Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of...
Transcript of Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of...
![Page 1: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
1
ReorganisationofChurchStructure,1901-03:SomeObservations1
DraftpaperaspresentedattheUnity2017Conference,June15,2017
BarryOliver
Introduction
Itisthepurposeofthispaperto:
1. BrieflydescribeaspectsofthedenominationalcontextandtheorganizationaldesignoftheSeventh-dayAdventistChurchin1863;
2. ListandbrieflydiscussanumberoffactorswhichledtothereorganisationoftheChurchin1901–1903;
3. ListthechangesthatreorganizationbroughttotheorganizationalstructuresoftheChurch;
4. Locatemissionastheprimaryimpetusforreorganization5. Discusstheprincipleswhich,in1901,undergirdedtheintroductionoftheUnionasan
addedlayeroforganizationalstructure;6. Distilfromthehistoricaldatalearningswhichmaybeinstructionalforthecontemporary
Seventh-dayAdventistChurch.
PerspectiveofthePaper
Withrespecttoperspective,thispapershouldbereadkeepingininmindthat:
1. ThepaperreflectsanabidingsenseofloyaltytoandlovefortheSeventh-dayAdventistChurch.Theauthor,nowretired,hasservedasanordainedpastor,evangelist,associateprofessor,administrator,andfinallyaspresidentoftheSouthPacificDivisionandvice-presidentoftheGeneralConferenceofSeventh-dayAdventists.
2. Carehasbeentakentoensurethatallquotationsreflectthecontextfromwhichtheyaretaken.Thoroughreferencinggivesthereaderopportunitytoinvestigatetheextendedcontext.
3. Thepaperiswritteninaspiritofopenenquiryanddiscussion.4. Itisacknowledgedthathistoryisalwayscontextual,asistheapplicationofprincipleand
practiceindiversecontemporarycontexts.
Limitations
1MuchofthecontentofthispaperisdirectlydrawnfromresearchconductedbytheauthorwhenpreparingandwritingaPh.D.dissertationatAndrewsUniversityin1989,andfromthepublishedversionofthedissertation.SeeBarryDavidOliver,SDAOrganizationalStructure:Past,Present,andFuture,(BerrienSprings,MI:AndrewsUniversityPress,1989).
![Page 2: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
ThepaperassumesaworkingknowledgeofSeventh-dayAdventistorganisationalstructure.Thereisnoattempttodescribecontemporarystructure.ThereislimiteddiscussionofthetheologicalinterplaybetweenAlonzoT.Jonesandthosealignedwithhimin1901,andArthurG.Daniellsandthosealignedwithhim.Thepolemicbetweenthesetwogroupsstronglyinfluencedtheoutcomeoftherestructuringprocess.2Further,inthispaperthereisonlypassingreferencetotheimpactoftheKelloggdebacleontheindividualsanddecisionsoftheearly20thcentury.
AspectsofthedenominationalcontextandtheorganizationaldesignoftheSeventh-dayAdventistChurchin1863
TheSeventh-dayAdventistChurchwasformallyorganisedatameetingofbelieversatBattleCreek,Michiganin1863.Atthattimethemembershipwasapproximately3500.ItwasdecidedthattherewouldbethreeadministrativelevelsofChurchstructure:thelocalchurch,theconference,andtheGeneralConferencewithheadquartersinBattleCreek.TheofficersoftheGeneralConferencewereapresident,secretary,andtreasurer.ThreepersonswereappointedasthemembersofaGeneralConferenceexecutivecommitteeandGeneralConferencesessionsweretobeheldannually.3
TherewerethosewhohadarguedthatbybeingorganizedtheChurchwouldbecomeBabylon.Butthosewhosawthenecessityforanefficientsystemoforganizationprevailed.IndeeditwasJamesWhitewho,throughoutthecontroversiessurroundingtheproposedorganizationinthelate1850sandearly1860s,wasthemostvocalproponentoftheneedfororganization.4White,aseditoroftheAdventReviewandSabbathHeraldandtheunofficialleaderoftheSabbatarianAdventists,wascontinuallywritingandspeakinginsupportoforganization.Hiswifealsosupportedtheneedforsoundorganization.Itappears,however,thatwhenitcametodenominationalstructures,theChurchunderstoodherroletobemoreexhortationaryandadvisorythandefinitive.
Forexample,inAugust1861EllenWhitehadreprovedthosewhodidnothavethecourageoftheirconvictions:
“Theagitationonthesubjectoforganizationhasrevealedagreatlackofmoralcourageonthepartofministersproclaimingpresenttruth.Somewhowereconvincedthat
2ForadiscussionofthepolemicseeBarryD.Oliver,“TheDevelopmentofOrganizationalandLeadershipParadigmsintheSeventh-dayAdventistChurch,”JournalofAdventistMissionStudies3/1Spring2007:4-28.3Foradetaileddiscussionofthefactorswhichprecipitateddenominationalorganizationin1863seeAndrewG.Mustard,JamesWhiteandSDAOrganization:HistoricalDevelopment,1844–1881(BerrienSprings,MI:AndrewsUniversityPress,1987).4SeeMustard,JamesWhiteandSDAOrganization.
![Page 3: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
organizationwasrightfailedtostandupboldlyandadvocateit....Theyfearedblameandopposition.Theywatchedthebrethrengenerallytoseehowtheirpulsebeatbeforestandingmanfullyforwhattheybelievedtoberight....Theywereafraidoflosingtheirinfluence....Thosewhoshunresponsibilitywillmeetwithlossintheend.Thetimeforministerstostandtogetheriswhenthebattlegoeshard.”5
Theargumentswhichwereusedtopersuadethebelieverstoorganizethemselvesintoadenominationwerenotbasedstronglyonbiblicalortheologicalreasoning.6Rather,pragmatismwontheday.In1907,A.G.Daniells,reflectingontheeventsofthe1860slistedsomeoftheproblemsofdisorganization,implyingthatorganizationsolvedtheseandotherissuesfacingtheChurch.Hislistincluded:failuretokeepproperchurchmembershiprecords;paucityofchurchofficers;inabilitytodeterminetheaccreditedrepresentativesofthepeople;noregularsupportfortheministry;andnolegalprovisionforholdingproperty.7
EvenalistofreasonswhichEllenWhitecompiledin1892waslargelypragmatic,althoughshedidleaveroomformorelatitude.Herreasonsfororganizingthechurchin1863were:(1)toprovideforthesupportoftheministry,(2)forcarryingtheworkinnewfields,(3)forprotectingboththechurchesandtheministryfromunworthymembers,(4)fortheholdingofchurchproperty,(5)forthepublicationoftruththroughthepress,and(6)formanyotherobjectives.8
FactorswhichledtothereorganisationoftheChurchin1901–1903;
Despitethesimplicityanduniquenessofthestructuressetupin1863,theneedformajormodificationofthosestructuresbecameevidentastheChurchexpandedduringthelastquarterofthenineteenthcentury.Anumberofcontextualfactorsledtotheneedforchange:
1NumericalGrowthandtheBeginningsofDiversity
AlthoughSeventh-dayAdventistsstillunderstoodthemselvestobesimply“abodyofbelieversassociatingtogether,takingthenameofSeventh-dayAdventists,andattachingtheirnamestoacovenantsimplytokeepthecommandmentsofGodandthefaithofJesus,”withtheBibleas“theironlycreedanddiscipline,”by1888therewerealreadythirtyorganizedconferencescontaining889organizedchurches.Therewere227ordainedand182licensedministers.Theconstituencywassupportingsixpublishinghouses,threesenioreducationalinstitutions,andtwomedicalestablishments.Bytheturnofthecenturythechurchhad75,000members
5EllenG.White,“CommunicationfromMrsWhite,”AdventReviewandSabbathHerald,Aug.27,1861,101-2.6SeeOliver,SDAOrganizationalStructure,46-48.7A.G.Daniells,“Organization:ABriefAccountofItsHistoryintheDevelopmentoftheCauseoftheThirdAngel’sMessage,”AdventReviewandSabbathHerald,February14,1907,5.8EllenG.WhitetotheBrethrenattheGeneralConference,Letter127,December19,1892,EllenG.WhiteResearchCentre.
![Page 4: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
spreadnotonlyacrosstheUnitedStates,butalsoinEurope,AustraliaandNewZealand,andincreasinglyinthe“missionfields.”9
Asthechurchcontinuedtogrowanddiversify,itwasevidentthatthemeagerorganizationthatwassetinplacein1863couldnotcopewiththisnumericalandgeographicalgrowth.
2InstitutionalGrowth
Further,theorganizationalstructuresof1863didnotanticipatetheincreaseoforganizationstocareforthepublishing,educational,health,andmissionaryinterestsoftheChurch.TheseentitieswerenotapartoftheconferenceadministrativestructureoftheChurch,butstoodasindependentunitsapartfromit.Althoughtheyhadaseparateinfrastructure,mostsharedpersonnelwiththeadministrativestructureofthedenomination.MostwerelocatedinBattleCreek.
