Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases...

62
1 PROCEEDINGS Agriculture, Food Security and Nutrition in NepalTaking Stock and Defining Priorities NUTRITION COLLABORATIVE SUPPORT RESESEARCH PROGRAM: SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 2122, 2012 AUTHORS: SUDEEP SHRESTHA SWETHA MANOHAR ROLF KLEMM RAPPORTEURS: DIPLAV SAPKOTA AKRITI SINGH RAMAN SHRESTHA SUDEEP SHRESTHA DISCLAIMER: The authors’ views expressed in this publication do not necessarily reflect the views of the United States Agency for International Development or the United States Government.

Transcript of Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases...

Page 1: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

1

PROCEEDINGS

Agriculture,FoodSecurityandNutritioninNepal‐TakingStockandDefiningPriorities

NUTRITIONCOLLABORATIVESUPPORTRESESEARCHPROGRAM:

SCIENTIFICSYMPOSIUM

March21‐22,2012

AUTHORS:

SUDEEPSHRESTHA

SWETHAMANOHAR

ROLFKLEMM

RAPPORTEURS:

DIPLAVSAPKOTA

AKRITISINGH

RAMANSHRESTHA

SUDEEPSHRESTHA

DISCLAIMER:Theauthors’viewsexpressedinthispublicationdonotnecessarilyreflecttheviewsoftheUnitedStatesAgencyforInternationalDevelopmentortheUnitedStatesGovernment.

Page 2: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

2

TABLEOFCONTENTS

AbouttheNutritionCollaborativeResearchSupportProgram(NutritionCRSP)......................4 

Acknowledgements.......................................................................................................................................................4 

ExecutiveSummary.......................................................................................................................................................5 

ProgramataGlance......................................................................................................................................................9 

Opening..............................................................................................................................................................................12 

SymposiumKeynoteAddress.................................................................................................................................14 

Roleofevidenceinleveragingagricultureforimprovedhealthandnutrition 

Session1............................................................................................................................................................................23 

Agriculturetomarkets..................................................................................................................................................23 

Session2...........................................................................................................................................................................27 

LinkingFoodMarketsand/orHomeProductiontoHouseholdAccess....................................................27 

Session3...........................................................................................................................................................................31 

HouseholdAvailability,AccessandUsetoDietaryIntakeandNutritionandHealthOutcomesofWomenandYoungChildren.......................................................................................................................................31 

Session 4.............................................................................................................................................................................33 

Identifying,Defining,MeasuringLinkagesandEvidenceGaps....................................................................33 

NextSteps.........................................................................................................................................................................40 

APPENDIX.........................................................................................................................................................................42 

Session1‐Abstracts....................................................................................................................................................42 

1.1HouseholdConsumptionofGrainLegumesinNepalTerai:AStudyonImpactofImprovedTechnoglogies.RKNeupane,NSThakur,PJha,DNPokharel,BPMahatoandRASah.................42 

1.2EfficienciesinLinkingAgriculturalDevelopmentwithHealthandNutritionTraininginNepal.L.ColavitoandM.Pariyar.......................................................................................................................................43 

1.3HighImpactTechnologiesApproachesforImprovedFoodSecurityandNutritionofRuralPoor.JoeSanders.......................................................................................................................................................44 

Session2‐Abstracts....................................................................................................................................................45 

2.1ApplicationoftheHouseholdEconomyApproachforAssessingFoodSecurityandDescribingLivelihoodsinNepal.SavilleNM1,AkhterN1,ShresthaBP2,ManandharDS,OsrinD,CostelloA........................................................................................................................................................................................45 

2.2HomesteadFoodProductioncontributestoDietaryIntakeofChildren6‐23montholdsinKailaliDistrict,FarWestTerai.DPAdhikari,PPandeyRana1,DDavis,NSharma,HBChand,RKNeupane..................................................................................................................................................................46 

2.3FoodSecurity,FoodPriceandIncomeTrendsinDhanushaDistrict,Nepalbetween2005and2011.ShresthaBP,AkhterN,ManandharDS,OsrinD,CostelloA,SavilleNM................................47 

2.4ValidatingDistrict‐LevelAssessmentwithSurveyData:ExamplefromtheNEKASP,WorldFoodProgramme.......................................................................................................................................................48 

Page 3: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

3

Session3‐Abstracts...................................................................................................................................................49 

3.1NutritionInterventionthatImproveChildandMaternalHealthandSurvivalFindingsfromTrialsintheTeraiofNepal(Expandedabstract)KeithP.West,Jr.,SubarnaK.Khatry,ParulChristian,RolfD.W.Klemm,JoanneKatz,LukeMullany,StevenC.LeClerq,JamesM.Tielsch.49 

3.2GrowthandHealthofRuralChildrenin3districtsofNepal:EffectofaCommunityDevelopmentIntervention.LCMiller,RShrestha,MLohani,PSingh,PSubba,DThapa,SNMahato,NJoshi.........................................................................................................................................................52 

3.3ImpactsofChangesinGrainPulse(legume)ConsumptiononMicronutrientSupplyofRuralWomeninNepalAndNorthIndia.PAndersen...........................................................................................53 

3.4CorrelatesofInfantandYoungChildFeedingPracticesinChepangCommunity.SubediN,PoudelS,RanaTandPaudelAK........................................................................................................................54 

TitleListingsforPosterPresentations...................................................................................................................55 

ListofParticipants.............................................................................................................................................................56 

References..............................................................................................................................................................................61 

Page 4: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

4

ABOUTTHENUTRITIONCOLLABORATIVERESEARCHSUPPORTPROGRAM(NUTRITIONCRSP)

TheUSGovernment’supcoming‘FeedtheFuture’initiativesupportsanewparadigmthatlinksagriculturewithhealthstrategiestoaddressundernutritionindevelopingcountries.Thisintegratedapproachaimstoprovidelongtermandsustainablesolutionstoundernutritionbyaddressingitsdeterminants.TheNutritionCRSPwillworkwithUSAIDmissions,developmentpartnersandhostcountriesthroughthe‘FeedtheFutureImplementationPlanandFoodSecurityCountryInvestmentPlans’todeterminethekindsofinvestmentsinagriculture,healthandnutrition,institutionalandhumancapacitydevelopmentandpolicydevelopmentneededtoachievelargescaleimprovementsinanation'shealth.TheNutritionCRSPisaprogramof‘research‐to‐practice’thatsupportshumanandinstitutionalcapacitybuildingforresearchandpolicyanalysisinhostcountries,inpartnershipwithlocaluniversities,researchorganizations,andcentersofpolicyformulationwithinthegovernment.ItwaslaunchedinOctober2010,andismanagedbytheFriedmanSchoolofNutritionScienceandPolicyatTuftsUniversity,inpartnershipwiththeSchoolsofPublicHealthatJohnsHopkinsUniversityandHarvard,theCollegeofAgricultureatPurdueUniversity,theCollegeofAgricultural,Environmental,andNaturalSciencesatTuskegeeUniversity,DevelopmentAlternativesInc.,theUSAIDBureauforFoodSecurityandUSAIDmissionsinFeedtheFuturefocuscountries.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

WegratefullyacknowledgethesupportoftheUnitedStatesAgencyforInternationalDevelopment(USAID)forprovidingthefundstosupportthisscientificsymposiumandproceedings.Specialthanksgototheco‐hostsofthesymposium,theDepartmentofCommunityMedicineandPublicHealthatInstituteofMedicine(IOM)atTribhuvanUniversity,especiallytoDr.SharadOnta,DepartmentHeadandDr.RameshAdhikari,PediatricianandProfessoratIOM.AdditionalthanksgototheNationalAgriculturalResearchCenter(NARC),especiallytoDr.DevendraGauchan.WealsothanktheNepalTechnicalAssistanceGroup(NTAG)foralltheir“behindthescenes”workinassistingwithlogistics,communicationsandregistrationfortheevent.WealsowouldliketorecognizeMr.AtmaramPandey,NPC,Ms.ShabnamShivakoti,MoAC,andMr.DiplavSapkotaaswellasthenumerousindividualswhohelpedsolicitparticipation.WeextendourgratitudetoDr.MarieRuelandDr.SuneethaKadiyalafortheirvaluableadviceandcontributions.Weextendspecialappreciationtotherapporteursoftheevent:Dr.SudeepShrestha,Ms.AkritiSingh,Mr.DiplavSapkotaandDr.RamanShrestha;withouttheirkeenattentionandcomprehensivenotes,thisreportwouldnothavebeenpossible.ThankyoutoDrs.PatrickWebb,RolfKlemmandKeithWestfortheirguidanceandsupportduringthepreparatoryphasesandconductofthisevent.SpecialthankstoMs.SwethaManoharforleadingtheorganizationofthisevent.Finally,wethankeachofthepresenterswhoputanextraordinaryamountofeffortintomakingthiseventasuccessfromsubmittingabstracts,tomakingrevision,tocreatingandshowcasingtheirpostersandoralpresentations.

Page 5: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

5

EXECUTIVESUMMARY

TheGlobalNutritionCollaborativeResearchSupportProgram(CRSP)‐Asiathroughitspartner,JohnsHopkinsBloombergSchoolofPublicHealth,organizedatwo‐dayscientificsymposiuminKathmandu,Nepal,co‐hostedbytheDepartmentofCommunityMedicineandPublicHealthattheInstituteofMedicine(IOM).TheNutritionCRSPisamultidisciplinaryresearchconsortiumwhichseekstodetermineinvestmentsneededinagriculture,healthandnutrition,institutionalandhumancapacitydevelopment,andprogramdevelopmenttoachievelargescaleimprovementsinnutritionoutcomes.Thepreliminaryreportofthe2011NepalDemographicHealthSurveyshowsanimprovementinchildnutritionalstatusbetween2001and2006withstunting,wastingandunderweightprevalencedecreasingfrom49%to41%,31%to11%and39to29%,respectively[1].Nonetheless,chronicundernutritionisstillwidespread,andwidedisparitiesexistacrosssocioeconomicgroupsandecologicalregionswithchildrenfromthepooresthouseholdsandthoselivinginthemountainandhillareasexhibitingthehighest levelsofstunting.NepalisoneofthepoorestcountriesinSouthAsia.Ahighproportion(estimatesrangefrom25%‐55%)ofitspopulationlivesonlessthan<$1.25/day[2].Over80percentofthepopulationworksintheagriculturalsector,mostofwhoworkonsubsistence‐orientedfamilyfarms.HouseholdsemployedinagricultureaccountformorethanthreequartersofNepal’spoor.Manyofthesehouseholdsweredeeplyaffectedbytheprotractedconflict,droughtandothernaturaldisasters.Improvementsinagriculturalproductivityhavenotmaintainedpacewithpopulationgrowth,particularlyamongsmalllandholdersandfemalefarmers,thelatterconstitutingover60%oftheagriculturallaborforce.In2009,theWorldFoodProgrammereportedthat43ofNepal’s75districtsfacedafooddeficit,and23districtswerechronicallyfoodinsecure.Theinabilityofhouseholdstosuccessfully“weather”transitoryfoodsupplyshocksfromdrought,flood,marketfailure,orcivilstrifecanimpacttheirnutritionalintake,nutritionalstatusandhealth.FAO’sreporton‘Guidingprinciplesforlinkingagricultureandnutrition:Synthesisfrom10developmentinstitutions’illustratedthatthelinkagesbetweenagriculturefacesfour“mainconstraints:(i)informationonwhattodo,(ii)howtodoit,(iii)howmuchitwillcost(perbenefitgained),and(iv)howitwillbesupportedorrewarded”[3].Further,Leroyetal.notedthattheimpactofmulti‐sectoralprogramsfocusingonnutritionislimitedin2008[4].Improvedagricultureleadingtobetterhouseholdfoodsecurityhasbeenidentifiedasafundamentaldeterminantofprocessesthatleadtofoodsecurity,adequatedietaryintakeandnutritionalstatus,andhealth,yetlimitedempiricalevidenceexistsonthekindsofactionsinagriculturethatdo(ordonot)supportnutritionandhealthforimpoverishedsegmentsofthepopulationorgroupspassingthroughvulnerablelifestages.Littledataexistsbeyondpilotprojectsthatrevealwaystooptimizetheproduction,availabilityandaccessoffoodproductsthatassuredietarydiversityamongthepoor.Thepathwaysthatleadfromfoodproductiontohouseholdfoodsecuritytoimprovednutritionarecomplicated,withmultipledeterminants.Yet,systemsdoexistthatconveyfoodwithinand

Page 6: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

6

acrosscommunitiesthroughouttheyear,withvariedefficiency,qualityandimpact.Itistheconnectedpathwaysthatweneedtounderstand,measureandclassify,andaddresstheirmodifiablecomponentsinordertoreducefoodinsecurityandundernutritioninhighriskgeographicareasandsocio‐economicgroups.Theserepresentcriticalstepstowardseffectiveprogramming.Theintentofthesymposiumwastoshare,understandandassimilatecountry‐relevantevidenceaboutfactorsthatcontributetocausalpathwaysthatleadfromagriculturetonutrition,innational,regionalandlocalcontexts.Anationalcallforabstractswasmadetoresearchersconductingworkacrossthesediversebutconnectedfieldstopresenttheirwork.Theeventwasattendedbyapproximately140participantsfromthescientific,research,program,policymakeranddevelopmentpartnercommunities.

Thesymposiumsoughttounderstand,fromdatarelevanttoNepal,(a)aspectsofagriculturalproductionthataffectfoodproductionquality,quantityandavailabilityinmarketsacrossecologicalzonesandseasons,(b)marketdynamicsthataffectyearroundandseasonalhouseholdaccesstofood,throughpurchaseorhomeproduction,(c)householdfoodsecurityandconsumptionnormsthatdeterminedietaryintake,and(d)elementsofdietaryadequacyandhygienethataffectnutritionalstatus,health,developmentandsurvival.Thesymposiumwasorganizedintofourthematicsessions:(1)Agriculture‐to‐Market,(2)MarketPurchaseorHomeProduction‐to‐Household,(3)HouseholdDiettoNutritionalStatusofWomenandYoungChildren,and(4)LinkagesAcrosstheCausalSpectrum.

Thefoursessionsdeconstructedandassessedthestrengthofevidenceofkeyfactorsalongthispathway,describedmethodsformeasuringthesefactors,exploredfactorsthatlinkdomainswithinthepathwayandattemptedtoidentifyevidencegaps.OralandposterpresentationsofabstractsonDay1coveredvariedtopics,includingtheimpactofconsumptionoflegumesonhealthoutcomes,resultsofcombinedinterventions(agriculturalproduction,incomegeneration,homegardening)onhealthandnutritional

Page 7: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

7

outcomes,methodsavailabletoassessfoodinsecurity,andreviewsoffindingsfromrandomizednutritionalinterventiontrials.Day2ofthesymposiumconsistedofaparticipatoryanddynamicdiscussionofdomainsofconcernthatspantheagriculturetonutritionpathway,toidentifygapsinknowledge,designandmeasurementsissues,andcapacitybuilding.Themesraisedincluded1)improvingdietaryintake(quality&quantity)ofpoorandmalnourishedwomen&children;2)settingofpracticaldietarygoalsinthehomethatmayimprovenutritionalconditions;3)contextualfactorsthatinfluencedietaryadequacy;4)relationshipsbetweenhomefoodproduction,storageandprocessingtodietaryadequacy;5)marketfactorsthataffectyearroundfoodaccess;and6)agriculturalfactorsthataffectavailability,marketpricesandaccess(effectivedemand)tofoodinthehousehold.

Symposiumparticipantsidentifiedknowledgegapsbothwithinandbetweenthedomains.Theseincludedneedstobetterunderstand:(i)determinantsofhouseholdandchildmalnutrition,(ii)howdifferenttargetgroupsperceivenutritioninformation,and(iii)effectsofcommoncookingandfoodpreparationmethodsonnutritionalvalue,(iv)women’srolesinagriculturewithrespecttocontrolofhouseholdresources,decision‐making,intra‐householdfoodallocation,theirownnutritionandtheirabilitytocareoftheirchildren,(v)rolesofpovertyalleviationstrategiesforimprovingnutritionalstatusofwomenandchildren.

ThereisaneedtobuildresearchcapacitywithinNepalandtotranslateresearchfindingsintopolicyandprogramsacrossthecountryandmobilizingevidence‐basedadvocateswithingovernmenttopresentconvincingandbetterunderstoodfindingsarenecessary.

Basedondiscussionsthattranspiredthroughoutthesymposium,thesymposiumorganizingcommitteeidentifiedthefollowingpriorityactionsasrecommended“nextsteps”fortheNepalresearchcommunity:

Formacross‐disciplinaryworkinggroupcomposedofestablishedresearchersfromeachrelevantsector—agriculture,economics,marketing,foodsecurity,dietaryintake,publichealthandnutrition—toidentifythekeyresearchquestionsthatneedtobeaddressedinthenext3,5and10yearstoinformtheagriculture‐to‐nutritioncausalpathway.

Conductefficacy(i.e.underoptimalconditions)andeffectiveness(underreal‐lifeandprogrammaticconditions)researchonpromisingandrelevantinterventions.

Establishcommunity‐basedsurveillancesitesinthemajoragro‐ecologicalzonesinNepalto(i)providelongitudinalmeasuresoftrendsandchangesovertimeinfoodavailability,accessandutilization,andrelatethemtohouseholdfoodsecurity,dietaryintakeandnutritionandhealthstatus,and(ii)generateempiricalevidenceaboutintegratedagricultureandotherfoodandnutritionprograminterventionshaveaneffectonnutritionandhealthoutcomes.ThisshouldbeapriorityareafortheNutritionCRSP.

Page 8: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

8

Organizeabi‐annualorannualforumforpolicymakersfromtheNPC,MoACandMoHPandresearcherstodiscussandtranslateresearchfindingsthatpertaintoimprovementofnutritionstatusthroughamulti‐sectoralapproach.

Organizeanannualscientificsymposiumor“evidencesummit”tofacilitatetherapidsharingoffindingsandinnovativesolutions.

