Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are...

34
Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From Different Stakeholders Academic Year: 2017-2018 Students Feedback: The students are the most important stakeholders of Higher Education systems. The interest and participation of students at all levels in both internal quality assurance and external quality assurance have to play a central role. From the current academic year the college has started online feedback system. We have collected online feedback from our under graduate third year students and post graduate students. A special five point scale feedback form on the curriculum is development. We have received total 597 student’s online feedback on the syllabus of the various programmes designed by the Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune. Questi on No. Curriculum Evaluation Points Response in % Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 1 Curriculum updated enough 31.83 40.20 17.76 9.05 1.17 2 Curriculum content interesting 43.22 36.18 15.75 4.52 0.34 3 Curriculum fulfilling your expectation 36.85 43.22 14.24 4.19 1.51 4 Curriculum helping in developing your personality 50.08 41.88 6.20 1.84 0.00 5 Curriculum applicable in your daily life 40.70 42.38 13.07 3.52 0.34 6 Curriculum is relevant for the solution of local problems 64.66 30.82 3.35 0.67 0.50 7 Need to include skill based content in current syllabus 40.37 44.22 13.40 1.84 0.17

Transcript of Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are...

Page 1: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From DifferentStakeholders

Academic Year: 2017-2018

Students Feedback:

The students are the most important stakeholders of Higher Education systems. The interest and

participation of students at all levels in both internal quality assurance and external quality assurance

have to play a central role. From the current academic year the college has started online feedback

system. We have collected online feedback from our under graduate third year students and post

graduate students. A special five point scale feedback form on the curriculum is development. We have

received total 597 student’s online feedback on the syllabus of the various programmes designed by the

Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune.

Question No.

Curriculum EvaluationPoints

Response in %

StronglyAgree

Agree Neutral Disagree StronglyDisagree

1 Curriculum updated enough 31.83 40.20 17.76 9.05 1.17

2 Curriculum content interesting 43.22 36.18 15.75 4.52 0.34

3 Curriculum fulfilling yourexpectation

36.85 43.22 14.24 4.19 1.51

4 Curriculum helping indeveloping your personality

50.08 41.88 6.20 1.84 0.00

5 Curriculum applicable in yourdaily life

40.70 42.38 13.07 3.52 0.34

6 Curriculum is relevant for thesolution of local problems

64.66 30.82 3.35 0.67 0.50

7 Need to include skill basedcontent in current syllabus

40.37 44.22 13.40 1.84 0.17

Page 2: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

On an average 44% students are strongly agree, 40% are agree, 12% are neutral, 4% are disagree and

1% are strongly disagree with the current syllabus of the various programmes designed by the Savitribai

Phule Pune University, Pune.

Teachers Feedback:

The college is affiliated to the Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune and follows the prescribed

curriculum. Still online feedback on curriculum is taken by the respective subject teachers regarding

suggestions on improvement of the syllabus. We have received 69 teachers feedback on the curriculum

and analyzed.

QuestionNo.

Curriculum Evaluation Points Response in %StronglyAgree

Agree Neutral Disagree StronglyDisagree

1 Current syllabus is need based 63.54 33.33 2.08 1.042 02 Curriculum having current content 45.83 45.83 6.25 2.083 03 Programmes outcomes of the

syllabi is well defined38.54 46.88 13.54 1.042 0

4 Curriculum having good academicflexibility

52.08 40.63 6.25 1.042 0

5 The course content fulfils the needof students

46.88 38.54 12.50 2.083 0

6 Need of review of the syllabus 36.46 53.13 8.33 2.083 07 Curriculum enhanced

employability29.17 52.08 16.67 2.083 0

Page 3: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with

the current syllabus of the various programmes designed by the Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune.

Parent Feedback:

The online feedback from the parents is collected on the current syllabus of the various programmes and

analyzed. We have received total 143 parent’s feedback on the current content of the syllabus. Analysis

of the total 143 feedback received from the parents is done as follows:

QuestionNo.

Curriculum Evaluation Points Response in %

StronglyAgree

Agree Neutral Disagree StronglyDisagree

1 Syllabus of your ward having currentcontentlnj vH;kldzekrhy vk’k; ln; ifjLFkhrh’khlaca/khr vkgs

47.62 48.41 3.97 0 0

2 Curriculum help in enhancingintellectual aptitudelnj vH;kldzekrqu ckS/nhd {kerk ok<rs

26.98 61.11 11.11 0.79 0

3 Curriculum help in developingpersonality of your wardlnj vH;kldzekrqu rqeP;k ikY;kpk O;DrheÙofodkl gksrks

31.75 46.03 19.84 2.38 0

4 Curriculum enhancesemployabilitylnj vH;kldzek}kjs jkstxkj {kerk ok<rs

26.98 44.44 25.40 3.17 0

5 Syllabus is applicable to the solutionfor the local problemslnj vH;kldzekrwu LFkkfud leL;kaps fujkdj.k

26.98 53.17 17.46 2.38 0

Page 4: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

gksrs6 Your ward get adequate knowledge

from the curriculumlnj vH;kldzekrqu vkiY;k ikY;kl Kku feGrss

39.68 45.24 13.49 1.59 0

On an average 33% students are strongly agree, 50% are agree, 15% are neutral and 2% are disagree

with the current syllabus of the various programmes designed by the Savitribai Phule Pune University,

Pune.

