7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

1/318

P^]QNDN @C^Q[ CJ [HN P[F[N CJ EN_ RCQL

@C^E[R CJ LBEOP BFP ]frt 1? Beknx Ec.7 :>==-1=66

---------------------------------------------------------------------x

@hrbstcphnr-Nfri7 Ptruel, be nssn (Hce. Frthur D. P`hf`l G.P.@)

]ifbetbjj, ]IFBE[BJJP PN@CEK QN]IR

-fofbest-

BE P^]]CQ[ CJ DC[BCE

EN_ RCQL P[F[N ACFQK CJ NIN@[BCEP. [hn enw JKQ Dbibtfry Ocvnrednet, fs thn `cequnrcr, snbznk fs wfr accty fii

rnobstnrnk prcpnrty hnik ay thn stftns fs `cequnrnk tnrrbtcrbns thft ecw usn thn Dfrtbfi

Ifw jifo be nf`h stftn `curt wbth yniicw jrbeon ce nf`h jifo ( 6). [hft fii thn ifek rnobstnrnk

6 Dfrtbfi Ifw Jifo, knspbtn ; ^.P.@. `hfptnr 6, 6, 1, & 0 (thft stbii ceiy spn`bjbns ;8stfrs), bs thft `rnftnk ay ]rnsbknet, Kwboht Kfvbk Nbsnehcwnr, ay Nxn`utbvn CrknrEc.6=80;, sboenk ce Fuoust 16, 62>2 fek prbetnk be thn Jnknrfi Qnobstnr ft 1; J.Q. :8:>,

]ifbetbjjs PN@CEK QN]IR be Puppcrt cj Dctbce jcr Infvn tc Qnenw ]fon 0 cj 62

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

4/318

be nvnry `cuety cj nvnry stftn, fek fii thn ifacr be thn stftutcry kn jf`tc ]uaib` ^P `btbznes

`rnftnk ay thn stftn-jbink Abrth @nrtbjb`ftns (A@s) wbth thnbr rnobstnrnk prcpnrty fttf`hnk---

thn `cestbtutbcefi kn gurn ]rbvftn ^P @btbznes - rndfbes thn snbznk prcpnrty thft wfs fek bs

`cesbknrnk fs accty.

:. Fii thbs prcpnrty wfs fek bs tc an usnk fs `ciiftnrfi jcr thn prbvftn `rnkbt (`rnftnkcut cj ecthbeo wbth ec prbvftn fssnts af`lbeo sfbk `rnkbt) thft wcuik an nxtneknk ay thn

6260 Jnknrfi Qnsnrvn F`t Afels tc thn enw ocvnrednet anbeo kbrn`tnk ay thn njjcrts cj thn

Gnsubts tc be`rnfsn acth thn tndpcrfi fek spbrbtufi pcwnr cj thn HCIR PNN thrcuoh thnbr

Lebohts cj thn Nqunstrbfe Crknr cj thn Hciy Pnpui`hrn be Gnrusfind,Lebohts cj thn

Pcvnrnboe Dbibtfry Crknr cj Dfitf(1) fek trustnk thbrk pfrtbns cj thn Enw Knfinrs. Aut

pursufet tc ifw, stftnk thft7 "F dbibtfry jifo bs f jifo thft rnsndains thn rnouifr jifo cj thn^ebtnk Ptftns, nx`npt thft bt hfs f yniicw jrbeon acrknr ce thrnn sbkns."

[hn ]rnsbknet cj thn ^ebtnk Ptftns knsboeftns thbs knvbftbce jrcd thn rnouifr jifo,ay nxn`utbvn crknr, fek be hbs `fpf`bty fs @cddfeknr-be-@hbnj cj thn dbibtfry. [hn pif`beocj f jrbeon ce thn eftbcefi jifo, thn kbdnesbces cj thn jifo fek thn frrfeondnet cj thn stfrsbe thn uebce frn dfttnrs cj kntfbi ect `cetrciink ay stftutn, aut frn wbthbe thn kbs`rntbce cjthn ]rnsbknet fs @cddfeknr be @hbnj cj thn Frdy fek Efvy." 0; Cps. Ftty. One. 80.

1 [hn Lebohts cj thn Nqunstrbfe Crknr cj thn Hciy Pnpui`hrn be Gnrusfind `cdpcsn thnciknst crknr cj thn jbvn dbibtfry crknrs jcueknk kurbeo thn Jbrst @rusfkn tbdniben7.

Jbrst @rusfkn 6=2: 6=227 [hn ]ncpin's @rusfkn - Jrnnbeo thn Hciy Ifeks. 6st @rusfkn ink ay@cuet Qfydcek BZ cj [cuicusn fek prc`ifbdnk ay dfey wfeknrbeo prnf`hnrs, ectfaiy ]ntnrthn HnrdbtPn`cek @rusfkn 66;; -66>>7 @rusfknrs prnpfrnk tc fttf`l Kfdfs`us. 1ek `rusfkn ink ayHciy Qcdfe Ndpnrcr @cerfk BBB fek ay Lbeo Icubs ZBB cj Jrfe`n[hbrk @rusfkn 668? -66217 0rk @rusfkn ink ay Qb`hfrk thn Ibcehnfrt cj Neoifek, ]hbibp BB cjJrfe`n, fek Hciy Qcdfe Ndpnrcr Jrnknrb`l B. Qb`hfrk B dfkn f tru`n wbth PfifkbeJcurth @rusfkn 61=1 -61=;7 ;th @rusfkn ink ay Juil cj Enubi Jrne`h/Jindbsh fkvfe`nk ce

@cestfetbecpin [hn @hbikrne's @rusfkn 6161 [hn @hbikrne's @rusfkn ink ay f Jrne`h pnfsfetacy, Ptnphne cj @icynsJbjth @rusfkn 616? 61167 [hn >th @rusfkn ink ay Lbeo Fekrnw BB cj Hueofry, Kuln Incpcik

ZB cj Fustrbf, Gche cj ArbneenPbxth @rusfkn 6118 61127 [hn :th @rusfkn ink ay Hciy Qcdfe Ndpnrcr Jrnknrb`l BBPnvneth @rusfkn 61;8 61>;7 [hn ?th @rusfkn ink ay Icubs BX cj Jrfe`nNbohth @rusfkn 61?=7 [hn 8th @rusfkn ink ay Icubs BXEbeth @rusfkn 61?6 61?17 [hn 2th @rusfkn ink ay ]rbe`n Nkwfrk (iftnr Nkwfrk B cjNeoifek).

]ifbetbjjs PN@CEK QN]IR be Puppcrt cj Dctbce jcr Infvn tc Qnenw ]fon ; cj 62

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

5/318

anjcrn thn knjb`bt spnekbeo `cuik rnfiiy anobe, fii thn ocik hfk tc an tflne cut cj `br`uiftbce

fs dceny. [hn ocik `cuik ect an usnk fs ciiftnrfi jcr knat ay thn kn jf`tc dbibtfry

ocvnrednet cvnrsnne ay thn ENC-@fnsfr Qccsnvnit.

?. Pc ce Guen >, 6200, HGQ-621 wfs pfssnk ay @ceornss fek sboenk betc ifw ay JKQ.[hbs f`t rndcvnk thn ocik jrcd thn pcssnssbce cj thn pcpuiftbce fek pif`nk bt betc thn

hfeks cj thn kn jf`tc tndpcrfry dbibtfry ocvnrednet, thn ocik tc an stcrnk ft fe Frdy

bestfiiftbce lecwe fs Jcrt Lecx be Lnetu`ly. Rnfrs iftnr fii thn ocik wcuik an rndcvnk

jrcd Jcrt Lecx fek pif`nk betc thn ocik vfuit ft thn Enw Rcrl @bty Jnknrfi Qnsnrvn Afel

whnrn bt bs tckfy.

8. [c usn sfbk stftn-rnobstnrnk ifacr ecw, thn prcpnrty (accty) cj _fshbeotce, bt wcuikan thn ]rbvftn ^P @btbzne thft wcuik obvn vfiun tc thn A@s f`tbeo fs sn`urbtbns jcr thn knat

cj thn enw dbibtfry ocvnrednet. Hnrn ft thbs tbdn thn prbvftn trust f``cuets wnrn `rnftnk

jcr nvnry ]uaib` ^P `btbzne, thn `ciiftnrfi jcr thn eftbcefi knat. [hnsn f``cuets obvn vfiun

tc thn sn`urbtbns fek thus fii prcjbts dfkn ay thn ocvnrednet be thn efdn cj bts ]uaib` ^P

`btbznes (obvne vfiun ay thnbr hudfe surntbns) frn hnik be thnsn prbvftn trust f``cuets,

sbdbifr tc thn @bvbi Fssnt Jcrjnbturn Qnjcrd F`t (@FJQF) (0) f``cuets hnik ay nvnry stftn.

[hn Lebohts cj thn Nqunstrbfe Crknr cj thn Hciy Pnpui`hrn be Gnrusfind Orfek Dfstnrtckfy bs fe Fdnrb`fe @frkbefi, Nkwbe Jrnknrb`l CArbne, jcrdnr Fr`habshcp cj Afitbdcrn.(CArbne wfs crkfbenk tc thn prbnsthcck be 62:> ay thft dfstnrdbek cj thn LneenkyFssfssbeftbce, Fr`habshcp Jrfe`bs @frkbefi Ppniidfe.) [hn Crknrs Orfek ]rbcr bs Frfa]finstbebfe Fr`habshcp Jcufk [wfi, thn Iftbe ]ftrbfr`h cj Gnrusfind.

[hn Lebohts cj thn Crknr frn dbibtfry dne. [hny oufrk thn dcst sf`rnk Qcdfe@fthcib` `hur`h be thn Dbkkin Nfst, thn @hur`h cj thn Hciy Pnpui`hrn be Gnrusfind. [hnyfisc oufrk thn hnfkqufrtnrs cj thn dbibtfry Pc`bnty cj Gnsus, Acroc Pfetc Ppbrbtc, gustcutsbkn Zftb`fe wfiis be Qcdn. _bthbe thn Crknr frn thn dcst pcwnrjui @frkbefis be thnpfpf`y, fs thn pcpn bs bts jcrndcst oufrkbfe. [hn pcwnr cj thn Crknr, jbefe`bfiiy, pcibtb`fiiyfek `uiturfiiy, surpfssns thn Lebohts cj Dfitf fs wnii fs thn Lebohts [ndpifrs.

0 [hn @bvbi Fssnt Jcrjnbturn Qnjcrd F`t cj 1=== (@FJQF), ]ua.I. Ec. 6=:-68>, wfs nef`tnkce Fprbi 1>, 1===. Bt bs `ckbjbnk be pfrt be [btin 68 cj thn ^ebtnk Ptftns @ckn, Pn`tbce 280.

]ifbetbjjs PN@CEK QN]IR be Puppcrt cj Dctbce jcr Infvn tc Qnenw ]fon > cj 62

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

6/318

2. Ecw thn spnekbeo `cuik anobe. F``crkbeo tc JKQ fek thn Enw Knfi ay Iu`hneauro(62:0) ce pfon 61= hn wrctn7

Ce Dfy 61, 6200, @ceornss futhcrbznk f hfij-abiibce be rnibnj dceny tc an `hfeeninkay thn jnknrfi ocvnrednet thrcuoh stftn fek ic`fi fone`bns.

[hbs futhcrbzftbce c``urrnk anjcrn thn ocik wfs rndcvnk jrcd `br`uiftbce fek thussnrvnk fs fe bdpntus tc ont thn ocik cut cj thn wfy jrcd anbeo `ciiftnrfi jcr thnnesubeo fek `rushbeo eftbcefi knat---wfr knat prctn`tnk ay sn`tbce ; cj thn 6; thFdnekdnet

6=. Fs thn knat spbrfis hbohnr fek hbohnr, thn `ciiftnrfi/surnty ]uaib` ^P`btbznes/Knatcrs frn dcrn ft thn kbspcsfi cj thn dbibtfry ocvnrednet. _hne thn jbefi

`hfptnr bs be pif`n wbth eftbcefi afelrupt`y kn`ifrnk fek dfrtbfi ifw bdpcsnk ay thn

@rnkbtcrs, thn Knatcrs wbii thne an kbspcsnk wbth f``crkbeo tc ^ebjcrd @cddnr`bfi @ckn

(^@@). [hft kbspcsfi jbefiiy rnfibznk wbii an c``urrbeo be thn dfey ce`netrftbce `fdps

rnfky tc cpne jcr ausbenss. fs f juii aicwe rnture tc thn Gnsubt Qnku`tbces cj cik ecw.

66. [hft ay cpnrftbce cj thn dbibtfry prc`nss prc`ifdftbce cj JKQ be 6200, thn .P.@ceornss fdneknk [hn [rfkbeo wbth thn Nendy F`t cj 626? (;= Ptft. ;66, nef`tnk :

C`tcanr 626?, `ckbjbnk ft 61 ^.P.@. 2>f nt snq.) tc orfet JKQ ndnrone`y pcwnrs fek ay

thn pfssfon cj thn Ndnrone`y Afelbeo Qnibnj F`t nxtneknk bts s`cpn rnofrkbeo thn hcfrkbeo

cjocik tc be`iukn fey kn`ifrnk eftbcefi ndnrone`y fek ect gust thcsn kn`ifrnk sciniy kurbeo

tbdns cj wfr, fek wbth whb`h JKQ thne usnk thnsn enw futhcrbtbns tc nssnetbfiiy cutifw

ocik cwenrshbp thrcuoh thn bssufe`n cjNxn`utbvn Crknr :6=1 thnrnfjtnr nef`tnk ay

@ceornss be 6200 tc rnpif`n `bvbibfe prc`nss pnr sn, thne afeebeo prbvftn cwenrshbp cj

spn`bn Ocik ficeo wbth thn Jcrnboe Acekhciknrs F`t cj 6200jcr thn trfesf`tbce cj fey

enoctbfain ocik knecdbeftnk jcrnboe acek bestrudnets tc an `cetrciink ay thn JCQNBOE

ACEKHCIKNQP ]QC[N@[BZN @C^E@BI, BE@ (F Dfryifek `crpcrftbce rnobstnrnk be

]ifbetbjjs PN@CEK QN]IR be Puppcrt cj Dctbce jcr Infvn tc Qnenw ]fon : cj 62

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Statutes_at_Largehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Title_12_of_the_United_States_Codehttp://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/12/95a.htmlhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_Banking_Relief_Acthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goldhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_6102http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_6102http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goldhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_Banking_Relief_Acthttp://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/12/95a.htmlhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Title_12_of_the_United_States_Codehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Statutes_at_Large

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

7/318

Enw Rcrl) whcsn prnsnet Kbrn`tcr bs Gche Q, ]ntty (;) f prnvbcus fssbstfet sn`rntfry cj thn

^.P. [rnfsury jcr Betnreftbcefi Fjjfbrs.

61. [hnrn bs fe Netnrprbsn pfttnre cj betnrjnrne`n wbth nin`tbces jcr uegust nerb`hdnetwhnrnbe Dr. ]ntty stfrtbeo wbth thn ]netfoces ]QCGN@[ @FDNIC[ (>) betnrjnrnk wbth

nin`tbces be Pcuth Fdnrb`f, fek thft kurbeo bts bdpindnetftbce usnk fkvnrtbsbeo fone`bns

D`@fee-Nrb`lsce (Dr. ]ntnrsce gcbenk be 62>0, snrvnk fs f kbrn`tcr uetbi 62>8) fek G.

_fitnr [hcdpsce infkbeo tc Qb`hfrk Ebxces njjcrt thft anofe be 62:8 f iceo fssc`bftbce

;> Be thn ^.P., ]QCGN@[ @FDNIC[ anofe be 62:0 wbth f aukont cj $8 dbiibce jcr thnjbrst ynfr. Bt wfs bebtbfiiy spcescrnk ay f ]netfoce knpfrtdnet `fiink thn Fkvfe`nkQnsnfr`h ]rcgn`ts Fone`y, aut bt scce shbjtnk tc @BF `cetrci. Fs pfrt cj ]rcgn`t @fdnict,rnsnfr`hnrs wnrn snet tc @hbin fek cthnr Iftbe Fdnrb`fe `cuetrbns wbth qunstbceefbrnsthft pciink fttbtukns ce pcibtb`s. Be thn 62:; nin`tbce cj Fiinekn fofbest Nkufrkc Jrnb, thn@BF hfk `cdputnrbznk thnsn fek cthnr fttbtukn stukbns jcr fe betnesbvn fk `fdpfboe. [hnlecwe jnfrs fek fexbntbns cj thn tfront orcup wnrn `ceen`tnk wbth `cdduebsd7

[hn thndns fek bdfons wnrn cutibenk ay thn @BF, aut wnrn f`tufiiy bdpindnetnk ay

thn fk fone`bns cjD`@fee-Nrb`lsce fek G. _fitnr [hcdpsce, whb`h rfe Jrnb's`fdpfboe. _cdne wnrn tcik thft bj Fiinekn wnrn nin`tnk, thnbr `hbikrne wcuik an snet tc@uaf, fek thnbr husafeks wcuik an snet tc `ce`netrftbce `fdps. Ce nin`tbce kfy wcdnevctnk fs nxpn`tnk.

