Sales and Use Tax Reserve Strategies Under Latest SEC...
Transcript of Sales and Use Tax Reserve Strategies Under Latest SEC...
Sales and Use Tax Reserve Strategies
Under Latest SEC Orders and Guidance Best Practices for Setting Reserves Amid Government and Audit Scrutiny
Today’s faculty features:
1pm Eastern | 12pm Central | 11am Mountain | 10am Pacific
Please refer to the instructions emailed to the registrant for the dial-in information.
Attendees can still view the presentation slides online. If you have any questions, please
contact Customer Service at 1-800-926-7926 ext. 10.
TUESDAY, MARCH 12, 2013
Presenting a live 110-minute teleconference with interactive Q&A
William Ault, Director, Crowe Horwath, New York
Myron Vansickel, National Tax Director, Strategic Accounts, Experis, Washington, D.C.
For this program, attendees must listen to the audio over the telephone.
Tips for Optimal Quality
Sound Quality
Call in on the telephone by dialing 1-866-873-1442 and enter your PIN when
prompted.
If you have any difficulties during the call, press *0 for assistance. You may also
send us a chat or e-mail [email protected] immediately so we can address
the problem.
Viewing Quality
To maximize your screen, press the F11 key on your keyboard. To exit full screen,
press the F11 key again.
Continuing Education Credits
Attendees must stay on the line throughout the program, including the Q & A
session, in order to qualify for full continuing education credits. Strafford is
required to monitor attendance.
Record verification codes presented throughout the seminar. If you have not
printed out the “Official Record of Attendance,” please print it now (see
“Handouts” tab in “Conference Materials” box on left-hand side of your computer
screen). To earn Continuing Education credits, you must write down the
verification codes in the corresponding spaces found on the Official Record of
Attendance form.
Please refer to the instructions emailed to the registrant for additional
information. If you have any questions, please contact Customer Service
at 1-800-926-7926 ext. 10.
FOR LIVE EVENT ONLY
Program Materials
If you have not printed the conference materials for this program, please
complete the following steps:
• Click on the + sign next to “Conference Materials” in the middle of the left-
hand column on your screen.
• Click on the tab labeled “Handouts” that appears, and there you will see a
PDF of the slides and the Official Record of Attendance for today's program.
• Double-click on the PDF and a separate page will open.
• Print the slides by clicking on the printer icon.
Sales and Use Tax Reserving Strategies Under Latest SEC Orders and Guidance Seminar
Myron Vansickel, Experis
March 12, 2013
William Ault, Crowe Horwath
Today’s Program
Review Of Material Terms Of ASC 450
[William Ault]
Hypothetical Taxpayer Sales Tax Reserving Scenarios
[Myron Vansickel]
Slide 8 – Slide 20
Slide 21 – Slide 54
Notice
ANY TAX ADVICE IN THIS COMMUNICATION IS NOT INTENDED OR WRITTEN BY
THE SPEAKERS’ FIRMS TO BE USED, AND CANNOT BE USED, BY A CLIENT OR ANY
OTHER PERSON OR ENTITY FOR THE PURPOSE OF (i) AVOIDING PENALTIES THAT
MAY BE IMPOSED ON ANY TAXPAYER OR (ii) PROMOTING, MARKETING OR
RECOMMENDING TO ANOTHER PARTY ANY MATTERS ADDRESSED HEREIN.
You (and your employees, representatives, or agents) may disclose to any and all persons,
without limitation, the tax treatment or tax structure, or both, of any transaction
described in the associated materials we provide to you, including, but not limited to,
any tax opinions, memoranda, or other tax analyses contained in those materials.
The information contained herein is of a general nature and based on authorities that are
subject to change. Applicability of the information to specific situations should be
determined through consultation with your tax adviser.
7
Loss Contingencies: Material Terms
I. Recognition
- Probable, reasonably probable and remote
- Estimable
- What is a liability and what is a loss contingency?
II. Measurement rules and an estimated range of loss
III. Disclosure rules: Probable and reasonably possible
contingencies
IV. Recent end to FASB’s project on loss contingency disclosure
requirements
9
Recognition Of A Loss Contingency
An estimated loss from a loss contingency shall be accrued by a
charge to income if both of the following conditions are met:
a. Information available prior to issuance of the financial
statements indicates that it is probable that an asset had been
impaired or a liability had been incurred at the date of the
financial statements. It is implicit in this condition that it must be
probable that one or more future events will occur confirming the
fact of the loss.
b. The amount of loss can be reasonably estimated.
10
Probable, Reasonably Possible Or Remote?
Probable: The future event or events are likely to occur.
Reasonably possible: The chance of the future event or events
occurring is more than remote but less than likely.
Remote: The chance of the future event or events occurring is
slight.
12
Can The Amount Of The Loss Be Reasonably Estimated?
The requirement that the loss be reasonably estimable is intended
to prevent accrual in the financial statements of amounts so
uncertain as to impair the integrity of those statements.
Disclosure is preferable to accrual when a reasonable estimate of
loss cannot be made.