Alumni Feedback:

Our alumni are valuable for us. They provide us the inputs regarding improvement in facilities and

employability of our students. We appeal our alumni to provide there sincere feedback on curriculum.

We have received total 96 alumni online feedback on syllabus designed by Savitribai Phule Pune

University Pune. Based on the comments of the alumni, the analysis is done as follows:

QuestionNo.

Curriculum Evaluation Points ResponseStronglyAgree

Agree Neutral Disagree StronglyDisagree

1. Ned of syllabus updation 40.23 45.98 8.62 4.02 1.152. Course content is interesting 29.89 62.07 6.32 1.15 0.573. Course curriculum intellectually

stimulate you29.31 55.75 12.07 2.87 0.00

4. Course curriculum fulfilling yourexpectations

31.61 49.43 12.64 6.32 0.00

5 Programme help in developingyour personality

29.89 55.17 12.07 2.87 0.00

Page 5: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

6 Courses meet contemporaryrequirements

17.82 55.17 20.11 6.32 0.57

7 Reading material regardingcurriculum is easily available

22.41 49.43 17.24 10.34 0.57

8 Syllabus enhances employability 24.71 51.15 18.97 4.60 0.57

On an average 28% students are strongly agree, 53% are agree, 14% are neutral and 5% are disagree

with the current syllabus of the various programmes designed by the Savitribai Phule Pune University,

Pune.

Employers Feedback:

Employer’s online feedback is collected and analyzed on the syllabus designed by Savitribai Phule Pune

University Pune. We have received total 52 employer’s online feedback for the current academic year.

QuestionNo.

Curriculum Evaluation Points ResponseStronglyAgree

Agree Neutral Disagree StronglyDisagree

1 Curriculum relevant foremployability

50.00 37.50 12.50 0.00 0.00

2 Curriculum effective in developinginnovative thinking

34.38 51.56 14.06 0.00 0.00

3 Syllabus effective in developing skilloriented human resources

68.75 31.25 0.00 0.00 0.00

4 Current syllabus is need based 45.31 53.13 1.56 0.00 0.005 Effectiveness of curriculum for

development of entrepreneurship54.69 39.06 6.25 0.00 0.00

Page 6: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

On an average 51% students are strongly agree, 43% are agree and 7% are neutral with the current

syllabus of the various programmes designed by the Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune.

Page 7: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From Stakeholders

Academic Year: 2016-2017

Students Feedback:

The students are the most important stakeholders of Higher Education systems. The interest and

participation of students at all levels in both internal quality assurance and external quality

assurance have to play a central role. We have collected feedback from our under graduate third

year students and post graduate students personally. We have received total 195 students

feedback on the curriculum and analyzed.

QuestionNumber Question

ResponseYes No

Total % Total %1 Was the syllabus updated enough 181 92.82 14 7.18

2 Was the course content interesting 142 72.82 53 27.18

3Did the course curriculumintellectually motivate you

173 88.72 22 11.28

4Was the course curriculum fulfillingyour expectations

143 73.33 52 26.67

5

Does the syllabus create any interestto pursue post graduation / researchin the particular subject

148 75.90 47 24.10

6Did the subject / course help indeveloping your personality

152 77.95 43 22.05

7Were the subject applicable in yourpractical / daily life

155 79.49 40 20.51

8

Were reading material andreferences regarding curriculum /subject easily found

151 77.44 44 22.56

9Does the syllabus is relevant for thesolution of local problems

163 83.59 32 16.41

10Is there need to include skill basedcontent in current syllabus

148 75.90 47 24.10

Page 8: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

From the above diagram it is seen that the more than 80% students rated curriculum is updated

enough and 73% students say course content is interesting. 76% students say that the course

curriculum creates interest to pursue post graduation / research in the particular subject; it is

applicable in a practical life and relevant for the solution of local problems.

Teachers Feedback:

The college is affiliated to the Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune and follows the prescribed

curriculum. Still feedback on curriculum is taken by the respective subject teachers regarding

suggestions on improvement of the syllabus. We have received total 80 teachers feedback on the

curriculum and analyzed as follows:

QuestionNumber Question

ResponseYes No

Total % Total %

1Does the syllabus reflect current content 75 93.75 5 6.25

2Does the current syllabus is need based 68 85 12 15

3

Are the programmes outcomes, programmesspecific outcomes and course outcomes of thesyllabi is well defined

68 85 12 15

4Is the syllabus heavy for the students 41 51.25 39 48.75

5

Does the course / programmes of studies carriessufficient number of optional papers 59 73.75 21 26.25

92.82

72.82

88.72

73.33 75.90 77.95 79.49 77.4483.59

75.90

0.00

20.00

40.00

60.00

80.00

100.00

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Resp

onse

(%)