Themajorauxiliaryorganizationsthatwereinexistenceatthebeginningof1888weretheGeneralTractandMissionarySociety,establishedin1874;theGeneralSabbathSchoolAssociation,establishedin1878;theHealthandTemperanceAssociation,establishedin1879;andtheGeneralConferenceAssociation,establishedin1887.TheNationalReligiousLibertyAssociationwasestablishedin1889,anautonomousForeignMissionBoardinthesameyear,andtheSeventh-dayAdventistMedicalMissionaryandBenevolentAssociationin1893.10
3LossofCoordinationandIntegration
Theseorganizationswerelegallyincorporatedasindependentbodiesthathadtheirownofficersandexecutiveboardsorcommittees.AlthoughtheywereallpartoftheSeventh-dayAdventistChurch—officersbeingappointedbyandreportingtotheGeneralConferencesession—theywerenotadministereddirectlybytheGeneralConference.Becauseoftheirindependentstatus,coordinationandintegrationwereperennialproblemsduringthe1890s.Notuntilthe1901GeneralConferencesessionanditsreorganizationoftheadministrativestructuresofthechurchweretheauxiliaryorganizationsincorporatedintotheconferencestructureasdepartmentsoftheGeneralConference.
4AdministrativeCentralization
Thegrowingglobalmissionaryconsciousnessofthechurchduringthe1870sand1880swasaccompaniedbyincreasedcentralizationofadministrativecontrol.In1885,GeorgeButler,presidentoftheGeneralConferencefrom1871-1874andagainfrom1880-1888,spokeoftheprinciplesuponwhichtheorganizationofthechurchwasestablished.Hedeclared:
9ABriefSketchoftheOrigin,ProgressandPrinciplesoftheSeventh-dayAdventists(BattleCreek,MI:ReviewandHerald,1888),9,11-12.10ForasummaryoverviewoftheSeventh-dayAdventistChurchatthebeginningof1888,seeBriefSketch,9-40.
![Page 5: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
“Supervisionembracesallits[theGeneralConference]interestsineverypartoftheworld.Thereisnotaninstitutionamongus,notaperiodicalissued,notaConferenceorsociety,notamissionfieldconnectedwithourwork,thatithasnotarighttoadviseandcounselandinvestigate.ItisthehighestauthorityofanearthlycharacteramongSeventh-dayAdventists.”11
Butler’sconceptofadministrationgrewoutofhisconceptofleadership.AftertheGeneralConferenceof1888,EllenWhitewroteofButler:
“Asickman’smindhashadacontrollingpowerovertheGeneralConferencecommitteeandtheministershavebeentheshadowandechoofElderButleraboutaslongasitishealthyandforthegoodofthecause.Envy,evilsurmisings,jealousieshavebeenworkinglikeleavenuntilthewholelumpseemedtobeleavened....Hethinkshispositiongiveshimsuchpowerthathisvoiceisinfallible.”12
InresponsetosometensionsthatexistedbetweenJamesWhiteandotherchurchleaders,Butlerhadwrittenanessayin1873inwhichheencapsulatedhisattitudetowardleadership.Hispositionwasclearfromtheopeningsentence:“Thereneverwasanygreatmovementinthisworldwithoutaleader;andinthenatureofthingsitisimpossiblethatthereshouldbe.”13
Butlerdescribedaleaderasabenevolentmonarch.Hesupportedhisassertionbyreferencestonumerousbiblicalexamplesofauthoritarianleaders.WhilehewaswillingtoconcedethatChristwasindeedheadofthechurch,heinsistedthatsomemenwere“placedhigherinauthorityinthechurchthanothers.”14
Subsequently,the1875GeneralConferencesessionpassedaresolutionthatcalledforarevisionofButler’sessay.15The1877sessionrescindedallpartsoftheessaythatreferredtotheleadershipofthechurchasresidinginoneman.Thiswassupportedbyaresolutionwhichstatedthat:
“ThehighestauthorityunderGodamongSeventh-dayAdventistsisfoundinthewillofthebodyofthatpeople,asexpressedinthedecisionsoftheGeneralConferencewhenactingwithinitsproperjurisdiction;andthatsuchdecisionsshouldbesubmittedtobyallwithoutexception,unlesstheycanbeshowntoconflictwiththewordofGodand
11Seventh-dayAdventistYearBook:1888(BattleCreek,MI:ReviewandHerald,1889),50.12EllenG.WhitetoMaryWhite,Letter82,November4,1888,EllenG.WhiteEstateOffice.13GeorgeI.Butler,“Leadership,”AdventReviewandSabbathHerald,November18,1873,180.14Ibid.,180-81.15“GeneralConferenceReport,”AdventReviewandSabbathHerald,August26,1875,59.
![Page 6: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
therightsofindividualconscience.”16
AlthoughJamesWhitemadeitclearthathedidnotagreewithButler’sposition,anddespiteEllenWhite’scontinuousappeals,Butlerdidnotmodifyhisleadershipstyleverymuchuntilwellafterhewasvotedoutofthepresidencyatthe1888GeneralConferencesession.17
Intheearly1880s,EllenWhitebegantorebukeGeneralConferenceadministratorsfortakingtoomuchoftheresponsibilityfordecision-makingonthemselvesandfailingtogiveothersopportunitytohaveinput.InalettertoW.C.andMaryWhitein1883,EllenWhitepointedoutthat“everyoneofourleadingmen”consideredthat“hewastheveryonewhomustbearalltheresponsibilities”and“failedtoeducateotherstothink”and“toact.”Infact,shecharged,theleadingmengavetheothers“nochance.”18
Implicitinhercondemnationofthosewhofollowedthatpracticewasreproofforthosewhopermittedthemtodoitwithoutseekingtocorrectthesituation.Conferenceleaders,forinstance,weretoldthattheyweretomaketheirowndecisions.ThepresidentoftheGeneralConferencecouldnotpossibly“understandthesituationaswellasyouwhoareontheground.”19
Asacorrectiveforcentralizationofcontrol,EllenWhiteadvocatedproperuseofthecommitteesystemthathadbeenestablishedwhentheGeneralConferencehadbeenorganizedin1863.Shemadeitclearthatevenintheoperationofinstitutionsoneman’smindwasnottocontrolthedecision-makingprocess.Sheemphasizedthat“Godwouldnothavemanymindstheshadowofoneman’smind,”butthat“inamultitudeofcounselorsthereissafety.”20
5FinancialCrisis
Anotherprecipitatingfactorwhichledtorestructuringwasthestateofthefinancesofthechurch.WhenG.A.IrwinassumedthepresidencyoftheGeneralConferencein1897,hehadtofaceawoefulfinancialpredicament.Withinafewweeksofhisappointment,thesituationwassodesperatethathewrotetoN.W.AlleethattheGeneralConferencewas“livingfromhandtomouth,sotospeak.”HetoldAlleethat“somedayswegetintwoorthreehundreddollars,andotherdayswehavenothing.”Ontheparticulardaythathewaswriting,helamentedthatthe16“GeneralConferenceReport,”AdventReviewandSabbathHerald,October4,1877,106.17ForadiscussionoftheconflictbetweenJamesWhiteandGeorgeButlerovertheconceptofleadership,seeMustard,JamesWhiteandSDAOrganization,175-78;andBertHaloviak,“SDAsandOrganization,1844-1907”(paperpresentedattheCentralCaliforniaCampmeeting,August1987),39-41.18EllenG.WhitetoW.C.WhiteandMaryWhite,Letter23,August23,1883,EllenG.WhiteEstateOffice.19ThesewordswerespokentothedelegatesassembledattheGeneralConferencesessionin1883.EllenG.White,“GenuineFaithandHoliness,”Manuscript3,1883,EllenG.WhiteEstateOffice.20EllenG.WhitetoJohnHarveyKellogg,Letter7,April26,1886,EllenG.WhiteEstateOffice.
![Page 7: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
treasurywas“practicallyempty,”eventhoughtherewereatthattime“anumberofcallsformeans.”21
DespiteconcertedeffortbyGeneralConferenceleaders,thesituationdidnotimprovesubstantially.Whilethereweresomeperiodswhenthepredicamentwasnotasdesperateasitwasatothertimes,atalltimesthesituationwasoutofcontrol.Thefinancialstatementfor1899showedthatatthebeginningofthatyeartheGeneralConferencehadonly$55.33cashonhand.ThesamereportshowedthatbyOctober1ofthesameyeartherewasanoperatingdeficitof$9,529.74.22Atthebeginningof1901thedeficitwas$41,589.11.InAugustthedeficitwasstill$39,600.23
Becauseofthechronicshortageofoperatingcapital,nothingwasbeingdonetorepaydebtsthathadbeenincurredinordertoestablishvariousinstitutions.PercyMagan,whorealizedthatpartoftheproblemlayintheeasewithwhichinstitutionsborrowedmoneyandtheeasewithwhichchurchmemberslentittothem,chargedthat“allourinstitutions”hadbeenin“theborrowingbusiness.”Headvocatedthatitwastimeforthem“toquit”borrowing.Butnotonlywereinstitutionstoceaseborrowing:churchmembersweretoceasedabblingin“thelendingbusiness.”Hadthemembersnotbeen“inthelendingbusiness,”thenitwascertainthattheinstitutions“wouldneverhavebeenintheborrowingbusiness.”24
Desperatetimescalledfordesperatemeasures.
