Revised EIP Paper With Marks

10
Thompson1 Mary Thompson (Max) Mr. Campbell UWRT 1103 March 28. 2015 Distortion of the “F” Word: Gender Equality v. Anti-Man Introduction: In the early days of the feminist movement, the meaning of the word feminism became distorted. Through aggressive feminists in the past that were fighting to take away rights from men, a strong anti-male bias attached itself to the word feminism. However, as time has passed the movement has evolved and so have feminists. Feminism has never meant anti-male. Feminism is defined as the advocacy of women's rights on the grounds of political, social, and economic equality to men. It is not feminists goals to take power away from men; they simply want to give equal rights to women. According to the Institute for Women’s Policy Research, in the United States, women make only $0.78 to every dollar a man makes. They are performing the same job but just because they are female they are automatically paid 22 cents less than a man. I have personal experience with this matter, which caused me to become involved in the feminist movement. I was hired as a cashier my sophomore year of high school at $7.50/hour. I started dating one of my male coworkers; he was hired at $7.75/hour for the same job even though I had past experience and he did not. My male friends made the same wage while my female friends made the wage I received. We were hired at a lower wage just because I was a woman. I worked harder, I MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:44 AM Formatted: Indent: First line: 0" MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:44 AM Formatted: Font:Bold MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:27 AM Deleted: their MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:28 AM Deleted: I

Transcript of Revised EIP Paper With Marks

  • Thompson1 Mary Thompson (Max)

    Mr. Campbell

    UWRT 1103

    March 28. 2015

    Distortion of the F Word: Gender Equality v. Anti-Man

    Introduction:

    In the early days of the feminist movement, the meaning of the word feminism

    became distorted. Through aggressive feminists in the past that were fighting to take

    away rights from men, a strong anti-male bias attached itself to the word feminism.

    However, as time has passed the movement has evolved and so have feminists.

    Feminism has never meant anti-male. Feminism is defined as the advocacy of

    women's rights on the grounds of political, social, and economic equality to men. It is

    not feminists goals to take power away from men; they simply want to give equal

    rights to women.

    According to the Institute for Womens Policy Research, in the United States,

    women make only $0.78 to every dollar a man makes. They are performing the same

    job but just because they are female they are automatically paid 22 cents less than a

    man. I have personal experience with this matter, which caused me to become

    involved in the feminist movement. I was hired as a cashier my sophomore year of

    high school at $7.50/hour. I started dating one of my male coworkers; he was hired at

    $7.75/hour for the same job even though I had past experience and he did not. My

    male friends made the same wage while my female friends made the wage I received.

    We were hired at a lower wage just because I was a woman. I worked harder, I

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:44 AMFormatted: Indent: First line: 0"MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:44 AMFormatted: Font:Bold

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:27 AMDeleted: their

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:28 AMDeleted: I

  • Thompson2 worked longer, and I proved myself as a trustworthy employee; however, every single

    woman made $0.25 less than the men.

    I do not wish to take away their right to make money. I simply want, no, I

    simply demand the same opportunities and rights as him. I demand the right to make

    the same wage for the same job. I demand to be judged on individual achievements,

    not gender. I demand a change. This is what feminists are fighting for. We want the

    same rights that men have given themselves since the beginning of time but have

    always denied women. If I am to give birth to a man, I demand to have the same

    rights as him.

    Through my research I will prove that feminists are not anti-man, they are pro

    gender equality. I will provide information about the modern feminist agenda. I will

    closely examine the stigma associated with feminism and what is being done to break

    it. I will use books, websites, magazines, speeches, and scholarly articles to explore

    and provide you with the information you will need to truly understand feminism. I

    will hopefully prove to you along the way why everyone should be a feminist.

    The History of Feminism:

    There are considered to be three waves of feminism; we are currently in the

    third wave. In order to understand feminism we first need to understand the roots

    from which it grew.

    The first wave of feminism started in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. It

    emerged through urban industrialism and socialist politics according to Martha

    Rampton with Pacific University. The original focus was to obtain womens suffrage.

