REVIEW OF LITERATURE - INFLIBNETshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/18626/5... · REVIEW OF...
Transcript of REVIEW OF LITERATURE - INFLIBNETshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/18626/5... · REVIEW OF...
6
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
In Punjab (an Indian State), rough lemon (Citrus jambhiri Lush.) is being used
as major root stock for a number of Citrus spp. like mosumbies, kinnows, oranges,
grape fruits etc. for its high vigour and well adaptation to climate of Punjab as well as
resistance to Citrus tristeza virus (cause of an epidemic). However, the main drawback
is its sensitivity to Phytophthora, which leads to major losses in an orchard if proper
phytosanitary conditions are not followed. Phytophthora species have been shown to
cause some serious soil borne diseases of citrus including damping off of seedlings in
the seedbed, root and crown rot in nurseries, foot rot and brown rot of fruits.
2.1. CITRUS DISEASES CAUSED BY PHYTOPHTHORA SPP.
Phytophthora is a cosmopolitan Oomycete of warm temperate, subtropical, and
tropical environments. It has a broad host range including both herbaceous (e.g.
tobacco, tomato, carnation) and woody (e.g. Citrus and Eucalyptus) hosts.
Phytophthora spp. cause the most serious and economically important soilborne
diseases of Citrus crops. Tree and crop production losses occur from damping-off of
seedlings in the seedbed, root and crown rot in nurseries, foot rot and fibrous root rot
and brown rot of fruits in groves. Foot rot results from infection of the bark near the
ground level producing lesions on the trunk or crown roots that can girdle and kill the
tree. Phytophthora spp. also attack and cause the decay of fibrous roots, especially on
susceptible rootstocks in nurseries. In bearing groves, fibrous root rot damage causes
tree decline and yield losses. The most important species include Phytophthora
parasitica Dastur (P. nicotianae), P. citrophthora and P. palmivora. P. parasitica has
been reported to cause citrus diseases in India (Kamat, 1927; Uppal and Kamat, 1936;
Kumbhare and Moghe, 1976; Lele and Kapoor, 1982; Naqvi, 1988; Naqvi, 2000b) and
Florida (Zitko and Timmer, 1994; Widmer et al., 1998; Graham and Menge, 2000).
Other Phytophthora spp. viz. P. boehmeriae, P. cactorum, P. cinnamon, P. citricola, P.
citrophthora, P. dreschleri, P. hibernalis, P. megasperma, P. palmivora and P. syngiae
have been reported pathogenic on citrus from different Citrus growing areas of World
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
7
(Boccas and Leville, 1978; Erwin and Rebiero, 1996; Naqvi, 2002b). P. citropthora and
P. parasitica are wide spread in tropical and subtropical areas of citrus causing foot rot,
root rot, gummosis and brown rot of citrus.
2.1.1. History and distribution
Phytophthora is most destructive pathogen of Citrus trees. It had been causing
severe crop losses to citrus orchards much before its discovery in real scientific terms.
In 1836, large scale destruction of citrus plants because of Phytophthora infection was
recorded in Azore Island, much before the potato famine of Ireland in 1845, and after
31 years of famine Anton de Bary discovered the fungus as Phytophthora means “plant
destroyer”. The first appearance of Phytophthora epidemic of citrus was reported in
Azore Island during 1832-1836 (Bonavia, 1988). Later Phytophthora epidemics of
citrus were reported in 1841 from France, in 1845 from Purtagal, in 1855-1889 from
Italy, in 1860-1879 from Australia, in 1871 from Spain, in 1875 from California, in
1876 from Florida, in 1869-1880 from Greece, in 1906 from Cuba, in 1911 from
Paraguay, in 1917 from Brazil, in 1920 from Mexico and in 1935 from Trinidad
(Fawcett, 1936).
An extensive survey of citrus orchards and citrus nurseries in India has been
conducted under National Network Project on Phytophthora disease of Horticulture
Crops (Citrus) funded by Indian Council of Agricultural Research during 1997-2002.
Citrus cultivation belt of Vidarbha and Marathwada region of Maharashtra, Punjab,
Madhya Pradesh, Andhra Pradesh and North Eastern States of India were surveyed to
assess the impact of Phytophthora diseases. Two mating type (A1 and A2) of
Phytophthora parasitica (nicotianae) have been recorded from the orchards of Nagpur
mandarin in Nagpur district (Naqvi, 2000b, 2002b). P. parasitica Dastur has been a
common species associated with citrus disease in Assam (Chowdhury, 1951) and in
North-West India (Bajwa, 1941; Paracer and Chahal, 1962). Kapoor and Bakshi (1967)
reported that 14-18% decline in sweet orange was due to foot rot in Abohar (Punjab).
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
8
In Madhya Pradesh adjoining to Vidharbha region of Maharashtra, India 20-
50% Nagpur mandarin plants were found affected and causing severe decline due to P.
parasitica, P. citrophthora along with P. palmivora (Naqvi, 2000b). In Andhra
Pradesh, 20-100% acid lime plantation was severly affected with P. parasitica along
with P. citropthora and P. palmivora. Kinnow growing areas of Punjab state, 10-80%
plants of C. sinensis Osbeck and 10-100% plants of kinnow mandarin ranging from 12-
25 years old, were showing symptoms of diseases caused by P. parasitica, P.
citrophthora and P. palmivora due to accessive flood irrigation (Naqvi, 2002a, 2002b).
Northeastern states of India are considered the natural home of citrus and place of origin
of several Citrus species. In Tripura State, the citrus cultivation is mostly confined to
Jampui Hills and sankan area about 140 Km from Agartala. In Tripura and Mezoram
State, almost all the citrus orchards are seriously infested/infected with P. parasitica, P.
citrophthora and P. palmivora causing gummosis, root rot and leaf fall (Naqvi, 2000b,
2002b).
2.1.2. Symptomatology
A survey of Central India for Phytophthora diseases of Nagpur Mandarin and
other Citrus spp. has revealed that P. parasitica, P. citrophthora along with P.
palmivora are causing root rot and crown rot of C. jambhiri (rough lemon)- a major root
stock for the area and foot rot and leaf fall of nagpur mandarin (Naqvi, 1988, 2000a,
2002a, 2002b). A 1987 survey of nurseries in Florida indicated that 8 of 15 field
nurseries were infested with P. parasitica, whereas only 1 of 13 of the greenhouse
operations was infested (Zitko et al., 1987). Several species of Phytophthora have been
associated to this syndrome but P. citrophthora and P. parasitica (sin. P. nicotianae)
have been identified as the most destructive species causing foot rot (gummosis) and
root rot, often considered as two different diseases affecting citrus production
worldwide (Klotz, 1973; Timmer and Menge, 1993; Zitko et al., 1991; Martins et al.,
2001; Siviero et al., 2002; Timmer et al., 2003; Vernière et al., 2004).
In Chile, P. citrophthora and P. parasitica were reported on lemon and sweet
orange associated with foot rot and P. citrophthora to citrus brown rot on lemon fruits
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
9
(Besoain et al., 1998; Mujica and Vergara, 1980). However, a complete characterization
of the Phytophthora species involved in these syndromes and their relative importance
and distribution remain unknown in Chile. In Spain P. citrophthora was shown to affect
clementine (Citrus clementina Hort. ex Tan.) cultivars and their hybrids (Alvarez et al.,
2008a,b, 2009) resulting in considerable losses. Diseased trees showed cankers and gum
exudations on the above-ground parts on the scions, especially on the major limbs,
whereas rootstocks generally remained healthy. The trunk and secondary branches were
affected by the expansion of these lesions and eventually, the entire tree collapsed and
died (Alvarez et al., 2008a). Phytophthora branch canker has also been described in the
winter rainfall citrus-growing areas of South Africa affecting mainly clementine
cultivars (Schutte, 2007). Phytophthora causes the following common diseases in Citrus
cultivars.
2.1.2.1. Damping-off
Damping-off of seedlings in nursery bed is a widespread problem of citrus
industry and frequently occurs in citrus orchards where phytosanitory conditions are
difficult to maintain. More than 20% seedling mortality has been observed in central
India due to Phytophthora infection (Naqvi, 1996, 2000a). Damping-off of Citrus
seedlings is caused by Phytophthora parasitica, P. citrophthora and P. palmivora.
Typical symptoms of damping-off result when the soil or seed-borne fungus penetrates
the stem just above the soil line and causes the seedling to topple. Phytophthora spp.
also cause seed rot or pre-emergence rot. Infected seedlings are killed rapidly when
moisture is abundant and temperatures are favourable for fungal growth (Klotz et al.,
1969). Plants usually become resistant to damping-off once true leaves have emerged
and the stem tissue at the soil line has matured.
2.1.2.2. Foot rot and gummosis
The most serious diseases caused by Phytophthora spp. are foot rot and
gummosis (Fawcett, 1913; 1936). Foot rot results from an infection of the scion near the
ground level, producing lesions which extend down to the budunion on resistant
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
10
rootstocks. Scaffold root rot or crown rot below ground may occur when susceptible
rootstocks are used. Infected bark remains firm with small cracks through which
abundant gum exudation occurs. Citrus gum, which is water-soluble, disappears after
heavy rains but is persistent on the trunk under dry conditions. Lesions spread around
the circumference of the trunk, slowly girdling the tree. Badly affected trees have pale
green leaves with yellow veins, a typical girdling effect. If the lesions cease to expand
or the fungus dies, the affected area is surrounded by a callus tissue. Nursery trees and
young orchard trees of small trunk circumference can be rapidly girdled and killed.
Large trees may be killed likewise, but typically the trunks are partially girdled and the
tree canopy undergoes defoliation, twig dieback, and short growth flushes. On
susceptible rootstocks, lesions may occur on the crown roots below the soil line and
symptoms in the canopy develop without obvious damage to the trunk above ground
(Timmer and Menge, 1993; Timmer et al., 2003; Alvarez et al., 2008a).
2.1.2.3. Fibrous root rot
Phytophthora spp. infect the root cortex and cause a decay of fibrous roots. The
cortex turns soft, becomes somewhat discoloured and appears watersoaked. The fibrous
roots slough their cortex leaving only the white thread-like stele, which gives the root
system a stringy appearance. Root rot can be especially severe on susceptible rootstocks
in infested nursery soil. Root rot also occurs on susceptible rootstocks in bearing
orchards where damage causes tree decline and yield losses. In advanced stages of
decline, the production of new fibrous roots cannot keep pace with root death. The tree
is unable to maintain adequate water and mineral uptake and nutrient reserves in the
root are depleted by the repeated fungal attacks. This results in the reduction of fruit
size and production, loss of leaves and twig dieback of the canopy (Timmer and Menge,
1993; Timmer et al., 2003).
2.1.2.4. Brown rot of fruit
Phytophthora infection of fruit produces a decay in which the affected area is
light brown, leathery and not sunken compared to the adjacent rind. White mycelium
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
11
forms on the rind surface under humid conditions. In the orchard, fruits near the ground
become infected when splashed with soil containing the fungus. If favourable
conditions of optimum temperature (75-82°F) and long periods of wetting (18 plus
hours) continue, the disease spreads to fruit throughout the canopy. Most of the infected
fruit soon abscise, but those that are harvested may not show symptoms until after they
have been held in storage for a few days. If infected fruit is packed, brown rot may
spread to adjacent fruit in the container. In storage, infected fruit have a characteristic
pungent, rancid odour. Brown rot epidemics are usually restricted to areas where
rainfall coincides with the early stages of fruit maturity (Timmer and Menge, 1993;
Timmer et al., 2003).
2.1.3. Disease cycle
The disease cycle of P. parasitica begins with the production of sporangia
which release large numbers of zoospores, chlamydospores and oospores. With time
and appropriate conditions zoospores encyst and germinate to form mycelia. The
optimum temperature for mycelial growth is 86°-90°F. Sporangial production is favored
by small deficits in matric water potential (5 to -70 KPa), but not by saturated
conditions unless sporangia are produced on citrus root pieces. The optimum conditions
for sporangium formation probably represent a compromise between requirements for
free water and aeration. Nutrition depletion and light also stimulate sporangial
production from mycelium. Indirect germination of sporangia to produce zoospores
requires free water and is stimulated by a drop in temperature. Under moist conditions
sporangia may also germinate directly by growth of germ tubes, but the correlation
between soil saturation and severity of Phytophthora root rot suggests that indirect
germination is more important in the root disease cycle.
Chlamydospore production by P. parasitica occurs under unfavourable
conditions for fungal growth, i.e. nutrient depletion, and low oxygen levels and
temperature (59-64°F). Water requirements for germination of chlamydospores are
similar to those for sporangia. Chlamydospores of P. parasitica appear to become
dormant below 59°F, so exposure to temperatures of 82-90°F is used to stimulate
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
12
germination. Nutrients that are acquired from soil extracts and excised citrus roots are
known to stimulate chlamydospore germination. The requirements for oospore
germination are thought to be nearly identical to those of chlamydospores. Oospore
maturation appears to be an important factor in germinability of Phytophthora spp.
Periods of alternating high and low temperatures may also be a prerequisite for uniform
germination (Timmer and Menge, 1993; Timmer et al., 2003).
2.1.4. Epidemiology
Phytophthora inhabits the soil and is a water loving fungus. It survives in soil
through small thick walled spores (chlamydospores) and oospores which can tolerate
dry summer conditions. The chlamydospores are developed in cool and dry conditions
with limited soil moisture, poorly aerated soil with high CO2 concentration and in
paucity of actively growing roots since Phytophthora species are primarily parasites but
are poor saprophytes in soil. Under favourable conditions of high moisture and
temperature, infected roots produce sporangia which in turn release motile zoospores.
The zoospores swim in water for short distance by flagellar movement or may be
carried away by rain or irrigation water. Zoospores are attracted to the zone of
elongation of new roots by nutrients in exudations. Upon contact with the root,
zoospores encyst, germinate and then infect in the area of the zone of root elongation
(Duniway, 1983; Khew and Zentmeyer, 1973, 1974). Once the fungus has entered the
root tip, the infection may advance in the cortex resulting in rot of the entire rootlet. The
cycle can repeat itself as long as conditions are favourable and susceptible tissue is
available.
In case of P. parasitica, the fungus most likely survives unfavourable periods in
root debris. The rotted cortex is sloughed and the fungus produces chlamydospores
which may persist in the soil for long periods (Tsao and Ocana, 1969). When favourable
conditions return, chlamydospores germinate indirectly to produce sporangia and
zoospores or directly to produce mycelium. When both mating types are present
oospores may also be produced which aid survival of the fungus. Foot rot or gummosis
of the trunk occurs when zoospores or other propagules are splashed onto the trunk
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
13
above the bud union. A wound and moisture on or around the base of the trunk are
necessary for infection. Wounds are susceptible to infection for up to 14 days. Foot rot
lesions do not usually produce inoculum for subsequent infections and thus are of no
epidemiologic significance. Even though Phytophthora spp. in Citrus are usually
present, epidemics can develop in certain cases. When Phytophthora spp. are first
introduced into a grove or nursery, spread to other plants may be epidemic. However,
epidemics of foliage blight and brown rot are much more common, especially on highly
susceptible hosts such as lemons. When conditions are favourable, fruit and young
foliage may become infected by propagules splashed from the soil. Secondary
infections may then be caused by inoculum from the above-ground parts of the plant
which is dispersed by rain splash or wind-blown rain. This seldom occurs with P.
parasitica which does not readily produce aerial sporangia, but is more common in P.
citrophthora and other species which produce abundant sporangia on fruit and leaf
surfaces. Brown rot is most common in areas where these species are present and when
prolonged winter rains occur (Graham and Timmer, 1992; Naqvi, 1999a, 1999e, 2000a,
2000c).
2.1.5. Means of spread
The primary means by which Phytophthora spp. are spread through citrus
orchards is by use of infested nursery stock (Graham and Timmer, 1992; Naqvi, 1999a,
1999e, 2000a, 2000c). Ristaino and Gimpertz (2000) reported the mechanisms of
dispersal of Phytophthora species viz. (i) dispersal from root to root in soil involves
either root growth to inoculums, inoculum movement to roots or root to root contacts.
(ii) Inoculum dispersal in surface water. (iii) Splash dispersal from soil to aerial parts of
the plant. (iv) Aerial dispersal from sporulating lesions on leaves, stem, fruits or other
aerial parts of the plant and (v) dispersal by human or invertebrate activities including
movement of soil, plants or propagules. The pathogen may be present in soil or infected
roots even though disease symptoms are not readily apparent. The fungus is also carried
in soil on equipment when vehicles move from infested to non-infested groves or
nurseries. Propagule densities decline sharply when soil is air-dried, reducing the
probability of spread. Irrigation water may also move the pathogen from area to area.
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
14
Within groves, dispersal by irrigation water occurs especially where furrow or flood
irrigation is used. Surface water following heavy rains may carry the fungus as it drains
from the grove. More serious problems can arise in irrigated Citrus areas where run-off
water carries the pathogen into canals or ponds. Use of water from these sources may
then contaminate previously noninfested areas. Wind is not a major factor in dispersal
of Phytophthora spp. However, wind-borne soil carries Phytophthora spp. and may
recontaminate fumigated soils. Windblown rain can disseminate sporangia produced on
the surface of aboveground plant parts. Environmental factors also play an important
role in disease development, severity, dispersal and surviaval of Phytophthora in
causing epidemics (Govindarao, 1954; Cheema et al., 1954). Phytophthora parasitica
was prevalent in warmer and drier climate of Vidarbha, Ahmednagar and Kodur at 30◦-
32◦C temperature and rainfall below 1150-1300 mm (Lele and Kapoor, 1982). In Citrus
nurseries of Vidarbha region, population of P. parasitica and P. palmivora increases
with increase in temperature while population of P. citrophthora decreases with
increase in temperature. The soil temperature in central India remains between 20-29◦C
through out the year. Thus, Phytophthora remains active throughout the year in citrus
nurseries and irrigated orchards of high region (Naqvi, 1990, 2002b). The critical
threshold temperature for Phytophthora parasitica is 33◦C or above in Arizona. A
fivefold increase in zoospore motility was observed for P. citrophthora at 24◦C than at
30◦C, temperature that respectively prevents and favours colonization while an 11-fold
increase was detected for zoospores of P. parasitica at favourable temperature
compared to inhibitory soil temperatures of 30 and 36◦C respectively (Matheron and
Porchas, 1996).
2.1.6. Isolation and detection
For disease management purposes, it is frequently desirable to know whether
Phytophthora spp. are present and if so, at what level. Fruit and leaf baiting methods
were developed many years ago for detection of Phytophthora spp. (Grimm and
Alexender, 1973; Klotz et al., 1958). These are usually considered qualitative tests, but
propagule densities can be quantitated by use of more complex techniques. They are
relatively simple and require minimal equipment and supplies. Subsequently, media
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
15
have been developed for the selective isolation of Phytophthora spp. from soil to
determine propagule densities (Tsao, 1960; 1970; 1983). Methods for sample collection
and handling have been developed. Propagule densities are highest where fibrous root
densities are greatest. Thus, populations diminish with depth and with distance from the
tree. It is also important to recognize that Phytophthora populations are not uniform
across the orchard. Spatial distribution studies in Florida indicate a more random
distribution of the fungus in a grove. For routine propagule density determinations,
samples should be collected at random in the orchard. Propagule densities vary
considerably between sample times and populations may show seasonal trends of
abundance. Genus specific polyclonal and monoclonal antibodies have been produced
against Phytophthora. For detection and quantification of Phytophthora parasatica, P.
citrophthora and P. palmivora many mediums have been used viz. Modified Kerr’s
medium (Hendrix and Kuhlman, 1965), MacCain medium (McCain et al., 1967),
Masago medium (Masago et al., 1977), PVPH medium (Tsao and Guy, 1977), PARPH
medium (Mitchell et al., 1986) and BHMPVR medium (Bist and Nene, 1988). The
number of selective agar media containing antibacterial antibiotics and selective fungal
agents have been proved successful in Phytophthora isolations from soil and plant
tissues (Eckert and Tsao, 1960; Kuhlman and Hendrix, 1965; Flowers and Hendrix,
1969; Tsao and Ocana, 1969; Sneh, 1972; Fugisawa and Masago, 1975; Masago et al.,
1977; Tsao and Guy, 1977; Kueh and Khew, 1982). Leaflets of Albizzia falcatarea were
used as baits to isolate Phytophthora palmivora (Butl). Butt. MF4 from soil (Anandaraj
and Sharma, 1990).
Diagnostic kits using enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) have been
developed for detection of Phytophthora spp. in roots and in soil debris. The ELISA
method is highly sensitive and can detect the presence of Phytophthora at lower
population densities than dilution plating onto selective media (Miller and Martin, 1988;
Miller et al., 1990; Skaria and Miller, 1989). Theoretically, the tissue baiting and the
ELISA soil assay should be the most sensitive since they utilize larger volumes of soil.
However, in one study the leaf baiting and selective media were about equally sensitive
(Timmer et al., 1993). Although it is possible to quantify Phytophthora spp.
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
16
populations, the significance of those populations remains yet to be determined.
Populations may vary considerably during a season suggesting a need to sample
repeatedly through the year as well as from year to year. Propagule densities in most
Florida groves range from 1-20 propagules/cm3, but occasionally range as high as 100-
200 propagules/cm3. Threshold densities have not been established, but populations of
less than 5 propagules/cm3 have been considered insignificant. Increases in fibrous root
densities and in some cases, yield have been observed following fungicide treatment of
orchards with 10 propagules/cm3 or higher.
Recently, for quick and reliable identification of Phytophthora species, internal
transcribed spacers (ITS) based identification have been developed to identify known
species of Phytophthora and unknown isolates quickly (Cooke et al., 1996; Cooke et
al., 2000; Crawford et al., 1996; Cooke and Duncan, 1997; Lee et al., 1993; Levesque
et al., 1998; Ristaino et al., 1994). An identification website has also been developed to
facilitate Phytophthora workers where user generated ITS digest profiles of any
unidentified taxa may be entered to the search page for comparison with the database.
The website (www.phytid.com) includes a database of 48 Phytophthora species.
However, some species remain as polyphyletic assemblages awaiting more rigorous
analysis (Braiser and Hanson, 1992). There is need to optimize PCR assays for
detection of different propagule types in soil, if these assays are to be used for precision
agriculture application (Ristaino and Gumpertz, 2000). Molecular detection methods of
Phytophthora and their impacts on plant disease management have been reviewd
(Martin et al., 2000).
2.1.7. Pathogenicity testing
Zoospore suspensions have been successfully used by several workers to
establish the pathogenicity of Phytophthora spp. on their hosts (Mehrotra, 1972;
McDonald and Duniway, 1978; Sastry, 1982; Dutta, 1984; Subramanian, 1993).
Sowic et al. (2001) reported the effects of culture filtrates (CFs) and
homogenates of Verticillium dahliae and Phytophthora cactorum on in vitro growth and
development of strawberry shoots of cvs. Elsanta, Real and Senga Sengana. The
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
17
filtrates of fungal cultures as well as filtrates of homogenated mycelia did not affect
strawberry shoot growth and development, whereas inoculation with mycelia of V.
dahliae and P. cactorum resulted in leaf yellowing, growth inhibition, inhibition of root
formation and after several days, the death of infected plants. However, fungal growth
on the culture media was irregular and the infection rate of individual plants was
variable.
Siviero et al. (2002) reported inoculation methods of Phytophthora parasitica
on seedlings and young plants of Citrus spp. to determine the resistance of citrus
rootstocks to Phytophthora gummosis. The following inoculation methods were tested:
non-wounded host-pathogen contact, bark removal, insertion of culture disc under bark,
insertion of inoculated needle or toothpick in the collar region and the culture disc
method. The assessment of resistance to gummosis in citrus seedlings produced in vitro
was achieved by inserting an inoculation in collar region. The disc method and insertion
of disc under the bark were the best inoculation methods for young plants under both
orchard and greenhouse conditions. The best variable for disease assessment had been
the measurement of the total lesion area. Lesion length can also be used when
pathogenesis tests were carried out in nurseries and in the field.
Vial et al. (2006) reported pathogenicity testing of different isolates of
Phytophthora spp. A total of 27 pathogenic isolates of Phytophthora were obtained in
2003 and 2004. Morphologically, 20 isolates were identified as P. citrophthora;
however, they were distinctively divided into sterile and fertile isolates. The latter were
morphologically similar to P. citrophthora sensu lato but, they induced oospore
production when pairing against P. cinnamomi A2. These fertile isolates exhibited a
98% match with several P. citrophthora strains and were considerably less aggressive
than sterile isolates. Phytophthora inundata, a relatively new described species, was
identified on the basis of analysis of the ITS regions of rDNA. Isolates of P. inundata
were weakly pathogenic on citrus and possibly were found as secondary pathogens
without importance on foot and root rot development on Citrus trees. P. citrophthora
was the cause of foot and root rot found on Chilean citrus groves, planted in temperate
and relatively dry weather conditions. The isolation and pathogenicity of P.
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
18
citrophthora on Citrus macrophylla and carrizo citrange, considered resistant
rootstocks, could be suggesting that these isolates have overcome resistant genes
associated with Phytophthora resistant citrus rootstocks.
