REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not...

104
REALITY BITES http:// www.realitybites.org.uk/

Transcript of REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not...

Page 1: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

REALITY BITES

http://www.realitybites.org.uk/

Page 2: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Christian Pedagogy?

Christian Epistemology?

Let’s work together!

Workshops not lectures.

Page 3: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Exploring the Biblical Story and

its View of Knowledge and

Knowing

Page 4: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Image of God in Scripture

Page 5: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

We tend to read Scripture through spectacles that:

• individualise it

• spiritualise it

Page 6: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Thereby we lose the down-to-Earth-ness and ordinariness of Scripture and fail to grasp the range and depth of rich cultural life it would create and nurture.

Page 7: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

God is interested/fascinated in our work places and activities outside of church services!

How do you respond to these photos?

Page 8: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 9: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 10: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

God’s fantastic creation is the contextin which humans image God.

Page 11: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

God’s rich hospitality to humans

Page 12: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 13: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 14: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Eh, bah gum – they’re funny up north!

Page 15: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

28 God blessed them and said to them, "Be fruitful and increase in number; fill the earth and subdue it. Rule over the fish of the sea and the birds of the air and over every

living creature that moves on the ground."

31 God saw all that he had made, and it was very good. And there was

evening, and there was morning - the sixth day.

Page 16: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

kabash and radah

(subdue and rule)

Page 17: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 18: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

The LORD God took the man and put him in the Garden of Eden to work it and take care of it.

Genesis 2:15

Page 19: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

abad and shamar

(serve and care forthe donkeys, the trees, the earth)

Page 20: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

God has created humans to live on the earth and not in heaven. He calls us to steward it and to unfold it to His glory and praise. He loves all that brings abundant life.

Page 21: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 22: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

This is sometimes called the Cultural Mandate! Very neglected theme in England.

Page 23: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Humans are unique. Unlikedonkeys and ferrets we can direct and guide creation. We can shape history in both good and bad ways.

Page 24: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 25: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

God calls humans to reflect His love, His goodness and His wisdom into His creation. God’s love, wisdom and goodness are reflected in faithful human imaging of God.

Page 26: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Knowledge must be understood in terms of God’s call to humans to be faithful stewards of His most excellent creation.

Page 27: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

This is Frank Dobson, a northerner. Is he a good steward ofhis ferrets?

And his house, his stamp collection and his money etc?

Page 28: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Provocative Question

Do we read Scripture from Genesis 1 to Revelation 22 or from Genesis 3 to Revelation

20?

Page 29: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

The Biblical DramaAct 1: Creation –

God establishes his KingdomAct 2: Fall – Rebellion in the KingdomAct 3: Redemption Initiated –

Abraham’s Line and a NationAct 4: Redemption accomplished –

The King Himself ComesAct 5: The Mission of the Church –

Spreading the News of the Kingdom Act 6: New Heavens and New Earth –

Kingdom fully present

Page 31: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

The fear of the Lord is the beginning of knowledge but fools despise wisdom and discipline.

Proverbs 1:7

Page 32: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

The word translated “beginning” means the key part of knowledge.

Page 33: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Proverbs 1:7 is a shocking statement as it strongly implies that ‘knowledge’ is intimately connected to our deepest religious commitments.

Fear of God is a vital ingredient.

Knowledge is not a religiously neutral affair.

Page 34: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

We get the very same idea in the New Testament.

Page 35: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

“Woe to you experts in the law, because you have taken away the key to knowledge. You yourselves have not entered, and you have hindered those who were entering.”

Luke 11:52

Page 36: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

“My purpose is that they may be encouraged in heart and united in love, so that they may have the full riches of complete understanding, in order that they may know the mystery of God, namely, Christ, in whom are hidden all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge.”

Colossians 2:2-3

Page 37: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

These passages are not just speaking about ‘moral’ or ‘religious’ knowledge. There is a comprehensive reference to all kinds of knowledge and knowing and Jesus is the key to all knowledge.

Outrageous? – Yes!

Page 38: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Group Work

“I, too, have definite religious convictions but would not

dream of letting them intrude into my philosophical

analysis”

Discuss this statement by a Christian academic.

Page 39: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Knowing and the Heart

Page 40: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 41: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Know then in your heart that as a man disciplines his son, so

the Lord your God disciplines you.