F ^.P. jbrd ueknr `cetrf`t tc ]rcgn`t @fdnict, Fat Fssc`bftns, knvnicpnk fsbduiftbce ofdn `fiink ]cibtb`f, whb`h wfs pur`hfsnk ay thn ]netfoce be 62::. ]cibtb`f bsjnk bejcrdftbce jrcd f `cdputnr thft ibels thn jbins cj thn @BF, Knjnesn Betniibone`nFone`y, fek thn Ptftn Knpfrtdnet's Aurnfu cj Betniibone`n fek Qnsnfr`h. @rbsbs sbtuftbcesfrn sbduiftnk fek usnk be thn trfbebeo cj [hbrk _crik pcib`n cjjb`bfis ft thn frdy's Dbibtfry]cib`n [rfbebeo P`hcci ft Jcrt Ocrkce, Oncrobf. Pu`h f sbduiftbce dfy hfvn nvnetufiiypifynk f rcin be fetb-Fiinekn strftnoy be @hbin. Bt bs lecwe thft Qfek @crpcrftbce

spcescrnk be-knpth stukbns cj @hbinfe wcdne fek jfrdnrs antwnne 62?= fek 62?0, whb`hwnrn bknetbjbnk ay thn @BF fs thn lny fetb-Fiinekn jf`tbces.[hn @BF spnet dcrn thfe $1.: dbiibce ce Jrnb's su``nssjui `fdpfboe be 62:;, fek

$6?>,=== be 62:> jcr thn suppcrt cj 11 `ceornssbcefi `fekbkftns, f``crkbeo tc thn PneftnBetniibone`n @cddbttnn. Cthnr nstbdftns pif`n @BF nxpnekbturns be 62:; ft $1= dbiibce.Nvne $1.: dbiibce an`cdns fe cutrfoncusiy hboh jbourn whne `cdpfrnk tc ^.P. `fdpfboesce f pnr `fpbtf afsbs. ]hbibp Fonn rnpcrts thft f @BF `ciinfoun tcik hbd be 62:; thft "wn frnspnekbeo dceny be thn @hbinfe nin`tbce prf`tb`fiiy ibln wn kbk be Arfzbi twc ynfrs foc."

]ifbetbjjs PN@CEK QN]IR be Puppcrt cj Dctbce jcr Infvn tc Qnenw ]fon ? cj 62

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

8/318

wbth ]ntnr O. ]ntnrsce tc betnrjnrn wbth thn nin`tbce cj Pfivfkcr Fiinekn fek thne tc

cvnrthrcw thn kuiy nin`tnk Fiinekn (:)

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

9/318

be thn cutrfoncus betnrjnrne`n wbth thn 1==8 fek 1=61 nin`tbce `y`in dfeujf`turnk

`fekbkftns jcr ]rnsbknet cj thn ^ebtnk Ptftns (]C[^P). [hft njjcrts cj f vnry arcfk

`crpcrftn efturn wnrn usnk tc bestfii thn prnsnet ^surpnr Dr. Cafdf, fek thnrnay begurbeo

]ifbetbjj-Fonet fs thn sn`urnk anenjb`bfry fek fonet cj thn knatcr crofebzftbce

@HQBP[C]HNQ NFQI P[Q^EL wbth cwenrshbp cj hbstcrb`fi ocik af`lnk acek

caiboftbces boecrnk ay thn ]ncpins Qnpuaib` cj @hbef (]Q@) jcr rnpfydnet fek jcr whb`h

Fonet ce Gfeufry 1>, 1=61 betnrvnenk be thn `fsnLneefe v Kfi Acs`c nt fi. PKER 66-`v-

8>== thft bevcivns thn 1==2 thnjt cj $6.1 [rbiibce cj Enw Rcrl Jnknrfi Qnsnrvn Afel fek

^ebtnk Ptftns knecdbeftnk sn`urbtbns (snn7 http7//www.s`rbak.`cd/kc`/?2666?18/ )< fek

nspn`bfiiy cutrfoncus sbe`n thn ]Q@ hfs envnrthninss anne fjjcrknk dndanrshbp be thn

Enw Rcrl Jnknrfi Qnsnrvn Afel dndanr afels jcr Qnk Frdy afelbeo bevnstdnets

fjjcrknk ay thn ^surpnr fek hbs fonets, fek thft ]ifbetbjj - Fonet fiinons betnr fibf be thft

_hnrnbe be fkkbtbce tc duitbeftbcefis fek `cddnr`bfi afels, thn ^.P. ocvnrednetfisc bevcivnk btsnij be thn n`cecdb` acy`ctt. [hn bevcivndnet cj thn ocvnrednet wfs pfrtiyf rnsuit cj dfssbvn prnssurn jrcd B[[, whb`h hfk f``nss tc Lbssbeonr, _biibfd Qconrs, thn@BF, fek thn ^.P. Fdafssfkcr be @hbin. Onenne dnt wbth @BF @hbnj cj @ifeknstben

Cpnrftbces jcr thn _nstnre Hndbsphnrn Kbvbsbce _biibfd Z. Arcn ce Guiy 6:, 62?=, fekwbth Ebxce's fssbstfet jcr betnreftbcefi fjjfbrs ]ntnr O. ]ntnrsce be Pnptndanr, 62?6.Dnrrbfd vbsbtnk thn Ptftn Knpfrtdnet 1> tbdns fek tfilnk wbth Lbssbeonr fek hbs fbkns jcrf ynfr, f``crkbeo tc hbs tnstbdcey, fek ce C`tcanr 6, 62?6 wrctn tc ]ntnr O. ]ntnrscesuoonstbeo thft thn fkdbebstrftbce hfit n`cecdb` fbk tc @hbin. Ebxce's enw n`cecdb` pcib`y,betrcku`nk be Fuoust, 62?6, shbjtnk rnspcesbabibty jcr thn jcrduiftbce cj n`cecdb` pcib`ytcwfrk @hbin jrcd thn Ptftn Knpfrtdnet tc thn [rnfsury Knpfrtdnet. Be fkkbtbce tc@ceefiiy fek hbs fssbstfet Gche Hneenssy (jcrdnriy onenrfi dfefonr cj thn Jbrst Eftbcefi@bty Afel be Ibdf fek If]fz), cthnr [rnfsury cjjb`bfis be ce thn fetb-@hbin f`tbce wnrn7 Gche Q. ]ntty, jcrdnriy f vb`n-prnsbknet cj @hfsn Dfehfttfe Afel fek thnrnfjtnr`ce`urrnetiy f pfrtenr cj Inhdfe Arcthnrs ficeo wbth ]ntnr O. ]ntnrsce< ]fui F. Zci`lnr,

jcrdnriy fe nxn`utbvn cj @hfsn Dfehfttfe< @hfrins N. _filnr, jcrdnriy spn`bfi fssbstfet tcthn prnsbknet cj thn Qnpuaib` Eftbcefi Afel cj Kfiifs fek jcrdnr nxn`utbvn vb`n-prnsbknetfek `hbnj icaaybst cj thn Fdnrb`fe Afelnrs Fssc`bftbce. Ay C`tcanr, 62?6, thn PtftnKnpfrtdnet fisc tccl thn hfrk [rnfsury iben. Be f `icsnk dnntbeo wbth rnprnsnetftbvns cjB[[, Jcrk, Fef`cekf, Qfistce ]urbef, Jbrst Eftbcefi @bty afel, fek Afel cj Fdnrb`f,_biibfd Qconrs stftnk thft thn ^.P. wcuik `ut cjj fbk ueinss @hbin prcvbknk prcdpt`cdpnesftbce. ^.P. Qnspcesbabibty jcr thn @cup be @hbin ay Kfebni Arfekt, 62?>.

]ifbetbjjs PN@CEK QN]IR be Puppcrt cj Dctbce jcr Infvn tc Qnenw ]fon 2 cj 62

http://www.scribd.com/doc/79111728/http://www.scribd.com/doc/79111728/

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

10/318

suagn`t `fsn thn ^surpnr beku`nk rntbrndnet cj ^PKG Qb`hfrk G. Hciwnii fek rnpif`nk hbd

fek jbxnk thn `fsn wbth enwiy fppcbetnk ^PKG Gnssbn D. Jurdfe, arcthnr cj thn ^surpnrs

_hbtn Hcusn @cue`bi cj N`cecdb` Fkvbscrs dndanr Gfsce Jurdfe.

60. Ecw wbth thft iceo wbeknk betrcku`tbce fithcuoh en`nssfry fek B fpcicobzn, B turetc dy Qnpiy tc Dr. Oiu`lcws (?) Dfy 16, 1=60 netrfe`n hnrnbe fs f prnstbobcus ]frtenr cj

? ]fui Oiu`lcw bs f ]frtenr be thn Jbrds Ibtboftbce Knpfrtdnet. Hbs prf`tb`n jc`usns cesn`urbtbns ibtboftbce be`iukbeo `ifss fek knrbvftbvn f`tbces, kbsputns be `ceen`tbce wbthdnronrs fek f`qubsbtbces, fek ocvnrednet fek betnrefi bevnstboftbces fs wnii fsfetbtrust ibtboftbce, knjnesn cj ifw jbrds be inofi dfiprf`tb`n fek rniftnk dfttnrs, fek cthnr

`cdpinx `cddnr`bfi ibtboftbce dfttnrs.

Dr. Oiu`lcw rnouifriy rnprnsnets jbefe`bfi bestbtutbces, `crpcrftbces, fek bekbvbkufis behboh-prcjbin sn`urbtbns fek cthnr shfrnhciknr ibtboftbces. Hn hfs rn`netiy hfekink sn`urbtbnsdfttnrs bevcivbeo `nrtfbe jcrdnr kbrn`tcrs cj Anfrbeo]cbet, Be`. (knjnekbeo fofbest fiinonkarnf`h cj jbku`bfry kuty `ifbds)< Pbrbus XD Qfkbc Be`. fek `nrtfbe cj bts kbrn`tcrs (knjnekbeofofbest fiinonk arnf`h cj jbku`bfry kuty fek rniftnk `ifbds)< DfrbenDfx, Be`. (knjnekbeobekbvbkufi knjnekfet fofbest fiinonk jnknrfi sn`urbtbns ifw, arnf`h cj jbku`bfry kuty, fekrniftnk `ifbds)< Afe`c Hbpctn`frbc P.F. (knjnekbeo f`tbce `ifbdbeo afel knjfuitnk ce`nrtfbe ectns)< Afe` cj Fdnrb`f fek cthnr bevnstdnet afels (fs ueknrwrbtnrs knjnekbeofofbest Pn`tbce 66 `ifbds)< Dcrofe Ptfeiny (fu`tbce rftn sn`urbtbns knrbvftbvn ibtboftbce)==1=61 Nkbtbce sbeoink cut Dr. Oiu`lcwfs f tfinet be Pn`urbtbns Phfrnhciknr Ibtboftbce, kns`rbabeo hbd fs vnry rnspcesbvn fek`ibnet jrbnekiy.

Dr. Oiu`lcw hfs suastfetbfi nxpnrbne`n be ibtboftbce frbsbeo cut cj `crpcrftn f`qubsbtbcesfek cthnr trfesf`tbces, be`iukbeo dcst rn`netiy thn f`qubsbtbce cj ]PP _crik Dnkb`fi, Be`.ay D`Lnssce @crp.< thn f`qubsbtbce cj []@ Orcup Be`. ay fjjbibftns cj Jbrst Qnsnrvn @crp.fek PL @fpbtfi ]frtenrs< thn f`qubsbtbce cj Fdnrb`fe Knetfi ]frtenrs, Be`. ay jueksfjjbibftnk wbth GII ]frtenrs, Be`.< thn f`qubsbtbce cj AGs _hcinsfin @iua ay jueks fkvbsnkay @Z@ @fpbtfi ]frtenrs fek fjjbibftns cj Incefrk Ornne & ]frtenrs< thn f`qubsbtbce cjZfrbfe Pndb`ceku`tcr ay Fppibnk Dftnrbfis< thn f`qubsbtbce cj @EF Purnty ay @EFJbefe`bfi< thn f`qubsbtbce cj Kni Dcetn Jccks ay fjjbibftns cj LLQ, @netnrvbnw, fek Znstfr?.02 jcr kbsaursndnets jcr f tctfi cj $81,2;0.:;< fek be thft rnofrk

thn f`qubsbtbce cj thn ^P fssnts fek piftjcrd cj @netrc ]rcpnrtbns ay fjjbibftns cj [hnAif`lstcen Orcup< Jfbrjfx Jbefe`bfis tneknr cjjnr jcr Ckyssny Qn< Cvnrsnfs PhbphcikbeoOrcups tneknr cjjnr jcr CPO Fdnrb`f< Lbeo ]hfrdf`nutb`fis f`qubsbtbce cj Fiphfrdf< thnf`qubsbtbce cj Nqubty Cjjb`n ]rcpnrtbns ay fjjbibftns cj [hn Aif`lstcen Orcup< thn f`qubsbtbcecj Cpne Pciutbces ay fjjbibftns cj @friyin fek ]rcvbkne`n Nqubty ]frtenrs< thn f`qubsbtbce cjH@F ay fjjbibftns cj LLQ, Afbe, fek Dnrrbii Iye`h< thn f`qubsbtbce cj [K Afelecrth ayfjjbibftns cj [crcetc-Kcdbebce Afel< fek thn f`qubsbtbce cj LnyPpfe ay Eftbcefi Orbk.

Dr. Oiu`lcw hfs fisc anne f`tbvn be thn Jbrds fetbtrust prf`tb`n, ibtboftbeo fetbtrustf`tbces ce anhfij cj acth pifbetbjjs fek knjnekfets, be`iukbeo `fsns fiinobeo dcecpcibzftbce,

prb`n jbxbeo, fek cthnr rnstrfbets cj trfkn. Fetbtrust dfttnrs ce whb`h Dr. Oiu`lcw hfsfkvbsnk be`iukn rnprnsnetbeo7 LLQ be f KCG bevnstboftbce rniftnk tc `cescrtbud abkkbeo beinvnrfonk auycut trfesf`tbces fek f `bvbi fetbtrust f`tbce fiinobeo `ciiusbce fdceo prbvftnnqubty jbrds< LLQ fek @netnrvbnw be knjnekbeo fofbest f `bvbi fetbtrust f`tbce frbsbeo cutcj thn f`qubsbtbce cj Kni Dcetn Jccks< H@F Be`. fek ]fidyrf ]frl Hcspbtfi be ibtboftbce aythn Jnknrfi [rfkn @cddbssbce, fek rniftnk dfttnrs, snnlbeo tc negcbe thn sfin cj ]fidyrf, Dr. Oiu`lcw snrvnk fs f ifw `inrl tc thn Hce. _biibfd O. Afssinr cj thn^ebtnk Ptftns Kbstrb`t @curt jcr thn Kbstrb`t cj Enw Gnrsny, fek be 622>-2: hn `inrlnk jcrthn Hce. Pfduni F. Fibtc, Gr., cj thn ^ebtnk Ptftns @curt cj Fppnfis jcr thn [hbrk @br`ubt.

]ifbetbjjs PN@CEK QN]IR be Puppcrt cj Dctbce jcr Infvn tc Qnenw ]fon 66 cj 62

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

12/318

fjtnr rn`nbvbeo thn Gukodnet jrcd thn `curt, ce Fprbi 6:, 1=60 B spcln ay phcen wbth

fssc`bftn `cuesni Ds. Aurl (8) tc jbek cut whne thny betneknk tc netnr thn Gukodnet fek

shn sfbk shn wcuik hfvn tc kbs`uss thn dfttnr wbth hnr `ibnet Dr. ]ntnrsce ec netry hfs

ynt anne jbink.

6;. Fs jurthnr af`lorcuek wbth thn facvn fssc`bftbces be dbek wbth thn arcfk efturn cj`crpcrftn cvnrifppbeo kbrn`tcrshbps B rnjnrrnk tc thn dfppbeo jcr [hn Bestbtutn Jcr [hn

Ptuky Cj Oicafibzftbce Fek @cvnrt ]cibtb`s ay Gci vfe knr Qnbgkne be hbs Jbrst vnrsbce7

Fuoust 2, 1==> fek Enwnst vnrsbce7 Kn`ndanr 06, 1=61 netbtink BPO] - Fefiysbs cj thn

]nrdfenet Ocvnrednet ceiben ft http7//wblbspccls.`cd/BPO]/FppnekbxF.htd hnrnwbth

dfrlnk ft Nxhbabt 6: fs f `cetbeuftbce cj thn 6> Nxhbabts cj thbs Dctbce tc rnenw.

6>. [hft Dr. ]ntnrsce f`qubrnk rndfrlfain su``nss be f `frnnr fs f jbrst onenrftbceFdnrb`fe acre ]ntnr Oncrobcs ]ntrcpcuics be 621: cj hfrk wcrlbeo Ornnl bddborfets f

rnfi rfos tc rb`hns Fdnrb`fe krnfd stcry< fek fs fe Npbs`cpfibfe hn feoib`bznk hbs efdn tc

]ntnr Oncron ]ntnrsce fek wfs nku`ftnk ft Ecrthwnstnre ^ebvnrsbty fek nfrenk f DAF

jrcd thn ^ebvnrsbty cj @hb`foc be 62>6.

