Research on tablet pc adoption model
-
Upload
arun-savukar -
Category
Documents
-
view
43 -
download
0
Transcript of Research on tablet pc adoption model
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)1. Introduction of Consumer behaviour
The study of consumer behavior focuses on how individuals make decisions to spend
their available resources (time, money, effort) on consumption-related items (Schiffman
and Kanuk, 1997). The field of consumer behavior covers a lot of ground. According
to Solomon (1996), consumer behavior is a study of the processes involved when
individuals or groups select, purchase, use, or dispose of products, services, ideas, or
experiences to satisfy needs and desires.
“A customer is the most important visitor on our premises. He is not dependent on us.
We are dependent on him. He is not an interruption on our work. He is the purpose of
it and not an outsider on our premises. He is a part of it. We are not doing him a favour
by serving him. He is doing us a favour by giving us the opportunity to do so.”
Mahatma Gandhi
Customer Vs Consumer
The term ‘customer’ and ‘consumer’ have been used synonymously most of the
time. The term customer refers to the purchaser of a product or service whereas the term
consumer refers to the end user of a product or service. The customer may or may not
be a consumer. Similarly the consumer may or may not be the customer.
Definitions
“Consumer behaviour is defined as activities people undertake when obtaining,
consuming, and disposing of products and services.”
- Roger D. Blackwell, Paul W. Miniard and James F. Engel
“Simply it can be stated that consumer behaviour is the study of “why people buy.”
“Consumer behaviour has been referred to as the psychological, social and physical
behaviour of all potential consumers as they become aware of, evaluate, purchase and
consume and tell others about products and services.”
- Suja R. Nair
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 1
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)Obtaining: refers to the activities involved in purchase of a product. The activities
include searching for information regarding product features, evaluating the
alternatives, and purchasing. It also includes the place of purchase (shopping
malls/nearest grocery stores), the mode of purchase (cash/credit card), etc.
Consuming: refers to how, where, when and under what circumstances consumers use
products. How – as side dish or main dish; Where – place (home, office or restaurant),
When – time (morning or afternoon or evening) and under what circumstances (happiest
moments or with friends or when alone).
Disposing: refers to how they get rid of products and packaging. Whether they resell it
or give it to children or use it for different purpose.
“Consumer behaviour can be said to be the study of how individuals make decisions on
how to spend their available resources (time, money, effort) on various consumption-
related items.”
- Suja R. Nair
The above definition talks about various activities surrounding the ultimate
consumer and helps the marketer to gauge the consumer behaviour specifically focusing
on:
Who buys the products or services?
How do they buy products or services?
Where do they buy them?
How often do they buy them?
When do they buy them?
Why do they buy them? And
How often do they use them?
These questions will help in understanding better what factors influence the
decision making process of the consumers.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 2
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
1.1. Consumer Behaviour – for Whom?
It has been said that the field of consumer behaviour holds for various categories
of people such as consumers, marketers and students of marketing.
Consumers: All the firms have started considering ‘customer’ as the ‘king’ or ‘queen’.
Interestingly, after liberalization of India’s economy, the market place is flooded with
many new players including the MNCs’ resulting in the availability of more number of
brands in every segment of the market. On account of this, the customer has started
being choicy about what to buy. Thus all firms are becoming not only customer
focused but are also trying to build relationship with them. This is done by
continuously updating knowledge, information and understanding of the customer needs
and expectations.
Awareness of such devotion from the firm has made consumers to take more interest
into their own consumption related decisions. They are keen to gain more knowledge
about taking various decisions related to products and the promotional influences that
persuade them to buy. Thus the study of consumer behaviour will enable them to
become better and wiser consumers.
Marketers: have woken up to the reality that exist in a competitive environment and
hence they have to be more focused. The marketers have observed that the choice
empowered customer cannot be taken for granted. This is particularly true because of
the rapidly rising consumer earnings, sharp drop in the savings rate and increase in
earnings resulting in a huge amount of disposable income that are spent lavishly.
Simultaneously, there are changes occurring in the personal, social and influences
making consumer more individualistic, conscious (about the products or services to
fulfill their needs). So, the study of consumer behaviour will help marketers to assess
the consumers’ needs and wants, and make better strategic marketing decisions.
Students: As students of marketing, one will be more concerned with the study of
consumer behaviour. Such a study will help to gauge into the consumer’s mind and
underst and the various consumption related aspects of individuals (consumers). As
students of marketing, understanding of consumer behaviour will make the study of
‘marketing management’ more interesting, understandable and increase awareness of its
practical implications.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 3
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
1.2. Development of Consumer Behaviour as a Field of Study
Consumer behaviour as a separate field of study gained attention from the
1960s. In the absence of a history or a separate research of its own, this new discipline
drew/or borrowed concepts from other scientific disciplines such as –
Psychology (the study of individuals)
Sociology (the study of groups)
Socio-psychology (the study of how persons are influenced by groups)
Cultural anthropology (the influence of the culture and society on the individual)
Economics (the relationship between demand and supply in the flow of
marketing activity)
Positivism: Initially, the study of consumer research was emphasizing from a
managerial perspective. In that, if the marketing manager could obtain consumption
related behaviour i.e., if they are able to predict consumer behaviour, then they could
influence it. This type of consumer behaviour approach came to be known as
‘positivism’.
Interpretism: A group of academicians who are interested in the study of consumer
behaviour and are more interested in knowing consumption behaviour going by the
influence of the various disciplines on the consumer behaviour. This approach of
studying the consumer behaviour with a view on understanding consumption behaviour
and the interpretations of such behaviour is known as ‘interpretivism or post-
modernism.’
These interpretivists have included many subjective aspects of consumer
behaviour such as the effect of moods, emotions, type of situations etc. These
interpretivists have also treated each purchase experience as unique because of the many
variables which influence the behaviour at that particular moment of time. On account
of its focus on the consumption experience, the interpretive approach is also referred to
as ‘experientalism’.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 4
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
1.3. Consumer Behaviour and Marketing
Broadly, buyers can be classified into two major categories:
Consumers (in the household sector, who buy goods or services for personal
consumption) Industrial buyers (who purchase goods and services for carrying out
activities in the various industrial units).
In this age of information explosion, and internet marketing becoming a reality,
it is all the more necessary that they (marketers) go for the creation of appropriate
database which can help them to go for ‘tailor made’ products to suit individual tastes,
preferences and buying behaviour.
The industrial or organizational markets consist of buyers who buy goods and
services needed in the process of furthering their industrial and institutionlal activities.
The behavioural differences between the domestic consumers and industrial buyers can
be done on the basis of the ultimate objective sought by them. While the domestic
consumers seek need satisfaction and value added by the purchase of the product, the
industrial buyers seek profit or measurement of improved operational efficiency. The
latter’s behaviour, thus, will be influenced by the objectives of the organization they
serve. Accordingly there is also a difference in the buying process adopted by both the
domestic consumer and industrial buyer.
A major implication of the differences in the consumer and industrial behaviour
for marketers is the relative emphasis to be placed on the various marketing mixes to be
adopted by the concerned marketer. Understanding of the consumer behaviour will
enable marketers to design effective marketing strategy and programmes.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 5
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
1.4. Consumer Modeling
Model: “A physical, visual or mathematical ….. Simplified representation of a complex system.”
A model is very often referred to as an abstract representation of a process or
relationship. We (human beings) hold various models in our minds which allow us to
make sense of the world and also help to predict the likely course of events. Simply
stated models help us in the following way:
They help in the development of theories
They help to understand complex relationships
They provide the framework for discussions and research work
The primary concern is to use the models to understand consumer behaviour.
Consumer behaviourists as well as marketers are interested in understanding how and
why certain decisions are made. The discussions have been about some of the
important models of consumer behaviour, which attempts to give a comprehensive view
of all those aspects of the buying situations which are deemed to be significant by their
creators.
Andreason (1965) proposed one of the earliest models of consumer behavior. This
model is shown in Figure 2.1.The model recognizes the importance of information in
the consumer decision-making process. It also emphasizes the importance of consumer
attitudes although it fails to consider attitudes in relation to repeat purchase behavior.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 6
Perceived beliefs, Norms,
Values of significant others.
Other customer Decision-makers
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Information
Intrinsic attributes
Extrinsic attributes
Price availability
Advocate impersonal
sources
Independent impersonal
sources
Advocate personal sources
Independent personal sources
Information storage
Attitudes towards sources
Filtration
Personality
Direct experience
Beliefs
Wants Want strength
Feelings
Disposition
Search
Select
No action
Attitudes towards product, substitutes,
complement
Income, budget piorities, physical capacity,
household capacity
Ownership Other
purchase decisions
Hold
Key
Direct Flows
Feedbacks
Yes
No
Figure 1 Andreason, A.R (1965 Attitudes and Consumer Behavior: A Decision Model in New Research in Marketing (ed. l. Preston). Institute of Business and Economic Research, University of California, Berkeley, pp.1-61
Constraints
7
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)second model, which concentrates on the buying decision for a new product, was
proposed by Nicosia (1976). This model is shown in Figure 2.2. The model
concentrates on the firm's attempts to communicate with the consumer, and the
consumers' predisposition to act in a certain way. These two features are referred to as
Field One. The second stage involves the consumer in a search evaluation process,
which is influenced by attitudes. This stage is referred to as Field Two. The actual
purchase process is referred to as Field Three, and the post-purchase feedback process
is referred to as Field Four. This model was criticized by commentators because it
was not empirically tested (Zaltman, Pinson and Angelman, 1973), and because of the
fact that many of the variables were not defined (Lunn, 1974).
Perhaps, the most frequently quoted of all consumer behavior models is the Howard-
Sheth model of buyer behavior, which was developed in 1969. This model is shown in
Figure 1. The model is important because it highlights the importance of inputs to the
consumer buying process and suggests ways in which the consumer orders these
inputs before making a final decision. The Howard-Sheth model is not perfect as it
does not explain all buyer behavior. It is however, a comprehensive theory of buyer
behavior that has been developed as a result of empirical research (Horton, 1984).
Schiffman and Kanuk (1997) mentioned that many early theories concerning
consumer behavior were based on economic theory, on the notion that individuals act
rationally to maximize their benefits (satisfactions) in the purchase of goods and
services. A consumer is generally thought of as a person who identifies a need or
desire, makes a purchase, and then disposes of the product during the three stages in
the consumption process in Figure2.2 (Solomon, 1996)
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 8 8
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
1.5. CONCEPTS AND DIMENSIONS OF CONSUMER BEHAVIOUR
Consumer behaviour is an interdisciplinary science and relatively
emerged as a new field of study in the mid to late 1060s. This new discipline is
borrowed heavily from concepts developed in other scientific disciplines such as
applied psychology, social psychology, cultural anthropology, economics and
econometrics. Therefore, it is crucial to discuss various dimensions of consumer
behaviour in the context of Indian consumer.
(a) Consumer Needs and Motivation: Consumer needs are the basis of all
modern marketing. The key to a company‟s survival, profitability and growth in a
highly competitive environment is its ability to identify and satisfy unfulfilled
consumer needs Marketers do not create needs though in some instances they
may make consumer more keenly aware of unfelt need. Motivation can be
described as the deriving force within individuals that impels them to action.
The deriving force is produced by a state of tension exists as the result of an
unfilled need. Motivation is a need-induced tension which exerts a “push” on the
individual to engage in behaviour that he expects, will gratify needs and thus
reduce tension. Individuals strive both consciously and subconsciously to reduce
this tension through behaviour that they anticipate will fulfill their needs.
Consumer motivation is dynamic in nature because their wants are frequently
changing.
(b) Consumer Psychographics: Marketing practitioner and consumer researchers
refer Psychographics as lifestyle analysis or AIO (activity, interest and
opinions) research. Consumer specific psychographics researches are related to
consumer personality, buying motives, interests, attitudes, beliefs and values.
Services specific psychographics researches are related to product attributes
such as consumer responses about products, brands or a specific consumption
situation.
Consumer perception: Perception is defined as the process by which an
individual selects, organises and interprets stimuli into a meaningful and
coherent manner. Stimuli are sensory inputs include services, packages, brand names,
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 9 9
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)advertisements and commercials. Sensory receptors are the human organs that
receive sensory inputs. Sensation is the immediate and direct response of the
sensory organs to simple stimuli.
Learning and consumer involvement: Consumer learning is the process of
acquiring the knowledge related to purchase and consumption information.
Consumer attitudes: Attitudes are expression of inner feelings that reflects
whether a person is favorably or unfavorably predisposed to some object,
person or event. As an outcome of psychological process attitudes are not
directly observable but must be inferred from what people say or do.
(c) Demographic Factors: Demographics describe a population in terms of its
size, distribution and structure. Demographics influence buying behaviour both
directly and indirectly by affecting other attributes of individuals such as their
personal values and decision styles. There are contradictory conclusions about the
effect of age, income and gender for a particular service. Age, age-groups, education
level, income, occupation etc. serves as various dimensions of demographics. In
India additional factors such as religion, social denominations, caste, age,
family background, regional disparities instates, linguistic difference, regional
perception of class factor and the degree of impact of these factors in affecting the
social status, all play crucial role in determining the social status of an individual.
(d) Economic Factors: Wealth, home ownership, number of earning members in a
family, household income, expenditure, rate of interest, inflation, economic
conditions and investment pattern are some of the economic factors have
strong influence on consumer purchase decision.
(e) Communication and Consumer Behaviour: Communication is the
transmission of messages from a sender to a receiver by means of signals of
some sort sent through a channel. There are four basic components of all
communications: a source, a destination, a medium and a message. There are two
types of communication to which a consumer is exposed interpersonal
communication and impersonal (or mass) communication.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 10 10
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)(f) Socio-cultural Factors: Consumer in a group and consumer reference
groups: A group may be defined as two or more people who interact to
accomplish similar goals. Consumer relevant groups are family, friends, formal
social groups, shopping groups, consumer action groups, work groups, references
groups etc. Four basic functions provided by the family are relevant to consumer
behaviour these include; economic well-being, emotional-support, suitable family
lifestyles and family-member socialization. Sociologists and researchers have
strongly favoured the concept of Family Life Cycle (FLC) - a way to classify
family units into significant groups. FLC is a strategic tool for marketers to
segment families in terms of a series of stages spanning the life course of a
family unit. Traditional family life cycle stages are bachelorhood,
honeymooners, parenthood, post parenthood and dissolution.
Consumer and their social classes: Social class is defined as the division of members
of a society into a hierarchy of distinct status classes so that members of each
class have relatively the same status and members of all other classes have
either more or less status. Social class is measured in terms of social status of its
members and comparison of members of each social class with other social
classes. Some of the variables of the social class are occupation, income,
educational level and property ownership etc. Culture and consumer behaviour:
Culture is a sum total of learned beliefs, values and customs that serves to direct
the consumer behaviour of a particular society. Subculture can be thought as a
distinct cultural group that exists as an identifiable segment within a larger and more
complex society.
(g) Consumer and Consumerism: The word consumerism has many expressions
depending on who is using the term government, business, consumer groups,
academicians and researchers. Consumerism is defined as a social movement of
citizens and government to enhance the rights and powers of buyers in relation
to seller.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 11 11
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
2. BUYING PROCESS OR CONSUMER DECISION MAKING
A decision is the selection of an action from two or more alternatives. In other words,
in order to make a decision, there must be a choice of alternatives available.
If a person has a choice between making a purchase and not making a
purchase, or a choice between brands, we can say that this person is in a position to
make a decision. A “no-choice” decision is commonly referred to as a “Hobson‟s
choice.”
Buyer decision making is an attempt to solve consumer problems. A problem refers to
a discrepancy between a desired state and an ideal state which is sufficient to
arouse and activate a decision process. Thus problem can be major or minor and the
broader and more ambiguous a problem is, the more potential solutions are
generally available.
The study of buyer behaviour is the most dynamic marketing activities as the
buyer rapidly change their preferences and are affected by multiple factors at a
given point of time, are difficult to analyze. Therefore, it is necessary that
continuous study of buying behaviour must be conducted and extended. This
monitoring will make an understanding of marketing management to take effective
decisions regarding service price, distribution and promotion. A marketer
understands how buyer will respond to different service features, prices, advertising
appeals and so on will have an enormous advantage over his adversaries. When a
buyer takes a decision to buy there is no rigid rule to bind them. Sometimes the
decisions are taken on spot or after evaluating various alternatives available
and reassuring himself with the opinion of those who have already purchased
the service.
Four views of buyer decision making: Before presenting a simple model how
consumers make decisions. For depicting consumer decision making it‟s important to
consider several models of man. The term model of man refers to a general
perspective held by a significant number of people concerning how (and why)
individuals behave as they do. Following are the consumer-related models of man:-
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 12 12
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
(1) Economic man (Traditional view): Economics reflects a world of perfect
competition and the consumer is often characterised as an economic man. The
economic theory of consumer behaviour was synthesized by Alfred Marshall
from the ideas of Classical Economists and the proponents of theory of
„Marginal Utility.‟ Economic view explains the consumer as an economic man
who buys rationally to maximize the utility (benefits) derived from a service.
To behave rationally in the economic sense a consumer would have to be aware of all
available service alternatives. The consumer would have to be capable of correctly
ranking each alternative in terms of its benefits and disadvantages. According
to leading social scientists this view is unrealistic because of three reasons (a)
people are limited by their existing skills, habits and reflexes (b) people are
limited by their existing values and goals (c) people are limited by the extent
of their knowledge. However, consumers rarely have enough information,
sufficient or sufficiently information, or even an adequate degree of involvement or
motivation to make perfect decision. Consumers are living in an imperfect world
where they do not maximise their decisions in terms of economic considerations
such as price- quantity relationships, marginal utility or indifference curves. Indeed
the consumers are often unwilling to engage in extensive decision making
activities and will instead settle for a “satisfactory” decision, one that is “good
enough.” For this reason, the economic model is often rejected as too idealistic
and simplistic. The economists described man as a rational buyer and viewed the
market as a collection of homogenous buyers.
(2) Passive man: This model is quite opposite to the economic model of man. The
passive view depicts the consumer basically submissive to the self-serving
interest and promotional efforts of marketers. Consumers are perceived as
impulsive and irrational purchasers, ready to yield to the arms and aims of
marketers. At least to some degree the passive model of the consumer was
subscribed by the hard deriving salesman who is trained to manipulate
customer. The passive man view fails to recognize that the consumer plays an equal
(if not dominant) role in many buying situations by seeking information about
service alternatives and selecting the service that appears to offer greatest
satisfaction.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 13 13
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
(3) Cognitive man: According to this view consumer is defined as a thinking
problem solver. Within this framework consumers are frequently depicted as
either receptive to or actively seeking services that fulfill their needs and
enrich their lives. The cognitive man focuses on the process by which
consumers seek and evaluate information about the services. There are six
types of consumer perceived risks (functional risk, economic risk, physical risk,
social risk, psychological risk and time risk) which a consumer use to handle
such as collecting information about alternatives, patronizing specific agents,
brand loyalty etc. These risks are key components of cognitive view and
consumers are viewed as information-processing systems. Consumer may use a
preference formation strategy that is “other-based” in which they allow another
person probably a trusted person or an expert to establish preferences to them.
