8/10/2019 Rev Draft PWS - RFI- Black Lung Lawyer Writers

1/4

The Department of Labor (DOL) Office of Administrative Law Judges (OALJ) is contemplatingto seek potential sources capable of providing the services described below:

DESCRIPTION OF SERVICES

Interested Offerors will be required to provide lawyer writers to draft proposed decisions andorders and/or recommendations in the form of decisions and orders addressing all factual andlegal issues involved in Black Lung cases before OALJ Administrative Law Judges includingthose remanded from the Benefits Review Board or a Federal court. The lawyer writer will berequired to modify or amend the draft after the submission of the initial draft to the presidingJudge if requested (occurs on average over 70 % of the time).

OALJ has a contemplated need for lawyer writers, at the following places of performance:

Cincinnati District Office - 5-10 writersPittsburgh District Office - 4-8 writers

Cherry Hill District Office - 5-10 writersNational Office - 8-15 writers

The Black Lung Benefits Act, 30 U.S.C. 901 et seq., as amended (Act), and implementingregulations, 20 C.F.R. Parts 718, and 725 (Regulations), provide compensation and other

benefits to:

1.

Living coal miners who are totally disabled due to pneumoconiosis and theirdependents. Pneumoconiosis is a disease of the lung s arising from coal mineemployment and is commonly known as Black Lung Disease;

2. Surviving dependents of coal miners whose death was due to pneumoconiosis; and,3. Surviving dependents of coal miners who were totally disabled due to

pneumoconiosis at the time of their death.

While the Act and regulations appear to present a straight-forward regulatory program to be usedto determine whether or not benefits will or will not be awarded to claimants, the variousdecisions and orders of the Benefits Review Board, U.S. Department of Labor, and the CircuitCourts of Appeals of the United States, have established a complex overylay of federal common-law.

Note:

The Government contemplates awarding multiple- award contracts.

Lawyer writers will be assigned to a specific judges docket.

Lawyer writers will be paid a fixed price per case only after the decision is issued.

All Lawyers Writers should have required skills sets and experience in the Black Lungprogram area.

Work is envisioned to be performed at the Lawyer writers home/office and not at agovernment site.

8/10/2019 Rev Draft PWS - RFI- Black Lung Lawyer Writers

2/4

The typical Lawyer writer is expected to carry a workload of 5-8 concurrent cases.Additional workload is available if requested by the writer.

To ensure there are no conflicts of interests, all lawyer writers must provide a signed,sworn statement that they are not currently practicing or participating in Black Lung caselitigation before the U.S. Department of Labor, and Lawyer Writers will continue to not

be involved in Black Lung litigation before OALJ, while serving as a writer. The writerwill also agree that the writer will not work on a Black Lung case if the writerparticipated or was involved with any prior litigation with that case or the parties in thecase.

Black Lung cases fall into two types: first, those in which there is no responsible operator andonly the Director, Office of Workers' Compensation Programs (Director) remains as the

opposing party, i.e., Directors caseand, secondly, those in which there is a responsibleoperator opposing the award of benefits and the Director is only a party-in-interest, i.e.,Responsible Operator (RO) case.The typical Directors case can take eight hours or more tocorrectly draft while the average Responsible Operator case may take twenty-four or more hours

depending on ones familiarity with the Black Lung program.

In both types of cases, the contractor will be required to perform a record analysis of the casewhich includes: a study of pleadings, testimony, exhibits, hearing transcripts and briefs ofcounsel in connection with a determination on the merits of formal cases; a review of thecontested issues and facts; and, an appraisal of the evidence and inferences to be drawntherefrom. In addition, legal research of applicable statutes, regulations, opinions, legislativehistory, and other legal authorities on points of law involved will be required including analysisand application of such findings to the case at hand. This will be done at the direction of thepresiding Judge.

