RANKING - eaton.com
Transcript of RANKING - eaton.com
Q2 / 2007 // ETHISPHERE 019www.ethisphere.com
feature
Ethisphere Magazine recognizes and rewards ethical leadership
and business practices worldwide
RANKING
Q2 / 2007 // ETHISPHERE 019
020 ETHISPHERE // Q2 / 2007 www.ethisphere.com
feature
The absolutes are the necessary grounding for a company to have strong core values to build upon. The context is the environment in which a company operates, both geographically as well as industrially.
The best lens through which to view a company’s ethical leadership behavior is to examine a company compared to other companies in the same industry. Are they leading, are they following, or are they ignoring? And to be a leader, the company needs to have or build a com-petitive edge, such as size or technology, which allows it to be infl uential.
In assembling the 2007 rankings of the World’s Most Ethical Companies, the researchers and editors of Ethisphere examined more than 5,000 companies across 30 separate industries looking for true ethical leadership.
We looked for absolutes. We exam-ined companies in relational context of their industries. And we looked for infl uential leadership that moved others to change or follow.
Companies were measured in a rigor-ous eight-step process and then scored against nine distinct ethical leadership criteria. Refer to page 21 for more on the methodology or visit www.ethisphere.com/methodology to download the methodology report.
Some may ask, “How can McDonald’s be on the list?” The answer is that the food service industry is the largest industry in the world—and McDonald’s has clearly stood apart in introducing healthier food fare, sustainable packaging, food safety, and ethical purchasing practices.
Ethics are absolute. Business ethics are relational. And ethical leadership requires a position of infl uence.
What does that mean? Certainly there are absolutes to business ethics, such as respecting employees and stakeholders, competing fairly and within the law, and being a responsible corporate citizen.
Companies routinely compete for recognition for their “corporate citizen-ship” or “best place to work” award. And predictably, a select few pharmaceutical companies, a handful of consulting and high-tech fi rms, and a couple of retailers appear near the top of the list.
Those lists are based only upon absolutes.
Not surprisingly, the companies that appear on those lists usually are from high net margin industries that can afford to invest in self-promotion, and may have a more vested interest in the awards than other companies. For example, the consulting fi rm that knows it will help them in the ‘war for talent’; the pharmaceutical company that wants to blunt criticism over patent practices or high prices; or the retailer that wants to attract the higher spending ‘ethical’ demographic shopper.
Yes, many of those companies truly are ‘ethical’—but those industries represent only a minority (less than 20%) of the overall industry of global business, commerce and workforce.
What about the rest of the economy? How can we accurately examine and compare business ethics practices and leadership when we only look at a small portion of the economic landscape?
Frankly, we can’t. We need to look at the relational context.
THE WINNERS OF THE WORLD’S MOST ETHICAL COMPANIES ARE THE STANDOUTS. EACH FORCES OTHER COMPANIES TO FOLLOW ITS LEADERSHIP OR FALL BEHIND. EACH USES ETHICAL LEADERSHIP AS A PROFIT DRIVER.
The winners of the World’s Most Ethical Companies are the standouts. Each of these companies has materially higher scores versus competitors in their industries. Each forces other companies to follow its leadership or fall behind. Each uses ethical leadership as a profi t driver. And each of these companies embodies the true spirit of Ethisphere’s credo: Good. Smart. Business. Profi t.
BUSINESS.Companies that leverage relative positions of infl uence to affect positive industry change.
SMART.Companies that invest in innovation, quality and sustainable business practices that reduce resource consumption in the production or use of their products and/or increase consumer health or safety.
GOOD.Companies that proactively engage with the communities in which they serve, impact, or operate.
ETHISPHERE COUNCIL DEFINITION OF ETHICAL BUSINESS LEADERSHIP[eth-i-kul + lee-der-ship]
PROFIT.Companies that look strategically to profi t fairly from such ethical leadership business practices, as ultimately only profi t ensures continuance of desired institutional behavior.