Does it relate to the current period or a prior period?
13
Loss Contingency Vs. Liability
A loss contingency is defined as an existing condition, situation or
set of circumstances involving uncertainty as to possible loss to an
enterprise that will ultimately be resolved when one or more
future events occur or fail to occur.
Amounts owed are not contingencies even though the accrued
amounts may have been estimated. There is nothing uncertain
about the fact that those obligations have been incurred.
14
Measurement Of A Loss Contingency
When both of the recognition criteria are met, and the reasonably
estimable loss is a range, accrual is required of:
- The amount that appears to be a better estimate than any other
estimate within the range, or
- The minimum amount in the range, if no amount within the
range is a better estimate than any other amount.
15
Disclosure When A Loss Contingency Is Not Recognized
Disclosure of the contingency shall be made when there is at least
a reasonable possibility that a loss or an additional loss may have
been incurred.
The disclosure shall indicate the nature of the contingency and
shall give an estimate of the possible loss or range of loss, or
state that such an estimate cannot be made.
16
Disclosure When A Loss Contingency Is Not Recognized (Cont.)
Disclosure is not required of a loss contingency involving an
unasserted claim or assessment, when there has been no
manifestation by a potential claimant of an awareness of a
possible claim or assessment, unless:
- It is considered probable that a claim will be asserted, and
- There is a reasonable possibility that the outcome will be
unfavorable.
Information may become available indicating that an asset was
impaired or a liability was incurred after the date of the financial
statements, or that there is at least a reasonable possibility that
an asset was impaired or a liability was incurred after that date.
17
The FASB’s Loss Contingency Disclosure Project Ends
Decision reached at the July 9, 2012 board meeting:
The staff summarized its outreach with regulators and provided a
short review of the feedback received on the two previous
exposure drafts. The staff posed the question to the board as to
whether the project should remain on the agenda, and if so what
the next steps are. The board voted 5-2 to remove the project
from the agenda, with no further action.
18
Scope Of FASB July 2012 Invitation To Comment
The invitation to comment applies only to notes to financial
statements. It does not address parts of a financial report outside
of financial statements, such as management’s discussion and
analysis (MD&A).
The invitation to comment applies to financial statements of
public and non-public entities.
20
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450
Sales and use tax reserves have come under more scrutiny as a result of the enactment of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act and pressure on state and local jurisdictions to raise revenue. The SEC is now following up on contingent liabilities as well. Senior management has become aware of internal controls to understand what is in each reserve, and sales and use taxes have greater visibility before the C-suite now.
22
Nexus Reviews
Regarding nexus, as it relates to the level of activities a business performs within a given state and meaning a connection such that the taxpayer enjoys state benefits such as courts, fire and police protection
- Review what activities a state dictates that create nexus for sales tax collection and/or use tax payments
- Review business expansion plans, when possible, in order to be proactive on identifying new states where nexus has been created
- Nexus meaning a connection to the State where the taxpayer in is enjoying the benefits the State has to offer, such as, the state courts, fire and police protection.
23
Voluntary Disclosure Programs
The majority of states use voluntary disclosure agreement (VDA) programs that allow an unregistered taxpayer to present itself to resolve outstanding tax liabilities. These programs usually allow for a limited lookback period for taxes, and may limit interest and waive penalties.
Review each state’s program to understand what its requirements are, and if interest is capped and/or penalties waived
Also, be aware of what taxes are available to resolve under a VDA. Most commonly, income/franchise and sales/use taxes qualify. Other taxes may be included, but be aware that when you apply for one tax, the taxing authorities may ask if you have complied with all taxes due and owed to their state.
24
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
Corporation V Corporation V is a publicly traded media and printing company with
$2 billion of annual revenue. In 1999, it was composed of 35 U.S. companies with three major business lines. The consolidated financial statements showed a $7 million ASC 450 sales/use tax contingency. Of that figure, $6.7 million was related to sales tax. Annual additions to the reserve were close to $1 million.
26
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
Where do you start the analysis to determine whether this reserve is
adequate for potential exposure?
What caused this reserve to grow?
Should this reserve be greater or less?
27
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
Information-gathering is the first step. After reviewing prior sales and use
tax audits, it was determined that the majority of assessments were for sales tax on products; then came use tax on purchases of supplies and fixed assets.
28
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
The first areas to review were the order entry, sales tax rates, sales tax determination, and the computation module and billing system.
The process was to determine how product codes were set up as either taxable or non-taxable.
29
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
It was discovered that the taxpayer had three different ERP systems, which
had varying degrees of sophistication regarding their abilities to tax the companies’ products correctly.
30
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
The largest ERP system was reviewed to determine the level of compliance. It
was determined that there were several disconnects within the system, and the tax and IT staffs would have to identify issues and resolve them together. This was an older version of tax software in which coding changes needed to be implemented to make tax corrections.
31
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
The other two ERP systems had both similar and dissimilar issues related to taxing products.
Issues were identified, and then plans were implemented to resolve these issues.