(4) Emotional man: Marketers prefer to think of customer in terms of either
economic or passive models. Emotional man is also a reality of each of us
because of deeply rooted feeling and emotions: joy, fear, love, hope, fantasy,
sadness etc. These emotions have an impact on purchases and possessions.
Such feelings or emotions are likely to be highly involved for making a
purchase decisions. When a consumer makes any emotional purchase.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 14 14
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
2.1 Models of consumer behaviour
The Economic Model
Learning Model
Psychological Model
The Sociological Model
Howard-Sheth Model (1969)
McNeals’ Basic Model of Consumer Behavior(1973)
The Engel-Kollat-Blackwell (EKB) Model (1960)
Nicosia Model(1976)
Solomon Model of comparison process (1996)
Theory of Innovation Diffusion Rogers Model (1995)
Diffusion of Innovation Theory in Information System
Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) (1975)
The Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB)
Unified Theory of Use and Acceptance of Technology
Technology Acceptance Model (TAM)(1989)
Technology Acceptance Model 2
Bettman’s Information Processing Model of Consumer Choice
Sheth-Newman Gross Model of Consumption Values
Model of Travel-Buying Behavior Mathieson and Wall
Stimulus-Response Model of Buyer Behavior
Model of Consumer Decision-Making Framework
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 15 15
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
2.2. VARIOUS MODELS OF CONSUMER BEHAVIOUR
2.2.1 Nicosia Model
This model focuses on the relationship between the firm and its potential consumers.
The firm communicates with consumers through its marketing messages (advertising),
and the consumers react to these messages by purchasing response. Looking to the
model we will find that the firm and the consumer are connected with each other, the
firm tries to influence the consumer and the consumer is influencing the firm by his
decision.
Field 1
Attitude
Field 2: Search And evaluation Of mean/end(s)
Experience relation(s) (Pre action field)
Motivation Field 4: Feedback
Field 3: Act of Purchase
Purchasing Behavior
Figure2. Nicosia Model of Consumer Decision Processes Source: Nicosia, (1976).
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME
Message Exposure
Subfield 1
FirmsAttribute
Subfield 2
ConsumersAttributes
(EspeciallyPredisposition
Searchand evaluation
Decision(Action)
Consumption
16 16
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
The Nicosia model is divided into four major fields:
Field 1: The consumer attitude based on the firms’ messages.
The first field is divided into two subfields.
The first subfield deals with the firm’s marketing environment and communication
efforts that affect consumer attitudes, the competitive environment, and characteristics
of target market. Subfield two specifies the consumer characteristics e.g., experience,
personality, and how he perceives the promotional idea toward the product in this
stage the consumer forms his attitude toward the firm’s product based on his
interpretation of the message.
Field 2: search and evaluation The consumer will start to search for other firm’s brand and evaluate the firm’s brand
in comparison with alternate brands. In this case the firm motivates the consumer to
purchase its brands.
Field 3: The act of the purchaseThe result of motivation will arise by convincing the consumer to purchase the firm
products from a specific retailer.
Field 4: Feed backThis model analyses the feedback of both the firm and the consumer after purchasing
the product. The firm will benefit from its sales data as a feedback, and the consumer
will use his experience with the product affects the individuals attitude and
predisposition’s concerning future messages from the firm.
The Nicosia model offers no detail explanation of the internal factors, which may
affect the personality of the consumer, and how the consumer develops his attitude
toward the product. For example, the consumer may find the firm’s message very
interesting, but virtually he cannot buy the firm’s brand because it contains something
prohibited according to his beliefs. Apparently it is very essential to include such
factors in the model, which give more interpretation about the attributes affecting the
decision process.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 17 17
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
2.2.2 Howard – Sheth model
This model suggests three levels of decision making:
1. The first level describes the extensive problem solving. At this level the consumer
does not have any basic information or knowledge about the brand and he does not
have any preferences for any product. In this situation, the consumer will seek
information about all the different brands in the market before purchasing.
2. The second level is limited problem solving. This situation exists for consumers
who have little knowledge about the market, or partial knowledge about what they
want to purchase. In order to arrive at a brand preference some comparative brand
information is sought.
3. The third level is a habitual response behavior. In this level the consumer knows
very well about the different brands and he can differentiate between the different
characteristics of each product, and he already decides to purchase a particular
product. According to the Howard-Sheth model there are four major sets of variables;
namely:
Inputs.
These input variables consist of three distinct types of stimuli (information sources) in
the consumer’s environment. The marketer in the form of product or brand
information furnishes physical brand characteristics (significative stimuli) and verbal
or visual product characteristics (symbolic stimuli). The third type is provided by the
consumer’s social environment (family, reference group, and social class). All three
types of stimuli provide inputs concerning the product class or specific brands to the
specific consumer.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 18 18
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Inputs Perceptual Constructs Learning Constructs Outputs
Stimuli display
Figure 3 A Simplified Description of the Theory of Buyer Behavior Source: Howard, and Sheth,Pp32 (1969)
Perceptual and Learning Constructs,
The central part of the model deals with the psychological variables involved when
the consumer is contemplating a decision. Some of the variables are perceptual in
nature, and are concerned with how the consumer receives and understands the
information from the input stimuli and other parts of the model. For example,
stimulus ambiguity happened when the consumer does not understand the message
from the environment. Perceptual bias occurs if the consumer distorts the information
received so that it fits his or her established needs or experience.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME
Significativea. Qualityb. Pricec. Distinctived. Servicee. Availability
Symbolic a. Qualityb. Pricec. Distinctived. Servicee. Availability
Sociala. Familyb. Reference groupsc. Social class
Purchase
Intention
Attitude
BrandComprehen- sion
Attention
Overtsearch
Stimulusambiguity
Attention
Percept-ual bias
Confidence
Attitude
Motives
ChoiceCriteria
BrandCompre-hension
Intention
19 19
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Learning constructs category, consumers’ goals, information about brands, criteria for
evaluation alternatives, preferences and buying intentions are all included. The
proposed interaction In between the different variables in the perceptual and learning
constructs and other sets give the model its distinctive advantage.
OutputsThe outputs are the results of the perceptual and learning variables and how the
consumers will response to these variables (attention, brand comprehension, attitudes,
and intention).
Exogenous(External) variables
Exogenous variables are not directly part of the decision-making process. However,
some relevant exogenous variables include the importance of the purchase, consumer
personality traits, religion, and time pressure.
The decision-making process, which Howard-Sheth Model tries to explain, takes
place at three Inputs stages: Significance, Symbolic and Social stimuli. In both
significative and symbolic stimuli, the model emphasizes on material aspects such as
price and quality. These stimuli are not applicable in every society. While in social
stimuli the model does not mention the basis of decision-making in this stimulus, such
as what influence the family decision? This may differ from one society to another.
Finally, no direct relation was drawn on the role of religion in influencing the
consumer’s decision-making processes. Religion was considered as external factor
with no real influence on consumer, which give the model obvious weakness in
anticipation the consumer decision.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 20 20
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)2.2.3 Engel – kollat- Model
This model was created to describe the increasing, fast-growing body of knowledge
concerning consumer behavior. This model, like in other models, has gone through
many revisions to improve its descriptive ability of the basic relationships between
components and sub-components, this model consists also of four stages;
First stage: decision-process stages
The central focus of the model is on five basic decision-process stages: Problem
recognition, search for alternatives, alternate evaluation (during which beliefs may
lead to the formation of attitudes, which in turn may result in a purchase intention)
purchase, and outcomes. But it is not necessary for every consumer to go through all
these stages; it depends on whether it is an extended or a routine problem-solving
behavior.
Second stage: Information input
At this stage the consumer gets information from marketing and non-marketing
sources, which also influence the problem recognition stage of the decision-making
process. If the consumer still does not arrive to a specific decision, the search for
external information will be activated in order to arrive to a choice or in some cases if
the consumer experience dissonance because the selected alternative is less
satisfactory than expected.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 21 21
Stimuli:Marketer-
Dominated,other
Exposure
External search
Attention
ComprehensionPerception
Yielding/ Acceptance
Retention
Dissatisfaction Satisfaction
M E M O R Y
ProblemRecognition
SearchInternalsearch
Outcomes
Purchase
Alternative evaluation
IndividualCharacteristics
:
MotivesValues
LifestylePersonality
Beliefs
Attitude
Intention
SocialInfluences
:
CultureReference
group
Family
SituationalInfluences
Input Information Processing
Decision Process Variables Influencing Precision Process
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Figure 4 .The Engel-Kollat-Blackwell Model of Consumer Behavior.Source: Engel , Blackwell, and Miniard,(1995) page No 95
Third stage: information processing
This stage consists of the consumer’s exposure, attention, perception, acceptance, and
retention of incoming information. The consumer must first be exposed to the
message, allocate space for this information, interpret the stimuli, and retain the
message by transferring the input to long-term memory.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 22 22
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)Fourth stage: variables influencing the decision process
This stage consists of individual and environmental influences that affect all five
stages of the decision process. Individual characteristics include motives, values,
lifestyle, and personality; the social influences are culture, reference groups, and
family. Situational influences, such as a consumer’s financial condition, also
influence the decision process.
This model incorporates many items, which influence consumer decision-making
such as values, lifestyle, personality and culture. The model did not show what factors
shape these items, and why different types of personality can produce different
decision-making? How will we apply these values to cope with different
personalities? Religion can explain some behavioral characteristics of the consumer,
and this will lead to better understanding of the model and will give more
comprehensive view on decision-making.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 23 23
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)2.2.4 Bettman’s Information Processing Model of Consumer Choice
Bettman (1979) in his model describes the consumer as possessing a limited capacity
for processing information. He implicate that the consumers rarely analyze the
complex alternatives in decision making and apply very simple strategy.
In this model there are seven major stages.
Stage No. 1: Processing capacity
In this step he assumes that the consumer has limited capacity for processing
information, consumers are not interested in complex computations and extensive
information processing. To deal with this problem, consumers are likely to select
choice strategies that make product selection an easy process.
Stage No. 2: Motivation
Motivation is located in the center of Bettman model, which influence both the
direction and the intensity of consumer choice for more information in deciding
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 24 24
Motivation Goal hierarchy
Processingcapacity
Attention
Informationacquisition
andevaluation
Decision Processes
Consumptionand
learningprocesses
Perceptualencoding
Perceptual
Scannerand
interruptmechanisms
interruptinterpretation
andresponse
Memorysearch
Externalsearch
Scannerand
interruptmechanisms
Interrupt interpretation and response
Scannerand
interruptmechanisms
Interruptinterpretation
andresponse
Scanner and interrupt mechanisms
Interrupt interpretation and response
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Figure 5. the Bettman Information-Processing Model of Consumer ChoiceSource: Bettman. (1979). Pp 402
Between the alternatives Motivation is provided with hierarchy of goals’ mechanism
that provides a series of different sub-goals to simplify the choice selection. This
mechanism suggests that the consumers own experience in a specific area of market
and he doesn’t need to go through the same hierarchy every time to arrive at a
decision, which make this mechanism serves as an organizer for consumer efforts in
making a choice. No concern was given on religious motives, and how religion may
motivate the consumer in his decision. Most of the general theories of motivation such
as Maslow’s hierarchy of needs (1970) emphasizes self-achievement, the need for
power, and the need for affiliation.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 25 25
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Stage No. 3: Attention and perceptual encoding.
The component of this step is quite related to the consumer's goal hierarchy. There are
two types of attention; the first type is voluntary attention, which is a conscious
allocation of processing capacity to current goals. The second is involuntary attention,
which is automatic response to disruptive events (e.g., newly acquired complex
information). Both different types of attention influence how individuals proceed in
reaching goals and making choices. The perceptual encoding accounts for the
different steps that the consumer needs to perceive the stimuli and whether he needs
more information.
Stage No. 4: Information acquisition and evaluation
If the consumer feels that the present information is inadequate, he will start to look
for more information from external sources. Newly acquired information is evaluated
and its suitability or usefulness is assessed. The consumer continues to acquire
additional information until all relevant information has been secured, or until he
finds that acquiring additional information is more costly in terms of time and money.
Stage No. 5: Memory
In this component the consumer keeps all the information he collects, and it will be
the first place to search when he need to make a choice. If this informations is not
sufficient, no doubt he will start looking again for external sources.
Stage No. 6: Decision Process
This step in Bettman’s model indicates that different types of choices are normally
made associated with other factors, which may occur during the decision process.
Specifically, this component deals with the application of heuristics or rules of thumb,
which are applied in the selection and evaluation of specific brand. These specific
heuristics a consumer uses are influenced by both individual factors (e.g., personality
differences) and situational factors (e.g., urgency of the decision); thus it is unlikely
that the same decision by the same consumer will apply in different situation or other
consumer in the same situation.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 26 26
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Stage No. 7: Consumption and Learning Process
In this stage, the model discusses the future results after the purchase is done. The
consumer in this step will gain experience after evaluating the alternative. This
experience provides the consumer with information to be applied to future choice
situation. Bettman in his model emphasize on the information processing and the
capacity of the consumer to analyze this information for decision making, but no
explanation was given about the criteria by which the consumer accepts or refuses to
process some specific information.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 27 27
Consumer Choice Behavior
Functional Value Conditional Value SocialValue
Emotional Value EpistemicValue
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
2.2.5 Sheth-Newman Gross Model of Consumption Values
According to this model, there are five consumption values influencing consumer
choice behavior. These are functional, social, conditional, emotional, and epistemic
values. Any or all of the five consumption values may influence the decision. Various
disciplines (including economics, sociology, several branches of psychology,
marketing and consumer behavior) have contributed theories and research findings
relevant to these values, (Sheth et al. 1991). Each consumption value in the theory is
consistent with various components of models advanced by Maslow (1970), Katona
(1971), Katz (1960), and Hanna (1980). Five consumption values form the core of the
model:
Figure 6. The five values influencing Consumer Choice BehaviorSource: Sheth, Newman, and Gross (1991) Pp159-170
The first value: Functional value
To Sheth et al. (1991) the functional value of an alternative is defined as:
"The perceived utility acquired from an alternative for functional, utilitarian, or
physical performance. An alternative acquires functional value through the possession
of salient functional, utilitarian, or physical attributes. Functional value is measured
on a profile of choice attributes."
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 28 28
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Traditionally, functional value is presumed to be the primary driver of consumer
choice. This assumption underlies economic utility theory advanced by Marshall
(1890) and Stigler (1950) and popularly expressed in terms of "rational economic
man." An alternative’s functional value may be derived from its characteristics or
attributes, (Ferber, 1973) such as reliability, durability, and price. For example, the
decision to purchase a particular automobile may be based on fuel economy and
maintenance record.
By identifying the dominant function of a product (i.e., what benefits it provides),
marketers can emphasize these benefits in their communication and packaging.
Advertisements relevant to the function prompt more favorable thoughts about what is
being marketed and can result in a heightened preferences for both the ads and the
product, (Solomon 1996;160).
Katz (1960) developed the functional theory of attitudes. He identifies four attitudes based on the functional values:
1) Utilitarian function. The utilitarian function is related to the basic principles of
reward and punishment. We develop some of our attitude toward products simply
based on whether these products provide pleasure or pain.
2) Value-expressive function. Attitude that performs a value-expressive function
expresses the consumers’ central values or self-concept. A person forms a product
attitude not because of its objective benefits, but because of what the product says
about him or her as a person.
3) Ego-defensive function. Attitude formed to protect the person, either from external
threats or internal feelings, perform an ego-defensive function. Example of this
function is deodorant campaigns that stress the dire, embarrassing consequences of
being caught with underarm odor in public.
4) Knowledge function. Some attitude is formed as a result of a need for order,
structure, or meaning. This need is often present when a person is in an ambiguous
situation or is confronted with a new product.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 29 29
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
The second value: Social value
Sheth et al. (1991;161) defined social value of an alternative as:
"The perceived utility acquired from an alternative association with one or more
specific social groups. An alternative acquires social value through association with
positively or negatively stereotyped demographic, socioeconomic, and cultural-ethnic
groups. Social value is measured on a profile choice imagery."
Social imagery refers to all relevant primary and secondary reference groups likely to
be supportive of the product consumption. Consumers acquire positive or negative
stereotypes based on their association with varied demographic (age, sex, religion),
socioeconomic (income, occupation), cultural/ethnic (race, lifestyle), or political,
ideological segments of society.
Choices involving highly visible products (e.g., clothing, jewelry) and good service to
be shared with others (e.g., gifts, products used in entertaining) are often driven by
social values. For example, a particular make of automobile is being chosen more for
the social image evoked than for its functional performance. Even products generally
thought to be functional or utilitarian, are frequently selected based on their social
values.
The third value: Emotional value
Sheth et al. (1991; 161) defined emotional value of an alternative as:
"The perceived utility acquired from an alternative’s capacity to arouse feelings or
affective states. An alternative acquires emotional value when associated with specific
feelings or when precipitating those feelings. Emotional values are measured on a
profile of feelings associated with the alternative."
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 30 30
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Consumption emotion refers to the set of emotional responses elicited specifically
during product usage or consumption experience, as described either by the distinctive
categories of emotional experience and expression (e.g., joy, anger, and fear) or by the
structural dimensions underlying emotional categories such as pleasantness/
unpleasantness, relaxation/action, or calmness/excitement. Goods and services are
frequently associated with emotional responses (e.g. the fear aroused while viewing
horror movie). Emotional value is often associated with aesthetic alternatives (e.g.
religion, causes). However, more tangible and seemingly utilitarian products also
have emotional values. For example, some foods arouse feeling of comfort through
their association with childhood experiences, and consumers are sometimes said to
have "love affairs" with their cars.
A number of different attempts have been made to identify the various emotions that
people experience. Izard (1977) develops the taxonomy of affective experience
approach that describes the basic emotion that people feel. He measures emotions
using ten fundamental categories: interest, joy, surprise, sadness, anger, disgust,
contempt, fear, shame, and guilt. This approach has been used extensively by
consumer researchers, for example, Westbrook and Oliver (1991).
The fourth value: Epistemic value
Sheth et al. (1991 ;162) defined epistemic value as:
"The perceived utility acquired from an alternatives capacity to arouse curiosity,
provide novelty, and/or satisfy a desire for knowledge. An alternative acquires
epistemic value by items referring to curiosity, novelty, and knowledge."