Page 9: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

9

PROGRAMATAGLANCE

March21,2012:Day1

9:00‐9:20 MorningTeaandParticipantRegistration

9:20‐9:30 Welcome(Dr.SharadOnta)

9:30‐9:40 WelcomeandRemarksonFeedtheFutureandGlobalHealthInitiative:USAIDMissionDirector(Mr.DavidAtteberry)

9:40‐10:00 KeynoteaddressonAgriculture–NutritionPathway(Dr.RolfKlemm)

10:00‐10:10 OfficialOpeningandInauguralRemarksbyChiefGuest(HonorableDr.ShivaKumarRai)

10:10–10:20 OpeningRemarks(Dr.PraveenMishra,MoHP)

SESSION1:AGRICULTURETOMARKET

10:30–10:50 StateoftheArt/Evidence(Dr.DevendraGauchan)

10:50–11:05 1.1HouseholdConsumptionofGrainLegumesinNepalTerai:AStudyonImpactofImprovedTechnologies(Dr.RamKrishnaNeupane,FORWARDNepal)

1105‐11:20 1.2EfficienciesinLinkingAgriculturalDevelopmentwithHealthand

NutritionTraininginNepal(Dr.LukeCovalito,IDE)11:20‐11:35 1.3Highimpact,integratedapproachesforimprovedfoodsecurity

andnutritionofruralpoor(JoeSanders,Fintrac)

11:35‐12:00 Q&A,Rapporteurkeycomments,identifyingtheevidencegaps

12:00–12:45 Lunch

SESSION2:FOODMARKETSAND/ORHOMEPRODUCTIONTOHOUSEHOLDACCESS

12:45‐1:05 StateoftheArt/Evidence:ImprovingAccesstoNutritiousFoodsinRuralMarkets(Dr.MarieRuel)

1:05‐1:20 2.1ApplicationoftheHouseholdEconomyApproachforassessingfoodsecurityanddescribinglivelihoodsinNepal(Dr.NaomiSaville,MIRA&UCL)

Page 10: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

10

1:20‐1:35 2.2HomesteadFoodProductioncontributestodietaryintakeamongchildren6‐23monthsoldinKailalidistrict,FarWesternTerai(DebendraAdhikari,HKI)

1:35‐1:502.3Foodsecurity,foodpriceandincometrendsinDhanushadistrictNepalbetween2005‐2011(BPShrestha,MIRA)

1:50–2:05 2.4Validatingdistrict‐levelassessmentwithsurveydata:examplefromtheNepalFoodSecurityMonitoringSystem(MarikoKawabata,WFP)

2:05‐2:30 Q&A,Rapporteurkeycomments,identifyingtheevidencegaps

2:30–3:00 Tea

SESSION3:HOUSEHOLDAVAILABILITY,ACCESSANDUSETODIETARYINTAKEANDNUTRITIONANDHEALTHOUTCOMESOFWOMENANDYOUNGCHILDREN

3:00‐3:20 StateoftheArt/Evidence(Dr.RameshAdhikari)

3:20‐3:35 3.1NutritionInterventionsthatImproveChildorMaternalHealthorSurvival:FindingsfromRCTsintheTeraiofNepalNNIPSresearch(Dr.KeithWest,JHU)

3:35‐3:50 3.2Growthandhealthofruralchildrenin3districtsofNepal:effectof

acommunitydevelopmentintervention(NeenaJoshi,HeiferInternational)

3:50‐4:05 3.3ImpactsofChangesinGrainPulse(legumeconsumption)onmicronutrientsupplyofruralwomeninNepalandNorth(Dr.PeterAndersen,UIB)

4:05–4:20 3.4CorrelatesofInfantandYoungChildFeedingPracticesinChepangcommunityofMakawanpur(Dr.Subedi,NepalPublicHealthFoundation,IOM)

4:20‐4:45 Rapporteurkeycomments,identifyingtheevidencegaps

4:45‐5:00 Closingremarks(Dr.Adhikari/Dr.Klemm)

Page 11: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

11

March22,2012:Day2

SESSION4:IDENTIFYING,DEFINING,MEASURINGLINKAGESANDEVIDENCEGAPS

9:30‐9:45 ObjectivesforDay2(Dr.KeithWest&Dr.SharadOnta)

9:45‐12:15 Agriculture‐NutritionPathway:ResearchgapsintheNepalcontext(GeneralDiscussion,Moderators:Dr.KeithWest&Dr.SharadOnta)

12:15‐12:20 Closingremarks(Dr.PatrickWebb)12:20‐12:30 VoteofThanks(Dr.SharadOnta)12:30‐1:30Lunch1:30 Meetingadjourned

Page 12: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

12

OPENING

Dr.SharadOnta,theDeanofCommunityMedicineandPublicHealthattheInstituteofMedicine,co‐hostfortheevent,openedtheNutritionCRSP’s“NepalAgriculture,FoodSecurityandNutritioninNepal:TakingStockandDefiningPriorities”symposiumbysettingforththepurposeforthesymposium.Theaim,Dr.Ontastatedwastoreviewevidenceandassessresearchgapsrelatingagriculture,markets,householdfoodsecurityandultimatelynutritionstatus.Throughthis,Dr.Ontastatedthesymposiumwouldserveasaplatformtomapfutureresearchagendas,prioritiesandcollaborations.Dr.OntawelcomedhonorableguestsandparticipantsandthenintroducedDr.PraveenMishra,theSecretaryoftheMinistryofHealthandPlanning(MoHP).

Inhisopeningremarks,Dr.PraveenMishra,Secretary,MoHP,statedthatthecomponentsoffarmtohealthandfitnessneedtobeexploredinatime,costandresourceeffectivemanner.Healsopointedouttheneedofidentifyingandaccessingmechanismoffoodsource,flowandtrendsofavailabilitythroughoutthecountry.

Next,Mr.DavidAtteberry,USAIDMissionDirectorprovidedopeningremarksonUSAID’seffortsand

commitmenttoamulti‐sectoral,integratedapproachtoaddressandfoodinsecurityandmalnutrition.AccordingtoMr.Atteberry,agriculture,foodsecurityandnutritionarethetopthreeforeignassistanceprioritiesoftheUnitedStatesGovernment.Heemphasizedaclearintersectionacrossdevelopmentsectorstoachievebetterandacceleratedresults.Henotedgapsinourunderstandingabouttherelationshipsbetweenagriculturalproduction,consumption,marketaccessandnutritionoutcomes,andtheneedtofillthesegaps,especiallyinlightofUSAID’sflagshipprogram,FeedtheFuture,whichseekstoimproveagriculturalproduction,incomegenerationandhealthandnutritioneducationalactivitiestodecreasehungerandpoverty.Aresearchagendatobetterelucidatetheagriculture‐nutritionlink,heemphasized,ispartofthisnewprogram.AtteberrynotedkeyUSAIDinvestmentsinNepal’seffortstoimprovenutritionthroughagriculture,includingtheSuaaharaProgramwhichwillcommenceimplementationin2012,theGlobalAgricultureandFoodSecurityProgram(GAFSP),managedbytheWorldBank,andaNepal‐based‘FeedtheFuture’program.HelaudedtheGON’scommitmenttowardsmulti‐sectoralplanningasevidencedbytheNationalPlanningCommittee’sformationofajointfoodsecurityandnutritionsteeringcommitteeanditsMulti‐SectoralNutritionPlan.Hestressedtheimportanceofresearchtoinformevidence‐basedprogramming.He

Page 13: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

13

encouragedamulti‐disciplinaryresearchspanningtechnicalareasofpublichealth,socialsciences,economics,andagriculturetocollectivelystudytherelationshipbetweenmalnutritionandfoodproductionandcreateinnovativemethodsandsolutionstoaddressmulti‐facetedproblem.Heconcludedbychallengingtheparticipantstoremovetheir“technicalhats”andstepoutsideoftheirtechnicalsilostofindinnovativewaystosolvethispersistentandsignificantglobalpublichealthproblem.

FollowingMr.Atteberry’sspeech,Dr.RolfKlemmoftheJohnsHopkinsBloombergSchoolofPublicHealth,gavethekeynoteaddress.Detailsofhistalkarefoundinthenextsection.

TheHonorableMemberoftheNationalPlanningCommittee(NPC)andChiefGuest,Dr.ShivaKumarRai,officiallyinauguratedanddeclaredtheScientificSymposiumopen.Hewelcomedallparticipantsandreiteratedtheimportanceofevidenceasabasisforinforminggovernmentpolicy.HeexpressedtheGON’scommitmentforamulti‐sectoralapproachtoaddressmalnutritionand

foodsecurityinthecountry.Heremindedparticipantsabouttheimportanceofintegritywhilstconductingandpublishingresearchandtheneedtobevigilantofresearchersfalsifyingresultsfortheirownprofessionaladvancement.Heralliedforresearcherstocontinueintheireffortswhilstfulfillingallethicaltotheirsubjectsandthelargerresearch,programandpoliticalcommunities.

Page 14: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

14

SYMPOSIUMKEYNOTEADDRESS

ROLEOFEVIDENCEINLEVERAGINGAGRICULTUREFORIMPROVEDHEALTHANDNUTRITION

BackgroundNepalisafooddeficit,land‐lockedcountryof~30millionpeople,withhighlevelsofundernutritioninwomenandchildren.Recentestimateshaveshownadeclineinstuntingprevalenceamongchildrenunderfiveyearsofagefrom49%in2006to41%in2011(DHS,2011),butaggregateratesmaskdifferencesacrossregions,socio‐economicorcastestrata.Childhoodstuntingremainshighestamongruralchildrenresidinginmountainsandhilldistricts,whichalsohavethehighestratesoffoodinsecurity(FAO,AssessmentoffoodSecurityandNutritionSituationinNepal,2010).Thecausesofpoormaternalandyoungchildnutritionaremultifacetedandaregenerallyage‐specific.Atbirth,infantweightandlengtharedeterminedbymaternalfactors‐‐includingnutrition‐‐andgestationalage,i.e.whethertheinfantisfullterm.However,fromaboutsixmonthsthroughtwoyearsofageinfantfeedingpractices,particularlybreastfeedingandcomplementaryfeedingpractices,alongwithexposuretoinfectiousdiseaseappeartobethemaininfluencesongrowth.Studiesconductedinpoorpopulationsindicatethatthisisalsotheperiodwhengrowthfailureandnutritionalstressaregreatest.Amongundernourishedyoungchildrenpoornutritionisassociatedwithincreasedmortality,higherincidenceandgreaterseverityofinfection,suppressedimmune‐competence,anddelayedmotorandcognitivedevelopment(Figure1).Sub‐optimalnutritioninearlylifeoftenleadstopermanentsmallsizeinadulthood,andincreasesawoman’sriskofcomplicationsduringchildbirthanddeliveringasmallbaby,thusperpetuatingpoorgrowthintothenextgeneration.Amongundernourishedwomen,risksforobstetricmorbidityanddeliverycomplicationsarehigher,asisinfection,anemiaandriskofdeath.Earlylifenutrition‐InfluenceonlifelonghealthTheeffectsofearlylifenutritionareknowntohavelifelonginfluencesonhealth(Figure2).Awoman’snutritionalstatusatthestartofandduringherpregnancyinfluencesthenutrientsavailabletobetransferredtoherfetusandfetalgrowth.Itiswellknownthat

FIGURE1

Page 15: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

15

FIGURE2

deficiencyiniodineandconsequentthyroidhormoneproductionduringcriticalperiodsoforganogenesiscandamagethebrainandnervoustissueofthedevelopingfetus,causingirreversiblementalretardationandotherdevelopmentalabnormalities.Inadequateweightgainduringpregnancycaninfluencethebaby’ssizeatbirthandotherdeficienciescompromisethephysiologicendowmentandmaturityoftheinfantatbirth.Duringearlyinfancyandchildhood,inadequatedietaryintakesofthemotherandinfantaffecttheyoungchild’sgrowth,abilitytoresistandfightinfectionandcognitivedevelopment.Eachofthese,inturn,canaffectthechildintohisschoolyearsandadultlife.Theperiodfromconceptionthroughaninfant’sfirsttwoyearsofliferepresentsacriticalwindowofopportunitytopreventthelifelongconsequencesofmalnutrition.Thisperiodisknownasthe“first1000days”andevidencesuggeststhatoncethiswindowofopportunitycloses,itisdifficultifnotimpossibletoreversethenegativeconsequencesofpoorgrowthandnutrition.EssentialNutrientFactsMuchhasbeenlearnedaboutessentialnutrientssincethefirstvitaminwasidentifiedalmost100yearsago,butthisknowledgeisoftenunderappreciated.Micronutrients,suchasvitaminA,iron,zinc,iodineandothers,cannotbeproducedbythebody,sotheymustbeprovidedthroughthediet.Thesenutrientsperformmillionsoffunctionsinthetrillionsofcellsinthehumanbody.Theyserveasco‐enzymes,regulatemetabolism,areinvolvedwithoxygentransportandcellularrespiration,playanactiveroleintheimmunesystem,andarecriticalforfunctionsinvirtuallyallcells,allofthetrillionsofcellsthatmakeupthehumanbody.

Page 16: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

16

AlignmentoftheFoodSystemwithNutritionalOutcomesAgriculture,nutritionandhealthareinterrelated.Producingandconsumingadequateamountsandkindsoffoodpromotehealthynutrition.Inreality,however,foodproductionandconsumptionpatternsvarywidely,andareoftennotwellalignedandcanworkatcross‐purposes.Whenfoodsystemsarealignedwithnutritionalneedsintermsoftheamount,quality,safety,availability,affordabilityandaccessibility,theycancontributesignificantlytotheproductionofanutritionallyhealthypopulation(Figure3).Whenfoodsystemsaremisalignedwithnutritionalneedsofapopulationtheycansignificantlyinfluencetheratesofunderandover‐nutrition.Ofcourse,thefoodsystemoperatesinacontextwherecultural,socioeconomicandotherfactorsalsoinfluencehealthandnutrition,andwherethesefactorscanpositivelyornegativelyinteractwiththefoodsystemtoinfluencethepopulation’snutritionandhealth.Sounderstandingboththefoodsystemandthecontextinwhichitoperatesisvitalforunderstandingwhatpartsofthefoodsystemshouldbereshapedtobetterimprovenutritionalwell‐being.Nepal:TheAgriculture‐NutritionConnectionInNepal,considerableprogresshasbeenmadeinreducingpoverty,increasingproductivity,andreducingstuntinginchildreninthepast5‐10years.However,wastingprevalenceorabnormalthinnessamongchildrenhasincreased.Disaggregatingnationalestimatesrevealimportantandimpressivereductionsinchildhoodstunting–thatis,childrenbeingabnormallyshortfortheirage‐‐acrossallecologicalzones,rangingfromalowof14.7%inmountaindistrictstoahighof17.2%intheterai(Figure4).Butstuntingprevalenceremainsathighlevelsinallthreeecologiczones.Adifferentpictureemergeswithrespecttowastingprevalence.Theteraihasshownmajorreductionsinchildhoodwasting;butwastinghassignificantlyincreasedinthehillsandmountaindistricts.Largedisparitiesinbothstuntingandwastingratesremainbywealthquintile.Poorchildrenarealmosttwiceaslikelytobestuntedandwastedcomparedwiththeirwealthiercounterparts.MuchlessisknownaboutthechangesthathaveoccurredwithrespecttomicronutrientdeficienciesinNepaloverthepast5‐10years.ThelatestDHSshowslittleoverallchangeinanemiaprevalenceamongpregnantwomenandchildren,withsteepincreasesamongwomenintheHillsandMountains.ResearchpublishedbyNNIPSinSarlahirevealsthat

FIGURE3

Page 17: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

17

micronutrientdeficienciesarecommon,concurrentandvarybyseasonamongruralNepalesepregnantwomen(JiangTetal,JNutr.2005).Newopportunitiestore‐focusagriculturetoachievebetternutritionandhealthoutcomesWhileNepal’sprogresshasbeencommendable,itstillfacesenormouschallengesrelatedtofoodsecurityandmalnutrition.ItalsofacesmanyopportunitieswiththeresurgenceofinterestandinvestmentinagricultureandstartofnewprogramslikeUSAID’sSuaaharaprojectwhichis,bydesign,attemptingtointegratenutritionandagricultureinterventions.Amajorquestionishowtousethesenewopportunitiestore‐focusandrealignagriculturetoimprovenutritionandhealthamongwomenandyoungchildren.Severalbroadstepsareneeded:

identifyandfillknowledgegaps ensurethatagriculture,healthandnutritionsectorsdonotworkatcross‐purposes proactivelyfindandscaleupinnovativeapproacheswithinappropriatecontexts,

and createanenablingenvironmentforcross‐disciplinarycollaborationand

cooperationPathwaysofimpactofagriculturalinterventionsonnutritionAgriculturecanworkthroughseveralkeypathwaystomightimpactnutritionaloutcomes(Figure5).Themostdirectpathwayisproducingfoodforhouseholdconsumption.Thesecondisthroughincreasedhouseholdincomethroughthesaleoffoodproducedorwagesfromfarmlabor.Athirdpathwayisthroughagriculturalpoliciesthataffectfoodprices.A

FIGURE4

Page 18: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

18

fourthpathwayishowincomeobtainedfromagriculturalproductionorlaborisspent.Andafinalpathwayisthroughtheimplicationsthattheincreasingroleofwomenasagriculturallaborershason(i)theirabilitytoinfluencedecision‐makingregardingnutritionandhealthinthehome,(ii)timetocarefortheirchildren,and(3)impactontheirownhealth. Overthepast40‐50years,muchhasbeenlearnedabouthowagriculturalinterventionsdoordonotinfluencenutrition.TheGreenRevolutionofthe1960’sand70’sfocusedonincreasingfoodproductionandagriculturalproductivitythroughimprovedseedvarieties,agriculturalextensionandirrigationprojects.Whiletheseeffortsincreasedcerealproduction,theyignoreddistributionalissuesandnon‐cerealcrops,andthereforewereinsufficienttoeliminateundernutritionbecausethepoorestdidnothaveaccesstobothanadequatequantityandqualityoffood.Fromthelate1970’s,especiallyafterAmartyaSen’sworkoncausesoffaminein1981,malnutritionwaslinkedtofoodsecurity,andthefocusshiftedtowardsincreasingincomesandlivelihoodsratherthanfoodproduction.Butincreasesinincomedidnotimmediatelytranslatetoincreasedcaloricconsumptionorimproveddietaryquality.Thisrealizationinspiredanewwaveofresearchthataimedtoaddressbothissuesatthesametime.Projectssuchasdairydevelopment,andthepromotionofvegetablegardens,fisheriesandlivestock,aimedtoincreaseincomesofthepoorandincreaseavailabilityandaccesstonutritiousfoods.Theseinterventionswerethefocusofarecentlycompletedsystematicreview.DepartmentforInternationalDevelopment(DFID)SystematicreviewDFIDcommissionedasystematicreviewofagriculturalinterventionsthatassessedtheimpactofpotential“win‐win”agriculturalinterventionsthataimedtoimprovechildren’snutritionalstatusbyimprovingBOTHtheincomesANDdietsoftheruralpoor.Previousreviewsonthesamesubjectfoundmixedresultsornoimpactofagriculturalinterventionsonnutritionalstatus.Thisreviewbuiltonandexpandedpreviousreviewsbycoveringtheperiodof1990‐2010.

FIGURE5

Page 19: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

19

Thekeyconclusionofferedbytheauthorsofthisreviewstated,“Weattributethelackofimpactofagriculturalinterventionsonchildnutritiontomethodologicalweaknessesofthestudiesreviewedratherthanspecificcharacteristicsoftheseinterventions”.Inotherwords,theauthorsconcludedthatweakstudydesignsandmeasurementissueswereresponsiblefortheinconclusiveevidence.Thus,thequestionofwhetheragriculturalinterventionshaveapositiveimpactonthenutritionalstatusofchildrenremainsunanswered.Thereviewhighlightedfourmethodologicalweaknessesofstudieslinkingagriculturetochildnutritionstatus:(1)thelackofacrediblecounterfactual,(2)theuseofinadequateandoftenincomparablemetrics,(3)thelackofdataonparticipationratesorcharacteristicsofparticipantsofagriculturalinterventions,and(4)thelackofstatisticalpowertodetermineanimpactonchildnutritionalstatus.Theseweaknessesarebrieflydiscussedbelow:1. Lackofacrediblecounterfactual.Amajormethodologicalweaknesswhichledto

90%ofstudiesbeingexcludedfromthereviewwasthelackofacrediblecounterfactual.Acounterfactualenablestheestimationofeffectsthatwouldhaveoccurrediftheinterventionhadnotbeenimplemented.Crediblecomparisongroupsarenecessarytoestimateeffectsthatcanbeattributedtoanintervention.Thus,whenmeasuringtheimpactofanagriculturalprogramonanutritional(orother)outcome,anappropriatecounterfactualisneededsothattheobservedimpactcanbeattributedtotheintervention,andonecanruleoutotherfactorsthatmighthavehadanindependenteffectontheoutcome.