Question Number

Student Feedback Analysis 2016-2017

Yes

No

Page 9: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

6

Is the current syllabus / course content madeinterest in the subject area 62 77.5 18 22.5

7

Are the books prescribed / listed as referencematerials relevant and updated 62 77.5 18 22.5

8

Does the course contents fulfilled the need ofstudents 61 76.25 19 23.75

9Is there a need of review of the syllabus 57 71.25 23 28.75

10

Does the syllabus reflects good balance betweentheory and practical’s 61 76.25 19 23.75

From the above analysis it is observed that the 94% terachers rated the syllabus reflects current

contents. 95% teachers say that the current syllabus is need based and the programmes

outcomes, programmes specific outcomes and course outcomes of the syllabi is well

defined. On an average 76% teachers are satisfied with the current syllabus designed by the

Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune.

Parent Feedback:

The feedback from the parents is also collected on the current syllabus of the various

programmes and analyzed. We have received total 147 parent’s feedback on the current content

of the syllabus. Analysis of the feedback received from the parents is done as follows:

93.7585 85

51.25

73.75 77.5 77.5 76.25 71.25 76.25

0102030405060708090100

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Resp

onse

(%)

Question Number

Teachers Feedback Analysis 2016-2017

Yes

No

Page 10: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

QuestionNumber Question

Response

Yes No

Total % Total %

1Whether the syllabus of your childhaving current content

130 88.44 17 11.56

2Does the content of the syllabus isheavy for your child

118 80.27 29 19.73

3Whether the course curriculumintellectually motivate your child

125 85.03 22 14.97

4Was the course curriculum fulfillingyour child expectations

118 80.27 29 19.73

5Does the course help in developingpersonality of your child

128 87.07 19 12.93

6Were the course is applicable indaily life

118 80.27 29 19.73

7Whether the child achieved the courseoutcomes after completing the courses

121 82.31 26 17.69

8

Whether study tour or field visits arenecessary for enhancing the learningability of your child

120 81.63 27 18.37

9Does the syllabus is relevant to thesolution for the local problems

107 72.79 40 27.21

10Does the your child gets adequateknowledge from the course

126 85.71 21 14.29

88.4480.27 85.03 80.27

87.0780.27 82.31 81.63

72.79

85.71

0.0010.0020.0030.0040.0050.0060.0070.0080.0090.00100.00

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Resp

onse

(%)

Question Number

Parent Feedback Analysis 2016-2017

Yes

No

Page 11: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

The above analysis shows that the more than 80% parents are satisfied with the current syllabus

of the various programmes designed by the Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune.

Alumni Feedback:

Our alumni are valuable for us. They provide us the inputs regarding improvement in facilities

and employability of our students. We appeal our alumni to provide there sincere feedback on

curriculum. We have received total 99 alumni feedback on syllabus designed by Savitribai Phule

Pune Univesity Pune. Based on the comments of the alumni, the analysis is done as follows:

Question

NumberQuestion

Response

Yes No

Total % Total %

1Was the syllabus updated enough 93 93.94 6 6.06

2Was the course content interesting 78 78.79 21 21.21

3Did the course curriculum intellectually stimulate you 82 82.83 17 17.17

4

Was the course curriculum fulfilling your expectations73 73.74 26 26.26

5

Does the syllabus create any interest to pursue postgraduation / research in the particular subject 68 68.69 31 31.31

6

Did the subject / course help in developing yourpersonality 73 73.74 26 26.26

7

Were the subject applicable in your practical / daily life61 61.62 38 38.38

8

Were reading material and references regardingcurriculum / subject easily found 74 74.75 25 25.25

9

Was the subject relevance to your job and the futureaspirations 70 70.71 29 29.29

10

Does the syllabi is effective in enhancing team workabilities 75 75.76 24 24.24

Page 12: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

The above analysis shows that on an average more than 71% alumni’s are satisfied with the

current syllabus of the programmes B.A., M. A., B. Sc. M. Sc., B. Sc. computer science and M.

Sc. computer science designed by Savitribai Phule Pune Univesity Pune.

Employer Feedback:

Employer feedback is collected and analyzed taken on the syllabus designed by Savitribai Phule

Pune Univesity Pune. We have received total 79 employer’s feedback for the current academic

year.

QuestionNumber Question

ResponseYes No

Total % Total %

1

Was the curriculum followed by the employeerelevant for employability? 71 89.87 8 10.13

2

Whether the curriculum is effective in developinginnovative thinking 62 78.48 17 21.52

3

Does the syllabus is effective in developing skilloriented human recourses 60 75.95 19 24.05

4

Whether the syllabus is helpful for development ofteam work abilities 61 77.22 18 22.78

5Does the current syllabus is need based 60 75.95 19 24.05

6

Does the syllabus is effective for development ofentrepreneurship 60 75.95 19 24.05

93.94

78.79 82.8373.74 68.69 73.74

61.6274.75 70.71 75.76

0.00

20.00

40.00

60.00

80.00

100.00

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Resp

onse

(%)

Question Number

Alumni Feedback Analysis 2016-2017

Yes

No

Page 13: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

7

Whether curriculum is effective for development ofcommunication skills 62 78.48 17 21.52

From the above diagram it is seen that the more than 75% employer say that the curriculum is

effective for development of communication skills and relevant for employability. More than 75

% employers rated that the curriculum is effective in developing innovative thinking, team work

abilities and entrepreneurship. 76% employers rated that the syllabus is effective in developing

skill oriented human recourses.

