Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one...

44
Copyright of Shell Canada Ltd. 1 Road Transport Forum September 15, 2015 Grande Prairie, AB

Transcript of Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one...

Page 1: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

Copyright of Shell Canada Ltd. 1

Road Transport Forum

September 15, 2015

Grande Prairie, AB

Page 2: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

2

Safety Moment

Exits

Muster Point

Restrooms

Please ensure you signed in.

Page 3: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

AGENDA

8:00 – 9:00 Room Open / Breakfast

9:00 – 9:20 Opening Remarks – Mike Bertamini (Shell)

9:20 – 9:35 Rollover Incident Review – Holly Baird (Rockwater)

9:35 – 10:00 Trends – Dwaine Stovka (Shell)

10:00 – 10:20 Break - Back in 20 minutes

10:20 – 10:50 Risk Management Gap Review & Winter Prep – Mike Bertamini

10:50 – 11:15 Worker Compentence Journey – Whitney Irwin (ENTREC)

11:15 – 11:45 Hours of Service Tool – Shane Kennedy (Fleet Complete)

11:45 - Noon Asana – Mandy Dawson (JDA Ventures)

Noon – 12:15 Road Safety Initiatives & Closeout – Mike Bertamini

Page 4: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

4

Meeting Ground Rules

Arrive on time, keep to time

Be open, in

your

contribution Switch off mobile phones

Be short and to the point

No side talks

Respect others’ opinions

No cross talks

Be present and participate

One voice at a time

No unsafe acts

Page 5: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

5

Antitrust Guidelines

It is Shell policy to strictly comply with all Federal and Provincial antitrust

laws. Meeting participants are reminded that during, before and after

meetings, there shall be no discussion of competitively sensitive

information, including but not limited to prices, costs, customers,

suppliers, output or production, commercial plans, allocation of territories

or customers, or any other discussion that could be viewed as restraining

competition or limiting any person or company from free access to any

business, market, customer, or vendor.

Discussion should be limited to agenda items only. Any questions about

the propriety of a discussion item should be raised immediately and

should be addressed with an abundance of caution. When in doubt,

participants should table issues until reviewed by legal.

Page 6: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

6

Antitrust Guidelines – Things to Remember

Don’t discuss prices with competitors.

Don’t forget that conviction of antitrust violations is criminal and

can lead to personal incarceration and substantial fines for you as

well as your company.

Don’t agree with competitors to boycott suppliers or customers.

Don’t prepare documents or make presentations without

considering antitrust implications.

Don’t discuss with competitors levels of production outputs.

Page 7: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

7

Safety Moment

Road Departures and Rollovers historically increase during the

winter months.

Commuting Incidents Target audience for this alert All Business drivers. What happened Recently, three single vehicle rollover incidents have occurred during commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations of these incidents are not yet complete. Incidents occurred during hours of darkness on straight roadways covered in ice and snow. All three vehicles were travelling below the posted speed limits. Lessons learned Challenge the need for the trip and explore the possibility to car pool to site. Vehicles should be equipped with the proper tires for the season/conditions. Road and weather conditions must be part of a Journey Management Plan. Review the weather reports and road condition reports daily before starting a journey. If required, check the

conditions often throughout the day. Recommendations Review the Shell Winter Driving Guide and Safety Meeting Presentation with staff and contractors. Remind drivers to drive to the road / weather conditions and if the conditions are too poor for travel, cancel the journey. Further information For more incident details or more information regarding the questions, please contact your local Road Transport Safety focal or UA Road Safety.

Page 8: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

8

Journey Management

Page 9: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

9

Introductions

Karen Spring Logan – Regional Road Transport Safety Manager

Sean Brierley – Logistics Manager - Unconventionals

Andrew Ward – Logistics Lead Greater Deep Basin

Sam Beggs – Logistics Lead Groundbirch & Gundy

Dwaine Stovka – Road Transport Unconventionals

Trevor Kostrosky & Jesse Evenshen – RT Groundbirch

Emmersen Close – RT Greater Deep Basin

David Myrah – HSE Manager – Menlo

Page 10: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

10

What Shell would like from you and your teams...