FIGURE6

Page 20: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

20

2. Inadequateandnon‐comparablemetrics.Asecondmethodologicalweaknesscitedbythereviewisrelatedtothemeasurementstakenornottaken,theirvalidityandtheircomparabilityacrossstudies—particularlymeasurementofchangesinincomeanddietrelatedtoagriculturalinterventions.Forexample,studiesmaycaptureincomefromhomegardeningoroncashincomefromsalesoffooditemspromotedbytheagriculturalintervention.Butthesecanbeveryimprecisemeasuresofincomebecausepeoplemayinvestmoretimeandlaborinthisincomestream,whiledecreasingincomefromanothersource.Thus,withoutmeasuringtotalhouseholdincome,onecannotestimatetheoverallimpactoftheinterventiononhouseholdincomeandfoodexpenditure.Similarly,programsmeasureimpactondietdifferently.Someuseconsumptionoffooditemsspecificallypromotedbytheintervention,butthisalsoignoresthepotentialofa“substitutioneffect”.Soitisimportantthatstudiesfocusonindicatorsofdietaryconsumptionthatlookatthewholediet.Inaddition,someprogramsmeasurehouseholdexpenditureonfoodandstillothersmeasurethequantityoffoodsconsumedalthoughtheymayusedifferentmethods(24hrfoodrecall,semi‐quantitativefoodfrequencies),differentrecallperiods(pastday,pastweek,pastmonth),andreportconsumptionfrequencydifferently(e.g.yes/no,consumptioncomparedtoacut‐off,orbyusingadietarydiversityindex.Validandcomparableindicatorsareneededinordertoassesstheimpactofagriculturalinterventionsonnutritionaloutcomesacrossstudies.

3. Datalackingonparticipantratesandcharacteristics.Thereviewalsocitedthelackofdataonparticipationratesorcharacteristicsofparticipantsintheagriculturalinterventionsasaweakness.Agriculturalinterventionsareoftentargetedatspecificpopulationgroupsorattractindividualswithspecificcharacteristics—typically,thepoorortheverypoorparticipateintheseprograms,orthosewithaccesstolandandperhapswater.Becausethesegroupshavebaselineorpre‐interventioncharacteristics,includingnutritionalstatus,whichdifferfromthoseinthegeneralpopulation,theycannotbecomparedtothegeneralpopulation.Thelackofdataonparticipationratesandcharacteristicsofparticipantscompromisesourabilityto(1)assesstheimpactofinterventionsonspecificvulnerablegroups;(2)assessthetargetingefficiencyofinterventions;(3)understandwhodoesandwhodoesnotparticipate

Page 21: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

21

intheintervention,and(4)whethertheinterventionimpactdependsonorismodifiedbythecharacteristicsoftheparticipants.Studiesshouldmakeanefforttocollectdataonbothparticipantsandnon‐participantsintheinterventionandcomparisongroupstoassessselectionandparticipantbiasandtoinvestigatethedeterminantsofparticipationandtheimpactoftheinterventionacrossvulnerablegroups.

4. Studieswereunderpowered.Anothermethodologicalweaknessidentifiedbythereviewwasthelackofpower—inastatisticalsense—todetectanutritionalimpactifoneexisted.Statisticalpowerislargelydeterminedbysamplesizeandthesizeoftheimpactonehopestodetect.Amongthestudiesreviewed,theaveragepowertodetectsmall(i.e.2%),medium(i.e.10%)andlarge(i.e.30%)differencesinstuntingprevalencewasonly4%,15%and51%,respectively.Therefore,futurestudiesshouldbedesignedtobesufficientlypoweredtodetectnutritionalimpactofagriculturalinterventions.

Awayforward? Fillinformationgaps.ForNepalandothercountriestodesignthemosteffective

policiesandprograms,moreneedstobelearnedabouthowmuchandwhatarethetypesormixesofagriculturalinterventionsarebestfornutritionandhealth.Forexample,shouldNepalinvestinstaplecrops,high‐valuecropsorlivestock?Whattypesofagriculturalinterventionswillimprovetheconsumptionofadiverseandadequatediet,especiallyamongvulnerablegroups?Whatconditionalfactors,suchaslandownership,caste,education,women’sstatus,marketstructures,andruralinfrastructure,dothemosttoleverageagriculturalgrowthforbetternutritionandhealthofwomenandchildren?Thereisanurgentneedtofillthisgapinknowledge.

Prioritizeresearchablequestions.Fillingeverygapinknowledgeimmediatelyisnot

possible;thusthereisaneedtoprioritizeresearchablequestionsthatwillhavethegreatestpotentialtoinformpoliciesandprograms,especiallyinthehillandmountaindistrictswherechildundernutritionratesarethehighest.

Createanenablingenvironmentfor“integrated”cross‐disciplinaryresearch.Modelsfor

successfulresearchthatbridgesinglesectorperspectivesareneeded.Researchersacrosssectorsneedtobecomeconversantineachother’s’professionallanguage,andincentivesmaybeneededtofostercross‐sectoralresearch.

Identifyandorcreatemetricsthatbridgetheag‐nutpathway.Thereisaneedto

identify,createandusevalidmeasuresthathaveutilityacrossthedomainsandsectorsalongtheagriculture‐to‐nutritioncontinuum.Forexample,inpublichealththeoutcomesweareconcernedwitharenutritionalstatus,morbidity,mortalityandincreasinglychilddevelopment.Importantagriculturaloutcomesincludeproductivity,agriculturalgrowth,incomeandreturnsoninvestments.Aretherewaystobridgethesetwoparadigms,and

Page 22: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

22

Identifyasetofindicatorsthatarebothvalidandfeasibletocollectunderfieldconditions?

Disseminateresultsandlessonslearnedacrossdisciplinessothatinnovativeapproaches

canbetakentoscaleinappropriatecontexts.Waystodisseminateresultsquicklyandbroadlyacrossdisciplinesandsectorsareneeded.Mechanismsneedtobecreatedtodothis.Publichealthnutritionsymposiararelyattractagriculturalistsoreconomistsandviceversa.Newplatformsandforumsforinformationandideaexchangeandcollaborationareneeded.

Embracefailureandsuccessandlearnfromthem.Finally,ascross‐disciplinaryresearchthataimstoilluminatethepathwaysbywhichagricultureimpactsonnutritionaloutcomesisconducted,thereisaneedtoembracebothfailureandsuccess.Programsuccessesandfailuresneedapost‐mortumtounderstandwhy,amongwhomandinwhatconditionstheinterventionssucceededorfailed(Figure7).Ifthechoiceofagriculturalinterventionsaddressesthemajorcausesofinadequatedietaryintakeandiftheyareimplementedwell,onewouldexpecttoseeimprovementsinnutritionalstatus.Ifthedesiredoutcomesarenotachieved,thebasisforinterventionchoicesaswellastheadequacyofprogramimplementationmustbereviewed.Wastheimplementationchoicecorrect?Wasimplementationadequateintermsofcoverage,qualityandreachingthoseatgreatestrisk?Werethestudydesignsusedtomeasureprogramimplementationandoutcomesadequate?Didtheinterventionchoicestrulyaddressanimportantunderlyingdeterminantofmaternaland/orchildundernutrition.Adequateandrobuststudydesignsandimplementationareneededtoassessif,andwhatkindsof,investmentsinagriculture‐andfood‐basedstrategieseffectivelyachievesignificantandacceleratedreductionsinmaternalandchildundernutritionatscale,overandabovenutritionandhealthinterventions.

FIGURE7

Page 23: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

23

SESSION1

AGRICULTURETOMARKETS

Session1focusedonresearchthatexploredthelinkbetween‘agriculturetomarket’andfactorsthatinfluencedagriculturalproductionandmarketavailability.Althoughagricultural(food)productionisconsideredadirectpathwayforhouseholdconsumption,thereexistseveralkeyintermediatepathwaysorfactorsthatimpactnutritionaloutcomesatthehouseholdlevel.Oneintermediatepathwayisthroughincreasedfoodproduction,whichmayincreasehouseholdincomethroughthesaleoffoodproducedorwagesfromfarmlabor.FindingsaddressingthisintermediatepathwaypresentedinSession1were:

increasedhomesteadandoff‐seasonfoodproductionandtheuseofimprovedtechnologyincreasedfoodavailabilityandhouseholdfoodconsumption

healthandnutritiontrainingwhenlinkedwithagricultureresultsincreasedhouseholdnutritionintermsofcalorieandproteinintakeandchangeinhealthbehavior

improvednutritionaloutcomesthroughagriculturearepossiblewheninterventionsfrommultiplesectorsareintegratedsuchasacoordinatedapproachofnutritionawarenessandbehaviorchangetrainingwithagriculturalproductionand/orincomegenerationactivities

researchthatmeasurestheeffectsofeachtheseinterventionsaloneversusincombinationonnutritionoutcomesoverasignificantperiodoftimeislimited

Dr.Gauchan,fromtheNepalAgriculturalResearchCouncil(NARC),presentedanoverviewofNepal’sagro‐economyandinsightsontheroleofagricultureinfoodsecurityandnutritioninNepalinhissession‐specifickeynotetalk.HestatedthatNepal’sruralagrarianeconomymakesagriculturethemainsourceofincomeandemploymentandthusisaprimarycontributortothelivelihoodofNepalipeople.Itisakeydriveroffoodconsumptionpatternsinbothruralandurbanareaandanessentialfactorforfoodsecurity

andnutritionbyvirtueofbeingbothasourceoffoodandincome.Agriculturalproductionalsoinfluencesthefluctuationsinfoodpriceswhichinfluenceshouseholdfoodsecurity.Intheory,increasedfoodproductionmayincreasemarketsupplyand,inturn,increasehomeconsumption.Butinpractice,significantamountsoffoodand/orthenutrientvalueofthosefoodsaredisplacedbythetimeitis

FIGURE8

Page 24: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

24

availableforindividualconsumption.Therefore,despitethelinkagesbetweenfoodproductionandfoodavailability,gapsinthispathwayexist.AgriculturalproductivityinNepalislowerthanthecountry’spotentialproductivityasindicatedbyareportonpulseproductionpresentedbyMr.Neupane.Thereportstatesthatthenationalaverageofpulseproductionislessthanhalfofpulseproductionpotential.AmajorreasonforfoodinsecurityinNepalisthelimitedinvestmentinagricultureandagriculturalresearch.Also,smalllandplotsandtheuseofnon‐commercializedfarmingmethods,especiallyamongstpoorerfarmers,contributetolowfoodproduction.

Householdsoftenselltheirproduceinsteadofconsumingitforincome;however,amajorportionoffarmers’incomesareultimatelyspentonfoodpurchases.Otherconstraintsofoptimalproductionispooraccesstoimprovedseedsandalackoffarmers’knowledgeonutilizationofimprovedtechnologies,limitedlandareawithminimaloutput,cropdiseases,pests,poorpostharvestsaswellaslimitedmarketoptions.Duetothegeographicaldiversityin

Nepal,seasonalityisanimportantfactorinfluencingfoodavailabilityandmarketprices.Duringleanmonths(i.e.MaytoSeptember)poorhouseholdsaremostvulnerableandsufferfromhigherratesofundernutrition.Climatechanges(rainfallvariability,temperatureandincreaseincidenceofdiseasesandpests)furtherdriveupratesofundernutritionamongvulnerablegroupsinthistimeswindow.Interventionssuchashomesteadfoodproduction,thepromotionanduseofimprovedtechnology,commercialfarmingandinfrastructuredevelopment(allofwhichwerediscussedduringSession1)havebeenshowntostabilizemarketvariabilityandprice.Dr.Gauchanrecommendedstrengtheningeffortstoensureyear‐roundavailabilityofnutrientrichfoods,andtheneedforexpandingtheuseoftechnologiessuchasoff‐seasonfoodproductionofvegetables,breedingnutrientrichcropvarieties,fortificationduringfoodprocessing,technologyfordetectingfoodcontaminants,improvingtheshelflifeofprocessedfoodproducts,technologyforreducingdrudgeryandpost‐harvesthandlinglosses.However,heacknowledgedthelackofdatadefinitivelylinkingtheseapproachestoimprovementsinagricultureproductionandfoodavailabilityatthehouseholdlevels.RamKrishnaNeupane,fromFORWARDNepal,reportedonastudyshowingthatlegumeproductionandhouseholdlegumeconsumptioncanbeincreasedusinginterventionsthatcombinewiltresistant/tolerantvarietiesoflegumes,croprotation,seeddressingwithfungicidealongwithcapacitybuildingoflegumegrowers(throughtraining,regularvisits,workshopsandawarenessraising).Hesuggestedthataccesstoimprovedseedsandknowledgeatthelocallevelisimportanttocontributetoincreasedproductivity.Although

Page 25: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

25

hisresearchfindingsshowedanincreaseinpulseconsumption,theoverallimpactontotalhouseholddietornutritionalstatusofhouseholdmemberswasnotmeasured.Henotedthatmostoftheincomegeneratedbyincreasedpulseproductionwasspentonimprovingsoilqualityandthehousehold’spersonalhealthexpenses.Healsospeculatedthatnutritionalstatusmightbeimprovediftheincreasedpulseconsumptionaddedtotheoveralldietofhouseholdmembersand/orreplacedfoodsoflessernutritionalvalue.

Dr.LukeCovalitopresentedfindingsfromtheSmallholderIrrigationMarketInitiative(SIMI).Henotedthatthisprojectincreasedsmalllandholderincomes,healthandnutritionthroughtrainingandthecreationofvalue‐chains.KeyfeaturesofSIMIincludedaccesstomicroirrigation,improvedtechnologies,multiple‐usepipedwatersystems,andthedevelopmentofsmallholdercommercialpockets.TheuseoftrainingmethodologycalledtheParticipatoryLearningApproach(PLA),whichincludesliteracyembeddedwithhealthnutritiontraining,wasconsideredespeciallyimportantinimprovingparticipants’healthandnutrition.Theprojectreportedthat15%ofvegetablesproducedbyhouseholdswereconsumedbythehouseholdmembers,althoughfurtherresearchiswarrantedtoestablishifandtowhatextentminimumnutrientrequirementsaremetgivensuchconsumptionlevels.Dr.Covalitonotedthecostbenefitsofcombiningagriculture,healthandnutritiontraining,andrecommendedfurtherresearchtobetterunderstandhowbehaviorchangesduetoincomegenerationimpactonfoodandnutrition.Henotedthattargetinginterventionstoclustersofthepooresthouseholdsislikelytoachievebetterresults.

JoeSandersfromUSAID’sNepalFloodRecoveryProgramexplainedthatintegratedinterventionsacrosssectorslikecommercialagriculture,nutrition,andinfrastructurecanhaveanimpactonfoodsecurityofruralpeople.Inhispresentation,hestatedthatwithoutunderstandingtargetedfarmers’economicsituations,landholdingsize,andpotentialasproducers,foodsecurityprogrammaticinterventionsmaynotbeveryeffective.Inadditiontotraditionalfarmingpractices,aside‐by‐sideinvestmentinimprovedtechnologies,inputsandagronomicpracticesarerequiredtoincreaseoutput,farmers’capitalbaseandlongertermsustainabilityofsuchoutcomes,statedSanders.Suchinvestmentswouldalsoaffectlocalvaluechains,andtheincorporationofnutritioneducationandbehaviorchangetrainingcouldhaveimpactsonhouseholdfoodsecurityoverall.Henotedthatmajorityoffoodinsecurehouseholdsaresmalllandholdersso,thesewouldbeappropriatetargetgroups.TheimpactofcommercialfarmingonhouseholdfoodsecurityisnotwellstudiedinNepal.

DuringSession1,ingeneral,barrierstolinkagriculturetomarketwereidentifiedandsuggestionsweremade.Poorroadconnectivityandinfrastructure,inefficientsmall‐scale

Page 26: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

26

andscatteredproduction,lackofmarketinformation,highpost‐harvestlossesaremanyofthebarriersthatexistbetweenfoodproductionandavailability.Validtestingisrequiredtoidentifywhetherthosebarriersspecificallylieinthepathwaycontributingtopoornutritionaloutcomes.Itwasreportedthattargetedinvestmentsinproductiveinfrastructureshouldbemadeinordertoachievesubstantialimprovementsinagriculturalproductionandcommercialization.

Potentialactorsinthepathwayofagriculturetomarketsuchasretailers,localtraders,agro‐processors,exportersandothersshouldbecarefullyexaminedfortheircontributiontofarmers’economy,foodavailabilityandfoodmarketstability.ItisstillnotclearwhetherNepal’scurrentagriculturalpoliciessupportsthesustainabilityofapproachestoimproveproductionandwhethertheyfacilitatefarmer‐marketlinkages.Internationaltradeandliberalizationoffoodmarketsaswellasexpansionoffoodretail,foodprocessingandmarketingindustriesarebelievedtohelplinkagriculturetomarket,therefore,shouldbeconsiderationswhiledesigningstudies.

Therearestillmanyknowledgegapsinourunderstandingofhowtoreshapeagriculturetoimprovenutritionaloutcomes.Therearenotvalidreportstodescribehowincomefromagricultureproductionisbeingspentandhowandtowhatextentthisimpactshouseholdconsumptionofnutritiousfoods.Relationshipsbetweenincreasedproductionandincreasedmarketavailabilityandimprovedhouseholdfoodsecurityandnutritionneedtobevalidated.

TimewasallocatedforquestionsandanswersbetweentheaudienceandpresentersfollowingSession1.Theaudiencechallengedthepanelaskingwhetherincreasedproductionandconsumptionoflegumespotentiallydisplacesconsumptionofotherstaplefoodsandwhattrulywasthecosteffectivenessoflinkingagriculturetonutrition.GivenNepal’slimitedresources,thepanelurgedtothinkofhowtobestapplylimitedresourcesforoptimalreturns.Studiesneedtofocusonthecomparisonbetweengrowtoeatversusgrowtomarkettoseewhichoneismorecontributorytoimprovedfoodproductionand

Page 27: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

27

nutritionalhealth.Itisalsoimportanttoidentifydemandversussupplypatternsaswellaswhatisactuallyconsumptionversusmarketavailability.Intermsofnutrition,farmerstendtosellproducenotconsumewhattheygrowwhichneedstobeexploredinastandarddesignforitsimpactonnutrition.

Itwassuggestedduringthediscussiontoexplorewhethernutritioneducationtomothersbestassociatedwithchangesinbehavioractuallyhaveanimpactonnutritionoutcomes.Postharvestnutrientlossesareanotherareathattheaudienceprobed.AttheendofSession1,thespeakersandaudiencesexpressedtheirthoughtsoncropprotectionfrominsects,postharvestfoodpreservation,anti‐nutrientfactors,developmentofruralmarketstoimprovefoodsecurityandnutrition,astrategyofmulti‐sectoralandinter‐disciplinaryinterventioncombiningagriculture,nutritionandhealth,andtheneedformoreinclusiveagriculturalgrowthtargetedwithnutritioninterventionsthatempowerofwomenandtargetdisadvantagedgroups.

