Regulation & Language Training: Is there a case for it? Philip Shawcross ICAEA ICAO LPRI workshop,...

9
Regulation & Language Training: Regulation & Language Training: Is there a case for it? Is there a case for it? Philip Shawcross Philip Shawcross ICAEA ICAEA ICAO LPRI workshop, ENAC, Rome, 4 ICAO LPRI workshop, ENAC, Rome, 4 th th March 2010 March 2010

Transcript of Regulation & Language Training: Is there a case for it? Philip Shawcross ICAEA ICAO LPRI workshop,...

Page 1: Regulation & Language Training: Is there a case for it? Philip Shawcross ICAEA ICAO LPRI workshop, ENAC, Rome, 4 th March 2010.

Regulation & Language Training:Regulation & Language Training:

Is there a case for it?Is there a case for it?

Philip ShawcrossPhilip Shawcross

ICAEAICAEA

ICAO LPRI workshop, ENAC, Rome, 4ICAO LPRI workshop, ENAC, Rome, 4thth March 2010 March 2010

Page 2: Regulation & Language Training: Is there a case for it? Philip Shawcross ICAEA ICAO LPRI workshop, ENAC, Rome, 4 th March 2010.

Regulation & Language Training?Regulation & Language Training?

A few issues …A few issues …

… … a bit of provocationa bit of provocation

Page 3: Regulation & Language Training: Is there a case for it? Philip Shawcross ICAEA ICAO LPRI workshop, ENAC, Rome, 4 th March 2010.

Regulation & Language Training?Regulation & Language Training?

Current situationCurrent situation

Aviation English training: Aviation English training:

New activityNew activity Few long track recordsFew long track records Little academic researchLittle academic research UnregulatedUnregulated High stakes outcomesHigh stakes outcomes

Page 4: Regulation & Language Training: Is there a case for it? Philip Shawcross ICAEA ICAO LPRI workshop, ENAC, Rome, 4 th March 2010.

Regulation & Language Training?Regulation & Language Training?

Accreditation: a paradoxAccreditation: a paradox

Many TEFL accrediting bodies …Many TEFL accrediting bodies … … … but without aviation expertisebut without aviation expertise FTOs accredited by CAAs ….FTOs accredited by CAAs …. … … but private language schools not but private language schools not

covered covered

Page 5: Regulation & Language Training: Is there a case for it? Philip Shawcross ICAEA ICAO LPRI workshop, ENAC, Rome, 4 th March 2010.

Regulation & Language Training?Regulation & Language Training?

Some regulation optionsSome regulation options

Free unregulated marketFree unregulated market Regulation centralized by a single Regulation centralized by a single

recognized international bodyrecognized international body Individual State regulation following Individual State regulation following

national / international guidelinesnational / international guidelines Self-regulation through a voluntary Self-regulation through a voluntary

international consortium of training international consortium of training organisationsorganisations

Page 6: Regulation & Language Training: Is there a case for it? Philip Shawcross ICAEA ICAO LPRI workshop, ENAC, Rome, 4 th March 2010.

Regulation & Language Training?Regulation & Language Training?

Obstacles to regulationObstacles to regulation

Consensus on training criteriaConsensus on training criteria Widely differing local conditionsWidely differing local conditions Absence of a recognized authorityAbsence of a recognized authority Perceived interference with a free marketPerceived interference with a free market Lack of incentiveLack of incentive Funding Funding Time frameTime frame

Page 7: Regulation & Language Training: Is there a case for it? Philip Shawcross ICAEA ICAO LPRI workshop, ENAC, Rome, 4 th March 2010.

Regulation & Language Training?Regulation & Language Training?

Positive outcomes of regulationPositive outcomes of regulation

Creation of a recognized statement of best Creation of a recognized statement of best practicepractice

Formative effect on organisations & Formative effect on organisations & practitionerspractitioners

Robust criteria for decision-makersRobust criteria for decision-makers Improved use of resourcesImproved use of resources More systematic approach to training processMore systematic approach to training process

Page 8: Regulation & Language Training: Is there a case for it? Philip Shawcross ICAEA ICAO LPRI workshop, ENAC, Rome, 4 th March 2010.

Regulation & Language Training?Regulation & Language Training?

So, where do we go from here?So, where do we go from here?

Page 9: Regulation & Language Training: Is there a case for it? Philip Shawcross ICAEA ICAO LPRI workshop, ENAC, Rome, 4 th March 2010.

Regulation & Language Training?Regulation & Language Training?

What are your thoughts?What are your thoughts?

[email protected]@icaea.net

ICAO LPRI workshop, ENAC, Rome, 4th March 2010ICAO LPRI workshop, ENAC, Rome, 4th March 2010


2.4 ELPAC presentation ICAO LPRI Kuwait Nov 2015 v2 · Microsoft PowerPoint - 2.4 ELPAC presentation ICAO LPRI Kuwait Nov 2015 v2 Author: SKodsi Created Date: 11/11/2015 11:07:12

2.4 ELPAC presentation ICAO LPRI Kuwait Nov 2015 v2 · Microsoft PowerPoint - 2.4 ELPAC presentation ICAO LPRI Kuwait Nov 2015 v2 Author: SKodsi Created Date: 11/11/2015 11:07:12

