Queensland Heritage Act 1992 - qld.gov.au · clear finished joinery, including built-in timber...

Place name Feniton 388 and 404 Bowen Terrace

BRISBANE CITY COUNCIL

Address

LGA

RPD 13 RP54676 2 RP54676

/

kh // /̂7 /'

/ , 4,444.24

0 SUP22/

2 122553126

420.-

R1.5'832P

2.24. 921110430 41.

mumps

;>`,. / N

N0/ /

/

01.2.10. Mister Lourdes, **Mains allot Lol 13 RP541576 and ssIsnda into

/ .10

Lot2 RPS1076 tn an ENE seer., from ttre south CM.. or Ms Nam. Irttersectin. tho .0u211-easlam seem of Lot 13 RPSOSZE

N E 504250.621. N 6981984.17E and Ow

n0201-.0.1 sosnt el .12 ROSS670 N \ E 50,1277.21E,N 6901271.171.

I

Feniton 650078

Figure 2: 650078 - Feniton - Map 2 -square (2018) (see attached map)

Heritage Recommendation 650078 Queensland Heritage Act 1992

Under delegation from the Chief Executive, Department of Environment and Science, and under the provisions of s.44 of the Queensland Heritage Act 1992, I, Chief Executive:

Recommend t En er this place in the Queensland Heritage Register as a State Heritage Plac

Recommendation Date: 30-Apr-2018 Delegate Nay/Position Del gated Authority, Tony Roberts

Figure 1: Feniton front (southwest) elevation

Queensland Theme(s) 06.04 Building settlements, towns, cities and dwellings: Dwellings

Prepared by Heritage, Department of Environment and Science_27-Apr-2018 1

, NEW FARM, 4005

Statement of Significance Criterion A

The place is important indemonstrating the evolution orpat tern of Queensland'shistory

Feniton (1906-7), a surviving example of nationally acclaimedarchitect Robert Smith (Robin) Dods’ ‘first quality’ suburban timberhouses from the middle period of Hall & Dods’ practice 1901-09, isimportant in demonstrating Dods’ contribution to the evolution ofQueensland’s architecture.

As a substantial, architect-designed house, which was constructed for John Elworthy Trude, a director and local manager for Australian tea merchants Atcherley and Dawson, and set in a large garden, Feniton is important in demonstrating the lifestyle of Brisbane's prosperous elite in the inner suburbs of Brisbane during the early 20th century.

Criterion D

The place is important indemonstrating the principalcharacteristics of a particularclass of cultural places

Feniton, a substantial residence designed by influential architectRobin Dods, is a fine, largely intact example of Dods’ high qualityresidential work, which is characterised by a pervading sense oftradition, solidity, and an honest use of materials. It is important indemonstrating the principal characteristics of that work, retainingits steep, hipped, dominant roof; pedimented gables; generousverandahs and carefully orientated piazza with a northeast aspect;oversized timber elements and openings; mitred weatherboards;pleasing proportions and restrained decoration; and finely-detailed,clear finished joinery, including built-in timber furniture. Its siting,detailing and unconventional but rational planning optimise views,cross ventilation and solar orientation.

Criterion E

The p lace i s impor tan tbecause of i ts aesthet icsignificance

Sited well back from Bowen Terrace, with views to and fromprovided across a large and attractive garden setting, Feniton isimportant for its Federation aesthetic, successfully combining Artsand Crafts and Classical elements in a pleasingly proportionedasymmetrical highset house with dominant roof, wide verandahs,piazza with a northeast aspect, and visually firm connection to theground. Largely intact, it demonstrates, internally and externally,fine architectural quality and skilful arrangement of generous andrefined formal and informal spaces that evoke a sense of anearlier, gracious lifestyle.

Criterion H

The place has a specialassociation with the life orwork of a particular person,group or organisat ion ofimportance in Queensland'shistory

Feniton, occupied by Edward Granville ‘Red Ted’ Theodore (1884-1950) as his family home from 1916 to 1927, has a specialassociation with the life and work of Theodore as his place ofresidence and work when he was Premier of Queensland (1919-25). Theodore renamed Feniton ‘Almaden’, after the site of a strikevictory during his union career. As Premier, Theodore implementedimportant social, industrial and constitutional reforms inQueensland, including state intervention in the economy andcompleting Labor’s campaign to abolish Queensland’s LegislativeCouncil, and is a person of importance in Queensland’s history.