89.8778.48 75.95 77.22 75.95 75.95 78.48

0.00

20.00

40.00

60.00

80.00

100.00

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Resp

onse

(%)

Question Number

Employer Feedback Analysis 2016-2017

Yes

No

Page 14: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From Stakeholders

Academic Year: 2015-2016

Students Feedback:

The students are the most important stakeholders of Higher Education systems. The interest and

participation of students at all levels in both internal quality assurance and external quality

assurance have to play a central role. We have collected feedback from our under graduate third

year students and post graduate students personally. We have received total 200 students’s

feedback on the curriculum designing and analyzed as follows:

QuestionNumber Question

ResponseYes No

Total % Total %1 Was the syllabus updated enough 186 93.00 14 7.00

2 Was the course content interesting 156 78.00 44 22.00

3Did the course curriculumintellectually motivate you

168 84.00 32 16.00

4Was the course curriculum fulfillingyour expectations

152 76.00 48 24.00

5

Does the syllabus create any interestto pursue post graduation / researchin the particular subject

169 84.50 31 15.50

6Did the subject / course help indeveloping your personality

170 85.00 30 15.00

7Were the subject applicable in yourpractical / daily life

161 80.50 39 19.50

8

Were reading material andreferences regarding curriculum /subject easily found

159 79.50 41 20.50

9Does the syllabus is relevant for thesolution of local problems

165 82.50 35 17.50

10Is there need to include skill basedcontent in current syllabus

163 81.50 37 18.50

Page 15: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

From the above diagram it is seen that the more than 80% students are satisfied with the current

content of the syllabus designed by the Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune.

Teachers Feedback:

The college is affiliated to the Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune and follows the prescribed

curriculum. Still feedback on curriculum is taken by the respective subject teachers regarding

suggestions on improvement of the syllabus. We have received total 81 teacher’s feedback on the

syllabus designed by the Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune.

QuestionNumber Question

Response

Yes No

Total % Total %

1Does the syllabus reflect current content 76 93.83 5 6.17

2Does the current syllabus is need based 71 87.65 10 12.35

3

Are the programmes outcomes, programmesspecific outcomes and course outcomes of thesyllabi is well defined

67 82.72 14 17.28

4Is the syllabus heavy for the students 36 44.44 45 55.56

5

Does the course / programmes of studies carriessufficient number of optional papers 56 69.14 25 30.86

6 Is the current syllabus / course content made 64 79.01 17 20.99

93.00

78.0084.00

76.0084.50 85.00 80.50 79.50 82.50 81.50

0.00

20.00

40.00

60.00

80.00

100.00

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Resp

onse

(%)

Question Number

Student Feedback Analysis 2015-2016

Yes

No

Page 16: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

interest in the subject area

7

Are the books prescribed / listed as referencematerials relevant and updated 68 83.95 13 16.05

8

Does the course contents fulfilled the need ofstudents 64 79.01 17 20.99

9Is there a need of review of the syllabus 60 74.07 21 25.93

10

Does the syllabus reflects good balance betweentheory and practical’s 65 80.25 16 19.75

From the above diagram it is observed that the more than 80% teacher’s rated the syllabus

reflects current content, need based and well defined. However, 74% teachers rated there is need

of review of the syllabus. On an average more than 80% teacher’s are satisfied with the current

content of the syllabia.

Parent Feedback:

93.8387.65

82.72

44.44

69.1479.01

83.9579.01

74.0780.25

0.0010.0020.0030.0040.0050.0060.0070.0080.0090.00100.00

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Resp

onse

(%)

Question Number

Teachers Feedback Analysis 2015-2016

Yes

No

Page 17: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

The feedback from the parents is also collected on the current syllabus of the programmes and

analyzed. We have received total 150 parent’s feedback on the current content of the syllabus.

Analysis of the feedback received from the parents is done as follows:

QuestionNumber Question

Response

Yes No

Total % Total %

1Whether the syllabus of your childhaving current content

132 88.00 18 12.00

2Does the content of the syllabus isheavy for your child

113 75.33 37 24.67

3Whether the course curriculumintellectually motivate your child

120 80.00 30 20.00

4Was the course curriculum fulfillingyour child expectations

120 80.00 30 20.00

5Does the course help in developingpersonality of your child

126 84.00 24 16.00

6Were the course is applicable indaily life

111 74.00 39 26.00

7Whether the child achieved the courseoutcomes after completing the courses

127 84.67 23 15.33

8

Whether study tour or field visits arenecessary for enhancing the learningability of your child

127 84.67 23 15.33

9Does the syllabus is relevant to thesolution for the local problems

103 68.67 47 31.33

10Does the your child gets adequateknowledge from the course

133 88.67 17 11.33

Page 18: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

From the above diagram it is observed that the on an average 81% parents are satisfied with the

current content of the syllabus designed by Savitribai Phule Pune Univesity Pune.

