Ruby Glass Composites

download Ruby Glass Composites

of 23

Transcript of Ruby Glass Composites

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    1/23

    ADiscussiononRubyGlass

    Composites&TheirPotentialImpact

    ontheNomenclatureinusefor

    FractureFilledorClarityEnhanced

    stonesinGeneral

    KennethScarratt

    GIALaboratory,Bangkok

    (FirstlimitedLMHCdistributionFebruary2008)

    Introduction

    Theassociationofrubywithtreatmentsthatresultinanadditionofglasstothefinal

    productbegan in1984withtheappearanceon themarketofThaioriginrubies in

    which cavities had been filled with glass (Kane, 1984, Scarratt, et al., 1984) a

    treatmentthathadevolved intoglasscrackfillingby1987(Hughes,1987,Scarratt,

    1987). In1992withthediscoveryofcorundumdeposits intheareaofMongHsu,

    Burma(Myanmar)thatrequiredhightemperaturefluxheatingregimestobringthe

    material to market the association of ruby treatments and glass was dramatically

    expanded(Hlaing,1993,Kremkow,1993,Laughter,1993,Peretti,1993,Smith,etal.,

    1994). Twentyyearsafterthe firstassociationanewrubyglassassociationanew

    formofglassfracturefilling inrubyappearedonthemarket (GAAJ,2004,Pardieu,

    2005,SmithC.P.,2005,McClure,2006).

    Pardieu (Pardieu, 2005) noted that some terminologyproblemsmayoccurabout

    this treatment regarding to theLeadGlassdefinitionasmanydifferentformulas

    canbeused:Pureleadoxide,leadoxidesmixedwithsilicaorfluxeslikeboraxcanbe

    encountered Temperatures, parameters and result can be very different. Some

    specificstudieswillprobablybedoneinthefutureregardingtothisissue.

    Pardieu (Pardieu, 2005) also witnessed the treatment procedure as performed in

    Chantaburi, Thailand by Master Burner Mahiton Thondisuk and reported that the

    most suitable rubiesfor repairare stoneswith colorpotentialand thatare rich in

    fissures.Hestated further thatthisnew treatment isperformedcurrentlymostly

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    2/23

    on Andilamena rubies (Madagascar) on which Mr. Thondisuk has had extensive

    experiencebutanyrubymaterialwithfissurescouldberepaired.Itisamultistep

    treatment involvingsimpleheatingandtheuseofdifferent leadrichcompoundsto

    fillthefissuresandcavitiesofthestones.Ifmostoftherepairedstonesseenwere

    largesizestones,stoneslessthan1carathavealsobeentreatedthisway.

    WhilePardieudidalludetowidetractsofglasscrossingthesurfaceofexampleshe

    examined in 2004 5 until recently (early 2008) the material observed in

    laboratories1 had an equivalence to treatments applied to clarity enhance

    emeralds (with the use of resins and oils) and diamonds (glass) and therefore the

    terminologyusedwasadaptedfromthese,i.e.,minor,moderateorsignificantclarity

    enhancement. In reality the vast majority fell into the significant clarity

    enhancement category although as McClure (McClure, 2006) points out the

    efficiencyofthetreatmentissuchthatasingle largefracture inanotherwiseclean

    rubycouldbemadetodisappeartotheunaidedeyeexactlyasfilledfracturescan

    bemade todisappear inemeraldsanddiamonds. Infact,wehavealreadyseen

    several stones that fall into this category. Further and following stability tests

    laboratories within the Laboratory Manual Harmonization Committee (LMHC)2

    added Glass filler may be unstable to elevated temperatures and to chemical

    agents.Specialcareshallbetakenwhenrepairingjewelryitemssetwithglassfilled

    corundum.Duringjewelryrepairtheunmountingofsuchstonesisrecommendedto

    reportsonthesestones.

    During a meeting of the LMHC held October 18th

    20th

    2007 in New York City, Dr.

    PornsawatWathanakul(ScientificAdvisortotheGITmember)reopeneddiscussions

    on glass fracture filling in ruby. Several members had noted myriads of large gas

    bubbleswithinthenewermaterialbeingsubmittedtotheirlaboratoriesandthatin

    many cases the glass was filling wide seams crossing facets and seemed to be

    accounting for an ever increasing volume of the finished product. Further, it was

    surmised fromobservationthatthematerialwasbeingheldtogetherbytheglass,

    i.e.theglassacting insimilarmannertoanadhesive. Followingdiscussionsandan

    agreementthatthistreatmentwentbeyondwhatmightberegardedasafracture

    fillingorclarityenhancementprocess, thegroupdecidedtodescribethis(heavily

    treated)materialasrubyglasscompositesionallfutureidentificationreports.