Deut 8:5

Page 42: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

The heart (Hebrew – Leb) is the seat of knowing.

The biblical teaching about the centrality of the heart is a key to understanding all

forms of knowledge.

Page 43: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Theologian Gordon Spykman states that the image of God embraces our entire selfhood in all

its many functions centred and unified in the

heart.

Page 44: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 45: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

It is the wellspring of all our willing, thinking,

imagining, feeling, acting etc.

In short the heart is the mini-me.

Page 46: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 47: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Notice that the heart in Scripture is not referring to our feelings. It is the core, the religious centre of our entire being.

Page 48: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Different Kinds of Knowing

Page 49: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Scripture presents a fundamentally relational

view of knowledge/knowing

(over against a narrowly intellectualistic Greek

view).

Page 50: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 51: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

The meaning of the Hebrew word yada ranges widely. It

includes sensory perception, intellectual activity, practical

skills, careful attention to close relationships, wise

stewardship and also physical intimacy in a sexual sense

(Genesis 4 :1)

Page 52: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

In Scripture there are many different kinds of knowledge.

We need these different kinds of knowing in order to serve God

in all areas of life as faithful servants/stewards of God’s

world.

Let’s explore some of them.

Page 53: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 54: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Be sure you know the condition of your flocks, 

    give careful attention to your herds;

for riches do not endure forever,     and a crown is not secure for all

generations.

Proverbs 27:23

Page 55: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Shepherds have an appropriate

knowledge/wisdom which they need to develop

(cultural mandate) if they are to be faithful to God’s

covenant.

Page 56: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Then the Lord said to Moses,  “See, I have chosen Bezalel son of Uri, the son of Hur, of the tribe of Judah, and I have filled him with the Spirit of God, with wisdom, with understanding, with knowledge and with all kinds of skills —  to make artistic designs for work in gold, silver and bronze, to cut and set stones, to work in wood, and to engage in all kinds of crafts.

Exodus 31:1-5

Page 57: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

This is Ron Saunders a southerner, an imaginary mate of mine.A superb craftsman who is a fantastic blessing to my imaginary aunty Elsie!

Page 58: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Bezalel the holy craftsman?

This is the first mention of a person being filled with the Holy Spirit in Scripture. And it explicitly mentions the knowledge of a craftsman!

Page 59: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 60: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

God gave Solomon wisdom and very great insight, and a breadth of understanding as measureless as the sand on the seashore. His fame spread to all the surroundingnations…...He described plant life, from the cedar of Lebanon to the hyssop that grows out of walls. He also taught about animals and birds, reptiles and fish. Men of all nations came to listen to Solomon’s wisdom. (1 Kings 4:29-34)

Page 61: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Solomon impressed the pagans because he had a very down-to-earth kind of knowledge.

It included Botany and Zoology.

Did he know anything about ferrets?

Page 62: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 63: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Provocative Question

Why are some Christians surprised by Solomon’s Botanical and Zoological

insights?

Page 64: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

My Answer to the Provocative Question

Some Christians reduce knowledge to Theology!

Page 65: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 66: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

“Woe to him who builds his palace by unrighteousness, his upper rooms by injustice, making his own people work for nothing, not paying them for their labour. He says, ‘I will build myself a great palace with spacious upper rooms.’ So he makes large windows in it , panels it with cedar and decorates it in red.

Page 67: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

“Does it make you a kingto have more and more cedar?Did not your father have food and drink? He did what was right and just, so all went well with him.He defended the cause of the poor and needy, and so all went well.Is that not what it means to know me?”declares the Lord.

Jeremiah 22:13-16

Page 68: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Here we have Jeremiah talking about the knowledge of God (da at elohim).

It isn’t a detached and rational affair at all.

It calls for a sensitivity to justice and mercy.

Page 69: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 70: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

“To these four young men God gave knowledge and understanding of all kinds of literature and learning. And Daniel could understand visions and dreams of all kinds. At the end of the time set by the king to bring them into his service, the chief official presented them to Nebuchadnezzar.

Page 71: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

The king talked with them, and he found none equal to Daniel, Hananiah, Mishael and Azariah; so they entered the king’s service. In every matter of wisdom and understanding about which the king questioned them, he found them ten times better than all the magicians and enchanters in his whole kingdom.”

