OSHA Strategic Management Plan OSHA Strategic Management Plan
RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice...
Transcript of RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice...
![Page 1: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
RAILCARFALLPROTECTION:
EricJ.ConnHeadoftheOSHAPracticeGroupatEpsteinBecker&Green,P.C.
[email protected](202)861‐5335
WHATOSHAREQUIRESFROM GRAINELEVATOROPERATORS
December3,2013
![Page 2: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
ERICJ.CONN
istheHeadoftheOSHAPracticeGroupatEpsteinBecker&Green,wherehefocusesonallaspectsofoccupationalsafety&healthlaw:
– Representsemployersininspections,investigations&enforcementactionsinvolvingOSHA,CSB,MSHA,&EPA
– Respondstoandmanagesinvestigationsofcatastrophicindustrial,construction,andmanufacturingworkplaceaccidents,includingexplosionsandchemicalreleases
– HandlesallaspectsofOSHAlitigation,includingcriminalmatters,appealsofcitations,andnegotiationofsettlementstominimizeeffectofenforcementoncivilactionsandfutureoperations
– Conductssafetytraining&compliancecounseling
EricJ.Conn [email protected]/(202)861.5335
![Page 3: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Agenda
![Page 4: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
HistoryofRollingStockFallProtection
![Page 5: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
• Employeesmusttie‐offorbeprotectedbyguardrailswhenworkingatheightsabove4feet
• FallprotectionforworkontopofRollingStockisNOTaddressedin:– Walking‐workingsurfacesgeneralindustrystandard(SubpartD);or
– ThePPEStandard(29CFR§ 1910.132(d))
FallProtection
![Page 6: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
• NGFArequestedclarificationofOSHA’senforcementpolicyre:fallhazardsfromworkatoprailcars– IndustryconcernedthatOSHAwaswronglycitinggrainhandlers
• OSHAandindustryleadersmettofindapracticalsolution
• OSHAissuedaninternalenforcementmemotoitsRegionalAdministrators
The1996“MilesMemo”
![Page 7: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
TheMilesMemo
![Page 8: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
• Casedidnotinvolvethegrainindustry• Employeeseriouslyinjuredafterhefell10’
offatanker
truckduetowindgusts• OSHAissuedaGeneralDutyClausecitation– “expos[ed]employeestofallhazardswhentheywereworkingontopoffueltankertrucks”
• TheALJaffirmedthecitationissuedbyOSHA
EricksonAir‐Crane–
ALJDecision
![Page 9: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
EricksonAir‐CraneCaseSecretaryofLabor’sPosition:
• MilesMemoreferencetorollingstockpositionedinsideorcontiguoustobuildingwhereinstallationoffallprotectionisfeasibleputemployeronnoticethatithadtoprovidefallprotection
– Thetankerhadbracketstoholdahelicopterbladeboxinplace,whichcouldalsosecurefallprotectionequipment
• Employershouldhaverealizedthat,soequipped,itstankerwasessentiallylocatedinsideoforcontiguoustoastructurethatcouldsupportfallprotectionequipment
Employer’sPosition:
• BasedonguidancefromMilesMemo,itlackednoticethatfallprotectionwasrequired;and
• ItcannotbeheldinviolationoftheOSHActifitfailedtoreceivepriornoticeoftheconductrequiredofit
![Page 10: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
• OSHRCfoundthattheMilesMemodid putemployersonnoticeofadutytousefallprotecti
onorproviderelatedtraining
• But,theCommissionemphasized2elementsfromtheMilesMemo:– BroadexemptionofallrollingstockfromOSHA’sfallprotectionrequirements(exceptforrollingstocklocatedinsideofornexttoabuilding);and
– UndertheGDC,OSHAonlyrequiresadministrativecontrolstoreducefallhazards,whicharedistinct
from
thefallprotectionequipmentsoughtbytheSecretary
EricksonAir‐Crane‐
OSHRCDecision
![Page 11: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
EricksonAir‐CraneDecision
“[T]hepolicydescribedinthe[MilesMemo]regardingtheenforcementofsubpartD,thePPEstandard,andthegeneraldutyclauseasappliedtotankertrucks[or
railcars]thatarenotadjacenttoabuildingorstructureisconsistent–
theuseoffall
protectionequipmentisnotconsideredfeasibleandthus,arenotrequiredunder
anyoneoftheseprovisions.”
“[T]hepolicydescribedinthe[MilesMemo]regardingtheenforcementofsubpartD,thePPEstandard,andthegeneraldutyclauseasappliedtotankertrucks[or
railcars]thatarenotadjacenttoabuildingorstructureisconsistent–
theuseoffall
protectionequipmentisnotconsideredfeasibleandthus,arenotrequiredunder
anyoneoftheseprovisions.”
