RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact...

35
RARGOM Annual Science Meeting GoMA CML

Transcript of RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact...

Page 1: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

RARGOMAnnualScienceMeeting

GoMACML

Page 2: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

1

PROGRAM

RARGOMAnnualScienceMeeting

ScienceforsustainingtheGulfofMaine’s

ecosystemsandcoastalcommunities

Date:October13,2016Location:RedHookBrewery,1RedhookWay,Portsmouth,NewHampshire

Featuredkeynotespeaker:

AnthonyCharles

Director,SchooloftheEnvironment SaintMary’sUniversity,Halifax,NovaScotia

ContentsMeetingScheduleandOralPresentations..................................................................................................2

PosterSession:TitlesandPresenters..........................................................................................................3

Abstracts:Oralpresentations......................................................................................................................4

Abstracts:Posterpresentations................................................................................................................16

GettingtotheRARGOMAnnualScienceMeeting.....................................................................................32

Presentingauthoraffiliationsandcontactinformation............................................................................33

Page 3: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

2

MeetingScheduleandOralPresentationsStart Dur. Presenter Title

8:30AM 0:30 REGISTRATIONandpostersetup9:00AM 0:05 WELCOME9:05AM 0:15 Staudinger,M. It’sabouttime:AsynthesisofchangingphenologyintheGulfofMaineEcosystem

9:20AM 0:15Townsend,D.

WatermassfluxestotheGulfofMaine:Importancetowatertemperaturesandnutrientloads

9:35AM 0:15Valentine,P.C.

High-resolutionmapsofgeologicsubstratesonStellwagenBankprovideaframeworkfordescribinghabitatsinacomplex,glaciatedbankandbasinterrain

9:50AM 0:15Kaufman,L.

ThefunctionalroleofsandlancesintheSouthernGulfofMaineEcosystem:Silverthreadsweavingecosystem-basedmanagementtogether

10:05AM 0:15Wiley,D.

Thedistributionandrelativeabundanceofsandlance,seabirdsandwhalesinStellwagenBankNationalMarineSanctuary(2013–2016)

10:20AM 0:25 BREAK&POSTERS10:45AM 0:25 Charles,A. Keynote:Sustainingecosystems,sustainingcoastalcommunities

11:10AM 0:15Stoll,J.

HowaccesstoMaine’sfisherieshaschangedoveraquartercentury:thecumulativeeffectsoflicensingonresilience

11:25AM 0:15Strong,A.

UnderstandingtheGulfofMaine’scoastalecosystemserviceshedsandtheirimplicationsforstakeholdersincoastalenvironmentalmanagement

11:40AM 0:15Runnebaum,J.

Usingmodelingapproachandfishermen'sknowledgetodefinesuitablehabitatforcusk(Brosmebrosme)andevaluatepotentialeconomicimpactsofconservation

11:55AM 0:15Rodrigue,M.

Developingasentinellongline/jigsurveyforgroundfishspeciesintheeasternGulfofMaine

12:10PM 1:35 LUNCH&POSTERS1:45PM 0:05 JohnAnnalaFisheryLeadershipAwardannouncement

1:50PM 0:15Tanaka,K.R.

ImpactsofclimaticvariationsonthespatialdistributionofHomarusamericanusintheinshoreGulfofMaine

2:05PM 0:15McGuire,C.

IdentifyingthedistributionofAtlanticcodspawningactivitytoinformfisherymanagementinthewesternGulfofMaine

2:20PM 0:15Winton,M.

InvestigatingtheseasonalresidencyandhabitatuseofwhitesharksinthecoastalwatersoffCapeCod,Massachusetts,usingpassiveacoustictelemetry

2:35PM 0:15 Scopel,L. Howwelldofishery-derivedherringestimatespredictseabirddiets?

2:50PM 0:15Taylor,P.H.

Makewayformarshes:Aregionalmodelforknowledgesharingamongscientistsandmanagerstosupportsustainabilityofecosystemsandcoastalcommunities

3:05PM 0:15Belknap,S.

Lobsterandoceanplanning:AspatialcharacterizationofthelobsterfisheryfortheNewEnglandregionalplanningbody

3:20PM 0:15Zaykoski,P.

Findingefficiencythroughintegratedfisheriesmanagement&marineplanningdatacollection

3:35PM 0:25 BREAK&POSTERS

4:00PM 0:15Mills,K.

EvaluatingclimatevulnerabilityandadaptationstrategiesforNortheastUSfishingcommunities

4:15PM 0:15 Franklin,B. Evaluatingeconomicimpactsofclimate-drivenspecieschangesonNortheastUSfishingcommunities

4:30PM 0:15 Leslie,H. Sustainingcoupledsocial-ecologicalmarinesystemsoftheGulfofMaine:theroleofecosystemservicescienceandtools

4:45PM 0:15 Stephenson,R. ScienceforsustainingtheGulfofMaine’secosystemsandcoastalcommunities5:00PM 0:15 FacilitatedDiscussionledbyLeslieandStephenson5:15PM END-OntoHappyHour!

Page 4: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

3

PosterSession:TitlesandPresentersPresenter Title

Ackerman,S.AccessingseafloorandcoastalvideoandphotographsfromtheUSGSCoastalandMarineGeologyProgram

Arno,H. MonitoringChangesinSomesSoundInthePastTwoDecadesBalstad,B. You’regonnagetwet:IntertidalmonitoringatAppledoreIslandBelknap,S. StakeholderDrivenDiseaseModeling:TheCaseofLobsterShellDisease

Bogomoli,A.PopulationassessmentofHarbor(Phocavitulina)andGreyseals(Halichoerusgrypus)atDuckIslandledges,ME

Brayden,C.Assessingtheimpactofecolabelsonconsumerpreferencesforseafood:theroleofproductionmethod,certificationandoriginonwildharvestandaquacultureproducts

Caffrey,M. TheCitizenIntertidalEcologistProject

Calandrino,M.VariationinminimumGrayseal(Halichoerusgrypus)andHarborseal(Phocavitulina)minimumabundancecountsonDuckIsland,MEduetometeorologicalvariables

Carr,M.EntanglementofGrey(Halichoerusgrypus)andHarborseals(Phocavitulina)atDuckIslandledges,ME

Cole,K. Understandingexchangeatthebay-shelfinterface

ConlonL.HighresolutionmodelingofnearshoreflowpatternsandbluemusselpopulationconnectivityinDowneastMaine

Coupland,K.UnderstandingshellfishgrowthpotentialintheDamariscottaRiverusingacoupledmodelingapproach

Feeney,R.G.CatchShareManagementintheNortheastMultispeciesFishery:HavetheTheorizedBenefitsBeenRealizedinNewHampshire?

Gallo,B. Factorsaffectingspinydogfish(Squalusacanthias)atJeffrey’sLedgeintheGulfofMaineGassett,P. OceanandcoastalacidificationgovernanceinMaine:Conservationinnetworks

Goldstein,J.Afisheryinflux:Clawremovalanditsimpactsonsurvivorship,behavior,andphysiologicalstressinJonahcrab(Cancerborealis)

Mazur,M.EvaluatingfishingeffortlevelsintheMainelobsterfishery:anindividual-basedmodelapproach

Ozmon,I.ACollaborativeApproachtoCharacterizingSandandGravelDepositsUsingMultibeamSonarintheGulfofMaine

Parlee,K. ESIP’snewICUCsmartphoneapp-linkingcitizenscientiststotheirownplacesofwonderPowers,K. MovementsandForagingAreasofGreatShearwatersPuffinusgravisintheGulfofMaineRandall,S. Soft-ShellClamsinCrisisMode:FieldResearchTellsUsWhyandGivesUsToolstoAdaptRitchie,M. ImpactsofDataQuantityandQualityonHabitatModelingSchlipp,L. Size-at-agetrendsinNorthwestAtlanticgroundfishandimplicationsforstockassessment

Tsourounakis,G.Fine-scalehaul-outpreferencesofharborseals(Phocavitulina)andgrayseals(Halichoerusgrypus)atDuckIsland,ME

Valentine,P. High-resolutionmapsofgeologicsubstratesonStellwagenBank

Wang,L.Maximumentropymodelingofmarinefishspecies’spatiotemporaldistributionsutilizingearthsystemdata

Wells,P.DilutedBitumenSpillsintheBayofFundyandGreaterGulfofMaine:anupdateonthescientificandtechnologicalchallenges

Wells,P.SustainingtheGulfofMaine:TheImportanceofUnderstandingtheScience,Information,andPolicyInterfaceforEffectiveCoastalandOceanManagement

Wildermuth,R.Structuraluncertaintyanddatalimitedecosystem-basedmanagementoftheGeorgesBanksocial-ecologicalsystem

Yakola,K.Long-termchangesintheChickDiet,GrowthandFledglingSuccessofThreeStrenaspp.inResponsetoChangingClimaticConditionsintheGulfofMaine

Page 5: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Oralpresentations

4

Abstracts:OralpresentationsLobsterandOceanPlanning:ASpatialCharacterizationoftheLobsterFisheryfortheNewEnglandRegionalPlanningBodyBelknap,S.,Battista,N.,Clark-Uchenna,R.,Lapointe,G.Presentedby:Belknap,S.([email protected])ThelobsterfisheryissynonymouswithNewEngland’scoast,providingfood,economicandculturalvaluesincethecolonialera.NowhereisthismoreevidentthaninMaine.Formanycoastalcommunities,thelobsterfisheryhasprovidedstabilityandasenseofplacethatismoreimportanttodaythaninthepast.Increasedlandingsinthefishery,combinedwithreducedfishingopportunitiesinotherfisheries,createasignificanteconomicdependenceonthelobsterfishery.Theareacoveredbythefisheryhaschangedoverthepast20-30yearswithfisherylandingsshiftingfartheroffshoreandfarthertotheeasternportionoftherangeofU.S.lobsterfishing.Informationonthespatialcharacteristicsofthelobsterfisheryaregenerallyunderstoodbytheindustryandmanagers,butarepoorlyquantified.Mappingoflobsterfishingpatternshasbeenanobjectiveofregionaloceanplanningefforts.Thisefforthasbeenhamperedbylackofregionalspatialcharacterizationproductswithsufficientresolutionorconsistencytodeterminehowotheroceanuses,particularlyplace-baseduses,wouldimpactlobsterfishinglocally,sub-regionally,andregionally.WeinterviewedMainelobstermentobetterunderstandspatialusepatternsinthelobsterfishery,andhowlobstermenviewnewandshiftingusesoftheoceaninthecontextoftheirlobsterfishingbusinesses.Lobstermenwereselectedinalllobstermanagementzones,withanemphasisonlobstermenwhofishfederalwatersbecausethedevelopingNewEnglandRegionalOceanPlanfocusesonfederalwaters.Sustainingecosystems,sustainingcoastalcommunitiesCharles,A.([email protected])Thereisnodoubtthathumanwellbeingdependsonlivingwithinahealthyandproductiveenvironment—thisistheessenceof‘sustainabledevelopment’.Whilecertainlysustainingmarineandcoastalecosystemsisaprerequisiteforsustainablecommunitiesalongthecoast,whatislessoftenrealizedisthatbenefitsalsoflowinthereversedirection.Theevidenceshowsthatstrongandsustainablecoastalcommunitiesaremorelikelytohavewithinthemtheinterestandcapabilitytomaintaintheirlocalecosystems.Indeed,asshownbyElinorOstromandmanyothers,abundantexamplesofcommunityinitiativesshowhowenvironmentalconservationandlivelihoodsecuritycanbesustainedtogether.Itisatwo-waystreet.Thispresentationexploresthenatureanddynamicsofcoastalcommunities,theirdriversofenvironmentalstewardship,andthemannerbywhichlocalmarineandcoastaldecision-makingsustainsecosystemsandsustainscommunities.ThisdrawsonworkintheCommunityConservationResearchNetwork(CCRN),aglobalpartnershipofindigenous,community,academic,governmentalandnon-governmentalorganizations.