Daniel 1:17-20

Page 72: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 73: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

“Praise be to the name of God for ever and ever; wisdom and power are his. He changes times and seasons; he deposes kings and raises up others. He gives wisdom to the wise and knowledge to the discerning.He reveals deep and hidden things;

Page 74: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

he knows what lies in darkness,and light dwells with him. I thank and praise you, God of my ancestors: You have given me wisdom and power, you have made known to me what we asked of you, you have made known to us the dream of the king.”

Daniel 2:19-23

Page 75: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

When we study the book of Daniel carefully we discover that Daniel was an expert in academic knowing, diplomatic knowing and the knowledge that comes from visions and dreams. We must honour all these kinds of knowing and not privilege one over another.

Page 76: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

It is all too easy to overvalue one kind of knowing and devalue other kinds of knowing.

Scripture doesn’t do this. It affirms the validity of many different kinds of knowledge if unfolded in ways that honour God and his purposes for creation.

Page 77: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Scholars, boffins, shepherds, craftspeople, artists, midwives, blacksmiths, cobblers etc all need knowledge and insight as they go about their many tasks… loving God, neighbour and planet earth.

Page 78: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

So what?

Consider the life of one of the greatest Englishmen ever to have lived.

Page 79: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Steven Gerard is the current captain of the England football team and he has a ‘scouse’ accent!

Page 80: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 81: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Indeed, one of the articles of heresy against William

Tyndale, the major English Reformer, who was

executed for heresy in 1536 was that he taught the

following -

Page 82: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

“There is no work better than another to please God; to pour water, to wash dishes, to be a souter (cobbler) or an apostle,

all is one; to wash dishes and to preach is all one, as touching

the deed, to please God.”

William Tyndale

Page 83: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Just as we must honour the vocation of the

Christian cobbler, we must also learn to value his/her

knowledge.

Page 84: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

REALITY BITES

http://www.realitybites.org.uk/

Page 85: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

© Reality Bites 2012

Orphic Myth

Page 86: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

The Orphic religion appeared in Greece in the sixth century B.C.

Page 87: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

“I am a child of earth and of the starry heaven but heaven is my home.”

(Orphic inscription found in Petelia, Italy)

Page 88: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 89: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

The Orphics were inspired by the following ‘creation myth’. Dionysius Zagreus was the son of Zeus and in a battle with the evil Titans, he was cornered and turned himself into a bull. The Titans pounced on him, tore him apart and devoured him.

Page 90: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 91: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 92: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

When Zeus realised that his son had been killed by the wicked Titans, he is said to have hurled a thunderbolt which burned up the Titans. Out of the ashes rose the human race. The Orphics concluded from this that human beings are composed of a divine spark (the divine bit from Dionysius) and a body (the evil bit from the Titans).

Page 93: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 94: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 95: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

“Thus man is a blend of divine and earthly nature, and the purification and release of the divine element is the end to which the Orphic way of life is directed. The soul, the Orphics believed, was an immortal god imprisoned in the body and doomed, unless released by following the Orphic way of life to go around the wheel of

Page 96: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

“reincarnation in an endless succession of lives, animal and human…..By ritual purifications, by an ascetic life and by knowledge of the correct magical formulae to use on the journey after death, the Orphics hoped to win release from the body and return it to the company of the gods.” p.6

Page 97: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 98: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 99: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Reincarnation (again in the body) is believed to be a curse in many religions, including Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism and Pythagoreanism. Bodily existence is something to be avoided. It stinks!

Page 100: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.
Page 101: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Group Work

If you believed this creation myth how

would you have lived?

Page 102: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

So how did the Pythagoreans live and worship?

Page 103: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Pythagorean prayer

Bless us, divine number, thou who generated gods and men! O holy, holy Tetractys, thou that containest the root and source of the eternally flowing creation! For the divine number begins with the profound, pure unity until it comes to the holy four; then it begets the mother of all, the all-comprising, all-bounding, the first-born, the never-swerving, the never-tiring holy ten, the keyholder of all"

Page 104: REALITY BITES . Christian Pedagogy? Christian Epistemology? Let’s work together! Workshops not lectures.

Worship the number 10 and hope for a good rebirth. Do not pick up what has fallen.Do not touch a white cock.Do not stir the fire with iron.Do not eat meat.Do not eat beans.