6DecreasingAbilitytoSupportMissionaryExpansion
Theinabilityofthedenominationtofinanciallysupportitsgrowthwashavinganeffectonitsmissionaryexpansion.Inthelastfiveyearsofthenineteenthcenturytherewastheslackeningofmissionaryactivitybythedenomination.Atthe1899GeneralConferencesession,AllenMoon,presidentoftheForeignMissionBoard,reportedthat
“Duringthelasttwoyearswehaveopenedupnonewworkinanypartoftheworld.Ithasbeenanimpossibility.TherehavebeendemandsforopeningtheworkinChina.Thatworkoughttohavebeenopenedayearago,yetwehavebeenutterlyunabletodo
21G.A.IrwintoN.W.Allee,May5,1897,RecordGroup11,LetterBook18,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland.22GeneralConferenceCommitteeMinutes,Oct.10,1899,RecordGroup1,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland.23A.G.DaniellstoMembersoftheGeneralConferenceCommittee,August2,1901,RecordGroup11,LetterBook24,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland.SeealsoA.G.DaniellstoJ.E.Jayne,August3,1901,RecordGroup11,LetterBook24,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland.24PercyT.Magan,“DenominationalDebts,”AdventReviewandSabbathHerald,April11,1899,235-36.
![Page 8: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
anythingtowardopeningit.”25
Thefailuretocommenceanynewworkbetween1897and1899andthedecreaseinthenumberofmissionariesbeingsentabroadbetween1895and1900doesnotappeartohavebeentheresultofanymarkeddecreaseinthechurch’seschatologicalormissiologicalvision.Amorelikelyexplanationfortheproblemsisthatthecentralizedorganizationasitexistedwasjustnotabletocopefinanciallyandadministrativelywithitsmissionaryenterprise.26
ArthurDaniellsrealizedthatsuchasituationconfrontedthechurchashevisitedAfricaandEuropeonhiswayfromAustraliatothe1901GeneralConferencesession.InAugust1900,whileinEurope,hewrotetoW.C.Whitethat
“MyheartisfilledwithinterestthatIcannotexpressinbehalfoftheseforeignfields,andIsincerelyhopethatthenextsessionoftheGeneralConferencewillrisetothehighandimportantpositionitshouldtakeinbehalfofthesecountries....Iseemuchtoencourageus,andsomethingsthatneedcarefulmanagementinthewayofreorganization....InalltheseplacesIhavesecuredallthedetailsIcanregardingthework,thesameasIdidinAfrica,andshallarrangethesedataforfutureuseifneeded.”27
Changewasneedednotonlytoaccommodatethegrowthofthepastbutalsotofacilitategrowthinthefuture.
ThechangesthatreorganizationbroughttotheorganizationalstructuresoftheChurch;
Foralloftheseandperhapsotherreasonsinaddition,the1901GeneralConferencesessionsawamajorreorganizationoftheadministrativestructuresoftheChurch.Theimpetusforchangecontinuedatthe1903GeneralConferencesession.Thechangesthatweremadeatthosesessionswerebasedontheprinciplesoforganizationthatwereestablishedatthedenomination’sfoundingin1861-1863.By1901itwasrecognizedthatthoseprinciplesneeded
25GeneralConferenceBulletin[hereafterGCBulletin],1899,73.26Themissionaryprogramwasbeingstifledbecausedecisionswhichshouldhavebeenmadeby“thoseontheground”hadtobereferredtoBattleCreek.SeeW.A.SpicertoA.G.Daniells,October5,1893,RecordGroup9,A.G.DaniellsFolder2,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland;A.G.DaniellstoE.H.Gates,May23,1901,RecordGroup11,LetterBook23,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland.InhislettertoD.A.Robinson,Whitefocusedonthedilemmacausedbycentralization.Inreferencetoa“pioneertoanewmissionfield,”hesaid:“IfheconsultswiththeBoardineverythinghewillbeforcedsometimestovaryfrominstruction.Ifhedoesnotconsultthemhewillgetthecreditofmovingindependently.Whicheverwayhedoes,hewillwishhehaddonetheother.”InalettertoPercyMagan,W.C.Whitesaidthat“motherhasbeencautionednottogive?sanctiontoanyarrangementinconnectionwiththis[missionary]enterprisebywhichoneclassofmenorofinstitutionsshalllaybindingrestrictionsuponanotherclassofmenorinstitutions;thatHisservantsinonepartoftheworldshouldnotdictatetoorlayrestrictionsuponHisservantsinanotherpartofthegreatharvestfield”(W.C.WhitetoPercyT.Magan,March8,1900,LetterBook15,EllenG.WhiteEstateOffice.27A.G.DaniellstoW.C.White,August23,1900,IncomingFiles,EllenG.WhiteEstateOffice.
![Page 9: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
tobeupdatedandappliedinthecontemporarycontext.EllenWhitewasparticularlypointedinherendorsementofchange. Onthedaybeforetheofficialopeningofthe1901GeneralConferencesessionshedeclared,"Godwantsachange...righthere...rightnow."28Thefollowingdaywhenreiteratingtheconcernswhichshehadcommunicatedonthepreviousday,sheadded,"accordingtothelightthathasbeengivenme--andjusthowitistobeaccomplishedIcannotsay--greaterstrengthmustbebroughtintothemanagingforceoftheConference."29Shecalledforchangeandflexibility.Sheleftittotheassembleddelegatestodeterminejusthowthatchangewouldbeaccomplishedandwhatorganizationalstructureswouldbeputinplace
Theprincipalchangesthatweremadein1901-1903were:
1. TheformationofunionconferencesastheconstituentbodiesoftheGeneralConference;
2. Thedecentralizationofmuchdecision-makingfromtheGeneralConferenceadministrationtounionconferenceexecutivecommittees;
3. TheconsolidationofdepartmentsoftheGeneralConferenceandthedissolutionofindependentincorporatedentitiesthathadbeenoperatingdepartmentsandsomeinstitutions;
4. ThetitleofthechiefofficeroftheGeneralConferencewastobe“ChairmanoftheBoard”ratherthan“President.Atthe1903GeneralConferencesessionthetitle“President”wasreinstated.
Thedevelopmentofmissionasthemajorimpetusforreorganization
Atthetimeoforganizationin1863,missionwasarelativelyinsignificantreasonamongmanygivenforforminganorganizedchurch.Butbythetimeofreorganizationin1901,missionwasthepreeminentreasonfororganization.Itisabundantlyclearthatwhenitcametotheneedfororganization,A.G.DaniellsandhisassociatesbeganwiththecertaintyandimminenceofthereturnofJesusChrist.TheimminenceofthesecondcomingofChristdeterminedtheurgencyofthemission.
ForthosealliedwithDaniellsecclesiologywasmoreafunctionoftheireschatologicalandmissiologicalperceptions.Thechurchexistedbecauseithadbeencommissionedtoperformaspecifictask.Thattaskwasmissionaryinnature.Themissionarynatureofthechurchwasthetheologicalperspectivethatinformedtheneedforandshapeofthestructuresofthechurch.WritingtoW.C.Whitein1903,Daniellsstatedthat“thevitalobjectforwhichSeventh-da, 28"Talk of Mrs E. G. White, before Representative Brethren, In the College Library, April 1, 1901, 2:30 P.M.," MS 43a, 1901 (emphasis supplied). This manuscript together with MS 43, an edited edition of Ellen White's speech is available in the Ellen G. White Estae Office. The author commends to the careful reader a thorough reading of these manuscripts.
29General Conference Bulletin, 1901, 25 (emphasis supplied). Bulletins which report on General Conference sessions are available at the Ellen G. White Research Centre at Avondale College.
![Page 10: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
AdventistshavebeenraisedupistopreparetheworldfortheComingChrist;thechiefmeansfordoingthisworkisthepreachingofthepresenttruth,orthethirdangel’smessageofRev.14:6-12.”30
Becausetheneedfororganizationarosefromaperceptionofeschatologicalandmissiologicalnecessity,therewasnodoubtamongthosewhoheldthisviewthatthestructurewhichtheyerectedwasbiblicallybased.TheyunderstoodthattheNewTestamentaffirmedthatChristwasreturningandthatthetransmissionofthegospeltotheworldwastheprimarypreconditionforhisreturn.Withaconsciousnessofdivineprovidence,theyunderstoodthatSeventh-dayAdventistshadbeenspecificallychosenwithinaprecisetimereferenceinordertoheraldthe“everlastinggospel”toalltheworld.Itwasaconvictionbornofcommitmenttothenecessityofabiblicalfoundationfortheirfaithandpractice,includingtheirorganizationalpractice.Daniellsreflectedtheconvictionofthedenominationwhen,in1906,heconfidentlydeclaredthat
“Thedoctrinesweholdnotonlycreatedourdenomination,butourdenominationalaim,purpose,orpolicy,aswell.ThisdenominationalpurposeorpolicyisformedbyourviewofwhattheBibleteaches.Itispeculiartoourdenomination.Itdiffersfromthepoliciesofotherdenominationsandorganizationsaswidelyasourdoctrinalviewsdifferfromtheirs.”31(Emphasissupplied.)