    FurtheronNovember13th2007AmericanGemLaboratories (AGL)announcedthat

    they were changing their reporting policies with regards these stones (AGL, 2007)

    and indicated that their report wording henceforth would be Identification:

    CompositeRuby,Standardenhancement:Heat,andAdditionalenhancement:Lead

    glass. Theyalsoindicatedafurthercommentwouldbeadded Thisrubyhasbeen

    heavilytreatedusingahighrefractive index leadglasstofillfracturesandcavities,

    1Comparedwiththeprevalenceinthemarketrelativelyfewofthesestoneshavebeensubmittedto

    laboratoriesforreports.2

    The

    members

    of

    the

    LMHC

    are;

    AGTA

    Gemological

    Testing

    Center

    (USA),

    CISGEM

    (Italy),

    GAAJ

    Laboratory(Japan),GIAGemTradeLaboratory(USA),GITGemTestingLaboratory(Thailand),Gbelin

    GemLab(Switzerland),SSEFSwissGemmologicalInstitute(Switzerland)

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    3/23

    vastly improvingtheapparentclarityandpotentiallyaddingweight.Theglassmay

    bedamagedbyavarietyofsolvents.

    Thispaperdescribesseveralrubiestreatedwithglassandexperimentscarriedout

    at GIA Laboratory (Bangkok) and at GIA New York that demonstrate the LMHC

    assumptionthatthestonesarebeingbondedtogetherbyglass. Asanimplication

    oftheseexperimentsandgiventhatseveralgemstones(ruby,emeraldanddiamond

    being the most often cited but others including tourmaline and quartz being not

    uncommon)areclarityenhancedthroughtheinfusionoffractureswithoils,resins

    and glass, the paper also introduces new (February 2008) nomenclature for

    describing stones that have been clarity enhanced and those that are clearly

    composites.

    Materials and Methods

    Samples (Figure 1) were sourced on the Bangkok market between November 12th

    and23rd

    2007. Theytotaled40roughuntreated,703roughtreated,and116faceted.

    Fromthissamplegroup15facetedstoneswereselectedforaciddisintegrationtests,

    theserangedinsizefrom0.97ctto23.86ct(Table1). Thevastmajorityoftherough

    materialwasopaqueheavilytwinnedandconsiderablyfracturedtotheextentthatit

    wouldhavebeendifficultifnotimpossibletocutintofacetedmaterial.Thesurfaces

    ofthetreatedrough(thistreatment isnormallyappliedtotheroughmaterial)was

    covered in a smooth, often thick coating of glass The faceted samples appeared

    reasonably translucent to transparent and varied in color from pink, pinkish red

    throughredandorangishred.

    3Moreroughwasobtainedastreatedsamplesbutwaslatercutandthesestonesareincludedinthe

    cutspecimenlist.

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    4/23

    Figure1:Someofthespecimensusedforthisreport. Theroughspecimensontheleftrepresentthe

    startingmaterial,thespecimenstopandrightrepresentthetreatedrough,andthespecimensat

    centerarecutfromthetreatedrough.

    The material was examined using Gemolite microscopes in the magnifications

    rangingfrom10to60xandphotomicrographsrecordeddigitallyusingNikonsystem

    SMZ1500withaNikonDigitalSightCaptureSystemandavarietyofmagnifications.

    Fluorescence images were recorded using the DiamondView (The Diamond

    TradingCompany).ThechemistryoftheglasswasdeterminedwithThermoXSeries

    II LAICPMS system with an attached New Wave Research UP213 laser. Acid

    disintegrationtestswerecarriedoutusingconc.50%hydrofluoricacid(HF=20)at

    roomtemperatureandwithnoorlittleagitation, inanisolatedenvironmentunder

    anappropriatefumehood.

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    5/23

    Figure2:Arackholdingindividualplastictubesthatheldthespecimensthatunderwentacid

    disintegration. Thestoneswereplacedintothetubesandthencoveredwithhydrofluoricacid4

    sealedandlefttosoakforfromtwototendays.