Epistemic issues refer to reasons that would justify the perceived satisfaction of
curiosity, knowledge, and exploratory needs offered by the product as a change of
pace (something new, different). Entirely new experience certainly provides epistemic
value. However, an alternative that provides a simple change of pace can also be
imbued with epistemic value. The alternative may be chosen because the consumer is
bored or satiated with his or her current brand (as in trying a new type of food), is
curious (as in visiting a new shopping complex), or has a desire to learn (as in
experiencing another culture).
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 31 31
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
The concept of epistemic values has been influenced by theory and by several
important areas of research. Exploratory, novelty seeking, and variety seeking
motives have been suggested to active product search, trial, and switching behavior,
(Howard and Sheth 1969). One of the most significant contributors to the study of the
optimal stimulation and arousal has been Berlyne (1970), who contends that
individuals are driven to maintain an optimal or intermediate level of stimulation.
Finally, Hirschman (1980) has advanced innovativeness, or a consumer’ propensity to
adopt new products.
The Fifth value: Conditional value
Sheth et al. (1991;162) defined the conditional value as:
"The perceived utility acquired by an alternative is the result of the specific situation
or set of circumstances facing the choice maker. An alternative acquires conditional
value in the presence of antecedent physical or social contingencies that enhance its
functional or social value. Conditional value is measured on a profile of choice
contingencies."
An alternative’s utility will often depend on the situation. For example, some products
only have seasonal value (e.g., greeting cards), some are associated with once in a life
events (e.g., wedding dress), and some are used only in emergencies (e.g., hospital
services). Several areas of inquiry have also influenced conditional value. Based on
the concept of stimulus dynamism advanced by Hall (1963), Howard (1969)
recognized the importance of learning that takes place as a result of experience with a
given situation. Howard and Sheth (1969) then extended Howard’s earlier work by
defining the construct inhibitors as noninternalized forces that impede buyers’
preferences. The concept of inhibitors was more formally developed by Sheth (1974)
in his model of attitude-behavior relationship as anticipated situations and unexpected
events. Recognizing that behavior cannot be accurately predicted based on attitude or
intention alone, a number of researchers during the 1970s investigated the predictive
ability of situational factors (e.g., Sheth 1974).
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 32 32
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
The five consumption values identified by the theory make differential contributions
in specific choice contexts. For example, a consumer may decide to purchase coins as
an inflation hedge (functional value), and also realize a sense of security (emotional
value) from the investment. Social, epistemic, and conditional values have little
influence. Of course, a choice may be influenced positively by all five consumption
values For example, to a first-time home buyer, the purchase of a home might provide
functional value (the home contains more space than the present apartment), social
values (friends are also buying homes), emotional values (the consumer feels secure
in owning a home), epistemic value (the novelty of purchasing a home is enjoyable),
and conditional value (starting a family).
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 33 33
How does a consumer decide that he/she needs a product? What are the best sources of information to learn more about alternative choices?How are consumer attitudes toward products formed and/or changed?What cues do consumers use to infer which products are superior to others?
CONSUMER'S PERSPECTIVE MARKETER'S PERSPECTIVE
Is acquiring a product a stressful or pleasant experience? What does the purchase say about the consumer?How do situational factors, such as time pressure or store displays, affect the consumer’s purchase decision?
Does the product provide pleasure or perform its intended function?How is the product eventually disposed of, and what are the environmental consequences of this act?
What determines whether a consumer will be satisfied with a product and whether he/she will buy it again?Does this person tell others about his/her experiences with the product and affect their purchase decisions?
PREPURCHASE ISSUES
PURCHASE ISSUES
POSTPURCHASE ISSUES
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
2.2.6 Solomon Model of comparison process
Figure 7. Model of comparison process Source: Solomon (1996) Pp33Figure 2.2.7 explains some of the issus that are addressed during each stage of the
consumption process. The ‘exchange’, in which two or more organizations or people
give and receive something of value, is an integral part of marketing. He also
suggested that consumer behavior involves many different actors. The purchaser and
user of a product might not be the same person. People may also act as influences on
the buying processes. Organizations can also be involved in the buying process.
Much of marketing activity, they suggest, concentrates on adapting product offerings
to particular circumstances of target segment needs and wants. It is also common to
stimulate an already existing want through advertising and sales promotion, rather
than creating wants. The definitions and models, which have been presented so far,
have been from general marketing theory. Tourism is, by its very nature, a service
rather than a product, which may have a considerable effect on consumer behavior.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 34 34
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
3. TECHNOLOGY ADOPTION MODEL
3.2.1 Theory of Innovation Diffusion Rogers Model (1995)
Innovation Diffusion:
Implementation Success or Technology Adoption is depends the Compatibility of
Technology, Complexity of Technology, Relative Advantage (Perceived Need for
Technology) system (Rogers, 1995). Individuals are seen as possessing different
degrees of willingness to adopt innovations and thus it is generally observed that the
portion of the population adopting an innovation is approximately normally
distributed over time (Rogers, 1995). Breaking this normal distribution into segments
leads to the segregation of individuals into the following five categories of individual
innovativeness (from earliest to latest adopters): innovators (Figure 3), early adopters,
early majority, late majority, laggards (Rogers, 1995). Members of each category
typically possess certain distinguishing characteristics as shown below:
1.Innovators - venturesome, educated, multiple info sources
2.Early adopters - social leaders, popular, educated
3.Early majority - deliberate, many informal social contacts
4.Late majority - sceptical, traditional, lower socio-economic status
5.Laggards - neighbours and friends are main info sources, fear of debt
Figure 8. : Diffusion of Innovation Source: Roger 1995
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 35 35
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)Diffusion of Innovation Theory in Information System
Diffusion model
The model developed by Frank Bass (1969) and describes the process of how the new
product gets adopted as an interaction between users and prospects. It has been
described as one of the most famous empirical generalizations in marketing, along
with the Dirichlet Model of repeat buying and brand choice (Mark et al 1995). The
model is widely used in forecasting especially product forecasting and technology
forecasting. Mathematically, the basic Bass diffusion is a Riccati with constant
coefficients.
This model has been widely influential in marketing and management science. In
2004 it was selected as one of the ten most frequently cited papers in the 50-year
history of Management Science. It was ranked number five, and the only marketing
paper in the list. It was subsequently reprinted in the December 2004 issue of
Management Science.
(Moore and Benbasat, 1991), working in an Information System context, expanded
upon the five factors impacting the adoption of innovations presented by Rogers,
generating eight factors (voluntariness, relative advantage, compatibility, image, ease
of use, result demonstrability, visibility, and trialability) that impact the adoption of
Information Technology. Scales used to operationalize these factors were also
validated in the study.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 36 36
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Figure 9: Bass diffusion model of new adopters
Since the early applications of DOI to IS research the theory has been applied and
adapted in numerous ways. Research has, however, consistently found that technical
compatibility, technical complexity, and relative advantage (perceived need) are
important antecedents to the adoption of innovations see figure no. 4 (Bradford and
Florin, 2003; Crum et. al., 1996) leading to the generalized model.
Diffusion models only try to predict the type of customers only. But does not deal
with detailed the process of adoption. Hence does not focus more on the Consumer
Behaviour part of technology adoption.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 37 37
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)3.2.3 Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) (1975)
The Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) which was formulated in 1975 by Fishbein
and Ajzen has been used extensively in marketing research. Figure no.5presents a
diagrammatic model of the theory. TRA has been applied to explain the behaviour
beyond the acceptance of technology and includes four general concepts: behavioural
attitudes, subjective norms, intention to use and actual use. It argues that individuals
evaluate the consequences of a particular behaviour and create intentions to act that
are consistent with their evaluations. More specifically, TRA states that individuals'
behaviour can be predicted from their intentions, which can be predicted from their
attitudes and subjective norms. Following the chain of prediction further back,
attitudes can be predicted from an individual's beliefs about the consequences of the
behaviour. Subjective norms can be predicted by knowing how significant other
individuals think the behaviour should or should not be done.
Figure 10 :Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA)
A particularly helpful aspect of TRA from a technology perspective is its assertion
that any other factors that influence behavior do so only indirectly by influencing
attitude and subjective norms. Such variables would include, amongst others things,
the system design characteristics, user characteristics (including cognitive styles and
other personality variables) and task characteristics. Hence, TRA is quite appropriate
in the context of predicting the behavior of using multimedia technology. Although
TRA, is a very general theory and as such does not specify what specific beliefs
would be pertinent in particular situations.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 38 38
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)3.2.4 The Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB)
In exploring consumer's usage behavior, researchers adopt behaviour theories from
psychology and marketing. It is in this context that the TPB was constructed. The
TPB was proposed as an extension to the TRA mentioned earlier, by Ajzen in 1991.
The TPB sought to account for conditions where individuals do not have a complete
control over their behavior. When applied to the acceptance of information
technology systems or services, the model contains five concepts. As in TRA, it
includes behavioral attitudes, subjective norms, intention to use and actual use.
However, this theory interprets behavioral control as a perceived construct. Perceived
behavioral control covers both the intention to use and the actual usage. Actual usage
is in turn a weighted function of intention to use and perceived behavioral control.
Under this arrangement control aspects of the observation is introduced into the
model. This makes the TPB more functional in its application. Researchers have used
the TPB widely to model the acceptance of a variety of new information technologies
in businesses as well as to predict levels of usage.
Figure 11 :The Theory Planned Behaviour
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 39 39
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)3.2.5 Unified Theory of Use and Acceptance of Technology
A recent adoption theory formulated (Venkatesh et al. 2003) Unified Theory of
Acceptance and Use of Technology (UTUAT). UTUAT includes four core elements:
performance expectancy, effort expectancy, social influence and facilitating
conditions. These elements are direct determinants of information systems usage
intention and behaviour. In addition the model proposed that gender, age, experience,
and voluntariness of use mediate the impact of the four core elements on usage
intention and behaviour.
Figure 12 :Unified Theory of Use and Acceptance of Technology
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 40 40
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
The model has excellent explanatory power, and is able to explain up to 69 percent of
the variance in usage intention (Venkatesh et al., 2003). UTUAT has been widely
employed in studies of various IT innovations. Zhou et al. (2010) used UTUAT to
study Tablet Pc adoption, and found that performance expectancy, social influence
and facilitating conditions are direct predictors of user adoption, along with the extra
dimension of task technology fit. (Gupta,et. al., 2008) found that performance
expectancy, effort expectancy, social influence and facilitating conditions all
positively influence the use of the ICT. In addition UTUAT has been used in studying
users’ adoption of mobile wallets (Shin, 2009), health information technology
(Kijsanayotin et al., 2009) and intentions to continue using web-based learning (Chiu
and Wang, 2008).
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 41 41
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)3.3.1 Technology Acceptance Model (TAM)(1989)
The Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) (Davis, 1989; Davis,et. al., 1989)
examines the adoption of technology based on the perceived usefulness and ease of
use of the technology by the consumer. TAM theory applies its fundamentals to the
adoptions of technology, introducing variables like Perceived Usefulness (PU) and
Perceived Ease Of Use (PEOU) and removing Subjective Norms. The objective of
TAM is to provide an “explanation of the determinants of computer acceptance that is
general, capable of explaining usage behaviour across a broad range of systems or
end-user computing technologies and user populations, while at the same time being
both parsimonious and theoretically justified” (David, et. al.,1989,). Through TAM,
(Davis,1989) posits that an individual’s behavioural intention to adopt and use a
particular technology is determined by the individual’s attitude toward it. Two factors
contribute to the development of the Attitude (A): Perceived Usefulness (PU) and
Perceived Ease of Use (PEOU).
Will this technology enhance the individual’s performance professionally or socially?
Will the use of this technology be effortless? Each of these questions is a descriptor
for the factors. The two perceptions around usefulness (utility) and use are cognitions
around the innovation of technology. Usefulness is the cognitive evaluation of the
individual regarding the utility provided by the innovation.
Use is an indicator of the cognitive effort necessary to properly deploy the
technology. The usefulness variable is heavily influenced by the ease of use.
Figure 13 :The Technology Accptance Model
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 42 42
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)All other variables being equal, the easier the technology is perceived to be to use, the
useful it is perceived to be. A key strength of Technology Acceptance Model (TAM)
is its predictive power. It has been empirically verified as a tool for predicting
technology use (Szajna, 1996) and emerged as the dominant model in the literature
(Venkatesh, 2000; VenkateshandDavis, 1996; Szajna, 1994; Davis, 1989). Its
capability has been demonstrated to explain between 17% to 33% of the variance in
attitude and usage intentions (Thompson, et. al., 1991; Davis, et. al., 1989). The
variables introduced in this model, perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness,
continue to collect empirical support and momentum in predicted technology
acceptance behavior (Venkatesh, 2000: Venkatesh and Davis, 1996). As its popularity
is growing, Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) is being used outside of the
Information System research within the marketing discipline within consumer
research around online retail shopping (O’Cass and French, 2003;Childers, et. al.,
2001), buying intentions on the web (Gentry and Calantone, 2002) and understanding
technology-based self-service usage (Dabholkar and Bagozzi, 2002). Size as well as
the enterprise’s type of activity has an influenced on the adoption of technology
(Filiatrault and Huy 2006) Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) is a fairly efficient
model with a potential to help in understanding technology acceptance pre-service
teachers (Teo, 2010). All the independent variables (perceived usefulness, subjective
norm, and perceived ease of use) predict the attitude technology Acceptance (Shittu,
et. al, 2011).
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 43 43
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)3.3.2 Technology Acceptance Model 2
The original TAM model extended to explain perceived usefulness and usage
intentions in terms of social influence and cognitive instrumental processes
(Venkatesh and Davis 2000). As mentioned earlier, the original TAM model was
based on Aizen’s TRA model but did not include the subjective norms construct.
Since TAM’s introduction, consequent studies have built on TAM’s promising
robustness, trying to compare TAM to its origins and with other models used in
explaining technology acceptance such as diffusion of innovation which is discussed
in section 13. Previous studies agreed upon the need for adding other variables to
serve as determinants of the major construct since the original model lacked such
determinants for Perceived Usefulness (PU) & Perceived Ease of Use (PEOU).
TAM2, an extension of TAM, includes additional key determinants of perceived
usefulness and usage intention constructs which are meant to explain the changes in
technology acceptance over time as individuals gain experience in using the targeted
technology. Figure 9 shows the proposed model referred to as TAM2. The new model
incorporates additional theoretical constructs covering social influence processes
(subjective norm, voluntariness, and image) and cognitive instrumental processes (job
relevance, output quality, result demonstrability, and perceived ease of use).
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 44 44
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)Figure 14:
Figure 14:Technology Acceptance Model 2 (TAM2)
Venkateshand Davis explained the role of social influences in computer usage
contexts. According to them, TAM2 theorizes that the subjective norms direct effect
on intention over Perceived Usefulness (PU) & Perceived Ease Of Use (PEOU) will
occur in mandatory system usage settings. The model posits voluntariness as a
moderating variable to distinguish between mandatory versus voluntary compliance
with organizational settings. Nevertheless, subjective norms can influence intention
through Perceived Usefulness (PU) or what is called internalization.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 45 45
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)3.3.3 Technology Readiness Index(TRI)
Technology readiness (TR) refers to "people's propensity to embrace and use new
technologies to accomplish goals in home life and at work" (Parasuraman, 2000, p.
308). It combines the positive and negative technology-related beliefs. These beliefs
are assumed to vary among individuals. Collectively, these coexisting beliefs
determine a person's predisposition to interact with new technology (Parasuramanand
Colby 2001). Further, the findings show that these beliefs can be categorized into four
dimensions: optimism, innovativeness, discomfort, and insecurity (Parasuraman,
2000).
Optimism is defined as "a positive view of technology and a belief that it
[technology] offers people increased control, flexibility, and efficiency in their
lives" (Parasuramanand Colby, 2001, p. 34). It generally captures positive
feelings about technology.
Innovativeness is defined as "a tendency to be a technology pioneer and
thought leader" (Parasuramanand Colby 2001, p. 36). This dimension
generally measures to what degree individuals perceive themselves as being at
the forefront of technology adoption.
Discomfort is defined as "a perceived lack of control over technology and a
feeling of being overwhelmed by it" (Parasuraman and Colby 2001, p. 41).
This dimension generally measures the fear and concerns people experience
when confronted with technology.
Insecurity is defined as a "distrust of technology and scepticism about its
ability to work properly" (Parasuraman and Colby, 2001, p. 44). This
dimension focuses on concerns people may have in face of technology-based
transactions.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 46 46
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)Optimism and innovativeness are the drivers of technology readiness. High
score of these dimensions will increase overall technology
readiness.Discomfort and insecurity, on the other hand side, are inhibitors of
technology readiness. Thus, a high score of these dimensions will reduce
overall technology readiness (Parasuraman, 2000). Results show that the four
dimensions are fairly independent, each of them making a unique contribution
to an individual's technology readiness (Parasuraman and Colby, 2001).
Source: Parasuraman (2000, p. 34),Figure 15: Technology readiness Index
TRI emerged through an extensive multiphase research program in the United States.
In the final 36-item scale the four dimensions demonstrated, for purposes of group
analysis, a sound reliability with Cronbach's alpha ranging from .74 to .81. Further,
Parasuraman (2000) found a positive relationship between TR scores and technology-
related behaviours (i.e., ownership of new technology, use, and desirability to use in
the future). A replication in Great Britain has further strengthened the soundness of
the TRI. (Tsikriktsis 2004) extracted the same four-factor structure with Cronbach's
alpha ranging from .74 to .88. Both studies obtained large national cross sectional
samples by conducting random based telephone interviews: A total of 1000 adults
(over 18 years) participated in the United States, and 400 adults (over 16 years)
participated in Great Britain (Parasuraman, 2000; Tsikriktsis, 2004).
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 47 47
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)3.3.4 Technology Acceptance Model 3
A third iteration of the TAM model (TAM 3) was created, combining TAM 2 and the
determinants based on perceived ease of use by incorporating the findings of previous
research in order to improve acceptance rates of new technologies. The TAM 3 model
contains both factors influencing perceived ease of use (computer self-efficacy,
computer anxiety, computer playfulness, perceptions of external control, perceived
enjoyment and objective usability) and perceived usefulness (perceived ease of use,
subjective norm, image, and result demonstrability). The goal of the revised model is
to produce practical guidance and suggestions to practitioners (Venkatesh and Bala,
2008). TAM 3 longitudinal testing by Venkatesh and Bala (2008)identifies many new
relationships between variables. Specifically, perceived ease of use, subjective norm,
image, and result demonstrability are significant predictors of perceived usefulness at
all time periods. When participants experience increasing output quality, job
relevance has a strong positive effect on perceived usefulness. Additionally, with
increasing experience, the subjective norm has less effect than perceived usefulness.