Alumni Feedback:

Our alumni are valuable for us. They provide us the inputs regarding improvement in facilities

and employability of our students. We appeal our alumni to provide there sincere feedback on

curriculum. We have received total 97 alumni feedback on syllabus designed by Savitribai Phule

Pune Univesity Pune. Based on the comments of the alumni, the analysis is done as follows:

Question

NumberQuestion

ResponseYes No

Total % Total %

1Was the syllabus updated enough 87 89.69 10 10.31

2Was the course content interesting 66 68.04 31 31.96

3Did the course curriculum intellectually stimulate you 73 75.26 24 24.74

4

Was the course curriculum fulfilling your expectations64 65.98 33 34.02

5

Does the syllabus create any interest to pursue postgraduation / research in the particular subject 69 71.13 28 28.87

6

Did the subject / course help in developing yourpersonality 57 58.76 40 41.24

88.0075.33 80.00 80.00 84.00

74.0084.67 84.67

68.67

88.67

0.00

20.00

40.00

60.00

80.00

100.00

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Resp

onse

(%)

Question Number

Parent Feedback Analysis 2015-2016

Yes

No

Page 19: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

7

Were the subject applicable in your practical / daily life66 68.04 31 31.96

8

Were reading material and references regardingcurriculum / subject easily found 66 68.04 31 31.96

9

Was the subject relevance to your job and the futureaspirations 71 73.20 26 26.80

10

Does the syllabi is effective in enhancing team workabilities 71 73.20 26 26.80

The above diagram shows that on an average more than 71% alumni’s are satisfied with the

current syllabus of the programmes B.A., M. A., B. Sc. M. Sc., B. Sc. computer science and M.

Sc. computer science designed by Savitribai Phule Pune Univesity Pune.

Employer Feedback:

Employer feedback is collected and analyzed on the syllabus designed by Savitribai Phule Pune

Univesity Pune. We have received total 71 employer’s feedback for the current academic year.

QuestionNumber Question

ResponseYes No

Total % Total %

1

Was the curriculum followed by the employeerelevant for employability? 60 84.51 11 15.49

2 Whether the curriculum is effective in developing 60 84.51 11 15.49

89.69

68.0475.26

65.98 71.1358.76

68.04 68.04 73.20 73.20

0.00

20.00

40.00

60.00

80.00

100.00

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Resp

onse

(%)

Question Number

Alumni Feedback Analysis 2015-2016

Yes

No

Page 20: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

innovative thinking

3

Does the syllabus is effective in developing skilloriented human recourses 58 81.69 13 18.31

4

Whether the syllabus is helpful for development ofteam work abilities 54 76.06 17 23.94

5Does the current syllabus is need based 57 80.28 14 19.72

6

Does the syllabus is effective for development ofentrepreneurship 50 70.42 21 29.58

7

Whether curriculum is effective for development ofcommunication skills 51 71.83 20 28.17

From the above diagram it is seen that the more than 80% employer say that the curriculum is

effective for development of communication skills and relevant for employability. More than 70

% employers rated that the curriculum is effective in developing innovative thinking, team work

abilities and entrepreneurship.

84.51 84.51 81.69 76.06 80.2870.42 71.83

0.00

20.00

40.00

60.00

80.00

100.00

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Resp

onse

(%)

Question Number

Employer Feedback Analysis 2015-2016

Yes

No

Page 21: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From Stakeholders

Academic Year: 2014-2015

Students Feedback:

The students are the most important stakeholders of Higher Education systems. The interest and

participation of students at all levels in both internal quality assurance and external quality

assurance have to play a central role. We have collected feedback from our under graduate third

year students and post graduate students personally. We have designed a special feedback form

on curriculum development. Total 173 feedback on the curriculum from the students are

collected and analyzed as follows.

QuestionNumber Question

ResponseYes No

Total % Total %1 Was the syllabus updated enough 157 90.75 16 9.25

2 Was the course content interesting 138 79.77 35 20.23

3Did the course curriculumintellectually motivate you

140 80.92 43 24.86

4Was the course curriculum fulfillingyour expectations

125 72.25 48 27.75

5

Does the syllabus create any interestto pursue post graduation / researchin the particular subject

141 81.50 32 18.50

6Did the subject / course help indeveloping your personality

138 79.77 35 20.23

7Were the subject applicable in yourpractical / daily life

145 83.82 28 16.18

8

Were reading material andreferences regarding curriculum /subject easily found

141 81.50 32 18.50

9Does the syllabus is relevant for thesolution of local problems

142 82.08 31 17.92

10Is there need to include skill basedcontent in current syllabus

139 80.35 34 19.65

Page 22: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

From the above diagram it is seen that the on an average more than 80% students are satisfied

with the current content of the syllabus designed by the Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune.