Q2 / 2007 // ETHISPHERE 021www.ethisphere.com
METHODOLOGYThe World’s Most Ethical Companies—the 2007 Edition
The World’s Most Ethical Companies™ (WME) methodology analyzes companies that go
beyond making statements about doing business ‘ethically’, to translate those words into action.
WME winners demonstrate real and sustained ethical leadership within their industries, putting
the Council’s credo of “Good. Smart. Business. Profi t.” into real business practice.
Steps 1-6 narrowed the candidates to a select few per industry (Award Finalists), which were then notifi ed of their candidacy.
Step 7 consisted of examining outside ethics stakeholders’ reputation and perception of each of the fi nalist companies. This includes sending ethics audit letters to customers and suppliers, and getting input and opinions from nearly two dozens NGOs and Socially Responsible Investment (SRI) fi rms.
The fi nal Step 8 involved analyzing the company’s internal ethics and compliance systems. This involved tapping into Ethisphere’s database of information on thousands of corporations’ compliance and ethics programs, as well as having direct dialogue and surveys with the leadership of Award Finalist organizations. Step 8 is a critically important examination of how effectively each fi nalist company drives an internal cultural commitment to ethics and compliance, and how that commitment may benefi t their business.
Litigation and controversy/confl ict analysis
Ethical tone analysis
Innovation and industry leadership analysis
Corporate citizenship analysis
Pan-industry effort participation analysis
Governance and transparency analysis
Public and trade partner perception analysis
Ethics/compliance programs and systems analysis
STEP
01STEP
02STEP
03STEP
04STEP
05STEP
06STEP
07STEP
08
To gather the necessary information to measure industry leaderships against the nine criteria, Ethisphere researchers and editors screened thousands of companies across the globe through a rigorous, multi-step process. The eight separate and sequential analyses conducted were:
THE EIGHT-STEP PROCESS OF COLLECTING AND SCREENING INFORMATION
Once all the necessary information was collected, the companies were scored relative to industry peers on nine separate criteria. The analysis was segmented into 30 separate industries based on SIC Codes and given weighted scores for the nine criteria shown in the chart.
Within each industry, the companies that had a materially higher aggregate score compared to their competitors were designated as the year’s World’s Most Ethical Companies.
THE FINAL RANKING AND SCORING OF THE WORLD’S MOST ETHICAL COMPANIES
INNOVATION 10%
EXECUTIVELEADERSHIP 10%
INDUSTRYLEADERSHIP 15%
TRANSPARENCY 5%
PERCEPTION& REPUTATION 10%LEGAL &
15% REGULATORY
INTERNAL 15% SYSTEMS
15% CITIZENSHIP
5% GOVERNANCE
More detail on methodology is available at www.ethisphere.com/methodology
feature
Q2 / 2007 // ETHISPHERE 021www.ethisphere.com
022 ETHISPHERE // Q2 / 2007 www.ethisphere.com
feature
Accor // FRANCE
Marriott // UNITED STATES
Barilla Holding // ITALY
Danone // FRANCE
Kellogg // UNITED STATES
PepsiCo // UNITED STATES
Stonyfi eld Farm
// UNITED STATES
Tnuva // ISRAEL
Fluor // UNITED STATES
Trex // UNITED STATES
Duke Energy // UNITED STATES
FPL Group // UNITED STATES
Scottish & Southern Energy // UNITED KINGDOM
General Electric // UNITED STATES
Koch Industries // UNITED STATES
Tata Group // INDIA
Wesfarmers // AUSTRALIA
Hindustan Lever // INDIA
Kao // JAPAN