The anchors (computer self-efficacy, computer anxiety, computer playfulness, and
perceptions of external control) are significant predictors of perceived ease of use at
all points in time and adjustments of perceived enjoyment and objective usability
become significant at later times to perceived ease of use. Finally, perceived
usefulness is the strongest predictor of technology acceptance and use at all times
(Venkatesh and Bala, 2008). While research efforts to develop TAM and TAM 2 were
interested in identifying relationships between variables, TAM 3 focuses on
producing actionable points for practioners. Researchers divide their advice into two
stages: pre-implementation interventions and post-implementation (Venkatesh and
Bala, 2008). The pre-implementation stage occurs during the development and
deployment of a technology. Venkatesh and Bala (2008) suggest that
managers/administrators encourage user participation by allowing the employees to
help pick out new technology. Also, good managerial support of the new system is
needed. Lastly, they suggest managers/administrators implement an incentive
alignment, which entails matching the individual’s perception of the new technology
with his/her job requirements and value system (Venkatesh and Bala, 2008). The
TAM 3 Model is shown in figure no.10.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 48 48
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Figure 16: Technology Acceptance Model 3
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 49 49
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)As per the TAM 3 model, it is suggested that the determinants of perceived ease of
use will not influence perceived usefulness. The determinants of perceived ease of use
suggested by Venkatesh (2000) are primarily individual differences variables and
general beliefs about computers and computer use. These variables are grouped into
three categories: control beliefs, intrinsic motivation, and emotion. Perceived
usefulness is an instrumental belief that is conceptually similar to extrinsic motivation
and is cognition (as opposed to emotion) regarding the benefits of using a system. The
perceptions of control (over a system), enjoyment or playfulness related to a system,
and anxiety regarding the ability to use a system do not provide a basis for forming
perceptions of instrumental benefits of using a system. For example, control over
using a system does not guarantee that the system will enhance one’s job
performance. Similarly, higher levels of computer playfulness or enjoyment from
using a system do not mean that the system will help an individual to become more
effective (e.g., Van der Heijden, 2004). Therefore, it is expect that the determinants
of perceived ease of use will not influence perceived usefulness.
The summary of the various constructs used for in various adoption models are
summarised and listed in the table 2.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 50 50
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)Table 1:Models and Theories of Individual Acceptance
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 51 51
Models and Theories Constructs
Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) by Fishbein and Ajzen (1975) derives from psychology to measure behavioral intention and performance.
Attitude Subjective norm
Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) by Davis (1989) develops new scale with two specific variables to determine user acceptance of technology.
Technology Acceptance Model 2 (TAM2) by Venkatesh and Davis (2000) is adapted from TAM and includes more variables.
Perceived UsefulnessPerceived Ease of UseSubjective Norm*Experience*Voluntariness*Image*Job Relevance*Output Quality*Result Demonstrability** indicates TAM2 only
Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB) by Ajzen (1991) extends TRA by including one more variable to determine intention and behavior.
Attitude Subjective normPerceived Behavioral Control
Combined TAM and TPB (C-TAM-TPB) by Taylor and Todd (1995).
Perceived UsefulnessPerceived Ease of Use Attitude Subjective normPerceived Behavioral Control
Innovation Diffusion Theory (IDT) by Rogers (1962) is adapted to information systems innovations by Moore and Benbasat (1991). Five attributes from Rogers’ model and two additional constructs are identified.
Relative Advantage*Compatibility*Complexity*Observability*Trialability*ImageVoluntariness of Use* indicates Roger’s constructs.
Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology Model (UTUAT) by Venkatesh et al. (2003) integrates above theories and models to measure user intention and usage on technology
Performance ExpectancyEffort ExpectancyAttitude toward Using TechnologySocial InfluenceFacilitating ConditionsSelf-EfficacyAnxiety
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Taking this into consideration, the present study focuses on Tablet pc adoption
models that influence the adoption of Tablet pc. For this purpose, Theory Technology
acceptance model (TAM) perceived risk was used to construct a conceptual model to
study the adoption Tablet pc. It is important for Tablet pc service providers to
understand the factors influencing the intention to use or adopt Tablet pc. Further, this
study also validates the model by explaining the behavioral intentions from the user’s
perspective; the findings of this research not only help Tablet manufactures to develop
a more user-accepted Tablet pc adoption, but also provide insight into the best way to
promote new systems to potential users
3.4.1 Application of Adoption Models
The application of adoption models for various technology products are summarized
and presented in table no. 2. The following table i.e. Usage technology Adoption
Model lists the key application studies carried details in the area of technology
adoption. The table gives the details of the technology selected for the study and also
the details of the adoption models used for the validation.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 52 52
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
4. Application of Technology Adoption models.
Table No : 02Sl.No Year Name of author Sector/industries About
01 2009 Marie Pierre Healthcare A questionnaire, based on the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM), was developed. A panel of experts in technology assessment evaluated the face and content validity of the instrument. Two hundred and thirty-four questionnaires were distributed among nurses and doctors of the cardiology, pulmonologist, and internal medicine departments of a tertiary hospital. Cronbach alpha was calculated to measure the internal consistency of the questionnaire items. Construct validity was evaluated using interitem correlation analysis. Logistic regression analysis was performed to test the theoretical model. Adjusted odds ratios (ORs) and their 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were computed. Results: A response rate of 39.7% was achieved. With the exception of one theoretical construct (Habit) that corresponds to behaviors that become automatized, Cronbach’s alpha values were acceptably high for the remaining constructs. Theoretical variables were well correlated with each other and with the dependent variable. The original TAM was good at predicting telemonitoring usage intention, Perceived Usefulness being the only significant predictor (OR: 5.28, 95% CI: 2.12–13.11). The model was still significant and more powerful when the other theoretical variables were added. However, the only significant predictor in the modified model was Facilitators (OR: 4.96, 95% CI: 1.59–15.55).
02 2009 Vincent S. Lai internet banking The technology acceptance model (TAM) has been applied in different contexts to investigate a wide range of information technologies (IT), and a cumulative tradition has already been developed in this stream of research. Most TAM studies have been empirical investigations, using the survey approach with great success.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 53 53
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
TAM is a mature model and has been validated in different contexts. However, it still needs to be empirically investigated for its invariance across different respondent subgroups in order to make sure that different sample profiles would not have a negative effect on the findings. Unfortunately, this has not happened in most TAM research. Here, we applied different levels of invariance analysis on the TAM construct in the context of Internet banking acceptance.
03 2012 Versha Mehta Self-Service
Technologies in
Banks
Self-service technologies have found an immense use in our daily activities owing to
the rapid advancement in technology, paradigm shift in the taste and changing life-style
of consumers as well. To provide maximum benefit to their consumers, the firms have
been continuously finding alternatives to services which are in consonance with
consumer's needs, expectation and life-style besides providing them the satisfaction.
Hence, present study is an understanding of factors that lead to the formation of
consumer's attitude towards using self-service technology and finally its acceptance.
04 2011 Hala Al-Khatib
& Habin Lee
E-Government This paper proposes a conceptual model to explain user acceptance of E-Government systems considering the diverse layers of user groups. Due to digital division developing countries are providing e-Government services to heterogeneous user groups including non-educated and less skilful citizens for using computer based systems. Therefore this paper considers support quality of E-Government systems is one of critical success factors and integrates the factor in a widely adopted user
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 54 54
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
acceptance and success model of information systems.
05 2012 Abdulaziz
Alrashidi
E-Government The study has been focused on the integration of motivation into the technology acceptance model (TAM) and theory of planned behavior (TPB) towards using e Government. An online survey was created to measure the user opinion about the e Government ease of use, usefulness, and motivation.
06 2013 Hari Mohan &
Norani Ahmad
internet banking The objective of this study is to determine factors that influence individual intention towards online banking In Malaysia. Specifically, the study examines the influence of Self Efficacy (6 item), Trust (6 item), Perceived Ease of Use (5 item) and Media reference (4 item) on the intention towards Online banking. Each variable is measured using 7-point interval scale. To achieve a more balance findings among the internet banking users in Malaysia, a total of 250 questionnaires to online bank customers at 4 major banks in Klang Valley, Selangor, and across the major cities in Penang, Ipoh & Johor. 210 usable questionnaires were returned with a response rate of 84%. The data was analysed using SPSS. It was found that Self Efficiency; Trust; Perceived Ease of Use are significantly related to the intention to adopt internet banking among the users in Malaysia. Perceived Ease of Use was the main determinant towards the intention for online banking as compared to Self-Efficacy and Trust.
07 2013 Nurudeen
Abdulkadir &
Shehu Inuwa
Galoji
Mobile Banking This study extends the applicability of Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) and Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB) constructs to investigate the significant factors influencing users’ adoption of mobile banking services in one of the Malaysian public universities. The research model was empirically tested through a survey. Data collected from 125 respondents were analyzed by means of multiple regression. Findings showed that perceived usefulness and social influence have significant impact on mobile banking adoption.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 55 55
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
08 2011 Yi-Hsuan Lee &
Yi-Chuan Hsieh
E-Learning This study intends to investigate factors affecting business employees’ behavioral intentions to use the E- Learning system. Combining the innovation diffusion theory (IDT) with the technology acceptance model (TAM), the present study proposes an extended technology acceptance model. The proposed model was tested with data collected from 552 business employees using the e-learning system in Taiwan. The results show that five perceptions of innovation characteristics significantly influenced employees’ e-learning system behavioral intention. The effects of the compatibility, complexity, relative advantage, and trial ability on the perceived usefulness are significant. In addition, the effective of the complexity, relative advantage, trial ability, and complexity on the perceived ease of use have a significant influence. Empirical results also provide strong support for the integrative approach.
09 2011 Henny
Medyawati
Marieta
Christiyanti &
Muhammad
Yunanto
E- Banking The object of this research is customers on the five major banks in the city of Bekasi namely Bank Mandiri, BCA, BRI, Bank Danamon, and BNI. This study aimed to analyze the implementation of E-Banking with the approach of Technology Acceptance Model (TAM). The research method is a survey method with a descriptive analysis and statistical analysis. The data is processed and analyzed by multiple linear regression statistical models using statistical software. The results of this study indicate that the person's ability to use computers, and interface design does not significantly influence perceived ease of use. Experience of computer use, relevance, security and privacy significantly influence the perceived ease of use.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 56 56
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
10 2013 L. Hartmann, F.
Kerssenfischer
T. Fritsch, and T.
Nguyen
Customer Self-
Service Portals
The attitude of users towards an online customer self-service portal, which is newly introduced by one of the biggest finance companies worldwide, is the focus of this article. The Technology Acceptance Model (TAM), proposed by Davis in 1986, is applied to evaluate 521 customer responses to a questionnaire consisting of 22 questions.The authors choose partial least squares (PLS) as statistical instrument and define “attitude of customers towards the online self-service portal” as the dependent variable. Apart from this, six factors are specified to directly or indirectly correlate with attitude.
11 2013 Mohamed Gamal
Aboelmaged
and Tarek R.
Gebba
Mobile Banking This study aims at extending our understanding regarding the adoption of mobile banking through integrating Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) and Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB). Analyzing survey data from 119 respondents yielded important findings that partially support research hypotheses. The results indicated a significant positive impact of attitude toward mobile banking and subjective norm on mobile banking adoption. Surprisingly, the effects of behavioral control and usefulness on mobile banking adoption were insignificant.
12 2011 Basheer A. Al-
alak
&
E-Learning The aim of the study was to investigate Jordanian lecturers' attitudes towards the adoption of e-learning system. A number of hypotheses were formulated for this purpose. The findings of the study show that there existed positive relationship between perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, computer knowledge, management support and intention to adopt. Whereas there existed negative relationship between normative pressure, computer anxiety and intention to adopt.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 57 57
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Ibrahim A.M.
Alnawas
Based on the results a number of recommendations were proposed, and suggestions for future studies were made.
13 2013 Shallone K.
Chitungo
&
Simon Munongo
Mobile Banking Improvements in wireless technologies and increased uptake of advanced mobile handsets have led to a growing trend in mobile banking activities on a global scale. This empirical study sought to investigate the applicability of the extension of the renowned framework of Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) in determining factors that influence unbanked rural communities Zimbabwe‟s intention to adopt mobile banking services. A self-administered questionnaire was developed and distributed in Zaka, Chiredzi, Gutu and Chivi rural districts Out of the 400 questionnaires, only 275 useable questionnaires were returned, yielding a response rate of 69%.Results were subsequently analyzed by the SPSS package. The findings indicate that the extended TAM can predict consumer intention to use mobile banking.
14 2012 Geetha
Kallanmartho
di and
Malarvizhi
Vaithiyanatha
n
E-Banking Financial liberalization and technology revolution have allowed the developments of new and more efficient delivery and processing channels as well as more innovative products and services in banking industry. A strategic challenge facing banking institutions today is the growing and changing needs and expectations of consumers in tandem with increased education levels and growing wealth. Consumers are becoming increasingly discerning and have become more involved in their financial decisions. This study determines the factors influencing the consumer’s adoption of e-banking in India and hence investigates the influence of perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use and perceived risk on use of e-banking. It is an essential part of a bank’s strategyformulation process in an emerging economy like India. Survey based questionnaire design with empirical test was carried out. The results have supported the hypothesis that banks need to highlight the benefits of e-banking, make it easy to use, and enhance
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 58 58
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
its security to improve consumers’ trust.
15 2014 Dany Fabian
&
Römer,
Benedikt
Health care Today’s healthcare systems face tremendous challenges: demographic change and an ageing society lead to increasing healthcare needs and costs. Telemedical systems (TMS) might be an answer by improving healthcare systems’ efficiency and effectiveness. However, the diffusion of such systems is still low. A major barrier is the lack of acceptance by the key players in healthcare: physicians. To enhance the understanding of their intention to use TMS, we propose a comprehensive conceptual model and tested it empirically with survey data gathered from 213 medical doctors in Germany. Our statistical analysis confirms a very high explanatory power of the model. We extend the body of knowledge in this field of research by showing significant influences on physicians’ intentions to use TMS. The influencing factors stem from physicians’ technological contexts (data security and data reliability), financial contexts (billability and costs), individual contexts (technology affinity, subjective norms and motivations), and organizational contexts (compatibility of TMS with existing processes).
16 2013 Belghis Bavarsad
&
Mohammad Ali
Mennatyan
E-Government This paper tries to study the effects that the technology acceptance factors have on e-government services users’ satisfaction. The study data were gathered from a sample of 396 users of e-government services in Booshehr Province, Iran. The data collection tool was a structured questionnaire, its reliability was confirmed by Cronbach's alpha coefficient (α=0.91). Data were analyzed by Structural equation modeling (SEM) usingAMOS software. The analysis results indicated a good fit for the proposed model and the research findings also supported the positive and significant effect of the ease of use, trust, content and appearance of information and perceived usefulness on e-service
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 59 59
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
users’ satisfaction. However, no significant relationship was found between citizens support with the users’ satisfaction of e-service quality.
17 2013 Rawan T.
Khasawneh,
Wafa'a A.
Rabayah &
Emad A. Abu-
Shanab
E-Government Governments, all over the world, are trying so hard to increase the efficiency of their departments by using automated systems, replacing traditional services and providing online service channels which could be described as the primary features of technological revolution. This paper identifies trust and risk as important factors that could affect the usage of e-government application in a way that more trust of e-government application will decrease fear of using it and reduce risk issue. In order to achieve the goal of this paper that focused on trust and risk as two important factors that affect Jordanians’ intentions to use technology, an empirical test was conducted and resulted in moderate means regarding 5 major constructs.
18 2011 Panagiotis
Ketikidis,
Tomislav,
Dimitrovski,
Peter Bath,
Lambros Lazuras
Health Care The response of Health Professionals to the use of health information technology (IT)
is an important research topic that can partly explain the success or failure of any
Health IT application. The present study applied a modified version of the revised
Technology Acceptance Model1 to assess the relevant beliefs, and acceptance of
Health IT systems in a sample of health professionals (N = 133). Structured
anonymous questionnaires were used and a cross-sectional design was employed. The
main outcome measure was the intention to use Health IT systems. Analysis of
Variance (ANOVA) was employed to examine differences in TAM-related variables
between nurses and medical doctors, and no significant differences were found.
Multiple linear regression analysis was used to assess the predictors of Health IT usage
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 60 60
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
intentions. The findings showed that perceived ease of use, but not usefulness,
relevance and subjective norms directly predicted Health IT usage intentions. The
present findings suggest that a modification of the original TAM approach is needed to
better understand health professionals’ support and endorsement of Health IT.
Perceived ease of use, relevance of Health IT to the medical and nurse professions, as
well as social influences should be tapped by information campaigns aiming to enhance
support for Health IT in healthcare settings.
19 2013 Rahmath
Safeena, Hema
Date, Nisar
Hundewale, and
Abdullah
Kammani
Internet Banking Internet banking (IB) is the latest and most innovative service and is the new trendamong the consumers. The transformation from the traditional banking to e-banking has been a 'leap' change. This study determines the factors for the consumer acceptance of internet banking and hence investigates the influence of perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, subjective norm, attitude and perceived behavioral control on use of IB among consumers. It is an essential part of a bank‘s strategy to formulate a model for popularizing the technology adopted to provide customer services. Therefore in this study an integration of TAM and TPB is done. Survey based questionnaire design with empirical test was carried out.
20 2010 Yitbarek Takele
&
E-Banking This study is undertaken to analyze factors that influence customers’ intention to adopt e-banking service channels in Bahir Dar city. A conceptual framework was developed by integrating six variables from theory of planned behavior, technology acceptance model and previous studies. The findings revealed that attitude, subjective norm,
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 61 61
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Zeleke Sira perceived behavioral control, perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use and perceived risk were significant in affecting users’ intention to use e-banking service channels. The construct perceived behavioral control emerged as a dominant factor followed by attitudes and perceived usefulness in predicting an individual’s intention to adopt e-banking service channels. Finally, attitude is jointly predicted by perceived behavioral control, perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use and perceived risk while perceived ease of use contributed more for the variation in attitude.
21 2012 Mohammed
Alshehri, Steve
Drew and Rayed
AlGhamdi
E-Government this paper explores the key factors of Saudi citizens’ acceptance through a research survey and by gathering empirical evidence based on the Unified Theory of Acceptance and the Use of Technology (UTAUT). Survey Data collected from 400 respondents was examined using structural equation modeling (SEM) technique and utilized AMOS tools. The study results explored the factors that affect the acceptance of e-government services in KSA based on UTAUT model. Moreover, as a result of this study an amended UTAUT model was proposed. Such a model contributes to the discussion and development of adoption models for technology.
