RCTs are the Basis of Good Clinical Practice - CON

26
RCTs ARE the basis of good practise? Peter Brindley MD, FRCP-Can, FRCP-Edin, FRCP-Lond (20 weeks per annum ICU doc) Also: Professor of Critical Care Medicine; Medical Ethics; Anesthesiology Division of Critical Care Medicine

Transcript of RCTs are the Basis of Good Clinical Practice - CON

RCTs ARE the basis of good practise?

Peter Brindley MD, FRCP-Can, FRCP-Edin, FRCP-Lond(20 weeks per annum ICU doc)

Also:Professor of Critical Care Medicine; Medical Ethics; Anesthesiology

Division ofCritical Care Medicine

“luddite”; ”science-denier”

Is Myberg god? Is RCT the “one truth?”

Time to put the trial on trial

RARELY CLARIFIES TRUTH

TOO LONGOFTEN

DOOMED

MEASUREMENT BIAS/VANITY SMALL DIFFs

POSITIVE-BIAS

FIRST VS LASTGENERALIZABLE?/RARELY REPEATED

END POINTS/IGNORE

REAL WORLD

EXCLUSIONS

Of Acute Care

Medicine

DATA

LOSE

20

B Dollars

in preventable medical errors

J Health Care Finance. 2012;39(1):39-50.

What’s most important in patient safety?

RCTs

Human FactorsHuman Factors

Human Factors

Hit the target; miss the point

L.S.D

Over/under ventilate

Over/under resuscitate

Hypo/hyper glycaemia

Give antibiotics

A,B,Cs

Skill: solo/team

Prognostication

P-value (p=patient)

Communication

EOL

Brainless Protocols

RCTs

MANY HUMBLE THANKS