Reducing eDiscovery Cost and Risk with Intelligent ... 02_2.pdf · Business Week, Corporate...
Transcript of Reducing eDiscovery Cost and Risk with Intelligent ... 02_2.pdf · Business Week, Corporate...
Dean Gonsowski, Esq.
Sr. eDiscovery Counsel, Symantec
Reducing eDiscovery Cost and Risk with Intelligent Information Governance
Today’s Speaker
Mr. Gonsowski is the Sr. eDiscovery Counsel at Symantec. He is a member of The Sedona Conference Working Group on Electronic Document Retention and Production (WG1), the Electronic Discovery Reference Model (EDRM) and teaches a series of continuing legal education (CLE) courses on various eDiscovery topics.
He has contributed articles to a number of leading industry publications including: Business Week, Corporate Counsel, ILTA Peer to Peer, Inside Counsel and the Legal Tech Newsletter.
Dean Gonsowski, Esq.
2
3
Information Risk 1
eDiscovery Basics 2
Information Governance 3
An eDiscovery User Case 4
3
Sample Customers 5
eDiscovery Subject Matter Experts
Top Information Risk Categories
4
Regulatory/Statutory Compliance
• The Department of Justice received more than $1
billion in 2011 from criminal antitrust
offenders, including criminal fines and more
than $500 million in restitution, penalties, and disgorgement, which was an increase of more than
78%
Electronic Discovery • The average cost of electronic discovery in
litigation has climbed to more than $1.5 million
per matter and 90% of US corporations are engaged
in litigation • The average company with revenue exceeding
$1 billion dollars averages 147 simultaneous
lawsuits • E-Discovery related sanction awards have nearly doubled in the
past 12 months
Data Security • Zappos recently had 24
million of its customer accounts hacked, including customer’s names, e-mail
addresses, addresses, phone numbers, the last four digits of credit card numbers and cryptically
scrambled passwords
• The cost to businesses of unintentionally exposing
corporate information climbed 7 percent last year
to over $7 million per incident
IIG WW Kick-off: Information Governance
5
Information Risk 1
eDiscovery Basics 2
Information Governance 3
An eDiscovery User Case 4
5
Sample Customers 5
eDiscovery Subject Matter Experts
Case Examples
6
What is eDiscovery?
Civil Lawsuits
Government Investigations
Internal Investigations
Public Record Requests
Corporate Legal Departments and Law
Firms
The Formal Process for Exchanging Information Between Parties Involved In Civil Lawsuits (Litigation) – But….
DOJ, SEC, FDA, FTC, FBI, etc.
Companies/ Corporations
Federal, State & Local Government
Employment
Intellectual Property
Products Liability
Environmental
Contract Disputes
Insider Trading
Options Backdating
Tainted Food/Drugs
Mergers/Acquisitions
Bribery/Corruption
Harassment
Discrimination
IP Theft
Fraud
Money Laundering
FOIA
State Records Acts
Environmental
Budgetary
6 eDiscovery Subject Matter Experts
7
Know the EDRM
Information Management Identification
Preservation
Collection
Processing
Review
Analysis
Production
eDiscovery Timeline
Symantec Enterprise Vault™
Clearwell
The Electronic Discovery Reference Model (EDRM)
Symantec Archiving and eDiscovery 7 eDiscovery Subject Matter Experts
eDiscovery is Expensive
8
It costs about 20¢/day to buy 1GB of storage.
However, it costs around $3,500 to review 1GB of
storage —AIIM
The total costs per gigabyte reviewed were
generally around $18,000. —Rand Survey
And, Review is only part of the equation (at 73% of overall eDiscovery costs). Processing is 19% and
Collection is 8% of the total cost burden.
eDiscovery Subject Matter Experts
And, Risky…
• “Spoliation” of evidence is: “the intentional or negligent withholding, hiding, altering, or
destroying of evidence relevant to a legal proceeding.”
• The Court's authority to sanction a party for failing to preserve documents is both inherent and statutory (FRCP 37) – The most severe sanctions, such as entry of default judgment or
criminal punishment, are generally reserved for the intentional destruction of digital evidence.