22 2012 José Asua,
Estibalitz
Orruño, Eva
Reviriego
Healthcare A pilot experimentation of a telemonitoring system for chronic care patients is conducted in the Bilbao Primary Care Health Region (Basque Country, Spain). It seems important to understand the factors related to healthcare professionals’ acceptance of this new technology in order to inform its extension to the whole healthcare system.This study aims to examine the psychosocial factors related to telemonitoring acceptance among healthcare professionals and to apply a theory-based instrument.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 62 62
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
and
Marie Pierre
Gagnon
23 2014 Mohammad
Kamel Alomari
E-Government E-government has been considered as one approach for changing the face of government in the eyes of the citizenry. Therefore, citizens’ socialization in relation to their engagement with e-government should be explored. This study argues that citizens played a significant role in determining the success of an e-government project in the Middle Eastern country of Jordan. This paper aims to provide insight and evaluation into the factors that could influence e-government’s effective functioning in the Jordanian social community through its interaction with citizens. The study collected data from 356 Jordanian citizens via a survey, to ascertain their understanding of 10 factors that may influence their intention to use e-government services.
24 2011 Md Gapar Md
Johar and Janatul
Akmar Ahmad
Awalluddin
E-Commerce As the use of the Internet continues to grow in all aspects of daily life, there is an increasing need to better understand what trends of internet usage and to study the barriers and problem of ecommerce adoption. Hence, the purpose of this research is to define how far Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) contributed in e-commerce adoption. Data for this study was collected by the means of a survey conducted in Malaysia in 2010. A total of 611 questionnaire forms were delivered to respondents. The location of respondents was within Penang state. By studying this sample, conclusions would be drawn to generalize the interests of the population.
25 2014 Ali AlSoufi Mobile Banking Mobile applications have been rapidly changing the way business organizations deliver their services to their customers and how customers can interact with their service
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 63 63
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
and Hayat Ali providers in order to satisfy their needs. The use of mobile applications increases rapidly, and has been used in many segments including banking segment. This research aims at extending the Technology Adoption Model (TAM) to incorporate the role of factors in influencing customer’s perception towards M-banking adoption.
26 2014 Ni Nyoman
Kerti Yasa,
Luh Putu Rara
Ayu
Ratnaningrum &
Putu Gde
Sukaatmadja
Internet Banking The analysis unit of this study was clients of the five major banks in Denpasar. This study aimed to analyze the implementation of internet banking using Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) approach. The research method was SEM which was processed by using SPSS dan AMOS. The results of this study showed that both perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness had significant and positive effects on the attitude towards using internet banking. Both perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness also had positive and significant effects on actual usage. Attitude toward using had a significant and positive relationship with actual usage.
27 2010 Adesina
Aderonke
E-Banking This paper focuses on determining the level of users’ acceptance of the electronic banking services and investigating the factors that determine users’ behavioral intentions to use electronic banking systems in Nigeria.
The survey instrument employed involved design and administration of a total of 500 survey questionnaires within the Lagos metropolis and its environs. An extended Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) was employed as a conceptual framework to investigate the factors that influence users’ acceptance and intention to use electronic banking. To test the model, data was collected from 292 customers from various
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 64 64
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
commercial banks in Nigeria. The model measured the impact of Perceived Credibility (PC), Computer Self-Efficacy (CSE), Perceived Usefulness (PU), and Perceived Ease of Use (PEOU) on customer attitude and customer attitude on customer adaptation
.28 2011 Shih-Chih Chen,
Shing-Han Li
&
Chien-Yi Li
E-Learning
&
Mobile Banking
Technology Acceptance Model is widely applied to accessusers’ usage in various information system/information technology areas. Learning the critical role of Technology Acceptance Model can guide researchers to design different users’ interface for different online customers, and consequently achieve high user usage in different application areas. This study reviewed 24studiesto understand the past, nowand future of Technology Acceptance Model. We discussedthe related studies to clarify the extension of Technology Acceptance Model. Besides, the application areas are elaborated including electronic service, mobile data service, self-service technology, electronic learning and so on. Finally, the article concluded the conclusions and future research direction.
29 2012 David W.S. Tai,
Ren-Cheng
Zhang,
Sheng-Hung
E-Learning This study reports results of a meta-analytic path analysis e-learning Acceptance Model with k = 27 studies, Databases searched included Information Sciences Institute (ISI) website. Variables recorded included perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, attitude toward behavior, and behavioral intention to use e-learning. A correlation matrix of these variables was derived from meta-analytic data and then analyzed by using structural path analysis to test the fitness of the e-learning acceptance model to the observed aggregated data. Results showed the revised hypothesized model to be a reasonable, good fit to aggregated data.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 65 65
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Chang,
Chin-Pin Chen,
Jia-Ling Chen
30 2010 Bo Cheng &
Minhong Wang
E-Learning Investigating the influences of organizational contexts on employees’ perception on competency-based workplace E-learning and their intention to adopt this new learning approach in work environment. whether organizational context factors will impact employees’ perception of competency-oriented workplace E-learning; or whether employee’s perceptions have influences on their intention to use competency-oriented workplace E-learning.
31 2009 C. Boshoff Mobile Banking The role of consumer behavior in the marketing of new technology, and gain an understanding of the TAM and identify beliefs about internet banking that could influence Perceived ease of use and Perceived usefulness of cell phone banking.
32 2013 Tony Dwi
Susanto
E-government In order to develop more acceptable e-government services, government needs to understand the factors influencing citizens to use the services. This paper reviews prior studies on acceptable e-government services and accepting users of e-government services. Demographic characteristics of the users, the impact of culture, and the psychological factors for using e-government services are discussed. By understanding and measuring the adoption factors, government may predict acceptance of a new e-government service, evaluate an existing e-government service, and improve acceptance of the service by defining and running management strategies.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 66 66
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
33 2012 Alfie Chacko
Punnoose
E-Learning The purpose of this study was to find some of the predominant factors that determine the intention of students to use eLearning in the future. Since eLearning is not just a technology acceptance decision but also involves cognition, this study extended its search beyond the normal technology acceptance variables into variables that could affect the cognition of an individual due to his or her unique characteristics.
The variables in the literature of technology acceptance studies can be classified broadly into 5 categories. They are Individual Differences, Beliefs, Attitude, Behavioral Intention, and Actual Behavior. Since the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) is the most widely used model to study the acceptance of technology, this study adopted TAM and further extended it based on the recommendations from the literature of information systems and information technology.
34 2010 Ayo, C.K E-Banking The most widely used e-Banking instrument in nigeria is e-Payment, particularly the automatic teller machine (ATM) card. However, with the adoption of e-Banking by all the banks in nigeria, the volume of cash in circulation has continued to increase pre-and-post bank recapitalization/consolidation exercise. Furthermore, some of the 25banks that survived the exercise were found lately to have depleted their capital base and have lost credibility before the consumers, e-Banking implementation notwithstanding.
This paper, we review the state of e-Banking implementation in _igeria and evaluate the influence of trust on the adoption of e-Payment using an extended technology acceptance model (TAM). Similarly, we investigate organizational reputation, perceived risk and perceived trust in the management of banks as a factor for enhancing customer loyalty.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 67 67
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
35 2011 Abdelghani
Echchabi
Internet Banking The main purpose of this paper is to study the future prospects of online banking in Morocco, based on the technology acceptance model, by examining the intention of theMoroccan customers to adopt online banking and the factors that influence it. The questionnaire used in this study was distributed to 300 Moroccan banks’ customers, and the data gathered were then analyzed using structural equation modelling. The results indicate that perceived ease of use has a significant positive influence on the perceived usefulness of online banking, and both the variables have a significant positive influence on the attitude towards online banking. The latter further has a significant positive influence on the intention to adopt online banking services in Morocco. Furthermore, the invariance analysis showed that the influence is different for male and female customers. It is noteworthy that this is the first study to be conducted on online banking services in Morocco.
36 2013 Amer Al-
Adwan
&
Ahmad Al-
Adwan
E-Learning Today’s rapid changing world highlights the influence and impact of technology in all aspects of learning life. Higher Education institutions in developed Western countries believe that these developments offer rich opportunities to embed technological innovations within the learning environment. This places developing countries, striving to be equally competitive in international markets, under tremendous pressure to similarly embed appropriate blends of technologies within their learning and curriculum approaches, and consequently enhance and innovate their learning experiences. Although many universities across the world have incorporated internet based learning systems, the success of their implementation requires an extensive understanding of the end user acceptance process. Learning using technology has become a popular approach within higher education institutions due to the continuous growth of Internet innovations and technologies.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 68 68
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
This paper focuses on the investigation of students, who attempt to successfully adopt e-learning systems at universities in Jordan. The conceptual research framework of e-learning adoption, which is used in the analysis, is based on the technology acceptance model. The study also provides an indicator of students’ acceptance of e-learning as well as identifying the important factors that would contribute to its successful use.
37 2009 Sung Youl Park E-Learning It is obvious that the number of e-learning opportunities provided by higher educational institutes continues to grow in Korea. Yet little research has been done to verify the process of how university students adopt and use e-learning. A sample of 628 university students took part in the research. The structural equation modeling (SEM) technique was employed with the LISREL program to explain the adoption process. The general structural model, which included e-learning self efficacy, subjective norm, system accessibility, perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, attitude, and behavioral intention to use e-learning, was developed based on the technology acceptance model (TAM). The result proved TAM to be a good theoretical tool to understand users’ acceptance of e-learning. E-learning self efficacy was the most important construct, followed by subjective norm in explicating the causal process in the model.
38 2012 Kirendharen
Nadarajh Pillay
E-Government This research project examines the predictors that make e-government projects successful or unsuccessful. The aim of this research is to determine the factors that can lead to an e-government project's success or failure. This is done within the South African context. The factors are determined via a Literature survey of selected implementations around the world. Existing e-government implementations, SARS e-Filing and eNaTIS were assessed using the Technology Acceptance Model(TAM). Factors such as having a governmental policy, marketing, training and change
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 69 69
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
management are identified as positive factors. Impediments such as the digital divide, lack of skills, lack of penetration of technologies to all citizens have been determined as challenges to e-government. It is recommended that investigation into mobile phone technologies be done to bridge the telecommunications gap.
39 2010 Kelvin Joseph
Bwalya and
Mike Healy
E-Government There has recently been an escalation of e-Government initiatives in the Southern African Development Community (SADC) region, with South Africa, Mauritius, Seychelles and Botswana leading the way towards this cause. Evidence indicates e-Government implementation projects in this region either fail or succeed. Therefore it is important that before actual implementation is commissioned, there is need to understand the different challenges that come with e-Government implementations such as investment risks, failure to be adopted by the general citizenry, abandoning already-commissioned e-Government activities, and so forth. Such problems can be avoided by putting in place a properly and carefully authored e-Government adoption strategy that takes care of the local context and the multi-dimensionality of e-Government. This paper, with strong reference to Davis’ 1989 Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) theoretical underpinning, proposes a conceptual e-Government adoption model that may be commensurate with promoting the growth of e-Government in the SADC region. However, the limitation of this proposed model is that it has not been empirically tested and leaves room for its further validation. The paper follows up on the status of e-Government implementation in the SADC region by presenting two case studies that detail what interventions and initiatives have been put in place to encourage e-Government in Botswana and Zambia.
40 2010 Anna Che Azmi E-Filing The e-filing system is an important e-government service in Malaysia. This paper
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 70 70
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
and Ng Lee Bee investigates the factors that lead to the acceptance of e-filing among taxpayers by using TAM. This study proposes a model consisting of three constructs, which are perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use and perceived risk. The model proposed by this study is a simpler model compared to other studies on e-filing. The confirmatory factor analysis shows that the model is an adequate fit. Based on the data collected from 166 respondents, the results showed that the proposed model explained up to 61% of the variance in behavioral intention. All of the variables significantly influence behavioral intention. The perceived risk construct has a negative association with the perceived usefulness construct. However, there is no significant association between the perceived risk and perceived ease of use constructs.
41 2010 Cora Sio Kuan
Lai and
Guilherme Pires
E-Government Overall, the study proposes that user perceptions about the e-Government portal influence user attitude towards the portal. An Internet survey collected data from 464 online users of Macao‟s e-government portal. The model was found to explain a large proportion of the variance in citizen’s intention to reuse the portal. The portal partially mediates the relationship between success factors and intention-to-reuse. The results provide evidence that Information Quality, System Quality and Social Influence (but not Perceived Effectiveness) are success factors influencing user satisfaction and adoption. It is recommended that portal management needs to ensure ease-of-use, currency and accuracy of the supplied information. Timely information updating is a major concern for the e-Government portal in Macao. The content an e-government portal that is perceived by users to be easier to navigate is likely to facilitate satisfaction and reuse.
42 2013 Ali Tarhini, Kate E-Learning A number of studies have shown that e-learning implementation is not simply a technological solution, but a process of many different factors such as social and
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 71 71
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Hone, and
Xiaohui Liu
behavioral contexts. Yet little is known about the important rule of such factors in technology adoption and use in the context of developing countries such as Lebanon. Therefore, the main objective of our study is to empirically validate an extended Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) (to include Social Norms and Quality of Work Life constructs) in the Lebanese context.
43 2009 Raies Ahmad
Mir &
Dr. Altaf A Dar
E-Banking Financial liberalization and technology revolution have allowed the developments of new and more efficient delivery and processing channels as well as more innovative products and services in banking industry. Banking institutions are facing competition not only from each other but also from non - bank financial intermediaries as well as from alternative sources of financing. Another strategic challenge facing banking institutions today is the growing and changing needs and expectations of consumers in tandem with increased education levels and growing wealth. Consumers are becoming increasingly discerning and have become more involved in their financial decisions. The world is changing at a staggering rate and technology is considered to be the key driver for these changes around us. An analysis of technology and its uses show that it has permeated in almost every aspect of our life. Many activities are handled electronically due to the acceptance of information technology at home as well as at workplace. Slowly but steadily, the Indian customer is moving towards the internet banking. The ATM and the Net transactions are becoming popular. This paper investigates the factors which are affecting the acceptance of e- banking services among the customers. An initial conceptualization was developed from mainstream literature to be validated through empirical research. The conceptualization was then tested with primary quantitative survey data collected from students studying in different colleges/Universities of Kashmir Division of state J&K. Correlation and regression analysis and Sign. two-tailed were used to test the key hypothesis derived
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 72 72
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
from literature.
44 2013 Tapani Rinta-
Kahila
Retail Self-Service Self-service technologies (SSTs) are becoming increasingly essential drivers of business success. A large-scale utilization tends to be a prerequisite for a successful information technology (IT) investment. This study investigates the determinants of technology adoption in the case of self service checkouts (SCOs) in Finnish grocery stores. The objectives are to confirm the determinants of intention to use SCOs, examine the link between behavioral intention to use and actual use, and study how a contextual variable may act as a trigger that turns the intention into actual use. In addition, the influence of some relevant control variables is taken under scrutiny.
45 2009 Hassan M. Selim E-Learning This study develops an E-Learning Acceptance Model (ELAM) to investigate the relationships among the factors affecting students’ acceptance of e-learning. In line with the literature, three critical success factors were used, namely instructor characteristics, information technology infrastructure, and support. ELAM was analyzed and validated using data collected from 538 university students through structural equation modeling (LISREL 8.54). The influence of the three factors on students’ decision of accepting e-learning was empirically examined. The results showed that all three factors significantly and directly impacted the students’ decision of accepting e-learning-based university program. Information technology infrastructure and the institution support were proven to be key determinants of the instructor characteristics as a critical success factor of e-learning acceptance by students. Implications of this work are very important for higher education institutions, researchers, and instructors.
46 2009 S. Poelmans, P. E-learning E-learning systems, also known as a virtual learning environments (VLE’s), are
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 73 73
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Wessa, K. Milis,
E. Bloemen, C.
Doom
systems that use modern information and communication technology to support education and training efforts. In this paper we present the evaluation of a newly developed Compendium Platform (CP) that can be used to create educational applications that support effective learning of statistics and related analytical skills. Using the web-enabled CP, students are empowered to easily archive, exchange and reproduce statistical computations. The CP was applied in three statistics courses. Based on behavioral concepts from the Technology Acceptance Model (usefulness, ease of use and future usage intention) and object-based beliefs about the e-learning environment (information and system qualities), we tested an integrated and predictive e-learning acceptance model. Using a sample of 200 students, we report that the CP was well accepted and that the majority of our hypotheses are confirmed. System quality has a considerable impact on ease of use and does directly influence the students’ intention to use the CP in the future. The effect of information quality on intention is fully mediated by relative advantage. Relative advantage was used as an alternative to usefulness and is clearly a better predictor of usage intention. A detailed analysis indicates that the attractiveness of the user interface, the presence of appropriate search options and the availability of sufficient relevant information are critical success factors of the CP’s acceptance.
47 2013 Eugenia M. W.
Ng, Ronnie H.
Shroff, and Cher
Ping Lim
E-Portfolio The study involved student teachers enrolled in the Bachelor of Education English Language Programme at the Hong Kong Institute of Education. Students (N = 77) participated in a pilot study by electronically submitting their field experience portfolios in their third and fourth year of study. Student teachers were invited through e-mails to participate in focus group interviews. The purpose of this interview was to examine the merits and challenges of digitising the existing FE paper-based portfolio, using a digital portfolio platform, and to plan for future development using Technology
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 74 74
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Acceptance Model (TAM) as the research framework. All participants were requiredto create e-portfolios to showcase their achievements, the effects of actual system used led to long-term behavioural intention to use, diverging from the TAM’s original model, which predicted actual system use. Student teachers either participated in a semi-structured interview (n = 7) or replied via e-mails (n = 2). The results indicated that attitude towards usage (ATU) evidenced a direct relationship to behavioural intention to use. Furthermore, for those who had mixed ATU, perceived usage was the determining factor. The findings provide insightful information not only for the next implementation phase of an e-portfolio, but also for those considering implementing e-portfolios.
48 2014 Chung-Hung
Tsai
Healthcare
(tele health)
Tele health has become an increasingly applied solution to delivering health care to rural and underserved areas by remote health care professionals. This study integrated social capital theory, social cognitive theory, and the technology acceptance model (TAM) to develop a comprehensive behavioral model for analyzing the relationships among social capital factors (social capital theory), technological factors (TAM), and system self-efficacy (social cognitive theory) in telehealth. The proposed framework was validated with 365 respondents from Nantou County, located in Central Taiwan. Structural equation modeling (SEM) was used to assess the causal relationships that were hypothesized in the proposed model. The finding indicates that elderly residents generally reported positive perceptions toward the telehealth system. Generally, the findings show that social capital factors (social trust, institutional trust, and social participation) significantly positively affect the technological factors (perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness respectively), which influenced usage intention. This study also confirmed that system self-efficacy was the salient antecedent of perceived ease of use.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 75 75
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
49 2010 Norazah Mohd
Suki &
T. Ramayah
E-Government This paper identifies the factors that determine users’ acceptance of e-Government services and its causal relationships using a theoretical model based on the Technology Acceptance Model. Data relating to the constructs were collected from 200 respondents in Malaysia and subjected to Structural Equation Modeling analysis. The proposed model fits the data well. Results indicate that the important determinants of user acceptance of the e-Government services are perceived usefulness, ease of use, compatibility, interpersonal influence, external influence, self efficacy, facilitating conditions, attitude, subjective norms, perceived behavioral control, and intention to use e-Government services/system. Finally, implications and recommendations of these finding are discussed.