Crews that are knowledgeable and are willing to PAUSE

Crews in the fields are often the experts in their roles. They need to

PAUSE or stop work if uncertain

Report incidents/Near Miss/Potential incidents

If reported we can learn and correct potential or unsafe issues

Actively work on closing gaps identified on the Road Transport

Assessment &/or the Risk Management Assessment

Page 11: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

11

What Shell will strive to give to you...

Work

We give priority to people that work safely.

If you cannot work safe, we will drop the contract.

A safe work environment to train your new employees

SSE’s are fine – but they have to be mentored.

Full support to improve tools/procedures if you see a better way

A consistent standard of working

We know we are not perfect but we value consistency too.

Work with you to learn from every incident and continuously improve.

Page 12: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

12

Worker Competence Journey

Whitney Irwin

Vice President HSE & Training

ENTREC Corporation

Direct: 780-960-7005

[email protected]

www.entrec.com

Page 13: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

13

Learning from Incidents

Rockwater

Holly Baird

HSE Manager

Rockwater

780-831-4475

[email protected]

Page 14: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

14

Reporting – why report NM/UAC’s?

Page 15: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

15

Reporting Impacts TRCF Trend

Embrace Near Miss and Unsafe Act Reporting

• Correlation between Reporting and Results

• Build Trust to enable improvement in safety culture

• Identify underlying risks in our business

SUPPORT: Inquire with staff about the last UAC or NM they experienced.

Was it reported and shared?

Page 16: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

16

RT - Incident Reporting by Type (July YTD)

Groundbirch

Deep Basin

45

22

38

42

10

50

125

83

66

39

9

20

23

3

34

16

Page 17: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

17

Rolling Rollover Rate Alberta & BC

Weather played a significant role in creating unsafe conditions onsite and off work

sites, yet the majority of causes listed for these incidents were “procedures” related.

Driver complacency around mitigating hazardous situations created from

environmental events.

0.26 0.25 0.25 0.26

0.08

- - - - - - -

0.16

0.21 0.20 0.20

0.15 0.15

0.19 0.20

0.25 0.25 0.25

0.30

-

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

-

0.05

0.10

0.15

0.20

0.25

0.30

0.35

Aug-14 Sep-14 Oct-14 Nov-14 Dec-14 Jan-15 Feb-15 Mar-15 Apr-15 May-15 Jun-15 Jul-15

Km

s D

rive

n (

Mill

ion

s)

Inci

de

nt

Rat

e p

er

mill

ion

Km

s

Rollover 12 Month Rolling Rate (Groundbirch/Gundy & Deep Basin/Fox Creek)

GB/G Rollover Rolling Rate DB/FC Rollover Rolling Rate GB/G Kms (per million) DB/FC Kms (per million)

Page 18: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

18

Minor: MVI’s resulting in first aid cases or property damage (excluding rollovers).

Serious: MVI’s resulting in medical treatment cases and restricted work cases (excluding LTI and rollovers).

Major: MVI’s resulting in lost time injury (excluding fatalities) or vehicle rollover

4.92

0.83

3.91

1.19

10.51

2.09

3.36

4.38

6.42

- -

3.05

2.64

- - - - - - - - - - - - - -

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

1.2

1.4

1.6

-

2.00

4.00

6.00

8.00

10.00

12.00

Jul-14 Aug-14 Sep-14 Oct-14 Nov-14 Dec-14 Jan-15 Feb-15 Mar-15 Apr-15 May-15 Jun-15 Jul-15

Km

s D

riv

en

(M

illio

ns)

Incid

en

t R

ate

per

millio

n K

ms

Groundbirch/Gundy Incident Rate by Severity

(Previous 13 month comparison)

Minor MVI/RTE Incident Rate Serious MVI/RTE Incident Rate Major MVI/RTE Incident Rate Kilometers (per million)