Page 6: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Oralpresentations

5

EvaluatingEconomicImpactsofClimate-DrivenSpeciesChangesonNortheastUSFishingCommunitiesSun,J.,Franklin,B.,Kennedy,B.,Mills,K.,Allyn,A.,Schuetz,J.Presentedby:Franklin,B.([email protected])UnderstandingtheeconomicconsequencesofwarmingoceansandchangingecosystemsontheNortheastshelfiscriticaltoimplementingeffectiveadaptationstrategies.Astheconversationsurroundingclimateandfisheriesevolvestoincludetheimpactsonfisheriesandfishery-dependentcommunities,economicmodelsprovideameansofquantifyingtheimpactsofclimate-relatedchangesandbridgingthegapbetweenthesciencecommunityandfisherystakeholders.Inthispaper,welinkspeciesdistributionandvulnerabilityforecastswithaneconomicmodelthatincorporatesfleetcharacteristicsandmarketconditionstocapturethesupplyanddemandofcommerciallandingsandlandingsvaluesbyvariouscommunities.WewillfocusonbothMaine’slobsterfisheryandtheNewEnglandgroundfishfisheryandexplainhowtheeconomicmodellingwillprovideintegratedestimatesofchangesinfishingeffort,profits,andaggregateeconomicimpactunderdifferentwarmingscenarios.Ultimately,ourresultswillfacilitatediscussionanddecision-makingamongstcommunities,managers,andindustryastheyevaluatethecostsandbenefitsofmanagement,investment,andfishingstrategiesunderclimatevariabilityandchange.TheFunctionalRoleofSandLancesintheSouthernGulfofMaineEcosystem:Silverthreadsweavingecosystem-basedmanagementtogetherKaufman,L.,Altman,A.,Boumans,R.,Wiley,D.,andThompson,M.Presentedby:Kaufman,L.([email protected])TheNortheastRegionalOceanPlancallsforanecosystem-basedapproachformaximizingusecompatibilitiesandsynergies,andtominimizenegativetradeoffs.Secondandthird-orderconsumers(foragespecies)lieatthenexusoftradeoffsamongtheecosystemservicesthatprovidebiodiversitymaintenance,food,livelihoods,recreation,andbeachrenourishmentinrisingseas.Wereportearlyresultsofastudyfocusedonammodytidfishes(sandlances)inthesouthernGulfofMaine,includingtheirdistributionandabundance,functionaldifferentiation(thereare2localspecies),nutritionalvalue,lifehistory,andsystemicrelationshipswithpredatoryfishes,marinemammals,seabirds,people,andtheregionaleconomy.Theresultsindicateahighnutritivevalue,strongpredator-preylinkages,shortrealizedlifespan,andacomplexrelationshipwithecosystemserviceflowsandtradeoffs.Whatwehavelearnedofthesesmallsilverfishes,aboutwhichstillastonishinglylittleisknown,underscoresacriticalneedforlevelsofpreventativeguidance,monitoringvigilance,andadaptivepoliciesthatareabsentfromthefirstNortheastRegionalOceanPlan,andmustbeincludedinthesecond.

Page 7: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Oralpresentations

6

Sustainingcoupledsocial-ecologicalmarinesystemsoftheGulfofMaine:theroleofecosystemservicescienceandtoolsLeslie,H.M.([email protected])Sustainingecosystemservicesandthecoupledsocialandecologicalsystemsthatsupportandgeneratethemisacentralgoalofmarinespatialplanningandmarineecosystem-basedmanagement,bothintheUSandglobally.However,operationalizingthisgoalinwaysthatareSpecific,Measurable,Attainable,RelevantandTimelyremainsachallengeinmanycontexts.MypresentationwilladdressthischallengebyfocusingontheemergingopportunitiestofurtherdevelopandapplyecosystemservicesscienceandtoolsintheimplementationoftheNortheastOceanPlan,andintheGulfofMaineregionmorespecifically.TheNortheastOceanPlan,thenation’smostfullydevelopedregionaloceanplan,isclosetobeingfinalized,followingfouryearsofclosecollaborationamongstate,federal,andtribalpartners.ScientistsfromtheBayofFundytoLongIslandSound,togetherwithresearchersworkinginothermarinesettings,haveplayedasignificantroleinsupportingplandevelopment;theirparticipationinitsimplementationwillbeequallyifnotmoreimportant.Iwilldrawonmynearly20yearsofexperienceinthescienceandpracticeofcoastalconservationintheNortheasternUS,aswellasmysubstantialengagementinMexico’sGulfofCaliforniaregion,whereIleadaninterdisciplinaryresearchprogramfocusedonsustainingthecoupledsocialandecologicalsystemsassociatedwiththeregion’ssmall-scalefisheries.Iwillmakethecasethatbyleveragingapproachesfromboththenaturalandsocialsciences–particularlyanalysesframedbytheconceptsofecosystemservicesandsocial-ecologicalsystems–andcommittingtomeaningfulandlong-termengagementwithcoastalcommunitymembersandotherkeystakeholders,theNortheastOceanPlanhasthepotentialtomakeecosystem-basedmanagementfortheoceansrealinwaysthatmatterforthevariedcoastalcommunitiesofAmerica’soceans.IdentifyingthedistributionofAtlanticcodspawningactivitytoinformfisherymanagementinthewesternGulfofMaineMcGuire,C.,Zemeckis,D.,Dean,M.J.,Hoffman,W.S.,Izzi,A.,VanParijs,S.,Baumgartner,M.,Hatch,L.,andCadrin,S.X.Presentedby:McGuire,C.([email protected])RebuildingtheGulfofMainestockofAtlanticcod(Gadusmorhua)hasbeenmuchslowerthananticipated.Manyhistoricalspawningcomponentshavebeendepleted,whichhasreducedstockproductivityandstability.Inresponse,fisherymanagershaveimplementedclosurestoprotectcodspawningaggregations.Thespatialandtemporalextentoftheseclosureshaschangedduetoscientificuncertaintyandtoallowfishingforotherspecies.TheobjectiveofthisprojectwastoidentifythespatialandtemporaldistributionofcodspawningactivityduringthewintertoinformfuturefisherymanagementdecisionsforMassachusettsBayinthewesternGulfofMaine.Multipleacoustictechnologieswereused,includingacoustictelemetryandpassiveacousticmonitoringequipment,withthelatterinvolvingtherecordingofgruntsproducedbymalesduringcourtshiprituals.Bothtechnologiesweredeployedduringthreeconsecutivewinterspawningseasons(October2013throughMarch2016)ateitherfixedlocationsoronmobileSlocumgliders.Baseduponpreliminaryacoustictelemetryresults(n=317cod),peakspawningoccurredfromNovember–January.Spawningsitefidelity

Page 8: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Oralpresentations

7

wasdocumented,andmultiple‘hotspots’wereidentifiedwheretaggedcodwereannuallyaggregating,includingsomeevidenceforinter-annualvariabilityintiming.Preliminarypassiveacousticsresultsfromfixedlocationrecordersshowatemporaltrendofcodgrunts(aproxyforspawning)occurringfrommid-SeptemberthroughthebeginningofJanuaryinallthreeyears,withthemostgruntsoccurringduringYear3.ThemajorityofgruntsrecordedbygliderswerewithintheStellwagenBankNationalMarineSanctuary,oftenbeyondthedetectionrangeoffixedlocationequipment.Therefore,combinationofmultiplecomplimentarytechnologiesanddeploymentstrategiesincreasedourcapacitytomonitorcodspawningactivityovermultiplespatialandtemporalscales.Continuedanalyseswillintegrateresultsfromeachmethodandprovideamoreholisticdescriptionofcodspawningactivitytoinformfuturefisherymanagementdecisions.EvaluatingclimatevulnerabilityandadaptationstrategiesforNortheastUSfishingcommunitiesMills,K.,Allyn,A.,Colburn,L.,Hare,J.,Schuetz,J.,Alexander,M.,Eayrs,S.,Franklin,B.,Hartley,T.,Kennedy,B.,Labaree,J.,Pershing,A.,Sun,J.,Thunberg,E.Presentedby:Mills,K.([email protected])Throughouttheworld,climatechangeisaffectingmarineecosystems,fishpopulations,andfisheries.MarinewatersoftheNortheastShelfhavewarmedrapidlyoverthepastdecade,andtheimpactsofclimatevariabilityandchangearebeingfeltacutelyinthisregion.Theconversationaroundclimateandfisheriesismovingfromadiscussionofclimateimpactsonfishpopulationstoadiscussionofimpactsonfisheriesandfishingcommunities.Anticipatingclimate-relatedchangesinspeciesavailabilityanddevisingeffectiveadaptationstrategiestobuffernegativeimpactswillbeessentialforsustainingfishingcommunitiesinthecontextofclimatechange.ForfishingcommunitiesalongtheNortheastShelf,weareimplementingacoupledsocial-ecologicalvulnerabilityassessmentthatintegratesinformationonvulnerability,resilience,andadaptivecapacity.Preliminaryresultsofashelf-wideassessmenthavebeenderivedbyusingspeciesvulnerabilityratings,speciesdistributionprojections,fisherylandingsdata,fishinglocationrecords,andsocialresilienceindicatorstoratesocial-ecologicalvulnerabilityonacommunitybasis.Resultsenableahigh-levelviewofthevulnerabilityoffishingcommunitiesinthecontextofclimate-drivenecosystemchangesandsupportashelf-wideevaluationofrisklevelsandtypes.Ongoingandfutureworkwilluseeconomicmodels,stakeholderfocusgroups,andfishingindustrysurveysto(1)quantifyeconomiceffectsofclimateimpactsinspecificcommunities,(2)evaluatethebufferingpotentialofferedbydifferentadaptationstrategies,and(3)assessfactorsfacilitatingorhinderingtheimplementationofadaptationmeasures.

Page 9: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Oralpresentations

8

DevelopingaSentinelLongline/JigSurveyforGroundfishSpeciesintheEasternGulfofMaineRodrigue,M.,Chen,Y.Presentedby:Rodrigue,M.([email protected])TheeasternGulfofMaine,whilenotclosedtogroundfishing,hasbeenperceivedtohavealowgroundfishpopulationandissubjecttolittletargetedgroundfishactivity.Stateandfederalfisheries-independentsurveyprogramshavelimitedsamplingcoveragebecauseoffixedgearconflicts.Currently,groundfishstockassessmentandmanagementencompasstheentireGulfofMaine,althoughthemajorityoffishingeffortandcatchoccursinthewesternGulfofMaine.Sparsefishery-independentaswellasfishery-dependentdataintheeasternGulfofMaine,andskeweddistributionofthegroundfishfisheriesintothewesternGulfofMainemaycomplicatethedeterminationofthestatusofgroundfishstocksintheGulfofMaine.Workingwithlocalfishermen,wedevelopedastratifiedrandomsentinellongline/jigsurveytargetingkeygroundfishspeciesthathavelowcatchabilityinthebottomtrawlsurvey.WeestimatetheabundanceindicesforAtlanticcod(Gadusmorhua),cusk(Brosmebrosme),Atlantichalibut(Hippoglossushippoglossus),andwhitehake(Urophycistenius)intheeasternGulfofMaine.Thisstudyshowslargespatialinconsistencyoftemporalvariabilityinfishpopulations,raisingimportanceoffine-scalegroundfishpopulationsinmanagement.Usingmodelingapproachandfishermen'sknowledgetodefinesuitablehabitatforcusk(Brosmebrosme)andevaluatepotentialeconomicimpactsofconservationRunnebaum,J.,Guan,L.,Cao,J.,O’Brien,L.,Chen,Y.,Tanaka,K.Presentedby:Runnebaum,J.([email protected])Cusk(Brosmebrosme)isagadoidgroundfishcurrentlyunderstatusreviewfortheEndangeredSpeciesAct(ESA)intheUSA.Cuskareterritorialandthoughttohavecomplexstockstructureoflocalpopulations.IncreaseddistancebetweenlocalizedpopulationsandlossofhabitatledtotheESAstatusreview.ThisstudyaddressesknowledgegapsintheunderstandingofdistributionofsuitablehabitatforcuskintheGulfofMaineusingahabitatsuitabilityindexmodel.Habitatqualityisquantifiedbydensityofcuskcaughtatdifferentdepths,sedimenttypes,andseasons.Theimportantqualitiesofthephysicalenvironmentwherecuskaremostabundantareelucidatedthroughdistributionmaps.Thesemapsareproducedfromimperfectknowledge,butfishermen'slocalecologicalknowledgecanfillthesedatagaps.Fishermen'sknowledgeregardingimportantenvironmentalvariablesforcuskisusedtofine-tunehabitatmodeldevelopment.Fishermen’sknowledgeforareaswherecuskarelikelytobecaughtcanalsovalidatehabitatsuitabilitymapsproducedinmodeling.Combininghabitatsuitabilitymodelingwithfishermen'sknowledgewillprovideabetterunderstandingofcuskdistributionintheGulfofMaineaswellaspotentialcriticalhabitatareasforcusk.ThisresearchprovidesinformationcriticalforunderstandingareaswherecuskmaybebycaughtintheMainelobsterfisheryandpotentialeconomiccostsofconservationmeasuresforavoidingcuskbycatch.Basedonthefinalhabitatmapsforcusk,theeconomicimpactofpotentialareaclosuresforcusk,ifitwereclassifiedasendangeredspecies,willbeevaluatedbasedonlobsterseasonalfishingeffort.