50 2014 Hellena Mohamed
Mushi
Mobile Banking This paper intends to explore the most important dynamics that impact individual’s decision toward accepting and adopting a mobile service. The overall objective of this is to identify several mobile service characteristics which have were not previously discussed in traditional acceptance theories. It will then be easier to differentiate the importance of service characteristics over the concepts in traditional acceptance theories. Moreover, the discussion sheds some light to our understating regarding the individual IT acceptance.
51 2009 Su-Houn Liu
&
Jean A. Pratt
E-Learning Advances in e-learning technologies parallels a general increase in sophistication by computer users. The use of just one theory or model, such as the technology acceptance model, is no longer sufficient to study the intended use of e-learning systems. Rather, a combination of theories must be integrated in order to fully capture the complexity of e-learners, who are both system users and learners. The current research presents an integrated theoretical framework to study users’ acceptance of streaming media for e-
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 76 76
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
learning. Three streams of research provide the basis for this integrated framework: the technology acceptance model, flow theory and media richness theory. Students enrolled in an online section of an information systems course used one of three different combinations of text, streamed audio and streamed video.
Regression analysis was used to test the hypotheses in this field experiment. Perceived ease of use was a predictor of perceived usefulness; both the perceived usefulness and the attitude of the user were predictors of intention to use.
52 2010 Bander Alsajjan Internet Banking This article proposes a revised technology acceptance model to measure consumers’ acceptance of Internet banking, the Internet Banking Acceptance Model (IBAM). Data was collected from 618 university students in the United Kingdom and Saudi Arabia. The results suggest the importance of attitude, such that attitude and behavioral intentions emerge as a single factor, denoted as “attitudinal intentions” (AI). Structural equation modeling confirms the fit of the model, in which perceived usefulness and trust fully mediate the impact of subjective norms and perceived manageability on AI. The invariance analysis demonstrates the psychometric equivalence of the IBAM measurements between the two country groups. At the structural level, the influence of trust and system usefulness on AI vary between the two countries, emphasizing the potential role of cultures in IS adoption. The IBAM is robust and parsimonious, explaining over 80% of AI.
53 2011 Rahmath
Safeena, Hema
Internet Banking Information technology Services is considered as the key driver for the changes taking place around the world. Internet banking (IB) is the latest and most innovative service and is the new trend among the consumers. The shift from the formal banking to e-
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 77 77
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Date and
Abdullah
Kammani
banking has been a 'leap' change. This study determines the factors influencing the consumer’s adoption of internet banking in India and hence investigates the influence of perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use and perceived risk on use of IB. It is an essential part of a bank’s strategy formulation process in an emerging economy like India. Survey based questionnaire design with empirical test was carried out. The results have supported the hypothesis.
54 2012 Alfie Chacko
Punnoose
E-Learning The purpose of this study was to find some of the predominant factors that determine the intention of students to use eLearning in the future. Since eLearning is not just a technology ac-acceptance decision but also involves cognition, this study extended its search beyond the normal technology acceptance variables into variables that could affect the cognition of an individual due to his or her unique characteristics. The variables in the literature of technology acceptance studies can be classified broadly into 5 categories. They are Individual Differences, Beliefs, Attitude, Behavioral Intention, and Actual Behavior. Since the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) is the most widely used model to study the acceptance of technology, this study adopted TAM and further extended it based on the recommendations from the literature of information systems and information technology.
55 2009 Yanika
Kowitlawakul
Healthcare The Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) is one of the promising models that represent an important theoretical framework to explain and predict an individual’s technology acceptance. TAM has been used extensively in the business, education, and information technology settings, but rarely in a health care setting. Rapid growth of investment worldwide in information technology by health care organizations has dramatically raised the importance of technology acceptance as an issue. Technology systems can not enhance the performance of health care providers or improve patient outcomes if the technology systems are not accepted by the end users. In the health care industry, nurses are often identified as end users. Therefore, more investigation for
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 78 78
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
better understanding of why nurses accept or reject new technology is needed. This research study attempted to examine the applicability of the TAM in explaining nurses’ acceptance of telemedicine technology (eICU®) in a health care setting, and also determined factors and predictors that influenced the probability of the nurses’ acceptance of this technology. The psychometric evidence (validity and reliability) of the measurement scales used in the study was discussed.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 79 79
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
It can be observed from the above review that Technology Adoption Model has been widely
used or applied in sectors like Online shopping, Online Banking, Mobile technology, Health
care, Education, Self-Service Technologies in Banks, E-Government, E- Banking, Customer
Self-Service Portals, E-Filing, Retail Self-Service, E-Portfolio, etc… The studies are both
qualitative and quantitative. Further these studies have used constructs like Behavioural
Intention to Use (BIU), Attitude (A), Perceived Ease Of Use (PEOU), Perceived Use (PU),
Subjective norms, Compatibility, Habit, Facilitators, Intention, Trust, Fun, Enjoyment, and
learning, etc.. also we see that the above papers examine the different aspects of consumer
behavior like Trust, Fun, Enjoyment, and learning, etc. The above studies focus to highlight
the significance of TAM factors in the light of some external factors.
Most of the papers have used Structural Equation Modeling and Confirmatory Factor analysis
to validate and analyze the factors involved in their respective studies. Almost all the studies
have used primary data and individual responses from the actual and potential users of the
technology.
The above studies of TAM have shown positive results in the different technology adoption
areas and most of the models were statistically significant. The trend in the findings has
shown that perceived usefulness has a direct and positive relationship with satisfaction.
Behavioural Intention in turn leads to formation of brand relationship. Overall it is learnt
from the above studies that the user adoption is significantly affected by perceived
usefulness, relative advantage and trust. Perceived usefulness is directly affected by
subjective norms, image, output quality and perceived ease of use. The result shows that
TAM is efficient model to explain the intention to use the technology.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 80 80
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
5. GAPS Identified from the Literature
From the above studies the following gaps have identified.
1. It is observed from the above studies that most of the technology adoption studies,
irrespective of the model used to assess the same have been conducted in US,
European or the South East Asian context. There are very limited studies which have
been reported in the Indian context. It would be interesting to see how these models
behave in the Indian context.
2. The studies reviewed in this report lay more emphasis in understanding the
acceptance of the technology products like computer usage, internet usage, and
mobile technologies. However there remains a scope to understand these models from
the view point of the emerging technologies like adoption of social networking
medium, E-Learning, cloud computing, online recharge of mobile phones, online
purchase of term insurance, direct to home television services etc.
3. The earlier research studies have so far used a specific model from the literature like
innovation diffusion, Unified Theory of Use and Acceptance of Technology, TRA,
TPB, TAM TAM2 or TAM 3. Very few studies have laid emphasis on developing and
validating integrated models. By doing so we can have meaningful investigations and
draw valid conclusions.
The proposed research study will attempt to address the above research gaps and the
future review will be taken in that direction
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 81 81
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
6. Proposed Model and Development of HypothesisThe review of literature carried in the previous section identifies many different
models and constructs that have been reported in various research studies.This study
integrates TAM and TRI due to the following reasons. First, both TAM and TRI can be used
to explain peoples’ technology acceptance (Davis 1989; Parasuraman, 2000). Second, the
major difference between these two models lies in that TAM uses system-specific perceptions
to explain technology acceptance while TRI is via individuals’ general inclination (Tung
2003). Third, individual differences (i.e., psychological traits) are mediated by the cognitive
dimensions (i.e., PU and PEOU) in predicting people’s acceptance of technology (Agarwal
1999).Considering the product scope (i.e E-learning) for the present study the following
constructs were reviewed in further detail, which are selected from the TRI (2000) & TAM
(1989) Model.The same has led to propose an integrated model for research in this study
6.1 Effect of Optimism (Opti.) on Perceived Usefulness (PU) & Perceived
Ease of Use (PEU)
Optimism refers to “a belief that technology offers people increased control, flexibility and
efficiency in their lives” (Parasuraman, A 2000), and represents a positive view and a
dimension of confidence in technology. People who are optimistic and innovative with
reference to technology in general are thought to hold positive attitudes toward new
technology and technology use. Optimists perceive technologies as being moreuseful and
easy to use in that they are less irritated about the negative outcomes of technology(Kuo et.
al., 2013). Therefore, it is hypothesized that optimism and innovativeness are enablers that
have positive effects on how people perceive and relate to new technology (Parasuraman and
Colby, 2001; Tsikriktsis, 2004). Therefore, it is assumed that an optimist perceives a
technology as being more use fuland easier to use because he or she worries less about
possible negative out comes. In this research it is proposed to test following hypothesis
H1: Optimism is positively influence customers’ perceived usefulness of Tablet Pc Adoption
H2: Optimism is positively influence customers’ perceived ease of use Tablet Pc Adoption
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 82 82
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
6.2 Effect of innovativeness on Perceived Usefulness(PU) and Perceived
Ease of Use (PEU)
Innovativeness is defined as an individual’s tendency to be more receptive to new ideas
(Leung and Wei, 1998; Lin, 1998; Lin and Jeffres, 1998; Li, 2003; Rogers, 1995).
Innovativeness depends on individuals and is seen as critical in consumers’ technology
adoption. Individual innovativeness tends to differentiate adopters from non–adopters of new
technologies (Lin, 1998; Lin and Jeffres, 1998; Busselle, et al., 1999). (Rogers 1995) argued
that a high degree of individual innovativeness triggers early adoption of a new technology
and/or idea. Individual innovativeness is also introduced into the TAM research to expand the
scope of TAM applicability. (Lin 2004) pointed out that recent studies on innovative
attributes and computer–mediated technology adoption generally support the influences of
this personality trait on adoption of an innovation. Innovativenesshas a significant effect on
PEOU but not on PU(Kuo et. al., 2013)in Mobile electronic medical records.(Busselle, et
al.1999) found that an individual’s innovativeness is a positive predictor for the frequency of
Internet use. (Lin 1998) and (Lin 2004) also demonstrated that innovativeness is a significant
predictor for adoption. Thus it is proposed to test the following hypothesis
H 3: Innovativeness is positively influence customers’ Perceived Ease of Use of Tablet pc
Adoption
H 4: Innovativeness is positively influence customers’ Perceived Usefulness of Tablet pc
Adoption
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 83 83
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
6.3 Effect of discomfort on Perceived Usefulness(PU) and Perceived Ease of
Use (PEU)
Discomfort is defined as "a perceived lack of control over technology and a feeling of being
overwhelmed by it" (Parasuraman and Colby 2001, p. 41).People who have high level of
discomfort toward new technologies tend to find technology less easy to use (Walczuch et al.,
2007).Similarly, discomfort may have negative effect on perceived usefulness, because it is
an inhibitor of using new technologies (Parasuraman, 2000; Walczuch et al., 2007 and Kuo
et. al., 2013).This dimension generally measures the fear and concerns people experience
when confronted with technology. Discomfort, on the other hand, is not expected to have a
negative impact on perceived usefulness.
One would expect people to see the main value of a system, regardless of how they handle it.
Still, discomfort is expected to affect perceived ease of use. Discomfort can be reduced
through informative feedback and augmented ease of use (Dabholkar, 1996; Walczuch et al.,
2007).A system that is not manageable is more likely to be a non-user-friendly system. Thus,
it is hypothesized
H 5: Discomfort is not significantly related to Perceived Usefulness of Tablet pc Adoption
H 6: Discomfort is negatively related to Perceived Ease of Use of Tablet pc Adoption
6.4 Effect of Insecurity (Insc)Perceived Usefulness(PU) and Perceived Ease
of Use (PEU)
Insecurity is the result of a lack of trust in technology and its ability to work properly
(Parasuraman, 2000). A perceived lack of security is generally acknowledged to be important
and to have contributed to the slow adoption of e-commerce (Hoffman et al., 1999).
Insecurity is also related to the expected benefits of an innovation, or its realization (Ram,
1987).Previous researches suggest that the lower the expected realization, the higher the
resistance to innovation will be. The insecurity is related to technology are on the other hand
associated with ambiguity and low usage (Parasuraman and Colby, 2001; Tsikriktsis, 2004
and Kuo et. al., 2013). In accordance with earlier research we therefore assume that insecurity
predicts lower levels of perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use. Thus, we
hypothesize:
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 84 84
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
H 7: Insecurity is negatively related to Perceived Usefulness of Tablet pc Adoption
H8: Insecurity is negatively related to Perceived Ease of Use of Tablet pc Adoption
6.5 Effect of Perceived Usefulness (PU) on Attitude
Perceived usefulness has been defined as “the degree to which a person believes that using a
particular system would enhance his or her job performance” (Davis, 1989, p. 320).
According to (Gong and Xu 2004) he defines perceived usefulness as the user’s “subjective
probability that using a specific application system will increase his or her expectations.
Perceived usefulness is the primary antecedent that determines the behaviouralaimto use a
computer system (Venkatesh and Davis, 2000).Davis et al. (1989) proposed that perceived
ease of use is an antecedent of Perceived usefulness. Results from previous research also
revealed the significant effect of perceived ease of use toperceived usefulness (Kleijnen et al.,
2004; Wang et al., 2003; Davis et al., 1989). Huang,J. Linn Y., and Chuang S. (2007) posits
that two particular behavioural beliefs, perceived usefulness (PU) and perceived ease of use
(PEOU), are two fundamental factors for predicting user acceptance, and that the effect of
external variables on intention are mediated by these two key beliefs (Adams et al., 1992;
Davis, 1989; Davis et al., 1989; Mathieson, 1991).Perceived usefulness is also known as
performance expectancy (Venkatesh et al., 2003). Perceived usefulness is recognized as
having strong positive effect on the intention of adopters to use the innovation. Numerous
studies have shown that perceived usefulness is the primary predictor of information
technology usage (Davis, 1989; Davis, Bagozzi and Warshaw, 1989; Gefen, Karahanna and
Straub, 2003; Venkatesh and Morris, 2000). Previous researches have shown that perceived
usefulness influenced computer usage directly (Ha and Stoel, 2009; Huang, 2008;Sudha et al,
2010). Perceived usefulness directly affected attitudes towards E-Learning, and that attitude
was the major determinant of Tablet pc Adoption (Akturan and Tezcan, 2012). Yang (2005)
showed that perceived usefulness influence attitude toward using m-commerce. Usefulness,
ease of use of the system awareness about Tablet pc Adoption and risks related to it are the
main perusing factors to accept online banking system. These factors have a strong and
positive effect on customers to accept Tablet pc Adoption system (Rahamatet.al., 2012).
Thus, this research proposes the following hypothesis
H 9: Perceived Usefulness will have a positive effect on attitude towards use of Tablet Pc
Adoption
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 85 85
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
6.6 Effect of Perceived Ease of Use (PEU) on Perceived Use (PU) and
Attitude (Atti)
Perceived ease of use is the degree to which a person believes that using a particular system
would be free of effort (Dholakia and Dholakia, 2004). Numerous researches have provided
support that perceived ease of use had a significant effect on usage intention; it is an
important forecaster of technology adoption. Perceived ease of use refers to the degree to
which a person believes that using a particular system would be free of effort (Davis, 1989;
Liu and Li, 2010). Perceived ease of use (perceived complexity) has been found to be an
important determinant of technology usage, both in a direct and indirect manner, and
technology users have been proven to “attempt to minimize their cognitive effort on their
behaviours” (Cho, 2011). Individuals will thus exhibit a higher intention to use a system,
when it is perceived to be easy to use. As described, this has been found to operate mainly
through perceived usefulness, for when system is difficult to use, its usefulness is harder to
identify.
Thus, this research proposes the following hypothesis:
H 10: Perceived ease of use will have a positive effect on attitude of E-Learning
H 11: Perceived ease of use will have a positive effect on perceived usefulness of E-Learning
6.7 Effect of Attitude (Atti) on Behavioral Intention (BI)
Attitude is considered a multidimensional construct comprised of cognitive, affective, and
conative components. Yet, most attitude measurement techniques resulted in capturing only
the affective side of the concept (Ajzen et al. 2005). IS research has widely accepted the
attitude definition by Fishbein and Ajzen (Fishbein et al. 1975) in that attitude is “an
individual’s positive or negative feelings (evaluative affect) about performing the target
behavior” (Davis et al. 1989; Moonetal. 2001; Venkatesh et al. 2003). That is, attitudes are
often considered overall affective evaluations (Ajzen et al. 1980). The attitude is the
psychological tendency depending on a degree of favour or disfavor (Eagly and Chaiken
1993). Attitude is defined as “the degree to which a person has a favourable or unfavourable
evaluation or appraisal of the behavior in question” (Ajzen, I., 1991). Attitude toward user
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 86 86
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
acceptance of technology is defined as an individual’s overall affective reaction
(liking,enjoyment, joy, and pleasure) to use a technology (Davis, 1989; Taylor and
Todd,1995). Attitude also has a significant impact and appears to be the second positive
determinant of a consumer’s intention to accept Tablet Pc Adoption. This leads to hypothesis:
H12: Attitude will have a positive effect on Behavioral Intention of Tablet pc adoption
6.8 Effect of Subjective Norm (SN) on Behavioral Intention (BI)
The construct Subjective Norm (SN) was promoted by FishbeinandAjzen (1975), and was
developed by Mathieson (1991). Subjective Norm (SN) or Normative Pressure (NP) is
defined as a person‘s perception that most people who are important to her or him should or
should not perform the behavior in question (Fishbein and Ajzen, 1975).Subjective norm is
usually separated in interpersonal and external influences (Lin, 2007 and Bhattacherjee,
2000).Subjective Norms explain how thebehavior of an individual is influenced or changed
based on how other important people to him/her think he/she should behave.Subjective norm
is believed to influence intention to use because people may choose to perform behavior,
even if they are not themselves favorable toward the behavior or the consequences
(Venkatesh and Davis, 2000). What other individuals or groups will think, agree or disagree
about the decision of a person to perform a given behavior and how important these other
individuals or groups play a vital role for the decision maker. So sometime people may be
seek advice from others before them making any decisions.
Social norms have been widely validated in group-oriented I.T (Taylor and Todd, 1995),
email acceptance (Gefen and Straub, 1997; Karahana and Limayem, 2000), E-Learning
(Chan and Lu, 2004) and Tablet Pc adoption (Riquelme and Rios, 2010; Schepers and
Wetzels, 2007). The social context of the consumer should not be neglected (Schierz, et al.,
2010). The empirical research conducted by (Yu, 2012) in Taiwan by sampling 441
respondents, the most significant predictor was social influence, in the individual intention to
adopt Tablet Pc.
The opinion of other individuals or groups will think, agree or disagree about the decision of
a person to perform a given behaviour and how important these other individuals or groups
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 87 87
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
play a vital role for the decision maker. So sometime people may be seek advice from others
before them making any decisions.