Savita et al. (2011a) studied the effect of culture filtrate (CF) of P. parasitica
on rooting response by culturing shoots regenerated from calli on MS medium
containing 0.5 mg/l NAA and different concentrations of CF (5–100%). Two types of
controls were set: MSA- MS rooting medium containing autoclaved CF and MS0-MS
rooting medium without CF. When regenerated shoots were cultured on rooting
medium without CF they showed 91.66% rooting response whereas culture of shoots on
MSA medium showed rooting in 86.11% cultures. A dramatic fall in rooting response
(47.22%) was observed when shoots were cultured on rooting medium containing 5%
CF. At 10% CF only 19.45% shoots showed rooting. Whereas no rooting response was
observed with 15% and higher concentrations of CF. 100% necrosis of shoots was
observed with 25% and higher concentrations of CF.
2.1.8. Economic importance
Phytophthora species are responsible for significant economic losses to citrus
industry. Besides foot rot and brown rot, root rot caused by Phytophthora alone reduces
46% yield of citrus plants in California and Citrus industry losses around 12.9 million
dollar annually due to this pathogen (Anonymous, 1989; Menge, 1993). To combat this
problem in India, Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR) launched a National
Network Project on Phytophthora Diseases of Horticultural Crops (PHYTONET) in
1977. Phytophthora causes serious disease to Citrus and infect almost every part of
citrus plants (Naqvi, 2003).
2.1.9. Disease management
The disease is transmitted from soil, hence the use of Phytophthora resistant/
tolerant budwood or saplings is the recommended principle to check the spread of the
disease in the virgin areas. The “Budwood Certification Programme” including
surveillance, indexing and identification of mother trees resistant to Phytophthora
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
19
should be strengthened for raising disease free planting materials. The marked
Phytophthora resistant trees should be multiplied and distributed to nurserymen for
producing Phytophthora resistant seedlings. Strict plant quarantine measures should be
enforced to check the movement of contaminated budwood and planting material in the
new planting sites. Some of the effective fungicides for Phytophthora root rot diseases
include Subdue MAXX, Chipco Aliette, Banrot and Truban which can be used for
effective disease management.
2.2. TISSUE CULTURE STUDIES IN CITRUS SPECIES
Studies on citrus tissue and organ culture in vitro were initiated in early 1950s
with the aim of genetic improvement of the species as well as to obtain virus free plants.
In vitro techniques have the potentiality to multiply for large scale propagation.
Plantlets can be obtained through direct plant regeneration, indirect plant regeneration
through callus and through somatic embryogenesis.
2.2.1. Direct plant regeneration
Regeneration through callus has one major limitation in the sense that
regenerants produced via callus mediated regeneration exhibit somaclonal variations
which is not desirable in an attempt to produce uniform planting material. On the other
hand, tissue culture methods inducing direct shoot regeneration possesses less
probability of somaclonal variations among regenerants in comparison to callus
mediated regeneration pathways. Furthermore, the availability of an efficient
regeneration system is also a necessary pre-requisite for genetic improvement and
genetic resource conservation. Several researchers have reported regeneration in
different species of Citrus using different explants.
Edriss and Burger (1984) reported direct shoot formation from root segments of
troyer citrange (Citrus sinensis [L.] Osbeck x Poncirus trifoliata L. Raf.) on Murashige
and Skoog’s (MS) medium supplemented with 10 mg/l BA + 1 mg/l NAA. Sim et al.
(1989) reported shoot induction from different vegetative parts of Citrus mitis seedlings
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
20
(epicotyl, leaf, shoot tip and nodal segments) and mature plants. A high frequency (66–
100%) of shoot regeneration was obtained from shoot tip and nodal segments of mature
plants cultured on medium with or without benzylaminopurine (BA). Bud induction
from roots was examined in 3 systems: (a) intact roots on whole seedlings; (b) intact
roots on decapitated (shootless) seedlings; (c) excised roots. The highest yield of buds
was obtained from intact roots on whole seedlings cultured in medium with 0.5 mg/1
BA, from which 275 shoots were obtained from 13 cultures in 9 weeks. Regenerated
shoots were rooted in basal medium and the plantlets were successfully transplanted to
soil.
Tisserat et al. (1989) reported that juice vesicles isolated from 120-180 day old
fruits of different Citrus spp. were capable of proliferation via adventitious vesicle
branching in vitro. Gibberellic acid (GA3) levels of 1-100 mg/l greatly enhanced
adventitious vesicle branching while delaying vesicle senescence as evidenced by the
vesicle’s ability to retain its green colour for up to 4 to 6 months in culture. Vesicles
grown on media without GA3 readily matured, turning opaque within 2 months in
culture and rarely produced adventitious branches. Additions of 0.1 mg/l
α-naphthaleneacetic acid (NAA) or 1.0 mg/l BA to media containing 10 mg/l GA3
further enhanced vesicle branching in some species and cultivars. Adventitious juice
vesicles have been induced from a variety of Citrus species, including Citrus grandis
(L.) Osb., C. hystrix DC., C. limon (L.) Burm. f., C. medica L., C. paradisi Macf., C.
reticulata Blanco and C. sinensis (L.) Osb. Adventitious vesicle branches originate from
primordia initiated on the surface of the cultured vesicle. These primordia commonly
occurred on the terminal meristem region of the vesicle. However, some species (e.g. C.
grandis and C. paradisi) produced adventitious vesicle branches from their bodies and
stalks as well. Distinct vesicle branches begin to appear on preformed vesicles after 30-
60 days in culture.
Bhat et al. (1992) established root culture of lime, C. aurantifolia, in MS
medium containing 3% sucrose. De novo shoot bud initiation was recorded in basal
medium at a low frequency during three years of continuous culture. The effect of
indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) and BA investigated on root growth and shoot
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
21
morphogenesis. Inclusion of BA in the culture medium had an important effect on root
growth and shoot elongation. The frequency of shoot regeneration was only slightly
improved by the growth regulator treatment. Shoot bud differentiation occurred at the
proximal region of the root at or just distal to the cut end. Histology of shoot
regeneration revealed the endogenous origin of the shoot buds from the pericycle tissue
of the root. The regenerated plants contained normal diploid chromosome number (2n =
18) and were successfully established in soil.
Goh et al. (1995) reported shoot regeneration from root segments of Pummelo
(C. grandis) with 0.89 µM BA and shoot regeneration from epicotyl segments with 2.2
µM BA. Maggon and Singh (1995) reported promotion of adventitious bud regeneration
by absicic acid (ABA) in combination with BA in epicotyl and hypocotyl explants of
sweet orange (Citrus sinensis L. Osbeck var. mousambi). Epicotyl and hypocotyl
segments (1–1.5 cm) from 2 weeks old sweet orange seedlings germinated in vitro were
placed horizontally on MS basal medium. Adventitious shoot regeneration from the cut
ends occurred only in epicotyl explants. Addition to the MS medium of BA up to 2 mg/l
had a promotive effect, both in terms of the frequency of responding explants and the
number of shoots per explant, while higher concentrations of BA had a depressive
effect. GA3 at 0.04 and 0.4 mg/l with or without 2 mg/l BA suppressed shoot bud
regeneration in both types of explants. ABA alone suppressed shoot regeneration when
added to basal MS medium, but in combination with 2 mg/l BA it had a strong
promotive effect, particularly at 0.2 mg/l. A remarkable feature of this ABA effect was
that the bulk of the buds regenerated away from the cut ends directly from the epidermis
without any apparent callus formation. These shoot buds did not develop further even
8–10 weeks after their transfer to the basal MS medium, but showed normal growth on
medium containing 0.04 mg/l GA3.
El-Morsy and Millet (1996) reported shoot induction from nodal segments of C.
aurantium on MS medium supplemented with 0.5 mg/l Kinetin (KN) + 0.5 mg/l GA3 +
0.2 mg/l indole-3-butyric acid (IBA). Roots were induced from shoots on MS medium
supplemented with NAA 2 mg/l. Gutierrez et al. (1997) used Murashige and Tucker’s
medium supplemented with BA 5 mg/l to regenerate shoots from internodal stem
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
22
segments of sour orange (C. aurantium). Normah et al. (1997) reported multiple shoot
induction from shoot tips, nodal segments and hypocotyls of C. halimii on MS medium
supplemented with 4.4-11.1 µM BA, 2.2 µM BA and 2.2-11.1 µM BA respectively.
These shoots were separated and individual shoots were transferred on rooting medium.
Best rooting response was observed on MS medium supplemented with 2.7 µM NAA.
Garcia-Luis et al. (1999) reported that morphogenic pathway of adventitious
bud and shoot regeneration at the ends of troyer citrange epicotyl cuttings is determined
by polarity and explant orientation. In explants planted vertically with the basal end
inserted in the medium, bud formation at the apical end occurs by direct organogenesis.
Bud growth and subsequent shoot formation is markedly increased by the addition of
BA to the medium. This growth regulator also increases the number of buds formed.
When the epicoyl cuttings come in contact with the culture medium, both the apical end
and the basal end of the cutting form a vigorous callus with many xyllary elements. In
these calli, buds differentiate by a process of indirect organogenesis. This indirect
regeneration pathway requires the addition of BA to the medium and the number of
buds formed is higher at the apical end than at the basal end of the cuttings. This
pathway of regeneration is reduced as the position of the cuttings during incubation
deviates from the normal upright vertical position. Thus, for the basal end of the
cuttings, the number of buds and shoots formed is higher when the explants are placed
vertically than when they lie on the surface of the medium. For the apical end, this
number is higher in explants placed horizontally than when inserted vertically in the
medium in an inverted position.
Le et al. (1999) designed a method for direct in vitro bud regeneration of
trifoliate orange (Poncirus trifoliata L. Raf). Transverse thin cell layer (tTCL) explants
excised from the stem internodes of 1 year old young plants of P. trifoliata regenerated
bud in vitro on a medium containing BA 1-50 µM and N-phenyl-N’-1,2,3-thidiazol-5-yl
urea (thidiazuron, TDZ) (0.1–10 µM). The optimal concentrations for bud induction
were 25 µM BA and 1 µM TDZ leading to 87 and 72% of responsive tTCLs and 24 and
15 buds per tTCL, respectively. A higher percentage of responsive tTCLs and a higher
frequency of bud regeneration were obtained with BA and TDZ combined. With a
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
23
combination of 10 µM BA and 1 µM TDZ, 90% of responsive tTCLs forming 37 buds
per tTCL were obtained. Shoot elongation occurred after a transfer onto a medium
containing 1 µM GA3. Rooting of individual shoots was induced using 5 µM NAA. One
hundred per cent of rooted shoots developed normally after transfer to the greenhouse;
no phenotype variation was observed. High numbers of regenerated viable plants could
be produced directly without callus formation from tTCL after 9 weeks of culture.
Moreira-Dias et al. (2000) reported bud differentiation by direct organogenesis
at the apical end of troyer citrange (Citrus sinensis L. Osbeck X Poncirus trifoliata L.
Raf.) epicotyl cuttings inserted vertically in a semi-solid culture medium without any
hormone addition. The number of buds regenerated was slightly, but significantly,
increased when the incubation was performed in the light as compared to dark and by
the addition of BA (2.2 to 22 µM) to the medium. Bud sprouting and subsequent shoot
formation required the addition of BA and was increased by light to a higher extent than
bud formation. The best response was obtained with the highest BA concentration
tested (22 µM). Regeneration through the indirect organogenic pathway at the two
edges of the epicotyl cuttings when in contact with the culture medium did not occur in
the absence of BA, which was an absolute requirement for callus development. The best
regeneration response was obtained when the explants were incubated in the light in the
presence of 4.4 µM BA and an auxin. IAA 5.8 µM was more effective in increasing
shoot formation than NAA 0.54 µm. Higher NAA concentrations inhibited shoot
formation. Incubation in the dark or increasing the BA concentration (22 µM) increased
markedly callus growth, but inhibited both bud differentiation and sprouting, almost
completely suppressing shoot formation. The conditions during regeneration affected
the rooting of the regenerated shoots. Rooting of 86% of the shoots was achieved in a
medium with 2.7 µM NAA and 2.6 µM IBA. All the rooted explants acclimated and
survived transplanting. Under the optimal conditions tested, the proliferation rate
obtained through the indirect regeneration pathway ranged from 60 to 86 plants per
seedling.
Bordon et al. (2000) reported the influence of light, hormones and explant
orientation on in vitro regeneration in epicotyl cuttings and compared the influence in
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
24
four Citrus species (C. aurantium, C. macrophylla, C. reshni and C. sinensis) and
hybrid troyer citrange (C. sinensis × Poncirus trifoliata). Explants were planted in
various orientations on MS medium supplemented with 100 mg/l myo-inositol, 10 mg/l
thiamine-HCl, 10 mg/l pyridoxine, 1 mg/l Nicotinic acid; 30 g/l sucrose; 4.4 µM BA
and 0.54 µM NAA. Root formation occurred both in the presence of NAA or low
concentrations (2.2 to 4.4 µM) of the cytokinin BA, but no buds were formed. Paudyal
and Haq (2000) reported in vitro propagation of Pummelo (C. grandis (L.) Osb.) using
shoot tip explants from seedlings. Maximum shoots per explant were obtained on
medium supplemented with 1.8 µM BA. Addition of 5.8 µM GA3 to shoot
multiplication medium during second subculture, enhanced the shoot elongation
response significantly. Over 75% rooting response was observed when shoots were
transferred to half strength MS medium containing 1.3, 2.7, or 5.4 µM NAA.
Al-Khayari and Al-Bharany (2001) established a micropropagation protocol for
lime, Citrus aurantifolia Christm Swing., using nodal explants of mature trees. Nodes
were cultured on MS medium containing IBA at 0, 0.5 and 1 mg/l combined with BA at
0, 0.25, 0.5, 1 and 2 mg/l and KN at 0, 0.5 and 1 mg/l. Best results for multiple shoot
formation (8 shoots per node) were obtained with 1 mg/l BA and 0.5 mg/l KN. The
concentration of IBA had little effect on shoot multiplication. Shoot elongation
appeared to favour 0.25 mg/l BA combined with 1 mg/l KN. Shoot elongation and leaf
size were inhibited in response to high levels of BA. Transfer of shoots to a rooting
medium induced the highest percentage of rooting, 56%, on 1 mg/l IAA. Plantlets
survived in soil and exhibited normal growth in a greenhouse. Begum et al. (2001)
reported in vitro clonal propagation of pummelo (Citrus grandis L.).
Kotsias and Roussos (2001) reported in vitro shoot proliferation and rooting on a
modified Driver–Kuniyuki (DKW) basal medium in lemon (Citrus limon (L.) Burm, f.
cv. Interdonato) seedlings. BA alone (1, 2 and 4 mg/l) and in combination with either
orange juice (10%, v/v), silver nitrate (3 mg/l), GA3 (0.1 mg/l at the establishment stage
and 0.5 mg/l at all combinations during the proliferation stage) or ABA (0.2 mg/l only
at the establishment stage) were used to stimulate shoot formation during the
establishment and the proliferation stage. The combination of BA with ABA gave a
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
25
high rate of shoot formation, while GA3 and silver nitrate enhanced shoot elongation.
When these shoots were transferred to the rooting stage, the effect of application of two
different auxins IBA and NAA was examined, as well as different methods of
application (auxin added to the basal medium and auxin application by dipping the base
of the explant in auxin solution). Dipping the base of the explants in a 50% ethanol
solution of IBA at 1000 mg/l for 5s resulted in 80% rooting with subsequent 90%
survival of these explants, during acclimatization under mist.
Moriera-Dias et al. (2001) reported adventitious shoot regeneration in epicotyl
cuttings of troyer citrange (Citrus sinensis X Poncirus trifoliata) varied with the
conditions of illumination. The response to illumination and to growth regulators
differed for the direct and the indirect (through callusing) pathways of regeneration.
Shoot formation through the direct organogenic pathway decreased as the concentration
of BA in the medium was increased in the range 2.2-22 µM, when the explants were
incubated in the dark or under an 8 h daylength. For explants incubated under a 16 h
daylength, the number of shoots formed increased with BA concentration. Optimal
conditions of incubation for shoot formation through the direct pathway were either an
8 h daylength with a photon flux density of 74 µM m-2 s-1 in the presence of 2.2 µM
BA, or a 16 h daylength with a photon flux density of 37 µM m-2 s-1 in the presence of
22 µM BA. Irrespective of the conditions of incubation, shoot formation through the
indirect organogenic pathway was suppressed by the addition of 22 µM BA to the
medium. Optimal conditions for shoot formation through this pathway were incubation
under an 8 h daylength at a photon flux density of 74 µM m-2 s-1 in the presence of 2.2
µM BA. At the optimal conditions indicated, the addition of the synthetic auxin NAA
(0.54 µM) reduced shoot formation. Irrespective of the pathway of regeneration, the
number of shoots formed decreased markedly with the distance of the cutting from the
cotyledonary node.
Al-Bahrany (2002) reported production of multiple shoots from nodal segments
of lime (Citrus aurantifolia (Christm.) Swing) on MS medium supplemented with BA,
KN and NAA. The highest number of shoots (nine shoots per node) were produced on a
medium containing 2 mg/l BA, 1 mg/l KN and 1 mg/l NAA. Depending on the
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
26
concentration of BA and KN, NAA either inhibited, stimulated or did not affect shoot
multiplication, which also depended on the cytokinin level. Maximum shoot length was
obtained from treatments containing 0.5 mg/l BA combined with 1 mg/l KN (4.6 µM)
and 0.5 mg/l NAA. The largest leaves of resultant shoots were produced on a medium
containing 0.5 mg/l each of KN and NAA. Transferring in vitro shoots to rooting media
containing IBA and NAA produced complete plantlets. The highest rooting percentage
was obtained on a medium containing either 1 mg/l NAA alone or 0.5 mg/l NAA
combined with 2 mg/l IBA, whereas the highest number of roots was produced on a
treatment containing both 2 mg/l NAA and 2 mg/l IBA. Roots elongated most on
treatments containing 0.5 mg/l of either NAA or IBA. Shoot growth associated with the
rooting phase was the highest in response to 2 mg/l IBA or 0.5 mg/l NAA. Plantlets that
survived acclimatization (82%) exhibited normal growth in soil under greenhouse
conditions.
Almeida et al. (2002) defined organogenesis and plant regeneration protocols for
sweet orange varieties Natal, Valencia and Hamlin (Citrus sinensis L. Osbeck) and
Rangpur lime (Citrus limonia L. Osbeck). Teguments of seeds were removed and were
germinated in vitro and maintained in the dark for three weeks, followed by one week at
16-h photoperiod (40 µmol m-2s-1) and 27±2°C. Organogenesis was achieved by
introducing epicotyl segments on MT medium with 25 g/l sucrose and different BA
concentrations. After adventitious bud growth, the shoots were transferred to MT
medium with either NAA or IBA (1 mg/l), or absence of auxin, for rooting. The best
results were obtained with 1 mg/l BA for bud induction and 1 mg/l IBA for rooting for
all three sweet orange cultivars. The use of 0.5- 2.5 mg/l BA, followed by 1 mg/l IBA
were the best growth regulator combinations for bud induction and rooting,
respectively, for Rangpur lime.
Kobayashi et al. (2003) developed an efficient system for in vitro plant
regeneration from thin transversal stem sections of explants (1–2 mm) using mature
tissues of sweet orange cv. Pera. Explants were cultured on different media to evaluate
the frequency of regeneration and size of buds. A high percentage of explants (54%
with 3.1 buds/explant) producing large buds (1–4 mm) was observed when the explants
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
27
were cultivated for 2 weeks on MS medium and then transferred to Woody Plant
medium (WPM). Both media were supplemented with 1.8 µM BA and 0.7 µM GA3.
Adventitious buds were regenerated into whole plants by in vitro shoot-tip grafting.
Regenerated plants started to flower after 12 months in the greenhouse, confirming their
mature nature.
Begum et al. (2004) reported shoot proliferartion from nodal segments of in
vitro germinated seedlings of three pummelo varieties [Var-1 (pink pulp), Var.-2 (white
pulp colour) and Var.-3 (red pulp)] were cultured on half strength medium for axillary
shoot proliferation. A large number of shoot buds were produced when such four weeks
old culture were subcultured on half stength MS medium containing 1.0 mg/l BA. Roots
were induced when the isolated individual shoots were cultured on half strength MS
medium supplemented with 0.1 mg/l each of NAA, IBA or IAA. 100% root induction
was observed with 0.1 mg/l NAA.
Costa et al. (2004) studied in vitro morphogenesis responses of epicotyl explants
from ‘Cravo’ rangpur lime (Citrus limonia Osb.), ‘Foster’ grapefruit (C. paradisi
Macf.), and ‘Pera’ sweet orange (C. sinensis (L.) Osb.). Further analysis was performed
in ‘Cravo’ rangpur lime and ‘Foster’ grapefruit aiming to verify the in vitro
morphogenesis of five distinct regions of the epicotyl under different treatments. The
same general pattern of morphogenic gradient along the epicotyl axis was observed in
both citrus cultivars, with greater organogenic response as the distance of the explants
from the cotyledonary node increased. This morphogenic gradient was influenced by
factors related to plant material, composition of the culture medium and conditions of
incubation. The regions of the epicotyls farthest from cotyledons could be used as a
source of explants in experiments of genetic transformation of the genotypes evaluated
aiming to improve the efficiency of production of transgenic Citrus plants.
Rani et al. (2004) reported micropropagation of kinnow (Citrus nobilis x Citrus
deliciosa) through nodal segments on MS medium supplemented with different
concentrations and combinations of KN, adenyl sulphate (ADS), BA, 2-isopentyle
adenine (2-iP), NAA and malt extract (ME). Maximum shoot induction (91.67%) was
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
28
noted with 2-iP at 1 mg/l. Shoot multiplication was done on the same medium.
Multiplied shoots rooted best on MS medium supplemented with NAA (3 mg/l). Rooted
plantlets were established in soil after hardening and showed normal morphology.
Khawale and Singh (2005) reported a protocol for storage and regeneration of
plantlets of Citrus reticulata Blanco and Citrus jambhiri Lush. from the cotyledonary
segments. MS basal medium fortified with 2.0 mg/l BA + 0.5 mg/l KN + 1.0 mg/l
NAA, gave the highest frequency of adventitive embryony. The regenerated plantlets
were hardened and tested for clonal fidelity or variation using randomly amplified
polymorphic DNA (RAPD) markers. The results showed that plantlets regenerated
through this pathway were found to be true to the mother type.
Mukhtar et al. (2005) initiated to explore the role of explant type, growth
substances and organic additives in regeneration process of kinnow mandarin [Citrus
reticulata (Blanco)]. In vitro shoot tips and nodal segment explants were cultured on
MS media supplemented with different concentrations of KN and BA to produce
multiple shoots. The results revealed that the shoot tip explants cultured on MS media
supplemented with 1 mg/l of BA and 1.5 mg/l of KN gave highest shoot percentage.
Usman et al. (2005) reported in vitro multiple shoot induction from nodal
explants of Citrus cultivars, kinnow, sweet lime and succari. Six week old seedlings
were used as source of explant for nodal and internodal segments (3-5 mm in length)
between cotyledonary leaves and first two leaves. These segments were taken as
explants and cultured on MS medium supplemented with NAA (0.1 mg/l) and ME (500
mg/l) with varying concentrations of BA (0.1-10 mg/l) for shoot induction. Sweet lime
explants showed higher shoot regeneration (64%) when cultured at the lowest
concentration of BA (0.1 mg/l) followed by succari, while kinnow explants depicted the
lowest shoot regeneration capacity (47.50%). Significant increase in shoot regeneration
was observed with increase in the concentration of BA. Among cultivars, kinnow
explants gave the highest shoot regeneration (78.09%) followed by sweet lime and then
succari. Highest number of shoots (4.28) per explants was observed in kinnow followed
by sweet lime and succari (3.78 and 3.23 shoots respectively). The explants derived
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
29
shoots were excised and sub-cultured on MS medium supplemented with ME 500 mg/l
used as basal medium, further modified with different levels of NAA in the medium
significantly increased the rooting percentage. Kinnow showed the best rooting (91%)
followed by sweet lime (79%) at 10 mg/l NAA.
Ali and Mirza (2006) reported direct micropropagation of rough lemon (Citrus
jambhiri Lush.) from leaves, roots, stem segments and cotyledons from 5 weeks old in
vitro grown seedlings. These explants were tested on shoot regeneration medium having
several different concentrations of hormones individually or in combinations. Among
these explants only stem explants showed optimal shoot regeneration (83%) on MS
medium supplemented with BA 3 mg/l and 76% with BA 0.5 mg/l. Very little (13%)
shoot regeneration response was observed with cotyledons on MS medium
supplemented with BA 3 mg/l, while roots and leaf explants did not produce any shoots
on any media tested. For rooting of these regenerated shoots, they cut-off shoot
segments were cultured on MS medium supplemented with 0.5 mg/l NAA or 1 mg/l 2,
4-D. Best rooting response (70%) was observed on 0.5 mg/l NAA without callus
induction.
Almeida et al. (2006) induced adventitious bud development in epicotyl
segments of valencia sweet orange (Citrus sinensis L. Osbeck). Seeds were cultured in
vitro for three weeks in the dark, followed by one week at 16-h photoperiod. Epicotyl
segments were cultured on Murashige and Tucker (1969, MT) culture medium
supplemented with 1.0 mg/l BA for organogenesis. Samples were observed by light and
scanning electron microscopy from day 0 to day 25. The adventitious buds originated
directly from the cambial region on the cut ends of the explants.