Someyearslater,W.A.SpicerwasevenmoreemphaticthanDaniells.Challengingthechurchtotakeupthe“world-wideproclamationoftheeverlastinggospelandthefinishingofthework,”hecontendedthat“everyprincipleintheorganizationofourwork...isfoundintheWordofGod.”ClarenceCrislerwhowastheprivatesecretaryofEllenWhitefrom1901until1915,begantheforewordtoapamphletthathewrotetheyearbeforeherdeathbycategoricallystatingthat“theunderlyingprinciplesoftheorganizationoftheSeventh-dayAdventistdenomination...maybetracedintherecordsoftheNewTestament.”BothSpicerandCrislerwerecarefultosaythatitwas“principles”andnotformsthatweretobefoundintheNewTestament.32
Reorganizationwasundertakeninthefirstplacenotbecausetheendwascoming,butbecausetherewasa“work”todobeforetheendcouldcome.Reorganization,orforthatmatterorganization,couldnotbesubstantiatedonthebasisofthereturnofChristalone.ThosewhoinsistedthatorganizationalformbedeterminedonlybytheimminenceofthereturnofChrist30A.G.DaniellstoW.C.White,May17,1903,IncomingFiles,EllenG.WhiteEstateOffice.
31A.G.Daniells,“AStatementConcerningOurPresentSituation—No.3,”AdventReviewandSabbathHerald,February22,1906,6.
32W.A.Spicer,“DivineWarningsagainstDisorganization,”AdventReviewandSabbathHerald,September14,1916,4;C.C.Crisler,TheValueofOrganization:AnHistoricalStudy,(n.p.),3.SeealsoS.N.Haskell,“Organization—No.18,”AdventReviewandSabbathHerald,May16,1907,4;A.G.Daniells,“OrganizationasDevelopedbyOurPioneers,”AdventReviewandSabbathHerald,February21,1918,5;andJ.L.McElhany,“PrinciplesofConferenceAdministration,”Ministry,March1938,5.
![Page 11: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
had,inthehistoryofAdventism,oftendeniedthenecessityofanyformoforganizationatall.Itwasthemissionpolicyofthechurchthatin1905wasdescribedas“themostimportantfeatureofourdenominationalpolicy,”anditwastheurgencyassociatedwiththatmissionthatwasmoretheprecipitatingfactorinreorganizationthantheimminenceoftheChrist’sreturn.33
ThePrinciplesUndergirdingtheFormationofUnionConferences
Atthe1901GeneralConferencesessionthereweretwoopposingviewpointswithrespecttothereasonsforandtheshapeofreorganization.AlonzoT.Jonesandhisassociatesderivedtheirprinciplesoforganizationmorefromtheirindividualisticunderstandingofsoteriologyandtheirecclesiologicalemphasis.ArthurG.Daniellsandhisassociatesderivedtheirprinciplesoforganizationmorefromtheirevaluationofthepragmaticsituationofthechurchwithrespecttothefulfilmentofitsmissionarytask.Havingjustreturnedfromextendedperiodsofforeignmissionaryservice,Daniells,W.A.Spicer,EllenG.White,andWilliam.C.WhitewerekeenlyawareoftheinadequacyoftheexistingadministrativestructuretocopewiththeneedsoftheChurch’sglobalmissionaryenterprise.Theirfocuswasonthereorganizationoftheadministrativestructuresofthechurchsothattheycouldbeaninstrumentratherthananinhibitorofmission.
Thedevelopmentofthemissionaryfocusofthechurchintheyearssince1863certainlydidnotdiminishtheneedforstructures.Daniellscontendedthattheprincipleswhichgovernedthechoiceoforganizationalstructuresshouldbethosewhichsupportedthemaintenanceofthestructures,notthosewhichtendedtodestroythem.Inretrospect,hepointedoutthattheprincipleswhichguidedthechurchinitsreorganizationcouldnotbepermittedtoleadthechurchtowardsdisorganizationortheabandonmentofthose"generalprinciples"whichinthe1860shadtransformedascatteredgroupof"believers"intoaviabledenomination.34
Daniellswouldlaterlisttheadvantagesofreorganizationandattemptswouldbemadetosystematizethetheologicalrationaleforreorganization.35However,despiterepeatedreferenceto"principles,"again,nosystematictreatmentthatcouldbeusedasabasisfordecisionmakingwasforthcoming.Withoutasystematicecclesiology,therewasreallynosubstantialbasisuponwhichthechurchcouldbuilditsprinciplesoforganization.
33A.G.Daniells,“ThePresident’sAddress:AReviewandanOutlook—SuggestionsforConferenceAction,”AdventReviewandSabbathHerald,May11,1905,8.
34A.G.Daniells,"AStatementofFactsConcerningOurPresentSituation--No.9,"AdventReviewandSabbathHerald,April5.1906,6.
35Atthe1903GeneralConferencesessionDaniellsmadereferencetosomeofthe"features"ofthe"work"whichweretheresultofreorganization.SeeA.G.Daniells,"SomeBeneficialFeaturesofOurOrganization,"AdventReviewandSabbathHerald,March14,1918,6.
![Page 12: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
Thoseprincipleswhichcanbederivedfromextantrecordsandwhichappeartohavemoststronglyinfluencedreorganizationandtheformationofunionswereasfollows:
1. Decentralization
ForDaniellsandhisassociatesdecentralizationasaprincipleofreorganizationwasparamount.In1902,reflectingwiththeGeneralConferencecommitteeonwhathadbeenaccomplishedin1901,Daniellsaffirmedthat"theguidingprinciple[ofreorganization]hadbeenthedecentralizationofauthoritybythedistributionofresponsibility."Headdedthattheapplicationofthatprinciplehadled"totheorganizationofunionconferences,"andrepresentation"onalloperatingcommittees"ofthe"fourfeaturesofourwork--theevangelical,medical,educational,andpublishinginterests."36
Atthe1903GeneralConferencesessionwhenhewasexplaininghisunderstandingofthesentencefromEllenWhite's1896letterthathadbeenusedbyJones,Waggoner,andPrescottinanattempttodoawaywiththepresidencyoftheGeneralConference,Daniellsstatedthataccordingtohisunderstanding,EllenWhitewassayingthattheleadersofthechurchneededto"decentralizeresponsibilitiesanddetailsandplacetheminthehandsofalargernumberofmen."37Inthissentencehewasusingtheterm"decentralize"inthesenseoftheverb"todelegate."HeunderstoodEllenWhitetobediscussingtheneedforresponsibilitytobedelegatedtoseveralpersonsratherthanbeingconcentratedinjustoneperson--thepresidentoftheGeneralConference.
OneofDaniells’favoriteexpressions(onethathehadtakenfromEllenWhite),wasthatthose"ontheground"shouldbeartheburdenofadministrationandhavetheprerogativeofdecisionmaking.38Hesawtheimplementationoftheunionstructureasthemannerinwhich
36GeneralConferenceofSeventh-dayAdventists,MinutesofMeetingsoftheGeneralConferenceCommittee,13November1902,2:30P.M.,RecordGroup1,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland.
37“OriginalReportsandStenographicallyReportedDiscussionsThereofHadattheThirty-FourthBiennialSessionoftheSeventh-dayAdventistGeneralConference,April19,1901,”RecordGroup0,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland,75.
38EllenG.WhitetoA.O.Tait,August27,1896,Letter100,1896,EllenWhiteEstate;A.G.DaniellstoW.T.Knox,May21,1901,RecordGroup11,LetterBook23,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland;A.G.DaniellstoE.H.Gates,May23,1901,RecordGroup11,LetterBook23,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland;A.G.DaniellstoEdithR.Graham,May24,1901,RecordGroup11,LetterBook23,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland;A.G.DaniellstoW.C.White,June19,1901,RecordGroup11,LetterBook23,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland;A.G.DaniellstoMembersoftheGeneralConferenceCommittee,August2,1901,RecordGroup11,LetterBook24,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland.In1895EllenWhitehadusedthephraseinatestimonytoministers.Shesaid:"BesurethatGodhasnotlaiduponthosewhoremainawayfromtheseforeignfieldsoflabor,theburdenofcriticizingtheonesonthe
![Page 13: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
administrativeresponsibilitywasbeingdelegatedtothose"ontheground."Theunionadministratorswere,forDaniells,those"ontheground."39
UnderDaniells’leadershipthecommitmenttotheprincipleofdecentralizationwasneverrevoked.Decentralizationcontinuedtobeconsideredasavitalprinciplewhichgovernedthereorganizationofthechurch.However,theconfrontationandpolemicsoverorganizationalissuesthatbeganinmid-1902andcontinuedforthenextsevenyears(untilJoneswasremovedfromchurchmembershipin1909),causedarenewalofemphasisontheneedforunityinthechurch.Thatdesireforunityonthepartoftheadministrationofthechurchmeantthatthestructuresofthechurchbecamemoreaninstrumentofthecentralizationofauthoritythantheydidaninstrumentofdelegationanddecentralizationofauthority.Jonesclaimedthatjustsuchatendencywasbuiltintotheverystructuresthemselves.Suchwasnotnecessarilythecase,butcircumstancesandthedispositionoftheleadersthemselvesdidindeedinfluencejustwhatemphasiswasevidentinpractice.