SESSION2

LINKINGFOODMARKETSAND/ORHOMEPRODUCTIONTOHOUSEHOLDACCESS

ThemainfocusofSession2washouseholds’accesstofoodsthroughmarketavailabilityorhomefoodproductionandapproachestoimprovelinkagesbetweenagricultureandnutritionthroughmarketdynamics.Theruralpoor’saccesstofoodsrichinessentialmicronutrientssuchasfruitsandvegetables,meat,fish,dairyproducts,andbio‐fortifiedstaplefoodsisrestrictedbecauseoflimitedavailability,economicconstraints,lackofknowledgeandinformation,andarelatedlackofdemandfornutritiousfoods.

Agriculturalproductionmayhelpat‐riskgroupsgeneratemoreincomeandhelpmakenutritiousfoodsmoreavailable,affordable,acceptable,andofhigherquality.Onitswayfromfarmtomouth,foodundergoesstorage,distribution,processingandpreparationprocessesthataffecttheavailability,affordability,acceptability,andnutritionalqualityofthesefoodstotheconsumer.Itiscriticaltoanalyzewhathappensbetweenproductionandconsumptionthataffecteconomicandnutritionalvalueofthefoodproduct.

Session2startedwithakeynotespeechfromDr.MarieRuel,whopresentedmaterialontheconceptofanutrition‐sensitivevalue‐chaintoimproveaccesstonutritiousfoodsinruralmarkets.Thistypeofvaluechainisbelievedtohavethepotentialtoimpactnutrition,buttheconceptisinitspreliminarystageandisnotyetwidelyused.Dr.Ruelnotedthatmicronutrientdeficiencyisaglobalproblemandthepoorareoftenthemostvulnerabletothesedeficienciesbecausetheylackaccesstodiverse,nutrient‐richfoods.Dr.Ruel,basedonworkdoneinAfricaandHonduras,statedthatusingtheconceptofa“nutritionsensitivevaluechain”canprovidecluesforstrengtheningagriculture‐nutritionlinkagesandmaximizingthepotentialforaddednutritionalvaluealongthefoodchain,bymaximizing,conserving,oraddingnutrientsatkeypoints.Identifyingwherethenutritiveandeconomic

Page 28: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

28

valuescanbecreatedinthesupplyside,valuechainfornutritionapproachcanbeusedtoincreasetheavailability,affordability,andqualityofnutritiousfoods.Itcouldenhancetheperception,supplyanddemandofnutritiousfoodstothepoorandcreatetheeconomicbenefitstoat‐riskproducers(seeFigure9).Inadditiontoimprovingnutrition,thisconceptprovidessolutionstodevelopmentchallengesinothersectorssuchasinagricultureaswellastheconceptcanbeusedtoidentifytheproblemsandtodesignandimplementsolutionstoincreasetheavailability,affordability,andqualityofnutritiousfoods.

Inputs into production

Food production

Food storage, processing

Food distribution, transport

Food retail and labeling

MORE NUTRITIOUS/SAFER FOODS AVAILABLE/AFFORDABLE

Examples of actions that can be used to make value chains nutrition sensitive 

Increased intake of nutritious/safer foods among the poor

Activities on the supply side

Test, evaluate, adopt  solutions to enhance nutrient content & safety along the value chain Activities on the 

demand side

Characterize diets, markets & constraints to access to nutritious/safe   foods

Develop, test, evaluate new tools to improve knowledge, awareness, and demand for nutritiouand safe foods 

Identify bottlenecks and processes where nutrients are lost & opportunities to restore or increase them

FIGURE9

Anexampleofusingapplyinga“nutritionsensitivevaluechain”approachistheadditionofmicronutrientrichproductstotortillaproductioninHonduras.Carrots,sweetpotatoes,spinachandothermicronutrientrichfoodshavebeenaddedtotheproductionprocessandhaveaddedcolorandimprovedmicronutrientcontenttotortillaswhichhaveresultedinanincreaseddemandforandconsumptionofmorenutritioustortillasamongchildrenandpregnantmothers.Astheconceptofvaluechainfornutritionisinitspreliminaryphase,a

lotmoreworkneedstobedonetodetermineitsfeasibilityandpracticalityinthecontextofpovertystrickencountrylikeNepalasincreaseinnutritionvaluemayaccompanyincreaseinprice.

FIGURE10

Page 29: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

29

Nepalissociallyandculturallydiversecountryandadefinitiveassociationexistsbetweensocioeconomicstatusandhouseholdaccesstofood.Differentwealthgroupshavedifferentfoodconsumptionpatternsanditisimportanttoanalyzefoodsecurityandlivelihoodsituationamongthesegroups.Sincewomenarepredominantlyin‐chargeofhouseholdfoodpreparationsanddistribution,targetedinterventionstowomen’sgroupscouldimpacthouseholdbehavioralchangesassociatedwithnutritionoutcomes.Dr.NaomiSavilleusedthe

HouseholdEconomyApproach(HEA)tostudyfoodsecurityandlivelihoodsituationofdifferentwealthgroupsinTerai.Interviewsandmarketsurveyscompletedinthisstudyindicatedthathouseholdexpenditureincreaseswithwealthgroups,andthepoorspendsmoreinfoodandlessinagricultureinputsandeducation.Staplecropproductioncontributesmoretowardsthesourceoffoodconsumptiontothehigherwealthgroups(Figure10,Figure11).Thepoordependonlaborexchangetofulfilltheircalorierequirement.Thusthepooraremorelikelytoworktoaffordfoodandtheirlackofagriculturaloutiseitherduetothelackofknowledgeorresourcesleadingtolimitedfoodproductionandfoodsecurity.

Inadditiontosocialandculturaldiversity,diverseecologicalvariabilityinNepalaffectsfoodproduction,availabilityandconsumptionpatternsamongvariouspopulationgroupsinvariousregions.Thiscausesmorevariabilityinfoodsecurityandmakesfoodsecuritymonitoringcomplexandchallenging.MarikoKawabatafromtheWorldFoodProgrammeillustratedtwodifferentdatacollectionmethodstoassessfoodsecuritymonitoringinNepalinordertoprovidereliableandtimelyinformationforappropriateactiontopreventhumansufferingfromfoodinsecurity.Datacollection(especiallyinformationobtainedseasonallyatthevillagelevel)usingthephaseclassificationapproach(developedbasedontheprinciplesofglobalIntegratedFoodSecurityPhaseClassification(IPC)methodologypioneeredbyFAOinSomalia)bytheDistrictFoodSecurityNetworks(DFSNs)wascomparedandvalidatedagainstcrosscountryhouseholdsurveysdesignedtomonitorfoodsecurityby

FIGURE11

Page 30: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

30

ecologicalbeltorsub‐regionbyseasonandyear.KeyfoodsecurityindicatorsfromthehouseholddataconfirmedthedegreeoffoodinsecurityreportedbytheDFSNsprovidingvalidtoolsforfoodsecuritymonitoring.

BPShresthafromMotherandInfantResearchActivities(MIRA)ontheotherhandapplieddifferentfoodinsecuritymeasurementtoolsinhisstudy,namelytheHouseholdDietaryDiversityScore(HDDS),MonthsofAdequateHouseholdFoodProvisioning(MAHFP)andHouseholdFoodInsecurityAccessScale(HFIAS).ThesetoolsindicatedthatpoorandDalit(definedaslowercaste)sufferedthemostfromfoodinsecurity.Thisstudydemonstratedthatincomegenerationeitherbyagricultureorothermeansimprovesfoodsecurity.

CommunitydevelopmentprogramslikeActionAgainstMalnutritionThroughAgriculture(AAMA)haveshownpositiveresultsintermsofincomegeneration,micronutrientrichfoodavailabilityandknowledgeofhealthandnutritionthathaveimprovedmother’sandyoungchildren’snutritionalstatus.EssentialNutritionActions(breastfeeding,complementaryfeeding,maternalnutrition,nutritionforsickchild,micronutrientdeficiencies),homesteadfoodproduction(VillageModelFarms,homegardensandpoultry),behaviorchangecommunication(counselingandnegotiationsskill,IEC(flipchart,counselingcard,posteretc.)aresomeofthestrategiesthatAAMAimplementedintheFarWesternregionsofthecountry.DebendraAdhikarireportedthatthesestrategieshaveimprovedhomefoodproductionandincreasedknowledgeofappropriateinfantfeedingrequirementsleadingtoimprovedinfantfeedingpractices.

Povertyappearstobeakeydeterminantofhouseholdfoodaccess.Uponincomegeneration,peopletendtospendmoreonnutritiousfoods.Howeverduringthequestionanswersession,participantsexpressedtheirconcernaboutmaintenanceoffoodqualitythroughoutthesupplychain.Theaudiencenotedthatpeopleprefertoeatwhattheyhavetraditionallybeeneatingandchangingdietaryhabitscanbechallenging.PeopleinNepalseemtobemorereceptivetoeatingmorenutritiousrawfoodpreparationsratherthanprocessedfoods.However,itisimportanttogenerateevidencetodeterminewhichaspectsofbehaviorchangeareeffectiveinimprovingdietaryhabits.Thefarmer’sinstinctistogrowtosell.Noorlimitedlandholdingsofthepoorisanissueforthecreationofhomegardens.Themostfoodinsecurehouseholdsareoftenthosewithnoorlittlelandorotherresourcesrequiredforagriculturalproduction;thus,promotingonlyagriculturalinterventionsisnotadequate.Nonetheless,agricultureisthemainmechanismtoincreaseincomeastherearenootherjobopportunitiesintheruralareas.

Page 31: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

31

SESSION3

HOUSEHOLDAVAILABILITY,ACCESSANDUSETODIETARYINTAKEANDNUTRITIONANDHEALTHOUTCOMESOFWOMENANDYOUNGCHILDREN

Theimportantpartoftheagriculture‐to‐nutritionpathwayistoexplorehowdownstreamprocesses,suchasagriculturalproduction,marketaccessandaffordability,andhouseholdfoodavailability,influencedietaryintakeandnutritionandhealthoutcomesinwomenandyoungchildren.Understandingthefoodsupplysystem—fromproductiontoconsumption—enablesonetoexplorethepointsinthesystemthatinfluencetheamount,quality,safety,availability,affordabilityandaccessibilityoffoods,andultimately,thenutritionalhealthofaspecifictargetgroup.Ofcourse,afoodsystemoperateswithinacontextofcultural,socioeconomicandotherfactorsthatalsoinfluencehealthandnutrition.Thesefactorscanpositivelyornegativelyinteractwiththefoodsystemtoinfluencethepopulation’snutritionandhealth.Thusunderstandingthecontextinwhichitoperatesisvitalforunderstandingwhatelementsofthefoodsystemshouldbereshapedtobetterimprovenutritionalwell‐being.Dr.RKAdhikariinhiskeynotespeechhighlightedthedoubleburdenofthenutritionalproblemsinNepalreflectedbyindicatorsofundernutrition(i.e.lowbirthweight,stunting,underweight,wastingandirondeficiencyanemia)andalsoovernutrition(i.e.overweightandobesity).The2011DHSshowsanimprovementinmaternalnutritionandaslightdeclineintheprevalenceofstuntingandunderweightinchildren,however,wastingratesremainedalmoststaticsince2006.Despiteimprovementsinseveralmaternalandchildnutritionstatusindicators,ratesofundernutritionremainalarminglyhighinNepal.Forexample,theprevalenceofanemiainwomenandchildrenisstill35%and46%respectively.Iodinedeficiencyinhighmountainareaspersistsalthoughthehouseholdsusingiodizedsaltinotherpartsofthecountryhavelowlevelsofiodinedeficiency.Breastfeedingisuniversalandbreastfeedingpracticeshaveimprovedsignificantly.ButpoormaternalnutritionstatusandinappropriatecomplementaryfeedingpracticescontinuetocontributetopoorgrowthanddevelopmentinNepalichildren.Moreover,seasonality,workloadofmothers,gastrointestinalinfection,intra‐householdfooddistributionandfoodgiventochildrenalsoinfluencethenutritionalstatusofmothersandchildren.

Asmentionedearlier,dietaryhabitsalsoplayamajorroleofdietaryintakeandriskofundernutrition.Feedingpracticesdifferacrosscommunitiesduetodifferencesinculture,knowledgelevelandsocio‐economicstatus.Over‐dependenceoncerealfoods,withoutnutrient‐densefoods,canleadtohighratesofmicronutrientdeficiencies.Forexample,Dr.PeterAndersonmentionedthatpulseconsumptioncontributeslessthan3%tototalcalorieintakewhilericeconsumptioncontributesmorethan63%.Pulsesareagoodsourceof

Page 32: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

32

micronutrientslikevitaminB2,folate,calcium,potassiumandiron;declinesinpulseconsumptionmaybecontributingtolowintakesoffoodsrichinessentialmineralsandvitamins.Dr.Anderson’spresenteddatashowingadeclineinpulseconsumptioninSouthAsia,andmodeledtheimpactofincreasingpulseconsumptiononimprovingnutrientintake.Themodelsshowedthatadding30gofrice‐beanintaketothedietwouldsubstantiallyincreasefolateintake,aswellaslysine,Ca,K,FeandotherB‐vitamins.Dr.Andersonrecommendedpromotingpulseintake,alongwithfortificationofstaples,toimprovethemicronutrientintakeofthepopulation.

NeenaJoshi,ofHeiferInternational(HI),providedpreliminaryevidenceshowingthatcommunitydevelopmentinterventionscanimprovethelivelihoodofpoorandundernourishedcommunities.HIusesacomprehensiveapproachthatprovideshouseholdswithsmallanimals,mentorsthemtoincreaseincomeandassetownership,trainsthemonsavingandlendingschemes,andprovideshealthandnutritioneducation.PreliminaryresultsfromanHIstudyshowedimprovementsinchildren’sweightinheightintheTeraibutnotinthehills,butthestudydesignanddurationwerenotadequatetoevokecausalattributiontotheprogram.HIis,however,conductingalongtermfollow‐upoftheproject’sbeneficiaries,andwillreportontheirfindingsinthefuture.Dr.KeithWest,fromJohnsHopkinsSchoolofPublicHealth,summarizedanextensivebodyofevidenceonnutritionstatusandinterventionscontributedbytheNepalNutritionInterventionProjectSarlahi(NNIPS),whichhasbeenoperatinginNepalsince1987.NNIPShascompletednumerousrandomizedcontrolledtrials(RCT)toevaluatetheimpactofnutritionalinterventions.Thefirstofthese,NNIPS‐1,showedthatpreschoolvitaminAsupplementationreducedchildmortalityby30%.ThiswasfollowedbyNNIPS‐2,whichshowedthatweeklyvitaminAorβ‐carotenereducedmaternalmortalityby~40%.NNIPS‐3showedthatmaternalironandfolicacidsupplementationimprovedbirth,anemia,andinfantandchildsurvival.NNIPS‐4evaluatedtheeffectsofdailyiron/folicacidand/orzinconmortality.Finally,theNNIPScohortfollow‐upsassessedthelong‐termhealtheffectsofmicronutrientinterventions.Thesestudiesalsoprovideddatashowingthatmultiplemicronutrientdeficienciesco‐existamongwomeninruralNepalandthesupplementationtrialsimprovedhealth,functionandsurvivalamongthemostvulnerablegroupssuchasinfants,childrenandwomen.TheNNIPSstudiesalsorevealedimportanthouseholdbehaviorandeconomicinfluencesondietsandhealthrisksofchildren.Women’semploymentandaccesstocashwasfoundtobeacriticalfactorinraisingeffectivedemandforamorenutritiousdiet.NNIPSstudieshavealsoshownthatearlyinitiationofbreastfeedingreduceinfantmortality,thatdietaryadequacyinchildrendependonwithwhomtheyeatmealsand,thisinturn,canmarkedlyinfluencedietandnutritionalstatus.NNIPSfindingsconfirmedthatprovidinganincomeaccompaniedwithhealthandnutritioneducationcanimprovehouseholdnutrition.TheNNIPSstudieshaveprovidedawealthofevidence‐basedresultsthathaveandcancontinuetoinformnutritionandpublichealthpolicyandprogramdecisionsinNepal.

ThediscussionfollowingSession3presentationsnotedthelackofrandomizedtrialsusingfoodsratherthansupplementstoevaluatefood‐basedinterventionsonnutritional

Page 33: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

33

outcomes.Recommendationsfromthediscussionweretoevaluatetheroleofbio‐fortificationonnutrientintakeandstatus,theeffectsofhouseholdbehaviorchangeonnutrition,andtherisksoftheenvironmentalexposures(suchasaflatoxinandpollution)ongrowthandnutritionalwell‐being.ParticipantsrecommendedfutureresearchinNepalshoulduseonlyvalidateddatacollectionandmeasurementtools,identifyasetofcommonindicatorsthatcouldbeusedinbothagricultureandnutritionalsurveystofacilitatelinkages,enableinter‐sectoral“cross‐talk”andimprovefoodsecuritymonitoring.ProductionofstaplesandinstitutionalizationofthemarketingwasalsosuggestedtobeanapproachtofightfoodinsecurityinNepal.Inaddition,thediscussionhighlightedtheneedforresearchonpost‐harvestprocessestominimizefoodandnutrientlosses,andonfeasiblewaystomeasureindicatorsofhouseholdincomeandconsumption.

SESSION 4

IDENTIFYING,DEFINING,MEASURINGLINKAGESANDEVIDENCEGAPS

Day2ofthesymposiumwasaparticipatorydiscussiontoelicitandprioritizeresearchgaps,identifystudydesignandvariablemeasurementissues,andidentifyresearchcapacitybuildingpriorities.

Priorityresearchdomainsfocusedon:

Improvingthedietaryintake(quality&quantity)ofpoor/malnourishedwomen&children

Nutritionalgoalsinthehome Dietaryfactorsinthehomethatimprovenutritionalconditions Contextualfactorsthatinfluencedietaryadequacy Homefoodproduction,storageandprocessingfactorsthataffectdietaryadequacy Marketfactorsthataffecthomefoodsecurity Agriculturalfactorsthataffectmarketprices,availability,andhouseholdaccess

Page 34: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

34

Thediscussion,ledbyDr.SharadOntaandDr.KeithWest,drewonnationalexpertsincludingNPCMember,AthmaramPandey,Dr.ChetRajUprety,Dr.HariK.Upadhyaya,Dr.IndiraSharma,Dr.KedarP.Baral,Dr.LuciaRusso,Dr.RobinHouston,Dr.ShubhNarayanMahato,JoeSanders,Dr.KirkDeardern,M.R.Maharjan,ShabnamShivakoti,Dr.NaomiSaville,PoojaPandey,SabaMebrathu,SophiyaUprety,Dr.SubarnaKhatry,Dr.Y.B.ThapaandDr.RamChandraBhusal.