Page 19: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

19

0.6 0.6

0.9

1.9

2.7

3.2

1.4

0.7

-

1.9

- -

0.6

-

0.6 0.5

-

0.7

- -

0.6

-

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

-

0.50

1.00

1.50

2.00

2.50

3.00

3.50

Jul-14 Aug-14 Sep-14 Oct-14 Nov-14 Dec-14 Jan-15 Feb-15 Mar-15 Apr-15 May-15 Jun-15 Jul-15

Km

s D

riv

en

(M

illio

ns)

Incid

en

t R

ate

per

millio

n K

ms

Deep Basin/Fox Creek Incident Rate by Severity (Previous 13 month comparison)

Minor MVI/RTE Incident Rate Serious MVI/RTE Incident Rate Major MVI/RTE Incident Rate Kilometers (per million)

Page 20: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

20

Road Departures

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

Wheels Dropped offMatting

Turning RoadConditions

Turning Road Conditions Passing Collision Avoidance

Page 21: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

21

Infield Inspections – DB/Fox Creek

Carriers with the best results: Caron Transport, Bluewave, Rival

Trucking, Andy’s Oilfield Hauling & Pe Ben Oilfield

YTD 125 defects detected

1 or more defects were found in 76% of inspections

5 carriers are responsible for 45% of the total defects found

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

Cargo Securement Vehicle Defect Hours of Service Documents TDG

Page 22: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

22

Infield Inspections – GB/Gundy

Carriers with the best results: B & C Trucking, Bluewave, FSJ

Oilfield, Formula Powell, Rockwater & Rogers Trucking.

YTD 51 defects detected

1 or more defects were found in 26% of inspections

5 carriers are responsible for 33% of the total defects found

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

Cargo Securement Vehicle Defect Hours of Service Documents TDG Emergency Equip

Page 23: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

23

BREAK

20 MINUTE BREAK

Page 24: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

24

Risk Management & 7 Pillar Gap

Findings

Mike Bertamini

Page 25: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

25

7 Pillar Exceptions – Soon to expire!

IVMS

Are heavy goods vehicles

equipped with an In Vehicle

Monitoring System (IVMS)?

Total assessed in Canada = 124

# without IVMS System = 46

(37%)

DRIVING EXPERIENCE

Does the road transport operation

have a written recruitment and

screening policy or procedure

covering the minimum driving

experience requirements? (3 years of

driving type of vehicle concerned)

Total assessed in Canada = 124

# without policy = 64 (52%)

Page 26: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

26

Observed Gaps

Staff competence and assurance

Lacking formal process to evaluate competence.

Hours of Service

Does your staff know the legislation?

Do Dispatchers and Drivers understand the implications of breaking the law (personal &

to your business)?

How are Dispatchers managing HoS?

Could they tell you right now how many hours each driver has left in his/her shift?

Do Dispatchers ask a driver how many hours remaining before

assigning work?

Do drivers know to say “NO” to work which will put them over their

daily/cycle limit?

Driver self check is the last “weak” barrier and this should not be used.

Page 27: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

27

Observed Gaps

Fitness for duty / Fatigue Management

How does your company ensure drivers are fit for duty?

Does your company have a fatigue management policy & program?

Do drivers understand fatigue and it’s signs (self monitoring)?

Journey Management Planning

Is JMP being used for every trip?

Is there a process to verify everyone is where they should be at the end

of a shift?

How does your company manage areas with poor/no cell coverage?

Page 28: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

28

Winter Preparation

Mike Bertamini

Page 29: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

29

Winter Driving

Septem

ber 30,

2014

2

9

121

234

Page 30: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

30

Prepare NOW!

Winter Program Engagements (start now)

Reinforce taking a "pause" or stop work

Create a Winter Preparedness Checklist and review with staff

Safety kits in all vehicles

Winter Tire Selection

Chains – Inspection & Training

Expand Journey Management Plan to Include chain up area's

Separate Winter & Summer Driver Evaluations

Dispatch to relay current conditions and hazard area's

Assess routes prior to major jobs

Proper footwear

What else can we do?????