LPRI Vienna EASA 2102 final.ppt Meetings Seminars... · EASA.MBO ICAO LPRI Workshop Vienna 2012 Regulation Aircrew Annex I Part-FCL Subpart A General Rules Subpart B LAPL Subpart

LPRI Vienna EASA 2102 final.ppt Meetings Seminars... · EASA.MBO ICAO LPRI Workshop Vienna 2012 Regulation Aircrew Annex I Part-FCL Subpart A General Rules Subpart B LAPL Subpart

trustees - Charity Times · Shawcross added that the Charity Commission has accepted and is already implementing many of the recommendations set out in the Public Accounts Committee

trustees - Charity Times · Shawcross added that the Charity Commission has accepted and is already implementing many of the recommendations set out in the Public Accounts Committee

ADDRESS PRICE ARCHITECT...Gormley, Alex Chinneck, Conrad Shawcross and Richard Wilson. For downtime there’s a local pub, The Pilot, just a short walk away and you’ll also find

ADDRESS PRICE ARCHITECT...Gormley, Alex Chinneck, Conrad Shawcross and Richard Wilson. For downtime there’s a local pub, The Pilot, just a short walk away and you’ll also find

LES Presentation LPRI

LES Presentation LPRI

What do these 3 people have in common? They are all American serial killers!!! Arthur Shawcross: The Genesee River Killer. In March 1988, he murdered 11.

What do these 3 people have in common? They are all American serial killers!!! Arthur Shawcross: The Genesee River Killer. In March 1988, he murdered 11.

DRAFT PROGRAMME - ICAEA · 9.15-10.00 Keynote 1: Best practice in language test development Drawing from mainstream language testing practices – Speaker 1 Break 10.00-10.30 Main

DRAFT PROGRAMME - ICAEA · 9.15-10.00 Keynote 1: Best practice in language test development Drawing from mainstream language testing practices – Speaker 1 Break 10.00-10.30 Main

AVIATION ENGLISH TEACHING - ICAEA - Supporting the use of … · 2015-08-28 · PROCEEDINGS AVIATION ENGLISH TEACHING FORUM Organised by Joan Bellec and Fiona Robertson, the Centre

AVIATION ENGLISH TEACHING - ICAEA - Supporting the use of … · 2015-08-28 · PROCEEDINGS AVIATION ENGLISH TEACHING FORUM Organised by Joan Bellec and Fiona Robertson, the Centre

Chord, Conrad Shawcross

Chord, Conrad Shawcross

Time Management Session 2 Judith Shawcross jks45@eng.cam.ac.uk.

Time Management Session 2 Judith Shawcross [email protected].

Shawcross exhibition brochure

Shawcross exhibition brochure

WORLD MEN'S OPEN AND WORLD AMATEUR INDIVIDUAL · Notes: World Individual played in London - teams in Birmingham - opposite to 1987 Winner Shawcross had already won the Australian

WORLD MEN'S OPEN AND WORLD AMATEUR INDIVIDUAL · Notes: World Individual played in London - teams in Birmingham - opposite to 1987 Winner Shawcross had already won the Australian

Brilliant Ideas Episode #20: Conrad Shawcross · Industrial Revolution era in Britain, this artwork shows slowly movin g enormous structure that seems as if to fall down at any time,

Brilliant Ideas Episode #20: Conrad Shawcross · Industrial Revolution era in Britain, this artwork shows slowly movin g enormous structure that seems as if to fall down at any time,

Neil Bullock ICAEA Conference, Tokyo May 2019

Neil Bullock ICAEA Conference, Tokyo May 2019

ADDRESS Waterman Gardens, London SE10...Gormley, Alex Chinneck, Conrad Shawcross and Richard Wilson. For downtime there’s a local pub, The Pilot, just a short walk away and you’ll

ADDRESS Waterman Gardens, London SE10...Gormley, Alex Chinneck, Conrad Shawcross and Richard Wilson. For downtime there’s a local pub, The Pilot, just a short walk away and you’ll

A brief of a lineage of the very ancient family and ...memory.loc.gov/service/gdc/scd0001/2007/... · a lineage of the very ancient familyand surname of shallcross, or shawcross,

A brief of a lineage of the very ancient family and ...memory.loc.gov/service/gdc/scd0001/2007/... · a lineage of the very ancient familyand surname of shallcross, or shawcross,

Aviation Plus · 2020. 8. 26. · Air Law and is a consulting editor of Shawcross and Beaumont on Air Law – We wrote the extensive report Brexit scenarios for Business Aviation

Aviation Plus · 2020. 8. 26. · Air Law and is a consulting editor of Shawcross and Beaumont on Air Law – We wrote the extensive report Brexit scenarios for Business Aviation

Stu Oxley and Neil Shawcross

Stu Oxley and Neil Shawcross

International Civil Aviation Organization Implementation of ICAO Language Proficiency Requirements: Progressing Solutions ICAEA Seminar Buenos Aires, Argentina.

International Civil Aviation Organization Implementation of ICAO Language Proficiency Requirements: Progressing Solutions ICAEA Seminar Buenos Aires, Argentina.

PROGRAMME - ICAEA...Instructor for MPL and ATPL programmes in 2015 . Ab-initio trainees are trained in ATC communication based on ICAO phraseology. During flight training, if a traffic

PROGRAMME - ICAEA...Instructor for MPL and ATPL programmes in 2015 . Ab-initio trainees are trained in ATC communication based on ICAO phraseology. During flight training, if a traffic