Researchgapswereidentifiedundereachresearchdomain.Underthefirstresearcharea,‘improvingdietaryintakeofpoorandmalnourishedwomenandchildren’,discussantsidentifiedtheneedforamorebroadanddistilledunderstandingoftheunderlyingdeterminantsoflineargrowthamonginfantandyoungchildren.Whilematernalnutrition,thequalityandquantityofa

child’sdietandinfectionareknowntoinfluencelineargrowth,interventionsaddressingthesefactorshaveproducedlessthanoptimalchildgrowth,suggestingotherfactorssuchasenvironmentalenteropathiesmightmitigatethegrowthenhancingeffectsofdietonchildgrowth.Non‐Nepalspecificliteraturesupportscorrelationsbetweenstuntingandfactorssuchasmaternaleducation,improvedaccesstohealthcare,maternalhealthandoptimalfeedingbehaviors[5].Butfurtherresearchisneededparticularlyfocusingonmycotoxinandotherenvironmentalexposuresonguthealthandtheirassociationwithchildgrowth.DHS2011datashowsthatstuntingrateshavedecreasedfrom49%to41%,anditisworthexploringthesedatafurthertoidentifypotentialfactorsassociatedwiththisdecline.However,inequalitiespersistacrossagro‐ecologicalzonesinNepal,wherestuntingprevalenceratesamongchildrenresidinginmountainandhillareasare15%to43%higherthanthoselivingintheterai[1].

Therewasagreementthatresearcheffortsshouldfocusonpopulationsinthelowerwealthquintileswhichharborthehighestratesofundernutrition.Therewasalsoagreementabouttheneedtobetterunderstandthedeterminantsofthehighratesofanemiainwomenandchildren,andtherolethatfood‐basedapproachesandfortificationshouldplayinbringingdowntheserates.ResearchconductedinIndiahasshownthatironfortifieddriedmilksignificantlyloweredtheproportionofanemiachildrenrelativetocontrols(19.8%versus50%)among24‐36montholdchildren[6].ResearchisrequiredtodetermineifasimilareffectcanbeachievedinNepalesechildren.Nepal,however,hasfirmevidenceonthebenefitsofmaternaliron‐folicacidsupplementationindecreasingoverall

Page 35: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

35

anemiaprevalenceinwomen,improvingbirthweightsandchildcognitivefunctionandimprovingchildsurvivalthrough7yearsofage[7‐11].ThesefindingshavebeentranslatedintopolicyandnationalprogramsareinplaceinNepal.Nevertheless,despitesignificantreductionsinanemiaamongstwomen,rateshavestagnatedoverthepastyearandprevalenceofanemiaremainsat35%nearlyhalfofchildrenunder5(46%)areanemicdespitedewormingeffortsandscaleupofmicronutrientpowderprogramswarrantingfurtherresearch.

Finally,thedeterminantsofsevereacutemalnutrition(SAM),thecausesofsevereproteinenergymalnutrition(PEM)andmicronutrientdeficienciesamongstthisagegroupwereallidentifiedasareasoffocusthatwarrantedabetterunderstanding.

Anotherpertinentpointofdiscussionunderthisresearchdomainwastheneedforfurtherexaminationoftheinterplaybetweennutritionandinfection(includingenteropathies).Animalandhumanresearchsuggeststhatwhenconfrontedbyincessantmicrobialchallenge,nutrientsmaybechanneledtomobilizeanear‐continuousimmuneresponseattheexpenseofgrowth.Furtherresearchisneededinthisarea.

Inadditiontotheimmediateconsequencesofundernutritionandspecificmicronutrientdeficiencies,moreworkisneededtounderstandthelong‐termeffectsoftheseconditionsoncognition,schooloutcomesandadulthealth.Finally,investigatingintergenerationaleffectsofpoormaternalnutritionisanimportantresearchpriority,especiallyasitrelatestobirthsize,andsubsequentinfantandchildmalnutrition.

Underthe‘nutritionalgoalsinthehome’researchdomain,apriorityresearchareaishowcommunitiesunderstandandapply(ornot)nutritioninformationandmessagingatthehouseholdlevel.Suchresearchrequiresstudyingthecomponentsofbehaviorchangecommunication,andhoweacheffectsfoodpurchasingdecisionsanddietarybehavior.Anotherimportantresearchgapisidentifyinghowtoovercomehouseholdinformationgapsinnutritionacrossdifferentsocio‐economic,gender,ethnicityandcastegroups.Similarresearchgapsonhygienebehaviormessagingalsorequireattention.

Discussionsonthethirdresearcharea‐‐‘Dietaryfactorsinthehomethatimprovenutritionalconditions’‐‐identifiedtheneedforimprovingourunderstandingofdeterminantsofintra‐householdfoodallocationanditsrelationshipwithdietaryintake.Studiespublishedmorethan10yearsagoprovideevidencethateatingfromasharedplate,andwhoachildsharesfoodwith,caninfluencetheamountandqualityoffoodayoungchildconsumes.Inaddition,muchremainstobelearnedabouthowcommonlyusedcookingandfoodpreparationmethodsinfluencethenutrientcontentofcookedfood.Bothoftheseareaswarrantmoreresearch[12,13].

Page 36: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

36

Theimportanceofunderstandingthegendergapanddiscriminatorypracticesthatexistatthehouseholdandcommunitylevelthatultimatelyhavebearingonnutritionoutcomeswashighlightedunderthe‘contextualfactorsthatinfluencedietaryadequacy’researchdomain.Tounpackthisrelationship,questionssuchas“howdoesincomegenerationamongstwomeninfluencedietaryadequacy,purchasingpatterns?”wereposedaspotentialareasforfurtherresearch.Othermarginalizedgroupssuchasindigenouspeopleswereidentifiedaspopulationswhosedietaryintakeanddietarypatternsneededtobestudied.GroupssuchastheMadheshisandDalits,especiallythoseinthemountainsandhighhills,havenotbeenstudiedatgreatlengthandperhapslessonscanbelearnedfromthesegroupswithregardtospecial,nutritious,indigenousfoodsandfoodpreparationmethodsused.Theroleofalleviatingpovertyinimprovingnutritionwasalsorecognizedasabroadareaofresearchthatwouldinformtheagriculturetonutritionpathwayasoneoftheprimaryaimsofagriculturalinvestmentsandinterventionsistoimproveeconomicreturnsfromagriculturalproduction.Agrowingareawithinprogrammaticworkistheinvestmentinprogramsthatprovidehomeandkitchengardeninterventionstocontributetomeetingthehouseholds’dailydietary(anddietarydiversity)needs.Theseinterventionsoftentargetwomenandprovideeducationongardeningtechniquesandoccasionallyprovideseedstopromotehomeproductionoffoods.Thisemergingprogrammaticfocuswithanaimtoimprovenutritionstatusestablishedthenextresearchdomain:‘homefoodproduction,storageandprocessingfactorsthataffectdietaryadequacy’.Animportantpointofdiscussionwithinthisdomainwastheneedtodeterminemicronutrientcontentoflocallyavailablecrops,vegetablesandfruitsgrownathome.Commonlypromotedfoodsforhomeandkitchengardensincludegreenleafyvegetableslikespinachandorangefleshvegetables.Poultry‐raisingforeggsaswellasgoat‐raising,assourcesofanimalprotein,arealsofrequentlypromotedpractices.Whileevidencesupportsimprovedintakeofmicronutrientrichfoodsanddietarydiversityofparticipantsinhomefoodproductionprograms,rigorousevaluationsthatstudyimpactofsuchprogramsonnutritionstatusinwomenandchildrenisstilllacking[14].Soilqualityofthesehomegardenswasalsodeterminedtobearesearchtopicofinterest.Soilqualitycanaffectbothsoilproductivityandnutrientcontentandnutrientbioavailabilityofcrops.Ithasbeenshownthatinsubsistencefarmingwheresoilqualityislow,thecontentofproteinandanti‐nutrientsislowerthaninmediumtohighproductivitysoil.[15,16]

Page 37: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

37

Marketdynamicsandtheireffectsonaccessofhouseholdtofoodcontinuetobeanimportantlinkacrosstheagriculturetonutritionpathway.Discussionsonthedomain,‘marketfactorsthataffecthomefoodsecurity’,capturedopportunitiesforfurtherstudyincludingtopicssuchashowtoengagetheprivatesectortocontributetochangesinhouseholdconsumptionanddietarypractices,determinantsoffoodpurchaseandconsumption,documentingincentivesforagriculturalproductionofindigenousfoodcropandwhetherthisprovidesadequatemotivationoffarmerstoproducethesecrops,householdpurchasingpowerandpatterns,thecost‐effectivenessofgrowingandmarketingcertainnutritiouscropsandlastlymarketdemandforhighvaluecrops.

Finally,thesymposiumparticipantsdiscussedtheresearchdomain:“agriculturalfactorsthataffectmarketprices,availability,andhouseholdaccess”.Knowledgegapsidentifiedincludedtheroleoflivestockandfisheryversustypicalagriculturalinterventionsinpotentiallyimprovingnutritionwithinhouseholds,whatmarketoutletsexistandperfusionofagriculturalproduceinmarkets.Additionalgapsincludedtheneedtoexplorehowtoimproveproductionofstaplecropsacrossecologicalzones,howthere‐designofsomeagriculturaltoolshaveimpactedtimeconstraintsandworkloadoffarmers,howtoimproveproductionofspecializedcropsacrossecozones,whethertechnologiesandcertainseedvarietiescanbeusedacrossecologicalzonesandifso,whethertheseagriculturalapproachescanbescaledup.Acrucialcontributortoimprovedandsustainedagriculturalproductioniswater.Issuessurroundingsustainedwatermanagementapproachestosupportagriculturalproductionandpracticeswerediscussedandidentifiedasareasforfurtherresearch.Giventhesymposium’sfocusonultimatelyimprovingnutritionstatusofwomenandchildren,theroleofmedicinalherbsandoilwerediscussedaspotentialalternativecropinterventionsthatcouldpotentiallycontributeordetractfromdietquality.Theroleofbio‐fortificationofcropswasraised–itspotentialandfeasibilityinNepalanditsefficacyforimprovingnutritionstatus.Beyondagriculturalproduction,issuesfocusedonhomesteadpostharvestfoodlossandfoodpreservationmethodstomaintainnutrientintegrityoffoods.Theseareasrequirefurtherstudy.Auniquetopicthatemergedoutofthisdiscussionwasthepossibilityofdefining,creatingandmeasuringthenutritionaleffectsofa“nutritionfriendly”farmingsystem.TheuseofappropriateresearchdesignsandmethodssurfacedasanoverarchingdiscussionareathroughoutDay2.Acallwasmadefortheuseofmixmethodstostudytheagriculture‐to‐nutritionpathwayandtoquantifylongtermgains(orlosses)ofagricultural

investmentstoaccelerateimprovednutritionoutcomes.Severalparticipantsurgedresearcherstofocusonprogramandimplementationresearch–the“how”ofprogramsandthealsothetrueimpactofprograms.Howareprogramseffectiveinimprovingnutrition?Howisresearchtranslatedintoeffective

Page 38: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

38

programming?Leroyetal.states“themainconstraintslimitingtheeffectivenessoftheseprogramsincludeproblemsofdesignandintegrationoftheirdifferentcomponents(especiallyoftheirnutritionpackage);thelackofconceptualization,frameworkofanalysis,anddocumentationoftheirpathwaysofimpact;thelackofmeasurementandunderstandingoffacilitatingfactorsandconstraintstoimplementationandsuccess;andtheiroftenweakmonitoringandevaluationdesigns”[4].Theuseofquantitativemethodstoaccuratelymeasureresults,aswellasqualitativemethodstoexplainwhycertainbehaviorchangecommunicationmethodsworkorwhyhouseholdsconsumemoreofacertaincrop,forexamplewerestronglyencouraged.Moreover,deconstructingwhatnutritionspecificornutritionsensitiveinterventionswasbroughtupasanimportantconsiderationgiventhehighuseofsuchterminologyindevelopmentcircles. Takingthisdiscussiononestepfurther,questionsthathadpolicylevelimplicationswereraised.Whataretheproblemsintranslationandimplementationatthepolicylevel?Gapanalysesconductedontheidentificationoftheknowledgeofpolicymakersthemselvesontheagriculture‐nutritionpathwaywasputforthasawaytofacilitatetranslationofresearch.Thislackofinformationwasexpressedbythesymposiumattendeesasnotspecifictopolicymakersalonebutalsoagapthatexistedforsmallholderfarmersandmechanismsforeffectivecommunicationoftechnologicaladvanceswithinagriculture,marketdynamicandnutritionresearchitselfwassuggested.Concernswereraisedaboutlimitedgovernmentsupporttoresearch.Oneparticipantpointedoutthatcurrentlyonly3%ofthecountry’sGDPgoestoagriculturethusitmaynotberealistictothinkthatmuchresearchcanbeproducedwithsuchabudget.However,representativesfromtheNationalPlanningCommission(NPC)statedtheyhaveindeedbeguntoprioritizeresearchthatinformsthispathwaythroughtheireffortsinconsideringatechnicalassistancegrouptoreviewresearchthatwouldcontributetotheimplementationofthemulti‐sectoralnutritionplan.Governmentrepresentativesrequestedresearcherstosimplifyresearchfindingsandinturn,researcherscalledforaforumwheretheycouldinteractwithgovernmentrepresentativestoshareNepalspecificand/orNepalrelevantresearch.Tothisend,asuggestionmadewasforsuchaquarterlyorhalf‐yearlymeetingtobeheldbetweenresearchersandtheconcernedpolicymakers.Additionally,itwassuggestedthatlocalresearchbepublishedininternationalbutespeciallyNepalijournalstoestablishareliabledatabasetodrawformthatcanhelpinformpolicyandimplementationdecisions.Thecreationofamonitoringandevaluationsystemsatthepolicyleveltooverseeimplementationofmulti‐sectoralpoliciesseekingtoaddressnutritionandresearchfindingsbeingtestedinsmallerpilotstudiespriortogoingtoscalewasalsosuggested.

Page 39: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

39

Ultimately,capacitybuilding–themeasurethroughwhichnationalresearchagendaonthistopiccouldbeachievedwasaddressed.Itwasacknowledgedthatthereareconstraintswithregardstothenumberoftrainednutritionistsand/orresearcherswithstrongmethodologicaltraininginNepal.Atrainedmulti‐disciplinaryteamthathadbeenrecommendedbytheopeningspeakersonDay1ofthesymposiumandbyaudienceonDay2requiresinvestmentbydonorsandGONtoresearchandacademicinstitutions.Audiencemembersstressedtheneedforrigorousresearchdesignsandmethodologiesthatpolicyandprogrammingdecisionsarefirmlybasedonevidenceandnotonspeculationanduntestedassumptions.Therefore,prioritycapacitybuildingareasshouldberesearchmethodologies,surveymethods,datamanagementandanalysis.Itwasalsothoughtthatsuchatrainedworkforcecouldassistinsettingupandmonitoringsurveillancesystems.Anotherareaforcapacitystrengtheningistrainingpolicymakersontheuseofevidenceinpolicyformation,programdesignandtheevaluationofgovernmentprograms.

Page 40: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

40

NEXTSTEPS

TheNutritionCRSP“Agriculture,FoodSecurityandNutritioninNepal‐TakingStockandDefiningPriorities”symposiumco‐hostedbyJohnsHopkinsBloombergSchoolofPublicHealthandtheDepartmentofCommunityMedicineandPublicHealth,IOMwasoneofthefirsteventsofitskindtobringtogethertheresearchcommunityprimarily,aswellasgovernmentofficialsandprogramimplementerstotakestockoftheresearchthatexistsinNepalcurrentlyacrosstheagriculturetonutritionpathway.ThepresentationsandpostersshowcasedduringtheeventwerebynomeansrepresentativeofallresearchconductedinNepalthatwouldinformthispathway.However,basedonthepresentationsprovidedduringDay1,themoreglaringgapthatsurfacedwasthattherewaslittleresearchthatlinkedacrossallthreedomainsandeventheresearchthataddressedmorethanonedomaindidnotalwayscapturestronglinkagesbasedonmethodsusedoroutcomesmeasured(Figure12).

FIGURE12

Page 41: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

41

Basedondiscussionsthattranspiredthroughoutthesymposium,thesymposiumorganizingcommitteeidentifiedthefollowingpriorityactionsasrecommended“nextsteps”fortheNepalresearchcommunity:

Formacross‐disciplinaryworkinggroupcomposedofestablishedresearchersfromeachrelevantsector—agriculture,economics,marketing,foodsecurity,dietaryintake,publichealthandnutrition—toidentifythekeyresearchquestionsthatneedtobeaddressedinthenext3,5and10yearstoinformtheagriculture‐to‐nutritioncausalpathway.Eachsectoralexpertcouldprioritizeresearchinhis/herdomain,butconsensusshouldbeachievedoncross‐disciplinaryresearchandresearchthataddresseslinkagepointsacrosssectors.Securingdonorsupportforboththisinitialprocess,butalsoforfundingtheresearchprioritiesrecommendedbytheworkinggroup,shouldbeprioritized.

Conductefficacy(i.e.underoptimalconditions)andeffectiveness(underreal‐lifeandprogrammaticconditions)researchonpromisingandrelevantinterventions.Inaddition,aresearchagendaforunderstandinginterventiondelivery,reachanduptakeisneeded.Thisissometimesreferredtoas“implementationresearch”orunderstandingtheconditionsnecessaryforeffectivelarge‐scaleprogramimplementation.

Establishcommunity‐basedsurveillancesitesinthemajoragro‐ecologicalzonesinNepalto(i)providelongitudinalmeasuresoftrendsandchangesovertimeinfoodavailability,accessandutilization,andrelatethemtohouseholdfoodsecurity,dietaryintakeandnutritionandhealthstatus,and(ii)generateempiricalevidenceaboutintegratedagricultureandotherfoodandnutritionprograminterventionshaveaneffectonnutritionandhealthoutcomes.ThisshouldbeapriorityareafortheNutritionCRSP.

Organizeabi‐annualorannualforumforpolicymakersfromtheNPC,MoACandMoHPandresearcherstodiscussandtranslateresearchfindingsthatpertaintoimprovementofnutritionstatusthroughamulti‐sectoralapproach.

Organizeanannualscientificsymposiumor“evidencesummit”tofacilitatetherapidsharingoffindingsandinnovativesolutions.

