Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room

28

Transcript of Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room

Page 1: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room
Page 2: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room
Page 3: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room

We want a lawyer, pig!

OK, punks!

Page 4: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room
Page 5: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room

Nothing is grounded.

Page 6: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room

But I’d still like to buy an

elephant gun, please.

I am NOT an #Organism-Whole,

I am a

Page 7: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room
Page 8: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room
Page 9: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room
Page 10: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room

Well, as I’m

conscious, my

actions – and my

symbols for those

actions – are

grounded in the

OK, so we’re NOT

grounded directly …

… but we ARE grounded indirectly, since we learn to use

symbols from the texts arising from

YOUR grounded uses.

Page 11: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room
Page 12: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room
Page 13: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room
Page 14: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room
Page 15: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room
Page 16: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room

My words have

never carried so

much meaning now

that I can directly

ground them via

actions in the

Page 17: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room

Some colours

make me feel

While others

make me see

Some make me

with envy!

Page 18: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room

@everycolorbot is a minimalist data-only Twitterbot.

The bot generates a random six-digit color hex-code (for an R-G-B

Red/Green/Blue mix) and a swatch of corresponding color.

Though very simple, can we say that this bot’s use of RGB symbols is grounded in external visual reality?

Page 19: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room

Dulux uses pretentious names with positive effect, but a bot might call this one “cow urine” or “rusty battleship”.

This bot would exhibit humor and visual appreciation, while grounding its use of color symbols in real stimuli.

The RGB symbol-codes in @everycolorbot are not used as

linguistic symbols, and are not used to convey semantics.

What if we build a bot that assigns meaningful color names to these arbitrary RGB symbols?

Page 20: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room

First, let’s ground the meaning of color

words in actual RGB codes that a computer can render on screen.

When a bot combines color words, it can also combine their

RGB color codes.

A compositional semantics for linguistic symbols is paired to a compositional semantics for RGB codes,

so that we can also ground the meaning of complex phrases.

Page 21: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room
Page 22: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room

We can use Web n-grams to suggest attested combinations of

our color stereotypes, such as “paper tiger” and “rose garden”. Readymade combinations of words make much more sense

than purely random ones.

Page 23: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room

The lower the n-gram frequency, the less conventional the readymade ...

… so the more striking and unusual the color name that can be derived.

Page 24: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room
Page 25: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room
Page 26: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room
Page 27: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room

Questions / Judgments

@HueHueBot (Machine names)

ColorLovers.com (Human names)

Q1: Most Descriptive name

70.4% 29.6%

Q2: Most Preferred name

70.2% 29.8%

Q3: Most Creative name

69.1% 30.9%

Page 28: Seduced and abandoned in the Chinese Room