PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICES ANNUAL REPORT - Annual Report.pdf · 2016. 1. 13. · The Executive...
Transcript of PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICES ANNUAL REPORT - Annual Report.pdf · 2016. 1. 13. · The Executive...
Public Defender Services
F I S C A L Y E A R 2 0 1 5
P U B L I C D E F E N D E R S E R V I C E S
A N N U A L R E P O R T
One Players Club Drive, Suite 301
Charleston, WV 25311
Phone:304-558-3905
Fax: 304-558-1098
Website: www.pds.wv.gov DANA F. EDDY EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
Table of ContentsExecutive Director's PageExecutive Summary--Indigent Defense in West Virginia Infographic (FY15) --Appointed Counsel Summary--PDC SummaryAgency Information--Staff, History, and OrganizationFinancial Data--Summary of Appropriations, Expenditures, and Fund --Balances Statement of Revenues, Expenditures, and Changes Division Reports--Auditing and Accounting Division----Voucher Processing----Public Defender Corporations--Criminal Law Research Center--Appellate Advocacy Division--Indigent Defense CommissionAppendix A - Appointed Counsel StatisticsAppendix B - PDC StatisticsAppendix C - Appointed Counsel/PDC Comparisons Appendix D - AC Payee Totals--Top 100 Highest Compensated--Total Billed Travel TimeAppendix E - Historical Overview of Key Statistical Indicators
1345678
202123242525262730313289
126148190197212
The Executive Director’s Page
Public Defender Services’ administrative responsibilities include, by statute, processing for payment the vouchers setting forth the court-appointed counsel’s claims for fees and reimbursement of expenses; providing and administering grants to public defender corporations
operating in eighteen (18) judicial circuits; operating an appellate advocacy division; and providing support to criminal defense lawyers through a criminal law research center. In all these areas, the agency strives for excellence. However, each day in the world of indigent defense brings new challenges or exposes existing flaws.
The agency’s most daunting problem is overcoming the perception that panel attorneys are overbilling. This perception is the hurdle most often encountered in the effort to increase the rates of compensation. A common refrain from lawmakers or administrators is that, “attorneys have given themselves a raise”. One statistic is sufficient
to attest to an endemic problem in the billing: Since January 1, 2013, attorneys have billed over twenty-four hours in a day 183 times. This number will increase as additional vouchers with services in FY2015 are received.
The agency is auditing the vouchers of attorneys who are identified as billing in excess of twenty-four hours and have conferred with eleven counsel directly. The effort will continue. The hope is that by the end of FY2016, the level of billing will not be so obviously open to criticism, and a raise in the rates of compensation, assuming funding is available, will be more readily discussed.
In FY2015, Public Defender Services achieved a goal of processing vouchers for payment within thirty days of receipt. Unfortunately, the funding for the vouchers has not kept pace and attorneys may not be beneficiaries, yet, of this increased efficiency. In FY2015, the agency processed 36,266 vouchers.
In FY2015, Public Defender Services structured the funding for a public defender corporation in the Fourth Judicial Circuit of West Virginia and assisted in the formulation of a board of directors for the corporation. The anticipation is that the public defender corporation will take appointments, commencing in January 2016.
In FY2015, Public Defender Services provided continuing legal education credits to 264 attorneys throughout the state; provided newsletters summarizing all opinions of the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia; and provided summaries of legislation affecting criminal laws.
In closing, a delicate balance has to be reached by the agency. Public Defender Services is charged with “administer[ing], coordinat[ing,] and evaluat[ing] programs by which the state provides legal representation to indigent persons”. This means supporting attorneys in the effort, but it also means addressing issues with attorneys and challenging attorneys on questionable practices. So, at times, the agency will be perceived as an antagonist rather than a protagonist.
FY2015 Annual Report Page 1 of 212
While unfortunate, this is also unavoidable. In FY2016, the agency will continue to strive to achieve this balance and to enhance the experience of defending individuals whose liberty interests are at stake and who do not have the means to hire legal counsel.
Respectfully,
Dana F. Eddy Executive Director Public Defender Services
Front Row: Dana Eddy, Sarah Saul, Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin, Sheila Coughlin, Crystal Walden Second Row: Teresa Asbury, Brenda Thompson, Marjorie K. Wilson, Rachel Flynn, Don Stennett Third Row: Kimberly Bennett, Jonathan Friley, Lee Carper Back Row: Rhonda Ashworth, Heather Atkins, Lori Waller, Pam Clark, Jason Parmer,
Jackie Linthicome, Matt Brummond Not Picture: Betsy Chapman, Rosa McFarland
FY2015 Annual Report Page 2 of 212
Executive Summary
• Indigent Defense In West Virginia – FY2015 Infographic
• Appointed Counsel Summary
• Public Defender Corporation Summary
FY2015 Annual Report Page 3 of 212
Indigent Defense in West Virginia FY2015
Appointed Counsel
Public Defender Corporations
Claims Paid Cases Closed
Total Amount Total Paid in Claims Disbursements
Average Cost
Per Hour
Average Cost Per Case
* Average cost per hour for Public Defender Corpora ons is calculated by removing Administra ve Time (i.e., all
non‐client related work, such as office administra on and paid leave). This provides a be er indicator of the
amount it costs for direct legal services to compare to Appointed Counsel. If you include Administra ve Time, the
average cost per hour for Public Defender Corpora ons is $69.91.
FY2015 Annual Report Page 4 of 212
Total Amount Paid In Claims $25,954,897.24
Total Fees Paid to Counsel $23,399,286.67
Total Expenses Paid $2,555,610.57
Total Hours In‐Court 74,773.5
Total Hours Out‐Of‐Court 411,952.9
Total Number of Hours Paid 486,726.4
Percent of Total Hours In‐Court 15.36%
Percent of Total Hours Out‐Of‐Court 84.64%
Percent of Total Funds Paid Attributable To Fees 90.15%
Percent of Total Funds Paid Attributable To Expenses 9.85%
Average Total Cost Per Hour $53.33
Total Claims Paid 36,205
Less: Supplemental Claims Paid (1,669)
Less: Direct Claims Paid (777)
Total Claims Paid without Supplemental & Direct 33,759
All Claims W/O Supp & Dir.
Average Total Cost Per Claim $716.89 $768.83
Average Counsel Fee Per Claim $646.30 $693.13
Average Expenses Per Claim $70.59 $75.70
Comparative Analysis between All Claims and Claims With Out Supplemental and Direct
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL FISCAL YEAR 2015
STATISTICAL SUMMARY
FY2015 Annual Report Page 5 of 212
Total Number of Cases Closed
Total Amount Disbursed to Corporations*1
Average Total Cost Per Cases Closed
SUMMARY OF HOURS**
Total In Court Hours Worked
Total Out of Court Hours Worked
Total Drug Court Hours Worked
Total Administrative Hours Worked
Total Number of Hours Worked during FY 2014
Average Total Cost Per Hour
Percent of Total In Court Hours
Percent of Total Out of Court Hours
Percent of Drug Court Hours Worked
Percent of Total Administrative Hours
**Note: The Summary of Hours illustrates the difference in considering the total
administration time reported by Public Defenders. These Administrative Hours include
Holiday, Sick and Annual Leave hours paid to Corporation Attorneys. Moreover, it includes
performance reviews as well as management of the facilities and personnel. It also includes
time that cannot readily be allocated to a single case such as representing numerous clients
on the same day in municipal court and peer reviewing files to ensure adequate legal
representation by counsel.
0.51% 0.68%
25.25% Not Considered
*Note: Total amount disbursed includes payments made on behalf of Corporations to audit
providers; Office of Technology; State Auditor’s Office; and Legal Research Services.
1 Excludes $400,000 grant to 4TH Judicial Circuit PDC for startup expenses. This figure will be
included in the FY16 cost‐per‐case calculation.
69.91 93.53
21.32% 28.52%
52.92% 70.79%
1,297.70 1,297.70
64,124.00 Not Considered
253,930.20 189,806.20
With Admin Without Admin
54,135.50 54,135.50
134,373.00 134,373.00
$535.22
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICES
STATISTICAL SUMMARY
PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATIONS FISCAL YEAR 2015
33,170.00
$17,753,257.00
FY2015 Annual Report Page 6 of 212
Agency Information
FY2015 Annual Report Page 7 of 212
Agency Contact Information
Dana F. Eddy Executive Director Betsy Chapman Executive Assistant Donald L. Stennett Deputy Director Marjorie K. Wilson Chief Financial Officer Brenda K. Thompson General Counsel
One Players Club Drive, Suite 301
Charleston, WV 25311
Phone: (304) 558-3905 Fax: (304) 558-1098
Criminal Law Research Center Pam Clark Coordinator
Appellate Division Crystal Walden Director Matthew Brummond Appellate Counsel Jason Parmer Appellate Counsel Lori Waller Appellate Counsel Sarah Saul Paralegal Rhonda Ashworth Secretary
Accounting and Auditing Division Marjorie K. Wilson Director Jonathan Friley PDC Administrator Teresa Asbury Supervisor Heather Atkins Accounting Technician Rosa McFarland Accounting Technician Rachel Flynn Accounting Technician Kimberly Bennett Accounting Technician
Operations Donald L. Stennett Director Jackie Linthicome Receptionist Lee Carper Office Manager
Special Projects Sheila Coughlin Coordinator
FY2015 Annual Report Page 8 of 212
Employee Recognition & Activities
We host monthly luncheons to recognize the accomplishments of various members of our team. One of our more notable achievement luncheons was a tailgate theme, complete with grilled lunch and cornhole.
Pictured: Pam Clark, CLRC Coordinator, is all laughs
Pictured: Teresa Asbury, Kimberly Bennett, Heather Atkins, Rachel
Flynn, and Rosa McFarland after Teresa left Dana a surprise (see below)
Pictured: Teresa Asbury shows Dana Eddy what happened to the last person who beat her in cornhole
FY2015 Annual Report Page 9 of 212
We also hosted an agency-wide CPR certification class and held a staff retreat one afternoon at Coonskin Park.
Pictured: Matt Brummond, Brenda Thompson, Sheila Coughlin, Teresa Asbury, Lori Waller, and Rhonda Ashworth at the staff retreat
Pictured: Don Stennett observes Lori Waller, Lee Carper, and Rhonda Ashworth’s CPR skills
FY2015 Annual Report Page 10 of 212
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICES Historical Overview
1. The State of West Virginia’s Constitutional Obligation.
Over fifty years ago, the Supreme Court of the United States recognized that:
[R]eason and reflection require us to recognize that in our adversary system of criminal justice, any person haled into court, who is too poor to hire a lawyer, cannot be assured a fair trial unless counsel is provided for him. This seems to us to be an obvious truth. Governments, both state and federal, quite properly spend vast sums of money to establish machinery to try defendants accused of crime. Lawyers to prosecute are everywhere deemed essential to protect the public’s interest in an orderly society. … The right of one charged with crime to counsel may not be deemed fundamental and essential to fair trials in some countries, but it is in ours. From the very beginning, our state and national constitutions and laws have laid great emphasis on procedural and substantive safeguards designed to assure fair trials before impartial tribunals in which every defendant stands equal before the law. This noble idea cannot be realized if the poor man charged with crime has to face his accusers without a lawyer to assist him.
Gideon v. Wainwright, 372 U.S. 335, 344, 83 S.Ct. 792 (1963). With this decision, the Supreme Court of the United States extended the Sixth Amendment guarantee of the assistance of counsel in criminal prosecutions to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment. Essentially, states had to provide counsel for persons who were too poor to pay for legal services when these persons were confronted with criminal charges or the loss of other important rights by reason of state action.
The Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia reaffirmed this constitutional mandate as follows:
“There can be no equal justice where the kind of trial a man gets depends on the amount of money he has. ...” Griffin v. Illinois, 351 U.S. 12, 76 S.Ct. 585, 100 L.Ed. 891 (1956). … The state must, as a matter of equal protection, provide indigents with the basic tools for an adequate defense or appeal, when those tools are available for a price to others.
FY2015 Annual Report Page 11 of 212
State v. England, 363 S.E.2d 725, 727 (W. Va. 1987). Accordingly, a defense must be provided to indigent defendants and the defense must include not only the services of the attorney, but the provision of other services and material, including the transcripts of proceedings. Id. 2. The Legislative Findings. In 1981, the following was codified at W. Va. Code §29-21-1:
The Legislature finds and declares that in certain proceedings the state is required to provide high quality legal assistance to indigent persons who would be otherwise unable to afford adequate legal counsel; that providing legal representation to those who face an economic barrier to adequate legal counsel will serve the ends of justice in accordance with rights and privileges guaranteed to all citizens by the Constitution of the United States of America and the constitution of the state of West Virginia; that the availability of quality legal assistance reaffirms the faith of our citizens in our government of laws; that the present system which utilizes appointed counsel is not operating satisfactorily in some areas of this state and the Legislature is presently unable to determine what system or systems will provide the most efficient means for providing legal representation; that there is a need to explore alternative methods of delivering legal assistance, including the use of salaried public defenders complemented by private panel attorneys; that innovative programs and pilot projects as well as a continuation of the present appointed counsel system are necessary in separate areas of the state to provide information and experience upon which to base future legislative action.
The West Virginia Public Legal Services Council was then created “for the purpose of facilitating required legal representation of indigent persons”. W. Va. Code §29-21-3 (1981; superseded in 1989). In 1989, the agency was renamed as Public Defender Services and was charged as follows:
The agency shall have as its principal purpose the development and improvement of programs by which the state provides legal representation to indigent persons.
W. Va. Code §29-21-4. This remains the agency’s charge.
FY2015 Annual Report Page 12 of 212
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICES An Organizational Overview
VISION: “There can be no equal justice where the kind of trial a man gets depends on the amount of money he has.” Griffin v. Illinois, 351 U.S. 12 (1956)
MISSION STATEMENT: To fulfill the State of West Virginia’s constitutional obligation to provide quality legal assistance to persons who otherwise could not afford legal counsel in proceedings in which the person’s liberty interests are at stake. ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE: Public Defender Services is within the Department of Administration for the State of West Virginia. The chief administrative officer is the Executive Director, who is appointed by the governor.
The agency has three divisions. The Accounting and Auditing Division is charged with the following responsibilities:
The agency shall establish and the executive director or his or her designee shall operate an accounting and auditing division to require and monitor the compliance with this article by public defender corporations and other persons or entities receiving funding or compensation from the agency. The accounting and auditing division shall review all plans and proposals for grants and contracts and shall make a recommendation of approval or disapproval to the executive director. The accounting and auditing division shall prepare, or cause to be prepared, reports concerning the evaluation, inspection or monitoring of public defender corporations and other grantees, contractors, persons or entities receiving financial assistance under this article and shall further carry out the agency's responsibilities for records and reports as set forth in section eighteen of this article. The accounting and auditing division shall require each public defender corporation to submit financial statements monthly and to report monthly on the billable and nonbillable time of its professional employees, including time used in administration of the respective offices, so as to compare the time to similar time expended in nonpublic law offices for similar activities. The accounting and auditing division shall provide to the executive director assistance in the fiscal administration of all of the agency's divisions. This assistance shall include, but not be limited to, budget preparation and statistical analysis.
W. Va. Code §29-21-6(d).
FY2015 Annual Report Page 13 of 212
The Accounting and Auditing Division also contains the voucher processing staff that processes for payment the vouchers which are submitted by private attorneys who accept appointments in eligible proceedings, which are defined as follows:
Criminal charges which may result in incarceration; juvenile proceedings; proceedings to revoke parole or probation if the revocation may result in incarceration; contempt of court; child abuse and neglect proceedings which may result in a termination of parental rights; mental hygiene commitment proceedings; extradition proceedings; proceedings which are ancillary to an eligible proceeding, including, but not limited to, proceedings to enhance sentences brought pursuant to sections eighteen and nineteen, article eleven, chapter sixty-one of this code, forfeiture proceedings brought pursuant to article seven, chapter sixty-a of this code, and proceedings brought to obtain extraordinary remedies; and appeals from or post-conviction challenges to the final judgment in an eligible proceeding. Legal representation provided pursuant to the provisions of this article is limited to the court system of the state of West Virginia, but does not include representation in municipal courts unless the accused is at risk of incarceration ….
W. Va. Code §29-21-2(2). The Criminal Law Research Center is another division of the agency and has the following statutory charge:
(1) Undertake research, studies and analyses and act as a central repository, clearinghouse and disseminator of research materials; (2) Prepare and distribute a criminal law manual and other materials and establish and implement standard and specialized training programs for attorneys practicing criminal law; (3) Provide and coordinate continuing legal education programs and services for attorneys practicing criminal law; and (4) Prepare, supplement and disseminate indices and digests of decisions of the West Virginia supreme court of appeals and other courts, statutes and other legal authorities relating to criminal law.
W. Va. Code §29-21-7. Finally, the agency’s third division, the Appellate Advocacy Division is established as follows:
The agency shall establish and the executive director or his or her designee shall operate an appellate advocacy division for the purpose of prosecuting litigation on behalf of eligible clients in the Supreme Court of Appeals. The executive director or his or her
FY2015 Annual Report Page 14 of 212
designee shall be the director of the appellate advocacy division. The appellate advocacy division shall represent eligible clients upon appointment by the circuit courts or by the Supreme Court of Appeals. The division may, however, refuse the appointments due to a conflict of interest or if the executive director has determined the existing caseload cannot be increased without jeopardizing the appellate division's ability to provide effective representation. In order to effectively and efficiently use the resources of the appellate division, the executive director may restrict the provision of appellate representation to certain types of cases. The executive director may select and employ staff attorneys to perform the duties prescribed by this subsection. The appellate division shall maintain records of representation of eligible clients for record purposes only.
W. Va. Code §29-21-6(e). In addition to the agency’s divisions, the statutory framework for the agency includes two additional entities. Indigent Defense Commission.
The first is the Indigent Defense Commission. Specifically,
(a) There is hereby established the Indigent Defense Commission to provide assistance to Public Defender Services with regard to the general policies and procedures of the agency, including, but not limited to, the opening, closing or merging of public defender offices throughout the state and the establishment of performance measures for the qualitative review of indigent defense.
(b) In order to demonstrate a collaborative approach to solving criminal justice problems, the commission shall consist of the Executive Director of Public Defender Services, who shall serve as chair, and the following members appointed by the Governor:
(1) One former or retired circuit judge;
(2) Three lawyers, one from each congressional district,
who have significant experience in the defense of criminal cases or have demonstrated a strong commitment to quality representation of indigent defendants;
FY2015 Annual Report Page 15 of 212
(3) One current chief public defender; […],
(4) One nonlawyer with a demonstrated commitment to providing legal services to the indigent;
(5) One person who is a member of an organization that
advocates on behalf of people with mental illness and developmental disabilities; and
(6) One attorney with significant experience in the defense of juvenile delinquency and abuse and neglect cases.
(c) The commission shall meet at the times and places specified by
the call of the chair: Provided, That the commission shall meet no less than four times each year. Members shall serve without compensation but may receive reimbursement of actual and necessary expenses for each day or portion thereof engaged in this discharge of official duties in a manner consistent with the guidelines of the Travel Management Office of the Department of Administration. …
(f) The commission has the following powers and duties:
(1) To develop standards regarding the qualifications and training for public defenders, assistant public defenders and staff;
(2) To explore opportunities related to the training of appointed panel attorneys;
(3) To evaluate, on an annual basis, the compensation and caseloads of public defenders and appointed panel attorneys;
(4) To develop standards for providing and compensating expert witnesses, investigators and other persons who provide services related to legal representation under this article;
(5) To study, monitor and evaluate existing standards for determining eligibility for legal representation under section sixteen of this article;
(6) To study the feasibility and need of creating additional public defender corporations, the activation of public defender corporations and the formation of multicircuit
FY2015 Annual Report Page 16 of 212
or regional public defender corporations in accordance with the provisions of section eight of this article;
(7) To study the potential for the dissolution of public defender corporations;
(8) To study, monitor, evaluate and make recommendations regarding the training, experience and background necessary for a public defender or panel attorney to competently represent indigent defendants in capital cases; and
(9) To monitor and make recommendations regarding the following activities of the board of directors of each public defender corporation receiving funding pursuant to this article:
(A) The appointment of the public defender and any
assistant public defenders pursuant to subdivision (1), subsection (c), section fifteen of this article;
(B) The fixing of professional and clerical salaries pursuant to subdivision (2), subsection (c), section fifteen of this article; and
(C) The removal of any public defender, assistant public defender or other employee for misfeasance, malfeasance or nonfeasance pursuant to subdivision (3), subsection (c), section fifteen of this article.
W. Va. Code §29-21-3b. Public Defender Corporations. The second entity is the public defender corporation, which, if active within a judicial circuit, is “to provide legal representation … in accordance with the provisions” of the governing statute. W. Va. Code §29-21-8(a)(2).
For each public defender corporation, a board of directors is appointed. The chairperson of the board is appointed by the governor. One to two members for each county in the judicial circuit are appointed by the county commission. One to two additional members are appointed by each county bar association within the judicial circuit. The board selects a “chief” public defender who is then responsible for the delivery of legal services by the corporation. Unless
FY2015 Annual Report Page 17 of 212
inconsistent with the governing statute, the provisions of the state’s nonprofit corporate laws govern the public defender corporations.
FY2015 Annual Report Page 18 of 212
Financial Data
• Summary of Appropriations, Expenditures, and Fund Balances
• Statement of Revenues, Expenditures, and Changes in Fund Balances
FY2015 Annual Report Page 19 of 212
0010
009
900
4350
035
200
7880
091
300
TOTA
LTO
TAL
APPR
OPR
IATI
ON
S20
15 A
PP
RO
PR
IAT
ION
S1,
022,
620.
00$
317,
137.
00$
-
19,8
04,4
66.0
0$
10,7
23,1
15.0
0$
2,89
3.00
$ 31
,870
,231
.00
$ S
ecre
tary
Tra
nsfe
r 15
*5(4
5,00
0.00
)$
-
-
-
-
-
(45,
000.
00)
$
T
rans
fer
from
352
00 t
o 78
800
-
-
-
(400
,000
.00)
$
40
0,00
0.00
$
-
-
S
UP
P A
PP
RO
P r
ec
3/18
/201
5-
-
12
,700
,000
.00
$ -
-
-
12,7
00,0
00.0
0$
RE
AP
PR
OP
RIA
TIO
NS
-
-
-
-
2,12
3,38
4.28
$
-
2,
123,
384.
28$
TO
TAL
FUN
D A
PPR
OPR
IATI
ON
S97
7,62
0.00
$
317,
137.
00$
12,7
00,0
00.0
0$
19,4
04,4
66.0
0$
13,2
46,4
99.2
8$
2,89
3.00
$ 46
,648
,615
.28
$
TOAL
EXP
END
ITU
RES
PER
SON
AL S
ERVI
CES
& B
ENEF
ITS
120
0 P
erso
nal S
ervi
ces
549,
070.
33$
-
-
29
8,66
1.66
$
-
-
84
7,73
1.99
$
1
206
Ann
ual I
ncre
men
t10
,020
.00
$
-
-
-
-
-
10,0
20.0
0$
2
200
PE
IA F
ees
700.
00$
-
-
-
-
-
70
0.00
$
2
201
Per
sonn
el F
ees
2,21
0.00
$
-
-
810.
00$
-
-
3,
020.
00$
2
202
FIC
A40
,910
.30
$
-
-
20
,799
.15
$
-
-
61,7
09.4
5$
2
203
Pub
lic E
mpl
Insu
ranc
e66
,564
.00
$
-
-
27
,696
.00
$
-
-
94,2
60.0
0$
2
205
Wor
kers
Com
p1,
483.
06$
-
-
67
0.72
$
-
-
2,15
3.78
$
2206
U
nem
ploy
men
t C
ompe
nsat
ion
8,19
0.00
$
-
-
-
-
-
8,
190.
00$
22
07
Pen
sion
& R
etire
men
t76
,416
.44
$
-
-
41
,690
.37
$
-
-
118,
106.
81$
2208
PE
IA-O
PE
B C
ontr
ibut
ion
26,7
32.0
0$
-
-
7,38
0.00
$
-
-
34
,112
.00
$
TOTA
L PE
RSO
NAL
SER
V &
BEN
EFIT
S78
2,29
6.13
$
-
-
397,
707.
90$
-
-
321,
552.
04$
PUB
LIC
DEF
END
ER S
ERVI
CES
SUM
MA
RY
OF
APP
RO
PRIA
TIO
NS,
EXP
END
ITU
RES
, AN
D F
UN
D B
ALA
NC
ES B
Y A
CTI
VITY
FO
R T
HE
FUN
D 0
226-
2015
-022
1
FOR
TH
E PE
RIO
D J
ULY
1, 2
014
- JU
NE
30, 2
015
as o
f Jul
y 31
, 201
5
FY2015 Annual Report Page 20 of 212
UN
CLA
SSIF
IED
EXP
ENSE
S:
3200
O
ffic
e E
xpen
se-
17,0
06.3
6$
-
2,
245.
28$
-
-
19,2
51.6
4$
3201
P
rintin
g &
Bin
ding
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
3202
R
enta
l Exp
ense
-
58
,691
.04
$
-
19,8
43.1
6$
-
-
78
,534
.20
$
32
04 T
elec
omm
unic
atio
ns-
1,72
1.29
$
-
-
-
-
1,72
1.29
$
32
06
Con
trac
tual
& P
rofe
ssio
nal
-
1,
065.
50$
346,
395.
31$
18
,036
,093
.69
$ 35
5,24
2.78
$
-
18
,738
,797
.28
$
3207
P
rofe
ssio
nal S
ervi
ces
-
13
,343
.10
$
-
58,0
00.0
0$
-
-
71
,343
.10
$
32
11
Tra
vel E
mpl
oyee
-
3,
235.
47$
-
3,51
1.10
$
-
-
6,
746.
57$
3213
C
ompu
ter
Ser
vice
s-In
tern
al-
67,9
24.7
1$
-
55
,387
.50
$
-
-
123,
312.
21$
32
14
Com
pute
r S
ervi
ces-
Ext
erna
l-
500.
00$
-
-
-
-
50
0.00
$
3216
V
ehic
le R
enta
l-
599.
75$
-
1,41
8.00
$
-
-
2,
017.
75$
3217
Ren
tal(M
achi
ne &
Mis
c)-
28.3
5$
-
-
-
-
28.3
5$
3218
A
ssoc
Due
s &
Pro
f M
embe
rshi
ps-
2,45
0.00
$
-
2,
780.
00$
-
-
5,23
0.00
$
32
19
Fire
, A
uto,
Bon
d &
Oth
er In
sura
nce
-
82
7.25
$
-
-
-
2,
893.
00$
3,72
0.25
$
32
22
Sup
plie
s H
ouse
hold
-
13
.65
$
-
-
-
-
13
.65
$
32
24
Adv
ertis
ing
& P
rom
otio
n-
-
-
-
-
-
-
32
29
Rou
tine
Mtc
e C
ontr
acts
/War
rant
ies
-
4,
784.
38$
-
-
-
-
4,
784.
38$
3232
C
ellu
lar
Cha
rges
-
12
9.07
$
-
-
-
-
129.
07$
32
33
Hos
pita
lity
-
64
3.29
$
-
1,
222.
81$
-
-
1,86
6.10
$
32
35
Ene
rgy
Exp
ense
- V
ehic
le/A
ircra
ft-
-
-
-
-
-
-
32
41
Mis
cella
neou
s -
176.
76$
-
-
-
-
17
6.76
$
3242
T
rain
ing
& D
evel
opm
ent-
In-
762.
00$
-
955.
00$
-
-
1,
717.
00$
3243
Tra
inin
g &
Dev
elop
men
t-O
ut-
-
-
1,
750.
00$
-
-
1,75
0.00
$
32
44
Pos
tal
-
12
,038
.02
$
-
92.5
2$
-
-
12,1
30.5
4$
3245
F
reig
ht
-
56
6.27
$
-
11
.94
$
-
-
57
8.21
$
3246
S
uppl
ies-
Com
pute
r-
(495
.10)
$
-
-
-
-
(4
95.1
0)$
32
47
Sof
twar
e Li
cens
es
-
65
9.73
$
-
-
-
-
659.
73$
32
48
Com
pute
r E
quip
men
t -
4,48
3.60
$
-
-
-
-
4,48
3.60
$
32
49
Off
ice
Equ
ipm
entC
urre
nt E
xp
-
3,
186.
96$
-
-
-
-
3,
186.
96$
3250
A
ttor
ney
Lega
l Ser
vice
Pay
men
ts-
-
11
,504
,953
.85
$ -
11
,884
,592
.23
$ -
23,3
89,5
46.0
8$
32
51
Att
orne
y R
eim
burs
able
Exp
ense
-
-
704,
683.
95$
-
79
6,46
5.46
$
-
1,
501,
149.
41$
3252
M
isce
llane
ous
Equ
ipm
ent
Pur
chas
es-
950.
90$
-
-
-
-
95
0.90
$
3267
O
ther
Inte
rest
& P
enal
ties
-
-
1,09
5.92
$
-
239.
90$
-
1,
335.
82$
3272
P
EIA
Res
erve
Tra
nsfe
r-
5,59
4.00
$
-
3,
128.
00$
-
-
8,72
2.00
$
32
93
Med
ical
Ser
vice
Pay
men
ts-
-
14
2,86
9.09
$
-
209,
680.
06$
-
352,
549.
15$
33
24
Sta
te T
reas
urer
's O
ffic
e F
ees
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
5208
B
ooks
& P
erio
dica
ls-
2,81
0.64
$
-
23
1.42
$
-
-
3,04
2.06
$
82
03 C
ompu
ter
Sof
twar
e-
-
-
29
9.97
$
-
-
299.
97$
TOTA
L U
NC
LASS
IFIE
D E
XPEN
SES
-
20
3,69
6.99
$
12
,699
,998
.12
$ 18
,186
,970
.39
$ 13
,246
,220
.43
$ 2,
893.
00$
44,3
39,7
78.9
3$
TOTA
L FU
ND
EXP
END
ITU
RES
782,
296.
13$
20
3,69
6.99
$
12
,699
,998
.12
$ 18
,584
,678
.29
$ 13
,246
,220
.43
$ 2,
893.
00$
44,6
61,3
30.9
7$
FUN
D B
ALAN
CE
195,
323.
87$
11
3,44
0.01
$
1.
88$
819,
787.
71$
278.
85$
-
1,
987,
284.
31$
FY2015 Annual Report Page 21 of 212
2420-2015-0221
REVENUES Sales of Publications - Continuing Legal Education 23,920.00$ DVD/VIDEO Sales (with CLE) 530.00$ TOTAL REVENUES $24,450.00
EXPENDITURES 3200 Office Expense 3,197.58$
3202 Rental Expense 515.00$
3204 Telecommunications 45.00$
3211 Travel Employee 2,145.00$
3216 Vehicle Rental 218.00$
3217 Rental(Machine & Misc) 125.00$
3218 Assoc Dues & Prof Memberships 500.00$
3233 Hospitality 2,859.15$
3245 Freight 29.98$
3248 Computer Equipment 902.35$
3252 Miscellaneous Equipment Purchases 716.94$ $11,254.00
Revenues Over (Under) Expenditures $13,196.00
Fund Balance Beginning of Period July 1, 2014 $30,978.26
Fund Balance, June 30, 2015 $44,174.262421-2015-0221
Fund Balance Beginning of Period $6.00 Add: Consumer Sales Tax Collections - Less: Remittance of Taxes $6.00Fund Balance, June 30, 2015 -
Public Defender ServicesStatement of Revenues, Expenditures,
and Changes in Fund BalancesFor the Period July 1, 2014 to June 30, 2015
FY2015 Annual Report Page 22 of 212
Division Reports
• Voucher Processing
• Public Defender Corporations
• Criminal Law Research Center
• Appellate Advocacy Division
• Indigent Defense Commission
FY2015 Annual Report Page 23 of 212
DIVISION REPORTS
AUDITING AND ACCOUNTING DIVISION: VOUCHER PROCESSING
In FY2015, the staff of the voucher processing succeeded in its mission to process vouchers within thirty (30) days of the received date.
FY 2015: Public Defender Services Vouchers Paid July 1, 2014 through June 30, 2015
Dollar Amount Paid Number of Vouchers
July 2014 $1,201,738.49 1,774
August 2014 $1,891,803.92 2,579
September 2014 $2,697,217.03 3,404
October 2014 $1,446,151.67 2,186
November 2014 $1,969,203.34 2,800
December 2014 $2,245,734.16 3,122
January 2015 $1,319,258.83 1,828
February 2015 $411,827.74 489
March 2015 $6,353,213.40 9,100
April 2015 $2,506,103.62 2,799
May 2015 $2,476,974.69 4,122
June 2015 $1,460,798.66 2,023
TOTAL $25,980,025.55 36,226
Pictured: Marjorie K. Wilson accepts her 30 years-of-service certificate from Governor Earl Ray Tomblin
FY2015 Annual ReportPage 24 of 212
AUDITING AND ACCOUNTING DIVISION: PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATIONS
For FY2015, there were seventeen public defender corporations serving eighteen judicial
circuits (see subsequent table below). Although Public Defender Services establishes strategic objectives for the delivery of legal services to indigents in eligible proceedings, public defender corporations are not subordinate divisions of this agency, but are autonomous quasi-governmental entities. The Internal Revenue Code classifies these organizations as non-profit (see 26USC501) and as a public charity (see 26USC509). In essence, employees of the public defender corporations are neither employees of Public Defender Services nor employees of the State of West Virginia, but are employees of a specific non-profit organization governed by a board of directors appointed by the Governor, local bar associations, and county commissions.
Summary of Activated Public Defender Corporations
See W.Va. Code § 29-21-8 Circuit Fiscal Year Office Locations
1st 1990 Wheeling & Weirton 2nd Before 1991 Moundsville 4th 2015 Parkersburg 5th 1996 Ripley & Spencer
6th & 24th 1995 Huntington & Wayne 7th 1991 Logan 8th 1990 Welch 9th 1991 Princeton 10th Before 1991 Beckley 11th 2000 Lewisburg & Marlinton 12th 1990 Fayetteville 13th 1990 Charleston 15th 1994 Clarksburg 18th 2001 Kingwood 23rd Before 1991 Martinsburg & Charles Town 25th 2000 Madison & Hamlin 28th Before 1991 Summersville 30th 1990 Williamson
For FY2015, Public Defender Services made grants in the amount of $17,753,2601 to and
on behalf of the Public Defender Corporations. In return for these grants, the Public Defender Corporations reported 253,930.2 attorney hours and 33,170 closed cases. This represents approximately $69.91 per hour and $535.22 per closed case. However, reducing the attorney time by the 64,124 hours reported as administrative time (189,806.20), the cost per hour increases to $93.53 with no effect to the overall cost per case. 1 Excludes $400,000 grant to 4th Circuit for startup expenses. This figure will be included in the FY16 cost-per-case calculation.
FY2015 Annual Report Page 25 of 212
CRIMINAL LAW RESEARCH CENTER
In the FY2015, the Criminal Law Research Center provided the following legal seminars to public defenders and to private attorneys at a substantially lower cost than commercial providers: Up Your Game: Tools to Improve Your Practice
Flatwoods, WV February 27, 2015 Matt Brummond,
Brandon Cook, Dana Eddy, Jonathan Friley, Jason Nicholas, Jason Parmer, Don Stennett, Stephanne Thorton, Crystal Walden, Lori Waller
Fifty-seven (57) attorneys attended this conference. Attendees earned 7.3 hours of continuing education legal credits, including 3.5 hours of office management/ethics. Trial I – Pretrial Planning Marshall University, April 1, 2015 Matthew Brummond,
South Charleston Campus Jason Parmer, Don Stennett, Crystal Walden, Lori Waller
Northern Comm. College, April 10, 2015 Matthew Brummond,
Wheeling, WV Jason Parmer, Don Stennett, Crystal Walden, Lori Waller
Potomac State College, May 14, 2015 Matthew Brummond,
Keyser, WV Jason Parmer, Don Stennett, Crystal Walden, Lori Waller
Fifty-seven (57) attorneys attended these conferences. 6.0 credits of continuing legal education in ethics were earned by the attorneys in attendance.
FY2015 Annual Report Page 26 of 212
Public Defender Services—2015 Annual Conference Stonewall Resort June 18 & 19, 2015 Variety of Speakers
The Criminal Law Research Center organized the agency’s annual conference, to which public defenders and private counsel engaged in criminal defense were invited. The topics included:
Opening Remarks, Dana Eddy, Executive Director, Public Defender Services
Legislative Reform, Joseph D. Garcia, Esq., Governor's Office, Director of Legislative Affairs
Challenging Drug Evidence, Drew Northrup, Esq., Assistant Public Defender, Baltimore, MD
The 411 on 404: A Summary of Opinions of the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia on Rule 404(b) of the Rules of Evidence, Dana F. Eddy, Executive Director, Public Defender Services and Jason Parmer, Esq., Appellate Advocacy Division, Public Defender Services
Juvenile Welfare Reform (Improving the Effectiveness of Juvenile Justice Programs), Jason Nicholas, Esq., Assistant Public Defender, 13th Judicial Circuit PDC and Lori Waller, Esq., Appellate Advocacy Division, Public Defender Services
Domestic Violence, Allen E. Barry, Esq., Assistant Public Defender, 13th Judicial Circuit PDC
Resources for Clients Who Have Been Judged Incompetent, Georgette A. Bradstreet, Statewide Forensic Coordinator and Charity N. Sayre, JRI Coordinator, Office of the Cabinet Secretary, WV Dept. of Military Affairs and Public Safety
Perspectives on Representing the Youthful Offender, Alicia MacIntire, WVDHHR Youth Services Policy Specialist; Teresa Lyons, Panel Attorney, Hedges & Lyons, PLLC; Rob McKinney, Division of Probation Services, WV Supreme Court; Cindy Largent-Hill, Director, Juvenile Justice Commission, WV Supreme Court; and John Lehman, Esq., Assistant Public Defender, 23rd Judicial Circuit PDC
Panel Discussion - Magistrate Court - "Life in the Fast Lane", 15th Judicial Circuit PDC Attorneys: Perry B. Jones, Esq., Chief Defender; Jack E. Clark, Esq., Assistant Public Defender; Eric D. Householder, Esq. , Assistant Public Defender; and Elizabeth B. Gross, Esq., Assistant Public Defender
FY2015 Annual Report Page 27 of 212
Preventing Burnout in the Practice of Law: Psychoneuroimmunology, The Healing Power of Laughter, Music & Joyful Living, George Daugherty, Executive Director, WV Lawyer Assistance Program
ABC's of DUI, David Pence, Esq., Member, Zerbe & Pence, PLLC
Case Studies in Mitigation, Stephanne Thornton, LICSW,MAC, Sentencing Advocate Director, 13th Judicial Circuit PDC
How to Talk to Your Expert - Court Ordered Psychological Evaluations & Strategies, Timothy S. Saar, PhD
4th Circuit & U.S. Supreme Court Update, Jonathan Byrne, Esq., Federal Public Defender Office, Southern District of WV
Ethics, “The Presentation That Will Change Your Life -- Forever!!!”, Terri Tarr, Esq., Chief Counsel, Judicial Investigation Commission
Award Recipients
George Casetlle, Former Chief Public Defender, Public Defender Corporation for the 13th Judicial Circuit, Second Annual John A. “Jack” Rogers Award for Outstanding Leadership in Public Service
Greg Ayers, Former Supervisor of Appellate Attorneys, Public Defender Corporation for the 13th Judicial Circuit, Second Annual Award for Outstanding Scholarship in Criminal Law
One Hundred Fifty (150) attorneys attended these conferences. Attendees earned 11.5 credits of continuing legal education, including 1 hour of ethics and 1 hour of office management. Additional credits were available by ordering DVDs of concurrent seminars not attended.
The Criminal Law Research Center continued its publication of the Legislative Watch, and reported on legislative activity and laws affecting criminal laws or criminal defense. The Criminal Law Research Center also published six (6) newsletters that addressed general issues affecting the criminal defense practice, discussed specific issues affecting the operations of Public Defender Services, and provided summaries of relevant decisions of the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia and the Supreme Court of the United States. The Criminal Law Research Center continues to maintain a library of material that is available to practitioners throughout the state. The material is listed on the agency’s website at www.pds.wv.org.
Pictured: Jason Nicholas (13th PDC) and Lori
Waller (Appellate Division, PDS), presenting at the
2015 Annual Conference.
FY2015 Annual Report Page 28 of 212
APPELLATE ADVOCACY DIVISION
“The right of an accused in a criminal trial to due process is in essence, the right to a fair opportunity to defend against the State’s accusations.” Chambers v. Mississippi, 410 U.S. 284, 294, 93 S. Ct. 1038, 1045 (1973). The Appellate Advocacy Division strives to protect this right and to ensure that West Virginia conducts its criminal trials in accordance with the rule of law rather than compromising justice in light of the citizen-defendants’ perceived opprobrium.
The Appellate Advocacy Division’s primary task is to pursue appeals on behalf of
indigent criminal defendants throughout the state who stand convicted of serious crimes resulting in lengthy prison sentences. The four lawyers and two staff comprising the division zealously advocate for their clients in the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia, and in appropriate cases, three of the division’s lawyers can file petitions for certiorari to the Supreme Court of the United States. The Appellate Division prefers complex cases or cases presenting issues of first impression so that in addition to protecting each individual client’s rights, the law in general can advance in a positive direction.
The Appellate Advocacy Division believes that trial and appellate lawyers can develop a
united front in the defense of the indigent citizens of our state. In an effort to implement this team approach, the division assists attorneys throughout the State by answering attorney assistance calls and participating in continuing legal education programs offered by the Criminal Law Research Center. The Appellate lawyers participated in every CLE program the Criminal Law Research Center held this year, including the Annual Conference.
Attorney assistance calls are a new service the division offers to fulltime public defenders
and panel attorneys appointed to represent indigent defendants. Trial attorneys can call with a legal question and speak to one of the appellate attorneys who will research the issue and provide feedback, discuss strategy, provide sample motions or any other resource that could be helpful to the trial attorney. The division can also brainstorm and host moot court for attorneys either in person or via phone conference. In the first full year of the assistance call program, the division assisted more than 40 panel attorneys and fulltime public defenders calling with legal questions.
The Appellate Advocacy Division is dedicated to vigorous representation of every client
during both the trial and appellate phase. The division’s ultimate goal is to help to ensure that every indigent citizen charged with a crime enjoys all the constitutional rights and protections guaranteed under the constitutions of both the United States and West Virginia.
FY2015 Annual Report Page 29 of 212
INDIGENT DEFENSE COMMISSION
The Indigent Defense Commission was reconstituted in 2014. The members are the Honorable John L. Cummings, Senior Status Judge from Milton; Valena E. Beatty, WVU College of Law Professor and Chair of the WV Innocence Project, from Morgantown; Lonnie C. Simmons, a criminal defense attorney and the Chair of the Public Defender Corporation for the 13th Judicial Circuit, from Charleston; George Castelle, former Chief Public Defender for the 13th Judicial Circuit, from Charleston; Lawrence P. Shao, Ph.D., former Professor of Finance at Marshall University, from Huntington; Karen B. Yost, President and Chief Executive Officer of Prestera Center for Mental Health Services, Inc., from Huntington; and Vanessa Ann Welch, an attorney with significant experience in the defense of Juvenile delinquency and abuse and neglect cases, from Morgantown. The Executive Director of Public Defender Services serves as Chair of the Commission. The Commission met three times this year before the drafting of this Annual Report. On January 29, it held its organizational meeting at the PDS offices in Charleston. The members discussed the online voucher system; the statutory directives to develop standards for providing and compensating expert witnesses, investigators and others, and to study the feasibility of creating multi-circuit or regional public defender corporations; and the findings; and recommendations of two performance reviews issued by the Legislative Auditor’s office in January 1999 and June 2004. Also discussed was the concept of gathering information on the qualitative aspects of public defense and the reasons cases are assigned to panel attorneys rather than to public defender corporations. Members then discussed the possibilities of developing a continuing legal education seminar on how to navigate the mental health system, and preparing a video to be made available through the state bar, which panel attorneys could review before accepting appointments of mental health cases. The Commission met again on April 24. At that meeting, the Chair reported that he and members of the PDS staff had met with Barbara Core and Matt Arrowood, Division of Circuit Clerk Services of the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia, on April 2 in Marion County, to discuss the Supreme Court’s E-Filing Pilot Project. This project will allow PDS to have electronic access to Circuit Court documents, which will facilitate further analysis of vouchers submitted for payment. The Commission also discussed the hourly rates paid to panel attorneys, and the consideration of proposing a decrease of hourly rates for travel to effectuate an increase for legal services.