    The second wave began in the 1960s through the protests of the Vietnam War and the

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:29 AMDeleted: women

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:48 AMComment [1]: New paragraph introducing the topic

  • Thompson3 Civil Rights Movement. This agenda included the passing of the Equal Rights

    Amendment that guaranteed equality regardless of gender. The third wave began in

    the 1990s and is currently referred to as the post-modern feminist movement. This

    wave has expanded globally through cultures and is starting to focus on men as well.

    They have a stance of gender equality and want to make it clear they are not anti-

    man. The are fighting for equal pay, reproductive rights for women, and the

    significance of gender equality and the inclusion of men. Rampton sums it up by

    saying the third wave of feminism breaks boundaries.

    Angela McRobbie, cultural theorist and feminist at the University of London,

    traces womens sexuality through the waves of feminism. She says that due to shifts

    in modern feminism, women are being offered the same sexual freedom as men,

    within limits. Through the fight for reproductive rights such as access to birth control,

    women are able to take control of their bodies and their sexual orientation and explore

    the world around them. While there is still discrimination between the sexes on the

    subject of sex, women are slowly obtaining the rights they want. However, the notion

    that women who sleep with a lot of men are sluts while men that sleep with a lot of

    women are heroes is still very much present. This post-modern movement is hoping

    to change that stereotype.

    Modern Feminists:

    Debora Spar, author of Wonder Women: Sex, Power, and the Quest for

    Perfection, presents the agenda of modern feminists in her interview with National

    Public Radio. As a graduate of Harvard Business School and the president of Barnard

    College she understands what it is like to claw your way to the top in a mans world.

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:51 AMComment [2]: Paragraph Moved MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:51 AMFormatted: Strikethrough

  • Thompson4 She mainly focuses on the pressure on young women to be everything: to work, have

    a family, and balance a successful personal life. She gives this expectation reliability

    as she had the pressure on her shoulders as well. Spar talks about the need for more

    women in leadership positions and political equality. This is an example of a

    successful woman, who loves men, and is fighting for gender equality.

    Marisa Meltzer parallels with Spar. She is an accomplished author of two

    books and has had work regularly published in The Wall Street Journal, Slate, Elle,

    Vogue and The New York Times. Her insight into the subject of feminism provides a

    true realistic aspect of current feminists with claims that are relevant to todays youth.

    Her article in The New York Times titled Who is a Feminist Now? examines role

    models for young girls and if they truly know the meaning of feminism. She began

    with an interview with rising actress Shailene Woodley who had been asked if she

    considered herself a feminist. Her response was No, because I love men, and I think

    the idea of raise women to power, take the men away from the power is never going

    to work. Meltzer goes on to describe how young girls dont really know what the

    word feminism means or stands for. While older celebrities such as Beyonc and

    Lena Dunham embrace the word, younger celebrities such as Woodley and Taylor

    Swift steer clear of the word due to the attached stigma. Most, like Woodley, dont

    even know the real meaning. Feminism is not something that is often taught in school.

    Most people find the subject uncomfortable to talk about. Men feel that if they bring

    up the subject they might say something offensive and women feel they might say

    something that disintegrates their claims. In order to stop the stigma we have to talk

    about it. We have to force this history into the light and learn every aspect of this

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:55 AMComment [3]: Changed wording of sentence

  • Thompson5 controversial word in order to truly understand its meaning. We have to ask

    questions, do research, and not be afraid to feel uncomfortable. We have to embrace

    feminism head out in order to achieve gender equality.

    HeForShe Campaign:

    On September 20th, 2014 famous actress, Brown graduate, and ambassador

    of UN Women, Emma Watson cordially invited men to join the fight for gender

    equality. The HeForShe campaign she was promoting extended a hand to the male

    population to join the fight for gender equality, something long overdue. Watson

    gracefully pointed out the struggles for men such as showing emotion and having

    rights to their children. She focused on the fact that there are two sides to this battle

    and we have to fight together in order to obtain absolute equality for the genders.

    Throughout her moving speech Watson pointed out that unfortunately "no

    country in the world can yet say they have achieved gender equality."

    Watson not only talked of the struggles for women in todays society but also

    the social struggles for men. As many of use have witnessed boys are taught to be

    strong, not cry, and not show emotion, for the fear that it may make them look weak.