Page 42: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

42

APPENDIX

SESSION1‐ABSTRACTS

1.1HOUSEHOLDCONSUMPTIONOFGRAINLEGUMESINNEPALTERAI:ASTUDYONIMPACTOFIMPROVEDTECHNOLOGIES.RKNEUPANE,NSTHAKUR,PJHA,DNPOKHAREL,BPMAHATOANDRASAH.FORWARDNepal,BharatpurChitwan,andNARCSinghdurbarPlazaKathmandu,Nepal.Emailaddressofcorrespondingauthor:[email protected]

Background:Grainlegumesplayimportantrolesinthenutritionofthepoorersectorsofsocietywhocannotaffordexpensiveanimalproteinfoodsintheirdailydiets.However,againstasteadydecliningtrend,dailydietaryintakeofpulsesvariesacrossruralhouseholds,andlittletodatehasbeendocumentedontheimpacttechnologyinterventions,suchaswiltresistant/tolerantvarietiesofpulses,croprotationandseedtreatmenthavehadonhouseholdlegumeconsumption.Aims:ToestimatethechangesindailydietaryintakeofpulsesbyruralTeraihouseholdsasaresultoftechnologyinterventions.Methods:Householddietaryintakesurveyswereconductedbeforeand36monthsafteraprojectinterventionthatintroducedwilttolerant/resistantvarietiesoflentil(LensculinarisMedic),chickpea(CicerarietinumL)andpigeonpea(CajanuscajanL.Millsp)alongwithcroprotationandfungicidalseeddressingoptionsintofourdistricts‐Banke,Bardia,DangandKanchanpur,locatedinthemidandfarwesternterai.Atotal30householdswererandomlyselectedfromeachprojectareaofthefourdistricts(totalN=~120).Asemi‐structuredquestionnairewasdeveloped,pretestedandusedandachecklistwaspreparedforfocusgroupdiscussions(FGD).Secondarydataonareaandproductivityofpulsesinprojectdistrictswereobtainedfrompublishedreportsoflineagencies.DatawereanalyzedusingSPSS.Results:Theaverageproductivityoflentil,chickpeaandpigeonpeaincreasedbyabout15,59and48%respectivelyoverthebaseyear.Householdconsumptionofpulseswashigherafterprojectinterventioninallfourdistricts.Averageconsumptionofpulsesbeforeprojectinterventionwasonly2kg/capita/annumandtheconsumptionlevelincreasedto13.5kg/capita/annumafterprojectintervention.Thelevelofconsumptionvariedbylandholdings.Householdswithmorethan2haoflandshowedanaverageconsumptionof19.7kg/capita/annum,whileonly7.5kg/capita/annumwerereportedfromhouseholdsowninglessthan0.5ha.Afterprojectintervention,productivityincreasesofpulseswerehigherinsmallerthaninlargerfarms.However,thecashneedsofsmallerfarmerscompelledthemtoselltheproduceinmarket,resultinginlowerhouseholdconsumption.Conclusion:Technologyinterventionislikelytoimprovepulseproductivityatthehouseholdlevel.Increasesindietaryintakeofpulseshavebeenrecordedirrespectiveofhouseholdsizes,althoughfarmerswithlargerholdingstendedtoincludemorepulsesintheirdailydiets.

Page 43: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

43

1.2EFFECIENCIESINLINKINGAGRICULTURALDEVELOPMENTWITHHEALTHANDNUTRITIONTRAININGINNEPAL.L.COLAVITOANDM.PARIYAR.InternationalDevelopmentEnterprises,Kathmandu,NepalEmailaddressofcorrespondingauthor:[email protected]

Background:USAIDsupportedapilotprogramforhealthandnutritiontrainingforpregnantwomenandmotherswithchildrenlessthan5yearsold(2006‐9)thatwerefrom14,161targetedhouseholdsfromtheSmallholderIrrigationMarketInitiative.

Aims:Toassessthebenefitsoflinkinghealthandnutritiontraininginimprovementsinhealthandnutritionalindicatorsandcosteffectiveness.

Methods:ComparisonfromrandomizedbaselineandannualimpactsurveyswereconductedfortargetedHHsandforcontrolgrouphouseholds.ControlgroupsincludedbothSIMIprojecttargetedhouseholdsthatdidnotreceivethehealthandnutritiontrainingandcontrolhouseholdsthatdidnotbenefitfromSIMIorsimilarprojects.

Results:Theprogramshowedstrongstatisticallysignificantbenefitsfromlinkingagriculturetrainingandhealthandnutritiontrainingforavarietyofmeasuresforimprovedhealthandnutritionincludingincreasedcaloriesconsumed(329perday),increasedproteinconsumption(7.5gperweek),moremeals(2.5perweek),andsubstantialdecreasesintheincidencesofdiarrheaandpneumonia.Theprogramachievedtheseresultsatanadditionalcostofabout$50perHHs.

Conclusions:Theresultsshowstrongbenefitstolinkingagriculturedevelopmentandhealthandnutritiontrainingprograms.Thebenefitsincludetheabilitytochangebehaviorashouseholdsareincreasingincome,increasedconsumptionthroughincreasedincomesandagriculturalproductivityofnutritiousfoods,andhouseholdsinvestingmoreforbetterhealthcare.Theprogramalsoshowedthecosteffectivenessofaddinghealthandnutritiontrainingtoanongoingprogramthathadalreadysociallymobilizedcommunitiesforagriculturaldevelopment.

Page 44: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

44

1.3HIGHIMPACT.INTEGRATEDAPPROACHESFORIMPROVEDFOODSECURITYANDNUTRITIONOFRURALPOOR.JOESANDERS,COP,USAID/NepalFloodRecoveryProgram.Emailaddressofcorrespondingauthor:[email protected]:FoodinsecurityandmalnutritionarehighestintheFarWestregionofNepal,where82percentofhouseholdsinprogramworksitesaresubsistencefarmerswithhighfoodinsecurity.Objective:Improvetheaffordability,accessibility,andavailabilityofnutritiousfoodtoruralhouseholdsthroughintegratedcommercialagriculture,nutrition,andinfrastructureinterventions.Conceptualframework:Themultifacetedcausesofpoverty,foodinsecurity,andmalnutritionmustbeaddressedbyapproachesthatrecognizetheinterrelationshipsbetweenincomegeneration,foodproductivity,andconsumption.Improvedagriculturalproductivityandcommercializationcandramaticallyincreaseincomes,butcomplementaryinvestmentsinothersectorsarealsorequiredtosustainimpactsandaddressoverallfoodsecuritypriorities.Descriptionofimplementation:Commercialagricultureparticipantscontributesmallplotsoflandtoademonstrationfarmingprogramthatprovidestrainingandcost‐sharedfinancialassistancetopromotehigh‐valuevegetableproductionandimprovedagriculturaltechnologies.Nutritionandhygieneparticipantsfocusisonnutritiousfoodproductionthroughhomegardening.Bothcomponentsprovidetrainingatthehouseholdlevelinenhancednutritionactions,hygiene,andsanitation.Nutritionalimpactismeasuredbothintermsofchangesinfoodconsumptionandbyindicatorssuchasbodymassindex,prevalenceofbreastfeeding,anddietdiversity.Productiveinfrastructureprojectsthatprovidedirectbenefitstoprogramparticipantsarealsosupported.Outcome:CommercialAgriculture:7,536farmers(35%women)assistedon1,780hectares;843shallowtubewellsinstalled;800%increaseinland’seconomicproductivity;320%increaseinhouseholdincomes;225,000person‐daysofsurplusemploymentgenerated.NutritionandHygiene:5,960farmers(75%women)assistedon147hectaresofhomegardens;240modellatrinesand1,715improvedcookingstovesinstalled.ProductiveInfrastructure:131infrastructuresbenefiting837,726people;improvedtransportationaccessfor128,881households;165,106person‐daysoftemporaryemploymentgenerated.Program’simplications:Integratedinterventionsacrosssectorsdeepenimpactsandstrengthensustainability.Understandingfarmers’economicsituations,landholdingsize,andpotentialasproducersiscrucialtodesigningappropriatefoodsecurityinterventions.Co‐investinginimprovedtechnologies,inputs,andagronomicpracticeshelpsmaximizeoutputsandestablishesastrongcapitalbaseforfarmers.Demonstrationfarmingmodelsensurestrongcommitmentsfromfarmers,facilitateplanning,andprovideafirmbasisforestimatingprojectoutcomesandeffectsonthelocalvaluechain.Substantialimprovementsinagriculturalproductionandcommercializationcannotbeachievedwithouttargetedinvestmentsinproductiveinfrastructure.Nutritionawarenessandbehaviorchangetrainingislesseffectivewithoutcoordinatedassistanceinagriculturalproductionandincomegenerationactivities.Adoptionofimprovedagriculturaltechnologiesandnutritionpracticesrequiresanintensivetrainingprogramwithfrequentandconsistentmessagedelivery.

Page 45: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

45

SESSION2‐ABSTRACTS

2.1APPLICATIONOFTHEHOUSEHOLDECONOMYAPPROACHFORASSESSINGFOODSECURITYANDDESCRIBINGLIVELIHOODSINNEPAL.SAVILLENM1,AKHTERN1,SHRESTHABP2,MANANDHARDS2,OSRIND1,COSTELLOA11

CentreforInternationalHealthandDevelopment,InstituteofChildHealth,UniversityCollegeLondon,UK.2MotherandInfantResearchActivities(MIRA),GPObox921,Kathmandu,Nepal.

Emailaddressofcorrespondingauthor:[email protected]

Background:Improvementofnutritionalstatusthroughbehaviourchangeisonlypossibleifnutrient‐richfoodsareavailableandhouseholdsabletoaccessthem.IntheplainsdistrictofDhanusha,Nepalduring2006,weconductedaHouseholdEconomyApproach(HEA)studyasformativeresearch.Aim:tounderstandthefoodsecurityandlivelihoodsituationofdifferentwealthgroupsinthedistrictsoastodesignbehaviourchangestrategiesthatcouldbepromotedthroughcommunitymobilizationthroughwomen’sgroups.Methods:Weconducted60communityrepresentativeinterviewsand210in‐depthinterviewswithdisaggregatedwealthgrouprepresentatives.Foreachofour60VillageDevelopmentCommitteeclusters,detailedinformationonfoodproduced,marketandotherlinkages,commodityprices,resourcemaps,historicaltimelinesandseasonalityofproduction,migration,labourandmarketpriceswereobtained.Eachwealthgroupwasdescribedintermsofassetscoresandlivelihoodactivities.Wealthgroupinterviewsprovidedestimatesofincome,expenditureandfoodsourcesfora‘typicalhousehold’inthatgroup.Fromannualestimatesofkilosoffoodfromdifferentsources,kilocalorieaccessperpersonperhouseholdinthatwealthgroupwasestimated.Results:Foodproductioninthedistrictishighandmicronutrient‐richvegetables,fruitandanimalfoodsareavailableyearroundexceptinthemonsoon.‘Hungryseasons’precedericeharvests(Sep/OctandMarch/April).Thelandlesspoorestrelyonfoodpurchaseandagriculturallabourexchangetomeettheirbasicfoodneeds,makingthemvulnerabletofoodpriceandlabouravailabilityshocks.Middle/better‐offgroupsgrowstapleandnon‐staplefoodsforconsumptionandsale,andarevulnerabletoshocksaffectingproduction.PoorergroupsrelyonmigratorylabourtoIndia,plusdaily‐wagedlabour,whereasmiddle/better‐offrunbusinesses,haveregularjobsandremittancesfromArabcountriesandMalaysiaforcashincome.Thepoorborrowonunfavourabletermsinordertoaccessjobsoverseas.Quantitativeincomeestimatesweredifficulttostandardisebetweeninterviewsanddidnotmatchexpenditure.Conclusion:TheHEAprovidesrichdetailonlivelihoodpatternsthatmayhelpdesignappropriatenutritionalinterventions.However,indiverseagriculturaleconomiesquantitativeestimatesofkilocalorieintakeandhouseholdincomemaybelessreliable.

Page 46: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

46

2.2HOMESTEADFOODPRODUCTIONCONTRIBUTESTODIETARYINTAKEAMONGCHILDREN6‐23MONTHSOLDINKALIALIDISTRICT,FARWESTTERAI.DPADHIKARI1,PPANDEYRANA1,DDAVIS1,NSHARMA1,HBCHAND2,RKNEUPANE1.1HelenKellerInternational,NepalCountryOffice,Chakupat‐Patan,Lalitpur,P.O.Box3752,Nepal;2HelenKellerInternational,NepalFieldOffice,Dhangadi,Kailali,NepalEmailaddressofcorrespondingauthor:[email protected]

Issues:LimitedproductionandvarietyoffoodsandknowledgeabouttimelyintroductionofcomplementaryfoodandageappropriatefeedingpracticesarethekeyissuesaffectingthenutritionalstatusofchildrenandmothersinFar‐WesternNepal.Objectives:Toimprovenutritionalstatusofpregnantandlactatingwomenandchildrenlessthantwoyearsofagebyaddressingakeydeterminantofmalnutritionandincreasinghouseholdfoodproductionintheprojectdistricts.Conceptualframework:Knowledge,skills,technicalandmaterialinputs,andcommunitymobilizationleadtoimprovedavailabilityandincreasedconsumptionofnutritiousfoods.Programdesignanddescription:TheUSAIDsupportedActionAgainstMalnutritionthroughAgriculture(AAMA)Project,wasdesignedtoincreasefoodavailabilityanddiversificationthroughhomesteadfoodproduction(HFP)in4632householdswithpregnantwomenandmotherswithchildrenundertwo.BeneficiariesreceivedtraininginHFP,seeds/seedlingsandpoultrychicks.Processevaluationmethods:Acommunity‐based,bi‐annuallotqualityassurancesamplingsurveywasconductedusinga24hourrecallquestionnaire(WHO,2010)forassessingtheinfantandyoungchildfeedingpracticesusingthesevenrecommendedfoodgroups;recordedbyagegroupandconsumption.SPSSversion18.0wasusedtoanalyzedata.CrosstabulationandbivariteanalysiswereusedtoassesstheminimumdietarydiversityinrelationtotheHFPexposurestatus,andmotherswhoknewtimelyintroductionofcomplementaryfood,ageappropriateamountandfrequencyoffeeding.Results:Vegetablevarietiesincreased(3.8±1.9inJanuary2009,4±2.3inAugust2010,8±3.6inFebruary2011and7±3.1inAugust2011)andtheaveragevegetableproductionwithintheprevioustwomonthsincreasedfrom74kg/HHatbaseline(January2009)to175kg/HH(February2011).InAugust2011,mid‐monsoon,theproductiondroppedto123kg/HH.ThemeaneggproductionHH/weekincreasedfrom2.4eggsperhouseholdinAugust2010to5.7inAugust2011.Dietarydiversity,includingconsumptionofvitaminAandironrichplantsourcesandeggs,wassignificantlyhigheramongchildren6‐23monthsfromHFPinterventionhouseholds(p<001).Dietarydiversityofchildrenage6‐23monthswassignificantlyhigheramongthosewhosemothersknewwhentointroducecomplimentaryfeeding(71.7%)thanthosemotherswhodidn’tknow(36.7%).Dietarydiversityofchildrenage6‐23monthswassignificantlyhigheramongthosewhosemothersknewaboutageappropriatefeedingfrequency(82.0%)versusamongthosewhosemotherdidn’tknow(42.7%)(p<001).Programimplications:ThesefindingsdemonstratethatimprovedHFPandknowledgemayleadtoimprovedinfantfeedingpracticesandadditionaldemonstrationstudysitesarewarranted.

Page 47: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

47

2.3FOODSECURITY,FOODPRICEANDINCOMETRENDSINDHANUSHADISTRICT,NEPALBETWEEN2005AND2011.SHRESTHABP2,AKHTERN1,MANANDHARDS2,OSRIND1,COSTELLOA1,SAVILLENM1.1CentreforInternationalHealthandDevelopment,InstituteofChildHealth,UniversityCollegeLondon,UK.2MotherandInfantResearchActivities(MIRA),GPObox921,Kathmandu,Nepal.Emailaddressofcorrespondingauthor:[email protected]

Background:Householdfoodsecurityisdeterminedbyavailability,accessandutilisationoffood.AlthoughtheTeraiisNepal’s‘breadbasket’,thepoorlackaccesstofoods.Hence,inDhanushadistrict,MIRA/UCLmonitoredfoodsecurityandrelatedfactorsbetween2005‐6and2011aspartofprospectivesurveillanceofhouseholdswithrecentlydeliveredwomen.Aims:Ourobjectivesweretounderstand:a)howhouseholdfoodinsecuritywasexperiencedinrelationtoanxietyabout‐,insufficientqualityof‐andinsufficientquantityof‐food;b)whowasaffectedbyfoodinsecurity;andc)whetherthefoodpricecrisisaffectedfoodsecurity.Methods:Weused3standardizedmonitoringtoolswithrecentlydeliveredwomenbetweenSeptember2006andJune2011.‘HouseholdDietaryDiversityScore’(HDDS)‐and‘MonthsofAdequateHouseholdFoodProvisioning’(MAHFP)‐datawerecollectedfromSep2006toJun11in>35,000households.‘HouseholdFoodInsecurityAccessScale’(HFIAS)datawerecollectedin4,084householdsSept2006toMay2007andin11,039householdsNov2009toJune2011.Wemonitoredfoodpricesfor66itemsin48‐53marketsinDhanushain2005‐6,2008,2009andcompared2006and2008ratesfordifferentincomes.Results:AllfoodinsecuritymeasuresimprovesteeplywithassetquintileandDalitssufferworst.ComparingNov‐June2005‐6,2009‐10and2010‐11foodinsecurityindicatorsimprovedforasfollows:HFIAS3.8,2.4,1.9;anxietyaboutfoodaccess63%,41%,34%;insufficientfoodquality52%,36%,31%;insufficientfoodintake24%,15%,11%;HDDS4.3,4.5,4.8foodgroups;MAHFP10.2,10.4,10.5months;moderately/severelyfoodinsecure39%,24%,19%andinthepoorestquintile70%,53%,48%.Householdswithaccesstoremittanceincomesincreasedonaverage36%,48%,52%andinthepoorestquintile16%,31%,32%.Incomeratesincreasedby33%forlabor,26%forsalariedjobsand22%frombusinesses2006‐8.Foodpricesincreased32.6%2005‐8and25.2%2008‐9.Conclusion:Although48%ofpooresthouseholdsinDhanushastillsufferfoodinsecurity,foodsecurityhasimproveddespitethefoodpricecrisis.Effectsofpriceincreasesseemtohavebeenbufferedbysalaryincreasesandincreasingaccesstoremittanceincomes.

Page 48: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

48

2.4VALIDATINGDISTRICT‐LEVELASSESSMENTWITHSURVEYDATA:EXAMPLEFROMTHENEKASP,WORLDFOODPROGRAMMEEmailaddressofcorrespondingauthor:Mariko.Kawabata@wfp.orgFoodsecurityinNepalischaracterizedbyahighvariability:notabledisparityisfoundwithinrespectiveregionsanddistricts,aswellasamongdifferentpopulationgroups,whichmakesthefoodsecuritymonitoringcomplexandchallenging.TheNepalFoodSecurityMonitoringSystem(NeKSAP)employsdifferentdatacollectionmethodstoassessandmonitorthefoodsecuritysituation,deliveringreliableandtimelyinformation.ThepresentationillustrateshowthedifferentdatacollectionmethodscomplementeachothertoachievethebestresultunderpracticallimitationsinvolvedinfoodsecuritymonitoringinNepal.TheNeKSAPemploystwokeydatacollectionmethods:phaseclassificationapproachbytheDistrictFoodSecurityNetworks(DFSNs);andrepeatedcross‐sectionalsurveys.TheDFSNs,formedbystaffandrepresentativesfromdistrict‐basedorganizationsandinstitutions,assessandmonitorthefoodsecuritysituationintheirrespectivedistrictsbasedonstandardizedfoodsecurityphaseclassificationapproach.TheinformationisdisaggregatedtoVDC‐levelandupdatedbyseason(quarterly/bi‐annually).Householdsurveyisconductedacrossthecountry,designedtomonitorthefoodsecuritysituationbyecologicalbeltorsub‐regionbyseasonandyear.InformationgatheredbytheDFSNsisvalidatedusingtheNeKSAPhouseholdsurveydatathroughexaminingthedegreeofhouseholdfoodsecuritybyrespectivefoodsecurityphaseasclassifiedbytheDFSNs.EvidenceshowsthatkeyfoodsecurityindicatorsfromthehouseholddataconfirmthedegreeoffoodinsecurityreportedbytheDFSNs.