Page 10: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Oralpresentations

9

Howwelldofishery-derivedherringestimatespredictseabirddiets?Scopel,L.,Diamond,A.,Kress,S.,Shannon,P.Presentedby:Scopel,L.([email protected])Seabirdsareconsideredgoodbioindicatorsowingtotheirdependenceuponmarineprey,especiallyjuvenilefish.AsoceanographicconditionschangeintheGulfofMaine,adesiretomovetowardecosystem-basedfisheriesmanagementcouldseetheincorporationofseabirddatatobetterinformstockassessment.However,therelationshipbetweenseabird-derivedandfishery-derivedestimatesoffishabundanceispoorlyunderstood,makingthevalueofseabirddatainfisheriesmanagementdifficulttojudge.WeexaminedforagingdatafromthreeseabirdcoloniesintheGulfofMainefrom1995-2013,inordertoexaminetheirconcordancewithfishery-derivedandfishery-independentestimatesofAtlanticherring.Wecorrelatedtheincidenceofherringinthedietofthreeseabirdspecies(ArcticTern,AtlanticPuffin,andRazorbill)toestimatesofspawningstockbiomassfromacousticsurveys,estimatesofthenumberofjuvenilesfromtheDepartmentofFisheriesandOceans’virtualpopulationanalysis,andcombinedlandingsreportedintheGulfofMaineandBayofFundy.Lagsof+2to-2yearswerealsoimposedontheseabirddatatoassesswhetherstockassessmentdatacanpredictseabirddiets,andviceversa.Acrossspecies,acousticestimatesofspawningstockbiomassfromoneortwoyearspreviouscorrelatedmoststronglywithherringincidenceinseabirddiets(R2=0.51-0.92);thestrengthofthecorrelationvariedbycolony.Correlationsbetweenotherpairsoffisheryandseabirddatawerelessconsistent.Wewillexpandtheinvestigationofseabirdsasecosystembioindicatorsinfutureanalyses.It’sabouttime:AsynthesisofchangingphenologyintheGulfofMaineEcosystemStaudinger,M.,Mills,K.,Rebuck,N.,Hudak,C.,Jordaan,A.,Stamieszkin,K.,Pendleton,D.,Friedland,K.,Ji,R.,Allyn,A.,Calandrino,G.,Diamond,A.,Feng,Z.,Feurt,C.,Golet,W.,Henderson,M.,Hernandez,C.,Huntington,T.,Johnson,C.,Johnson,D.,Li,Y.,Liebman,M.,Mlsna,I.,Nichols,O.,Record,N.,Robben,T.,Seavey,J.,Sun,J.,Thomas,A.,Walsh,H.,Yakola,K.Presentedby:Staudinger,M.([email protected])The2015AnnualRARGOMmeetingconvenedaninterdisciplinarygroupofregionalscientistsfromgovernmental,academicandotherorganizationstoaddressthetheme,“HowisthetimingofallthingschangingintheGulfofMaine?”.Subsequently,anexpertworkinggroupformedtosynthesizethecurrentunderstandingofchangesintimingofrecurringseasonalenvironmentalandecologicalevents,aswellastheimplicationsofthoseshiftsonregionalmanagement,conservation,andclimatechangeadaptationstrategies.Thispresentationwilldescribetheprocess,goals,andchallengesofongoingworkinggroupactivities.Resultswillhighlightwherewehavesufficientevidenceandobservationstodetectregionalphenologicalshiftsandwheregapsremain.Twointegrativecasestudieswillexplorethedrivers,ecosystemresponses,andhumanimplicationssurrounding1)akeyzooplanktonspecies,Calanusfinmarchicus,and2)highlymigratorydiadromousfishes.Whileclimatechangeisalikelyfactorinfluencingobservedorinferredshiftsinphenology,wewillalsodiscussotherdirectandindirectmechanismsthatarepotentiallyconfoundingourdetectionofregionalsignals.Althoughphenologyhasbeenwellexploredinterrestrialsystems,particularlyforfloweringplants,insectsandsongbirds,

Page 11: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Oralpresentations

10

documentationofphenologicalchangesinmarinesystemslagsfarbehind.Thisispartiallyduetolimitationsinexistingmonitoringprogramsinthemarinerealm.Weconcludewithasetofrecommendationsthataddressbiasandgapsinsurveycoverageandidentifywhereeffortisneededtoimprovespatialandtemporalresolutionforspecificvariablesandspeciesofhighconservationandmanagementconcern.WeanticipatethiscomprehensiveexaminationofshiftingphenologywillbeusefultoinformclimatechangeadaptationstrategiesseekingtoreduceuncertaintyandsustainimportantnaturalresourcesintheGulfofMaineregion.ScienceforsustainingtheGulfofMaine’secosystemsandcoastalcommunitiesStephenson,R.([email protected])Evolving,moreholistic,ecosystem-basedandintegratedmanagementapproachesdemandconsiderationofecological,economic,socialandinstitutionaloutcomes.ThisposesaconsiderablechallengeforscienceintheGulfofMaine.Thereisincreasingneedforinterdisciplinary,ortrans-disciplinary,methodsappliedincollaborativeprocessesintheperspectiveofasocial-ecologicalsystem.Thispresentationwillexploreprogresshasbeenmadesincetheneedsidentifiedinthe2009GOMSymposium,includingrecentresearchintheCanadianFisheriesResearchNetwork.HowaccesstoMaine’sfisherieshaschangedoveraquartercentury:thecumulativeeffectsoflicensingonresilienceStoll,J.,Beitl,C.,Wilson,J.Presentedby:Stoll,J.([email protected])WedescribehowtheevolutionofthelicensingsystemforcommercialfisheriesinMainehasprogressivelylimitedtheabilityofbothfishersandtheStatetorespondtochangingenvironmentalcircumstances.Overthetwenty-fiveyearperiodfrom1990to2014newlicenseswerecreatedattherateofabout0.6peryear.Thechangesthathaveoccurredhavenotbeentheresultofastrategicpolicyagendathatwassettodecreasefishers’access,butrathertheconsequenceofmultipledecadesofpolicyinterventionsthathavesoughttoimprovethesocioeconomicandecologicalproductivityofindividualfisheries.However,thecumulativeeffecthaslimitedtheflexibilityofindividualfishersandcreatedstrongeconomicintereststhatareincompatiblewithshiftstowardsecosystem-basedmanagement.Weusethisfindingtocontributetotheliteratureonresilience,withaspecificfocusontherelationshipbetweenadaptivemanagementandsustainability.

Page 12: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Oralpresentations

11

UnderstandingtheGulfofMaine’scoastalecosystemserviceshedsandtheirimplicationsforstakeholdersincoastalenvironmentalmanagementStrong,A.([email protected])Thereisincreasingscientificandgovernmentinterestintheincorporationofthenon-marketvaluesprovidedbyecosystemstohumancommunitieswithinenvironmentalmanagement.In2015,theWhiteHouseissuedamemodirectingfederalagenciestodevelopguidelinesfortheincorporationofecosystemservices,includingthosegeneratedfrombothnaturalandworkinglandsandfromcoastalandmarineecosystems,intoallfederalagencydecision-makingprocesses.Thegoalofthisincreasedattentionisostensiblytoensurethatallofthequantifiedandnon-quantifiablevaluesthatfunctioningecosystemsprovidetohumancommunitiesareknownandconsideredwhenassessingcostsandbenefits,trade-offsandmanagementpriorities.Ecosystemservicesare,bydefinition,generatedfromwithinspatiallydefinedecosystemsthataregeographicallylocatableandbounded.Yetthevaluesprovidedbyecosystemsarealsomultiple;agivenecosystemcansimultaneouslygenerateprovisioning,regulating,sustaining,andculturalecosystemservices,andtheseservicesprovidevaluestocommunitiesatscalesrangingfromafewmeters(e.g.acoastalwetland’swaterpollutionmitigationbenefits)totheentireplanet(e.g.carbonsequestration’sclimatechangemitigationbenefits).TheGulfofMaine’stidalsaltmarshecosystemspresentexcellentcasesforexaminingthescalesanddistributionsofstakeholdersinecosystemservicesbecauseofthewiderangeofecosystemservicestheygenerate.Inparticular,forthecomplexcoastalsocial-ecologicalsystemsoftheGulfofMaineinwhichtheseecosystemsareembedded,understandingwhohasastakeinwhichecosystemservicesisakeyquestionfacingthefutureofenvironmentalandoceanmanagementintheregion.UsingaseriesofcasestudiesofSpartina-dominatedtidalsaltmarshecosystemsalongthecoastoftheGulfofMaine,Iarguethattheeffectivemanagementofcoastalecosystemservices,asenvisionedbyfederalagencies,requiresgovernanceapproachesthatcaneffectivelyengagewithstakeholdersacrossmultiplegeographicscalesofservicesheds.ImpactsofclimaticvariationsonthespatialdistributionofHomarusamericanusintheinshoreGulfofMaineTanaka,K.R.,Chang,J-H.,Chen,Y.Presentedby:Tanaka,K.R.([email protected])TheAmericanlobster(Homarusamericanus)supportsoneofthemostvaluablefisheriesintheUnitedStates.WhilebothabundanceanddistributionofH.americanusarehypothesizedtobeinfluencedbysomeclimate-drivenenvironmentalfactors,studiesthatquantifythespeciesresponsetoalteredclimatologicalconditionsassociatedwithclimatechangearelimited.Inthisstudy,wedevelopedaseasonalandsex-andsize-specificTweedie-generalizedadditivemodel(GAM)toquantifythespatialandtemporaldistributionofH.americanusintheGulfofMaine(GOM)overthelast32years(1982-2013).TheabundanceanddistributionofH.americanusaremodeledasafunctionofkeyabioticvariablesincludingbottomtemperature,bottomsalinity,depth,latitude,longitude,distanceoffshore,andbottomsubstrate.Impactsofclimaticvariationswereevaluatedbyforecastingdistributionsunderdifferenttemperaturescenarios,whichrevealedhigherrelativelobsterabundanceunderthewarmtemperaturescenario.Themodel-basedgravitycentersofH.americanusdistributionshowedsignificant

Page 13: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Oralpresentations

12

northeastwardshiftduringspring.Thisstudyprovidesahind/now/forecastingcoupledbio-physicalmodelingframeworktoevaluatespatialandtemporalvariabilityinabundanceanddistributionofH.americanus,whichcouldbeusedtoimproveourunderstandingofGOMlobsterspatialdynamicsgiventheexpectedchangesinclimate-drivenenvironmentinthenortheasternU.S.marineecosystem.MakeWayforMarshes:ARegionalModelforKnowledgeSharingAmongScientistsandManagerstoSupportSustainabilityofEcosystemsandCoastalCommunitiesTaylor,P.H.([email protected])SharingofknowledgeamongscientificandmanagementcommunitiesisacriticalcomponentofanyefforttosupportsustainabilityoftheGulfofMaine’secosystemsandcoastalcommunities.AninitiativesponsoredbytheNortheastRegionalOceanCouncil(NROC)in2014-15providesamodelforknowledgesharingonaprioritymanagementissuewhenscientificunderstandingoftheissueisnewlyemergingandrapidlyevolving.NROC’smembersandpartnerorganizationshadidentifiedtidalmarshmigrationinresponsetosealevelriseasanimportantissuebecauseofthemarshes’ecologicalsignificance,thediverseecosystemservicestheyprovidetopeople,andthemarshes’vulnerabilitytoclimatechange.ScientificresearchonthetopicisadvancingdramaticallyandmanagersareseekingtorespondonscalesrangingfromindividualmarshesandtownstostatesandtheentireNortheastregion.However,practitionerssawanimmediateneedforawell-targeted,timelyefforttolinkscienceandmanagementtosupporteffectivemanagementoutcomes.Inparticular,governmentagenciesandnon-governmentorganizationsareharnessingcomputer-basedmodelsofmarshecosystemstoinformmanagementandpolicystrategiestosustaintidalmarshes.WeworkedincollaborationwithNROC’sOceanandCoastalEcosystemHealthCommitteeandaprojectsteeringcommitteetofacilitateknowledgesharingonthisissue.Weconductedinterviewswith45scientificandmanagementexpertsatgovernment,academic,andnon-governmententities;conductedascientificandtechnicalliteraturesearch;andparticipatedinaregionalworkshop.ThetangibleresultofthisprocessisthepublicationMakeWayforMarshes:GuidanceonUsingModelsofTidalMarshMigrationtoSupportCommunityResiliencetoSeaLevelRise(northeastoceancouncil.org/marshmigration).Thisvisuallyengagingandreader-friendlyguidecoverstheentiremodelinglifecyclefromdevelopingamodelingapproachandworkingwithdatatocommunicatingmodelingresults.Thelesstangibleresultsareastrengthenedcommunityofpracticeandareplicableknowledge-sharingprocess.WaterMassFluxestotheGulfofMaine:ImportancetoWaterTemperaturesandNutrientLoadsTownsend,D.W.,Pettigrew,N.R.,Switzer,M.,Thomas,M.A.,Neary,M.G.Presentedby:Townsend,D.([email protected])TheoffshorewatersofGulfofMaineexhibitvariablewaterpropertiesbetweenandamongyears,andappeartobeevolvingovertimeinresponsetoclimatechangeandfar-fieldprocessesassociatedwithArcticmeltwaters.NutrientsandsaltaresuppliedtocontinentalshelfwatersoftheGulfofMaine-