    She was one of the first women to focus this battle on men. We dont often talk

    about men being imprisoned by gender stereotypes but I can see that that they are and

    that when they are free, things will change for women as a natural consequence.

    (Watson, 2014) Gender equality is something that not only affects women; Watson

    has been one of the first to focus on this fact. This shows first hand that feminists are

    not only concerned for their own rights, they are concerned for the rights of their

    fellow citizens, men and women alike.

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:46 AMFormatted: Font color: Black

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:48 AMComment [4]: Paragraph Moved

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:42 AMFormatted: Indent: First line: 0"

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:42 AMFormatted: Font:BoldMaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:42 AMFormatted: Font:Bold

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:36 AMDeleted: I:

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:59 AMFormatted: Indent: First line: 0"

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 12:01 PMFormatted: Font:(Default) Times NewRoman, 12 pt, Font color: CustomColor(RGB(37,36,36))

  • Thompson6 Since her speech, the HeForShe campaign sign has been seen globally. Steve

    Carrell tweeted a picture of him wearing HeForShe cufflinks at the Oscars. Harry

    Styles, famous boy band singer, instagramed a picture of him holding up the

    #HeForShe sign, along with many other male celebrities.

    Feminist Propaganda:

    Feminists grasped the worlds attention in this controversial commercial that

    used young girls cussing to express the real problems still evident in the world

    concerning women. In this case, even bad publicity was good publicity. The f-bombs

    dropped by these girls found its way to the top of Twitter, Tumblr, Facebook, and

    YouTube. It was talked about on The View, Ellen, and almost every news outlet. It

    served its purpose; to make people listen. Whether you agree or disagree with the way

    they went about publicizing this issue, you can't argue with the facts that it states. The

    girls stood there and said that 1 in 5 women will be raped, then counted five of them

    and asked who it would be. This made the problem real because these were young

    girls that you aren't helping by ignoring the problem. They talked about unequal pay

    and opportunities, one of the main issues facing American women today.

    The real question is though, will this actually change anything or give people

    another reason to turn away from feminism.

    On the opposite end of the feminist movement, Always released this

    commercial this past super bowl and captured everyones hearts and attention. It

    asked young women who had passed puberty to fight, run, and throw like a

    girl. Then they asked young girls who hadn't hit puberty to do the same. The results

    were shocking. They proved that through puberty and social media a girls view of

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:59 AMDeleted: She talked about the fact that women still make less than men do for the same work and that it wont be until 2086 until African girls are offered a secondary education. This is the sad truth unless men are able to stand with the fight and help to implement new standards for women. Standards where they are paid the same wage and where they are encouraged to pursue higher education. MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:42 AMFormatted: Font:BoldMaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:42 AMDeleted: II:

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:29 AMDeleted: sMaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:29 AMDeleted: you

  • Thompson7 herself can diminish and wither away. They believe that they are weak because that is

    what society tells them. They believe they can't play sports because it will make them

    look unattractive or "too-manly". Feminists goals consist of changing this

    environment for young girls; they want to make it so girls can grow up in a safe and

    supportive environment. They want to raise a new group of feminists who are ready

    to tackle and fight for women's rights, gender equality, and other social issues.

    This campaign made by UN Women was also broadcasted at the Super

    Bowl. They showed a series of pictures like this with womens mouths covered by

    Google searches of women cannot be, women should, and women need to.

    They were true accounts of what answers first appeared in the search bar; it was

    horrifying. It reflected the views of close-minded individuals still interested in living

    in the 15th Century. This is yet another campaign to force people to realize the

    discrimination women still face. For the purpose of this project I typed in the same

    words but for men. Below are screenshots of my results.

    This is not just a matter of womens discrimination, but men's as well. These

    results show the idea that men need to stand up and man up. They shouldn't express

    their emotions or cry. Men should drink beer and do manly things.