These cases involve both complex medical and legal issues, thus legal research will be requiredto resolve issues including:

a. Whether the claimant is a coal miner as defined by the Black Lung Benefits Actand its implementing regulations.

b. The identity of the responsible operator.

c. A determination of which Circuits jurisdiction applies.

d. Whether the claim was timely filed and filed by a proper party.

e. Legal status of dependents and survivors.

f. The existence of an employee-employer relationship between the miner and theidentified responsible operator.

g. The possibility of discrimination against the miner byhis/her employer because of pneumoconiosis.

8/10/2019 Rev Draft PWS - RFI- Black Lung Lawyer Writers

3/4

h. Whether the presumptions under 20 C.F.R. section 718.305 apply or not.

i. Resolution of subsequent claims issues, under section 725.309.

j. Resolution of claims modification issues, under section 725.310, includingwhether justice under the Act would be served by consideration of themodification request.

k. The existence of pneumoconiosis.

l. Causal relationship between coal mine employment and pneumoconiosis.

m. Whether the claimant is totally disabled due to pneumoconiosis.

n. Pre-trial motions.

o. Written rulings on the established evidence.

p. Length of coal mine employment and the nature of the miners usual coal minework including the arduousness of the work, i.e., sedentary, medium, heavy, veryheavy labor.

q. Determine the onset date for the initiation of benefits.

Additionally, the Lawyer Writer shall be able to describe and evaluate the objective medicaltesting, including x-ray readings, CT scan readings, PET scan readings, Arterial Blood Gasstudies, and Pulmonary Function Studies, and treatment records and determine whether theresults militate in favor of awarding benefits or not, when viewed in connection with the medicalopinion evidence. The lawyer writer must also be able to evaluate the credibility of eachphysicians opinion and describe why or why not they should be credited and to what degree.Each lawyer writer must demonstrate a command of the English grammar and punctuation. Eachpresiding Judges individual preferences for their decision and order may be taken into accountin the case preparation.

The draft shall be submitted in the form of a decision and order delivered either on a CD,

thumb-drive, or by e-mail attachment to the judge and shall be in Microsoft Office 2010

Word format.

NOTE:

Drafts of cases must be of a quality satisfactory to the presiding Judge and the first

draft submitted within 60 days of assignment.

Subsequent drafts and/or the final decision and order must be returned to the

presiding Judge along with the entire paper case file in the same condition as when

it was picked-up within ten (10) business days.

8/10/2019 Rev Draft PWS - RFI- Black Lung Lawyer Writers

4/4

All interested contractors are requested to submit a response providing fixed prices per case(rough order of magnitude) and demonstrating their capabilities to provide the required services.As stipulated in FAR 15.201, responses to this notice are not considered offers and cannot beaccepted by the Government to form a binding contract. No solicitation exists; therefore, do notrequest a copy of the solicitation. The decision to solicit for a contract shall be solely within the

Government's discretion.

Contractors responding should indicate their socio economic indicators, i.e., large business, asmall business, a socially and economically disadvantaged business, or a woman ownedbusiness. The NAICS Code to be used for this contemplated acquisition is 541110 with a sizestandard of $11.0M, per US SBA Table of Size Standards, www.sba.gov. Respondents arefurther requested to indicate their status as a Foreign-owned/Foreign-controlled contractor andany contemplated use of foreign national employees on this effort.

Any information submitted by respondents to this sources sought synopsis is voluntary. Thissources sought notice is not to be construed as a commitment by the Government, nor will the

Government reimburse any costs associated with the submission of information in response tothis notice. Respondents will not be individually notified of the results of any governmentassessments. The Government's evaluation of the capability statements received will factor intothe Acquisition Strategy, whether any forthcoming solicitation will be conducted as a full andopen competition or as a set-aside for small businesses, or any particular small businessdesignation (e.g. SDVOSB, HUB Zone, 8(a), SDB, WOSB, VOSB, etc.).

http://www.sba.gov/http://www.sba.gov/http://www.sba.gov/