Dejam et al. (2006) reported in vitro propagation of Bakrai (C. reticulata Blanco
× C. limetta Swing.) using epicotyl expalnts. Expalnts were excised from in vitro grown
seedlings, cultured on basal MS medium supplemented with various concentrations of
BA and NAA. Maximum number of cultures with adventitious shoots (83%) was
obtained on MS medium supplemented with BA 2 mg/l. However, maximum number of
shoot buds (20.33) was obtained with BA 4 mg/l but, most of these buds remained
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
30
quiescent. Addition of 0.5 mg/l NAA increased shoot number and shoot length but
higher NAA concentrations has an inhibitory effect on shoot regeneration, particularly
with 1 mg/l BA. The highest number of shoots (5.5) and longest shoots (9.68 mm) were
obtained with concentrations of 2 and 1 mg/l BA + 0.5 mg/l NAA, respectively. The
shoots were rooted on half strength MS medium supplemented with IBA (0.5-10 mg/l).
Highest percentage of rooting (91.67%) and the maximum number (1.71) and length
(20.33 mm) of roots were obtained with IBA 10 mg/l.
Garcia-Luis et al. (2006) studied the effect of orientation as regards to gravity,
and that of contact with the medium of culture, on shoot regeneration at the cut edges of
epicotyl explants of troyer citrange (Citrus sinensis (L.) Osbeck X Poncirus trifoliata
(L.) Raf.). The shoot regeneration pathway was not affected by the orientation of the
explants as regards to gravity and was determined by explant polarity and the contact
with the culture medium. At the apical edge of the explants, the contact with the
medium shifted the pathway of shoot regeneration from a direct one to an indirect one,
with formation of callus. This callus formation was cytokinin-dependent, but the change
in the pathway of organogenesis was not caused by the increase in cytokinin availability
resulting from the contact with the medium. In contact with the medium regeneration at
the basal edge of the explants occurred through an indirect pathway after callus
formation. No regeneration occurred, at the basal edge, if contact with the medium was
prevented. The orientation of the explants as regards to gravity affected shoot formation
through the direct pathway of organogenesis. The number of buds differentiated and
growing shoots increased when the orientation of the explants departed from the vertical
upright position.
Duan et al. (2007) aimed to optimize the organogenesis of epicotyl segments
and to efficiently obtain transgenic plants of ‘Bingtang’ sweet orange (Citrus sinensis L.
Osb.), an elite citrus cultivar in China. Organogenesis was induced from epicotyl
segments of 2 weeks old seedlings of this cultivar. Two important factors influencing
organogenesis in vitro were hormone combination (IAA and BA) and cut modes. IAA
had a positive effect on bud formation only when BA was used at the concentration of
2.0 mg/l and an inhibitive effect was observed with higher or lower concentration of
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
31
BA. The number of regenerated buds reached up to 8.9 per explant with the
combination of IAA 0.2 mg/l and BA 2.0 mg/l. Among cut modes, oblique cut
performed the best for its effect on the number and quality of regenerated shoots and its
convenience to manipulate. With the optimized hormone combination and oblique cut
mode, citrus transformation with green fluorescent protein (GFP) gene was performed
and twelve independently transformed plant lines were achieved. Southern blot
hybridization confirmed the stable integration of GFP gene into the citrus genome. The
successful transformation of this cultivar revealed that it is possible to introduce other
genes with agronomic traits into it. Furthermore, these GFP expressing transgenic plants
could serve as a visual marker material for citrus somatic fusion and sexual
hybridization.
Altaf et al. (2008) reported direct shoot regeneration from nodal segments of
Citrus jambhiri on MS medium supplemented with BA 3 mg/l. They observed 70%
rooting response from regenerated shoots on MS medium supplemented with NAA 0.5
mg/l. Miah et al. (2008) established a protocol for direct multiple shoot regeneration
from both in vitro grown seedlings and mature plants of Citrus macroptera. Both nodal
and shoot tip explants taken from in vitro grown seedlings were cultured on MS
medium supplemented with different concentrations of BA and KN either singly or in
combinations. Both these explants were capable to regenerate and produce in vitro
multiple shoots. Maximum number of shoots was obtained from nodal explants on MS
medium supplemented with 1.0 mg/l BA. BA alone was found superior to KN. Ex vitro
rooting in pot soil (mixed with biogas slurry derived from cow-dung) was most
successful compared to in vitro rooting on half strength of MS medium supplemented
with different concentrations of NAA and IBA.
Sharma et al. (2008) achieved direct shoot formation from the nodal segments of
kinnow (Citrus nobilis Lour x Citrus deliciosa Tenora) on MS medium supplemented
with 2-iP (1 mg/l) and ME (800 mg/l). Shoot tips from these nodal sprouts were further
excised and micrografted on to rough lemon in vitro. Khan et al. (2009) made attempts
to investigate culture of leaf explants derived from in vitro seedlings of two sweet
orange (Citrus sinensis (L.) Osbeck) cultivars, Bingtangcheng and Valencia. Effects of
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
32
several factors, including culture medium, lighting condition, explant age and genotype
on regeneration response were examined based on three parameters, percentage of
explants producing shoots, mean number of shoots per explant and shoot forming
capacity. Culture of explants on shoot inducing media (SIM) composed of MT salts
supplemented with different growth regulators gave rise to disparate shoot regeneration,
in which SIM1 (MT + 0.5 mg/l BA + 0.5 mg/l KN + 0.1 mg/l NAA + 3% sucrose +
0.8% agar, pH 5.8) was shown to be the most effective medium for direct induction of
shoots from leaf explants. Highly significant difference in the response of shoot bud
regeneration was noted between the two cultivars, with Bingtangcheng being more
responsive than Valencia. Culture of explants from fully developed leaves led to better
shoot regeneration capacity in comparison to undeveloped ones. However, the two
lighting conditions used herein did not cause significant difference in shoot
regeneration. Phenotypic observation and RAPD analysis confirmed that all the
regenerated plants from both genotypes were genetically identical to their donor plants,
suggesting absence of detectable genetic variation in the regenerated plants.
Tavano et al. (2009) studied in vitro organogenesis in Citrus volkameriana and
C. aurantium considering three explant types: epicotyl segments, internodal segments,
and hypocotyl segments with attached cotyledon fragment. The explants were cultured
on medium according to Grosser and Gmitter (EME) supplemented with 0, 0.5, 1.0, 1.5,
and 2.0 mg dm-3 BA, incubated firstly in darkness for 4 weeks and then transferred to
16-h photoperiod for 2 weeks. A higher number of shoots per explant were obtained
with epicotyl segments, regardless of the BA concentration. For C. volkameriana the
highest percentage of responsive epicotyl segments (42%) was obtained in EME with
1.0 mg/dm3 BA, while for C. aurantium (59%) in EME with 0.5 mg dm-3 BA. The
organogenesis efficiency was best with the use of the hypocotyl segment with attached
cotyledon fragment (77% for C. volkameriana and 75% for C. aurantium). With this
explant the morphogenesis occurred only in the hypocotyl region. The in vitro
organogenesis was characterized by histological analyses showing that the morphogenic
process started in the cambium region near the explant cut end.
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
33
Jajoo (2010) developed an efficient and highly reproducible plant regeneration
protocol from nucellar embryos of Citrus limonia. MS medium was used for plant
regeneration from nucellar embryos. It was noted that BA at a concentration of 2.22 µM
induced highest number of multiple shoots (18.26 shoots per explants). Transfer of
individual shoots to root inducing MS medium supplemented with IBA (2.46 µM) and
BA (1.11 µM) resulted in rooting in 78.80% cultures with an average of 5.53
roots/shoot. Plantlets thus obtained were successfully transferred to green house for
further observations.
Pe'rez-Tornero et al. (2010) investigated the influence of the basal medium and
different plant growth regulators on micropropagation of nodal explants from mature
trees of lemon cultivars. Although the basal medium did not affect any of the variables,
explants on DKW medium were greener. Several combinations of BA and GA3 were
used to optimise the proliferation phase. The number of shoots was dependent on the
BA and GA3 concentrations and the best results were obtained with 2 mg/l BA and 1 or
2 mg/l GA3. The best results for productivity with respect to number of shoots and the
average shoot length were obtained with 2 mg/l BA and 2 mg/l GA3. The transfer of in
vitro shoots to rooting media, containing different concentrations of IBA and IAA
produced complete plantlets. Lemon shoots rooted well in all rooting combinations. The
highest rooting percentages were obtained on medium containing 3 mg/l IBA alone or
IBA in combination with 1 mg/l IAA. Root length was greater when only 3 mg/l IBA
was used. The success during the acclimatisation was close to 100% and the plantlets
exhibited normal growth in soil under greenhouse conditions.
Niedz and Evens (2010) studied the effect of BA and meta-topolin (mT) on the
three responses i.e. shoot quality, numbers of epicotyl explants producing shoots and
the number of shoots greater than 2 mm from citrus rootstock US-812 (Citrus reticulata
x Poncirus trifoliata) epicotyl explants. The experiment was designed as a mixture-
amount. The two mixture components, BA and mT were varied proportionally from
0 BA: 1 mT to 1 BA: 0 mT and the amount of total cytokinin varied from 1 to 50 µM.
Models developed for each of the three measured responses were highly significant.
Results were as follows: first, the three responses were similar over the design space;
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
34
second, no synergistic or antagonistic interactions were detected; and third, BA and mT
resulted in similar responses, but at substantially different amounts – BA at 1 µM was
essentially equivalent to mT at 13.25 – 37.75 µM.
Saini et al. (2010) studied the effect of explants and cobinations of plant growth
regulators on the efficiency of plant regeneration in C. jambhiri Lush. The epicotyl
segments placed horizontally on culture media proved to be best for shoot bud
formation. The bud induction frequency of 83.975 was obtained on MS medium
supplemented with BA at 0.5 mg/l with an average of 8.6 buds per explant. Maximum
proliferation of shoots was observed on MS medium supplemented with BA 0.5 mg/l
and GA3 1.0 mg/l. The elongated shoots were rooted on MS medium containing NAA 1
mg/l + IBA 1.0 mg/l with 77% rooting response.
Samarina et al. (2010) investigated the effect of sterilization agents and the
composition of the nutrient medium on lemon explants regeneration, micropropagation
and rooting. Nodal segments of eight year old lemon trees cvs. Novoaphonsky,
Beskolyuchy, Udarnik, Meyer lemon were taken as explants during spring. Veltolen
0.2%, 0.2% HgOCl and hypochlorite Ca 7% solutions were used as disinfectants at
different exposures. The best result for surface sterilization was obtained when shoots
were dipped in Veltolen solution by about 40 min. In this case 58.7% sterile explants
were received. Several combinations of BA with NAA were used for optimization of
cell proliferation and micropropagation. Maximum effect at the stage of proliferation
was obtained by adding to the MS basal medium 0.1 mg/l BA and 0.5 mg/l NAA.
Cultural media consisted of MS minerals and vitamins with 1 mg/l BA and 0.1 mg/l
NAA resulted in multiplication of regenerated plants. Rooting of regenerants was
obtained on ½ MS medium supplemented with 0.5 mg/l NAA alone.
Singh and Rajam (2010) explored sweet orange (Citrus sinensis L Osbeck, var.
Nagpur) for efficient multiple shoot regeneration and rooting in different media. The
influence of phytohormones and carbon source on in vitro morphogenesis of sweet
orange epicotyl explants was investigated. Among various concentrations and
combinations of auxins (IAA and NAA) and cytokinins (BA, KN, Zeatin and TDZ)
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
35
tried, MT (Murashige and Tucker, 1969) medium fortified with 6-benzylaminopurine
(BA) at 1 mg/l without auxin had a strong promotive effect on shoot regeneration and
elucidated best morphogenic response from one-month-old etiolated epicotyl explants.
A 100% regeneration frequency was obtained and multiple shoots with an average of
8.24 shoots per explant were produced on all the explants. Root formation was seen in
response to all the three auxins viz. IBA, NAA and IAA, but best response with rapid
induction was observed under the influence of IBA at 1 mg/l. Sucrose was observed to
be at par with maltose as carbon source to support shoot regeneration.
Germana et al. (2011) examined the encapsulation of carrizo citrange uninodal
microcuttings (3–4 mm long) and evaluated the influence of the calcium alginate
coating, short time storage at cold temperature and different sowing substrates on the
viability and regrowth of the explants. A secondary aim was to develop an efficient
protocol to induce root formation in the microcuttings. The results showed that
encapsulation did not negatively affect the viability, providing a satisfactory regrowth,
and storage potential for 30 days at low temperature. No differences in viability and
regrowth were detected between the two different sowing substrates tested (agar-
solidified medium and paper filter).
Marques et al. (2011) studied the effects of BA and NAA treatments on
adventitious bud and shoot regeneration from internodal branch segments of 12 months
old plants of Citrus aurantium L. cv. Brazilian. High rates of bud initiation and shoot
development were obtained both with BA supplemented medium, in the range from 1
mg/l to 3 mg/l and with 0.1 mg/l NAA supplemented medium. NAA concentrations
above 1 mg/l significantly reduced bud initiation and shoot elongation. The results
obtained using different in vitro culture vessels such as Petri dishes, tubes and glass
culture jars were compared. The highest adventitious bud induction was observed in
Petri dishes for internodes cultured on 2 mg/l BA supplemented medium, with 95%
responsive explants forming 9.0±2.4 adventitious buds. The adventitious buds observed
in Petri dishes reached a maximum height of 1mm with no further development, while
some of the adventitious shoots cultured in tubes and glass culture jars grew over 1 cm
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
36
in height. A shoot regeneration gradient of the internodes collected along the branch
axis was noticed, with basal ones exhibiting higher regeneration frequency.
Singh et al. (2011) reported that sterculia gum can be used as an alternative to
agar as gelling agent to decrease the cost of tissue culture protocol. The study was
conducted on C. jambhiri Lush. Savita et al. (2012) reported an effiecient
micropropagation protocol for C. jambhiri Lush. using nodal segments as explant.
Maximum multiple shoot regeneration response (75%) was observed on MS medium
supplemented with BA at 3 mg/l. Shoots were multiplied for 30 days on fresh medium
with similar composition. A total of 67% cultures showed multiplication with optimum
number (4.02) and height of shoots (1.81 cm) with BA (3 mg/l) alone. Maximum
rooting response (87%) was observed with NAA at 0.5 mg/l. Transverse sections of
shoots obtained in vivo (sampled from seedlings) and in vitro (regenerated from nodal
segments) showed similar anatomies. RAPD analysis confirmed that all the regenerated
plants were genetically identical to their donor plant, suggesting absence of detectable
genetic variation in the regenerated plantlets. Summary of literature on direct
regeneration studies of different Citrus spp. is given in Table 2.1.
2.2.2. Indirect plant regeneration through callus
Plant tissue culture has emerged as a powerful tool for propagation and
improvement of many woody plant species including Citrus. In vitro culture has the
potential to eliminate diseases and provides scope for development of new cultivars
through somaclonal variations (Hammschlag et al., 1995). Production of callus and its
subsequent regeneration are the prime steps in crop plants to be manipulated by
biotechnological means and to exploit somaclonal variations (Islam et al., 2005).
Despite its rich genetic resources, scientists encounter difficulties in citrus hybridization
breeding due to high heterozygosity, incompatibility, sterility and nucellar embryos
(Shen et al., 1998). These obstruct scientific efforts to develop new varieties with
enhanced production and quality characteristics and rootstocks with improved
resistance to abiotic and biotic stresses. With the development of biotechnology, genetic
transformation and protoplast hybridization have been established to circumvent those
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
37
breeding obstacles in many fruit trees (Deng and Liu, 1996). For citrus, embryogenic
callus is widely used in genetic transformation and protoplast hybridization since it can
easily regenerate plants (Deng and Liu, 1996; Hao, 2000; Hao and Deng, 2002). Citrus
embryogenic calluses can be maintained in culture at one month intervals for a long
period (Yi and Deng, 1998; Hao and Deng, 2002). However, frequent subculture of
many cultures is labour intensive and costly (Ashmore, 1997; Engelmann, 1997). To
solve this problem, short and medium term storage methods have been developed to
reduce growth and increase subculture intervals. Tissue culture protocols have been
described for a number of Citrus spp. through callus (Ali and Mirza, 2006; Altaf et al.,
2008; Altaf et al., 2009a,b; Khan et al., 2009; Laskar et al., 2009; Singh and Rajam,
2009 and Savita et al., 2010, 2011a, 2011b).
Kobayashi et al. (1984) isolated protoplasts from nucellar callus of ‘Troviata’
orange (Citrus sinensis Osbeck) and cultured on MT medium containing 0.15 µM
sucrose, 0.45 µM glucose and 0.6% agar, but lacking phytohormones. Colonies with
26.3% plating efficiency were observed after 6 weeks culture. When the protoplasts
were cultured in the presence of exogenous phytohormones, reduction in colony
formation was observed. Some colonies were developed into green embryoids, which
eventually formed plants. Edriss and Burger (1984) Isolated epicotyl, root meristem and
root segment tissues of ‘Troyer’ citrange [Poncirus trifoliata (L.) Rat. × Citrus sinensis
(L.) Osbeck] and established in continuous culture to compare their regeneration
potential. Callus was obtained from these explants on MS medium containing NAA (10
mg/l) and BA (0.1–10 mg/l). Formation of shoots from root segments was direct
without callus formation on MS medium containing BA (10 mg/l) and NAA (1 mg/l).
Shoot formation from epicotyl callus occurred on MS medium containing 0.25 mg/l BA
and 0.1 mg/l NAA. Formation of shoots from epicotyl segments occurred on MS
medium containing BA (0.5 mg/l) and NAA (0.1–1.0 mg/l), while rooting of
regenerated shoots occurred in treatments containing 2.0 mg/l NAA alone.
Beloualy (1991) reported callus induction from embryos excised from seeds of
Poncirus trifoliata, Citrus aurantium and carrizo citrange (Citrus sinensis × Poncirus
trifoliata) on MT medium supplemented with 2,4-dichlorophenoxy acetic acid (2,4-D 2
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
38
mg/l), BA (5 mg/l) and casein hydrolysate (1000 mg/l). Sucrose 50 g/l and 0.8% agar
were added. Adventitious shoots and emryoids were induced from callus on MT
medium supplemented with NAA (1 mg/l), BA (5 mg/l), casein hydrolysate (100 mg/l)
and sucrose 50 g/l in case of Poncirus trifoliata and carrizo citrange, while in case of C.
aurantium NAA (1 mg/l), BA (10 mg/l), casein hydrolysate (100 mg/l) and sucrose 50
g/l were used to induce embryoids and adventitious shoots. Rooting was promoted by
supplement of 1 mg/l GA3 or NAA (1 mg/l). Saito et al. (1991) maintained suspension
culture from nucellar tissue of C. sudachi on MT medium containing BA (5 mg/l).
Francisco et al. (1992) reported callus induction from leaf and stem segments of
30 different genera including 28 citrus relatives on non-embryogenic callus induction
medium i.e. MTC [MT medium + 2,4-D (0.663µM) + KN (0.22 µM)] with and without
activated charcoal; MTNC [MT medium + KN (0.22 µM) + NAA (5.60 µM)] with and
without activated charcoal. A soft and friable callus was obtained from several genera
including Aegle, Afraegle, Atlantia, Basamocitrus, Citropcis, Citrus, Microcitrus and
Zanthoxylem.
Chakravarty and Goswami (1999) reported best callus induction on MS medium
containing BA and 2,4-D from explants incubated in the dark. High levels of MS
vitamins enhanced callus initiation and growth. These calli could be maintained in
culture for upto two years and plantlets regenerated from them on transfer to light.
Greening of callus and regeneration of shoot-buds from callus occurred on transfer to
MS medium with BA. These shoots grew further in media with both BA and GA3.
Rooting of shoots occurred on media with NAA or IBA and the rooted plantlets could
be transferred to soil. Regeneration of shoots and roots decreased with increase in age
of callus. Cytological study of the regenerants revealed no change in chromosome
number. Thus, genetically uniform plantlets could be regenerated continuously from
established callus upto two years old, thereby helping in multiplication and conservation
of the species.
Tadeo et al. (1995) studied the effect of I-aminocyclopropane- l-carboxylic acid
(ACC) treatment on callus formation from internodal explants of troyer citrange (C.
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
39
sinensis (L.) Osb.× Poncirus trifoliata). The in vitro culture of explants in media
supplemented with 0.05, 0.5 and 2 µM ACC resulted in rapid growth of whitish soft
friable calli, whereas no calli were observed in the absence of ACC. The calli were
evident 3-5 days after culture and callus growth reached a stationary phase 11 days after
culture. A rapid and transitory increase in the rate of ethylene production occurred at the
highest ACC concentrations used. Callus formation correlated with amounts of ethylene
released by the explants. The lowest ACC concentration (0.05 µM) stimulated callus
growth in only l0-20% of the explants, with callus weighing 100 mg and the explants
produced low ethylene levels at day 3 of culture (33 nl g-1 FW h-l). The highest ACC
concentrations (0.5 and 2 µM) stimulated callus growth in HI-75% of the explants, with
callus weights of 155 and 210 mg, respectively. The explants produced high levels of
ethylene at day 3 of culture (330-430 nl g-1 FW h-l). The inhibition of ethylene
biosynthesis or action with cobalt chloride and silver thiosulfate, respectively, reduced
callus formation in the ACC-treated explants in a concentration-dependent manner.
Taken together, these observations indicate that ethylene synthesized from ACC is
responsible for callus formation.
Gloria et al. (1999) reported embryogenic callus induction from nucellar tissue
of seven citrus cultivars i.e. ‘Cravo’ mandarin and ‘Ponkan’ mandarin (Citrus reticulata
Blanco); ‘Natal’ sweet orange, ‘Serra d’agua, sweet orange, ‘Perra’ sweet orange,
‘Valencia’ sweet orange (Citrus sinensis L. Osbeck); Murcott tangor (Citrus reticulata
Blanco × Citrus sinensis L. Osbeck). Three different media tested were; EME [MT
modified with the addition of ME (500 mg/l)]; ½ EME [Half conc. of MT
macronutrients + Half conc. of BH3 macronutrients + ME (500 mg/l) + glutamine (1.55
g/l)] and EBA [MT modified with the addition of ME (500 mg/l) + BA (0.44 µM) +
2,4-D (0.04 µM)]. Soft friable calli were obtained from ‘Carvo’ and ‘Ponkan mandarin’
(Citrus reticulata Blanco), Citrus reticulata Blanco × Citrus sinensis L. Osbeck
(Murcott tangor), ‘Serra d’agua and ‘Valencia’ sweet orange (Citrus sinensis L.
Osbeck) 120 days after callus induction.
Fleming et al. (2000) reported an alternative method for transforming sweet
orange (C. sinensis L. Osbeck) using plasmid DNA encoding the non-destructive
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
40
selectable marker enhanced green fluorescent protein (GFP) gene introduced using
polyethylene glycol (PEG) in protoplasts isolated from nucellar derived suspension
culture. Callus was induced from nucellar tissue on MT medium containing glutamine
1.55 g/l + 0.5 g/l ME. Regeneration of transformed protoplasts was observed with
13.3µM BA + 0.045 µM 2,4-D and rooting was obtained on ½ MT medium containing
0.11 µM NAA + 0.5 g/l activated charcoal (AC).
Das et al. (2000) standardized a protocol for micropropagation of elite plants of
sweet orange (Citrus sinensis) through nucellar embryo culture. MS medium
supplemented with NAA (1 mg/l) or 2,4-D (1 mg/l) promoted callus development in
both nucellar and zygotic embryos. GA3 (1 mg/l) enriched medium induced plantlets
initiation but their growth was very poor. No significant differences were observed
between initial growth patterns of nucellar and zygotic seedlings developing from the
same ovule. Five to six shoots were obtained from collar region of both categories of
embryos in MS medium supplemented with BA (1 mg/l) within 60 days of inoculation.
The number of plantlets was almost doubled after their transfer to the same medium and
culture for another 30 days. Higher doses of BA resulted in initiation of callus directly
from the embryos. The regenerated shoots (2-3 cm) could be rooted on MS medium
supplemented with either only NAA (0.75 mg/l) or NAA (0.50 mg/l) and IBA (2.0
mg/l). A number of plantlets could be obtained from a nucellar embryo grown shoot
within a limited time period.
Tao et al. (2002) studied the effect of 2,4-D, NAA, 2,4,5-trichlorophenoxy
acetic acid (2,4,5-T), 4-chlorophenoxyacetic acid (4-CPA), 2-methyl-4-chlorophenoxy-
acetic acid (MCPA) on callus induction from leaf explants taken from in vitro raised
seedlings in C. grandis (L.) Osbeck (pummelo). Begum et al. (2003) used cotyledon
explants from in vitro raised seedlings of three varities of pummelo for callus induction
on half strength MS medium supplemented with 1 mg/l BA + 5 mg/l NAA. These calli
were transferred on half strength MS medium supplemented with cytokinin only.
Maximum shoot regeneration was observed with BA 1 mg/l in three varieties of
pummel. For rooting, shoot cuttings were cultured on half strength MS medium
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
41
supplemented with NAA, IBA or IAA. Maximum rooting response was observed with
1.0 mg/l NAA.