L’Oreal // FRANCE
Natura Cosméticos // BRAZIL
S.C. Johnson & Son // UNITED STATES
Unilever // NETHERLANDS
Paychex // UNITED STATES
Pitney Bowes // UNITED STATES
H & M Hennes & Mauritz // SWEDEN
New Balance Athletic Shoe // UNITED STATES
NIKE // UNITED STATES
Patagonia // UNITED STATES
The Gap // UNITED STATES
Timberland // UNITED STATES
RANKING
FOOD & BEVERAGE
HOTEL & HOSPITALITY
COMPUTERS & SEMICONDUCTORS
Akzo Nobel // NETHERLANDS
Ecolab // UNITED STATES
CHEMICALS
AB Volvo // SWEDEN
Johnson Controls // UNITED STATES
Modine Manufacturing // UNITED STATES
Toyota Motor // JAPAN
AUTOMOTIVE
Dunavant Enterprises // UNITED STATES
Dole Foods // UNITED STATES
AGRICULTURAL & FOOD PROCESSING
Canon // JAPAN
Royal Philips Electronics // NETHERLANDS
Sharp // JAPAN
ELECTRONICS
Bright Horizons // UNITED STATES
CONSUMER SERVICES
DIVERSIFIED INDUSTRIES
ENGINEERING & CONSTRUCTION
HSBC // UNITED KINGDOM
Rabobank Group // NETHERLANDS
Standard Chartered Bank // UNITED KINGDOM
BANKING
APPAREL
BUSINESS SERVICES
American Express // UNITED STATES
Berkshire Hathaway // UNITED STATES
PNC Financial Services // UNITED STATES
Principal Financial // UNITED STATES
FINANCIAL SERVICES
ENERGY & UTILITIESCONSUMER PRODUCTS
NEC Corp. // JAPAN
Sun Microsystems // UNITED STATES
Texas Instruments // UNITED STATES
Xerox
// UNITED STATES
Q2 / 2007 // ETHISPHERE 023www.ethisphere.com
feature
McDonald’s // UNITED STATES
Starbucks // UNITED STATES
Alcoa // UNITED STATES
Baxter International // UNITED STATES
Becton Dickinson // UNITED STATES
Kiplinger // UNITED STATES
Time Warner // UNITED STATES
Caterpillar // UNITED STATES
Danfoss // DENMARK
Deere // UNITED STATES
Eaton // UNITED STATES
Milliken & Company // UNITED STATES
Ethical leadership can and should be profi table. Through recognizing companies that pursue an ethical leadership model, the Ethisphere Council both rewards such behavior and motivates winners and other companies to strive for future recognition.
INDUSTRIAL MANUFACTURING
Genzyme // UNITED STATES
Novartis // SWITZERLAND
Novo Nordisk // DENMARK
PHARMA & BIOTECH
Google // UNITED STATES
Salesforce.com // UNITED STATES
SOFTWARE & INTERNET
United Parcel Service (UPS) // UNITED STATES
TRANSPORTATION & LOGISTICS
MEDICAL DEVICES
International Paper // UNITED STATES
MeadWestvaco // UNITED STATES
Tetra Pak // SWITZERLAND
PAPER & PACKAGING
AFLAC // UNITED STATES
GEICO // UNITED STATES
Swiss Reinsurance Company // SWITZERLAND
INSURANCE
MEDIA & ENTERTAINMENT
METALS & MINING
RESTAURANTS & CAFES
Royal Dutch/Shell // NETHERLANDS
Suncor Energy // CANADA
OIL & GAS TELECOM
Q2 / 2007 // ETHISPHERE 023www.ethisphere.com
RETAIL
AEON // JAPAN
Aldi Group // GERMANY
Costco Wholesale // UNITED STATES
IKEA // SWEDEN
Marks & Spencer // UNITED KINGDOM
Otto GmbH & Co // GERMANY
Target // UNITED STATES
Wegmans Food Markets // UNITED STATES
Whole Foods Market // UNITED STATES
Avaya
// UNITED STATES
Nokia // FINLAND
Vodafone // UNITED KINGDOM
024 ETHISPHERE // Q2 / 2007 www.ethisphere.com
When we spoke to Knight Kiplinger about the company his grandfather started, his pride, dedication and passion was obvious. When Kiplinger speaks
about the ethical culture of the company, he emphasizes that they “go the extra mile for their clients and their employees.” Founder W.M. Kiplinger, a social liberal and economic conservative of the 1920s, believed in communal capitalism within his company and shared his success with his employees by giving company stock to employees, among other great benefi ts.