650078Feniton

Assessment of significance


History The highset timber residence located at 388 Bowen Terrace, New Farm, originally called Feniton and later Almaden, was built on just over half an acre (approximately 2036m2) ofland in 1906-7 for the Trude family. Designed by the renowned architect Robert Smith(Robin) Dods, the residence was subsequently occupied from 1916-27 by Edward GranvilleTheodore, Premier of Queensland from 1919-25. The property was reduced by one third in1938, and in 2018 Feniton remains a private residence. Feniton is a surviving example ofDods’ first quality timber houses from the middle period of Hall & Dods’ practice 1901-09.With its generous setback and views to and from Bowen Terrace, the house is important forits Federation aesthetic, successfully combining Arts and Crafts and Classical elements, andalso has a special association with EG Theodore, a person of importance in Queensland’shistory. The New Farm area was traditionally the land of the Jagera and Turrbal peoples. After theMoreton Bay penal settlement was established on the Brisbane River in 1825, in the late1820s food was grown on the river flats between today’s Merthyr Road and the southeastend of the New Farm peninsula.[1] Following free settlement of Brisbane in 1842, the New Farm peninsula was surveyed andsold in the 1840s for cultivation and livestock, as well as residences for Queensland’spastoralists, merchants and politicians. In the late 1850s, subdivision of allotmentsoverlooking the Shafston Reach of the Brisbane River, at the northwest end of BowenTerrace, resulted in the construction of villas for Brisbane’s business leaders during the1860s, and more of Brisbane’s wealthy inhabitants moved to New Farm in the 1870s.[2] Thesubdivision of New Farm intensified during the 1880s, and transport improvements alsoencouraged closer residential settlement. Horse-drawn trams ran along Brunswick Street tojust past Langshaw Street by 1895, and the electrification of this line occurred in 1897.[3] Despite subdivision into smaller allotments, the area of New Farm between Brunswick Streetand the Shafston Reach maintained grand homes on properties covering multiplesubdivisions. Described in 1906 as the province of ‘the attractive homes and trim gardens ofmany of Brisbane’s most distinguished citizens, who enjoy all the advantages of country airand surroundings within a twopenny tram ride of the city proper’, Bowen Terrace and MorayStreet included affluent residents drawn from the judiciary, politics, civil service, the churchand business.[4] Feniton was one such residence. The site of Feniton was once part of Eastern Suburban Allotment 15, a block of 4.6haextending from Brunswick Street southwest to the Brisbane River, which was subdivided in1874 as part of the Langshaw Estate – advertised as occupying ‘the very finest positionabout the city or suburbs for gentlemen’s Villa Residences’.[5] After passing through thehands of various owners from 1875, three subdivisions of the estate, totalling 3 roods and 34perches (3895m2), were by October 1881 consolidated under the ownership of Henry JamesOxley, a well-known Brisbane accountant.[6] By July 1880 Oxley had built his home Mossleigh at the north corner of Bowen Terrace andLangshaw Street, with the remainder of his property, to the northwest, used as his garden.After Oxley’s mortgagee obtained the property in 1905, just over half an acre – 2 roods andhalf a perch (2036m2) – of Mossleigh’s garden was sold to John Elworthy Trude in 1906.[7]

Trude (1869-1952) was born in Poughill, Devon, England, and by April 1891 he was workingin Brisbane as the local manager for Australian tea merchants Atcherley and Dawson. InJuly 1906 he married Phyllis Emlyn Gore, a member of the pioneering pastoralist family ofYandilla Station on the Darling Downs.[8]

650078Feniton



The Trude’s new house at 388 Bowen Terrace was named Feniton, after Phyllis’ familyhome at Yandilla and an earlier Gore residence at Parramatta. Tenders for the house werecalled in July 1906, the tender of £980 from Louis Hammer, a building contractor of Deagon,was accepted, and the house was under construction by the end of August 1906. [9] Feniton was designed by architect Robert Smith (Robin) Dods (1868-1920), principal of theBrisbane firm of Hall & Dods. Born in Dunedin, New Zealand, Dods lived briefly in Britainbefore coming to Brisbane in the late 1870s. He later trained as an architect in Scotland andEngland under a number of esteemed architects who were working in the Arts and Craftsidiom. He returned to Brisbane in 1896 and started in practice with architect Francis Hall (ofJohn Hall & Son) as Hall & Dods. In 1904, Dods was also appointed Diocesan Architect forthe Church of England’s Brisbane Diocese. [10] The practice of Hall & Dods produced a wide range of accomplished buildings and wascredited with achieving an 'architectural revolution' in Brisbane. Dods was responsible formost of the design within the firm, integrating contemporary British design philosophies withthe traditions of Queensland housing and the requirements of a subtropical climate. In 1913,Dods moved to Sydney to join the firm Spain Cosh & Dods, maintaining his Brisbaneassociation with FR Hall for several years. He died in Sydney in 1920. Dods was one of thefew Australian architects to have his work published in the United Kingdom, and has beenacknowledged as ‘one of the most significant early 20th century Australian architects' and asa rare practitioner of the Arts and Crafts style in Queensland.[11] Arts and Crafts was an international design movement flourishing between 1860 and 1910,its influence continuing into the 1930s. The style championed traditional craftsmanship usingsimple forms and often applied medieval, romantic or folk styles of decoration. Arts andCrafts architecture is characterised by solidity and heaviness through well-proportioned solidforms, wide porches and prominent steep roofs. The texture of ordinary materials isexpressed in the detailing and building composition is asymmetrical.[12] The most noticeable characteristic of Dods’ Queensland houses was a general feeling ofsolidity and substance. This was established through a generous roof continuous over theverandah; enclosed or screened understorey to give the house a visually solid base;oversized individual elements; and dark coloured materials to give the house a weightygravity. Chimney elements were generally tall and flat, topped with a plain rectangularshaft.[13] The composition of facades and circulation routes is a more nuanced element of Dods'houses. Facades often only implied symmetry. Entries were often off-centre orperpendicular, emphasised by wide and expressive entry stairs. Projecting bay windows andcorner fireplaces were recurrent elements, and these features are present in Feniton. The health and comfort of the occupants were major considerations in Dods’ designs. Livingspaces were well-oriented and internal layouts permitted cross ventilation. Other ventilationdevices included wide window and door openings, ventilated gables and ridges, andventilation fleches. Door fanlights were often solid hinged panels, where not on an externalwall. The houses were often provided with generous, considered service spaces includingback halls and wash houses. Dods houses are also notable for their informal spaces,including verandah ‘piazzas’, a generous verandah area suitable for informal occupation andusually given a northeast aspect. Dods’ piazzas were a principal external space, designedfor the Queensland climate. Interiors included fine decorative timber joinery and panelling. Fireplace surrounds and built-in cupboards were also a feature. Offices and halls, dining and drawing rooms often hadpine boards up to the picture rail stained in a colour to simulate mahogany. This finish wasused also on doors and windows as well as skirtings and architraves.[14]