FY2015 Annual Report Page 30 of 212
Appendix A
Appointed Counsel Statistics
• Summary of Claims Paid • Claims Paid
o Total o Without Supplemental or Direct Expenses o Supplemental and Direct Expenses Only
• Hours Paid by Case Type • Fees Paid by Case Type • Expenses Paid by Case Type • Expenses Paid by Category • Hours Paid In Court / Out of Court • Average Costs by Case Type
o Total o Without Supplemental or Direct Expenses
• Average Per Charge
FY2015 Annual Report Page 31 of 212
Attorney Fees $23,399,286.67 Attorney Expenses $1,479,912.09 Direct Expenses $1,075,698.48 Total Claims Paid $25,954,897.24
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESSUMMARY OF APPOINTED COUNSEL CLAIMS PAID
Attorney Fees90.15%
Attorney Expenses5.70%Direct Expenses
4.14%
FY2015 Annual Report Page 32 of 212
Attorney Attorney Direct Total Total FeesCircuit Attorney Fees Expenses Expenses Expenses & ExpensesCounty Hours ($) ($) ($) ($) ($)
01 Circuit
BROOKE 6,361.47 302,787.94 20,369.09 16,997.50 37,366.59 340,154.53
HANCOCK 8,552.43 411,064.16 25,558.83 6,963.00 32,521.83 443,585.99
OHIO 14,095.82 659,022.02 33,292.46 31,083.21 64,375.67 723,397.69
Total 29,009.72 1,372,874.12 79,220.38 55,043.71 134,264.09 1,507,138.21
02 Circuit
MARSHALL 3,173.21 152,999.06 5,546.57 1,735.00 7,281.57 160,280.63
TYLER 1,783.04 85,893.84 7,038.79 7,723.05 14,761.84 100,655.68
WETZEL 2,952.10 142,291.22 7,858.57 139.02 7,997.59 150,288.81
Total 7,908.35 381,184.12 20,443.93 9,597.07 30,041.00 411,225.12
03 Circuit
DODDRIDGE 4,532.00 212,676.04 22,907.80 7,866.31 30,774.11 243,450.15
PLEASANTS 3,262.90 154,603.91 13,153.40 6,454.68 19,608.08 174,211.99
RITCHIE 5,087.00 241,933.84 21,375.01 13,377.92 34,752.93 276,686.77
Total 12,881.90 609,213.79 57,436.21 27,698.91 85,135.12 694,348.91
04 Circuit
WIRT 1,616.90 75,712.97 9,072.69 7,405.46 16,478.15 92,191.12
WOOD 25,879.74 1,227,967.43 80,328.26 60,975.20 141,303.46 1,369,270.89
Total 27,496.64 1,303,680.40 89,400.95 68,380.66 157,781.61 1,461,462.01
05 Circuit
CALHOUN 4,556.30 221,131.30 23,135.81 620.50 23,756.31 244,887.61
JACKSON 8,208.60 399,946.29 44,569.22 3,116.56 47,685.78 447,632.07
MASON 8,693.20 420,406.07 17,795.77 1,500.00 19,295.77 439,701.84
ROANE 4,224.70 205,120.65 23,477.86 ‐ 23,477.86 228,598.51
Total 25,682.80 1,246,604.31 108,978.66 5,237.06 114,215.72 1,360,820.03
06 Circuit
CABELL 18,848.72 943,129.44 32,680.58 47,840.47 80,521.05 1,023,650.49
Total 18,848.72 943,129.44 32,680.58 47,840.47 80,521.05 1,023,650.49
07 Circuit
LOGAN 11,732.20 567,309.74 29,362.04 2,552.70 31,914.74 599,224.48
Total 11,732.20 567,309.74 29,362.04 2,552.70 31,914.74 599,224.48
08 Circuit
MCDOWELL 9,840.30 476,368.30 17,104.99 30,781.32 47,886.31 524,254.61
Total 9,840.30 476,368.30 17,104.99 30,781.32 47,886.31 524,254.61
09 Circuit
MERCER 30,296.27 1,462,332.11 129,507.25 92,969.01 222,476.26 1,684,808.37
Total 30,296.27 1,462,332.11 129,507.25 92,969.01 222,476.26 1,684,808.37
10 Circuit
RALEIGH 18,587.48 901,838.32 63,042.23 15,798.96 78,841.19 980,679.51
Total 18,587.48 901,838.32 63,042.23 15,798.96 78,841.19 980,679.51
11 Circuit
GREENBRIER 7,605.30 360,106.03 5,292.57 3,833.32 9,125.89 369,231.92
POCAHONTAS 2,821.10 132,309.76 6,524.78 341.60 6,866.38 139,176.14
Total 10,426.40 492,415.79 11,817.35 4,174.92 15,992.27 508,408.06
12 Circuit
FAYETTE 7,976.20 385,865.47 1,600.00 18,516.02 404,381.49
Total 7,976.20 385,865.47 16,916.02 1,600.00 18,516.02 404,381.49
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESSUMMARY REPORT FOR APPOINTED COUNSEL
ATTORNEY HOURS, FEES, AND EXPENSES
FY2015 Annual Report Page 33 of 212
Attorney Attorney Direct Total Total FeesCircuit Attorney Fees Expenses Expenses Expenses & ExpensesCounty Hours ($) ($) ($) ($) ($)
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESSUMMARY REPORT FOR APPOINTED COUNSEL
ATTORNEY HOURS, FEES, AND EXPENSES
13 Circuit
KANAWHA 35,498.85 1,711,050.92 80,665.35 46,502.72 127,168.07 1,838,218.99
Total 35,498.85 1,711,050.92 80,665.35 46,502.72 127,168.07 1,838,218.99
14 Circuit
BRAXTON 5,824.07 282,915.68 26,168.16 700.35 26,868.51 309,784.19
CLAY 7,359.39 351,134.75 24,225.89 207.90 24,433.79 375,568.54
GILMER 3,640.75 175,380.11 18,704.66 546.10 19,250.76 194,630.87
WEBSTER 10,712.20 513,526.82 62,622.63 28,700.00 91,322.63 604,849.45
Total 27,536.42 1,322,957.36 131,721.34 30,154.35 161,875.69 1,484,833.05
15 Circuit
HARRISON 10,733.90 508,117.91 89,198.52 79,031.93 168,230.45 676,348.36
Total 10,733.90 508,117.91 89,198.52 79,031.93 168,230.45 676,348.36
16 Circuit
MARION 17,834.20 830,121.03 22,139.87 84,829.20 106,969.07 937,090.10
Total 17,834.20 830,121.03 22,139.87 84,829.20 106,969.07 937,090.10
17 Circuit
MONONGALIA 23,827.99 1,129,932.23 49,353.63 40,717.03 90,070.66 1,220,002.89
Total 23,827.99 1,129,932.23 49,353.63 40,717.03 90,070.66 1,220,002.89
18 Circuit
PRESTON 7,604.30 358,126.10 26,687.23 12,358.02 39,045.25 397,171.35
Total 7,604.30 358,126.10 26,687.23 12,358.02 39,045.25 397,171.35
19 Circuit
BARBOUR 6,466.60 304,220.86 18,273.71 1,302.50 19,576.21 323,797.07
TAYLOR 7,210.20 337,919.80 18,845.91 ‐ 18,845.91 356,765.71
Total 13,676.80 642,140.66 37,119.62 1,302.50 38,422.12 680,562.78
20 Circuit
RANDOLPH 10,126.80 493,737.00 26,036.91 47,354.05 73,390.96 567,127.96
Total 10,126.80 493,737.00 26,036.91 47,354.05 73,390.96 567,127.96
21 Circuit
GRANT 2,734.80 132,746.47 8,320.52 5,219.25 13,539.77 146,286.24
MINERAL 5,925.10 278,560.28 11,658.47 31,977.61 43,636.08 322,196.36
TUCKER 786.40 37,274.00 3,365.78 4,490.44 7,856.22 45,130.22
Total 9,446.30 448,580.75 23,344.77 41,687.30 65,032.07 513,612.82
22 Circuit
HAMPSHIRE 6,504.90 316,700.94 17,588.08 22,175.94 39,764.02 356,464.96
HARDY 5,437.60 263,260.01 15,287.07 11,047.54 26,334.61 289,594.62
PENDLETON 1,324.40 62,908.88 6,820.72 4,950.00 11,770.72 74,679.60
Total 13,266.90 642,869.83 39,695.87 38,173.48 77,869.35 720,739.18
23 Circuit
BERKELEY 18,197.45 870,562.96 54,176.02 93,501.65 147,677.67 1,018,240.63
JEFFERSON 7,368.30 355,270.91 25,700.32 42,318.55 68,018.87 423,289.78
MORGAN 4,839.10 232,698.49 20,120.17 12,958.99 33,079.16 265,777.65
Total 30,404.85 1,458,532.36 99,996.51 148,779.19 248,775.70 1,707,308.06
24 Circuit
WAYNE 4,929.80 257,221.30 14,019.70 10,420.20 24,439.90 281,661.20
Total 4,929.80 257,221.30 14,019.70 10,420.20 24,439.90 281,661.20
FY2015 Annual Report Page 34 of 212
Attorney Attorney Direct Total Total FeesCircuit Attorney Fees Expenses Expenses Expenses & ExpensesCounty Hours ($) ($) ($) ($) ($)
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESSUMMARY REPORT FOR APPOINTED COUNSEL
ATTORNEY HOURS, FEES, AND EXPENSES
25 Circuit
BOONE 4,707.82 241,420.17 8,639.88 3,308.69 11,948.57 253,368.74
LINCOLN 7,692.60 376,922.01 14,960.49 1,486.00 16,446.49 393,368.50
Total 12,400.42 618,342.18 23,600.37 4,794.69 28,395.06 646,737.24
26 Circuit
LEWIS 7,722.94 371,118.12 22,332.10 15,522.15 37,854.25 408,972.37
UPSHUR 5,926.40 286,261.19 10,860.39 14,782.91 25,643.30 311,904.49
Total 13,649.34 657,379.31 33,192.49 30,305.06 63,497.55 720,876.86
27 Circuit
WYOMING 10,476.20 501,375.03 30,751.56 36,943.18 67,694.74 569,069.77
Total 10,476.20 501,375.03 30,751.56 36,943.18 67,694.74 569,069.77
28 Circuit
NICHOLAS 4,963.24 238,949.86 22,132.14 6,761.52 28,893.66 267,843.52
Total 4,963.24 238,949.86 22,132.14 6,761.52 28,893.66 267,843.52
29 Circuit
PUTNAM 15,493.70 739,879.86 44,543.44 25,375.03 69,918.47 809,798.33
Total 15,493.70 739,879.86 44,543.44 25,375.03 69,918.47 809,798.33
30 Circuit
MINGO 8,814.78 434,975.70 6,498.24 25,561.23 32,059.47 467,035.17
Total 8,814.78 434,975.70 6,498.24 25,561.23 32,059.47 467,035.17
31 Circuit
MONROE 2,416.20 117,700.57 10,269.68 2,973.01 13,242.69 130,943.26
SUMMERS 2,938.40 144,480.80 13,034.26 ‐ 13,034.26 157,515.06
Total 5,354.60 262,181.37 23,303.94 2,973.01 26,276.95 288,458.32
State Total 486,726.36 23,399,286.67 1,479,912.09 1,075,698.48 2,555,610.57 25,954,897.24
FY2015 Annual Report Page 35 of 212
Felony 8,937Misdemeanor 9,312Mental Hygiene 2,531Juvenile 3,248Parole/Prob. Rev. 1,430Term/Abuse & Neglect 8,949Habeas, Supreme Court 392Municipal Court Charges 604Other 802 (Mag. Ct. Appeal, Mandamus/Prohibition, Extradition, Contempt, Fugitive, Other)
Total Claims Paid 36,205
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL CLAIMS PAID
Felony24.68%
Misdemeanor25.72%
Mental Hygiene6.99%
Juvenile8.97%
Parole/Prob. Rev.3.95%Term/Abuse &
Neglect24.72%
Habeas, Supreme Court
1.08%
Municipal Court Charges1.67%
Other2.22%
FY2015 Annual Report Page 36 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Municipal
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juvenile
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Claim
s
01 Circuit
BR
OO
KE
85
63
50
17
5
82
1
‐
3
30
6
HA
NC
OC
K1
25
79
17
27
27
15
9
5
4
5
44
8
OH
IO9
7
81
25
5
10
3
18
1
18
‐
2
64
7
Total
307
223
322
54
35
422
24
4
10
1,401
02 Circuit
MA
RSH
ALL
63
49
60
11
10
58
2
‐
2
25
5
TYLE
R1
8
10
6
12
5
36
1
‐
2
90
WET
ZEL
59
17
52
8
9
57
‐
‐
‐
20
2
Total
140
76
118
31
24
151
3
‐
4
547
03 Circuit
DO
DD
RID
GE
79
80
12
28
33
98
‐
‐
19
34
9
PLE
ASA
NTS
57
74
6
30
9
54
1
‐
8
23
9
RIT
CH
IE5
2
10
5
7
16
7
98
1
‐
4
29
0
Total
188
259
25
74
49
250
2
‐
31
878
04 Circuit
WIR
T4
2
56
1
33
8
22
2
‐
6
17
0
WO
OD
55
6
1,2
07
29
2
21
3
70
53
8
26
‐
65
2,9
67
Total
598
1,263
293
246
78
560
28
‐
71
3,137
05 Circuit
CA
LHO
UN
42
8
3
5
2
14
8
9
‐
2
21
9
JAC
KSO
N1
14
46
2
18
32
25
2
16
‐
23
50
3
MA
SON
19
9
29
9
49
11
9
50
84
6
‐
14
82
0
RO
AN
E6
6
22
13
34
7
15
5
5
‐
11
31
3
Total
421
375
67
176
91
639
36
‐
50
1,855
06 Circuit
CA
BEL
L4
85
91
60
7
12
4
74
42
0
22
‐
28
1,8
51
Total
485
91
607
124
74
420
22
‐
28
1,851
07 Circuit
LOG
AN
14
2
46
0
1
14
5
16
17
1
7
‐
5
94
7
Total
142
460
1
145
16
171
7
‐
5
947
08 Circuit
MC
DO
WEL
L1
94
15
2
24
21
3
17
0
5
‐
6
57
5
Total
194
152
24
21
3
170
5
‐
6
575
09 Circuit
MER
CER
52
7
40
4
16
7
46
0
69
71
4
16
29
42
2,4
28
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL CLA
IMS PAID
FY2015 Annual Report Page 37 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Municipal
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juvenile
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Claim
s
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL CLA
IMS PAID
Total
527
404
167
460
69
714
16
29
42
2,428
10 Circuit
RA
LEIG
H2
89
22
3
8
41
35
81
4
14
‐
8
1,4
32
Total
289
223
8
41
35
814
14
‐
8
1,432
11 Circuit
GR
EEN
BR
IER
96
48
6
9
12
11
0
7
3
5
29
6
PO
CA
HO
NTA
S4
1
15
19
7
‐
33
‐
‐
1
11
6
Total
137
63
25
16
12
143
7
3
6
412
12 Circuit
FAYE
TTE
15
9
15
2
‐
16
15
20
0
8
5
1
55
6
Total
159
152
16
15
200
8
5
1
556
13 Circuit
KA
NA
WH
A8
47
64
8
‐
13
0
74
67
6
51
42
2
39
2,8
87
Total
847
648
‐
130
74
676
51
422
39
2,887
14 Circuit
BR
AX
TON
93
15
3
10
29
11
14
5
1
‐
11
45
3
CLA
Y6
9
63
1
10
4
18
0
1
1
1
33
0
GIL
MER
62
91
1
19
5
52
2
5
28
26
5
WEB
STER
15
5
11
1
2
21
9
19
6
4
‐
13
51
1
Total
379
418
14
79
29
573
8
6
53
1,559
15 Circuit
HA
RR
ISO
N1
46
10
6
43
40
23
16
3
17
‐
14
55
2
Total
146
106
43
40
23
163
17
‐
14
552
16 Circuit
MA
RIO
N3
77
45
9
13
2
21
2
10
9
19
1
15
38
50
1,5
83
Total
377
459
132
212
109
191
15
38
50
1,583
17 Circuit
MO
NO
NG
ALI
A4
93
59
4
16
3
10
4
10
8
18
7
20
69
38
1,7
76
Total
493
594
163
104
108
187
20
69
38
1,776
18 Circuit
PR
ESTO
N6
4
82
8
3
9
18
7
5
‐
19
37
7
Total
64
82
8
3
9
187
5
‐
19
377
19 Circuit
BA
RB
OU
R9
7
10
9
7
72
5
14
2
3
‐
1
43
6
TAYL
OR
12
0
92
9
17
4
18
15
4
2
‐
32
60
1
Total
217
201
16
246
23
296
5
‐
33
1,037
FY2015 Annual Report Page 38 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Municipal
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juvenile
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Claim
s
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL CLA
IMS PAID
20 Circuit
RA
ND
OLP
H1
99
29
0
18
10
3
46
67
14
9
33
77
9
Total
199
290
18
103
46
67
14
9
33
779
21 Circuit
GR
AN
T7
4
63
7
34
22
33
‐
‐
12
24
5
MIN
ERA
L1
83
33
1
9
60
55
44
3
‐
11
69
6
TUC
KER
14
33
‐
29
3
2
‐
‐
3
84
Total
271
427
16
123
80
79
3
‐
26
1,025
22 Circuit
HA
MP
SHIR
E1
53
21
7
6
52
35
44
6
‐
34
54
7
HA
RD
Y1
08
16
8
5
60
20
44
1
‐
13
41
9
PEN
DLE
TON
21
27
4
20
12
4
1
‐
5
94
Total
282
412
15
132
67
92
8
‐
52
1,060
23 Circuit
BER
KEL
EY3
05
10
1
‐
38
34
29
2
25
5
1
80
1
JEFF
ERSO
N1
12
13
0
‐
23
26
10
5
7
‐
3
40
6
MO
RG
AN
47
38
‐
13
17
85
5
‐
5
21
0
Total
464
269
‐
74
77
482
37
5
9
1,417
24 Circuit
WA
YNE
78
25
54
22
36
21
3
1
7
5
44
1
Total
78
25
54
22
36
213
1
7
5
441
25 Circuit
BO
ON
E7
5
34
‐
18
5
17
93
4
‐
5
41
3
LIN
CO
LN1
21
64
31
24
62
11
7
2
‐
89
51
0
Total
196
98
31
209
79
210
6
‐
94
923
26 Circuit
LEW
IS2
06
17
3
25
1
11
47
39
2
‐
14
74
3
UP
SHU
R1
15
18
4
11
77
33
76
1
‐
10
50
7
Total
321
357
262
88
80
115
3
‐
24
1,250
27 Circuit
WYO
MIN
G2
85
36
1
14
44
11
23
0
4
‐
6
95
5
Total
285
361
14
44
11
230
4
‐
6
955
28 Circuit
NIC
HO
LAS
82
27
‐
12
2
14
2
8
‐
‐
27
3
Total
82
27
‐
12
2
142
8
‐
‐
273
FY2015 Annual Report Page 39 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Municipal
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juvenile
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Claim
s
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL CLA
IMS PAID
29 Circuit
PU
TNA
M3
31
44
2
80
16
3
51
11
5
4
5
33
1,2
24
Total
331
442
80
163
51
115
4
5
33
1,224
30 Circuit
MIN
GO
15
8
16
5
5
22
7
18
3
10
1
9
56
0
Total
158
165
5
22
7
183
10
1
9
560
31 Circuit
MO
NR
OE
70
10
7
‐
16
10
33
‐
1
1
23
8
SUM
MER
S9
0
83
3
22
8
61
1
‐
2
27
0
Total
160
190
3
38
18
94
1
1
3
508
WV TOTA
L8,937
9,312
2,531
3,248
1,430
8,949
392
604
802
36,205
FY2015 Annual Report Page 40 of 212
Felony 7,657Misdemeanor 8,851Mental Hygiene 2,530Juvenile 2,926Parole/Prob. Rev. 1,380Term/Abuse & Neglect 8,718Habeas, Supreme Court 356Municipal Court Charges 576Other 765 (Mag. Ct. Appeal, Mandamus/Prohibition, Extradition, Contempt, Fugitive, Other)
Total Claims Paid 33,759
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL CLAIMS PAID
Without Direct Expenses and Supplementals
Felony22.68%
Misdemeanor26.22% Mental Hygiene
7.49%
Juvenile8.67%
Parole/Prob. Rev.4.09%
Term/Abuse & Neglect25.82%
Habeas, Supreme Court
1.05%
Municipal Court Charges1.71%
Other2.27%
FY2015 Annual Report Page 41 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Municipal
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juvenile
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Claim
s
01 Circuit
BR
OO
KE
65
58
49
15
5
78
1
‐
3
27
4
HA
NC
OC
K1
06
72
17
24
26
14
9
5
4
3
40
6
OH
IO8
5
79
25
5
10
3
17
8
16
‐
1
62
7
Total
256
209
321
49
34
405
22
4
7
1,307
02 Circuit
MA
RSH
ALL
59
47
60
10
10
57
2
‐
2
24
7
TYLE
R1
2
10
6
11
5
36
1
‐
2
83
WET
ZEL
50
17
52
8
8
57
‐
‐
‐
19
2
Total
121
74
118
29
23
150
3
‐
4
522
03 Circuit
DO
DD
RID
GE
57
68
12
24
32
94
‐
‐
19
30
6
PLE
ASA
NTS
46
62
6
27
9
54
1
‐
8
21
3
RIT
CH
IE3
7
96
7
16
6
97
1
‐
4
26
4
Total
140
226
25
67
47
245
2
‐
31
783
04 Circuit
WIR
T2
5
55
1
28
8
22
2
‐
6
14
7
WO
OD
40
4
1,1
17
29
2
17
6
67
51
3
23
‐
64
2,6
56
Total
429
1,172
293
204
75
535
25
‐
70
2,803
05 Circuit
CA
LHO
UN
38
8
3
5
2
13
9
9
‐
2
20
6
JAC
KSO
N1
04
46
2
16
31
22
9
15
‐
23
46
6
MA
SON
17
8
29
1
49
11
3
49
84
6
‐
13
78
3
RO
AN
E5
9
22
13
30
6
14
9
4
‐
11
29
4
Total
379
367
67
164
88
601
34
‐
49
1,749
06 Circuit
CA
BEL
L4
21
88
60
7
12
0
74
41
2
21
‐
27
1,7
70
Total
421
88
607
120
74
412
21
‐
27
1,770
07 Circuit
LOG
AN
12
8
45
0
1
14
3
16
17
1
6
‐
5
92
0
Total
128
450
1
143
16
171
6
‐
5
920
08 Circuit
MC
DO
WEL
L1
44
14
8
24
18
3
16
8
5
‐
6
51
6
Total
144
148
24
18
3
168
5
‐
6
516
09 Circuit
MER
CER
44
3
38
3
16
7
40
3
65
69
1
9
28
38
2,2
27
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL CLA
IMS PAID W
ITHOUT DIREC
T EX
PEN
SES OR SUPPLEMEN
TALS
FY2015 Annual Report Page 42 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Municipal
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juvenile
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Claim
s
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL CLA
IMS PAID W
ITHOUT DIREC
T EX
PEN
SES OR SUPPLEMEN
TALS
Total
443
383
167
403
65
691
9
28
38
2,227
10 Circuit
RA
LEIG
H2
33
21
4
8
33
31
79
4
13
‐
6
1,3
32
Total
233
214
8
33
31
794
13
‐
6
1,332
11 Circuit
GR
EEN
BR
IER
77
44
6
8
10
11
0
5
3
5
26
8
PO
CA
HO
NTA
S3
3
15
19
7
‐
33
‐
‐
1
10
8
Total
110
59
25
15
10
143
5
3
6
376
12 Circuit
FAYE
TTE
15
6
14
8
15
15
19
6
8
5
1
54
4
Total
156
148
‐
15
15
196
8
5
1
544
13 Circuit
KA
NA
WH
A7
20
58
9
‐
12
1
71
66
1
45
40
1
37
2,6
45
Total
720
589
‐
121
71
661
45
401
37
2,645
14 Circuit
BR
AX
TON
89
15
0
10
29
10
14
2
1
‐
11
44
2
CLA
Y6
0
59
1
10
4
17
7
1
1
1
31
4
GIL
MER
59
90
1
18
5
51
2
5
28
25
9
WEB
STER
13
3
10
9
2
18
9
19
3
4
‐
13
48
1
Total
341
408
14
75
28
563
8
6
53
1,496
15 Circuit
HA
RR
ISO
N1
11
10
1
43
37
21
16
2
17
‐
14
50
6
Total
111
101
43
37
21
162
17
‐
14
506
16 Circuit
MA
RIO
N3
49
44
1
13
2
18
4
10
4
18
9
14
37
45
1,4
95
Total
349
441
132
184
104
189
14
37
45
1,495
17 Circuit
MO
NO
NG
ALI
A4
38
55
6
16
3
87
10
4
18
4
20
65
37
1,6
54
Total
438
556
163
87
104
184
20
65
37
1,654
18 Circuit
PR
ESTO
N5
7
76
8
3
8
18
2
4
‐
15
35
3
Total
57
76
8
3
8
182
4
‐
15
353
19 Circuit
BA
RB
OU
R9
0
10
6
7
59
5
14
0
3
‐
1
41
1
TAYL
OR
10
5
81
9
13
9
17
15
2
2
‐
29
53
4
Total
195
187
16
198
22
292
5
‐
30
945
FY2015 Annual Report Page 43 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Municipal
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juvenile
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Claim
s
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL CLA
IMS PAID W
ITHOUT DIREC
T EX
PEN
SES OR SUPPLEMEN
TALS
20 Circuit
RA
ND
OLP
H1
71
27
8
18
96
45
65
13
8
32
72
6
Total
171
278
18
96
45
65
13
8
32
726
21 Circuit
GR
AN
T7
0
63
7
32
22
33
‐
‐
12
23
9
MIN
ERA
L1
69
32
4
9
59
55
44
2
‐
11
67
3
TUC
KER
12
32
‐
29
3
2
‐
‐
3
81
Total
251
419
16
120
80
79
2
‐
26
993
22 Circuit
HA
MP
SHIR
E1
35
21
0
6
46
35
43
6
‐
33
51
4
HA
RD
Y9
8
16
3
5
56
18
42
1
‐
13
39
6
PEN
DLE
TON
17
26
4
20
11
4
1
‐
5
88
Total
250
399
15
122
64
89
8
‐
51
998
23 Circuit
BER
KEL
EY2
58
99
‐
36
34
27
7
23
5
1
73
3
JEFF
ERSO
N9
1
12
6
‐
20
26
98
7
‐
3
37
1
MO
RG
AN
44
35
‐
10
17
82
5
‐
5
19
8
Total
393
260
‐
66
77
457
35
5
9
1,302
24 Circuit
WA
YNE
69
25
54
22
35
21
0
1
7
5
42
8
Total
69
25
54
22
35
210
1
7
5
428
25 Circuit
BO
ON
E6
6
34
‐
16
5
17
91
3
‐
5
38
1
LIN
CO
LN1
13
64
31
23
57
11
6
1
‐
83
48
8
Total
179
98
31
188
74
207
4
‐
88
869
26 Circuit
LEW
IS1
86
16
7
25
1
11
46
39
1
‐
14
71
5
UP
SHU
R1
06
17
9
11
73
32
75
1
‐
10
48
7
Total
292
346
262
84
78
114
2
‐
24
1,202
27 Circuit
WYO
MIN
G2
20
32
8
14
42
11
22
5
3
‐
6
84
9
Total
220
328
14
42
11
225
3
‐
6
849
28 Circuit
NIC
HO
LAS
78
27
‐
12
2
14
1
7
‐
‐
26
7
Total
78
27
‐
12
2
141
7
‐
‐
267
FY2015 Annual Report Page 44 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Municipal
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juvenile
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Claim
s
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL CLA
IMS PAID W
ITHOUT DIREC
T EX
PEN
SES OR SUPPLEMEN
TALS
29 Circuit
PU
TNA
M2
88
42
1
80
14
9
51
11
3
4
5
32
1,1
43
Total
288
421
80
149
51
113
4
5
32
1,143
30 Circuit
MIN
GO
13
9
16
5
5
22
7
18
0
10
1
8
53
7
Total
139
165
5
22
7
180
10
1
8
537
31 Circuit
MO
NR
OE
66
10
7
‐
16
10
33
‐
1
1
23
4
SUM
MER
S9
0
82
3
22
7
61
1
‐
2
26
8
Total
156
189
3
38
17
94
1
1
3
502
WV TOTA
L7,657
8,851
2,530
2,926
1,380
8,718
356
576
765
33,759
FY2015 Annual Report Page 45 of 212
Felony 575Misdemeanor 75Mental Hygiene 0Juvenile 11Parole/Prob. Rev. 5Term/Abuse & Neglect 87Habeas, Supreme Court 17Municipal Court Charges 1Other 6 (Mag. Ct. Appeal, Mandamus/Prohibition, Extradition, Contempt, Fugitive, Other)
Total Claims Paid 777
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL DIRECT EXPENSE PAID
Felony74.00%
Misdemeanor9.65%
Mental Hygiene0.00%
Juvenile1.42%Parole/Prob.
Rev.0.64%
Term/Abuse & Neglect11.20%
Habeas, Supreme Court
2.19%
Municipal Court Charges0.13%
Other0.77%
FY2015 Annual Report Page 46 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Municipal
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juvenile
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Claim
s
01 Circuit
BR
OO
KE
6
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
6
HA
NC
OC
K3
‐
‐
‐
‐
1
‐
‐
‐
4
OH
IO8
‐
‐
‐
‐
1
1
‐
‐
10
Total
17
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
1
‐
‐
20
02 Circuit
MA
RSH
ALL
‐
1
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
1
TYLE
R3
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
3
WET
ZEL
1
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
1
Total
4
1
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
5
03 Circuit
DO
DD
RID
GE
13
5
‐
‐
1
‐
‐
‐
‐
19
PLE
ASA
NTS
5
6
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
11
RIT
CH
IE1
2
3
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
15
Total
30
14
‐
‐
1
‐
‐
‐
‐
45
04 Circuit
WIR
T1
1
‐
‐
1
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
12
WO
OD
98
9
‐
‐
1
24
3
‐
1
13
6
Total
109
9
‐
1
1
24
3
‐
1
148
05 Circuit
CA
LHO
UN
1
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
1
JAC
KSO
N2
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
‐
‐
‐
4
MA
SON
1
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
1
RO
AN
E‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
Total
4
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
‐
‐
‐
6
06 Circuit
CA
BEL
L2
9
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
‐
‐
‐
31
Total
29
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
‐
‐
‐
31
07 Circuit
LOG
AN
3
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
3
Total
3
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
3
08 Circuit
MC
DO
WEL
L1
4
‐
‐
‐
‐
1
‐
‐
‐
15
Total
14
‐
‐
‐
‐
1
‐
‐
‐
15
09 Circuit
MER
CER
31
‐
‐
2
‐
3
6
‐
‐
42
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
TOTA
L DIREC
T EX
PEN
SE CLA
IMS PAID
FY2015 Annual Report Page 47 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Municipal
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juvenile
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Claim
s
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
TOTA
L DIREC
T EX
PEN
SE CLA
IMS PAID
Total
31
‐
‐
2
‐
3
6
‐
‐
42
10 Circuit
RA
LEIG
H2
0
‐
‐
1
3
10
‐
‐
‐
34
Total
20
‐
‐
1
3
10
‐
‐
‐
34
11 Circuit
GR
EEN
BR
IER
4
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
1
‐
‐
5
PO
CA
HO
NTA
S2
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
Total
6
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
1
‐
‐
7
12 Circuit
FAYE
TTE
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
1
‐
‐
‐
1
Total
‐
‐
‐
‐
1
‐
‐
‐
1
13 Circuit
KA
NA
WH
A6
1
2
‐
1
‐
3
4
‐
1
72
Total
61
2
‐
1
‐
3
4
‐
1
72
14 Circuit
BR
AX
TON
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
1
‐
‐
‐
1
CLA
Y1
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
1
GIL
MER
1
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
1
WEB
STER
6
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
6
Total
8
‐
‐
‐
‐
1
‐
‐
‐
9
15 Circuit
HA
RR
ISO
N3
1
2
‐
1
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
34
Total
31
2
‐
1
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
34
16 Circuit
MA
RIO
N1
2
1
‐
‐
‐
1
‐
‐
‐
14
Total
12
1
‐
‐
‐
1
‐
‐
‐
14
17 Circuit
MO
NO
NG
ALI
A1
6
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
‐
‐
‐
18
Total
16
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
‐
‐
‐
18
18 Circuit
PR
ESTO
N2
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
1
‐
2
7
Total
2
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
1
‐
2
7
19 Circuit
BA
RB
OU
R2
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
TAYL
OR
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
Total
2
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
FY2015 Annual Report Page 48 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Municipal
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juvenile
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Claim
s
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
TOTA
L DIREC
T EX
PEN
SE CLA
IMS PAID
20 Circuit
RA
ND
OLP
H2
2
10
‐
‐
‐
2
‐
1
‐
35
Total
22
10
‐
‐
‐
2
‐
1
‐
35
21 Circuit
GR
AN
T3
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
3
MIN
ERA
L7
2
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
9
TUC
KER
2
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
Total
12
2
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
14
22 Circuit
HA
MP
SHIR
E8
2
‐
2
‐
‐
‐
‐
1
13
HA
RD
Y3
1
‐
1
‐
1
‐
‐
‐
6
PEN
DLE
TON
2
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
Total
13
3
‐
3
‐
1
‐
‐
1
21
23 Circuit
BER
KEL
EY3
9
‐
‐
1
‐
13
‐
‐
‐
53
JEFF
ERSO
N1
7
2
‐
‐
‐
4
‐
‐
‐
23
MO
RG
AN
2
1
‐
1
‐
3
‐
‐
‐
7
Total
58
3
‐
2
‐
20
‐
‐
‐
83
24 Circuit
WA
YNE
4
‐
‐
‐
‐
1
‐
‐
‐
5
Total
4
‐
‐
‐
‐
1
‐
‐
‐
5
25 Circuit
BO
ON
E3
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
‐
‐
‐
5
LIN
CO
LN‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
1
‐
‐
1
Total
3
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
1
‐
‐
6
26 Circuit
LEW
IS2
1
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
3
UP
SHU
R1
1
‐
‐
‐
1
‐
‐
‐
3
Total
3
2
‐
‐
‐
1
‐
‐
‐
6
27 Circuit
WYO
MIN
G3
5
25
‐
‐
‐
2
‐
‐
‐
62
Total
35
25
‐
‐
‐
2
‐
‐
‐
62
28 Circuit
NIC
HO
LAS
2
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
Total
2
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
FY2015 Annual Report Page 49 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Municipal
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juvenile
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Claim
s
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
TOTA
L DIREC
T EX
PEN
SE CLA
IMS PAID
29 Circuit
PU
TNA
M8
1
‐
‐
‐
2
‐
‐
1
12
Total
8
1
‐
‐
‐
2
‐
‐
1
12
30 Circuit
MIN
GO
14
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
‐
‐
‐
16
Total
14
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
‐
‐
‐
16
31 Circuit
MO
NR
OE
2
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
SUM
MER
S‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
Total
2
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
2
WV TOTA
L575
75
‐
11
5
87
17
1
6
777
FY2015 Annual Report Page 50 of 212
Felony 155,882.57
Misdemeanor 67,328.15
Mental Hygiene 8,258.42
Juvenile 34,200.31
Parole/Prob. Rev. 11,717.42
Term/Abuse & Neglect 183,270.05
Habeas, Supreme Court 16,966.07
Municipal Court Charges 3,977.16
Other 5,126.21 (Mag. Ct. Appeal, Mandamus/Prohibition, Extradition, Contempt, Fugitive, Other)
Total Hours Paid 486,726.36
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL HOURS
Felony32.03%
Misdemeanor13.83%
Mental Hygiene1.70%
Juvenile7.03%
Parole/Prob. Rev.2.41% Term/Abuse &
Neglect37.65%
Habeas, Supreme Court
3.49%Municipal Court
Charges0.82%
Other1.05%
FY2015 Annual Report Page 51 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Muni.
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juvenile
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Hours
01 Circuit
BR
OO
KE
1,8
23
.70
77
6.1
7
29
2.4
0
23
5.2
0
81
.30
2,9
30
.40
17
2.7
0
‐
49
.60
6,3
61
.47
HA
NC
OC
K2
,55
8.0
0
75
2.9
0
10
3.7
0
40
4.2
0
24
9.9
0
4,1
96
.13
23
1.6
0
30
.20
25
.80
8,5
52
.43
OH
IO3
,07
2.8
0
1,0
44
.50
1,7
45
.50
16
3.7
0
37
.60
6,7
31
.12
1,2
78
.10
‐
22
.50
14
,09
5.8
2
Total
7,454.50
2,573.57
2,141.60
803.10
368.80
13,857.65
1,682.40
30.20
97.90
29,009.72
02 Circuit
MA
RSH
ALL
1,1
26
.20
37
1.6
0
15
5.9
0
10
2.7
0
80
.50
1,2
36
.61
87
.40
‐
12
.30
3,1
73
.21
TYLE
R3
99
.10
11
9.1
0
15
.60
10
1.4
0
35
.50
1,0
27
.34
36
.70
‐
48
.30
1,7
83
.04
WET
ZEL
1,1
25
.30
11
1.4
0
12
5.5
0
12
2.1
0
79
.90
1,3
87
.90
‐
‐
‐
2,9
52
.10
Total
2,650.60
602.10
297.00
326.20
195.90
3,651.85
124.10
‐
60.60
7,908.35
03 Circuit
DO
DD
RID
GE
1,3
90
.20
77
6.2
0
40
.80
31
6.5
0
28
7.9
0
1,6
21
.90
‐
‐
98
.50
4,5
32
.00
PLE
ASA
NTS
1,2
23
.40
55
3.6
0
22
.60
29
7.5
0
55
.10
1,0
50
.70
20
.20
‐
39
.80
3,2
62
.90
RIT
CH
IE1
,09
9.8
0
90
0.5
0
25
.80
28
6.9
0
47
.40
2,5
40
.00
15
9.8
0
‐
26
.80
5,0
87
.00
Total
3,713.40
2,230.30
89.20
900.90
390.40
5,212.60
180.00
‐
165.10
12,881.90
04 Circuit
WIR
T5
52
.80
37
5.2
0
1.2
0
28
0.1
0
60
.40
21
7.9
0
70
.80
‐
58
.50
1,6
16
.90
WO
OD
6,5
13
.40
7,8
45
.50
60
5.3
0
1,5
23
.30
48
6.9
0
7,4
34
.44
1,1
84
.40
‐
28
6.5
0
25
,87
9.7
4
Total
7,066.20
8,220.70
606.50
1,803.40
547.30
7,652.34
1,255.20
‐
345.00
27,496.64
05 Circuit
CA
LHO
UN
1,5
89
.50
10
6.5
0
12
.90
16
.00
18
.30
2,5
44
.00
24
8.7
0
‐
20
.40
4,5
56
.30
JAC
KSO
N2
,05
8.6
0
37
2.9
0
4.9
0
28
8.0
0
24
4.8
0
4,4
01
.40
65
6.1
0
‐
18
1.9
0
8,2
08
.60
MA
SON
2,7
24
.40
2,1
40
.30
18
1.5
0
1,0
70
.40
42
2.1
0
1,8
02
.10
22
0.2
0
‐
13
2.2
0
8,6
93
.20
RO
AN
E1
,99
8.9
0
16
9.1
0
59
.90
25
5.0
0
88
.00
1,4
54
.20
11
5.1
0
‐
84
.50
4,2
24
.70
Total
8,371.40
2,788.80
259.20
1,629.40
773.20
10,201.70
1,240.10
‐
419.00
25,682.80
06 Circuit
CA
BEL
L8
,23
0.2
0
55
9.7
0
1,2
27
.82
66
9.2
0
59
1.2
0
6,5
09
.00
83
8.7
0
‐
22
2.9
0
18
,84
8.7
2
Total
8,230.20
559.70
1,227.82
669.20
591.20
6,509.00
838.70
‐
222.90
18,848.72
07 Circuit
LOG
AN
2,5
32
.40
2,7
30
.70
3.0
0
1,8
09
.70
20
5.0
0
4,0
73
.10
35
1.5
0
‐
26
.80
11
,73
2.2
0
Total
2,532.40
2,730.70
3.00
1,809.70
205.00
4,073.10
351.50
‐
26.80
11,732.20
08 Circuit
MC
DO
WEL
L4
,23
8.5
0
1,6
54
.70
11
8.0
0
14
6.9
0
17
.80
3,1
80
.90
40
1.1
0
‐
82
.40
9,8
40
.30
Total
4,238.50
1,654.70
118.00
146.90
17.80
3,180.90
401.10
‐
82.40
9,840.30
09 Circuit
MER
CER
10
,97
4.6
3
2,4
85
.44
58
6.5
0
4,5
88
.26
50
3.9
0
10
,15
3.8
4
50
1.7
0
18
0.1
0
32
1.9
0
30
,29
6.2
7
Total
10,974.63
2,485.44
586.50
4,588.26
503.90
10,153.84
501.70
180.10
321.90
30,296.27
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL HOURS PAID BY CIRCUIT & CASE TYPE
FY2015 Annual Report Page 52 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Muni.
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juvenile
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Hours
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL HOURS PAID BY CIRCUIT & CASE TYPE
10 Circuit
RA
LEIG
H4
,17
3.6
1
1,4
05
.31
22
.10
49
4.3
0
33
6.9
9
11
,57
3.1
7
53
9.4
0
‐
42
.60
18
,58
7.4
8
Total
4,173.61
1,405.31
22.10
494.30
336.99
11,573.17
539.40
‐
42.60
18,587.48
11 Circuit
GR
EEN
BR
IER
2,7
26
.90
50
2.5
0
12
.40
11
7.6
0
87
.20
3,8
25
.80
22
5.0
0
34
.40
73
.50
7,6
05
.30
PO
CA
HO
NTA
S1
,09
6.8
0
20
4.1
0
33
.20
73
.90
‐
1,3
99
.80
‐
‐
13
.30
2,8
21
.10
Total
3,823.70
706.60
45.60
191.50
87.20
5,225.60
225.00
34.40
86.80
10,426.40
12 Circuit
FAYE
TTE
2,9
79
.20
69
8.9
0
‐
23
5.8
0
10
2.7
0
3,5
98
.50
33
4.3
0
23
.40
3.4
0
7,9
76
.20
Total
2,979.20
698.90
235.80
102.70
3,598.50
334.30
23.40
3.40
7,976.20
13 Circuit
KA
NA
WH
A1
1,0
82
.40
5,1
96
.54
‐
1,7
01
.00
69
7.8
0
11
,32
4.9
0
2,4
42
.65
2,6
74
.45
37
9.1
0
35
,49
8.8
5
Total
11,082.40
5,196.54
‐
1,701.00
697.80
11,324.90
2,442.65
2,674.45
379.10
35,498.85
14 Circuit
BR
AX
TON
1,4
96
.14
86
1.2
9
13
.10
30
3.9
3
10
8.4
0
2,9
74
.31
20
.90
‐
46
.00
5,8
24
.07
CLA
Y1
,82
1.5
6
40
2.2
0
5.2
0
28
8.3
7
27
.90
4,7
66
.26
37
.20
5.9
0
4.8
0
7,3
59
.39
GIL
MER
1,1
56
.90
65
1.9
7
3.7
0
32
5.2
0
57
.40
1,2
95
.80
49
.32
43
.30
57
.16
3,6
40
.75
WEB
STER
3,5
06
.53
65
5.1
4
7.1
0
54
7.8
5
97
.63
5,5
39
.80
31
0.1
0
‐
48
.05
10
,71
2.2
0
Total
7,981.13
2,570.59
29.10
1,465.35
291.33
14,576.18
417.52
49.20
156.01
27,536.42
15 Circuit
HA
RR
ISO
N4
,18
3.5
0
94
1.7
0
93
.50
37
0.7
0
22
3.9
0
4,1
93
.70
59
2.2
0
‐
13
4.7
0
10
,73
3.9
0
Total
4,183.50
941.70
93.50
370.70
223.90
4,193.70
592.20
‐
134.70
10,733.90
16 Circuit
MA
RIO
N6
,79
3.6
9
3,3
94
.80
34
5.0
0
1,8
99
.70
80
3.2
0
3,3
44
.81
59
3.3
0
33
1.6
0
32
8.1
0
17
,83
4.2
0
Total
6,793.69
3,394.80
345.00
1,899.70
803.20
3,344.81
593.30
331.60
328.10
17,834.20
17 Circuit
MO
NO
NG
ALI
A9
,85
8.5
9
5,1
43
.40
46
5.4
0
1,4
05
.50
1,0
27
.30
4,4
49
.00
75
6.1
0
47
9.2
0
24
3.5
0
23
,82
7.9
9
Total
9,858.59
5,143.40
465.40
1,405.50
1,027.30
4,449.00
756.10
479.20
243.50
23,827.99
18 Circuit
PR
ESTO
N1
,70
8.4
0
83
6.1
0
28
.10
76
.20
99
.50
4,5
05
.10
12
0.7
0
‐
23
0.2
0
7,6
04
.30
Total
1,708.40
836.10
28.10
76.20
99.50
4,505.10
120.70
‐
230.20
7,604.30
19 Circuit
BA
RB
OU
R1
,36
6.4
0
79
7.5
0
18
.60
1,0
56
.00
37
.80
3,0
72
.10
91
.70
‐
26
.50
6,4
66
.60
TAYL
OR
1,7
44
.00
79
1.2
0
54
.80
1,4
41
.40
11
6.0
0
2,7
89
.70
44
.30
‐
22
8.8
0
7,2
10
.20
Total
3,110.40
1,588.70
73.40
2,497.40
153.80
5,861.80
136.00
‐
255.30
13,676.80
FY2015 Annual Report Page 53 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Muni.
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juvenile
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Hours
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL HOURS PAID BY CIRCUIT & CASE TYPE
20 Circuit
RA
ND
OLP
H3
,55
5.6
0
2,1
26
.30
71
.20
1,5
27
.80
26
2.1
0
1,8
03
.70
43
0.4
0
62
.40
26
8.9
0
10
,10
8.4
0
Total
3,555.60
2,126.30
71.20
1,527.80
262.10
1,803.70
430.40
62.40
268.90
10,108.40
21 Circuit
GR
AN
T1
,08
0.3
0
50
6.1
0
14
.00
28
5.4
0
17
3.0
0
62
3.7
0
‐
‐
70
.70
2,7
53
.20
MIN
ERA
L2
,13
7.5
0
1,9
63
.20
31
.00
33
9.9
0
24
2.8
0
1,0
63
.80
62
.60
‐
84
.30
5,9
25
.10
TUC
KER
22
9.3
0
22
3.3
0
‐
22
2.0
0
23
.50
83
.80
‐
‐
4.5
0
78
6.4
0
Total
3,447.10
2,692.60
45.00
847.30
439.30
1,771.30
62.60
‐
159.50
9,464.70
22 Circuit
HA
MP
SHIR
E2
,44
4.6
0
1,3
58
.50
16
.20
63
7.3
0
27
7.1
0
1,4
67
.40
23
4.7
0
‐
69
.10
6,5
04
.90
HA
RD
Y1
,56
1.4
0
1,3
00
.00
27
.50
63
0.4
0
14
1.2
0
1,6
74
.40
52
.70
‐
50
.00
5,4
37
.60
PEN
DLE
TON
50
3.7
0
20
9.8
0
11
.40
14
0.2
0
25
2.7
0
14
9.4
0
38
.70
‐
18
.50
1,3
24
.40
Total
4,509.70
2,868.30
55.10
1,407.90
671.00
3,291.20
326.10
‐
137.60
13,266.90
23 Circuit
BER
KEL
EY4
,39
9.3
0
44
4.2
0
‐
52
9.3
0
32
8.4
0
10
,78
0.4
5
1,6
88
.60
22
.20
5.0
0
18
,19
7.4
5
JEFF
ERSO
N1
,49
8.8
0
69
2.1
0
‐
34
9.2
0
26
1.4
0
4,2
32
.80
31
4.2
0
‐
19
.80
7,3
68
.30
MO
RG
AN
1,0
90
.90
41
3.6
0
‐
20
9.1
0
11
5.1
0
2,8
90
.30
10
1.9
0
‐
18
.20
4,8
39
.10
Total
6,989.00
1,549.90
‐
1,087.60
704.90
17,903.55
2,104.70
22.20
43.00
30,404.85
24 Circuit
WA
YNE
1,0
73
.20
13
5.6
0
13
4.2
0
10
7.8
0
23
7.7
0
3,0
86
.60
10
2.1
0
15
.30
37
.30
4,9
29
.80
Total
1,073.20
135.60
134.20
107.80
237.70
3,086.60
102.10
15.30
37.30
4,929.80
25 Circuit
BO
ON
E9
62
.10
10
2.6
0
‐
1,3
56
.70
13
9.3
0
1,8
48
.82
23
4.1
0
‐
64
.20
4,7
07
.82
LIN
CO
LN2
,33
1.8
0
65
8.4
0
17
2.7
0
41
2.4
0
65
2.9
0
3,1
42
.90
43
.70
‐
27
7.8
0
7,6
92
.60
Total
3,293.90
761.00
172.70
1,769.10
792.20
4,991.72
277.80
‐
342.00
12,400.42
26 Circuit
LEW
IS4
,00
3.6
4
1,3
60
.60
72
7.7
0
11
1.7
0
35
8.2
0
97
8.0
0
89
.90
‐
93
.20
7,7
22
.94
UP
SHU
R1
,90
4.8
0
1,1
00
.80
40
.40
81
9.5
0
19
9.5
0
1,8
03
.00
6.0
0
‐
52
.40
5,9
26
.40
Total
5,908.44
2,461.40
768.10
931.20
557.70
2,781.00
95.90
‐
145.60
13,649.34
27 Circuit
WYO
MIN
G3
,75
2.7
0
2,5
83
.40
52
.90
55
2.3
0
71
.90
3,2
45
.50
16
0.5
0
‐
57
.00
10
,47
6.2
0
Total
3,752.70
2,583.40
52.90
552.30
71.90
3,245.50
160.50
‐
57.00
10,476.20
28 Circuit
NIC
HO
LAS
1,4
41
.60
13
4.7
0
‐
55
.00
10
.30
2,9
95
.04
32
6.6
0
‐
‐
4,9
63
.24
Total
1,441.60
134.70
‐
55.00
10.30
2,995.04
326.60
‐
‐
4,963.24
FY2015 Annual Report Page 54 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Muni.
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juvenile
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Hours
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL HOURS PAID BY CIRCUIT & CASE TYPE
29 Circuit
PU
TNA
M5
,45
9.6
0
3,8
76
.90
49
6.6
0
2,1
27
.50
38
5.0
0
2,7
55
.60
91
.30
55
.70
24
5.5
0
15
,49
3.7
0
Total
5,459.60
3,876.90
496.60
2,127.50
385.00
2,755.60
91.30
55.70
245.50
15,493.70
30 Circuit
MIN
GO
2,9
23
.08
97
5.2
0
13
.90
42
8.8
0
55
.60
4,0
92
.20
24
0.6
0
13
.40
72
.00
8,8
14
.78
Total
2,923.08
975.20
13.90
428.80
55.60
4,092.20
240.60
13.40
72.00
8,814.78
31 Circuit
MO
NR
OE
1,2
48
.20
46
6.3
0
‐
11
3.8
0
50
.90
53
0.3
0
‐
5.6
0
1.1
0
2,4
16
.20
SUM
MER
S1
,35
4.0
0
36
7.9
0
17
.70
22
9.7
0
61
.60
87
6.6
0
15
.50
‐
15
.40
2,9
38
.40
Total
2,602.20
834.20
17.70
343.50
112.50
1,406.90
15.50
5.60
16.50
5,354.60
WV TOTA
L155,882.57
67,328.15
8,258.42
34,200.31
11,717.42
183,270.05
16,966.07
3,977.16
5,126.21
486,726.36
FY2015 Annual Report Page 55 of 212
Felony 7,458,273.81Misdemeanor 3,224,269.68Mental Hygiene 409,780.28Juvenile 1,659,347.82Parole/Prob. Rev. 563,854.00Term/Abuse & Neglect 8,871,695.83Habeas, Supreme Court 772,071.25Municipal Court Charges 195,874.20Other 244,119.80 (Mag. Ct. Appeal, Mandamus/Prohibition, Extradition, Contempt, Fugitive, Other)
Total Fees Paid 23,399,286.67
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL FEES PAID
Felony31.87%
Misdemeanor13.78%
Mental Hygiene1.75%
Juvenile7.09%
Parole/Prob. Rev.2.41%
Term/Abuse & Neglect37.91%
Habeas, Supreme Court
3.30%Municipal Court
Charges0.84%
Other1.04%
FY2015 Annual Report Page 56 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Muni.
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juv.
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Fee
01 Circuit
BR
OO
KE
86
,95
8.1
33
7,3
86
.72
13
,93
8.2
41
1,4
29
.47
3,8
66
.50
13
9,0
67
.38
7,8
27
.50
0.0
02
,31
4.0
03
02
,78
7.9
4
HA
NC
OC
K1
23
,59
1.8
33
7,9
02
.06
4,9
16
.27
19
,44
7.0
01
2,3
58
.32
19
9,5
12
.12
10
,55
4.5
61
,43
7.0
01
,34
5.0
04
11
,06
4.1
6
OH
IO1
42
,94
5.7
54
8,7
72
.50
82
,89
2.4
37
,61
4.5
01
,75
2.0
03
15
,87
7.7
25
8,1
48
.62
0.0
01
,01
8.5
06
59
,02
2.0
2
Total
353,495.71
124,061.28
101,746.94
38,490.97
17,976.82
654,457.22
76,530.68
1,437.00
4,677.50
1,372,874.12
02 Circuit
MA
RSH
ALL
54
,23
5.4
41
7,8
82
.52
7,6
56
.36
5,0
81
.50
3,9
65
.05
59
,55
7.6
94
,00
7.0
00
.00
61
3.5
01
52
,99
9.0
6
TYLE
R1
9,1
61
.91
5,6
16
.13
71
8.4
24
,97
3.2
21
,70
7.5
04
9,6
40
.48
1,6
51
.50
0.0
02
,42
4.6
88
5,8
93
.84
WET
ZEL
53
,19
3.7
35
,27
9.0
06
,04
9.6
65
,87
0.3
64
,00
5.5
06
7,8
92
.97
0.0
00
.00
0.0
01
42
,29
1.2
2
Total
126,591.08
28,777.65
14,424.44
15,925.08
9,678.05
177,091.14
5,658.50
0.00
3,038.18
381,184.12
03 Circuit
DO
DD
RID
GE
64
,49
6.1
53
6,1
72
.97
2,0
28
.31
14
,95
9.3
41
3,5
55
.56
76
,75
2.1
80
.00
0.0
04
,71
1.5
32
12
,67
6.0
4
PLE
ASA
NTS
57
,42
7.9
92
5,7
56
.40
1,1
77
.00
14
,22
3.4
52
,60
3.5
05
0,6
05
.57
92
5.0
00
.00
1,8
85
.00
15
4,6
03
.91
RIT
CH
IE5
1,4
90
.20
42
,43
5.4
21
,34
7.0
01
3,6
73
.31
2,2
61
.00
12
2,0
83
.42
7,3
79
.00
0.0
01
,26
4.4
92
41
,93
3.8
4
Total
173,414.34
104,364.79
4,552.31
42,856.10
18,420.06
249,441.17
8,304.00
0.00
7,861.02
609,213.79
04 Circuit
WIR
T2
5,7
91
.59
17
,66
6.0
05
8.0
01
3,2
47
.30
2,8
34
.00
10
,22
9.5
83
,18
6.0
00
.00
2,7
00
.50
75
,71
2.9
7
WO
OD
30
8,2
93
.29
37
2,9
60
.99
29
,16
4.5
57
2,0
99
.90
23
,12
9.6
63
54
,59
7.6
75
4,1
30
.00
0.0
01
3,5
91
.37
1,2
27
,96
7.4
3
Total
334,084.88
390,626.99
29,222.55
85,347.20
25,963.66
364,827.25
57,316.00
0.00
16,291.87
1,303,680.40
05 Circuit
CA
LHO
UN
75
,93
7.5
05
,09
3.6
06
74
.50
79
2.0
08
43
.50
12
5,6
53
.20
11
,19
1.5
00
.00
94
5.5
02
21
,13
1.3
0
JAC
KSO
N9
9,0
61
.45
18
,04
2.5
02
46
.76
14
,05
4.0
01
1,9
34
.68
21
7,7
39
.05
30
,07
4.5
00
.00
8,7
93
.35
39
9,9
46
.29
MA
SON
13
1,4
20
.25
10
1,6
76
.88
9,0
74
.18
52
,55
1.1
02
0,2
29
.16
88
,96
4.5
01
0,1
23
.00
0.0
06
,36
7.0
04
20
,40
6.0
7
RO
AN
E9
6,2
29
.49
8,0
94
.69
2,8
68
.38
12
,83
8.7
34
,27
0.0
07
1,5
54
.32
5,1
85
.74
0.0
04
,07
9.3
02
05
,12
0.6
5
Total
402,648.69
132,907.67
12,863.82
80,235.83
37,277.34
503,911.07
56,574.74
0.00
20,185.15
1,246,604.31
06 Circuit
CA
BEL
L4
05
,42
1.8
12
8,9
65
.58
64
,74
0.5
83
4,6
62
.43
28
,59
4.3
53
31
,97
6.1
83
7,9
57
.50
0.0
01
0,8
11
.01
94
3,1
29
.44
Total
405,421.81
28,965.58
64,740.58
34,662.43
28,594.35
331,976.18
37,957.50
0.00
10,811.01
943,129.44
07 Circuit
LOG
AN
12
0,6
74
.31
13
0,3
80
.90
14
9.0
08
7,9
69
.56
9,8
05
.00
20
0,9
77
.47
16
,07
3.5
00
.00
1,2
80
.00
56
7,3
09
.74
Total
120,674.31
130,380.90
149.00
87,969.56
9,805.00
200,977.47
16,073.50
0.00
1,280.00
567,309.74
08 Circuit
MC
DO
WEL
L2
04
,37
2.4
87
9,0
23
.81
6,0
52
.44
7,0
69
.30
85
3.5
01
56
,02
1.2
71
9,0
69
.50
0.0
03
,90
6.0
04
76
,36
8.3
0
Total
204,372.48
79,023.81
6,052.44
7,069.30
853.50
156,021.27
19,069.50
0.00
3,906.00
476,368.30
09 Circuit
MER
CER
52
3,3
49
.86
12
1,6
08
.61
28
,50
4.9
12
27
,35
7.1
62
4,7
64
.91
48
9,6
80
.53
22
,73
8.5
08
,97
7.7
71
5,3
49
.86
1,4
62
,33
2.1
1
Total
523,349.86
121,608.61
28,504.91
227,357.16
24,764.91
489,680.53
22,738.50
8,977.77
15,349.86
1,462,332.11
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL FEES BY CASE TYPE
FY2015 Annual Report Page 57 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Muni.
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juv.
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Fee
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL FEES BY CASE TYPE
10 Circuit
RA
LEIG
H2
00
,67
2.2
26
8,0
34
.48
1,1
36
.50
24
,01
1.0
11
6,1
78
.95
56
5,2
28
.66
24
,48
1.2
00
.00
2,0
95
.30
90
1,8
38
.32
Total
200,672.22
68,034.48
1,136.50
24,011.01
16,178.95
565,228.66
24,481.20
0.00
2,095.30
901,838.32
11 Circuit
GR
EEN
BR
IER
12
8,3
10
.47
23
,72
5.5
57
16
.00
5,6
54
.58
4,1
68
.00
18
2,4
64
.31
10
,04
7.6
21
,61
6.0
03
,40
3.5
03
60
,10
6.0
3
PO
CA
HO
NTA
S5
1,5
01
.52
9,6
17
.15
1,5
58
.09
3,6
07
.50
0.0
06
5,4
17
.00
0.0
00
.00
60
8.5
01
32
,30
9.7
6
Total
179,811.99
33,342.70
2,274.09
9,262.08
4,168.00
247,881.31
10,047.62
1,616.00
4,012.00
492,415.79
12 Circuit
FAYE
TTE
14
3,8
26
.47
34
,21
7.9
60
.00
11
,13
5.0
05
,05
7.6
21
75
,10
8.9
21
5,2
41
.50
1,1
15
.00
16
3.0
03
85
,86
5.4
7
Total
143,826.47
34,217.96
11,135.00
5,057.62
175,108.92
15,241.50
1,115.00
163.00
385,865.47
13 Circuit
KA
NA
WH
A5
28
,76
4.9
12
53
,21
7.8
80
.00
82
,12
5.0
33
3,5
24
.72
55
1,0
08
.56
11
0,6
61
.25
13
3,7
40
.06
18
,00
8.5
11
,71
1,0
50
.92
Total
528,764.91
253,217.88
0.00
82,125.03
33,524.72
551,008.56
110,661.25
133,740.06
18,008.51
1,711,050.92
14 Circuit
BR
AX
TON
71
,92
4.3
04
1,4
92
.61
74
1.5
01
5,5
23
.41
5,2
25
.07
14
4,6
95
.65
1,0
28
.50
0.0
02
,28
4.6
42
82
,91
5.6
8
CLA
Y8
5,4
14
.68
18
,99
2.1
53
12
.00
13
,95
4.5
51
,30
9.5
02
28
,96
2.3
71
,67
4.0
02
91
.50
22
4.0
03
51
,13
4.7
5
GIL
MER
55
,54
0.3
33
1,0
78
.75
21
0.5
01
5,6
72
.00
2,7
37
.00
62
,92
5.2
42
,30
5.4
22
,04
8.6
92
,86
2.1
81
75
,38
0.1
1
WEB
STER
16
7,2
63
.12
31
,58
1.7
63
53
.50
27
,17
1.4
34
,66
5.1
42
66
,01
0.8
11
4,1
64
.74
0.0
02
,31
6.3
25
13
,52
6.8
2
Total
380,142.43
123,145.27
1,617.50
72,321.39
13,936.71
702,594.07
19,172.66
2,340.19
7,687.14
1,322,957.36
15 Circuit
HA
RR
ISO
N1
97
,21
3.8
14
4,4
24
.47
4,4
39
.50
17
,73
9.7
51
0,7
22
.05
20
0,3
62
.02
26
,98
8.1
80
.00
6,2
28
.13
50
8,1
17
.91
Total
197,213.81
44,424.47
4,439.50
17,739.75
10,722.05
200,362.02
26,988.18
0.00
6,228.13
508,117.91
16 Circuit
MA
RIO
N3
13
,62
6.4
61
58
,57
0.6
51
7,2
38
.31
88
,77
1.6
23
7,5
89
.09
15
6,8
97
.65
26
,89
0.5
01
5,4
26
.00
15
,11
0.7
58
30
,12
1.0
3
Total
313,626.46
158,570.65
17,238.31
88,771.62
37,589.09
156,897.65
26,890.50
15,426.00
15,110.75
830,121.03
17 Circuit
MO
NO
NG
ALI
A4
66
,15
1.2
32
42
,88
2.9
62
4,4
18
.68
68
,08
2.2
94
8,7
94
.50
21
1,0
82
.94
34
,18
0.7
92
2,7
51
.18
11
,58
7.6
61
,12
9,9
32
.23
Total
466,151.23
242,882.96
24,418.68
68,082.29
48,794.50
211,082.94
34,180.79
22,751.18
11,587.66
1,129,932.23
18 Circuit
PR
ESTO
N8
0,3
12
.17
39
,28
2.3
11
,41
0.5
03
,61
1.0
04
,66
5.5
02
12
,80
0.3
95
,45
5.5
00
.00
10
,58
8.7
33
58
,12
6.1
0
Total
80,312.17
39,282.31
1,410.50
3,611.00
4,665.50
212,800.39
5,455.50
0.00
10,588.73
358,126.10
19 Circuit
BA
RB
OU
R6
4,8
71
.37
37
,23
8.4
19
03
.00
49
,34
4.2
21
,77
5.0
01
44
,72
7.8
64
,13
2.5
00
.00
1,2
28
.50
30
4,2
20
.86
TAYL
OR
82
,62
8.3
23
7,6
32
.20
2,9
50
.47
66
,29
8.2
55
,57
6.0
01
30
,23
8.7
11
,99
3.5
00
.00
10
,60
2.3
53
37
,91
9.8
0
Total
147,499.69
74,870.61
3,853.47
115,642.47
7,351.00
274,966.57
6,126.00
0.00
11,830.85
642,140.66
FY2015 Annual Report Page 58 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Muni.
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juv.