Page 14: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Oralpresentations

13

GeorgesBankregionbyinflowsofdeepoffshorewatermasses;onceintheGulftheyaretransportedwiththeresidualcirculationandmixwithsurfacewaters,bothintheGulfandontheBank.Becausewaterpropertiesofthoseinflowingwatermassesvary,variabilityinthemagnitudeofinfluxescanbeimportanttowatertemperatures(andsalinities)ofinteriorGulfwaters.Recentyears,since2001,havewitnessedperiodsofwarm,saltyandhigh-nutrientwatermassesinthedeepinteriorGulf(ofWarmSlopeWaterorigin),alternatingwithcold,relativelyfreshandlownutrientwatermasses(ofScotianShelfOrigin).Theseepisodicperiodslastmonthstoyears,and,aswewillshow,areimportantinalterednutrientregimesaswellasinrecentlyobservedwarming(andcooling)trendsinsurfacewaters.AnalysesarebasedonmooredsensorsmaintainedbytheUniversityofMaineOceanObservingSystem(UMOOS),whichisacomponentofNERACOOS(NortheastRegionalAssociationofCoastalOceanObservingSystems),whichhasrecentlybeensupplementedwithinsitunitratesensors,andeightrecentoceanographicsurveycruisestotheGulfofMaineandGeorgesBankaspartofNOAA’sECOHABProgram.Resultsshowvariabilityinboththemagnitudeandnature(relativeproportionsofsilicateandnitrate)ofnutrientfluxestotheinteriorGulfofMainefromoffshore,whichinturnarethemainnutrientsourcestoGeorgesBank,broughtontotheBankbytidalpumpingontheNorthernFlank.Theimportanceofthesewatermassfluxestothewell-known2012“oceanheatwave”arediscussed.Inaddition,weshowevidenceof,anddiscussthesignificanceof,penetrationofGulfStreamwatersintotheinteriorGulfofMaine.High-resolutionmapsofgeologicsubstratesonStellwagenBankprovideaframeworkfordescribinghabitatsinacomplex,glaciatedbankandbasinterrainValentine,P.C.,Wiley,D.N.Presentedby:Valentine,P.C.([email protected])TheStellwagenBankregionisabankandbasinterraincoveredbyglacialsedimentsthathavebeenmodifiedbyprocessesassociatedwithpost-glacialsea-levelrise,tidalcurrents,andbywavesandcurrentsgeneratedbyepisodicstormsfromthenortheast.Newhigh-resolutionmaps(1:25,000)compiledfrommultibeamsonarbathymetricandbackscatterimagery,videoimagery,andsedimentgrain-sizeanalyses(943)showthedistributionof27seabedsubstratesacrossthesouth-centralpartofthebank(~420km2)inwaterdepthsrangingfrom25monthebankcrestto>100minbasinstotheeastandwest.Geologicsubstratesarecharacterizedbysedimenttype(mud,sand,gravel),bysurficialfeatures(ripples,burrows),sedimentlayering(finersedimentpartlycoveringcoarsersediment),sedimentmovement(ripples),andwaterdepth.Inthemappedarea,substratetypesincluderippledcoarse-grainedsand,muddyfine-grainedsand,sandspartiallyveneeringgravel,boulderridges,andmud.Additionalmapssummarizethesubstratesonthebasisoftheirmobilityorimmobility,thedominanceoffine-orcoarse-grainedsand,andtheirmudcontent.Ahabitatisaplacedefinedfirstbyitsphysicalattributes(herethesubstrate)andthenbythespeciesassociatedwithit.Speciesfoundonmorethanonesubstrateutilizemorethanonehabitat.Researcherscanusethesemapstoassociatespecieswithsubstratetypes,toinvestigatehowspeciesusethephysicalenvironment,andtopredicttheoccurrenceofspeciesinareaswithsimilarcharacteristics.Forexample,inanongoingstudy,weobservedthatsandlance(Ammodytesdubius),animportantpreyspecies,predictablyseeksrefugebyburyingitselfinasinglesubstratetypewhennotfeedinginthewatercolumn.Inthemappedarea,the

Page 15: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Oralpresentations

14

preferredsubstrateofsandlanceisarippledcoarse-grainedsandthatextendsfromthebankcrestto~50monitseasternandwesternflanks,anareaof~151km2.Thedistributionandrelativeabundanceofsandlance,seabirdsandwhalesinStellwagenBankNationalMarineSanctuary(2013–2016)Wiley,D.,Valentine,P.,Cabe,B.,Robbins,J.,Kaufman,L.Presentedby:Wiley,D.([email protected])ForagefishesareessentialtosustainingtheGulfofMaine’secosystemandcoastalcommunities.Thenorthernsandlance(Ammodytesdubius)isanimportantforagespeciesthathasreceivedrelativelylittleattentionfromscientistsandmanagers.Since2013weconductedspringandfallsurveystomonitorsandlanceat44sitesinStellwagenBankNMSusingtheUSGSSEABedObservationandSamplingSystem(SEABOSS)equippedwitha0.1m2grabsamplerandvideocameras.AteachsiteonStellwagenBank,thenumberofsandlancecontainedinthegrabsampleandobservedduringa5-minutevideodriftwerecountedtoestimatetheirrelativeabundanceandspatialdistribution.Thesedatawereusedwithconcurrentobservationsofforagingactivitiesandsurfacecountsofmarinemammalsandseabirdstoinvestigatetherelationshipofthesetaxatosandlance.Further,weuseddatafromsatellite-trackedgreatshearwaters(Ardennagravis;n=10/year;2013-2016)andcomparedthehabitatuseofgreatshearwaterswiththatofsandlance.Independentdataonthenumberanddistributionofhumpbackwhalesinthesanctuary(2013–2015)alsocloselyfollowedsimilarpatternsobservedforsandlance.Observationstodateindicatethattheabundanceandspatialdistributionofwhalesandseabirdscloselyfollowthoseofsandlance,withalmostallactivityoccurringonthesouthernpartofthebank.Commercialfisheriesexistformanyspeciesofforagefish,andsandlanceconstituteoneofthelargestfisheriesintheNorthSea.WhilenocurrentsandlancefisheryexistsintheGulfofMaine,ourobservationssuggestthattheyareimportanttothesustainabilityofbothseabirdsandmarinemammals,andmanagersshouldbeawareofpotentialeffectsontheecosystemshouldafisherybeconsidered.InvestigatingtheseasonalresidencyandhabitatuseofwhitesharksinthecoastalwatersoffCapeCod,Massachusetts,usingpassiveacoustictelemetryWinton,M.,SkomalG.,ChisholmJ.,FayG.Presentedby:Winton,M.([email protected])Overthepastdecade,thecoastalwatersoffofCapeCod,Massachusetts,haveemergedastheonlyknownseasonalaggregationsiteforthewhitesharkinthewesternNorthAtlantic.Thespecies’now-predictablesummerpresenceintheregionhaslargelybeenattributedtotherecoveryofthelocalgraysealpopulation,whichhasrecolonizedtheprotectedbeachesofCapeCod.WhilemanymembersofCapeCod’scoastalcommunityhavecelebratedthewhiteshark’sreturnasthesignofahealthyecosystem,thegrowingpresenceofalargeapexpredatorincloseproximitytopopularswimming

Page 16: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Oralpresentations

15

beacheshasraisedconcernsregardingpublicsafety.TogainabetterunderstandingofwhitesharkmovementsandhabitatuseoffthecoastofCapeCod,theMassachusettsSharkResearchProgramtaggedsixtyindividualwhitesharks(ranginginlengthfrom2.1to5.4m)withpassiveacoustictransmittersfrom2010to2015.Herewepresentanoverviewofdetectiondatacollectedduring2015,theyearwiththegreatestnumberoftaggedsharksatliberty.Sharksweredetectedonallreceiversinthearrayduringthecourseoftheseason;thefirstdetectionwasrecordedinJuneandthelastinDecember.Ofthe36individualstaggedinpreviousyears,11weredetectedin2015.Geostatisticalmixedmodelswereappliedtoinvestigateaggregateandindividualtrendsinspaceuse.Modelresultsindicatethatmostsharkstraversethecoastduringthecourseofagivensummer,butalsosuggestthatsomeindividualsdisplayarelativelyhighdegreeofsitefidelity.Whenconsideredinconjunctionwithpotentialenvironmentaldrivers,knowledgeofthedistributionofwhitesharksinthewatersofftheCapemayhelpinformbeachmanagementandpublicsafetypracticestoreducethechanceofnegativeinteractionsbetweentheCape’sseasonalsharkandhumanresidents.FindingEfficiencythroughIntegratedFisheriesManagement&MarinePlanningDataCollectionZaykoski,P.([email protected])Bothresourcemanagementandoceanplanningeffortsaredatadrivenandoftenrequiredifferenttypesofdatafromthesamestakeholdergroups.ThroughacollaborativeeffortamongtheNortheastRegionalPlanningBody(NERPB),stateandfederalfisheriesofficials,theAtlanticCoastalCooperativeStatisticsProgram(ACCSP),SeaPlan,GeorgeLapointeConsulting,HarborLightSoftware,andpartyandcharterfishingindustrymembers(interchangeablyreferredtoasthefor-hiresector),projectpartnersconductedasmall-scalepilotstudyin2015and2016toexploretheintegrationofdatacollectionforfisheriesmanagementandoceanplanningpurposes.Usingatablet-basedsoftwareapplication,SAFISeTRIPS/Mobile,partnerscollectedcatchandeffortdatadirectlyfromparticipatingfor-hiresectorcaptainsinRhodeIsland,Connecticut,andNewYork,satisfyingtheirfisheriesmanagementreportingrequirements,whilespatialinformationwascollectedautomaticallybytheapplication,engagingthenativeGPScapabilitiesofthetablets.Wepositthatsuchconsolidateddatacollectionactivitiesresultinmorecollaborationandefficiencybetweenregulatorsandplannersandminimizestheburdenontheregulatedcommunity,allowingforanindividualprojecttoaddressbothecologicalandsocialgoals.

Page 17: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Posterpresentations

16

Abstracts:PosterpresentationsAccessingseafloorandcoastalvideoandphotographsfromtheUSGSCoastalandMarineGeologyProgramAckerman,S.,Golden,N.,Dailey,E.Presentedby:Ackerman,S.([email protected])TheU.S.GeologicalSurvey’sCoastalandMarineGeologyProgram(USGS-CMGP)hasavastcollectionofuniqueandvaluablevideoandphotographsfromseafloorandaerialsurveysalongcoastalshorelines.Until2013,onlyasmallamountofthesedatasetswereavailablepublically.Sincethen,anewgeospatialweb-portalhasbeencreatedinordertoprovideasinglepointofaccessforCMGPvideoandphotographdata.TheportalworkflowstreamlinestheprocessingandpublicationofimagerydatasetsandenablestheUSGS-CMGPtosharethedataquicklyandinameaningfulgeospatialformat.Videoandphotographdataoriginallycollectedforasingleuseisnowbeingeasilysharedwithourownscienceteams,ourresearchpartners,thegreaterscientificcommunityandthegeneralpublic.AsofSeptember2016,theUSGS-CMGPVideoandPhotoPortalcontainsover160,000stillimages,morethan1000hoursofvideoandcoversapproximately48,000kilometersofUScoastlineandseafloor.ThePortalisupdatedwithnewvideoandphotosastheyarecollectedbyUSGSscientistsanddataisbeingaddedfromourarchives.IncreasingfunctionalityofthePortalisalsoaprioritytocontinueto:1)makethesiteuser-friendly;2)provideeasyaccesstothisrichUSGSdatasetoffine-scaleimageryinaninteractiveweb-portal;and3)meettheneedsofUSGSscientists,USGSresearchpartners,oceanplanningexpertsandthepublic.MonitoringChangesinSomesSoundInthePastTwoDecadesArno,H.,Dawson,W.Presentedby:Arno,H.([email protected])ItiswellknownthattheGulfofMaineiswarmingincrediblyfast,infactfasterthanalmosteverywhereelseonearth.Becauseofthis,theGulfofMaineischangingveryrapidly.Toadapttothesechanges,wemustfirstunderstandexactlywhatishappeningonalocallevel.AcadiaInstituteofOceanographyhasbeencollectingdataduringthesummerintheSomesSoundsince1990,andthatdatacanbeusedtoshowlong–termtrendsintheGulfofMaine.Variablessuchasairandwatertemperature,pH,dissolvedoxygen,dissolvedcarbondioxide,salinity,turbidity,andwatercolorandotherswererecorded.ThisdatawasanalyzedalongwithhistoricweatherdatatodeterminethespecificchangesthathavehappenedintheSomesSoundinrecentyears,andwillallowustounderstandandthereforeadapttoarapidlychangingocean.Thisprojectwillalsoexplorecitizenscienceasawaytocollectvaluabledataforscientists,sincemuchofthisdatawascollectedbystudentsofAcadiaInstituteofOceanography,includingtheauthors.