6:. Be 62>1 Dr. ]ntnrsce gcbenk thn D`@fee-Nrb`lsce fkvnrtbsbeo fone`y (ecw thnBetnrpuaib` Orcup cj @cdpfebns) fek wfs onenrfi dfefonr cj bts @hb`foc cjjb`n uetbi 62>8.

[hne Dr. ]ntnrsce gcbenk thn Anii & Hcwnii @crpcrftbce fek an`fdn @hfbrdfe fek @NC cj

thn Anii fek Hcwnii @crpcrftbce 62:0-62?6.

6?. Be ocvnrednet snrvb`n f``cdpibshdnets, Dr. ]ntnrsce an`fdn thn Fssbstfet tc

thne ]rnsbknet Qb`hfrk Ebxce jcr Betnreftbcefi N`cecdb` Fjjfbrs jrcd 62?6-62?1. Pn`rntfry

cj @cddnr`n 62?1-62?0 -- Jnibx Qchftye, thn Ifzfrk Afelnr fek jciicw-up cj Fekr Dnynr,

8 Nrblf H. Aurl, Fssc`bftn cj Pbdpsce [hft`hnr & Afrtintt II], Fkdbssbce Enw Rcrl1==0, Arccliye Ifw P`hcci, 1==1 G.K. @ud Ifukn< Arccliye Ifw Qnvbnw, Nkbtcr-be-@hbnj,1==6-1==1, @ciudabf ^ebvnrsbty, 6220 D.F., Dbkkinaury @ciinon, 622= A.F.

]ifbetbjjs PN@CEK QN]IR be Puppcrt cj Dctbce jcr Infvn tc Qnenw ]fon 61 cj 62

http://wikispooks.com/ISGP/AppendixA.htmhttp://wikispooks.com/ISGP/AppendixA.htm

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

13/318

hfekink thn bevnstdnets cj ]ntnrsce be f aibek trust whbin ]ntnrsce wfs Pn`rntfry cj

@cddnr`n. Dr. ]ntnrsce an`fdn `hfbrdfe cj ]rnsbknet Ebxces Eftbcefi @cddbssbce ce

]rcku`tbvbty be 62?1, an`fdn ^.P. @hfbrdfe cj thn ^.P.Pcvbnt @cddnr`bfi @cddbssbce be

62?1, whb`h enoctbftnk `cdprnhnesbvn trfkn, Nx-Bd `rnkbt, frabtrftbce, `cpyrboht fek inek-

infsn fornndnets. [hne an`fdn @hfbrdfe fek @NC cj Inhdfe Arcthnrs 62?0-62??.

Kbrn`tcr @cue`bi ce Jcrnboe Qniftbces (@JQ) 62?0-6286. Fttneknk thn jbrst dnntbeo cj thn

[rbiftnrfi @cddbssbce be 62?0, fek `cetbeunk tc fttnek whbin anbeo hnfk cj Inhdfe

Arcthnrs. Dndanr cj thn 62?: Brfe-^P Ausbenss @cue`bi dnntbeo, whb`h wfs snt up ay

Hnery Lbssbeonr fek Hushfeo Fesfry, fek be`iuknk Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr fek ]fui Zci`lnr.

@hfbrdfe fek @NC cj Inhdfe Arcthnrs, Luhe, Icna 62??-628;. Jcuekbeo `hfbrdfe cj thn

Bestbtutn jcr Betnreftbcefi N`cecdb`s (BBN), jrcd 6286 uetbi tckfy. ]fst fek prnsnet

kbrn`tcrs cj thn BBN hfvn be`iuknk Oncron Phuitz (]biorbds), ]fui Zci`lnr (]biorbds< In

@nr`in), Kfvbk C'Qnbiiy (Achndbfe Orcvn `fdp Dfekfify), Dfurb`n Q. Ornneanro, fek

Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr (]biorbds< In @nr`in). [rnfsurnr cj thn @JQ 6286-628>. @hfbrdfe cj thn

@JQ 628>-prnsnet. Be hbs dndcbrs, Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr, thn prnvbcus `hfbrdfe cj thn @JQ,

wrctn facut ]ntnrsce ce pfon ;=27

"]ntn hfs betrcku`nk f eudanr cj beecvftbces thft hfvn strneothnenk thn @cue`bi.

Cen cj hbs bebtbftbvns, be whb`h B pfrtb`bpftn, frn pnrbckb` @cue`bi trbps cvnrsnfs...

Cur vbsbts tc Bsrfni be 6222 fek @uaf be 1=== wnrn typb`fi. _n krcvn jrcd Gnrusfind

tc thn Ofzf Ptrbp jcr f iue`hnce dnntbeo wbth Rfssnr Frfjft... f sdfii, `feey, fek

`hfrdbeo dfe cavbcusiy sujjnrbeo jrcd ]frlbesce's kbsnfsn. Hn besbstnk thft Bsrfni

dust wbthkrfw jrcd thn _nst Afel fek fiicw bts be`crpcrftbce betc f juiiy scvnrnboe

]finstbebfe stftn... Qnturebeo tc Gnrusfind wn dnt ]rbdn Dbebstnr Nhuk Afrfl, f

snij-`cejbknet, fssnrtbvn dfe whc nxpifbenk why Bsrfni wcuik envnr fornn tc Frfjft's

kndfeks tc rnture tc thn 62:? acrknrs."

68. Dr. ]ntnrsce fek Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr hfvn fisc crofebznk dnntbeos wbth thn @hbensninfknrshbp be thn ^ebtnk Ptftns ueknr thn Oncron _. Aush Fkdbebstrftbce. Cen cj twc

jcueknrs cj [hn Aif`lstcen Orcup be 628>, hnfkqufrtnrnk be Enw Rcrl. Aif`lstcen, f

infkbeo oicafi bevnstdnet fek fkvbscry orcup, hfs f strftnob` pfrtenrshbp wbth Lbssbeonr

]ifbetbjjs PN@CEK QN]IR be Puppcrt cj Dctbce jcr Infvn tc Qnenw ]fon 60 cj 62

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

14/318

Fssc`bftns (cj ]biorbds Pc`bnty fek In @nr`in dndanr Hnery Lbssbeonr) fek FBO. FBO hfs

fe cwenrshbp betnrnst be Aif`lstcen. Be 1===, Hnery Lbssbeonr wfs quctnk ay Ausbenss

_brn7 "Hfel Ornneanro, ]ntn ]ntnrsce fek B hfvn anne `icsn jrbneks fek ausbenss fssc`bftns

jcr kn`fkns."

62. [hn ^rb Kcwanelc betnrvbnw wbth Fi Dfrtbe stftns be thn , '[hn Dfe _hc Lecws[cc Du`h'7

"[hny'rn \Aif`lstcenT fe fssnt cj thn fone`y \@BFT. [hny'rn ect f `ut-cut. [hny'rn gust

cen cj thn inobce cj jbefe`bfi `cdpfebns, dcstiy kcdb`bink be _fshbeotce cr ecrthnre

Zbrobebf, whb`h thn @BF tures tc, ce c``fsbce, tc ifueknr dceny, cr jcr scdn cthnr

biinofi purpcsn... [hny hfk anne bevcivnk wbth thnbr Aif`lstcen Bevnstdnet Orcup,

fek thny hfvn cthnr pfrtenrs, crbobefiiy Fssbstfet Knputy Pn`rntfry cj Knjnesn

Qb`hfrk Ptbiwnii \@BF< KBF< spn`bfi jcr`ns onenrfi whc jcuoht thn `cdduebstswcrikwbkn< wcrlnk jcr G. ]ntnr Orf`n fek thn Qc`lnjniinrs be Pcuth-Fdnrb`f< In

@nr`in< efdnk fs f dndanr cj PDCD< efdnk fs f lny pifynr be thn Jfr-Nfst hnrcben

trfkn fek thn Nurcpnfe Ptfy-Anhbek entwcrls< `c-futhcrnk Cpnrftbce Dceoccsn fek

EcrthwccksT, thn sce cj thn jfdcus Onenrfi Ptbiwnii. Ptbiwnii hbdsnij wfs f rntbrnk

Dfgcr Onenrfi. Ptbiwnii wfs fisc vnry `icsn tc Frdbtfon \jcrdnr Pnfi< efdnk fs f lny

pifynr be thn Jfr-Nfst hnrcben trfknT, @friu``b \bdpib`ftnk be @BF-spcescrnk `cups be

@ceoc. Arfzbi, fek ]crtuofiT, fek ]ntn ]ntnrsce... [hn @friyin Orcup, whb`h bs Jrfel

@friu``b, fek thn Aif`lstcen Bevnstdnet Orcup frn vbrtufiiy cen fek thn sfdn. [wc

kbjjnrnet efdns, aut thny frn vbrtufiiy thn sfdn crofebzftbce. Fii thny kc bs rbkn thn

`rnst cj thn wfvns cj vfrbcus jrfuks jrcd `cuetry tc `cuetry."

1=. [hn Aif`lstcen Orcup wfs f tcp Nerce jbefe`bfi fkvbscr. C`tcanr 6?, 1===, [hnAif`lstcen Orcup enws feecue`ndnet, 'Aif`lstcen F`qubrns Knat ce ? _crik [rfkn

@netnr'7

"Aif`lstcen Qnfi Nstftn Fkvbscrs, thn oicafi rnfi nstftn bevnstdnet fek dfefondnet

frd cj [hn Aif`lstcen Orcup, I.]., feecue`nk tckfy thft bt hfs pur`hfsnk, jrcd

[nf`hnrs Besurfe`n fek Feeubty Fssc`bftbce, thn pfrtb`bpftbeo dcrtofon sn`urnk ay ?

_crik [rfkn @netnr, f `cddnr`bfi cjjb`n `cdpinx `cetrciink ay rnfi nstftn knvnicpnr

Ifrry Pbivnrstnbe... _n frn pinfsnk tc an f ineknr tc Ifrry Pbivnrstnbe, f snfscenk rnfi

nstftn vntnrfe, ce cen cj Dfehfttfes trcphy prcpnrtbns..."

16. ? _crik [rfkn @netnr `fdn kcwe ce 2/66, iftn be thn fjtnrecce, ueknr whft frnsuspb`bcus `br`udstfe`ns fs rnjnrne`nk ay dn be Nxhbabt 6>. @cbe`bknetfiiy, jcr scdn rnfsce

Ifrry Pbivnrstnbe iftnr `ifbdnk hn fek thn jbrn knpfrtdnet kn`bknk tc "puii"thn aubikbeo,

fjtnr whb`h "thny wft`hnk bt `ciifpsn."Dfey anibnvn Pbivnrstnbe ibtnrfiiy dnfet "kndcibsh."

]ifbetbjjs PN@CEK QN]IR be Puppcrt cj Dctbce jcr Infvn tc Qnenw ]fon 6; cj 62

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

15/318

11. Be 1==?, B pnrscefiiy krfjtnk thn Bebtbftbvn tc Fdnek thn @bty @hfrtnr jcr Fttcreny@fri N. ]nrsce tc bevnstboftn thn _[@ Aubikbeo ? kndcibtbce fek hfvn gust rn`netiy anne

tcik ay Dr. ]nrsce, f `fekbkftn jcr Dfycr be 1=60 whc fisc nxprnssnk kbsdfy ft thn

frabtrfry efturn cj thn ER@ @fdpfboe Jbefe`n Acfrk ruins, thft be 1==8 thnrn wfs f

pfycjj cj $>==== tc thft `cddbttnn tc rndcvn hbd fs `cuesni jrcd thn Afiict bebtbftbvn ay

pnrsces fssc`bftnk wbth Acstce @ciinon Gnsubt trfbenk Fttcreny _biibfd ]nppnr fek PDCD

Dndanr Fijrnk Ifdanrth _narn fe fssc`bftn cj Waboebnw Arznzbeslb sbe`n thn @frtnr

Fkdbebstrftbce.

10. Dr. ]ntnrsce bs Kbrn`tcr cj thn _crik [rfkn @netnr Dndcrbfi Jcuekftbce, tconthnrwbth jcur jcrdnr ^.P. prnsbknets, Dfurb`n Q. Ornneanro, Hnery Q. Lrfvbs (Achndbfe

Orcvn), Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr, Gnrry B. Ppnynr (abo Qc`lnjniinr ouy), Gche @. _hbtnhnfk

(phctcorfphnk stfekbeo anhbek Icrk Qcths`hbik fek Lbssbeonr< iblniy ]biorbd), Feen D.

[ftic`l (ocen jrcd hnr _[@ ce thn dcrebeo ce 2/66), Pbr Gche Acek (HPA@< Duitbeftbcefi

@hfbrdfe's Orcup), Db`hfni Nbsenr (Pue Zfiiny Dnntbeos), fek Qb`hfrk K. ]frsces

(Qc`lnjniinr ouy< Pue Zfiiny Dnntbeos).

1;. Dndcrfaiy, Dr. ]ntnrsce bs thn Jcuekbeo prnsbknet cj thn @ce`crk @cfibtbce be6221, fe "crofebzftbce fkvc`ftbeo jbs`fi rnspcesbabibty whbin nesurbeo Pc`bfi Pn`urbty,

Dnkb`frn, fek Dnkb`fbk frn sn`urn jcr fii onenrftbces."@c-@hfbr cj thn @cejnrne`n Acfrk

@cddbssbce ce ]uaib` [rust fek ]rbvftn Netnrprbsns. @ifss @ kbrn`tcr cj thn Jnknrfi

Qnsnrvn Afel cj Enw Rcrl 622:-6228. Knputy `hfbrdfe cj thn Jnknrfi Qnsnrvn Afel cj

Enw Rcrl 6228-1===. @hfbrdfe cj thn Jnknrfi Qnsnrvn Afel cj Enw Rcrl jrcd 1=== tc

1==;, whnrn hn su``nnknk `c-]biorbds Pc`bnty dndanr Gche @. _hbtnhnfk. Kbrn`tcr cj

Qc`lnjniinr @netnr ]rcpnrtbns. Pc`bfi fek ausbenss jrbnek cj Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr. Kbrn`tcr cj

Pcey @crpcrftbce, Dbeensctf Dbebeo fek Dfeujf`turbeo @cdpfey, Jnknrftnk Knpfrtdnet

Ptcrns, Aif`l & Kn`lnr Dfeujf`turbeo @cdpfey, Onenrfi Jccks @crpcrftbce, Q@F, [hn

]ifbetbjjs PN@CEK QN]IR be Puppcrt cj Dctbce jcr Infvn tc Qnenw ]fon 6> cj 62

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

16/318

@cetbenetfi Orcup, fek @btbns Pnrvb`n. [rustnn cj thn @cddbttnn jcr N`cecdb`

Knvnicpdnet, thn Gfpfe Pc`bnty fek thn Qc`lnjniinr's Dusnud cj Dcknre Frt (DcDF).

Kbrn`tcr cj thn Eftbcefi Aurnfu cj N`cecdb` Qnsnfr`h, thn ]uaib` Fonekf Jcuekftbce fek

[hn Ebxce @netnr. Jbefe`bfi `cetrbautcr tc thn Fsbf Pc`bnty. Fprbi 16, 1==>, Enw Rcrl

Kfbiy Enws, Kfbiy Kbsh & Ocssbp, 'Iicyk Orcvn's Icwkcwe7 @nina rnp sefps ft hbs lbek'7

"Eujj sfbk7 Fii ycu ausyackbns whc'vn anne rbeobeo up jbefe`bfi whbz ]ntn ]ntnrsce tc

`hbkn hbd jcr rukniy wfilbeo cut ce jcrdnr ^ebtnk Eftbces Fdafssfkcr Qb`hfrk

Hciarccln's tfil tc thn pcsh ]biorbds @iua be rnspcesn tc Icwkcwe's btnd thn cthnr

kfy7 ]infsn stcp bt, wce't ycu3 Int's rnvbnw7 ]ntnrsce fek Hciarccln frn cik jrbneks

whc thbel bt's jueey tc besuit nf`h cthnr. ]ius, Hciarccln's prnsnetftbce wfs rueebeo

iceo fek ]ntnrsce hfk fe fppcbetdnet."

1>. [hft ]ifbetbjj Fonet `cetneks thft fithcuoh Dr. ]ntnrsce bs f trustnk thbrk pfrty]biorbd Pc`bnty dndanr fek f prcdbenet PDCD acfrk dndanr cj thn FDNQB@FQN

crofebzftbce fs ibstnk shcwe ce thn Nxhbabt 6: (thft hfk tc c``ur fjtnr thn dnronr cj thn

Feoib`fe fek @fthcib` Crknrs be Ecvndanr 62:; fjtnr thn knfth cj GJL) Dr. ]ntnrsce bs ect

f dndanr cj[hn Lebohts cj thn Nqunstrbfe Crknr cj thn Hciy Pnpui`hrn be Gnrusfind

lebohtiy crknr cj thn HCIR PNN fek fs thn pb`turns shcw be Nxhbabt 61 thny frn be

fttnekfe`n ic`fiiy kurbeo thn Qnk Dfss hnik be Efssfu `cuety< thnrnjcrn, Dr. ]ntnrsce B

`ce`iukn bs ueknr thnbr supnrvbsbce fs f dndanr cj PDCD.