H 13: Subjective norms will have positive effect on behavioural intention of Tablet pc
adoption
Research model
Figure 17:
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 88 88
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
7. Proposed Research Methodology
A two phase research methodology is proposed to be used for the study. An effective
instrument should cover the content domain of each construct (Nunnally, 1978; Churchill,
1979).The items that measure a construct should agree (converge) with each other, and the
items of one construct should disagree (discriminate) with measures of the other constructs.
Each construct should be reliable and short and easy to use. The study will adopt a two-phase
approach. In the first phase, the definitions of the constructs as well as the measurement items
for each construct will be established. In this phase, we will also provide tentative indications
of reliability and validity. This phase will include item generation, pre-pilot study, and pilot
study. In the second phase, we propose to further refine this scale and validate the measures
using Likert scale survey data based on the scales developed in the first phase. Stratified
Sampling technique will be used to select the sample so that the selected sample has a
representation of the respondents from different strata’s on the basis of age, gender,
qualification and profession. The survey will be conducted in Bijapur with 200 respondents
from each city. The survey instrument will be developed in order to test the research model.
The items and questions in the proposed questionnaire will be adopted from existing studies;
the questionnaire will be pre-tested with reputed experts from Education sector (Technical
Students) to ensure that the wording and format of the questions are appropriate.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 89 89
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Questionnaire
The questionnaire included the technology readiness index (TRI) developed by A.
Parasuraman and Rockbridge Associates (2000) and the technology acceptance model (TAM)
as introduced by Davis (1989) (see Appendix A and B for a complete list of the items in the
TRI and TAM). The technology readiness index (TRI) is a multi-item scale compromising 36
technology belief statements, both positive and negative, related to one of the four TR
dimensions. Each statement is scored on a 5-point scale (from 1 = strongly disagree, to 5 =
strongly agree).
Perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use are measured as distinct dimensions in
the technology acceptance model. Each dimension comprises 6 statements, scored on a 7-
point scale (from 1 = extremely unlikely, to 7 = extremely likely).
Students many very from factor to factor were translated into Norwegian and then
back translated by a third independent person. The TAM scales were modified in accordance
to the technology used by the respondents. Actual use was self-reported on a 7-point scale
(from 1 = not at all, to 7 = several times a day).
Procedure
The research model was tested using structural equation (SEM) modeling which
allows researchers to perform path analytic modeling with latent variables (Bollen, 1989). In
our research design the latent variables represented by the TRI were optimism,
innovativeness, insecurity and discomfort. TAM consists of the two cognitive dimensions
perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use. Items associated with each latent dimension
were included in the structural model in Amos 21st.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 90 90
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
8. Data analysis and results
This section will analysis the result obtained from the questionnaire that was
distributed to respondents using research questionnaire.
This analysis will also look at the students knowledge of tablet Pc Adoption and also
adoption rate. The finding from the students shows that more students are ready to adopt
Tablet Pc.
A) Respondents demographic characteristics
The frequency where use to determine how often respondents made a certain response
in answering questions, and this allowed general information about the information collected
to be analyze. Questionnaire was constructed and also distributed among students through
using google Doc. The demographic detail shows Gender, Age, Academic Year and these are
shown in the table below.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 91 91
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Table 3: Frequency distribution
Age In Years
Frequency Percent Valid Percent
Cumulative Percent
Valid
18-20 66 32.8 32.8 32.821-22 104 51.7 51.7 84.623-24 31 15.4 15.4 100.0Total 201 100.0 100.0
Chart No 1:Interpretation
As per the respondents above table shows that 18-24 Age students are 32.8% , 21-22
Age students are 51.8% and reaming 23-24 Age students are 15.4% they given responses.
Table No 4 :Respondents of Gender
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 92 92
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Chart No 2:
Interpretation
As per the respondents above table shows that Female Gender students are 34.8% ,
Male Gender students are 65.8% .
Table No 5 : Respondents of academic year
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME
GnderFrequency Percent Valid
PercentCumulative
Percent
ValidFemale 70 34.8 34.8 34.8Male 131 65.2 65.2 100.0Total 201 100.0 100.0
93 93
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Academic YearFrequency Percent Valid
PercentCumulative
Percent
Valid
I st 27 13.4 13.4 13.4II nd 42 20.9 20.9 34.3III rd 97 48.3 48.3 82.6IV th 35 17.4 17.4 100.0Total 201 100.0 100.0
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 94 94
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Chart No 3:Interpretation
As per the respondents above table shows that Ist year students are 13.4% , II nd year
students are 20.9%, III rd year students are 48.3% and reaming IV th year students are
17.4% they given responses.
8.1 Results
Preliminary analyses
Before testing our hypotheses we assessed the reliability and validity of the translated
TRI and TAM. A confirmatory factor analyses (CFA) using structural equation modeling
(SEM) was conducted in Amos 6.0 to examine how well each item corresponded to the latent
dimensions. Our limit for low factor loadings was set to .30, as recommended by Ulleberg
and Nordvik (2001). Further, we assessed the Cronbach’s alphas to test the internal
consistency reliability for each dimension. According to Nunnally (1978) alphas above .70
are acceptable.
The CFA of TRI revealed four items with low factor loadings. Hence, they were
excluded from subsequent analyses. With these items excluded, the alpha for the TRI
dimensions ranged from .68 to .84. The alpha values are presented in Table 2 along with the
alphas obtained by Parasuraman (2000) in the United States and Tsikriktsis (2004) in Great
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 95 95
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Britain. Three of the four dimensions show acceptable internal consistency reliability for
group analysis. The Cronbach’s alpha for discomfort is just below the acceptance criteria
suggested by Nunnally (1978).
Table 6
Comparison of Cronbach’s alphas on TRI dimensions in the US, Great Britain and Norway
Country Optimism Innovativeness Discomfort Insecurity
Norway .84 .83 .68 .75
United States .81 .80 .75 .74
Great Britain .83 .85 .74 .88
Regarding the CFA of TAM, all items showed high factor loadings (above .70).
Hence, there was no need to exclude items from these scales. Both dimensions exhibited
strong alphas (above .90) indicating good measures for the internal consistency reliability.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 96 96
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
In sum, seven of thirteen hypotheses were supported. The relationships between the
variables are depicted in Figure 18, showing the standardized estimates for significant results
only. Regarding the complete model fit, this was found to have an acceptable fit at best (2 =
1764.2, d.f. = 935, 2 /d.f. = 1.89, RMSEA = .087, CFI = .663, TLI = .647). The 2 /d.f. ratio
and the RMSEA are acceptable, but the CFI and TLI are below the general cutoff criteria
(.95) for acceptable fit as proposed by Schreiber, Nora, Stage, Barlow, and King (2006).
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 97 97
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Figur 18. The integrated model, as depicted, shows standardized estimates of the hypothesized path analysis. All estimates are significant, unless noted as not significant by “n.s.”.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 98 98
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)9. Discussion
This study has investigated the relationship between the personality
dimensions in the TRI and main elements of the TAM (i.e. perceived usefulness,
perceived ease of use and Behavioral intention ).
Our findings reveal that some, but not all, personality dimensions of the TRI
influence technology acceptance and Behavioral intention. Optimism and
innovativeness were the only personality dimensions that significantly affected
perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use. The positive relationship between
optimism and the cognitive dimensions of TAM makes logical sense. An individual
that in general is optimistic about technology will find a specific system more useful,
and easier to use, than someone less optimistic.
The effect of innovativeness was more intriguing. As expected there was a
positive relationship between innovativeness and perceived ease of use. This implies
that innovative Students find it easier to use a system. Unexpectedly, however, the
relationship between innovativeness and perceived usefulness was negative. Thus,
highly innovative Students find systems less useful than less innovative Students.
This is somewhat contradicting to previous findings were innovativeness is
found to have a positive effect on the adoption level of technology (Jong, Ruyter, &
Lemmink, 2003; Ward, Chitty, & Graham, 2007). Then again, Walczuch et al. (2007)
found the exact same negative relationship between innovativeness and perceived
usefulness as the present study. They concluded “that innovative people are more
critical towards technology since they are aware of the newest developments and
possibilities, and expect all technology to fulfill highest demands” (p. 212).
The question that arises here is how innovativeness can be positively related
with technology adoption, and at the same time be negatively related with perceived
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 99 99
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)usefulness. One possible explanation is that highly innovative people are more willing
to adopt and try new technologies than other people. However, they easily cease to
use a system due to their high standards for new technological development.
Insecurity and discomfort had no significant effect on the cognitive
dimensions of TAM. Except for the relationship between discomfort and perceived
usefulness, this was not as expected. However, the beta coefficients were in the
predicted direction, and a larger sample size could give a significant result. Yet, even
with a larger sample size and significant relationships, the effects would be small due
to the low standardized beta coefficients.
Further, our results revealed that actual use was directly affected by perceived
usefulness, but not perceived ease of use. However, the positive relationship between
perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness indicate an indirect influence of
perceived ease of use on actual use. In sum, the perceived characteristics of the
systems, influence actual usage; and perceived usefulness is found to be the main
contributor to system usage. These findings are in accordance with the majority of
previous research on TAM (e.g. King & He, 2006; Legris et al., 2003; Schepers &
Wetzels, 2007).
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 100 100
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
9.1 Limitations and perspectives for future research
There are several limitations with this study. First, when testing the model on
two different technologies the total outcome may have been biased. This may have
caused little variation in the dependent variable (actual use). An investigation of how
mandatory use affects adoption of technology compared with voluntary use would be
of major interest for the field.
Second, the subgroups are quite different demographically. The group consists
of mostly women (89,4%), while age is evenly distributed. This homogeneity may
have biased the results. Future research should take care to eliminate possible
confounding effects of age and gender. It is also advisable to assess age in a more
specific metric manner.
Third, deleting items from the TRI scales may cause a validity problem.
However, only four out of a total of 36 items were deleted. Removing two items from
the insecurity dimension, and two items in the discomfort dimension led to higher
alphas values of the two dimensions and a better overall fit of the model; hence
improving the internal consistency. It is recommended by Ulleberg and Nordvik
(2001) to exclude low factor loadings, and as long as the majority of items on each
dimension of the TRI are still included it may be argued that the reduced subsets still
measures the constructs in question. One reason for the low factor loadings may be
due to poor translations. Further, it is possible that the some of the TRI items are
outdated. Some of the statements in the test may therefore begin to lose what they are
meant to capture. For example, the statement “The human touch is very important
when doing business with a company” could be related to stronger feelings ten years
ago than it does now. Hence, a scale revision may be a direction for future research.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 101 101
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)Fourth, the Cronbach’s alpha for discomfort is below Nunnally’s (1978)
suggested cutoff for acceptance (.70). It is also lower compared to the alphas obtained
in the United States and Great Britain, as presented in Table 2. The reasons for low
alpha in the Norwegian study could be related to poor translations of some items.
However, according to Sekaran (2000) alphas between .60 and .70 may be acceptable
for studies with group analysis design.
Fifth, when translating the TRI and TAM further assessment of reliability
should have been undertaken. It is argued above that we did get acceptable results for
the internal consistency reliability for each dimension in the test. There is, however,
no guarantee for this consistency over time. A test-retest could have dealt with this
limitation and strengthened the study.
Sixth, TRAM represents a fairly complex model and the complexity could
easily expand further with additional paths and variables. It is no limit to the
complexity of a model, however it is a very fine line between what is understandable
and what is not. Research that examines TRAM connections beyond those that have
been presented in this study, will add to the understanding of implementation of new
technologies in general. It would be interesting to see how the TRI dimensions
correspond with actual use directly. If insecurity and discomfort are not mediated
through TAM, the dimensions may have direct effects on actual use. It is also possible
that the effect of these dimensions are mediated through other variables not included
in this study, such as for example social norm. Further, this study has focused on
technology related beliefs and perceptions. How this corresponds with more generic
personality traits has to our knowledge not been investigated thus far. We encourage
future research to look into these aspects.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 102 102
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)Finally, care should also be taken in generalizing these results to other
technologies. IM and EHR can be categorized as interactive technology as they both
simplify communication and sharing of information via computer networks. They are
also fairly novel in the organizational settings where they were tested. It is probable
that the results are adaptable to other novel technologies, especially in organizational
contexts. Adopting the results to well established technologies is however more
problematic as the TRI is less applicable regarding such systems. We believe that the
link between technological readiness and technological acceptance is worth taking a
step further by testing the TRAM model on different new technologies in different
settings (e.g. organisational, educational and private). Only thorough research in this
area can determine how the relationship between the different dimensions in the
model depends on different technologies and contexts.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 103 103
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)10. Conclusion
The results from this study to a large extent replicate and extend the findings
from Walczuch et al. (2007). The personality dimensions of TRI influences the
cognitive dimensions of TAM and subsequently technology usage. An integrated
model expands the applicability of the prior models due to the focus on both
individual and system specific characteristics. On one hand there should be
considerable emphasis on the users and their general attitudes toward technology,
especially in settings where it may be impractical to test the system before it is
adopted. With general user knowledge, the necessary steps could be taken to initiate
successful implementations.
On the other hand the model explains why some systems are rejected even in
organizations where people are highly optimistic towards technology in general. If the
system specific characteristics (i.e. perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use)
are too low, a system will be rejected regardless of people’s general technology
readiness. Hence, measures of the perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use add
valuable information for those designing and implementing new technology.
In sum, a combination of these two models comprises a holistic view. It indicates that
adoption of new technologies involves individual as well as system specific factors. In
our view, a fundamental aspect of research is that it should be applicable. An
integration of psychometric constructs and system-related experiences will in this
respect be future-oriented, innovative and useful.
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 104 104
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)10.1 ReferencesAdams, D. A., Nelson, R. R., & Todd, P. A. (1992). Perceived usefulness, ease of use,
and usage of information technology: A replication. MIS Quarterly, 16, 227-
247. doi:10.2307/249577
Bollen, K. A. (1989). Structural equations with latent variables. New York: John
Wiley & Sons.
Burton-Jones, A., & Hubona, G. S. (2006). The mediation of external variables in the
technology acceptance model. Information & Management, 43, 706-717.
doi:10.1016/j.im.2006.03.007
Davis, F. D. (1989). Perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, and user acceptance
of information technology. MIS Quarterly, 13, 319-340. doi:10.2307/249008
Davis, D., Bagozzi, R. P., & Warshaw, P. R. (1989). User acceptance of computer
technology: A comparison of two theoretical models. Management Science,
35, 982-1003. doi:10.1287/mnsc.35.8.982
Fishbein, M., & Ajzen, I. (1975). Belief, attitude, intention, and behavior: An
introduction to theory and research. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
Jong, A. de, Ruyter, K. de, & Lemmink, J. (2003). The adoption of information
technology by self-managing service teams. Journal of Service Research, 6,
162-179. doi:10.1177/1094670503257046
King, W. R., & He, J. (2006). A meta-analysis of the technology acceptance model.
Information & Management, 43, 740-755. doi:10.1016/j.im.2006.05.003
Legris, P., Ingham, J., & Collerette, P. (2003). Why do people use information
technology? A critical review of the technology acceptance model.
Information and Management, 40, 191-204. doi:10.1016/S0378-
7206(01)00143-4
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 105 105
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)Lin, C.-H., Shih, H.-Y., & Sher, P. J. (2007). Integrating technology readiness into
technology acceptance: The TRAM model. Psychology & Marketing, 24, 641-
657. doi:10.1002/mar.20177
Lin, C.-H., Shih, H.-Y., Sher, P. J., & Wang Y.-L. (2005). Consumer adoption of e-
service: Integrating technology readiness with the technology acceptance
model. Proceedings of PICMET ’05: Technology Management: A Unifying
Discipline for Melting the Boundaries, Portland, Oregon, USA, 483-488.
doi:10.1109/PICMET.2005.1509728
Malhotra, Y., & Galletta, D. F. (1999). Extending the technology acceptance model to
account for social influence: Theoretical bases and empirical validation.
Proceedings of the 32nd Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences,
Maui, Hawaii, USA, 1-14. doi:10.1109/HICSS.1999.772658
McFarland, D. J., & Hamilton, D. (2006). Adding contextual specificity to the
technology acceptance model. Computers in Human Behavior, 22, 427-447.
doi:10.1016/j.chb.2004.09.009
Nunnally, J. C. (1978). Psychometric theory (2nd ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill.
Parasuraman, A. (2000). Technology readiness index (Tri): A multiple-item scale to
measure readiness to embrace new technologies. Journal of Service Research,
2, 307-320. doi:10.1177/109467050024001
Parasuraman, A., & Colby, C. L. (2001). Techno-ready marketing: How and why your
customers adopt technology. New York: Free Press.
Porter, C. E., & Donthu, N. (2006). Using the technology acceptance model to explain
how attitudes determine Internet usage: The role of perceived access barriers
and demographics. Journal of Business Research, 59, 999-1007. doi:
10.1016/j.jbusres.2006.06.003
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 106 106
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)Schepers, J., & Wetzels, M. (2007). A meta-analysis of the technology acceptance
model: Investigating subjective norm and moderation effects. Information &
Management, 44, 90-103. doi:10.1016/j.im.2006.10.007
Schreiber, J. B., Nora, A., Stage, F. K., Barlow, E. A., & King J. (2006). Reporting
structural equation modeling and confirmatory factor analysis results: A
review. The Journal of Educational Research, 99, 323 – 338.
doi:10.3200/JOER.99.6.323-338
Sekaran, U. (2000). Research methods for business: A Skill-building approach. (3rd
ed.). New York: John Wiley & Sons.
Tsikriktsis, N. (2004). A technology readiness-based taxonomy of costumers: A
replication and extension. Journal of Service Research 7, 42-52.
doi:10.1177/1094670504266132
Ulleberg, P., & Nordvik, H. (2001). Faktoranalyse: Innføring i faktorteori og
faktoranalyse Factor analysis: Introduciton in factor theory and factor
analysis. Trondheim, Norway: Tapir Akademisk Forlag.
Venkatesh, V. (2000). Determinants of perceived ease of use: Integrating control,
intrinsic motivation, and emotion into the technology acceptance model.
Information Systems Research, 11, 342-365. doi:10.1287/isre.11.4.342.11872
Venkatesh, V., & Davis F. D. (2000). A theoretical extension of the technology
acceptance model: Four longitudinal field studies. Management Science, 46,
186-204. doi:10.1287/mnsc.46.2.186.11926
Walczuch, R., Lemmink, J., & Streukens, S. (2007). The effect of service employees’
technology readiness on technology acceptance. Information & Management,
44, 206-215. doi:10.1016/j.im.2006.12.005
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 107 107
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)Ward, S., Chitty, B., & Graham, G. (2007). Finding the tutorial I want: An
examination of factors leading to adoption of online self service technology.