2. UnityandDiversity
WhenDaniellsdiscussedtheprincipleswhichweretogovernthereorganizationofthechurchatthe1901GeneralConferencesessionanddescribedthebenefitswhichwouldaccruefromtheimplementationoftheunionconferenceplan,hedidnotparticularlymentionunity.CertainlyEllenWhitehaddonesointheCollegeLibraryAddressandcertainlytheprincipleofunityhadalwaysbeenatoppriorityforSeventh-dayAdventistsandwouldcontinuetobeso,butforbothEllenWhiteandA.G.Daniellstheimmediateprioritieswereelsewhere.Inhissingle,mostsignificantexplanationoftheoperationoftheAustralasianUnionConferenceanditsapplicationtotheworldchurch,Daniellsdiscussedthesimplificationofmachineryfortransactingbusiness,theneedtoplacelaborers[administrators]inthefieldinpersonalcontactwiththepeople,theadvantageofhavinggeneralboardsinthefield,thenecessityofhavingageneralorganizationwhichdidnotconcernitselfprimarilywithaffairsintheUnitedStates,theGeneralConferenceasa"world'sGeneralConference,"andthenecessityfortheboardsof
groundwheretheworkisbeingdone.Thosewhoarenotonthegroundknownothingaboutthenecessitiesofthesituation,andiftheycannotsayanythingtohelpthosewhoareontheground,letthemnothinderbutshowtheirwisdombytheeloquenceofsilence,andattendtotheworkthatiscloseathand....LettheLordworkwiththemenwhoareontheground,andletthosewhoarenotonthegroundwalkhumblywithGodlesttheygetoutoftheirplaceandlosetheirbearings"(EllenG.White,SpecialInstructiontoMinistersandWorkers[BattleCreek,MI:ReviewandHerald,1895],33.
39A.G.DaniellstoH.W.Cottrell,June17,1901,RecordGroup11,LetterBook23,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland.
![Page 14: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
institutionsandthecommitteesofunionconferencestobecomposedofpersonsfamiliarwiththeirgeographicalareasofadministration.40Buthedidnotevenmentiontheneedforunity.
AtthesecondmeetingoftheGeneralConferencesessionin1903,however,Daniellsdidincludeunityamongthelistofadvantagesandbenefitsthatwererealizedbyreorganization.Havingpointedoutthatreorganizationhadresultedinadistributionofresponsibilityandthat"workinallpartsoftheworld"wastobedealtwithbythosewhowere"ontheground,"andthatthe"details"weretobe"workedout"bythem;hesummarized:"inshort,theplanrecognizesonemessage,onebodyofpeople,andonegeneralorganization."41
By1903,eventhoughdecentralizationwasstillvital,itwasnowaformofadecentralizationwhichwascarriedoutonlyalong‘prescribedlines.’Insomerespects,particularlyintheorganizationofdepartmentsoftheGeneralConference,therewasmorecentralizationthandecentralization.Apparentlysomewereconcernedthatthingsweregoingbacktowhathadoccurredduringtheyearsleadinguptoreorganization.42
EllenWhitesensedthedangerofslippingbackwardsandplacinginordinatestressontheonenessoftheorganization.Herconcernwasthatsuchapositionwouldresultintheneedtocentralizeauthority,resultinginorganizationaluniformity.Specificallywithreferencetothepublishingconcernsofthechurch,shesaid:
“Noman'sintelligenceistobecomesuchacontrollingpowerthatonemanwillhavekinglyauthorityinBattleCreekorinanyotherplace.Innolineofworkisanyonemantohavepowertoturnthewheel.Godforbids.”43
Shewasparticularlyoutspokenregardingfailuretoimplementprinciplesthathadbeenintroducedin1901.WritingtoJudgeArthurinJanuary1903,shemaintainedthatasthedelegateswhohadbeeninattendanceatthesessionreturnedtotheirhomes,theycarried
40GCBulletin,1901,228-29.
41GCBulletin,1903,17-21.
42See“OriginalReportsandStenographicallyReportedDiscussionsThereofHadattheThirty-FourthBiennialSessionoftheSeventh-dayAdventistGeneralConference,9April1903,RecordGroup0,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland,20-20a.
43EllenG.White,"PrinciplesfortheGuidanceofMeninPositionsofResponsibility,"Manuscript140,1902,EllenG.WhiteEstateOffice.
![Page 15: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
withtheminto"theirworkthewrongprinciplesthathadbeenprevailingintheworkatBattleCreek."44
Thecontextdoesnotindicateexactlywhat"principles"werebeingdiscussed.Althoughstructuralchangeswhichsheapprovedofhadbeenmadein1901,apparentlythenewstructurescouldbeabusedwiththesameresultastheformerstructures.ThusEllenWhiteonceagainfounditnecessarytoreprovetheleadersofthechurchanditsdepartmentsbecauseofthetendencytogatherpoweraboutthemselves.Whenevertheneedtopromoteunitywasprioritizedtotheextentthatitdisruptedthemaintenanceofequilibriumbetweentheprinciplesofunityanddiversity,anddiversitywasnottakenintoconsiderationasitshouldhavebeen,centralizationwastheresult.
Duringthe1890sbothunityanddiversityhadnegativeandpositiveaspectsasfarasthemissionofthechurchwasconcerned.Diversitywaspositivewhenitenhancedthepotentialofthechurchtoreachdiverse"nations,tongues,andpeoples,"andledtodecentralizationofdecision-making.Itwasnegativewhenitcausedchaosandconfusion,suchaswasthecasewiththemultiplicationofauxiliaryorganizations.UnitywaspositivewhenitboundthechurchintoonenessinChrist.Itwasnegativewhenitwasinterpretedtorequireuniformityandunnecessarycentralizationofauthority.
Unitywasnecessaryinordertoencompassthedimensionsofthemissionofthechurch.TherewasnowayfortheSeventh-dayAdventistChurchwithitsemphasisonworld-wideevangelizationtosucceedinthattaskunlesstherewasunityofpurpose,belief,andaction.Unityofactionrequiredadministrativeco-ordinationthatcouldbestfacilitatestrategicinitiativesonaglobalscale.Further,thefunctionalecclesiologicalself-imagethatwascharacteristicofthechurchpermittedacentralizedadministrationthatcouldco-ordinateandfacilitatethemissionofthechurch.Itcannotbedeniedthat,giventhechurch'stheologicalandpragmaticpriorities,somecentralizationwasnecessaryandlegitimate.Butin1901theprincipleofdiversitywasmoredeterminativethantheprincipleofunityintheestablishmentofanadditionallevelofadministration,andbydelegatingsomefunctionswhichhadpreviouslybeenperformedbytheGeneralConferencetounionconferences.Theemphasiswasontheneedtorecognizediversitybydecentralization.Pastgrowthhadmadetherecognitionofdiversitynecessary,butprojectedfuturegrowthmadeprovisionfordiversityimperative.
3. Participation/Representation
Localconferenceparticipation
44EllenG.WhitetoJudgeJesseArthur,January14,1903,Letter17,1903,EllenG.WhiteEstateOffice.
![Page 16: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
Daniellsmadeaconcertedefforttocarryhisemphasisondiversityanddecentralizationnotonlyintounionconferencesbutalsointothelocalconferencesetting.Soonafterthe1901GeneralConferencesession,hebegantopromotebroad-basedparticipationinthedecision-makingprocessbyencouragingthestateconferencestopermitallstatechurchmemberstoparticipateattheirrespectivestatesessionsasdelegates.Daniells'.innovationinthisrespectwasadeparturefromthesystemofpermittingonlydulyappointeddelegatestovoteatthesession.