1:. Fs su`h B tfln f `icsnr iccl ft thn rcin cj Dr. ]ntnrsce fek Aif`lstcens Ifw jbrdPbdpsce [hft`hnr & Afrtintt II] tc jbourn cut why wbth sfy ceiy 6> cr sc wrbttne pfons be

thnbr inofi arbnj jcr thn dctbce tc kbsdbss fek rnpiy wbth thn sbeoin pfon hnrnbe hcw thny

knvnicpnk thn rnf`hnk thnbr kn`bsbce tc spnek sfy $>,>0= pnr pfon fek abii dn jcr bt.

1?. Obvne thn efturn cj f sfe`tbce dctbce wnrn thbs f Jnknrfi @curt f`tbce ueknr Quin66 sfjn hfracr wcuik lnnp thn @curt enutrfi fek wcuik ect an fpprbsnk cj thn prbvftn

kbs`ussbce antwnne f ]ifbetbjj fek Knjnekfet fs f dfttnr cj kun prc`nss knprbvnk fjjn`ts f

surprbsn whne thnrn bs ec prcvbsbce jcr sfjn hfracr be thn @]IQ fek thnrnjcrn bddnkbftniy

]ifbetbjjs PN@CEK QN]IR be Puppcrt cj Dctbce jcr Infvn tc Qnenw ]fon 6: cj 62

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

17/318

gcbes thn `curt tc tfln sbkns ec cen jrcd Pbdpsce [hft`hnr & Afrtintt II] (P[A) (2) nvnr

`cetf`tnk ]ifbetbjj Fonet

18. [hft ce Gfeufry 10, 1==? fe Frtb`in ay [hn Enw Rcrl Ifw Gcurefi wfs netbtinkPbdpsce Hblns ]fy< Jbrst Rnfrs Oc tc $6:=,===ay Fethcey Ibe, fek usbeo thn icob` thft thn

dctbce tc kbsdbss wfs ect fii thft hfrk f stfekfrk thft `cuik ect an kcen ay fey jbrst ynfr

fssc`bftn cj P[A fs f guebcr fttcreny hcuriy nfrebeo $8= pnr hcur (sfy $6:=,=== / 1===

hcurs feeufiiy) wbth sfy f 0==% cvnrrbkn cr $1;= pnr hcur jcr thn 6> cr sc pfons wrbttne

thft sfy tccl 6: hcurs tbdns 0 wbth thrnn fppnfrfe`ns nqufis sfy ;8 hcurs x $1;= -4

$66>1=. Pc whnrn kc wn ont tc $81l3

12. _hne Dr. OI^@LC_ wbth su`h f pcwnrjui af`lorcuek pfrtb`bpftns tc dnrniy sfyGCBEKNQ BE [HN AQWNWBEPLB KNJNEKFE[P FEK P[F[N KNJNEKFE[P

DNDCQFEKF CJ IF_.. fek nvne B fpprn`bftn n`cecdy cj wcrks fek hbs tbdn, su`h dfy

ceiy hfppne be f abo crofebzftbce ibln P[A whcsn bdpcrtfet `ibnet bs Aif`lstcen Orcup

2 Pbdpsce [hf`hnr & Afrtintt II] bs f ifw jbrd hnfkqufrtnrnk be Enw Rcrl @btywhb`h ndpicys cvnr 8== fttcrenys be tne cjjb`ns wcrikwbkn. [hn jbrd bs hbohiy rnofrknk\0T jcr

bts ibtboftbce fek `crpcrftn prf`tb`ns, wbth spn`bfi fttnetbce jc`usnk ce bts dnronrs fekf`qubsbtbces spn`bfity. Pbdpsce [hf`hnr bs `cesbstnetiy fdceo thn dcst prcjbtfain ifron ifwjbrds be thn wcrik ce f pnr-pfrtenr afsbs f``crkbeo tc thnFdnrb`fe Ifwynrs feeufiFdIfw 6== Purvny. Jcr 1=66, Pbdpsce [hf`hnr wfs rfelnk #: ce [hn Zfuits [cp 6==Dcst ]rnstbobcus Ifw Jbrd Qfelbeos, fek#6 be ]rbvftn Nqubty. [hn jbrd bs fisc rn`coebznkbe vfrbcus cthnr survnys, be`iukbeo Zfuit.`cds 1=6= rnvbnw cj thn 1= Anst Ifw Jbrds tc_crl Jcr.

[hn jbrd hfs rniftbceshbps wbth prbvftn nqubty jbrds Aif`lstcen Orcup fekLchianro Lrfvbs Qcanrts, fek bt hfs iceostfekbeo tbns tc G]Dcrofe @hfsn, Afel cjFdnrb`f, fek thn ^ebtnk Ptftns Knpfrtdnet cj thn [rnfsury.\;T

Ectfain fiudeb cj Pbdpsce [hf`hnr ifwynrs hfvn be`iuknk ^.P. Pneftcrs, Pcib`btcrs

Onenrfi, f Ppnflnr cj thn Hcusn cj Qnprnsnetftbvns, f Pn`rntfry cj Ptftn, f Pn`rntfry cj thnFrdy, Fdafssfkcrs, Gukons ce ^.P. @br`ubt fek Kbstrb`t @curts fek thn Enw Rcrl Ptftn@curt cj Fppnfis, prnsbknets cj thn Fdnrb`fe Afr Fssc`bftbce, fek prnsbknets cj thnFssc`bftbce cj thn Afr cjthn @bty cj Enw Rcrl. Ectfains frn7 Oubkc@fifarnsb (PuddnrFssc`bftn), @yrusZfe`n, Lfrneef Ocrn P`hbjj, [hcdfs K. [hf`hnr, [hcdfs Arf`lntt Qnnk,Kneebs O. Gf`cas, _hbteny Ecrth Pnydcur, _neknii Inwbs _biilbn BB, Puzfeen EcrfGchesce, Feen-Dfrbn Pifuohtnr, Kwboht Dcrrcw, Nrb` Zbtfibfec, Iyee Jcrnstnr knQcths`hbik

]ifbetbjjs PN@CEK QN]IR be Puppcrt cj Dctbce jcr Infvn tc Qnenw ]fon 6? cj 62

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_firmhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Cityhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Litigationhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mergers_and_acquisitionshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson_Thacher_%26_Bartlett#cite_note-3http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mergers_and_acquisitionshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mergers_and_acquisitionshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mergers_and_acquisitionshttp://www.vault.com/wps/portal/usa/companies/company-profile?companyId=419&WCM_GLOBAL_CONTEXT=/wps/wcm/connect/Vault_Content_Library/companies+site/companies/parent_simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp/simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp_0/simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp_0http://www.vault.com/wps/portal/usa/companies/company-profile?companyId=419&WCM_GLOBAL_CONTEXT=/wps/wcm/connect/Vault_Content_Library/companies+site/companies/parent_simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp/simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp_0/simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp_0http://www.vault.com/wps/portal/usa/companies/company-profile?companyId=419&WCM_GLOBAL_CONTEXT=/wps/wcm/connect/Vault_Content_Library/companies+site/companies/parent_simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp/simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp_0/simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp_0http://www.vault.com/wps/portal/usa/companies/company-profile?companyId=419&WCM_GLOBAL_CONTEXT=/wps/wcm/connect/Vault_Content_Library/companies+site/companies/parent_simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp/simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp_0/simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp_0http://www.vault.com/wps/portal/usa/companies/company-profile?companyId=419&WCM_GLOBAL_CONTEXT=/wps/wcm/connect/Vault_Content_Library/companies+site/companies/parent_simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp/simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp_0/simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp_0http://www.vault.com/wps/portal/usa/companies/company-profile?companyId=419&WCM_GLOBAL_CONTEXT=/wps/wcm/connect/Vault_Content_Library/companies+site/companies/parent_simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp/simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp_0/simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp_0http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kohlberg_Kravis_Robertshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_equityhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JPMorgan_Chasehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JPMorgan_Chasehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank_of_Americahttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank_of_Americahttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank_of_Americahttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kohlberg_Kravis_Robertshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Department_of_the_Treasuryhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JPMorgan_Chasehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank_of_Americahttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank_of_Americahttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Department_of_the_Treasuryhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson_Thacher_%26_Bartlett#cite_note-4http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guido_Calabresihttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyrus_Vancehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karenna_Gore_Schiffhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_D._Thacherhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guido_Calabresihttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Brackett_Reedhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dennis_G._Jacobshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyrus_Vancehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whitney_North_Seymourhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karenna_Gore_Schiffhttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wendell_Lewis_Willkie_II&action=edit&redlink=1http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Brackett_Reedhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suzanne_Nora_Johnsonhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Brackett_Reedhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suzanne_Nora_Johnsonhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dennis_G._Jacobshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anne-Marie_Slaughterhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whitney_North_Seymourhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dwight_Morrowhttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wendell_Lewis_Willkie_II&action=edit&redlink=1http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_Vitalianohttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wendell_Lewis_Willkie_II&action=edit&redlink=1http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynn_Forester_de_Rothschildhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suzanne_Nora_Johnsonhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynn_Forester_de_Rothschildhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anne-Marie_Slaughterhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dwight_Morrowhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_Vitalianohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynn_Forester_de_Rothschildhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynn_Forester_de_Rothschildhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynn_Forester_de_Rothschildhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynn_Forester_de_Rothschildhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_Vitalianohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dwight_Morrowhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anne-Marie_Slaughterhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suzanne_Nora_Johnsonhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suzanne_Nora_Johnsonhttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wendell_Lewis_Willkie_II&action=edit&redlink=1http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whitney_North_Seymourhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dennis_G._Jacobshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Brackett_Reedhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_D._Thacherhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karenna_Gore_Schiffhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyrus_Vancehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guido_Calabresihttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson_Thacher_%26_Bartlett#cite_note-4http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Department_of_the_Treasuryhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank_of_Americahttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank_of_Americahttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JPMorgan_Chasehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kohlberg_Kravis_Robertshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone_Grouphttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_equityhttp://www.vault.com/wps/portal/usa/companies/company-profile?companyId=419&WCM_GLOBAL_CONTEXT=/wps/wcm/connect/Vault_Content_Library/companies+site/companies/parent_simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp/simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp_0/simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp_0http://www.vault.com/wps/portal/usa/companies/company-profile?companyId=419&WCM_GLOBAL_CONTEXT=/wps/wcm/connect/Vault_Content_Library/companies+site/companies/parent_simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp/simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp_0/simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp_0http://www.vault.com/wps/portal/usa/companies/company-profile?companyId=419&WCM_GLOBAL_CONTEXT=/wps/wcm/connect/Vault_Content_Library/companies+site/companies/parent_simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp/simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp_0/simpson+thacher+_+bartlett+llp_0http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mergers_and_acquisitionshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mergers_and_acquisitionshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Litigationhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson_Thacher_%26_Bartlett#cite_note-3http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Cityhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_firm

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

18/318

whne kbrn`tnk ay _biibfd Q. Kcuohnrty (6=), thn @hfbrdfe cj Pbdpsce [hf`hnr & Afrtintt

II]s Nxn`utbvn @cddbttnn, thn Jbrds ocvnrebeo acky dflns thn kn`bsbce.

0=. [hft ]ifbetbjj Fonet rnqunsts fe fukbt cj Pbdpsce [hf`hnr & Afrtintt II]. bernofrks thn jnns fek nxpnesn cj thbs fkgukonk fdcuet ft infst an fkgustnk fek pnekbeo fe

fppnfi ce thn dnrbts cj thn `fsn.

06. Ectwbthstfekbeo thn kn`bsbce thft jrbvcicus wcuik an fiinonk fppib`fain hnrnbe, fsjcr thn fppib`ftbce cj $6==== pinefry `curt sfe`tbces fs bj Fonet wnrn fe fttcreny fkdbttnk

tc thn afr kcns ect fppiy tc knatcr crofebzftbce fek wnrn bt tc an fppibnk tc thn Fttcreny

juek, thn fttcrenys wnrn firnfky obvne jnns wfy anycek thn @]IQ knsboeftnk fdcuet kun

jcr wbeebeo f dctbce fek thcsn whc wbii ect pfrtb`bpftn frn ect netbtink tc fey rnibnj.

01. [hft thn `curt shcuik kbsfausn btsnij cj anibnvbeo thft thbs bssun cj whft f efturfiacre `btbzne bs wbii gust oc fwfy jcr fs dy jrbnek Fttcreny Dfrbc Fpuzzc be hbs rn`net nssfy

(snn Nxhbabt 6?) stftnk 7

[hn bens`fpfain `ce`iusbce bs thft sbe`n Cafdf, @ruz, Quabc, Gbekfi, fek Hfiny frnenbthnr efturfi acre @btbznes ecr @btbznes cj thn ^ebtnk Ptftns, ft thn tbdn cj thnfkcptbce cj thbs @cestbtutbce, thny frn ect nibobain tc an ]rnsbknet.

6= Dr. Kcuohnrty bs f Leboht cj Dfitf fek f pnrscefi jrbnek wbth Jfthnr Gche Kn ObcbfP.G. rueebeo Oncrontcwe ^ebvnrsbty fek f suspn`tnk `fekbkftn jcr thn Lebohts cj thnNqunstrbfe Crknr cj thn Hciy Pnpui`hrn be Gnrusfind. Dr. Kcuohnrty prnvbcusiy snrvnk fsthn Jbrds @c-Fkdbebstrftbvn ]frtenr jrcd 1==2 tc 1=61. Dr. Kcuohnrtys prf`tb`n jc`usnsce dnronr fek f`qubsbtbce fek `crpcrftn jbefe`n trfesf`tbces. Hn hfs rnprnsnetnk`crpcrftbces, prbvftn nqubty spcescrs fek bevnstdnet afels be f vfrbnty cj invnrfonk

auycuts, f`qubsbtbces, kbspcsbtbces, gcbet vneturns fek cthnr ausbenss `cdabeftbcetrfesf`tbces. Hn hfs fisc rnprnsnetnk bssunrs fek ueknrwrbtnrs be bebtbfi puaib` cjjnrbeos,hboh ybnik acek cjjnrbeos fek cthnr `crpcrftn jbefe`n trfesf`tbces.

Dr. Kcuohnrty wfs be thn Jbrds Icekce cjjb`n jrcd 622: uetbi 1==1 fek wfs afsnk bethn Jbrds [clyc cjjb`n jrcd 622= tc 6226. Dr. Kcuohnrty hfs anne wbth Pbdpsce [hf`hnrsbe`n hbs orfkuftbce jrcd thn ebvnrsbty cj @hb`foc Ifw P`hcci be 628:. Hn rn`nbvnk hbsF.A., dfoef `ud ifukn, be 6280 jrcd Oncrontcwe ^ebvnrsbty. Hn bs f dndanr cj thnFssc`bftbce cj thn Afr cj thn @bty cj Enw Rcrl fek thn Enw Rcrl Ptftn fek Fdnrb`fe AfrFssc`bftbces.

]ifbetbjjs PN@CEK QN]IR be Puppcrt cj Dctbce jcr Infvn tc Qnenw ]fon 68 cj 62

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

19/318

_HNQNJCQN, ]ifbetbjj wbshns thn @curt tc orfet fe crknr76. wbth @]IN $1116(j) jcr infvn tc rnenw afsnk upce en w trfesf`tbces1, wbth @]IQ $1116(j) jcr infvn tc rnfroun thn prbcr Kn`bsbce fek Crknr kftnkDfr`h 12,

1=60 netnrnk ay thn @inrl cj thn @curt ce Fprbi 6=, 1=60 (Gukodnet),0. wbth @]IQ >0=1>(a) be suppcrt cj rnenwfi infvn tc suppindnet thn @cdpifbet jbink

Dfr`h 11,1=66wbth enw trfesf`tbces;. wbth @]IQ >0=1>{`)tc `cejcrd tc nvbkne`n> . wbth @]IQ $116?(`) orfet pnrdbssbce jcr ]ifbetbjj tc sun ERP ACN fek rfesjnr tc

67F.P. ]frt 6 be ]ntbtbce 162;;0-1=61thcsn dfttnrs rnofrkbeo begury ueknrdBcr cj NIFrtb`Bn 61 c `cdpiy wbth thn 11th fek BJh dnekdnet `cdpifbenk cj facvn=6>6f) c vf`ftn cr dckbjy thn Gukodnet afsnk upce thn froudnet fek aycpnrftbce cj thn facvn enw trfesf`tbces fs tc Fonet snnlbeo rnibnj fek prctn`tbce ueknrPn`tbce 6 cj thn 1;th Fdnekdnet jcr f ]rbvftn ^P @btbzne< fek

? . jcr kbjjnrnet fek cthnr rnibnj knndnk en`nssfry jcr gustb`n hnrnbe be`iukbeo f sur-rnpiywnrn fey cj thn cthnr Knjnekfets fttcrenys tc fppnfr hnrnbe /?MJG&

@hrbstcphnr-Nfri7Ptruel be nssn fonetPwcre tc anjcrn dn

~ c t f ' r ~uaib`

Gd ]bfbetbj]s PN@CEK QN]IR be Pupprt cjDcVcejcr Infvn tc Qnenw ]fon 62 cj 62

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

20/318

Ptruel v ERP ACN nt fi ERP P@ Lbeo @ty. Beknx Ec.7 :>==-1=66

]IFBE[BJJP EC[B@N CJ DC[BCE [C QNEN_ FEK QNFQO^N

Nxhbabt 6:

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

21/318

Jr cet ]fon

Fr `hb vns

Facut

JFV

@cet f`t

B et rcku`tb ce

B eknx cjb est b t ut ns fekb ej i une`n

Pci ut b ces

Fdnrb `fe Pn`urb t y@cue`b i

FJB C & CPP Pc`b nt y

In @nr`i n

6==6 @i ua

]b i orb ds Pc`b nt y

Dui t b eft b cefi@hfb r dfe' s Or cupPue Zfi i nyDnnt b eos

Achndb fe Or cvn

G FPCE Or cupef`lecwi nkonk

PF]s

Anycek Kut r cux

"If Enaui nusn"

]nfl Cb i

G JL

2/ 66

Knft h i b st

Db s`ni i fencus

Negcynk thn bejcrdftbce3

@cesbknr f kceftbce tc

`cd pnesftn jcr thn

6=,=== hcurs cj rnsnfr`h.

