Randomized Trial of a Clinical Decision Support System
16
Randomized Trial of a Clinical Decision Support System: JOLT ROUKEMA, MD, PHD, EWOUT W. STEYERBERG, PHD, JOHAN VAN DER LEI, MD, PHD, HENRIËTTE A. MOLL, MD, PHD Impact on the Management of Children with Fever without Apparent Source J Am Med Inform Assoc. 2008;15:107–113. Speaker : Yen-Chih Huang Advisor : Yu-Chuan Li
Transcript of Randomized Trial of a Clinical Decision Support System
Randomized Trial of a Clinical Decision Support System:
JOLT ROUKEMA, MD, PHD, EWOUT W. STEYERBERG, PHD, JOHAN VAN DER LEI, MD, PHD, HENRIËTTE A. MOLL, MD, PHD
Impact on the Management of Children with Fever without Apparent Source
J Am Med Inform Assoc. 2008;15:107–113.
Speaker : Yen-Chih Huang Advisor : Yu-Chuan Li
Introduction
Fever Without apparent Source (FWS)- body temperature ≧ 38.0 degrees Celsius- no apparent source found after evaluation
Serious Bacterial Infection (SBI)1 – 36 months Sophia Children’s Hospital ( 2003.9.1 – 2005.12.31 )
Time spent at the ED Identified SBI
Page 2
OpenSDE
Page 3
http://www2.eur.nl/fgg/mi/OpenSDE/
Two Rules
GP-referred (general practitioner)Self-referred
Page 4
GP-referred
Page 5
Self-referred
Page 6
Page 7
1744 Febrile children, 1-36 months
1399 Eligible
683 CDSS - Registered
390 Patients with FWS
172 High risk-score & randomized( Informed consent n = 164 )
375 chronic co-morbidity
716 not registered
293 Fever with a clear source
218 Low risk-score
74 Order laboratory tests 90 Routine evaluation by physician
Methods
Randomization ( 1-1000 )- odd : intervention group (order laboratory tests)- even : control group
laboratory tests- complete blood count (CBC)- C-reactive protein (CRP)
Page 8
Measurements
ED time- arrival time ～ departure time
Serious Bacterial Infection (SBI) - culture or radiographically
Page 9
Page 10
1744 Febrile children, 1-36 months
1399 Eligible
683 CDSS - Registered
390 Patients with FWS
172 High risk-score & randomized( Informed consent n = 164 )
375 chronic co-morbidity
716 not registered
293 Fever with a clear source
218 Low risk-score
74 Order laboratory tests 90 Routine evaluation by physician
49%
57%
95% (164/172)
Results
Results
Laboratory tests:- intervention group : 82% ( 61/74 )- control group : 44% ( 40/90 )
Page 11
Results
Page 12
Results
Page 13
30 patients missing time of arrival at or departure from the ED(16 in the intervention group, 14 in the control group)
Results
Page 14
Conclusion
Time constraintsED nurses were aware the decision ruleFWS registration rate is relatively highLaboratory tests affected diagnostic testing
The prediction rules need adjustmentReduce false high-riskIncreasing the risk-score threshold
Page 15
THANK YOU ！
Page 16
九十七年十二月一日
天氣：陰