Like many publishers today, Kiplinger is facing tougher times, but believes that “in the more diffi cult of times, the belt tightening should start at the top rather than at the bottom.” Setting the ethical tone at the top, Kiplinger maintains the idea that “we are all in this together” by freezing executive bonuses instead of cutting jobs. “It’s easy for a company to act generously and ethically during boom times. It’s when diffi cult times come that you see how a company truly is.”
Maintaining trust with non-employee family shareholders is also of great importance to Kiplinger. “Our company is a model of how to deal ethically with family members that don’t work in the business but have a stake within the business,” says Kiplinger. In the midst of maintaining company stability and sustainability, Kiplinger upholds its responsibility to its readers and will oftentimes reject ads that are of little or no value to its readers.
KNIGHT KIPLINGERPresident & Editor-in-Chief
Sandy Cutler, CEO of Eaton Corporation, spoke in great detail about the basic beliefs that make Eaton a value-based com-pany. These core values
have allowed Eaton to maintain a strong foundation and sense of stability during recent internal changes and mergers. Rather than approaching ethics as a compliance issue, Cutler believes, “It’s about doing business right through internal philosophies and customer commitments. We’ll lose business before we will compromise our values.”
Eaton employs 61,000 people in 125 countries, and almost all of their products target helping people and companies effectively use energy. For example, Eaton developed a technology with the EPA for UPS, that allowed the shipping company to save 70% in fuel economy. Additionally, Eaton developed a hybrid electric bus technology for possible use during the Beijing Olympics.
Eaton places high value on contribu-tions in the workplace and community, believing they are key components for doing business right. “People will work where the company and the community involvement values refl ect their own,” insists Cutler. Every employee at Eaton has the opportunity to raise questions if they believe their personal morals are at risk. If a company is committed to doing business ethically, “you can cut the top off and the bottom would keep working,” maintains Cutler.
SANDY CUTLERCEO
Perry Minnis is the Director of Global Ethics & Compliance for Alcoa, a metals and mining company with over 120,000 employees in 44 countries.
Minnis, who started with Alcoa in fi nance 39 years ago, runs the Global Ethics & Compliance department to track metrics and determine if the company has a positive impact on the community. According to Minnis, “Our management has a very strong focus on safety. Alcoa is considered to be one of the safest corporations in the world.” The company’s Ethics and Compliance Council, which includes the CEO, vice presidents, and department directors, was formed in order to notify all executives of the latest in operations. The Council presents fi ndings to the Board on a quarterly basis.
Minnis told us that Alcoa’s Code of Conduct has been condensed to apply to specifi c roles and translated into different languages in order to make it an effective tool for all employees. The Code is also provided to suppliers, so they understand Alcoa’s expectations and policies. “If a vendor’s values or policies differ drasti-cally from Alcoa, chances are they won’t be doing business with us,” emphasizes Minnis. He continues, “The most important thing is our values. We have a set of values and policies that is consistent across the company, and we train all employees to adhere to and uphold those values.”
PERRY MINNISDirector of Global Ethics & Compliance
spotlightON SELECTED WINNERS
As part of the 2007 Word’s Most Ethical Companies analysis, Ethisphere Council researchers interviewed dozens and dozens of companies in great depth about their compliance and ethics activities. This included talking to “both” CEOs (the Chief Executive Offi cer and the Chief Ethics Offi cer) in most cases. Following are some excerpts and reports from selected companies that we found particularly worth highlighting.
feature
Q2 / 2007 // ETHISPHERE 025www.ethisphere.com
feature
In business for 170 years, John Deere prides itself on enabling “human fl ourishing.” With core values of integrity, quality, innovation and commit-
ment, the company provides advanced products and services for agriculture, forestry, construction and landscaping, as well as manufacturing engines for use in heavy equipment. James R. Jenkins, Senior VP and General Counsel for Deere & Company, told us “John Deere fully recognizes the need to conduct business with integrity. Our broad approach to citizenship, coupled with market leadership, helps us improve the world while growing a business.”