Ali and Mirza (2006) studied the effect of various concentrations and
combinations of 2,4-D, BA and NAA on regeneration of rough lemon (Citrus jambhiri
Lush.) explants. Optimal callus induction response was observed on MS medium,
supplemented with 2,4-D 1.5 mg/l from all types of explants, with stem explants
showing the highest response (92%). Maximum shoot regeneration response (70 %)
from callus was observed on MS medium supplemented with BA 3 mg/l. Direct shoot
regeneration was highest in stem segment explants on MS medium with BA 3 mg/l. MS
medium supplemented with NAA 0.5 mg/l provided 70 % rooting response.
Molina et al. (2007) reported that ilumination did not affect the pathway of
shoot regeneration at the cut edges of epicotyl explants of troyer citrange, but
signigficantly affected the number of developed shoots and the response to exogenous
cytokinins. Shoot regeneration at the apical end occurred through a direct organogenic
pathway without callus formation. For explants incubated in the light, this regeneration
did not require cytokinin addendum, but the number of shoots formed was significantly
increased by BA, but not by zeatin or KN. Incubation in the dark almost suppressed
shoot formation at the apical end. The addition of BA or KN, but not zeatin, restored
shoot formation in the dark to the value obtained in the light. At the basal end of the
explants, shoot regeneration occurred through an indirect organogenic pathway after the
formation of primary callus. In explants incubated in the light, callus formation and
shoot growth was supported by a low (0.5–1 mg/l) BA concentration and by zeatin. KN
did not support callus growth. Shoot formation was higher in the presence of BA (0.5–1
mg/l) than of zeatin, but was inhibited by a high BA (5 mg/l) concentration. Incubation
in the dark increased callus growth and shoot formation at the basal cut as compared to
explants incubated in the light.
Laskar et al. (2009) reported shoot regeneration from leaf derived callus in
Citrus indica Tanaka. Regenerative calli were induced on MS medium supplemented
with 0.01 mg/l TDZ + 0.1 mg/l NAA. Shoots were regenerated on WPM medium
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
42
supplemented with 0.5 mg/l BA + 0.25 mg/l TDZ + 0.25 mg/l NAA. These shoots were
rooted on MS medium supplemted with 1.0 mg/l NAA. Sharma et al. (2009)
standardized a protocol for in vitro propagation of citrus rootstocks viz. rough lemon,
cleopatra mandarin, pectinifera and troyer citrange. The shoot tip explants of these
rootstocks were found better for callus induction than the nodal segments.
Savita et al. (2010) established a protocol for micropropagation of C. jambhiri
via callus induction and regeneration. Leaf segments, nodal segments and root segments
excised from in vitro raised seedlings were used as explants. Maximum callus induction
(98.66%) was observed from leaf segments on MS medium supplemented with 2, 4-D
(4 mg/l). For nodal segments, maximum callus induction (96%) was observed with 2, 4-
D (1 mg/l) and from root segments, it was 48.66% on MS medium supplemented with
2, 4-D (2 mg/l). Callus raised from leaf segments showed maximum regeneration
(57%) with NAA (0.5 mg/l) + BA (1 mg/l) whereas nodal segments showed better
regeneration (71.89 %) with NAA (0.5 mg/l) + BA (3 mg/l). However, callus from root
segments did not regenerate. Regenerated shoots were rooted on MS medium
supplemented with different PGRs and best response (71%) was observed with NAA
(0.5 mg/l).
Savita et al. (2011b) developed an efficient miropropagation protocol for Citrus
jambhiri Lush. using cotyledons as explants. Maximum callus induction (91.66%) was
observed on MS medium supplemented with 2,4-D (2 mg/l) in combination with ME
(500 mg/l). Green healthy calli were cut into small pieces and cultured on MS medium
for regeneration. Maximum shoot regeneration (87.50%) was observed with BA (3
mg/l). Effect of increasing age of callus was also studied which showed that callus
retained regeneration capacity (58.33%) even after 420 days of culture. Regenerated
shoots were separated out and cultured on rooting medium. Maximum rooting response
(91.67%) was observed on half strength MS medium supplemented with NAA (0.5
mg/l). After hardening and acclimatization the plantlets were transferred to the field and
showed 67% survival. Summary of literature on micropropagation of Citrus
(regeneration through callus) is given in Table 2.2.
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
43
2.2.3. Somatic embryogenesis
Somatic embryogenesis is the process of a single cell or group of cells initiating
the developmental pathway that leads to reproducible regeneration of non-zygotic
embryos capable of germinating to form complete plants. A remarkable homology is
known to exist between somatic and zygotic embryos (Redenbaugh et al., 1988). In
Citrus species, this phenomenon has been studied in detail by Rangaswamy, 1961;
Sabharwal, 1963; Rangan et al., 1968; Vardi et al., 1975; Kochba and Spiegel-Roy,
1977; Tisserat and Murashige, 1977; Kunitake et al., 1991; Gill et al., 1995; Carimi et
al., 1995, 1998,1999; Perez et al., 1998; Chaturvedi et al., 2001; Ricci et al., 2002;
Fiore et al., 2002; Guo and Grosser, 2005; Shimada et al., 2005.
The embryogenic potential of citrus varied with genotype and type of explant,
but better results were usually obtained from regeneration protocols involving the use of
explants of ovular origin. Embryogenic cultures derived from the shamouti orange have
been described as proembryogenic masses (PEMs) (Button et al., 1974) rather than non-
differentiated cell masses (Gavish et al., 1991). Embryos, pseudobulbils and
embryogenic callus were obtained by in vitro culture of undeveloped ovules excised
from ripe fruits of the navel orange group and lemon (Starrantino and Russo, 1980).
Large number of seedlings were produced by subculturing the embryos, pseudobulbils
and embryogenic callus on fresh MS medium with added 6-methyl aminopurine. The
technique of growing isolated citrus embryos in artificial media was described by
Hurosvilli (1957). Rangan et al. (1968) reported culture of nucellar tissues in C.
grandis. Nucellar tissue isolated from monoembryonic varieties gave rise to 10-15
embryos per culture, which developed into complete plantlets. The plants arising from
embryogenesis of nucellus in vitro were found to be free from most of the pathogenic
viruses (Bitters et al., 1970).
Chaturvedi and Mitra (1972) produced embryoids and complete plants from
unpollinated ovaries and from ovules of in vivo grown emasculated flower buds of
Citrus spp. Explants of unpollinated ovaries of Citrus aurantifolia and C. sinensis, but
not of C. maxima, a monoembryonic species, produced embryoids and complete plants
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
44
under certain cultural conditions. Subsequent experiments showed that ovary wall tissue
was more prone to produce these responses. In long-term culture, the responses
gradually decreased resulting in complete cessation of embryoid formation. This
cessation occurring earlier in C. aurantifolia than in C. sinensis. Explants of nucellus
contained in longitudinal halves of ovules taken from in vivo grown emasculated flower
buds of C. auranti-folia produced three types of responses, namely, (a) an increasing
mass of proliferating embryoids, (b) friable, spongy and pale-white tissue along with
callusing integumentary tissue and (e) mixed responses of (a) and (b). The explants with
continuously increasing mass of proliferating embryoids contained most of the stages of
zygotic embryogenesis. Using different culture media, a good number of embryoids
could be induced in explants of friable and spongy tissue of nucellar origin, but they did
not develop into seedlings. No embryoids could be induced from callusing
integumentary tissue regardless of medium employed.
Kobayashi et al. (1983,1985) examined the effects of protoplast density and
mannitol concentration on cell division and embryoid formation using protoplasts
isolated from 6-year old nucellar callus of 'Trovita' orange (Citrus sinensis Osb.).
Somatic embryogenesis in nearly direct manner was observed only at a combination of
low cell densities (4 × 104/ml) and low mannitol concentrations (0.4 M). Orange
protoplasts (cells) showed embryogenic potential and repression of embryogenesis
occurred when protoplasts were cultured at a high density and/or under high osmotic
pressure.
Grosser et al. (1988) used MT medium containing 500 mg/l ME to maintain
suspension culture of ‘Hamlin’ sweet orange (C. sinensis). MT medium containing 1
mg/l GA3 and 15 mg/l coumarin was used for somatic embryo germination and 5 mg/l
BA for shoot multiplication.
Sim et al. (1988) isolated protoplasts from embryogenic suspension cultures of
Citrus mitis and cultured in a medium without any plant growth substances. Somatic
embryos developed directly from protoplasts without an obvious intervening callus
phase. As many as 1,800 somatic embryos developed from 4 ml of protoplast
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
45
suspension (density 2 x 106/ml) cultured for 35 days. Upon transferring the embryoids
to medium with 1.0 mg/l GA3, they developed into plantlets. Rooted plantlets were
obtained in 3 months after protoplast isolation.
Vardi and Gulan (1988) reported callus growth on MT medium with 4% sucrose
and embryo induction with 2% glycerol. Somatic embryo maturation was observed on
MT medium supplemented with ME (1500 mg/l) and 4% sucrose. Addition of NAA to
MT medium promotes root formation and axis elongation of normal shaped embryos
induced from protoplasts of C. limon, C. paradisi, C. reticulata and C. sinensis.
Ohgawara et al. (1989) and Kobayashi et al. (1991) used MT liquid medium containing
10 mg/l BA to maintain suspension culture of cells from ovules of navel orange and
somatic embryos were initiated on MT medium supplemented with GA3 (5 mg/l).
Gmitter and Hu (1990) used various formulations of MT medium including
doubled MT inorganic component concentration (2 MT) supplemented with 2,4-D (1-2
mg/l), KN (5 mg/l) and GA3 (2-10 mg/l) to test their ability to induce callus from
endosperm of C. sinensis, to induce globular embryogenic callus from primary callus
and to allow embryo development and plantlet production from proliferating calli
respectively.
Nito and Iwamasa (1990) tried various concentrations of NAA, KN and GA3 in
MS medium to induce callus from juice vesicles of Satsuma (Citrus unshiu Marc.).
Belouly (1991) regenerated complete plantlets from callus derived embryo culture of
Citrus aurantium, Poncirus trifoliata and carrizo citrange (C. sinensis × Poncirus
trifoliata) via somatic embryogenesis and organogenesis. Isolated embryoids were
differentiated on medium containing 1000 to 1500 mg/l ME. Both embryoids and
shoots were obtained by the use of plant growth regulators, NAA and BA. The highest
frequency was obtained with 1 mg/l NAA + 5 mg/l BA in Poncirus trifoliata and
citrange. Rooting was promoted by a supplement of 1 mg/l GA3 or 1 mg/l NAA. GA3
enhanced stem elongation and rooting in embryoids and NAA stimulated adventitious
root formation.
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
46
Augustin and Millo (1995) cultured unfertilized ovules of troyer citrange treated
with a chemical mutagen (EMS) on MS medium supplemented with GA3 (1 mg/l) and
ADS (27 mg/l) for somatic embryo induction. Carimi et al. (1995) reported somatic
embryogenesis from styles (including the stigma) of Citrus aurantium L. (cvs. ‘AA 12’,
‘AA 30’ and ‘AA31’), C. deliciosa Tenore (cvs. ‘Avana’ and ‘Tardivo di Ciaculli’), C.
paradisi Macf. (cvs. ‘Marsh seedless’ and ‘Star Ruby’) and C. sinensis (L.) Osb. (cvs.
‘Bonanza’, ‘Brasiliano 92’, ‘Sanguinello’ and ‘Valencia’). Explants were excised from
flower buds which were collected during full bloom and cultured on MS basal medium
supplemented with 146 µM sucrose, 500 mg/l ME and 13.3 µM BA as well as the same
medium without BA. Callus development was observed from the style base 4 weeks
after treatment initiation and embryogenesis occurred 2-3 months later. Embryogenesis
has been induced from the style derived callus of all the cultivars tested except for the
cultivars ‘Avana’ and ‘Star Ruby’. The best results for callus growth and embryo
regeneration were obtained from explants of ‘Brasiliano 92’ cultured on medium
containing BA. Somatic embryos were isolated from callus and placed on MS medium
supplemented with 146 µM sucrose, 500 mg/l ME and 0.27 µM NAA where they
formed entire plants. Two months later plants were successfully established in soil.
Gill et al. (1995) initiated callus cultures from leaf, epicotyl, cotyledon and root
segments of in vitro grown nucellar seedlings of Citrus reticulata Blanco ‘Local
Sangtra’. Callus initiation was seen on cut ends of all the explants within 10 days of
culture. The epicotyl segments were the best explants for callus induction. Best callus
induction occurred on MS medium containing NAA (10 mg/l) and KN (0.5 mg/l). MS
medium supplemented with NAA (10 mg/l), KN (1 mg/l) and vitamins (10 X normal
MS levels) were best for induction of somatic embryogenesis. The epicotyl-derived
callus exhibited significantly higher (83.0%) mean somatic embryogenesis than calli
derived from other explants. Most of the somatic embryos germinated like normal
embryos, but some only produced shoots. The time taken for root initiation from
separated shoots was 7-10 days. The number of roots per shoot and root length also
varied with culture media.
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
47
Carimi et al. (1998) reported somatic embryogenesis and plant regeneration
from undeveloped ovules and stigma/style explants of sweet orange navel group [Ctrus
sinensis (L.) Osb.]. Explants were cultured on three different modifications of MS
medium with 500 mg/l ME or 500 mg/l ME + 4.6 µM KN or 500 mg/l ME + 13.3 µM
BA. Sucrose (146 µM) was used as carbon source. High frequency of somatic
embryogenesis was observed with ME (500 mg/l) + 13.3 µM BA.
Carimi et al. (1999) reported callus induction, somatic embryogenesis and plant
regeneration in six different Citrus species [Citrus deliciosa Ten. (cv ‘Avana’), C. limon
(L.) Burm. (cv ‘Berna’), C. madurensis Lour. (cv ‘CNR P9’), C. medica L. (cv ‘Cedro
di Trabia;), C. tardiva Hort. ex Tan. (cv ‘CNR P6’), C. sinensis (L.) Osb. (cv
‘Ugdulena7’)] from cultures of pistil transverse thin cell layer explants. Explants were
cultured on three different media: MS basal medium; MS medium + 500 mg/l ME; MS
medium + 500 mg/l ME + 13.3 µM BA.
Perez et al. (1999) reported somatic embryogenesis in different Citrus spp.
(Citrus deliciosa Ten. (C. reticulata Blanco × C. sinensis (L.) Osb.), (C. paradisi Macf
×C. tangerine Hort. ex Tan.), (C. clementina Hort. ex Tan. × C. paradise Macf. × C.
tangerina Hort. ex Tan.), (C. nobilis Lour. × C. deliciosa Ten.), (C. clementia Hort. ex
Tan. × (C. paradise Macf ×C. tangerina Hort. ex Tan.) × (C. clementina Hort. ex Tan.)
× (C. paradisi Macf. × C. tangerine Hort. ex Tan.) using ovules as explants. Somatic
embryos were obtained on MS medium supplemented with 500 mg/l ME + 50 g/l
sucrose.
Carimi et al. (2000) reported a new method for rearing the citrus flower moth
(Prays citri Mill.) (Lepidoptera, Yponomeutidae) on lemon [Citrus limon (L.) Burm.]
callus induced from lemon stigma and style explants cultured on MS medium
supplemented with 500 mg/l ME, 13.3 µM BA and 146 µM sucrose. Somatic
embryogenesis and plant regeneration was also obtained from the cultures of styles and
stigmas of lemon. Obukosia and Waithaka (2000) reported somatic embryogenesis in
Citrus sinensis and Citrus limon from nucellar embryos on MS medium supplemented
with 10% coconut water or 0.4 g/l casein hydrolysate. Yang et al. (2000) reported callus
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
48
induction and embryoid regeneration from the endosperm culture of C. grandis (L.)
Osb. on MS medium consisting of 1% sucrose, 1µM BA. Embryogenesis and rooting
were induced with addition of 30 µM GA3 to basal MS medium.
D’Onghia et al. (2001) cultured stigmas and styles of C. reticulata, C. sinensis
and C. reticulata × C. sinensis on MS medium supplemented with 6 mg/l BA to induce
somatic embryogenesis. Bespalhok et al. (2001) described a protocol for shoot
regeneration of sweet orange cvs. Pera, Valencia and Folha Murcha from thin sections
excised from juvenile explants.
Tomaz et al. (2001) reported somatic embryogenesis from nucellus-derived
callus cultures of five Citrus cultivars, including three (Caipira, Seleta Vermelha, and
Valencia) of sweet oranges (C. sinensis L. Osbeck), one each of rangpur lime (C.
limonia L. Osbeck), and cleopatra mandarin (C. reticulata Blanco) (lines I and II).
Callus lines maintained on MT medium consisting of 50 g/l sucrose were transferred to
MT medium supplemented with different carbohydrate sources like galactose, glucose,
lactose, maltose or sucrose at 18, 37, 75, 110, or 150 µM, or glycerol at 6, 12, 24, 36, or
50 µM. Globular embryos were observed after approximately 4 weeks in several
treatments. Cultures of valencia, caipira sweet oranges and cleopatra mandarin (line I)
showed higher numbers of embryos on medium containing galactose, lactose and
maltose. Histological studies showed somatic embryos in all developmental stages with
a normal histodifferentiation pattern. The other two cultivars (rangpur lime and
cleopatra mandarin, line II) formed very few embryos, which did not develop further
following the globular stage. Some of the abnormalities observed were lack or
dedifferentiation of protoderm and absence of apical meristems and procambial strands.
Embryos that followed the normal sequence of development were easily converted into
plants. Non-embryogenic cultures continued as proliferating callus cultures, eventually
forming a few embryos which did not convert into plants.
Fiore et al. (2002) reported callus induction and somatic embryogenesis from
stigmas and styles of C. sinensis and C. limon. Best response was observed with stigma
of C. limon on MT medium supplemented with 4 µM 4-CPPU [N-(2-chloro-4-pyridyl)-
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
49
N’-phenylurea. Madhav et al. (2002) reported somatic embryogenesis from nucellus
tissues in C. reticulata on MT medium supplemented with 500 mg/l ME and 0.5 mg/l
BA. Miah et al. (2002) reported callus induction and plant regeneration through somatic
embryogenesis from immature ovules on MS medium supplemented with 500 mg/l ME
in Citrus macroptera Mont. Var. anammensis (‘Sat Kara’). Han et al. (2002) obtained
somatic embryos from aborted seeds of C. unshiu on MS medium supplemented with 5
µM KN + 0.2% gellan gum.
Neidz et al. (2002) reported that somatic embryos initiated from embryogenic
callus of sweet orange [C. sinensis L. Osbeck cv. ‘Hamlin’] generally results in
abnormal morphogenesis of somatic embryos. To normalize development, glycerol-
induced globular stage somatic embryos were cultured on 6000–8000 MW cutoff
cellulose acetate, 400000 MW cutoff cellulose acetate, nitrocellulose, polyvinylidene
fluoride (PVDF), cellulose filter paper or positive or neutral charged nylon membranes.
Only the two cellulose acetate membranes resulted in the development of normal, two-
cotyledon, bipolar, heart-shaped embryos and no aberrant teratoma-like structures.
Heart-shaped embryos developed and germinated normally on Murashige and Tucker
basal medium with 0.5% sucrose and 1 µM GA3. Culture of embryogenic callus directly
onto cellulose membranes also resulted in the development of normal heart-shaped
embryos, indicating that glycerol induction of globular-stage embryos is not necessary.
Heart-shaped embryos were not observed when the osmotic potential of the medium
was increased by the addition of 2.5–15% PEG; neither were they observed when the
matric potential of the medium was increased by increasing the gelling agent
concentrations of agar and gelrite from 0.8% to 3% and 0.15% to 0.9%, respectively.
Ricci et al. (2002) reported somatic embryogenesis in C. reticulata, C. sinensis
and C. nobilis × C. deliciosa on MT medium supplemented with ME and different
carbohydrates (galactose, maltose, lactose, sucrose and glucose). Wu and Mooney
(2002) reported callus induction and somatic embryogenesis from ovules excised from
immature fruits of citrus cultivars on MT medium containing 50 mg/l sucrose, 500 mg/l
ME and 7.5 g/l agar. This callus was treated with colchicine to induce chromosome
doubling in order to produce autotetraploid plants.
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
50
Germana et al. (2005) reported the influence of light quality on anther culture of
Citrus clementina Hort. exTan., cultivar Nules. After one month of cultivation in
darkness, four light qualities were tested: White, Red, Far-Red and Blue. Continuous
darkness and white light under photoperiod of 16 hrs were used as control conditions.
Gametic embryoids and embryogenic callus were obtained only under photoperiodic
conditions of White light, suggesting that the alternation of light and dark can be used
for the process of gametic embryogenesis in Citrus.
Mukhtar et al. (2005) used nodal segments and leaf discs of sweet orange
(Citrus sinensis L.) cv. Musambi and lime (Citrus aurantifolia ) cv. Kaghzi nimbu to
obtain aseptically raised plantlets on MS medium supplemented with 2,4-D (2 mg/l) and
coconut milk (20%). Callus induction was highest when shoot segments of lemon were
cultured on MS media supplemented with 2, 4-D and coconut milk. Embryo
proliferation was highest when they were cultured on MS medium supplemented with
1.5 mg/l of KN. Shoot induction was highest when embryos were cultured on MS
medium supplemented with 2.0 mg/l of BA in both species. Highest rooting percentage
in musambi was obtained at concentration of 1.5 mg/l NAA. Singh et al. (2005) used
MS medium supplemented with 9.29 µM KN to induce somatic embryogenesis from
ovules in kinnow (C. nobilis × C. deliciosa).
Carra et al. (2006) investigated the possibility that three diphenylurea (DPU)
derivatives, N-phenyl-N¢-benzothiazol-6-ylurea (PBU), N,N¢-bis-(2,3-methilendioxy-
phenyl) urea (2,3-MDPU) and N,N¢-bis-(3,4-methilendioxyphenyl) urea (3,4-MDPU),
stimulate the induction of somatic embryogenesis in three Citrus species. The
hypothetical embryogenic activity was assessed using stigma and styles of Citrus
myrtifolia Raf., Citrus madurensis Lour. and Citrus limon (L.) Burm. The three
compounds influenced the production of somatic embryos differently as regards the
concentrations tested and the Citrus species. PBU was able to induce somatic
embryogenesis at all the concentrations tested and in all the three species with
percentages that ranged from 44 (C. limon) to 85% (C. myrtifolia). 2,3-MDPU and 3,4-
MDPU were completely unable to induce the production of somatic embryos in C.
myrtifolia while both the compounds at the higher concentration (12 µM) acted
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
51
positively in both C. madurensis and C. limon (68% of embryogenic explants). The
phenylurea derivatives, used for the first time in this study to induce somatic
embryogenesis in plants, showed a higher embryogenic performance when compared
with BA, a classical adenine-cytokinin, and with N-(2-chloro-4-pyridyl)-N¢-phenylurea
(CPPU), a classical DPU derivative.
Chiancone et al. (2006) investigated the influence of polyamines on anther
culture of Citrus clementina, cv. Nules, with particular attention to the free, soluble and
insoluble-conjugated polyamine levels. Putrescine, spermidine and putrescine plus
spermidine, were added to the standard induction medium. Before culture, spermidine
was the most abundant among the free polyamines detected in anthers. The exogenous
supply of either putrescine or spermidine, either independently or combined, effected
greater uptake and accumulation of polyamines. The addition of 2 µM spermidine to the
medium stimulated gametic embryogenesis in clementine Nules, whereas putrescine did
not influence embryo production. Regenerants were mostly tri-haploids; a few doubled-
haploids and no haploid plants were obtained.
El-Sawy et al. (2006) initiated embryogenic cultures from undeveloped ovules
(8-weeks old after anthesis) of several Citrus species on three different media: basal MS
supplemented with ME alone (M1 medium) or in combinations with BA (M2 medium)
or KN (M3 medium). Differences were observed in callusing percentage, embryogenic
callus and the number of embryos among species, cultivars and culture media under
investigation. Also, embryo germination was determined. Somatic embryogenesis via
ovules depended on the genotype and the culture medium. The most effective treatment
for embryo production varied among genotypes as the highest percentage of
embryogenesis was obtained with local mandarin on M1 medium (100%) and for
shamouti orange on M2 medium (44.4%) but M3 medium was the best for Washington
navel orange (100%). In general, M1 medium gave the best response for most
genotypes.
Kayim and Kemal (2006) studied the effects of several carbohydrates i.e.
glycerol, sorbitol, mannitol, lactose, glucose, and galactose at different concentration
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
52
ranges (1–5%) on embryogenesis of ovule-derived calli from three species and four
varieties of Citrus; clementine mandarin (Citrus clementina), Washington navel orange
(C. sinensis), kutdiken and Zagara bianca lemon (C. limon). The best results of embryo
formation from calli of different citrus varieties were obtained in 4% and 5% glycerol
concentrations. Sixty seven Washington navel orange embryos and 137 Zagara bianca
lemon embryos were obtained at a concentration of 4% glycerol. Clementine mandarin
and kutdiken lemon produced significant numbers of embryos 808 and 453,
respectively, with 5% glycerol. Embryogenesis was also stimulated at fewer rates with
other carbohydrates, such as lactose and sorbitol, at various concentrations in all citrus
calli utilized in this study.
Moiseeva et al. (2006) reported organization of initial stages of somatic
embryogenesis in tissue culture of Citrus sinensis cv. Toracco at the organismal level.
The callus (pre-embryogenic mass) was induced from nucellus tissue on MT medium
containing 1% sucrose, 2% glycerol and 500 mg/l ME.