Page 18: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Posterpresentations

17

You’regonnagetwet:IntertidalmonitoringatAppledoreIslandBalstad,B.,Brewster,S.,Clarke,B.,Miller,K.,andSiddon,C.Presentedby:Balstad,B.([email protected])Since1976,studentsatShoalsMarineLabhavesurveyedpermanentverticaltransectsintherockyintertidalofAppledoreIsland.Since2011,wehavefocusedon5sitesrepresentingtheexposedandshelteredsidesoftheislandandhaveincludedreplicatedpermanentphotoplotsat4tidallevelsattwosites.Ourgoalistoprovidebaselineinformationonthecomposition,abundanceandverticaldistributionofkeyintertidalorganisms.From1992to2016,thezonationpatternscreatedbythedominantorganismsareconsistent,althoughthereisstronginter-annualvariabilityamongmanyofthecommonspecies,especiallyFucus,barnacles,andmusselsduetoepisodicrecruitmentevents.Barnaclecoverdeclinedmarkedlyin2013,butrecoveredin2014-2016tolevelscomparabletothoseof2011/2012.CoverofElachistaandVertebrata,epiphytesonthefoundationspeciesAscophyllumnodosum,weredifferentonshelteredcomparedtoexposedshores.CoverofMastocarpusandChondrus,foundationspeciesinalowerzone,weresimilarfrom1996to2006,afterwhichthecoverofChondrusdeclineddramatically,likelyduetocolderthanusualwinters(periodsof3ormorehoursat-5C).Todetectcommunity-relatedresponsestoclimatechangeinthefaceoflargeinter-annualvariability,along-termbaselineisessential.Soft-ShellClamsinCrisisMode:FieldResearchTellsUsWhyandGivesUsToolstoAdaptBeal,B.,Randall,S.,Coffin,C.,Goodenow,C.Presentedby:Randall,S.([email protected])Soft-shell(“steamer”)clams,Myaarenaria,areaneconomicallyvaluablefisheryandculturallyimportantMainefoodsource;however,predation,spurredbywarmingoceanwaters,hastakenatollonthisiconicspecies.Recently,clammersfromtheMaineClammersAssociationsoundedthealarmaboutthedramaticincreaseofinvasivegreencrab,Carcinusmaenas,populationsinCascoBayandthecorrespondingdecreaseinsoft-shellclampopulations.TheTownofFreeport,MEtookinitialstepstobegineffortstoaddresstheproblemin2013.In2014,theDowneastInstituteforAppliedMarineResearch&Education(DEI)andtheUniversityofMaineatMachiaslauncheditslarge-scalefieldresearchprograminFreeport,MEtoexaminetheeffectivenessofdifferentmethodstoprotectshellfishfromgreencrabsandotherpredators,andhowtorestoresoft-shellclampopulations.Since2014,theprojecthasdeployednineteendifferentfieldexperimentstothisend,including:greencrabtrapping;operationofupwellerclamnurseries;predatorexclusionfencing,netting,andboxes;recruitmentboxes;bio-remediation;andexaminingtherelativeimportanceofpredationvs.coastalacidificationonjuvenileclamrecruitment.The2016setoffieldexperimentsarestillunderway,butoverarchingconclusionsdrawnfrompreviouslyanalyzedfielddataaswellas2016observationsshowclearlythatpredationisthemostimportantfactorcausingthedeclineofsoft-shellclams,whiletheeffectsofocean/coastalacidificationrelativetopredationareminimal.Inadditiontogreencrabs,nativemilkyribbonworms,Cerebratuluslacteus,areanotherkeypredatornegativelyimpactingclampopulations.Ourfieldtrials

Page 19: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Posterpresentations

18

demonstratethatpredator-deterrentnettingandboxesarepromisingclamprotectiontools.ConsideringpredictionsofincreasedGulfofMaineoceanwatertemperaturesinthefuture,andthatgreencrabsthriveinwarmerwaters,itiscriticalthatShellfishManagersquicklyimplementtoolstoadapttothechangingecosystemtomaintainandpreservethefishery.PopulationassessmentofHarbor(Phocavitulina)andGreyseals(Halichoerusgrypus)atDuckIslandledges,MEBogomoli,A.,Calandrino,G.,Carr,M.,Lysiak,N.,Tsourounakis,G.Presentedby:Bogomoli,A.([email protected])Harbor(Phocavitulina)andgreyseals(Halichoerusgrypus)congregateincloseproximityatarockyhauloutsitewithintheIslesofShoalsknownasDuckIslandledges.Thisarealiesinthemiddleofbothspecies’rangesandactsasacentralrestingpointalongtheirseasonalmigrationroutes.Anongoingstudythatbeganin2011usesshipboardphotographicmark-recapturesurveystoassessthistransientpopulationofseals.Since2011,theminimumabundanceofeachspecieshasincreasedeachyear.In2016,theaverageminimumabundancewas325forP.vitulinaand181forH.grypsus.Interestingfindingsin2016includedover11casesofsealpoxandmorethan30injuriesofvaryingseverity.Oneharborsealwassightedwithagreentagonitshindflipper.Entanglementinfishinggearandothermaterialsaffected24H.grypusand18P.vitulina,andmorethantwentysealswereresightedfrompreviousyears,includingagreyseal“Granite”thathadnotbeenseenatthishauloutsince2011.DuckIslandservesasanimportanthabitatforharborandgreyseals,andthecontinuationofthisstudyisimperativeinordertocreatelong-termdatasetsforbettermonitoringofhumaninteractionsandpopulationhealth.Assessingtheimpactofecolabelsonconsumerpreferencesforseafood:theroleofproductionmethod,certificationandoriginonwildharvestandaquacultureproductsBrayden,C.,Noblet,C.,Snell,M.,Kashkooli,M.Presentedby:Brayden,C.([email protected])TheproductionofseaweedandbivalveshellfishrepresentsasubstantialandgrowingsectoroftheU.S.andglobalseafoodindustry(NOAA,2016;Watson,2016).Whiletheincreaseinproductionofbivalveshellfishandseaweedhasbeenmatchedbyheightenedseafooddemand,consumersoftenexperienceconfusionoverthecharacteristicsofproductsduringthepurchasingprocess.Atthesametime,producersandretailersstruggletodetermineoptimalmethodsofproductionandmarketingtomaximizeprofits.Seafoodlabelsplayanimportantroleinthecommunicationofproductcharacteristicsfromtheproducertotheconsumerandviceversa.Thispaperexplorestheimpactofecolabelsonconsumerpreferencesforseafoodproducts.Weexaminethreekeyattributesthatmayimpactconsumerchoice:(1)preferencesforproductionmethod:wildharvestoraquacultureproducts;(2)

Page 20: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Posterpresentations

19

preferencesfororganic(aquaculture)orsustainablyharvested(wildharvest)products;and(3)whetheraproductislabeledasimported,fromtheU.S.,orfromaconsumer’shomestate.Weusedatafroma2016onlineconsumerexperiment(n=2000)andperformaconjointanalysistoimproveourunderstandingoftherolethesethreeattributesmayplayindecisionmaking.Thisworkfillsakeyknowledgegapbyexaminingconsumerpreferencesforcoastalshellfish(oysters,mussels,scallopsandclams)andseaweedproductsacrossthenation.Preliminaryfindingsindicatethatconsumerspreferproductsfromtheirhomestateregardlessofproductionmethodorcertification.TheCitizenIntertidalEcologistProjectCaffrey,M.,Jones,A.,Wiley,M.Presentedby:Caffrey,M.([email protected])AlthoughtheGulfofMaineisoneofthefastestwarmingpartsoftheoceanintheworld,fewlongtermandwidespreadstudieshavebeenconductedtoexaminehowthiswarmingisaffectingtheGulfofMaineintertidalzone.Weareinitiatingacitizenscientistprogramtocollectintertidalspeciesabundancedataasitwillalloweachparticipantorgrouptoestablishtransectstocollectdatamultipletimesandmultiplesiteseachyear.WiththepotentialtoattracttensorhundredsofparticipantsthroughouttheGulfofMaine,theamountofdataaccessiblethroughourdatabaseshouldpaintapictureoftheecologyoftheintertidalintheentiretyoftheGulfofMaine,andhowspeciescompositionischangingduetowarming.Theprotocolissimplifiedforcitizenscientistsandutilizesalistofspeciesthatfulfillseveralcriteria.SampledatafortheprojectwerecollectedonStarIslandoftheIslesofShoalstodemonstratespeciestrends.Thecitizenscienceapproachalsoservestogetthepublicinvolvedinbiologyandinformedonhowhumanimpactseffecttheirlocalenvironment.VariationinminimumGrayseal(Halichoerusgrypus)andHarborseal(Phocavitulina)minimumabundancecountsonDuckIsland,MEduetometeorologicalvariablesCalandrino,M.,Bogomolni,A.,Lysiak,N.Presentedby:Calandrino,M.([email protected])Abundancedatafromastudyconductedbetween2011to2016wereusedtoexaminemeteorologicalpredictorvariablesinrelationtoharborsealandgraysealhaul-outbehavioronasmall,mixed-specieshaul-outsiteintheGulfofMaine.Juliandaywashighlypositivelycorrelatedwithwatertemperatureonemeterbelowtheoceansurfaceandwatertemperaturetwentymetersbelowthesurface.TherewasanobservedsignificantrelationshipbetweennumberofgraysealsseenperhourandJulianday,withamidsummerpeakinnumberofgraysealsobserved.Thispeakinobservedabundancewasalsocorrelatedwithwatertemperatureonemeterbelowthesurface.Winddirectionwastheonlyvariablesignificantlycorrelatedwithharborsealsseenperhour,withapeakinobservedabundanceoccurringwhenwindsoriginatedinthenortheast.

Page 21: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Posterpresentations

20

EntanglementofGrey(Halichoerusgrypus)andHarborseals(Phocavitulina)atDuckIslandledges,MECarr,M.,Lysiak,N.,Bogomolni,A.Presentedby:Carr,M.([email protected])Grey(Halichoerusgrypus)andharborseals(Phocavitulina)congregateatDuckIslandledges,ahauloutlocatedintheIslesofShoals,ME.Thissitewasmonitoredusingshipboardphotographicmark-recapturesurveystoassesspopulationhealthduringsummers2011-2016.Incidenceofdiseased,injuredandentangledsealswasnoted.Entangledanimalswereassessedaccordingtotheseverityoftheirwounds,typeofentanglinggear,andlocationofentanglementonthebody.Duringsummers2011-2016,63greysealsand86harborsealswereobservedentangledinmarinedebrisatDuckIslandanditssurroundingledges.Mostentanglements(85%)werelocatedontheneck,while6%affectedtheface,flippers,orbodyand9%affectedmultiplepartsofthebody.Oftheidentifiableentanglinggear,monofilamentlineandgillnetweremostcommon.Thoughthedominantlocalfisheryislobstering,nosealswereobservedentangledinlobsterfishinggear,possiblyduetotheheavylinesassociatedwiththegear.Severeorveryseverewoundswerenotedin95%*ofP.vitulinaentanglementsand89%*ofH.grypusentanglements(*entanglementsthatcouldbescored).TherelativeentanglementrateforP.vitulina––washigherthanH.grypus.Thissite'shighincidenceofentanglementidentifiesasignificantthreattobothsealpopulationsintheGulfofMaine.Understandingexchangeatthebay-shelfinterfaceCole,K.,Pettigrew,N.Presentedby:Cole,K.([email protected])Understandingexchangebetweenabayandthesurroundingshelfisimportantformanyoceanapplicationsincludingsediment,nutrientandpollutanttransport.PreviousstudiesfindatransitionregioninouterCascoBaywherenear-surfacecross-shorecurrentsshiftfrompredominantlyalong-shorewinddrivenEkmanresponsetocross-shorewindforcedwithintheeastbay.However,theverticalstructureandtemporalandspatialscalesofvariabilityofthiscross-shorecurrentstructurearenotwellunderstoodandcannotbesimplysummarizedbyanexclusivecoastalorestuarineprocess.Inthisresearch,theimpactofphysicalenvironmentalconditionsinCascoBayandthesurroundingshelfonthesalinityandcurrentstructureoftheeastbayisexaminedusingidealizedexperimentswiththeRegionalOceanModelingSystem(ROMS).Thiseffortisfocusedonbetterunderstandingtheroleofbottomboundarylayerdynamicsatthebay-coastalinterface.Thebottomboundarycouldcontributesignificantlytocross-shoretransportforthreereasons:cross-shoreexchangeislinkedtoalongshoreflowstructure,whichistiedtotheupcoastKennebecRiverplumeattheentrancetoCascoBay.Poorlyunderstoodmid-tofar-fieldplumedynamicsoccurintheregionwherethebayformsabreakinthecoastalwall.Underwhatforcingplumeisohalinesintersectthebottomisnotwellunderstood,butcouldresultinsignificantbuoyancytransportcross-shore.Second,boundarylayerscanspantheentire