650078Feniton



For the Trudes, Dods designed a highset timber house with verandahs on three sides. It wassheltered by a large, steeply-pitched hip roof with a projecting gable over a front (southwest)entrance and over a piazza on the rear, eastern corner. The roof featured two tall, projecting,face brick chimneys and a ventilated ridge. The walls were clad in timber weatherboards,which were mitred at corners and extended down to the ground-plane, concealing theunderstorey. Exterior timber detailing was restrained and reinforced the solidity of the house,with oversized timber posts and curved brackets to verandahs.[15] The formal entry to the Trudes’ house was via a bifurcated front stair leading to the frontverandah and an impressive entry hall. Feniton included: generous living and entertainingareas, including the piazza, which was connected to the garden via a stair; two bedrooms(plus dressing room) at the rear; kitchen; utility rooms; and servant’s quarters. A back hall offthe kitchen had internal stairs to the laundry in the understorey.[16] Dods designed gardens as a setting for his houses. They featured formal parterre gardens,terraces and walls, flower beds, tennis courts, hedges, topiaries, flowering ornamental trees,and geometric path and lawn layouts. In locating a house on its block, Dods considered thesize of the site and of the house, the fall of the land, the orientation and outlook, the setbackfrom the street, the location of any drive, the garden, fences and gates.[17] At 388 Bowen Terrace, Dods’ sited the residence so it had a large garden to both the front(southwest) and side (southeast). Feniton faces Bowen Terrace but is set well back (25m)on the site’s shallow slope; this approach was also used for the Dods-designed Lyndhurst inClayfield (1896) [QHR 601841], which has since lost most of its large front garden; and Kitawah at East Brisbane (1911) [QHR 601023].[18] Feniton forms part of a group of major works or ‘first quality houses’ of the middle period ofthe Hall & Dods practice (1901-09), a group described as comprising ‘most of the interestinghouses designed by Dods’. Of these, six timber suburban examples survive. Out of all ofDods’ suburban residential works (193 designed), at least 53 are known to survive in2018.[19] The Trudes were living at Feniton by April 1907, and a dance was held there on the eveningof 17 July, celebrating the first anniversary of their marriage.[20] In August 1910 a gardenparty was held with more than 100 guests.[21] It is not known if Dods designed a landscaping scheme for the garden of Feniton, but familyphotographs show that by 1908 the garden layout had been established, with lawns, gardenbeds, recent plantings, timber front fence with gothic pickets in concave panels, and frontgate. A pathway also led from Bowen Terrace towards the southern corner of the house, andto the front entrance porch and piazza.[22] The Trudes lived only intermittently at Feniton from late 1913, periodically occupying Endrim in Toowong [QHR 650071], during absences of Phyllis’s mother and sister who had movedto Brisbane after the death of her father, Gerard Ralph Gore.[23] In the Trudes’ absences, Feniton was rented to a Mrs King in 1913-14, and to Allan Jaffrey, Queensland Manager ofAustralian Estates in 1914-15. The Trudes finally settled at Endrim in 1916.[24] From 1916 Feniton was rented by Edward Granville (‘Red Ted’) Theodore (1884-1950), MLAfor Chillagoe, Deputy Premier, Treasurer, and Secretary for Public Works in Queensland’sTJ Ryan Labor Government. Theodore, a former union organiser and miner, entered theQueensland Parliament in 1909, aged 24.[25] Together with his wife Esther, nee Mahoney, and four young children, Theodore occupied388 Bowen Terrace for most of the next decade. In May 1918, the year before he becamePremier, Theodore purchased Feniton, which he had already renamed Almaden (or Alma-den), after the mining town near Chillagoe, North Queensland, where he had his first major