Niedz et al. (2006) isolated protoplasts from nucellar-derived embryogenic
callus of sweet orange (C. sinensis L. Osbeck) cultured in alginate beads for 5–30 days,
and the resulting protoplast derived calli (p-calli) released by liquefaction and cultured
on semi-permeable membranes overlaid on MT culture medium. Somatic embryos did
not develop from 5- to 10-day-old p-calli but did develop from 15-, 20-, 25-, and 30-
day-old p-calli. There were no significant differences in the numbers of embryos
produced among the 15- to 30-day-old p-calli and no abnormal embryo morphologies
were observed. The minimum size of p-calli to form embryos was 77.84 mm in
diameter. Embryos were smaller from p-calli than those produced from embryogenic
callus; p-calli-derived embryos ranged in size between 0.5 and 0.8 mm, while embryos
derived from embryogenic callus ranged between 1 and 2 mm.
Singh et al. (2006) reported callus induction from nucellus tissues of kinnow
(C. nobilis × C. deliciosa) on MS medium supplemented with 9.02 µM 2,4-D, and 400
mg/l ME in combination with 7.56 µM ABA or 500 mg/l ME was used for somatic
embryogenesis. Siragusa et al. (2007) reported regeneration of somatic embryos from
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
53
calamondin (Citrus madurensis Lour.) style stigma explants cultured in the presence of
BA and three synthetic phenylurea derivatives, N-(2-chloro-4-pyridyl)-N-phenylurea
(4-CPPU), N-phenyl-N¢-benzothiazol-6-ylurea (PBU) and N,N¢-bis-(2,3-
methilendioxyphenyl)urea (2,3-MDPU). The phenylurea derivative compounds tested at
micromolar level (12 µM) were able to induce a significant percentage of responsive
explants as compare that obtained with BA and hormone-free conditions.
Singh et al. (2007) investigated the effect of storage conditions on per cent
germination of encapsulated and non-encapsulated somatic embryos of kinnow
mandarin (Citrus nobilis Lour × C. deliciosa Tenora). Different batches of encapsulated
and non-encapsulated embryos were preserved at room temperature, 4◦C, in liquid
nitrogen as such and by embedding in liquid paraffin. In the encapsulated somatic
embryos stored at room temperature in sealed Petri plates, percentage of germination
was 24.99%, but 5.55% in non-encapsulated embryos after 3 days of storage.
Encapsulated embryos stored in vials containing liquid paraffin at room temperature
were germinated at 18.05% after 60 days of storage, while it was 13.88% in non-
encapsulated embryos after 45 days of storage. Encapsulated somatic embryos stored at
4◦C in sealed Petri plates remained viable for up to 75 days with 6.94% germination,
whereas non-encapsulated embryos remained viable for up to 45 days with 24.99%
germination. Encapsulated embryos stored at 4◦C in vials filled with paraffin germinated
at 11.11% after 120 days of storage, but 5.55% in non-encapsulated embryos after 90
days of storage. Encapsulated and nonencapsulated embryos stored in liquid nitrogen
showed 58.33 and 51.38% survival, respectively, after 7 months of storage. The
plantlets developed from these embryos were transplanted after acclimatization and
showed normal growth.
Altaf et al. (2008) reported somatic embryogenesis from immature ovules. The
callus was formed on explants cultured on MS medium supplemented with KN 2 mg/l +
2,4-D 2 mg/l. Embryos were obtained in MS + ME 0.5 mg/l + ADS 25 mg/l. Wu et al.
(2009) reported that embryogenic callus culture of Citrus sinensis gave rise to a large
number of embryos on the embryo inducing medium (EIM) containing glycerol,
whereas very few embryos were observed on the callus growth medium (CGM).
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
54
Exogenous application of 1 µM putrescine to EIM together with 5 µM a difluoro methyl
ornithine led to dramatic enhancement of endogenous polyamines, which successfully
restored somatic embryogenesis. All of these, collectively, demonstrated that free
polyamines, at least spermidine and spermine, were involved in glycerol-mediated
promotion of somatic embryogenesis, which will open a new avenue for establishing a
sophisticated system for somatic embryogenesis based on the modulation of
endogenous polyamines. Summary of literature on somatic embryogenesis in Citrus
spp. is given in Table 2.3.
2.3. INDUCED MUTAGENESIS
The discoveries during the late 1920s that the genetic material is amenable to
changes excited geneticists who saw new opportunities for both basic and practical
applications. During the 1950s, induced mutagenesis was widely pursued in the US,
Europe, Japan and China. In India, Swaminathan and his team at the Indian Agricultural
Research Institute, New Delhi initiated a major programme on mutagenesis in crop
plants. These studies were broadly aimed at understanding the process of mutations,
testing the efficacy of various mutagens, identifying optimum dose and the best method
of treatment for different crop species; isolation of mutants of basic and applied value;
elucidating the biological effects of radiation-treated medium, seeds and vegetative
propagules on the organisms consuming them. Chemical mutagens mostly used for
mutation induction in plants belong to class of alkylating agents (ethyl methansulfonate
(EMS); diethylsulfate (DES); ethyleneimine (EI); ethyl nitroso urethane (ENU); ethyl
nitrosourea (ENH), methyl nitroso urea (MNH) and azides (Heslot, 1977).
2.3.1. EMS as chemical mutagen for crop improvement
EMS is one of the most widely used chemical mutagen in mutation studies.
Carlson (1970) selected auxotrophic mutants in haploid cells using EMS as the
mutagen. Nabors et al. (1975) selected NaCl-resistant cell lines from Nicotiana
tabacum L. cell suspension culture treated by the mutagen EMS and grown in a medium
containing 0.03 M NaCl. Cells derived from these lines even resisted concentrations as
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
55
high as 0.09 M NaCl in the medium. The mutant was resistant to seed germination
inhibition by spermine.
Epp (1987) suggested incubation of shoot-tips for 1 hour in 12.41-37.23 mM
EMS. Omar et al. (1989) used EMS as mutagen to induce variations in banana by
treating shoot tips of two banana clones: SH-3362 (AA); and GN-60A, a mutant of
Grande Naine (AAA) and then regenerated adventitious buds. The best response was
achieved with 24.69 mM and 3 h of incubation.
Lu and Jia (1994) treated embryogenic calli of millet with 0.5% EMS for 2.5 h,
the regenerated plants exhibited strong resistance to NaCl stress. Pius et al. (1994) used
EMS (Ethyl methane sulfonate) to induce variation in fingermillet. Embryogenic tissues
were treated with 0.5 and 1% EMS. The calli were immersed into filter sterilized
solution of EMS for ½, 1 and 2 h, washed four times with sterile distilled water and
transferred to MS basal medium.
Venkatachalam and Jayabalan (1995a) established callus cultures from
immature leaf explants of two cultivars of Arachis hypogaea (VRI-2 and TMV-7) on
MS medium supplemented with 2.0 mg/l of NAA and 0.5 mg/l of BA. Three week old
calli were subjected to mutagenic treatments (gamma rays: 50-250 Gy and EMS: 5-25
raM). Mutagen-treated calli were subcultured to fresh medium containing various
concentrations (25-100% v/v) of pathotoxic culture filtrate (CF). Calli were challenged
in vitro with pathotoxic CF of the fungal pathogen and were assessed by visible growth
ratings expressed as the percent response to the doses/concentrations of mutagen.
Selected mutagen-treated calli showed resistance in vitro on media containing
Cercosporidium personatum pathotoxic CF. Resistant calli were then transferred to MS
regeneration medium supplemented with BA (2.0 mg/l) and NAA (0.5 mg/l) for shoot
bud regeneration. The progeny of the plants produced 13 disease-resistant plants (R2) in
both the cultivars. Among the eight R 2 populations studied, 70.2-82.5% of the plants
exhibited enhanced resistance. This study suggested that groundnut plants with
resistance to C. personatum can be selected from mutagen-treated callus of tikka leaf
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
56
spot-susceptible cultivars using host-specific pathotoxic CFs of C. Personatum through
in vitro technology.
Alcantra et al. (1996) determined optimal conditions for mutagenesis of
Capsicum annuum L. Seeds of the cultivar Keystone Resistant Giant No. 3 were treated
with 0.5%, 1.0%, and 1.5% EMS and exposed for 3, 6, and 9h at 5°C, 10°C, 15°C and
20°C. Several unique and interesting mutants were generated in this study. In the M
generation, seeds treated with 1.5% EMS at 20°C for 9 h had the lowest germination
percentage among 36 treatments, but the observed differences in germination
percentage were not significant. This study suggests that concentration and duration of
seed exposure to EMS could be increased to induce even greater number of mutants.
Mirza and Saeed (1997) isolated a spermine-resistant mutant of Arabidopsis
thaliana L. Henth. from M2 population of EMS mutagenized seeds. Subhash et al.
(1997) reported EMS to induce lincomycin resistance in Capsicum annuum.
Mutagenized cotyledons were cultured on shoot regenerating medium containing
lincomycin (100 mg/l). Approximately 14% of regenerated shoots were chlorophyll
deficient and about 4% of regenerated shoots were green from mutaganized cotyledons.
The regenerated green plants were resistant to lincomycin but sensitive to
chloramphenicol, kanamycin, spectinomycin and streptomycin. Reciprocal crosses were
made between resistant and sensitive plants. Inheritance of lincomycin resistance was
transmitted as a non-Mendelian trait. Lincomycin resistance is a first selectable and
maternally inherited organelle encoded genetic marker described in chilli pepper.
Bhagwat and Duncan (1998) reported mutagen treatment with EMS in banana
(Musa spp. AAA group) to produce variants for tolerance to Fusarium wilt. The
mutagens tested were EMS (100-300 mM), DES (10-25 mM) and sodium azide (1.1-4.6
mM). Shoot apices were immersed in a buffered solution for 30 or 60 minutes. Optimal
doses (2.3 mM NaN3 for 30 min, 25 mM DES for 60 min and 200 mM EMS for 30
min) were determined on the basis of number of parameters such as the survival rate of
treated apices, the regeneration frequency and the phenotypic variation among the
regenerated shoots.
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
57
Rai and Kumar (2000) reported a recessive EMS-induced mutation inherited in
Mendelian fashion which caused monocotyledonous embryo formation and seed
germination on high salt medium in Catharanthus roseus which is a dicotyledonous
plant. Availability during embryo development of exogenously supplied cytokinin KN
suppressed the mutant phenotype. These observations suggest that, in C. roseus, (i)
insufficiency in endogenous KN may lead to monocotyledonous embryo patterning and
(ii) dicotyledonous embryo formation requires a critical amount of KN in certain cells
of early embryos.
Jabeen and Mirza (2002) used seeds of Capsicum annuum for mutagenesis with
EMS. They used 0.01, 0.1 and 0.5% concentration of EMS for different time duration
i.e. 3 and 6 h. 0.5% concentration with 6 h duration exposure was highly toxic and
produced adverse effect on seed germination. Latado et al. (2004) reported induction of
mutations in chrysanthemum using EMS in immature floral pedicels, followed by the
induction and production of adventitious buds in vitro. Preliminary studies on the
sensitivity of pedicels to EMS revealed that the LD50 was close to 0.82% (v/v).
Immature pedicels of chrysanthemum cv. Ingrid (dark pink color) were treated with
0.77% (0.075 M) EMS solution for 1 h and 45 min, which was followed by rinsing in
water for 15 min and surface disinfection. Afterwards, they were cultivated on MS
medium (salts and vitamins) amended with 1 g/l of hydrolyzed casein, 1 mg/l BA and 2
mg/l IAA. A total of 910 plants were obtained from the pedicels treated with EMS and
were evaluated at the flowering stage. Forty eight mutants (5.2%) were obtained,
deviating in petal colour (pink-salmon, light-pink, bronze, white, yellow and salmon
color). Most of them (89.6% of the total) were phenotypically uniform. The results
showed the efficiency of EMS to induce in vitro mutation of chrysanthemum.
Oliveira et al. (2004) used 0.010 mol dm-3, 0.015 mol dm-3 and 0.020 mol dm-3
of EMS to induce mutations in seeds of sunflower. Seeds were pre-treated with
potassium phosphate buffer of pH 8.0 for 8h. They were then treated with EMS solution
for 16 h, rinsed and were sown in the field at the Embrapa Soybean experimental
station, in Londrina, PR, Brazil and M1 plants were harvested in bulk. M2, M3 and M4
plants were screened for disease resistance under natural infection in the field. Plants
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
58
were evaluated for Alternaria leaf spot symptoms, using a diagrammatic scale from 0
(no symptoms) to 5 (maximum infection). Before flowering, plants showing no
symptoms of Alternaria leaf spot (grade 0) or less than 5% diseased leaf area (grade 1)
were bagged for self-pollination. Self-pollinated plants and open-pollinated plants from
150 Gy and 165 Gy populations with no or mild disease symptoms were selected. In
the second experiment, sunflower seeds of the genotypes HA 300 and HA BR 104 were
treated with ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) at 0.015mol dm-3. Selected M2 and M3
were screened for disease resistance in the field. From the EMS treatment, 300 M3
plants with no disease were recovered.
Svetleva and Crino (2005) investigated the influence of EMS and N-nitroso-N´-
ethyl urea (ENU) mutagenic treatments on three time sub-cultured calli obtained from
leaf petiole explants of 7-day old sterile plants. Calibrated sterile seeds of the common
bean Bulgarian variety Plovdiv 11M were pre-cultivated on MS basal medium
supplemented with 1 µmM BA. Then, both mutagens EMS and ENU were applied for
different times such as 15, 30, 60 and 90 min on the explants at the concentrations of:
2.5×10-2 M and 6.2×10-3 M, respectively. Times of the mutagenic treatments influenced
callus growth, calli from 30 min treatment with both mutagens showed the highest
weights. In both cases, the 90-min mutagen application caused a too relevant effect
either on callus browning or growth inhibition. In general, ENU showed a stronger
effect than EMS. The effect of subcultures on callus growth was higher than mutagenic
treatments. Interactions between these factors checked by correlation ratio (η%) were
quite low.
Swamy et al. (2005) induced streptomycin-resistant plantlets showing
chloroplast encoded mutants in Solanum surattense from mutagenised (EMS and
gamma-rays) cotyledon explants. Chloroplast encoded streptomycin resistant – shoots
were developed from green (unbleached) sectors of the cotyledons. The streptomycin-
resistant plants were similar to parental plants in morphology and ploidy level.
Reciprocal crosses between streptomycin-resistant and the original streptomycin
sensitive plants have shown the non-Mendelian transmission under the control of
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
59
chloroplast DNA. These antibiotic resistant plants are useful in designing biochemical
selection schemes aimed at somatic hybrid/cybrid recovery in S. surattense.
Venkataiah et al. (2005) studied the effects of atrazine on cotyledon cultures of
Capsicum annuum (L.) cv. G4 with a view of establishing a system for in vitro selection
of resistant mutants. At low levels, herbicide produced little growth inhibition, some
chlorophyll loss occurred associated with the production of albino shoots. At 20 mg/l
atrazine bleaching was more pronounced and was accompanied by the development of
necrotic spots; however, efficient bleaching was associated with severe suppression of
growth. Mutagenized cotyledon explants resulted in production of herbicide-resistant
plants on medium containing selective levels of sucrose (0.5%) and atrazine (20 mg/1).
Differential morphogenetic responses were observed when the levels of sucrose (0.5–
5%) were altered. Shoot regeneration was maximum in 2% sucrose and the regenerating
ability decreased with a further increase in sucrose concentration (3–5%). However,
lowering of sucrose concentration from 2 to 0.5% caused complete bleaching of
explants and permitted the selection of herbicide-resistant plants. Complete atrazine-
resistant plantlets were obtained after rooting of regenerated green shoots on rooting
medium containing 10 mg/l atrazine, 1.0 mg/l IAA and 0.5% sucrose. Leaf segment
assay of differentiated plants revealed that all regenerants were resistant to the atrazine.
Reciprocal crosses between atrazine-resistant and sensitive plants showed a non-
Mendelian transmission of resistance trait.
Wani and Khan (2006) treated seeds of mungbean (Vigna radiata (L.) Wilczek)
var. PDM-11, presoaked in distilled water for 9 h with 0.1%, 0.2% EMS or 0.01%,
0.02% hydrazine hydrate (HZ) for 6 h to induce mutations. A significant increase in
mean values of the fertile branches per plant, pods per plant and seed yield per plant
was noticed in mutants of mungbean. Luan et al. (2007) reported in vitro screening for
salt tolerance and plant regeneration of sweet potato (Ipomoea batatas L.) by using
EMS. Calli initiated from leaf explants were treated with 0.5% EMS for 0, 1, 1.5, 2, 2.5
and 3 h, followed by rinsing with sterile distilled water for four times. Preliminary
experiments showed that 200 mM NaCl could be used as selection pressure. Salt
tolerant calli were sub-cultured on medium supplemented with 200 mM NaCl for
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
60
selection of mutant cell lines and this process repeated 5 times (20 days each). The
selected calli were transferred onto somatic embryo formation medium (MS medium
supplemented with 4 mg/l abscisic acid (ABA), 10 mg/l GA3). After 15 days, somatic
embryos were transferred onto MS medium supplemented with 0.05 mg/l ABA, 0.2
mg/l zeatin for regeneration. Plants designated as ML1, ML2 and ML3 were regenerated
from the somatic embryos formed by calli treated with 0.5% EMS for 2 and 2.5 h. After
propagation, salt tolerance of these mutants was investigated. Data suggested that the
mutants were more salt tolerant than control plants.
Basu et al. (2008) developed early maturing fenugreek mutants with a
determinate growth habit to ensure uniform maturity within the 100 frost free days
available on the Canadian prairies. Seeds from Tristar Fenugreek, a forage cultivar
developed for production in western Canada were treated with 10–300 µM EMS for 2–
24 h and plants were selected for determinate growth habit, early maturity and high seed
yield. This mutation breeding approach has detected new breeding material exhibiting
early seed maturity coupled with high seed yield, seed quality and determinate growth
habit.
Van et al. (2008) reported regeneration of Plants from EMS-treated. Immature
embryo cultures in Soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merr.]. 2 to 4 mm long immature
cotyledons were placed in induction medium after EMS treatment and the numbers of
somatic embryos formed per explant were counted four weeks after culture initiation. In
this study, genotypic differences in the efficiency of somatic embryogenesis from
immature embryos among four cultivars treated with different concentrations of EMS
for six hours were observed. Cultivars, Sinpaldalkong 2 and Jack, displayed highly
efficient somatic embryogenesis regardless of EMS concentration, whereas very low
efficiency or no survival was observed in Jinju 1 and Iksannamulkong cultivars.
Preculture duration did not influence the efficiency of somatic embryogenesis. Because
Sinpaldalkong 2 exhibited the best somatic embryogenesis, much higher concentrations
of EMS were used to test somatic embryo formation under different periods of time in
this cultivar. Three and six hour treatments with both 1 and 2 mM EMS yielded higher
embryo formation than longer periods of time. Increasing the time with embryos in 2
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
61
mM EMS caused a reduction in somatic embryogenesis in Sinpaldalkong 2, but many
chlorophyll-deficient soybean variants were identified in the M1R0 and M2R1
generations. In addition to Jack, Sinpaldalkong 2 is a good genotype for plant
regeneration from EMS-treated immature embryo cultures.
Khan and Goyal (2009) induced mutations in two mungbean varieties, K-851
and PS-16 using EMS and gamma rays as mutagens. Selection studies were conducted
to improve the yield and to generate genetic variability in different quantitative traits
viz., fertile branches per plant, pods per plant and seed yield per plant. Mean values in
traits increased significantly over the controls and genetic parameters were recorded
higher for the mutants isolated in M5 generation.
Okubara et al. (2009) reported genetic resistance/tolerance to Rhizoctonia solani
AG-8 and R. oryzae in wheat (Triticum aestivum L. em Thell) germplasm ‘Scarlet-Rz1’.
Scarlet-Rz1 was derived from the allohexaploid spring wheat cultivar Scarlet using
EMS mutagenesis. Tolerant seedlings displayed substantial root and shoot growth after
14 days in the presence of 100–400 propagules per gram soil of R. solani AG-8 and R.
Oryzae in greenhouse assays. BC2F4 individuals of Scarlet-Rz1 showed a high and
consistent degree of tolerance.
Dai et al. (2011) reported that EMS treatment inhibited callus proliferation in
Viburnum dentatum L., particularly in the early stage of callus recovery. However, no
significant difference in shoot regeneration among different treatments was observed,
indicating that the inhibitory effect of EMS was minimal after calluses re-acquired their
capacity to grow and regenerate in the regular medium. Kulkarni (2011) exposed seeds
of horse gram [Mocrotyloma uniflorum (Lam) Verdcourt] to various doses of EMS,
Sodium azide (SA) and NMU. The results indicated the reduction in seed germination
67.67% to 47.65% with EMS, 69.66% to 50.33% with SA and 72.33% to 57.59% with
NMU, whereas in control it showed 86% seed germination. Dry/Fresh Wt. ratio (of 8
days old seedling) shows great reduction from 0.102 to 0.079 with EMS, 0.110 to 0.081
with SA and 0.091 to 0.071 with NMU as against 0.108 in control. Pollen fertility was
also reduced with the increase in the concentration of the mutagen. It was noticed
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
62
86.4%, 74.3% and 54.6% with EMS; 87.8%, 78.9% and 61.3% with SA; 89.3%, 73.6%
and 64.7% with NMU. In general, greater shift in mean and variance was observed in
treatment with higher doses of mutagen.
2.4. IN VITRO SELECTION FOR DISEASE RESISTANCE IN PLANTS
USING PHYTOTOXINS/CULTURE FILTRATES OF PATHOGENS AS
SELECTIVE AGENTS
Toxins are considered to be the special weapons of the plant pathogens to evade
or overcome the inherent resistance strategies of host plants (Kimura et al., 2001).
Culture filtrates (CF), as well as other biotic elicitors (polysaccharides, proteins,
glycoproteins, unsaturated fatty acids, cytoplasm of parasitic and non-parasitic bacteria
and fungi), are able to induce the production of phytoalexins in vitro. The elicitor-
induced accumulation of antimicrobial phytoalexins deserves special attention for
explaining plant fungal parasite interactions (Barz et al., 1988). Substances that trigger
most plant defence reactions (e.g. exogenous elicitors) may originate from mycelial
walls or CF (Knogge, 1996a). The phytotoxicity of numerous secondary metabolites
contained in CF of many pathogenic fungi has been demonstrated in bioassays on
plants. Most of these compounds are non-host-selective phytotoxins that interact with
different targets of the physiology of plants (Abbas et al., 1995). Progress in the field of
in vitro selections is often complicated by: (1) the substances contained in filtrates may
not yet have been completely characterized; (2) the expression of resistance to the toxin
in vitro may vary from that shown to the pathogen in plant; and (3) the level of desired
resistance is not obtainable via toxin influence (Lebeda et al., 1988). Part of the
published studies in this field were focused on basic research; they defined the effects of
particular substances contained in the selective agent in the cultures and tried to find
correlations between their in vitro and in vivo effects (Behnke, 1980; Fereol, 1984;
Buiatti et al., 1985; Connel et al., 1990; Hunold et al., 1992; Huang and Hartman, 1998;
Jayasankar et al., 1999; Hamid and Strange, 2000; Jayasankar et al., 2000; Hollmann et
al., 2002). Valuable and significant results were achieved concerning the induction of
substances involved in plant pathogenesis, e.g. b-glucanases, peroxidases (Broekaert et
al., 2000; Huang, 2001; Singh et al., 2003), glucanases and chitinases (Jayasankar and
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
63
Litz, 1998), lignin deposition and accumulation of polyphenolic compounds (Cvikrova´
et al., 1992; Rodeva et al., 2000). Other studies dealt with the effects of these agents on
cells or tissues in vitro and compared them with the in vivo response of plants after
inoculation with fungi or bacteria (Bonnet et al., 1985; Buiatti et al., 1987; Kleijer et
al., 1997; Koike and Nanbu, 1997; Jayasankar and Litz, 1998; Fernandez et al., 2000).
The results were often different, positive and/or negative, depending on the particularity
of the plant pathogen interactions involved.
Many studies on the use of specific toxin for in vitro selection of somaclonal
variants resistant to toxin have been carried out on maize plants (Bretell and Thomas,
1980; Umbeck and Gengenbach, 1983; Gengenbach et al., 1997) and oats (Rines and
Luke, 1985). In vitro selection with CF or non-specific toxins has often given
contrasting results. During 1980 to 1990 many studies reported that the selection of in
vitro calli for insensitivity to CF or toxins gives an increase in the percentage of
resistant regenerants (Sacristan, 1982; Ling et al., 1985). However, in some studies the
frequency of in vitro selection for resistance to toxic medium was not improved (Shahin
and Spivey, 1986).
Behnke (1979) selected dihaploid calli from Solanum tuberosum which were
resistant to the CF of Phytophthora infestans. Each of the selected calli was resistant to
all four pathotypes of Phytophthora used in these experiments. The resistance was not
lost through regeneration and the induction of new callus. Behnke (1980) selected calli
from Solanum tuberosum, which were resistant to the CF of Fusarium oxysporum.
Lower fungus growth correlated with resistance to the CF on the level of calli tissues.