    Inclusion observations

    Figure 1 through to Figure 9 shows the typical remaining natural inclusions in the

    facetedtreatedstones. Silkintheformoffineintersectingneedlesbothinisolated

    clusters and as part of hexagonal zones were often present as were crystals and

    negativecrystals. None of these inclusions revealedany indications that theyhad

    beensubjecttoheating,atleastabove1300C. Thereforeitissurmisedthatanyheat

    involveinthistreatmentprocessshouldbebelow1300C. ThusconfirmingPardieus

    observations (Pardieu,2005) the stonesarewarmed. Infact, thisstep isa

    heat treatment.Thisstep is important toremove the impuritiespossiblypresent in

    thefissures that could create someproblems when the glass is added. The heat

    treatment may also by itself improve the stone color. This warming can be

    conducted at different temperaturesfrom 900C to 1400C depending on the ruby

    type.As900C isnothotenoughtomeltsome inclusionsasrutile,manystonescan

    stillhaveanunheatedaspect.Butallstonesareheated.

    The natural inclusion scenes were largely indicative of some East African and

    Madagascarsources.

    4Note: Hydrofluoricacidisdangerousandshouldonlybeusedundercontrolledconditions

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    6/23

    Figure3:Rutileneedles(silk)in

    arubyglasscomposite; thesilk

    isunalteredbyheating

    Figure4:Anhexagonalcrystalin

    arubyglasscomposite; the

    crystalisunalteredbyheating

    Figure5:Rutileneedles(silk)in

    arubyglasscomposite: thesilk

    isunalteredbyheating

    Figure6:Rutileandother

    needlesinarubyglass

    composite:theneedlesare

    unalteredbyheating

    Figure7:Anhexagonalcrystalin

    arubyglasscomposite: the

    crystalisunalteredbyheating

    Figure8:Rutileneedles(silk)in

    anhexagonalformationina

    rubyglasscomposite: thesilkis

    unalteredbyheating

    Figure9Acrystalinarubyglass

    composite:thecrystalis

    unalteredbyheating

    Alsoincludedwerecopiousnumbersofbothfattenedandfullyexpanded(Figure10

    toFigure16)gasbubbleswithinthetractsofglassineachofthetreatedstones. In

    many cases the bubbles were so large and/or so prolific that the observers first

    thoughtsstrayedtowardsaconclusionthatthestonewasalowqualityglassrather

    thansomethingassociatedwithruby. Thetractsofglassalsowereresponsiblefor

    the obvious color flashes (Figure 17 to Figure 19) that were visible even to the

    unaidedeye. Thesecolorflashesbeinginstarkcontrasttosomewhatdifficulttosee

    colorflashesthathavebeentreatedinthesamemannerbuttoalesserdegree.

    Inonecasethemicroscoperevealedthattheglassbeingusedhasanorangecolor

    (Figure20toFigure24).SuchorangecoloredglassisdescribedbyPardieu(Pardieu,

    2005)werehestatesInrubiesenhancedinBangkokbyOrangeSapphirecompany,

    someyellowtoorangecolorconcentrationappearsislargefissuresandincavities.

    AstatementsupportedbyimagesthatcomparewellwithFigure20toFigure24.He

    further states Thefact that leadglassused inmostChantaburi treatment ispink

    explainswhyitismostofthetimenotvisibleinsidethegem.