650078Feniton



victory as a union organiser in 1908 (the Etheridge Railway Strike).[26] Esther used the garden for fetes and other fund-raising activities as part of her work forphilanthropic and patriotic causes. On 7 October 1916 a brass band as well as singers andother musicians performed in the garden at her fete for the war effort; and in August 1918Esther invited a large party of guests to another fete at Almaden, this time in aid of thebachelor’s stall at the coming fete for St Patrick’s Church.[27] Some changes to the gardens occurred under the Theodores, who increased the density ofplanting with trees, shrubs and flower beds, including a greenhouse in the front garden and avegetable garden behind the house. By 1924 the front path from Bowen Terrace had beenconcreted. A 1930 photograph of the house shows flower beds in the front and southeastside gardens, with one palm tree near the southern corner of the house. A brick front fencewith infill timber pickets existed by 1934, and a small addition to the northwest side of thehouse had been added by the 1930s.[28] Theodore also constructed a study and library for his book collection under the southerncorner of the house and the front verandah. The large garden setback at Feniton would haveafforded Theodore some privacy as he worked in his study under the house. To provide day-lighting, casement windows were cut in the weatherboard cladding of the understorey, andwere protected by a continuous window shade. The front half of Theodore’s study and itswindows was later removed, with only a possible rear wall surviving under the house in2018.[29] While residing at Almaden between 1916 and 1927, Theodore implemented important social,industrial and constitutional reforms in Queensland. As TJ Ryan’s Treasurer and Secretaryfor Public Works, he established an arbitration system and state employment bureaux, andenacted legislation to provide for workers’ compensation and regulate working conditionsand accommodation. He also established a series of state enterprises, including butchershops, fish shops, cattle stations, sawmills, mining ventures and a hotel. During World War I,he was instrumental in the Ryan Government’s campaign against military conscription. In1922, he completed Labor’s campaign to abolish Queensland’s Legislative Council, withQueensland becoming the only Australian state with a unicameral legislature.[30] Theodore decided to enter federal politics, resigning as Premier in February 1925 to contestthe federal seat of Herbert in north Queensland. Unsuccessful in his bid, he moved toSydney in 1927 upon winning the NSW federal seat of Dalley at a by-election thatJanuary.[31] Theodore attempted to sell Almaden, but was unsuccessful and so rented it out for severalyears. In 1929-30 the house was rented by Norah Burrows, who ran it as a guest housecalled Garden of Kama, which she advertised as a ‘magnificent home’. From June 1930 thehouse was rented by Louis Emanuel (Lee) Steindl, a former Maryborough brewer, whoresided there with his wife Gertrude, nee Brennan, and Gertrude’s unmarried sisters,Florence and Winifred Brennan.[32] In March 1933, Almaden was sold to the Steindls, who during their occupation created adisplay garden containing flower beds of annuals, which had made the garden a local touristattraction by 1934. Severe drought conditions and watering restrictions in 1936 negativelyaffected the display garden. The Steindls also used Almaden to host parties and dances.[33] In 1937 the Steindls subdivided the property, and in 1938 they sold 29.33 perches (742m2)of the southeast garden, which became the site of a two-storey brick house (built c.1940) at404 Bowen Terrace. The sale of this land required the partial demolition of the piazza of Almaden, and its stair, and also separated Almaden from its former pedestrian entrance inthe front brick fence, and the concrete path from Bowen Terrace. The Steindls, left with 1

650078Feniton



●

rood, 11.14p (1293m2) of land, constructed a new front entry gate toward the northwest endof the front fence, with a new path to the front stair of the house.[34] By 1979, the front entry porch and piazza had been enclosed with casement windows anddoorways, and the southeast leg of the front stair had been removed.[35] After Gertrude Steindl’s death in 1971, her daughter Vera inherited Almaden. The house wassold in 1988 to Albert Kuceli, who had founded Kuceli Real Estate in New Farm in 1965.[36]Kuceli reopened the front entry porch and piazza and made other changes internally, whileleaving the panelling and joinery of the principal rooms intact. The cladding below the frontverandah and most of Theodore’s study was demolished, with similar cladding added in linewith the internal wall of the front verandah.[37] Kuceli made major changes to the gardens, including planting palms along the northwestboundary of the front garden, jacarandas on the southeast side of the front garden, adding apond and fountain, forming new garden beds with stone or brick edging, and laying newbrick paths. What had been an open front garden with some flower beds in 1942, and a fewtrees and shrubs by the 1960s, was lushly treed by the 1990s – resembling the time of theTheodore’s occupation. Kuceli also replaced the former vegetable garden area at the rearwith a swimming pool in the early 2000s.[38] Between 1979 and 2018, windows to the kitchen were removed and replaced by casements,and the adjoining section of wall was reclad to match existing fabric. Internally, the kitchenand back hall walls (including the wall, window and door that divided them and a storecupboard) and some bedroom walls were plastered over and corkboard laid over the floors.New skirting boards were installed in these locations. The pantry joinery and walls wereremoved and the area incorporated into the kitchen. The dressing room adjacent to the mainbedroom was renovated as an ensuite and walk-in wardrobe. Some mantelpieces andmouldings which had previously been painted were stripped and refinished with clearvarnish. [39] Feniton was added to the Brisbane City Council’s Heritage Register in 2000. FollowingAlbert Kuceli’s death in 2009, the property passed to his partner Carole Kotowski, who sold itto Judith Noble in 2012. The property was sold to Georgina Lalor in 2013, and to StrathallanPty Ltd in 2015. In June 2017 the property was transferred to Dave & Dunc Pty Ltd. [40] In 2018 Feniton continues to be used as a private residence, and retains most of its Dods’features and its Arts and Crafts aesthetic, including its solid and substantial form, dominantand steeply pitched roof, distinctive chimneys, materiality, partially enclosed understorey,well-proportioned rooms, interior timber joinery/mantlepieces, timber interior linings,generous verandahs and rear verandah louvres. It also retains its large front setback fromBowen Terrace, with views to and from the street.