Taylor and Secor (1990) selected callus cultures of S. tuberosum by inoculation and
bilayer culture with Erwinia carotovora subsp. caraotovora. Calli resistant to E.
carotovora were identified, number of regenerants were too low to determine
correlation between in vitro response and tuber resistance.
Thanutong et al. (1983) reported in vitro selection of calli of tobacco in the
presence of toxin isolated from Pseudomonas syringae pv. Tabaci and Alternaria
alternata. Assay of R1 generation derived from toxin resistant calli indicated the
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
64
inheritance of resistance. Bonnet et al. (1985) studied phytotoxicity of individual filtrate
fractions isolated from CF of Phytophthora cryptogea on the leaves of N. tabacum.
Tuzun and Kuc (1987) proved transfer of induced resistance via tissue culture by
inoculating callus cultures of N. tabacum with fungus Peronospora tabacina. Ishida and
Kumashiro (1988) reported that AT toxin of A. alternata induced typical symptoms on
leaves of susceptible cultivars of N. tabacum and cells of resistant cvs. survived toxin
treatment better than those of susceptible cultivar. Field evaluation for tolerance among
cvs. was expressed at the cultured cell level.
Fereol (1984); Peros and Chagvardieff (1987) reported production of disease
resistant plants of Saccharum officinarum (Sugar cane) by treating calli and
micropropagated plants with CF of Ustilago scitaminea. The study showed correlation
between in vitro response and resistance of plants. Mohanraj et al. (2003) reported in
vitro selection of resistant calli of sugercane on the media containing phytotoxin of
Colletotrichum falcatum.
Buiatti et al. (1985) studied the correlation between in vivo resistance to
Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. dianthi and in vitro response to fungal elicitors and toxic
substances, phenylalanine ammonialyase and phytoalexin accumulation in "in vitro"
cultures of three susceptible and four resistant Dianthus caryophyllus cultivars.
Cultivars showing varying degrees of resistance in vivo either tolerated higher CF
concentrations or showed high phenylalanine ammonia-lyase (PAL) enzyme activity
and phytoalexin production when treated with Fusarium elicitor, or responded
positively to both treatments. No such responses were shown in tissue cultures of
susceptible cultivars.
Rines and Luke (1985) studied the effect of Toxin-victorin isolated from
Helminthosporium victoriae on the growth of calli of Avena sativa. This study revealed
that insensitivity to toxin was heritable; specific resistance can be selected in tissue
cultures of oats. Gupta et al. (1986) reported the effect of CF of Alternaria pori on seed
germination in Alium cepa. Seed germination and seedling vigour reduced after filtrate
treatment. Gaurd et al. (1988) exposed the calli and shoot cultures of Allium cepa to the
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
65
CF of Pyrenochaeta terestris. Calli exposed to the filtrate reflected the degree of whole
plant susceptibility.
Scala et al. (1985) used filtrate and mycelial cell wall components-elicitors of F.
oxysporum f. sp. Lycopersici for in vitro selection of callus cultures of L. esculentum.
Correlation between in vivo resistance and in vitro hypersensitive response and
phytoalexin induction were observed, but tolerance to toxic filtrate in vitro was not
indicator of in vivo resistance. Shahin and Spivey (1986) reported in vitro selection of
calli of L. esculentum for resistance to Fusarium oxysporum in the presence of fusaric
acid (FA). Single dominant gene type of resistance to Fusarium wilt was obtained after
in vitro selection on FA.
Barlass et al. (1986) produced downy mildew resistant plants of Vitis vinifera by
co-cultivation and dual culture of in vitro raised shoots with Plasmopara viticola.
Selected plants were resistant to the pathogen and technique can be used for screening
and selection for host resistance. Fanizza et al. (1995) cultured shoots of several table
and wine grape cultivars in vitro on a medium supplemented with polysaccharides
obtained from a CF of Botryotinia fuckeliana through differential ethanolic
precipitations. The general effects of polysaccharides resulted in leaf yellowness and in
a reduction of fresh and dry weight. Differential response of assayed cultivars to
polysaccharides seemed to be not related to their bunch susceptibility to grey mould
under field conditions.
Beech and Gessler (1986) reported that ultrastructural interactions
between Venturia inaequalis and callus cultures from scab susceptible and resistant
apple varieties, were similar. Host cell wall changes, appositions and invagination of
host plasmamembrane at sites of close contact with fungal hyphae were regularly
observed. The host cell alterations as well as many fungal structures corresponded to
those known in young leaves of susceptible apple varieties. Joung et al. (1987) reported
selection of resistant shoots of M. domestica by inoculation with Gymnosporangium
juniper-virginianae. Shoots from resistant variety were not affected by the fungus;
differences in resistance between cotyledonary or embryo axis shoots were observed.
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
66
Cucuzza and Kao (1986) developed an in vitro assay using excised cotyledons
of alfalfa that accurately detects resistance to Colletotrichum trifolii. The cotyledons
were sprayed with a spore suspension and resistant and susceptible reactions were
determined after incubation for 14 days at 24◦C with a 16-hr light period. Susceptibility
is based on the presence of sporulating acervuli. Five isolates of C. trifolii reacted
similarly in the assay, and the range of effective inoculum was 2,500–10,000 spores per
spray. Excised cotyledons and the seedlings from which the cotyledons were obtained
were simultaneously tested in vitro and in a greenhouse. Saranac AR and Saranac had
86.5 and 96.2% agreement of observations, respectively, between the two screening
techniques. Results indicated the usefulness of this technique as an alternative to
greenhouse screening methods.
Vardi et al. (1986) used nucellar calli from four Citrus cultivars with known
resistance to the Phytophthora citrophthora pathogen to test the pathogen's response to
CF. Sensitivity of the four calli to CF of the fungus was in reverse order to what is
known on the susceptibility of the cultivars in vivo. Sensitivity of protoplasts derived
from the same four calli to 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) was in the same
order as that of calli to CF. Protoplasts derived from calli selected for tolerance to CF
showed a higher plating efficiency with increasing concentration of CF in the medium.
TLC and GLC analysis showed the presence of IAA in the CF. Results indicate that CF
of P. citrophthora cannot be used as a selection tool in vitro. Gentile et al. (1992) used
CF and partially purified toxin (PPT)- malseccin, non-specific phytotoxin of Phoma
tracheiphila for selection of disease resistant calli of Citrus limon (lemon) and C.
sinensis (orange). CF increased the weight of calli, PPT reduced the growth of calli;
HPLC analysis proved low presence of KN and GA3, and high amount of IAA. In citrus
selective toxic effect exists and PPT can be used for screening and also for in vitro
selection.
Buiatti et al. (1987) used CF of Fusarium and cell wall components of Fusarium
and Phytophthora for selection of resistant cell lines of Lycopersicon esculentum
(tomato). Cells selected with Fusarium elicitor showed the same behavior as those with
Phytophthora elicitor; low and high phytoalexin producing clones were selected.
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
67
Kramer et al. (1988) developed toxin tolerant cell lines of L. esculentum by in vitro
selection of cell lines in the presence of toxin isolated from Clavibacter michiganensis.
Bulk et al. (1991) selected resistant somaclonal variation derived from leaves,
cotyledons and hypocotyles of L. esculentum in the presence of suspension culture of
Clavibacter michiganensis subsp. michiganensis. Limited potential of somaclonal
variation as a source of resistance to bacterial cancer was proved. Kodama et al. (1991)
reported in vitro selection of calli of L. esculentum for resistance to AL-toxin of
Alternaria alternata. Storti et al. (1992) reported in vitro selection of calli of L.
esculentum resistant to F. oxysporum in the presence of dual culture and cell wall
components of pathogen. Resistant cultivars had higher content of polysaccharides (that
lead to phytoalexin synthesis and increased peroxidase activity and callose) and were
tolerant to FA.
Chawla and Wenzel (1987a) reported calli selection of two genotypes of barley,
‘Dissa’ and W 193 for resistance against fusaric acid, a pathotoxin of Fusarium. Callus
was induced from 7 to 10 days old immature embryos. 80% of the calli were killed
during first selection cycle on medium containing 0.8 mM fusaric acid. After 4 selection
cycles 8 to 11% resistant calli were selected and regenerated. Chawla and Wenzel
(1987b) selected calli of Hordeum hordeum (barley) and Triticum aestivum (wheat) for
resistance to toxic filtrate of Helminthosporium sativum by continuous cycles of
recurrent cultivation on media with and without filtrate. 6–17% surviving calli of toxin-
tolerant lines showed one more isozyme than unselected sensitive calli; majority of
regenerated selected plants were less sensitive to H. sativum. Wenzel and Foroughi-
Wehr (1990) reported that in vitro selection did not possess significant improvement in
disease resistance when suspension cultures of H. vulgare (barley), T. aestivum (wheat)
and S. tuberosum (potato) were exposed to extracts of H. sativum, Fusarium coeruleum,
F. sulphureum, Phytophthora infestans and fusaric acid. Hunold et al. (1992) reported
selection of callus cultures of H. vulgare for resistance in the presence of toxin of
Drechslera teres. Nine progenies of S2 showed a correlation between toxin tolerance
and resistance against the pathogen.
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
68
Ireland and Leath (1987) treated intact plants of M. sativa with CF of
Verticillium albo-atrum and reported that symptoms on stems and leaves of alfalfa after
filtrate treatment were typical for field-infected plants; the filtrate has a potential for use
in screening for resistance. Cvikrova´ et al. (1992) reported selection of resistant calli of
M. sativa by giving challenge of CF of F. oxysporum. Results revealed that cell cultures
derived from genotype susceptible to F. oxysporum accumulated double the amount of
phenolic acids than the resistant ones. Alfalfa protoplast and cell cultures were selected
with fungal cell-wall components and heat-released elicitors for resistance to V. albo-
atrum (Koike et al., 1993b; Koike and Nanbu, 1997). Nedenı´k and Rˇ epkova´ (1998)
reported in vitro selection of calli resistant to fusaric acid, which showed enhanced level
of resistance than the control.
McComb et al. (1987) cocultured callus of Eucalyptus marginata with agar
blocks of fungal culture of Phytophthora cinnamomi. The study revealed that hyphal
growth on callus is correlated with susceptibility of the plant. Cahill et al. (1992) used
suspension culture of Phytophthora cinnamomi to challenge micropropagated clones of
Eucalyptus marginata. Primary roots of resistant micropropagated lines were able to
restrict and confine colonisation by P. cinnamomi. Stukey et al. (2007) reported
selection of Phytophthora cinnamomi resistant plants of jarrah ortest (Eucalyptus
marginata). Plantlets were planted in a former bauxite mine-site in the jarrah forest and
inoculated with P. cinnamomi. Mortality after 13 years in resistant clones was 0–30%,
while that of susceptible clones was 40–100%. Mean heights of resistant clones after 13
years were 7.8–13.6 m, while heights of surviving susceptible clones were 0.9–6.7 m.
The resistance character of the seedling ortets was transmitted consistently to the
clones. The field mortality of clones of some rare, apparently resistant seedlings
selected from susceptible half-sib families was low after 1 year, but approached that of
the susceptible clones after 2 years. The results showed that Phytophthora-resistant
jarrah ortets could be selected using stem inoculation of glasshouse-grown seedlings;
the resistance of the resulting clones was validated in the field in an inoculation trial.
Heath-pagliuso et al. (1988) produced resistant lines of Apium graveolens by
inoculating roots of somaclones in the suspention culture of Fusarium oxysporum.
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
69
Heath-pagliuso et al. (1989) reported that somaclonal lines (S1 progeny) of Apium
graveolens showed significantly more resistance to F. oxysporum by inoculation of
soaking roots in suspension culture of F. oxysporum. Heath-pagliuso and Rappaport
(1990) tested S1 and S2 somaclonal lines Apium graveolens for the inheritance of
resistance to Fusarium by inoculating the roots of somaclones in the suspention culture
of Fusarium oxysporum. Evenor et al. (1994) studied the effect of CF of Septoria
apiicola on callus of Apium graveolens (celery). Calli showed enhanced degree of
tolerance to CF in selection.
Sjodin et al.(1988); Sjodin and Glimelius (1989) reported selection of disease
resistant plants of Brassica juncea, B. napus, B. carinata and B. nigra (rape), B.
oleracea (rape), Nicotiana tabacum (tobacco) and Solanum tuberosum (potato) from
protoplast, calli and intact plants selection on medium containg toxin-sirodesmine PL
extracted from Phoma lingum. Clear correlation between resistance to P. lingam and
insensitivity to sirodesmin PL was present; toxin could be used to distinguish resistant
and susceptible material both in vitro and in vivo. Hodgkin (1990) selected disease
resistant plants of B. napus (rape) by pollination with pollens treated with toxic extract
of Alternaria alternata. Progeny of 25% selected plants showed pollen resistance
(possibility of utilisation for resistance breeding). Pedras and Biesenthal (2000) used
toxins- phomalide and destruxin isolated from Phoma lingam and Alternaria brassicae
respectively, for selection of disease resistant plants of B. juncea, B. napus (rape) and
Sinapis alba (mustard) using callus cultures. The study revealed differential
phytotoxicity of phomalide and direct correlation with plant disease resistance;
destruxin showed less clear relationship to disease resistance. Rresistant plants of
Brassica oleracea var. botrytis through selection of callus cultures against the CF of
Xanthomonas campestris pv. Campestris were peoduced by Mangal and Sharma (2002).
Mutagenised calli were selected on 30% CF, high level of correlation between
resistance of calli to the filtrate and resistance of regenerated plants to pathogen was
observed.
Connel et al. (1990) studied the cytotoxic effects of CF of Verticillium albo-
atrum on the growth of the protoplasts and cell suspension cultures of Humulus lupulus
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
70
(hop). Cytotoxicity of the CF correlated both with the virulence of the isolates and the
resistance of the cultivars.
Hammerschlag (1990) reported selection of regenerants of peach (Prunus
persica L. Batsch.) cvs. Sunhigh (susceptible to leaf spot) and Redhaven (moderately
resistant to leaf spot) for resistance to Xanthomonas campestris pv. pruni, the causal
agent of bacterial leaf spot using a detached-leaf bioassay. Regenerants obtained from
calli produced on two ‘Sunhigh’ embryos, #61 and #156, and on three ‘Redhaven’
embryos were evaluated. Sixty-four percent of the regenerants derived from ‘Sunhigh’
embryo #156 and 13% of the regenerants derived from ‘Sunhigh’ embryo #61
demonstrated significantly greater spot resistance than ‘Sunhigh’. Regenerants with
resistance greater than ‘Redhaven’ were also obtained from both ‘Sunhigh’ embryos.
The frequency of variation in the ‘Sunhigh’ seedling population, with respect to the
response to bacterial leaf spot, was not so great as that exhibited by the regenerants
derived from ‘Sunhigh’ embryo #156. None of the ‘Redhaven’ seedlings or any of the
regenerants derived from ‘Redhaven’ embryos were more resistant than ‘Redhaven’.
These studies suggest that the frequency of somaclonal variation is genetically
determined and that screening for somaclonal variation may be a feasible approach to
obtaining leaf spot-resistant peach plants.
Pijut et al. (1990) exposed callus culture and stem cuttings of Ulmus americana
(elm) to CF of Ceratocystis ulmi. Reduction in callus growth of susceptible variety on
media with filtrate and correlation between callus reaction and cut stem assay was
observed.
Saindrenan et al. (1990) reported that Phytophthora cryptogea produces elicitor
active component(s) which caused necrosis, accumulation of the phytoalexins kievitone
and phaseollidin and electrolyte leakage from cowpea leaf tissues. Elicitor activity of
CF was enhanced upon treatment of the fungus with 2.44 µM phosphonate, a dose
which slightly effected fungal growth in vitro. The necrosis-inducing activity of CF was
diminished after heating, treatment with pronase and protease, whereas active
substance(s) was/were periodate-sensitive. The fact that phosphonate improved fungal
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
71
cells in vitro to overproduce compound(s) which elicited a resistance response,
supported the hypothesis that the toxophore may act indirectly in vivo interfering with
the processes of pathogenicity.
Wolf and Earle (1990) treated leaf mesophyll protoplasts of susceptible and
resistant corn (Zea mays L.) and non-host oats (Avena sativa L.) with HC toxin. This
toxin, a cyclic tetrapeptide produced by the fungus Helminthosporium carbonum race 1,
is a pathogenicity factor for the disease Helminthosporium leaf spot. The effects of HC
toxin on susceptible protoplasts differed from those in other toxin/protoplast systems in
which toxin rapidly decreased viability. In contrast, HC toxin promoted long-term
viability (i.e. staining with fluorescein diacetate) of protoplasts cultured in a minimal
medium. The first effect of HC toxin, observed after 36 h or more depending on the
culture medium used, involved changes in the distribution of chloroplasts within the
protoplasts. Increases in budding of protoplasts occurred after 48 h of exposure to toxin.
Effects of HC toxin on chloroplast distribution and protoplast shape might be due to
enhanced nutrient uptake. As in other types of studies with HC toxin, protoplasts from a
susceptible genotype were affected by low toxin concentrations (1 µg/ml), whereas
protoplasts from resistant genotypes (host and non-host) showed similar effects at
higher toxin concentrations (10 µg/ml). Chlamydocin, a cyclic tetrapeptide similar to
HC toxin produced by the fungus Diheterospora chlamydosporia, also altered
chloroplast distribution in corn protoplasts, with no differential effect on susceptible and
resistant protoplasts.
Ahmed et al. (1991) reported in vitro selection of calli of spring and winter
wheats (Triticum aestivum L.) for Fusarium resistance, using the double-layer culture
technique. Potato-dextrose agar medium in vials was inoculated with mycelia
of Fusarium graminearum and F. culmorum. After one week, fungal cells were killed
by autoclaving and the agar medium containing the thermostable toxic metabolites was
overlayered with MS callus-growing medium. Later, wheat calluses were placed on the
upper medium for 4–5 weeks, and from the surviving calluses plants were regenerated.
R2 seedling populations from self-fertilized R1 plants of 4 varieties were tested
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
72
for Fusarium resistance by artificial infections in the greenhouse, and 3% of the
regenerated R2 plants have been found to be more resistant than the original cultivars.
Mezzetti et al. (1992) tested two methods for early screening of disease
resistance in apple rootstocks and cultivars. The capacity of Phytophthora cactorum CF
to act as selective agent was tested both on in vitro proliferating shoots and on cell
membrane polarization using an optical probe (Merocyanine 540). With both assays,
four rootstocks (M.26, MM.106, MM.111, Mark), five cultivars ('Gala', 'Liberty',
'McIntosh', 'Empire', 'Jonathan') and some M.26 and MM.106 regenerants were tested.
Both methods were able to characterize different tolerance to CF among the rootstocks,
which correlated with their known field resistance. The second method could be
considered more efficient for genotypes discrimination and also for host-pathogen
interaction studies.
Takahashi et al. (1992) obtained resistant clones of Fragaria vesca by
inoculation of fungus (A. alternata) to wounded plantlets of F. vesca. Orlando et al.
(1997) developed a novel strategy in selecting strawberry (Fragaria x ananassa L.)
plants with resistance to Rhizoctonia fragariae and Botrytis cinerea. Purified pectic
enzymes produced by R. fragariae were used in vitro to select morphogenetic calluses.
Both regenerated shoots and plants were tested in vitro and in vivo with R. fragariae
and B. cinerea. The in vitro resistance of shoots regenerated under selection pressure
was confirmed by in vivo tests with runner plants either by root immersion in a
suspension of R. fragariae mycelium before potting the plants in sterile soil or by
spraying the leaves with several strains of B. cinerea spores. The increase of resistance
against pathogens was correlated with the increase of phenolic compounds, particularly
orthodihydroxyphenols.
Bruins et al. (1993) tested four types of wheat plant material i.e., seedlings,
coleoptile segments, anther-derived callus and anther-derived embryos at different
concentrations of deoxynivalenol (DON) and 3-acetyldeoxynivalenol (3-ADON). DON
inhibited growth of all types of plant material. Seedling growth response to 4 × 10−5M
DON of a large set of genotypes did not differentiate between tolerant and sensitive
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
73
genotypes according to observed Fusarium Head Blight (FHB) resistance level in the
field. In general, coleoptile segments showed a growth reduction at 10−5M DON. A
concentration of 10−4M DON appeared to be the optimum concentration to differentiate
between haploid wheat calli for DON tolerance. However, growth analysis data of 40
callus clones did not show any correlation with the known FHB resistance levels of the
original donor genotypes and populations. Regeneration of the anther-derived embryos
in the embryo selection experiment was decreased 100-fold on DON-containing
medium. Averaged across the callus and embryo selection experiments, green plant
regeneration showed a decrease of approximately 20-fold on medium containing toxin.
Cerato et al. (1993) reported the selection of callus of seven potato cultivars
with CF of Phytophthora infestans (Mont.) de Bary. Regenerated plants were tested for
late blight resistance. Cells selected in one selection cycle were resistant to CF. In vivo
screening of clones regenerated from selected cells was done in two steps: on whole
plants assessing foliage late blight, and on detached leaves, assessing single factors of
horizontal resistance. Koike et al. (1993a, 1996) reported in vitro selection of calli of S.
tuberosum and S. melongena (eggplant) for resistance against the CF of V. albo-atrum.
Trillas-Gay and Araus (1993) reported in vitro selection of calli of D.
caryophyllus for resistance against CF of Fusarium oxysporum. Cells of resistant calli
showed proliferation of endoplasmic reticulum cisternae, nuclei and concentration of
free Ca2+ increased in resistant carnation callus after treatment with filtrate. Trillas- Gay
and Azcon-Bieto (1995) observed different respiratory pattern of two cvs. differing in
degree of susceptibility to F. oxysporum when callus cultures of D. caryophyllus were
exposed to CF and cell wall components of F. oxysporum.
Hammerschlag et al. (1994) reported phenotypic stability of bacterial leaf spot
resistance in peach (Prunus persica (L.) Batsch) regenerants, either selected at the
cellular level for insensitivity to a toxic CF of Xanthomonas campestris pv. pruni or
screened at the whole plant level for resistance to X. campestris pv. pruni. A detached-
leaf bioassay was used to evaluate the original regenerants again after three years in the
greenhouse and also after a two to three year cycle of tissue culture propagation. Peach
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
74
trees derived through micropropagation from the original regenerants were also
evaluated after one to three years growth in the field. Although leaf spot resistance was
retained in some regenerants over time in the greenhouse, following in vitro
propagation, and under field conditions, resistance was either lost or not expressed in
others. Regenerants # 19-1 and #156-6, derived from embryo callus of bacterial spot
susceptible `Sunhigh', were significantly more resistant than `Sunhigh'. High levels of
resistance were exhibited in greenhouse plants and field-grown trees of regenerant #
122-1, derived from embryo callus of moderately resistant 'Redhaven'.
Keller et al. (1994) reported in vitro selection of embryogenic calli of wheat on
media containg toxin of Septoria nodorum. Good correlation between field resistance
and embryo resistance in vitro was observed. Ahmed et al. (1996) selected calli of
resistant, intermediary and susceptible wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) varieties using CFs
of Fusarium graminearum and F. culmorum and evaluated the regenerants for
resistance up to R3. Resistant calli were transferred again to fresh MST for further two
selection cycles. The surviving calli produced less fertile regenerated lines (Ro) than the
non-selected ones. Among 18 R, lines tested for Fusarium-resistance in the seedling
stage by artificial inoculation in the green house, two (11.1%) were significantly more
resistant, one (5.6%) was more susceptible than the original cultivar and the rest
(83.3%) behaved similarly to the donor plants. Kleijer et al. (1996) inoculated
embryogenic calli of triticale with F. culmorum and F. graminearum. No influence of
toxins produced by both Fusarium strains on regeneration was observed.
Mackay et al. (1994) developed an in vitro selection system using roridin E as a
selection agent in Cucumis melo. Vacuum infiltration of callus with the toxin solution
was the only successful selection method at the concentrations tested. Primary callus
(callus originating directly from the explant) was not sensitive to roridin A or E at the
concentrations used. Secondary callus (callus produced from primary callus) exhibited a
differential response to roridins A and E similar to that of detached-leaf assays.
Electrolyte leakage studies of callus were not conclusive in establishing the membrane
as the site of toxin action or useful for screening tolerance in vitro. A small percentage
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
75
of callus from tolerant and susceptible cultivars survived repeated exposure to roridin E
at 50 µg"mÅl-1.
Brosch et al. (1995) reported that HC toxin, the host-selective toxin of the maize
pathogen Cochliobolus carbonum, inhibited maize histone deacetylase (HD) at 2 µM.
Chlamydocin, a related cyclic tetrapeptide, also inhibited HD activity. The toxins did
not affect histone acetyltransferases. After partial purification of histone deacetylases
HD1-A, HD1-B and HD2 from germinating maize embryos, it was demonstrated that
the different enzymes were similarly inhibited by the toxins. Inhibitory activities were
reversibly eliminated by treating toxins with 2-mercaptoethanol, presumably by
modifying the carbonyl group of the epoxide-containing amino acid Aeo (2-amino-9,
10-epoxy-8-oxodecanoic acid). Kinetic studies revealed that inhibition of HD was of the
uncompetitive type and reversible. HC toxin, in which the epoxide group had been
hydrolyzed, completely lost its inhibitory activity; when the carbonyl group of Aeo had
been reduced to the corresponding alcohol, the modified toxin was less active than
native toxin. In vivo treatment of embryos with HC toxin caused the accumulation of
highly acetylated histone H4 subspecies and elevated acetate incorporation into H4 in
susceptible-genotype embryos but not in the resistant genotype. HDs from chicken and
the myxomycete Physarum polycephalum were also inhibited, indicating that the host
selectivity of HC toxin is not determined by its inhibitory effect on HD.