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Fee
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL FEES BY CASE TYPE
20 Circuit
RA
ND
OLP
H1
73
,08
2.8
31
02
,55
7.9
63
,87
4.0
07
6,0
50
.32
12
,70
4.6
48
9,6
50
.30
19
,99
8.0
02
,93
8.0
01
2,8
80
.95
49
3,7
37
.00
Total
173,082.83
102,557.96
3,874.00
76,050.32
12,704.64
89,650.30
19,998.00
2,938.00
12,880.95
493,737.00
21 Circuit
GR
AN
T5
2,0
74
.70
24
,60
2.9
07
22
.00
13
,84
9.0
08
,31
9.5
22
9,7
00
.85
0.0
00
.00
3,4
77
.50
13
2,7
46
.47
MIN
ERA
L1
00
,17
9.8
79
2,1
08
.75
1,6
09
.61
16
,14
3.2
21
1,4
55
.10
50
,31
9.2
32
,81
7.0
00
.00
3,9
27
.50
27
8,5
60
.28
TUC
KER
10
,73
6.5
01
0,4
78
.50
0.0
01
0,6
08
.00
1,1
17
.50
4,1
21
.00
0.0
00
.00
21
2.5
03
7,2
74
.00
TOTA
L162,991.07
127,190.15
2,331.61
40,600.22
20,892.12
84,141.08
2,817.00
0.00
7,617.50
448,580.75
22 Circuit
HA
MP
SHIR
E1
19
,27
9.0
46
5,7
09
.10
96
7.0
03
1,6
44
.41
13
,41
4.3
17
1,3
00
.68
10
,84
2.8
70
.00
3,5
43
.53
31
6,7
00
.94
HA
RD
Y7
5,3
47
.33
61
,96
3.4
61
,53
3.5
03
1,4
52
.85
6,7
99
.37
81
,37
0.0
02
,37
1.5
00
.00
2,4
22
.00
26
3,2
60
.01
PEN
DLE
TON
23
,81
9.0
09
,92
7.1
75
69
.21
6,7
11
.00
11
,97
9.5
07
,21
1.0
01
,79
3.5
00
.00
89
8.5
06
2,9
08
.88
Total
218,445.37
137,599.73
3,069.71
69,808.26
32,193.18
159,881.68
15,007.87
0.00
6,864.03
642,869.83
23 Circuit
BER
KEL
EY2
14
,33
9.4
22
1,5
97
.63
0.0
02
5,5
85
.06
15
,83
8.7
05
15
,50
7.9
47
6,3
54
.21
1,0
63
.00
27
7.0
08
70
,56
2.9
6
JEFF
ERSO
N7
3,6
70
.29
33
,74
0.6
30
.00
16
,67
8.0
01
3,1
32
.35
20
2,8
17
.64
14
,28
9.0
00
.00
94
3.0
03
55
,27
0.9
1
MO
RG
AN
52
,80
0.3
21
9,6
08
.15
0.0
09
,92
7.8
95
,56
5.9
11
39
,30
5.7
24
,61
9.5
00
.00
87
1.0
02
32
,69
8.4
9
Total
340,810.03
74,946.41
0.00
52,190.95
34,536.96
857,631.30
95,262.71
1,063.00
2,091.00
1,458,532.36
24 Circuit
WA
YNE
54
,39
2.0
07
,54
8.8
78
,47
1.9
55
,43
3.2
11
1,7
94
.50
16
2,1
36
.69
4,6
80
.50
79
4.5
01
,96
9.0
82
57
,22
1.3
0
Total
54,392.00
7,548.87
8,471.95
5,433.21
11,794.50
162,136.69
4,680.50
794.50
1,969.08
257,221.30
25 Circuit
BO
ON
E5
0,9
65
.06
5,6
25
.40
0.0
06
7,1
15
.57
6,9
26
.63
97
,08
6.0
11
0,5
74
.50
0.0
03
,12
7.0
02
41
,42
0.1
7
LIN
CO
LN1
13
,16
9.9
73
1,8
74
.14
8,1
47
.50
20
,56
6.0
03
1,5
02
.50
15
6,2
11
.93
2,0
16
.50
0.0
01
3,4
33
.47
37
6,9
22
.01
Total
164,135.03
37,499.54
8,147.50
87,681.57
38,429.13
253,297.94
12,591.00
0.00
16,560.47
618,342.18
26 Circuit
LEW
IS1
92
,79
2.5
16
4,8
00
.43
35
,47
4.5
05
,32
0.5
01
7,5
59
.47
46
,63
2.1
24
,11
6.5
90
.00
4,4
22
.00
37
1,1
18
.12
UP
SHU
R9
1,9
81
.16
53
,19
3.2
92
,13
0.0
03
9,3
39
.73
9,8
49
.71
86
,94
9.3
02
70
.00
0.0
02
,54
8.0
02
86
,26
1.1
9
Total
284,773.67
117,993.72
37,604.50
44,660.23
27,409.18
133,581.42
4,386.59
0.00
6,970.00
657,379.31
27 Circuit
WYO
MIN
G1
78
,46
7.3
31
23
,32
4.1
22
,84
6.5
02
6,8
73
.68
3,5
43
.74
15
6,2
10
.06
7,3
32
.50
0.0
02
,77
7.1
05
01
,37
5.0
3
Total
178,467.33
123,324.12
2,846.50
26,873.68
3,543.74
156,210.06
7,332.50
0.00
2,777.10
501,375.03
28 Circuit
NIC
HO
LAS
69
,56
8.1
76
,66
0.2
40
.00
2,8
17
.00
52
0.1
31
44
,65
3.3
01
4,7
31
.02
0.0
00
.00
23
8,9
49
.86
Total
69,568.17
6,660.24
0.00
2,817.00
520.13
144,653.30
14,731.02
0.00
0.00
238,949.86
FY2015 Annual Report Page 59 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Muni.
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juv.
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Fee
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL FEES BY CASE TYPE
29 Circuit
PU
TNA
M2
57
,84
6.3
61
86
,05
3.7
42
3,1
22
.97
10
2,3
06
.83
18
,37
7.7
11
33
,84
4.7
44
,13
6.5
02
,70
6.5
01
1,4
84
.51
73
9,8
79
.86
Total
257,846.36
186,053.74
23,122.97
102,306.83
18,377.71
133,844.74
4,136.50
2,706.50
11,484.51
739,879.86
30 Circuit
MIN
GO
14
4,3
02
.50
50
,03
8.4
37
49
.50
20
,97
0.0
82
,59
0.0
02
01
,22
6.2
51
0,9
61
.94
70
5.0
03
,43
2.0
04
34
,97
5.7
0
Total
144,302.50
50,038.43
749.50
20,970.08
2,590.00
201,226.25
10,961.94
705.00
3,432.00
434,975.70
31 Circuit
MO
NR
OE
60
,37
8.6
92
2,5
01
.70
0.0
05
,87
4.1
62
,51
2.8
82
6,1
19
.64
0.0
02
64
.00
49
.50
11
7,7
00
.57
SUM
MER
S6
7,0
06
.22
17
,64
8.5
09
16
.50
11
,46
6.0
43
,02
8.0
04
3,0
07
.04
69
7.5
00
.00
71
1.0
01
44
,48
0.8
0
Total
127,384.91
40,150.20
916.50
17,340.20
5,540.88
69,126.68
697.50
264.00
760.50
262,181.37
WV TOTA
L7,458,273.81
3,224,269.68
409,780.28
1,659,347.82
563,854.00
8,871,695.83
772,071.25
195,874.20
244,119.80
23,399,286.67
FY2015 Annual Report Page 60 of 212
Felony 1,466,581.02Misdemeanor 200,694.53Mental Hygiene 13,452.13Juvenile 90,290.58Parole/Prob. Rev. 34,234.51Term/Abuse & Neglect 600,113.83Habeas, Supreme Court 121,781.33Municipal Court Charges 6,111.78Other 22,350.86
Total Expenses Paid 2,555,610.57
APPOINTED COUNSEL EXPENSES PAIDINCLUDING DIRECT EXPENSES
(Mag. Ct. Appeal, Mandamus/Prohibition, Extradition, Contempt, Fugitive, Other)
Felony57.39%
Misdemeanor7.85%
Mental Hygiene0.53%
Juvenile3.53%
Parole/Prob. Rev.1.34%
Term/Abuse & Neglect23.48%
Habeas, Supreme Court4.77%
Municipal Court Charges0.24%
Other0.87%
FY2015 Annual Report Page 61 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Muni.
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juv.
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Expenses
01 Circuit
BR
OO
KE
22
,32
2.5
33
,18
1.8
84
99
.33
71
3.5
23
08
.68
7,6
70
.73
1,6
40
.06
0.0
01
,02
9.8
63
7,3
66
.59
HA
NC
OC
K1
6,3
43
.14
2,2
29
.00
15
9.8
01
,34
9.3
11
,07
2.9
89
,87
2.8
61
,26
4.4
49
9.6
11
30
.69
32
,52
1.8
3
OH
IO4
3,0
93
.22
2,8
20
.23
21
.24
29
5.2
71
20
.64
11
,71
2.9
36
,28
3.6
10
.00
28
.53
64
,37
5.6
7
Total
81,758.89
8,231.11
680.37
2,358.10
1,502.30
29,256.52
9,188.11
99.61
1,189.08
134,264.09
02 Circuit
MA
RSH
ALL
2,0
51
.98
2,3
04
.23
49
1.0
01
84
.00
11
0.8
81
,72
3.2
53
95
.87
0.0
02
0.3
67
,28
1.5
7
TYLE
R9
,84
9.5
65
14
.90
72
.32
32
8.1
11
80
.78
3,4
03
.65
19
0.1
00
.00
22
2.4
21
4,7
61
.84
WET
ZEL
2,8
36
.48
32
8.3
25
50
.28
17
8.2
63
20
.49
3,7
83
.76
0.0
00
.00
0.0
07
,99
7.5
9
Total
14,738.02
3,147.45
1,113.60
690.37
612.15
8,910.66
585.97
0.00
242.78
30,041.00
03 Circuit
DO
DD
RID
GE
12
,48
2.6
05
,50
4.5
43
34
.28
1,5
30
.66
1,9
09
.00
8,4
52
.28
0.0
00
.00
56
0.7
53
0,7
74
.11
PLE
ASA
NTS
10
,17
0.8
33
,86
5.5
91
20
.14
81
3.8
52
88
.06
4,1
83
.12
91
.66
0.0
07
4.8
31
9,6
08
.08
RIT
CH
IE1
6,4
12
.55
4,4
26
.44
16
3.9
42
88
.33
14
3.2
71
2,6
59
.06
56
5.2
70
.00
94
.07
34
,75
2.9
3
Total
39,065.98
13,796.57
618.36
2,632.84
2,340.33
25,294.46
656.93
0.00
729.65
85,135.12
04 Circuit
WIR
T1
1,0
79
.60
1,9
98
.47
0.9
41
,50
4.5
72
72
.08
90
9.1
04
52
.73
0.0
02
60
.66
16
,47
8.1
5
WO
OD
66
,25
2.4
61
7,3
57
.15
1,0
82
.97
2,9
80
.60
2,5
01
.48
29
,49
7.0
92
0,8
19
.28
0.0
08
12
.43
14
1,3
03
.46
Total
77,332.06
19,355.62
1,083.91
4,485.17
2,773.56
30,406.19
21,272.01
0.00
1,073.09
157,781.61
05 Circuit
CA
LHO
UN
10
,21
2.3
48
61
.41
49
.35
0.0
01
41
.35
10
,13
7.3
42
,18
7.4
20
.00
16
7.1
02
3,7
56
.31
JAC
KSO
N1
7,3
51
.05
2,7
23
.46
14
.06
1,4
16
.07
1,2
36
.96
19
,37
2.5
44
,60
4.8
10
.00
96
6.8
34
7,6
85
.78
MA
SON
8,6
65
.74
4,5
52
.14
0.0
01
,72
4.0
83
24
.32
2,6
16
.03
1,2
57
.66
0.0
01
55
.80
19
,29
5.7
7
RO
AN
E1
3,2
79
.30
1,0
18
.81
52
2.9
01
,00
4.7
88
12
.18
5,1
34
.64
92
3.4
50
.00
78
1.8
02
3,4
77
.86
Total
49,508.43
9,155.82
586.31
4,144.93
2,514.81
37,260.55
8,973.34
0.00
2,071.53
114,215.72
06 Circuit
CA
BEL
L7
0,3
40
.84
31
8.9
94
21
.74
33
1.6
39
50
.65
5,8
95
.73
2,0
16
.37
0.0
02
45
.10
80
,52
1.0
5
Total
70,340.84
318.99
421.74
331.63
950.65
5,895.73
2,016.37
0.00
245.10
80,521.05
07 Circuit
LOG
AN
11
,34
4.4
88
,71
1.0
30
.30
2,6
06
.07
1,1
71
.19
6,5
05
.35
1,5
49
.88
0.0
02
6.4
43
1,9
14
.74
Total
11,344.48
8,711.03
0.30
2,606.07
1,171.19
6,505.35
1,549.88
0.00
26.44
31,914.74
08 Circuit
MC
DO
WEL
L3
5,3
86
.60
1,4
49
.47
21
6.5
84
13
.00
88
.44
8,0
39
.65
2,0
23
.05
0.0
02
69
.52
47
,88
6.3
1
Total
35,386.60
1,449.47
216.58
413.00
88.44
8,039.65
2,023.05
0.00
269.52
47,886.31
09 Circuit
MER
CER
11
9,2
90
.93
10
,78
7.6
72
,19
3.6
32
1,4
05
.33
1,6
98
.60
51
,25
5.8
61
4,0
38
.01
1,0
18
.51
78
7.7
22
22
,47
6.2
6
Total
119,290.93
10,787.67
2,193.63
21,405.33
1,698.60
51,255.86
14,038.01
1,018.51
787.72
222,476.26
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL EX
PEN
SES BY CASE TYPE
FY2015 Annual Report Page 62 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Muni.
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juv.
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Expenses
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL EX
PEN
SES BY CASE TYPE
10 Circuit
RA
LEIG
H2
2,9
74
.23
3,9
65
.67
23
.25
72
7.1
12
,51
6.2
24
4,8
43
.72
3,6
77
.53
0.0
01
13
.46
78
,84
1.1
9
Total
22,974.23
3,965.67
23.25
727.11
2,516.22
44,843.72
3,677.53
0.00
113.46
78,841.19
11 Circuit
GR
EEN
BR
IER
5,4
36
.32
88
.79
10
.67
2.4
07
2.3
92
,74
6.6
76
31
.21
35
.64
10
1.8
09
,12
5.8
9
PO
CA
HO
NTA
S3
,58
7.4
74
74
.47
6.5
89
5.2
00
.00
2,6
91
.85
0.0
00
.00
10
.81
6,8
66
.38
Total
9,023.79
563.26
17.25
97.60
72.39
5,438.52
631.21
35.64
112.61
15,992.27
12 Circuit
FAYE
TTE
7,1
53
.50
41
8.2
30
.00
79
7.4
73
11
.08
8,4
70
.97
1,3
16
.73
36
.20
11
.84
18
,51
6.0
2
Total
7,153.50
418.23
797.47
311.08
8,470.97
1,316.73
36.20
11.84
18,516.02
13 Circuit
KA
NA
WH
A8
0,6
72
.69
7,2
00
.52
0.0
03
,48
5.3
35
93
.54
22
,13
8.4
28
,54
0.9
63
,03
3.6
01
,50
3.0
11
27
,16
8.0
7
Total
80,672.69
7,200.52
0.00
3,485.33
593.54
22,138.42
8,540.96
3,033.60
1,503.01
127,168.07
14 Circuit
BR
AX
TON
9,0
76
.41
4,2
04
.92
0.0
09
94
.76
69
9.7
21
1,6
60
.60
86
.49
0.0
01
45
.61
26
,86
8.5
1
CLA
Y4
,64
2.1
12
,42
9.1
30
.00
1,8
06
.58
28
6.4
51
4,8
12
.29
36
0.6
14
6.0
65
0.5
62
4,4
33
.79
GIL
MER
7,0
27
.41
3,3
77
.06
0.0
01
,35
5.1
04
31
.17
6,5
59
.00
20
8.1
01
47
.02
14
5.9
01
9,2
50
.76
WEB
STER
47
,68
9.4
83
,38
7.0
83
2.8
74
,02
1.3
36
19
.58
33
,38
8.8
91
,88
5.4
70
.00
29
7.9
39
1,3
22
.63
Total
68,435.41
13,398.19
32.87
8,177.77
2,036.92
66,420.78
2,540.67
193.08
640.00
161,875.69
15 Circuit
HA
RR
ISO
N1
52
,27
7.5
31
,74
2.1
34
19
.18
2,2
88
.18
61
6.0
56
,54
7.4
34
,18
6.1
80
.00
15
3.7
71
68
,23
0.4
5
Total
152,277.53
1,742.13
419.18
2,288.18
616.05
6,547.43
4,186.18
0.00
153.77
168,230.45
16 Circuit
MA
RIO
N9
3,5
11
.60
4,0
50
.96
86
8.3
81
,96
6.7
08
38
.83
3,1
97
.09
1,9
34
.31
20
9.9
73
91
.23
10
6,9
69
.07
Total
93,511.60
4,050.96
868.38
1,966.70
838.83
3,197.09
1,934.31
209.97
391.23
106,969.07
17 Circuit
MO
NO
NG
ALI
A6
0,2
17
.52
9,3
60
.84
1,0
75
.15
2,1
70
.49
1,5
02
.68
10
,63
1.6
13
,51
5.0
68
21
.29
77
6.0
29
0,0
70
.66
Total
60,217.52
9,360.84
1,075.15
2,170.49
1,502.68
10,631.61
3,515.06
821.29
776.02
90,070.66
18 Circuit
PR
ESTO
N7
,94
3.3
22
,24
7.5
11
50
.94
35
2.4
74
31
.61
18
,78
6.7
32
,86
8.1
20
.00
6,2
64
.55
39
,04
5.2
5
Total
7,943.32
2,247.51
150.94
352.47
431.61
18,786.73
2,868.12
0.00
6,264.55
39,045.25
19 Circuit
BA
RB
OU
R5
,16
1.7
22
,77
7.2
94
9.1
12
,74
5.4
73
58
.79
7,7
37
.82
71
4.2
70
.00
31
.74
19
,57
6.2
1
TAYL
OR
6,0
00
.11
2,2
00
.34
54
.51
2,5
16
.47
25
7.9
36
,69
8.0
06
30
.72
0.0
04
87
.83
18
,84
5.9
1
Total
11,161.83
4,977.63
103.62
5,261.94
616.72
14,435.82
1,344.99
0.00
519.57
38,422.12
FY2015 Annual Report Page 63 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Muni.
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juv.
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Expenses
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL EX
PEN
SES BY CASE TYPE
20 Circuit
RA
ND
OLP
H5
4,6
82
.51
8,1
12
.49
12
4.2
72
,11
8.4
57
18
.39
3,9
59
.77
2,5
60
.94
40
9.7
87
04
.36
73
,39
0.9
6
Total
54,682.51
8,112.49
124.27
2,118.45
718.39
3,959.77
2,560.94
409.78
704.36
73,390.96
21 Circuit
GR
AN
T7
,39
8.5
87
09
.50
1.8
89
41
.84
36
0.0
73
,94
5.5
40
.00
0.0
01
82
.36
13
,53
9.7
7
MIN
ERA
L3
4,0
20
.50
6,6
81
.54
9.2
02
52
.10
51
2.8
01
,48
2.9
46
29
.70
0.0
04
7.3
04
3,6
36
.08
TUC
KER
5,1
42
.02
1,4
43
.44
0.0
08
42
.02
11
8.9
42
94
.29
0.0
00
.00
15
.51
7,8
56
.22
Total
46,561.10
8,834.48
11.08
2,035.96
991.81
5,722.77
629.70
0.00
245.17
65,032.07
22 Circuit
HA
MP
SHIR
E2
3,5
45
.33
4,6
92
.57
0.0
02
,51
6.4
54
81
.03
2,7
34
.16
4,7
96
.63
0.0
09
97
.85
39
,76
4.0
2
HA
RD
Y1
3,1
67
.57
5,2
83
.22
1.8
81
,07
0.2
84
86
.44
6,0
85
.12
14
8.3
20
.00
91
.78
26
,33
4.6
1
PEN
DLE
TON
9,0
39
.86
38
5.1
33
3.8
47
83
.70
1,0
43
.09
13
8.8
63
10
.28
0.0
03
5.9
61
1,7
70
.72
Total
45,752.76
10,360.92
35.72
4,370.43
2,010.56
8,958.14
5,255.23
0.00
1,125.59
77,869.35
23 Circuit
BER
KEL
EY7
9,1
88
.43
1,0
18
.67
0.0
01
,66
9.1
77
91
.15
56
,41
9.8
78
,54
4.1
14
6.2
70
.00
14
7,6
77
.67
JEFF
ERSO
N4
0,2
13
.22
5,3
05
.75
0.0
01
,58
7.1
64
23
.45
15
,91
4.2
94
,51
7.4
30
.00
57
.57
68
,01
8.8
7
MO
RG
AN
10
,14
6.7
03
,31
4.2
20
.00
1,0
88
.88
60
7.2
01
6,7
90
.61
89
2.8
50
.00
23
8.7
03
3,0
79
.16
Total
12
9,5
48
.35
9,6
38
.64
0.0
04
,34
5.2
11
,82
1.8
08
9,1
24
.77
13
,95
4.3
94
6.2
72
96
.27
24
8,7
75
.70
24 Circuit
WA
YNE
14
,22
2.0
62
90
.50
46
.07
11
6.2
81
65
.95
9,3
21
.78
25
2.3
33
.45
21
.48
24
,43
9.9
0
Total
14,222.06
290.50
46.07
116.28
165.95
9,321.78
252.33
3.45
21.48
24,439.90
25 Circuit
BO
ON
E2
,90
0.3
13
2.7
40
.00
2,0
39
.83
48
3.1
54
,91
8.6
81
,52
6.1
20
.00
47
.74
11
,94
8.5
7
LIN
CO
LN3
,60
4.9
11
,37
5.1
52
46
.78
1,5
79
.85
93
1.2
26
,65
8.7
11
,48
6.0
00
.00
56
3.8
71
6,4
46
.49
Total
6,505.22
1,407.89
246.78
3,619.68
1,414.37
11,577.39
3,012.12
0.00
611.61
28,395.06
26 Circuit
LEW
IS2
6,8
98
.34
3,8
17
.64
2,2
43
.53
35
2.8
01
,26
4.4
31
,79
8.1
61
,06
4.4
50
.00
41
4.9
03
7,8
54
.25
UP
SHU
R7
,38
6.4
32
,52
5.6
31
28
.68
1,1
23
.25
46
8.8
91
3,8
58
.13
0.7
00
.00
15
1.5
92
5,6
43
.30
Total
34,284.77
6,343.27
2,372.21
1,476.05
1,733.32
15,656.29
1,065.15
0.00
566.49
63,497.55
27 Circuit
WYO
MIN
G3
7,3
85
.77
15
,74
6.3
81
56
.04
1,6
20
.85
26
5.7
31
1,7
87
.06
50
2.6
10
.00
23
0.3
06
7,6
94
.74
Total
37,385.77
15,746.38
156.04
1,620.85
265.73
11,787.06
502.61
0.00
230.30
67,694.74
28 Circuit
NIC
HO
LAS
13
,10
3.2
25
76
.56
0.0
09
7.0
90
.00
13
,17
8.3
01
,93
8.4
90
.00
0.0
02
8,8
93
.66
Total
13,103.22
576.56
0.00
97.09
0.00
13,178.30
1,938.49
0.00
0.00
28,893.66
FY2015 Annual Report Page 64 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Muni.
Total
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juv.
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Expenses
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL EX
PEN
SES BY CASE TYPE
29 Circuit
PU
TNA
M3
1,4
56
.39
12
,26
2.4
87
29
.24
4,6
14
.61
1,2
52
.99
17
,47
3.9
25
92
.21
18
3.9
91
,35
2.6
46
9,9
18
.47
Total
31,456.39
12,262.48
729.24
4,614.61
1,252.99
17,473.92
592.21
183.99
1,352.64
69,918.47
30 Circuit
MIN
GO
26
,84
7.2
46
98
.72
0.0
08
.10
1.4
93
,49
4.8
11
,00
2.3
10
.00
6.8
03
2,0
59
.47
Total
26,847.24
698.72
0.00
8.10
1.49
3,494.81
1,002.31
0.00
6.80
32,059.47
31 Circuit
MO
NR
OE
8,0
62
.80
1,9
33
.92
0.0
05
84
.02
27
3.3
52
,36
4.3
70
.00
20
.39
3.8
41
3,2
42
.69
SUM
MER
S6
,03
1.1
81
,60
9.6
11
25
.28
89
1.3
53
96
.68
3,7
58
.40
15
6.4
20
.00
65
.34
13
,03
4.2
6
Total
14,093.98
3,543.53
125.28
1,475.37
670.03
6,122.77
156.42
20.39
69.18
26,276.95
WV TOTA
L1,466,581.02
200,694.53
13,452.13
90,290.58
34,234.51
600,113.83
121,781.33
6,111.78
22,350.86
2,555,610.57
FY2015 Annual Report Page 65 of 212
Expert Witness $410,010.98Court Reporter $82,000.02Investigator $471,101.18Travel $870,422.48Miscellaneous Office $287,900.03Paralegal $85,539.97Other $348,635.91Total Expenses $2,555,610.57
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL EXPENSES BY CATEGORY
Expert Witness16.04%
Court Reporter3.21%
Investigator18.43%
Travel34.06%
Miscellaneous Office11.27%
Paralegal3.35%
Other13.64%
FY2015 Annual Report Page 66 of 212
Circuit
County
01 Circuit
BR
OO
KE
45
0.0
01
,14
2.3
50
.00
15
,90
6.8
42
,46
6.9
05
36
.00
16
,86
4.5
03
7,3
66
.59
HA
NC
OC
K6
,90
0.0
05
36
.30
0.0
01
8,5
67
.79
4,8
96
.84
1,0
80
.00
54
0.9
03
2,5
21
.83
OH
IO1
8,5
75
.00
5,1
20
.35
4,4
98
.08
15
,52
7.2
79
,28
9.9
22
,09
1.3
09
,27
3.7
56
4,3
75
.67
Total
25,925.00
6,799.00
4,498.08
50,001.90
16,653.66
3,707.30
26,679.15
134,264.09
02 Circuit
MA
RSH
ALL
1,7
35
.00
0.0
00
.00
4,1
05
.71
1,4
40
.86
0.0
00
.00
7,2
81
.57
TYLE
R0
.00
0.0
01
,20
3.0
56
,20
0.8
07
35
.50
0.0
06
,62
2.4
91
4,7
61
.84
WET
ZEL
0.0
08
4.7
11
39
.02
6,8
44
.47
79
2.1
20
.00
13
7.2
77
,99
7.5
9
Total
1,735.00
84.71
1,342.07
17,150.98
2,968.48
0.00
6,759.76
30,041.00
03 Circuit
DO
DD
RID
GE
0.0
00
.00
8,4
27
.87
19
,42
0.7
32
,22
5.5
16
34
.70
65
.30
30
,77
4.1
1
PLE
ASA
NTS
1,2
00
.00
11
4.0
06
,93
5.2
48
,27
9.7
51
,12
7.7
11
,95
1.3
80
.00
19
,60
8.0
8
RIT
CH
IE5
,83
0.4
41
,22
9.7
58
,36
2.1
81
3,8
92
.51
3,9
97
.43
1,3
05
.70
13
4.9
23
4,7
52
.93
Total
7,030.44
1,343.75
23,725.29
41,592.99
7,350.65
3,891.78
200.22
85,135.12
04 Circuit
WIR
T0
.00
0.0
07
,40
5.4
66
,00
5.9
41
,31
9.2
52
47
.50
1,5
00
.00
16
,47
8.1
5
WO
OD
3,4
20
.88
7,2
18
.10
53
,31
6.3
53
0,5
55
.61
19
,98
0.3
01
4,0
58
.41
12
,75
3.8
11
41
,30
3.4
6
Total
3,420.88
7,218.10
60,721.81
36,561.55
21,299.55
14,305.91
14,253.81
157,781.61
05 Circuit
CA
LHO
UN
0.0
01
,60
7.9
00
.00
19
,06
1.6
83
,08
6.7
30
.00
0.0
02
3,7
56
.31
JAC
KSO
N0
.00
1,2
05
.80
6,2
08
.16
32
,66
1.1
95
,93
9.7
17
21
.00
94
9.9
24
7,6
85
.78
MA
SON
1,5
00
.00
30
.80
47
6.3
81
4,4
44
.33
2,2
09
.76
0.0
06
34
.50
19
,29
5.7
7
RO
AN
E0
.00
90
0.9
50
.00
20
,59
0.7
41
,98
6.1
70
.00
0.0
02
3,4
77
.86
Total
1,500.00
3,745.45
6,684.54
86,757.94
13,222.37
721.00
1,584.42
114,215.72
06 Circuit
CA
BEL
L1
3,7
12
.80
6,9
66
.50
34
,19
3.7
31
0,0
74
.24
5,1
10
.03
8,0
36
.00
2,4
27
.75
80
,52
1.0
5
Total
13,712.80
6,966.50
34,193.73
10,074.24
5,110.03
8,036.00
2,427.75
80,521.05
07 Circuit
LOG
AN
2,1
00
.00
6,6
54
.55
29
1.0
01
7,0
59
.86
4,1
57
.63
1,6
42
.55
9.1
53
1,9
14
.74
Total
2,100.00
6,654.55
291.00
17,059.86
4,157.63
1,642.55
9.15
31,914.74
08 Circuit
MC
DO
WEL
L5
,40
0.0
09
83
.95
16
,52
8.1
01
2,3
84
.40
4,0
75
.11
0.0
08
,51
4.7
54
7,8
86
.31
Total
5,400.00
983.95
16,528.10
12,384.40
4,075.11
0.00
8,514.75
47,886.31
09 Circuit
MER
CER
30
,69
3.0
01
,65
1.7
04
9,8
74
.60
73
,95
5.7
61
7,6
23
.21
7,4
60
.34
41
,21
7.6
52
22
,47
6.2
6
Paralegal
Other
Total Expenses
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL TO
TAL EX
PEN
SES BY CIRCUIT & CATEGORY
Expert
Witness
Court
Reporter
Investigator
Travel
Misc. Office
FY2015 Annual Report Page 67 of 212
Circuit
County
Paralegal
Other
Total Expenses
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL TO
TAL EX
PEN
SES BY CIRCUIT & CATEGORY
Expert
Witness
Court
Reporter
Investigator
Travel
Misc. Office
Total
30,693.00
1,651.70
49,874.60
73,955.76
17,623.21
7,460.34
41,217.65
222,476.26
10 Circuit
RA
LEIG
H3
00
.00
90
6.2
01
5,7
91
.32
38
,94
7.4
51
0,7
55
.89
9.0
31
2,1
31
.30
78
,84
1.1
9
Total
300.00
906.20
15,791.32
38,947.45
10,755.89
9.03
12,131.30
78,841.19
11 Circuit
GR
EEN
BR
IER
3,3
60
.00
57
.75
12
0.0
02
,99
4.6
78
80
.29
1,3
59
.86
35
3.3
29
,12
5.8
9
PO
CA
HO
NTA
S0
.00
16
5.5
53
06
.95
6,0
78
.50
13
2.6
81
82
.70
0.0
06
,86
6.3
8
Total
3,360.00
223.30
426.95
9,073.17
1,012.97
1,542.56
353.32
15,992.27
12 Circuit
FAYE
TTE
1,6
00
.00
1,0
54
.90
18
0.0
01
1,2
35
.22
3,4
80
.98
69
9.1
02
65
.82
18
,51
6.0
2
Total
1,600.00
1,054.90
180.00
11,235.22
3,480.98
699.10
265.82
18,516.02
13 Circuit
KA
NA
WH
A1
0,8
58
.00
6,3
49
.78
58
,67
1.1
52
7,7
39
.32
19
,38
2.2
01
,11
8.0
53
,04
9.5
71
27
,16
8.0
7
Total
10,858.00
6,349.78
58,671.15
27,739.32
19,382.20
1,118.05
3,049.57
127,168.07
14 Circuit
BR
AX
TON
0.0
07
0.3
50
.00
22
,40
7.6
33
,60
6.3
82
8.8
07
55
.35
26
,86
8.5
1
CLA
Y0
.00
30
0.3
02
07
.90
19
,70
5.4
63
,79
1.1
34
24
.00
5.0
02
4,4
33
.79
GIL
MER
0.0
00
.00
54
6.1
01
6,8
71
.33
1,7
36
.53
28
.80
68
.00
19
,25
0.7
6
WEB
STER
17
,05
0.0
00
.00
1,5
00
.00
53
,41
5.4
38
,93
1.6
01
24
.60
10
,30
1.0
09
1,3
22
.63
Total
17,050.00
370.65
2,254.00
112,399.85
18,065.64
606.20
11,129.35
161,875.69
15 Circuit
HA
RR
ISO
N3
9,9
50
.96
3,4
46
.65
41
,48
9.0
21
0,3
09
.07
13
,29
3.8
01
3,0
58
.00
46
,68
2.9
51
68
,23
0.4
5
Total
39,950.96
3,446.65
41,489.02
10,309.07
13,293.80
13,058.00
46,682.95
168,230.45
16 Circuit
MA
RIO
N6
,17
5.0
02
,83
8.9
51
2,6
00
.15
7,6
10
.97
9,2
93
.01
3,6
93
.24
64
,75
7.7
51
06
,96
9.0
7
Total
6,175.00
2,838.95
12,600.15
7,610.97
9,293.01
3,693.24
64,757.75
106,969.07
17 Circuit
MO
NO
NG
ALI
A1
2,4
87
.64
2,3
23
.95
20
,14
1.4
12
0,4
54
.94
13
,95
2.8
34
,92
0.2
71
5,7
89
.62
90
,07
0.6
6
Total
12,487.64
2,323.95
20,141.41
20,454.94
13,952.83
4,920.27
15,789.62
90,070.66
18 Circuit
PR
ESTO
N5
,48
3.5
01
,63
4.7
25
,04
1.2
02
0,1
17
.33
5,0
99
.41
1,1
61
.09
50
8.0
03
9,0
45
.25
Total
5,483.50
1,634.72
5,041.20
20,117.33
5,099.41
1,161.09
508.00
39,045.25
19 Circuit
BA
RB
OU
R0
.00
33
2.5
00
.00
9,1
10
.19
8,4
18
.05
15
.60
1,6
99
.87
19
,57
6.2
1
TAYL
OR
0.0
03
19
.45
0.0
09
,78
1.1
78
,14
7.3
00
.00
59
7.9
91
8,8
45
.91
Total
0.00
651.95
0.00
18,891.36
16,565.35
15.60
2,297.86
38,422.12
FY2015 Annual Report Page 68 of 212
Circuit
County
Paralegal
Other
Total Expenses
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL TO
TAL EX
PEN
SES BY CIRCUIT & CATEGORY
Expert
Witness
Court
Reporter
Investigator
Travel
Misc. Office
20 Circuit
RA
ND
OLP
H1
3,0
85
.00
7,7
18
.96
26
,02
6.2
01
5,7
94
.77
4,5
50
.08
0.0
06
,21
5.9
57
3,3
90
.96
Total
13,085.00
7,718.96
26,026.20
15,794.77
4,550.08
0.00
6,215.95
73,390.96
21 Circuit
GR
AN
T4
,75
0.0
04
69
.25
0.0
06
,64
9.5
21
,65
5.0
01
6.0
00
.00
13
,53
9.7
7
MIN
ERA
L1
2,6
50
.39
71
6.8
01
4,2
67
.22
4,6
09
.05
6,1
21
.72
0.0
05
,27
0.9
04
3,6
36
.08
TUC
KER
0.0
00
.00
4,4
90
.44
3,0
22
.75
25
1.5
30
.00
91
.50
7,8
56
.22
Total
17,400.39
1,186.05
18,757.66
14,281.32
8,028.25
16.00
5,362.40
65,032.07
22 Circuit
HA
MP
SHIR
E1
8,9
40
.78
0.0
04
,10
8.7
86
,53
4.8
96
,16
6.4
22
,96
1.2
41
,05
1.9
13
9,7
64
.02
HA
RD
Y1
1,0
47
.54
2.0
08
13
.00
10
,68
8.3
83
,10
1.1
56
4.0
06
18
.54
26
,33
4.6
1
PEN
DLE
TON
4,9
50
.00
0.0
00
.00
3,7
86
.80
69
3.0
41
0.0
02
,33
0.8
81
1,7
70
.72
Total
34,938.32
2.00
4,921.78
21,010.07
9,960.61
3,035.24
4,001.33
77,869.35
23 Circuit
BER
KEL
EY5
9,4
22
.67
10
,57
3.0
09
,29
4.8
41
6,5
69
.74
20
,36
2.6
75
,08
7.9
02
6,3
66
.85
14
7,6
77
.67
JEFF
ERSO
N2
7,8
51
.26
1,7
39
.50
3,9
58
.34
12
,99
5.3
68
,00
4.2
32
,71
4.6
01
0,7
55
.58
68
,01
8.8
7
MO
RG
AN
11
,58
7.5
09
59
.20
1,1
59
.74
14
,24
5.6
71
,81
9.0
03
,23
5.3
07
2.7
53
3,0
79
.16
Total
98,861.43
13,271.70
14,412.92
43,810.77
30,185.90
11,037.80
37,195.18
248,775.70
24 Circuit
WA
YNE
3,7
35
.00
14
7.0
01
,53
8.2
08
,88
9.6
21
,26
2.0
81
,65
8.0
07
,21
0.0
02
4,4
39
.90
Total
3,735.00
147.00
1,538.20
8,889.62
1,262.08
1,658.00
7,210.00
24,439.90
25 Circuit
BO
ON
E8
08
.13
41
9.6
52
91
.60
6,1
31
.11
1,6
17
.17
2,6
80
.91
0.0
01
1,9
48
.57
LIN
CO
LN0
.00
1,4
86
.00
0.0
01
3,6
17
.50
1,0
60
.75
34
.00
24
8.2
41
6,4
46
.49
Total
808.13
1,905.65
291.60
19,748.61
2,677.92
2,714.91
248.24
28,395.06
26 Circuit
LEW
IS1
4,9
82
.00
25
.00
54
0.1
51
9,3
76
.90
2,9
09
.00
0.0
02
1.2
03
7,8
54
.25
UP
SHU
R1
1,4
89
.98
0.0
03
,51
7.9
38
,49
3.2
02
,06
3.6
70
.00
78
.52
25
,64
3.3
0
Total
26,471.98
25.00
4,058.08
27,870.10
4,972.67
0.00
99.72
63,497.55
27 Circuit
WYO
MIN
G3
00
.00
18
2.0
03
8,0
50
.10
20
,66
1.2
37
,31
3.7
60
.00
1,1
87
.65
67
,69
4.7
4
Total
300.00
182.00
38,050.10
20,661.23
7,313.76
0.00
1,187.65
67,694.74
28 Circuit
NIC
HO
LAS
1,8
50
.00
45
6.0
00
.00
17
,89
1.8
53
,11
0.7
92
20
.00
5,3
65
.02
28
,89
3.6
6
Total
1,850.00
456.00
0.00
17,891.85
3,110.79
220.00
5,365.02
28,893.66
FY2015 Annual Report Page 69 of 212
Circuit
County
Paralegal
Other
Total Expenses
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL TO
TAL EX
PEN
SES BY CIRCUIT & CATEGORY
Expert
Witness
Court
Reporter
Investigator
Travel
Misc. Office
29 Circuit
PU
TNA
M1
5,9
75
.00
1,1
63
.90
4,0
50
.01
33
,35
7.1
38
,51
2.3
30
.00
6,8
60
.10
69
,91
8.4
7
Total
15,975.00
1,163.90
4,050.01
33,357.13
8,512.33
0.00
6,860.10
69,918.47
30 Circuit
MIN
GO
5,1
00
.00
31
1.8
54
,54
0.2
13
,43
7.6
12
,12
1.6
82
70
.00
16
,27
8.1
23
2,0
59
.47
Total
5,100.00
311.85
4,540.21
3,437.61
2,121.68
270.00
16,278.12
32,059.47
31 Circuit
MO
NR
OE
2,7
03
.51
38
1.1
50
.00
9,1
75
.34
98
2.6
90
.00
0.0
01
3,2
42
.69
SUM
MER
S0
.00
0.0
00
.00
12
,17
5.7
68
58
.50
0.0
00
.00
13
,03
4.2
6
Total
2,703.51
381.15
0.00
21,351.10
1,841.19
0.00
0.00
26,276.95
WV TOTA
L410,010.98
82,000.02
471,101.18
870,422.48
287,900.03
85,539.97
348,635.91
2,555,610.57
FY2015 Annual Report Page 70 of 212
In‐Court at $65 per hour 74,773.45Out‐Of‐Court at $45 per hour 411,952.91
Total Hours Paid 486,726.36
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL TIME PAID IN/OUT‐OF‐COURT
In‐Court at $65 per hour
15.36%
Out‐Of‐Court at $45 per
hour84.64%
FY2015 Annual Report Page 71 of 212
Circuit/County In‐Court Out‐Of‐Court Total Hours
01 Circuit
BROOKE 824.10 5,537.37 6,361.47
HANCOCK 1,310.10 7,191.73 8,501.83
OHIO 1,234.60 12,861.22 14,095.82
Total 3,368.80 25,590.32 28,959.12
02 Circuit
MARSHALL 509.80 2,663.41 3,173.21
TYLER 281.70 1,501.34 1,783.04
WETZEL 472.20 2,479.90 2,952.10
Total 1,263.70 6,644.65 7,908.35
03 Circuit
DODDRIDGE 435.80 4,096.20 4,532.00
PLEASANTS 388.30 2,874.60 3,262.90
RITCHIE 649.90 4,437.10 5,087.00
Total 1,474.00 11,407.90 12,881.90
04 Circuit
WIRT 147.40 1,469.50 1,616.90
WOOD 3,165.10 22,714.64 25,879.74
Total 3,312.50 24,184.14 27,496.64
05 Circuit
CALHOUN 804.80 3,751.50 4,556.30
JACKSON 1,527.70 6,680.90 8,208.60
MASON 1,459.80 7,233.40 8,693.20
ROANE 749.50 3,475.20 4,224.70
Total 4,541.80 21,141.00 25,682.80
06 Circuit
CABELL 4,744.12 14,104.60 18,848.72
Total 4,744.12 14,104.60 18,848.72
07 Circuit
LOGAN 1,967.50 9,764.70 11,732.20
Total 1,967.50 9,764.70 11,732.20
08 Circuit
MCDOWELL 1,676.50 8,163.80 9,840.30
Total 1,676.50 8,163.80 9,840.30
09 Circuit
MERCER 4,947.73 25,348.53 30,296.27
Total 4,947.73 25,348.53 30,296.27
10 Circuit
RALEIGH 3,267.19 15,320.29 18,587.48
Total 3,267.19 15,320.29 18,587.48
11 Circuit
GREENBRIER 896.90 6,708.40 7,605.30
POCAHONTAS 267.90 2,553.20 2,821.10
Total 1,164.80 9,261.60 10,426.40
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL IN/OUT OF COURT HOURS
FY2015 Annual Report Page 72 of 212
Circuit/County In‐Court Out‐Of‐Court Total Hours
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL IN/OUT OF COURT HOURS
12 Circuit
FAYETTE 1,345.10 6,631.10 7,976.20
Total 1,345.10 6,631.10 7,976.20
13 Circuit
KANAWHA 5,677.80 29,821.05 35,498.85
Total 5,677.80 29,821.05 35,498.85
14 Circuit
BRAXTON 1,040.80 4,783.27 5,824.07
CLAY 997.00 6,362.39 7,359.39
GILMER 577.10 3,063.65 3,640.75
WEBSTER 1,573.20 9,139.00 10,712.20
Total 4,188.10 23,348.32 27,536.42
15 Circuit
HARRISON 1,253.50 9,480.40 10,733.90
Total 1,253.50 9,480.40 10,733.90
16 Circuit
MARION 1,377.90 16,456.30 17,834.20
Total 1,377.90 16,456.30 17,834.20
17 Circuit
MONONGALIA 2,883.80 20,944.19 23,827.99
Total 2,883.80 20,944.19 23,827.99
18 Circuit
PRESTON 794.40 6,809.90 7,604.30
Total 794.40 6,809.90 7,604.30
19 Circuit
BARBOUR 660.80 5,805.80 6,466.60
TAYLOR 672.40 6,537.80 7,210.20
Total 1,333.20 12,343.60 13,676.80
20 Circuit
RANDOLPH 1,941.90 8,166.50 10,108.40
Total 1,941.90 8,166.50 10,108.40
21 Circuit
GRANT 442.50 2,310.70 2,753.20
MINERAL 595.60 5,329.50 5,925.10
TUCKER 94.30 692.10 786.40
Total 1,132.40 8,332.30 9,464.70
22 Circuit
HAMPSHIRE 1,198.10 5,306.80 6,504.90
HARDY 927.90 4,509.70 5,437.60
PENDLETON 165.50 1,158.90 1,324.40
Total 2,291.50 10,975.40 13,266.90
23 Circuit
BERKELEY 2,582.70 15,665.35 18,248.05
JEFFERSON 1,184.20 6,184.10 7,368.30
MORGAN 746.30 4,092.80 4,839.10
Total 4,513.20 25,942.25 30,455.45
FY2015 Annual Report Page 73 of 212
Circuit/County In‐Court Out‐Of‐Court Total Hours
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL IN/OUT OF COURT HOURS
24 Circuit
WAYNE 1,768.80 3,161.00 4,929.80
Total 1,768.80 3,161.00 4,929.80
25 Circuit
BOONE 1,477.70 3,230.12 4,707.82
LINCOLN 1,525.50 6,167.10 7,692.60
Total 3,003.20 9,397.22 12,400.42
26 Circuit
LEWIS 1,178.80 6,544.14 7,722.94
UPSHUR 978.40 4,948.00 5,926.40
Total 2,157.20 11,492.14 13,649.34
27 Circuit
WYOMING 1,496.90 8,979.30 10,476.20
Total 1,496.90 8,979.30 10,476.20
28 Circuit
NICHOLAS 779.30 4,183.94 4,963.24
Total 779.30 4,183.94 4,963.24
29 Circuit
PUTNAM 2,131.20 13,362.50 15,493.70
Total 2,131.20 13,362.50 15,493.70
30 Circuit
MINGO 1,915.20 6,899.58 8,814.78
Total 1,915.20 6,899.58 8,814.78
31 Circuit
MONROE 447.90 1,968.30 2,416.20
SUMMERS 612.30 2,326.10 2,938.40
Total 1,060.20 4,294.40 5,354.60
WV TOTAL 74,773.45 411,952.91 486,726.36
FY2015 Annual Report Page 74 of 212
Felony 998.64Misdemeanor 367.80Mental Hygiene 167.22Juvenile 538.68Parole/Prob. Rev. 418.24Term/ Abuse & Neglect 1,058.42Habeas/Sup. Ct. 2,280.24Municipal Court Charges 334.41Other 332.26 (Mag. Ct. Appeal, Mandamus/Prohibition, Extradition, Contempt, Fugitive, Other)
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL STATEWIDE AVERAGE COSTS BY CASE TYPE
$0 $500 $1,000 $1,500 $2,000 $2,500
Felony
Misdemeanor
Mental Hygiene
Juvenile
Parole/Prob. Rev.
Term/ Abuse & Neglect
Habeas/Sup. Ct.
Municipal Court Charges
Other
$0 $500 $1,000 $1,500 $2,000 $2,500
Felony
Misdemeanor
Mental Hygiene
Juvenile
Parole/Prob. Rev.
Term/ Abuse & Neglect
Habeas/Sup. Ct.
Municipal Court Charges
Other
FY2015 Annual Report Page 75 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Muni.
Circuit
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juv.
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Average
01 Circuit
BR
OO
KE
1,2
85
.65
64
3.9
5
28
8.7
5
71
4.2
9
83
5.0
4
1,7
89
.49
9,4
67
.56
‐
1,1
14
.62
1,1
11
.62
HA
NC
OC
K1
,11
9.4
8
50
7.9
9
29
8.5
9
77
0.2
3
49
7.4
6
1,3
16
.89
2,3
63
.80
38
4.1
5
29
5.1
4
99
0.1
5
OH
IO1
,91
7.9
3
63
6.9
5
32
5.1
5
79
0.9
8
62
4.2
1
1,8
09
.89
3,5
79
.57
‐
52
3.5
2
1,1
18
.08
Average
1,417.77
593.24
318.10
756.46
556.55
1,620.17
3,571.62
384.15
586.66
1,075.76
02 Circuit
MA
RSH
ALL
89
3.4
5
41
1.9
7
13
5.7
9
47
8.6
8
40
7.5
9
1,0
56
.57
2,2
01
.44
‐
31
6.9
3
62
8.5
5
TYLE
R1
,61
1.7
5
61
3.1
0
13
1.7
9
44
1.7
8
37
7.6
6
1,4
73
.45
1,8
41
.60
‐
1,3
23
.55
1,1
18
.40
WET
ZEL
94
9.6
6
32
9.8
4
12
6.9
2
75
6.0
8
48
0.6
7
1,2
57
.49
‐
‐
‐
74
4.0
0
Average
1,009.49
420.07
131.68
535.98
428.76
1,231.80
2,081.49
‐
820.24
751.78
03 Circuit
DO
DD
RID
GE
97
4.4
1
52
0.9
7
19
6.8
8
58
8.9
3
46
8.6
2
86
9.4
3
‐
‐
27
7.4
9
69
7.5
6
PLE
ASA
NTS
1,1
85
.94
40
0.3
0
21
6.1
9
50
1.2
4
32
1.2
8
1,0
14
.61
1,0
16
.66
‐
24
4.9
8
72
8.9
2
RIT
CH
IE1
,30
5.8
2
44
6.3
0
21
5.8
5
87
2.6
0
34
3.4
7
1,3
74
.92
7,9
44
.27
‐
33
9.6
4
95
4.0
9
Average
1,130.21
456.22
206.83
614.72
423.68
1,098.94
4,480.47
‐
277.12
790.83
04 Circuit
WIR
T8
77
.89
35
1.1
5
58
.94
44
7.0
3
38
8.2
6
50
6.3
0
1,8
19
.37
‐
49
3.5
3
54
2.3
0
WO
OD
67
3.6
4
32
3.3
8
10
3.5
9
35
2.4
9
36
6.1
6
71
3.9
3
2,8
82
.66
‐
22
1.6
0
46
0.7
2
Average
687.99
324.61
103.44
365.17
368.43
705.77
2,806.71
‐
244.58
465.14
05 Circuit
CA
LHO
UN
2,0
51
.19
74
4.3
8
24
1.2
8
15
8.4
0
49
2.4
3
91
7.5
0
1,4
86
.55
‐
55
6.3
0
1,1
18
.21
JAC
KSO
N1
,02
1.1
6
45
1.4
3
13
0.4
1
85
9.4
5
41
1.6
1
94
0.9
2
2,1
67
.46
‐
42
4.3
6
88
8.1
6
MA
SON
70
3.9
5
35
5.2
8
18
5.1
9
45
6.0
9
41
1.0
7
1,0
90
.24
1,8
96
.78
‐
46
5.9
1
53
6.2
2
RO
AN
E1
,65
9.2
2
41
4.2
5
26
0.8
7
40
7.1
6
72
6.0
3
49
4.7
7
1,2
21
.84
‐
44
1.9
2
73
0.3
5
Average
1,074.01
378.84
200.75
479.44
437.28
846.90
1,820.78
‐
445.13
733.20
06 Circuit
CA
BEL
L9
80
.95
32
1.8
1
10
7.3
5
28
2.2
1
39
9.2
6
80
4.4
6
1,8
16
.99
‐
39
4.8
6
55
3.0
3
Average
980.95
321.81
107.35
282.21
399.26
804.46
1,816.99
‐
394.86
553.03
07 Circuit
LOG
AN
92
9.7
1
30
2.3
7
14
9.3
0
62
4.6
6
68
6.0
1
1,2
13
.35
2,5
17
.63
‐
26
1.2
9
63
2.7
6
Average
929.71
302.37
149.30
624.66
686.01
1,213.35
2,517.63
‐
261.29
632.76
08 Circuit
MC
DO
WEL
L1
,23
5.8
7
52
9.4
3
26
1.2
1
35
6.3
0
31
3.9
8
96
5.0
6
4,2
18
.51
‐
69
5.9
2
91
1.7
5
Average
1,235.87
529.43
261.21
356.30
313.98
965.06
4,218.51
‐
695.92
911.75
09 Circuit
MER
CER
1,2
19
.43
32
7.7
1
18
3.8
2
54
0.7
9
38
3.5
3
75
7.6
1
2,2
98
.53
34
4.7
0
38
4.2
3
69
3.9
1
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL AVER
AGE COST BY CASE TYPE
FY2015 Annual Report Page 76 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Muni.
Circuit
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juv.
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Average
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL AVER
AGE COST BY CASE TYPE
Average
1,219.43
327.71
183.82
540.79
383.53
757.61
2,298.53
344.70
384.23
693.91
10 Circuit
RA
LEIG
H7
73
.86
32
2.8
7
14
4.9
7
60
3.3
7
53
4.1
5
74
9.4
7
2,0
11
.34
‐
27
6.1
0
68
4.8
3
Average
773.86
322.87
144.97
603.37
534.15
749.47
2,011.34
‐
276.10
684.83
11 Circuit
GR
EEN
BR
IER
1,3
93
.20
49
6.1
3
12
1.1
1
62
8.5
5
35
3.3
7
1,6
83
.74
1,5
25
.55
55
0.5
5
70
1.0
6
1,2
47
.41
PO
CA
HO
NTA
S1
,34
3.6
3
67
2.7
7
82
.35
52
8.9
6
‐
2,0
63
.90
‐
‐
61
9.3
1
1,1
99
.79
Average
1,378.36
538.19
91.65
584.98
353.37
1,771.47
1,525.55
550.55
687.44
1,234.00
12 Circuit
FAYE
TTE
94
9.5
6
22
7.8
7
‐
74
5.7
8
35
7.9
1
91
7.9
0
2,0
69
.78
23
0.2
4
17
4.8
4
72
7.3
0
Average
949.56
227.87
745.78
357.91
917.90
2,069.78
230.24
174.84
727.30
13 Circuit
KA
NA
WH
A7
19
.52
40
1.8
8
‐
65
8.5
4
46
1.0
6
84
7.8
5
2,3
37
.30
32
4.1
1
50
0.3
0
63
6.7
2
Average
719.52
401.88
‐
658.54
461.06
847.85
2,337.30
324.11
500.30
636.72
14 Circuit
BR
AX
TON
87
0.9
8
29
8.6
8
74
.15
56
9.5
9
53
8.6
2
1,0
78
.32
1,1
14
.99
‐
22
0.9
3
68
3.8
5
CLA
Y1
,30
5.1
7
34
0.0
2
31
2.0
0
1,5
76
.11
39
8.9
9
1,3
54
.30
2,0
34
.61
33
7.5
6
27
4.5
6
1,1
38
.09
GIL
MER
1,0
09
.16
37
8.6
4
21
0.5
0
89
6.1
6
63
3.6
3
1,3
36
.24
1,2
56
.76
43
9.1
4
10
7.4
3
73
4.4
6
WEB
STER
1,3
86
.79
31
5.0
3
19
3.1
9
1,4
85
.37
58
7.1
9
1,5
27
.55
4,0
12
.55
‐
20
1.1
0
1,1
83
.66
Average
1,183.58
326.66
117.88
1,018.98
550.81
1,342.09
2,714.17
422.21
157.12
952.43
15 Circuit
HA
RR
ISO
N2
,39
3.7
8
43
5.5
3
11
2.9
9
50
0.7
0
49
2.9
6
1,2
69
.38
1,8
33
.79
‐
45
5.8
5
1,2
25
.27
Average
2,393.78
435.53
112.99
500.70
492.96
1,269.38
1,833.79
‐
455.85
1,225.27
16 Circuit
MA
RIO
N1
,07
9.9
4
35
4.3
0
13
7.1
7
42
8.0
1
35
2.5
5
83
8.1
9
1,9
21
.65
41
1.4
7
31
0.0
4
59
1.9
7
Average
1,079.94
354.30
137.17
428.01
352.55
838.19
1,921.65
411.47
310.04
591.97
17 Circuit
MO
NO
NG
ALI
A1
,06
7.6
9
42
4.6
5
15
6.4
0
67
5.5
1
46
5.7
1
1,1
85
.64
1,8
84
.79
34
1.6
3
32
5.3
6
68
6.9
4
Average
1,067.69
424.65
156.40
675.51
465.71
1,185.64
1,884.79
341.63
325.36
686.94
18 Circuit
PR
ESTO
N1
,37
8.9
9
50
6.4
6
19
5.1
8
1,3
21
.16
56
6.3
5
1,2
38
.43
1,6
64
.72
‐
88
7.0
1
1,0
53
.50
Average
1,378.99
506.46
195.18
1,321.16
566.35
1,238.43
1,664.72
‐
887.01
1,053.50
19 Circuit
BA
RB
OU
R7
21
.99
36
7.1
2
13
6.0
2
72
3.4
7
42
6.7
6
1,0
73
.70
1,6
15
.59
‐
1,2
60
.24
74
2.6
5
TAYL
OR
73
8.5
7
43
2.9
6
33
3.8
9
39
5.4
9
32
4.1
1
88
9.2
0
1,3
12
.11
‐
34
6.5
7
59
3.6
2
Average
731.16
397.25
247.32
491.48
346.42
977.71
1,494.20
‐
374.26
656.28
FY2015 Annual Report Page 77 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Muni.
Circuit
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juv.