Deere believes in creating and distributing service in ways that respect the earth’s limited resources while providing safe and healthy work-places to help employees develop to their full potential. Deere continually reinforc-es its commitment to helping fi nd policy solutions that benefi t the environment. “We believe that effective policy to address global climate change must include development and support of renewable energy sources including agricultural, forestry, wind and bio-technologies, as well as processing and distribution improvements,” says Jenkins.
With a passionate commitment to doing what is right and operating ethically, John Deere makes their conduct guidelines transparent to employees, customers, and suppliers. Acting out of principled, long-term self-interest, Deere contributes to the greater good by supporting the quality of life in their com-munities, protecting the environment and preserving precious resources. According to Jenkins, “We believe that exceptional performance will not be sustainable if it is at the expense of our values.”
When we spoke to Neil Nyberg, VP of Ethics & Compliance and Gary Pilnick, General Counsel for Kellogg’s, they declared, “W.K. Kellogg believed in
doing things the right way and built this company on integrity.” In business for 100 years, Kellogg’s has taken pride in its ethics and compliance program known as “K Values.” According to Pilnick, “It starts with the values, which guide behavior and ethical choices.”
Founder W.K. Kellogg wanted to do good things for people, starting with nutrition and the environment, and began promoting environmentally-friendly processes by producing the fi rst boxes of cereal in recycled packaging in 1906. Today, Kellogg’s uses 100% recycled packaging. In addition, Kellogg’s created a Social Responsibility Committee in 1979 that now deals with environmental concerns, health & safety, addiction and abuse, and other issues that impact employees and communities.
According to Nyberg, culture and diversity truly matter. “We see ourselves as role models. Our commitment to ethics is absolutely non-negotiable.” Kellogg’s recently received an award from the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People for diversity in compliance and ethics. Kellogg’s is also the 2007 national sponsor for Race for the Cure, and has a comprehensive program for United Way’s Days of Caring, in which the entire company donates time. “You can tell in the eyes of the employees that it is a great reminder of what we have and how lucky we are,” says Nyberg.
We spoke with Brackett Denniston, General Coun-sel for General Electric about creating an ethical culture and maintaining strong compliance programs.
Denniston believes “a good company thinks about its human side,” and how people are impacted by business practices. To answer the needs of employees and communities, GE is active in organizations like NAFTA and the National Electrical Manufacturers Association, and is a founder of Transparency International, a global society that fi ghts the impact of corruption on people worldwide. “You have to act like a leader, be a leader, and be aware of the impact of your actions and how they affect hundreds of thousands of people,” says Denniston.
GE dates back to 1892 and carefully considers the social impact of its prod-ucts and operations on the communities in which it operates. From jet engines to household appliances and fi nancial services to plastics, General Electric is dedicated to converting ideas into lead-ing products to help solve the world’s challenges. Compliance and governance challenges are equally important to GE and remain non-negotiable aspects of operations. “A strong compliance practice begins with the basics of incorporating good citizenship into the company culture,” says Denniston.
NEIL NYBERG, VP, Ethics & ComplianceGARY PILNICK, General Counsel
BRACKETT DENNISTONGeneral Counsel
JAMES R. JENKINS,Senior Vice President and General Counsel
026 ETHISPHERE // Q2 / 2007 www.ethisphere.com
with high potential for growth and profi tability. Companies that maximize the potential of all their employees, including women, are more likely to be successful in this competitive global market over the long term. For information, call 888.552.9363 or e-mail [email protected].
THE CENTER FOR BUSINESS
ETHICS (www.stthom.edu/academics/centers/cbes) at the University of St. Thomas works with the corporate community
to help business people and students make good choices that will benefi t themselves, their businesses, and their community. CBES offers ethical leadership training programs and other business ethics programming. The Center is business-friendly. We believe that companies and managers have an ethical duty to protect stakeholders, including shareholders and their property rights. We recognize the important role business institutions play in developing and maintaining a democratic system. CBES also explores the effects of individual and corporate actions upon others, including the more mar-ginal members of the community.