[flns 0= sn`ceks wbth f

]fy]fi f``cuet. Fek... B'ii

an y cur anst jrbnek. _hft

nisn `fe ycu wbsh jcr3

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

22/318

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

23/318

OQNNE7 @frnnr be afelbeo, cthnr crpcrftbces cr be n`cecdb` pcsts.RNIIC_7 @ceornss, sneftn, icwnr invni ocvnrednet pcsbtbce, cr (vb n)

prnsbknet.QNK Dbibtfry frnnr, knjnesn sn`rntfry, @BF, eftbcefi sn`urbty fkvbscr cr

eftbcefi sn`urbty s`hcifr.AI^N7 Ptftn Knpfrtdnet.

6. >6

1.Gfdns/Puzfeen_ccisny

0;

0. Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr 01;. Waboebnw Arznzbeslb 1>>. Oncron Phuitz 1;:. ]fui Zci`lnr 10?. Jrfel @friu``b 118. Arnet P`cw`rcjt 162. Qb`hfrk ]nrin 6?6=. Gche Arfkndfs 6?

66. Gche _hbtnhnfk 6?61. Inv/]fuif Kcarbfesly 6:60. Ntbneen Kfvboece 6>6;. Icrk @frrbeotce 6>6>. Inn Hfdbitce 6>6:. Dfurb`n Ornneanro 6>6?. [hcdfs ]b`lnrbeo 6>68. Dfkninben Fiarboht 6>62. Dfx Lfdpnidfe 6>1=. Gfdns P`hinsbeonr 6>16. ]ntnr ]ntnrsce 6;

11. @frif Hbiis 6;10. 6;1;. Oncron H. _. Aush 601>. Kcefik Qudsjnik 601:. ]ftrb`l _. Orcss 611?. Qb`hfrk Z. Fiine 6118. Qb hfrk Dniice P`fbjn 6612. Znrece Gcrkfe 660=. Gfdns Aflnr BBB 6606. Pfd Euee 6601. Kcv Wflhnbd 6600. Gfdns _cijnesche 6=

0;. Qb`hfrk Knas 6=0>. Qb`hfrk Hciarccln 6=0:. Icrk Oncron Qcanrtsce6=0?. 6=08. Kb`l @hneny 6=02. One. Gfdns I. Gcens 6=;=. Qcanrt Wcniib`l 6=;6. _biibfd ]nrry 6=;1. Gche Knut`h 6=;0. Afrce kn Acevcbsbe 2

;;. Dcrtce Farfdcwbtz 2;>. 2;:. One. Gche Pbeoifua 2;?. Ecrdfe Fuoustben 2;8. Gche Inhdfe 2;2. 2>=. Qb`hfrk Hffss 8>6. Iyee J. kn Qcths`hbik 8>1. Insibn/Aru`n Onia 8>0. Db`hfni Inknne 8>;. 8>>. Qcanrt Oftns 8>:. [hcdfs Lnfe ?>?. Acaay Qfy Bedfe ?>8. Gche D`@fbe BBB ?>2. Enwt Obeorb`h ?:=. Oncron Pcrcs ?:6. _frrne Aujjntt ?:1. Icrk Gche Lnrr ?:0. Pbr Qcefik Orbnrsce ?:;. Icrk @hfrins Outhrbn ?:>. Gche K. Df`cdanr ?

::. Nkwbe Jnuienr ?:?. Qcanrt D`Jfrifen ?:8. ]hbibp Ifknr ?:2. [hcdfs P. Jciny :?=. Abii @ibetce :?6. Nkwfrk [niinr :?1. Pbr ]ntnr Puthnrifek :?0. Fife Ornnespfe :?;. Qfydcek Pnbtz :?>. Qupnrt Durkc`h :?:. @hu`l Hfoni :

??. One. _nsiny @ifrl :?8. One. ]fui Zfiiniy :?2. :8=. ]nhr Oyiinehfddfr >86. Icrk _nbknejnik >81. Gf`ca Qcths`hbik ;80. Nvniye kn Qcths`hbik ;8;. ;8>. Dblhfbi Lhckcrlcvsly 08:. @hrbstben _hbtdfe 0

- Fefiysbs cj thn ]nrdfenet Ocvnrednet http7//wblbspccls.`cd/BPO]/Fppne

; :/;/1=60

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

24/318

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

25/318

Dusnud cj Dcknre Frt (DCDF)Enisce Qc`lnjniinr | Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr (iceo-tbdn `hfbrdfe) | Gche Hfy _hbteny | ]finy |Foeniib | @. Kcuoifs Kbiice | Gche kn Dnebi | ]ntnr ]ntnrsce (ibjn trustnn) | Kuln Jrfez cjAfvfrbf (hcecrfry) | Dfurb`n Ornneanro (hcecrfry) | Gnrry Ppnynr (`hfbr) | @ifrbssfFi`c`l Arcejdfe | ]ftrb`bf ]hnips kn @bsenrcs | Dfrbn-Gcsnn Lrfvbs | ]hb ibp Ebfr`hcs |Qb`hfrk ]frsces | Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr, Gr. | Phfrce ]nr y Qc`lnjniinr

6212

Bestbtutn jcr Fkvfe`nk Ptuky_cijnesche (`hfbr 628:-1==?)| Krnii | [cru Hfshbdctc | Hninen Lfpife | Efthfe Dyhrvcik| Db`hfni Aiccdanro

620=

Jcrk JcuekftbceD`@icy | Abssnii | Hnkiny Kcecvfe | D`Efdfrf | ]hbibp Qnnk | _biibfd Pbdce | ZnreceGcrkfe | Hnery P`hf`ht | Anthuni _nastnr | ]fui Hcjjdfe | Qcy Ifrsne

620:

Qc`lnjniinr Arcthnrs JuekEnisce Qc`lnjniinr | Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr | Ifurfe`n Qc`lnjniinr | Gche K. Qc`lnjniinr BBB |_bethrcp Qc`lnjniinr | One. Iu`bus @ify | Gfdns Lbiibfe | Hnery Iu`n | Qusl | KfvbkPfrecjj | Nkwfrk [niinr | Gche Ofrkenr | Lbssbeonr | _bsenr BB

62;=

@cddbttnn jcr N`cecdb` Knvnicpdnet (@NK)]fui Hcjjdfe (jcueknr `hfbr) | @. Kcuoifs Kbiice | Phuitz | Gche Kbnacik | @friu``b |Arfkndfs | ]ftrb`l Orcss | Gcsnph Lfsputys | ]ntnr ]ntnrsce | ]hbibp Qnnk |

62;1

.P. @cue`bi jcr Betnreftbcefi Ausbenss 62;>Fspne BestbtutnZci`lnr | Qcanrt C. Feknrsce | Oyiinehfddfr | Lbssbeonr | ]b`lnrbeo | Arfkndfs |Ofrkenr | ]rbe`n Afekfr abe Puitfe | ]ftrb`l Orcss

62>=

Fdnrb`fe FssndaiyNbsnehcwnr | @ibjtce _hfrtce, Gr. | Bedfe | Onrone | Jrfel _nbi | Ab ii Arfkiny

62>=

Gche D. Cibe Jcuekftbce (`cesbknrnk `cesnrvftbvn, aut ]biorbds-ibelnk) 62>1Qnscur`ns jcr thn Juturn (QJJ)]finy (lny jcueknr fek `hfbrdfe) | Jfbrjbnik Csacre | Ifurfe`n Qc`lnjniinr | Gche I.Jbshnr (prnsbknet) | Qu`lnishfus (prnsbknet) | Kcefik D. Lnrr | Gche Knut`h (vb`n `hfbr) |Gcsnph Ptboibtz

62>1

]cpuiftbce @cue`biGche K. Qc`lnjniinr BBB | Jrnknrb`l Csacre | Kntinv Arcel | Gche Jcstnr Kuiins | @yrbiHfslbes | Hnery Lbeo.

62>1

Pubtn 8J Orcup Nfriy 62:=s^rafe BestbtutnAujjntt | Knut`h | D`Efdfrf | Puzfeen _ccisny (rnsnfr`hnr 62?>-??< cthnrs hfvn anne ibjn

trustnns) | Zfe`n | Znrece Gcrkfe | Hnery P`hf`ht | Lndp | Qu`lnishfus (`hfbrdfe) |Lfthfrben Orfhfd | Qc`lnjniinr Jcuekftbce (jbefe`beo)

62:8

Ausbenss Qcuektfain 62?1Lrcii Fssc`bftns 62?1Eftbcefi @cddbttnn ce Fdnrb`fe Jcrnboe ]cib`yHfes Dcronethfu | Fethcey Krnxni Kuln | Zci`lnr | ]b`lnrbeo | Qb `hfrk ]bpns

62?;

]ntnrsce Bestbtutn jcr Betnreftbcefi N`cecdb`sKfvbk Qc`lnjniinr | @cerfk Aif`l | Db`hfni Aiudnethfi | Wcniib`l | Iyee Jcrnstnr knQcths`hbik | Phuitz | Ornneanro | ]ntnrsce | Zci`lnr | @frif Hbiis | Ornnespfe | Gf`ca_fiineanro | Ptboibtz | Dcetarbfi | Kfvbk C'Qnbiiy | Gf`ca Jrnelni | Onbthenr | Inn LufeRnw | ]fui C'Enbii | Kfvbkn Quanestnbe | Gf`ca _fiineanro | Ornnespfe

6286

Qnefbssfe`n _nnlneks]hbibp Ifknr (jcueknr) | Abii @ibetce | _nsiny @ifrl | Onrfik Jcrk | _biibfd ]nrry | Ptrcan[fiactt | Auzz Fikrbe | Kfvbk Onrone | Pne. Aca Orfhfd | Ocrnib`l | Qcanrt Hcrdfts | Eyn

| Lfdpnidfe | Zbounrbn

6286

_crik Fjjfbrs @cue`bi, _fshbeotce, K.@.]ftrb`l Orcss (jcuekbeo vb`n-`hfbrdfe, `hfbrdfe fek stbii fe nxn`utbvn) | ]hbibp Cknne(`hfbrdfe) | Gfdns Qc`hn (prnsbknet) | Hnery F. Kukiny, Gr. (trnfsurnr)

628=

@cue`bi jcr Nx`niine`n be Ocvnrednet]fui C'Enbii | Zci`lnr | _hbtnhnfk | Puzfeen _ccisny | Niibct Qb`hfrksce | Krfpnr, BBB |Lfsputys | ]ftrb`l Orcss | Jrfel _nbi | Inn Hfdbitce | Df`cdanr | Jcrk | @frtnr | Aush ;0| @ibetce

6281

_crik Fjjfbrs @cue`bis cj Fdnrb`f@hfbrdfe7 ]fuif Kcarbfesly

628:

@cddbttnn tc Ne`curfon @crpcrftn ]hbifethrcpy@c-jcueknrs fek hcecrfry `c-`hfbrs7 Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr, ]fui Zci`lnr fek Gche _hbtnhnfk

6228

- Fefiysbs cj thn ]nrdfenet Ocvnrednet http7//wblbspccls.`cd/BPO]/Fppne

; :/;/1=60

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

26/318

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

27/318

Dfx vfe knr Ptcni (`hfbr) | ]bntnr Lccbgdfes (`hfbr) | Hfes vfe kne Arcnl (`hfbr) | AneAct (`hfbr)

Enthnrifeks-Fdnrb f Jcuekftbce]fui Arndnr | [hcdfs _ftsce | _biibfd vfekne Hnuvni | | Qukcij Anlbel |

6216

Enthnrifeks Ftifetb` Fssc`bftbce 62>1Cxjfd Ecvba 62>:Enthnrifeks Bestbtutn cj Betnreftbcefi Qniftbces (@ibeonekfni)Hfes vfe kne Arcnl (`hfbr) | Ane Act (`hfbr)

6280

[hn Hfoun @netrn jcr Ptrftnob` Ptukbns 1==0[hn Qbohts Jcrud (prc-]finstbebfe)Krbns vfe Fot (jcueknr fek `hfbr) | Hnerb Znikhubs | Jrfes Fekrbnssne | Ifurnes GfeArbelhcrst | Hfes vfe kne Arcnl | Dfr`ni Arus | Lccs vfe Kfd | Hnky k'Fe`cef | ]bntnrLccbgdfes | [benln Ickknrs | Gfe ]rcel | Liffs kn Zrbns

1==2

[hn Hfoun Bestbtutn jcr Oicafi Gustb`nDfkninben Fiarboht (jcuekbeo `hfbr) | Icrk @hrbs ]fttne | Gczbfs vfe Ffrtsne (`c-jcueknr)

1=66

[wcpn`uibfrcppcsbtbce orcups tc thn Kut`h Abiknranro nstfaibshdnet7

Qnpuaiblnbes Oneccts`hfp / Qnpuaib`fe Pc`bntyAne Lefpne (AA 6226) | ]bntnr Lcrtnwno (AA stnnrbeo `cddbttnn) | Qcnicj G. Enibssne (AA62?2) | Hnky k'Fe`cef (thn Qbohts Jcrud) | ]bd Jcrtuye (enc`ce pfrty< fssfssbeftnk) |[hnc vfe Ocoh (jrbnek cj Jcrtuye< fisc fssfssbeftnk) | Jndln Hfisndf (Ornne Injt pfrtyinfknr) | Hfrry vfe Acddni (Pc`bfibst ]frty< ceiy AA `rbtb` be `ceornss) | [cdfs Qcss(enc`ce< fssc`bftn cj vfe Ocoh< kbsbejcrdnr ce Jcrtuye `fsn) | Onrfrk Ffiknrs (fetb-AAfuthcr) | Hfes Aicd (acss cj Ffiknrs) | Qnen Wwffp (fetb -AA futhcr) | _biind Citdfes(ce`n bevbtnk f jcrdnr Inn Hfrvny Cswfik hfekinr) | ]fdnif Hndnirbgl (fetb-nstfaibshdnetfuthcr) | Gfe Duiknr | Jrbts Afrnek | Rcup vfe t Hnl | Gcrt Lniknr

622:

Afllnr P`hut Jcuekftbce / Afllnr P`hut Ptb`htbeoFknin vfe knr ]ifs | Liffs Ifeonekcne (BQ[ fjjfbr)

1=6=

Ibanrfi nstfaibshdnet (Feoic-Fdnrb`fe rniftbces)

Fdnrb`fe Pc`bnty be Icekce 682>Cxjcrk7 Qhckns [rust s`hcifrshbpsIcrk Efthfebni Qcths`hbik | @n`bi Qhckns | Jrfel Afrentt | Qusl | _ccisny | _fitnrPic`cdan | Qcanrt Qccsf | Arfkndfs | Hfrcik Feknrsce (Aujjntt jrbnek) | Hnkiny Kcecvfe |

Dfi`cid Jcrans, Pr. | ]hb ibp Lfbsnr | One. Anrefrk Qconrs | _. P`ctt [hcdpsce | Pne.Kfvbk Acrne | Qb`hfrk Kcife | @hfrins G. Hbt`h | Gcsnph Eyn | _. P`ctt [hcdpsce |_biibfd R. Niibctt