Proceedings of the ANZMAC Conference 2007, Otago, Dunedin, New
Zealand, 2580-2587. Retreived from
http://conferences.anzmac.org/ANZMAC2007/papers.html
Yang, H.-D., & Yoo, Y. (2004). It’s all about attitude: Revisiting the technology
acceptance model. Decision Support Systems, 38, 19-31. doi:10.1016/S0167-
9236(03)00062-9
Yi, M. Y., & Hwang, Y. (2003). Predicting the use of web-based information systems:
Self-efficacy, enjoyment, learning goal orientation, and the technology
acceptance model. International Journal of Human-Computer Studies, 59,
431-449. doi:10.1016/S1071-5819(03)00114-9
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 108 108
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
AnnexureQuestionnaire
Dear Respondent,Myself Arun M Savukar. I am fellow student of B.L.D.E.A’s MBA A.S.Patil College of Commerce Bijapur.I am doing Research on
Understanding New technology by Engineering Students application of TRAT. This is survey tries to capture attitude towards using Tablet
Pc adoption of Engineering Students. This Questionnaire was two sections, Section A and B. We request you spare around 5 to 10 minutes for
giving your response to the items below. We thank you in anticipations.
This is an anonymous survey about the use of Tablet Pc.
Age :-Gender :- Academic Year :-
Sl.No Items Ratings1 2 3 4 5
Perceived usefulness (PU)01 PU1 Using Tablet PC will save my time in Learning
02 PU2 Using Tablet PC would improve my performance in Learning
03 PU3 Using Tablet PC would improve my productivity in Learning
04 PU4 Using Tablet PC would improve my effectiveness in Learning
05 PU5 I find Tablet PC to be useful in Learning
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 109 109
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Attitude (ATTI)06 ATTI1 In my opinion it is desirable to use Tablet PC for learning
07 ATTI2 I think it will be good for me to use Tablet PC for learning
08 ATTI3 I think learning through Tablet PC is a good idea
09 ATTI4 Overall, my attitude toward Tablet PC is favourable
10 ATTI5 Generally speaking, I like the idea of Tablet PC for learning
Perceived Ease of Use (PEU)11 PEU1 I find Tablet PC easy to use
12 PEU2 Use of Tablet PC is clear and understandable
13 PEU3 It is easy for me to remember how to perform tasks using Tablet PC
14 PEU4 Overall, I find the Tablet PCis easy to use
Subjective Norm (SN)15 SN1 Most people who are important to me expect me to use Tablet
16 SN2 Most of my friends believe using Tablet PC is a wise decision.
17 SN3 People whose opinions I valued preferred that I use Tablet PC
Optimism (Opti)
18 OPTI1 Tablet PC gives more control on my daily life
19 OPTI2 Tablet PCis much more convenient to use
20 OPTI3 I like the idea of learning via Tablet pc because I am not limited to manual
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 110 110
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
transactions
21 OPTI4 I prefer to use the most advanced technology available
22 OPTI5 I like Tablet PC that allow you to tailor things to fit your own needs
23 OPTI6 Tablet PC makes you more efficient in your occupation
24 OPTI7 I find Tablet PC to be mentally stimulating
25 OPTI8 Tablet PC gives you more freedom of mobility
26 OPTI9 Learning about technology can be as rewarding as the technology itself
27 OPTI10 I feel confident that Tablet PC will follow through with what you instructed them
to do
Innovativeness (Inn)28 INNO1 Other people come to me for advice on Tablet PC
29 INNO2 It seems my friends are learning more about the Tablet PC than me
30 INNO3 In general, I am the first among in my circle of friends to acquire Tablet PC when
it appears
31 INNO4 I can usually figure out Tablet PC without help from others
32 INNO5 I keep up with the latest technological developments in my areas of interest
33 INNO6 I enjoy the challenge of figuring out high-technologies
34 INNO7 I find i have fewer problems than other people in making technology work for me
Discomfort (Disc)
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 111 111
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
35 DISC1 Technical support lines are not helpful because they do not explain things in terms
you understand
36 DISC2 Sometimes, I think that Tablet PC is not designed for use by ordinary people
37 DSIC3 There is no such thing as a manual for a high-tech product or service that is written
in plain language
38 DSIC4 When i get technical support from a provider of a Tablet PC, in sometimes i feel as
if i being taken advantage of by someone who knows more than i do
39 DSIC5 If I useTablet PC,I prefer to have a lot of features
40 DSIC6 It is embarrassing when I have trouble with a Tablet PCsystem while people are
watching
41 DSIC7 Tablet PC makes it too easy for teachers to monitor student performance
42 DSIC8 Technology always seems to fail at the worst possible time
Insecurity (INSC)
43 INSC1 I do not consider it safe in adopting Tablet PC
44 INSC2 I do not consider it safe to learn online
45 INSC3 I worry that information you send over the Internet will be seen by other people
46 INSC4 I do not feel confident doing banking with a place that can only be reached online
47 INSC5 Any business transaction I do electronically should be confirmed later with
something in writing
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 112 112
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
48 INSC6 Whenever something gets automated, I need to check carefully that the Tablet pc
or software is not making mistakes
49 INSC7 The human touch is very important while transacting through Tablet PC
50 INSC8 When I call a business, I prefer to talk to a person rather than a machine
51 INSC9 If I am provided information to a machine or over the Internet, I can never be sure
it really gets to right place
Behavioural Intention (BI)52 BI1 I predict that I will use Tablet PC on a regular basis in the future
53 BI2 I expect that I will use Tablet PC system, or a similar type of system for Learning
54 BI3 I will use Tablet PC in future
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 113 113
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)Constructs and Item Measures From the Questionnaire
1. Perceived Usefulness (PU)
PU1 Using Tablet PC will save my time in Learning
PU2 Using Tablet PC would improve my performance in Learning
PU3 Using Tablet PC would improve my productivity in Learning
PU4 Using Tablet PC would improve my effectiveness in Learning
PU5 I find Tablet PC to be useful in Learning
2. Attitude (Att)
ATTI1 In my opinion it is desirable to use Tablet PC for learning
ATTI2 I think it will be good for me to use Tablet PC for learning
ATTI3 I thinklearning through Tablet PC is a good idea
ATTI4 Overall, my attitude toward Tablet PC is favourable
ATTI5 Generally speaking, I like the idea of Tablet PC for learning
3. Perceived Ease of Use (PEU)
PEU1 I find Tablet PC easy to use
PEU2 Use of Tablet PC is clear and understandable
PEU3 It is easy for me to remember how to perform tasks using Tablet PC
PEU4 Overall, I find the Tablet PCis easy to use
4. Subjective Norm (SN)
SN1 Most people who are important to me expect me to use Tablet PC
SN2 Most of my friends believe using Tablet PC is a wise decision.
SN3 People whose opinions I valued preferred that I use Tablet PC
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 114 114
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)5. Optimism (Opti)
OPTI1 Tablet PC gives more control on my daily life
OPTI2 Tablet PCis much more convenient to use
OPTI3 I like the idea of learning via Tablet pc because I am not limited to
manual transactions
OPTI4 I prefer to use the most advanced technology available
OPTI5 I like Tablet PC that allow you to tailor things to fit your own needs
OPTI6 Tablet PC makes you more efficient in your occupation
OPTI7 I find Tablet PC to be mentally stimulating
OPTI8 Tablet PC gives you more freedom of mobility
OPTI9 Learning about technology can be as rewarding as the technology itself
OPTI10 I feel confident that Tablet PC will follow through with what you
instructed them to do
6. Innovativeness (Inn)
INNO1 Other people come to me for advice on Tablet PC
INNO2 It seems my friends are learning more about the Tablet PC than me
INNO3 In general, I am the first among in my circle of friends to acquire
Tablet PC when it appears
INNO4 I can usually figure out Tablet PC without help from others
INNO5 I keep up with the latest technological developments in my areas of
interest
INNO6 I enjoy the challenge of figuring out high-technologies
INNO7 I find i have fewer problems than other people in making technology
work for me
7. Discomfort (Disc)
DISC1 Technical support lines are not helpful because they do not explain
things in terms you understand
DISC2 Sometimes, I think that Tablet PC is not designed for use by ordinary
people
DSIC3 There is no such thing as a manual for a high-tech product or service
that is written in plain language
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 115 115
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)DSIC4 When i get technical support from a provider of a Tablet PC, in
sometimes i feel as if i being taken advantage of by someone who knows
more than i do
DSIC5 If I useTablet PC,I prefer to have a lot of features
DSIC6 It is embarrassing when I have trouble with a Tablet PCsystem while
people are watching
DSIC7 Tablet PC makes it too easy for teachers to monitor student
performance
DSIC8 Technology always seems to fail at the worst possible time
8. Insecurity (Insc)
INSC1 I do not consider it safe in adopting Tablet PC
INSC2 I do not consider it safe to learn online
INSC3 I worry that information you send over the Internet will be seen by
other people
INSC4 I do not feel confident doing banking with a place that can only be
reached online
INSC5 Any business transaction I do electronically should be confirmed later
with something in writing
INSC6 Whenever something gets automated, I need to check carefully that the
Tablet pc or software is not making mistakes
INSC7 The human touch is very important while transacting throughTablet
PC
INSC8 When I call a business, I prefer to talk to a person rather than a
machine
INSC9 If I am provided information to a machine or over the Internet, I can
never be sure it really gets to right place
9. Behavioural Intention (BI)
BI1 I predict that I will use Tablet PC on a regular basis in the future
BI2 I expect that I will use Tablet PC system, or a similar type of system for
Learning
BI3 I will use Tablet PC in futur
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 116 116
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Table No 7
Descriptive StatisticsN Mean Std.
DeviationVariance Skewness Kurtosis
Statistic
Statistic Statistic Statistic Statistic Std. Error Statistic Std. Error
PU1 201 3.93 .967 .935 -.865 .172 .745 .341
PU2 201 3.96 .976 .953 -.822 .172 .458 .341
PU3 201 4.00 .964 .930 -.811 .172 .207 .341
PU4 201 3.98 .938 .880 -.915 .172 .761 .341
PU5 201 3.99 1.049 1.100 -1.004 .172 .458 .341
ATTI1 201 3.80 1.063 1.130 -.805 .172 .163 .341
ATTI2 201 4.10 1.000 1.000 -1.171 .172 1.129 .341
ATTI3 201 4.11 .976 .952 -1.309 .172 1.801 .341
ATTI4 201 4.00 1.007 1.015 -.879 .172 .353 .341
ATTI5 201 4.00 1.044 1.090 -.985 .172 .554 .341
PEU1 201 4.14 1.025 1.050 -1.352 .172 1.503 .341
PEU2 201 4.05 1.073 1.152 -1.016 .172 .330 .341
PEU3 201 4.07 .982 .965 -.972 .172 .402 .341
PEU4 201 4.18 .985 .971 -1.359 .172 1.692 .341
SN1 201 3.86 1.093 1.194 -.801 .172 -.062 .341
SN2 201 3.94 1.068 1.141 -1.039 .172 .670 .341
SN3 201 3.85 1.043 1.088 -.899 .172 .458 .341
OPTI1 201 3.82 1.154 1.331 -.759 .172 -.356 .341
OPTI2 201 4.02 .985 .970 -.865 .172 .323 .341
OPTI3 201 3.92 1.093 1.194 -.886 .172 .173 .341
OPTI4 201 4.16 1.074 1.155 -1.470 .172 1.634 .341
OPTI5 201 4.01 1.075 1.155 -1.202 .172 1.067 .341
OPTI6 201 3.99 1.015 1.030 -.966 .172 .597 .341
OPTI7 201 3.75 1.145 1.310 -.721 .172 -.262 .341
OPTI8 201 4.08 1.065 1.134 -1.189 .172 .843 .341
OPTI9 201 4.05 .912 .832 -.867 .172 .621 .341
OPTI10 201 4.03 .919 .844 -.969 .172 .837 .341
INNO1 201 3.72 1.221 1.492 -.732 .172 -.408 .341
INNO2 201 3.69 1.215 1.476 -.645 .172 -.531 .341
INNO3 201 3.75 1.196 1.430 -.844 .172 -.100 .341
INNO4 201 3.94 1.125 1.266 -.987 .172 .315 .341
INNO5 201 4.06 1.013 1.026 -1.024 .172 .593 .341
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 117 117
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)INNO6 201 4.15 .985 .971 -1.328 .172 1.622 .341
INNO7 201 3.77 1.153 1.330 -.836 .172 .029 .341
DISC1 201 3.59 1.218 1.483 -.586 .172 -.630 .341
DISC2 201 3.50 1.257 1.581 -.520 .172 -.714 .341
DISC3 201 3.69 1.079 1.164 -.638 .172 -.197 .341
DISC4 201 3.82 1.145 1.311 -.885 .172 .114 .341
DISC5 201 4.08 1.031 1.064 -1.045 .172 .517 .341
DISC6 201 3.74 1.176 1.383 -.751 .172 -.265 .341
DISC7 201 4.00 1.079 1.165 -1.099 .172 .734 .341
DISC8 201 3.48 1.249 1.561 -.454 .172 -.806 .341
INSC1 201 3.38 1.326 1.758 -.525 .172 -.913 .341
INSC2 201 3.36 1.386 1.921 -.459 .172 -1.033 .341
INSC3 201 3.58 1.189 1.414 -.656 .172 -.424 .341
INSC4 201 3.61 1.157 1.339 -.687 .172 -.318 .341
INSC5 201 3.77 1.034 1.070 -.558 .172 -.275 .341
INSC6 201 3.80 1.142 1.303 -.977 .172 .282 .341
INSC7 201 4.08 1.036 1.074 -1.114 .172 .754 .341
INSC8 201 3.86 1.106 1.224 -.785 .172 -.072 .341
INSC9 201 3.78 1.128 1.272 -.806 .172 .019 .341
BI1 201 4.03 1.012 1.024 -.948 .172 .448 .341
BI2 201 4.07 1.010 1.019 -1.122 .172 .953 .341
BI3 201 4.28 .982 .964 -1.492 .172 1.742 .341
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 118 118
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
Items Mean Cronbach’s
Alpha
Perceived usefulness (PU)PU1 Using Tablet PC will save my time in Learning 3.93 0.822
PU2 Using Tablet PC would improve my performance in Learning 3.96PU3 Using Tablet PC would improve my productivity in Learning 4.00PU4 Using Tablet PC would improve my effectiveness in Learning 3.98PU5 I find Tablet PC to be useful in Learning 3.99Attitude (ATTI)ATTI1 In my opinion it is desirable to use Tablet PC for learning 3.80 0.807
ATTI2 I think it will be good for me to use Tablet PC for learning 4.10ATTI3 I think learning through Tablet PC is a good idea 4.11ATTI4 Overall, my attitude toward Tablet PC is favourable 4.00ATTI5 Generally speaking, I like the idea of Tablet PC for learning 4.00Perceived Ease of Use (PEU)PEU1 I find Tablet PC easy to use 4.14 0.848
PEU2 Use of Tablet PC is clear and understandable 4.05PEU3 It is easy for me to remember how to perform tasks using Tablet PC 4.07
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 119 119
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
PEU4 Overall, I find the Tablet PCis easy to use 4.18Subjective Norm (SN)SN1 Most people who are important to me expect me to use Tablet 3.86 0.744
SN2 Most of my friends believe using Tablet PC is a wise decision. 3.94
SN3 People whose opinions I valued preferred that I use Tablet PC 3.85
Optimism (Opti)
OPTI1 Tablet PC gives more control on my daily life 3.82 0.904
OPTI2 Tablet PCis much more convenient to use 4.02OPTI3 I like the idea of learning via Tablet pc because I am not limited to manual
transactions 3.92
OPTI4 I prefer to use the most advanced technology available 4.16OPTI5 I like Tablet PC that allow you to tailor things to fit your own needs 4.01OPTI6 Tablet PC makes you more efficient in your occupation 3.99OPTI7 I find Tablet PC to be mentally stimulating 3.75OPTI8 Tablet PC gives you more freedom of mobility 4.08OPTI9 Learning about technology can be as rewarding as the technology itself 4.05OPTI10 I feel confident that Tablet PC will follow through with what you instructed them to
do 4.03
Innovativeness (Inn)
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 120 120
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
INNO1 Other people come to me for advice on Tablet PC 3.72 0.798
INNO2 It seems my friends are learning more about the Tablet PC than me 3.69INNO3 In general, I am the first among in my circle of friends to acquire Tablet PC when it
appears 3.75
INNO4 I can usually figure out Tablet PC without help from others 3.94INNO5 I keep up with the latest technological developments in my areas of interest 4.06INNO6 I enjoy the challenge of figuring out high-technologies 4.15INNO7 I find i have fewer problems than other people in making technology work for me 3.77Discomfort (Disc)DISC1 Technical support lines are not helpful because they do not explain things in terms
you understand 3.590.787
DISC2 Sometimes, I think that Tablet PC is not designed for use by ordinary people 3.50DSIC3 There is no such thing as a manual for a high-tech product or service that is written
in plain language 3.69
DSIC4 When i get technical support from a provider of a Tablet PC, in sometimes i feel as if
i being taken advantage of by someone who knows more than i do 3.82
DSIC5 If I useTablet PC,I prefer to have a lot of features 4.08DSIC6 It is embarrassing when I have trouble with a Tablet PCsystem while people are
watching 3.74
DSIC7 Tablet PC makes it too easy for teachers to monitor student performance 4.00
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 121 121
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
DSIC8 Technology always seems to fail at the worst possible time3.48
Insecurity (INSC)
INSC1 I do not consider it safe in adopting Tablet PC 3.38 0.851
INSC2 I do not consider it safe to learn online 3.36INSC3 I worry that information you send over the Internet will be seen by other people 3.58INSC4 I do not feel confident doing banking with a place that can only be reached online 3.61INSC5 Any business transaction I do electronically should be confirmed later with
something in writing 3.77
INSC6 Whenever something gets automated, I need to check carefully that the Tablet pc or
software is not making mistakes 3.80
INSC7 The human touch is very important while transacting throughTablet PC 4.08INSC8 When I call a business, I prefer to talk to a person rather than a machine 3.86INSC9 If I am provided information to a machine or over the Internet, I can never be sure it
really gets to right place 3.78
Behavioural Intention (BI)
BI1 I predict that I will use Tablet PC on a regular basis in the future 4.03 0.742
BI2 I expect that I will use Tablet PC system, or a similar type of system for Learning 4.07
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 122 122
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
BI3 I will use Tablet PC in future 4.28
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 123 123
UNDERSTANDING NEW TECHNOLOGY BY ENGINEERING STUDENTS: APPLICATION OF TECHNOLOGY READINESS AND ACCEPTING
TECHNOLOGY (TRAT)
A S PATIL COLLEGE OF COMMERCE (AUTONOMOUS ),BIJAPURMBA-PROGRAMME 124 124