Room:115Start: 4:30 PMPublic Forum Varsity

S

MSDL STATE DEBATE FINALMar 28 -28,2015

Resolved: ln the United States, students should be guaranteed two years of free tuition to a community or technical college ' Belore every

round, flip a coin. The winner ol the coin llip can either (1) choose to d€bate PRO or CON, or (2) choose to speak firsl or second. The other

team mai<es the remaining choice. After the coin tlip, be sure that the teams are seated in front of you the same way they app€ar on the ballot.

ln particulal make sure the team on the left on your ballot is seated on your lett, and that the team on the right on the ballot is seated toyour right. ldentify who is PRO and CON on the ballot, and which speaker is speaking lirst on each team. BEFORE THE ROUND STARTS -

VERBALLY DOUBLE CHECK THAT YOU HAVE CORRECTLY IDENTIFIED WHICH TEAM IS WHICH.

Other judges on panel: Br. A.K. Cavet, Cheryl Hoffman. Please do not stan until ell iudges are present.

Ehrlich, llya

elL l*.^

rr g ut lL,'

wes{ Ao*qj"l o^ lr,r,,*'o tu olv J

&rrt, rr*5 icoq{.L 0 /*"^-

D,ller"ro {ar"-.t h9-

r"t {f,s l! [l* l(". l- wfhnt*l o'- llul,t u.,t*

Ir

^1d .h r{.,t f(o

..lo So-g [,b ol,lL*J

o.r$u. u,*J /[ -.J rl\,,/SDeech Times:

f,, elvco l, ou,

/osv q, l,\

J- & l,wol " olls:t,/t_a\9ol* l,o,^ c dr\ , ,fo. l,oll1 o{+rq

th

hOYI u s [.]-^-

l t, o* -

lt lrit Scele:

Use whole or half points 23 to 3030: Truly amazing - top 3 Pct29: Fantastic - top 10 Pct28: Very good - top 25 Pct27: Solid debater - top half26: Still learning but with potential

25: Nafl at debate Yet trYing24: Unprepared or unable toexpress ideas23: Rude or unprofessional (rare,

explain on ballot)

Ce* -[*r,-

pl* r^

h.A

d,lL*-J u-{

* ln,

,lP.= {.^,^-

oe{tr,n^ l, r"+.

a.L c

U-

..p t..0 Construclive (Spkrs A1 & 81):4 min - Team A4 min - Team BCross-x: 3 minRehrttal (Spkrs A2 & B2):Team A:4 minTeam B:4 minCross-x: 3 minSummary (Spkrs A1 & 81):Team A: 2 minTeam B:2 minGrand cross: 3 min (all spkrs)Final Focus (Spkrs A2 & B2):Team A:2 minTeam B: 2 minq..t

Printed by Tabroom.com, Free Online Tournament Management

^ P-' /rr,r!,

Page 2 of 3

Room:115Start:4:30 PMPublic Forum Varsity

MSDL STATE DEBATE FINALMar 28'28,2015

Resolved: ln the United States, students should be guaranteed two years of lree tuition to a community or technic,al college . Before every

round, llip a coin. The winner oi the coin flip can eith6r (1) choose to debate PRO or CON, or (2) choose to speak first or second. The other

team mai<es the remaining choice. Atter the coin flip, be sure that the teams are seated in front of you the same way they appear on the ballot.

ln particular, make sure iie team on the left on your ballot is seated on your left, and that the team on the right on the ballot is seated to

your right. tdentify who is pRO and CON on the battot, and which speakei is speaking_first on each team. BEFORE THE ROUND STARTS -

VrneALLv DoUbLE cHECK THAT YoU HAvE coRREcTLY IDENTIFIED wHICH TEAM lS WHICH.

,t^ t* ZuA ++l^Lexington BL (Bozkaya & Lee) vs Waring MK (Malley & Kelly)

Debaters shoutd ttip for sides. Please mark entry designations by side on the lines below

,'-c\i..----o+o7\ ru $LPRO

ltJ^,rl^z M KcoN

?KO

signature: . ', {Y){ ""n".t,

Rolfon L*t"^o Scl''*l.please chair this round. Other iudges on panel: llya Ehrlich, Cheryl Hoffman. Please do not start until all iudges are prosent'

11,,n VKo te^,^ gvrceess{,Jly a,rgu€h'+4:,* (t^ee- +l*LtLo',, * ctunulu^;A

c-olI e je w,ll vt1 (b{"s{g-( e+tfol I nt e",t

soei -1 cts a wluols , leo/ +- hii'i,.*

\l *e0..^lr

E fo 9 tv'e

ezXa,-"-p le ttue elucti)1t e\l

"t

S*Gavet, Br. A.K.