Page 49: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

49

SESSION3‐ABSTRACTS

3.1NUTRITIONINTERVENTIONSTHATIMPROVECHILDANDMATERNALHEALTHANDSURVIVAL:FINDINGSFROMTRIALSINTHETERAIOFNEPAL(EXPANDEDABSTRACT)KEITHP.WEST,JR.,SUBARNAK.KHATRY,PARULCHRISTIAN,ROLFD.W.KLEMM,JOANNEKATZ,LUKEMULLANY,STEVENC.LECLERQ,JAMESM.TIELSCH.TheNepalNutritionInterventionProject‐Sarlahi(NNIPS),CenterforHumanNutritionandDepartmentofInternationalHealth,JohnsHopkinsBloombergSchoolofPublicHealth,Baltimore,Maryland,USA21205Emailcorrespondingauthor:[email protected]

Background:Nutritionaldeficienciesstemfromadietchronicallyinsufficienttosupporthealthanddevelopment,includinghostdefensestoinfectionandotherenvironmentalstresses.Pregnancy,infancyandearlychildhoodareperiodsofgreatestriskofdeficiencywithpotentialshortandlongtermhealthconsequences.Communityresearchcanrevealthehealthimpactofsupplementingorimprovingthedietinapopulationandprovideabasisforpreventiveprogramsandpolicies.Methods:TheNepalNutritionInterventionProject‐Sarlahi(NNIPS)waslaunchedin1988byJohnsHopkinsUniversityandtheNepalNetraJyotiSangh,withUSAIDsupport,toconductmicronutrientdeficiencypreventionresearchthatwouldinformhealthpoliciesandprogramsinNepal.SarlahiDistrictwaschosenbasedonitscomparabilitywithnumerousfeaturesintheTerai.Keyfindingsfromthefollowingfieldtrialsandassociatedstudiesaresummarized:NNIPS‐1(1989‐92,n=28,630)assessedtheefficacyofperiodic,high‐dosevitaminAinreducingpreschoolchildmortality;NNIPS‐2(1994‐7,n=44,646women/22,189pregnancies)assessedtheimpactofprovidingarecommendeddietaryallowance(RDA)ofvitaminA,eitherpreformedorasbeta‐carotene,towomenonaweeklybasisbefore,duringandafterpregnancyonmaternalandinfantmortality;NNIPS‐3(2000‐1,n=4926pregnantwomen)evaluatedagainstacontroltheeffectsofantenatalsupplementationwithiron,iron+folicacid,iron+folicacid+zincora14‐nutrientsupplementonbirthsize(allgroupsreceivinganRDAofvitaminA);afollow‐upstudyofthesethreecohorts,fundedbytheGatesFoundation,in2006‐8(n=~55,000childrenandmothers)examinedlong‐termeffectsofearlylifeinterventionsonchildren;and,NNIPS‐4(2001‐6,n=41,276)studiedtheefficacyofdailyzinc,ironorbothinreducingmorbidityandmortalityinchildren1to35monthsofage.Results:NNIPS‐1revealedthatvitaminAcouldreducepreschoolchildmortalityby30%[17]which,withsimilarfindingsfromatrialinJumla[18],providedevidenceforNepal'svitaminAprogramwhichhaspreventedatleast120,000childdeathsinthepastdozenyears.TheNNIPSfollow‐upstudyalsofound,byages15‐23years,thatvitaminAhadreducedhearinglossassociatedwithmiddleearinfectionby42%[19],attributedtoareductioninseverityofinfection.VitaminAgivenatbirthmayalsoreduceinfantmortality.InBangladesh[20],India[21]andIndonesia[22],newbornvitaminAhasbeenshowntolowermortality<6monthsofageby~20%,aninterventionbeingpilotedinNepal.

Page 50: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

50

NNIPS‐2reducedmortalityrelatedtopregnancybyanaverageof44%witheithermaternalvitaminAorbeta‐carotenesupplementation[23].Maternalsupplementationalsoreducednightblindness[24]andmaternalmorbidity[25]buthadnooveralleffectoninfantmortality[26].At9‐12yearsofage,however,thefollow‐upstudyrevealedgreaterlungcapacity(byspirometry)amongchildrenborntovitaminAsupplementedmothers[27],likelybyimprovingfetallungdevelopment[28].Therewerenoeffectsonbloodpressureorcognitionofoffspring.EpidemiologicalfindingsrevealedmaternalnightblindnesstobeamajorriskfactorformaternalvitaminAdeficiency,undernutrition,morbidityandmortalityduringandlongaftertheendofpregnancy[29,30].DuringNNIPS‐3,motherswerefoundtobelow‐to‐deficientinmultiplemicronutrients15,raisingconcernthatmulti‐nutrientsupplementsmaybeneededduringpregnancyorlactationintheabsenceofdietaryadequacy.However,thetrialshowedvariedeffects:Folicacidalonehadnoeffectonbirthweight[31]butsignificantlyreducedpreterminfantmortality[9].Addingironreducedanemiainthisiron‐deficientsetting,andriskoflowbirthweightby16%[32].Addingzinctothesupplementreversedeffectsofiron.Themultiplemicronutrientsupplementalsoreducedriskoflowbirthweight,by14%,comparabletothatseenwithfolicacid‐ironalone[9],butconveyednosurvivaladvantageforinfants[32].Longerfollow‐upstrengthenedthecaseforantenatalfolicacid‐ironsupplementuse:Byage6‐8yearsofage,childrenborntofolicacidsupplementedmotherswere~40%lesslikelytohaveabnormalkidneyfunction(bymicroalbumintocreatinineratio)andearlybiomarkerindicationsofmetabolicsyndrome[33].Morestrikingly,childrenborntomothersreceivingironwithfolicacidinpregnancyweremorelikelytosurvivethepreschoolyears[10]andperformbetteroncognitivetests[34].Theseeffectswerenotseenwithamultiplemicronutrientsupplement.Itisunlikelythatfoodbasedapproacheswill,inthenearfuture,assureadequatedietaryintakesofbioavailableiron,indicatingthatantenatalfolicacid‐ironsupplementationremainastandardofcareforachievingmaternaladequacyinthesenutrientsinNepal.NNIPS‐4standsasoneoftwocommunitybasedtrials(theotherinZanzibar)thatassessedeffectsofdailyzincorironsupplementationonchildsurvival.InNepal,dailyzincsupplementusehadnoeffectoninfantmortalitybutexertedanon‐significant20%reductioninmortality>12monthsofage[35].However,becausebothtrialsinNepalandZanzibarwerecomparableindesign,underlyingrisksandeffectestimates,datafrombothwerepooledtorevealasignificantoverallmortalityreductionof18%[35].Whiletheevidenceismarginaltopromoteuniversal,dailyzincsupplementationforchildsurvival,thefindingsareconsistentwithknowneffectsofzincinreducingprevalence,severityandsubsequentincidenceofdiarrhea,andemphasizeitsimportanceintreatingdiarrhea[36].Twoepidemiologicalstudiesreveallikelybenefitsof(a)earlyexclusivebreastfeedingand(b)theimportanceofguidingmealconsumptionpatternstoassureadequateintakesbychildrenathome.Inthefirst,adose‐responserelationshipwasobservedbetweenthenumberofhoursinwhichbreastfeedingwasdelayedandriskofneonatalmortality,suggestingthat19%ofallneonataldeathsinruralNepalcouldbeavertedbyinitiatingbreastfeedingwithinthefirsthouroflife[37].Inthesecond,ananthropologicalstudyshowedthattheoddsoftoddlersconsumingavarietyofnutritiousfoodswas1.5to12timeshigherifthechildhadsharedaplatewithanoldersiblingratherthaneatalone[38].Sharingaplateatmealtimewithanolderfemalewasmoreadvantageoustothechildthanwithanoldermale.

Page 51: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

51

Conclusions:Communityresearchcanprovideevidencefornutritionprogramdecisions:PreschoolvitaminAsupplementationcontinuestoprotectlives,sightandhealthofchildren.SupplementationshouldcontinueuntilsuchtimethatadequatedietaryvitaminAintakeandstatusinthepopulationisassured.AmaternaldietadequateinvitaminAwilllikelyhelpreducesriskofmaternalmortalityinNepal,helpcontrolriskofnightblindness.Pregnantandlactatingwomenshouldbeaskedaboutnightblindness,providedlowdosevitaminAifpositive,andofferedgeneraldietaryandhealthcareguidance.Amongothernutrients,antenatalfolicacidandironassuresasubstantialpublichealthimpactforbothmotherandchildinNepal,forwhichthereispresentlynoadequatedietaryalternative.Amultiplemicronutrientsupplementmaynotaddfurtherpublichealthbenefit,forwhichmoreresearchmaybeneeded.Zincsupplementationisacriticaladjuncttreatment(withoralrehydration)fordiarrhea,andcouldreduceunder‐fivemortalityifintakeisincreaseduniversally,preferablythroughfoodbasedstrategies.Immediateandexclusivebreastfeedingcanlikelyreduceneonatalmortality.And,foodbasedstrategieswillneedtoalsoguideintrahouseholdmealpracticestoassuredietaryadequacyinyoungchildren.

Page 52: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

52

3.2GROWTHANDHEALTHOFRURALCHILDRENIN3DISTRICTSOFNEPAL:EFFECTOFACOMMUNITYDEVELOPMENTINTERVENTION.LCMILLER*#,RSHRESTHA^,MLOHANI#,PSINGH#,PSUBBA^,DTHAPA^,SNMAHATO#,NJOSHI#*TuftsUnivSchofMedicine,Boston,MAUSA;^NepalTechnicalAssistanceGroup,Kathmandu,Nepal;#HeiferInternational,Kathmandu,NepalEmailaddressofcorrespondingauthor:[email protected]:Morethan50%ofchildreninNepalaremalnourished.Economicgrowthandpovertyreductionarenotalwayssufficienttoimprovethehealthandnutritionalstatusofchildren.Becausechildhealth/nutritionarevitalcornerstonesofcommunitydevelopment,HeiferNepalconductedalongitudinalrandomizedcontrolledtrialtoevaluatetheeffectsofitsprogramsontheseimportantoutcomes.Aims:(1)systematicallyassesseffectsofHeiferactivitiesonchildhealthandnutritionalstatus;(2)delineatecharacteristicsoffamiliesandchildrenaffectingthese(andother)outcomes.Studydesign:6communitiesin3districtsofNepal[Chitwan/Nawalparasi(Terai),Nuwakot(hills)],werepair‐matchedforspecificcharacteristicsandthenrandomlyassignedtoreceiveHeifercommunitydevelopmentactivitiesatbaseline(INT)orat1year(CON).Atbaseline,6,12,18,and24months,a125‐itemquestionnaireaddressingfamilydemographics,SES,diet,andchildhealth/nutritionwascompletedineachhousehold,alongwithchildgrowthmonitoring.Results:By12months,2903individualsin430householdswereenrolled,including528children6mo‐8yrs.INTandCONcommunitieswereequivalentforbaselineand12monthsSES,householdsize,land/animalownership,andchildnutrition/health,butthereweremarkeddifferencesbetweenTeraiandhilldistricts.At12months,TeraiINTgrouphadimprovedchildweight(p=.04),height(p=.05),andreducedsickdays(p=.01),aswellasincreasedhouseholdincome(p=.004),animal(p=.04)andlandownership(p=.04)comparedtoCON.SignificantimprovementswerenotedinsanitationpracticesinINTgroupat12months(p<.01).Childhealthandnutritionstronglycorrelatedwithage.Conclusions:Significantimprovementsat12monthsinmanyindicatorswerenotedinTeraibutnothillsINTvs.CON.Familyclusteringandotherhouseholdcharacteristicslikelyaffectoutcomesofcommunitydevelopmentinterventions.Extendedfollow‐upwillbeimportanttofurtherunderstandfactorsaffectingchildoutcomesandidentifyspecifictargetsforimprovement.

Page 53: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

53

3.3IMPACTSOFCHANGESINGRAINPULSE(LEGUME)CONSUMPTIONONMICRONUTRIENTSUPPLYOFRURALWOMENINNEPALANDNORTHINDIA.PANDERSEN,DepartmentofGeographyandRKChandyo,CentreforInternationalHealth,UniversityofBergen,Norway.Emailaddressofcorrespondingauthor:[email protected]:AnimportantfoodsystemchangeinSouthAsia,isthereductionofpulses(legumes)inthedietsoverthelastfourtofivedecades,duetostagnantagriculturalproduction.Thereasonsforstagnantpulseavailabilityincludelowpriorityinresearchanddevelopmentandagriculturalincentives,anddepletionofsoilmicronutrientsandrhizobiumduetoagriculturalintensification.Thepercapitaconsumptionofpulseshasdeclinedbymorethanhalf.Forruralandpoorpeople,pulseshaveprimarilybeenreplacedbystaplegrains,notbyanimalsourcefoods,leadingtoreducedmicronutrientdensity.ThepaperisbasedontheFOSRINprojectwhichstudiedricebean(Vignaumbellata)inparticular.Aims:Pulsesareoftenseenasasourceproteinforpoorand/orvegetarianpopulations.Weinvestigatetheroleofpulsesinpreventionofmicronutrientsufficiency–“hiddenhunger”.Methods:Dietaryrecallsof800ruralwomenofreproductiveageinNepalandNorthIndia,wereanalyzedusingtheWorldFood2program.Thedietaryintakeswerecomparedtorecommendedintakevaluestopredictgeneraldeficiencyproblems.Contributionsofdifferentfoodgroupswereassessed.Results:Staplegrainsprovidedabout80%oftheenergy,ricealone62%.Majordeficienciespredictedwerelysine,Ca,K,Fe,vit.A,C,D,folateandB12;theintakesofFeandfolatewereparticularlyinadequateforpregnantwomen.Thepredicteddeficiencies,combinedwiththenutrientdensityofpulsescomparedtostaplegrains,definesthewindowofopportunityforpulses.Themajorcontributionsofpulseswerelysine,Ca,K,FeandBvitaminsotherthanB12.Conclusion:Pulseshaveacentralbutnotsufficientroleinpreventionofhiddenhunger.Thepolicyimplicationsofthestudyincludesifinterventionsshouldbeenrichmentofrice,substitutionwithotherstaples,supplementationorcomplementaryfooditems,includingpulses.

Page 54: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

54

3.4CORRELATESOFINFANTANDYOUNGCHILDFEEDINGPRACTICESINCHEPANGCOMMUNITY.SUBEDIN,1POUDELS,2RANAT1ANDPAUDELAK3.1NepalPublicHealthFoundation,2KarnaliIntegratedRuralDevelopmentandResearchCenterNepal,3DepartmentofCommunityMedicineandPublicHealth,InstituteofMedicine,TribhuvanUniversityEmailaddressofcorrespondingauthor:[email protected]

Background:Infantandyoungchildfeeding(IYCF)practicesdiffersincommunitiesduetodifferenceinknowledge,healthserviceutilization,culture,andothersocio‐economicfactors.TheobjectiveofthisstudywastoexploreknowledgeandpracticeofChepangmothersonIYCFandtheircorrelates.Methods:AcrosssectionaldescriptivestudywasconductedinChepangcommunityofMakawanpurdistrict.Quantitativemethodologywasusedinwhich360mothersofundertwoyearagechildrenwereselectedrandomly.Logisticregressionanalysisofselectedchildfeedingindicatorswasdonetofindtheirassociationwithsocio‐economicandhealthrelatedfactors.Results:Feedingpracticesofmotherswerefoundbetterthantheirknowledgelevel.About35%hadknowledgeaboutearlyinitiationofbreastfeeding.Exclusivebreastfeedingandintroductionofcomplementaryfoodsattheageofsixmonthswere81%and90%respectively.Literatemotherswerefoundinitiatingbreastfeedingearlythantheilliterate(OR=2.61,95%CI,1.59‐4.27).Growthmonitoringserviceutilizationwasfoundtohavesignificantassociationwithexclusivebreastfeedingpractices(OR=2.75;95%CI,1.30‐5.78).Feedingdiversecomplementaryfoodswasfoundtobeassociatedwithaveragemonthlyfamilyincomeanddurationoffoodsufficiency.Conclusions:FeedingpracticesinChepangcommunitywereassociatedwithhealthandsocioeconomicdeterminants.Someofthefeedingpracticeswerefoundgoodhowever,mealfrequencyforthechildren9‐23monthsofageandfeedingdiversefoodsforchildren6‐23monthswerefoundlowerwhichneedstobeimprovedthroughnutritionawarenessprograms.Qualitativestudiesareneededfurthertoexploretheculturalfactors.

Page 55: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

55

TITLELISTINGSFORPOSTERPRESENTATIONS

IMPROVEMENTOFWOMEN’SLIVELIHOODS,INCOMEANDNUTRITIONTHROUGHCARP‐SIS‐PRAWNPOLYCULTUREINTERAI,NEPAL.SunilaRai,MadhavK.Shrestha,NabaRajDevkota.InstituteofAgricultureandAnimalScience,Rampur,Chitwan,NepalEmailaddressofcorrespondingauthor:[email protected]

RICESEEDBUSINESSMODELINGANDFOODSECURITY:ACASESTUDYOFKAVREPALANCHOKANDRAUTAHATDISTRICTSOFNEPAL.MeghBahadurNepali1,*,SudeepGautam2,SabitaMohiniAmatyaShrestha2andSanjeevAdhikari21,2SocioeconomicsandAgriculturalResearchPolicyDivision,NARC,Khumaltar,NepalEmailaddressofcorrespondingauthor:[email protected]

HEALTHANDHUMANDEVELOPMENTNEXUSINNEPAL.MukeshKumarMishra*,VinodMishra1,FarhatN.Siddiquie2.*BhopalNIMSCollege,Lalitpur,Nepal,1Departmentofsociology,TribhuwanUniversityNepal2DepartmentOfClinicalNutritionandDietetics,Emailaddressofcorrespondingauthor:[email protected]