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Average
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL AVER
AGE COST BY CASE TYPE
20 Circuit
RA
ND
OLP
H1
,14
4.5
5
38
1.6
2
22
2.1
3
75
8.9
2
29
1.8
1
1,3
97
.17
1,6
11
.35
37
1.9
8
41
1.6
8
72
0.6
2
Average
1,144.55
381.62
222.13
758.92
291.81
1,397.17
1,611.35
371.98
411.68
720.62
21 Circuit
GR
AN
T8
03
.69
40
1.7
8
10
3.4
1
43
5.0
2
39
4.5
3
1,0
19
.59
‐
‐
30
4.9
9
58
7.4
9
MIN
ERA
L7
33
.34
29
8.4
6
17
9.8
7
27
3.2
6
21
7.6
0
1,1
77
.32
1,1
48
.90
‐
36
1.3
5
46
2.9
3
TUC
KER
1,1
34
.18
36
1.2
7
‐
39
4.8
3
41
2.1
5
2,2
07
.65
‐
‐
76
.00
53
7.2
6
Average
773.26
318.56
146.42
346.64
273.55
1,137.52
1,148.90
‐
302.41
499.14
22 Circuit
HA
MP
SHIR
E9
33
.49
32
4.4
3
16
1.1
7
65
6.9
4
39
7.0
1
1,6
82
.61
2,6
06
.58
‐
13
3.5
7
65
1.6
7
HA
RD
Y8
19
.58
40
0.2
8
30
7.0
8
54
2.0
5
36
4.2
9
1,9
87
.62
2,5
19
.82
‐
19
3.3
7
69
1.1
6
PEN
DLE
TON
1,5
64
.71
38
1.9
4
15
0.7
6
37
4.7
4
1,0
85
.22
1,8
37
.47
2,1
03
.78
‐
18
6.8
9
79
4.4
6
Average
936.87
359.13
207.03
561.96
510.50
1,835.22
2,532.89
‐
153.65
679.94
23 Circuit
BER
KEL
EY9
62
.39
22
3.9
2
‐
71
7.2
2
48
9.1
1
1,9
58
.66
3,3
95
.93
22
1.8
5
27
7.0
0
1,2
66
.47
JEFF
ERSO
N1
,01
6.8
2
30
0.3
6
‐
79
4.1
4
52
1.3
8
2,0
83
.16
2,6
86
.63
‐
33
3.5
2
1,0
42
.59
MO
RG
AN
1,3
39
.30
60
3.2
2
‐
84
7.4
4
36
3.1
2
1,8
36
.43
1,1
02
.47
‐
22
1.9
4
1,2
65
.61
Average
1,013.70
314.44
‐
764.00
472.19
1,964.22
2,951.81
221.85
265.25
1,202.33
24 Circuit
WA
YNE
87
9.6
7
31
3.5
7
15
7.7
4
25
2.2
5
33
2.2
3
80
4.9
7
4,9
32
.83
11
3.9
9
39
8.1
1
63
8.6
9
Average
879.67
313.57
157.74
252.25
332.23
804.97
4,932.83
113.99
398.11
638.69
25 Circuit
BO
ON
E7
18
.20
16
6.4
2
‐
37
3.8
1
43
5.8
7
1,0
96
.82
3,0
25
.16
‐
63
4.9
5
61
3.4
8
LIN
CO
LN9
65
.08
51
9.5
2
27
0.7
8
92
2.7
4
52
3.1
2
1,3
92
.06
1,7
51
.25
‐
15
7.2
7
77
1.3
1
Average
870.61
397.01
270.78
436.85
504.35
1,261.31
2,600.52
‐
182.68
700.69
26 Circuit
LEW
IS1
,06
6.4
6
39
6.6
4
15
0.2
7
51
5.7
5
40
0.5
1
1,2
41
.80
2,5
90
.52
‐
34
5.4
9
55
0.4
3
UP
SHU
R8
64
.07
30
2.8
2
20
5.3
3
52
5.4
9
31
2.6
8
1,3
26
.41
27
0.7
0
‐
26
9.9
6
61
5.2
0
Average
993.95
348.28
152.58
524.28
364.28
1,297.72
1,817.25
‐
314.02
576.70
27 Circuit
WYO
MIN
G7
57
.38
38
5.2
4
21
4.4
7
64
7.6
0
34
6.3
2
73
0.4
2
1,9
58
.78
‐
50
1.2
3
59
5.8
8
Average
757.38
385.24
214.47
647.60
346.32
730.42
1,958.78
‐
501.23
595.88
28 Circuit
NIC
HO
LAS
1,0
08
.19
26
8.0
3
‐
24
2.8
4
26
0.0
7
1,1
11
.49
2,0
83
.69
‐
‐
98
1.1
1
Average
1,008.19
268.03
‐
242.84
260.07
1,111.49
2,083.69
‐
‐
981.11
FY2015 Annual Report Page 78 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Muni.
Circuit
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juv.
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Average
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL AVER
AGE COST BY CASE TYPE
29 Circuit
PU
TNA
M8
74
.03
44
8.6
8
29
8.1
5
65
5.9
6
38
4.9
2
1,3
15
.81
1,1
82
.18
57
8.1
0
38
9.0
0
66
1.6
0
Average
874.03
448.68
298.15
655.96
384.92
1,315.81
1,182.18
578.10
389.00
661.60
30 Circuit
MIN
GO
1,0
83
.23
30
7.5
0
14
9.9
0
95
3.5
5
37
0.2
1
1,1
18
.69
1,1
96
.43
70
5.0
0
38
2.0
9
83
3.9
9
Average
1,083.23
307.50
149.90
953.55
370.21
1,118.69
1,196.43
705.00
382.09
833.99
31 Circuit
MO
NR
OE
97
7.7
4
22
8.3
7
‐
40
3.6
4
27
8.6
2
86
3.1
5
‐
28
4.3
9
53
.34
55
0.1
8
SUM
MER
S8
11
.53
23
2.0
3
34
7.2
6
56
1.7
0
42
8.0
9
76
6.6
5
85
3.9
2
‐
38
8.1
7
58
3.3
9
Average
884.24
229.97
347.26
495.15
345.05
800.53
853.92
284.39
276.56
567.83
State Average
998.64
367.80
167.22
538.68
418.24
1,058.42
2,280.24
334.41
332.26
716.89
FY2015 Annual Report Page 79 of 212
Felony 1,165.58Misdemeanor 386.96Mental Hygiene 167.29Juvenile 597.96Parole/Prob. Rev. 433.40Term/ Abuse & Neglect 1,086.47Habeas/Sup. Ct. 2,510.82Municipal Court Charges 350.67Other 348.33 (Mag. Ct. Appeal, Mandamus/Prohibition, Extradition, Contempt, Fugitive, Other)
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL STATEWIDE AVERAGE COSTS BY CASE TYPE
Without Direct Expenses and Supplementals
$0 $500 $1,000 $1,500 $2,000 $2,500 $3,000
Felony
Misdemeanor
Mental Hygiene
Juvenile
Parole/Prob. Rev.
Term/ Abuse & Neglect
Habeas/Sup. Ct.
Municipal Court Charges
Other
$0 $500 $1,000 $1,500 $2,000 $2,500 $3,000
Felony
Misdemeanor
Mental Hygiene
Juvenile
Parole/Prob. Rev.
Term/ Abuse & Neglect
Habeas/Sup. Ct.
Municipal Court Charges
Other
FY2015 Annual Report Page 80 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Muni.
Circuit
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juv.
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Average
01 Circuit
BR
OO
KE
1,6
81
.24
69
9.4
6
29
4.6
4
80
9.5
3
83
5.0
4
1,8
81
.26
9,4
67
.56
‐
1,1
14
.62
1,2
41
.44
HA
NC
OC
K1
,32
0.1
4
55
7.3
8
29
8.5
9
86
6.5
1
51
6.5
9
1,4
05
.27
2,3
63
.80
38
4.1
5
49
1.9
0
1,0
92
.58
OH
IO2
,18
8.6
9
65
3.0
7
32
5.1
5
79
0.9
8
62
4.2
1
1,8
40
.40
4,0
27
.01
‐
1,0
47
.03
1,1
53
.74
Average
1,700.21
632.98
319.09
833.65
572.92
1,688.18
3,896.31
384.15
838.08
1,153.13
02 Circuit
MA
RSH
ALL
95
4.0
2
42
9.5
1
13
5.7
9
52
6.5
5
40
7.5
9
1,0
75
.10
2,2
01
.44
‐
31
6.9
3
64
8.9
1
TYLE
R2
,41
7.6
2
61
3.1
0
13
1.7
9
48
1.9
4
37
7.6
6
1,4
73
.45
1,8
41
.60
‐
1,3
23
.55
1,2
12
.72
WET
ZEL
1,1
20
.60
32
9.8
4
12
6.9
2
75
6.0
8
54
0.7
5
1,2
57
.49
‐
‐
‐
78
2.7
5
Average
1,168.01
431.42
131.68
572.95
447.40
1,240.01
2,081.49
‐
820.24
787.79
03 Circuit
DO
DD
RID
GE
1,3
50
.50
61
2.9
0
19
6.8
8
68
7.0
8
48
3.2
7
90
6.4
3
‐
‐
27
7.4
9
79
5.5
9
PLE
ASA
NTS
1,4
69
.54
47
7.7
7
21
6.1
9
55
6.9
4
32
1.2
8
1,0
14
.61
1,0
16
.66
‐
24
4.9
8
81
7.9
0
RIT
CH
IE1
,83
5.2
1
48
8.1
4
21
5.8
5
87
2.6
0
40
0.7
1
1,3
89
.10
7,9
44
.27
‐
33
9.6
4
1,0
48
.06
Average
1,517.72
522.84
206.83
678.94
441.71
1,121.37
4,480.47
‐
277.12
886.78
04 Circuit
WIR
T1
,47
4.8
5
35
7.5
4
58
.94
52
6.8
5
38
8.2
6
50
6.3
0
1,8
19
.37
‐
49
3.5
3
62
7.1
5
WO
OD
92
7.0
9
34
9.4
3
10
3.5
9
42
6.5
9
38
2.5
5
74
8.7
2
3,2
58
.66
‐
22
5.0
6
51
5.5
4
Average
959.01
349.81
103.44
440.35
383.16
738.75
3,143.52
‐
248.07
521.39
05 Circuit
CA
LHO
UN
2,2
67
.10
74
4.3
8
24
1.2
8
15
8.4
0
49
2.4
3
97
6.9
1
1,4
86
.55
‐
55
6.3
0
1,1
88
.77
JAC
KSO
N1
,11
9.3
5
45
1.4
3
13
0.4
1
96
6.8
8
42
4.8
9
1,0
35
.42
2,3
11
.95
‐
42
4.3
6
96
0.5
8
MA
SON
78
7.0
0
36
5.0
5
18
5.1
9
48
0.3
1
41
9.4
6
1,0
90
.24
1,8
96
.78
‐
50
1.7
5
56
1.5
6
RO
AN
E1
,85
6.0
8
41
4.2
5
26
0.8
7
46
1.4
5
84
7.0
3
51
4.6
9
1,5
27
.30
‐
44
1.9
2
77
7.5
5
Average
1,193.03
387.09
200.75
514.52
452.18
900.45
1,927.88
‐
454.22
778.06
06 Circuit
CA
BEL
L1
,13
0.0
8
33
2.7
8
10
7.3
5
29
1.6
2
39
9.2
6
82
0.0
8
1,9
03
.52
‐
40
9.4
9
57
8.3
3
Average
1,130.08
332.78
107.35
291.62
399.26
820.08
1,903.52
‐
409.49
578.33
07 Circuit
LOG
AN
1,0
31
.40
30
9.0
9
14
9.3
0
63
3.4
0
68
6.0
1
1,2
13
.35
2,9
37
.23
‐
26
1.2
9
65
1.3
3
Average
1,031.40
309.09
149.30
633.40
686.01
1,213.35
2,937.23
‐
261.29
651.33
08 Circuit
MC
DO
WEL
L1
,66
4.9
9
54
3.7
4
26
1.2
1
41
5.6
8
31
3.9
8
97
6.5
5
4,2
18
.51
‐
69
5.9
2
1,0
16
.00
Average
1,664.99
543.74
261.21
415.68
313.98
976.55
4,218.51
‐
695.92
1,016.00
09 Circuit
MER
CER
1,4
50
.66
34
5.6
8
18
3.8
2
61
7.2
8
40
7.1
3
78
2.8
3
4,0
86
.28
35
7.0
1
42
4.6
7
75
6.5
4
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL AVER
AGE COST BY CASE TYPE WITHOUT DIREC
T EX
PEN
SES AND SUPPLEMEN
TALS
FY2015 Annual Report Page 81 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Muni.
Circuit
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juv.
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Average
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL AVER
AGE COST BY CASE TYPE WITHOUT DIREC
T EX
PEN
SES AND SUPPLEMEN
TALS
Average
1,450.66
345.68
183.82
617.28
407.13
782.83
4,086.28
357.01
424.67
756.54
10 Circuit
RA
LEIG
H9
59
.86
33
6.4
5
14
4.9
7
74
9.6
4
60
3.0
7
76
8.3
5
2,1
66
.06
‐
36
8.1
3
73
6.2
5
Average
959.86
336.45
144.97
749.64
603.07
768.35
2,166.06
‐
368.13
736.25
11 Circuit
GR
EEN
BR
IER
1,7
36
.97
54
1.2
4
12
1.1
1
70
7.1
2
42
4.0
4
1,6
83
.74
2,1
35
.77
55
0.5
5
70
1.0
6
1,3
77
.73
PO
CA
HO
NTA
S1
,66
9.3
6
67
2.7
7
82
.35
52
8.9
6
‐
2,0
63
.90
‐
‐
61
9.3
1
1,2
88
.67
Average
1,716.69
574.68
91.65
623.98
424.04
1,771.47
2,135.77
550.55
687.44
1,352.15
12 Circuit
FAYE
TTE
96
7.8
2
23
4.0
3
79
5.5
0
35
7.9
1
93
6.6
3
2,0
69
.78
23
0.2
4
17
4.8
4
74
3.3
5
Average
967.82
234.03
‐
795.50
357.91
936.63
2,069.78
230.24
174.84
743.35
13 Circuit
KA
NA
WH
A8
46
.44
44
2.1
4
‐
70
7.5
2
48
0.5
4
86
7.0
9
2,6
48
.94
34
1.0
8
52
7.3
4
69
4.9
8
Average
846.44
442.14
‐
707.52
480.54
867.09
2,648.94
341.08
527.34
694.98
14 Circuit
BR
AX
TON
91
0.1
2
30
4.6
5
74
.15
56
9.5
9
59
2.4
8
1,1
01
.10
1,1
14
.99
‐
22
0.9
3
70
0.8
7
CLA
Y1
,50
0.9
5
36
3.0
7
31
2.0
0
1,5
76
.11
39
8.9
9
1,3
77
.26
2,0
34
.61
33
7.5
6
27
4.5
6
1,1
96
.08
GIL
MER
1,0
60
.47
38
2.8
4
21
0.5
0
94
5.9
5
63
3.6
3
1,3
62
.44
1,2
56
.76
43
9.1
4
10
7.4
3
75
1.4
7
WEB
STER
1,6
16
.18
32
0.8
2
19
3.1
9
1,7
32
.93
58
7.1
9
1,5
51
.29
4,0
12
.55
‐
20
1.1
0
1,2
57
.48
Average
1,315.48
334.67
117.88
1,073.32
570.49
1,365.92
2,714.17
422.21
157.12
992.54
15 Circuit
HA
RR
ISO
N3
,14
8.5
7
45
7.1
0
11
2.9
9
54
1.3
0
53
9.9
1
1,2
77
.22
1,8
33
.79
‐
45
5.8
5
1,3
36
.66
Average
3,148.57
457.10
112.99
541.30
539.91
1,277.22
1,833.79
‐
455.85
1,336.66
16 Circuit
MA
RIO
N1
,16
6.5
8
36
8.7
6
13
7.1
7
49
3.1
4
36
9.5
0
84
7.0
6
2,0
58
.92
42
2.5
9
34
4.4
9
62
6.8
2
Average
1,166.58
368.76
137.17
493.14
369.50
847.06
2,058.92
422.59
344.49
626.82
17 Circuit
MO
NO
NG
ALI
A1
,20
1.7
6
45
3.6
8
15
6.4
0
80
7.5
0
48
3.6
3
1,2
04
.97
1,8
84
.79
36
2.6
5
33
4.1
5
73
7.6
1
Average
1,201.76
453.68
156.40
807.50
483.63
1,204.97
1,884.79
362.65
334.15
737.61
18 Circuit
PR
ESTO
N1
,54
8.3
4
54
6.4
5
19
5.1
8
1,3
21
.16
63
7.1
4
1,2
72
.46
2,0
80
.91
‐
1,1
23
.55
1,1
25
.13
Average
1,548.34
546.45
195.18
1,321.16
637.14
1,272.46
2,080.91
‐
1,123.55
1,125.13
19 Circuit
BA
RB
OU
R7
78
.15
37
7.5
1
13
6.0
2
88
2.8
8
42
6.7
6
1,0
89
.04
1,6
15
.59
‐
1,2
60
.24
78
7.8
3
TAYL
OR
84
4.0
8
49
1.7
6
33
3.8
9
49
5.0
7
34
3.1
7
90
0.9
0
1,3
12
.11
‐
38
2.4
2
66
8.1
0
Average
813.65
427.00
247.32
610.63
362.17
991.10
1,494.20
‐
411.68
720.17
FY2015 Annual Report Page 82 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Muni.
Circuit
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juv.
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Average
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL AVER
AGE COST BY CASE TYPE WITHOUT DIREC
T EX
PEN
SES AND SUPPLEMEN
TALS
20 Circuit
RA
ND
OLP
H1
,33
1.9
6
39
8.1
0
22
2.1
3
81
4.2
6
29
8.2
9
1,4
40
.15
1,7
35
.30
41
8.4
7
42
4.5
4
78
1.1
7
Average
1,331.96
398.10
222.13
814.26
298.29
1,440.15
1,735.30
418.47
424.54
781.17
21 Circuit
GR
AN
T8
49
.62
40
1.7
8
10
3.4
1
46
2.2
1
39
4.5
3
1,0
19
.59
‐
‐
30
4.9
9
61
2.0
8
MIN
ERA
L7
94
.09
30
4.9
1
17
9.8
7
27
7.8
9
21
7.6
0
1,1
77
.32
1,7
23
.35
‐
36
1.3
5
47
8.7
5
TUC
KER
1,3
23
.21
37
2.5
6
‐
39
4.8
3
41
2.1
5
2,2
07
.65
‐
‐
76
.00
55
7.1
6
Average
834.87
324.64
146.42
355.30
273.55
1,137.52
1,723.35
‐
302.41
517.23
22 Circuit
HA
MP
SHIR
E1
,05
7.9
6
33
5.2
5
16
1.1
7
74
2.6
3
39
7.0
1
1,7
21
.74
2,6
06
.58
‐
13
7.6
2
69
3.5
1
HA
RD
Y9
03
.21
41
2.5
6
30
7.0
8
58
0.7
7
40
4.7
7
2,0
82
.26
2,5
19
.82
‐
19
3.3
7
73
1.3
0
PEN
DLE
TON
1,9
32
.87
39
6.6
3
15
0.7
6
37
4.7
4
1,1
83
.87
1,8
37
.47
2,1
03
.78
‐
18
6.8
9
84
8.6
3
Average
1,056.79
370.83
207.03
608.02
534.43
1,897.08
2,532.89
‐
156.66
722.18
23 Circuit
BER
KEL
EY1
,13
7.7
0
22
8.4
5
‐
75
7.0
6
48
9.1
1
2,0
64
.72
3,6
91
.23
22
1.8
5
27
7.0
0
1,3
89
.14
JEFF
ERSO
N1
,25
1.4
7
30
9.8
9
‐
91
3.2
6
52
1.3
8
2,2
31
.96
2,6
86
.63
‐
33
3.5
2
1,1
40
.94
MO
RG
AN
1,4
30
.61
65
4.9
2
‐
1,1
01
.68
36
3.1
2
1,9
03
.61
1,1
02
.47
‐
22
1.9
4
1,3
42
.31
Average
1,196.84
325.33
‐
856.61
472.19
2,071.68
3,120.49
221.85
265.25
1,311.30
24 Circuit
WA
YNE
99
4.4
1
31
3.5
7
15
7.7
4
25
2.2
5
34
1.7
3
81
6.4
7
4,9
32
.83
11
3.9
9
39
8.1
1
65
8.0
9
Average
994.41
313.57
157.74
252.25
341.73
816.47
4,932.83
113.99
398.11
658.09
25 Circuit
BO
ON
E8
16
.14
16
6.4
2
‐
41
9.1
2
43
5.8
7
1,1
20
.93
4,0
33
.54
‐
63
4.9
5
66
5.0
1
LIN
CO
LN1
,03
3.4
1
51
9.5
2
27
0.7
8
96
2.8
6
56
9.0
1
1,4
04
.06
3,5
02
.50
‐
16
8.6
4
80
6.0
8
Average
953.30
397.01
270.78
485.64
538.43
1,279.59
3,900.78
‐
195.14
744.23
26 Circuit
LEW
IS1
,18
1.1
3
41
0.8
9
15
0.2
7
51
5.7
5
40
9.2
2
1,2
41
.80
5,1
81
.04
‐
34
5.4
9
57
1.9
9
UP
SHU
R9
37
.43
31
1.2
8
20
5.3
3
55
4.2
9
32
2.4
6
1,3
44
.10
27
0.7
0
‐
26
9.9
6
64
0.4
6
Average
1,092.67
359.36
152.58
549.24
373.62
1,309.10
2,725.87
‐
314.02
599.73
27 Circuit
WYO
MIN
G9
81
.15
42
4.0
0
21
4.4
7
67
8.4
4
34
6.3
2
74
6.6
5
2,6
11
.70
‐
50
1.2
3
67
0.2
8
Average
981.15
424.00
214.47
678.44
346.32
746.65
2,611.70
‐
501.23
670.28
28 Circuit
NIC
HO
LAS
1,0
59
.89
26
8.0
3
‐
24
2.8
4
26
0.0
7
1,1
19
.37
2,3
81
.36
‐
‐
1,0
03
.16
Average
1,059.89
268.03
‐
242.84
260.07
1,119.37
2,381.36
‐
‐
1,003.16
FY2015 Annual Report Page 83 of 212
Parole
Circuit
Mental
Prob.
Term
.Hab
eas
Muni.
Circuit
County
Felony
Misd.
Hygiene
Juv.
Rev.
Abuse
Sup. C
t.Court
Other
Average
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
APPOINTED COUNSEL AVER
AGE COST BY CASE TYPE WITHOUT DIREC
T EX
PEN
SES AND SUPPLEMEN
TALS
29 Circuit
PU
TNA
M1
,00
4.5
2
47
1.0
6
29
8.1
5
71
7.5
9
38
4.9
2
1,3
39
.10
1,1
82
.18
57
8.1
0
40
1.1
6
70
8.4
8
Average
1,004.52
471.06
298.15
717.59
384.92
1,339.10
1,182.18
578.10
401.16
708.48
30 Circuit
MIN
GO
1,2
31
.29
30
7.5
0
14
9.9
0
95
3.5
5
37
0.2
1
1,1
37
.34
1,1
96
.43
70
5.0
0
42
9.8
5
86
9.7
1
Average
1,231.29
307.50
149.90
953.55
370.21
1,137.34
1,196.43
705.00
429.85
869.71
31 Circuit
MO
NR
OE
1,0
36
.99
22
8.3
7
‐
40
3.6
4
27
8.6
2
86
3.1
5
‐
28
4.3
9
53
.34
55
9.5
9
SUM
MER
S8
11
.53
23
4.8
6
34
7.2
6
56
1.7
0
48
9.2
4
76
6.6
5
85
3.9
2
‐
38
8.1
7
58
7.7
4
Average
906.92
231.18
347.26
495.15
365.35
800.53
853.92
284.39
276.56
574.62
WV Average
1,165.58
386.96
167.29
597.96
433.40
1,086.47
2,510.82
350.67
348.33
768.83
FY2015 Annual Report Page 84 of 212
CHARGE AVERAGE TOTAL $ # CLAIMS
ABUSE & NEGLECT 1,055.99 9,424,344.13 8,926
CONTROLLED SUBSTANCES 682.52 1,792,156.22 2,626
JUVENILE 538.76 1,749,638.40 3,248
MURDER 4,202.15 1,046,334.63 249
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE 399.13 817,740.33 2,048
BURGLARY 819.71 675,431.37 824
PAROLE/PROBATION 418.29 598,577.07 1,431
SEXUAL ASSAULT 2,037.08 529,277.89 260
CONSPIRACY 775.06 516,967.73 667
ASSAULT & BATTERY 417.07 489,369.39 1,174
GRAND LARCENY 767.17 474,877.88 619
HABEAS CORPUS 2,164.96 471,960.93 218
MENTAL HYGIENE 167.22 423,232.41 2,531
CHILD ABUSE 996.70 392,699.35 394
MFG/POSS OR DIST OF METH 923.13 366,482.95 397
DUI 1ST OFFENSE 364.40 360,870.56 990
SUSPEND/REV LICENSE 376.80 351,173.56 932
BREAKING & ENTERING 772.95 346,282.48 448
AGGRAVATED ROBBERY 1,194.94 311,880.44 261
MAL WOUNDING/ASSAULT 908.63 288,036.17 317
SEXUAL ABUSE 1,837.85 272,001.40 148
PETIT LARCENY 350.11 246,601.68 704
SUPREME COURT APPEAL 2,672.86 221,847.72 83
FORGERY & UTTERING 703.98 212,600.48 302
OBSTRUCTION JUSTICE 358.62 207,284.47 578
FRAUD 628.08 206,008.85 328
ATTEMPT 1,200.17 202,346.63 175
ABUSE & NEGLECT APPEAL 2,198.28 200,043.93 91
REC/TRANS STOLEN PRO 525.11 199,016.51 379
DESTRUCTION OF PROPERTY 418.95 159,335.31 380
SHOPLIFTING 445.40 153,395.76 345
DUI 3RD OFFENSE 777.50 115,070.07 148
DUI 2ND OFFENSE 428.93 107,660.22 251
FAIL TO REG SEX OFFENDER 658.38 103,365.61 157
WANTON ENDANGERMENT 742.95 93,612.01 126
FALSE PRETENSES 517.42 93,136.02 180
DEADLY WEAPON 610.58 92,197.00 151
ARSON 1,244.39 85,862.98 69
ROBBERY 1,006.73 78,524.67 78
KIDNAPPING 1,611.84 75,124.24 46
SENTENCE REDUCTION 438.28 70,449.96 162
EMBEZZLEMENT 740.43 62,936.80 85
FAIL PAY CHILD SUPPORT 309.17 52,867.79 171
DISORDERLY CONDUCT 361.89 52,753.45 145
TERM PARENTAL RIGHTS 2,063.72 47,465.53 23
PORNOGRAPHY 1,333.80 46,683.13 35
INCEST 3,036.90 45,553.55 15
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAVERAGE PER CHARGE IN TOTAL $ ORDER
FY2015 Annual Report Page 85 of 212
CHARGE AVERAGE TOTAL $ # CLAIMS
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAVERAGE PER CHARGE IN TOTAL $ ORDER
FLEEING VEHICLE W/DUI 631.70 44,850.60 71
TRUANCY 390.50 41,783.14 107
TERRORIST ACTS 1,112.44 36,710.50 33
HOME CONFINEMENT 322.22 36,410.68 113
JAIL ESCAPE 773.78 35,593.86 46
CRUELTY TO ANIMALS 661.62 35,065.90 53
BRANDISHING WEAPON 390.79 32,826.13 84
FALSE SWEARING 389.17 32,690.19 84
CONTRIBUTE DEL MINOR 442.67 30,986.58 70
MOTOR VEHICLE SAFETY 400.43 29,631.99 74
UNLAWFUL WOUNDING 757.87 29,556.98 39
COMPUTER RELATED FRAUD 746.15 29,099.89 39
EXTRADITION 210.83 27,618.19 131
FAILURE TO APPEAR 517.67 26,918.59 52
HARASSMENT 337.96 26,360.82 78
FUGITIVE/JUSTICE 203.98 25,089.90 123
BOND REDUCTION 535.19 22,477.98 42
ACCESSORY 506.63 21,785.15 43
TRESPASSING 273.35 21,594.70 79
AIDING & ABETTING 629.65 21,408.09 34
LEAVE SCENE ACCIDENT 327.41 20,954.50 64
SOLICIT/PROSTITUTION 818.56 20,463.88 25
PUBLIC INTOXICATION 316.35 20,358.67 64
RECKLESS DRIVING 349.29 19,909.31 57
DUI W/ INJURY 649.02 17,523.67 27
WELFARE FRAUD 620.78 17,381.95 28
INTIMIDATE WITNESS 589.77 14,744.26 25
UNDER AGE DRINKING 359.07 14,721.96 41
JOYRIDING 374.72 14,614.10 39
MISCELLANEOUS 498.83 13,967.18 28
MAGISTRATE APPEAL 734.77 13,960.58 19
NEGLIGENT HOMICIDE 3,486.04 13,944.14 4
DNR CHARGE 414.61 13,682.28 33
CONCEAL A MINOR 755.63 12,090.10 16
DEL CONTRABAND INMATE 816.34 11,428.72 14
NO OPERATORS 316.62 11,398.26 36
PERMITTING DUI 329.64 10,878.11 33
NO PROOF OF INS 274.78 10,441.46 38
JUVENILE STATUS MISC 599.99 10,199.80 17
ANIMAL CONTROL 423.42 9,738.56 23
RESISTING ARREST 384.60 9,615.05 25
COUNTERFEITING 553.23 8,298.41 15
ADULT ABUSE 780.26 7,022.31 9
SHOOT W/N 500 FEET 462.36 6,935.39 15
AUTO TAMPERING 420.31 6,724.98 16
STALKING 310.32 6,206.34 20
EXTORTION 946.35 5,678.11 6
FY2015 Annual Report Page 86 of 212
CHARGE AVERAGE TOTAL $ # CLAIMS
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAVERAGE PER CHARGE IN TOTAL $ ORDER
VOL MANSLAUGHTER 1,394.46 5,577.85 4
PERMIT UNAUTH/DRIVE 348.88 5,233.23 15
SPEEDING 312.78 4,691.72 15
FAIL MAINTAIN CONTROL 456.02 4,560.19 10
DISTURB THE PEACE 317.88 4,450.28 14
CONTEMPT 314.93 4,094.05 13
OPEN CONTAINER 235.15 3,997.51 17
OBSTRUCT CITY PERSONNEL 1,963.32 3,926.64 2
INDECENT EXPOSURE 323.23 3,878.72 12
RETALIATE PUBLIC OFFICIAL 894.26 3,577.02 4
CONCEAL DEAD BODY 1,700.06 3,400.12 2
UNLAWFUL RESTRAINT 487.63 2,925.75 6
RESTITUTION 324.81 2,923.28 9
BRIBERY 712.35 2,849.41 4
PROHIBITION 890.82 2,672.47 3
DUI/W DEATH 2,564.00 2,564.00 1
EXPUNGEMENT 331.04 1,986.26 6
LITTERING 230.47 1,843.74 8
PEACE WARRANT 361.47 1,807.34 5
MANDAMUS 885.96 1,771.91 2
CIVIL RIGHTS VIOLATION 1,462.80 1,462.80 1
FORFEITURE 1,316.10 1,316.10 1
PRE GRAND JURY 518.79 518.79 1
OBS EMERGENCY PERSONNEL 168.23 336.46 2
OFFENSES BY INMATES 110.00 110.00 1
STATE AVERAGE & TOTALS 716.89 25,954,897.24 36,205
FY2015 Annual Report Page 87 of 212
Appendix B
Public Defender Corporation Statistics
• Map
• Chairpersons of PDC Boards of Directors
• Grants and Total Disbursements
• Attorney Time
• Total Cases Closed
• PDC Office Narratives
FY2015 Annual Report Page 88 of 212
PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATION CIRCUITS
FY2015 Annual Report Page 89 of 212
PD CORPORATIONS’ BOARD OF DIRECTORS’ CHAIRPERSONS CIRCUIT COUNTIES CHAIRS 1ST BROOKE KAREN E. KAHLE, ESQ. CHAIR HANCOCK WHEELING, WV OHIO 2ND MARSHALL VICKI VOORHIS, CHAIR TYLER NEW MARTINSVILLE, WV WETZEL 4TH WOOD BLAINE MYERS, WIRT PARKERSBURG, WV 5TH CALHOUN JEANETTE ATKINSON, CHAIR JACKSON SPENCER, WV ROANE 6TH/24TH CABELL JOHN F. CYRUS, ESQ., CHAIR WAYNE HUNTINGTON, WV 7TH LOGAN MARK HOBBS, ESQ., CHAIR CHAPMANVILLE, WV 8TH MCDOWELL JOHN “MIKE” CALLAWAY, CHAIR WELCH, WV 9TH MERCER WILLIAM O. HUFFMAN, ESQ., CHAIR PRINCETON, WV 10TH RALEIGH JANE CALVERT, CHAIR CRAB ORCHARD, WV 11TH GREENBRIER A. DAVID SMITH, CHAIR POCAHONTAS RONCEVERTE, WV 12TH FAYETTE CHRIS MOOREHEAD, ESQ., CHAIR FAYETTEVILLE, WV 13TH KANAWHA LONNIE SIMMONS, ESQ., CHAIR CHARLESTON, WV 15TH HARRISON GEORGE F. FORDHAM, ESQ., CHAIR CLARKSBURG, WV 18TH PRESTON DEBORAH DELAUDER, CHAIR TERRA ALTA, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 90 of 212
PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATIONS BOARD CHAIRS CONTINUED CIRCUIT COUNTIES CHAIRS 23RD BERKELEY JAMES CRAWFORD III, ESQ., CHAIR JEFFERSON CHARLES TOWN, WV MORGAN 25TH BOONE JAMES HENSLEY, CHAIR LINCOLN DANVILLE, WV 28TH NICHOLAS MALCOLM F. VAUGHAN, ESQ., CHAIR SUMMERSVILLE, WV 30TH MINGO JANE MORAN, ESQ., CHAIR WILLIAMSON, WV
Pictured: Dana Eddy presenting to Chief Public Defenders and Office Managers. Flatwoods, WV. December 2014
FY2015 Annual Report Page 91 of 212
Circuit
Distributed Contractual
Amounts
Total Funds Allocated toEach Circuit
Total PDC
Funding1ST 1,100,391 10,363 1,110,754 2ND 494,148 5,471 499,619 5TH 837,791 8,339 846,130
6TH/24TH 1,799,418 16,503 1,815,921 7TH 654,966 9,152 664,118 8TH 453,241 5,132 458,373 9TH 979,136 6,402 985,538
10TH 1,006,343 11,496 1,017,839 11TH 609,105 8,204 617,309 12TH 574,567 6,419 580,986 13TH 3,247,523 30,657 3,278,180 15TH 1,048,740 11,602 1,060,342 18TH 431,762 5,252 437,014 23RD 2,683,906 16,401 2,700,307 25TH 756,947 7,020 763,967 28TH 329,810 4,435 334,245 30TH 575,568 7,047 582,615
TOTALS 17,583,362 169,895 17,753,257
1Excludes $400,000 grant to 4TH Judicial Circuit PDC for startup expenses. This figure will be included in the FY16 cost-per-case calculation.
GRANTS TO PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATIONS1PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICES
July 1, 2014 to June 30, 2015
Corporations for Legal Research, Auditing Services, InformationTechnology Services, and Auditor Transaction Fees.
NOTES: Total funds Allocated to Each Circuit represents fundsdisbursed by the WVPDS on behalf of the Public Defender
FY2015 Annual Report Page 92 of 212
1,297.7
253,930.2
In‐Court
Out‐of‐Court
Administrative
Drug Court
TOTAL TIME
PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATION ATTORNEY TIMEBY IN‐COURT/OUT‐OF‐COURT/ADMINISTRATIVE/DRUG COURT
54,135.5
134,373.0
64,124.0
In‐Court21.32%
Out‐of‐Court52.92%
Administrative25.25%
Drug Court0.51%
FY2015 Annual Report Page 93 of 212
IN OUT OF DRUG
COURT COURT COURT
1st Circuit 2,415.2 11,891.2 3,965.6 ‐ 18,272.0
2nd Circuit 987.1 4,978.9 2,038.0 ‐ 8,004.0
5th Circuit 2,520.8 5,785.8 2,616.0 ‐ 10,922.6
6th & 24th Circuits 7,921.4 15,496.4 6,205.1 391.9 30,014.8
7th Circuit 1,174.9 3,577.9 1,524.3 1.8 6,278.9
8th Circuit 1,457.0 3,512.9 938.0 ‐ 5,907.9
9th Circuit 3,007.7 7,231.6 2,845.8 130.4 13,215.5
10th Circuit 4,922.8 7,031.4 4,261.3 2.0 16,217.5
11th Circuit 1,865.6 5,381.5 1,620.4 63.8 8,931.3
12th Circuit 1,708.0 4,833.2 1,849.5 ‐ 8,390.7
13th Circuit 9,779.5 20,462.4 12,251.1 345.5 42,838.5
15th Circuit 3,224.4 9,741.3 5,131.3 148.1 18,245.1
18th Circuit 687.4 3,525.3 1,651.5 98.7 5,962.9
23rd Circuit 7,720.8 18,902.8 10,323.1 ‐ 36,946.7
25th Circuit 2,490.0 6,067.7 3,553.8 115.0 12,226.5
28th Circuit 1,446.0 1,685.6 889.3 0.5 4,021.4
30th Circuit 806.9 4,267.1 2,459.9 ‐ 7,533.9
PD TOTAL 54,135.5 134,373.0 64,124.0 1,297.7 253,930.2
PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATIONS ATTORNEY TIMEBY IN‐COURT/OUT‐OF‐COURT/ADMINISTRATION/DRUG COURT
ADMIN. TOTALPDC
FY2015 Annual Report Page 94 of 212
Felony 8,209
Misdemeanor 17,560
Mental Hygiene 1,511
Juvenile 2,757
Parole / Probation Revocation 1,139
Term/Abuse & Neglect 722
Habeas / Sup. Ct. 47
Drug Court ‐
Other 1,225
Total Cases 33,170
PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATION
TOTAL CASES CLOSED
Felony24.75%
Misdemeanor52.94%
Mental Hygiene4.56%
Juvenile8.31%
Parole / Probation Revocation
3.43%
Term/Abuse & Neglect2.18%
Habeas / Sup. Ct.0.14%
Drug Court>0.00%
Other3.69%
FY2015 Annual Report Page 95 of 212
1ST 319 1,001 ‐ 80 46 9 ‐ ‐ 69 1,524
2ND 274 443 ‐ 55 60 30 3 ‐ 17 882
5TH 294 599 39 105 18 89 ‐ ‐ 26 1,170
6TH, 24TH 1,740 2,265 ‐ 336 157 21 2 ‐ 77 4,598
7TH 264 279 11 36 42 35 ‐ ‐ 21 688
8TH 235 752 4 116 ‐ 26 ‐ ‐ 79 1,212
9TH 321 1,401 8 276 50 156 2 ‐ 175 2,389
10TH 588 1,261 131 201 199 13 3 ‐ 94 2,490
11TH 198 598 57 51 1 36 1 ‐ 43 985
12TH 271 427 12 32 21 27 ‐ ‐ 15 805
13TH 1,181 4,025 1,004 621 257 ‐ 27 ‐ 123 7,238
15TH 306 724 10 227 81 19 4 ‐ 73 1,444
18TH 247 303 15 74 50 37 4 ‐ 75 805
23RD 1,064 2,125 134 339 53 140 ‐ ‐ 235 4,090
25TH 401 591 18 89 96 34 ‐ ‐ 8 1,237
28TH 196 360 24 63 1 45 1 ‐ 33 723
30TH 310 406 44 56 7 5 ‐ ‐ 62 890
Total 8,209 17,560 1,511 2,757 1,139 722 47 ‐ 1,225 33,170
TOTAL
PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATIONS
CASES CLOSED BY CASE TYPE
FelonyPD Circuit Misd.Mental
HygieneJuv.
Term/
Abuse &
Neglect
Habeas,
Sup. Ct.Drug Court
Parole &
Prob. RevOther
FY2015 Annual Report Page 96 of 212
Public Defender Corporation for the First Judicial Circuit Under the direction of our nine-member Board of Directors, the Public Defender
Corporation for the First Judicial Circuit is a client focused non-profit organization operating in the Northern Panhandle of West Virginia. In order to meet the demands of the four judges and ten magistrates located in our tri-county circuit, we employ a diverse collection of nine full time attorneys representing approximately 177 years of combined legal experience. Our attorneys are supported through five non-lawyer staff associates with 65 years of dedicated service. Our attorneys and staff are split between two offices located in Wheeling and Weirton.
Our primary mission is the direct representation of indigent citizens accused by the
government of crimes against the state. We do this well—everyone knows what we bring! Our secondary mission focuses on preserving the Rule of Law.
Gideon correctly states that attorneys are not luxuries but necessities. FY14 witnessed increases in total cases by the Corporation over FY13 from 55.99% to 59.48%. For example, felonies increased from 59.71% to 64.35%; Misdemeanors increased from 87.36% to 89.07%; and juveniles increased from 61.66% to 68.93%. Also relevant, our cost per case remains $495.77 lower than the panel attorney. These raw numbers provide the best evidence of our cost effectiveness.1 In addition to the above, the Corporation, by Circuit Court appointment, also represents citizens in municipal court, parole/probation revocations, juvenile matters, abuse and neglect proceedings, as well as other miscellaneous matters involving jeopardized freedom.
To be clear, cost-saving measures are not the true measure of our effectiveness. That honor belongs to the performance of our employees. Our Corporation takes pride in the competent delivery of legal services to our clients. Collectively, our board, attorneys, and support staff are the Corporation. We are a learning organization—combining experience, talent, and advocacy—collectively aimed towards assisting the indigent accused through the legal and regulatory minefield. Equally important, we are vested in the community we serve. Our employees are military veterans, members of local boards, former elected officials, community volunteers, and are active in community events. Our dedication to the rule of law shapes our end state—that being our well-earned reputation as an obstacle on the road to tyranny. We are the quiet guardians of liberty. Shayne M. Welling, Chief Public Defender Sulum Teneo Quis Nos Addo
1 Source: http://www.pds.wv.gov/Documents/2014%20Annual%20Report.pdf
FY2015 Annual Report Page 97 of 212
Public Defender Corporation for the Second Judicial Circuit A proverb claims, “Change is neither good nor bad, it is simply constant”. However, the Second Judicial Circuit Public Defender Corporation has experienced change in Fiscal Year 2015 while maintaining its high quality legal representation of the indigent. Although Chief Public Defender David L. Zehnder is retiring, he continues to serve as Chief Public Defender as a consultant, and supervises the Corporation and Managing Attorney Brett M. Ferro, who started work on January 5, 2015. The Second Judicial Circuit Public Defender Corporation reduced its cost per case from $565.78 in FY2013 to $456.78 in FY2014, which increased the savings achieved from $23.87 per case in FY2013 to $222.49 per case in FY2014. As of June 30, 2015, the office employed Mr. Zehnder, Mr. Ferro, three assistant public defenders, and two clerical staff. Public Defender Services has funded a third clerical position for FY2016. Two additional lay board members have been nominated and are awaiting confirmation from the Commissions of Tyler and Wetzel Counties. If both nominees are confirmed, the Board will consist of the Chairwoman, a Marshall County attorney, and lay members from all three Counties. In January 2015, Circuit Judge David W. Hummel, Jr., became Chief Judge of the Second Judicial Circuit and assumed criminal jurisdiction in Marshall County, the most populous County in the Circuit. A large backlog of cases was swiftly cleared in January and February by the Court with the assistance and efforts of all of the attorneys, and several felony trials were conducted. All three assistant public defenders achieved felony acquittals in Marshall County Circuit Court during that time. John Anderson had three felony jury trial acquittals, Jeremiah Gardner had one felony jury trial acquittal in Wetzel County and one in Marshall County, and John Gainer had a client acquitted of a felony and convicted of the lesser-included offense of misdemeanor battery. He also kept another jury deliberating about the meaning of reasonable doubt until ten o’clock on a Friday night. Our office has continued to provide effective representation of its clients in a cost-effective way. We continue to represent a majority of the Circuit's Drug Court and Mental Health Court participants. We remain ready, willing, and able to serve when called to duty. Brett M. Ferro, Managing Attorney
FY2015 Annual Report Page 98 of 212
Public Defender Corporation for the Fourth Judicial Circuit On January 4, 2016, West Virginia’s eighteenth public defender office will officially open its doors for business, serving indigent criminal clients in Wood and Wirt counties. Ultimately, this office will employ a total of nine attorneys, including the Chief Public Defender Michele Rusen and five to six legal assistants. Throughout 2015, plans and preparations for the office were underway. This marks the first time a new public defender corporation has opened in West Virginia in many years. Working closely with our board of directors, office space was located, renovations were planned and designed, and furniture and computers were purchased. Staff was hired. The challenges of opening a new office were daunting at times, but the end result is an office of which we are quite proud.
As we prepared to open our office, we focused on our future goals: providing our clients with skilled legal representation while hopefully guiding them to resolve issues that may have led to their involvement in the criminal justice system whenever possible. To that end, we spent many hours meeting and conferring with court officials ranging from probation officers, magistrates and judges and meeting with a variety of social service providers. We compiled information on as many available services and programs as possible so that our clients could be steered to appropriate providers. We also now participate in Juvenile Drug Court and plan to remain an active participant in that valuable program.
It is fast becoming apparent that the state cannot continue to incarcerate as many people
as historically has occurred. Politicians at all levels are coming to this realization including county commissions who no longer want to pay enormous jail bills as well as state officials who are contemplating state revenue shortfalls. Accordingly, we are committed to thinking outside the box as we work with our future clients to ensure that they receive the best possible legal services and legal advice we can provide. Michele Rusen, Chief Public Defender
FY2015 Annual Report Page 99 of 212
Public Defender Corporation for the Fifth Judicial Circuit Organizational Information Organization’s History:
The Public Defender Corporation held its first board meeting on the 31st day of July 1996 and includes the 5th Judicial Circuit of Calhoun, Roane, Jackson, and Mason counties in West Virginia. However, during the process the Mason County Bar brought a lawsuit against the corporation and was granted an injunction for operation in Mason County. At the time, the injunction was not challenged and the corporation along with Public Defender Services made the mutual decision not to litigate the injunction as Public Defender Services and the corporation being in their infancies and it was agreed it was more important to firmly establish the corporation and Public Defender Services generally. To this day, the injunction has not been challenged. The corporation has revisited the topic in meetings and with communication with the local Mason County Bar and Judge Nibert of Mason County, West Virginia through its Chief Public Defender and has decided not to challenge the injunction as of this date. Organizational Goals and Objectives:
Our goal is to provide high quality legal assistance to indigent persons who would be otherwise unable to afford adequate legal counsel; to provide legal representation to those who face an economic barrier to adequate legal counsel that will serve the ends of justice in accordance with rights and privileges guaranteed to all citizens by the constitution of the United States of America and the constitution of the state of West Virginia; to make available quality legal assistance that reaffirms the faith of our citizens in our government of laws.
The objective is to protect the ordinary citizen from wrongful conviction and to protect
the basic and fundamental rights of all citizens by navigating those individuals charged with crimes through an evolving and complex legal system. A conviction based on sound law and tested facts with competent counsel is rarely overturned by the courts whereby society as a whole is protected by protecting individual rights. Programs and Services:
Pursuant to W. Va. Code §29-21-8(a)(2) the purpose of a public defender corporation is to provide legal representation in the respective circuits in accordance with the provisions of that article. To that end, we provide appointed counsel in felony, misdemeanor, abuse & neglect, juvenile delinquency, juvenile status offenses, family court contempt when jail is contemplated, and mental hygiene proceedings. Organizational Structure (board, staff, volunteers):
The Board of Directors is organized pursuant to W. Va. Code §29-21-15 consisting of a chairperson appointed by the Governor, and two members from each county in which the
FY2015 Annual Report Page 100 of 212
corporation operates for a total of seven members. (A lawyer and non-lawyer each from Jackson, Roane, and Calhoun counties with a chairperson from Roane County.) There are currently three office staff members, including our office manager. In addition, there are seven lawyers, including our chief public defender.
The board oversees the corporation pursuant to W. Va. Code §29-21-15. The chief public defender reports to the board of directors, each of the assistant public defenders and staff members report to the chief public defender.The chief public defender is ethically responsible for the conduct of the assistant public defenders and the staff pursuant to Rules 5.1 and 5.3 of the West Virginia Rules of Professional Conduct (2013) for lawyers. Community Involvement:
Currently, the Chief Public Defender is an adjunct criminal law instructor at West Virginia University at Parkersburg, Jackson County campus on one night per week. The chief is also on the Community Corrections Board for Wood County and Jackson counties.
One of the assistant public defenders is a board member of DayMark, Inc., a non-profit youth service agency.
An administrative assistant is active in the 4H program in Roane County, WV and is also a member of the Spencer Volunteer Fire Department. Another administrative assistant is actively involved in coordinating beauty pageants and other activities of that nature to help young women receive college tuition assistance including grants and scholarships. New & Noteworthy for 2015
Earlier this summer we had a felony trial in Roane County that resulted in an acquittal. However, there have been multiple cases where through plea bargaining or further investigation by police charges have been reduced or dismissed. We have worked diligently to protect each client’s rights as they navigate the criminal justice system, often steering them toward sobriety. We have had several clients participate in the Drug Court Program. These folks have made and continue to make remarkable strides from addiction to sobriety. We have had graduates who have moved beyond a life of addiction to a life of sobriety. They now hold full time jobs and maintain close family relationships that had been previously abandoned. Kevin Postalwait, Chief Public Defender
FY2015 Annual Report Page 101 of 212
Public Defender Corporation for the Sixth & Twenty-fourth Judicial Circuit
The Public Defender Corporation for the 6th and 24th Judicial Circuits was founded on
June 1, 1994 and serves Cabell and Wayne Counties. One notable aspect of our case load is the large number of felonies versus misdemeanors. Cabell County has had over 500 indicted people annually in the last three calendar years and this is the primary reason for this surge. In FY2015, the Huntington office closed 3,581 cases and the Wayne office closed 1,017 cases, totaling 4,598 cases. There are eleven attorneys in Huntington and three in Wayne. The addition of an investigator has helped both offices although he primarily works in Huntington.
Our office has been active in helping establish and maintain Adult Drug Courts in both
counties, Truancy Courts in both counties, Day Report Centers in both counties, a Veterans Treatment Court in Wayne County, a Juvenile Drug Court in Wayne County and a Pre-Trial Board in Cabell County. The Pre-Trial Review Board saved Cabell County an estimated $179,931 in jail costs in FY 2015 on misdemeanor cases.
Our office is an example of the high volume, low cost legal representation envisioned under the Public Defender Corporation program:
Third lowest cost per case among Public Defender Corporations at $377.75 Highest number of felonies among Public Defender Corporations (1,507) Third highest share of representing felonies (76.14%) in the state Second highest number of misdemeanors (2,512) Second highest share of representing misdemeanors (93.35%) in the state Second highest number of cases among Public Defender offices FY14 cost per hour $86.11. FY15 cost per hour $76.27 FY15 cost per case $394.94
In addition to our office serving as an example of cost-effective operations, appointed
counsel in our circuits also have some of the best statistics in the state: Cabell county had the lowest cost per case for court appointed counsel at $502.43 Wayne county had the fourth lowest cost per case for court appointed counsel at $590.24 The combined cost per case for appointed counsel in our circuit was the lowest in the
state at $543.89 Court appointed counsel represented 2,509 cases including 492 felony cases, 570 abuse
and neglect cases, and 874 mental hygiene cases. Bob Wilkinson, Chief Public Defender
FY2015 Annual Report Page 102 of 212
Public Defender Corporation for the Seventh Judicial Circuit
The Public Defenders Corporation for the Seventh Judicial Circuit has been serving Logan County since late November, 1989. This fiscal year we successfully acquired many dismissals, pre-trial diversions, probation, home confinement, drug court for both adults and juveniles, and many options outside of prison and jail. We have come to recognize that addiction has changed the practice of criminal law in West Virginia over the last two decades. We must work aggressively towards meeting the needs of our clients who often struggle to stay drug free while on bond before any significant hearing even occurs. Our very experienced criminal defense team has taken up the torch of aggressive pre-conviction and post-conviction sentencing alternatives which save lives and decrease risk to clients while still saving the county and state money.
We believe that we have had very few cases result in long term prison commitments
primarily because we effectively and aggressively utilize the alternative sentencing, community based programs in our county, inpatient treatment facilities, and sober living homes both in an outside our county. We have built essential connections with drug addiction service providers to help our clients maintain their freedom and to have productive lives.
We pride ourselves on having one of the most experienced criminal defense teams in the
state. Dwayne Adkins has been the Chief Public Defender for nearly a decade now and has
practiced law for twenty years. He has a broad background with experience as a criminal trial lawyer, and civil trial lawyer (both as a plaintiff’s lawyer and a defense lawyer). He was also an assistant prosecuting attorney in the past. He is an active member of Southern Regional Day Report Board and Drug Court Teams for Logan County. Dwayne is a graduate of both Marshall and WVU.
Gerald Merceruio has over twenty-five years’ experience as a criminal trial lawyer. His
long-standing loyalty to the public defender system places him among a short list of public defenders who have essentially been on board since the early 1990’s. Gerald received his undergraduate and law degree from WVU.
Don McDaniel is an experienced criminal trial lawyer and civil trial lawyer, having
practiced in Texas as well as West Virginia. Don is an Ivy League Graduate with an undergraduate degree from Yale and law degree from Vanderbilt. He is known for his caring optimism and Christian charity.
Ashley Cochran, a former intern, recently joined our office. Her practice focuses on
Juvenile and Abuse & Neglect cases. Ashley returns to our office with the valuable experience of having clerked for Judge O’Briant, as well as a stint under well-known Abuse and Neglect guru Jane Moran. She also practiced as a guardian ad litem in family court. Ashley is a graduate of Appalachian School of Law in Grundy Virginia.
Long standing support staff member Carol Booth is the administrative right hand of our
office. She is focuses on the financial aspects of the office, as well as working to get clients into
FY2015 Annual Report Page 103 of 212
drug rehabilitation programs. She worked for multiple lawyers prior to coming to work for our office but has far exceeded the traditional secretarial role long ago.
Pamela Esposito came to us as an experienced secretary having worked in a plaintiff’s
law firm. She has continued to work hard to increase her commitment and skills since coming to work for us. She is known among clients and the community as having a sunny disposition and always being willing to help.
Brandi Clark is also a recent addition to our office. She joins us as an administrative
assistant, having worked for other lawyer include Robert “Bob” Noone. She is enthusiastic to help others, and eager to learn new skills specific to our office and operations.
In addition to our legal representation, we also work hand-in-hand with other criminal
defense lawyers. We recently began a local continuing legal education program in combination with the Logan County Bar Association. We recently cosponsored a training session taught by duo Robert “Bob” & Beth Noone on the specialized needs of children in court cases. We have another training scheduled for this fall with Dr. Timothy Saar of Saar Psychological Group.
We also assist local attorneys by covering emergency hearings when certain
circumstances prevent a panel attorney from appearing for his or client. This typically occurs for detention hearings and for other hearings in which there is little notice and the panel attorney is unavailable due to an appearance at a hearing in another circuit. When possible, we also serve as a local resource to other criminal defense lawyers by giving them access to our pre-trial motions and pre-existing legal research.
