RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high...

41
September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 1 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies. RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application Meeting September 18, 2012 Open Session Shielding Evaluations Robatel Technologies, LLC Roanoke, VA

Transcript of RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high...

Page 1: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 1 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application Meeting

September 18, 2012 Open Session Shielding Evaluations Robatel Technologies, LLC Roanoke, VA

Page 2: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 2 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Agenda

Introductions RT-100 Shield Design Package contents Source Terms Shielding Methodology NCT Shielding Evaluations HAC Shielding Evaluations RT-100 Loading Table Example Conclusions

Page 3: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 3 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Introductions

Robatel RT-100 Team Robatel Technologies Robatel Industries

NRC

Page 4: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 4 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

RT-100 Shield Design

Cavity - 195.6 cm high, 173 cm diameter Radial Wall – 3 cm steel, 9 cm lead, 3.5 cm steel,

(0.5 cm ceramic paper and 0.5 cm steel thermal shield)

Bottom Wall – 5 cm steel, 7.5 cm lead, 3.3 cm steel Primary Lid – 21 cm steel Secondary Lid – 10 cm steel, 6 cm lead, 1 cm steel Body – 232.4 cm high, 203 cm diameter

Page 5: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 5 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Package Contents

Resins, filters and reformed resin from nuclear power plant operation

Typical Materials: Polystyrene based resins such as Duralite Activated Charcoal Nylon filter media Zeolite - hydrated aluminosilicates such as Faujasite

Media contaminated with by-product material

Page 6: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 6 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Package Contents

Content limits Content mass: 15,000 lbs (6806 kg) including liners Decay Heat: 200 Watts Activity: 3000 A2 External Dose Rates: 10 CFR 71.51 and 71.71

Individual nuclides limited by activity per gram to ensure compliance

Page 7: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 7 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Sources of Source Terms Data

Gamma Spectra – SCALE 6.0 ORIGEN-S Photon Yield Library, origen.rev02.mpdkxgam.dat

Beta Spectra – ICRU Report 56, Appendix D Bremsstrahlung Photons – MCNP5 mode e p Spontaneous Fission and Alpha-N Spectra from

SCALE 6.0 ORIGEN-S and actinide decay library, origen.rev00.alphdec.data

Page 8: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 8 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Source Terms – Gamma Emitting Nuclides

For gamma emitting nuclides, the shielding approach is generic. Energy dependent responses are computed for each tally and specific nuclide gamma line responses are found by interpolation.

All gamma emitting nuclides in ORIGEN-S database with > 1 day half life (281 nuclides) evaluated.

201 produced external dose rate responses.

Page 9: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 9 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Source Terms – Gamma Emitting Nuclides

2 Meter Tally Energy Dependent Response

0.00E+00

1.00E-02

2.00E-02

3.00E-02

4.00E-02

5.00E-02

6.00E-02

0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0

Resp

onse

(mRe

m/h

r/Ci

)

Energy (MeV)

2m Dose Rate Response NCT, Cask Side, Segment 15 (0.5-2.0 MeV)

Page 10: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 10 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Source Terms – Beta Emitting Nuclides

For beta emitting nuclides, explicit Bremsstrahlung calculations are performed with MCNP5 in mode e p for: Y-90 Sb-124 Cs-137 La-140 Ce-144

Emax > 2 MeV

Page 11: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 11 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Source Terms – Neutron Emitting Nuclides

For the neutron emitting nuclides alpha-n+ spontaneous fission neutrons computed with ORIGEN-S for 1 Ci of the following: Cm-242 Cm-243 Cm-244 Am-241 Pu-238 Pu-239 Pu-240

Pu-242

Page 12: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 12 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations – Methodology

MCNP5 Monte Carlo, release 1.41 Computed exterior dose rate (mrem/hr) for 1 Ci of each

energy line or nuclide distributed in the cavity Tallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2

meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined the maximum value on the cask surface, 2

meter surface and cab surface; this defined the dose rate response functions in mrem/hr/curie

Computed responses for the side, top and bottom Utilized ANSI/ANS 6.1.1-1977, Neutron and Gamma Flux-To-

Dose Conversion Factors

Page 13: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 13 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations

Analyzed Trailer Vehicle Dimensions 8’ wide 42’ long Cask is centered on trailer and is vertical Distance from cask centerline to cab 29’ 3”

Page 14: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 14 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations

Major Conservatisms in Shielding Evaluations Both NCT and HAC evaluations assumed minimal shell,

lead and lid thickness (i.e. nominal – manufacturing tolerance)

Dose rate responses included 2σ Monte Carlo uncertainty NCT 2 meter limit set to 9.5 mrem/hr NCT Cab limit set 1.9 mrem/hr HAC 1 meter limit set to 950 mrem/hr

Page 15: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 15 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

RT-100 Shield Model Dimensions

Component Nominal Model

Inner Shell 3.0 2.97

Lead 9.0 8.5

Outer Shell 3.5 3.47

Bottom 5.0 4.97

Bottom Lead 7.5 7.0

Bottom Plate 3.3 3.27

Primary Lid 21.0 20.95

Secondary Lid 17.0 16.95

Secondary Lid Lead 7.5 7.0

Page 16: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 16 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations

Nuclide Activity Limits (Max Ci/g) were established by using the NCT and HAC dose rate limits

Definition of Maximum Curies per Gram NCT 2 Meter:

9.5 mrem/hr / Response (mrem/hr/Ci) /Content Mass

NCT at Cab 1.9 mrem/hr / Response (mrem/hr/Ci) /Content Mass

HAC at 1 meter 950 mrem/hr / Response (mrem/hr/Ci) /Content Mass

Page 17: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 17 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations

Max. Ci/g addresses non homogeneity . Analysis assumes max. Ci/g is homogenously

distributed throughout the cavity. Resins generally saturate and are uniform in

activity Nylon filter media takes no credit for metal

cartridge and material is filled through the cavity. End user is ultimately responsible for determining

the maximum Curie per gram of their contents.