Daniells'ideaofrepresentationwasthatanyandeverypersonwhowasinattendanceatalocalconferencesessionandamemberinthatconferenceshouldbeadelegatetothesession.Hestronglyadvocatedaparticipatoryelectionprocessforlocalconferencesatmostofthelocalconferencesessionsthatheattendedin1901,attheLakeUnionConferencesession(ofwhichhewaspresident),andattheEuropeanUnionConferencein1902.InEuropehestatedhisconceptasaprinciple.Hesaid:
“Astorepresentation,nobodycanrepresentanybodyexcepthimself.AllshouldbetheLord'srepresentatives;butnobodycanrepresentsomeotherperson,orachurch.Achurchis"fullyrepresented"inaConferencewhenallitsmembersarepresent;butnobodycandelegatehismindorhisconsciencetoanother.Ifapersonispresentatanymeeting,hedoesnotwantsomebodyelsetospeakforhim.”45
Itwasfurtherreportedthatwhilehedidnotpresume"todictatetoanyhowtheyshoulddo,hegaveitashisconvictionthatjustasinanychurchmeetingallthememberspresentareentitledtospeak,soinanyConferenceallthememberspresentareproperlydelegates."Headdedthathisplanhad"beenadoptedinquiteanumberofConferencesinAmerica."46
Daniellswasquestionedatlengthconcerninghisproposal.ApparentlyquiteafewofthedelegateshadreadLoughborough'sarticle,orwerefamiliarwiththeearlyhistoryofthedevelopmentoftheorganizationalstructureofthechurchandsawpragmaticdifficultieswiththeplan.Theywereconcernedthatsuchaplancouldgiveonedistrictanundueproportionalinfluenceandcontrol.DaniellsrebuffedsuchasuggestiononthebasisthatallwereChristians;theimplicationbeingthatnoonememberorgroupofmemberswouldexercisearbitraryorpoliticalpoweroverothers.Daniellscounteredevenfurther.Givenhiscommitmenttomission,heassuredthedelegatesthattheprincipleofnumericalrepresentationcouldnotbeasatisfactoryprinciplebecauseifitwerestrictlyfollowedfromthelocalconferencesright
45BulletinoftheEuropeanUnionConferenceHeldinLondon,May15-25,1902,[HereafterEuropeanConferenceBulletin],2.
46Ibid.
![Page 17: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
throughtotheGeneralConference,it"wouldleavetheheathenlandswhollyunprovidedfor,andwasthusopposedtomissionaryeffort."Eachmemberwasto"considerhimselfasrepresentativeoftheworld,andnotmerelyofhisparticularlocality."47Hewassomewhatinconsistentinhisreasoning,however.Hewasnotpromotingparticipatoryrepresentationasaprincipletobeadoptedatalllevelsofchurchadministration.Hewasonlyconcernedforitsadaptationtolocalconferencegovernance,and,tosomeextent,tounionconferences.AtGeneralConferencelevel,Daniells'ideasofrepresentation,especiallywithreferencetooverseasfields,werenotatallparticipatory,norweretheyevenparticularlyrepresentative.
Unionconferencerepresentation
Attheunionlevelofadministration,theconceptofrepresentationchangedfrombroad-basedparticipationbythepeopletounilateralrepresentationofthedepartmentsandtheinstitutionsintheunion.ThesamesituationappliedattheGeneralConference.In1901Daniellsallowedtheproposalthattheexecutivecommitteeelectitsownchairmanbecausehe,alongwithW.C.White,consideredthecommitteetobea"thoroughlyrepresentativeone."48Butthecommitteeselectedin1901comprisedrepresentativesofdepartmentsandinstitutions,withonlytheunionpresidentsasrepresentativesof"thepeople"whoweresupposedtobetheauthoritybaseinthechurch.Theunionpresidentswereoutnumberedseventeentoeightandcouldveryeasilybeoutvoted.Further,aschairmenorexecutiveboardmembersoftheinstitutionswithintheirownunions,unionpresidentsweremoreoftenfocusedoninstitutionalconcernsthanontheconcernsofthelocalchurchesandthechurchmembers.Theywere,therefore,morelikelytobesympathetictoinstitutionalproblemsandneedsthantotheneedsandconcernsofthechurchatlarge.Thecompositionofthecommitteeinevitablyledtoafocusoninstitutionalconcerns.InthisrespectSeventh-dayAdventistmissionmethodologywasinaccordwiththatofmostmissionagencieswhichdependedtoalargedegreeontheestablishmentofinstitutions
Internationalrepresentation
Thesituationwithregardtorepresentationoftheworld-wideconstituencyofthechurchwasevenmoretroublesome.AsthecompositionoftheGeneralConferenceexecutivecommitteewasbeingdiscussedin1901,G.G.Rupertaskediftherewasanyprovisionforthe"differentnationalitiesamongus"beingrepresentedonthecommittee.PrescottansweredhimbyquotingGal3:28andassuringthedelegatesthatsuchwasnotnecessarybecause"yearealloneinChristJesus.Theoutcomewasthatthesafestcoursewaschosen--
47Ibid.,2-3.
48GCBulletin,1901,206.
![Page 18: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
onlyNorthAmericanswereelectedtotheexecutivecommittee.Butthatisnottosaythattherewasnocommitmenttotheprincipleofrepresentation.Representationwasunderstoodasbeingcompatiblewiththehigherprincipleofdecentralization.ThechurchanditsmemberswereverymuchinthemindofDaniellsbothattheGeneralConferencesessionin1901andintheyearthatfollowed.Thoughhewasconscious"moreandmore"ofthe"influenceandpower"thattheGeneralConferencehad,hewasanxioustousethatpower"rightly"andgetinto"sympathetictouch"withthe"rankandfile"ofthechurchconstituency.Hecensuredconferenceofficersforfailingtoconsulttheirconstituencieswhendecisionsofimportanceweretobemade.In1901hehadwantedadministrationandgovernmentintheSeventh-dayAdventistChurchtobe"ofthepeople,bythepeople,andforthepeople."49
4. Decisionbyconsensus
Alongwithhisregardfortheprerogativesofthemembersofthechurchandhisdesiretoimplementaparticipatorydecisionmakingprocessatlocalconferencelevel,Daniellsadvocateddecisionmakingbyconsensusin1901and1902,ratherthanbymajorityvote.Incontrasttohisconceptofparticipationwhichwaspromotedonlyonthestateconferencelevel,headvocatedconsensusdecisionmakingateverylevelofadministration.DaniellstoldE.R.Palmer,hisassociateandconfidanteinAustralia,thatatthe1901GeneralConferencesessionnomeasure"receivedunkindtreatment."Someoftheproposalsadvancedwere"amended"andafew"droppedout,"butithadallbeendoneby"commonconsent,"notby"majorityvote."Daniellsdeclaredthathehadneverseen"anythinglikeit."50
OnemaywonderjustwhatDaniellshadinmindwhenheadvocatedtheconceptofconsensusdecisionmaking.51Whateverwasthecase,hisattitudechangedrapidly,againasa
49A.G.DaniellstoE.A.Sutherland,December20,1901,RecordGroup11,LetterBook25,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland;A.G.DaniellstoW.C.White,June18,1901,IncomingFiles,EllenG.WhiteEstateOffice;A.G.DaniellstoN.P.Nelson,July17,1901,RecordGroup11,LetterBook24,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland.
50A.G.DaniellstoE.R.Palmer,May3,1901,RecordGroup9,A.G.DaniellsFolder6,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland.
51Justbeforehisdeathin1932,R.A.UnderwoodmadesometerseobservationswithregardtoJamesWhite'sconceptofconsensusdecisionmaking.Hesaid:"ElderJamesWhitewaswhatmenwouldcallashrewdleader--Heunderstoodtheeffectofbeingunited--andoneofhisdiplomaticmoveswasthisinallthequestionsthatsecuredamajorityvoteintheGeneralConferenceordistrictorotherwisewhatevercarriedbyamajorityofevenafewvotes--hegotthedelegatestoagreethatitshouldbereportedunanimous--andnooppositionwasreferredtointhereport"(R.A.UnderwoodtoL.E.Froom,December8,1930,RecordGroup58,1920s-1930sInterpretationDevelopmentofFolder,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland).Underwood'spunctuationwasnotpreciseandhismemorywasnotacute--districtswerenotintroducedintotheadministrativestructureuntileightyearsafterthedeathofJamesWhite.However,onewondershowmuchcorrelationtherewasbetweenthe
![Page 19: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
consequenceoftheconfrontationwithKellogg,sothat,bytheGeneralConferenceSessionof1903,vitaldecisionswerebeingmadeonthestrengthofmajorityvote.52
Thechurchhadsomeadjustmentstomakeintheyearsimmediatelyafter1901.Someoftheplansthatweremadeandthemethodsthatwerefollowedwerenotwise.Daniellshimselfadmittedthat.However,theshiftfromemphasisonparticipatoryrepresentationandconsensusdecisionmakingtoemphasisonmorestructuredrepresentationandmajority-votedecisionmakingaftertheclashwithKelloggandtheextendedpolemicswiththoseopposedtothechurchstructurewasindicativeofashiftfromemphasisontheneedfordiversity(ordecentralization)toemphasisonpreservationofunity.
