QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Testing High Energy Cosmic Ray Interaction Models with the Atmospheric Muon Data L.G. Dedenko, G.F. Fedorova, T.M. Roganova Moscow State University Faculty of Physics, Skobeltsin Institute of Nuclear Physics QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 CONTENT 1. Introduction 2. Method of testing 3. Results and Discussion 4. Conclusion QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Introduction The longitudinal development of extensive air showers and, hence, the depth X max of its maximum depends strongly on the rate of the projectile particle energy E degradation. If a probability of secondary particles production in the energy range of ~0.6E 0.01E is high then the depth X max is expected to be rather large. And contrary, in case of the severe energy degradation the length of a shower and the depth X max of its maximum will be small. QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Introduction Number of muons in a shower is also determined by the secondary particles produced in the energy range of ~0.6E 0.01E. So, this energy interval is the most important for the extensive air shower development. The study of the secondary particle production with the most considerable energies is also of importance for understanding of particle interactions. The extensive air shower data are interpreted in terms of some models of hadronic interactions. QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Introduction These models are tested at the accelerator experiments (LHCf and TOTEM) We suggest to test also the most popular models of hadronic interactions with the atmospheric muon data, measured with rather high accuracy. This test is of the primary importance for the study of composition of the primary particles. QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Energy spectrum and composition of the primary particles All features of the energy spectrum and composition of the primary particles are of importance to understand the origin of cosmic rays, their possible sources and a transport of particles in magnetic fields on their ways to the Earth. QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Study of composition Standard approach: The depth X max of shower maximum vs. E QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Depth X max as an indicator of composition QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Alternative approach THE FRACTION OF MUONS ratio of signals in the underground and the surface detectors at a distance of 600 m from the shower core: =s (600)/s(600) QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Importance of model testing The Yakutsk array data interpreted in terms of the same model QGSJETII-03 gave 1) Heavy composition no testing 2) Light composition with testing L.G. Dedenko, G.F. Fedorova, T.M. Roganova et al., 2012, J. Phys. G: Nucl. Part. Phys QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 The fraction of muons calculated in terms of the QGSJETII-03 model for the primary protons (solid line) and the primary iron nuclei (dashed line) and the Yakutsk array data vs. the signal E s (600) in the SD. NO TESTING QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 The fraction of muons calculated in terms of the QGSJETII-03 model for the primary protons (solid line) and the primary iron nuclei (dashed line) vs. the signal E s (600) With testing QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Composition with testing QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Main idea of testing Kochanov had calculated transport equations and had found in terms of the QGSJETII-03 model and the ATIC2 primary particle spectrum the atmospheric muon energy spectrum which is by a factor 1.5 lower than data. We suggest the very simple method to simulate the muon energy specrum to test some hadronic interaction models. QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 A. Kochanov, PhD Thesis QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Transport equations A. Kochanov had used the transport equations to estimate the muon energy spectrum Many papers used the same method QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 References . ., . ., . . , // . 50. . 142156. Lipari P. Lepton spectra in the Earths atmosphere // Astropart. Phys Vol. 1. Pp. 195227. Bugaev E. V. et al. Atmospheric muon flux at sea level, underground and underwater // Phys. Rev Vol. D58. Pp ; hep ph/ QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 References Volkova L. V. Fluxes of high and ultrahigh- energy cosmic ray muons // Bull. Russ. Acad. Sci. Phys Vol. 71. Pp. 560563. Yushkov A. V., Lagutin A. A. Spectra of hadrons and muons in the atmosphere: Primary spectra, characteristics of hadron air interactions // Nucl. Phys. B. (Proc. Suppl.) Vol Pp. 170173. QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 References Kochanov A.A., Sinegovskaya T.S., Sinegovsky S.I., Calculation of the atmospheric muon flux // Astropart. Physics, 30, p.219, 2008 QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Suggestion We suggest to test the models of hadron interactions with the atmospheric muon data A. Kochanov had used the transport equations to estimate the muon energy spectrum We suggest the very simple simulations to calculate this spectrum in terms of various models. QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Ratio of Kochanov (the ATIC2 primary spectrum) to our results (the G&H primary spectrum) QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Simulations The package CORSIKA 7.4 had been used to estimate the energy spectra of muons D(E ) with energies in the energy range of 10^2-10^5 GeV in the atmosphere from the primary protons and He nuclei with energies within the interval 10^2-10^7 Gev in terms of the QGSJET- 01, QGSJETII-04, SIBYLL 2.1 models with statistics 10^6 10^2 events. QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Simulations To estimate the energy spectra of muons D(E ) with energies in the energy range of 10^2-10^5 GeV in the atmosphere we need to know 1) the energy spectra dI p /dE and dI He /dE of the primary protons and He nuclei with energies within the interval 10^2-10^7 Gev 2) the energy spectra of muons S p (E ,E) and S He (E ,E) calculated from the primary