Description Overview Feniton is a highset detached timber house located at 388 Bowen Terrace in the innerBrisbane suburb of New Farm, 2.8 kilometres from the centre of Brisbane on a 1,292m2allotment. Built in 1906, this substantial dwelling set in spacious grounds, is in an Arts andCrafts style and demonstrates a high standard of design and quality. It has distinctivefeatures that are characteristic of the domestic works of Robert Smith Dods and contribute toits aesthetic significance. It retains:

evidence of careful siting to take best advantage of aspect, garden views and privacy;

650078Feniton



●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

a solid and substantial appearance;overall form and massing combining symmetry within an asymmetrical form;a large and dominant roof;distinctive chimneys;verandahs of various widths in response to functional needs including verandahrooms/piazza;narrow weatherboards with mitred corners;oversized verandah posts;design for climate; innovative sub-tropical design features include orientation, planningto maximise ventilation and careful design of internal and external spaces.pleasing proportions;sparing use of ornament; andhigh quality materials and craftsmanship.

Setting Feniton stands on the rear half and highest part of the allotment, facing southwest andsloping to Bowen Terrace with rear access off Oxley Lane to the northeast. It has agenerous setback providing privacy and affording views to and from the house and BowenTerrace across the garden. The siting of the house close to the northwest boundaryoptimises the natural light and ventilation to the principal external spaces – the piazza andfront verandah. The portion of land included in the boundary at the rear of Lot 2 RP54676 (404 BowenTerrace) forms part of the significance of the place because it provides an open aspect, lightand ventilation to the piazza. Exterior The house has a proportionally large, steeply pitched hipped roof with projecting gables overa front entrance porch and over a wide verandah ‘piazza’ on the east corner. Two tall, brickchimneys (originally facebrick, now painted), venting the kitchen and drawing room/mainbedroom fireplaces are distinctively utilitarian in design with simple, rectangular shafts andflat rendered cornices. The eaves are lined with either fibrous sheeting or tongue-and-groovev-jointed (vj) boards, which also line the verandah ceilings (the extent and detail of originaleaves linings is unknown). Although it is offset to the south, the dominant, projecting entrance implies symmetry to thefront elevation through a classically derived pedimented gable supported on four posts. Thelarge entrance porch with verandahs on both sides is accessed by a wide L-shaped stair.(One flight of the originally bifurcated stair and an overhead trellis have been removed andnewel posts replaced).Across the porch, a wide pair of doors with decorative arched fanlightcentred between bay windows to the dining room and drawing room, opens into the entrancehall. Original applied decoration was limited to a heavy timber dentil detail to the eaves,mouldings to the large, oval louvred wall vent and front door surround and simple verandahbrackets. (verandah brackets have been replaced with ornate brackets and post mouldingsadded). All verandahs have a simple battened balustrade and handrail detail. (Handrails arecomparable replacements to the original design and some balusters have been replaced butmatch existing). A narrow northerly-facing verandah extends along the rear of the house to the east cornerwhere it widens to form the piazza. Vertical timber louvres are fixed along this verandah

650078Feniton



above the battened balustrade providing privacy and solar protection to the bedrooms. Theverandah and piazza walls have exposed framing and are lined with vj boards. A baywindow from the main bedroom projects into the piazza (reduced c1938) which was a keyfeature designed as an outdoor living room to take advantage of the best aspect for light andventilation. Cross ventilation is also a clear consideration in the detailing of the house. Large Frenchdoors, wide windows and fanlights above door openings throughout provide for continuousair flow. Contributing to the solid appearance of the house are oversized posts which support allverandah areas. Walls are generally clad with weatherboards. Original, narrowweatherboards with mitred corners are confined to the upper walls; the understorey walls,which provide the visually firm attachment with the ground are clad in wider weatherboards.The understorey at the rear of the house is lined with timber battens. Along the northwestside is a small verandah clad in weatherboards to handrail height, which has been enclosedwith casement windows above. A timber stair leads to a path to the rear gate. Interior The floor plan incorporates a level of symmetry within an asymmetrical layout comprisingliving, sleeping and service zones. The entrance hall is formal and symmetrical with doubledoorways (doors to the drawing room have been removed) opening into a generous diningroom on the left (northwest)and larger drawing room on the right (southeast) which opensonto the piazza. Through the finely detailed archway at the end of the entrance hall, aperpendicular hall provides access to the best bedroom and dressing room and leads to thespacious back hall. The kitchen, enclosed northwest verandah and two bedrooms open offthe back hall. The northwest verandah has a laundry (a later addition) at its south end, and astair to the back yard at its north end. In the service area of the house, partitions between the kitchen and pantry rooms have beenremoved and the kitchen fireplace is partially rendered. A large window between the kitchenand back hall has been enclosed; and the back hall stair and cupboard opposite, removed.The back hall retains a glazed fanlight to the service verandah; the doors below have beenremoved. Under the kitchen in the west corner of the understorey, accessed by the (removed) stairfrom the back hall, is the former laundry, which retains a concrete slab with spoon drain andevidence of a removed corrugated iron wall lining formed in the slab edge. The chimneybreast in this space has a void and piping for a copper. Extending across the front of thehouse is a store room lined with recent sheeting which adjoins a workroom in the southcorner lined with recycled vj boards that have been refixed upside down. This room, locatedpartially within what is thought to have been Theodore’s library, has concrete upstandsaround its perimeter. No definitive evidence of the library survives. The walls of the dining room, entrance hall and transverse hall are lined with clear finishedhoop pine vj boards to picture rail height and painted above – a characteristic lining andfinish of Dods’ interiors. Also characteristic are built-in cupboards; in the dining room, there isa built-in sideboard[1] and shelves and cupboards either side of the bay window. The north(former maid’s) room has a painted vj lining and the remaining rooms have been relined andplaster cornices installed. An unusual feature in the drawing room and best bedroom is theevidence of flush-jointed wall linings which provided for a wallpaper finish and an earlyplaster lining in the bedroom bay window. Another unusual feature is the presence of afireplace in the bedroom. Early joinery includes multi-paned double hung windows, widemulti-paned French doors and six-panelled doors with splayed panels and two-paneloperable fanlights above. Casement windows are later additions.