Page 56: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

56

LISTOFPARTICIPANTS

   NAME  DESIGNATION  INSTITUTION 

1  MS.  AKRITI SINGH  SR. NUTRITION COORDINATOR  SUAAHARA 

2  MS.  ALINA MAHARJAN   BOARD MEMBER  IOM/NPHF 

3  DR.  ARJUN KARKI  VC  PAHS 

4  MR.  ARUN UPRETY     BNMT 

5  MR.  ASHOK BHURTYAL  NATIONAL PROFESSIONAL OFFICER  WHO 

6  MR.  ATMA RAM PANDEY  JOINT SECRETARY  NPC 

7  MR.  BAL GOPAL BAIDYA  SR.RESEARCH  ASSOCIATE  NEW ERA 

8  MR.  BASUDEV SHARMA     DRISHYAVOLOKAN 

9  MS.  BASUNDHARA SHER.     COLLEGE 

10  MR.  BED MANI DAHAL  ASST. PROFESSOR  KATHMANDU UNIVERSITY 

11  MR.  BHIM SHRESTHA  R.MANAGER  MIRA 

12  MR.  BHIM SUNUWAR  DRIVER  NTAG 

13  DR.  BIBHUSAN SHRESTHA  DOCTOR  KUSMS 

14  MR.  BIJAY K. SINGH  CONSULTANT  RENAISSANCE SOCIETY NEPAL 

15  MR.  BIJU K. SHRESTHA  PROGRAM DIRECTOR  NPCS 

16  DR.  BIKRAM SHRESTHA  MEDICAL DOCTOR  KUSMS 

17  MS. BIMALA MANANDHAR     MIRA 

18  MR.  BINESH MAN SAKHA  SENIOR SCIENTIST  NARC (PRP) 

19  MR.  BINOD KHANAL  STUDENT  IAAS,RAMPUR,CHITWAN 

20  MR.  BIRENDRA YADAV  ASST. PROFESSOR  BPKIHS DHARAN 

21  MR.  CHARLES ENCISO  DIR. OF PROGRAMMING/TRANING  PEACE CORPS 

22  DR.  CHET RAJ PANT  VICE CHAIRMAN  NNJS 

23  DR.  CHET RAJ UPRETI  PRINCIPAL SCIENTIST  NARC 

24  DR.  CHOP LAL BHUSAL     NHRC 

25  MR.  DARRELL DEPPET  CHIEF OF PARTY  EIG/WINROCR 

26  MR.  DAVID C. ATTEBERRY  MISSION DIRECTOR  USAID 

27  MR.  DEBENDRA ADHIKARI  M &E MANAGER  HKI 

28  DR. DEBENDRA GAUCHAN  SENIOR SCIENTIST  NARC 

29  MR.  DEEPAK THAPA  PROGRAM MANAGER  NTAG 

30  MR. DHANANJAYA POUDYAL  FREELANCER    

31  DR. DHARMA MANANDHAR  PEDIATRICIAN  MIRA 

32  MR. DURGA PRASAD PAHARI  FACULTY  IOM 

33  MS.  DUSHALA ADHIKARI  MEMBER  PHI 

Page 57: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

57

34  MS.  ELISA FACCHINI  INTERN  USAID EIG 

35  DR. GAJANANDA BHANDARI  DIRECTOR  NPHF 

36  DR.  GERALD SHIVELY  PROFESSOR  PURDVE UNIVERSITY  

37  MR.  HAN KANG  DEPUTY DIRECTOR  USAID 

38  MR.  HARI KOIRALA  PROGRAM SPECIALIST  USAID 

39  DR.  INDIRA SHARMA  PROFESSOR  T.U. PADMA KANYA CAMPUS 

40  MR.  JOE SANDERS  USAID‐NFRP  FINTRAC 

41  MR.  JYOTI SHRESTHA  COORDINATOR  MIRA 

42  DR.  K.K. LAL  AGRONOMY EXPERT  R.S NEPAL 

43  MR.  K.P ACHARYA  TECHNICAL MANAGER  NTAG 

44  DR.  KALPANA TIWARI  NUTRITION SPECIALIST  NTAG 

45  MR.  KAMAL SHRESTHA  M&O SPECIALIST  USAID ‐NFRP 

46  DR. KANTI LATA BHANDARI  CHAIRPERSON  IRHDTC/NEPAL 

47  DR.  KEDAR P. BARAL  PROFESSOR  PAHS 

48  DR.  KEITH WEST  PROFESSOR  JOHNS HOPKINS 

49  MS. KENDA CUNNINGHAM  RESEARCHER  IFPRI 

50  MR.  KIPP SUTTON  AGRICULTURAL OFFICER  USAID 

51  MR.  KIRK DEARDEN  DCOP  HKI/SUAAHARA 

52  MR.  KUMAR SANJEL     NTAG 

53  MR.  LILA B. THAPA SENIOR PUBLIC HEALTH OFFICER  CHD/DOHS 

54  MS.  LUEIA RUSSO  COORDINATOR  ISAS 

55  MR.  LUIS GUZMAN  FOREIGN SERVICE  USAID 

56  MR.  LUKE COLAVITO  COUNTRY DIRECTOR  IDE 

57  MS.  LYNN LEDERER  CHIEF OF PARTY  SUAAHARA 

58  MR.  M .R MAHARJAN  DIRECTOR  MI 

59  DR.  MADAN PARIYAR  PD/M &E DIRECTOR  IDE NEPAL 

60  DR. MADHAV K. SHRESTHA  PROFESSOR  IAAS/RAMPUR 

61  DR. MADHU DIXIT DEVKOTA  PROFESSOR  IOM 

62  MR. MADHUKAR B.SHRESTHA  SENIOR PROGRAM MANAGER  HKI 

63  MS. MANASA THAPA THAKURATHI  ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR  PADMA KANYA CAMPUS 

64  MR.  MANDIP RAI  PROGRAM OFFICER  FAO 

65  MS. MANDIRA TAMRAKAR  ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR  PADMA KANYA CAMPUS 

66  MS.  MANJITA SHRESTHA     NTAG 

67  MS. MANODHARA SHAKYA  ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR  PADMA KANYA CAMPUS 

Page 58: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

58

68  MS.  MARIE RUEL     IFPRI 

69  MS.  MARIKO KAWABATA  HEAD FSMAV  WFP 

70  MR. MEGH BAHADUR NEPALI  T.OFFICER  NARC  

71  MS.  MONA SHARMA  SENIOR OFFICER  WINROCK INTL' 

72  MR.  MUKTI SANJEL  DRIVER  NTAG 

73  DR.  NABA RAJ DEVKOTA  PROFESSOR  IAAS,RAMPUR,CHITWAN 

74  MR. NANDA PRASAD SHRESTHA  LIV. EXPERT  RNS/FAO 

75  MS.  NAOMI SAVILLE  TECHNICAL ADVISOR  MIRA/UCL 

76  MR.  NARAYAN SUBEDI  PROGRAM MANAGER  NPHF 

77  MR.  NAVEEN PAUDYAL  P.O. NUTRITION  UNICEF 

78  MR.  NAVIN HADA  AG. SPECIALIST  USAID 

79  MS.  NEENA JOSHI  SENIOR PROGRAM MANAGER  HEIFER INTERNATIONAL 

80  MS.  NICOLE MENAGE  REPRESENTATIVE  WFP 

81  MS.  NIRMALA PANDEY AG. FOOD SECURITY COORDINATOR  HKI 

82  MS.  NIRMALA SHARMA  PROG.DEV. COORDINATOR  CARE 

83  DR.  P. MISHRA  SECRETARY  MOHP 

84  MS.  PASCASIE ADEDZE  NUTRITION ADVISOR  USAID 

85  DR.  PATRICK WEBB Dean of Academic Affairs, Friedman School  Tufts University 

86  MR.  PETER ANDERSEN   ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR  UNIVERSITY OF BERGEN 

87  MS.  POOJA RANA  DIRECTOR OF PROGRAM  HKI/SUAAHARA 

88  MR.  PRADEEP DIXIT  DIRECTOR  AFFAN 

89  MR.  PRADIUMNA DAHAL  NUTRITION SPECIALIST  UNICEF 

90  MS.  PRAGYA GARTAULLA  LECTURER NEPAL INSTITUTE OF HEALTH SCIENCES 

92  MR.  PRAMOD G.C  ASST. PROFESSOR  BPKIHS  

93  MR.  PRAMOD KOIRALA  DFTQC    

94  MR.  PRAVEEN BAIDYA  DCOP  WINROCK INTL' 

95  MS.  PREETI SUBBA  M&E OFFICER  NTAG 

96  MS.  PUSHPA SHRESTHA  PROGRAM OFFICER  WFP 

97  MR. RADHA KRISHNA PRADHAN  PROGRAM DIRECTOR  NPC 

98  MR. RADHA SHYAM CHAUDHARY  NUTRITION COORDINATOR  USAID/NFRD (FINTRAC) 

99  MR.  RAJAN PAUDEL  LECTURER  IOM 

100  MR.  RAJU KANDEL  CONSULTANT  CHEMONICS 

101  DR. RAM CHANDRA BHUSAL 

VALUE CHAIN/MARKETING SPECIALIST  CEAPRED 

102  MR.  RAM GUPTA     USAID/NFRP 

103  DR.  RAM K. CHANDYO  RESEARCHER  IOM 

Page 59: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

59

104  MR. RAM KRISHNA NEUPANE  PROGRAM DIRECTOR  FORWARD NEPAL 

105  MR. RAM KUMAR NEUPANE  HFPC  HKI 

106  DR.  RAMAN SHRESTHA  M & E OFFICER  NTAG 

107  MR.  RAMESH K. ADHIKARI  PROFESSOR  IOM 

108  MS.  RITA PRADHAN      NTAG 

109  DR.  RIWAAJ LAMSAL  DOCTOR(MED.OFFICER)  SAHARA HOSPITAL 

110  MR.  ROBIN HOUSTON  DCOP  NFHP 

111  DR.  ROLF KLEMM     JOHNS HOPKINS 

112  MR.  RUDRA SHARMA  PLANNING OFFICER NATIONAL PLANNING COMMISSION 

113  MS.  RUPA MAHARJAN     NTAG 

114  MS. RUPA PANDEY(THAPA)  ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR 

NEPAL INSTITUTE OF HEALTH SCIENCES 

115  DR.  S.K KHATRY  DIRECTOR  NNIPS 

116  MS.  SABA MEBRAHTU  CHIEF NUTRITION  UNICEF 

117  MS.  SABNAM SHIVAKOTI     MOAC 

118  MS. SAHARAH MOON CHAPOTIN     USAID 

120  MS.  SARAH NISCHALKE     UNIVERSITY COLLEGE 

121  MS.  SHANDA STEIMER  DIRECTOR  USAID 

122  DR.  SHARAD ONTA  PROFESSOR  IOM 

123  MS.  SHARADA PANDEY  SPHA  MOHP 

124  DR.  SHIBA KUMAR RAI  HON. MEMBER  NPC 

125  DR. SHIDDI GANESH SHRESTHA  PROGRAM DIRECTOR 

DIRECTORATE OF AG.EXTENSION 

126  MS.  SHIKHA BASNET  FREELANCER    

127  MR.  SHREERAM NEUPANE  LECTURER  GOLDENGATE COLLEGE 

128  MR.  SHROCHIS KARKI  D.PHIL. STUDENT  OXFORD UNIVERSITY 

129  MR.  SHUBH MAHATO  COUNTRY DIRECTOR  HEIFER 

130  MS.  SOPHIYA UPRETY  PROGRAM OFFICER  WFP 

131  MR.  STEVE LECLERQ  FIELD DIRECTOR/JHUREP  NNIPS/JHU 

132  MS.  STUTI BASNYET     USAID 

133  DR.  SUDEEP SHRESTHA  FELLOW  JHU 

134  MS.  SUMI DEVKOTA  CONSULTANT  DAI 

135  MR.  SUMIT KARN  NPC  NS/CHD 

136  MS.  SUNEETHA KADIYALA  RESEARCH FELLOW  IFPRI 

137  DR.  SUNILA RAI  ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR  IAAS 

138  MR.  SURYA P. PAUDEL  SR. LIVESTOCK OFFICER  MUAC 

139  MS.  SUSHILA RISAL  MOH LIAISON OFFICER  NTAG/CHD 

140  MS.  SWETHA MANOHAR  RESEARCH ASSOCIATE  JHSPH 

141  DR.  TIRTHA RANA  FREELANCER    

Page 60: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

60

142  DR.  TRISHNA SHARMA  DOCTOR    

143  MR. TUYU NARAYAN PACHHAI  IEC OFFICER  NTAG 

144  MR.  Y.B.THAPA  TEAM LEADER  FNSP 

145  MS.  ZARIN A .PRADHAN  M&E  USAID EIG 

Page 61: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

61

REFERENCES

1. NepalDemographicandHealthSurvey2011(DHS).,2011,MacroInc&NewEra.2. WHO.CountryHealthSystemProfile.2007[cited2012April30];Availablefrom:

http://www.searo.who.int/LinkFiles/Country_Health_System_Profile_8‐Nepal.pdf.3. FAO,Guidingprinciplesforlinkingagricultureandnutrition:Synthesisfrom10development

institutions,2012,FAO.4. JefLLeroy,M.R.,ElenVerhofstadt,DeannaOlneyTheMicronutirentImpactofMultisectoral

ProgramfocusingonNutrition:Examplesfromconditionalcashtransfer,microcreditwitheducationandagriculturalprograms.2008.

5. Frost,M.B.,R.Forste,andD.W.Haas,MaternaleducationandchildnutritionalstatusinBolivia:findingthelinks.SocSciMed,2005.60(2):p.395‐407.

6. Sazawal,S.,etal.,EffectsoffortifiedmilkonmorbidityinyoungchildreninnorthIndia:communitybased,randomised,doublemaskedplacebocontrolledtrial.BMJ,2007.334(7585):p.140.

7. Stewart,C.P.,etal.,Antenatalsupplementationwithfolicacid+iron+zincimproveslineargrowthandreducesperipheraladiposityinschool‐agechildreninruralNepal.AmJClinNutr,2009.90(1):p.132‐40.

8. Christian,P.,etal.,SupplementationwithmicronutrientsinadditiontoironandfolicaciddoesnotfurtherimprovethehematologicstatusofpregnantwomeninruralNepal.JNutr,2003.133(11):p.3492‐8.

9. Christian,P.,etal.,EffectsofalternativematernalmicronutrientsupplementsonlowbirthweightinruralNepal:doubleblindrandomisedcommunitytrial.BMJ,2003.326(7389):p.571.

10. Christian,P.,etal.,AntenatalandpostnatalironsupplementationandchildhoodmortalityinruralNepal:aprospectivefollow‐upinarandomized,controlledcommunitytrial.AmJEpidemiol,2009.170(9):p.1127‐36.

11. Christian,P.,etal.,Prenatalmicronutrientsupplementationandintellectualandmotorfunctioninearlyschool‐agedchildreninNepal.JAMA,2010.304(24):p.2716‐23.

12. Gittelsohn,J.,Openingthebox:intrahouseholdfoodallocationinruralNepal.SocSciMed,1991.33(10):p.1141‐54.

13. Shankar,A.V.,etal.,EatingfromasharedplateaffectsfoodconsumptioninvitaminA‐deficientNepalichildren.JNutr,1998.128(7):p.1127‐33.

14. LoraIannotti,K.C.,MarieRuel,Improvingdietqualityandmicronutrientnutrition:HomesteadfoodproductioninBangladesh,inIFPRIdiscussionpapers9282009.

15. Brandt,K.,Planthealth,soilfertilityrelationshipsandfoodquality.FAO,2007.16. ChristensenLP,H.‐M.J.,HansenSL,HaraldsdóttirJ,JespersenL,PurupS,KharazmiA,

BarkholtV,FrøkiærH&Kobæk‐LarsenMHealthpromotingcompoundsinvegetablesandfruits.Asystematicapproachforidentifyingplantcomponentswithimpactonhumanhealth.TrendsFoodSci.Techno,2004.15(15):p.384‐393.

17. West,K.P.,Jr.,etal.,EfficacyofvitaminAinreducingpreschoolchildmortalityinNepal.Lancet,1991.338(8759):p.67‐71.

18. Daulaire,N.M.,etal.,ChildhoodmortalityafterahighdoseofvitaminAinahighriskpopulation.BMJ,1992.304(6821):p.207‐10.

19. Schmitz,J.,etal.,VitaminAsupplementationinpreschoolchildrenandriskofhearinglossasadolescentsandyoungadultsinruralNepal:randomisedtrialcohortfollow‐upstudy.BMJ,2012.344:p.d7962.

20. Klemm,R.D.,etal.,NewbornvitaminAsupplementationreducedinfantmortalityinruralBangladesh.Pediatrics,2008.122(1):p.e242‐50.

Page 62: Scientific Symposium Proceedings Final Draft - K4Health · SCIENTIFIC SYMPOSIUM March 21 ... phases and conduct of this event. ... These represent critical steps towards

62

21. Rahmathullah,L.,etal.,ImpactofsupplementingnewborninfantswithvitaminAonearlyinfantmortality:communitybasedrandomisedtrialinsouthernIndia.BMJ,2003.327(7409):p.254.

22. Humphrey,J.H.,etal.,ImpactofneonatalvitaminAsupplementationoninfantmorbidityandmortality.TheJournalofpediatrics,1996.128(4):p.489‐96.

23. West,K.P.,Jr.,etal.,Doubleblind,clusterrandomisedtrialoflowdosesupplementationwithvitaminAorbetacaroteneonmortalityrelatedtopregnancyinNepal.TheNNIPS‐2StudyGroup.BMJ,1999.318(7183):p.570‐5.

24. Christian,P.,etal.,Maternalnightblindnessincreasesriskofmortalityinthefirst6monthsoflifeamonginfantsinNepal.TheJournalofnutrition,2001.131(5):p.1510‐2.

25. Christian,P.,etal.,VitaminAorbeta‐carotenesupplementationreducesbutdoesnoteliminatematernalnightblindnessinNepal.TheJournalofnutrition,1998.128(9):p.1458‐63.

26. Katz,J.,etal.,Maternallow‐dosevitaminAorbeta‐carotenesupplementationhasnoeffectonfetallossandearlyinfantmortality:arandomizedclustertrialinNepal.TheAmericanjournalofclinicalnutrition,2000.71(6):p.1570‐6.

27. Checkley,W.,etal.,MaternalvitaminAsupplementationandlungfunctioninoffspring.TheNewEnglandjournalofmedicine,2010.362(19):p.1784‐94.

28. Massaro,D.andG.D.Massaro,Lungdevelopment,lungfunction,andretinoids.TheNewEnglandjournalofmedicine,2010.362(19):p.1829‐31.

29. Christian,P.,etal.,NightblindnessofpregnancyinruralNepal‐‐nutritionalandhealthrisks.Internationaljournalofepidemiology,1998.27(2):p.231‐7.

30. Christian,P.,etal.,NightblindnessduringpregnancyandsubsequentmortalityamongwomeninNepal:effectsofvitaminAandbeta‐carotenesupplementation.Americanjournalofepidemiology,2000.152(6):p.542‐7.

31. Jiang,T.,etal.,Micronutrientdeficienciesinearlypregnancyarecommon,concurrent,andvarybyseasonamongruralNepalipregnantwomen.TheJournalofnutrition,2005.135(5):p.1106‐12.

32. Christian,P.,etal.,Effectsofmaternalmicronutrientsupplementationonfetallossandinfantmortality:acluster‐randomizedtrialinNepal.TheAmericanjournalofclinicalnutrition,2003.78(6):p.1194‐202.

33. Stewart,C.P.,etal.,Antenatalmicronutrientsupplementationreducesmetabolicsyndromein6‐to8‐year‐oldchildreninruralNepal.TheJournalofnutrition,2009.139(8):p.1575‐81.

34. Christian,P.,etal.,Prenatalmicronutrientsupplementationandintellectualandmotorfunctioninearlyschool‐agedchildreninNepal.JAMA:thejournaloftheAmericanMedicalAssociation,2010.304(24):p.2716‐23.

35. Tielsch,J.M.,etal.,EffectofdailyzincsupplementationonchildmortalityinsouthernNepal:acommunity‐based,clusterrandomised,placebo‐controlledtrial.Lancet,2007.370(9594):p.1230‐9.

36. WHO/UNICEF,Clinicalmanagementofacutediarrhea,2004,UnitedNationsChildren’sFundandtheWorldHealthOrganization:Geneva,Switzerland.

37. Mullany,L.C.,etal.,Breast‐feedingpatterns,timetoinitiation,andmortalityriskamongnewbornsinsouthernNepal.TheJournalofnutrition,2008.138(3):p.599‐603.

38. Shankar,A.V.,etal.,EatingfromasharedplateaffectsfoodconsumptioninvitaminA‐deficientNepalichildren.TheJournalofnutrition,1998.128(7):p.1127‐33.