32
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
New versions of sales tax software now allow the company tax department to make the tax determinations directly, due to the data basis nature. This eliminates IT maintenance time and allows for timely changes within the system.
33
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
Corrective action plan:
Re-compute the reserve requirements on what was learned and use this as the benchmark to measure improvement
A product code matrix was developed that included all other separately stated invoice items, e.g. shipping costs.
34
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
Review the matrix and add a taxable or non-taxable column
Reference appropriate tax research to support the tax determination
Review this matrix with what was already in the system, and prepare a corrective action plan
35
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
The tax department continued to investigate whether the company was filing
in all jurisdictions where it had created nexus, for sales tax purposes. This required reviewing the business operations, including the sales force, to
determine what activities were occurring that might create nexus for collection responsibilities.
36
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
After coming up with a revised list of taxing jurisdictions, tax met with the legal department to determine where the company should be registered to “do business” and register for sales tax collection.
37
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
Subsequently, with the legal department’s and CFO’s support, the tax
department became the clearinghouse for determining where the company needed to qualify to do business and register for sales and use taxes.
38
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
This meant that every time a new home office or new state needed to be established, for payroll purposes, the tax department was notified and investigated if nexus was created. The tax department initiated all registrations for taxes, whether payroll or sales/use, through the legal department. This kept the tax department immediately in the know about any business change that would affect sales and use tax collection.
39
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
The next phase was to implement the necessary changes for sales tax that arose from errors identified in sales tax audits. This was done via a product code matrix/tax determination process.
40
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
Fixed-asset purchase procedures were reviewed, and use tax accrual procedures were developed and implemented. Printing companies are similar to manufacturers in many aspects, so in several states, their equipment purchases were exempt. However, some states lacked an exemption, so use tax needed to be paid.
42
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
Tax audits were reviewed for the types of expense purchases that were subject to use tax. A taxability matrix was developed, similar to the product code/tax determination matrix. This was implemented through the purchasing chain in order to provide for appropriate accrual of use taxes.
43
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
The tax department developed use tax accrual worksheets that included the appropriate use tax rates, to facilitate the accrual process. Although manual, they did provide a mechanism to facilitate compliance.
44
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
The tax department implemented policies and procedures regarding company purchases, in order to take advantage of resale and manufacturing exemptions where applicable.
45
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
The tax department, along with the sales force, reviewed customer files to validate whether the customer should complete a resale certificate or an exemption certificate.
46
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
Policies and procedures were then implemented in the sales-ordering
process, in order to obtain appropriate documentation from each new customer. Annual reviews of customer files were performed to make sure that valid resale and exemption documentation were maintained.
47
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
The company’s reserve dropped to less than $500,000 within five years, based on the implementation and review of controls. Annually, steps taken reduced the cost of audits by about $900,000. That is a dollar-for-dollar pick-up to the bottom line.
48
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
Information needed to calculate the ASC 450 sales/use tax reserves:
Remember that your company may have nexus issues, and that the statute of limitations do not run in a taxing jurisdiction until you have filed returns.
I. Listing of all taxing jurisdictions where the entities have sales/use tax nexus
II. Date the business began operating in these taxing jurisdictions
49
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
• Listing of the statute of limitations for each taxing jurisdiction
• Date of registration in each jurisdiction
• Starting dates when returns were first filed in each jurisdiction
• Copies of all sales and use tax audits settlements for the past five years, and any current issues from ongoing audits
• Develop a spreadsheet to incorporate all this information
50
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
Review the audit settlements and determine if corrective action was taken, and the time period during which any action was taken
Calculate whether there was a unresolved time period for which an error was noted in an audit
51
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
Calculate the potential tax for each tax uncertainty for a time period that is still open under the statute of limitation
Accrue the tax calculated in the reserve
52
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
Update your reserve monthly, as new uncertainties are uncovered and a month of the statute of limitations rolls off
This will be the basis of your reserve analysis
53
Case Study: Application Of ASC 450 (Cont.)
Sales Tax Accrual Analysis - A/C 000-000-0000
6/30/2009
Tax
Estimat
ed Total Average Projected
Audit Amount Date Unpaid Audit
No.
Of Audit Next
Aud
it Open Monthly Reserve
Period Paid Paid Amount Liability Status
Aud
its Liability
Assessme
nt
Peri
od
Period
s
Assessme
nt Accrual
California Jan-84 - Mar-87 352,653 0 352,653 Final 1 36
Jul-87 - Dec-90 450,000 0 450,000 Final 2 36
Jan-91 - Dec-94
1,152,45
5 0
1,152,45
5 Final 3 651,703 36
Jan-95 - Dec-97 80,000 Final 4 508,777 36
Jan-98 - May-98 Lapsed 5
Apr-98 - Dec-00 333,833 10/01/02 Final 5 473,788 33
Jan-01 97,692 Self audit 36
Sep-04 93,511 01/01/06 Final 6 426,691 9
Oct-04 Dec-07 126,600 05/01/09 Final 7 36
Jan-08 Jun-09 Accrual 100,000 36 18 2,778 50,000
54