– The penalties for negligent spoliation include fines, attorneys' fees, as well as the dreaded “spoliation inference”
9 eDiscovery Subject Matter Experts
10
Information Risk 1
eDiscovery Basics 2
Information Governance 3
An eDiscovery User Case 4
10
Sample Customers 5
eDiscovery Subject Matter Experts
Data Explosion Exacerbates the Problem
11 11
Worldwide E-Discovery Spend $ Millions
Worldwide Data Growth Exabytes by year
2005 2010 2015
130
1,227
7,910
Source: “6th Annual Electronic Discovery Survey” Socha-Gelbmann, 2008
Source: “The Digital Universe,” IDC, June 2011
IIG WW Kick-off: Information Governance
12
Example: Social Media
12
Cost of social media incidents $4,292,897
Past 12 Months Reduced Stock
Price $4,292,897
BIGGEST COSTS
Litigation Costs $650,361
Direct Financial Cost
$641,993 Damaged
Brand/Trust $638,496
Lost Revenue $619,360
IIG WW Kick-off: Information Governance
Information Governance Defined
Components of IG are: – All information types
(structured and unstructured) – An umbrella for all
information management activities
– Legal risk – Business value – Controls
– Processes – Technology
A comprehensive program of controls,
processes, and technologies designed to
help organizations maximize the value of
information assets while minimizing associated
risks and costs.
13 IIG WW Kick-off: Information Governance
Describing Information Governance
14 IIG WW Kick-off: Information Governance
IG is a Big Umbrella
15 IIG WW Kick-off: Information Governance
IG Budgets
IG budgets may not exist, per se, but budgets for storage
and archiving, eDiscovery, and compliance do
16 IIG WW Kick-off: Information Governance
17
“The same data has many stakeholders –
who is ultimately accountable? “
“Information Governance must adapt & improve – ‘set it
and forget it’ doesn’t work “How do I even know if
we’re doing a good job?”
There’s way too much data, and it lives in too many places
Common IG Pain Points
“Keyword policies are too generic – it’s the
exceptions that keep us up at night”
* top quotes from enterprise and law firm customers, October 2011 Information Governance Working Session at Clearwell Inner Circle Meeting
IIG WW Kick-off: Information Governance
Improving The Current Process
18
Symantec Information Intelligence
7 to 12 weeks
8 to 10 different logins and systems
No link between eDiscovery and Data Security
Manual tracking
Ad-hoc communication across organizations
2 days
2 logins and systems
One-click link between eDiscovery and Data Security
Automated tracking
Single common platform across organizations
Current Process
IIG WW Kick-off: Information Governance
Any InfoGov Solution Must Meet Fundamental Requirements
IIG WW Kick-off: Information Governance 19
• Who owns the data? • Where is the data? Data Intelligence
• On-premise and Cloud • Retention and Discovery and Security
Data Products should work together
• Shorten/automate workflow • Audit/track automatically Streamline Processes
• Show success/ROI immediately • Add capabilities over time Solve InfoGov Incrementally
20
Information Risk 1
eDiscovery Basics 2
Information Governance 3
An eDiscovery User Case 4
20
Sample Customers 5
eDiscovery Subject Matter Experts
Rapidly and cost-effectively discover
IIG WW Kick-off: Information Governance
100 TB 10 TB
Archive & Expire
Deduplicate & Compress
Collect & Process
500 GB 300 TB
Review & Produce
Filter & Search
50 GB 5 GB
• Storage Footprint: 70% reduction
• eDiscovery Data Volume: 95% reduction
Leverage integration and advanced technology for speed and accuracy
21
22
Information Risk 1
eDiscovery Basics 2
Information Governance 3
An eDiscovery User Case 4
22
Sample Customers 5
eDiscovery Subject Matter Experts
Fed-Enforcement
Energy Financial Services
Sample Enterprise And Government Customers
23
Healthcare
Technology
Media
Manufacturing
Telco
Retail/Consumer
Transportation
Fed-Civilian
State/Local Govt.
IIG WW Kick-off: Information Governance
Thank you!
Copyright © 2011 Symantec Corporation. All rights reserved. Symantec and the Symantec Logo are trademarks or registered trademarks of Symantec Corporation or its affiliates in the U.S. and other countries. Other names may be trademarks of their respective owners. This document is provided for informational purposes only and is not intended as advertising. All warranties relating to the information in this document, either express or implied, are disclaimed to the maximum extent allowed by law. The information in this document is subject to change without notice.
IIG WW Kick-off: Information Governance 24