Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of...

23
Science and Poli,cs Erika Hamden July 24 th , 2017 Carnegie Observatories

Transcript of Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of...

Page 1: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

ScienceandPoli,cs

ErikaHamdenJuly24th,2017

CarnegieObservatories

Page 2: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

WhydoesanyofthismaEer?

Page 3: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

WhydoesanyofthismaEer?

Page 4: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

WhydoesanyofthismaEer?

Page 5: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

WhydoesanyofthismaEer?

WashingtonPost

Page 6: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

PopQuiz!

1.Areyouregisteredtovote?

Page 7: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

PopQuiz!

1.  Areyouregisteredtovote?2.  Whoisyourcongressperson?Whatdistrict

doyouvotein?

Page 8: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

PopQuiz!

1.  Areyouregisteredtovote?2.  Whoisyourcongressperson?Whatdistrict

doyouvotein?

3.  Whoareyoursenators?

Page 9: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

PopQuiz!

1.  Areyouregisteredtovote?2.  Whoisyourcongressperson?Whatdistrict

doyouvotein?

3.  Whoareyoursenators?

4.  Whorepresentsyouatthestatelevel?Onyourtowncouncil?

Page 10: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

Poli,calac,onforci,zens

•  Knowwhoyourrepsareandcontactthemonaregularbasis.Everyday,everyweek.

•  hEps://whoaremyrepresenta,ves.org/

Page 11: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer
Page 12: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer
Page 13: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

Contac,ngelectedofficials

•  YOUROPINIONMATTERS!Youhaveavoice.

•  Youcanvisittheofficetoo!!

•  Callabout1issueata,me.

•  Makearequest,askforanac,on.

•  CallsaretalliedandprovidedtotheMember

•  Localandstateofficesgethardlyanycalls!

•  Callevenifyourrepresenta,veagreeswithyou!•  Howtoknowwhatrequesttomake?

Page 14: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

Whattoaskabout

•  Youdon’thavetohaveananswer.•  Organiza,onslike:hEps://5calls.org/•  OrhEps://www.ourstates.org/•  Providescriptsbasedonissue•  Butthinkofyourownissues!WhatdoyoucareaboutandwanttoseemadebeEer?

•  AIPhasaweeklynewsleEercalledFYI,aboutsciencepolicy,whichisveryinforma,ve.

•  Youcanalsoprovidecommentstodepartmentsandagenciesduringtheirpubliccommentperiod

Page 15: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

Beingascien,stintheworld

•  Youhavearesponsibilitytospeakout-eitherthroughoutreachevents,wri,ngar,cles/leEerstotheeditor,interac,ngwithregularpeople.

•  Theriseof“fakenews”,denial-ismofvariouskinds,aretreatfromfactdrivenpolicy,isacrisisthatscien,stscanfightagainst.

•  Knowtherhetoricaldevicesusedtoderailaconversa,on:TheGishGallop,gasligh,ng,whatabou,sm,andothers

•  Aswithmanythings,CarlSaganwroteaboutthisin“TheDemonHauntedWorld”,inachaptercalled“TheFineArtofBaloneyDetec,on”

Page 16: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

Tellastory

Page 17: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

PublicNarra,ve

•  DevelopedbyMarshallGanz-organizerforUnitedFarmWorkers,nowatHarvard.

•  Appealstoac,onviaemo,on,notnecessarilyfacts.

•  Summarizedas:Storyofself,storyofus,storyofnow.

Page 18: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

PublicNarra,ve:Crea,ngastoryofself

•  Whatisthechangeyouwanttomakeintheworld:yourstoryofnow?

•  Whyareyoucalledtomakethatchange:Whatspecificexperienceshaveshapedyourstoryofself?

•  Whatpersonalstorycanyoutellthatwillhelpothersunderstandwhyyouwanttomakethatchange?StructureitwithChallenge,Choice,Outcome.

Page 19: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

PublicNarra,ve:Expandtostoryofus

•  “IstandhereknowingthatmystoryispartofthelargerAmericanstory.”–BarackObama,2004DNCspeech

•  “IfIamnotformyself,whowillbeforme?IfIamformyselfalone,whatamI?Ifnotnow,when?”–RabbiHillel,quotedbyMarshallGanz

Page 20: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

PublicNarra,ve:Storyofnow

Page 21: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

Standontheshouldersofgiants

•  Therearemanysuccessfulmovementsyoucanlearnfrom-studywhatothershavedoneandusetheirlessonstocrahyourownmessage.

•  Joinupwithgroupsthatalreadyexistorarenewlyformed.

•  Takeupspaceintheworld-beasloudasthepeoplewhowouldopposeyou.

Page 22: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

NoonewantstobeagainstScience

•  Pickatopicyoucareaboutandfocusonit•  SignupforAAScongressionalvisitdaysandothercongressionalvisitopportuni,es

•  Invitestafferstovisityourcampusandlabs,developprofessionalrela,onshipswiththemifpossible.

•  ContactyourofficeofGovernmentRela,onsandseehowyoucanworkwiththemforbeEerresults

•  Personalstoriesaremorepersuasivethanfactsalone!