650078Feniton



●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

Significance of features All 1906 fabric and design features are of state level significance, including concealed liningsand decorative finishes. Features of the exterior of the house that are not of state level significance include:

corrugated pre-finished long-length roof sheeting, associated rainwater goods, ‘colonial’roof ventreplaced eaves liningsreplaced weatherboard cladding (wider weatherboards, corner stops)post 1906 joineryrecent decorative finishes

Features of the interior of the house that are not of state level significance post 1906 linings and trimspost 1906 joinery and hardwarekitchen and bathroom fitoutslight fittingsrecent decorative finishes

Features of the grounds that are not of state level significance include: all fenceslevel changes that have elevated the front yardpaving and garden edgesall vegetation individuallyswimming poolpool house

650078Feniton



Illustrations

Figure 3: Feniton_front garden from Bowen Terrace, looking northeast

Figure 4: Feniton_looking southwest towards Bowen Terrace from entrance verandah

650078Feniton



Figure 5: Feniton_Front Entrance, looking northeast

Figure 6: East corner of Feniton, and piazza, looking west from Oxley Lane

650078Feniton



Figure 7: Feniton_piazza looking east

Figure 8: Feniton_rear (southwest) verandah

650078Feniton



650078Feniton



Proposed heritage register boundary The heritage register boundary contains all of Lot 13 RP54676 and extends into Lot 2RP54676 in an ENE bearing from the south corner of the piazza, intersecting the south-eastern extent of Lot 13 RP54676 at E 504259.621, N 6961964 at E 504277.239, N6961971.471.

Figure 13: 650078 - Feniton - Boundary Map 1 (2018)

650078Feniton



Figure 14: 650078 - Feniton - Boundary Map 2 (2018)

650078Feniton



References [1] ‘New Farm Park’, QHR 602402. [2] ‘New Farm Park’, QHR 602402; DNRM Survey Plan B12342, 1843; Application to enter,dated 31 October 2017, pp.1-4 (based on Joint Expert Reports and other submissions,Appeal No. 2828 of 2016, Planning and Environment Court, (2017). Contributors were DrsHelen Bennett and Judith McKay, Susan Hill, John Taylor, Arno King, Peter Marquis Kyleand Michael Kennedy). [3] Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017, p.3; ‘New Farm Park’, QHR 602402;‘McKellar’s Official Map of Brisbane and Suburbs’ (6 Chains to an inch) 1895, Sheet 5;‘Electric Tramways. New Farm Service’, Telegraph, 22 September 1897, p.4. By 1914 theelectric tram line ran down Brunswick Street, turned right onto Barker Street, then left ontoMoray Street, and headed southeast until turning left onto Merthyr Rd and running northeast(Map, ‘City of Brisbane and Suburbs’, 8 Chains to an Inch, 1914). [4] ‘Brisbane’s Suburban Beauties’, Brisbane Courier, 12 May 1906, p12; Application toenter, dated 31 October 2017, pp.3-4. To the north-east of Brunswick Street, workingclasses occupied homes within walking distance of their places of employment: the factoriesand shops of Fortitude Valley; the Colonial Sugar Refinery at New Farm; the BulimbaBrewery; and the large wool stores and wharves being established at Teneriffe. [5] Telegraph, 20 March 1874, p.2; Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 p.4; DNRMSurvey Plan B12342, 1843; Map, 20 chains to an inch, undated (c1880s or later, but showsoriginal New Farm land owners and allotment sizes); DNRM Survey Plan RP8634, 1874. [6] DNRM Certificates of Title 10249147, 10299006, 10303172, 10316122, 10343024. [7] DNRM Certificates of Title 10303172, 10316122, 10343024, 1105080; Application toenter, dated 31 October 2017 p.5; DNRM Survey Plan RP8651, 1906 (resubdivision ofsubdivision 12); ‘McKellar’s Official Map of Brisbane and Suburbs’ (6 Chains to an inch)1895, Sheet 5 (shows location of the Mossleigh property). [8] From 1 October 1896 John Trude was admitted as a partner in Atcherley and Dawson;and when it was incorporated in New South Wales in November 1897 (with offices inSydney, Melbourne and Brisbane), Trude was one of the new company’s seven directors(Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 pp.5-6; ‘Weddings’, Queenslander, 28 July1906, p.13). [9] Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 p.6. There is also a village in Devon calledFeniton – about 26km southeast of John Trude’s birthplace in Poughill. [10] ‘Weemalla’, QHR 602820. [11] ‘Weemalla’, QHR 602820; Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 pp.5-13. [12] ‘Weemalla’, QHR 602820. [13] ‘Weemalla’, QHR 602820; Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 pp.9-10. Dodspioneered in Queensland the use of linseed oil as a wood preserver and exterior finish andcoloured it with various pigments. Red and deep brown were the most common colours andthis finish on the exterior walls was offset with white or cream enamel paint on the trim. [14] Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 p.10. [15] Almaden [image], c1930, Theodore Family Collection. [16] Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 (conjectural plan, Robert Riddel, 1986),p.11. [17] ‘Weemalla’, QHR 602820; Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 p.16. [18] Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 p.12; ‘Lyndhurst’, QHR 601841; ‘Kitawah’,QHR 601023. However, not all Dods houses had large front gardens, given that he designedeach house to suit its site. Wairuna (1896) [QHR 600226] was set back from the road by 3m,with a large garden and tennis court to the side (north); and a smaller house built as a rentalproperty for his mother in New Farm (1900) [QHR 601020] is set back about 7m. Turrawan [‘Clayfield House’, QHR 602452] was set close to London Road, with a tennis court to the