    We Should All Be Feminists:

    Recently while shelving books at my part time job I came across Chimamanda

    Ngozi Adichi's book We Should All Be Feminists. Adichi is a well-known Nigerian

    author and advocate for gender equality and womens rights. This book was

    originally a TedTalk she gave back in April of 2013. She told a few stories of her

    childhood and growing up in Nigeria. She talked about the first boy that called her a

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:29 AMDeleted: sMaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:29 AMDeleted: b

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:30 AMDeleted: c

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:43 AMFormatted: Indent: First line: 0"MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:43 AMFormatted: Font:BoldMaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:43 AMDeleted: III:

  • Thompson8 feminist, and meant it as an insult. She discussed how a man told her that her novel

    was feminist and that she should "never call [herself] a feminist, since feminists are

    women who are unhappy because they cannot find husbands." After much criticism

    she finally had to call herself a "Happy African Feminist Who Does Not Hate Men

    and Who Like to Wear Lip Gloss and High Heels for Herself and Not for Men."

    One of my favorite parts about her speech was when she talked about how it

    made sense for men to rule a thousand years ago because whoever was the strongest

    ruled. Since men have testosterone they are able to gain more muscle (with

    exceptions.) In today's world however, we have iPhones, we are not cavemen. You do

    not rule based on how strong you are, you rule based on your intelligence, your

    creativity, and innovation. There is no hormone to control that so women are just as

    capable to possess these qualities as men. Therefore, women should have the same

    rights and should be able to hold the same positions.

    She shared that people have told her to not use the word feminist, simply say

    you are a "believer in human rights." Her response: to choose to use the vague

    expression human rights is to deny any particular problem or gender." Her opinion is

    that feminism is the word to describe what we have to fight for and there should be no

    exceptions to that. People should embrace the true meaning of feminism and men

    should join the fight as well.

    Looking Ahead:

    Gender equality is a pressing matter that must be achieved for the sake of our

    future and the generation beyond ours. Feminists are the means to achieving this

    ideal; we cannot ignore them, we cannot fight them, we must join them. In order to

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:56 AMDeleted: able

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:45 AMDeleted: VI: MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:43 AMFormatted: Font:BoldMaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:44 AMFormatted: Indent: First line: 0"MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:44 AMFormatted: Font:BoldMaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:44 AMFormatted: Font:BoldMaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:44 AMDeleted: VI:

  • Thompson9 declare this world as equal between the genders, men and women must join together.

    They must destroy the anti-male stigma attached to feminism and create a strong

    front. Through my research I hope to have not only informed you of the problems

    facing feminists, I hope to have influenced the way you think of them. I hope I have

    convinced you to become a feminist. Your daughters, sisters, and mother deserve

    equal pay; they deserve the ability to hold a political position without being called

    incompetent. Your sons deserve to be allowed to express their emotions freely

    without discrimination; they deserve the same rights to their children as mothers do.

    The battle of the sexes has to cease. Abilities should not be based on your gender but

    on your personality, your creativity, and your passions. Feminism is not anti-man;

    it is pro gender equality.

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:30 AMDeleted:

  • Thompson10 Works Cited

    Adichie, Chimamanda Ngozi. We Should All Be Feminists. Vintage, 2014. Print.

    Always #LikeAGirl. 2014. Film.

    Potty-Mouthed Princesses Drop F-Bombs for Feminism. 2014. Film.

    Hegewisch, Ariane. "Pay Equity & Discrimination." Institute for Women's Policy

    Research. IWPR, 1 Jan. 2013. Web. 29 Mar. 2015.

    McRobbie, Angela. Beyond Post-Feminism. Juncture 179-84. IPPR. 1 Sept. 2013.

    Web. 8 Mar. 2015.

    Meltzer, Marisa. Who Is a Feminist Now? The New York Times. nytimes.com. 21

    May. 2014. Web. 8 Mar. 2015.

    Rampton, Martha. "The Three Waves of Feminism." Pacific University Oregon.

    Pacific University, 23 Oct. 2014. Web. 29 Mar. 2015.

    Spar, Debora. Interview by Terry Gross. Todays Wonder Women Must Reframe

    Feminism. National Public Radio, 16 Sept. 2013. NPR.org. Web. 8 Mar.

    2015.

    Watson, Emma. "Gender Equality Is Your Issue Too." UN Women. UN Women, 4

    Sept. 2014. Web. 8 Mar. 2015.

    MaryAlex Thompson 4/22/2015 11:33 AMDeleted: Barnard President