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    7/23

    Glassrelatedinclusionsobservedinsomeoftherubyglasscompositesexaminedfor

    thisreport

    Figure10:RGC001flattened

    bubbleswithinfilledfractures

    Figure11:RGC005expanded

    bubbleswithinfilledfractures

    Figure12:RGC006flattened

    bubbledwithinfilledfractures

    Figure13:Flattenedbubbles

    withinfilledfractures

    Figure14:RGC007flattenedand

    expandedbubbleswithinfilled

    fractures

    Figure15:RGC007flattenedand

    expandedbubbleswithinfilled

    fractures

    Figure16:Bubbleswithinfiled

    fractures

    Figure17:RGC008colorflashed

    fromrevealingtheglassfilled

    fractures

    Figure18:RGC011colorflashed

    fromrevealingtheglassfilled

    fractures

    Figure19:RGC001colorflashed

    fromrevealingtheglassfilled

    fractures

    Figure20:RGC015orangeglass

    fillingacavityand

    fracture.Figure21toFigure24

    showthisindifferentlighting

    conditions

    Figure21:RGC015orangeglass

    fillingacavityand

    fracture.Figure20toFigure24

    showthisindifferentlighting

    conditions

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    8/23

    Figure22:RGC015orangeglass

    fillingacavityand

    fracture.Figure20toFigure24

    showthisindifferentlighting

    conditions

    Figure23:RGC015orangeglass

    fillingacavityand

    fracture.Figure20toFigure24

    showthisindifferentlighting

    conditions

    Figure24:RGC015orangeglass

    fillingacavityand

    fracture.Figure21toFigure23

    showthisindifferentlighting

    conditions

    Fluorescenceobservations

    Inanattemptto furthercategorize (visually)thevolumeofglassused intheruby

    glasscomposites,15ofthesampleswereexaminedand imagesrecordedwiththe

    DiamondView (Diamond Trading Company). These images are produced here

    fromFigure25toFigure39. Thisexercisewasrewardinginthatitquicklyrecorded

    images that allowed for a close estimation of the position and volume of glass

    present in each stone. In particular stones RGC011 and RGC015 revealed copious

    amountsofglass.

    DiamondView (Diamond Trading Company) images of specimens RGC001 to

    RGC015. Glassrevealsitselfaseitherblackorbluetractsrunningacrosseachstone.

    The brighter red areas reflect the positions of gas bubbles. Sample numbers are

    givenforeachstone.

    Figure25:RGC001 Figure26:RGC002 Figure27:RGC003

    Figure28:RGC004 Figure29:RGC005 Figure30:RGC006

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    9/23

    Figure31:RGC007 Figure32:RGC008 Figure33:RGC009

    Figure34:RGC010 Figure35:RGC011 Figure36:RGC012

    Figure37:RGC013 Figure38:RGC014 Figure39:RGC015

    Surfacereflectionrelatedobservations

    Probablythemostconvenientmethodfor locatingfracturesthatmay(ormaynot)

    havebeenfilledwithanysubstance istopositionanoverhead lightandafaceton

    thesampleinamannerthatachievesneartotalsurfacereflection(NTSF)ofthelight

    fromthefacetunderexamination. Thestone,beingexaminedonamicroscope, is

    then turned to achieve NTSF from each facet. In a position of NTSR any

    inhomogeneity (whether a change in substance, a cavity or a surface reachingfractures)becomesclearlyvisible.

    Figure 40 to Figure 63 show various facets on the selected 15 test specimens

    (RGC001RGC015)inNTSF. Allclearlyshowthepresenceglassintractscrossingthe

    stone(Figure52toFigure57),manyrevealaveritablejigsawpuzzleofrubyandglass

    (Figure40 toFigure51)whileothersshow facets thathaveanapproximate50/50

    rubyglasscomposition(Figure61).