5. ConstituentAuthority
In1901DaniellsintendedthattheGeneralConferenceexecutivecommitteeshouldbeadvisory,notexecutive.Referringtotheplanoforganizingunions,hehopedthattheGeneralConferenceandtheMissionBoard(whichhadbeenintegratedintotheGeneralConferenceexecutivecommittee),wouldbe"ultimately...quitefreefromperplexingdetails."Hewasconvincedthatthenewplanoforganizationwouldenablethecommittees"totakethepositionofgeneraladvisoryboards."53TwoweekslaterhewrotetothemembersoftheGeneralConferenceCommittee:
“WearegladthatthedetailsinthevariousUnionConferencesarebeingsofullytakenoverbythosewhoareontheground....Ourhopeisthatweshallbeleftalmostentirelyfreetostudythelargequestionsofpolicyaffectingtheentirefield,andtodevoteourenergiestofosteringtheworkintheweakpartsofthefield,andalsothe
practiceofWhite(asrecalledbyUnderwood)toseekunanimityforthesakeofthereport,andthatofDaniellswhowasnotinthe"habitofcallingfortheoppositionvotetoanymeasure"(EuropeanConferenceBulletin,3).
52InthereplytoJonesin1906,itwaspointedoutthatthedecisiontoadoptthenewconstitutionatthe1903GeneralConferencesessionwasmadebymajorityvote.Infact,allthedecisionsmadeattheGeneralConferencesessionin1903wereadoptedbymajorityvote.Bythattimemajorityvotewasthemethodbeingconsistentlyfollowed,despiteDaniellsstateddesiretothecontrarylessthanoneyearearlier.SeeAStatementRefutingChargesMadebyA.T.JonesAgainsttheSpiritofProphecyandthePlanofOrganizationoftheSeventh-dayAdventistDenomination,”(WashingtonD.C.:GeneralConferenceCommittee,1906),28.Thestatementcanbefoundathttp://ellenwhite.org/content/file/statement-refuting-charges-made-t-jones-against-spirit-prophecy-and-plan-organization#document
53A.G.DaniellstoJ.J.Wessells,July151901,RecordGroup11,LetterBook24,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland.
![Page 20: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20
greatmissionfieldsintheregionsbeyond.Thusthegeneralmachineryisbeingreducedtoafewsimpleparts.”54
Somewereconcerned,evenso,thattoomuchpowerwasbeingcentralizedinthehandsofoneboard.TheymayhavebeenbeginningtoquestionthewisdomofformingdepartmentsintheGeneralConferencetoreplacetheauxiliaryorganizations.Apparentlyinresponse,DaniellswrotetoEdithGraham,thetreasureroftheAustralasianUnion,thattheGeneralConferenceexecutivecommitteecouldnotpossiblybeguiltyofcentralizingbecausethefactsofthematterwerethattheauthoritytoactwasbeingplacedinthehandsof"thoseontheground."Daniellscontinued:
“TheGeneralConferenceCommitteedoesnotproposetodealdirectlywiththeaffairsinanyUnionConference.WeproposetointerestourselvesinthewelfareofeveryUnionConference,ineverylineofwork....Soinsteadofcentralizingourwork,wehavebeendistributingit.”55
Daniells’answertothecentralizationofpowerintheGeneralConferencecommitteewasthatthecommitteewasnotgoingtomakeexecutivedecisions.Itwasgoingtobeafostering,advisory,boardwhoseinterestwasco-ordination,notsupervision.WithEllenWhite'sadviceinmind,nodoubt,DaniellswasconcernedthattheGeneralConferencecommitteeshouldnotexerciseexecutivecontrol,butthatitshoulddoeverythinginitspowertoco-ordinatetheadministrativefunctionsofthechurchsoastorespectthatauthorityresidentinthechurchmembership.Withthereformsthatweresuggestedandimplementedandwiththemovementawayfromcentralizationofauthority,Daniellshailedtheeventsof1901asthe"beginningofanewera,"thebeginningof"ourlastgrandmarch."56
By1903Daniellswasspeakingasthoughhestillheldthe"advisory"conceptoftheroleoftheGeneralConferenceexecutivecommittee.Buthewasnotspeakingwiththesamecertainty.AttheGeneralConferencesessionhestated:"Astheworkisnowshaping,theprovinceoftheGeneralConferenceCommitteeisofanadvisorycharactertoalargeextent--notaltogether,by
54A.G.DaniellstoMembersoftheGeneralConferenceCommittee,August2,1901,RecordGroup11,LetterBook24,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland.
55A.G.DaniellstoEdithR.Graham,May24,1901,RecordGroup11,LetterBook23,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland.
56A.G.DaniellstoE.H.Gates,May23,1901,RecordGroup11,LetterBook23,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland;A.G.DaniellstoM.H.Brown,June17,1901,RecordGroup11,LetterBook23,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland.
![Page 21: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
anymeans--anditisofamissionarycharacterorphase."57NolongerwastheroleoftheGeneralConferenceexecutivecommitteemerelyadvisory.Achangeofattitudehadtakenplace.Notice,however,thatnochangehadtakenplacewithregardtothepriorityofmission.AnychangesintheroleoftheGeneralConferenceexecutivecommitteewithrespecttocoordinationassetoveragainstcontrolwerebeingmadewithreferencetothemissionaryfocusofthecommitteeandthechurch.58
6. Simplicity
Inviewofthecomplicationandconfusionthathadcharacterizeddenominationaladministrationinthe1890s,reorganizationwasperceivedasasimplificationoftheorganizationalsystem.Inthe1890sEllenWhitehadadvocatedsimplicityinorganizationandinsistedthatthemachinerywasnottobe"agallingyoke."59Therefore,whenreorganizationwasbeingconsideredin1901,simplicitywasunderstoodtobeanessentialprinciple.Theprinciplesofrepresentationanddistributionofauthoritywererelatedtotheprincipleofdecentralization.Soalsowastheprincipleofsimplicity.60
DaniellsexpressedhimselfmostsuccinctlyontheneedforsimplicityattheEuropeanUnionConferencesessionin1902.Hesaid:Organizationshouldbeassimpleaspossible.Thenearer
57GCBulletin,1903,100.
58FrancisWernickhassomewhatastutelymadereferencetoDaniells'1901-1902conceptoftheroleoftheGeneralConferenceasanimpartial,advisory,fosteringboard.Wernickobserved,however,thatsincethattime,theGeneralConferencehasenlargeditsrolefromacoordinating,counsellingbodyto"moreofasupervisoryrole."Wernickadvisedthat"weneedtorethinktheroleoftheGeneralConference."Headded:"Wedoneedacentralofficetopreserveunity,togivecoordination,andtogivecounsel....Supervisionversuscoordinationneedsfurtherstudyanddefinition"(FrancisW.Wernick,"PhilosophyoftheRoleoftheGeneralConference"[paperpreparedforthecommitteeontheroleandfunctionofdenominationalorganizations,1984],RecordGroup500,MonographsSeries,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland).NoteWernick'sagenda.Thepreservationofunityheadsthelistofconcerns.Ithasbeenthatwayeversincethemid-1902crisis.
59GCBulletin,1893,22-24;EllenG.White,"OverbearingControlReproved,"Manuscript43,1895,EllenG.WhiteEstateOffice.
60Inearly1902Daniellssaid:"Ibelievethatwehavethrownawayagreatamountofmoneyandenergyintryingtokeepuselessmachineryrunning.Ifindthatthelesscomplexwemakeourwork,andthemorewecenteroureffortsonthesimplestraightlinesofmissionaryevangelization,theheartieristheresponseofthepeople,andthegreateristhemanifestationoflifeintheenterprise"(A.G.DaniellstoC.H.Jones,April21,1902,IncomingFiles,EllenG.WhiteEstateOffice).
![Page 22: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
wegettotheend,thesimplerwillbetheorganization.Ihavenoideathatwehavegottothelimitofsimplicity.61
In1903simplicitywasstilldescribedasadesirableprincipleofreorganization.Inhis"Chairman'sAddress"DaniellsusedtheintegrationoftheauxiliaryorganizationsintoGeneralConferencedepartmentsasanexampleoftheapplicationoftheprincipleofsimplification.62However,itwasadmittedthatinsomeregards,themachinerywasstilltoocomplicated.Simplicitywasprovingtobeanelusivequalityinorganizationanditwastoremainso.EspeciallywasthattocontinuetobethecaseinthosepartsoftheworldwheretheadministrativemachinerythatmayhavebeennecessaryinNorthAmericaorEuropewasjust"toocomplicated."63
7. Adaptability
Theprincipleofadaptabilitywas,in1901,almosttooobvioustoneedextendedtreatment.Theveryfactthatthechurchwaswillingtoenterintoaprocessofradicalreorganizationissufficienttoindicatethatprioritywasgiventoadaptabilityinorganizationalstructures.Furtheradaptationsin1903indicatethatthecommitmenttoadaptabilityremained.In1902,inadditiontohisremarksattheEuropeanUnionconferenceregardingsimplicity,Daniellsinsisted
“Weseemanythingsdifferentlyfromwhatwedidtenyearsago,andIexpectthatweshallseestillmore.Asnewlightcomes,weoughttoadvancewithit,andnotholdrigidlytooldformsandoldmethods.Becauseathingisdoneacertainwayinoneplaceisnotreasonwhyitshouldbedoneinthesamewayinanotherplace,oreveninthesameplaceatthesametime.”64
61EuropeanConferenceBulletin,2.