winner: lexiwqko^ PL debatingontheSchool/Ieam Side (PRO or CON)

i.n /.vvw,e- ,

lLe. C-n

C8\c/^e+ev,s.f6m,

tq czv-,e-a5e e-J.uc *tL^ I z rtl +. +AL

golnt S€le:Use whole or hall points 23 to 3030: Truly amazing - top 3 pct29: Fantastic - top 10 pct28: Very good - top 25 pct27: Solid debater - top half26: Still learning hrt with potential25: New at debate yel trying24: Unprepared or unable toexpress ideas23: Rude or unprofessional (rare,explain on ballot)

Speech Tlmes:

Constructive (Spkrs A1 & 81):4 min - Team A4 min - Team BCross-x: 3 minReMtal (Spkrs A2 & B2):Team A:4 minTeam B:4 minCross-x: 3 minSummary (Spkrs Al & 81):Team A:2 minTeam B:2 minGrand cross: 3 min (all spkrs)Final Focus (Spkrs A2 & B2):Team A:2 minTeam B:2 min

Printed by Tabroom.com, Free Online Tournament Management. Page 1 of3

Room: 1 15

Stari: 4:30 PMPublic Forum Varsity

MSDL STATE DEBATE FINALMar 28 - 28,2015

Resolv€d: ln the unit€d States, students should be guaranl€ed two years ol lree tuition lo a communily or technical coll€ge . Betor€ everyround, llip a coin. The wlnner ol the coin llip can either (1) chooso to debate PRO or CON, or (2) choose io speak tirst or second. Th€ oth€rteam makes lhe remaining choice. Atler lhe coin flip, be sure that lhe leams are sealed in lront ol you th6 same way they app€ar on the ballot.ln particular, make sure th€ t€am on the left on your ballot is sealed on your l€ft, and that the team on the right on the ballot is seated toyour right. ldenlity who is PRO and CON on the ballot. and which speakor is speaking first on each learn. BEFORE THE ROUND STARTS -

\ vErLY DOUBLE CHECK THAT yOU HAVE CORRECTLY tDENT|FtED WHTCH TEAM lS WHtCH.

: lq'Y,'"''1[.[,:::J?3;ii]ir!::lr,.ry1rr9ylff"rlev.a Karv), \ . r-/at , I oeUte.s srro ukl ttip br sides. Ptease nE* entty .lesignetions W side on the tines betox.

'.af \ry[7 k&ut^, l,Uc-,, ^--\\.)\-/ #

Othq] ludges on paneli Br. A.K. Cavot, flya Ehr ch. please do not sta.t until all iudgos aro p.esent.

Ll,wUtuI^

trNXv\X-^: -- t J

U'r I I ^ - 4 /)Mit^L'[f ytu."- WG1* ^""r .L +1'-d \o-4&Nc'r [t

a,\<* ,,i* t-. ur-^ v*v'iJ*{ \9^^(Lry^}-

ry,NWffi' ^#\/-4-,( l^ //v-24-14t'/tL ,)\ , ,

h[* 'on^ "'1 *C'frJ

WM/-41 t''\t UU'Lt.'i 4;#";t t (14 (**lXZ:":

<--t^W r ) ''4'.r\,.-li,Hi

L2*\'r^4- t ), N " I F:'":F;

m^re'trfiF.li"'a^-f*rfrPrint€d by Tabroom.com, Free Online Tournamonl Managemenl.

S Hoffman, Cheryl

lolx^. e*AAUr{- {,,,'U

0 sion"r,,",

'I-w4t11,-1,,

+vz"!^0.^S

"^'ffit-r#w#t w^kt{-,"^

F. (.".[,:lJse whole or hatt points 23lo 3030: Truly amazing - lop 3 pct29: Fartaslic - top 10 pct28: Very good - top 25 pcr27: Solid detatsr - top halt25: Stillleaming bul with Dotentiat25: New at debate yet trying24: Unprepared or unabte to

23: Rude or unprolessional (rare,€xplain on ballot)

Constructive (Spkrs A1 & 81):

Rebuttal ispkrs A2 & B2):

Cross'x: 3 minSummary (Spks Al I 81):Team A:2 min

Grand cross: 3 mrn (attspkrs)FinalFoo.js (Soks A2 & 82):Team A:2 min

Page 3 of 3