Cassels and Walsh (1995) reported selection of somaclones derived from shoots
and leaves of Helianthus tuberosus (sunflower) on medium containg metabolites of
Sclerotinia sclerotorum. The results revealed that selection on media was successful,
strong correlation between growth in vitro on calcium free media and field resistance
was observed. Kintzios et al. (1996) studied the effect of toxin isolated from A.
alternata on the growth of callus cultures of H. tuberosus. The calli selected in the
presence of toxin could not regenerate further.
Dan and Stephens (1995) reported selection of resistant plants of Asparagus
officinalis (asparagus) using CF of Fusarium oxysporun and F. proliferatum.
Somaclones originated from protoplast culture were selected for resistances in the
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
76
presence of CF. Somaclonal lines were more resistant to CF of F. oxysporum than
vegetatively propagated plants.
Matsumoto et al. (1995) selected tolerant variant of banana with fusaric acid
(FA) after chemical mutagenesis. Multiple shoots were selected for tolerance on the
medium containg different concentrations of FA. Trujillo and De-Garcia (1996)
inoculated callus and intact plants of banana with Cercospora musae and
Mycosphaerella musicola. Both calli and plants showed similar levels of survival after
inoculation. Okole and Schulz (1997) obtained the fungus resistant plantlets in a double
selection system. This involved in a first step the use of a fungal crude filtrate and in
the second step the purified host-specific toxin 2,4,8-trihydroxytetralone extracted
from the fungus Mycosphaerella fijiensis, the causal agent of Black Sigatoka
disease. Resistant plantlets obtained from the double selection system were
inoculated with conidia of M. fijiensis in a growth chamber to reproduce Black
Sigatoka symptoms. Compared to non-treated control plantlets, which were highly
susceptible to the fungus, 10.7-19.3% toxin-resistant plantlets which arose from
tissues that went through the double selection system were resistant against M.
fijiensis. This technique of using micro-cross sections for selection on fungal toxins
seems to be amenable to different Musa genotypes for the production of fungus-
resistant plants.
Venkatachalam and Jayabalan (1995b) established callus cultures from
immature leaf explants of Arachis hypogaea on MS medium supplemented with 2.0
mg/l of NAA and 0.5 mg/l of BA of the susceptible cultivars namely VRI-2 and TMV-
7. Three-week-old calli were subjected to mutagenic treatments (gamma rays: 50-250
Gy and EMS: 5-25 raM). Mutagen-treated calli were subcultured to fresh medium
containing various concentrations (25-100% v/v) of pathotoxic CFs. Calli were
challenged in vitro with pathotoxic CF of the fungal pathogen and were assessed by
visible growth ratings expressed as the percent response to doses/concentrations of
mutagen. Selected mutagen-treated calli showed resistance in vitro on media containing
Cercosporidium personatum pathotoxic CF. Resistant calli were regenerated with BA
(2.0 mg/l) and NAA (0.5 mg/l). The progeny of the plants produced 13 disease-resistant
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
77
plants (R2) in both the cultivars. Among the eight R2 populations studied, 70.2-82.5%
of the plants exhibited enhanced resistance. This study suggested that groundnut plants
with resistance to C. personatum can be selected from mutagen-treated callus of tikka
leaf spot-susceptible cultivars using host-specific pathotoxic CF of C. personatum
through in vitro technology.
Jin et al. (1996) selected embryogenic calli of Glycine max on the medium
containing different concentrations of crude CF of Fusarium solani. Regenerants
showed lower disease ratings than susceptible cultivars. Li et al. (1999) tested the
phytotoxicity of CF of Fusarium solani f. sp. glycines, the fungus causing sudden death
syndrome (SDS) of soybean (Glycine max), with a viability stain of soybean
suspension-cultured cells and a stem cutting assay of soybean seedlings. Suspension-
cultured cells from a SDS-susceptible soybean cultivar were exposed to cell-free CF of
F. solani f. sp. glycines or other F. solani isolates for 2, 4, 6, and 8 days and then
stained with 0.1% phenosafranin. The percentage of dead soybean suspension-cultured
cells was greater (P<0.001) with filtrates prepared from F. solani f. sp. glycines than
from other F. solani isolates, and dead cells increased over time and with higher
concentrations of CF. Cuttings of soybean seedlings with their stems immersed in CF of
F. solani f. sp. glycines isolates developed SDS-like foliar symptoms, but not when
immersed in filtrates of other isolates. There was a positive correlation (r=0.94,
P<0.001) between soybean foliar symptom severity and percentage of stained soybean
suspension cultured cells. Both methods were used to determine the phytotoxicity of
fungal CFs. Rodeva et al. (2000) inoculated intact plants of Glycine max with Fusarium
solani f. sp. glycines and its filtrate. Calli were obtained from selected resistant plants of
G. max and were exposed to CF of pathogen. Field performance and callus reaction to
fungal CF showed enhanced resistance against the pathogen.
Remotti and Loffler (1996) selected shoots, callus cultures and intact plants of
Gladiolus species on medium containing different concentrations of fusaric acid. Shoot
assay and ion-release with intact cormels gave significantly coinciding results. These
selected plants showed enhanced resistance to Fusarium solani f. sp. gladioli. Part of
the fusarium resistance was based on insensitivity to fusaric acid.
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
78
Nyange et al. (1997) used hypocotyl-derived calli of genotypes and segregating
populations of Coffea arabica, differing in susceptibility to Colletotrichum kahawae to
produce cell suspensions and protoplasts which were exposed to partially purified
culture filtrate (PPCFs) prepared from the pathogen. The growth and viability of PPCF-
treated cells and protoplasts were measured using packed cell volume, fluorescein
diacetate staining and a colorimetric assay involving the tetrazolium salt MTT.
Differential responses of cells and protoplasts were influenced by genotype, time of
exposure and PPCF concentration. Protoplasts of resistant genotypes responded
differentially from more susceptible genotypes as early as 4h after challenge with the
phytotoxin, suggesting that they were more sensitive than cell suspensions to the
treatments. Protoplasts exposed to PPCFs from C. kahawae may therefore be used to
screen and select genotypes resistant to, or tolerant of coffee berry disease.
Wedge and Tainter (1997) reported that Dogwood anthracnose, caused by the
fungus Discula destructiva Redlin, is a severe disease of flowering dogwood (Comus
florida L.) and Pacific dogwood (C. nutta Uii Aud.). Selection of callus for insensitivity
to D. destructiva metabotites was done by placement of individual cultures on media
amended with progressively higher concentrations of a partially purified culture filtrate
(PPCF) containing low molecular weight compounds. Following this selection process,
cultures were challenged in a dose-response format with PPCF to determine whether the
sensitivity of the callus to the CF had changed. During the selection period, the fresh
weight of callus grown on medium containing 2,4-D and amended with PPCF was
always less than that of callus grown on medium amended with the same concentration
of potato-dextrose broth (PDB, negative control). Fresh weight of callus was greater on
medium containing NAA amended with PPCF than on medium with the same
concentration of PDB. Callus selected in the presence of NAA showed decreased
sensitivity to toxic metabolites at higher concentrations of CF.
Hidalgo et al. (1998) examined two pineapple varieties differing in resistance to
phytotoxic effect of CF of Fusarium subglutinans. The cultivars were Perolera (more
resistant to pathovars of Fusarium subglutinans) and Smooth Cayenne (more
susceptible). The phytotoxic effect of CF was assessed in tissue cultured pine apple
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
79
plantlets (by electrolyte leakage and placing the CF on wounded leaf segments) and
callus (inhibition of growth). Smooth Cayenne proved to be the more sensitive cultivar
in each test, whereas Perolera showed resistance to the CF and its callus grew in the
presence of high concentrations of CF that were completely toxic to Smooth Cayenne.
These results show that plants can display cellular resistance to the CF. Borras et al.
(2001) reported in vitro selection of resistant plants of Ananas comosus (pine apple)
using CF of Fusarium subglutinans. CF allowed the selection of resistant plants to
fungus; susceptible plants were sensitive to CF.
Jayasankar and Litz (1998) selected embryogenic nucellar cultures of two
polyembryonic mango cultivars, “Hindi” and “Carabao”, for resistance to the CF and
phytotoxin of a virulent strain of Colletotrichum gloeosporioides Penz. that was isolated
from mango leaves. The cultures were recurrently selected either with progressively
increasing concentrations of CF or by continuous challenge with the same concentration
of either CF phytotoxin. Mycelium growth was inhibited when the pathogen was
cocultured with the selected, resistant embryogenic cultures. Conditioned plant growth
medium containing macerated resistant embryogenic cultures did not inhibit mycelium
growth, confirming that extracellular antifungal compounds were involved in the
defense response. Enhanced secretion of chitinase and glucanase was observed in the
plant growth medium in which resistant embryogenic cultures and regenerated somatic
embryos were grown in comparison with the controls.
Jayasankar et al. (1998) did RAPD analysis of embryogenic cultures of two
mango cultivars, 'Hindi' and 'Carabao', that had been selected for resistance to the CF of
Colletotrichum gloeosporioides. In vitro selection caused changes in RAPD markers in
the selected embryogenic cultures with respect to the unchallenged control cultures and
the stock plants. The differences involved both the absence and the presence of
additional RAPD markers in the resistant lines, although the former was most
commonly observed. The absence of differences between the unchallenged control of
either cultivar and DNA from the leaves of parent trees confirmed that the changes were
not due to prolonged maintenance in liquid cultures.
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
80
Yang and Huang (1998) developed an efficient in vitro selection system for scab
resistance by using in vitro screening for tolerance to DON. Immature embryos of two
wheat varieties, a scab-resistant variety Sumai 3 and a susceptible variety Mianyang 11,
and their reciprocal F1 hybrids were cultured on MS medium supplemented with 2,4-D
2 mg/l and 0.6×10-4 M DON for callus induction. The responses of callus induction and
plant regeneration to 0.6×10-4 M DON differed significantly between resistant and
susceptible varieties, according to observed scab resistance levels at the plant level in
the field. The percentage of callus formation of resistant variety Sumai 3 on induction
medium containing DON was higher than that of susceptible variety Mianyang 11.
Regeneration of DON-tolerant calli on DON-containing differentiation medium differed
significantly between Sumai 3 and Mianyang 11. Averaged across the DON-tolerant
calli of two varieties and their reciprocals, regeneration of DON-tolerant calli was
decreased 3-fold on DON-containing medium. The somaclonal lines had lower disease
scoring (reaction index, infected spikelets and disease incidence), shorter plants and
better yield components than Sumai 3, a famous Chinese resistant variety.
Cristinzio and Testa (1999) analyzed in vitro resistance of ten potato cultivars
(Agria, Ajax, Desire, Liseta. Kennebec, Majestic, Monalisa, Prima, Spunta and Tonda
di Berlino) to Phytophthora infestans using 8 fungal strains. An assay based on
electrolyte leakage was used for screening leaves and tuber tissues with fungal CFs.
With almost all cultivars the resistance of leaves did not correlate with the resistance of
tubers. Cultivar Ajax appeared, the least susceptible in both leaf and tuber tests, while
the cv. Prima was the most susceptible in tuber tests.
Jayasankar et al. (1999) reported that partially purified phytotoxin produced by
Colletotrichum gloeosporioides Penz., presumably colletotrichin, caused anthracnose-
like symptoms on young mango leaves, was toxic to embryogenic suspension cultures
of two mango cultivars, 'Hindi' and 'Carabao'; and inhibited in vitro seed germination of
two nonhosts, lettuce and tobacco. There were linear relationships between
concentration of the partially purified phytotoxin and mortality of mango embryogenic
cultures. Embryogenic cultures grown in the presence of the partially purified
phytotoxin showed significantly lower growth rates than the controls. Similarly,
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
81
embryogenic cultures grown in the presence of 40% (v/v) fungal CF showed
significantly lower growth rates than unchallenged controls. Medium containing 40%
(v/v) Czapek-Dox fungal broth did not reduce growth of embryogenic cultures,
indicating the production of phytotoxin in vitro. The results suggest that either fungal
CF or purified phytotoxin can be used as in vitro selection agents to screen for
resistance to this fungus.
Danson et al. (2000) reported that infection of rice plants with Rhizoctonia
solani, the sheath blight fungus, at the flowering stage resulted in an increase in acid
invertase activity. Activity of the invertase(s) with optimum pH at 3.5 and 4.5 was
higher in the susceptible plants compared to resistant plants. Healthy control plants had
no change in invertase activity. These results suggested that the fungus produced an
invertase for the hydrolysis of sucrose that resulted in alterations of source-sink
relationships in the colonized cells. Thus, the increased invertase activity in the
susceptible plants regulated the ratio of hexose to sucrose. This observation is further
supported by the lack of a significant invertase increase in the resistant plants.
Fernandez et al. (2000) used a bioassay in which CF of Colletotrichum
lindemuthianum caused dark brown lesions on the lower surface veins of bean leaves, to
study the production of toxic fungal metabolites. Calli from anthracnose-susceptible
bean cultivars ‘Collacia’, ‘Andecha’ and ‘Seronda’ were sensitive to a 12.5% solution
of race 38 filtrate or to a 25% solution of race 7 filtrate. In contrast, calli from
anthracnose-resistant bean genotypes A 247, TU, PI 207262, ‘Collacia’ ‘Tu’, ‘Collacia’
AB 136 and ‘Collacia’ PI 207262 did not develop browning. CF was passed through an
ionic-exchange resin and a gel filtration resin. Toxic activity of fractions from two races
of the fungal pathogen was different, although in both races slight necrosis was
produced by the same nine fractions. Pathogenicity could be related with common
substances and toxicity could be identified with differential compounds.
Hammerschlag (2000) reported a detached-leaf bioassay to evaluate peach
[Prunus persica (L.) Batsch] somaclone 122-1 (derived from callus produced on an
immature embryo of peach cultivar Redhaven) for resistance to several virulent strains
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
82
of Xanthomonas campestris pv. pruni [E.F. Sm.) Dows] and to a virulent isolate of
Pseudomonas syringae van Hall pv. syringae, causal agent of bacterial canker. The
detached-leaf bioassay was also used to evaluate progeny of 122-1 for resistance to X.
campestris pv. pruni virulent strain XP1. Somaclone 122-1 was significantly more
resistant to most strains of X. campestris pv. pruni than was ‘Redhaven’, and all of its
progeny exhibited high levels of resistance to X. campestris pv. pruni strain XP1.
Somaclone 122-1 exhibited significantly higher levels of resistance to Pseudomonas
syringae pv. syringae than did ‘Redhaven’ and this resistance was retained over time in
the greenhouse and following a 2-year cycle of tissue culture propagation.
Hoss et al. (2000) investigated the host–pathogen interactions of Musa spp.
and Mycosphaerella fijiensis in order to determine the function of secondary
metabolites within the pathosystem of the Black Sigatoka disease. The pentaketide
metabolites flaviolin, 2-hydroxyjuglone, juglone and 2,4,8-trihydroxytetralone (2,4,8-
THT) of the pathogen were identified. The concentration of 2,4,8-THT was
significantly increased by application of the synthetic compound tricyclazole and by
natural activators extracted from the intercellular space of leaf tissue of
resistant Musa cultivars. When inoculated host plants were treated with tricyclazole,
extensive necrosis of both susceptible and resistant Musa cultivar leaves was observed.
Plant defence mechanisms of resistant Musa cultivars were first detected as an
activation of phenylalanine–ammonia lyase and the subsequent accumulation of post-
infectional substances which blocked fungal growth. These results indicated the
bivalent importance of 2,4,8-THT for host-specific reactions, depending on its
concentration at different stages of pathogenesis.
Rao and Padmaja (2000) regenerated Fusarium resistant plants of Cicer
arietinum (chickpea) from callus cultures selected on medium containg CF of F.
oxysporum f. sp. ciceri. Plantlets obtained from filtrate-selected calli showed resistance
to Fusarium CF. Hamid and Strange (2000) used CF and toxins i.e. solanapyrone A, B,
C of Ascochyta rabiei and F. oxysporum for selection of disease resistant shoots of
Cicer arietinum. Sensitivity to the toxins was correlated with susceptibility to the
disease; selection of plants with well expressed glutathion/glutathion-S-transferase may
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
83
be one means. Singh et al. (2003) protected chickpea (Cicer arietinum) plants from
Sclerotium rolfsii infection when applied singly or in combination as seed treatment
with two plant growth-promoting rhizobacteria (PGPR), viz., Pseudomonas fluorescens
strain Pf4 and P. aeruginosa strain Pag. The two PGPR strains induced the synthesis of
specific phenolic acids, salicylic acid (SA), as well as total phenolics at different growth
stages of chickpea seedlings with varied amount. The maximum amount of total
phenolics was recorded in all the aerial parts of 4 week old plants. Gallic, ferulic,
chlorogenic and cinnamic acids were the major phenolic acids detected in high-
performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) analysis. Induction of such phenolic acids
in the seedlings was observed up to 6 weeks in comparison with control. Salicylic acid
(SA) was induced frequently during the first 3 weeks of growth only. Between the two
strains, Pag was more effective in inducing phenolic acid synthesis applied either singly
or in combination with strain Pf4 during the entire 6 weeks of growth of chickpea. In
the presence of a CF of S. rolfsii, the two Pseudomonas strains induced more phenolic
acids in treated than in non-treated and control plants.
Reustle and Matt (2000) reported in vitro selection of protoplasts isolated from
calli of V. vinifera on medium containg CF of Botrytis cinerea. With increasing filtrate
concentration the plating efficacy and embryogenic competence of regenerated calli
decreased. Jayasankar et al. (2000) exposed proembryogenic masses of grapevine (Vitis
vinifera L.) `Chardonnay' (clone 02Ch) to the CF of Elsinoe ampelina (deBary) Shear,
the causal agent of anthracnose disease. After four or five cycles of recurrent in-vitro
selection with medium containing 40% fungal CF, putative resistant lines RC1 and RC2
respectively, were established. The selected lines inhibited the growth of E. ampelina
and Fusarium oxysporium (Schlecht.) (isolated from watermelon) in a dual-culture
assay and reduced the growth of mycelium on a conditioned-medium test, thus
suggesting the involvement of extracellular compounds in resistance. Sodium dodecyl
sulfate-polyacrylamide (SDS-PAGE) gel electrophoresis of extracellular proteins from
spent suspension-culture medium showed enhanced secretion of new proteins by
selected lines. A 36-kDa protein was immunodetected by a chitinase antiserum. This
chitinase continued to express constitutively in differentiated somatic embryos and also
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
84
in the intercellular fluids of plants regenerated from the selected lines. Somatic embryos
from selected lines grew uninhibitedly in a medium containing 40% fungal CF, whereas
non-selected (control) somatic embryos became necrotic and died within a few days.
Plants regenerated from selected lines exhibited resistance to infection by E. ampelina
in both greenhouse tests and detached leaf bioassays.
Chen and Swart (2002) examined five Amaranthus hybridus varieties in vitro for
sensitivity to a CF of Fusarium oxysporum. The phytotoxicity of the CF was assessed
for its inhibitory effect on callus and seedling root growth, as well as on the viability of
callus cells. The five varieties exhibited a significant amount of variation in response to
the CF of the pathogen. Variety 17 was the most sensitive variety in each bioassay,
whereas variety 20 displayed least sensitivity to the CF. Callus of variety 20 grew well
in the presence of concentrations of CF that were toxic to another four varieties and the
percentage mortality of callus cells after exposure to the filtrate was also lowest of the
five varieties. Root growth of variety 20 was also least affected by exposure to the CF
for up to 6 days.
Fujii et al. (2002) isolated two polyketides, decumbenones A and B and versiol
from the CF of the fungus, Penicillium decumbens. Their respective structures were 1-
(2,8-dihydroxy-1,2,6-trimethyl-1,2,6,7,8,8a-hexahydronaphthalen-1-yl)-3-hydroxy-1-
propanone and 1-(2,8-dihydroxy-1,2,6-trimethyl-1,2,4a,5,6,7,8,8a-octahydronaphthalen-
1-yl)-3-hydroxy-1-propanone based on NMR spectroscopic data, chemical conversion,
and X-ray analysis. Decumbenone A inhibited melanization in Magnaporthe grisea, the
rice blast pathogen, whereas decumbenone B like versiol did not.
Prachi et al. (2002) used salicylic acid (SA) to induce insensitivity in the callus
cultures of Zingiber officinale against CF of Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. zingiberi. The
treatment of callus cultures with SA (104 µM) prior to selection with CF of the
pathogen-increased survival of callus. Exogenous application of SA resulted in
increased activity of peroxidase and β-1,3-glucanase enzymes in the callus cultures. No
increase in the activity of phenylalanine ammonia lyase was obtained. Two new protein
bands of 97 and 38 kDa molecular weights were obtained by SDS-PAGE analysis of
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
85
soluble proteins extracted from SA-treated calli. The PR-1 monoclonal antibody used
for immunodetection of induced proteins cross-reacted with the 38 kDa protein band. In
vitro antifungal activity of protein extract of calli treated with SA tested against the
spores of F. oxysporum f.sp.zingiberi showed significant reduction in spore germination
and germ tube elongation. It is concluded that in ginger, SA may result in the induction
of resistance to F. oxysporum f.sp. zingiberi by inducing increased activity of
peroxidase, β-1,3-glucanase and antifungal PR-proteins.
Thakur et al. (2002) used callus culture derived from internodal segments of two
cultivars of carnation susceptible to Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. dianthi for in vitro
selection for resistance to this pathogenic fungus. Resistant lines were selected by
culturing calli on growth medium containing various concentrations of the CF of F.
oxysporum f.sp. dianthi. Resistant calli obtained after two cycles (25 days/cycle) of
selection were used for plant regeneration. About 32% of the plants regenerated from
the resistant calli had acquired considerable resistance against the pathogen in the field.
No phenotypic variation was observed in the selected regenerants.
Zemanek et al. (2002) studied the response of three different peach (Prunus
persica L. Batsch) genotypes to bacterial and fungal CF, wounding and sterile nutrient
broth (NB) treatments by evaluating β-1,3-glucanase mRNA levels. Northern blot
analysis was conducted using the 3′ end of a peach β-1,3-glucanase gene, PpGns1, as a
probe. Autoradiographs were analyzed using a Stratagene Eagle Eye II gel
documentation system. Analysis of the accumulation of mRNAs encoded by β-1,3-
glucanase demonstrated that activation trends were different among the three peach
genotypes. All genotypes, ‹Evergreen›, ‹Stark’s Earliglo›, and ‹White Lady›, showed an
increase in β-1,3-glucanase mRNA following treatment with CF of the bacterial
pathogen Xanthomonas campestris pv. pruni. Two genotypes, ‹Evergreen› and ‹White
Lady›, showed an increase in mRNA levels following treatment with CF of the bacterial
pathogen Pseudomonas syringae pv. syringae, and two genotypes, ‹Evergreen› and
‹Stark’s Earliglo›, showed an increase in mRNA levels following treatment with CF of
the fungal pathogen Monilinia fructicola. Differences in induction patterns were
observed between bacterial and fungal CF treatments. Wounding induced high levels of
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
86
β-1,3-glucanase mRNA in one genotype, ‹White Lady› while treatment with a sterile
nutrient broth showed an increase in mRNA in another genotype, ‹Evergreen›. The use
of gene-specific primers in RT-PCR indicated that PpGns1 and a second closely-related
gene family member, PpGns2, were transcriptionally active and were differentially
regulated.
Collonnier et al. (2003) produced interspecific somatic hybrids between
Solanum melongena L. (2n = 2x = 24) and two accessions of Solanum torvum Sw. (2n =
2x = 24) in view of transferring resistance to two soil-born pathogens, Ralstonia
solanacearum and Verticillium dahliae, from the wild species into the cultivated
eggplant. Tests for resistance performed in vitro by using suspensions of two strains of
R. solanacearum (race 1 and 3) and filtrate of culture medium of one strain of V.
dahliae, revealed that S. melongena was susceptible, whereas both accessions of S.
torvum had high levels of resistance. Except for two hybrid clones, which were found
susceptible to race 3, as was S. melongena, all somatic hybrids tested showed good
levels of bacterial and fungal resistance, either intermediate or as high as that of the
wild parent.
Companioni et al. (2003) developed a rapid and non-destructive procedure to
differentiate field-grown banana resistant from susceptible clones. This procedure
implicated application of CF of Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. cubense race 1 onto banana
leaves. The relationship between duration of the fungal in vitro incubation, and the
fungal culture fresh mass, the CF absorbency, and the Gross Michel (susceptible
cultivar) leaf lesion area (after application of the CF) were similar and at 24 day-
incubation the highest values of the recorded indicators were observed. A comparison
between Gross Michel and FHIA-01 (resistant) was also performed. The most relevant
differences between cultivars were observed at 48 hours after application of the CF, and
in the middle-aged leaves.