Page 22: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Posterpresentations

21

watercolumnandaffectorbeaffectedbythestrengthandstructureofinteriorflow.Winddrivencirculationisimportantthroughoutmuchofthewatercolumninthiscase,buttheresponsetothetimingandvariabilityofthisforcinginaregionoffreshwaterinfluence,anditsaffectsubsurface,possiblythroughseasurfacesetup,isnotclear.Third,thespatialscalesandbathymetricslopeoftheouterbaysupportthepossibilityofthesedynamics.HighresolutionmodelingofnearshoreflowpatternsandbluemusselpopulationconnectivityinDowneastMaineConlonL.,XueH.,YundP.Presentedby:ConlonL.([email protected])Knowledgeofpopulationconnectivityiscriticalforunderstandingpopulationdynamicsanddevelopingappropriatemanagementstrategiesforbenthicmarinespecies.Circulationmodelsareausefultoolinassessingconnectivitybecausetheyincorporatenumerousparameterssuchastemperature,salinity,andflowpatternsandthuspermitanevaluationofthephysicaldynamicsthatunderlayconnectivity.WeusedahighresolutionFVCOMmodel(FiniteVolumeCoastalOceanModel)tosimulatethenearshoreflowpatternsalongtheeasternMainecoasttoinvestigatepopulationconnectivityofbluemussels(Mytilusedulis).Ourmodelishighlyresolvedinintertidalandnearshoreregionstoaccuratelysimulateflowdynamicsintheseregionsthatarecriticalforlarvaldispersal.Wearevalidatingthemodelusinginsitutemperature,salinity,andcurrentvelocitydatacollectedwithinthestudyregion.Tosimulatedispersal,werepresentlarvalmusselsasLagrangianparticleswithatemperaturedependantgrowthandsurvivalfunction,releasedfrommusselbedlocations.Thesesimulationsshowparticleslingeringinthenearshorewatersforseveraldays,andtheneithermovingamongneighboringbaysorenteringthecoastalcurrentandmovingalongthecoastfromnortheasttosouthwest.Whetherornotparticlesenterthecoastalcurrentisdependentonanumberoffactors,suchastides,bathymetry,andseason.UnderstandingshellfishgrowthpotentialintheDamariscottaRiverusingacoupledmodelingapproachCoupland,K.,Cole,K.,Brady,D.,Newell,C.Presentedby:Coupland,K.([email protected])Asclimatechangecontinuestoaltermarineecosystemsthroughtemperatureandsalinitychanges,acidification,andsealevelrise,understandinghowtheestuariesandaquaculturemayrespondtothesechangesiscriticaltosustainablemanagement.TheDamariscottaRiveristhehighestproducerofoystersannuallyinMaine.Understandingthissystemisparamounttoexpandaquaculturethroughoutthestatetomeettheneedsofagrowingpopulationandsupportcoastalcommunities.Wearedevelopingacoupledhydrodynamic-biogeochemicalmodeloftheDamariscottaRiverthatwillfocuson

Page 23: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Posterpresentations

22

understandingwhytheDamariscottaRiverissuchaproductiveoysteraquaculturearea.Themodelwillincorporateparameterssuchastemperatureandsalinity,nutrientsources,freshwaterflow,primaryproductivityrates,chlorophyllastandingstock,uptakeratesbyoysters,proportionoffoodcomingfromdetritusvsphytoplankton,benthicpelagiccouplingandremineralizationrates,bottomtype,andbathymetry.Severalquestionsofinteresttobeansweredwiththemodelinclude:WhatisthecarryingcapacityoftheDamariscottaRiverforoysters?Howdoesthecompositionofdetritusintheriverimpactoystergrowthrates,andwhatarethepossiblyimplicationsduetoshiftindetrituscomposition?Increasedtemperaturewilllikelyincreaseoystergrowthrates,willtheoysterfoodsupplyincreaseproportionately?Willshelfintrusionofacidicwaterbeofconcernforthegrowingareasintheupperportionsoftheriver?WilldecreasedpHduetoincreasedfreshwaterrunoffhaveanimpactongrowthrates?CatchShareManagementintheNortheastMultispeciesFishery:HavetheTheorizedBenefitsBeenRealizedinNewHampshire?Feeney,R.G.Presentedby:Feeney,R.G.([email protected])Agreatdealofcontroversyhasattendedtheintroductionofcatchsharesinfisheries,particularlytheNortheastgroundfishsectorprogram.Althoughsocialresearchofteninvolvestheorygeneration,inthecaseofsectors,andcatchshareprogramsmoregenerally,anumberoftheorieshavealreadyemergedthatareripefortesting.Thisdissertationresearch(whileastudentattheUniversityofNewHampshire)examinedthesetheories-theirvalidityandlimitsrelativetothesectorprogram,particularlywithinNewHampshire,thoughbroaderoutcomeswereconsidered.Answerstocommonlyaskedquestionsaboutcatchsharesweresoughtthroughaseriesoffisheryparticipantinterviewsin2012.Itwashypothesizedthatfishinginasectorhasresultedin:moreefficiencyandflexibilityforfishermentodecidewhere,when,andhowtofish;greatersocialcapitalamongfishermen;reducedbycatch;andimprovedeconomicperformance,safety,andwell-being.ThegroundfishfishermenofNewHampshirerevealedthatthetheorizedbenefitsofcatchshareprogramsdonotnecessarilyholdtrue;onlythebenefitsrelatedtofishingpractices,bycatchandsafetyalignedwithwhathadoccurredinthislocalfishery.Withdecliningfisheryparticipation,anddimpotentialforpositiveeconomicperformance,thesenseofwell-beingandfutureoutlookforselfandfisheryhaddiminished.Theseconclusionsmustbecontextualizedwithoutcomesforothersectorsandtheconcurrentseverereductionsincatchlimitsthathavelikelymaskedmuchofthepositivepotentialforcatchshares.Successunderacatchshareprogramisperhapsmorelikelyattainedinfisheriesnotconstrainedbystockrebuildingplansandbythoseparticipantsabletoadapt(e.g.,withtools,skills,financialresources,businesssavvy).

Page 24: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Posterpresentations

23

Factorsaffectingspinydogfish(Squalusacanthias)atJeffrey’sLedgeintheGulfofMaineGallo,B.,Chapman,E.Presentedby:Gallo,B.([email protected])IntheWesternAtlanticOcean,SpinyDogfish(Squalusacanthias)isahighlymigratoryspecies(HMS)foundfromNorthCarolinatoCanada.Historicallyconsideredbycatchbycommercialfishermen,recentdeclinesinsomevaluablegroundfishstocks(e.g.AtlanticCod(Gadusmorhua)andaconcurrentincreaseinabundanceandannualresidencetimehavecreatedafisheryforSpinyDogfishintheGulfofMaine(GOM).Thesechangeshaveimpactedfishingoperationsandarelikelytohaveimportantecologicaleffectsduetothestrongpredationpressureassociatedwiththisspecies.AlthoughincreasingwatertemperaturesintheGOMhavebeenimplicatedasanimportantenvironmentaldriverbehindchangesindogfishabundance,littleisknownaboutfactorsassociatedwiththisphenomenon.From2014-2016,UNHandTheNatureConservancyhaveworkedwithlocalfishermentobetterunderstandfactorsassociatedwiththeseasonalentranceanddepartureofdogfishfromJeffery’sLedge.Temperatureloggerswereplacedongillnetgeartocollectbenthicwatertemperatureandfishermen’scatchwasalsorecordedduringthestudy.ThedataallowedanalysisofconditionsduringoneseasonalappearanceandtwodeparturesofSpinyDogfishfromJeffery’sLedge.Resultssuggestthatthespringappearanceofdogfishintheareamaybeassociatedwithwarmingtemperatures(6.5-7.0⁰C,60-90m)whilethelatesummerorearlyfalldepartureofdogfishoccursaswatertemperaturesarecontinuingtowarm(8.0-8.5⁰C,60-90m),perhapsindicatingecologicalfactorstriggeringmovementoutofthearea.Informalobservationsalsosuggestapossibledemographicshiftfromlargerpregnantfemalesinearlysummertosmallermalesinlatesummerandfall.Futureresearchdirectionsincludeaddingmorevesselstotheresearchprogramtobroadenregionalcoverage,continuingtobuildthetimeseries,trackingageandsexdistribution,andaddingadditionalexistingdata-setstotheanalysis.OceanandcoastalacidificationgovernanceinMaine:ConservationinnetworksGassett,P.,Strong,A.Presentedby:Gassett,P.([email protected])Astheunderstandingofthedriversandimpactsofoceanandcoastalacidification(OCA)hasimproved,stateshaveincreasinglyrecognizedthattheyhavearoleinregional-to-localOCAmanagement,andMainehasbeenattheforefrontofamovementforstateactionstoaddressOCA.In2014,astatecommissionwasformedtoassessthethreatsofOCAtoMaine’sfisheriesandtheopportunitiestotakeactionstoaddressthosethreats.Onerecommendationofthecommissionwasthecreationofanon-goingstate-sponsoredcounciltomanagethestate’sOCAresponses.In2015,inthewakeoffailedlegislativefundingtosupportsuchastatesponsoredOCAtaskforce,leadersfromamongMaine’srobustnetworkofnon-profitconservationorganizationshavepartneredtogethertoleadMaine’sresponse.Unlikeotherstatesthathaveaddressedthisissuethroughtop-downstateaction,Maine’sapproachiscurrentlymulti-faceted,volunteer,and“bottom-up”.Suchanapproachinvolvesanevolvingcommunityofwaterqualityorganizations,aquaculturefisheries,municipalengineers,conservationorganizationsandUniversityresearchers.BecauseOCAhasmultiple,complexdrivers,andbecause

Page 25: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Posterpresentations

24

adaptabilitytoOCAislinkedtoenvironmental,social,andeconomicconditions,allofwhicharelocallyhighlyvariable,understandinghowthecurrentgovernanceapproachcanimproveresiliencetochangingoceanchemistryrequiresunderstandinghowcommunitiesdevelopanidentityasstakeholdersinthisissue.Here,IexplorethechallengesandpotentialforindependentcollaborationstoimplementregionalOCAgovernanceactionsinresponsetoenvironmentalchange.Inparticular,thisworkinvestigatesthefacilitatorsofstakeholderbuy-intoOCAmitigationandadaptationstrategies.Understandingcommunityresponsestoenvironmentalconcern,inabsenceofformalgovernmentaction,isakeyelementofglobalchangeresearch,andMaine’scurrentsituationprovidesacasestudyofthesocialstructures,opportunities,andbarriersofbottomupapproachestolargescalestrategyforenvironmentalchange.Afisheryinflux:Clawremovalanditsimpactsonsurvivorship,behavior,andphysiologicalstressinJonahcrab(Cancerborealis)Goldstein,J.,Carloni,J.,Kibler,R.Presentedby:Goldstein,J.([email protected])FoundincoastalandshelfwatersalongtheAtlanticcoastofNorthAmerica,fromNewfoundlandtoFlorida,Jonahcrab(Cancerborealis)havebeencapturedasincidentalbycatchintheNewEnglandlobsterindustryforover80years.Inthelast20yearshowever,Jonahcrabshavebecomeanalternativefisherytargetandlandingshavemorethanquadrupled.Thishasnecessitatedevaluationofthecurrentstatusandprospectivelong-termhealthofthefishery.ThebiologicalimplicationsofharvestingJonahcrabthroughtheliveremovalofclawsremainmostlyunknown.Thegoalofthisongoingresearchistoevaluatecurrentharvestpractices(clawremoval)andtheimplicationsonthehealthandbehaviorofJonahcrabs.Preliminaryresultsfromlaboratorytrials(n=232totalcrabs)suggestthatdouble-clawremovalincursmarkedlymoremortality(~74%)comparedwithsingle-clawremoval(~56%)andcontrolanimals(~19%).Physiologicalstress,assessedthroughconcurrenthaemolymphanalysessuggestelevatedlevelsofglucoseandlactateinde-clawedcrabs.Continuedstudiesonbehavior(feeding)andgrowthareongoinginanefforttobetterunderstandJonahcrabsandmanagethisrapidlydevelopingfisheryinNewEnglandwaters.StakeholderDrivenDiseaseModeling:TheCaseofLobsterShellDiseaseHupper,A.,Belknap,S.,Homola,J.,Tanaka,K.Presentedby:Belknap,S.([email protected])Thespreadofemergingandestablishedmarinediseasesposesubstantialthreattomarineresourcesandthecommunitiesthatrelyuponthemfortheirlivelihoodsandsenseofidentity.ThethreatposedbythesemarinediseasesiswelldocumentedbythecaseoflobstershelldiseaseinLongIslandSound(LIS).LobsterharvestersinMainearewellawareoftheimpactofthisdiseaseinLISanditspotentialthreatit