We also try to provide assistance as a local resource for criminal trial lawyers by giving
them access to our pre-trial motions and pre-existing legal research. Dwayne J. Adkins, Chief Public Defender
FY2015 Annual Report Page 104 of 212
Public Defender Corporation for the Eighth Judicial Circuit The Public Defender Corporation for the Eighth Judicial Circuit was established in 1990. The rise of unemployment, in once thriving McDowell County was the result of the failing coal industry. The loss of income for the citizens of McDowell County created an overwhelming need of legal representation for those who became indigent. Along with the migration of qualified attorneys away from McDowell County and an increasing case load for court appointed attorneys, a majority of the active members of the bar and the chief judge agreed to activate the Public Defender Corporation for the 8th Judicial Circuit.
Our county experienced further loss with the devastating floods of 2001 and 2002. As a result
of the floods more jobs exited creating a greater indigent population. During the second flood of 2002 the PDC was flooded with water up to 3 feet. Nevertheless the employees continued to serve the public without fail, while shoveling mud and fighting mold for a month before the office could be relocated.
Our office handles the following types of cases: felony, misdemeanor, abuse and neglect, juvenile delinquency, truancy, appeals of felonies and misdemeanors, mental hygiene hearings, guardian ad litem, and extraditions. Our staff is comprised of three attorneys, including a chief, an Office Manager, and our Secretary. Floyd Anderson, Chief Public Defender
FY2015 Annual Report Page 105 of 212
Public Defender Corporation for the Ninth Judicial Circuit
The Public Defender Corporation for the Ninth Judicial Circuit is located in Princeton. We began operations on June 1, 1991 with three attorneys and two support staff. Currently, seven attorneys and five support staff handle court proceedings in front of three circuit court judges, five magistrates, and in municipal courts. We also regularly participate in Supreme Court proceedings.
Our office and the Mercer County court system have strived to adapt to the needs of indigent
defendants as they have arisen. Due to the increased drug challenges in our society, our corporation became involved in serving on Adult Drug Court and Juvenile Drug Court.
Adult Drug Court increases the likelihood of successful rehabilitation through early,
continuous, and intense treatment. Our clients in Adult Drug Court must comply with mandatory periodic drug testing, community supervision, appropriate sanctions and incentives, and other rehabilitation services, all of which a judicial officer supervises. By participating in Adult Drug Court clients reduce the chances of recidivism because they are less likely to begin using drugs again.
We work with our juvenile offenders in Juvenile Drug Court to redirect juvenile offenders with alcohol or substance abuse behavior from the traditional juvenile court process, to an intensive, individualized treatment process. The mutual goal of our office and Juvenile Drug Court is to reduce future court involvement for these youth.
Mercer County has historically had one of the highest numbers of open child abuse and neglect caseloads in the state. During these proceedings, we help to ensure that parents’ constitutional rights to parent their children remain protected. We also interact with the West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources (DHHR) to assure parents obtain services through the DHHR providers to learn proper parenting techniques.
We also participate on the Southern Regional Community Criminal Justice Board with representatives from the Court system and the community. The purpose of the board is to oversee the day-to-day operations of the Day Report Center. Previously, our corporation was involved with court personnel and community leaders in obtaining a Justice Reinvestment Grant, which has now led to the opening of the Four Seasons Recovery Center. They hope to have at least sixty residents. Their goal is to rehabilitate drug offenders and reintroduce them into society as productive citizens.
Staff attorneys, Adam B. Wolfe and Joshua J. Lawson are currently teaching an advanced mock trial class at Concord University. Adam also teaches a legal writing class.
Staff attorney, Gerald R. Linkous, won a West Virginia Supreme Court appeal, Robinson v. City of Bluefield, 234 W.Va 209 764 S. E. 2d 740 (W.Va 2014), which ruled a municipal court lacks the authority to order a dog to be put down. The Wall Street Journal published an article regarding this case.
Our attorneys and support staff are involved in arranging for substance abuse rehabilitation services for clients who do not qualify for Drug Court services. We make referrals, prepare orders to transport, and evaluate clients to assist them in overcoming addictions.
In the past year, our attorneys have been successful in obtaining dismissals in several felony
FY2015 Annual Report Page 106 of 212
cases, and have had charges reduced through the impressive use of pre-trial motions and compelling arguments at the preliminary hearing stage. Our attorneys have also been successful in reunifying families in various abuse and neglect cases.
Our involvement in Truancy Court has enabled us to reveal the unmet needs of children in our county. While working with the Truancy Court system, we have assisted children in receiving necessary educational, psychological, and medical services.
Tracy Burkes, Chief Public Defender
FY2015 Annual Report Page 107 of 212
Public Defender Corporation for the Tenth Judicial Circuit
Our office has been located at 228 N. Fayette Street in Beckley, WV for more than eighteen years. It currently employs a chief public defender, seven staff attorneys, and a full time support staff of five individuals plus a bookkeeper/office manager. Our office opened in 1989, making it one of the oldest Public Defender Corporations in the State.
Jane Calvert currently acts as Chairperson for our Board of Directors. In addition to Ms.
Calvert, Board members include John Wooton, Leigh Lefler, Harriet Jones, and Pam Bates. Each Board member has served in their capacity for a minimum of four years.
The lawyers currently employed have been working at the office an average of about 8 years and have on average more than 20 years of legal experience each. During FY15 our office closed a total of 2,490 cases which included 588 felonies and 1261 misdemeanors. This amounted to an average cost per case of approximately $408.77. This is one of the lowest cost per case ratio in the state. In FY14, our office also represented approximately 54% of all cases in the circuit for which counsel is appointed, this was ninth highest rate in the state for that period of time. Much of the lower cost per case can be attributed to the experienced legal and support staff, the high ratio of cases per attorney (310.5 cases per counsel), as well as a continuing effort to reduce cost incidental to operating the office.
Cases are assigned evenly on a rotation basis so that each attorney handles matters in
magistrate court, circuit court, and before other miscellaneous tribunals (parole hearings, mental hygiene, etc...).
Lawyer schedules are kept electronically on Time Matters as well as on desk calendars. All lawyers have access to Time Matters to keep their time and to check their calendar. Attorneys can access their files through the E-File Program as well as through the hard copy maintained in their office. Closed files can also be accessed through the E-File program. Cases over the last thirteen years have been scanned, reducing the need for storage of those documents. Backups of all records are maintained on and off premises insuring their survival.
Our basic principle is to provide the best possible legal defense to each client. The legal staff meets frequently to review and discuss cases giving a committee approach to most cases. Standard pretrial motions are filed in all cases and attorneys individually review their cases to see what particular motions should be filed to properly advocate for their clients. Our office is capable of running paperless since all documents received or produced are scanned digitally. Our office maintains a form bank for motions and research on most legal issues and is supplemented with the current use of West Law.
Over the past year, we meet weekly with the prosecuting attorney and local day report representative to review defendants who are incarcerated in jail to see if their release might be obtained through recognizance or other means of conditional bond. On average, three individuals per week are released after these meetings, saving counties approximately $1,000 per week.
As with other offices, the recent initiation of Truancy Court has strained staff. Looking
FY2015 Annual Report Page 108 of 212
ahead, Juvenile Drug Court begins in August 2015, with Adult Drug Court commencing shortly thereafter. These programs will place additional burdens on our office and on an already financially strained system. However, we will continue to persevere and uphold our statutory obligation to the state and professional obligation to our clients.
Our office would seek to share any resources and information with other public defenders and lawyers representing criminal defendants to improve representation of those charged with crimes and those represented on matters where there is a legal mandate requiring representation by appointed counsel. Joe Noggy, Chief Public Defender
FY2015 Annual Report Page 109 of 212
Public Defender Corporation for the Eleventh Judicial Circuit
The Public Defender Corporation, 11th Judicial Circuit is a 501(c)(3) non-profit corporation formed pursuant to West Virginia Code Chapter 29, Article 21 to the State’s obligation to provide cost-effective legal representation to indigents facing eligible criminal and quasi-criminal charges within the 11th Judicial Circuit. The Corporation is guided by a board of directors chaired by David Smith, the Mayor of Ronceverte, WV, with the Chief Defender, Joshua Edwards, serving as the day-to-day administrator.
The Public Defender Corporation for the Eleventh Judicial Circuit operates in two
locations: (1) the Greenbrier County office in Lewisburg and (2) the satellite office located in Marlinton, Pocahontas County. Our office was formed in 1999 under the direction of its first Chief Defender, Richard Lorensen.
Our primary purpose is to provide cost-effective, competent legal representation to
indigents defendants. However, we also serve an important role the community as leaders in alternative programs such as community corrections, drug court programs, truancy diversion and pretrial supervision. Our attorneys have been an important part of these efforts. Chief Defender Joshua Edwards and Deputy Chief Defender Dewitt Daniell both serve on the advisory committee for Greenbrier County’s Day Report Program, which received the Honorable Martin J. Gaughan Award for Excellence in Community Corrections. In addition to their formal role on the advisory committee, both serve as informal advisors on policy matters and legal questions as they arise. Both are also members of the advisory committee in Pocahontas County serving in a similar capacity. We provide attorneys for the weekly drug court treatment teams in both counties. Mr. Edwards serves on the Planning Committee for the Juvenile Drug Court and previously served on the Juvenile Drug Court weekly treatment team. He is also part of the planning team to bring a Juvenile Day Report Center to Greenbrier County. Both counties also have Truancy Diversion Programs and our attorneys are responsible for representing the vast majority of the juveniles in those programs.
Outside of the court system, our attorneys have volunteered to assist with the Supreme
Court of Appeals LAWS (Legal Advancement for West Virginia Students) Program, lectured middle school students on the consequences of bullying, attended career day programs to discuss a legal career with students, and given additional presentations in schools on the criminal justice system.
The Corporation is entirely funded by the State of West Virginia through a grant from Public Defender Services. The Corporation owns both of their locations and therefore has necessary maintenance and repair expenses as well as snow removal, cleaning and the other assorted expense associated with two physical facilities. Historically, our office has been a cost-effective provider of legal services. Our cost-per-case in FY 2014 was $425.86 compared to private appointed counsel in the Judicial Circuit at $1,342.75. Josh Edwards, Chief Public Defender
FY2015 Annual Report Page 110 of 212
Public Defender Corporation for the Twelfth Judicial Circuit This year marks the twenty-fifth anniversary of our office. While we are very proud of the work and legacy we have built, our hearts are heavy, as our office has suffered a great loss. On June 16, 2015, our friend, mentor, protector, leader, and Chairman, Frederick Alexander Jesser, III, unexpectedly passed. We want to use this space to honor him and his legacy. When West Virginia Code §21-29-8 was passed, Frederick Alexander Jesser, III (known by our office as Fred), was named as one of the Fayette County Bar Association’s representatives on the founding board of directors. He served as a very active member, and was instrumental in making the initial hires, securing office space, and creating an atmosphere where the indigent defendants in our county could receive high quality representation. As years passed, Fred’s role with our office expended and at the time of his death, he had been the Chairman of our board of directors for a number of years. Fred filled the role of acting Chair for many years prior to being formally appointed to that post, first by then Governor Manchin and then again by Governor Tomblin.
At the time of Fred’s death on June 16, 2015, he had planned to attend the annual Public Defender Services Conference the next week. It was his practice to attend each annual conference to allow him the opportunity to spend time with the professional staff of our office, and to attend the trainings so that he could better understand the challenges we face on a daily basis. Fred also liked to share at least one meal each conference with an attorney from another Public Defender Office. At the last board meeting held before his passing, Fred offered direction to our office on filling a vacancy created by Assistant Public Defender Elizabeth Campbell leaving our office to take a job with our local Prosecutor. He expressed pride in this office as to how our hard work was documented in the annual report and reassured us that the budget conference held with Public Defender Services would be successful and no cause for stress. Fred was always available to our office to sign checks, offer advice, run interference with Judges and Magistrates and, for a period of time when between Chief Defenders, even ruled on Financial Affidavits. Although we grieve for our friend, as a part of being a successful leader he supported the skills necessary for us to continue without him. This office will survive, none of us are irreplaceable, and there is always work to accomplish. Therefore, our staff, Terri Lawhorn, E. Scott Stanton, Esq., Nancy S. Fraley, Esq., James Adkins, Esq., and Stacey Barnhouse, together with our surviving board members; Howard Scott and James Keenan, Esq., take and cherish this opportunity to individually and collectively express our sincere thanks to Frederick Alexander Jesser, III, Esq., for all that he gave to our office. We will miss you our friend.
Fred was born on February 20, 1945, in Washington, D.C. and was the son of the late
Frederick A. Jesser, Jr. and Elizabeth Sutherland Jesser. He was a 1962 graduate of Charleston High School and attended Morris Harvey College, Concord College, Marshall University, Virginia Commonwealth University, and Richmond Professional Institute. He earned his Bachelor of Arts Degree at Hampden-Sydney College in Virginia in 1967. He graduated from the
FY2015 Annual Report Page 111 of 212
West Virginia University College of Law in 1972, where he was a member of the West Virginia Law Review. Upon graduation from Law School and being admitted to the Bar, Fred came to Fayette County where he became associated with the firm of Love, Abbot and Hill, later to become Jesser and Harrington and eventually Jesser and Associates, where he remained throughout the balance of his successful professional life. Fred developed a thriving real estate and banking practice and became a fixture (with his faithful assistant Barbara Jennings) in the Fayette County record room where he established a personal desk. He was a former member of the Goochland, Virginia Junior Chamber of Commerce and the Fayetteville Rotary Club. He was an active member and former President of the Oak Hill Rotary club. During his professional career, he served as President of the Fayette County Bar Association and was a member of the Board of Governors of the West Virginia State Bar. He was a member of the Board of Directors of Fayette County National Bank, where he served as General Counsel and was Chairman of the Board of FCNB BANCORP, INC. He was a member of the White Oak Country Club in Oak Hill, West Virginia and Edgewood Country Club in Charleston.
Fred will be missed by our office, all the employees at the Fayette County Courthouse, the employees of Fayette County National Bank, his office staff Barbara Jennings and Lisa Mattox, and his host of friends. His passing is also grieved by his sister, Betsy White of Charleston, West Virginia; his sons, Frederick Alexander Jesser, IV and wife Angela, of Williamstown, West Virginia and Banks Sutherland Jesser, and wife Courtney, of Sinks Grove, West Virginia and his grandchildren, Gavin Dunbar McCraw, Lila Roxalana, Monroe Beatrice and Frederick Alexander Jesser, V (who Fred lovingly called Quincy).
Frederick Alexander Jesser, III February 20, 1945 - June 16, 2015
Nancy Fraley, Chief Public Defender
FY2015 Annual Report Page 112 of 212
Public Defender Corporation for the Thirteenth Judicial Circuit
The Public Defender Corporation for the Thirteenth Judicial Circuit (Kanawha County Public Defender Office) prides itself in providing client-centered representation to indigent individuals. Opened as a full-scale office in 1989 with the mission to provide legal services to individuals facing criminal charges in Kanawha County, the Office has thrived and affected positive change in our court system by employing a staff that vigorously represents our clients and strives to protect their rights.
The Office currently employs twenty-two full-time lawyers, one part-time senior counsel, and fifteen support staff to represent individuals in felony, misdemeanor, municipal court, juvenile, appellate, parole revocation, extradition, mental hygiene, and specialty court cases. Our lawyers appear before seven circuit court judges, ten magistrates, municipal court judges, mental hygiene commissioners, and the Justices of the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia. Our office also represents individuals in drug court (both adult and juvenile courts) and the Court’s domestic violence pilot program.
Our dedicated legal staff has had many victories over the years, successfully lodging
challenges to the court system, securing acquittals at trial and dismissals in a wide range of cases, helping clients overcome addiction problems and start on a productive path, and securing favorable sentences. Our support staff, comprised of equally dedicated individuals, helps provide effective representation to our clients. Together, we were able to close 7,238 cases this fiscal year.
A member of the office since 1996, Chief Defender Diana Panucci serves on the
Kanawha County Community Corrections Advisory Board, is a board member for the Mid-Atlantic Juvenile Defender Center, participates in Domestic Pilot Program stakeholder meetings, is a member of the West Virginia State Bar Criminal Law Committee, participated in several legislative task force meetings, and lectures on a variety of criminal law topics. Ms. Panucci has also volunteered for the the West Virginia State Bar’s Lawyer Referral Service, judged a WVU College of Law Lugar Mock Trial Association competition, participated in the Read Aloud Program and various local school-related activities, and served as a board member and secretary for the Friends of the Clay Center. Ms. Panucci graduated from WVU College of Law in 1996 as a Public Interest Fellow, member of the National Lugar Mock Trial Team, and an Order of Barristers graduate.
Several of our lawyers also enhance the practice of law with their legal and community
services. Their legal activities include serving on the West Virginia State Bar Criminal Law Committee, the Indigent Defense Commission, the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals Community Supervision Committee, the Justice Reinvestment in West Virginia Work Group, the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals Prison Overcrowding Compliance Commission, the Charleston Community Coalition, the planning and advisory committees of Kanawha County Drug Court, teaching at the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals new magistrate training, giving legal presentations on several law topics, publishing articles on a variety of legal topics, participating in legislative task forces, co-teaching organizational skills for public defenders at a Gideon’s Promise training, serving as a board member for West Virginia’s ACLU, and serving as
FY2015 Annual Report Page 113 of 212
a fellow board member for the Mid-Atlantic Juvenile Defender Center. Community activities include serving as a judge for We The People, serving as a board
member for the Charleston Ballet Company, serving as a board member and chorister with the West Virginia Symphony Orchestra, coaching little league baseball, serving as organist for the WVU College of Law Hooding Ceremony, spearheading a campaign for food donations for the local animal shelter, and volunteering at a soup kitchen.
The Office’s legal staff boasts impressive law school careers as well, with current lawyers
having graduated from law schools at West Virginia University, Georgetown, Northwestern, Tulane, University of Kentucky, Syracuse, Brooklyn School of Law, and Appalachian School of Law, with several lawyers having participated in moot court, law review, mock trial teams, clinic programs, and having been recipients of public interest fellowships and awards.
Diana Panucci, Chief Public Defender
FY2015 Annual Report Page 114 of 212
Public Defender Corporation for the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit
Our office opened in 1994 with the goal of providing indigent defendants with access to counsel specializing in criminal matters. In our first year of operation, three attorneys took on approximately 99 cases.
More than twenty years later, our office is recognized as the standard for criminal defense
in Harrison County. Defendants and respondents are protected by a corps of experienced, dedicated attorneys who handle approximately 1,500 cases a year, ranging from simple misdemeanor offenses to high profile felony cases. In addition to the misdemeanor and felony matters, our eight full-time attorneys handle Abuse and Neglect, Family Court Contempt, Mental Hygiene, Extradition, Probation and Parole Revocation, and Juvenile Status and Delinquency proceedings. Several attorneys are also certified to accept Guardian Ad Litem appointments to represent children in Abuse and Neglect cases.
A majority of the offenses committed within the county are substance abuse related. For
this reason, our office has forged relationships with area substance abuse professionals and facilities in an effort to reduce recidivism and secure better outcomes for clients. A number of these clients are also returning combat veterans. With that in mind, we partnered with the local VA Hospital in an effort to provide additional treatment and alternative sentencing options for those clients. In addition, we also work closely with Highland Hospital’s newly opened location, which provides much-needed substance abuse, psychiatric, and forensic services to our clients in a local setting.
In addition to our goal to provide expert legal representation, we also feel it is important
to provide to the community as well, whether it be by procuring needed services for clients or by participating in programs within the community. We participated in the development of both the Juvenile and Adult Drug Courts in our circuit. We now serve on the Board and Treatment Team of both Courts, and the majority of Adult Drug Court participants are referrals from our office.
Our Chief Defender, Perry Jones, is an active member of the Circuit’s Court Advisory
Board and the Community Corrections Board. Several staff members are also involved in various organizations and groups, including an Assistant Defender who served on the State’s Intergovernmental Task Force on Juvenile Justice, and another Assistant Defender who serves on the Indigent Defense Commission.
The Corporation’s size and proximity to the WVU College of Law allow us the unique
opportunity to partner with the Law School to host Summer Interns and Fall Externs. This opportunity provides valuable hands-on experience to those aspiring to become criminal defense attorneys. In fact, during the past year the Corporation has hired three former Summer Interns to fill vacant positions within the Corporation.
We hope that our office can make a positive impact in the lives of our clients, as well as
in the community it serves. Perry Jones, Chief Public Defender
FY2015 Annual Report Page 115 of 212
Public Defender Corporation for the Eighteenth Judicial Circuit
The Public Defender Corporation for the Eighteenth Judicial Circuit of Preston County opened in the year 2000, and is located at 202 Tunnelton Street, Suite 303 in Kingwood, West Virginia.
Our office consists of a Chief Public Defender, two associate staff attorneys, and two support personnel. We provide representation in felonies, misdemeanors, juvenile matters, abuse and neglect, and mental hygiene proceedings. All three attorneys share equally in every category of cases assigned to our office by our circuit judge, Judge Lawrance S. Miller, Jr. Our staff is our greatest asset in serving to meet the needs of our indigent population through our representation in their cases and consequently our brief involvement in their lives and that of their families.
Our office has had changes in personnel this year. Our Chief Defender Randy Goodrich, who established this office after having started the Public Defender Corporation in Harrison County, retired effective this January. Also, our Office Manager, Susan Bolyard, who was instrumental in setting up the original office, also retired at the end of this year. We will miss them, and we wish them well.
Our current office staff is:
Sally C. Collins, Chief Public Defender as of January 2015. She has served as a staff attorney in our office since 2005. Prior to this, she was an Assistant Prosecutor, operated a private law practice, and was a secondary school mathematics teacher.
Claire L. Niehaus, Assistant Public Defender since 2002. Her prior experience includes clerking for the Logan County Circuit Court and serving as a staff attorney for the Logan County Public Defender Office.
Lisa R. Hyre, Assistant Public Defender as of January 2015. She served as an attorney for Morgantown Legal Aide and operated a private legal practice here in Preston County. She is also a licensed social worker.
C. Russella Hare, Secretary since 2004. She has a wealth of experience working in the legal field. Her prior experience includes serving as a secretary in a private law practice and in the Prosecuting Attorney’s Office. She has worked as a Magistrate Court Assistant and Deputy Circuit Clerk.
Judy L. Starcher, Office Manager since June 2015. Judy has had previous experience in the County Clerk’s Office as well as several years as Office Manager for private industries. Judy is also an Honorably Discharged Veteran having served in the U.S.Navy.
Our attorneys and staff are members of various organizations and participate in
community events in Preston and Monongalia Counties. Our attorneys have served on the Board of Directors for the Community Corrections since its beginning. Lisa Hyre currently serves on its
FY2015 Annual Report Page 116 of 212
Board. Our attorneys are also active with our Adult Drug Court. Claire L. Niehaus participated in the establishment of the Drug Court and currently serves on its local Advisory Board. Sally Collins currently serves on the Drug Court Team.
Sally Collins, Chief Public Defender
FY2015 Annual Report Page 117 of 212
Public Defender Corporation for the Twenty-third Judicial Circuit
The Mission of the Eastern Panhandle Public Defender Office (EPPDO) is to provide competent, thoroughly professional legal representation to the indigent criminally accused in all Courts in the Twenty-third (23rd) Judicial Circuit of West Virginia in an efficient, cost-effective manner when appointed to do so by competent judicial authority.
Our clientele primarily consists of defendants in criminal matters at the felony and
misdemeanor levels in Circuit and Magistrate Court, but the obligation to provide professional, competent legal representation extends to and includes appointments to represent offending respondents in parental rights termination matters ("abuse and neglect" cases), Family Law Court contempt proceedings, juvenile offender matters and mental hygiene involuntary commitment proceedings, as well as appellate matters at various levels when assigned to do so by a Court, to include prosecuting appeals in the WV Supreme Court of Appeals.
The EPPDO office responsibilities include all the courts in all three county jurisdictions in
the Eastern Panhandle (Berkeley, Jefferson and Morgan), as well as seven individual municipal courts in various towns throughout the Panhandle, particularly Martinsburg's Municipal Court. Our two separate offices are located in Martinsburg, which covers all matters in Berkeley and Morgan counties, and a satellite office in Charles Town, which handles all matters in Jefferson County. In calendar year 2013, the office handled over 4330 individual, discrete cases and we are currently on pace to exceed that total by several hundred additional cases in 2014, due to a combination of population growth, as well as the easing of financial eligibility guidelines that dictate and control the availability of court-appointed counsel.
Established nearly thirty years ago and operating continuously since, we are the second
largest Public Defender Corporation in West Virginia, with a staff of 33 individuals: 20 licensed attorneys and 13 clerical support staff members and investigators. The team at the EPPDO is a committed, dedicated crew, truly devoted to ensuring that our clients of all types are treated justly: we fiercely protect the rights of poor, often powerless and uneducated people accused of being criminals, or are somehow enmeshed in other legal difficulties touching upon fundamental rights, thus ensuring that the criminal justice system is administered fairly, remains open, accessible and even-handed -- and is perceived as such by the general public and citizenry that we serve. We ensure that the everyday-person accused of wrongdoing by a powerful government and police apparatus is not overwhelmed and unduly intimidated and that his or her voice and "side of the story" is told by a tenacious, professional advocate committed to his or her cause. As Chief Public Defender, and a veteran of nearly twenty years in the trenches at the EPPDO, I am supremely confident that we are well-regarded and respected by all the judges and opposing counsel in our bailiwick. We are the proverbial "overworked and underpaid" public servants: despite staggering caseloads —well above and greatly surpassing ABA guideline levels - and extremely low compensation relative to our peers in the local prosecutors' offices, we enjoy very low turnover among the staff and have accrued a level of experience and expertise unrivaled in the State: a devoted team of career Public Defenders serving the State and her people and Courts. Tom Delaney, Chief Public Defender
FY2015 Annual Report Page 118 of 212
Public Defender Corporation for the Twenty-fifth Judicial Circuit
Our office opened in June 2000 to serve the needs of indigent defendants in Boone and Lincoln counties. Our six attorneys and four support staff operate out of two offices, one at 320 Main Street in Madison and the other at 406 Walnut Street in Hamlin.
Our Madison office is home to four attorneys and three support staff. Robert “Bob” White, our Chief Public Defender, has over thirty-three years of experience in the practice of criminal law, including over eight years as a prosecutor. He has jury acquittals in murder and sexual assault cases, and the only jury acquittal in a delivery of a controlled substance case in the history of Boone County. Our other three attorneys are Howard Nolen, who has been with our office over ten years, Dave Ford, who has been with the office over two years, and Tim Gibson, who has been with the office for over a year. Sonya Dolan, our firm administrator, has been with our office for over thirteen years. Our secretaries, Jeanna Baldwin and Katherine Lane, round out the rest of the Madison team. Jeanne joined our office in 2012, and Katherine has been with us since 2010.
The Hamlin office houses two attorneys, David Lockwood and H.C. Woods, and one support staff, Delena Toler. David has been with the office over thirteen years, and H. C. has been with the office over fifteen years. Delena joined our team in 2013.
Our office had successful jury trials during this past year. Bob White and Tim Gibson obtained an acquittal in a burglary trial, and David Ford successfully defended a grand larceny trial when the State dismissed a felony during jury selection. Bob also got an acquittal of a first-degree sexual assault case when the State agreed to dismiss with prejudice during jury selection.
Our service also includes activities outside the office. Bob serves as the Chairman of the Board of Directors of a 501(c)(3) Corporation that operates a community center in his neighborhood. David Lockwood serves alongside Bob on the Drug Court Treatment Teams in Boone and Lincoln Counties.
Bob White, Chief Public Defender
FY2015 Annual Report Page 119 of 212
Public Defender Corporation for the Twenty-eighth Judicial Circuit
The 28th Judicial Circuit Public Defender Corporation in Summersville was first established in 1983, making it the first public defender corporation in the state.
D. Mark Snyder was the sole practitioner and public defender until Cynthia Stanton was hired in October 1987. For the first seven years, Ms. Stanton was the sole public defender. In 1994, a decision was made to hire an assistant public defender and in the last twenty years, six attorneys have held the positions. Ms. Sarah Campbell was hired and began working in October 2013. Our office is home to two attorneys and two administrative assistants. Robin Wellman worked for the corporation for twenty-two years and retired in August 2015 to become a full time nanny to her grandson. Ms. Cattwright began working on August 3, 2015. Kathy O'Dell has worked for eighteen years. Ms. Stanton is the oldest serving public defender in the state.
The 28th Judicial Circuit Public Defender Corporation has maintained an annual caseload of approximately 500-600 cases per year since Ms. Stanton has taken over. This office has been responsible for indigent representation in all areas of criminal defense eligible proceedings. Our two attorneys handle 73% of all criminal applicants that are appointed in the county. We handle all Mental Hygiene hearings during work hours and at night unless we have a conflict. We handle all court appointments unless there is a codefendant or similar conflict. Ms. Stanton handles family court. Drug Court has not been established yet but is mandated to be set up.
We have always had each attorney prepared and ready to conduct any kind of criminal proceeding. Since there is still a satellite magistrate office in Richwood (26 miles away) we are also required to attend court there an average of one day a week or three times a month or more. Every attorney that has left the office is typically prepared to handle all types of criminal proceedings. The ability to accomplish this is based upon necessity as our one Judge Circuit expects our office to be available for all proceedings during the weekdays, weeknights, and weekends. In fact, several of our attorneys have served as assistant prosecutors, and of the five former assistant public defenders, two currently serve as the Chief Prosecuting Attorney in their circuit, ours included. We purchased our building in 1996 for $50,000 and paid it off in 2003.
Because we have not had to pay for rent, we have been able to use that money to better represent indigent clients.
At this point, we believe that we have a sound system in place to address indigent clients in our circuit. Ms. Stanton is also the President of the Community Corrections Board that oversees the Day Report Center. She traveled to Charleston in June to obtain grant monies for the continuance of the successful program, which established itself as a separate entity last year.
Cindy Stanton, Chief Public Defender
FY2015 Annual Report Page 120 of 212
Public Defender Corporation for the Thirtieth Judicial Circuit LEADERSHIP UNDER FIRE
The Public Defender Corporation for the 30th Judicial Circuit is the largest, busiest, and
most experienced law firm in Mingo County. We are proud to be leaders in our legal community. During the past two years, 2013-15, that leadership was put to the test. In an almost
unimaginable scandal, our former Circuit Judge, County Prosecutor, Chief Magistrate and Williamson’s mayor would all be convicted of federal crimes for abusing their offices. Months before the federal investigation was made public, our office stood alone, filing motion after motion challenging the officials’ corrupt practices. Challenging the only judge in a one-judge circuit was not popular, but it was right.
Following the officials’ convictions, others looked to our office to help stabilize and
rebuild. In fact, two of our attorneys were recommended by the Governor’s Judicial Vacancy Advisory Commission to replace the deposed Judge. Although these have been tough years, fraught with the difficulties inherent in practicing first in front of a rotating cast of retired judges and then a new judge two of us had run against, we are happy to see much improvement in Mingo County, and very proud of the role we played.
Our office opened for business on January 15, 1990. Since that time, we have grown from
a one attorney, one secretary office to a four-attorney office with a clerical staff of three. Our office handles approximately 500 cases a year, including felony, misdemeanor, juvenile and mental hygiene matters. Over the years, our attorney staff has supervised 30+ law student interns from 10 different law schools, many of whom have chosen to practice law in West Virginia.
Our chief defender, Teresa McCune, attended Marshall University and Antioch School of Law. She handles most of our juvenile matters and murder cases. Teresa is active in state and local bar and community service. She chairs the State Bar Commission on Children and the Law, serves on the WV Supreme Court of Appeals Region Three Fatality Review Task force and the MCLE Commission. Teresa is a member of the WV State Bar CLE and Criminal Law Committees. She has been named a WV Bar Foundation Fellow, and has received the Governor’s Service Award. Teresa founded and directs “On Track for College”, an award-winning college bound coaching program that helps students preparing for higher education. She is also a member of Williamson Woman’s Club and the Mingo/Pike branch of AAUW. Locally, Teresa is also the Chair of Christian Help of Mingo County, a charitable organization that provides direct aid to the needy. At the 2015 King Coal Festival Teresa was awarded the Humanitarian Award for her community service.
FY2015 Annual Report Page 121 of 212
Dave Foley, a former WV Public Defender of the Year, is a graduate of the WVU College of Law, and attended James Madison University where he was on the varsity debate team. Dave handles misdemeanors and felonies, and is our “go to guy” for extradition cases. Dave is an Executive Board Member for the Coalfield Association of Southern Baptists, sings in his church choir, teaches Sunday school and bowls competitively. He is happily married to Debbie. Paul Montgomery, a U.S. Navy veteran, attended the University of Oklahoma and Appalachian School of Law. He handles misdemeanor and felony cases, is our point man for mental hygiene cases, and also handles some delinquency matters. Paul is married to Megan, and is the father of two toddlers, Syrus Jonah and Royce Asher (aka Bobby Cars). Paul is a member of Delta Theta Phi Law fraternity. His hobby is stargazing. Will Duty, our law clerk, is a graduate of Williamson High School, the University of Kentucky, and Appalachian School of Law. Will is the oldest of five children and is actively involved in his siblings’ lives and the lives of their children. He is a licensed pilot and stays in shape by running. Tiera Asbury, our office manager, is a graduate of Mingo County Vocational School. Tiera volunteers at Beech Creek Park. She is married to Chad and is the mother of 8-year-old Callie. Jessica Randolph, secretary, is a graduate of Williamson High School and has an associate degree from Olympic College. She a member of Tug Valley Road Runners Club and is the mother of 5 year old Eli.
Briana Stokes, paralegal/secretary, is a graduate of St. Albans High School and University of Pikeville. She also has a Paralegal Certification from Eastern Kentucky University. Jane Moran, the Chair of our Board of Directors is an iconic figure amongst lawyers delivering services involving children’s rights and serving on committee positions and chairmanships. Jane has received numerous awards for her work and is often called upon as a trainer in juvenile and child abuse law.
FY2015 Annual Report Page 122 of 212
Former members of our staff can be found in various positions across our state, including Mark Snyder, Kanawha County Family Court Judge, Nancy Fraley, Chief Public Defender in Fayette County, Richard Holicker, Kanawha County Public Defender and former Kanawha County Magistrate, and Jonathan Friley, now at PDS as Public Defender Corporation Administrator.
Teresa McCune, Chief Public Defender
FY2015 Annual Report Page 123 of 212
[Page left blank intentionally.]
FY2015 Annual Report Page 124 of 212
Appendix C
Appointed Counsel/PDC Comparisons
FY2015 Annual Report Page 125 of 212
1ST CIRCUIT (BROOKE, HANCOCK & OHIO COUNTIES)
PDC CASES CLO
SED COMPARED
TO AC CLA
IMS PAID FY 2015
PDC
AC
PDC
AC
TOTA
L%PDC
%AC
DISBURSEMEN
TSDISBURSEMEN
TSTO
TAL
%PDC
%AC
CASE TYPES
FELO
NY
31
92
56
57
55
5.4
8%
44
.52
%$
1,1
10
,75
4.0
0$
1,5
07
,13
8.2
1$2,617,892.21
42
.43
%5
7.5
7%
MIS
D.
1,0
01
20
91
,21
08
2.7
3%
17
.27
%
MH
03
21
32
10
.00
%1
00
.00
%AVG PDC COST
AVG AC COST
JUV
ENIL
E8
04
91
29
62
.02
%3
7.9
8%
PER
CASE
PER
CASE
PA
R./
PR
OB
46
34
80
57
.50
%4
2.5
0%
TER
M/A
BU
SE9
40
54
14
2.1
7%
97
.83
%$728.84
$1,153.13
HA
BEA
S/SC
02
22
20
.00
%1
00
.00
%
Mu
ni.
Co
urt
04
40
.00
%1
00
.00
%
OTH
ER6
97
76
90
.79
%9
.21
%
TOTA
L1,524
1,307
2,831
53
.83
%4
6.1
7%
0%
20
%
40
%
60
%
80
%
10
0%
1ST CIRCUIT
CLO
SED CASES/CLA
IMS PA
ID
PD
C (
CA
SES)
AC (
CLA
IMS
PA
ID)
42
.43
%
57
.57
%
1st CIRCUIT
PDC/AC DISBURSEMEN
TS
PD
CA
C
FY2015 Annual Report Page 126 of 212
2ND CIRCUIT (MARSH
ALL, TYLER & W
ETZEL COUNTIES)
PDC CASES CLO
SED COMPARED
TO AC CLA
IMS PAID FY 2015
PDC
AC
PDC
AC
TOTA
L%PDC
%AC
DISBURSEMEN
TSDISBURSEMEN
TSTO
TAL
%PDC
%AC
CASE TYPES
FELO
NY
27
41
21
39
56
9.3
7%
30
.63
%$
49
9,6
19
.00
$4
11
,22
5.1
2$910,844.12
54
.85
%4
5.1
5%
MIS
D.
44
37
45
17
85
.69
%1
4.3
1%
MH
01
18
11
80
.00
%1
00
.00
%AVG PDC COST
AVG AC COST
JUV
ENIL
E5
52
98
46
5.4
8%
34
.52
%PER
CASE
PER
CASE
PA
R./
PR
OB
60
23
83
72
.29
%2
7.7
1%
TER
M/A
BU
SE3
01
50
18
01
6.6
7%
83
.33
%$566.46
$787.79
HA
BEA
S/SC
33
65
0.0
0%
50
.00
%
Mu
ni.
Co
urt
00
0#D
IV/0
!#D
IV/0
!
OTH
ER1
74
21
80
.95
%1
9.0
5%
TOTA
L882
522
1,404
62
.82
%3
7.1
8%
0%
20
%
40
%
60
%
80
%
10
0%
2ND CIRCUIT
CLO
SED CASES/CLA
IMS PA
ID
PD
C (
CA
SES)
AC (
CLA
IMS
PA
ID)
54
.85
%
45
.15
%
2ND CIRCUIT
PDC/AC DISBURSEMEN
TS
PD
CA
C
FY2015 Annual Report Page 127 of 212
5TH
CIRCUIT (CALH
OUN, JACKSO
N, M
ASO
N & ROANE COUNTIES) (W
ITHOUT MASO
N COUNTY
)
PDC CASES CLO
SED COMPARED
TO AC CLA
IMS PAID FY 2015
*A Circuit Court order prohibits PDC work in
Mason County. All indigent work is perform
ed by Appointed Counsel.
PDC
AC
PDC
AC
TOTA
L%PDC
%AC
DISBURSEMEN
TSDISBURSEMEN
TSTO
TAL
%PDC
%AC
CASE TYPES
FELO
NY
29
42
01
49
55
9.3
9%
40
.61
%$
84
6,1
30
.00
$9
21
,11
8.1
9$1,767,248.19
47
.88
%5
2.1
2%
MIS
D.
59
97
66
75
88
.74
%1
1.2
6%
MH
39
18
57
68
.42
%3
1.5
8%
AVG PDC COST
AVG AC COST
JUV
ENIL
E1
05
51
15
66
7.3
1%
32
.69
%PER
CASE
PER
CASE
PA
R./
PR
OB
18
39
57
31
.58
%6
8.4
2%
TER
M/A
BU
SE8
95
17
60
61
4.6
9%
85
.31
%$723.19
$953.54
HA
BEA
S/SC
02
82
80
.00
%1
00
.00
%
Mu
ni.
Co
urt
00
0#D
IV/0
!#D
IV/0
!
OTH
ER2
63
66
24
1.9
4%
58
.06
%
TOTA
L1,170
966
2,136
54
.78
%4
5.2
2%
0%
20
%
40
%
60
%
80
%
10
0%
5TH
CIRCUIT
CLO
SED CASES/CLA
IMS PA
ID
PD
C (
CA
SES)
AC (
CLA
IMS
PA
ID)
47
.88
%
52
.12
%
5TH
CIRCUIT
PDC/AC DISBURSEMEN
TS
PD
CA
C
FY2015 Annual Report Page 128 of 212
6TH
CIRCUIT and 24TH
CIRCUIT (CABELL & W
AYNE COUNTIES)
PDC CASES CLO
SED COMPARED
TO AC CLA
IMS PAID FY 2015
*The 6th/24th Circuits operate under one Public Defender Corporation.
AC figures include both Cab
ell an
d W
ayne Counties
PDC
AC
PDC
AC
TOTA
L%PDC
%AC
DISBURSEMEN
TSDISBURSEMEN
TSTO
TAL
%PDC
%AC
CASE TYPES
FELO
NY
1,7
40
49
02
,23
07
8.0
3%
21
.97
%$
1,8
15
,92
1.0
0$
1,3
05
,31
1.6
9$3,121,232.69
58
.18
%4
1.8
2%
MIS
D.
2,2
65
11
32
,37
89
5.2
5%
4.7
5%
MH
06
61
66
10
.00
%1
00
.00
%AVG PDC COST
AVG AC COST
JUV
ENIL
E3
36
14
24
78
70
.29
%2
9.7
1%
PER
CASE
PER
CASE
PA
R./
PR
OB
15
71
09
26
65
9.0
2%
40
.98
%
TER
M/A
BU
SE2
16
22
64
33
.27
%9
6.7
3%
$394.94
$593.86
HA
BEA
S/SC
22
22
48
.33
%9
1.6
7%
Mu
ni.
Co
urt
07
70
.00
%1
00
.00
%
OTH
ER7
73
21
09
70
.64
%2
9.3
6%
TOTA
L4,598
2,198
6,796
67
.66
%3
2.3
4%
0%
20
%
40
%
60
%
80
%
10
0%
6TH
/24TH
CIRCUIT
CLO
SED CASES/CLA
IMS PA
ID
PD
C (
CA
SES)
AC (
CLA
IMS
PA
ID)
58
.18
%
41
.82
%
6TH
/24TH
CIRCUITS
PDC/AC DISBURSEMEN
TS
PD
CA
C
FY2015 Annual Report Page 129 of 212
7TH
CIRCUIT (LO
GAN COUNTY
)
PDC CASES CLO
SED COMPARED
TO AC CLA
IMS PAID FY 2015
PDC
AC
PDC
AC
TOTA
L%PDC
%AC
DISBURSEMEN
TSDISBURSEMEN
TSTO
TAL
%PDC
%AC
CASE TYPES
FELO
NY
26
41
28
39
26
7.3
5%
32
.65
%$
66
4,1
18
.00
$5
99
,22
4.4
8$1,263,342.48
52
.57
%4
7.4
3%
MIS
D.
27
94
50
72
93
8.2
7%
61
.73
%
MH
11
11
29
1.6
7%
8.3
3%
AVG PDC COST
AVG AC COST
JUV
ENIL
E3
61
43
17
92
0.1
1%
79
.89
%PER
CASE
PER
CASE
PA
R./
PR
OB
42
16
58
72
.41
%2
7.5
9%
TER
M/A
BU
SE3
51
71
20
61
6.9
9%
83
.01
%$965.29
$651.33
HA
BEA
S/SC
06
60
.00
%1
00
.00
%
Mu
ni.
Co
urt
00
0#D
IV/0
!#D
IV/0
!
OTH
ER2
15
26
80
.77
%1
9.2
3%
TOTA
L688
920
1,608
42
.79
%5
7.2
1%
0%
20
%
40
%
60
%
80
%
10
0%
7TH
CIRCUIT
CLO
SED CASES/CLA
IMS PA
ID
PD
C (
CA
SES)
AC (
CLA
IMS
PA
ID)
52
.57
%4
7.4
3%
7TH
CIRCUIT
PDC/AC DISBURSEMEN
TS
PD
CA
C
FY2015 Annual Report Page 130 of 212
8TH
CIRCUIT (MCDOWELL COUNTY
)
PDC CASES CLO
SED COMPARED
TO AC CLA
IMS PAID FY 2015
PDC
AC
PDC
AC
TOTA
L%PDC
%AC
DISBURSEMEN
TSDISBURSEMEN
TSTO
TAL
%PDC
%AC
CASE TYPES
FELO
NY
23
51
44
37
96
2.0
1%
37
.99
%$
45
8,3
73
.00
$5
24
,25
4.6
1$982,627.61
46
.65
%5
3.3
5%
MIS
D.
75
21
48
90
08
3.5
6%
16
.44
%
MH
42
42
81
4.2
9%
85
.71
%AVG PDC COST
AVG AC COST
JUV
ENIL
E1
16
18
13
48
6.5
7%
13
.43
%PER
CASE
PER
CASE
PA
R./
PR
OB
03
30
.00
%1
00
.00
%
TER
M/A
BU
SE2
61
68
19
41
3.4
0%
86
.60
%$378.20
$1,016.00
HA
BEA
S/SC
05
50
.00
%1
00
.00
%
Mu
ni.
Co
urt
00
0#D
IV/0
!#D
IV/0
!
OTH
ER7
96
85
92
.94
%7
.06
%
TOTA
L1,212
516
1,728
70
.14
%2
9.8
6%
0%
20
%
40
%
60
%
80
%
10
0%
8TH
CIRCUIT
CLO
SED CASES/CLA
IMS PA
ID
PD
C (
CA
SES)
AC (
CLA
IMS
PA
ID)
46
.65
%
53
.35
%
8TH
CIRCUIT
PDC/AC DISBURSEMEN
TS
PD
CA
C
FY2015 Annual Report Page 131 of 212
9TH
CIRCUIT (MER
CER
COUNTY
)
PDC CASES CLO
SED COMPARED
TO AC CLA
IMS PAID FY 2015
PDC
AC
PDC
AC
TOTA
L%PDC
%AC
DISBURSEMEN
TSDISBURSEMEN
TSTO
TAL
%PDC
%AC
CASE TYPES
FELO
NY
32
14
43
76
44
2.0
2%
57
.98
%$
98
5,5
38
.00
$1
,68
4,8
08
.37
$2,670,346.37
36
.91
%6
3.0
9%
MIS
D.
1,4
01
38
31
,78
47
8.5
3%
21
.47
%
MH
81
67
17
54
.57
%9
5.4
3%
AVG PDC COST
AVG AC COST
JUV
ENIL
E2
76
40
36
79
40
.65
%5
9.3
5%
PER
CASE
PER
CASE
PA
R./
PR
OB
50
65
11
54
3.4
8%
56
.52
%
TER
M/A
BU
SE1
56
69
18
47
18
.42
%8
1.5
8%
$412.53
$756.54
HA
BEA
S/SC
29
11
18
.18
%8
1.8
2%
Mu
ni.
Co
urt
02
82
80
.00
%1
00
.00
%
OTH
ER1
75
38
21
38
2.1
6%
17
.84
%
TOTA
L2,389
2,227
4,616
51
.75
%4
8.2
5%
0%
20
%
40
%
60
%
80
%
10
0%
9TH
CIRCUIT
CLO
SED CASES/CLA
IMS PA
ID
PD
C (
CA
SES)
AC (
CLA
IMS
PA
ID)
36
.91
%
63
.09
%
9TH
CIRCUIT
PDC/AC DISBURSEMEN
TS
PD
CA
C
FY2015 Annual Report Page 132 of 212
10TH
CIRCUIT (RALEIGH COUNTY
)
PDC CASES CLO
SED COMPARED
TO AC CLA
IMS PAID FY 2015
PDC
AC
PDC
AC
TOTA
L%PDC
%AC
DISBURSEMEN
TSDISBURSEMEN
TSTO
TAL
%PDC
%AC
CASE TYPES
FELO
NY
58
82
33
82
17
1.6
2%
28
.38
%$
1,0
17
,83
9.0
0$
98
0,6
79
.51
$1,998,518.51
50
.93
%4
9.0
7%
MIS
D.
1,2
61
21
41
,47
58
5.4
9%
14
.51
%
MH
13
18
13
99
4.2
4%
5.7
6%
AVG PDC COST
AVG AC COST
JUV
ENIL
E2
01
33
23
48
5.9
0%
14
.10
%PER
CASE
PER
CASE
PA
R./
PR
OB
19
93
12
30
86
.52
%1
3.4
8%
TER
M/A
BU
SE1
37
94
80
71
.61
%9
8.3
9%
$408.77
$736.25
HA
BEA
S/SC
31
31
61
8.7
5%
81
.25
%
Mu
ni.
Co
urt
00
0#D
IV/0
!#D
IV/0
!
OTH
ER9
46
10
09
4.0
0%
6.0
0%
TOTA
L2,490
1,332
3,822
65
.15
%3
4.8
5%
0%
20
%
40
%
60
%
80
%
10
0%
10TH
CIRCUIT
CLO
SED CASES/CLA
IMS PA
ID
PD
C (
CA
SES)
AC (
CLA
IMS
PA
ID)
50
.93
%4
9.0
7%
10TH
CIRCUIT
PDC/AC DISBURSEMEN
TS
PD
CA
C
FY2015 Annual Report Page 133 of 212
11TH
CIRCUIT (GREENBRIER & POCAHONTA
S COUNTIES)
PDC CASES CLO
SED COMPARED
TO AC CLA
IMS PAID FY 2015
PDC
AC
PDC
AC
TOTA
L%PDC
%AC
DISBURSEMEN
TSDISBURSEMEN
TSTO
TAL
%PDC
%AC
CASE TYPES
FELO
NY
19
81
10
30
86
4.2
9%
35
.71
%$
61
7,3
09
.00
$5
08
,40
8.0
6$1,125,717.06
54
.84
%4
5.1
6%
MIS
D.
59
85
96
57
91
.02
%8
.98
%
MH
57
25
82
69
.51
%3
0.4
9%
AVG PDC COST
AVG AC COST
JUV
ENIL
E5
11
56
67
7.2
7%
22
.73
%PER
CASE
PER
CASE
PA
R./
PR
OB
11
01
19
.09
%9
0.9
1%
TER
M/A
BU
SE3
61
43
17
92
0.1
1%
79
.89
%$626.71
$1,352.15
HA
BEA
S/SC
15
61
6.6
7%
83
.33
%
Mu
ni.
Co
urt
03
30
.00
%1
00
.00
%
OTH
ER4
36
49
87
.76
%1
2.2
4%
TOTA
L985
376
1,361
72
.37
%2
7.6
3%
0%
20
%
40
%
60
%
80
%
10
0%
11TH
CIRCUIT
CLO
SED CASES/CLA
IMS PA
ID
PD
C (
CA
SES)
AC (
CLA
IMS
PA
ID)
54
.84
%
45
.16
%
11TH
CIRCUIT
PDC/AC DISBURSEMEN
TS
PD
CA
C
FY2015 Annual Report Page 134 of 212
12TH
CIRCUIT (FA
YETTE
COUNTY
)
PDC CASES CLO
SED COMPARED
TO AC CLA
IMS PAID FY 2015
PDC
AC
PDC
AC
TOTA
L%PDC
%AC
DISBURSEMEN
TSDISBURSEMEN
TSTO
TAL
%PDC
%AC
CASE TYPES
FELO
NY
27
11
56
42
76
3.4
7%
36
.53
%$
58
0,9
86
.00
$4
04
,38
1.4
9$985,367.49
58
.96
%4
1.0
4%
MIS
D.
42
71
48
57
57
4.2
6%
25
.74
%
MH
12
01
21
00
.00
%0
.00
%AVG PDC COST
AVG AC COST
JUV
ENIL
E3
21
54
76
8.0
9%
31
.91
%PER
CASE
PER
CASE
PA
R./
PR
OB
21
15
36
58
.33
%4
1.6
7%
TER
M/A
BU
SE2
71
96
22
31
2.1
1%
87
.89
%$721.72
$743.35
HA
BEA
S/SC
08
80
.00
%1
00
.00
%
Mu
ni.
Co
urt
05
50
.00
%1
00
.00
%
OTH
ER1
51
16
93
.75
%6
.25
%
TOTA
L805
544
1,349
59
.67
%4
0.3
3%
0%
20
%
40
%
60
%
80
%
10
0%
12TH
CIRCUIT
CLO
SED CASES/CLA
IMS PA
ID
PD
C (
CA
SES)
AC (
CLA
IMS
PA
ID)
58
.96
%
41
.04
%
12TH
CIRCUIT
PDC/AC DISBURSEMEN
TS
PD
CA
C
FY2015 Annual Report Page 135 of 212
13TH
CIRCUIT (KANAWHA COUNTY
)
PDC CASES CLO
SED COMPARED
TO AC CLA
IMS PAID FY 2015
PDC
AC
PDC
AC
TOTA
L%PDC
%AC
DISBURSEMEN
TSDISBURSEMEN
TSTO
TAL
%PDC
%AC
CASE TYPES
FELO
NY
1,1
81
72
01
,90
16
2.1
3%
37
.87
%$
3,2
78
,18
0.0
0$
1,8
38
,21
8.9
9$5,116,398.99
64
.07
%3
5.9
3%
MIS
D.
4,0
25
58
94
,61
48
7.2
3%
12
.77
%
MH
1,0
04
01
,00
41
00
.00
%0
.00
%AVG PDC COST
AVG AC COST
JUV
ENIL
E6
21
12
17
42
83
.69
%1
6.3
1%
PER
CASE
PER
CASE
PA
R./
PR
OB
25
77
13
28
78
.35
%2
1.6
5%
TER
M/A
BU
SE0
66
16
61
0.0
0%
10
0.0
0%
$452.91
$694.98
HA
BEA
S/SC
27
45
72
37
.50
%6
2.5
0%
Mu
ni.
Co
urt
04
01
40
10
.00
%1
00
.00
%
OTH
ER1
23
37
16
07
6.8
8%
23
.13
%
TOTA
L7,238
2,645
9,883
73
.24
%2
6.7
6%
0%
20
%
40
%
60
%
80
%
10
0%
13TH
CIRCUIT
CLO
SED CASES/CLA
IMS PA
ID
PD
C (
CA
SES)
AC (
CLA
IMS
PA
ID)
64
.07
%
35
.93
%
13TH
CIRCUIT
PDC/AC DISBURSEMEN
TS
PD
CA
C
FY2015 Annual Report Page 136 of 212
15TH
CIRCUIT (HARRISON COUNTY
)
PDC CASES CLO
SED COMPARED
TO AC CLA
IMS PAID FY 2015
PDC
AC
PDC
AC
TOTA
L%PDC
%AC
DISBURSEMEN
TSDISBURSEMEN
TSTO
TAL
%PDC
%AC
CASE TYPES
FELO
NY
30
61
11
41
77
3.3
8%
26
.62
%$
1,0
60
,34
2.0
0$
67
6,3
48
.36
$1,736,690.36
61
.06
%3
8.9
4%
MIS
D.
72
41
01
82
58
7.7
6%
12
.24
%
MH
10
43
53
18
.87
%8
1.1
3%
AVG PDC COST
AVG AC COST
JUV
ENIL
E2
27
37
26
48
5.9
8%
14
.02
%PER
CASE
PER
CASE
PA
R./
PR
OB
81
21
10
27
9.4
1%
20
.59
%
TER
M/A
BU
SE1
91
62
18
11
0.5
0%
89
.50
%$734.31
$1,336.66
HA
BEA
S/SC
41
72
11
9.0
5%
80
.95
%
Mu
ni.
Co
urt
00
0#D
IV/0
!#D
IV/0
!
OTH
ER7
31
48
78
3.9
1%
16
.09
%
TOTA
L1,444
506
1,950
74
.05
%2
5.9
5%
0%
20
%
40
%
60
%
80
%
10
0%
15TH
CIRCUIT
CLO
SED CASES/CLA
IMS PA
ID
PD
C (
CA
SES)
AC (
CLA
IMS
PA
ID)
61
.06
%
38
.94
%
15TH
CIRCUIT
PDC/AC DISBURSEMEN
TS
PD
CA
C
FY2015 Annual Report Page 137 of 212
18TH
CIRCUIT (PRESTO
N COUNTY
)
PDC CASES CLO
SED COMPARED
TO AC CLA
IMS PAID FY 2015
PDC
AC
PDC
AC
TOTA
L%PDC
%AC
DISBURSEMEN
TSDISBURSEMEN
TSTO
TAL
%PDC
%AC
CASE TYPES
FELO
NY
24
75
73
04
81
.25
%1
8.7
5%
$4
37
,01
4.0
0$
39
7,1
71
.35
$834,185.35
52
.39
%4
7.6
1%
MIS
D.