650078Feniton



side (east) (DNRM aerial photograph ADA85663, 20 April 1936). [19] Desktop study in 2018 of surviving Dods’ residential works, undertaken by DES; RRiddel, ‘R.S. (Robin) Dods 1868-1920. The Life and Work of a Significant AustralianArchitect’. PhD thesis, University of Queensland, 2008, p.27. Riddel defines the ‘first qualityhouses’ of this period as those major works costing between £900 and £2000 or more. Ofthe thirteen ‘major’ houses identified in this middle period (not including rural homesteads),three were masonry; the remaining ten were timber. Of these timber houses, four have beendemolished. Of the remaining six, half of the Sparkes’ house in Hamilton (1907; £1715) hasbeen removed and the site much reduced; Rangemoor in Clayfield (1907; £1280) remainson its original site but has been substantially extended; and Turrawan for Dr Halford inClayfield (1905; £1382) [QHR 602452] is substantially intact, but the grounds have beenreduced and the house has been moved eastwards and rotated on the block. Only Feniton,plus Weemalla at Corinda (1908; £953) [QHR 602820], and the Stark house at Morningside(1902; lowest tender £958), are believed to substantially retain the relationship betweenhouse and site (Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 p.12). [20] Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 p.6; ‘Woman’s World, dance at Feniton’, Brisbane Courier, 18 July 1907, p.7. The Trudes received their guests in the hall; attendeesthen ‘passed through to the drawing room and large verandahs, where dancing took place’.The verandahs were enclosed with flags, and roses were placed on supper tables in thedining room. [21] ‘Social and Personal’, The Telegraph, 17 August 1910, p.8. Guests were received byMrs Trude in the drawing room, and afternoon tea was held on the lawn. [22] Photographs of Christina and May Gore with Everil Trude at Feniton, 1908 (Applicationto enter, dated 31 October 2017 pp.16-17). The timber picket fence shown in an earlyphotograph of Feniton supplied by Robert Riddel probably originally surrounded Mossleigh’s garden, as it matches a c.1910 photograph of Mossleigh’s fence, included in the Applicationto enter, dated 31 October 2017, p.5). [23] Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 p.6; Queensland Historical Births, PhyllisEmlyn Gore, 1884, #C1882. Phyllis’ mother was Cristiana Mary Bernays. In 1901, GR Gorewas living at Feniton, three miles upriver from Yandilla House (Queensland Country Life, 12March 1901, p.13). [24] Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 p.6. [25] Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 p.13. [26] Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 p.13; DNRM Certificate of Title 11067214(May 1918 sale of property to Theodore); ‘Etheridge Railway’ QHR 601637. The residencewas already called Almaden by August 1916, when Mrs EG Theodore, of ‘Almaden, BowenTerrace’, convened a meeting of ladies, from the surrounding suburbs, at the Social ServicesInstitute in Brunswick Street for a Queensland Patriotic Fund effort (‘Public Service troubles’, Daily Standard, 11 August 1916, p.6). [27] Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 p.13; ‘Social’, Brisbane Courier, 27 August1918, p.9. For the 1918 fete the drawing-room was decorated with sweet peas, and the lawnwas ‘festooned with flags’. The grounds were ‘brilliantly lighted’ at night, and sweets andflowers were sold. During a six-month overseas trip in 1924, Almaden was occupied byFrank Tenison Brennan, Theodore’s Assistant Home Secretary and MLA for Toowoomba.While their parents were overseas, the two daughters boarded at Stuartholme Convent inToowong and the elder boy at Christian Brothers’ College, Nudgee. The youngest boystayed at Almaden with Brennan and his wife. (‘Eve of departure, Premier leaving tomorrowfor Canada, America, England’, Telegraph, 4 January 1924, p.2). [28] Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 p.14, (photograph of house, garden bedsand path layout, c1930) and pp.18-19 (recollections of the garden by Myra Theodore);Metropolitan Water Supply and Sewerage Board Field Survey Book 28C, Folio 64. 1912(additions in green ink in December 1924 show that the path visible in 1908 photographs