Page 26: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Posterpresentations

25

posestotheGulfofMaineLobsterFishery.In2013,Mainelobsterharvestersbroughttheirconcernstotheattentionofourresearchteamandrequestedmoreinformationregardingthefuturespreadofthediseaseunderclimatechangescenarios.Thisposterpresentsinitialresultsofastakeholderconcernandneedsassessmentregardingthefuturespreadofshelldisease,aswellasadescriptionofmodelingeffortsdirectlymotivatedbytheseconcernsandneeds.EvaluatingfishingeffortlevelsintheMainelobsterfishery:anindividual-basedmodelapproachMazur,M.,Chen,Y.Presentedby:Mazur,M.([email protected])TheMainelobsterfisheryisthemostvaluablecommercialfisheryinthestate,andassuch,supportsalargenumberoffamiliesacrossverydiversecommunities.EvaluatingfishingeffortlevelsandefficiencyoftheMainelobsterfisheryisimportantplatformfromwhichtounderstandhowregulationimpactsthefisherydynamicsandtheeconomy.Anefficientfisherymaintainsaspecificyieldwhilereducingeffortandcosts.AlthoughcurrentGulfofMainelobsterlandingsareatahistoricalhigh,thelargequantityoftraps(andthusfishingeffort)usedinthefisherymakesitlessprofitable.Toresearchefficiency,anindividualbasedmodel(IBM),previouslydevelopedfortheGulfofMainelobster,willbemodifiedandusedtoevaluatehowyieldmaychangeatdifferentlevelsandtemporaldistributionsoffishingeffortsi.e.,trapshauls.ThelobsterIBMmimicsthelifehistoryandfisheryofindividuallobstersandquantifieshowtheygrowinsize,becomematureanddieduetofishingandnaturalmortalities.Usingthismodel,wesimulatetheMainelobsterfisheryunderdifferentrealisticmanagementstrategies.ThisresearchfocusesonidentifyingwaystomaximizeeconomicvalueoftheMainelobsterfisherythroughimprovedfisheryefficiency.ACollaborativeApproachtoCharacterizingSandandGravelDepositsUsingMultibeamSonarintheGulfofMaineOzmon,I.,Enterline,C.,Nixon,M.,Dobbs,K.Presentedby:Ozmon,I.Acomprehensiveunderstandingofthebenthicenvironmentisnecessarytoeffectivelymanagecoastalresourcesandincreaseresiliency.Wecharacterizesubstrate,biologicalcommunities,habitatandinfaunaatsubmergedglacialpaleodeltasinMaine(3-8nmoffshore)usingaKongsbergmultibeamsonarandPonardredgepairedwithunderwatervideocamera.Althoughhistoricalsidescanandmultibeamsonarandseismicprofilesprovidesomebathymetryinformationandhavebeenusedtomodelsurficialsedimentcompositiontherearestilllargegapsinhighresolutionbathymetry,andverylittleisknownaboutbenthichabitatinMainewaters.TheMaineCoastalMappingInitiativeutilizesasmallvesselsurveyplatforminbothoffshoreandnearshoreareastocollectbathymetryinformationandcomparebackscatterintensitydatawithvideofootageandsedimentgrabstoground-truthsedimenttype.We

Page 27: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Posterpresentations

26

characterizebenthicinfauna,which,whenpairedwithanunderwatervideocameraandwatercolumnprofiles,areusedtocharacterizebiologicalcommunitiestoaidbenthichabitatclassification.Thesedatawilldramaticallyenhancethecapacityforcoastalresiliency,oceanplanning,andresourcemanagementonMaine’sinnerandoutercontinentalshelf.WewillpresentdatacollectedonthesubmergedKennebecRiverpaleodelta,withintheSacoRiver,andmarinewatersofsouthernMaine.ESIP’snewICUCsmartphoneapp–linkingcitizenscientiststotheirownplacesofwonderParlee,K.,Tilburg,C.,Latimer,J.Presentedby:Parlee,K.([email protected])TheGulfofMaineCouncil’sEcoSystemIndicatorPartnership(ESIP)wasformedin2006tolookatchangesinthehealthoftheGulfofMaineecosystemthroughtheuseofenvironmentalindicators.ESIPhasalwaysrecognizedthevalueofdatasetsgeneratedbycitizenscientists.Toharnessmoreoftheenergyandcuriosityofcitizenscientistsintheregion,ESIPhasreleasedanewsmartphoneapp:ICUC(“ISeeYouSee”).ESIP’sinitialapproachtoindicatordevelopmentfocusedonsevenecosystemthemes,whichwerebasedonpriorityissuesidentifiedbyscientists,decision-makers,andotherstakeholders.Todate,ESIPhasmadeindicatordataavailableonlinethroughitsIndicatorReportingToolandfactsheetspublishedonsevenofitsindicatorthemes:aquaculture,aquatichabitats,climatechange,coastaldevelopment,contaminants,eutrophication,andfisheries.ESIP’scommunityofusers,whichincludeacademics,governmental,andnon-governmentalindividuals,hasgrowndramaticallysinceitsformation.Concurrently,thecitizensciencemovementhasconnectedcitizensintheUSandCanadausingobservationalscience.ThenewappprovidesuserswithinformationonmonitoringactivitiesintheGulfofMaineandtheopportunitytoparticipateinknowledgecollectionintheirlocalareasbyuploadingsmartphonephotosatspecificlocationstoanon-linephotolibrary.Asthephotolibrarygrows,bothinnumberofphotosandnumberoflocations,userswillbeabletoobserveenvironmentalchangesateachlocationovertimeviaanassociatedwebpageontheESIPwebsite(http://www.gulfofmaine.org/2/esip-homepage/).MovementsandForagingAreasofGreatShearwatersPuffinusgravisintheGulfofMainePowers,K.D.,Wiley,D.N.,Allyn,A.J.,Welch,L.J.,Ronconi,R.A.Presentedby:Powers,K.([email protected])InthewesternNorthAtlantic,greatshearwatersPuffinusgravisconsumevastamountsofmarinepreyandareamongthemostabundantseabirdsduringsummermonths,yetlittleisknownabouttheirmovementecologyandhabitatrequirementsinthisecosystem.Weusedplatformterminaltransmitters(PTTs)andaBayesianswitchingstate-spacemodel(SSSM)todescribeshearwatermovements,foragingareas,migrationtiming,andhowsuchhabitatusemightberelatedtoageintheGulfofMaine.FromJulytoNovembergreatshearwaterstraveledanaverage515kmperweek(individualweeklyaveragebirdrange365-765km)andspentthemajorityoftheirtimeforaging(AreaRestrictedSearchbehavior)

Page 28: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Posterpresentations

27

aroundtherimofthegulfprimarilyusingshallowerwaters(<100m)wherebathymetrywasmoresteeplysloped.MovementsassociatedwiththeirsouthernmigrationbeganinAugustandcontinuedthroughmuchofSeptemberwithbirdsleavingthestudyareaviaapathwaysouthofNovaScotia,Canada.TheagecompositionoftheGulfofMainegreatshearwatersasdeterminedbynapeplumagewaspredominatelyyoung;89%ofbirdsexaminedwere<3yearsold.Coreforagingareaswereidentifiedinthreelocations:lowerBayofFundy,northeastGeorgesBankandStellwagenBank/CapeCodSlope.Foragingareaswerenotcharacterizedbyconsistentenvironmentalvariablesacrosssitesindicatingaflexibleforagingstrategybasedonhighmobility.GiventheapparentadaptabilityassumedfromtheiruseofdifferenthabitatpatcheswithintheGulfofMaine,greatshearwatersmayhavethecapacitytoadapttoclimatechangeandenvironmentalvariabilityduringthenon-breedingseason.ImpactsofDataQuantityandQualityonHabitatModelingRitchie,M.,Tanaka,K.,Chen,Y.Presentedby:Ritchie,M.([email protected])Understandingfactorsinfluencinghabitatqualityofstudyspeciesplaysacriticalroleininformingusofchangesinthedistributionandabundanceoffishpopulations.Well-developedhabitatmodelscanhelpmanagersassessthechangesinhabitatforspecieslikelytobeimpactedbyclimatechange.Thisstudyevaluatesandquantifiestheimpactsofdataquantityandqualityonhabitatmodeling.Twospeciesofeconomicandecologicalimportanceareusedascasestudies:theAmericanLobster(Homarusamericanus),andtheNorthernShrimp(Pandalusborealis)intheGulfofMaine.Fisheriesindependentsurveydataareusedtodevelopspecies-specificHabitatSuitabilityIndex(HSI)models.Threeseparatemodelcalibrationprocessesarecompared.First,aparsimoniousmodelselectioncriterioniscomparedtoaliteraturebasedvariableselection.Second,threedifferentcovariateweightingtechniques,equalweighting,machinelearningandparametricgeneralizedadditivemodelweights,arecompared.Third,modelperformancesusingthefullandtrimmeddatasetarecomparedtoassesstheimpactofoutliers.Modeloutcomesarecomparedforeachcasespeciestoascertainwhichmodelcalibrationtechniqueprovidesthebestmodelperformancemeasuredincrossvalidations.SpatiotemporalvariabilityinsuitablehabitatwillthenbeevaluatedandquantifiedusingthebestmodeloutcomeforeachspeciesinthecontextofpotentialclimatechangescenariosintheGulfofMaine.Size-at-agetrendsinNorthwestAtlanticgroundfishandimplicationsforstockassessmentSchilpp,L.,Fay,G.,Miller,T.J.Presentedby:Schlipp,L.([email protected])Ourworkfocusesonimplicationsofchangingecosystemdynamicsonfisheriesbyexploringpossibledriversonvariationinsize-at-age,andimplicationsforstockassessment.Weusegeneralizedlinearmodelstoevaluatetheeffectsofdemographic,temporalandenvironmentalfactorsonvariabilityin

Page 29: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Posterpresentations

28

weight-at-ageandconditionfactorforeightcommerciallyimportantstocks.Althoughthemostsignificantfactorsaffectingsize-at-agetendtobedemographic(iematurity,sex),locationandtemporalfactorsareimportantaswell;generallyfishonGeorgesBankhavehigherweights-at-agethanintheGulfofMaine.Wethenexploretheimplicationsofthisvariationformodelingnaturalmortalitywithinastate-spacestatisticalcatchatagestockassessmentmodel.Wecomparethestatusquomodelwithvariousmodelswhichincorporatetime,age,andsize-at-agevaryingnaturalmortality.Althoughthesemorecomplexmodelsmayresultinabetterfittothedata,theAICsuggeststhatthesimplestmodelisthemostparsimonious.Ourworkexploresthelinkagesbetweenecosystemcomponentssuchasclimatevariationandsusceptibilitytopredationandhealthyfisheriesbyfocusingonsize-at-ageasbotharesponsetothesechangesaswellasapossiblecomponentinfisheriesmodelinaccuracies.Fine-scalehaul-outpreferencesofharborseals(Phocavitulina)andgrayseals(Halichoerusgrypus)atDuckIsland,METsourounakis,G.,Bogomolni,A.,Lysiak,NPresentedby:Tsourounakis,G.([email protected])HarborSeals(Phocavitullina)andGraySeals(Halichoerusgrypus)haul-outatDuckIslandandthesurroundingledges,butthereasonsareunknown.Dataforsealnumberswerecollectedbyameansofsummingthecountdataforeachledgeforeachyear.Ledgedescriptionwasassayedbyshipboardanalysis,photographicanalysis,andbyuseofanavigatingapp.Aninvestigationofprobabilityofpresencerevealsapreferenceforspecificledges:harborsealsforlowreliefareasandgraysealsforintermediatereliefareas.Algalcover,depth,slope,andsizeofledgeshadlittletonoeffectonharbororgraysealpresence.Finescaleanalysisofsuchsitescanprovideinsightonhabitatpreferenceswhenitcomestorecreatingthesesiteswithrespecttorisingsealevelsandwarmingoceans.Maximumentropymodelingofmarinefishspecies’spatiotemporaldistributionsutilizingearthsystemdataWang,L.,Kerr,L.A.,Bridger,E.,Record,N.R.,Tupper,B.Presentedby:Wang,L.([email protected])Understandinghowoceanconditionsinfluencemarinefishdistributionsiscriticalforelucidatingtheroleofclimateinecosystemchangeandforecastinghowfishmaybedistributedinthefuture.Speciesdistributionmodels(SDMs)enableestimationofthelikelihoodofencounteringspeciesinspaceortimeasafunctionofenvironmentalconditions.TraditionalSDMsareappliedtoscientificsurveydatathatincludebothspeciespresenceandabsenceinformation.Maximumentropy(MaxEnt)modelsarepromisingtoolsastheycanbeappliedtopresence-onlydata,suchasthosecollectedfromfisheriesorcitizenscienceprograms.WeusedMaxEnttorelatetheoccurrencerecordsofmarinefishspecies(e.g.Atlanticherring,Atlanticmackerel,andbutterfish)fromtheNOAANortheastFisheriesObserver