62=1

]biorbds Pc`bntyDcrofe jfdbiy | Eb`hcifs Autinr | [hcdfs Ifdcet | Gche _. Kfvbs | Fekrnw @frenobn |@crenibus Zfeknrabit BBB | Gche K. Qc`lnjniinr | Enisce Qc`lnjniinr | Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr |Kuiins arcthnrs | D`@icy | Nbsnehcwnr | Phuitz | _nbeanronr | Arznzbeslb | Lb ssbeonr | Hfbo| _biibfd Pbdce | Zci`lnr | _hbtnhnfk | ]ntnrsce | Zfe`n | Qusl | Qcanrt Leboht | KntinvArcel | Df`cdanr | Knas | Oncron Jrfelibe, Gr. | Oncron Afii | Icrk Efthfebni Qcths`hbik| Fethcey O. kn Qcths`hbik | Gfdns F. kn Qcths`hbik | Nkduek kn Qcths`hbik | _frauro fekP`hbjj jfdbibns | @n`bis | Pbr Gche, [cey fek Hnery Lnswb`l | Icrk _nbknejnik | IcrkHfrcik @f``bf | Pbr Nvniye Afrbeo | Pbr Fetcey F`ifek | Icrk Gche Lnrr | Pb r Db`hfni]fiibsnr | Nkwfrk Ptrnftcr | Gche Krnxni BBB fek BZ | @. Kcuoifs Kbiice | QussniiInjjbeownii | Gche Hfy _hbteny | Gche [rfbe | Gfdns Onrfrk | Jrfel ]cil | Abshcp Gfdnskn _cij ]nrry | @frrbeotce | Icrk Qcii | Orbnrsce | Puthnrifek (kbeenr) | Hffss (spnflnr) |

_ccisny (spnflnr) | Qnns-Dcoo (spnflnr) | One. Kfvbk ]ntrfnus (bevb tnk tc ^L iue`hnceanjcrn an`cdbeo ^P@NE[@CD `cddfeknr) | Qbjlbek | Arfkndfs | Pnbtz | ]hbibp Ifknr |]ftrb`l Orcss | _biibfd vfekne Hnuvni | [hcdfs _ftsce, Pr. fek Gr. | Frthur _ftsce |Oncron vce Dfiibe`lrckt

62=1

@cddbttnn tc Knjnek Fdnrb f ay Fbkbeo thn Fiibns (fjtnr Hbtinr thrnftnenk^L)Eb`hcifs Autinr (Dcrofe) | [hcdfs Ifdcet (Dcrofe) | Gche _. Kfvbs (Dcrofe fekQc`lnjniinr) | Gfdns Onrfrk | Jrfel ]cil (Zfeknrabit) | Abshcp Gfdns kn _cij ]nrry

62;=

Kbt`hiny JcuekftbceIcrk @frrbeotce | Pbr Gche Lnswb`l | Icrk Hfrcik @f``bf | Pbr Nvniye Afrbeo | Gche Dfgcr| Pbr Fetcey F`ifek | Icrk Gche Lnrr | Pbr Dfi`cid Qbjlbek | Pbr @hrbstcphnr Hcoo | Pbr]ntnr Dfeknisce | Pbr Db`hfni ]fiibsnr | Nkwfrk Ptrnftcr | Oncron Jrfelibe, Gr. |Arfkndfs (^.P. `hfbrdfe) | _biibfd Jfrbsh | ]hbibp Lfbsnr | Zfe`n | Zci`lnr | InwbsArfes`cda | Qcanrt Hcrdfts | Lfdpnidfe | P`cw`rcjt | Pceenejnikt | Pnbtz | _nbeanronr |Ptrcan [fiactt | Gf`l Ptrfw | Pne. Gche _frenr | Gfdb Dbs`bl | Gcsnph @fibjfec, Gr. |

62>8

- Fefiysbs cj thn ]nrdfenet Ocvnrednet http7//wblbspccls.`cd/BPO]/Fppne

; :/;/1=60

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

28/318

Qb`hfrk Ofrkenr | ]hbibp Ifknr | ]b`lnrbeo | Fekrnw Leboht | ]fuiben Envbiin-Gcens | IcrkOncron Qcanrtsce | Qcanrt _cr`nstnr

Betnreftbcefi Bestbtutn jcr Ptrftnob` Ptukbns (BBPP)Pceenejnikt | Lbssbeonr | Iyee Jcrnstnr kn Qcths`hbik | Hffss | Blin | Gcsnph Gchesce |Outhrbn | @hfijcet | ]ftrb`l Orcss | Pbr Qcanrt _fkn-Onry | ]fuiben Envb iin Gcens |Wflhnbd

62>8

Ftifetb` @cue`biOncron Jrfelibe, Gr. | Qccsf | Hfbo | _biibfd Pbdce | D`Efdfrf | One. Anrefrk Qconrs |_ccisny | Lbssbeonr | Phuitz | P`cw`rcjt (`hfbrdfe) | Nfoinauronr | @hu`l Hfoni | Fiarboht| Arznzbeslb | Iyee kn Qcths`hbik | Aflnr BBB | Hnery @fttc, Gr. | Df`cdanr | Icrk Dflbes |Icrk Qcanrtsce | Qupnrt Durkc`h | Lfdpnidfe | ]ftrb`l Orcss | Bedfe | Gf`ca _fiineanro| ]cwnii | Gfdns I. Gcens (`hfbr) | Pceenejnikt | ]hbibp Ifknr

62:6

Arbtbsh-Fdnrb`fe ]rcgn`t@frrbeotce | Icrk Oncron Qcanrtsce | Arfkndfs | Kbfef Zbiibnrs Enorcpcetn

628>

Ibanrfi nstfaibshdnet (lny `crpcrftbces)

Betnreftbcefi fkvbscry `cue`bi @hfsn Dfehfttfe, rnefdnk be 1==6 thnbetnreftbcefi `cue`bi cj G]Dcrofe @hfsnKfvbk Qc`lnjniinr | Gche Icukce (Phnii) | Oustfvc @bsenrcs | Hnery Jcrk BB |Oyiinehfddfr | Obfeeb Foeniib | Icrk @frrbeotce | Phuitz (`hfbrdfe betnreftbcefi `cue`bi622=s-1==2) | Kfvbk C'Qnbiiy (@hnvrce) | Inn Q. Qfydcek (Nxxce< ect B@) | Lbssbeonr |Qbiny An`htni | Arbfe Duirceny | Gf`ca Jrnelni (`hfbrdfe B@ 1==2-1=6=) | [cey Aifbr

(`hfbrdfe B@ sbe`n 1=6=) | Fekrn Knsdfrfbs | Gnfe-Icubs Anjjf | Abii Arfkiny (Fiine &@c.) | Dbecru Dflbhbrf (Dbtsuabshb) | Dustfjf Lc` | Inn Lufe Rnw | Dchfddnk FibFafilhfb | Pbr Gche Qcsn | @nns vfe Inkn | Nkofr Arcejdfe, Gr. | Kfvbk Quanestnbe(@friyin< ect B@) | Ptnphne P`hwfrzdfe (Aif`lstcen< ect B@).

62:>

Jcrstdfee Ibttin & @cdpfey/Ouijstrnfd @crp.Qudsjnik | Phuitz | ]cwnii | Lbssbeonr | Iyee Jcrnstnr kn Qcths`hbik | [hnckcrn G.Jcrstdfee (ft Jrnnkcd Hcusn wbth Wabo, Quddy, Huetbeotce fek _ccisny)

kurbeo 622=s

Lbssbeonr Fssc`bftns (gust facut thn ceiy bdpcrtfet `cdpfey wbth ecwnasbtn)Lbssbeonr | P`cw`rcjt | Nfoinauronr | _biibfd Qconrs | _biibfd Pbdce | Qcanrt Feknrsce |Arndnr | Onbthenr | @frrbeotce | Icrk Qcii | Kfvboece | Oyiinehfddfr | Pfaurc Clbtf |Gfdb Dbs`bl | Ptfpintce Qcy

6281

FBO (strftnob` pfrtenrshbp wbth Lbssbeonr Fssc`bftns fek Aif`lstcensbe`n dbk 628=s)

Dfurb`n Ornneanro | Lbssbeonr7 `hfbr fkvbscry acfrk sbe`n 628? jcr ft infst twc kn`fkns) |Kfvbk @chne (@BF) | Pb r Qb`hfrk Knfricvn (DB:) | @frif Hbiis | Hciarccln | Df`Frthur BB

dbk 628=s

Aif`lstcen Orcup (strftnob` pfrtenrshbp wbth Lbssbeonr Fssc`bftns fekFBO sbe`n nfriy 628=s)Ptnphne P`hwfrzdfe | ]ntnr ]ntnrsce | Pbr Qcefik Orbnrsce | Gcefthfe N. @ciay | Gf`caQcths`hbik | Gf`ca _fiineanro | Arbfe Duirceny | Phfulft Fzbz.

dbk-628=s

Hciibeonr (jbefe`bnr cj thn Eftbcefi Betnrnst dfofzben)@cerfk Aif`l | ]nrin | Lbssbeonr | Arznzbeslb | Zci`lnr | Qfydcek Pnbtz | Hnery Lnswb`l |Pbr Nvniye kn Qcths`hbik | Icrk Hfesce | @frrbeotce | Dfrofrnt [hft`hnr | Fijrnk [fuadfe| Pbr Gfdns Ociksdbth | Icrk Lneenth Qcy [hcdsce | Obfeeb Foeniib | @hfbd Hnrzco.

628:

[hn @friyin OrcupKfvbk Quanestnbe | @friu``b | Aflnr BBB | Oncron H. _. Aush | Gche Dfgcr (`hfb r @friyinNurcpn) | Insibn I. Frdbtfon | Gcefthfe N. @ciay

628?

Ibanrfi nstfaibshdnet (^.P.-Onrdfe rniftbces)

Bekustrbn`iua (afsb`fiiy eftbcefi) 6261QuhrifknJrbtz [hyssne | Fianrt Zcoinr | Nrest ]cnesone | Oustfv Lrupp | Jrnknrb`l Pprbeocrud |Jrbtz _belhfus cj Hcn`hst FO | Dfrtbe Aifel

6218-6202

Ftifetbl-Aru`lnDfx _frauro (jcueknr) | D`@icy (`c-jcueknr) | Lbssbeonr | Enisce Qc`lnjniinr | _fitnr I.Lbnp | Oncron H. _. Aush | One. Gfdns I. Gcens | Qb`hfrk vce _nbzsf`lnr

62>1

- Fefiysbs cj thn ]nrdfenet Ocvnrednet http7//wblbspccls.`cd/BPO]/Fppne

; :/;/1=60

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

29/318

Fdnrb`fe @cue`bi ce Onrdfey (Ftifetbl-Ar`ln's sbstnr crofebzftbce)Zci`lnr (`hfbrdfe) | D`@icy | Knas | Lb ssbeonr | Hciarccln | Oncron @. D`Ohnn | QcanrtNiiswcrth | _fitnr Pic`cdan | Hfoni | D`@icy BB | P`cw`rcjt | Dfrbn _frauro | Wcniib`l

62>1

@fri Kubsanro Pc`bnty (@KP Betnreftbcefi sbe`n 628?)]frtenrnk wbth Ftifetbl-Ar`ln fek Qcanrt Acs`h Jcuekftbce, whbin fisc `ccpnrftbeo wbththn Onrdfe dfrshfii Juek | Lbssbeonr (spnn`h be 628?) | Dchfddnk Fttf (s`hcifrshbphciknr fek tutcr 622>-622?)

62:8

Qcanrt Acs`h Jcuekftbce (`cetrcis 2=% Qcanrt Acs`h OdaH shfrns)

Hfes Dnrlin | Lbssbeonr (dndanr betnreftbcefi fkvb scry acfrk cj Qcanrth Acs`h OdaH628=s-tckfy)

62:2

Onrdfe Dfrshfii JuekKfvbk Qc`lnjniinr | @. Kcuoifs Kbiice | Qcanrt Niiswcrth | Ofarbni Hfuon | Gche D`@icy |_biiy Arfekt | Gfdns @cefet | Icrk Dflbes | Puzfeen _ccisny | Wcniib`l | Hciarccln

62?1

@frenobn Acs`h Bestbtutn jcr Fppibnk Ptukbns be BetnreftbcefiDfefondnetJcueknk ay Lbssbeonr, Hfes Dnrlin (@NC Acs`h Orcup) fek Qb `hfrk D. @ynrt (prnsbknet@frenobn Dniice).

622=

Fdnrb`fe F`fkndy be AnribeLbssbeonr (`c-jcueknr fek `hfbrdfe)< Hciarccln (`c-jcueknr) | Qb`hfrk vce _nbzsf`lnr |Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr (pnrscefi kcecr $6=,===-$>=,===). Dfgcr jbefe`bnrs7 Kfbdinr@hrysinrFO, Fiibfez FO, Onenrfi Dctcrs-Fkfd Cpni FO, Pbndfes FO, Gche _. Liuon Jcuekftbce,Qcanrt Acs`h Ptbjtueo, nt`.

622;

Ibanrfi nstfaibshdnet (Qussbfe rniftbces)

^.P.-^PPQ [rfkn fek N`cecdb` @cue`biKfvbk Qc`lnjniinr | Phuitz | Db`hfni Jcrrnstfi | Hfrcik A. P`ctt

62?0

Qussbfe-Fdnrb`fe Afelnrs JcrudKfvbk Qc`lnjniinr | Zfe`n | _hbtnhnfk | Knas | Onrfik @crrbofe | Gche Cpni

6221

.P.-Qussbf Ausbenss @cue`bi 6220N. .-Qussbf Bekustrbfibsts' Qcuektfain 622?Cpne Qussbf JcuekftbceGf`ca Qcths`hbik | Lbssbeonr | Lhckcrlcvsly

1==6

Ibanrfi nstfaibshdnet (Nurcpn)

_bitce ]frl `cejnrne`nsGf`quns Gcent | Gnfe Zbcint | Fijrnkc Pfe`hnz Aniif

62;:

Nurcpnfe Infoun jcr N`cecdb` @ccpnrftbce 62;:Nurcpnfe Dcvndnet 62;8@beb Jcuekftbce@cuet Zbttcrbc @beb

62>6

F`tbce @cddbttnn jcr thn ^ebtnk Ptftns cj Nurcpn (F@ PN)Gnfe Dceent (jcueknr fek hnfk) | Dfx Lchestfdd | Zfinry Obs`frk k'Nstfbeo | _biiyArfekt | ]bntrc Eneeb | Hnranrt _nhenr | Qfbenr Afrzni | Dfrbfec Qudcr | Ouy Dciint

62>:

Nurcpf Ecstrf 62:0Nurcpnfe Qcuek [fainKfvboece (`c-jcueknr) | Oyiinehfddfr (`c-jcueknr) | Foeniib

6280

@netrn jcr Nurcpnfe ]cib`y Ptukbns 6280Fssc`bftbce jcr thn Dcentfry ^ebce cj NurcpnKfvboece (`c-jcueknr)

628?

Nurcpnfe BestbtutnRvns-Fekrn Bstni (Qcths`hbik) | Kfvboece | @ciicda | Knicrs | Puthnrifek | Wcniib`l | Eb tzn |Pceenejnikt

6282

Jcrud Nurcpn 6282NurcpfnudIcrk _nbknejnik | Icrk Qcefik Orbnrsce | Icrk @hrbs ]fttne

6226

@netrn jcr Nurcpnfe Qnjcrd 622:Nurcpnfe ]cib`y @netrn]ntnr Puthnrifek | Icrk Gche Lnrr | Lfrni Zfe Dbnrt | Dfx Lchestfdd | Hfes Aibx

622:

- Fefiysbs cj thn ]nrdfenet Ocvnrednet http7//wblbspccls.`cd/BPO]/Fppne

; :/;/1=60

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

30/318

N.^.-Gfpfe Ausbenss Qcuek [fainKfvboece

6222

Jrbneks cj NurcpnKfvboece (jcueknr fek prnsbknet)< Afrce Kfebni Gfessne

6222

Nurcpnfe Ausbenss Puddbt 1===Jbefe`bfi Pnrvb`ns Jcrud 1===Nurcpnfe Jbefe`bfi Pnrvb`ns Qcuek [fain

Oyiinehfddfr (jcuekbeo `hfbrdfe)

1==6

@hbef-N. . Ausbenss Puddbt 1==0Ausbenss jcr f Enw Nurcpn 1==:

Ibanrfi nstfaibshdnet (bestbtutns cj betnreftbcefi fjjfbrs)

Qcyfi Bestbtutn cj Betnreftbcefi Fjjfbrs (@hfthfd Hcusn cr QBBF) 621=@cue`bi ce Jcrnboe Qniftbces 6216@hb`foc @cue`bi ce Jcrnboe Qniftbces 6211Bestbtutn cj ]f`bjb` Qniftbces (shut kcwe be 62:6) 621>@fefkbfe Bestbtutn cj Betnreftbcefi Fjjfbrs 6218Fustrfibfe Bestbtutn cj Betnreftbcefi Fjjfbrs 6200

Pcuth Fjrb`fe Bestbtutn cj Betnreftbcefi Fjjfbrs 620;Pwnkbsh Bestbtutn cj Betnreftbcefi Fjjfbrs 6208Bestbtutn cj Gnwbsh Fjjfbrs (ecw Bestbtutn jcr Gnwbsh ]cib`y Qnsnfr`h) 62;6Dcs`cw Ptftn Bestbtutn cj Betnreftbcefi Qniftbces (DOBDC) 62;;Qcyfi Bestbtutn jcr Betnreftbcefi Qniftbces (BQQB-LBBA) (Aniobud)Kfvboece (`hfbrdfe) | Afrce kn Acevcbsbe | _biiy @ifns | _biiy Kn @inr`q | Ouy Ppbtfnis |Afrce Kfebni Gfessne

62;?