Teachers Feedback:

The college is affiliated to the Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune and follows the prescribed

curriculum. Still feedback on curriculum is taken by the respective subject teachers regarding

suggestions on improvement of the syllabus. We have received total 72 teacher’s feedback on the

curriculum and analyzed as follows.

QuestionNumber Question

ResponseYes No

Total % Total %

1Does the syllabus reflect current content 68 94.44 4 5.56

2Does the current syllabus is need based 59 81.94 13 18.06

3

Are the programmes outcomes, programmesspecific outcomes and course outcomes of thesyllabi is well defined

69 95.83 9 12.50

4Is the syllabus heavy for the students 38 52.78 34 47.22

5

Does the course / programmes of studies carriessufficient number of optional papers 52 72.22 20 27.78

6

Is the current syllabus / course content madeinterest in the subject area 59 81.94 13 18.06

90.7579.77 80.92

72.2581.50 79.77 83.82 81.50 82.08 80.35

0.00

20.00

40.00

60.00

80.00

100.00

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Resp

onse

(%)

Question Number

Student Feedback Analysis 2014-2015

Yes

No

Page 23: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

7

Are the books prescribed / listed as referencematerials relevant and updated 61 84.72 11 15.28

8

Does the course contents fulfilled the need ofstudents 60 83.33 12 16.67

9Is there a need of review of the syllabus 64 88.89 8 11.11

10

Does the syllabus reflects good balance betweentheory and practical’s 58 80.56 14 19.44

The above diagram shows that the teachers are satisfied with the current content of the syllabus

designed by the Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune. It is also observed that the more than

90% teacher’s are rated syllabus reflects current content and the programmes outcomes,

programmes specific outcomes and course outcomes of the syllabi is well defined.

Parent Feedback:

The feedback from the parents is also collected on the current syllabus of the programmes and

analyzed. We have received total 144 parent’s feedback on the current content of the syllabus.

Analysis of the feedback received from the parents is done as follows:

QuestionNumber Question

ResponseYes No

Total % Total %

94.4481.94

95.83

52.78

72.2281.94 84.72 83.33 88.89

80.56

0.00

20.00

40.00

60.00

80.00

100.00

120.00

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Resp

onse

(%)

Question Number

Teachers Feedback Analysis 2014-2015

Yes

No

Page 24: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

1Whether the syllabus of your childhaving current content

131 90.97 13 9.03

2Does the content of the syllabus isheavy for your child

114 79.17 30 20.83

3Whether the course curriculumintellectually motivate your child

116 80.56 28 19.44

4Was the course curriculum fulfillingyour child expectations

114 79.17 30 20.83

5Does the course help in developingpersonality of your child

123 85.42 21 14.58

6Were the course is applicable indaily life

99 68.75 45 31.25

7Whether the child achieved the courseoutcomes after completing the courses

112 77.78 32 22.22

8

Whether study tour or field visits arenecessary for enhancing the learningability of your child

110 76.39 34 23.61

9Does the syllabus is relevant to thesolution for the local problems

104 72.22 40 27.78

10Does the your child gets adequateknowledge from the course

125 86.81 19 13.19

From the above diagram it is observed that the on an average 80% parents are satisfied with the

current content of the syllabus designed by Savitribai Phule Pune Univesity Pune.

Alumni Feedback :

Our alumni are valuable for us. They provide us the inputs regarding improvement in facilities

and employability of our students. We appeal our alumni to provide there sincere feedback on

90.9779.17 80.56 79.17

85.42

68.7577.78 76.39 72.22

86.81

0.00

20.00

40.00

60.00

80.00

100.00

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Resp

onse

(%)

Question Number

Parent Feedback Analysis 2014-2015

Yes

No

Page 25: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

curriculum. We have received total 96 alumni feedback on syllabus designed by Savitribai Phule

Pune Univesity Pune. Based on the comments of the alumni, the analysis is done as follows:

Question

Number Question

Response

Yes No

Total % Total %

1Was the syllabus updated enough 91 94.79 5 5.21

2Was the course content interesting 72 75.00 24 25.00

3Did the course curriculum intellectually stimulate you 79 82.29 17 17.71

4

Was the course curriculum fulfilling your expectations60 62.50 36 37.50

5

Does the syllabus create any interest to pursue postgraduation / research in the particular subject 70 72.92 26 27.08

6

Did the subject / course help in developing yourpersonality 61 63.54 35 36.46

7

Were the subject applicable in your practical / daily life74 77.08 22 22.92

8

Were reading material and references regardingcurriculum / subject easily found 66 68.75 30 31.25

9

Was the subject relevance to your job and the futureaspirations 67 69.79 29 30.21

10

Does the syllabi is effective in enhancing team workabilities 70 72.92 26 27.08

Page 26: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

The above diagram shows that on an average more than 74% alumni’s are satisfied with the

current syllabus designed by Savitribai Phule Pune Univesity Pune.