30
37
63
79
79
.95
%2
0.0
5%
MH
15
82
36
5.2
2%
34
.78
%AVG PDC COST
AVG AC COST
JUV
ENIL
E7
43
77
96
.10
%3
.90
%PER
CASE
PER
CASE
PA
R./
PR
OB
50
85
88
6.2
1%
13
.79
%
TER
M/A
BU
SE3
71
82
21
91
6.8
9%
83
.11
%$542.87
$1,125.13
HA
BEA
S/SC
44
85
0.0
0%
50
.00
%
Mu
ni.
Co
urt
00
0#D
IV/0
!#D
IV/0
!
OTH
ER7
51
59
08
3.3
3%
16
.67
%
TOTA
L805
353
1,158
69
.52
%3
0.4
8%
0%
20
%
40
%
60
%
80
%
10
0%
18TH
CIRCUIT
CLO
SED CASES/CLA
IMS PA
ID
PD
C (
CA
SES)
AC (
CLA
IMS
PA
ID)
52
.39
%4
7.6
1%
18TH
CIRCUIT
PDC/AC DISBURSEMEN
TS
PD
CA
C
FY2015 Annual Report Page 138 of 212
23RD CIRCUIT (BER
KELEY, JEFFERSO
N & M
ORGAN COUNTIES)
PDC CASES CLO
SED COMPARED
TO AC CLA
IMS PAID FY 2015
PDC
AC
PDC
AC
TOTA
L%PDC
%AC
DISBURSEMEN
TSDISBURSEMEN
TSTO
TAL
%PDC
%AC
CASE TYPES
FELO
NY
1,0
64
39
31
,45
77
3.0
3%
26
.97
%$
2,7
00
,30
7.0
0$
1,7
07
,30
8.0
6$4,407,615.06
61
.26
%3
8.7
4%
MIS
D.
2,1
25
26
02
,38
58
9.1
0%
10
.90
%
MH
13
40
13
41
00
.00
%0
.00
%AVG PDC COST
AVG AC COST
JUV
ENIL
E3
39
66
40
58
3.7
0%
16
.30
%PER
CASE
PER
CASE
PA
R./
PR
OB
53
77
13
04
0.7
7%
59
.23
%
TER
M/A
BU
SE1
40
45
75
97
23
.45
%7
6.5
5%
$660.22
$1,311.30
HA
BEA
S/SC
03
53
50
.00
%1
00
.00
%
Mu
ni.
Co
urt
05
50
.00
%1
00
.00
%
OTH
ER2
35
92
44
96
.31
%3
.69
%
TOTA
L4,090
1,302
5,392
75
.85
%2
4.1
5%
0%
20
%
40
%
60
%
80
%
10
0%
23RD CIRCUIT
CLO
SED CASES/CLA
IMS PA
ID
PD
C (
CA
SES)
AC (
CLA
IMS
PA
ID)
61
.26
%
38
.74
%
23RD CIRCUIT
PDC/AC DISBURSEMEN
TS
PD
CA
C
FY2015 Annual Report Page 139 of 212
25TH
CIRCUIT (BOONE & LINCOLN
COUNTIES)
PDC CASES CLO
SED COMPARED
TO AC CLA
IMS PAID FY 2015
PDC
AC
PDC
AC
TOTA
L%PDC
%AC
DISBURSEMEN
TSDISBURSEMEN
TSTO
TAL
%PDC
%AC
CASE TYPES
FELO
NY
40
11
79
58
06
9.1
4%
30
.86
%$
76
3,9
67
.00
$6
46
,73
7.2
4$1,410,704.24
54
.16
%4
5.8
4%
MIS
D.
59
19
86
89
85
.78
%1
4.2
2%
MH
18
31
49
36
.73
%6
3.2
7%
AVG PDC COST
AVG AC COST
JUV
ENIL
E8
91
88
27
73
2.1
3%
67
.87
%PER
CASE
PER
CASE
PA
R./
PR
OB
96
74
17
05
6.4
7%
43
.53
%
TER
M/A
BU
SE3
42
07
24
11
4.1
1%
85
.89
%$617.60
$744.23
HA
BEA
S/SC
04
40
.00
%1
00
.00
%
Mu
ni.
Co
urt
00
0#D
IV/0
!#D
IV/0
!
OTH
ER8
88
96
8.3
3%
91
.67
%
TOTA
L1,237
869
2,106
58
.74
%4
1.2
6%
0%
20
%
40
%
60
%
80
%
10
0%
25TH
CIRCUIT
CLO
SED CASES/CLA
IMS PA
ID
PD
C (
CA
SES)
AC (
CLA
IMS
PA
ID)
54
.16
%
45
.84
%
25TH
CIRCUIT
PDC/AC DISBURSEMEN
TS
PD
CA
C
FY2015 Annual Report Page 140 of 212
28TH
CIRCUIT (NICHOLA
S COUNTY
)
PDC CASES CLO
SED COMPARED
TO AC CLA
IMS PAID FY 2015
PDC
AC
PDC
AC
TOTA
L%PDC
%AC
DISBURSEMEN
TSDISBURSEMEN
TSTO
TAL
%PDC
%AC
CASE TYPES
FELO
NY
19
67
82
74
71
.53
%2
8.4
7%
$3
34
,24
5.0
0$
26
7,8
43
.52
$602,088.52
55
.51
%4
4.4
9%
MIS
D.
36
02
73
87
93
.02
%6
.98
%
MH
24
02
41
00
.00
%0
.00
%AVG PDC COST
AVG AC COST
JUV
ENIL
E6
31
27
58
4.0
0%
16
.00
%PER
CASE
PER
CASE
PA
R./
PR
OB
12
33
3.3
3%
66
.67
%
TER
M/A
BU
SE4
51
41
18
62
4.1
9%
75
.81
%$462.30
$1,003.16
HA
BEA
S/SC
17
81
2.5
0%
87
.50
%
Mu
ni.
Co
urt
00
0#D
IV/0
!#D
IV/0
!
OTH
ER3
30
33
10
0.0
0%
0.0
0%
TOTA
L723
267
990
73
.03
%2
6.9
7%
0%
20
%
40
%
60
%
80
%
10
0%
28TH
CIRCUIT
CLO
SED CASES/CLA
IMS PA
ID
PD
C (
CA
SES)
AC (
CLA
IMS
PA
ID)
55
.51
%
44
.49
%
28TH
CIRCUIT
PDC/AC DISBURSEMEN
TS
PD
CA
C
FY2015 Annual Report Page 141 of 212
30TH
CIRCUIT (MINGO COUNTY
)
PDC CASES CLO
SED COMPARED
TO AC CLA
IMS PAID FY 2015
PDC
AC
PDC
AC
TOTA
L%PDC
%AC
DISBURSEMEN
TSDISBURSEMEN
TSTO
TAL
%PDC
%AC
CASE TYPES
FELO
NY
31
01
39
44
96
9.0
4%
30
.96
%$
58
2,6
15
.00
$4
67
,03
5.1
7$1,049,650.17
55
.51
%4
4.4
9%
MIS
D.
40
61
65
57
17
1.1
0%
28
.90
%
MH
44
54
98
9.8
0%
10
.20
%AVG PDC COST
AVG AC COST
JUV
ENIL
E5
62
27
87
1.7
9%
28
.21
%PER
CASE
PER
CASE
PA
R./
PR
OB
77
14
50
.00
%5
0.0
0%
TER
M/A
BU
SE5
18
01
85
2.7
0%
97
.30
%$654.62
$869.71
HA
BEA
S/SC
01
01
00
.00
%1
00
.00
%
Mu
ni.
Co
urt
01
10
.00
%1
00
.00
%
OTH
ER6
28
70
88
.57
%1
1.4
3%
TOTA
L890
537
1,427
62
.37
%3
7.6
3%
0%
20
%
40
%
60
%
80
%
10
0%
30TH
CIRCUIT
CLO
SED CASES/CLA
IMS PA
ID
PD
C (
CA
SES)
AC (
CLA
IMS
PA
ID)
55
.51
%
44
.49
%
30TH
CIRCUIT
PDC/AC DISBURSEMEN
TS
PD
CA
C
FY2015 Annual Report Page 142 of 212
STATISTICS FO
R BOTH
PDC AND APPOINTED COUNSEL STATEWIDE
PDC CASES CLO
SED COMPARED
TO ALL AC CLA
IMS PAID FY 2015
(Excludes $400,000 Disbursement to 4th Circuit PDC)
PDC
AC
PDC
AC
TOTA
L%PDC
%AC
DISBURSEMEN
TSDISBURSEMEN
TSTO
TAL
%PDC
%AC
CASE TYPES
FELO
NY
8,2
09
7,6
57
15
,86
65
1.7
4%
48
.26
%$
17
,75
3,2
57
.00
$2
5,9
54
,89
7.2
4$43,708,154.24
40
.62
%5
9.3
8%
MIS
D.
17
,56
0
8,8
51
26
,41
16
6.4
9%
33
.51
%
MH
1,5
11
2,5
30
4,0
41
37
.39
%6
2.6
1%
AVG PDC COST
AVG AC COST
JUV
ENIL
E2
,75
7
2,9
26
5,6
83
48
.51
%5
1.4
9%
PER
CASE
PER
CASE
PA
R./
PR
OB
1,1
39
1,3
80
2,5
19
45
.22
%5
4.7
8%
TER
M/A
BU
SE7
22
8,7
18
9,4
40
7.6
5%
92
.35
%$535.22
$768.83
HA
BEA
S/SC
47
35
64
03
11
.66
%8
8.3
4%
Mu
ni.
Co
urt
‐
57
65
76
0.0
0%
10
0.0
0%
OTH
ER1
,22
5
76
51
,99
06
1.5
6%
38
.44
%
TOTA
L33,170
33,759
66,929
49
.56
%5
0.4
4%
0%
20
%
40
%
60
%
80
%
10
0%
STATEWIDE
CLO
SED CASES/CLA
IMS PA
ID
PD
C (
CA
SES)
AC (
CLA
IMS
PA
ID)
40
.62
%
59
.38
%
STATEWIDE
PDC/AC DISBURSEMEN
TS
PD
CA
C
FY2015 Annual Report Page 143 of 212
ALL PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
CORPORATION CIRCUITS (18 CIRCUITS 29 COUNTIES) (Excludes Mason County)
PDC CASES CLO
SED COMPARED
TO AC CLA
IMS (W
ITHIN PDC CIRCUITS) PAID FY 2015
(Excludes $400,000 Disbursement to 4th Circuit PDC)
PDC
AC
PDC
AC
TOTA
L%PDC
%AC
DISBURSEMEN
TSDISBURSEMEN
TSTO
TAL
%PDC
%AC
CASE TYPES
FELO
NY
8,2
09
3,9
59
12
,16
86
7.4
6%
32
.54
%$
17
,75
3,2
57
.00
$1
4,8
47
,21
2.4
2$32,600,469.42
54
.46
%4
5.5
4%
MIS
D.
17
,56
0
3,1
90
20
,75
08
4.6
3%
15
.37
%
MH
1,5
11
1,4
30
2,9
41
51
.38
%4
8.6
2%
AVG PDC COST
AVG AC COST
JUV
ENIL
E2
,75
7
1,3
47
4,1
04
67
.18
%3
2.8
2%
PER
CASE
PER
CASE
PA
R./
PR
OB
1,1
39
60
5
1,7
44
65
.31
%3
4.6
9%
TER
M/A
BU
SE7
22
5,8
47
6,5
69
10
.99
%8
9.0
1%
$535.22
$853.93
HA
BEA
S/SC
47
24
3
29
01
6.2
1%
83
.79
%
Mu
ni.
Co
urt
‐
45
4
45
40
.00
%1
00
.00
%
OTH
ER1
,22
5
31
2
1,5
37
79
.70
%2
0.3
0%
TOTA
L33,170
17,387
50,557
65
.61
%3
4.3
9%
0%
20
%
40
%
60
%
80
%
10
0%
CLO
SED CASES/CLA
IMS PA
ID
WITHIN PDC CIRCUITS
PD
C (
CA
SES)
AC (
CLA
IMS
PA
ID)
54
.46
%
45
.54
%
PDC/AC DISBURSEMEN
TS
WITHIN PDC CIRCUITS
PD
CA
C
FY2015 Annual Report Page 144 of 212
STATISTICS FO
R BOTH
PDC AND APPOINTED COUNSEL STATEWIDE (LESS AC CLA
IMS IN PDC CIRCUITS)
PDC CASES CLO
SED COMPARED
TO AC CLA
IMS PAID FY 2015
(Includes Mason County)
(Excludes $400,000 Disbursement to 4th Circuit PDC)
PDC
AC
PDC
AC
TOTA
L%PDC
%AC
DISBURSEMEN
TSDISBURSEMEN
TSTO
TAL
%PDC
%AC
CASE TYPES
FELO
NY
8,2
09
36
98
11
,90
76
8.9
4%
31
.06
%1
7,7
53
,25
7.0
0$
11
,10
7,6
84
.82
$
$11,107,684.82
15
9.8
3%
10
0.0
0%
MIS
D.
17
,56
0
56
61
23
,22
17
5.6
2%
24
.38
%
MH
1,5
11
11
00
2,6
11
57
.87
%4
2.1
3%
AVG PDC COST
AVG AC COST
JUV
ENIL
E2
,75
7
15
79
4,3
36
63
.58
%3
6.4
2%
PER
CASE
PER
CASE
PA
R./
PR
OB
1,1
39
77
51
,91
45
9.5
1%
40
.49
%
TER
M/A
BU
SE7
22
28
71
3,5
93
20
.09
%7
9.9
1%
$535.22
$678.46
HA
BEA
S/SC
47
11
31
60
29
.38
%7
0.6
3%
Mu
ni.
Co
urt
‐
12
21
22
0.0
0%
10
0.0
0%
OTH
ER1
,22
5
45
31
,67
87
3.0
0%
27
.00
%
TOTA
L33,170
16,372
49,542
66
.95
%3
3.0
5%
0%
20
%
40
%
60
%
80
%
10
0%
CLO
SED CASES/CLA
IMS PA
ID
STATEWIDE (LESS AC IN
PDC CIRCUITS)
PD
C (
CA
SES)
AC (
CLA
IMS
PA
ID)
61
.51
%
38
.49
%PDC/AC DISBURSEMEN
TS
STATEWIDE (LESS AC IN
PDC CIRCUITS)
PD
CA
C
FY2015 Annual Report Page 145 of 212
[Page left blank intentionally.]
FY2015 Annual Report Page 146 of 212
Appendix D
Appointed Counsel Payee Totals
• Fees & Expenses Paid by Payee Total Claims in Descending Order
o Attorney Fees o Direct Expenses o Rojas
• Fees & Expenses Paid by Payee Total Claims in Alphabetical Order
o Attorney Fees o Direct Expenses o Rojas
• Top 100 Highly Compensated Panel Attorneys • Travel Claims
FY2015 Annual Report Page 147 of 212
TypeAmount Paid
Percentage of
Total FundingAppointed Counsel Fees 24,879,198.76 96%Direct Expenses 973,741.03 4%Rojas 101,957.45 0%
Total 25,954,897.24
TypeClaims Paid
Percentage of
Total ClaimsAppointed Counsel Fees 35,428 98%Direct Expenses 747 2%
Rojas 30 0%
Total 36,205
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL FEES, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS TOTALS
Note: Rojas vouchers are claims submitted by retained counsel for reimbursement of, or
direct payment of, expenses incurred in the defense of an indigent client as set forth in
Rojas v. Wilkes, 455 S.E.2d 575 (W.Va. 2004)
FY2015 Annual Report Page 148 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
* NANNERS & WILLETT LAW OFFICES OF LC 299,998.62 422 BUCKHANNON, WV
* HARVEY & JANUTOLO 286,445.66 321 BLUEFIELD, WV
* GRINDO DANIEL R LAW OFFICE OF PLLC 273,850.83 189 GASSAWAY, WV
* SAL SELLARO THORN CULPEPPER LEGAL GROUP PLLC 232,167.81 457 MORGANTOWN, WV
* KELLEY DAVID B LAW OFFICE OF 211,240.64 269 BLUEFIELD, VA
RUTH LAW OFFICES PLLC 208,449.97 229 CHARLESTON, WV
* VICTOR VICTOR & HELGOE LLP 207,049.61 292 CHARLESTON, WV
* MOUNTAINEER LEGAL SERVICES PLLC 202,734.43 400 GRAFTON, WV
* JACOVETTY GERALD G JR LC 188,285.39 297 WHEELING, WV
* MOFFATT CHRISTOPHER G 181,474.95 139 CHARLESTON, WV
* CHILDLAW SERVICES INC 178,488.33 191 PRINCETON, WV
SHERMAN LAWRENCE E JR LC 167,169.74 248 ROMNEY, WV
* CASTEEL & ALLENDER PLLC 163,321.22 147 KINGWOOD, WV
* WIEDEL DIANA CARTER 155,320.34 132 WILLIAMSON, WV
* MAZZEI ROCCO E 154,206.24 100 CLARKSBURG, WV
POWELL ERIC K 153,273.98 236 PARKERSBURG, WV
* FLINCHUM R KEITH 153,205.90 330 PRINCETON, WV
WHITEMAN BURDETTE PLLC 149,461.00 326 FAIRMONT, WV
KURELAC LAW OFFICE PLLC 149,042.48 108 MOUNDSVILLE, WV
* EVANS THOMAS HANNA PLLC 148,571.62 125 OCEANA, WV
* RUMORA & RUMORA LC 147,575.81 200 WILLIAMSON, WV
COREY DANIEL S 146,540.92 121 POCA, WV
WINDOM LAW OFFICES PLLC 146,033.08 113 HARRISVILLE, WV
* SUMMERS WILLIAM B 144,895.98 566 PARKERSBURG, WV
BLACKWATER LAW PLLC 144,258.76 220 KINGWOOD, WV
* WHITT MICHAEL R 143,246.35 53 LEWISBURG, WV
ESCUE LAW OFFICE 142,784.28 231 HURRICANE, WV
CHILDERS SHARON K 142,056.51 126 CHARLESTON, WV
SCALES LAW OFFICE 139,346.42 58 MARTINSBURG, WV
RICE WILLIAM T 137,641.66 69 MARTINSBURG, WV
GARRETT & GARRETT 136,585.28 143 MOOREFIELD, WV
HUGHART KEVIN W 136,357.19 136 SISSONVILLE, WV
* HIVELY HERBERT L 134,938.02 245 CHARLESTON, WV
* COOKE MICHAEL P 134,661.09 404 BLUEFIELD, WV
SKAGGS G ERNEST 133,860.94 82 FAYETTEVILLE, WV
* CONLEY LAW OFFICE PLLC 133,175.53 240 PARKERSBURG, WV
LACARIA PHILIP A 129,548.17 109 WELCH, WV
HAMILTON CHARLES R 128,485.43 186 CHARLESTON, WV
* LOCKWOOD JAMELLA L 125,066.75 160 BUCKHANNON, WV
* REBROOK EDWARD III 123,100.05 149 CHARLESTON, WV
* JOHNSON REBECCA S LAW OFFICE OF 122,009.74 196 CHARLESTON, WV
COLLINS LAW FIRM 119,343.62 193 KEYSER, WV
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Appointed Counsel
FY2015 Annual Report Page 149 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Appointed Counsel
* BRISCOE L SCOTT 118,806.48 238 DANVILLE, WV
COURTRIGHT LAW OFFICES PLLC 117,067.64 194 HURRICANE, WV
* MORGAN E LAVOYD JR & ASSOCIATES LC 116,771.77 96 LEWISBURG, WV
* THOMPSON JOHN M 116,337.14 206 OAK HILL, WV
* REDDING R STEVEN ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 116,129.26 69 MARTINSBURG, WV
* WHITE KEITH 115,972.24 276 SAINT MARYS, WV
STARCHER & FRUM PLLC 115,163.70 223 PARKERSBURG, WV
WILLIAMS JOHN E JR 114,231.45 145 PRINCETON, WV
FOLICKMAN PAMELA R LAW OFFICE OF 113,024.60 131 FAIRMONT, WV
* HILL JOHNSON LAW PLLC 112,007.59 97 BELINGTON, WV
WHITEMAN FRANCES C 111,644.27 113 FAIRMONT, WV
* SAAD ABRAHAM J PLLC 111,329.11 237 HUNTINGTON, WV
MOSES JOSEPH J 110,989.14 53 WHEELING, WV
* GREENE TRACIE L 109,819.41 172 DALLAS, TX
HASSAN LAW OFFICE 109,243.20 89 WELCH, WV
* DILLON WELLS H 109,217.75 173 PARKERSBURG, WV
MAGANN LAW OFFICE PLLC 108,045.62 251 BLUEFIELD, WV
* NEISWONGER & WHITE 107,881.52 238 MOUNDSVILLE, WV
CHATTIN ANDREW B 106,315.48 95 CHARLESTON, WV
* LUPARDUS LAW OFFICE 106,102.35 207 PINEVILLE, WV
* CORNETTE LAW PLLC 105,096.36 184 WESTON, WV
* MONK TERESA C LAW FIRM OF 103,674.78 126 WALTON, WV
PANEPINTO MARK D 102,456.91 34 WHEELING, WV
BELLOMY & TURNER LC 100,491.97 263 HUNTINGTON, WV
* YOUNG WILLIAM PRENTICE 99,077.00 12 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WV
* SIMMONS HUNTER D 98,853.78 356 BUCKHANNON, WV
* ANDERSON JOHN CLARK 97,167.11 163 LEWISBURG, WV
* SOUTHERN WV LAW CLINIC 96,550.86 130 BECKLEY, WV
GUNN ERICA BRANNON ATT AT LAW PLLC 96,166.14 228 SPENCER, WV
HINKLE BRYAN S 95,682.44 156 BUCKHANNON, WV
* WEESE TRACY 94,414.75 24 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WV
ORNDORFF DAVID L 93,245.71 77 BUCKHANNON, WV
* NESSEL LAW FIRM 92,174.14 59 HUNTINGTON, WV
PULLIN FOWLER FLANAGAN BROWN & POE PLLC 91,990.02 305 CHARLESTON, WV
GUNNOE LAW OFFICE 91,604.91 170 HINTON, WV
COLVIN NICHOLAS FORREST LAW OFFICE OF ESQ PLLC 90,627.25 102 MARTINSBURG, WV
* NAVY L VICTOR 89,490.71 132 BARBOURSVILLE, WV
MCGRAW LAW OFFICES 89,341.91 98 PROSPERITY, WV
* MUNOZ A JOSEPH LAW FIRM OF 87,468.07 110 PARKERSBURG, WV
* RODGERS JEFFREY S 87,418.24 136 LEWISBURG, WV
SHAW & SHAW LC 87,071.59 177 POINT PLEASANT, WV
BULLMAN & BULLMAN 86,187.02 108 CHARLESTON, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 150 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Appointed Counsel
* PRITT & PRITT PLLC 85,816.92 128 CHARLESTON, WV
MORGAN WARD LAW OFFICE OF 85,310.40 82 BLUEFIELD, WV
PRENTICE TIMOTHY H 85,196.58 130 ELKINS, WV
MULLENS & MULLENS PLLC 85,078.14 205 PHILIPPI, WV
* LEFLER & BOGGS PLLC 85,019.46 72 BECKLEY, WV
CAREY JAMES T 83,745.20 118 WEIRTON, WV
* SPENIA LAW OFFICE PLLC 83,674.19 87 BARBOURSVILLE, WV
KETTERING DELLIGATTI LAW OFFICES PLLC 81,356.98 129 FAIRMONT, WV
LONG ROBBY N LAW OFFICE OF LC 81,212.95 116 HAMLIN, WV
* DUFFY KEVIN C 81,081.70 19 CLAY, WV
HOLDREN JASON D 80,919.09 94 GALLIPOLIS, OH
* NOLAN LAW FIRM 80,812.96 231 HUNTINGTON, WV
* KEESEE RYAN HAMILTON 80,742.31 114 SMOOT, WV
* OSHOWAY F JOHN 80,475.78 114 GRANTSVILLE, WV
* SHOUGH SCOTT A 80,292.65 133 FAIRMONT, WV
LORD JASON S 80,133.73 83 CHARLESTON, WV
* KIRKPATRICK LAW OFFICE PLLC 78,848.56 55 BECKLEY, WV
HAYDEN & HART PLLC 78,298.61 102 BECKLEY, WV
THOMPSON & PARDO PLLC 78,097.27 14 CHARLES TOWN, WV
CLYBURN BRENT A LAW OFFICE OF 77,360.93 81 WHEELING, WV
* STURM HEIDI M GEORGI 76,036.84 77 FAIRMONT, WV
* AHLBORN COURTNEY L LAW OFFICE OF PLLC 75,880.68 188 PARKERSBURG, WV
* ASBURY LAW OFFICE PLLC 75,841.86 40 CLAY, WV
DAVIS LAW FIRM 75,638.29 109 CLARKSBURG, WV
ASHTON & CRAWLEY WOODS PLLC 75,438.73 72 MARTINSBURG, WV
HOOSIER LAW FIRM PLLC 75,126.29 53 CHARLESTON, WV
* FAERBER KRISTOPHER 74,857.47 54 LEWISBURG, WV
MCNEER HIGHLAND MCMUNN & VARNER LC 74,802.62 20 CLARKSBURG, WV
WHEELER LAW FIRM 74,439.40 164 CHARLESTON, WV
MCQUADE RUTH A LAW OFFICE OF 73,745.84 101 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WV
* SIKORA SNEAD PLLC 70,902.06 87 MORGANTOWN, WV
HAWKINS JAMES E JR 70,488.80 144 BUCKHANNON, WV
* HOLROYD FRED F 70,386.11 99 CHARLESTON, WV
THORNE STEVEN M 69,618.85 133 LOGAN, WV
* BAILEY DENNIS R 67,124.55 109 CHARLESTON, WV
SAYRE TRAVIS LAW OFFICE OF 66,905.76 66 PARKERSBURG, WV
* FUDA THOMAS L PLLC 66,294.54 155 PRINCETON, WV
HUFFMAN WILLIAM O 64,985.83 71 PRINCETON, WV
* HALL DWIGHT R 64,700.21 97 ELKINS, WV
BAYLISS SHAWN D 63,994.07 61 HURRICANE, WV
ROSINSKY LAW OFFICE 63,701.43 31 HUNTINGTON, WV
JURCO JOHN M 63,291.43 35 ST CLAIRSVILLE, OH
FY2015 Annual Report Page 151 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Appointed Counsel
STEWART P ZACHARY LAW OFFICE OF 63,004.09 91 WEIRTON, WV
BIDDLE JACQUELYN STOUT 62,615.27 43 HUNTINGTON, WV
* FITTRO JONATHAN 61,361.70 60 CLARKSBURG, WV
TROISI JOSEPH G 61,330.49 94 SAINT MARYS, WV
* CRANE JENNIFER DAY 60,914.07 111 FAYETTEVILLE, WV
* TYSON DAVID R 60,911.94 130 HUNTINGTON, WV
HEDGES & LYONS PLLC 60,317.93 84 MORGANTOWN, WV
ANDERSON ERIC B PLLC 60,032.49 83 HUNTINGTON, WV
MCCOY JAMES A 59,656.48 59 HAMLIN, WV
COWDEN ALLISON ADYNIEC 59,567.41 16 WEIRTON, WV
* GRUNAU DAVID M 59,256.85 41 MORGANTOWN, WV
* DEMOSS DAVID B 58,754.17 90 FAIRMONT, WV
MICK REBECCA E 58,649.04 84 CHARLESTON, WV
MICHAEL NELSON M LC 58,171.14 135 KEYSER, WV
GENTILOZZI & ASSOCIATES 57,062.17 124 CLARKSBURG, WV
SNYDER & HASSIG 57,028.07 35 NEW MARTINSVILLE, WV
BAILEY & HOWARD PLLC 56,435.30 54 BARBOURSVILLE, WV
NESTOR WILLIAM T PLLC 56,237.77 89 ELKINS, WV
MANYPENNY RAINES LAW OFFICE PLLC 56,139.12 83 CHESTER, WV
* TAYLOR ADAM D LAW OFFICE OF INC 55,866.47 110 BECKLEY, WV
WOLFE LAW OFFICE PLLC 55,691.45 151 LOGAN, WV
ROLLO EDMUND J 55,599.00 66 MORGANTOWN, WV
* EVERETT MARK ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 55,006.03 107 MORGANTOWN, WV
LUTTRELL & PREZIOSO PLLC 54,773.77 26 MARTINSBURG, WV
HANDLEY & HUNT PLLC 54,763.40 97 POINT PLEASANT, WV
RIST LAW OFFICES LC 54,658.11 85 FAYETTEVILLE, WV
* HINERMAN HOLLY W 54,486.47 40 PENTRESS, WV
* DALBY NANCY A ATTY AT LAW PLLC 53,949.27 27 CHARLES TOWN, WV
* J A M LAW PLLC 53,361.80 72 HARRISVILLE, WV
* HOLLANDSWORTH RICHARD W 53,229.16 40 WHEELING, WV
WILLIAMS TRENA LAW OFFICE OF PLLC 53,070.50 71 WESTON, WV
* REES JAMES B 52,964.40 53 FAYETTEVILLE, WV
* ARBUCKLE DOUGLAS H 52,934.46 71 LEWISBURG, WV
MILLER CHRISTOPHER H 52,825.87 57 MORGANTOWN, WV
SANDERS AUSTIN FLANIGAN & FLANIGAN 52,669.24 60 PRINCETON, WV
MYERS JESSICA E 52,652.35 37 PARKERSBURG, WV
* COOK LAW OFFICES PLLC 52,590.83 79 BARBOURSVILLE, WV
* BELL SIDNEY H 52,559.47 50 WELCH, WV
TAYLOR PAUL G 52,248.55 79 MARTINSBURG, WV
CROMLEY BRYAN S 52,100.56 138 POINT PLEASANT, WV
WILSON CHRISTOPHER M LAW OFFICE OF PLLC 51,974.27 53 FAIRMONT, WV
FAIR MATTHEW H 51,412.13 64 ELKINS, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 152 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Appointed Counsel
HOUCK G TODD ATTORNEY AT LAW LC 51,389.60 71 MULLENS, WV
PRALL THOMAS J 51,340.68 116 WESTON, WV
* BLAIR JERRY 51,206.90 81 CLARKSBURG, WV
* BROOKS JOHN B 51,178.85 31 MORGANTOWN, WV
WESTON LAW A LEGAL CORP 51,012.88 41 HUNTINGTON, WV
KATZ KANTOR STONESTREET & BUCKNER PLLC 50,953.09 61 PRINCETON, WV
PHILLIPS P TODD 50,185.18 42 MORGANTOWN, WV
* KING WAYNE 50,107.85 29 CLAY, WV
RYAN KOURTNEY A & ASSOCIATES 50,080.30 28 BUCKHANNON, WV
CONAWAY & CONAWAY 49,126.04 91 MADISON, WV
NELSON LEGAL SERVICES LC 49,049.31 69 PETERSBURG, WV
COCHRAN ASHLEY N 48,287.18 44 LOGAN, WV
PENNINGTON WILLIAM 48,244.91 81 MORGANTOWN, WV
MOORE D. KYLE 47,880.28 68 RIPLEY, WV
* HARDY ROY T 47,708.86 88 KEYSER, WV
NOGAY CATHRYN A 47,484.15 18 WEIRTON, WV
* CASTEEL LAW FIRM PLLC 47,339.61 40 KINGWOOD, WV
KEPPLE LAW FIRM PA 47,273.15 41 OAKLAND, MD
* WEESE HEATHER M LAW OFFICE OF PLLC 47,262.61 50 ELKINS, WV
LONG LAW OFFICES PLLC 47,192.32 81 SCOTT DEPOT, WV
WOLFE B SCOTT LAW OFFICE OF PLLC 46,864.07 63 HARRISVILE, WV
* SCHEETZ CHRISTOPHER A 46,810.82 48 FOLLANSBEE, WV
CAMPBELL LAW OFFICES 46,810.12 100 CHARLESTON, WV
* BURTON LAW OFFICE 46,529.37 58 MORGANTOWN, WV
* WARMAN CHERYL L 46,418.90 74 MORGANTOWN, WV
ASHLEY ANITA HAROLD 46,392.65 107 SPENCER, WV
TATE REBECCA 46,103.46 71 FAIRMONT, WV
* GAIN LAW OFFICES 45,824.73 54 NUTTER FORT, WV
BOWERS & BOWERS PLLC 45,268.24 44 FRANKLIN, WV
STEPHENS RICHARD D 45,245.85 87 MARTINSBURG, WV
* SINKKANEN DREAMA D LAW OFFICES OF 45,017.19 55 CLARKSBURG, WV
ROOP & SMITH LAW OFFICE PLLC 44,778.80 21 BECKLEY, WV
MOORE DAVID K 44,549.75 35 RIPLEY, WV
* DEAN LAW OFFICES PLLC 44,506.86 63 SAINT MARYS, WV
KARICKHOFF DAVID 44,237.93 115 SUTTON, WV
* WALL RANDALL D 43,999.47 287 HUNTINGTON, WV
CURRY AMOS & ASSOCIATES LC 43,984.33 54 FAIRMONT, WV
FRANCIS ERIC M 43,479.75 29 LEWISBURG, WV
* ASH LAW OFFICE PLLC 43,301.92 96 MORGANTOWN, WV
SANTER & SANTER 43,118.27 96 PARKERSBURG, WV
KUENZEL & ASSOCIATES PLLC 43,073.82 53 CHAPMANVILLE, WV
TIPTON LAW OFFICES 42,866.00 48 FAIRMONT, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 153 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Appointed Counsel
* MORELLI LAW 42,767.86 35 WEIRTON, WV
HATFIELD KAREN S 42,693.59 106 GILBERT, WV
PRATT LENA D 42,666.81 41 LOGAN, WV
STEDMAN JASON M 42,660.39 70 MARTINSBURG, WV
* KELLEY LAW OFFICE 42,592.16 34 HUNTINGTON, WV
ARNOLD & BAILEY PLLC 42,472.50 75 CHARLES TOWN, WV
LYALL JERRY M 42,463.38 81 WILLIAMSON, WV
* GARLOW RICHELLE KEENER 42,155.56 67 SAINT ALBANS, WV
* WALKER LELA ATTY AT LAW PLLC 42,117.32 55 OCEANA, WV
FARNSWORTH LAW OFFICE 41,794.46 54 PARKERSBURG, WV
BAILEY REGGIE R 41,770.15 88 PARKERSBURG, WV
WHITE MAX H PLLC 41,520.62 125 KEYSER, WV
FORBES LAW OFFICES PLLC 41,470.94 31 CHARLESTON, WV
* EACHUS MICHAEL N 41,260.93 27 GALLIPOLIS, OH
* DINARDI PETER D 41,193.95 35 MORGANTOWN, WV
GOAD LAW FIRM 41,126.78 111 HUNTINGTON, WV
HARSH LAW LC 40,911.67 34 PARKERSBURG, WV
GEARY & GEARY LC 40,836.53 73 PETERSBURG, WV
* FRENCH ELIZABETH A 40,375.68 108 BLUEFIELD, WV
* APPALACHIAN LAW PLLC 40,108.42 38 MOUNDSVILLE, WV
LANTZ LAW OFFICE 39,994.36 26 MOUNDSVILLE, WV
WALLACE MICHAEL K 39,383.21 70 SOUTH CHARLESTON, WV
* PARKULO JOHN F 39,056.48 36 DANIELS, WV
* TREADWAY JOHN H JR 38,503.47 30 MOOREFIELD, WV
CZARNIK R THOMAS & ASSOCIATES 38,103.72 70 PRINCETON, WV
MORGAN DAMON B 37,948.51 112 POINT PLEASANT, WV
* PRITT ALAN L 37,833.00 47 CHARLESTON, WV
* WILSON LAW OFFICE 37,178.39 111 KEYSER, WV
NOONE ROBERT T 37,063.70 27 GADSDEN, AL
DAVIS & CHAPMAN PLLC 36,962.09 27 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
* LESTER WILLIAM M 36,918.15 23 BECKLEY, WV
SAVILLE ROYCE B PLLC 36,200.50 135 ROMNEY, WV
DOUGLASS ERNEST M 36,169.28 94 PARKERSBURG, WV
CALLAGHAN & CALLAGHAN PLLC 35,536.67 37 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
* COLLINS LAW OFFICE PLLC 35,506.31 76 CHARLESTON, WV
SAFFER MARTIN V 35,376.50 21 MARLINTON, WV
ROSE PADDEN PETTY TAYLOR & LILLY LC 35,267.47 47 FAIRMONT, WV
GREENBAUM STEVEN A ESQ ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 35,206.58 70 MARTINSBURG, WV
PARTAIN LAW OFFICE 35,171.92 30 LOGAN, WV
* JARRELL ROBERT STEPHEN 35,165.50 31 MILTON, WV
MORGAN TONY 35,108.60 55 GRANTSVILLE, WV
HOBBS MARK E 35,092.00 27 CHAPMANVILLE, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 154 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Appointed Counsel
GREINER & CYRUS LC 34,946.16 35 HUNTINGTON, WV
* CONRAD & CONRAD 34,888.90 37 FAYETTEVILLE, WV
HUSON ALLISON K 34,652.50 46 HUNTINGTON, WV
BALL GREGORY K 34,280.71 56 PRINCETON, WV
* KITTLE LAW OFFICE PLLC 34,147.45 59 FAIRMONT, WV
* RICHARDSON DAVID B LAW OFFICE 34,003.02 90 WINFIELD, WV
BAUMGARTEL ROLF E 33,986.83 90 MARIETTA, OH
BRILL JONATHAN G PLLC 33,689.00 46 ROMNEY, WV
* SHUMATE ANDREW R 33,464.36 71 CHARLESTON, WV
SELDEN LAW OFFICES LC 33,369.50 24 BECKLEY, WV
ROBINSON & MCELWEE 33,364.59 20 CHARLESTON, WV
DIXON SARAH E 32,859.06 42 HUNTINGTON, WV
* MORGAN DENNIE S 32,558.42 44 MOUNT HOPE, WV
MASCIO DAVID A LAW OFFICE OF 32,334.67 30 WEIRTON, WV
MARSH LAW OFFICE PLLC 32,101.71 32 CHARLESTON, WV
STEPTOE & JOHNSON 31,740.73 8 BRIDGEPORT, WV
* SALMONS RONALD G ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 31,616.39 55 WEST HAMLIN, WV
HARPER SETH LAW OFFICE OF PLLC 31,521.16 61 RIPLEY, WV
CARLTON ROBERT H LAW OFFICES 31,457.86 33 WILLIAMSON, WV
STEWART JOYCE E 31,218.80 29 MOOREFIELD, WV
* WILDMAN ERIC KEITH 30,897.34 62 FAIRMONT, WV
WALTERS & HEISHMAN PLLC 30,783.93 81 MOOREFIELD, WV
* BRANCAZIO HELEN M 30,711.91 41 WEIRTON, WV
KEATON FRAZER & MILLESON PLLC 30,409.88 85 ROMNEY, WV
* KOHOUT EDWARD R LAW OFFICES OF PLLC 30,373.69 110 MORGANTOWN, WV
STEPHENS GLORIA M 30,197.26 29 WELCH, WV
BUCK & PRENTICE PLLC 30,134.45 15 MARTINSBURG, WV
PAYNE WILBERT A 29,957.07 91 BECKLEY, WV
BOWEN LAW OFFICE PLLC 29,906.43 78 WEST HAMLIN, WV
CLEVENGER JAMES C LAW OFFICE OF 29,383.76 50 WESTON, WV
BECK GARTH W 29,261.96 46 CLARKSBURG, WV
MOOREHEAD CHRISTOPHER S 29,153.23 38 FAYETTEVILLE, WV
* RILEY JAMES P IV ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 29,150.97 14 MARTINSBURG, WV
* YANNI LAW FIRM 29,000.21 45 MARTINSBURG, WV
THARP LIOTTA & YOKUM LLP 28,802.38 36 FAIRMONT, WV
ROAHRIG RANDAL W 28,779.36 23 PRINCETON, WV
LAISHLEY JOHN 28,700.39 27 HUNTINGTON, WV
CRAFT LAW FIRM PLLC 28,568.45 57 NEW MARTINSVILLE, WV
* ALBERTY MICHAEL C 27,790.50 13 WHEELING, WV
JUBA‐PLUMLEY ROSALEE 27,459.50 28 ELEANOR, WV
WOODS JOHN 27,424.50 41 BELLEVILLE, WV
* HARMAN MARLA ZELENE 27,311.31 40 FRANKLIN, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 155 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Appointed Counsel
TORRES GEORGE M 26,810.00 31 PARKERSBURG, WV
HYER & LITTLEPAGE 26,779.49 25 POINT PLEASANT, WV
BOTTNER & SKILLMAN 26,622.63 51 CHARLES TOWN, WV
* BROCK MATTHEW C 26,548.54 38 WEIRTON, WV
WATSON LAW 26,543.67 38 MARTINSBURG, WV
BRAGG STEVEN M LAW OFFICE OF PLLC 26,304.42 66 BARBOURSVILLE, WV
GARVIN LAW PLLC 26,283.35 20 NUTTER FORT, WV
SAMMONS OLIVERO & PARASCHOS PLLC 26,123.05 8 HUNTINGTON, WV
HAYNIE BELINDA A 26,024.91 39 MORGANTOWN, WV
DUNLAP ROBERT ESQ PLLC 25,935.21 50 BECKLEY, WV
ROKISKY & ASSOCIATES 25,826.57 12 WEIRTON, WV
DAVIS R STEPHEN 25,591.51 11 BECKLEY, WV
* CARY LAW OFFICE PLLC 25,548.47 94 CHARLESTON, WV
SKLAVOUNAKIS LAW OFFICE 25,548.10 22 WHEELING, WV
JUDY & JUDY 25,480.82 51 MOOREFIELD, WV
* FORESTER WILLIAM T 25,460.07 55 LOGAN, WV
TYREE EMBREE & ASSOCIATES PLLC 25,386.42 66 HURRICANE, WV
RICHARDSON RICHARDSON & CAMPBELL 25,327.39 82 PARKERSBURG, WV
* SAFCSAK MICHAEL LAW OFFICE OF PLLC 25,305.20 33 FAIRMONT, WV
SHUMAKER J BRANDON 25,244.19 30 MORGANTOWN, WV
* THOMPSON LAW OFFICE PLLC 24,949.00 40 WILLIAMSON, WV
GUTMANN RICHARD M LC 24,552.94 27 MORGANTOWN, WV
MOORE LAW FIRM PLLC 24,261.82 27 FRANKLIN, WV
WILLIAMS PAUL ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 24,063.24 52 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
SMITH RICHARD D JR LAW OFFICES OF 23,976.88 92 PARKERSBURG, WV
DONADIEU MICHAEL R 23,545.27 23 HEDGESVILLE, WV
JOHNSTON HOLROYD & ASSOCIATES 23,276.61 50 PRINCETON, WV
HILL DAVID L 23,230.70 65 HURRICANE, WV
ERHARD CRAIG P LAW OFFICES OF PLLC 23,144.47 70 FAIRMONT, WV
BEAN & BEAN 23,139.38 38 MOOREFIELD, WV
CICCARELLO DEL GUIDICE & LAFON 22,985.17 32 CHARLESTON, WV
WINTERS J MINGO ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 22,737.48 57 BECKLEY, WV
CLAY PAUL O JR 22,591.59 27 FAYETTEVILLE, WV
ROLLO LANCE E 22,476.53 35 MORGANTOWN, WV
* KIRBY GILBERT & ASHLEY LC 22,222.68 46 BECKLEY, WV
SIMMERMAN LAW OFFICE PLLC 22,210.43 3 CLARKSBURG, WV
SHOCKLEY JAMES B 22,121.08 31 MORGANTOWN, WV
GORDON MARGARET A 22,103.81 14 BERKELEY SPRINGS, WV
JARRELL L CLIFTON 21,783.13 42 MARLINTON, WV
BURCHAM JEFFREY G 21,595.71 31 MARTINSBURG, WV
ANTOLINI KRISTEN D 21,527.70 33 MORGANTOWN, WV
* SCHAMBERGER LEGAL SERVICES 21,227.17 43 CLAY, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 156 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Appointed Counsel
HATFIELD & HATFIELD PLLC 20,979.96 39 MADISON, WV
BOUCHILLON CROSSAN & COLBURN LC 20,856.75 10 HUNTINGTON, WV
GRAVES MATTHEW F PLLC 20,822.54 23 ST MARYS, WV
SHAFER LAW OFFICES 20,400.07 22 WHEELING, WV
* SNODGRASS LORA LAW OFFICE OF 20,351.22 74 PARKERSBURG, WV
DITRAPANO BARRETT DIPIERO MCGINLEY & SIMMONS PLLC 20,325.33 2 CHARLESTON, WV
BREWER & GIGGENBACH PLLC 20,132.24 21 MORGANTOWN, WV
GALL D CONRAD 19,984.11 35 FAIRMONT, WV
BUCY WINIFRED 19,922.17 11 BECKLEY, WV
CLINE COLIN M ATTY AT LAW 19,891.36 18 PRINCETON, WV
* RIBEL KATICA 19,806.64 54 FAIRMONT, WV
SMITH CLINTON W 19,662.08 63 CHARLESTON, WV
WINTER KURT J 18,954.11 64 BURGETTSTOWN, PA
SMITH MCMUNN & GLOVER PLLC 18,761.64 20 CLARKSBURG, WV
* KLATT LAW OFFICES PLLC 18,605.03 14 WHEELING, WV
FORBES CHARLES CASEY 18,516.50 33 CHARLESTON, WV
LOUDERBACK ROBIN R 18,400.58 18 CHARLESTON, WV
VAN ZANT SUSAN J LC 18,204.09 46 WILLIAMSON, WV
HUNTER LAW OFFICE 18,076.87 32 SCOTT DEPOT, WV
* CHASE JOHN K IV 18,058.56 21 MOUNDSVILLE, WV
* KRATOVIL LAW OFFICES PLLC 18,026.92 38 CHARLES TOWN, WV
KAUFMAN & MCPHERSON PLLC 17,928.66 10 BRIDGEPORT, WV
BROWN SCOTT C LAW OFFICE 17,870.19 20 WHEELING, WV
OURS JOHN G 17,825.50 47 PETERSBURG, WV
HERNDON STEPHEN D 17,783.34 1 WHEELING, WV
LEGAL AID OF WEST VIRGINIA INC 17,694.62 8 CHARLESTON, WV
DOLANCE JACK C PLLC 17,156.65 17 WAYNE, WV
* MILLS KEVIN D & ASSOCIATES PLLC 17,144.14 8 MARTINSBURG, WV
VITAL RICHARD L 16,906.77 21 BARBOURSVILLE, WV
WRIGHT LACY W 16,684.67 37 WELCH, WV
HENDERSON HENDERSON & STAPLES LC 16,567.35 11 HUNTINGTON, WV
* MURPHY S SEAN PLLC 16,415.72 36 MORGANTOWN, WV
NEELY & CALLAGHAN 16,415.55 28 CHARLESTON, WV
ABRAHAM & ILDERTON PLLC 16,309.24 44 LOGAN, WV
BRADLEY JAMES M JR ESTATE OF 16,263.41 26 PARKERSBURG, WV
HARBOUR PAULA L PLLC 16,142.72 16 HUNTINGTON, WV
BARNETT KENNETH J LC 16,134.59 15 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
* HERSHBERGER LAW OFFICE 16,079.17 14 WHEELING, WV
* FUGATE LORA L 16,025.01 6 HARTS, WV
SIMMONS & SIMMONS LC 15,867.61 25 ELIZABETH, WV
GIBSON LEFLER & ASSOCIATES 15,831.74 41 PRINCETON, WV
LOVE JAY CARTER 15,748.74 137 HUNTINGTON, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 157 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Appointed Counsel
* MAIER LAW OFFICE LLC 15,729.75 18 HINTON, WV
BAZZLE J PARKER II LAW OFFICE OF 15,676.13 5 CHARLESTON, WV
YOST BRIAN D 15,429.85 17 HURRICANE, WV
WLO MANAGEMENT LLC 15,366.21 20 HUNTINGTON, WV
EVANS J M LAW LLC 15,352.50 28 GALLIPOLIS, OH
* NOEL WILLIAM C 15,221.83 10 MORGANTOWN, WV
MAUSER BERNARD R 15,118.23 44 SUTTON, WV
COOPER & PRESTON PLLC 15,064.63 1 PARSONS, WV
* NOVOBILSKI JEROME E 14,973.96 54 CLAY, WV
* RAY LAW PLLC 14,951.16 19 MORGANTOWN, WV
* DEVORE MATTHEW E LAW FIRM OF 14,722.34 40 PARKERSBURG, WV
* CONWAY LAW OFFICE 14,652.95 42 HUNTINGTON, WV
WHITE THOMAS E 14,412.54 18 MOUNDSVILLE, WV
* STALNAKER CHARLES E 14,396.18 57 PARKERSBURG, WV
BLYLER HOWARD J 14,353.55 45 COWEN, WV
MOYE LAW OFFICE 14,126.38 29 WINFIELD, WV
STOLLINGS HARLEY E 14,038.02 22 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
TISSUE PHILIP J 13,935.25 22 OAK HILL, WV
MALLETT SHANE M LAW OFFICES 13,889.66 17 WHEELING, WV
MARTINO GARY J 13,714.00 30 FAIRMONT, WV
CRAWLEY‐WOODS BEN JOSEPH 13,656.92 9 MARTINSBURG, WV
MOYE LISA M 13,654.66 15 WINFIELD, WV
TAYLOR JENNIFER N 13,571.86 55 CHARLESTON, WV
* PRICE LOUIE T 13,479.00 14 CHARLESTON, WV
* MCDONOUGH C EDWARD 13,465.00 19 PARKERSBURG, WV
DONEGHY BRENDAN 13,420.47 30 CHARLESTON, WV
* PANCAKE JANE ANN 13,399.53 11 BARBOURSVILLE, WV
PENNINGTON DEANNA L 13,341.50 20 MORGANTOWN, WV
OGLE CANDACE L 13,201.96 96 MORGANTOWN, WV
CILIBERTI LAW OFFICE PLLC 13,059.60 29 FAYETTEVILLE, WV
HYLTON LAW OFFICE PLLC 12,963.67 12 BEAVER, WV
GADD W ERIC LAW OFFICE OF 12,819.06 11 WHEELING, WV
LOCKWOOD & LOCKWOOD 12,754.30 16 HUNTINGTON, WV
NUTTALL LEGAL LLC 12,611.20 11 BUCKHANNON, WV
HARRIS WILSON TURNER & DAVISSON PLLC 12,371.41 12 CLARKSBURG, WV
* NEW STEPHEN P LC 12,289.68 15 BECKLEY, WV
* HYRE LAW OFFICE PLLC 12,184.95 17 KINGWOOD, WV
MORAN JANE LAW OFFICES 12,166.73 34 WILLIAMSON, WV
HALL KAREN L 12,044.49 3 MORGANTOWN, WV
MCINTYRE‐NICHOLSON RACHELLE D 11,993.74 9 CLARKSBURG, WV
SOUDERS MELISHA D 11,849.17 5 HANCOCK, MD
KUHL LAW OFFICES PLLC 11,679.81 30 SCOTT DEPOT, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 158 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Appointed Counsel
ROBB RICHARD A 11,637.22 1 SOUTH CHARLESTON, WV
SITES LAW FIRM 11,586.38 51 KEYSER, WV
WILMOTH DAVID H LC 11,507.38 18 ELKINS, WV
SCHARF WILLIAM H 11,465.54 8 CHARLESTON, WV
WOOTON WOOTON & DAVIS PLLC 11,441.39 27 BECKLEY, WV
MATHERLY JEFFREY K 11,427.44 11 MARTINSBURG, WV
STEED DEBRA L PLLC 11,218.87 13 PARKERSBURG, WV
LEWIS GLASSER CASEY & ROLLINS PLLC 11,198.08 1 CHARLESTON, WV
LOGUE SEAN PLLC 11,104.86 13 CARNEGIA, PA
GERLACH LAW 11,030.64 14 WAYNE, WV
TICHENOR LAW OFFICE 11,001.97 22 FAIRMONT, WV
ARONSON FINEMAN & DAVIS CO LPA 10,931.76 12 EAST LIVERPOOL, OH
LUSK KYLE G 10,482.00 19 BECKLEY, WV
* KARR THOMAS B 10,412.88 88 VIENNA, WV
* BAILEY BRIAN W 10,393.19 32 BUCKHANNON, WV
* BENFORD LEE F 10,313.18 2 RIPLEY, WV
CASSELL & CREWE PC 10,129.48 19 WYTHEVILLE, VA
* BALDWIN SHANNON L ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 9,862.99 21 BLUEFIELD, WV
HAMSTEAD & ASSOCIATES LC 9,609.90 10 CHARLES TOWN, WV
CLINE GENTILE DELLA 9,329.70 10 WILLIAMSON, WV
* REDMAN & PAYNE 9,276.83 3 CHARLESTON, WV
BUCCI BAILEY & JAVINS LC 9,182.92 13 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
* BLEVINS MICHAEL T 9,151.50 21 SAINT ALBANS, WV
COOPER LAW OFFICES PLLC 8,975.39 1 BRIDGEPORT, WV
BROWN‐BAILEY COLLEEN MICHELLE 8,749.17 13 BECKLEY, WV
GIGGENBACH MELISSA J 8,640.07 2 MORGANTOWN, WV
BOGGS APRYLL H LAW FIRM PLLC 8,600.51 22 HURRICANE, WV
* DASCOLI LAW OFFICE 8,554.00 9 CHARLESTON, WV
HART DAVID W 8,486.44 17 ELKINS, WV
MCFARLAND JOSEPH W 8,429.09 10 WELLINGTON, FL
ANGOTTI MARY BETH 8,412.25 10 GRANVILLE, WV
LASH FRANKLIN W 8,383.91 12 WHEELING, WV
BUTLER JOHN M 8,297.74 9 SAINT MARYS, WV
HUDNALL MARK D 8,295.03 16 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
FAST LAW OFFICE LC 8,243.09 10 FAYETTEVILLE, WV
SHAHEEN MICHAEL J 8,196.49 19 ST CLAIRSVILLE, OH
ROHRIG FREDERICK M DEAN 8,086.38 10 MIDDLEBOURNE, WV
* ERITANO REBECCA L 8,076.06 11 KINGWOOD, WV
LIVINGOOD LAW PLLC 7,937.03 8 DANVILLE, WV
POWELL & MAJESTRO PLLC 7,840.55 12 CHARLESTON, WV
HAUGHT IRA M 7,701.09 5 HARRISVILLE, WV
* SEAY ROBERT ROCKWELL 7,665.05 13 PRINCETON, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 159 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Appointed Counsel
BURTON KILGORE & BALDWIN PLLC 7,624.15 34 PRINCETON, WV
* FROBLE MICHAEL E 7,576.69 17 BECKLEY, WV
HAMILTON NEAL J 7,433.46 26 FAIRMONT, WV
AVIS WITTEN & WANDLING LC 7,408.47 1 LOGAN, WV
WEESE ROGER R 7,271.50 4 NEW MARTINSVILLE, WV
HOWLEY LOREN B 7,180.25 11 GRANTSVILLE, WV
BARRY CHAD D LC 7,085.72 43 HUNTINGTON, WV
BAILEY & WYANT PLLC 7,015.90 1 WHEELING, WV
YATES CHELSEA LEGAL LAW OFFICE OF CHELSEA E 6,909.77 10 CHARLESTON, WV
HOPKINS VIRGINIA JACKSON 6,904.42 3 KINGWOOD, WV
REGULA RAE LYNN 6,839.06 12 BROWNFIELD, PA
HODGES & RIFFLE PLLC 6,569.07 13 FAIRMONT, WV
DAVIS GREGG PHILLIP 6,562.86 16 ARTHURDALE, WV
SPADARO LAURA E 6,561.07 5 GLEN JEAN, WV
MCCAMIC SACCO & MCCOID PLLC 6,451.05 3 WHEELING, WV
PRIM LAW FIRM PLLC 6,309.05 18 HURRICANE, WV
RADMAN SCOTT S 6,188.50 21 MORGANTOWN, WV
BUCK DALE LAW OFFICE OF PLLC 6,152.74 4 MARTINSBURG, WV
SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE PLLC 6,149.24 12 CHARLESTON, WV
SHARLEY MICHAEL J 6,117.64 16 WESTOVER, WV
FRIEND & ROZAS LLC 6,093.70 8 CUMBERLAND, MD
DYER LAW OFFICES 6,084.80 13 CLARKSBURG, WV
RIFFE RICHARD M 6,048.49 3 ALUM CREEK, WV
* SIRK TIMOTHY M 6,034.06 12 KEYSER, WV
CASSELL & PRINZ PLLC 5,763.13 15 CHARLES TOWN, WV
BYRER F SAMUEL PLLC 5,691.03 2 CHARLES TOWN, WV
GLASS DEFENSE FIRM 5,663.93 6 CLARKSBURG, WV
MCGEELAW 5,627.38 10 CHARLESTON, WV
CAMILLETTI DAVID A ATTORNEY AT LAW LC 5,568.54 4 CHARLES TOWN, WV
STONE ROBERT C JR PLLC 5,549.40 5 MARTINSBURG, WV
DEMARINO SHELLY PLLC 5,386.50 7 GLENVILLE, WV
ALLEN KOPET & ASSOCIATES PLLC 5,304.71 1 HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SC
BLACKBURN & KOHARI PSC 5,233.50 18 SOUTH WILLIAMSON, KY
ELLEM LAW OFFICE 5,180.23 24 PARKERSBURG, WV
MCCLURE GOAD PLLC 5,118.44 26 HUNTINGTON, WV
STAPLETON LAW OFFICES LC 5,056.43 21 HUNTINGTON, WV
THOMPSON DAVID G 5,044.88 23 PINEVILLE, WV
MAZE LESLIE L 4,957.50 6 ELIZABETH, WV
HOLTZAPFEL LAW OFFICES PLLC 4,951.08 8 HURRICANE, WV
JAMES LAW FIRM 4,927.88 17 KEYSER, WV
FRENCH MICHAEL A 4,920.89 7 PRINCETON, WV
EAGLOSKI N EDWARD 4,834.47 20 HURRICANE, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 160 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Appointed Counsel
FLANIGAN LAW OFFICE 4,819.01 3 PRINCETON, WV
UTT BARBARA LYNN LAW OFFICES OF 4,699.32 1 CHARLESTON, WV
POMEROY LAW OFFICE PLLC 4,457.00 1 BRIDGEPORT, WV
BUSH FRANK P JR LAW OFFICE OF 4,426.53 19 ELKINS, WV
ZIMAROWSKI THOMAS 4,422.06 20 MORGANTOWN, WV
HENDRICKS PETER A 4,203.20 12 MADISON, WV
* MEADOWS TODD R 4,129.50 1 ONA, WV
WEST CHARLES STANFORD 3,818.50 6 WILLIAMSON, WV
STANTON SHIRLEY J 3,798.78 4 FAIRMONT, WV
GODDARD & WAGONER 3,773.19 1 CLARKSBURG, WV
FRAGILE PAT C 3,580.00 4 BECKLEY, WV
KAYSER LAYNE & CLARK PLLC 3,576.07 16 POINT PLEASANT, WV
* WEBB‐RUMORA MARSHA 3,569.11 10 WILLIAMSON, WV
HILL LAW FIRM PLLC 3,567.00 1 CHARLESTON, WV
TSORAS THEODORE L 3,408.28 4 POWHATON POINT, OH
* ESTEP LAW OFFICE PLLC 3,308.08 9 HUNTINGTON, WV
* MOORE HARRY W JR LAW OFFICES OF 3,283.50 3 MOUNDSVILLE, WV
GIATRAS LAW FIRM PLLC 3,197.84 3 CHARLESTON, WV
* PARROTT MATTHEW 3,181.80 5 PRINCETON, WV
KOONTZ MARK TIMOTHY 3,155.85 2 WILLIAMSON, WV
CASSIDY COGAN SHAPELL & VOEGELIN LC 3,151.58 2 WHEELING, WV
BARRAT ROBERT E 3,112.67 14 MARTINSBURG, WV
SCHILLACE LAW OFFICE 3,017.10 2 CLARKSBURG, WV
PEYTON LAW FIRM PLLC 3,012.69 2 NITRO, WV
BISCHOFF LAW FIRM PLLC 2,995.74 3 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
FORMAN ROGER D LAW OFFICE OF LC 2,899.76 5 BUCKEYE, WV
THOMPSON BARNEY 2,870.28 1 CHARLESTON, WV
TURNER & JOHNS PLLC 2,815.58 8 CHARLESTON, WV
* AUCREMANNE JOSEPH 2,815.27 4 HINTON, WV
PELLEGRIN MARK P 2,770.00 8 MORGANTOWN, WV
VAN DEYSEN LAW OFFICE PLLC 2,719.32 10 MORGANTOWN, WV
* CARR LAW OFFICES PLLC 2,703.00 1 SAINT MARYS, WV
PRICE JOSHUA D 2,623.50 9 JACKSON, OH
QUALLS ALVIE E 2,583.84 15 HUNTINGTON, WV
YOUNGER C CHRISTOPHER 2,580.50 8 WILLIAMSON, WV
KUHN & HAINES LC 2,569.52 12 KEYSER, WV
* PROCTOR LAW OFFICES PLLC 2,546.40 1 HUNTINGTON, WV
BOGARAD SHARON N 2,460.04 3 WEIRTON, WV
COOPER CHRISTOPHER W 2,449.12 3 DAVIS, WV
RILEY V ALAN ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 2,440.43 7 ROMNEY, WV
SMITH JAMES E II 2,433.40 1 KEYSER, WV
ADAMS LEGAL GROUP PLLC 2,419.83 5 DELLSLOW, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 161 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Appointed Counsel
ESTES LISA A 2,354.10 8 HURRICANE, WV
JACKSON KELLY PLLC 2,342.27 1 CHARLESTON, WV
BAILEY & GLASSER LLP 2,307.00 2 CHARLESTON, WV
SUPPLE LAW OFFICES PLLC 2,252.85 13 POINT PLEASANT, WV
BEAVERS LAW FIRM PLLC 2,226.05 2 BLUEFIELD, WV
MITCHELL JOHN R LC 2,156.31 3 CHARLESTON, WV
SPONAUGLE & SPONAUGLE 2,147.50 1 FRANKLIN, WV
* MULLIGAN CHRISTINA A LAW OFFICES OF 2,119.70 1 FAIRMONT, WV
SPROLES GREGORY W PLLC 2,104.22 1 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
PRICE DONNA M 2,103.00 5 MARLINTON, WV
WRIGHT STEVEN MCKAY 2,099.84 6 HUNTINGTON, WV
* BAILESS LAW PLLC 2,016.50 1 CHARLESTON, WV
BEVER DARLA A 1,908.50 3 VIENNA, WV
POWER BECK & MATZUREFF 1,881.87 2 MARTINSBURG, WV
WORKMAN ELLIOTT E PLLC 1,856.04 4 MADISON, WV
PRESTON & SALANGO PLLC 1,838.36 7 CHARLESTON, WV
ATKINSON & POLAK PLLC 1,823.54 6 CHARLESTON, WV
LOSCH & MCCOURT PLLC 1,820.99 3 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
MORTON JOYCE H 1,816.41 1 WEBSTER SPRINGS, WV
FRANKOVITCH ANETAKIS COLANTONIO & SIMON 1,781.40 3 WEIRTON, WV
HARVEY MATTHEW L 1,733.22 4 MARTINSBURG, WV
FUNKHOUSER JOHN RAY 1,686.20 1 FAIRMONT, WV
DIEHL LAW PLLC 1,629.11 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
FAIRCLOTH LAURA & ASSOCIATES LAW OFFICE OF 1,570.80 4 MARTINSBURG, WV
HUNTER STEVE ASSOCIATES LC 1,555.00 1 LEWISBURG, WV
BURDETTE KRISTINE ADELE 1,548.25 6 FAIRMONT, WV
* SPARACINO ANTHONY J JR 1,460.50 4 BECKLEY, WV
ATKINS JAMES B 1,457.14 1 SCOTT DEPOT, WV
BATTEN LAW FIRM 1,373.90 5 HEDGESVILLE, WV
ROSENLIEB DUANE C JR 1,368.67 4 SAINT ALBANS, WV
RUSEN & AUVIL PLLC 1,294.05 1 PARKERSBURG, WV
* KENTUCKY LAW OFFICE OF CECIL C VARNEY PSC 1,293.93 3 WILLIAMSON, WV
SPURLOCK JAMES E 1,276.50 1 HUNTINGTON, WV
* WITT RICHARD C 1,235.90 3 POCA, WV
RINGER DARRELL W 1,234.50 1 MORGANTOWN, WV
LOVE LAW FIRM PLLC 1,169.78 3 CHARLESTON, WV
CROCKETT LAW 1,124.40 4 FALLING WATERS, WV
CLARK BRAGG TRISTAN ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 1,075.68 1 SHADY SPRING, WV
SUTTON & JANELLE PLLC 1,064.50 2 MARTINSBURG, WV
* WEBB‐BARBER CELESTE E 1,006.60 7 CULLODEN, WV
ISLA MESLER LAW OFFICE PLLC 992.72 1 WEIRTON, WV
* FURNER DEAN A ATTY AT LAW PLLC 990.00 3 PARKERSBURG, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 162 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Appointed Counsel
COOK & COOK 858.50 1 MADISON, WV
ROSS KRISTEN E 666.50 1 HUNTINGTON, WV
CARRICO LAW OFFICES LC 641.10 1 CHARLESTON, WV
RODRIGUEZ VANESSA LYNN LAW OFFICES OF 638.93 3 FAIRMONT, WV
* CURNUTTE LAW OFFICE 635.51 4 ELKINS, WV
PATTERSON THOMAS K A LEGAL CORP 568.00 5 BECKLEY, WV
KUPEC & ASSOCIATES PLLC 551.50 1 CLARKSBURG, WV
KRESCH LAW FIRM 515.19 2 HUNTINGTON, WV
GIANOLA BARNUM BECHTEL & JECKLIN LC 503.84 3 MORGANTOWN, WV
WOLFE HAROLD B III 471.49 1 PRINCETON, WV
HEWITT & SALVATORE PLLC 457.00 2 FAYETTEVILLE, WV
* MULLINS‐TAYLOR MINDI M 435.50 6 PRINCETON, WV
* GERBER JAY W JR 355.00 1 PARKERSBURG, WV
ALBERT & SULLIVAN LLP 311.00 3 WHEELING, WV
FRALEY LEGAL SERVICES 310.56 2 REEDSVILLE, WV
TUCKER GREGORY A PLLC 302.00 1 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
ADAMS FISHER & CHAPPELL PLLC 278.00 1 RIPLEY, WV
* MAYO NICHOLAS 266.02 1 HUNTINGTON, WV
STEVENS C JOSEPH LAW FIRM OF PLLC 192.00 1 HAMLIN, WV
KLIE LAW OFFICES PLLC 175.00 1 BUCKHANNON, WV
CARR JOHN A ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 147.50 1 CHARLESTON, WV
WEBER & WEBER 52.00 1 WESTON, WV
FARMER CLINE & CAMPBELL PLLC 49.50 1 CHARLESTON, WV
APPOINTED COUNSEL TOTAL 24,879,198.76 35,428
* Using third party financing.