P and He nuclei with the fixed energies E in terms of the QGSJET- 01, QGSJETII-04, SIBYLL 2.1 models QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Simulations of the energy spectra of muons From the primary protons: D p (E )dE =dE(dI p /dE )S p (E ,E)dE From the primary He nuclei: D He (E )dE =dE(dI He /dE)S He (E ,E)dE The sum D(E )=(D p (E ) + D He (E )) QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Spectra of muons Spectrum of muons from the primary protons with fixed energy E S p (E ,E)dE Spectrum of muons from the primary He nuclei with fixed energy E S He (E ,E)dE QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 The energy spectra of muons generated by the primary protons with various energies E ( QGSJETII-04) : 13.16210 2, 210 3, 310 4, 4 10 5, 5 10 6, 6 10 7 GeV; QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 The energy spectra of muons generated by the primary He nuclei with various energies E ( QGSJETII-04) : 1 10 3, 2 10 4, 3 10 5, 4 10 6, 5 10 7 GeV. QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Muon spectrum for the primary protons with the energy E=10 5 GeV in terms of the various models + SIBYLL2.1, QGSJETII-04, QGSJET01 QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Muon spectrum for the primary He nuclei with the energy E=10 5 GeV in terms of the various models + SIBYLL2.1, QGSJETII-04, QGSJET01 QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Testing Models QGSJET- 01, N.N. Kalmykov et al., Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl B. 52, 17-28, 1997 QGSJETII-04, S.S. Ostapchenko, Phys. Rev. D 83, , 2011 SIBYLL 2.1, E.J. Ahn et al., Phys. Rev. D 80, , 2009 are tested with the help of the atmospheric muon data QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Atmospheric muon data The smooth approximation of the atmospheric muon data observed by the collaborations: 1) L3+Cosmic: arXiv: hep-ex v1K (2004) 2) MACRO: M. Ambrosio et al., Phys. Rev. D 52, 3793, (1995) 3) LVD: M. Aglietta et al., arXiv: hep-ex v1, (1998) had been used for comparison with results of simulations QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Method of simulation The energy spectra and the primary particles composition: As the energy per nucleon of importance only the energy spectra of the primary protons and He nuclei should be taken into account QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Energy spectra of the primary protons and He nuclei. Yoshiki Tsunesada,Tokyo Institute of Technology July Rapporteur Talk at 33-d ICRC 2013, Rio de Janeiro QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 The primary spectrum of (P+He). Dashed line modified Gaisser-Honda approximation QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 The energy spectrum of the primary protons QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 The energy spectrum of the primary He nuclei QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Approximation G&H for the primary P and He nuclei Gaisser T. K., Honda M. Flux of atmospheric neutrinos // Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci Vol. 52. Pp. 153199. dN A /dE k = K * (E k + b exp(c E k ) , Nuclei K b c P (1) He (4) We will use G&H as (dI p /dE) GH and (dI He /dE) GH QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Modified G&H approximation of the energy spectra of the primary particles 1. For the primary protons: (dI p /dE) m = (dI p /dE) GH (E 1 /E)^ For the primary HE nuclei: (dI He /dE) m = (dI He /dE) GH (E 1 /E)^0.5 where E 1 =310^6 GeV. Modified G&H will be used at energies above E 1. QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 The primary spectrum of (P+He) Dashed line the G&H and the modified Gaisser- Honda approximation, solid line AMS02, ATIC2, CREAM, ARGO, WCFTA, KASKADE (QGSJETII-03) and + KASKADE (SIBYLL2.1) RUNJOB, - TUNKA (all particles), SPHERE2 (all particles) QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 The primary spectra of (P, He) AMS02: Proc. 33-d ICRC, Rio de Janeiro, 2013 ATIC2: A.D. Panov et al., Bull. Bull. RAS, Phys.,73, 564, 2009 CREAM: H. S. Ahn et al., Astrophys. J. Lett. 714,L89-L93, 2010 ARGO: B.Bartoli et al., Phys. Rev. D, 85, , 2012 WCFTA: S.S. Zhang et al., NIM, A, 629,57-65, 2011 KASKADE (QGSJETII-03),+ KASKADE (SIBYLL2.1): T. Antoni et al., Astropart. Phys., 24, 1-25, 2005 RUNJOB:V.A. Derbina et al., ApJ, 628, L41-L44, 2005 TUNKA (all particles), V.V. Prosin et al., Proc. 33-d ICRC, Rio de Janeiro, 2013 SPHERE2 (all particles), R.A. Antonov et al., Proc. 33-d ICRC, Rio de Janeiro, 2013 QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Results The simulated muon spectra in terms of the + SIBYLL2.1, QGSJETII-04, QGSJET01 models QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 The calculated spectra of near vertical muons + SIBYLL2.1, QGSJETII-04, QGSJET01 QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 The calculated spectra of near vertical muons + SIBYLL2.1, QGSJETII-04, QGSJET01 At energies above B~100 GeV (the decay constant for the charged mesons) the simulated spectra are steepened QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Comparison with the atmospheric muon data MC/DATA: + SIBYLL2.1, QGSJETII-04, QGSJET01 QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Comparison with the atmospheric muon data MC/DATA: + SIBYLL2.1, QGSJETII-04, QGSJET01 At energy E =10^4 GeV the calculated muon spectra are above the data by a factor f SIBYLL2.1 f=2 QGSJETII-04 f=1.7 QGSJET01 f=1.55 QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 The LHC data Experiments: LHCf TOTEM QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 James L. Pinfold The University of Alberta Report at 33-d ICRC 2013, Rio de Janeiro QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 LHCf: forward photon production pp X QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 CONCLUSION At energy E =10^4 GeV the calculated muon spectra are above the data by a factor f SIBYLL2.1 f=2 QGSJETII-04 f=1.7 QGSJET01 f=1.55 Models of hadron interaction should be updated at very high energies of secondary particles QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Acknowledgements. Authors thank LSS (grant ) for support QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014 Thank you for attention! QUARKS-2014 Suzdal 7 June 2014