![Page 12: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
• TheEricksonAir‐CanedecisionreinforcedthattheMilesMemo:– RemainsOSHA’sbindingandofficialinterpretationofthelawasitrelatestofallprotectionontopofrollingstock;and
– Appliestocircumstancesbeyondjustgraininspectorswhohavetoinspectrailcarsdowntrack
• ThefactthatsomeOSHAAreaOfficescontinueissuingcitationscontrarytotheMilesMemodoesNOTchangethelaw
EricksonAir‐CraneDecision
![Page 13: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
• DespiteErickson
,someOSHAAreaOfficesstillissuecitationscontrarytotheMilesMemo– AdherencetotheMilesMemovariesbetweeneachareaoffice,region,andadministration
• Someonlyissuecitationsinsideloadingareascontiguoustotheelevator
• Othersissuecitationsoutsidetheloadingzone
OSHA’sEnforcementAgenda
![Page 14: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
• July2011:OSHAcitedUSDA’sFGISforlackoffallprotectionontopofrailcar– FGISperforminggraininspectionservicesatgrainfacilityinTexas
– FGISemployeesallegedlydidnot:• Conductproper“hazardassessments”beforeworkingontopofrailcars;and
• ReceiveadequatetraininginhowtousePPEwhileoncar
– Citationbasedonemployeeinterview
FGISCitation
![Page 15: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
• OSHAwithdrawrollingstockfallprotectioncitationbutkeptPPEtrainingcitations
• FGIShasagreedto:– Reviewandmodifyitsrollingstockfailprotectiontrainingprograms;
– Develop“scenarios”
thatincludedifferenttypesoffacilities,equipment,andoperationstodetermineiffallprotectionisfeasible;and
– Revisedemployeedirectiveduetobecompletedbytheendofthisyear(2013)
OSHA– FGISSettlement
![Page 16: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
• May24,2010:OSHApublishedNPRMtorevisetheWalkingWorkingSurfacesStandard
• NPRM:TheMilesMemo“didnotresultincleardirectiontothepublicortoOSHA”
• NotincludedonDOL's2013FallRegulatoryAgenda(i.e.,itisnotcomingsoon)
• OSHAalsoindicateditwouldproposeseparaterollingstockfallprotectionrule
NPRMWalking‐WorkingSurfaces
![Page 17: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
NPRMWalking‐WorkingSurfaces
![Page 18: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
1. Inyourestablishmentorindustry,howmanyorwhatpercentageofemployeesworkingontopofrollingstockareexposedtofallhazards?
2. Howaretheseemployeesprotectedfromfallhazardswhileworkingonsuchequipment?
3. Ifemployeetrainingontherecognitionoffallhazardsisprovided inyourworkplace,describethenatureandfrequencyofthetraining.
4.
Iffallprotectionequipmentisused,pleaseprovidedetailedinformationonthetypesandcostsofthefallprotectionusedonrollingstockandpleaseexplainhowitisused.
5. Iffallprotectionequipmentisnotused,pleaseexplainwhattechnologicaland/oreconomicobstaclestosuchusemaybeinvolved.
6. Aretherealternativemeanstoprotectemployeesfromfallhazardswhileworkingonrollingstock?Pleaseexplain.
7. Whatisyoursafetyexperiencew/fallhazardson/fromrollingstock?8. ShouldOSHAexcluderollingstockfromcoverageundersubpartD?
NPRMQuestionsre:RollingStockFallProtection
![Page 19: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Performallrailcarworkunderfallprotectioniffeasible
Ifnotfeasible,providefallprotectionforworkonrailcarslocatednexttotheelevator
Forworkonrailcarsawayfromtheelevator,implementasetofadministrativecontrols,suchas:
– Blue‐flag/isolatetrackstoensurecarsarenotmovedwithworkersontop
– Employeesareprohibitedfromworkingontopofrailcarsininclementweather(snow/ice/highwinds)
– Trainemployeesonproperwaystoclimbontocars(i.e.,three‐pointsofcontactwithoutcarryinganything)
– Requireallworktobedonefromtherailcar’scatwalk
RecommendedPractices
PhotocourtesyofFallProtectionSystems,Inc.
![Page 20: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Ifyoucannotperformallworkunderafallprotection system,document
aPPEHazardAssessmentthat:
• Recognizesthefallhazardforworkontopofrailcars;• Explainsthefacility’srailcarfallprotectionpolicy&administrativecontrolstoaddressthefallhazard
• Explainswhere/why/whenitisnotfeasibletousefallprotection
Considerhavingafeasibilityanalysisperformedundertheprotectionoftheattorney‐clientprivilege
Trainandenforcebydiscipline
Bepreparedtochallengecitations
RecommendedPractices
![Page 21: RAILCAR FALL PROTECTION - GrainnetRAILCAR FALL PROTECTION: Eric J. Conn Head of the OSHA Practice Group. at Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. econn@ebglaw.com (202) 861 ‐ 5335. WHAT OSHA](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042221/5ec739e1e52bd9124d44029b/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
QUESTIONS?
PhotocourtesyofFallProtectionSystems,Inc.