Page 23: Science and Poli,cs · “The Demon Haunted World”, in a chapter called “The Fine Art of Baloney Detec,on” Tell a story Public Narrave • Developed by Marshall Ganz- organizer

Runforoffice!

•  Everypersoninthisroomshouldconsiderrunningforpublicoffice.

•  Thereareabunchofgroupsthatexisttohelpyou!


You’re Such a Phony Baloney!”

You’re Such a Phony Baloney!”

evaluation of electrochemical impedance techniques for detec

evaluation of electrochemical impedance techniques for detec

Document Title prego services - DETEC

Document Title prego services - DETEC

Fire Related Crime Investigation and Detec. Course

Fire Related Crime Investigation and Detec. Course

Ueda2015 early detec of dm dr.ihab salem

Ueda2015 early detec of dm dr.ihab salem

AselfcalibrangreceiverforEOR detec-on - caastro.org · AselfcalibrangreceiverforEOR detec-on ... keith.bannister@csiro.au" 24Aug2012" CSIROASTRONOMYANDSPACESCIENCE(CASS)" • Alex"Dunning

AselfcalibrangreceiverforEOR detec-on - caastro.org · AselfcalibrangreceiverforEOR detec-on ... [email protected]" 24Aug2012" CSIROASTRONOMYANDSPACESCIENCE(CASS)" • Alex"Dunning

2 LDO Regulat or with Voltage Detector and Watchdog …rohmfs.rohm.com/en/products/databook/datasheet-nrnd/ic/power/... · e reset detec ing resistors n be used as s while detec OS

2 LDO Regulat or with Voltage Detector and Watchdog …rohmfs.rohm.com/en/products/databook/datasheet-nrnd/ic/power/... · e reset detec ing resistors n be used as s while detec OS

Information Architecture is Baloney

Information Architecture is Baloney

LAURA MULVEY – MALE GAZE Visual Pleasures & Narrave … · LAURA MULVEY – MALE GAZE Visual Pleasures & Narrave Cinema 1973 • Women in cinema reflect back the gaze of a male

LAURA MULVEY – MALE GAZE Visual Pleasures & Narrave … · LAURA MULVEY – MALE GAZE Visual Pleasures & Narrave Cinema 1973 • Women in cinema reflect back the gaze of a male

metal gas detec robo

metal gas detec robo

VSPMiner: Detec

VSPMiner: Detec

Lecture9 Detec Tors

Lecture9 Detec Tors

Detec Cancer

Detec Cancer

Real%Time)Detec-on)and)Tracking)) …ee225b/sp14/lectures/Presentation_AR.pdfReal%Time)Detec-on)and)Tracking)) for)Augmented)Reality)on)Mobile)Phones))) D.)Wagner,)A.)Mulloni)and)D.)Schmals-eg)

Real%Time)Detec-on)and)Tracking)) …ee225b/sp14/lectures/Presentation_AR.pdfReal%Time)Detec-on)and)Tracking)) for)Augmented)Reality)on)Mobile)Phones))) D.)Wagner,)A.)Mulloni)and)D.)Schmals-eg)

Annual Report 2002 Rheinmetall DeTec AGir.rheinmetall.com/download/companies/rheinmetall/Annual Reports/… · Rheinmetall DeTec at a glance 1) German Commercial Code as primary accounting

Annual Report 2002 Rheinmetall DeTec AGir.rheinmetall.com/download/companies/rheinmetall/Annual Reports/… · Rheinmetall DeTec at a glance 1) German Commercial Code as primary accounting

Walk Through Metal Detec tor s27-isimattelecom.com/assets/docs/thruscan/2_ThruScan-S27-i.pdf · s27-i Walk Through Metal Detec tor ECAC NILECJ 6 CE EMC TSE ISO features... •International

Walk Through Metal Detec tor s27-isimattelecom.com/assets/docs/thruscan/2_ThruScan-S27-i.pdf · s27-i Walk Through Metal Detec tor ECAC NILECJ 6 CE EMC TSE ISO features... •International

Telling the Difference Between Baloney and Serious Claims About What Works Martin Kozloff.

Telling the Difference Between Baloney and Serious Claims About What Works Martin Kozloff.

SAN MATEO COUNTY - smcgov.org · Jeff Garibaldi Ray Locke Ione Yuen Mike Garibaldi Kelly Mayer Pest Detec on Supervisor Gerardo Ibarra Jr. Pest Detec on Specialists Jonathan Asbury

SAN MATEO COUNTY - smcgov.org · Jeff Garibaldi Ray Locke Ione Yuen Mike Garibaldi Kelly Mayer Pest Detec on Supervisor Gerardo Ibarra Jr. Pest Detec on Specialists Jonathan Asbury

See our Baloney Detection Kit, below. - Peters Chemical

See our Baloney Detection Kit, below. - Peters Chemical

SlidesbyJeffreyD.Ullman · Highdim. data Locality) sensive) hashing) Clustering) Dimensional ity) reducon) Graph’’ data PageRank,) SimRank) Community) Detec-on) Spam) Detec-on)

SlidesbyJeffreyD.Ullman · Highdim. data Locality) sensive) hashing) Clustering) Dimensional ity) reducon) Graph’’ data PageRank,) SimRank) Community) Detec-on) Spam) Detec-on)