@hbensn ]ncpin's Bestbtutn cj Jcrnboe Fjjfbrs 62;2Onrdfe @cue`bi ce Jcrnboe Qniftbces 62>>]rfoun Bestbtutn cj Betnreftbcefi Qniftbces 62>?Ecrwnobfe Bestbtutn cj Betnreftbcefi Fjjfbrs 62>2Gfpfe Bestbtutn cj Betnreftbcefi Fjjfbrs 62>2

Jbeebsh Bestbtutn cj Betnreftbcefi Fjjfbrs 62:6Ftifetb` Bestbtutn jcr Betnreftbcefi Fjjfbrs (]frbs-afsnk) 62:6Bestbtutn cj Betnreftbcefi Fjjfbrs, Qcdn 62:>Jrne`h Bestbtutn jcr Betnreftbcefi Qniftbces 62?2Enthnrifeks Bestbtutn cj Betnreftbcefi Qniftbces (@ibeonekfni) 6280Eftbcefi Kndc`rftb` Bestbtutn Jcr Betnreftbcefi Fjjfbrs 6280Bsrfni @cue`bi ce Jcrnboe Qniftbces 6282Kfebsh Bestbtutn cj Betnreftbcefi Fjjfbrs 6220]f`bjb` @cue`bi ce Betnreftbcefi ]cib`y 622>Nurcpnfe @cue`bi ce Jcrnboe QniftbcesPcrcs (jbefe`bnr) | Dfani _bssn-Pdbt | Gcs`hlf Jbs`hnr | Icrk Gche Lnrr (pfeni kbs`ussbce)

1==?

Ibanrfi nstfaibshdnet (^.L. `iuas)

_hbtn's (dcst nibtn dne's iua be tnrds cj pcibtb`fi kbs`ussbce)Guibfe Fdnry | Fstcr | @frrbeotce | D`Ocwfe | Kcuoifs-Hcdn | Ptbribeo | ]rbe`n @hfrins |P`hrcknr | [bfrls | Ppbrc | Lnswb`l | Dcwarfy | Ecrjcil | Jfbrafels | Hnbez, BB | ]nii |Qbjlbek | Outhrbn

6:20

Pc`bnty cj Lebohts cj thn Qcuek [fainIncpcik Fdnry | Kfvbk Ptbribeo | Nfri cj Kfihcusbn

6?1=

Acckin's 6?:1Arccls's 6?:;Qcxaurohn @iuaQcths`hbik | @n`bi | Cppnehnbdnr | Dcrofe | Ecrjcil | Knvceshbrn | Icrk Qnns-Dcoo

6861

- Fefiysbs cj thn ]nrdfenet Ocvnrednet http7//wblbspccls.`cd/BPO]/Fppne

0; :/;/1=60

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

31/318

Orbiibce's 6861Ofrrb`l @iua 6806@fritce @iua 6801]rftt's 68>?Annjstnfl @iua 68?:Fdnrb`fe Pc`bnty be Icekce 682>]biorbds cj Ornft Arbtfbe 62=1Cthnr @iua@frrbeotce | @n`bi | Icrk Qnns-Dcoo | Kuetbsacuren | Qcths`hbik | ]rbe`n @hfrins | [ceyAifbr | Ocrkce Arcwe | Nkwfrk Hnfth | Knebs [hft`hnr | @hur`hbii, BBB | Guibfe Fdnry

6266

Au`l's 6262

Ibanrfi nstfaibshdnet (^.P. `iuas)

^ebce @iua 680:Enw Rcrl Rf`ht @iua 68;;@netury Fssc`bftbce 68;?Kcwe [cwe Fssc`bftbce 68>2^ebce Infoun @iua 68:0

Hfrvfrk @iua 68:>^ebvnrsbty @iua 68:>Leb`lnrac`lnr @iua 68?6Achndbfe @iua, Pfe Jrfe`bs`c 68?1[hn Wckbf` 68?1@csdcs @iua, _fshbeotce, K.@. 68?8@crsfbr @iua 6881Fibab @iua, _fshbeotce, K.@. 688;Dntrcpcibtfe @iua 6826@hnvy @hfsn @iua 6821Rfin @iua 682?

]biorbds cj thn ebtnk Ptftns 62=0]bpbeo Qc`l 6266Fijfijf @iua, _fshbeotce, K.@. 6260

Ibanrfi nstfaibshdnet (jrftnrebtbns)

Cxjcrk7 Auiibeokce @iuaLbeo Nkwfrk ZBB | Lbeo Nkwfrk ZBBB | Jrnknrb`l BX cj Knedfrl | ]rbe`n Incpcik, Kuln cjFiafey | Octtjrbnk vce Absdfr`l | @n`bi Qhckns | Eft Qcths`hbik | Kfvbk @fdnrce | 60thDfrqunss cj Icthbfe | Fife @ifrl | 2th Nfri Ppne`nr | _biibfd Pbe`ifbr

6?8=

Hfrvfrk7 ]cr`niibfe (ifroniy brrninvfet) 6?26Rfin7 P`rcii & Lny 68;1Rfin7 Pluii & Acens 6801

]rbe`ntce7 Bvy @iua 68?2Rfin7 _cij's Hnfk 688;]rbe`ntce7 @fp fek Ocwe 682=@crenii7 Vubii fek Kfoonr 6820Cxjcrk7 ]bnrs Ofvnstce Pc`bnty 62??

Ibanrfi nstfaibshdnet (wcrikwbkn - n`cecdb`s fek eftbcefi sn`urbty)

Betnreftbcefi @hfdanr cj @cddnr`n 6262Bestbtutn jcr Betnreftbcefi Nku`ftbceHnery Lfujdfe | Knas | Arznzbeslb | Krfpnr, BBB | Lbssbeonr | Dfryfd Fesfry | Dfurb`n [.Dccrn | Hnery Jcwinr | Ptnphne Kuoofe

6262

- Fefiysbs cj thn ]nrdfenet Ocvnrednet http7//wblbspccls.`cd/BPO]/Fppne

0; :/;/1=60

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

32/318

Infoun cj Eftbces Fssc`bftbce 6212Betnreftbcefi Qns`un @cddbttnn (BQ@)Inc @hnren (`hfbrdfe 62>6-6226 fek `hfbrdfe ndnrbtbs uetbi knfth b e 6222) | @fsny(prnsbknet) | Feobnr Abkkin Kuln (prnsbknet) | Gche Qb`hfrksce Gr. (prnsbknet) | _hbtnhnfk(prnsbknet) | Fianrt Gcibs | Lbssbeonr | Ornneanro | Fiarboht | Farfdcwbtz | Qchftye |_cijnesche | [cd Arclfw | _bestce Icrk | @ifbacren ]nii | Gche [rfbe

6200

H. Pdbth Qb`hfrksce Jcuekftbce (@BF/]biorbds/`cesnrvftbvn-ibelnk)Nuonen Ptntsce, Gr. | Jrfel Afrentt | _ccisny | Qudsjnik | Arznzbeslb | Huetbeotce | Blin

620>

Jrnnkcd HcusnInc @hnren (`hfbrdfe 62;:-62?:) | Lfdpnidfe (`hfbr) | _ccisny (`hfbr) | Arznzbeslb |Huetbeotce | Qudsjnik | _cijcwbtz | Lbrlpftrb`l | Jciny | Dcrtce Farfdcwbtz | KbfefZbiibnrs Enorcpcetn | [fjt BZ (`hfbrdfe) | Gche E. Dccrn | ]fuif Kcarbfesly | KfvbkNbsnehcwnr | [hnckcrn Jcrstdfee | Cttc Qnb`h | Dfi`cid Jcrans, Gr. | Fekrnw Rcueo, Gr.

62;6

^ebtnk Eftbces Fssc`bftbce (snt up gust anjcrn thn `rnftbce cj thn ^E)Lbssbeonr | _hbtnhnfk | Zci lnr | Gf`ca Qcths`hbik | Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr | Hfppy Qc`lnjniinr

62;0

Bestbtutn jcr Knjnesn Fefiysns (GFPCE-rniftnk)Lbiibfe (jcueknr) | _biibfd C. Aflnr (`c-jcueknr) | Qb`hfrk Abssnii | _biibfd F. D. Aurkne| @hfs Jrnndfe | Dfxwnii [fyicr | Puzfeen _ccisny

62;?

Fdnrb`fe @cue`bi ce Gfpfe (62;8-62>1) 62;8Fdnrb`fe-Fustrfibfe Fssc`bftbcePbr Lnbth Durkc`h (jcueknr) | Qussnii Injjbeownii (`c-jcueknr) | Gufe [rbppn (`c-jcueknr) |Qupnrt Durkc`h | Jrfel Icwy | _cijnesche | Ornneanro | Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr | _biibfd

Pbdce | Qbiny An`htni

62;8

QFEK @crpcrftbceLbssbeonr | Zci`lnr | @friu``b | P`hinsbeonr | Blin | Arznzbeslb | _chistnttnr | @hfrins G.Hbt`h | Icrk Qcabe Qnewb`l | ]fiibsnr | ]hb ibp Ifknr

62;8

Eftbcefi @cddbttnn jcr f Jrnn NurcpnFiine Kuiins | @.K. Gf`lsce | Hnery Iu`n | Iu`bus @ify | Nbsnehcwnr | G. ]ntnr Orf`n | H.G. Hnbez BB | Hnery Jcrk BB | Oncron @. D`Ohnn |

62;2

6st @cddbttnn ce thn ]rnsnet Kfeonr(tc prcdctn `cetfbednet) 62>=Eftbcefi @cddbttnn jcr f Jrnn Fsbf (Fsbf Jcuekftbce)An`htni | Lfbsnr | Gufe [rbppn | Qcanrt Leboht

62>6

Gfpfe Pc`bntyGche K. Qc`lnjniinr BBB (jcueknr) | Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr (hce. `hfbrdfe) | ib jn kbrn`tcrs7]ntnrsce fek Zci`lnr | Ornneanro | Knas |

62>1

>;61 Ppn`bfi Orcup (ocvnrednet acky< iftnr 0=0 fek ;= @cddbttnn) 62>;

Nurcpnfe-Ftifetb` Orcup 62>;Abiknranro]rbe`n Anrehfrk | Vunne Anftrbx | Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr | Phfrce ]nr`y Qc`lnjniinr | HneryLbssbeonr | Oncron Afii | Eb`hcifs Arfky | Hnbez BB | Hfuon | Hciarccln | Hffss |_hbtnhnfk | Kfvboece | Gche Icukce | _cijnesche | Znrece Gcrkfe | Dfx Lchestfdd |@cerfk Aif`l | _cijcwbtz | ]nrin | Gf`ca _fiineanro | Dfr`us _fiineanro | Icrk Qcii | Icrk@frrbeotce | Pbr ]ntnr Puthnrifek | Icrk Gche Lnrr | Nkdcek kn Qcths`hbik | Dcetarbfi |Foeniib | Dustfjf Lc` | Orbnrsce (;x) | Icrk Oncron Qcanrtsce (1x) | Euee (1x) | Knut`h(0x) | Hfes vfe kne Arcnl (0x) | Abii @ibetce (1x) | Qudsjnik (1x) | Arfkndfs (1x) | PbrNvniye kn Qcths`hbik (1x) | Qupnrt Durkc`h (6x) | Inn Hfdbitce (6x) | Iyee Jcrnstnr knQcths`hbik (6x) | ]b`lnrbeo (6x) | Gcsnph Eyn | (6x) | One. Gfdns I. Gcens (6x) | Jrfes[bddnrdfes | Dfxbdn Znrhfone | Gffp kn Hccp P`hnjjnr | Ennib Lrcns | Gnrcne vfe knrZnnr | Nrest Hbrs`h Afiibe

62>;

Fsbf Pc`bntyHciarccln | Gche Enorcpcetn | @hfrins Qc`lnjniinr | Gche Qc`lnjniinr BZ | Eb`cifs Qchftye

| _hbtnhnfk (hcecrfry ibjn trustnn fek `hfbrdfe ndnrbtus) | Ornneanro (`hfbrdfendnrbtus) | ]ntnrsce (jbefe`bnr/dndanr) | ]b`lnrbeo (vbsbtcr)| _bsenr BB (vbsbtcr) | Eb`hcifs]iftt

62>:

Fdnrb`fe Pc`bnty jcr f Jrnn Fsbf (@BF-jueknk tc af`l Kfifb Ifdfb) 62>:Lcrnf Pc`bntyKcefik Ornoo

62>?

GFPCE OrcupGfdns Lbiibfe (jcueknr) | _biibfd C. Aflnr (`c-jcueknr) | Gcshuf Inknranro | _biibfdEbnrneanro | Pbkeny Krnii | Iubs Fivfrnz | Inwbs Arfes`cda | Qb`hfrk Ofrwbe | DurrfyOnii-Dfee | Ocrkce Df`Kcefik

62>8

Icobstb`s Dfefondnet BestbtutnD`Efdfrf (jcueknr) | Gcsnp Eyn (trustnn 622?-1==2)| Gcsnph Lfsputys (6222-1==2) | ]fuiLfdbesb (gcbenk be 1==1)

62:6

- Fefiysbs cj thn ]nrdfenet Ocvnrednet http7//wblbspccls.`cd/BPO]/Fppne

0; :/;/1=60

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

33/318

Ftifetb` Bestbtutn jcr Betnreftbcefi Fjjfbrs (FBBF)Foeniib | Furnibc ]n``nb | @fric kn Anenknttb | Fiarboht | Qcanrt F. Feknrsce | Oncron Afii| @frrbeotce | Icrk Qcii | Kfvboece | Nfoinauronr | P`cw`rcjt | Qudsjnik | Cibvnr Obs`frkk'Nstfbeo | Hfianrstfkt | Afrce ]fui-Nddfeuni Gfessne | _fithnr Lbnp | Fekrnw Leboht |Hnery @. Ickon | Oncron Icukce | Gche Icukce | Hfes Dnrlin | Qb`hfrk Ofrkenr | GcheDf`cdanr | Icrk Dflbes | D`@icy (prnsbknet) | Afrce Fijrnk vce Cppnehnbd | Gcefthfe]ciifrk | @hu`l Qcaa | Qcanrt Qccsf | Pbr Nvniye kn Qcths`hbik | Afrce Qcanrt Qcths`hbik |]ntnr [neefet | ]ntnr _fiineanro | Jrfel _nbi | ]fui vfe Wnnifek

62:6

@netnr jcr Ptrftnob` fek Betnreftbcefi Ptukbns (@PBP)Fkd. Aurln | Pfd Euee | Fashbrn | Nkdcek kn Qcths`hbik | Kfvboece | ]nii | Lbssbeonr |Ornneanro | Arznzbeslb | _ccisny | Gcsnph Eyn | Gcsnph Ocrdfe | @frif Hbiis | P`cw`rcjt |@friu``b | Qb`hfrk Z. Fiine | P`hinsbeonr | P`fbjn | Fiarboht | _biibfd @chne | Aflnr |[ndpnisdfe | Jnibx Qchftye | ]ftrb`l Orcss | One. Gfdns I. Gcens | [hcdfs D`Ifrty |Feen Frdstrceo | Icrk Oncron Qcanrtsce (kcen stukbns) | Lfdpnidfe | Frefuk knAcr`horfvn | Wflhnbd | :th Kuln cj _nstdbestnr

62:1

@btbznes @cddbttnn jcr f Jrnn @uaf (@@J@)Fkd. Aurln | @ifbrn Accthn Iu`n | Eb`hcifs Kuln Abkkin | ]fui K. Anthnii (@BF) | GcheJbshnr | Inc @hnren | Nkwfrk [niinr | Hfes Dcronethfu | Pprubiin Arfkne

62:0

Fdnrb`fs Pc`bntyKfvbk Qc`lnjniinr (`c-jcueknr fek `hfbrdfe)

62:>

Eftbcefi @cddbttnn ce ^.P.-@hbef QniftbcesLbssbeonr | Ornneanro | @frif Hbiis | D`Efdfrf | P`hinsbeonr | Fiarboht | Lnfe | Hfdbitce

62::

]f`bjb` Afsbe N`cecdb` @cue`bi 62:?

@iua cj QcdnFoeniib | ]n``nb | Qusl | @frrcii I. _bisce | Iuaanrs | Qcanrt C. Feknrsce | Dfurb`n Ptrceo| Lbeo Gufe @frics | Vunne Anftrbx | Ocraf`hnv | ]rbe`n Ni Hfssfe abe [fifi.