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    10/23

    Figure40:RGC007thisNTSR

    imageofthetablefacetreveals

    avirtualjigsawpuzzleofglass

    andrubyislandsofrubyina

    glassmatrix

    Figure41:RGC007(magnified

    fromFigure40)thisNTSRimage

    ofthetablefacetrevealsa

    virtualjigsawpuzzleofglass

    andrubyislandsofrubyina

    glassmatrix

    Figure42:RGC007(magnified

    fromFigure41)thisNTSRimage

    ofthetablefacetrevealsa

    virtualjigsawpuzzleofglass

    andrubyislandsofrubyina

    glassmatrix

    Figure43:RGC010asinRGC007

    thisNTSRimageofthetable

    facetalsorevealsavirtual

    jigsawpuzzleofglassandruby

    islandsofrubyinaglassmatrix

    Figure44:RGC010(magnified

    fromFigure43)asinRGC007

    thisNTSRimageofthetable

    facetalsorevealsavirtual

    jigsawpuzzleofglassandruby

    islandsofrubyinaglassmatrix

    Figure45:RGC010(magnified

    fromFigure44)asinRGC007

    thisNTSRimageofthetable

    facetalsorevealsavirtual

    jigsawpuzzleofglassandruby

    islandsofrubyinaglassmatrix

    Figure46:RGC011asinRGC007

    andRGC010thisNTSRimageof

    thetablefacetalsorevealsa

    virtualjigsawpuzzleofglass

    andrubyislandsofrubyina

    glassmatrix

    Figure47:RGC011(magnified

    fromFigure46)asinRGC007

    andRGC010thisNTSRimageof

    thetablefacetalsorevealsa

    virtualjigsawpuzzleofglass

    andrubyislandsofrubyina

    glassmatrix

    Figure48:RGC011(magnified

    fromFigure47)asinRGC007

    andRGC010thisNTSRimageof

    thetablefacetalsorevealsa

    virtualjigsawpuzzleofglass

    andrubyislandsofrubyina

    glassmatrix

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    11/23

    Figure49:RGC006asin

    RGC007,RGC010and

    RGC011thisNTSRimageofthe

    tablefacetalsorevealsavirtual

    jigsawpuzzleofglassandruby

    islandsofrubyinaglassmatrix

    Figure50:RGC006(magnified

    fromFigure49)asinRGC007,

    RGC010andRGC011thisNTSR

    imageofthetablefacetalso

    revealsavirtualjigsawpuzzleof

    glassandrubyislandsofruby

    inaglassmatrix

    Figure51:RGC006(magnified

    fromFigure50)asinRGC007,

    RGC010andRGC011thisNTSR

    imageofthetablefacetalso

    revealsavirtualjigsawpuzzleof

    glassandrubyislandsofruby

    inaglassmatrix

    Figure52:RGC002showinga

    widetractofglasscrossingthe

    tablefacetinNTSF,twobubbles

    areseencutthroughatthe

    surface

    Figure53: RGC002showinga

    widetractofglasscrossingthe

    tablefacetinNTSF,highlighted

    areaonthesamefacetseen

    inFigure52.

    Figure54RGC002showinga

    widetractofglasscrossingthe

    tablefacetinNTSF,highlighted

    areaonthesamefacetseen

    inFigure52

    Figure55:RGC002showinga

    widetractofglasscrossingthe

    tablefacetinNTSF,highlighted

    areaonthesamefacetseen

    inFigure52

    Figure56:RGC003showinga

    widetractofglasscrossinga

    facetinNTSF

    Figure57:RGC004showinga

    widetractofglasscrossinga

    facetinNTSF

    Figure58:RGC007showing

    severalwidetractsofglass

    crossingtwofacetsinNTSF

    Figure59:RGC010showingwide

    andnarrowtractsofglass

    crossingafacetinNTSF

    Figure60:RGC012showingwide

    andnarrowtractsofglass

    crossingafacetinNTSF

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    12/23

    Figure61:RGC014showingwide

    tractsofglasscrossingafacetin

    NTSF,Theproportionofrubyto

    glassisintheregionof50/50

    Figure62:RGC014showing

    widetractsofglasscrossinga

    facetinNTSF.

    Figure63:RGC014showingwide

    tractsofglasscrossingafacetin

    NTSF.

    Glasscomposition

    The composition of the glass used in the specimens collected for this series of

    examinationsisindicatedinTable2.

    Acid disintegration tests and observations

    Asseen inFigure1andconfirmed through industrycontactsthestartmaterial for

    the product described here is extremely low quality corundum and further the

    assumption is that the material cannot be cut and faceted as mined. This

    assumption is confirmed in part both through industry contacts and our own

    observations that the material has to be infused with glass prior to cutting and

    faceting(seeagainFigure1).

    During the October 2007 LMHC meeting a further assumption was made that

    withoutthepresenceoftheglassmanyofthesetreatedstoneswouldnotremainin

    onepiece;indicatingthattheglasswasactingmuchinthesamewayasacommon

    adhesive. Inordertotestthisassumption15stoneswereselected fromatotalof

    116 faceted stones present on the Bangkok market in November 2007. These 15

    stones were immersed in hydrofluoric acid for either 44hrs:45mins or 107hours.

    These timeslots werenotchosen throughany formof calculation but rather they

    wereconvenienttimespansthatfittedinwithnumerousotherprojectsandregular

    workloads.

    Theacidbegantovisuallydisintegratetheglasswithinminutesofimmersion(Figure

    64 and Figure 65). As immersion progressed and the acid disintegrated the glass

    further so small parts of the stones began to fall off from the main body of each

    specimen(Figure66toFigure81). Longer immersionresulted inthestonesfalling

    into many pieces (Figure 96 to Figure 121) and in one case a total disintegration

    occurred(Figure89toFigure92).

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    13/23

    Figure64:RGC014seenhereimmersedin

    hydrofluoricacid. Thewhitesubstanceisresidue

    fromdisintegration oftheglassbytheacid.The

    disintegration processbeginsassoonasthe

    stoneisplacedintheacid. Thisimageistaken

    within30minutesofimmersion.

