56".9$%/#$#"6’9’-/$F%P".9$9?-5(#$6-/9’#".

Seed$availability$ for$non GM# cotton%production An# ... · Seed availability for non-GM cotton...

Documents

Transcript of Seed$availability$ for$non GM# cotton%production An# ... · Seed availability for non-GM cotton...