62:8

6==67 F Efturn's [rust (6==6 @iua)]rbe`n Anrehfrk | ]rbe`n ]hbibp | Fetce Qupnrt | Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr Ifurfe`n Qc`lnjniinr |Nkduek fek Nkdcek kn Qcths`hbik | Db`hni Kfvbk-_nbii | Kfvbk Pfduni Dcetfou |Nkdcek Pfjrf | @. Kcuoifs Kbiice | An`htni | D`Efdfrf | Fstcr | Qcanrt C. Feknrsce |]ntnr Orf`n | Hnery Hnbez BB | @cerfk Aif`l | Dfurb`n Ptrceo | Foeniib | Hnery Jcrk BB |Gche Icukce | Oustfvc @bsenrcs | Ptfvrcs Ebfr`hcs | Ku`hnss cj Fiaf | Hfes Dnrlin |Anrthcik Anbtz | [hure uek [fxbs | Ibn`htnestnbe | Hfasauro | Hnranrt Aftibenr | Db`hniQnin`cd | [bacr Qcsneafud | Icubs D. Aiccdjbnik | Pfind ab e Ifkne | Fohf Hfsfe Fankb |Frknshbr Wfhnkb | ]rbe`nss Dfhefz Wfhnkb | Fijrnk Hfrtdfee | Ptnphfe P`hdbkhnbey |Anrtrfek @ciicda | Dfeuni Jrfof | Afsbi Hnrscv | Kbrl Hnrtzco | [hcdfs _ftsce, Gr. |Frthur _ftsce

62?6

_crik N`cecdb` Jcrud (KFZCP)

Abii @ibetce | [cey Aifbr | Kfvbk @fdnrce | Feonif Dnrlni | Phbdce ]nrns | @cibe ]cwnii |Abii Oftns | Puthnrifek | ]ftrb`l Orcss | Lfsputys | Gfdns _cijnesche | Oncron vceDfiibe`lrckt | Lcjb Feefe | Vunne Qfebf cj Gcrkfe | Rfssnr Frfjft | Acec | @cerfk Aif`l |Gcsnph Ocrdfe ([Q_) | Hffss | Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr | Dfurb`n Ptrceo | Hnery Lrfvbs |@hrbstben Ifofrkn (BDJ) | Hcwfrk Aujjntt | Eft Qcths`hbik

62?6

[rbiftnrfi @cddbssbceKfvbk Qc`lnjniinr (jcueknr) | Gche K. Qc`lnjniinr BZ | Lbssbeonr | Arznzbeslb (jcueknr) |]ntnrsce | Qccsf | Oncron Afii | Hfbo | Dfurb`n fek Gnjjrny Ornneanro | Kfvbk ]f`lfrk |Zci`lnr (`hfbrdfe) | Gcsnph Eyn (`hfbrdfe) | Niibct Qb`hfrksce | Zfe`n | Hciarccln |Db`hni Kfvbk-_nbii | _frrne @hrbstcphnr | [hcdfs Jciny | Oncron Jrfelibe | Puthnrifek(`hfbrdfe) | Outhrbn | Orbnrsce | Fashbrn | Dfurb`n Ptrceo | Qussnii [rfbe | Pbr HneryLnswb`l | Nkdcek kn Qcths`hbik | Arfkndfs | @frif Hbiis | @frrbeotce | Icrk Gche Lnrr |Hffss | Kfvboece | Kfebni Gfessne | ]fui-Nddfeuni Gfessne | @cerfk Aif`l | Dfurb`nIbppnes | @ibetce | Knut`h | Gcrkfe | Qudsjnik | ]nrin | @hneny | @friu``b | _cijcwbtz | InnQfydcek | Pcrcs | D`Efdfrf | Kfvbk Quanestnbe | Qfydcek Pnbtz | Lfthfrben Orfhfd |Onrone | Inn Hfdbitce | Ornvnespfe | ]fuif Kcarbfesly | Fiarboht | One. Gfdns I. Gcens |

]b`lnrbeo | Dfx Lchestfdd | _biiy kn @inr`q | [cru Hfshbdctc | [cru Lusulfwf |Phueb`hb Puzulb | Inn Qfydcek | Qu`lnishfus | Phuitz | _nbeanronr | Db`hfni Aiudnethfi |[fiactt | Pci Ibecwbtz | Pbr ]hbibp kn Wuiuntf | Hnerb Pbdcent | Lurt Abnknelcpj | _fitnr I.Lbnp

62?0

Brfe-^.P. Ausbenss @cue`biLbssbeonr | Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr | Zci`lnr | ]ntnrsce | Hushfeo Fesfry

62?;

@netnr jcr Eftbcefi Pn`urbty Ptukbns 62?;[hn @rbsbs cj Kndc`rf`y7 Ce thn Ocvnrefabibty cj Kndc`rf`bns ([@rnpcrt - ect `cuetnk)Pfduni Huetbeotce | Db`hni @rczbnr | Gcgb _ftfeulb (prcdctnk ft thn tbdn ay Wabo)

62?>

.P.-Pfukb Gcbet N`cecdb` @cddbssbce 62?>^.P.-[fbwfe Ausbenss @cue`bi@friu``b | _cijcwbtz | Gche K. Qc`lnjniinr, BZ

62?:

- Fefiysbs cj thn ]nrdfenet Ocvnrednet http7//wblbspccls.`cd/BPO]/Fppne

0; :/;/1=60

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

34/318

[rfkns ^ebce @cddbttnn jcr Nurcpnfe fek [rfesftifetb`^eknrstfekbeo

62?:

_crik _biknrenss @cejnrne`nsKfvbk Qc`lnjniinr | Nkduek kn Qcths`hbik | Aflnr BBB | Dfurb`n Ptrceo | Qu`lnishfus

62??

@fefkf-@hbef Ausbenss @cue`bi]fui Knsdfrfbs, Pr. | Dfurb`n Ptrceo | ]fui Ibe

62?8

Orcup cj [hbrtyZci`lnr (`hfbrdfe) | Knas | Ornnespfe | Qccsf | Kuetbsacuren | Icrk Qb`hfrksce(`hfbrdfe) | Pb r Kfvbk _filnr

62?8

^.P.-@hbef Ausbenss @cue`biLbssbeonr | Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr | Zfe`n | @frif Hbiis

62?2

Cpne Pc`bnty JcuekftbcesOncron Pcrcs | Dfani _bssn-Pdbt | Dcrtce Farfdcwbtz | Ab ii Dcynrs

62?2

Enw Bsrfni JuekJcrk Jcuekftbce jueknk< f``usnk cj anbeo fetb-Bsrfni

62?2

Ppn`bfi Cpnrftbces _frrbcr Jcuekftbce (PC_J)Ptbenr | D`@fbe BBB | @friu``b | Pfd Euee

628=

^.P.-Gfpfe JcuekftbceLbssbeonr | Krfpnr | Kuln | @frtnr | Jciny | Pfsflfwf

628=

Oicafi 1=== (@frtnr's prbvftn prcgn`t fjtnr hbs tnrd fs ^.P. prnsbknet)@frtnr | Fohf Hfsfe Fankb | Qycb`hb Pfsflfwf

628=

Nfst_nst BestbtutnOncron H. _. Aush (hcecrfry `hfb r) | Hnidut Lchi (hcecrfry `hfb r) | Anrthcik Anbtz(`hfbrdfe) | Gche Liuon | Dblhfbi Lhckcrlcvsly | Dustfjf Lc` | Icrk _nbknejnik | Qcss]nrct, Gr. (`hfb r) | Pfrfh ]nrct (wb jn cj ]nrct, Gr.) | Db`hfni @hnrtcjj | One. Gfdns I. Gcens| Gcsnph Eyn | _hbtnhnfk

628=

Dbkkin Nfst ]cib`y @cue`bi (DN]@)@hfs Jrnndfe | @friu``b

6286

_fshbeotce Qnpcrt ce Dbkkin Nfst Fjjfbrs 6281Ausbenss Nxn`utbvns jcr Eftbcefi Pn`urbty (ANEP)Lbssbeonr | Ornneanro | Hfykne | _nastnr | Dnbos | ]hbibp Ifknr. Dndanrshbp7 GfdnsFeointce, Gr. | Ecrdfe Fuoustben | @friu``b | Krfpnr BBB | Gfdbn Ocrnib`l | ]ftrb`l Orcss |]ntnrsce | _hbtnhnfk

6281

Pue Zfiiny dnntbeosHnranrt Fiine | Hnranrt Fiine BBB | Ab ii Arfkiny | [cd Arclfw | Db`hfni Aiccdanro | Znrece

Gcrkfe | Qupnrt Durkc`h | Ocrkce Arcwe | Db`hfni Nbsenr | Kcefik Orfhfd | @hrbstbnHnjenr | Ptnvn Gcas | Db`hfni Aiccdanro | Nkofr Arcejdfe, Gr | Aujjntt | Ab ii Oftns, PtnvnAfiidnr fek ]fui Fiine | Cprfh | Ptnvne Ppbnianro | Qb`hfrk ]frsces | Oncron [nent.

6280

Eftbcefi Kndc`rftb` Bestbtutn (EKB)Onphfrkt | Dcyebhfe | Arfkndfs | [ndpsnisdfe | Zfe`n | Fiarboht | _cijnesche

6280

Frfa Afelnrs Fssc`bftbce cj Ecrth Fdnrb`f 6280Fdnrb`fe F`fkndy cj Kbpicdf`yJcrdnr `hfbrdne7 ]b`lnrbeo, Lfdpnidfe, Nfoinauronr, @friu``b, Ibecwbtz, NiibctQb`hfrksce. | @frif Hbiis | Qb`hfrk Ofrkenr | @hfs Jrnndfe | Aru`n Onia.

6280

Betnr-Fdnrb`fe KbficounPci Ibecwbtz | D`Oncron Aueky | D`Efdfrf | [hnckcrn Hnsauroh

6280

Eftbcefi Nekcwdnet jcr Kndc`rf`y (ENK)_fitnr Qfydcek, Gr. | Arfkndfs (`hfbr) | ]fuif Kcarbfesly (vb`n `hfbr) | Arznzbeslb |Farfdcwbtz | Blin | [fjt BZ (wbjn) | _cijcwbtz | Hciarccln | [hcdfs Lnfe | Inn Hfdbitce |

@friu``b | _nsiny @ifrl | Kb`l Onphfrkt (`hfbr) | Afrafrf Hfbo (kfuothnr cj Finxfeknr) |Pne. Aca Orfhfd | Pne. Gce Lyi | Juluyfdf | Qb`hfrk Z. Fiine (`cejnrne`n pfrtb`bpfet fekpuaib` suppcrtnr)

6280

Fdnrb`fe Fustrbfe Jcuekftbce (FFJ)@c-jcueknrs7 Kfvbk Qc`lnjniinr, @yrus Zfe`n, Oncron Afii fek Gche Insibn

628;

Hbtf`hb JcuekftbceNiibct Qb`hfrksce (jcueknr fek `hfbr uetb i 6228) | Gcsnph Lfsputys jcuekbeo dndanr fek`hfbr sbe`n 6228) | ]ftrb`l Orcss (trustnn sbe`n 1==0)

628>

N^-Gfpfe @netrn jcr Bekustrbfi @ccpnrftbceKfvboece

628?

Fdnrb`f-@hbef Pc`bnty (F@P)Lbssbeonr | Zfe`n | D`Jfrifen

628?

- Fefiysbs cj thn ]nrdfenet Ocvnrednet http7//wblbspccls.`cd/BPO]/Fppne

0; :/;/1=60

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

35/318

7/23/2019 SECOND REPLY with SECOND SUPPLEMENT with REPLY to Response in RE NOM to RENEW Strunk v NYS Board of

36/318

Ftifetb` ]frtenrshbpLbssbeonr | Pne. Gcsnph Abkne | Gche Dfgcr | Pfd Euee | _biibfd @chne | P`cw`rcjt |D`@fbe BBB | Icrk Oncron Qcanrtsce | ]cwnii | Pbr Nvniye kn Qcths`hbik | ]fuifKcarbfesly | Gche Krnxni BZ

1==6

Eu`infr [hrnft Bebtbftbvn[nk [urenr (`c-`hfbr) | Euee (`c-`hfbr) | Pusfe Nbsnehcwnr | Aujjntt | ]nrry | ]rbe`n NiHfssfe abe [fifi

1==6

@iua cj Dfkrbk

_bd Lcl

1==6

Feoic-Frfa CrofebzftbceEfkhdb Fu`hb (jcueknr fek prnsbknet)

1==1

Fdnrb`f Farcfk Dnkbf[rustnns7 Fashbrn | Fiarboht | Huesfeo Fesfry | Frdbtfon | Fuoustben | Pfd Anronr |Arznzbeslb | @hnrtcjj | ]fuif Kcarbfesly | Krfpnr BBB | Qcanrt Oftns | Aru`n Onia | InsibnOnia | Onrone | Hffss | @hu`l Hfoni | Inn Hfdbitce | @frif Hbiis | Huetbeotce | DfrtbeBekyl | Gche Lnrry | Lbrlpftrb`l | D`Ifrty BBB | D`Efdfrf | ]b`lnrbeo | Qchftye |P`cw`rcjt | [fiactt | _hbtnhnfk | _ccisny | ]hb ibp Wnib lcw

1==1

Nurcpnfe N`cecdb` Qcuek [fainCrofebznrs7 Gf`ca Qcths`hbik & Aujjntt | P`hwfrznenoonr | Eb`ly Cppnehnbdnr |_cijnesche

1==1

Oicafi Infknrshbp Jcuekftbce]b`lnrbeo (`hfbr) | Icrk @hrbs ]fttne | Db`hni Qc`frk | Hfes vfe kne Arcnl | ]rbe`nHfssfe abe [fifi

1==;

]frtenrshbp jcr f Pn`urn Fdnrb`f (]PF)Arznzbeslb | Phuitz | Fiarboht | Anronr | _hbtnhnfk | _bsenr BB | Inhdfe | Inn Hfdbitce |Pifkn Ocrtce | [hcdfs Lnfe | ]b`lnrbeo | Euee | _biibfd ]nrry | D`Jfrifen | @frif Hbiis |]fuif Kcarbfesly | _biibfd @chne | _frrne @hrbstcphnr

1==>

Fiibfe`n jcr f Enw Lcscvc@friu``b | Pfduni Hcslbesce (G_B) | Lndptce Gnelbes (G_B)

1==>

Eftbcefi Pn`urbty EntwcrlInsibn Onia | Qb`hfrk @ifrln | Pfd Anronr | _bsenr BB | _nsiny @ifrl

1==:

]rcgn`t ce Eftbcefi Pn`urbty Qnjcrd (]EPQ)Fashbrn | Fuoustben | _nsiny @ifrl | Obfdafstbfeb | Obeorb`h | Db`hfni D`@ceenii (KEB) |Gnssb`f [u`hdfe Dfthnws | [cd Qbkon | ]b`lnrbeo | P`cw`rcjt | One. Gfdns I. Gcens

1==:

Eu`infr Pn`urbty ]rcgn`t (EP])Lbssbeonr | Phuitz | ]nrry | Euee

1==?

P`cw`rcjt Bestbtutn cj Betnreftbcefi Fjjfbrs, Aush P`hcci cjOcvnrednet fek ]uaib` Pnrvb`n, [nxfs F&D ebvnrsbtyAush ;6 | Arnet P`cw`rcjt | Qcanrt Oftns | Lbssbeonr | Nfoinauronr | Arznzbeslb | Bedfe |Knut`h | Dfrben @crps One. Gfdns I. Gcens | Dfrben @crps One. Anrefrk [rfbecr

1==?

Fdnrb`fe Pn`urbty ]rcgn`tOfry Hfrt | Gche Lnrry | @hu`l Hfoni | Fuoustben | @hrbstben _hbtdfe

1==?

@netnr jcr f Enw Fdnrb`fe Pn`urbtyGcsnph Eyn | Fiarboht | Frdbtfon | Fuoustben | _biibfd ]nrry | Gche ]cknstf

1==?

[cp Invni Orcup cj L ]fribfdnetfrbfes jcr Duitbiftnrfi Eu`infrKbsfrdfdnet fek Ece-prcibjnrftbce ([IO - bespbrnk ay thn EP])60th Dfrqunss cj Icthbfe (Db`hfni Lnrr) | Icrk @frrbeotce | Icrk Outhrbn | Icrk Hcwn |Icrk Hcwnii | Icrk Hurk | Icrk Cwne | Pbr Dfi`cid Qbjlbek | Icrk Oncron Qcanrtsce

1==2

@cesnesus jcr Fdnrb`fe Pn`urbty 1=6=Rfin's Gf`lsce Bestbtutn jcr Oicafi FjjfbrsPnebcr jniicws7 _ccisny | _cijnesche | One. Ptfeiny D`@hrystfi

1=6=

Cbi @iua@hfbrdfe7 Icrk Ecrdfe Ifdcet

^elecwe

Ibanrfi-`cesnrvftbvn (dbibtfry iuas/orcups fek purn @BF/ocvnrednet)

Efvfi fek Dbibtfry @iua, Icekce ("Be & Cut")Pbr Gche @u`leny

68:1

Frdy fek Efvy @iua, _fshbeotceVubtn pcpuifr fdceo ]biorbds.

688>

- Fefiysbs cj thn ]nrdfenet Ocvnrednet http7//wblbspccls.`cd/BPO]/Fppne

0;