Employer Feedback Analysis:

Employer feedback is collected and analyzed on the syllabus designed by Savitribai Phule Pune

Univesity Pune. We have received total 65 employer’s feedback for the current academic year.

QuestionNumber Question

ResponseYes No

Total % Total %

1

Was the curriculum followed by the employeerelevant for employability? 57 87.69 8 12.31

2

Whether the curriculum is effective in developinginnovative thinking 53 81.54 12 18.46

3

Does the syllabus is effective in developing skilloriented human recourses 55 84.62 10 15.38

4

Whether the syllabus is helpful for development ofteam work abilities 41 63.08 24 36.92

5Does the current syllabus is need based 47 72.31 18 27.69

6

Does the syllabus is effective for development ofentrepreneurship 51 78.46 14 21.54

7 Whether curriculum is effective for development of 48 73.85 17 26.15

94.79

75.0082.29

62.5072.92

63.5477.08

68.75 69.79 72.92

0.00

20.00

40.00

60.00

80.00

100.00

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Resp

onse

(%)

Question Number

Alumni Feedback Analysis 2014-2015

Yes

No

Page 27: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

communication skills

From the above diagram it is seen that the more than 80% employer say that the curriculum is

effective for development of communication skills and relevant for employability. More than 70

% employers rated that the curriculum is effective in developing innovative thinking, team work

abilities and entrepreneurship.

87.6981.54 84.62

63.0872.31

78.46 73.85

0.00

20.00

40.00

60.00

80.00

100.00

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Resp

onse

(%)

Question Number

Employer Feedback Analysis 2014-2015

Yes

No

Page 28: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From DifferentStakeholders

Academic Year: 2013-2014

Students Feedback:

The students are the most important stakeholders of Higher Education systems. The interest and

participation of students at all levels in both internal quality assurance and external quality

assurance have to play a central role. We have collected feedback from our under graduate third

year students and post graduate students personally. We have received total 166 student’s

feedback on the curriculum and analyzed.

QuestionNumber Question

ResponseYes No

Total % Total %1 Was the syllabus updated enough 154 92.77 12 7.23

2 Was the course content interesting 139 83.73 27 16.27

3Did the course curriculumintellectually motivate you

127 76.51 39 23.49

4Was the course curriculum fulfillingyour expectations

123 74.10 42 25.30

5

Does the syllabus create any interestto pursue post graduation / researchin the particular subject

125 75.30 41 24.70

6Did the subject / course help indeveloping your personality

110 66.27 56 33.73

7Were the subject applicable in yourpractical / daily life

127 76.51 39 23.49

8

Were reading material andreferences regarding curriculum /subject easily found

122 73.49 44 26.51

9Does the syllabus is relevant for thesolution of local problems

125 75.30 41 24.70

10Is there need to include skill basedcontent in current syllabus

139 83.73 27 16.27

Page 29: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

From the above diagram it is seen that the more than 80% students rated curriculum is updated

enough and course content is interesting. More than 70% students say that the course curriculum

creates interest to pursue post graduation / research in the particular subject; it is applicable in a

practical life and relevant for the solution of local problems. 83.73 % students rated that there is

need to include skill based content in current syllabus

Teachers Feedback:

The college is affiliated to the Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune and follows the prescribed

curriculum. Still feedback on curriculum is taken by the respective subject teachers regarding

suggestions on improvement of the syllabus. We have received 69 teachers feedback on the

curriculum and analyzed.

QuestionNumber Question

ResponseYes No

Total % Total %

1Does the syllabus reflect current content 64 92.75 5 7.25

2Does the current syllabus is need based 61 88.41 8 11.59

3

Are the programmes outcomes, programmesspecific outcomes and course outcomes of the

61 88.41 8 11.59

92.7783.73

76.51 74.10 75.3066.27

76.51 73.49 75.3083.73

0.00

10.00

20.00

30.00

40.00

50.00

60.00

70.00

80.00

90.00

100.00

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Resp

onse

(%)

Question Number

Student Feedback Analysis 2013-2014

Yes

No

Page 30: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

syllabi is well defined

4Is the syllabus heavy for the students 37 53.62 32 46.38

5

Does the course / programmes of studies carriessufficient number of optional papers 46 66.67 23 33.33

6

Is the current syllabus / course content madeinterest in the subject area 51 73.91 18 26.09

7

Are the books prescribed / listed as referencematerials relevant and updated 55 79.71 14 20.29

8

Does the course contents fulfilled the need ofstudents 55 79.71 14 20.29

9Is there a need of review of the syllabus 56 81.16 13 18.84

10

Does the syllabus reflects good balance betweentheory and practical’s 53 76.81 16 23.19

From the above diagram it is observed that the more than 80% teacher’s rated the syllabus

reflects current content, need based and the syllabus is well defined. However, 81% teachers

rated there is need of review of the current syllabus.