FY2015 Annual Report Page 163 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
TRI S INVESTIGATIONS INC 108,492.28 125 PARKERSBURG, WV
JONES DYKSTRA & ASSOCIATES INC 60,807.36 1 COLUMBIA, MD
FORENSIC PSYCHIATRY PLLC 49,100.00 28 HUNTINGTON, WV
KRADEL PAUL F 36,846.85 7 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WV
WOODS INVESTIGATIONS 35,925.75 30 BECKLEY, WV
INTL MEDICAL LEGAL FORENSIC EXPERTS LLC 26,246.98 2 HUNTSVILLE, AL
RINI GARY A 25,000.00 4 NORTH OLMSTED, OH
LANE INVESTIGATIONS LLC 24,202.58 13 GRAYSON, KY
PATE PHILIP E 24,143.91 18 WINCHESTER, VA
* CABELLS PRIVATE INVESTIGATION 23,371.43 45 CABIN CREEK, WV
GUARDIAN DIGITAL FORENSICS 22,733.19 6 RALEIGH, NC
FREMOUW SIGLEY PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSOC PLLC 22,125.00 12 MORGANTOWN, WV
JACKSON GROUP INC 21,835.10 4 HICKORY, NC
VAUGHAN INVESTIGATIONS 20,469.28 43 BRADLEY, WV
* JONES INVESTIGATIONS 20,376.00 10 BLUEFIELD, WV
COOPERS INVESTIGATIVE AGENCY 20,263.93 14 BRIDGEPORT, WV
BRAMBLE CHARLES E III & ASSOC 19,704.23 3 STONEWOOD, WV
SPECIAL SECURITY SERVICES LLC 16,751.38 4 BAKER, WV
CORNELL INVESTIGATIONS 15,979.31 35 HARRISVILLE, WV
CLAYMAN & ASSOCIATES PLLC 13,822.50 4 CHARLESTON, WV
PETERS LARRY A INC 13,371.42 12 WINCHESTER, VA
LEGAL SCIENCE 11,050.00 2 CHARLESTON, WV
FEINGOLD BARNET 10,753.28 1 WINCHESTER, VA
PSYCHOLOGICAL CONSULTING INC 10,725.00 9 MARTINSBURG, WV
HENDERSHOT PROCESS SERVING & INVESTIGATIONS 9,596.76 18 PARKERSBURG, WV
ASHBURN PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES LLC 9,550.00 2 ASHBURN, VA
BERNSTEIN LAWSON F MD PC 9,225.96 2 PITTSBURGH, PA
MOUNTAIN STATE PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES PLLC 8,950.39 7 KEYSER, WV
MARANATHA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES LLC 8,760.43 16 DANIELS, WV
WYATT WILLIAM J 8,450.00 2 HURRICANE, WV
STEALTH INVESTIGATIONS 7,771.34 16 GASSAWAY, WV
HART LESLIE W 7,576.51 5 ELKINS, WV
FORENSIC PRESS INC 7,560.00 1 WAKE FOREST, NC
MORGAN WARD LAW OFFICE OF 7,457.00 2 BLUEFIELD, WV
LAW‐SCIENCE TECHNOLOGIES INC 7,334.87 2 WEST MILTON, OH
TRAINOR GREGORY E MA & ASSOC 7,325.00 3 KEYSER, WV
SAVED BY GRACE MINISTRY INC 7,210.00 1 EAST AURORA, NY
* CAPITOL CITY INVESTIGATIONS LLC 7,170.24 7 CHARLESTON, WV
GREENBUSCH GROUP INC 6,610.00 2 SEATTLE, WA
* CONFIDENTIAL INVESTIGATIONS & SERVICES 6,316.99 13 CHARLESTON, WV
JFC CONSULTING LLC 6,200.00 2 ARMONK, NY
COOK INVESTIGATION SERVICE INC 6,176.64 1 HUNTINGTON, WV
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Direct Expenses
FY2015 Annual Report Page 164 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Direct Expenses
TORSNEY JACK R 6,000.00 2 MORGANTOWN, WV
* TURNING POINT INVESTIGATIVE SERVICES 5,934.67 9 TORNADO, WV
HARLOW STACY LLC 5,920.00 20 PARKERSBURG, WV
SAAR PSYCHOLOGICAL GROUP PLLC 5,578.86 5 SOUTH CHARLESTON, WV
KLM INVESTIGATIONS 5,342.65 8 WILLIAMSTOWN, WV
SHAW‐BLACK INDUSTRIES LLC 5,257.10 1 CINCINNATI, OH
KEYSTONE ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS INC 5,060.00 2 MCMURRAY, PA
CASTO INVESTIGATIONS INC 4,961.52 1 BANCROFT, WV
DANIEL JOHN S III 4,866.67 3 MIDLOTHIAN, VA
4DISCOVERY LLC 4,800.00 2 CHICAGO, IL
HEARTLAND FORENSIC PATHOLOGY LLC 4,780.00 2 KANSAS CITY, MO
NELSON ELJORN DON 4,400.00 1 CINCINNATI, OH
ADVANCED PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES 4,350.00 3 WHEELING, WV
WISE WOODRUFF INVESTIGATIVE SERVICES ETC INC 4,173.86 1 WALTERSBURG, PA
MCCLELLAND SERVICES 3,553.12 11 WHITEOAK, WV
G & G FIREARMS EXPERTS INC 3,504.55 1 MILFORD, NH
GOPHER LAND SERVICE INC 3,488.68 1 BEAVER, WV
FERDA BRIAN T INVESTIGATIVE CONSULTANT 3,487.50 1 WHEELING, WV
MOORE INVESTIGATION & SECURITY AGENCY LLC 3,169.07 1 PEYTONA, WV
EASTERN PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES INC 3,075.00 3 ROMNEY, WV
STEWART ROBERT D 3,049.28 6 PINEVILLE, WV
PEDIATRIC NEUROLOGY INC 3,000.00 1 ST LOUIS, MO
MOUNTS MICHAEL E 2,905.97 2 SAINT ALBANS, WV
BUZZO BILL J 2,845.68 4 BLUEFIELD, WV
STEVENS PRIVATE INVESTIGATIONS & SECURITY 2,731.50 6 LENORE, WV
STOUT NATASHA K 2,680.91 3 SAINT ALBANS, WV
WILSON JOSEPH BRYANT 2,604.55 6 VIENNA, WV
JURAND JOSEPH A 2,500.00 1 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WV
KISH PAUL ERWIN FORENSIC CONSULTANT 2,437.50 1 CORNING, NY
CRABTREE MICHAEL 2,340.00 1 WASHINGTON, PA
NATL MEDICAL SERVICES INC 2,296.00 1 PHILADELPHIA, PA
COMPLETE SURVEILLANCE & INVESTIGATIVE SVS INC 2,265.20 3 WYTHEVILLE, VA
FORENSIC PSYCHOLOGY CENTER INC 2,250.00 1 WINCHESTER, VA
BEHRMANN JAMES P 2,092.50 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
HALL JEANNE S 2,055.40 3 HUNTINGTON, WV
NATL LEGAL RESEARCH GROUP INC 1,955.70 1 CHARLOTTESVILLE, VA
BEHAVIORAL SCIENCE ASSOCIATES INC 1,735.00 1 WHEELING, WV
ALLDRIDGE REPORTING INC 1,731.67 2 MORGANTOWN, WV
HERRON‐RICE TRACY P 1,544.55 4 MARTINSBURG, WV
CELLMARK FORENSICS INC 1,500.00 1 BURLINGTON, NC
PEACE OF MIND PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES 1,500.00 1 PARKERSBURG, WV
HARTS REPORTING & VIDEOCONFERENCING LLC 1,486.00 1 HARRISONBURG, VA
FY2015 Annual Report Page 165 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Direct Expenses
PRUITT LESLIE M QUEEN 1,446.00 1 MT CLARE, WV
* INVESTIGATIVE ASSOCIATES INC 1,412.71 3 PARKERSBURG, WV
BETLERS REPORTING & LEGAL VIDEO SERVICES LLC 1,389.85 1 HUNTINGTON, WV
SOLID ROCK INVESTIGATIONS LLC 1,304.89 2 RED HOUSE, WV
TRI COUNTY PASTORAL COUNSELING SERVICES 1,275.00 3 MARTINSBURG, WV
CHRISTIAN PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES PLLC 1,200.00 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
DNA DIAGNOSTICS CENTER INC 1,180.00 1 FAIRFIELD, OH
MACKENZIE GROUP LLC 1,162.50 1 SEARCY, AR
SLAYDEN CATHERINE A 1,124.20 3 MARTINSBURG, WV
PANHANDLE ACCIDENT RECONSTRUCTION 1,085.74 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
KL REPORTING 1,069.55 7 HUNTINGTON, WV
SECOND CREEK TECHNOLOGIES LLC 1,000.00 1 BABOURSVILLE, WV
EADES EVONNE RENEE 986.00 1 BRIDGEPORT, WV
LUNSFORD WILLIAM G 984.24 1 MILTON, WV
HICKMAN SANDRA L 964.25 2 WAVERLY, WV
BLAKE KENNETH W 951.34 1 HURRICANE, WV
BLOSSER JULIE A 870.10 1 MORGANTOWN, WV
REUTZEL WAYNE B 825.50 1 AMBRIDGE, PA
ASSURED POLYGRAPH SERVICES INC 750.00 1 PITTSBURGH, PA
CALLAHAN PETER J PLLC 750.00 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
DRESBOLD MICHELLE 750.00 1 PITTSBURGH, PA
DEAK INVESTIGATIONS 685.95 1 ELLENBORO, WV
ALLEGHENY CONSULTANT SERVICES INC 645.67 2 ATHENS, WV
GAUJOT‐TURNER CLAUDETTE M 633.00 1 KEARNEYSVILLE, WV
REALTIME REPORTERS LLC 620.50 1 CHARLESTON, WV
SOVANI VINAYAK KRISHNA 600.00 1 WHEELING, WV
DILORENZO REPORTING SERVICE LLC 542.85 1 BECKLEY, WV
BECKETT HERMAN H 540.13 1 SALT ROCK, WV
LAWSON SHERRY M 504.35 2 CHARLESTON, WV
MORROW CHRISTINE E 501.60 1 MORGANTOWN, WV
FERRELL ROBERT L 501.00 1 BAKER, WV
KENTUCKY MEDICAL SERVICES FOUNDATION INC 500.00 1 LEXINGTON, KY
SCHEIDLER SAMUEL H 500.00 1 MILTON, WV
SPAULDING PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES PLLC 500.00 1 HARRISVILLE, WV
GREENE JUDITH A 477.40 1 WINFIELD, WV
CROWE MARY SUE 469.25 1 FROSTBURG, MD
KOENIG JOHN C 454.00 1 BAGDAD, KY
COMPUTER RESCUE REPAIR LLC 450.00 1 WEIRTON, WV
TOTAL FAMILY CARE PLLC 445.00 1 KINGWOOD, WV
CHACALOS CAROL L 435.75 1 WHEELING, WV
KELLEY SHAMELLE D 419.65 1 CHARLESTON, WV
VALLEY COMPREHENSIVE COMM MHC INC 408.00 2 MORGANTOWN, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 166 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Direct Expenses
WOLFE PARALEGAL SERVICES LLC 408.00 1 HUNTINGTON, WV
ASHBURN CAROL A 404.70 1 BRIDGEPORT, WV
CLAY BOB INVESTIGATIONS 400.00 1 REEDSVILLE, WV
POLYGRAPH STATION LLC 400.00 1 CHARLESTON, WV
BLUE RIDGE COUNSELING CENTER 375.00 1 WINCHESTER, VA
PATTERSON REPORTING 373.45 1 HARPERS FERRY, WV
CASTO THERESA LEE 360.00 1 CLINTONVILLE, WV
CHESLOCK TERRI R 358.05 1 FAIRMONT, WV
PRIMECARE MEDICAL INC 353.32 1 HARRISBURG, PA
CHANDLER MARCIA L 327.25 1 GREENCASTLE, PA
JARRELL NANCY S 284.90 1 PARKERSBURG, WV
PANHANDLE PSYCHOLOGICAL CENTER PLLC 272.54 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
CURRAN AUCTIONEERING & REAL ESTATE 250.00 1 BURLINGTON, WV
BAKER LYNDE G 219.45 1 VIENNA, WV
HEALTHPORT TECHNOLOGIES LLC 208.13 1 ATLANTA, GA
HAMRICK TERRY C 154.00 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
HUNTER AMANDA R 147.00 2 HUNTINGTON, WV
ARTHUR DEBRA R 140.00 1 COLLIERS, WV
ROGERSON INVESTIGATIONS LLC 139.02 1 POMPANO BEACH, FL
INVESTIGATIVE SPECIALTY SERVICES LLC 120.00 1 SHADY SPRINGS, WV
KREEFER JULIE L 63.00 1 EAST LIVERPOOL, OH
CROCK HAMRICK REPORTING SERVICES 60.05 1 INWOOD, WV
NELSON JUDY K 34.65 1 BEAVER, WV
HALL LAURA ANNE 23.00 1 HEDGESVILLE, WV
DIRECT EXPENSE VOUCHER TOTAL 973,741.03 747
* Using third party financing.
FY2015 Annual Report Page 167 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
MCCAMIC SACCO & MCCOID PLLC 13,573.42 2 WHEELING, WV
MAY KAREN L LLC 9,250.00 1 FREDERICK, MD
KRADEL PAUL F 9,012.50 2 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WV
BURKONS DAVID M MD INC 8,600.00 1 S EUCLID, OH
UNIVERSITY HEALTH ASSOCIATES 8,000.00 1 MORGANTOWN, WVLEGAL SCIENCE 7,400.00 2 CHARLESTON, WV
WECHT CYRIL H & PATHOLOGY ASSOCIATES INC 7,000.00 1 PITTSBURGH, PA
WHEELER ANDREW 7,000.00 1 BECKLEY, WV
KENTUCKY MEDICAL SERVICES FOUNDATION INC 4,900.00 1 LEXINGTON, KY
FORENSIC PSYCHIATRY PLLC 3,800.00 2 HUNTINGTON, WV
SAAR PSYCHOLOGICAL GROUP PLLC 3,600.00 1 SOUTH CHARLESTON, WV
LANE INVESTIGATIONS LLC 3,437.20 1 GRAYSON, KY
HINCHMAN HARRY DAVID 3,150.00 1 HUNTINGTON, WV
ROGERSON INVESTIGATIONS LLC 2,141.24 1 POMPANO BEACH, FL
HANNA DARREN J 1,942.80 1 WELLSBURG, WV
HENDRICKS PETER A 1,651.87 1 MADISON, WV
CAPITOL CITY INVESTIGATIONS LLC 1,500.00 1 HUNTINGTON, WV
LAW‐SCIENCE TECHNOLOGIES INC 1,500.00 1 WEST MILTON, OH
WARSHAW ENGINEERING 1,400.00 1 CATONSVILLE, MDGAUT WILLIAM T 875.00 1 NAPLES, FL
* MILLS KEVIN D & ASSOCIATES PLLC 700.35 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
WYATT WILLIAM J 600.00 1 HURRICANE, WVGREENBAUM STEVEN A ESQ ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 403.87 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
HERRON‐RICE TRACY P 192.50 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
EASTRIDGE HEALTH SYSTEMS 165.00 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
COFFINDAFFER LARRY K 161.70 1 LOGAN, WV
ROJAS VOUCHER TOTAL 101,957.45 30
* Using third party financing.
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Rojas Vouchers
FY2015 Annual Report Page 168 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
ABRAHAM & ILDERTON PLLC 16,309.24 44 LOGAN, WV
ADAMS FISHER & CHAPPELL PLLC 278.00 1 RIPLEY, WV
ADAMS LEGAL GROUP PLLC 2,419.83 5 DELLSLOW, WV
* AHLBORN COURTNEY L LAW OFFICE OF PLLC 75,880.68 188 PARKERSBURG, WV
ALBERT & SULLIVAN LLP 311.00 3 WHEELING, WV
* ALBERTY MICHAEL C 27,790.50 13 WHEELING, WV
ALLEN KOPET & ASSOCIATES PLLC 5,304.71 1 HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SC
ANDERSON ERIC B PLLC 60,032.49 83 HUNTINGTON, WV
* ANDERSON JOHN CLARK 97,167.11 163 LEWISBURG, WV
ANGOTTI MARY BETH 8,412.25 10 GRANVILLE, WV
ANTOLINI KRISTEN D 21,527.70 33 MORGANTOWN, WV
* APPALACHIAN LAW PLLC 40,108.42 38 MOUNDSVILLE, WV
* ARBUCKLE DOUGLAS H 52,934.46 71 LEWISBURG, WV
ARNOLD & BAILEY PLLC 42,472.50 75 CHARLES TOWN, WV
ARONSON FINEMAN & DAVIS CO LPA 10,931.76 12 EAST LIVERPOOL, OH
* ASBURY LAW OFFICE PLLC 75,841.86 40 CLAY, WV
* ASH LAW OFFICE PLLC 43,301.92 96 MORGANTOWN, WV
ASHLEY ANITA HAROLD 46,392.65 107 SPENCER, WV
ASHTON & CRAWLEY WOODS PLLC 75,438.73 72 MARTINSBURG, WV
ATKINS JAMES B 1,457.14 1 SCOTT DEPOT, WV
ATKINSON & POLAK PLLC 1,823.54 6 CHARLESTON, WV
* AUCREMANNE JOSEPH 2,815.27 4 HINTON, WV
AVIS WITTEN & WANDLING LC 7,408.47 1 LOGAN, WV
* BAILESS LAW PLLC 2,016.50 1 CHARLESTON, WV
BAILEY & GLASSER LLP 2,307.00 2 CHARLESTON, WV
BAILEY & HOWARD PLLC 56,435.30 54 BARBOURSVILLE, WV
BAILEY & WYANT PLLC 7,015.90 1 WHEELING, WV
* BAILEY BRIAN W 10,393.19 32 BUCKHANNON, WV
* BAILEY DENNIS R 67,124.55 109 CHARLESTON, WV
BAILEY REGGIE R 41,770.15 88 PARKERSBURG, WV
* BALDWIN SHANNON L ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 9,862.99 21 BLUEFIELD, WV
BALL GREGORY K 34,280.71 56 PRINCETON, WV
BARNETT KENNETH J LC 16,134.59 15 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
BARRAT ROBERT E 3,112.67 14 MARTINSBURG, WV
BARRY CHAD D LC 7,085.72 43 HUNTINGTON, WV
BATTEN LAW FIRM 1,373.90 5 HEDGESVILLE, WV
BAUMGARTEL ROLF E 33,986.83 90 MARIETTA, OH
BAYLISS SHAWN D 63,994.07 61 HURRICANE, WV
BAZZLE J PARKER II LAW OFFICE OF 15,676.13 5 CHARLESTON, WV
BEAN & BEAN 23,139.38 38 MOOREFIELD, WV
BEAVERS LAW FIRM PLLC 2,226.05 2 BLUEFIELD, WV
BECK GARTH W 29,261.96 46 CLARKSBURG, WV
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
ALPHABETICAL ORDERAppointed Counsel Payments
FY2015 Annual Report Page 169 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
ALPHABETICAL ORDERAppointed Counsel Payments
* BELL SIDNEY H 52,559.47 50 WELCH, WV
BELLOMY & TURNER LC 100,491.97 263 HUNTINGTON, WV
* BENFORD LEE F 10,313.18 2 RIPLEY, WV
BEVER DARLA A 1,908.50 3 VIENNA, WV
BIDDLE JACQUELYN STOUT 62,615.27 43 HUNTINGTON, WV
BISCHOFF LAW FIRM PLLC 2,995.74 3 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
BLACKBURN & KOHARI PSC 5,233.50 18 SOUTH WILLIAMSON, KY
BLACKWATER LAW PLLC 144,258.76 220 KINGWOOD, WV
* BLAIR JERRY 51,206.90 81 CLARKSBURG, WV
* BLEVINS MICHAEL T 9,151.50 21 SAINT ALBANS, WV
BLYLER HOWARD J 14,353.55 45 COWEN, WV
BOGARAD SHARON N 2,460.04 3 WEIRTON, WV
BOGGS APRYLL H LAW FIRM PLLC 8,600.51 22 HURRICANE, WV
BOTTNER & SKILLMAN 26,622.63 51 CHARLES TOWN, WV
BOUCHILLON CROSSAN & COLBURN LC 20,856.75 10 HUNTINGTON, WV
BOWEN LAW OFFICE PLLC 29,906.43 78 WEST HAMLIN, WV
BOWERS & BOWERS PLLC 45,268.24 44 FRANKLIN, WV
BRADLEY JAMES M JR ESTATE OF 16,263.41 26 PARKERSBURG, WV
BRAGG STEVEN M LAW OFFICE OF PLLC 26,304.42 66 BARBOURSVILLE, WV
* BRANCAZIO HELEN M 30,711.91 41 WEIRTON, WV
BREWER & GIGGENBACH PLLC 20,132.24 21 MORGANTOWN, WV
BRILL JONATHAN G PLLC 33,689.00 46 ROMNEY, WV
* BRISCOE L SCOTT 118,806.48 238 DANVILLE, WV
* BROCK MATTHEW C 26,548.54 38 WEIRTON, WV
* BROOKS JOHN B 51,178.85 31 MORGANTOWN, WV
BROWN SCOTT C LAW OFFICE 17,870.19 20 WHEELING, WV
BROWN‐BAILEY COLLEEN MICHELLE 8,749.17 13 BECKLEY, WV
BUCCI BAILEY & JAVINS LC 9,182.92 13 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
BUCK & PRENTICE PLLC 30,134.45 15 MARTINSBURG, WV
BUCK DALE LAW OFFICE OF PLLC 6,152.74 4 MARTINSBURG, WV
BUCY WINIFRED 19,922.17 11 BECKLEY, WV
BULLMAN & BULLMAN 86,187.02 108 CHARLESTON, WV
BURCHAM JEFFREY G 21,595.71 31 MARTINSBURG, WV
BURDETTE KRISTINE ADELE 1,548.25 6 FAIRMONT, WV
BURTON KILGORE & BALDWIN PLLC 7,624.15 34 PRINCETON, WV
* BURTON LAW OFFICE 46,529.37 58 MORGANTOWN, WV
BUSH FRANK P JR LAW OFFICE OF 4,426.53 19 ELKINS, WV
BUTLER JOHN M 8,297.74 9 SAINT MARYS, WV
BYRER F SAMUEL PLLC 5,691.03 2 CHARLES TOWN, WV
CALLAGHAN & CALLAGHAN PLLC 35,536.67 37 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
CAMILLETTI DAVID A ATTORNEY AT LAW LC 5,568.54 4 CHARLES TOWN, WV
CAMPBELL LAW OFFICES 46,810.12 100 CHARLESTON, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 170 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
ALPHABETICAL ORDERAppointed Counsel Payments
CAREY JAMES T 83,745.20 118 WEIRTON, WV
CARLTON ROBERT H LAW OFFICES 31,457.86 33 WILLIAMSON, WV
CARR JOHN A ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 147.50 1 CHARLESTON, WV
* CARR LAW OFFICES PLLC 2,703.00 1 SAINT MARYS, WV
CARRICO LAW OFFICES LC 641.10 1 CHARLESTON, WV
* CARY LAW OFFICE PLLC 25,548.47 94 CHARLESTON, WV
CASSELL & CREWE PC 10,129.48 19 WYTHEVILLE, VA
CASSELL & PRINZ PLLC 5,763.13 15 CHARLES TOWN, WV
CASSIDY COGAN SHAPELL & VOEGELIN LC 3,151.58 2 WHEELING, WV
* CASTEEL & ALLENDER PLLC 163,321.22 147 KINGWOOD, WV
* CASTEEL LAW FIRM PLLC 47,339.61 40 KINGWOOD, WV
* CHASE JOHN K IV 18,058.56 21 MOUNDSVILLE, WV
CHATTIN ANDREW B 106,315.48 95 CHARLESTON, WV
CHILDERS SHARON K 142,056.51 126 CHARLESTON, WV
* CHILDLAW SERVICES INC 178,488.33 191 PRINCETON, WV
CICCARELLO DEL GUIDICE & LAFON 22,985.17 32 CHARLESTON, WV
CILIBERTI LAW OFFICE PLLC 13,059.60 29 FAYETTEVILLE, WV
CLARK BRAGG TRISTAN ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 1,075.68 1 SHADY SPRING, WV
CLAY PAUL O JR 22,591.59 27 FAYETTEVILLE, WV
CLEVENGER JAMES C LAW OFFICE OF 29,383.76 50 WESTON, WV
CLINE COLIN M ATTY AT LAW 19,891.36 18 PRINCETON, WV
CLINE GENTILE DELLA 9,329.70 10 WILLIAMSON, WV
CLYBURN BRENT A LAW OFFICE OF 77,360.93 81 WHEELING, WV
COCHRAN ASHLEY N 48,287.18 44 LOGAN, WV
COLLINS LAW FIRM 119,343.62 193 KEYSER, WV
* COLLINS LAW OFFICE PLLC 35,506.31 76 CHARLESTON, WV
COLVIN NICHOLAS FORREST LAW OFFICE OF ESQ PLLC 90,627.25 102 MARTINSBURG, WV
CONAWAY & CONAWAY 49,126.04 91 MADISON, WV
* CONLEY LAW OFFICE PLLC 133,175.53 240 PARKERSBURG, WV
* CONRAD & CONRAD 34,888.90 37 FAYETTEVILLE, WV
* CONWAY LAW OFFICE 14,652.95 42 HUNTINGTON, WV
COOK & COOK 858.50 1 MADISON, WV
* COOK LAW OFFICES PLLC 52,590.83 79 BARBOURSVILLE, WV
* COOKE MICHAEL P 134,661.09 404 BLUEFIELD, WV
COOPER & PRESTON PLLC 15,064.63 1 PARSONS, WV
COOPER CHRISTOPHER W 2,449.12 3 DAVIS, WV
COOPER LAW OFFICES PLLC 8,975.39 1 BRIDGEPORT, WV
COREY DANIEL S 146,540.92 121 POCA, WV
* CORNETTE LAW PLLC 105,096.36 184 WESTON, WV
COURTRIGHT LAW OFFICES PLLC 117,067.64 194 HURRICANE, WV
COWDEN ALLISON ADYNIEC 59,567.41 16 WEIRTON, WV
CRAFT LAW FIRM PLLC 28,568.45 57 NEW MARTINSVILLE, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 171 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
ALPHABETICAL ORDERAppointed Counsel Payments
* CRANE JENNIFER DAY 60,914.07 111 FAYETTEVILLE, WV
CRAWLEY‐WOODS BEN JOSEPH 13,656.92 9 MARTINSBURG, WV
CROCKETT LAW 1,124.40 4 FALLING WATERS, WV
CROMLEY BRYAN S 52,100.56 138 POINT PLEASANT, WV
* CURNUTTE LAW OFFICE 635.51 4 ELKINS, WV
CURRY AMOS & ASSOCIATES LC 43,984.33 54 FAIRMONT, WV
CZARNIK R THOMAS & ASSOCIATES 38,103.72 70 PRINCETON, WV
* DALBY NANCY A ATTY AT LAW PLLC 53,949.27 27 CHARLES TOWN, WV
* DASCOLI LAW OFFICE 8,554.00 9 CHARLESTON, WV
DAVIS & CHAPMAN PLLC 36,962.09 27 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
DAVIS GREGG PHILLIP 6,562.86 16 ARTHURDALE, WV
DAVIS LAW FIRM 75,638.29 109 CLARKSBURG, WV
DAVIS R STEPHEN 25,591.51 11 BECKLEY, WV
* DEAN LAW OFFICES PLLC 44,506.86 63 SAINT MARYS, WV
DEMARINO SHELLY PLLC 5,386.50 7 GLENVILLE, WV
* DEMOSS DAVID B 58,754.17 90 FAIRMONT, WV
* DEVORE MATTHEW E LAW FIRM OF 14,722.34 40 PARKERSBURG, WV
DIEHL LAW PLLC 1,629.11 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
* DILLON WELLS H 109,217.75 173 PARKERSBURG, WV
* DINARDI PETER D 41,193.95 35 MORGANTOWN, WV
DITRAPANO BARRETT DIPIERO MCGINLEY & SIMMONS PLLC 20,325.33 2 CHARLESTON, WV
DIXON SARAH E 32,859.06 42 HUNTINGTON, WV
DOLANCE JACK C PLLC 17,156.65 17 WAYNE, WV
DONADIEU MICHAEL R 23,545.27 23 HEDGESVILLE, WV
DONEGHY BRENDAN 13,420.47 30 CHARLESTON, WV
DOUGLASS ERNEST M 36,169.28 94 PARKERSBURG, WV
* DUFFY KEVIN C 81,081.70 19 CLAY, WV
DUNLAP ROBERT ESQ PLLC 25,935.21 50 BECKLEY, WV
DYER LAW OFFICES 6,084.80 13 CLARKSBURG, WV
* EACHUS MICHAEL N 41,260.93 27 GALLIPOLIS, OH
EAGLOSKI N EDWARD 4,834.47 20 HURRICANE, WV
ELLEM LAW OFFICE 5,180.23 24 PARKERSBURG, WV
ERHARD CRAIG P LAW OFFICES OF PLLC 23,144.47 70 FAIRMONT, WV
* ERITANO REBECCA L 8,076.06 11 KINGWOOD, WV
ESCUE LAW OFFICE 142,784.28 231 HURRICANE, WV
* ESTEP LAW OFFICE PLLC 3,308.08 9 HUNTINGTON, WV
ESTES LISA A 2,354.10 8 HURRICANE, WV
EVANS J M LAW LLC 15,352.50 28 GALLIPOLIS, OH
* EVANS THOMAS HANNA PLLC 148,571.62 125 OCEANA, WV
* EVERETT MARK ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 55,006.03 107 MORGANTOWN, WV
* FAERBER KRISTOPHER 74,857.47 54 LEWISBURG, WV
FAIR MATTHEW H 51,412.13 64 ELKINS, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 172 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
ALPHABETICAL ORDERAppointed Counsel Payments
FAIRCLOTH LAURA & ASSOCIATES LAW OFFICE OF 1,570.80 4 MARTINSBURG, WV
FARMER CLINE & CAMPBELL PLLC 49.50 1 CHARLESTON, WV
FARNSWORTH LAW OFFICE 41,794.46 54 PARKERSBURG, WV
FAST LAW OFFICE LC 8,243.09 10 FAYETTEVILLE, WV
* FITTRO JONATHAN 61,361.70 60 CLARKSBURG, WV
FLANIGAN LAW OFFICE 4,819.01 3 PRINCETON, WV
* FLINCHUM R KEITH 153,205.90 330 PRINCETON, WV
FOLICKMAN PAMELA R LAW OFFICE OF 113,024.60 131 FAIRMONT, WV
FORBES CHARLES CASEY 18,516.50 33 CHARLESTON, WV
FORBES LAW OFFICES PLLC 41,470.94 31 CHARLESTON, WV
* FORESTER WILLIAM T 25,460.07 55 LOGAN, WV
FORMAN ROGER D LAW OFFICE OF LC 2,899.76 5 BUCKEYE, WV
FRAGILE PAT C 3,580.00 4 BECKLEY, WV
FRALEY LEGAL SERVICES 310.56 2 REEDSVILLE, WV
FRANCIS ERIC M 43,479.75 29 LEWISBURG, WV
FRANKOVITCH ANETAKIS COLANTONIO & SIMON 1,781.40 3 WEIRTON, WV
* FRENCH ELIZABETH A 40,375.68 108 BLUEFIELD, WV
FRENCH MICHAEL A 4,920.89 7 PRINCETON, WV
FRIEND & ROZAS LLC 6,093.70 8 CUMBERLAND, MD
* FROBLE MICHAEL E 7,576.69 17 BECKLEY, WV
* FUDA THOMAS L PLLC 66,294.54 155 PRINCETON, WV
* FUGATE LORA L 16,025.01 6 HARTS, WV
FUNKHOUSER JOHN RAY 1,686.20 1 FAIRMONT, WV
* FURNER DEAN A ATTY AT LAW PLLC 990.00 3 PARKERSBURG, WV
GADD W ERIC LAW OFFICE OF 12,819.06 11 WHEELING, WV
* GAIN LAW OFFICES 45,824.73 54 NUTTER FORT, WV
GALL D CONRAD 19,984.11 35 FAIRMONT, WV
* GARLOW RICHELLE KEENER 42,155.56 67 SAINT ALBANS, WV
GARRETT & GARRETT 136,585.28 143 MOOREFIELD, WV
GARVIN LAW PLLC 26,283.35 20 NUTTER FORT, WV
GEARY & GEARY LC 40,836.53 73 PETERSBURG, WV
GENTILOZZI & ASSOCIATES 57,062.17 124 CLARKSBURG, WV
* GERBER JAY W JR 355.00 1 PARKERSBURG, WV
GERLACH LAW 11,030.64 14 WAYNE, WV
GIANOLA BARNUM BECHTEL & JECKLIN LC 503.84 3 MORGANTOWN, WV
GIATRAS LAW FIRM PLLC 3,197.84 3 CHARLESTON, WV
GIBSON LEFLER & ASSOCIATES 15,831.74 41 PRINCETON, WV
GIGGENBACH MELISSA J 8,640.07 2 MORGANTOWN, WV
GLASS DEFENSE FIRM 5,663.93 6 CLARKSBURG, WV
GOAD LAW FIRM 41,126.78 111 HUNTINGTON, WV
GODDARD & WAGONER 3,773.19 1 CLARKSBURG, WV
GORDON MARGARET A 22,103.81 14 BERKELEY SPRINGS, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 173 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
ALPHABETICAL ORDERAppointed Counsel Payments
GRAVES MATTHEW F PLLC 20,822.54 23 ST MARYS, WV
GREENBAUM STEVEN A ESQ ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 35,206.58 70 MARTINSBURG, WV
* GREENE TRACIE L 109,819.41 172 DALLAS, TX
GREINER & CYRUS LC 34,946.16 35 HUNTINGTON, WV
* GRINDO DANIEL R LAW OFFICE OF PLLC 273,850.83 189 GASSAWAY, WV
* GRUNAU DAVID M 59,256.85 41 MORGANTOWN, WV
GUNN ERICA BRANNON ATT AT LAW PLLC 96,166.14 228 SPENCER, WV
GUNNOE LAW OFFICE 91,604.91 170 HINTON, WV
GUTMANN RICHARD M LC 24,552.94 27 MORGANTOWN, WV
* HALL DWIGHT R 64,700.21 97 ELKINS, WV
HALL KAREN L 12,044.49 3 MORGANTOWN, WV
HAMILTON CHARLES R 128,485.43 186 CHARLESTON, WV
HAMILTON NEAL J 7,433.46 26 FAIRMONT, WV
HAMSTEAD & ASSOCIATES LC 9,609.90 10 CHARLES TOWN, WV
HANDLEY & HUNT PLLC 54,763.40 97 POINT PLEASANT, WV
HARBOUR PAULA L PLLC 16,142.72 16 HUNTINGTON, WV
* HARDY ROY T 47,708.86 88 KEYSER, WV
* HARMAN MARLA ZELENE 27,311.31 40 FRANKLIN, WV
HARPER SETH LAW OFFICE OF PLLC 31,521.16 61 RIPLEY, WV
HARRIS WILSON TURNER & DAVISSON PLLC 12,371.41 12 CLARKSBURG, WV
HARSH LAW LC 40,911.67 34 PARKERSBURG, WV
HART DAVID W 8,486.44 17 ELKINS, WV
* HARVEY & JANUTOLO 286,445.66 321 BLUEFIELD, WV
HARVEY MATTHEW L 1,733.22 4 MARTINSBURG, WV
HASSAN LAW OFFICE 109,243.20 89 WELCH, WV
HATFIELD & HATFIELD PLLC 20,979.96 39 MADISON, WV
HATFIELD KAREN S 42,693.59 106 GILBERT, WV
HAUGHT IRA M 7,701.09 5 HARRISVILLE, WV
HAWKINS JAMES E JR 70,488.80 144 BUCKHANNON, WV
HAYDEN & HART PLLC 78,298.61 102 BECKLEY, WV
HAYNIE BELINDA A 26,024.91 39 MORGANTOWN, WV
HEDGES & LYONS PLLC 60,317.93 84 MORGANTOWN, WV
HENDERSON HENDERSON & STAPLES LC 16,567.35 11 HUNTINGTON, WV
HENDRICKS PETER A 4,203.20 12 MADISON, WV
HERNDON STEPHEN D 17,783.34 1 WHEELING, WV
* HERSHBERGER LAW OFFICE 16,079.17 14 WHEELING, WV
HEWITT & SALVATORE PLLC 457.00 2 FAYETTEVILLE, WV
HILL DAVID L 23,230.70 65 HURRICANE, WV
* HILL JOHNSON LAW PLLC 112,007.59 97 BELINGTON, WV
HILL LAW FIRM PLLC 3,567.00 1 CHARLESTON, WV
* HINERMAN HOLLY W 54,486.47 40 PENTRESS, WV
HINKLE BRYAN S 95,682.44 156 BUCKHANNON, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 174 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
ALPHABETICAL ORDERAppointed Counsel Payments
* HIVELY HERBERT L 134,938.02 245 CHARLESTON, WV
HOBBS MARK E 35,092.00 27 CHAPMANVILLE, WV
HODGES & RIFFLE PLLC 6,569.07 13 FAIRMONT, WV
HOLDREN JASON D 80,919.09 94 GALLIPOLIS, OH
* HOLLANDSWORTH RICHARD W 53,229.16 40 WHEELING, WV
* HOLROYD FRED F 70,386.11 99 CHARLESTON, WV
HOLTZAPFEL LAW OFFICES PLLC 4,951.08 8 HURRICANE, WV
HOOSIER LAW FIRM PLLC 75,126.29 53 CHARLESTON, WV
HOPKINS VIRGINIA JACKSON 6,904.42 3 KINGWOOD, WV
HOUCK G TODD ATTORNEY AT LAW LC 51,389.60 71 MULLENS, WV
HOWLEY LOREN B 7,180.25 11 GRANTSVILLE, WV
HUDNALL MARK D 8,295.03 16 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
HUFFMAN WILLIAM O 64,985.83 71 PRINCETON, WV
HUGHART KEVIN W 136,357.19 136 SISSONVILLE, WV
HUNTER LAW OFFICE 18,076.87 32 SCOTT DEPOT, WV
HUNTER STEVE ASSOCIATES LC 1,555.00 1 LEWISBURG, WV
HUSON ALLISON K 34,652.50 46 HUNTINGTON, WV
HYER & LITTLEPAGE 26,779.49 25 POINT PLEASANT, WV
HYLTON LAW OFFICE PLLC 12,963.67 12 BEAVER, WV
* HYRE LAW OFFICE PLLC 12,184.95 17 KINGWOOD, WV
ISLA MESLER LAW OFFICE PLLC 992.72 1 WEIRTON, WV
* J A M LAW PLLC 53,361.80 72 HARRISVILLE, WV
JACKSON KELLY PLLC 2,342.27 1 CHARLESTON, WV
* JACOVETTY GERALD G JR LC 188,285.39 297 WHEELING, WV
JAMES LAW FIRM 4,927.88 17 KEYSER, WV
JARRELL L CLIFTON 21,783.13 42 MARLINTON, WV
* JARRELL ROBERT STEPHEN 35,165.50 31 MILTON, WV
* JOHNSON REBECCA S LAW OFFICE OF 122,009.74 196 CHARLESTON, WV
JOHNSTON HOLROYD & ASSOCIATES 23,276.61 50 PRINCETON, WV
JUBA‐PLUMLEY ROSALEE 27,459.50 28 ELEANOR, WV
JUDY & JUDY 25,480.82 51 MOOREFIELD, WV
JURCO JOHN M 63,291.43 35 ST CLAIRSVILLE, OH
KARICKHOFF DAVID 44,237.93 115 SUTTON, WV
* KARR THOMAS B 10,412.88 88 VIENNA, WV
KATZ KANTOR STONESTREET & BUCKNER PLLC 50,953.09 61 PRINCETON, WV
KAUFMAN & MCPHERSON PLLC 17,928.66 10 BRIDGEPORT, WV
KAYSER LAYNE & CLARK PLLC 3,576.07 16 POINT PLEASANT, WV
KEATON FRAZER & MILLESON PLLC 30,409.88 85 ROMNEY, WV
* KEESEE RYAN HAMILTON 80,742.31 114 SMOOT, WV
* KELLEY DAVID B LAW OFFICE OF 211,240.64 269 BLUEFIELD, VA
* KELLEY LAW OFFICE 42,592.16 34 HUNTINGTON, WV
* KENTUCKY LAW OFFICE OF CECIL C VARNEY PSC 1,293.93 3 WILLIAMSON, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 175 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
ALPHABETICAL ORDERAppointed Counsel Payments
KEPPLE LAW FIRM PA 47,273.15 41 OAKLAND, MD
KETTERING DELLIGATTI LAW OFFICES PLLC 81,356.98 129 FAIRMONT, WV
* KING WAYNE 50,107.85 29 CLAY, WV
* KIRBY GILBERT & ASHLEY LC 22,222.68 46 BECKLEY, WV
* KIRKPATRICK LAW OFFICE PLLC 78,848.56 55 BECKLEY, WV
* KITTLE LAW OFFICE PLLC 34,147.45 59 FAIRMONT, WV
* KLATT LAW OFFICES PLLC 18,605.03 14 WHEELING, WV
KLIE LAW OFFICES PLLC 175.00 1 BUCKHANNON, WV
* KOHOUT EDWARD R LAW OFFICES OF PLLC 30,373.69 110 MORGANTOWN, WV
KOONTZ MARK TIMOTHY 3,155.85 2 WILLIAMSON, WV
* KRATOVIL LAW OFFICES PLLC 18,026.92 38 CHARLES TOWN, WV
KRESCH LAW FIRM 515.19 2 HUNTINGTON, WV
KUENZEL & ASSOCIATES PLLC 43,073.82 53 CHAPMANVILLE, WV
KUHL LAW OFFICES PLLC 11,679.81 30 SCOTT DEPOT, WV
KUHN & HAINES LC 2,569.52 12 KEYSER, WV
KUPEC & ASSOCIATES PLLC 551.50 1 CLARKSBURG, WV
KURELAC LAW OFFICE PLLC 149,042.48 108 MOUNDSVILLE, WV
LACARIA PHILIP A 129,548.17 109 WELCH, WV
LAISHLEY JOHN 28,700.39 27 HUNTINGTON, WV
LANTZ LAW OFFICE 39,994.36 26 MOUNDSVILLE, WV
LASH FRANKLIN W 8,383.91 12 WHEELING, WV
* LEFLER & BOGGS PLLC 85,019.46 72 BECKLEY, WV
LEGAL AID OF WEST VIRGINIA INC 17,694.62 8 CHARLESTON, WV
* LESTER WILLIAM M 36,918.15 23 BECKLEY, WV
LEWIS GLASSER CASEY & ROLLINS PLLC 11,198.08 1 CHARLESTON, WV
LIVINGOOD LAW PLLC 7,937.03 8 DANVILLE, WV
LOCKWOOD & LOCKWOOD 12,754.30 16 HUNTINGTON, WV
* LOCKWOOD JAMELLA L 125,066.75 160 BUCKHANNON, WV
LOGUE SEAN PLLC 11,104.86 13 CARNEGIA, PA
LONG LAW OFFICES PLLC 47,192.32 81 SCOTT DEPOT, WV
LONG ROBBY N LAW OFFICE OF LC 81,212.95 116 HAMLIN, WV
LORD JASON S 80,133.73 83 CHARLESTON, WV
LOSCH & MCCOURT PLLC 1,820.99 3 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
LOUDERBACK ROBIN R 18,400.58 18 CHARLESTON, WV
LOVE JAY CARTER 15,748.74 137 HUNTINGTON, WV
LOVE LAW FIRM PLLC 1,169.78 3 CHARLESTON, WV
* LUPARDUS LAW OFFICE 106,102.35 207 PINEVILLE, WV
LUSK KYLE G 10,482.00 19 BECKLEY, WV
LUTTRELL & PREZIOSO PLLC 54,773.77 26 MARTINSBURG, WV
LYALL JERRY M 42,463.38 81 WILLIAMSON, WV
MAGANN LAW OFFICE PLLC 108,045.62 251 BLUEFIELD, WV
* MAIER LAW OFFICE LLC 15,729.75 18 HINTON, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 176 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
ALPHABETICAL ORDERAppointed Counsel Payments
MALLETT SHANE M LAW OFFICES 13,889.66 17 WHEELING, WV
MANYPENNY RAINES LAW OFFICE PLLC 56,139.12 83 CHESTER, WV
MARSH LAW OFFICE PLLC 32,101.71 32 CHARLESTON, WV
MARTINO GARY J 13,714.00 30 FAIRMONT, WV
MASCIO DAVID A LAW OFFICE OF 32,334.67 30 WEIRTON, WV
MATHERLY JEFFREY K 11,427.44 11 MARTINSBURG, WV
MAUSER BERNARD R 15,118.23 44 SUTTON, WV
* MAYO NICHOLAS 266.02 1 HUNTINGTON, WV
MAZE LESLIE L 4,957.50 6 ELIZABETH, WV
* MAZZEI ROCCO E 154,206.24 100 CLARKSBURG, WV
MCCAMIC SACCO & MCCOID PLLC 6,451.05 3 WHEELING, WV
MCCLURE GOAD PLLC 5,118.44 26 HUNTINGTON, WV
MCCOY JAMES A 59,656.48 59 HAMLIN, WV
* MCDONOUGH C EDWARD 13,465.00 19 PARKERSBURG, WV
MCFARLAND JOSEPH W 8,429.09 10 WELLINGTON, FL
MCGEELAW 5,627.38 10 CHARLESTON, WV
MCGRAW LAW OFFICES 89,341.91 98 PROSPERITY, WV
MCINTYRE‐NICHOLSON RACHELLE D 11,993.74 9 CLARKSBURG, WV
MCNEER HIGHLAND MCMUNN & VARNER LC 74,802.62 20 CLARKSBURG, WV
MCQUADE RUTH A LAW OFFICE OF 73,745.84 101 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WV
* MEADOWS TODD R 4,129.50 1 ONA, WV
MICHAEL NELSON M LC 58,171.14 135 KEYSER, WV
MICK REBECCA E 58,649.04 84 CHARLESTON, WV
MILLER CHRISTOPHER H 52,825.87 57 MORGANTOWN, WV
* MILLS KEVIN D & ASSOCIATES PLLC 17,144.14 8 MARTINSBURG, WV
MITCHELL JOHN R LC 2,156.31 3 CHARLESTON, WV
* MOFFATT CHRISTOPHER G 181,474.95 139 CHARLESTON, WV
* MONK TERESA C LAW FIRM OF 103,674.78 126 WALTON, WV
MOORE DAVID K 44,549.75 35 RIPLEY, WV
MOORE D. KYLE 47,880.28 68 RIPLEY, WV
* MOORE HARRY W JR LAW OFFICES OF 3,283.50 3 MOUNDSVILLE, WV
MOORE LAW FIRM PLLC 24,261.82 27 FRANKLIN, WV
MOOREHEAD CHRISTOPHER S 29,153.23 38 FAYETTEVILLE, WV
MORAN JANE LAW OFFICES 12,166.73 34 WILLIAMSON, WV
* MORELLI LAW 42,767.86 35 WEIRTON, WV
MORGAN DAMON B 37,948.51 112 POINT PLEASANT, WV
* MORGAN DENNIE S 32,558.42 44 MOUNT HOPE, WV
* MORGAN E LAVOYD JR & ASSOCIATES LC 116,771.77 96 LEWISBURG, WV
MORGAN TONY 35,108.60 55 GRANTSVILLE, WV
MORGAN WARD LAW OFFICE OF 85,310.40 82 BLUEFIELD, WV
MORTON JOYCE H 1,816.41 1 WEBSTER SPRINGS, WV
MOSES JOSEPH J 110,989.14 53 WHEELING, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 177 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
ALPHABETICAL ORDERAppointed Counsel Payments
* MOUNTAINEER LEGAL SERVICES PLLC 202,734.43 400 GRAFTON, WV
MOYE LAW OFFICE 14,126.38 29 WINFIELD, WV
MOYE LISA M 13,654.66 15 WINFIELD, WV
MULLENS & MULLENS PLLC 85,078.14 205 PHILIPPI, WV
* MULLIGAN CHRISTINA A LAW OFFICES OF 2,119.70 1 FAIRMONT, WV