    Figure65:RGC015seenhereimmersedin

    hydrofluoricacid. Thewhitesubstanceisresidue

    fromdisintegrationoftheglassbytheacid.The

    disintegrationprocessbeginsassoonasthe

    stoneisplacedintheacid. Thisimageistaken

    within30minutesofimmersion.

    15rubyglasscopositessubjectedtoaciddisintigrationtests(placinginhydrofluoric

    acidforbetween2and10days)

    Figure66:RGC001

    beforeacid

    disintegration.

    Figure67:RGC001

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure68:RGC001

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure69:RGC001after

    aciddisintegration.

    Figure70:RGC002

    beforeacid

    disintegration.

    Figure71:RGC002

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure72:RGC002

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure73:RGC002after

    aciddisintegration.

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    14/23

    Figure74:RGC003

    beforeacid

    disintegration.

    Figure76:RGC003

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure77:RGC003after

    aciddisintegration.

    Figure78:RGC004

    beforeacid

    disintegration.

    Figure79:RGC004

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure80:RGC004

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure81:RGC004after

    aciddisintegration.

    Figure82:RGC005

    beforeacid

    disintegration.

    Figure83:RGC005

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure84:RGC005

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure85:RGC005after

    aciddisintegration

    Figure86:RGC006

    beforeacid

    disintegration.

    Figure87:RGC006

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure88:RGC006

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure75:RGC003after

    aciddisintegration.

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    15/23

    Figure89:RGC007

    beforeacid

    disintegration.

    Figure90:RGC007

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure91:RGC007

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure92:RGC007after

    aciddisintegration.

    Figure93:RGC008

    beforeacid

    disintegration.

    Figure94:RGC008

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure95:RGC008

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure96:RGC009

    beforeacid

    disintegration.

    Figure97:RGC009

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure98:RGC009

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure99:RGC010

    beforeacid

    disintegration.

    Figure100:RGC010

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure101:RGC010

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure102:RGC010after

    aciddisintegration.

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    16/23

    Figure103:RGC011

    beforeacid

    disintegration.

    Figure104:RGC011

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure105:RGC011

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure106:RGC012

    beforeacid

    disintegration.

    Figure107:RGC012

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure108:RGC012

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure109:RGC012after

    aciddisintegration.

    Figure110:RGC013

    beforeacid

    disintegration.

    Figure111:RGC013

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure112:RGC013

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure113:RGC013after

    aciddisintegration.

    Figure114:RGC014

    beforeacid

    disintegration.

    Figure115:RGC014

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure116:RGC014

    afteracid

    disintegration

    Figure117:RGC014after

    aciddisintegration

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    17/23

    Figure118:RGC015

    beforeacid

    disintegration.

    Figure119:RGC015

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure120:RGC015

    afteracid

    disintegration.

    Figure121:RGC015after

    aciddisintegration.

    Discussion

    Fromtheaboveobservationsandresultsofaciddisintegrationexperimentsitwould

    appearthatanadjustmentinreportingnomenclatureisnecessaryandthattheline

    taken by LMHC (rubyglass composite) is integral with this. However, this single

    (LMHC)change impactsotherreportingareas. Theseotherareasarethosewhere

    presently report language describes clarity enhancement (fracture filling)

    regardless of the stone type and whether this involves glass or some other

    substance.

    Themarketcontinuestobewatchedandassessedforanynewdevelopmentstothis

    orsimilartreatmentprocessesandthisdiscussionpaperwillbeperiodicallyupdated.

    The following new report nomenclature was introduced for use within GIA

    LaboratoriesatFebruary1st2008.Suggestionsandfurtherinputiswelcome.

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    18/23

    Condition PresumedIntent/

    ApplicationCaseA

    Fissurespresent,butobviouslyintactmaterial Clarity enhancement;

    corundum, emeralds,

    tourmaline,etc

    SpeciesNatural(Corundum,BerylorTourm

    Variety(Ruby/Sapphire,EmeraldorTourm

    Theimagesofrubywithglassheregenerallyreflectthematerialdescribed

    inthissectionandwouldalsoreflectthesituationwithemerald.

    Treatment:

    A (minor, moderate, significant) amount

    glass,resin,oil)toreducethevisibilityoffis

    Add(indicationsofheating)iffillerisglass.