92.7588.41 88.41

53.62

66.6773.91

79.71 79.71 81.1676.81

0.0010.0020.0030.0040.0050.0060.0070.0080.0090.00100.00

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Resp

onse

(%)

Question Number

Teachers Feedback Analysis 2013-2014

Yes

No

Page 31: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

Parent Feedback:

The feedback from the parents is also collected on the current syllabus of the various

programmes and analyzed. We have received total 143 parent’s feedback on the current content

of the syllabus. Analysis of the total 143 feedback received from the parents is done as follows:

QuestionNumber Question

Response

Yes No

Total % Total %

1Whether the syllabus of your childhaving current content

129 90.21 14 9.79

2Does the content of the syllabus isheavy for your child

107 74.83 36 25.17

3Whether the course curriculumintellectually motivate your child

109 76.22 34 23.78

4Was the course curriculum fulfillingyour child expectations

115 80.42 28 19.58

5Does the course help in developingpersonality of your child

118 82.52 25 17.48

6Were the course is applicable indaily life

110 76.92 33 23.08

7Whether the child achieved the courseoutcomes after completing the courses

115 80.42 28 19.58

8

Whether study tour or field visits arenecessary for enhancing the learningability of your child

102 71.33 31 21.68

9Does the syllabus is relevant to thesolution for the local problems 100 69.93 43 30.07

10Does the your child gets adequateknowledge from the course 126 88.11 17 11.89

Page 32: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

From the above diagram it is observed that the on an average 79% parents are satisfied with the

current content of the syllabus designed by Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune.

Alumni Feedback:

Our alumni are valuable for us. They provide us the inputs regarding improvement in facilities

and employability of our students. We appeal our alumni to provide there sincere feedback on

curriculum. We have received total 96 alumni feedback on syllabus designed by Savitribai Phule

Pune University Pune. Based on the comments of the alumni, the analysis is done as follows:

Question

Number Question

ResponseYes No

Total % Total %

1Was the syllabus updated enough 86 89.58 10 10.42

2Was the course content interesting 69 71.88 27 28.13

3Did the course curriculum intellectually stimulate you 64 66.67 32 33.33

4

Was the course curriculum fulfilling your expectations66 68.75 30 31.25

5

Does the syllabus create any interest to pursue postgraduation / research in the particular subject 73 76.04 23 23.96

6 Did the subject / course help in developing your 62 64.58 34 35.42

90.21

74.83 76.22 80.42 82.5276.92 80.42

71.33 69.93

88.11

0.0010.0020.0030.0040.0050.0060.0070.0080.0090.00100.00

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Resp

onse

(%)

Question Number

Parent Feedback Analysis 2013-2014

Yes

No

Page 33: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

personality

7

Were the subject applicable in your practical / daily life72 75.00 24 25.00

8

Were reading material and references regardingcurriculum / subject easily found 64 66.67 32 33.33

9

Was the subject relevance to your job and the futureaspirations 75 78.13 21 21.88

10

Does the syllabi is effective in enhancing team workabilities 67 69.79 29 30.21

The above diagram shows that on an average more than 70% alumni’s are satisfied with the

current syllabus of the programmes B.A., M. A., B. Sc. M. Sc., B. Sc. computer science and M.

Sc. computer science designed by Savitribai Phule Pune University Pune.

Employer Feedback:

Employer feedback is collected and analyzed on the syllabus designed by Savitribai Phule Pune

University Pune. We have received total 52 employer’s feedback for the current academic year.

QuestionNumber Question

ResponseYes No

Total % Total %1 Was the curriculum followed by the employee 47 90.38 5 9.62

89.58

71.88 66.67 68.7576.04

64.5875.00

66.6778.13

69.79

0.00

20.00

40.00

60.00

80.00

100.00

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Resp

onse

(%)

Question Number

Alumni Feedback Analysis 2013-2014

Yes

No

Page 34: Report of Analysis of Feedback on Curriculum Collected From … · On an average 45% students are strongly agree, 44% are agree, 9% are neutral and 2% are disagree with the current

relevant for employability?

2

Whether the curriculum is effective in developinginnovative thinking

39 75.00 13 25.00

3

Does the syllabus is effective in developing skilloriented human recourses

43 82.69 9 17.31

4

Whether the syllabus is helpful for development ofteam work abilities

37 71.15 15 28.85

5Does the current syllabus is need based

34 65.38 18 34.62

6

Does the syllabus is effective for development ofentrepreneurship

39 75.00 13 25.00

7

Whether curriculum is effective for development ofcommunication skills

44 84.62 8 15.38

From the above diagram it is seen that the more than 80% employer say that the curriculum is

effective for development of communication skills and relevant for employability. More than 70

% employers rated that the curriculum is effective in developing innovative thinking, team work

abilities and entrepreneurship.

90.38

75.0082.69

71.15 65.3875.00

84.62

0.00

20.00

40.00

60.00

80.00

100.00

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Resp

onse

(%)

Question Number

Employer Feedback Analysis 2013-2014

Yes

No