650078Feniton



was now concreted. The fernery is also shown near the southwest corner of the front gardenby 1924). The path layout is also shown in the Metropolitan Water Supply and SewerageBoard, City of Brisbane Detail Plan No.162, 1925. The brick front fence is visible in aphotograph of the front garden in 1934 (‘A Zinnia garden’, Telegraph, 20 January 1934, p.2).In 2018, this brick fence still exists, along the front boundary of both 388 and 404 BowenTerrace. [29] It was in the library that Theodore’s friend, James Duhig, the Roman CatholicArchbishop of Brisbane, would meet him during Duhig’s visits to Almaden. Speaking atTheodore’s requiem mass in 1950, Duhig stated: ‘I knew Theodore best at New Farm, wherehe was my neighbour for several years. I was not interested so much in Mr Theodore’spolitics as in his high intelligence, his love of culture and the charm of his personality. In hishome I did not go further than his library for it summed up the man’s whole character. It washis workshop, his joy and his life’ (Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 p.14). [30] He was also the first Australian premier to raise government loans in America, andopened up the Dawson, Upper Burnett and Callide areas for closer settlement. To assistprimary producers, he oversaw the creation of marketing boards, a state cannery, a coldstore to hold perishable exports, and a new Agricultural Bank (Application to enter, dated 31October 2017 pp.14-15). ‘Walkerston State Butcher's Shop (former)’ QHR 602659; ‘BabindaHotel’, QHR 602189. [31] Theodore later served as Treasurer in the Scullin Labor Government and was Director-General of the Allied Works Council during World War II. He was also a founder of theAustralian Women’s Weekly and a developer of gold mines in Fiji before his death in 1950(Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 p.14). [32] Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 p.15. While Theodore and his wife were outof the state in May-June 1927, a number of small precious items were stolen from a suitcasethey had left stored in a bedroom at Almaden (‘New Farm Burglary, ex-Premier’s residence’, Telegraph, 29 June 1927, p.5). Gertrude, Florence and Winifred were the sisters of FrankTenison Brennan. [33] Certificate of Title 11067214; ‘A Zinnia garden’, Telegraph, 20 January 1934, p.2;‘Glorious display of Cinerarias’, Telegraph, 8 September 1934, p.17; Application to enter,dated 31 October 2017 p.20 (drought); ‘Stray gleanings’, Daily Standard, 4 April 1935, p.12(bridge party and dance at Almaden). [34] Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 p.15; DNRM Survey Plan RP54676, 1937;DNRM Certificates of Title 11067214, 12059019. The 404 Bowen Terrace property waspurchased by Mary Jane Healy (who died 22 February 1939) and in 1940 it was sold by thePublic Curator of Queensland to Mary Agnes Collins, who built the brick house (DNRMCertificate of Title 12052150). The property was transferred to Mrs Collins’ daughter, MarieAgnes Rosbrook, in 1975. The new, curving entrance path to Almaden is visible in 1942, asis the brick house at 404 Bowen Terrace, and the new tennis court behind it (DNRM aerialphotograph MAP3174-22996, 4 June 1942). In 2018 part of the straight section of Almaden’s concreted path from the street still survives at 404 Bowen Terrace, alongside thenorthwest elevation of the brick house; but the remainder of this path, which curved to thefront stair of Almaden, the piazza, and later to the east side of Theodore’s study, no longersurvived. [35] Images provided by Robert Riddel, 1979, unpublished. [36] Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 p.15; DNRM Certificate of Title 12059019. [37] Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 p.16. [38] Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 pp.16, 20; ‘Joint Expert Report, LandscapeArchitecture and Heritage Garden Experts’, Planning and Environment Court of AppealNo.2828 of 2016, 23 March 2017, pp.59-61; DNRM aerial photographs MAP3174-22996, 4June 1942; QAP1070-24, 30 September 1960; QAP1989-184, 13 September 1969;QAP3735-7726, 6 September 1980; QAP5487-262, 4 September 1997. The swimming pool

650078Feniton



was built between 2001 and 2003 (Google Earth images) [39] Images provided by Robert Riddel, 1979, unpublished; Department of Environment andScience site visit, 13 March 2018. [40] Application to enter, dated 31 October 2017 pp.1, 16; DNRM Certificate of Title12059019; Riddel, Robin Dods 1868-1920, p.181 (Fenton in Sydney). In a 2010 BCCHeritage Citation the residence was called ‘Fenton’, a misspelling of Feniton, but also,coincidentally, the name of the house (extant in 2018) that Dods built for himself in Sydney in1919. In February 2016, a development application was lodged over the site to reposition thehouse 6m from Bowen Terrace (instead of the original 25m setback), raise and build underit, and construct three townhouses, each three storeys high, to the rear abutting Oxley Lane.The application was refused on 1 July 2016 and a subsequent appeal to this decision wasdismissed in the Planning and Environment Court in August 2017. [41] Some sections have been modified

650078Feniton



Queensland Heritage Act 1992 - qld.gov.au · clear finished joinery, including built-in timber...

Documents

Transcript of Queensland Heritage Act 1992 - qld.gov.au · clear finished joinery, including built-in timber...