El-Kazzaz and Ashour (2004) selected resistant calli in vitro from cucumber
(Cucumis sativus) explants under challenging stress of cucumber wilt pathogen
Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. cucumerinum culture filtrate. The selection protocol has two
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
87
directions: First one is step-by-step selection from lower to higher selective CF
concentrations; meanwhile the second one is exchangeable continuous cycles with
and/or without CF using the same selective CF concentration until the end of selection
regime. The progenies of in vitro regenerated plants, obtained under CF stress, showed
resistance when exposed to the pathogen infection. The results indicated that resistance
in cucumber to wilt pathogen is controlled by one pair of genes and segregated as 3
resistant: 1 susceptible.
Olieviera et al. (2004) reported that genetic variability for resistance to
Alternaria leaf spot disease (Alternaria helianthi) can be induced by radiation or
chemical mutagens. Genetic variability was induced in cultivated sunflower to select
lines resistant to Alternaria leaf spot. Sunflower seeds of the genotype HA BR 104 were
irradiated with 150 and 165 Gy of gamma rays. Seeds were sown in the field at the
Embrapa Soybean experimental station in Londrina, PR, Brazil and M1 plants were
harvested in bulk. M2, M3 and M4 plants were screened for disease resistance under
natural infection in the field. Plants were evaluated for Alternaria leaf spot symptoms,
using a diagrammatic scale from 0 (no symptoms) to 5 (maximum infection). Before
flowering, plants showing no symptoms of Alternaria leaf spot (grade 0) or less than 5%
diseased leaf area (grade 1) were bagged for self-pollination. Self-pollinated plants and
open-pollinated plants from 150 Gy and 165 Gy populations with no or mild disease
symptoms were selected. In the second experiment, sunflower seeds of the genotypes
HA 300 and HA BR 104 were treated with EMS at 0.015 mol dm-3. Selected M2 and
M3 were screened for disease resistance in the field. From the EMS treatment, 300 M3
plants with no disease were recovered.
Gayatri et al. (2005) reported selection of resistant calli of Curcuma longa L. cv.
suguna against the CF of Pythium graminicolum which causes root rot disease. Callus
was obtained from in vivo vegetative buds when cultured on LSBM (Linsmaier and
Skoog’s Based Medium) supplememted with 2,4-D (3 mg/l) after 45 days of culture.
Callus was challenged with pure CF to select resistant calli within 30 days of culture
which was further subjected to pure CF treatment. Four tolerant cell lines were selected
after 3 cycles of treatment through continuous in vitro selection and subcultured on
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
88
LSBM supplemented with BA (4 mg/l) along with control non-selected callus. Plants
regenerated from tolerant and non-selected calli were screened for disease tolerance by
adopting in vitro sick plot technique. The data obtained from this experiment revealed a
ratio of 225:49 tolerant: susceptible in vitro clones retrieved from tolerant callus.
Khan et al. (2005) tested the nematicidal potential of CFs of the blue-green alga,
Microcoleus vaginatus (Cyanobacterium) against Meloidogyne incognita on L.
esculentum in pots under greenhouse conditions. Prior to the transplantation of tomato
seedling, roots were dipped in different concentrations (0.2%, 0.5%, 1%, 2%, 10%, 50%
and 100%) of CF of M. vaginatus for 30 min. Root-dip treatment reduced the root
galling and final population of M. incognita and increased vegetative growth of plants
and root-mass production compared with the control. The beneficial effect of root-dip
treatment increased with the increase in the concentration of CF. Root galling and final
nematode populations were reduced by 65.9% and 97.5%, respectively when treated at
the highest concentration.
Palmer et al. (2005) isolated a phytotoxic protein that evoked the typical
symptoms of Verticillium wilt disease in seedlings of Gossypium hirsutum L. (upland
cotton) from CF of Verticillium dahliae. The protein was purified by ammonium sulfate
precipitation, Sephadex- G100 fractionation, and native PAGE. The 18.5 kD a protein,
designated VD18.5, appears to be a single subunit protein with an isoelectric point
between 3 and 5. VD18.5 induced symptoms of leaf dehydration, chlorosis, necrosis
and stem discoloration in seedlings of the disease susceptible cotton cultivar Siokra 1–4.
The LD50 of VD18.5 on protoplasts of Siokra 1–4 was 18 mg/l. VD18.5 had no
noticeable effect on Pima S-7, which is a disease resistant cultivar. Phytotoxic activity
was partially destroyed at high temperature and was abolished by digestion with
proteinase K. Mass spectrometry fingerprinting and protein sequence data from VD18.5
yielded no significant matches when submitted to the Mascot search engine and NCBI
non-redundant protein databases, respectively. These results suggest that VD18.5 is a
novel protein that may be involved in the development of some of the symptoms
associated with Verticillium wilt disease in the cotton plant.
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
89
Boso et al. (2006) studied resistance to downy mildew in different Vitis vinifera
L. cv. albariño clones belonging to the collection of the Mision Biológica de Galicia,
CSIC (Spain). V. riparia, V. vinifera cv. Solaris and V. vinifera cv. Müller Thurgau
were used as controls. Plants were inoculated with Plasmospora viticola in the
laboratory using the leaf disc, whole leaf and whole plant techniques. The results were
compared with those obtained in the field for the same Albariño clones. The most
susceptible group of clones included MBG-2, MBG-14, MBG-12 and MBG-9, while
MBG-13, MBG-3 and MBG-6 formed the most resistant group. The remaining clones
showed intermediate resistance. These results coincide with observations made in the
field. The resistance observed in MBG-12 could have been generated from in vitro
culture because this induces changes in the downy mildew resistance.
Ganeshan and Jayabalan (2006) reported an in vitro selection method that led to
isolation of Fusarium wilt and Alternaria leaf spot disease-tolerant plantlets in cotton
(Gossypium hirsutum L. cv. SVPR2). Embryogenic callus was isolated from hypocotyl
explants of cotton cultured on 5–50% Fusarium oxysporum CF-fortified callus
induction medium. Somatic embryos tolerant to fungal culture filtrate (FCF) were
isolated from this embryogenic callus on somatic embryo regeneration medium fortified
with 40% FCF. Sixteen plantlets were selected as FCF tolerant from 34 somatic
embryos tested, which corresponded to about 47% success rate. The FCF-tolerant plants
were analyzed for disease tolerance by challenging them with spores of F. oxysporum
and Alternaria macrospora. Four plants were selected as F. oxysporum tolerant from a
total of 24 plants tested. The selected plants showed an enhanced survival rate
compared with the control when they were grown in earthen pots inoculated with 1-105
spores/ml of F. oxysporum. From the FCF-tolerant plants, another nine randomly
selected plantlets were challenged with spores of A. macrospora in order to test their
tolerance to Alternaria leaf spot disease. The number of lesions per leaf significantly
decreased from 8.2 to 0.9 and the lesion lengths were also reduced from 2.8 to 1.2 mm
per leaf spot in these plants. Electrophoresis analysis of extracellular proteins from the
FCF-tolerant plants showed enhanced secretion of proteins in the range of 24–36 kDa.
Isozyme analysis of FCF-tolerant plants by using native gels showed the presence of
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
90
chitinase. Quantitative analysis showed that there was 13-fold increase in chitinase
activity in the selected FCF-tolerant plants compared to the control plants. The results
showed that overexpression of chitinase enzyme leads to enhanced disease resistance
against F. oxysporum and A. macrospora.
Gonzales et al. (2006) tested in vitro culture responses from different explants of
a race-specific resistant cultivar (Red Mexican) and a race susceptible cultivar
(Palmena) to halo-blight pathogen (Pseudomonas syringae pv. phaseolicola). Two kinds
of filtrate obtained from a phaseolotoxin producer wild type and a non-producer mutant
of P. syringae pv. phaseolicola race-7 were used. Callus formation of Red Mexican was
significantly reduced in the presence of phaseolotoxin. Bud-shoot growth was more
sensitive than callus formation to other metabolites present in the pathogen filtrate, but
the presence of phaseolotoxin in the media showed a positive correlation between
resistance to halo blight race-7 pathogen and bud-shoot growth. The results indicated
that differential in vitro responses are influenced by the plant genotype and metabolite
composition and concentration of the filtrate.
Martin-pinto et al. (2006) investigated the interactions between the mycorrhizal
fungi Boletus edulis, Rhizopogon roseolus, Laccaria laccata and Lactarius deliciosus
and damping off pathogens (Fusarium oxysporum and F. moniliforme) in vitro and
mechanisms involved in the protection of damping off in Pinus nigra seedlings. The
effect of filtrates from mycorrhizal species on spore germination of F. oxysporum
varied throughout the tests. At the end of the assay, the inhibitory effect only could be
observed in the L. deliciosus treatment. None of the filtrates reduced spore germination
in F. moniliforme. Finally, three of the four mycorrhizal species grown for 2 months in
the substrate, L. laccata, L. deliciosus and B. edulis, increased the survival of Fusarium
inoculated P. nigra seedlings. Plantlets of Pisum sativum were selected for resistance
against the Fusarium spp. by using CF and autoclaving inactivating filtrate. The effect
of the filtrates was compared; degree of resistance/susceptibility and of regeneration
capacity was evaluated. Regenerants were tested in field conditions and artificially
inoculated substrates; improved resistance evaluated with infection degree was
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
91
observed (Lebeda and Svabova, 1997; Svabova and Griga, 1997; Svabova et al., 1998;
Svabova and Odstrcilova, 2001).
Rani and Ravikumar (2006) compared sporophytic and gametophytic recurrent
selection with the aim to enhance the level of resistance to Alternaria leaf blight.
Alternaria leaf blight, caused by Alternaria helianthi Hanf., is one of the most important
diseases of sunflower causing significant yield losses in several tropical countries. The
base population was synthesized by random mating three populations, two interspecific
derivatives involving different species of Helianthus and one germplasm accession
based on their partial resistance to disease incidence. The base population was subjected
to 1-2 cycles of both sporophytic and gametophytic selection. The gametophytic
selection was practiced by applying pathogen CF to the stigma and style one hour
before pollination. The selection response was measured by scoring the percent disease
index at flowering, 15 days after flowering, and at physiological maturity and by
quantifying economic yield gain. A significant reduction in mean per cent disease index
values and a gain in seed yield were observed for both the types of selection cycles, but
more so for gametophytic selection. The populations improved through gametophytic
selection appeared to be more promising as the pollen selection allowed the selection of
rare favorable allelic combinations that would hardly be detected at the sporophytic
level. A combination of gametophytic selection and conventional sporophytic selection
should be considered as an effective tool in population improvement programs to
achieve higher levels of resistance in relatively short time.
Duan et al. (2007) tested the metabolites of Helminthosporium gramineum
Rabenth. for their antagonistic effects towards Rhizoctonia solani (AG-1-IA), the rice
sheath blight fungus. The CF and EtOAc extract of the CF and mycelia (termed as crude
toxin) of H. gramineum significantly reduced the in vitro growth of R. solani. The
biologically active metabolite isolated from crude toxin of H. gramineum was identified
as ophiobolin A by spectroscopic analysis. Significant inhibition of mycelial growth of
R. solani by ophiobolin A was detected for all concentrations tested. In the field
experiments, the treatments of crude toxin effectively reduced the development of rice
sheath blight, whereas there were no significant adverse effects on the growth and yield
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
92
attributes of rice plants. HPLC tests indicated no detectable ophiobolin A remaining in
rice grain for all treatments. These results showed that the crude toxin and metabolite
produced by H. gramineum may be developed as a biocontrol agent for rice sheath
blight control.
El-Kazzaz and El-Mougy (2007) selected resistant calli under in vitro conditions
from explants of watermelon under challenging stress of (0–100%) CF which was
obtained from the wilt pathogen Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. niveum. The selection
protocol had two directions: the first was a step-by-step selection from lower to higher
selective CF concentrations and the second was exchangeable continuous cycles with
and without CF using the same selective CF concentration until the end of the selection
regime. The plantlet regeneration occurred under CF stress. The progenies of in vitro
regenerated plants showed resistance when exposed to the pathogen infections. The
results were clear in that the resistance in cucumber to wilt pathogen was segregated as
1 resistant: 2 moderately resistant: 1 susceptible meaning that it is controlled by one pair
of genes.
Quaglia and Zazzerini (2007) reported in vitro selection of sunflower calli
against CFs of two pathogen (Diaporthe helianthi) isolates (7/96 and 101/96). This
technique may be an effective and rapid tool to discriminate the most virulent D.
helianthi isolate and to screen for host resistance in the early stage of a breeding
programme. Further investigation on the mechanisms involved in defence pathways
showed no induction of salicylic acid and pathogenesis-related proteins in calli,
indicating that the host resistance is not associated with Systemic Acquired Resistance
(SAR) but probably other biochemical mechanisms.
Rodriguez et al. (2007) used reaction to the CF of Alternaria solani (sorauer) as
an indicator in an in vitro screening test to select lines with decreased field
susceptibility to early blight from a population of 1000 putative mutants. Plantlets of cv.
Desire derived from irradiated callus of potato were inoculated in vitro with a CF of A.
solani (sorauer). Of the 45 lines selected and subsequently evaluated under conditions
of natural infection in the greenhouse, six showed lesser degrees of early blight
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
93
infection than the cv. Desire control. The six lines selected in the greenhouse retained
lower degrees of infection during 2 years of field trials.
Kumar et al. (2008) described an efficient plant regeneration protocol via
organogenesis and somatic embryogenesis of safflower (Carthamus tinctorius L.) cv.
NARI-6 in fungal culture filtrate (FCF) treated cultures. Cotyledon explants cultured on
callus induction medium with different levels of FCF (10–50%) produced embryogenic
callus. In organogenesis, 42.2% microshoots formed directly from embryogenic callus
tissues in plant regeneration medium with 40% FCF. Isolated embryogenic callus
cultured on embryo induction medium containing 40% FCF induced 50.2% somatic
embryogenesis. Embryo germination percentage was decreased from 64.5% to 28% in
embryo maturation medium containing 40% FCF. However, nine plantlets from
organogenesis and 24 plantlets from somatic embryogenesis were selected as FCF-
tolerant. Alternaria carthami fungal spores (5 × 105 spores/ml) sprayed on the leaves of
FCF-tolerant plants showed enhanced survival rate over control plants which were more
susceptible to fungal attack. The number of leaf spot lesions per leaf was decreased
from 3.4 to 0.9 and their lesion length was also reduced from 2.9 to 0.7 mm in
organogenic derived FCF-tolerant plants over control. In somatic embryo derived FCF-
tolerant plants, the number of lesions was decreased from 3.1 to 0.4 and the lesion size
was also reduced to 2.7–0.5 mm when compared to the control. This study also
examined antioxidant enzyme activity in FCF-tolerant plants. Catalase (CAT) activity
was slightly decreased whereas peroxidase (POD) activity was increased to a maximum
of 42% (0.19 µmol min-1 mg-1 protein) from organogenesis and 47% (0.23 µmol min-1
mg-1 protein) from embryogenesis in FCF-tolerant plants. Superoxide dismutase (SOD)
activity was also increased to 17% (149 U mg-1 protein) and 19.5% (145 U mg-1
protein) in FCF-tolerant plants derived from organogenesis and somatic embryogenesis
when compared with control plants.
Saxena et al. (2008) established a protocol for induction of disease resistance in
callus cultures of rose-scented geranium, Pelargonium graveolens cv. Hemanti against
leaf blight disease caused by the fungal pathogen Alternaria alternata. The callus
cultures were raised and maintained on medium supplemented with various
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
94
concentrations of CF (0%, 4%, 8%, 12%, 16% and 20%) obtained from A. alternata.
Resistant calli were selected and placed on regeneration medium for regeneration. The
regenerants were confirmed for A. alternata resistance by exposing their leaves to the
same concentrations of CF as used previously. While the parental wild type
demonstrated typical susceptibility, the leaves of putative resistant clones remained
green and viable in the presence of toxin and regenerated shoots directly on the toxin-
free regeneration medium (MS supplemented with 5 mg/l KN and l mg/l NAA). The
above experiment demonstrated the induction of disease resistance in rose-scented
geranium plants at the cellular level.
Mala et al. (2011) examined defence responses in embryogenic cell suspension
cultures of Norway spruce (Picea abies [L.] Karst) elicited by intracellular protein and
cell wall fractions (PF and WF, respectively) prepared from mycelia of the fungus
Sirococcus strobilinus Preuss focusing on changes in (soluble and cell wall-bound)
phenolic and stilbene concentrations. Treatment with both preparations induced an
increase in the total contents of phenolic acids in Norway spruce cells and variations in
the levels of stilbene glycosides. More rapid and intense induction of defence response
was observed in cells after WF application. Significantly decreased concentrations of
stilbene glycosides, isorhapontin, astringin and piceid, were determined in PF and WF
treated Norway spruce cell cultures. The total content of stilbene glycosides decreased
within 8 h after WF application to 68% of the amount determined in the control and
within 12 h to 73% of the control in PF-treated cells. These results demonstrate that
both PF and WF prepared from the Sirococcus strobilinus mycelium elicit changes in
the metabolism of phenylpropanoids, which are involved in the defence responses of
plants to pathogens.
Savita et al. (2011a) reported selection of Phytophthora tolerant lines of Citrus
jambhiri and their regeneration. Cotyledon derived calli were cultured on selective MS
medium supplemented with 5–100 % of CF, to estimate the critical concentration of the
selective agent. The survived calli under stress were subcultured for 20 days on callus
multiplication medium (2,4-D 2 mg/l + BA 0.75 mg/l) without CF. After multiplication,
these calli were further exposed to other cycles of selection, which contained the same
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
95
and the 3 steps higher concentrations of the selective agent (CF) and this procedure was
repeated several times until the selection regime completed. The selected tolerant calli
were transferred to regeneration medium (MS medium supplemented with 3 mg/l of BA
and same concentration of CF on which the calli were selected). Regenerated shoots
were transferred to rooting medium (½ strength MS medium supplemented with 0.5
mg/l of NAA). Under in vivo conditions about 81% of the selected regenerants
exhibited resistance to Phytophthora parasitica, whereas none of the control plants
showed resistance. Summary on literature on in vitro selection for disease resistance in
plants using phytotoxins/culture filtrates of pathogens as selective agents is given in
Table 2.4.
2.5. CHARACTERIZATION OF VARIATIONS (SOMACLONAL/INDUCED)
IN PLANTS RAISED IN VITRO USING MOLECULAR MARKERS
Molecular markers generally refer to biochemical constituents including primary
and secondary metabolites and other macromolecules such as proteins and DNA (Joshi
et al., 1999). Secondary metabolites as markers have extensively been used in quality
control and standardization of botanical drugs. The analysis of genetic diversity within a
species may involve storage proteins such as glutenins, gliadins, hordeins, etc. (Vapa
and Radovic, 1998; Metakovsky, 1991; Shariflou et al., 2001; 1995; Cerny and Sasek,
1996a,b). A piece of DNA or a protein can be used as a marker (Ovesna et al. 2002).
During late 1950s, development of protein electrophoresis techniques provided
selectively neutral markers spanning several genes, thus contributing significantly to the
current understanding of plant genetic diversity (Hunter and Markert, 1957; Smithies,
1955).
Quality checks are essential to assure reproduction of high quality
micropropagated plants and to have end-users confidence. Quality assurance becomes
more important when the plant material is for export. The choice of explants source,
freedom of the donor from viruses, disease causing fungi, bacteria, viroids,
phytoplasmas, vigour and conformity of the variety and eliminination of somaclonal
variations are critical for maintaining plant quality. Variety identification by proper
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
96
labelling at all stages of micropropagation is essential of suitable tests to maintain
quality control and the assurance of micropropagated material irrespective of the system
used. No industry can prosper without a quality policy based on carefully identified,
relevant and recognized quality specifications and standard methods to test and verify
them. Hence, the plant coming out of any facility should be subjected to quality testing
without discrimination or prejudice. It has been reported that in vitro cultured plantlets
might exhibit somaclonal variations (D’Amato, 1978; Skirvin, 1978; Larkin and
Scowcroft, 1981; Earle and Demarly, 1982; Rani et al., 1995; Hashimi et al., 1997).
These variations are often heritable (Larkin et al., 1984; Breiman et al., 1987) and are
therefore, unwanted in clonal propagation. Thus, it would be very important to be able
to detect these variations quite early in the life of a plant. Many workers have tried to
assess these variations in various plant species through morphological, biochemical and
molecular analysis (Patel and Berlyn, 1982; Renfroe and Berlyn, 1984; Mo et al., 1989;
Shenoy and Vasil, 1992).
Marker-assisted selection is becoming the method of choice in facilitating
tagging of the desirable traits in many crops (Abdel-Tawab et al., 2003). It was evident
that salinity tolerance is a complex trait which is greatly affected by the environmental
factors. However, Marker assisted selection could enhance the identification of wheat
genotypes tolerant to salt stress. This approach would enable the molecular plant
breeders to grasp the promising genotypes with more confidence in their merits as
selection will be based on genetic rather than phenotypic basis with the elimination of
the confounding effects of environmental factors. Moreover, this process is fast, reliable
and cost effective which can reduce the required time for breeding program.
Quality testing of tissue culture raised plants includes testing of clonal fidelity or
establishing true to mother type whichever is applicable and could be accomplished by
testing genetic uniformity at random loci. The utility of DNA markers for genetic
mapping has enabled the location of several genes of agronomic interest within the
context of an existing Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism (RFLP) map
(Rafelsky and Tingey, 1993). DNA markers have also been effectively used for cultivar
identification (Moore and Durham, 1992). Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) based
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
97
methods [i.e., Randomly Amplified Polymorphic DNA (RAPD) analysis], are being
used for identifying molecular markers due to their speed and simplicity in comparison
with RFLPs (Tulseiram et al., 1992). Therefore, variety identification based on DNA
fingerprinting, such as RAPD, microsatellites, STR’s (Sequence Tagged Repeats),
AFLP (Amplified Fragment Length Polymorphism) and multi-locus probes, is
potentially useful. Molecular markers have been shown to enhance breeding efforts in
annual and perennial crops, since they are not altered by major environmental effects
and are more reliable than morphological characters for identification of varieties.
2.5.1. RAPD in determining somaclonal or induced variations
The RAPD marker system is based on the PCR amplification of random DNA
segments in the genome using primers (usually 10-mers) of arbitrary nucleotide
sequence (Williams et al., 1990). Allelic variation among individuals is detected as the
presence or absence of the amplification product, visualized as a band after PCR and
electrophoresis (Welsh and McClelland, 1990). Analysis of variation at the nuclear
genome level using RAPDs has advantages over RFLPs, as a single primer produces
several loci, covering a larger portion of the genome (Tulseiram et al., 1992). Among
other perennial fruit species, RAPDs have been used to determine genetic relationships
in Anona spp. (Ronning et al., 1995a), cacao (Theobroma cacao L.) (Ronning et al.,
1995b) and papaya (Carica papaya L.) (Stiles et al., 1993). In Mangifera indica,
RAPDs have been used to determine phylogenetic relationships and for cultivar
identification (Schnell et al., 1995). RAPD markers have also been useful for
confirming somatic hybrids following protoplast fusion between Citrus spp. (Deng et
al., 1995). Somaclonal variations in regenerants of Vitis spp. from protoplasts and of
Prunus persica (L.) Batsch from embryogenic cultures derived from zygotic embryos
were detected by RAPDs by Schneider et al. (1996) and Hashimi et al. (1997),
respectively. Jayasankar et al. (1998) reported variations at genetic level in the resistant
cultures selected against the CF of Colletotrichum gloeosporioides which were analysed
by RAPD markers. RAPD analysis has been used for Brassica (Demeke et al., 1992),
Triticum (Chandrashekhar and Nguyen, 1993; Abdel-Tawab et al., 2003) and cotton
(El-Kady et al., 2006). Moreover, RAPD analysis has been used earlier for genetic
................................................................................................................................Review of literature
98
diversity analysis of Egyptian barley cultivars (Abdelsalam et al., 1998 and El-Halfawy
et al., 2006).
2.5.2. RAPD analysis in Citrus species
RAPD markers have also been used for the assessment of variations, variety
identification and assessment of genetic diversity in genus Citrus. Iannelli et al. (1998)
identified genotypes of lemon by flow cytometry and RAPD markers. Guo et al. (2000)
identified somatic hybrids between navel orange (Citrus sinensis) and grapefruit (C.
paradisi) for seedless triploid breeding using RAPD markers. Guo and Deng (2001)
produced wide somatic hybrids of Citrus with its related genera and somatic hybrids
were identified by morphology, cytology, isozyme, RAPD and RFLP analyses. Abkenar
and Isshiki (2003) characterized genetic diversity among Japanese acid Citrus (Citrus
spp.) based on RAPD markers. Hao et al. (2004) used RAPD markers for genetic and
epigenetic evaluations of citrus calluses recovered from slow-growth culture.
Anantakrishnan et al. (2006) identified somatic hybris of Sour orange (Citrus aurantium
L.) using RAPD markers. High levels of citrus genetic diversity in Vietnam were
observed for varieties presenting in pummelo, orange and mandarin groups, particularly
in mandarin originated from the south of China, and Vietnam (Webber, 1943; Scora,
1975) showing morphological variability and also identified by RAPD analysis.
Orbovic et al. (2008) carried out analysis of genetic variability in various tissue culture-
derived lemon plant populations using RAPD and flow cytometry. Khan et al. (2009)
reported regeneration and characterization of plants derived from leaf in vitro culture of
two sweet orange (Citrus sinensis (L.) Osbeck) cultivars using RAPD markers. Biswas
and Deng (2010) used RAPD, ISSR, IRAP and REMAP markers for the genetic
analysis of Citrus spp.