THE NEW ALTERNATIVES FUND (www.newalternativesfund.com) began operation in September 1982 as the fi rst environmental mutual fund with a signifi cant operation in alternative energy. We seek to be affi rmatively socially responsible by selecting companies that produce something that benefi ts the environment, including alternative energy, recycling, clean air and water, pollution prevention and conservation. Our environmentally oriented investments are positive forms of social investment.
WINSLOW MANAGEMENT COMPANY, LLC. (www.winslowgreen.com) is a registered investment advisor based in Boston, Massachusetts. Winslow has practiced green investing since 1983, and its client portfolios are composed of public companies that develop environmental solutions and companies with clean environmental operations. Winslow spe-cializes in small-cap growth equity investing and employs a proprietary research process that integrates fi nancial, environmental and governance analysis. The fi rm offers the Winslow Green Growth Fund (WGGFX), a green small-cap growth mutual fund; a hedge fund (open to qualifi ed investors); and separately managed accounts for individuals, endowments, corporate pension plans, foundations and other institutions.
FORESTETHICS (www.forestethics.org) was founded in 1994 and is a nonprofi t environ-mental organization with staff in Canada, the United States and Chile. Our mission is to protect endangered forests. By high-profi le, public campaign work or private work behind the scenes, we show companies such as Limited Brands, Staples, Home Depot, Dell and Williams-Sonoma how they can help protect endangered forests through forest ethics that guide their purchases of wood and paper products. These forest ethics include excluding endangered forest material from the supply chain, preferring Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) certifi ed products, increasing post-consumer recycled content and choosing paper products containing processed chlorine-free fi ber. We believe that protecting forests is everyone’s business.
THE WOMEN’S EQUITY FUND (www.womens-equity.com) was created in 1993 to broaden the participation and collective invest-
ing power of individual investors to advance the social and economic status of women in the workplace. We believe that by screening for companies with positive policies on behalf of women, we are selecting those companies
The editors of Ethisphere Magazine and the researchers for the 2007 World’s Most Ethical Companies ranking want to thank the following organizations for generously taking the time and effort to review the fi nalists for this year’s awards, and providing feedback on which companies merit recognition for their ethical leadership practices.
SUSTAINABILITY (www.sustainability.com) is a hybrid strategy consultancy and think tank. Our mission is to inspire and support the innovation that creates tomorrow’s values. We combine rigorous business insight with in-depth knowledge of the sustainability agenda in global markets, including the emerging economies. We work with business leaders to identify and manage key sustainability risks and opportunities. We are focused on six sectors: chemicals, capital markets and fi nance, energy, food and beverages, healthcare and the knowledge economy. For more information, contact Seb Beloe at +44 207 269 6900.
THE WORLD BUSINESS COUNCIL FOR
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT (www.wbcsd.org) is a CEO-led, global association of some 190 companies, dealing exclusively with business and sustainable development. The Council provides a platform for companies to explore sustainable development, share knowledge, experiences and best practices, and to advocate business positions on these issues in a variety of forums, working with governments, non-governmental and intergovernmental organizations. Members are drawn from more than 35 countries and 20 major industrial sectors. The Council also benefi ts from a global network of 55+ national and regional business councils and regional partners.
TRILLIUM ASSET MANAGEMENT
CORPORATION (www.trilliuminvest.com) has been a leader in socially responsible investing for over
twenty-fi ve years. We are guided by a belief that active investing can offer good returns to the investor, while also promoting social and economic justice. Trillium Asset Manage-ment is an independent employee-owned fi rm, dedicated to professional, high quality, individualized service for our valued clients. Our professional staff, in four offi ces across the country, carries on a mission started in 1982: To help our clients meet their fi nancial goals and have a positive impact on society through socially responsible investing.
thankYOU
feature