62GCBulletin,1903,18.
63Atthe1903GeneralConferencesessionDaniellsquotedEllenWhitewithreferencetothesimplificationofmachinery.Henotedthatshehaddeclaredthatin"`somepartsoftheworkitistrue,themachineryhasbeenmadetoocomplicated'"(“OriginalReportsandStenographicallyReportedDiscussionsThereofHadattheThirty-FourthBiennialSessionoftheSeventh-dayAdventistGeneralConference,9April1903,”RecordGroup0,GeneralConferenceArchives,SilverSpring,Maryland,75b).Evenin1909EllenWhitefounditnecessarytostressthat"simpleorganizationandchurchorder"weresetforthintheNewTestamentandthattheLordhadordainedsuchfor"theunityandperfectionofthechurch"(EllenG.WhitetotheLeadingMinistersinCalifornia,December6,1909,Letter178,1909,EllenG.WhitestateOffice).
64EuropeanConferenceBulletin,2.
![Page 23: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23
FurtherattentioncouldbegiventoEllenWhite'sattitudetoadaptabilityandthepossibilityofsubsequentstructuralchange.65ApartfromEllenWhite,W.A.SpicerwasprobablythemostvocaladvocateoftheimportanceofallowingadaptabilityintheformthatorganizationtookintheSeventh-dayAdventistChurch.ItwasSpicer,anexperiencedmissionary,whowasresponsibleasmuchasanyoneforthesuccessofthemissionaryenterpriseofthechurchintheearlyyearsofthetwentiethcentury.Withhiswideexposuretodifferentculturesandsituations,herepeatedlysaid:
“Thedetailsoforganizationmayvaryaccordingtoconditionsandwork,buteverasGodhascalledhischurchtogethertherehasappearedinitthespiritualgiftoforderandgovernment,thespiritthatrulesinheaven.”66(Emphasissupplied.)
LearningswhichmaybeinstructionalforthecontemporarySeventh-dayAdventistChurch.
Bywayofconclusion,themajorlearningsderivedfromthispaperwhichmaybeinstructionalforthecontemporarySeventh-dayAdventistChurchare:
1. Whenamajordiscussionisneededandadecisiontobemadeitisnecessaryforpeopleofinfluencetospeakupandparticipateinthediscussionratherthankeepingsilent.
2. Itispossibleforleaderstotaketoomuchresponsibilityfordecisionmakingontheirownshouldersandnotlistentoothersorgivethemopportunitytoparticipateintheprocess.
3. Thecommitteesystemwhenutilizedproperlycanbeacorrectiveforcentralization.
65Forexample,soonaftertheGeneralConferencesessionof1901,EllenWhitewrotetoA.G.Daniells,regardingtheworkamongthe“coloredpeople”intheSouth.SheadmonishedDaniellstobeflexibleinhisadministrationbecauseoftheuniqueneedsoftheSouth.Thechurchwasnottobecome“narrow”andconfinedby“regularlines.”Differentmethodsoforganizationandapproachwerenecessaryinculturallydiversesituations.Foradministrationtobetiedtoaninflexiblepredeterminedpolicywhichcouldnotadapttodiverseculturalandsociologicalneedswas,forEllenWhite,anabuseofadministrativeprerogative.SeeEllenG.WhitetoA.G.Daniells,Letter65,June30,1901,EllenG.WhiteEstateOffice.Theverysameday,EllenWhitewrotetohersonEdson,whowasworkinginthesouthernpartoftheUnitedStates.Edsonwasinclinedtobetooadventurousinhisinnovations.WhereasDaniells,theadministrator,hadtobecounseledtoallowchangeandinnovationinadifferentsocio-culturalmilieu,Edsonhadtobecautionednottobetoohasty.EllenWhitewrote:“Youneednowtobeabletothinkandjudgewithcleardiscrimination.Greatcaremustbeexercisedinmakingchangeswhichdifferfromtheold-establishedroutine.Changesaretobemade,buttheyarenottobemadeinsuchanabruptmannerthatyouwillnotcarrythepeoplewithyou.YouwhoareworkingintheSouthmustlaborasifinaforeigncountry.Youmustworkaspioneers,seekingtosaveexpenseineverywaypossible.Andaboveall,youmuststudytoshowyourselvesapproveduntoGod”(EllenG.WhitetoJ.EdsonWhite,Letter62June30,1901,EllenG.WhiteEstateOffice).
66W.A.Spicer,"TheDivinePrincipleofOrganization,"AdventReviewandSabbathHerald,March25,1909,5.
![Page 24: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
24
EllenWhitedeclaredthat“Godwouldnothavemanymindstheshadowofoneman’smind,”butthat“inamultitudeofcounselorsthereissafety.”67GroupthinkisnottobeinevidenceinthedecisionsoftheChurch.
4. Theholdingofpositionofresponsibilitybyanyindividual,doesnotinitselfguaranteethebestopinionsorthebestdecisionsbythatindividual.
5. Positiondoesnotgrantirrevocablepower.
6. Financialcrisiscanbeapowerfulcatalystforchange.
7. AcommitmenttoaglobalmissionwhicharisesfrombeliefintheimminenceofChrist’sreturnisthemajorcatalystforefficientandeffectiveorganization.Organizationmustservemission,notviceversa.
8. Thedeterminingprinciplesoforganizationarederivedmorefromanevaluationofthepragmaticsituationofthechurchwithrespecttothefulfilmentofitsmissionarytaskthanfromsystematictheologicalconsiderations.ApragmatismwhichtakesintoaccountbiblicalteachingandcontextualimperativehasbeenthemodusoperandioftheChurch.
9. Decentralizationwasthemostpervasiveprincipleofreorganization.Asacorrectivetocentralization,asmuchaspossibleandpractical,decisionsaretobemadebythose“ontheground.”
10. ConfrontationandpolemicsintheChurchresultinemphasisbyleadersontheneedforunity.Inthiscontextthestructuresofthechurchbecomemoreaninstrumentofthecentralizationofauthoritythananinstrumentofdelegationanddecentralizationofauthority.Circumstancesandthedispositionoftheleadersthemselveshaveconsiderablebearingonwhichisevidentinpractice.
11. Noonepersonistobecomesuchacontrollingpowerthathe/shehastoomuchinfluenceonthedirectionthattheChurchtakesonanyissue.
12. BothunityanddiversitycanhavenegativeandpositiveimpactsonthemissionoftheChurch.Diversityispositivewhenitsacceptanceenhancesthepotentialofthechurchtoreachdiverse"nations,tongues,andpeoples,"anddecentralizeddecision-makingispracticed.Itisnegativewhenitistakentoofar,appropriateorganizationalboundaries
67EllenG.WhitetoJohnHarveyKellogg,Letter7,April26,1886,EllenG.WhiteEstateOffice.
![Page 25: Reorganisation of Church Structure - WordPress.com · Conference of 1888, Ellen White wrote of Butler: “A sick man’s mind has had a controlling power over the General Conference](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040711/5e12c7ca6b05b15fcb2fa7e0/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
25
arenotrespected,anditresultsinsyncretism.UnityispositivewhenitbindstheChurchintoonenessinChrist.Itisnegativewhenitisinterpretedtorequireuniformityandunnecessarycentralizationofauthority.
13. Giventhechurch'stheologicalandpragmaticpriorities,somecentralizationisnecessaryandlegitimate.Butin1901theprincipleofdiversitywasmoredeterminativethantheprincipleofunityintheestablishmentofunions,andbydelegatingsomefunctionswhichhadpreviouslybeenperformedbytheGeneralConferencetounionconferences.Theemphasiswasontheneedtorecognizediversitybydecentralization.
14. Inthereformsof1901DaniellsaffirmedthatitwasnottheintentionoftheGeneralConferencecommitteetodealdirectlywiththeaffairsofanyUnionConference.Daniells’answertothecentralizationofpowerintheGeneralConferencecommitteewasthatthecommitteewasnotgoingtomakeexecutivedecisions.Itwasgoingtobeafostering,advisory,boardwhoseinterestwasco-ordination,notsupervision.By1903Daniellswasspeakingasthoughhestillheldthe"advisory"conceptoftheroleoftheGeneralConferenceexecutivecommittee.Butinpractice,nolongerwasitsrolemerelyadvisory.Achangeofattitudehadtakenplace.
15. AdaptabilityandflexibilityarevitalforthefulfilmentofthemissionoftheSeventh-dayAdventistChurch.Noteverythingistobedonethesamewayeverywhere.Whenthereisnodirect“ThussaiththeLord,”theChurchmustbeflexibleifitistobetruetoisreasonforexistence.