    Comment:

    Fissure filling materials (glass/oil/resin e

    temperatures and to chemical agents. S

    cleaningorrepairingjewelryitemssetwith

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    19/23

    Condition PresumedIntent/

    ApplicationCaseB

    Highly fractured and/or twinned material with

    filledvoids,channels and fissures. Materialwas

    onepiece initiallybutmay lose integrity if filling

    material is removed. An exceptionally large

    amountoffillingmaterialispresent.

    Tostrengthenfractured

    roughtoenablecutting;

    improveclarityand

    appearance;currently

    appliestocorundum

    andberyl

    Species Natural(CorundumorBeryl)with (f

    Variety:(Ruby/SapphireorEmerald)with(

    Theimagesofrubywithglassheregenerallyreflectthematerialdescribed

    inthissectionandwouldalsoreflectthesituationwithemerald.

    Treatment: Fractures filled with (glass/re

    visibility.Add(indicationsofheating)iffille

    Comment:

    Significant fractures present in this stone

    treatmentdescribedabove.Fracturefilling

    unstabletoelevatedtemperaturesandtoc

    betakenwhencleaningorrepairingjewelry

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    20/23

    Condition PresumedIntent/

    Application

    CaseC

    3.

    Assemblage

    or

    bonding

    of

    unrelated

    gemstone

    pieces(chunksorpowder) to

    produce

    large

    cutting

    material from unusable

    pieces or powders;

    currently applies to

    corundumandberyl

    Species

    (CorundumGlass/Berylresin)Composite

    Variety:

    (RubyGlass/Emeraldresin)Composite

    Theimagesofrubywithglassheregenerallyreflectthematerialdescribed

    inthissectionandwouldalsoreflectthesituationwithemerald.

    Treatment:

    Nothingstated

    Comment:

    This item is a combination of (ruby / eme

    material may be unstable to elevated tem

    Specialcareshouldbetakenwhencleaning

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    21/23

    Table

    1

    Ct Weight

    preacid

    L W D Aciddisintegrated Ct Weight post acid and after

    drying

    RGC001 0.97330 7.007 5.187 2.782 IntoHF14:15November24th 2007 out

    11:00 November 26th 2007. Total 44

    hours45mins

    0.93 major piece alone including

    residue

    RGC002 1.29770 6.973 5.613 3.969 Into HF15:22November24th 2007 out

    10:00 November 26th 2007. Total 44

    hours45mins

    1.00850 major piece alone

    includingresidue

    RGC003 1.58270 7.920 6.929 3.012 Into HF16:00November24th 2007 out

    12:00 November 26th 2007. Total 44

    hours45mins

    1.55 major piece alone including

    residue

    RGC004 1.60520 7.510 5.593 4.245 Into HF 12:00 December 7th

    2007 out

    11:00 December 15th 2007. Total 107

    hours

    1.58 major piece alone including

    residue

    RGC005 1.83240 8.488 6.381 3.611 Into HF 12:00 December 7th

    2007 out

    11:00 December 15th 2007. Total 107

    hours

    1.56 major piece alone including

    residue

    RGC006 1.83830 8.390 6.664 3.504 Into HF 12:00 December 7th

    2007 out

    11:00 December 15th 2007. Total 107

    hours

    1.82 major piece alone including

    residue

    RGC007 2.09230 7.776 6.204 4.919 Into HF 12:00 December 7th

    2007 out

    11:00 December 15th 2007. Total 107

    hours

    1.67Onlydustleft

    RGC008 2.47430 8.371 7.279 4.783 Into HF 12:00 December 7th

    2007 out

    11:00 December 15th 2007. Total 107

    hours

    2.41 major piece alone including

    residue

    RGC009 3.58680 9.491 7.430 5.298 Into HF 12:00 December 7th

    2007 out

    11:00 December 15th 2007. Total 107

    hours

    3.11 major piece alone including

    residue

    RGC010 5.75550 11.176 9.264 6.267 Into HF 12:00 December 7th

    2007 out

    11:00 December 15th 2007. Total 107

    hours

    5.05 major piece alone including

    residue

    RGC011 9.84210 14.640 10.280 6.585 Into HF 12:00 December 7th 2007 out

    11:00 December 15th 2007. Total 107

    hours

    8.23 major piece alone including

    residue

    RGC012 11.71390 11.733 11.817 7.440 Into HF 12:00 December 7th

    out 11:00

    December15th2007.Total107hours

    11.19majorpiecealoneincluding

    residue

    RGC013 12.89150 14.109 11.383 8.473 Into HF 12:00 December 7th

    out 11:00

    December15th2007.Total107hours

    12.72majorpiecealoneincluding

    residue

    RGC014 21.05030 21.063 15.255 8.896 Into HF 12:00 December 7th

    2007 out

    11:00 December 15th 2007. Total 107

    hours

    20.68majorpiecealoneincluding

    residue

    RGC015 23.86110 16.675 16.437 9.721 Into HF 12:00 December 7th

    out 11:00

    December15th2007.Total107hours

    23.00majorpiecealoneincluding

    residue

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    22/23

  • 8/6/2019 Ruby Glass Composites

    23/23

    References

    Kane,R.E.(1984)Naturalrubieswithglassfilledcavities.Gems&Gemology.20.4.187199

    Scarratt,

    K.,et

    al.

    (1984)

    Glass

    infilling

    of

    cavities

    in

    natural

    ruby.

    Journal

    of

    Gemmology.

    19.

    4.

    293297

    Hughes,R.W.(1987)Glassinfillingofcracksinruby.ICALabAlert.4.1

    Scarratt,K.(1987)Glassinfillingofcavitiesinrubyandsapphire.JournalofGemmology.20.7/8.

    421

    Hlaing,U.T.(1993)MongHsurubyupdate.AustralianGemmologist.18.5.157160

    Kremkow,C.(1993)Burmaisback:MongHsurubyrushtransformsmarket.ICAGazette.1,9

    Laughter,

    T.

    (1993)

    How

    do

    you

    do?

    Im

    from

    Mong

    Hsu.

    JewelSiam.

    4.

    5.

    3841

    Peretti,A.(1993)ForeignsubstancesinMongHsurubies.JewelSiam.4.5.42

    Smith,C.P.,etal.(1994)TheMongHsuruby:AnewtypeofBurmeseruby.JewelSiam.4.6.8298

    GAAJ. (2004) GAAJ Lab Alert: lead glass impreagnated ruby. http://www.gaaj

    zenhokyo.co.jp/researchroom/kanbetu/2004/gaaj_alert040315en.html

    Pardieu, V. (2005) Lead Glass Filled/Repaired Rubies, Version

    04.http://www.aigslaboratory.com/Filearticle/55.pdf

    Smith C.P., M. S. F., Wang W., Hall M. (2005) Some characteristics of leadglassfilled

    corundum.JewelleryNewsAsia.November.255.7984.

    McClure, S. F., Smith,C.P.,Wang,W.,Hall,M. (2006) Identification and Durabuility of Lead

    GlassFilledRubies.Gems&Gemology.42.1.2234

    AGL. (2007) AGL Modifies its Disclosure Policy on LeadGlass Filled

    Rubieshttp://www.aglgemlab.com/AGLModifiesDisclosure.html

    iComposite m aterials (or composites for short) are engineered materials made from two or

    more constituent materials with significantly different physical or chemical properties and which

    remain separate and distinct on a macroscopic level within the finished structure. -

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Composite_material

    http://www.gaaj-zenhokyo.co.jp/researchroom/kanbetu/2004/gaaj_alert-040315en.htmlhttp://www.gaaj-zenhokyo.co.jp/researchroom/kanbetu/2004/gaaj_alert-040315en.htmlhttp://www.gaaj-zenhokyo.co.jp/researchroom/kanbetu/2004/gaaj_alert-040315en.htmlhttp://www.gaaj-zenhokyo.co.jp/researchroom/kanbetu/2004/gaaj_alert-040315en.htmlhttp://www.gaaj-zenhokyo.co.jp/researchroom/kanbetu/2004/gaaj_alert-040315en.htmlhttp://www.gaaj-zenhokyo.co.jp/researchroom/kanbetu/2004/gaaj_alert-040315en.htmlhttp://www.aigslaboratory.com/Filearticle/55.pdfhttp://www.aigslaboratory.com/Filearticle/55.pdfhttp://www.aglgemlab.com/AGLModifiesDisclosure.htmlhttp://www.aglgemlab.com/AGLModifiesDisclosure.htmlhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Materialhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Materialhttp://www.aglgemlab.com/AGLModifiesDisclosure.htmlhttp://www.aigslaboratory.com/Filearticle/55.pdfhttp://www.gaaj-zenhokyo.co.jp/researchroom/kanbetu/2004/gaaj_alert-040315en.htmlhttp://www.gaaj-zenhokyo.co.jp/researchroom/kanbetu/2004/gaaj_alert-040315en.html