Page 18: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 18 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Preliminary Shielding Evaluations

Normal Conditions of Transport (NCT) Model Impact limiters in place Impact limiter foam at reduced (35 and 15 lbs/ft3) density Shells, lead and lids at minimal dimensions Baseline analysis assumes uniform source in polystyrene

resin at 0.65 g/cm3, variation in density and composition are evaluated and accounted for in final results.

Cavity filled with resin and uniform cylindrical source, compaction is evaluated

Page 19: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 19 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Preliminary Shielding Evaluations

NCT Model Sensitivity Studies Compaction of resin and source: 10% Resin Density Variation: 0.325 and 1.13 g/cm3 Resin Compositions: Carbon, Nylon and Zeolite

Page 20: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 20 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

NCT Shielding Evaluations NCT Model

Upper Impact Limiter

Lower Impact Limiter

Inner Shell

Lead

Outer Shell

Primary Lid

Secondary Lid

Resin

Page 21: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 21 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

NCT Shielding Evaluations NCT 10% Compacted Model

Upper Impact Limiter

Lower Impact Limiter

Inner Shell

Lead

Outer Shell

Primary Lid

Secondary Lid

Resin,10% Compacted

Page 22: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 22 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations NCT Tally Surfaces

Cask Radial Surfaces

Cask Top Surface

Cask Bottom Surface

2 Meter Surface

2 Meter Surface

Cab Surface

Cab Surface

Page 23: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 23 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations Sensitivity Study Results

Compaction results in lower side and top dose rates, but a slight increase (2%) in the bottom

0.65 g/cm3 produces the lowest Max. Ci/g Carbon produced the lowest gamma attenuation. NCT and

HAC polystyrene gamma responses are increased by 1.07, 1.10 and 1.09 for the side, bottom and top, respectively.

Zeolite has the lowest neutron attenuation. NCT and HAC polystyrene neutron responses are increased by 3.10, 2.75 and 5.40 for the side, bottom and top, respectively.

Page 24: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 24 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations NCT Dose Rate Response Results (mrem/hr/Ci)

Page 25: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 25 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations NCT Dose Rate Response Results (mrem/hr/Ci)

Page 26: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 26 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations NCT Dose Rate Response Results (mrem/hr/Ci)

Page 27: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 27 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations NCT Max. Ci/g

Page 28: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 28 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations NCT Dose Rate Results for Typical Loading

Page 29: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 29 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations

Hypothetical Accident Conditions Impact Limiters off For end drop, lead slumps to bottom creating an annular

void at the top. Also includes 1 inch pin puncture in side. Resin compacts and redistributes to top.

For side drop, lead slumps to one side creating a crescent void along the inside of the outer shell. Resin compacts and redistributes to side.

Page 30: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 30 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations

Hypothetical Accident Conditions Source and material relocation Bounding Source Conditions End drop- resin and source compacts and relocates to

the top. Side drop- resin and source compress into a hemi-

cylinder next to the side void

Page 31: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 31 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

HAC Shielding Evaluations Annular Void and Puncture with Resin Relocation

Annular void, 2.47 cm high

2.54 cm thick Puncture

Page 32: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 32 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

HAC Shielding Evaluations Crescent Void with Resin Relocation

Crescent void, 2.32 cm thick

Page 33: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 33 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

HAC Shielding Evaluations Tally Surfaces and Detectors

1 Meter Side

1 Meter Bottom

1 Meter Top

1 Meter Ring Detector 1 Meter Point Detector

.

. .

Page 34: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 34 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

HAC Shielding Evaluations Tally Surfaces and Detectors

1 Meter Point Detector

1 Meter Bottom

1 Meter Top

1 Meter Point Detector 1 Meter Point Detector

.

.

.

Page 35: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 35 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations HAC Results

End drop annular void with relocation to the top produces the most limiting 1 meter dose rate

Page 36: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 36 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations HAC Response Results (mrem/hr/Ci)

Page 37: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 37 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations HAC Max. Ci/g

Page 38: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 38 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations Neutron and Beta/Bremsstrahlung

Beta/Bremsstrahlung: NCT and HAC responses are negligible. NCT < 1E-6 mrem/hr/Ci and HAC < 1E-4 mrem/hr/Ci.

Neutron NCT and HAC responses evaluated and incorporated into results. However, activities are typically low, and the contributions are negligible.

Page 39: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 39 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations Loading Table Based on Min of NCT and HAC Responses

User fills In this column with the contents of their package

Based on either NCT or HAC which ever is more limiting

Page 40: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 40 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations Loading Table Based on Min of NCT and HAC Responses

Page 41: RT-100 Cask Certificate of Compliance Pre-Application MeetingTallied on segmented (10 cm high segments) cask surface, 2 meters from the vehicle surface and at the cab surface Determined

September 18, 2012 RT-100 Pre-Application Meeting 41 This information is company confidential and may not be used without written consent of Robatel Technologies.

Shielding Evaluations

Conclusions Evaluations show the RT-100 is below NCT and HAC

regulatory limits if max. Ci/g criteria is met. Dose rate responses and max. Ci/g limits for all significant

isotopes will be provided in the SAR.