Page 30: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Posterpresentations

29

Programtoenvironmentalconditions.Environmentalvariablesincludedseasurfacetemperature(SST)andChlorophyll-abasedonNASAsatelliteobservations,aswellasbathymetryandclimateindices(NAOandAMO).WedevelopedhabitatsuitabilitymapsforthesefishspeciesinNortheastShelfarea,andassessedtherelativeinfluenceofenvironmentalfactorsontheirdistributions.Overall,SSTandChlorophyll-ahadthegreatestinfluenceontheirmonthlydistributions,withbathymetryhavingmoderateinfluenceandclimateindiceshavinglittleinfluence.Acrossmonths,Atlanticherringdistributionwasmostrelatedtothe10thpercentilevaluesofmonthlySST,andAtlanticmackerelandbutterfishdistributionsweremostrelatedtothepreviousmonth’sSST.Fishdistributionsweremostaffectedbythepreviousmonth’sChlorophyll-ainsummermonths,whichmayberelatedtotheaccumulativeimpactofprimaryproductivity.TheseMaxEnthabitatsuitabilitymodelshavethepotentialtoprovidehindcastsofwherespeciesmighthavebeeninthepastinrelationtohistoricalenvironmentalconditions,nowcastsinrelationtocurrentconditions,orforecastsoffuturespeciesdistributions,andprovideusefulinformationforsustainingmarineecosystemsandcoastalcommunitiesintheGulfofMaine.SustainingtheGulfofMaine:TheImportanceofUnderstandingtheScience,Information,andPolicyInterfaceforEffectiveCoastalandOceanManagementWells,P.G.,Soomai,S.S.,DeSanto,E.M.,MacDonald,B.H.,Ross,J.D.Presentedby:Wells,P.([email protected])Fewwoulddisagreethatincombattingseriousanthropogenicecologicalproblemsaffectingtheoceans,suchasclimatechange,publicpolicydevelopmentshouldbeinformedbythebestavailablescientificinformation.However,withthevastvolumeofinformationnowavailablethroughmultiplecommunicationmethodsandwithpublicresourcesoftenconstrainedbycurrentausteritymeasures,anurgentneedexiststounderstandandstrengthenthechannelsbywhichscientificinformationreachespolicy-anddecision-makers.Inthisposter,wepresentkeyconclusionsdrawnfromthecontributionstothenewbook,Science,Information,andPolicyInterfaceforEffectiveCoastalandOceanManagement,publishedbyCRCPress(Taylor&Francis),2016.Theposteroutlinesfundamentalconceptsandprinciplesofthescience-policyinterface,including:1)Thecomplexityofthepathwaysbywhichscientificinformationflowswithinandamongorganizationsthatsetthecontextforpolicyandmanagementdecisions;2)Thesignificanceoftheprocessesbywhichinformationisgeneratedandassembledtoinformpolicy;3)Thenecessitytoproduceinformationinstylesandformatsthatarehelpfultointendedusers;and4)Thediversityofmethodsbywhichinformationcanbeused(ormisused)inpolicydevelopment.Theposterwillalsonotemajorchallengesfacingresearchersandpractitionerswhowishtoimprovetheprocessesofevidence-baseddecision-makingrelevanttooceans,includingtheneedto:1)Developpolicysolutionstobalancetrade-offsbetweenevidentiary,political,andeconomicimperatives;2)Enhanceknowledgesharingandinformationmanagementprocessestoensurethatdecisionmakersaccesstherelevantinformation;3)Improvethereliabilityofscientificinformationpresentedtopolicymakers;4)Understandandeffectivelycommunicatetheconsequencesofinactiononenvironmentalissues;and5)Encourageinterdisciplinaryapproaches,thatincludeinformationmanagement,inthepracticeandstudyofintegratedcoastalandoceanmanagement.

Page 31: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Posterpresentations

30

DilutedBitumenSpillsintheBayofFundyandGreaterGulfofMaine:anupdateonthescientificandtechnologicalchallengesWells,P.,Stewart,I.Presentedby:Wells,P.([email protected])Safetransportationofdilutedbitumen(dilbit)onlandandseaalreadyposescriticalscientificandtechnicalchallengesforthefurthersustainabledevelopmentofCanada’soilindustry,andtheproposedEnergyEastpipeline(fromAlbertatoSaintJohn,NB)wouldseesubstantialincreasesintankertrafficofdibitintheBayofFundyandthegreaterGulfofMaine.Scientificknowledgeofthedistinctivebehaviourofdilbit(comparedtootherhydrocarbons)whenreleasedintomarineenvironmentsisevolving,althoughinterpretationofthatinformationhasvaried,ashaveclaimsregardingourtechnologicalcapacityformitigatingenvironmentalimpactsofdilbitspills.Thispaperwillpresentanupdateonwhatscientificconsensushasemergedintherecentliterature,andindicateremainingareasofuncertaintyandconcernthatarerelevantinparticulartotheregion’secosystemsandcommunities.Structuraluncertaintyanddatalimitedecosystem-basedmanagementoftheGeorgesBanksocial-ecologicalsystemWildermuth,R.,Fay,G.,Gaichas,S.Presentedby:Wildermuth,R.([email protected])Ecosystem-basedmanagementrequiresmakinginformeddecisionsaboutsystemsthatmeetmultiplesocial,economic,andenvironmentalobjectives.Limitedsamplingofmarinesocial-ecologicalsystemsoftenrestrictsapplicationsofquantitativemodels.However,qualitativemodelsinformmanagementdecisionsusingexpertknowledge.Additionally,uncertaintyabouttheunderlyingsystemstructureaffectsmodelestimatesandresultingconclusionsaboutpotentialmanagementactions.WeapplyqualitativeloopanalysistoassesssensitivitytostructuraluncertaintywithintheGeorgesBanksocial-ecologicalsystem.ThisworkparallelsmodelsdevelopedfortheGulfofMainesystemaspartoftheICESWorkingGroupontheNorthwestAtlanticRegionalSea.Loopanalysisdefinesinteractionsaspresenceofpositiveornegativecausalrelationshipsbetweensystemcomponents.Theseanalysesprovideinferenceaboutthecascadingeffectsofincreasedpressurestocertainsystemcomponents.WecomparesensitivityoftwomanagementscenariosinabasemodeltotwoalternatestructuresoftheGeorgesBanksystem:additionallowertrophicinteractions,andincreasedsocioeconomiccomplexity.Weevaluateeachscenario-structurecombinationbysummarizingsystemresponsestoperturbationandcomparingresponsestostatedmanagementobjectives.Ourapproachdemonstrates1)theabilitytoinvestigatethedynamicsoftheGeorgesBanksocial-ecologicalsystemusingqualitativemodels,2)expectedtradeoffsamongpotentiallyconflictingecosystem-basedmanagementobjectives,and3)effectsofuncertaintyinsystemstructureonmodeloutcomesandassociatedmanagementimplications.

Page 32: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

Posterpresentations

31

Long-termchangesintheChickDiet,GrowthandFledglingSuccessofThreeStrenaspp.inResponsetoChangingClimaticConditionsintheGulfofMaineYakola,K.,Staudinger,M.,Jordaan,A.,Kress,S.,&Shannon,P.Presentedby:Yakola,K.([email protected])Environmentalandecologicalchangessuchasvariabilityinoceantemperaturesandpreyavailabilityarenegativelyaffectingmanymarinepopulationsglobally.Indeed,intheGulfofMaine(GOM)whereseasurfacetemperaturesarerapidlyrising,climatechangepresentsanewsetofconservationchallenges.TheNationalAudubonSeabirdRestorationProgramhascollectedover25yearsofdataonnestingseabirdsonsevenislandsintheGOM,includingtheMaineCoastalIslandsNationalWildlifeRefuge.Thistime-serieshasnotyetbeenfullyexploredandpresentsanexceptionalopportunitytostudyhowanincreasinglyvariableecosystemandclimateareaffectingthreemigratoryseabirdspeciesofhighconservationconcern:thefederallyendangeredRoseateTernSternadougalii,CommonTernS.hirundo,andArcticTernS.paradisaea.Wewillusethislong-termdatasettoquantifychangesinpopulationdynamicsinresponsetophysicalchangesintheenvironmentandtoevaluatehowthecompositionofchickdietsinfluenceschickgrowthandsurvival.Inaddition,wewillexplorethepotentialforphenologicalmismatchesbetweenthetimingofchickrearingandpeaksinprimarypreyabundance.Resultsareanticipatedtoincreasetheunderstandingofhowcross-trophic-levelinteractionsandchangingenvironmentalconditionsareimpactingSternapopulationsatthecolonyandregionallevelsintheGOM,andtoincreasethepredictivecapacityofpopulationviabilitymodelssupportingconservationdecisionsandactions.

Page 33: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

32

GettingtotheRARGOMAnnualScienceMeetingMeetingLocation:RedhookBrewery1RedhookWay,Portsmouth,NH03801Phone:(603)430-8600DRIVINGFromsouth:TakeI-95NUsetheleft2lanestotakeexit4forUS-4/NH-16towardWhiteMts1.8miFromnorth:TakeI-95STakeexit5forUS-4/NH-16towardNewington/DoverSamefromnorthandsouth:ContinueontoNH-16N/US-4W0.5miTakeexit1forGoslingRdtowardPeaseInternationalTradeport0.3miTurnleftatendoframpontoGoslingRd./NewingtonSt.Usetheleft2lanestoturnleftontoInternationalDr0.2miTurnleftontoCorporateDr0.2miTurnleftontoRedhookWay

Page 34: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

33

PresentingauthoraffiliationsandcontactinformationName Affiliation ContactBelknap,Samuel UniversityofMaine [email protected],Andrea WoodsHoleOceanographicInstitution [email protected],Christian UniversityofMaine [email protected],Mary UniversityofNewHampshire [email protected],Mila UMassAmherst [email protected]

Carr,MegUniversityofNewHampshireandShoalsMarineLaboratory [email protected]

Charles,Anthony SaintMary’sUniversity [email protected],Kelly UniversityofMaine [email protected],LeAnn UniversityofMaine [email protected],Kate UniversityofMaine [email protected],Rachel NewEnglandFisheryManagementCouncil [email protected],Bradley GulfofMaineResearchInstitute [email protected],Benjamin Univ.ofNewHampshireSeaGrant [email protected],Parker UniversityofMaine [email protected],Jason WellsNationalEstuarineResearchReserve [email protected],Les BostonUniversity [email protected],Heather UniversityofMaine [email protected],Mackenzie UniversityofMaine [email protected],Christopher TheNatureConservancy [email protected],Katherine GulfofMaineResearchInstitute [email protected]

Ozmon,IvyMaineCoastalProgram,Dept.ofAgriculture,Conservation,andForestry [email protected]

Parlee,Kathryn EnvironmentandClimateChangeCanada,RegionalAnalysisandRelations

[email protected]

Powers,Kevin StellwagenBankNationalMarineSanctuary [email protected],Sara UniversityofMaine [email protected],Max UniversityofMaine [email protected],Mattie UniversityofMaine [email protected],Jocelyn UniversityofMaine [email protected],Liberty UMassDartmouth [email protected],Lauren UniversityofNewBrunswick [email protected]

Staudinger,Michelle DepartmentoftheInteriorNortheastClimateScienceCenter

[email protected]

Stephenson,Rob DFOCanada,[email protected]

Stoll,Joshua UniversityofMaine [email protected],Aaron UniversityofMaine [email protected],Kisei UniversityofMaine [email protected],Peter WaterviewConsulting [email protected],David UniversityofMaine [email protected],George CornellUniversity,ShoalsMarineLab [email protected],Page USGSWoodsHole [email protected]

Page 35: RARGOM Annual Science Meeting...changes in fishing effort, profits, and aggregate economic impact under different warming scenarios. Ultimately, our results will facilitate discussion

34

Wang,Lifei GulfofMaineResearchInstitute [email protected],Peter DalhousieUniversity [email protected],Robert UMassDartmouth [email protected],David StellwagenBankNationalMarineSanctuary [email protected],Megan UMassDartmouth [email protected],Keenan UMassAmherst [email protected],Peter SeaPlan [email protected]