Page 31: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

Third Party

Driver

Evaluation

If able, Have a

LGV drive route

prior

Better Training

on Resource Rds

for New Drivers

Chains

Inspection

s and

Better

Training

Hiring

Referen

ce

Checks

Improve

Drive BC

Website

Dispatch to help

relay hazards to

fleet

Earlier Winter

Engagement

Safety Stand

down going

into Season

Change

Reinforcin

g “Pause”

Survival

Equipment

Prep

Construct

More

Pullouts

Have Separate

Winter/Summe

r Driver Evals

Create Winter

Prep Checklist

for driver review

Make Winter

Driving

Program

Interactive

Ride

Along’s

Plan for extra

travel Times

in Winter

Better

Winter

Tire

Selectio

n

Include

Chain up

areas in

SJMP

Impactful

Engagemen

ts

Shell

Support for

Stop Work

Lower

Speed

Limits

Driver

Engagemen

t 1-on-1 or

small

groups

Make

Program

Interactiv

e

Mix

Experience

Levels of

Attendee’s

Obtain Driver

feedback on

Conditions to

share

Page 32: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

32

Driving

Maintain a safe following distance

Drop your speed to match road conditions.

Watch for black ice.

Accelerate and brake slowly.

Avoid sudden moves.

Know how to handle a skid.

See and be seen.

Be extremely cautious when approaching highway

maintenance vehicles

Wild life

Be aware of Fatigue, take extra breaks

Page 33: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

33

Reduce winter related incidents

How can Shell & Menlo help reduce winter related incidents?

Page 34: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

34

Worker Competence Journey

Whitney Irwin

Vice President HSE & Training

ENTREC Corporation

Direct: 780-960-7005

[email protected]

www.entrec.com

Page 35: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

35

FLEET COMPLETE

Hours of Service Management System

Shane Kennedy

Regional Sales Manager - Northern Alberta

M: 780-886-8167

[email protected]

fleetcomplete.com

Page 36: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

36

ASANA

Mandy Dawson

HSE Manager

JDA Ventures

780-532-5101

[email protected]

Page 37: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

37

ROAD SAFETY INITIATIVES

Mike Bertamini

Page 38: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

38

Road Safety User Groups

Groundbirch Road User Group

Fox Creek Operators Group

“Bad Actor” Hotline

Page 39: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

39

“Bad Actor” Hotline

Page 40: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

40

ROAD SAFETY MATERIAL

Fatigue Awareness

IVMS

Field Guides

Past Forums

Posters

Driver Awareness Videos

Journey Management

Tool Box Talks

UA Contractor website: http://uacontractor.com/roadtransport/index.php

Royal Dutch Shell: http://www.shell.com/hsse/road-safety.html

Page 41: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

http://roadcrashvictims.ccmta.ca/home.php?lang=en_CA

Facts

• On average, one person dies every five hours on Canadian roads.

More than 175 people lose their lives in a month. 40 people are killed

each week; five people die on Canada’s roads every single day.

• Each year in Canada, almost 2,100 people are killed in road crashes

and another 165,000 are injured.

• Alcohol, drugs, speeding, driver distraction, fatigue and failure to

buckle up are key factors that can contribute to collisions.

• Road crash victims also include families, friends and colleagues

who must live with the loss or suffering of their loved ones.

• Drug impaired driving is now rivaling alcohol impaired driving.

• Distracted driving is a growing concern; Canada’s youth are the

demographic most likely to text while driving.

• The four high risk factors that lead to crashes are all preventable.

These include:

- Driving impaired: Alcohol, drugs

- Speeding and/or aggressive driving

- Driver distraction and/or fatigue

- Failure to wear a seat belt

Page 42: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

42

Close Out Discussion

Open discussion/challenge:

How should we raise our game to respond to today’s challenges

creating a safer workplace together?

Demonstrate Personal Commitment and Personal CARE

Boots on the ground, where the work gets done

Performance Management

Report Everything

Page 43: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations

43

Conclusion

Survey will be sent.

Please complete – we value your input.

Page 44: Road Transport Forum · commutes. Two contractors (non-Shell) driving light goods vehicles and one contractor (non-Shell) driving a heavy goods vehicles. Why it happened The investigations