* MULLINS‐TAYLOR MINDI M 435.50 6 PRINCETON, WV
* MUNOZ A JOSEPH LAW FIRM OF 87,468.07 110 PARKERSBURG, WV
* MURPHY S SEAN PLLC 16,415.72 36 MORGANTOWN, WV
MYERS JESSICA E 52,652.35 37 PARKERSBURG, WV
* NANNERS & WILLETT LAW OFFICES OF LC 299,998.62 422 BUCKHANNON, WV
* NAVY L VICTOR 89,490.71 132 BARBOURSVILLE, WV
NEELY & CALLAGHAN 16,415.55 28 CHARLESTON, WV
* NEISWONGER & WHITE 107,881.52 238 MOUNDSVILLE, WV
NELSON LEGAL SERVICES LC 49,049.31 69 PETERSBURG, WV
* NESSEL LAW FIRM 92,174.14 59 HUNTINGTON, WV
NESTOR WILLIAM T PLLC 56,237.77 89 ELKINS, WV
* NEW STEPHEN P LC 12,289.68 15 BECKLEY, WV
* NOEL WILLIAM C 15,221.83 10 MORGANTOWN, WV
NOGAY CATHRYN A 47,484.15 18 WEIRTON, WV
* NOLAN LAW FIRM 80,812.96 231 HUNTINGTON, WV
NOONE ROBERT T 37,063.70 27 GADSDEN, AL
* NOVOBILSKI JEROME E 14,973.96 54 CLAY, WV
NUTTALL LEGAL LLC 12,611.20 11 BUCKHANNON, WV
OGLE CANDACE L 13,201.96 96 MORGANTOWN, WV
ORNDORFF DAVID L 93,245.71 77 BUCKHANNON, WV
* OSHOWAY F JOHN 80,475.78 114 GRANTSVILLE, WV
OURS JOHN G 17,825.50 47 PETERSBURG, WV
* PANCAKE JANE ANN 13,399.53 11 BARBOURSVILLE, WV
PANEPINTO MARK D 102,456.91 34 WHEELING, WV
* PARKULO JOHN F 39,056.48 36 DANIELS, WV
* PARROTT MATTHEW 3,181.80 5 PRINCETON, WV
PARTAIN LAW OFFICE 35,171.92 30 LOGAN, WV
PATTERSON THOMAS K A LEGAL CORP 568.00 5 BECKLEY, WV
PAYNE WILBERT A 29,957.07 91 BECKLEY, WV
PELLEGRIN MARK P 2,770.00 8 MORGANTOWN, WV
PENNINGTON DEANNA L 13,341.50 20 MORGANTOWN, WV
PENNINGTON WILLIAM 48,244.91 81 MORGANTOWN, WV
PEYTON LAW FIRM PLLC 3,012.69 2 NITRO, WV
PHILLIPS P TODD 50,185.18 42 MORGANTOWN, WV
POMEROY LAW OFFICE PLLC 4,457.00 1 BRIDGEPORT, WV
POWELL & MAJESTRO PLLC 7,840.55 12 CHARLESTON, WV
POWELL ERIC K 153,273.98 236 PARKERSBURG, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 178 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
ALPHABETICAL ORDERAppointed Counsel Payments
POWER BECK & MATZUREFF 1,881.87 2 MARTINSBURG, WV
PRALL THOMAS J 51,340.68 116 WESTON, WV
PRATT LENA D 42,666.81 41 LOGAN, WV
PRENTICE TIMOTHY H 85,196.58 130 ELKINS, WV
PRESTON & SALANGO PLLC 1,838.36 7 CHARLESTON, WV
PRICE DONNA M 2,103.00 5 MARLINTON, WV
PRICE JOSHUA D 2,623.50 9 JACKSON, OH
* PRICE LOUIE T 13,479.00 14 CHARLESTON, WV
PRIM LAW FIRM PLLC 6,309.05 18 HURRICANE, WV
* PRITT & PRITT PLLC 85,816.92 128 CHARLESTON, WV
* PRITT ALAN L 37,833.00 47 CHARLESTON, WV
* PROCTOR LAW OFFICES PLLC 2,546.40 1 HUNTINGTON, WV
PULLIN FOWLER FLANAGAN BROWN & POE PLLC 91,990.02 305 CHARLESTON, WV
QUALLS ALVIE E 2,583.84 15 HUNTINGTON, WV
RADMAN SCOTT S 6,188.50 21 MORGANTOWN, WV
* RAY LAW PLLC 14,951.16 19 MORGANTOWN, WV
* REBROOK EDWARD III 123,100.05 149 CHARLESTON, WV
* REDDING R STEVEN ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 116,129.26 69 MARTINSBURG, WV
* REDMAN & PAYNE 9,276.83 3 CHARLESTON, WV
* REES JAMES B 52,964.40 53 FAYETTEVILLE, WV
REGULA RAE LYNN 6,839.06 12 BROWNFIELD, PA
* RIBEL KATICA 19,806.64 54 FAIRMONT, WV
RICE WILLIAM T 137,641.66 69 MARTINSBURG, WV
* RICHARDSON DAVID B LAW OFFICE 34,003.02 90 WINFIELD, WV
RICHARDSON RICHARDSON & CAMPBELL 25,327.39 82 PARKERSBURG, WV
RIFFE RICHARD M 6,048.49 3 ALUM CREEK, WV
* RILEY JAMES P IV ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 29,150.97 14 MARTINSBURG, WV
RILEY V ALAN ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 2,440.43 7 ROMNEY, WV
RINGER DARRELL W 1,234.50 1 MORGANTOWN, WV
RIST LAW OFFICES LC 54,658.11 85 FAYETTEVILLE, WV
ROAHRIG RANDAL W 28,779.36 23 PRINCETON, WV
ROBB RICHARD A 11,637.22 1 SOUTH CHARLESTON, WV
ROBINSON & MCELWEE 33,364.59 20 CHARLESTON, WV
* RODGERS JEFFREY S 87,418.24 136 LEWISBURG, WV
RODRIGUEZ VANESSA LYNN LAW OFFICES OF 638.93 3 FAIRMONT, WV
ROHRIG FREDERICK M DEAN 8,086.38 10 MIDDLEBOURNE, WV
ROKISKY & ASSOCIATES 25,826.57 12 WEIRTON, WV
ROLLO EDMUND J 55,599.00 66 MORGANTOWN, WV
ROLLO LANCE E 22,476.53 35 MORGANTOWN, WV
ROOP & SMITH LAW OFFICE PLLC 44,778.80 21 BECKLEY, WV
ROSE PADDEN PETTY TAYLOR & LILLY LC 35,267.47 47 FAIRMONT, WV
ROSENLIEB DUANE C JR 1,368.67 4 SAINT ALBANS, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 179 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
ALPHABETICAL ORDERAppointed Counsel Payments
ROSINSKY LAW OFFICE 63,701.43 31 HUNTINGTON, WV
ROSS KRISTEN E 666.50 1 HUNTINGTON, WV
* RUMORA & RUMORA LC 147,575.81 200 WILLIAMSON, WV
RUSEN & AUVIL PLLC 1,294.05 1 PARKERSBURG, WV
RUTH LAW OFFICES PLLC 208,449.97 229 CHARLESTON, WV
RYAN KOURTNEY A & ASSOCIATES 50,080.30 28 BUCKHANNON, WV
* SAAD ABRAHAM J PLLC 111,329.11 237 HUNTINGTON, WV
* SAFCSAK MICHAEL LAW OFFICE OF PLLC 25,305.20 33 FAIRMONT, WV
SAFFER MARTIN V 35,376.50 21 MARLINTON, WV
* SAL SELLARO THORN CULPEPPER LEGAL GROUP PLLC 232,167.81 457 MORGANTOWN, WV
* SALMONS RONALD G ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 31,616.39 55 WEST HAMLIN, WV
SAMMONS OLIVERO & PARASCHOS PLLC 26,123.05 8 HUNTINGTON, WV
SANDERS AUSTIN FLANIGAN & FLANIGAN 52,669.24 60 PRINCETON, WV
SANTER & SANTER 43,118.27 96 PARKERSBURG, WV
SAVILLE ROYCE B PLLC 36,200.50 135 ROMNEY, WV
SAYRE TRAVIS LAW OFFICE OF 66,905.76 66 PARKERSBURG, WV
SCALES LAW OFFICE 139,346.42 58 MARTINSBURG, WV
* SCHAMBERGER LEGAL SERVICES 21,227.17 43 CLAY, WV
SCHARF WILLIAM H 11,465.54 8 CHARLESTON, WV
* SCHEETZ CHRISTOPHER A 46,810.82 48 FOLLANSBEE, WV
SCHILLACE LAW OFFICE 3,017.10 2 CLARKSBURG, WV
* SEAY ROBERT ROCKWELL 7,665.05 13 PRINCETON, WV
SELDEN LAW OFFICES LC 33,369.50 24 BECKLEY, WV
SHAFER LAW OFFICES 20,400.07 22 WHEELING, WV
SHAHEEN MICHAEL J 8,196.49 19 ST CLAIRSVILLE, OH
SHARLEY MICHAEL J 6,117.64 16 WESTOVER, WV
SHAW & SHAW LC 87,071.59 177 POINT PLEASANT, WV
SHERMAN LAWRENCE E JR LC 167,169.74 248 ROMNEY, WV
SHOCKLEY JAMES B 22,121.08 31 MORGANTOWN, WV
* SHOUGH SCOTT A 80,292.65 133 FAIRMONT, WV
SHUMAKER J BRANDON 25,244.19 30 MORGANTOWN, WV
* SHUMATE ANDREW R 33,464.36 71 CHARLESTON, WV
* SIKORA SNEAD PLLC 70,902.06 87 MORGANTOWN, WV
SIMMERMAN LAW OFFICE PLLC 22,210.43 3 CLARKSBURG, WV
SIMMONS & SIMMONS LC 15,867.61 25 ELIZABETH, WV
* SIMMONS HUNTER D 98,853.78 356 BUCKHANNON, WV
* SINKKANEN DREAMA D LAW OFFICES OF 45,017.19 55 CLARKSBURG, WV
* SIRK TIMOTHY M 6,034.06 12 KEYSER, WV
SITES LAW FIRM 11,586.38 51 KEYSER, WV
SKAGGS G ERNEST 133,860.94 82 FAYETTEVILLE, WV
SKLAVOUNAKIS LAW OFFICE 25,548.10 22 WHEELING, WV
SMITH CLINTON W 19,662.08 63 CHARLESTON, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 180 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
ALPHABETICAL ORDERAppointed Counsel Payments
SMITH JAMES E II 2,433.40 1 KEYSER, WV
SMITH MCMUNN & GLOVER PLLC 18,761.64 20 CLARKSBURG, WV
SMITH RICHARD D JR LAW OFFICES OF 23,976.88 92 PARKERSBURG, WV
* SNODGRASS LORA LAW OFFICE OF 20,351.22 74 PARKERSBURG, WV
SNYDER & HASSIG 57,028.07 35 NEW MARTINSVILLE, WV
SOUDERS MELISHA D 11,849.17 5 HANCOCK, MD
* SOUTHERN WV LAW CLINIC 96,550.86 130 BECKLEY, WV
SPADARO LAURA E 6,561.07 5 GLEN JEAN, WV
* SPARACINO ANTHONY J JR 1,460.50 4 BECKLEY, WV
* SPENIA LAW OFFICE PLLC 83,674.19 87 BARBOURSVILLE, WV
SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE PLLC 6,149.24 12 CHARLESTON, WV
SPONAUGLE & SPONAUGLE 2,147.50 1 FRANKLIN, WV
SPROLES GREGORY W PLLC 2,104.22 1 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
SPURLOCK JAMES E 1,276.50 1 HUNTINGTON, WV
* STALNAKER CHARLES E 14,396.18 57 PARKERSBURG, WV
STANTON SHIRLEY J 3,798.78 4 FAIRMONT, WV
STAPLETON LAW OFFICES LC 5,056.43 21 HUNTINGTON, WV
STARCHER & FRUM PLLC 115,163.70 223 PARKERSBURG, WV
STEDMAN JASON M 42,660.39 70 MARTINSBURG, WV
STEED DEBRA L PLLC 11,218.87 13 PARKERSBURG, WV
STEPHENS GLORIA M 30,197.26 29 WELCH, WV
STEPHENS RICHARD D 45,245.85 87 MARTINSBURG, WV
STEPTOE & JOHNSON 31,740.73 8 BRIDGEPORT, WV
STEVENS C JOSEPH LAW FIRM OF PLLC 192.00 1 HAMLIN, WV
STEWART JOYCE E 31,218.80 29 MOOREFIELD, WV
STEWART P ZACHARY LAW OFFICE OF 63,004.09 91 WEIRTON, WV
STOLLINGS HARLEY E 14,038.02 22 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
STONE ROBERT C JR PLLC 5,549.40 5 MARTINSBURG, WV
* STURM HEIDI M GEORGI 76,036.84 77 FAIRMONT, WV
* SUMMERS WILLIAM B 144,895.98 566 PARKERSBURG, WV
SUPPLE LAW OFFICES PLLC 2,252.85 13 POINT PLEASANT, WV
SUTTON & JANELLE PLLC 1,064.50 2 MARTINSBURG, WV
TATE REBECCA 46,103.46 71 FAIRMONT, WV
* TAYLOR ADAM D LAW OFFICE OF INC 55,866.47 110 BECKLEY, WV
TAYLOR JENNIFER N 13,571.86 55 CHARLESTON, WV
TAYLOR PAUL G 52,248.55 79 MARTINSBURG, WV
THARP LIOTTA & YOKUM LLP 28,802.38 36 FAIRMONT, WV
THOMPSON & PARDO PLLC 78,097.27 14 CHARLES TOWN, WV
THOMPSON BARNEY 2,870.28 1 CHARLESTON, WV
THOMPSON DAVID G 5,044.88 23 PINEVILLE, WV
* THOMPSON JOHN M 116,337.14 206 OAK HILL, WV
* THOMPSON LAW OFFICE PLLC 24,949.00 40 WILLIAMSON, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 181 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
ALPHABETICAL ORDERAppointed Counsel Payments
THORNE STEVEN M 69,618.85 133 LOGAN, WV
TICHENOR LAW OFFICE 11,001.97 22 FAIRMONT, WV
TIPTON LAW OFFICES 42,866.00 48 FAIRMONT, WV
TISSUE PHILIP J 13,935.25 22 OAK HILL, WV
TORRES GEORGE M 26,810.00 31 PARKERSBURG, WV
* TREADWAY JOHN H JR 38,503.47 30 MOOREFIELD, WV
TROISI JOSEPH G 61,330.49 94 SAINT MARYS, WV
TSORAS THEODORE L 3,408.28 4 POWHATON POINT, OH
TUCKER GREGORY A PLLC 302.00 1 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
TURNER & JOHNS PLLC 2,815.58 8 CHARLESTON, WV
TYREE EMBREE & ASSOCIATES PLLC 25,386.42 66 HURRICANE, WV
* TYSON DAVID R 60,911.94 130 HUNTINGTON, WV
UTT BARBARA LYNN LAW OFFICES OF 4,699.32 1 CHARLESTON, WV
VAN DEYSEN LAW OFFICE PLLC 2,719.32 10 MORGANTOWN, WV
VAN ZANT SUSAN J LC 18,204.09 46 WILLIAMSON, WV
* VICTOR VICTOR & HELGOE LLP 207,049.61 292 CHARLESTON, WV
VITAL RICHARD L 16,906.77 21 BARBOURSVILLE, WV
* WALKER LELA ATTY AT LAW PLLC 42,117.32 55 OCEANA, WV
* WALL RANDALL D 43,999.47 287 HUNTINGTON, WV
WALLACE MICHAEL K 39,383.21 70 SOUTH CHARLESTON, WV
WALTERS & HEISHMAN PLLC 30,783.93 81 MOOREFIELD, WV
* WARMAN CHERYL L 46,418.90 74 MORGANTOWN, WV
WATSON LAW 26,543.67 38 MARTINSBURG, WV
* WEBB‐BARBER CELESTE E 1,006.60 7 CULLODEN, WV
* WEBB‐RUMORA MARSHA 3,569.11 10 WILLIAMSON, WV
WEBER & WEBER 52.00 1 WESTON, WV
* WEESE HEATHER M LAW OFFICE OF PLLC 47,262.61 50 ELKINS, WV
WEESE ROGER R 7,271.50 4 NEW MARTINSVILLE, WV
* WEESE TRACY 94,414.75 24 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WV
WEST CHARLES STANFORD 3,818.50 6 WILLIAMSON, WV
WESTON LAW A LEGAL CORP 51,012.88 41 HUNTINGTON, WV
WHEELER LAW FIRM 74,439.40 164 CHARLESTON, WV
* WHITE KEITH 115,972.24 276 SAINT MARYS, WV
WHITE MAX H PLLC 41,520.62 125 KEYSER, WV
WHITE THOMAS E 14,412.54 18 MOUNDSVILLE, WV
WHITEMAN BURDETTE PLLC 149,461.00 326 FAIRMONT, WV
WHITEMAN FRANCES C 111,644.27 113 FAIRMONT, WV
* WHITT MICHAEL R 143,246.35 53 LEWISBURG, WV
* WIEDEL DIANA CARTER 155,320.34 132 WILLIAMSON, WV
* WILDMAN ERIC KEITH 30,897.34 62 FAIRMONT, WV
WILLIAMS JOHN E JR 114,231.45 145 PRINCETON, WV
WILLIAMS PAUL ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 24,063.24 52 SUMMERSVILLE, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 182 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
ALPHABETICAL ORDERAppointed Counsel Payments
WILLIAMS TRENA LAW OFFICE OF PLLC 53,070.50 71 WESTON, WV
WILMOTH DAVID H LC 11,507.38 18 ELKINS, WV
WILSON CHRISTOPHER M LAW OFFICE OF PLLC 51,974.27 53 FAIRMONT, WV
* WILSON LAW OFFICE 37,178.39 111 KEYSER, WV
WINDOM LAW OFFICES PLLC 146,033.08 113 HARRISVILLE, WV
WINTER KURT J 18,954.11 64 BURGETTSTOWN, PA
WINTERS J MINGO ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 22,737.48 57 BECKLEY, WV
* WITT RICHARD C 1,235.90 3 POCA, WV
WLO MANAGEMENT LLC 15,366.21 20 HUNTINGTON, WV
WOLFE B SCOTT LAW OFFICE OF PLLC 46,864.07 63 HARRISVILE, WV
WOLFE HAROLD B III 471.49 1 PRINCETON, WV
WOLFE LAW OFFICE PLLC 55,691.45 151 LOGAN, WV
WOODS JOHN 27,424.50 41 BELLEVILLE, WV
WOOTON WOOTON & DAVIS PLLC 11,441.39 27 BECKLEY, WV
WORKMAN ELLIOTT E PLLC 1,856.04 4 MADISON, WV
WRIGHT LACY W 16,684.67 37 WELCH, WV
WRIGHT STEVEN MCKAY 2,099.84 6 HUNTINGTON, WV
* YANNI LAW FIRM 29,000.21 45 MARTINSBURG, WV
YATES CHELSEA LEGAL LAW OFFICE OF CHELSEA E 6,909.77 10 CHARLESTON, WV
YOST BRIAN D 15,429.85 17 HURRICANE, WV
* YOUNG WILLIAM PRENTICE 99,077.00 12 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WV
YOUNGER C CHRISTOPHER 2,580.50 8 WILLIAMSON, WV
ZIMAROWSKI THOMAS 4,422.06 20 MORGANTOWN, WV
APPOINTED COUNSEL TOTAL 24,879,198.76 35,428
* Using third party financing.
FY2015 Annual Report Page 183 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
4DISCOVERY LLC 4,800.00 2 CHICAGO, IL
ADVANCED PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES 4,350.00 3 WHEELING, WV
ALLDRIDGE REPORTING INC 1,731.67 2 MORGANTOWN, WV
ALLEGHENY CONSULTANT SERVICES INC 645.67 2 ATHENS, WV
ARTHUR DEBRA R 140.00 1 COLLIERS, WV
ASHBURN CAROL A 404.70 1 BRIDGEPORT, WV
ASHBURN PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES LLC 9,550.00 2 ASHBURN, VA
ASSURED POLYGRAPH SERVICES INC 750.00 1 PITTSBURGH, PA
BAKER LYNDE G 219.45 1 VIENNA, WV
BECKETT HERMAN H 540.13 1 SALT ROCK, WV
BEHAVIORAL SCIENCE ASSOCIATES INC 1,735.00 1 WHEELING, WV
BEHRMANN JAMES P 2,092.50 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
BERNSTEIN LAWSON F MD PC 9,225.96 2 PITTSBURGH, PA
BETLERS REPORTING & LEGAL VIDEO SERVICES LLC 1,389.85 1 HUNTINGTON, WV
BLAKE KENNETH W 951.34 1 HURRICANE, WV
BLOSSER JULIE A 870.10 1 MORGANTOWN, WV
BLUE RIDGE COUNSELING CENTER 375.00 1 WINCHESTER, VA
BRAMBLE CHARLES E III & ASSOC 19,704.23 3 STONEWOOD, WV
BUZZO BILL J 2,845.68 4 BLUEFIELD, WV
* CABELLS PRIVATE INVESTIGATION 23,371.43 45 CABIN CREEK, WV
CALLAHAN PETER J PLLC 750.00 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
* CAPITOL CITY INVESTIGATIONS LLC 7,170.24 7 CHARLESTON, WV
CASTO INVESTIGATIONS INC 4,961.52 1 BANCROFT, WV
CASTO THERESA LEE 360.00 1 CLINTONVILLE, WV
CELLMARK FORENSICS INC 1,500.00 1 BURLINGTON, NC
CHACALOS CAROL L 435.75 1 WHEELING, WV
CHANDLER MARCIA L 327.25 1 GREENCASTLE, PA
CHESLOCK TERRI R 358.05 1 FAIRMONT, WV
CHRISTIAN PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES PLLC 1,200.00 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
CLAY BOB INVESTIGATIONS 400.00 1 REEDSVILLE, WV
CLAYMAN & ASSOCIATES PLLC 13,822.50 4 CHARLESTON, WV
COMPLETE SURVEILLANCE & INVESTIGATIVE SVS INC 2,265.20 3 WYTHEVILLE, VA
COMPUTER RESCUE REPAIR LLC 450.00 1 WEIRTON, WV
* CONFIDENTIAL INVESTIGATIONS & SERVICES 6,316.99 13 CHARLESTON, WV
COOK INVESTIGATION SERVICE INC 6,176.64 1 HUNTINGTON, WV
COOPERS INVESTIGATIVE AGENCY 20,263.93 14 BRIDGEPORT, WV
CORNELL INVESTIGATIONS 15,979.31 35 HARRISVILLE, WV
CRABTREE MICHAEL 2,340.00 1 WASHINGTON, PA
CROCK HAMRICK REPORTING SERVICES 60.05 1 INWOOD, WV
CROWE MARY SUE 469.25 1 FROSTBURG, MD
CURRAN AUCTIONEERING & REAL ESTATE 250.00 1 BURLINGTON, WV
DANIEL JOHN S III 4,866.67 3 MIDLOTHIAN, VA
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
ALPHABETICAL ORDERDirect Expenses
FY2015 Annual Report Page 184 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
ALPHABETICAL ORDERDirect Expenses
DEAK INVESTIGATIONS 685.95 1 ELLENBORO, WV
DILORENZO REPORTING SERVICE LLC 542.85 1 BECKLEY, WV
DNA DIAGNOSTICS CENTER INC 1,180.00 1 FAIRFIELD, OH
DRESBOLD MICHELLE 750.00 1 PITTSBURGH, PA
EADES EVONNE RENEE 986.00 1 BRIDGEPORT, WV
EASTERN PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES INC 3,075.00 3 ROMNEY, WV
FEINGOLD BARNET 10,753.28 1 WINCHESTER, VA
FERDA BRIAN T INVESTIGATIVE CONSULTANT 3,487.50 1 WHEELING, WV
FERRELL ROBERT L 501.00 1 BAKER, WV
FORENSIC PRESS INC 7,560.00 1 WAKE FOREST, NC
FORENSIC PSYCHIATRY PLLC 49,100.00 28 HUNTINGTON, WV
FORENSIC PSYCHOLOGY CENTER INC 2,250.00 1 WINCHESTER, VA
FREMOUW SIGLEY PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSOC PLLC 22,125.00 12 MORGANTOWN, WV
G & G FIREARMS EXPERTS INC 3,504.55 1 MILFORD, NH
GAUJOT‐TURNER CLAUDETTE M 633.00 1 KEARNEYSVILLE, WV
GOPHER LAND SERVICE INC 3,488.68 1 BEAVER, WV
GREENBUSCH GROUP INC 6,610.00 2 SEATTLE, WA
GREENE JUDITH A 477.40 1 WINFIELD, WV
GUARDIAN DIGITAL FORENSICS 22,733.19 6 RALEIGH, NC
HALL JEANNE S 2,055.40 3 HUNTINGTON, WV
HALL LAURA ANNE 23.00 1 HEDGESVILLE, WV
HAMRICK TERRY C 154.00 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
HARLOW STACY LLC 5,920.00 20 PARKERSBURG, WV
HART LESLIE W 7,576.51 5 ELKINS, WV
HARTS REPORTING & VIDEOCONFERENCING LLC 1,486.00 1 HARRISONBURG, VA
HEALTHPORT TECHNOLOGIES LLC 208.13 1 ATLANTA, GA
HEARTLAND FORENSIC PATHOLOGY LLC 4,780.00 2 KANSAS CITY, MO
HENDERSHOT PROCESS SERVING & INVESTIGATIONS 9,596.76 18 PARKERSBURG, WV
HERRON‐RICE TRACY P 1,544.55 4 MARTINSBURG, WV
HICKMAN SANDRA L 964.25 2 WAVERLY, WV
HUNTER AMANDA R 147.00 2 HUNTINGTON, WV
INTL MEDICAL LEGAL FORENSIC EXPERTS LLC 26,246.98 2 HUNTSVILLE, AL
* INVESTIGATIVE ASSOCIATES INC 1,412.71 3 PARKERSBURG, WV
INVESTIGATIVE SPECIALTY SERVICES LLC 120.00 1 SHADY SPRINGS, WV
JACKSON GROUP INC 21,835.10 4 HICKORY, NC
JARRELL NANCY S 284.90 1 PARKERSBURG, WV
JFC CONSULTING LLC 6,200.00 2 ARMONK, NY
JONES DYKSTRA & ASSOCIATES INC 60,807.36 1 COLUMBIA, MD
* JONES INVESTIGATIONS 20,376.00 10 BLUEFIELD, WV
JURAND JOSEPH A 2,500.00 1 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WV
KELLEY SHAMELLE D 419.65 1 CHARLESTON, WV
KENTUCKY MEDICAL SERVICES FOUNDATION INC 500.00 1 LEXINGTON, KY
FY2015 Annual Report Page 185 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
ALPHABETICAL ORDERDirect Expenses
KEYSTONE ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS INC 5,060.00 2 MCMURRAY, PA
KISH PAUL ERWIN FORENSIC CONSULTANT 2,437.50 1 CORNING, NY
KL REPORTING 1,069.55 7 HUNTINGTON, WV
KLM INVESTIGATIONS 5,342.65 8 WILLIAMSTOWN, WV
KOENIG JOHN C 454.00 1 BAGDAD, KY
KRADEL PAUL F 36,846.85 7 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WV
KREEFER JULIE L 63.00 1 EAST LIVERPOOL, OH
LANE INVESTIGATIONS LLC 24,202.58 13 GRAYSON, KY
LAW‐SCIENCE TECHNOLOGIES INC 7,334.87 2 WEST MILTON, OH
LAWSON SHERRY M 504.35 2 CHARLESTON, WV
LEGAL SCIENCE 11,050.00 2 CHARLESTON, WV
LUNSFORD WILLIAM G 984.24 1 MILTON, WV
MACKENZIE GROUP LLC 1,162.50 1 SEARCY, AR
MARANATHA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES LLC 8,760.43 16 DANIELS, WV
MCCLELLAND SERVICES 3,553.12 11 WHITEOAK, WV
MOORE INVESTIGATION & SECURITY AGENCY LLC 3,169.07 1 PEYTONA, WV
MORGAN WARD LAW OFFICE OF 7,457.00 2 BLUEFIELD, WV
MORROW CHRISTINE E 501.60 1 MORGANTOWN, WV
MOUNTAIN STATE PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES PLLC 8,950.39 7 KEYSER, WV
MOUNTS MICHAEL E 2,905.97 2 SAINT ALBANS, WV
NATL LEGAL RESEARCH GROUP INC 1,955.70 1 CHARLOTTESVILLE, VA
NATL MEDICAL SERVICES INC 2,296.00 1 PHILADELPHIA, PA
NELSON ELJORN DON 4,400.00 1 CINCINNATI, OH
NELSON JUDY K 34.65 1 BEAVER, WV
PANHANDLE ACCIDENT RECONSTRUCTION 1,085.74 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
PANHANDLE PSYCHOLOGICAL CENTER PLLC 272.54 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
PATE PHILIP E 24,143.91 18 WINCHESTER, VA
PATTERSON REPORTING 373.45 1 HARPERS FERRY, WV
PEACE OF MIND PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES 1,500.00 1 PARKERSBURG, WV
PEDIATRIC NEUROLOGY INC 3,000.00 1 ST LOUIS, MO
PETERS LARRY A INC 13,371.42 12 WINCHESTER, VA
POLYGRAPH STATION LLC 400.00 1 CHARLESTON, WV
PRIMECARE MEDICAL INC 353.32 1 HARRISBURG, PA
PRUITT LESLIE M QUEEN 1,446.00 1 MT CLARE, WV
PSYCHOLOGICAL CONSULTING INC 10,725.00 9 MARTINSBURG, WV
REALTIME REPORTERS LLC 620.50 1 CHARLESTON, WV
REUTZEL WAYNE B 825.50 1 AMBRIDGE, PA
RINI GARY A 25,000.00 4 NORTH OLMSTED, OH
ROGERSON INVESTIGATIONS LLC 139.02 1 POMPANO BEACH, FL
SAAR PSYCHOLOGICAL GROUP PLLC 5,578.86 5 SOUTH CHARLESTON, WV
SAVED BY GRACE MINISTRY INC 7,210.00 1 EAST AURORA, NY
SCHEIDLER SAMUEL H 500.00 1 MILTON, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 186 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
ALPHABETICAL ORDERDirect Expenses
SECOND CREEK TECHNOLOGIES LLC 1,000.00 1 BABOURSVILLE, WV
SHAW‐BLACK INDUSTRIES LLC 5,257.10 1 CINCINNATI, OH
SLAYDEN CATHERINE A 1,124.20 3 MARTINSBURG, WV
SOLID ROCK INVESTIGATIONS LLC 1,304.89 2 RED HOUSE, WV
SOVANI VINAYAK KRISHNA 600.00 1 WHEELING, WV
SPAULDING PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES PLLC 500.00 1 HARRISVILLE, WV
SPECIAL SECURITY SERVICES LLC 16,751.38 4 BAKER, WV
STEALTH INVESTIGATIONS 7,771.34 16 GASSAWAY, WV
STEVENS PRIVATE INVESTIGATIONS & SECURITY 2,731.50 6 LENORE, WV
STEWART ROBERT D 3,049.28 6 PINEVILLE, WV
STOUT NATASHA K 2,680.91 3 SAINT ALBANS, WV
TORSNEY JACK R 6,000.00 2 MORGANTOWN, WV
TOTAL FAMILY CARE PLLC 445.00 1 KINGWOOD, WV
TRAINOR GREGORY E MA & ASSOC 7,325.00 3 KEYSER, WV
TRI COUNTY PASTORAL COUNSELING SERVICES 1,275.00 3 MARTINSBURG, WV
TRI S INVESTIGATIONS INC 108,492.28 125 PARKERSBURG, WV
* TURNING POINT INVESTIGATIVE SERVICES 5,934.67 9 TORNADO, WV
VALLEY COMPREHENSIVE COMM MHC INC 408.00 2 MORGANTOWN, WV
VAUGHAN INVESTIGATIONS 20,469.28 43 BRADLEY, WV
WILSON JOSEPH BRYANT 2,604.55 6 VIENNA, WV
WISE WOODRUFF INVESTIGATIVE SERVICES ETC INC 4,173.86 1 WALTERSBURG, PA
WOLFE PARALEGAL SERVICES LLC 408.00 1 HUNTINGTON, WV
WOODS INVESTIGATIONS 35,925.75 30 BECKLEY, WV
WYATT WILLIAM J 8,450.00 2 HURRICANE, WV
DIRECT EXPENSE VOUCHER TOTAL 973,741.03 747
* Using third party financing.
FY2015 Annual Report Page 187 of 212
# OFPAYEE TOTAL $ CLAIMS OFFICE LOCATION
BURKONS DAVID M MD INC 8,600.00 1 S EUCLID, OH
CAPITOL CITY INVESTIGATIONS LLC 1,500.00 1 HUNTINGTON, WV
COFFINDAFFER LARRY K 161.70 1 LOGAN, WV
EASTRIDGE HEALTH SYSTEMS 165.00 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
FORENSIC PSYCHIATRY PLLC 3,800.00 2 HUNTINGTON, WV
GAUT WILLIAM T 875.00 1 NAPLES, FLGREENBAUM STEVEN A ESQ ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 403.87 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
HANNA DARREN J 1,942.80 1 WELLSBURG, WV
HENDRICKS PETER A 1,651.87 1 MADISON, WV
HERRON‐RICE TRACY P 192.50 1 MARTINSBURG, WVHINCHMAN HARRY DAVID 3,150.00 1 HUNTINGTON, WV
KENTUCKY MEDICAL SERVICES FOUNDATION INC 4,900.00 1 LEXINGTON, KY
KRADEL PAUL F 9,012.50 2 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WV
LANE INVESTIGATIONS LLC 3,437.20 1 GRAYSON, KY
LAW‐SCIENCE TECHNOLOGIES INC 1,500.00 1 WEST MILTON, OH
LEGAL SCIENCE 7,400.00 2 CHARLESTON, WV
MAY KAREN L LLC 9,250.00 1 FREDERICK, MD
MCCAMIC SACCO & MCCOID PLLC 13,573.42 2 WHEELING, WV
* MILLS KEVIN D & ASSOCIATES PLLC 700.35 1 MARTINSBURG, WV
ROGERSON INVESTIGATIONS LLC 2,141.24 1 POMPANO BEACH, FL
SAAR PSYCHOLOGICAL GROUP PLLC 3,600.00 1 SOUTH CHARLESTON, WV
UNIVERSITY HEALTH ASSOCIATES 8,000.00 1 MORGANTOWN, WVWARSHAW ENGINEERING 1,400.00 1 CATONSVILLE, MD
WECHT CYRIL H & PATHOLOGY ASSOCIATES INC 7,000.00 1 PITTSBURGH, PA
WHEELER ANDREW 7,000.00 1 BECKLEY, WV
WYATT WILLIAM J 600.00 1 HURRICANE, WV
ROJAS VOUCHER TOTAL 101,957.45 30
* Using third party financing.
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL, DIRECT EXPENSES, AND ROJAS VOUCHERS
ALPHABETICAL ORDERRojas Vouchers
FY2015 Annual Report Page 188 of 212
FY20
14FY
2013
FY20
12O
FFIC
E#
OF
ATTY
STO
TAL
$#
OF
CLAI
MS
AVER
AGE
TOTA
L $
TOTA
L $
TOTA
L $
LOCA
TIO
N
HARV
EY &
JAN
UTO
LO4
282,
225.
50
321
879.
21
20
2,77
8.50
20
3,95
3.00
13
1,44
0.50
BL
UEF
IELD
, WV
HAGE
R N
ATAL
IE82
,202
.00
142
578.
89
61
,419
.00
64,5
68.0
0
46
,085
.00
HARV
EY H
ENRY
71,9
17.0
0
83
86
6.47
31,7
83.0
0
55
,365
.00
29,6
00.0
0
HA
RVEY
JOSE
PH12
2,56
8.50
92
1,
332.
27
109,
576.
50
83,7
43.0
0
53
,471
.50
JAN
UTO
LO T
HOM
AS5,
538.
00
4
1,
384.
50
-
27
7.00
2,28
4.00
LA
W O
FFIC
ES O
F N
ANN
ERS
& W
ILLE
TT L
C3
277,
682.
00
422
658.
01
21
3,62
5.50
19
9,88
2.00
22
2,13
1.00
BU
CKHA
NN
ON
, WV
FLAN
IGAN
CHR
ISTI
NA
99,6
71.5
0
18
3
54
4.65
68,1
13.5
0
64
,374
.00
46,0
18.5
0
N
ANN
ERS
STEV
EN91
,528
.00
100
915.
28
86
,819
.00
89,5
56.5
0
11
8,16
3.00
W
ILLE
TT D
ENN
IS86
,482
.50
139
622.
18
58
,693
.00
45,9
51.5
0
57
,949
.50
LAW
OFF
ICE
OF
DAN
IEL
R G
RIN
DO P
LLC
225
4,04
7.60
18
9
1,
344.
17
242,
329.
00
167,
513.
50
150,
341.
50
GAS
SAW
AY, W
VAR
MST
RON
G DA
NIE
L11
4,32
1.59
70
1,
633.
17
83,4
46.5
0
32
,508
.50
821.
50
GR
INDO
DAN
IEL
139,
726.
01
119
1,17
4.17
15
8,88
2.50
13
5,00
5.00
14
9,52
0.00
SA
L SE
LLAR
O T
HORN
CU
LPEP
PER
LEG
AL G
ROU
P PL
LC7
217,
699.
00
457
476.
37
21
1,53
0.20
12
1,25
3.00
17
,814
.00
MO
RGAN
TOW
N, W
VAN
DERS
ON
DAV
ID71
,085
.00
257
276.
60
76
,186
.70
63,1
82.0
0
-
ASH
GABR
IELL
E-
-
-
38
5.50
-
-
BRO
OKS
PAT
RICK
-
-
-
14,1
98.0
0
88
7.50
-
DA
NFO
RD JO
HN80
,415
.00
93
864.
68
38
,459
.50
34,6
09.0
0
17
,639
.50
SAL
NAT
ALIE
3,42
3.50
8
427.
94
33
,951
.50
15,4
05.5
0
-
SHEE
TS JO
SHU
A-
-
-
15
,884
.00
5,91
4.00
17
4.50
STO
UT
MAT
THEW
14,7
71.0
0
29
50
9.34
5,71
9.50
56
5.00
-
TH
ORN
MAT
THEW
4,87
1.50
8
608.
94
2,
809.
50
-
-
VON
DO
LTER
EN M
ARGA
RET
42,2
69.5
0
57
74
1.57
23,9
36.0
0
69
0.00
-
W
ILLI
AMS
ASHL
EY86
3.50
5
17
2.70
-
-
-
M
OU
NTA
INEE
R LE
GAL
SER
VICE
S PL
LC2
194,
865.
00
400
487.
16
16
4,53
9.00
20
6,16
8.50
16
0,10
8.00
G
RAFT
ON
, WV
IAPA
LUCC
I ALL
ISO
N70
,984
.50
236
300.
78
62
,662
.50
71,7
81.5
0
71
,123
.00
NEL
SON
MAR
Y12
3,88
0.50
16
4
75
5.37
101,
876.
50
134,
387.
00
88,9
85.0
0
VI
CTO
R VI
CTO
R &
HEL
GO
E LL
P3
190,
962.
50
292
653.
98
22
4,45
7.50
19
4,10
7.52
18
7,94
8.50
CH
ARLE
STO
N, W
VHE
LGO
E BA
RRO
N8,
034.
50
37
217.
15
2,
230.
00
7,62
6.00
13
,275
.00
VICT
OR
JEN
NIF
ER66
,140
.50
77
858.
97
68
,712
.00
77,7
60.0
2
91
,140
.00
VICT
OR
MAT
THEW
116,
787.
50
178
656.
11
15
3,51
5.00
10
8,72
1.50
83
,533
.50
JACO
VETT
Y G
ERAL
D G
JR L
C1
183,
792.
50
297
618.
83
16
1,03
6.00
24
6,83
7.00
16
6,81
2.00
W
HEEL
ING
, WV
RUTH
LAW
OFF
ICES
PLL
C1
182,
334.
50
229
796.
22
19
8,21
9.00
19
3,50
1.00
12
4,97
6.50
CH
ARLE
STO
N, W
VLA
W O
FFIC
E O
F DA
VID
B KE
LLEY
118
1,63
4.00
26
9
67
5.22
142,
748.
50
171,
818.
50
169,
089.
00
BLU
EFIE
LD, V
AM
OFF
ATT
CHRI
STO
PHER
G1
165,
409.
24
139
1,18
9.99
19
8,15
1.00
19
8,31
6.00
18
4,47
3.00
CH
ARLE
STO
N, W
V
FY20
15
PUBL
IC D
EFEN
DER
SERV
ICES
TOP
100
HIG
HEST
CO
MPE
NSA
TED
APPO
INTE
D CO
UN
SEL
PAYE
E/AT
TORN
EY
FY2015 Annual Report Page 189 of 212
FY20
14FY
2013
FY20
12O
FFIC
E#
OF
ATTY
STO
TAL
$#
OF
CLAI
MS
AVER
AGE
TOTA
L $
TOTA
L $
TOTA
L $
LOCA
TIO
N
FY20
15
PUBL
IC D
EFEN
DER
SERV
ICES
TOP
100
HIG
HEST
CO
MPE
NSA
TED
APPO
INTE
D CO
UN
SEL
PAYE
E/AT
TORN
EY
CHIL
DLAW
SER
VICE
S IN
C4
162,
298.
00
191
849.
73
10
5,80
7.00
10
3,93
0.00
11
3,55
0.50
PR
INCE
TON
, WV
ALVA
REZ
JEN
NIF
ER54
,615
.50
74
738.
05
3,
904.
50
-
-
BON
D W
ALLA
CE C
ATHE
RIN
E58
,790
.50
57
1,03
1.41
62
,900
.00
4,79
4.00
-
CRES
CITE
LLI T
ODD
-
-
-
-
-
13,2
18.0
0
ES
TEP-
MO
RGAN
MAL
ORI
E45
,490
.50
58
784.
32
-
-
-
HUSO
N A
LLIS
ON
-
-
-
38,2
60.0
0
27
,239
.50
1,39
8.00
LY
NCH
JULI
E3,
401.
50
2
1,
700.
75
742.
50
71
,896
.50
98,9
34.5
0
M
ON
TGO
MER
Y ST
EPHE
N-
-
-
-
-
-
SHER
MAN
LAW
REN
CE E
JR L
C2
156,
628.
50
248
631.
57
12
8,98
1.00
16
1,81
8.50
12
4,73
7.00
RO
MN
EY, W
VSH
ERM
AN L
AWRE
NCE
E JR
59,3
92.5
0
97
61
2.29
56,6
27.0
0
69
,518
.50
55,5
06.5
0
VA
NCE
BRI
AN97
,236
.00
151
643.
95
72
,354
.00
92,3
00.0
0
69
,230
.50
WIE
DEL
DIAN
A CA
RTER
115
4,49
4.50
13
2
1,
170.
41
115,
843.
00
151,
337.
00
106,
260.
50
WIL
LIAM
SON
, WV
CAST
EEL
& A
LLEN
DER
PLLC
215
3,70
4.50
14
7
1,
045.
61
223,
695.
00
209,
423.
00
148,
357.
00
KIN
GW
OO
D, W
VAL
LEN
DER
MEG
AN74
,008
.50
60
1,23
3.48
79
,957
.50
92,1
61.0
0
36
,041
.00
CAST
EEL
CHAE
LYN
79,6
96.0
0
87
91
6.05
143,
737.
50
117,
262.
00
112,
316.
00
WHI
TEM
AN B
URD
ETTE
PLL
C2
146,
712.
50
326
450.
04
14
4,67
0.00
15
0,08
9.00
11
8,72
8.50
FA
IRM
ON
T, W
VDA
NFO
RD R
OBY
N76
,294
.50
161
473.
88
81
,052
.00
78,6
60.0
0
59
,700
.50
MIN
UTE
LLI M
ICHE
LLE
70,4
18.0
0
16
5
42
6.78
63,6
18.0
0
70
,853
.00
58,0
58.5
0
W
HITE
MAN
FRA
NCE
S C
-
-
-
-
57
6.00
969.
50
DA
NIE
L S
CORE
Y1
146,
537.
00
121
1,21
1.05
13
2,89
1.00
14
2,48
8.00
12
0,11
2.00
PO
CA, W
VRO
CCO
E M
AZZE
I1
144,
748.
00
100
1,44
7.48
99
,944
.50
94,9
38.5
0
10
8,84
0.50
CL
ARKS
BURG
, WV
RUM
ORA
& R
UM
ORA
LC
214
2,94
8.50
20
0
71
4.74
18,9
31.0
0
22
,330
.50
4,10
4.50
W
ILLI
AMSO
N, W
VRU
MO
RA M
ARSH
A10
5,56
1.50
12
6
83
7.79
-
-
-
RU
MO
RA R
ON
ALD
37,3
87.0
0
74
50
5.23
18,9
31.0
0
22
,330
.50
4,10
4.50
KU
RELA
C LA
W O
FFIC
E PL
LC2
142,
891.
00
108
1,32
3.06
25
6,90
8.64
20
5,63
2.50
12
3,21
0.50
M
OU
NDS
VILL
E, W
VKU
RELA
C PA
TRIC
IA52
,061
.50
48
1,08
4.61
12
0,86
2.00
93
,665
.00
47,7
48.5
0
KU
RELA
C PE
TER
90,8
29.5
0
60
1,
513.
83
136,
046.
64
111,
967.
50
75,4
62.0
0
FL
INCH
UM
R K
EITH
114
1,33
5.50
33
0
42
8.29
206,
524.
50
218,
647.
00
211,
889.
50
PRIN
CETO
N, W
VM
ICHA
EL R
WHI
TT1
141,
062.
00
53
2,66
1.55
11
5,55
5.00
13
9,65
1.00
12
3,21
2.00
LE
WIS
BURG
, WV
SHAR
ON
K C
HILD
ERS
114
1,00
9.00
12
6
1,
119.
12
103,
474.
50
117,
513.
00
119,
575.
00
CHAR
LEST
ON
, WV
EVAN
S TH
OM
AS H
ANN
A PL
LC1
140,
220.
00
125
1,12
1.76
11
8,95
0.00
11
8,59
3.50
11
4,59
2.50
O
CEAN
A, W
VW
INDO
M L
AW O
FFIC
ES P
LLC
313
7,63
9.50
11
3
1,
218.
05
117,
192.
50
97,5
76.5
0
84
,158
.00
HARR
ISVI
LLE,
WV
MO
RRIS
ON
PAU
L V
II52
,964
.50
46
1,15
1.40
60
,227
.00
48,0
05.5
0
41
,356
.50
WIN
DOM
RO
DNEY
41,1
78.5
0
25
1,
647.
14
21,9
59.0
0
21
,279
.50
14,2
35.5
0
W
INDO
M S
COTT
43,4
96.5
0
42
1,
035.
63
35,0
06.5
0
28
,291
.50
28,5
66.0
0
FY2015 Annual Report Page 190 of 212
FY20
14FY
2013
FY20
12O
FFIC
E#
OF
ATTY
STO
TAL
$#
OF
CLAI
MS
AVER
AGE
TOTA
L $
TOTA
L $
TOTA
L $
LOCA
TIO
N
FY20
15
PUBL
IC D
EFEN
DER
SERV
ICES
TOP
100
HIG
HEST
CO
MPE
NSA
TED
APPO
INTE
D CO
UN
SEL
PAYE
E/AT
TORN
EY
WIL
LIAM
B S
UM
MER
S2
136,
936.
00
566
241.
94
13
9,14
4.50
17
6,13
0.00
32
6,51
5.50
PA
RKER
SBU
RG, W
VAH
LBO
RN C
OU
RTN
EY L
-
-
-
-
1,
719.
50
97,4
70.0
0
BO
NO
VITC
H RO
BIN
91,5
04.0
0
39
1
23
4.03
75,8
36.0
0
90
,369
.00
123,
864.
00
SUM
MER
S W
ILLI
AM B
45,4
32.0
0
17
5
25
9.61
63,3
08.5
0
84
,041
.50
105,
181.
50
ESCU
E LA
W O
FFIC
E4
135,
558.
50
231
586.
83
16
1,90
0.50
15
4,58
9.00
97
,838
.50
HURR
ICAN
E, W
VCH
APM
AN N
ATE
30,4
42.0
0
83
36
6.77
1,23
0.00
-
-
ES
CUE
BRYA
N95
,119
.00
135
704.
59
11
0,60
6.00
90
,365
.50
60,4
37.0
0
PR
ITT
ALAN
L-
-
-
-
-
17
,287
.50
PRIT
T JU
STIN
8,37
1.00
11
76
1.00
20,8
59.5
0
38
,884
.50
18,9
45.0
0
SU
NYO
G EL
IZAB
ETH
1,62
6.50
2
813.
25
29
,205
.00
25,3
39.0
0
1,
169.
00
WIL
LIAM
T R
ICE
113
2,95
2.00
69
1,
926.
84
89,3
81.5
0
17
3,39
4.00
72
,911
.50
MAR
TIN
SBU
RG, W
VBL
ACKW
ATER
LAW
PLL
C2
131,
926.
00
220
599.
66
68
,549
.50
-
-
KIN
GW
OO
D, W
VCO
OPE
R CH
RIST
OPH
ER39
,563
.50
41
964.
96
57
,487
.50
-
-
COO
PER
JERE
MY
92,3
62.5
0
17
9
51
5.99
11,0
62.0
0
-
-
LA
CARI
A PH
ILIP
A1
129,
542.
50
109
1,18
8.46
10
0,05
7.50
12
7,60
0.00
98
,517
.50
WEL
CH, W
VG
ARRE
TT &
GAR
RETT
312
9,47
7.00
14
3
90
5.43
140,
872.
30
158,
987.
50
159,
015.
50
MO
ORE
FIEL
D, W
VBR
ILL
JON
ATHA
N-
-
-
-
-
19
,835
.00
GARR
ETT
KARE
N69
,155
.50
78
886.
61
59
,598
.50
80,7
48.5
0
67
,856
.00
GARR
ETT
LARY
57,1
33.0
0
60
95
2.22
81,2
73.8
0
78
,239
.00
71,3
24.5
0
O
RNDO
RFF
JOSH
UA
3,18
8.50
5
637.
70
-
-
-
CON
LEY
LAW
OFF
ICE
PLLC
412
7,54
8.50
24
0
53
1.45
127,
073.
00
15,1
77.0
0
-
PARK
ERSB
URG
, WV
BRU
NIC
ARDI
-DO
SS A
NGE
LA58
,164
.00
78
745.
69
53
,510
.50
12,3
65.0
0
-
CON
LEY
GIN
NY
781.
00
2
390.
50
-
1,88
1.50
-
HUDS
ON
BLA
IRE
31,5
59.0
0
52
60
6.90
39,1
73.0
0
93
0.50
-
SN
ODG
RASS
LO
RA37
,044
.50
108
343.
00
34
,389
.50
-
-
ERIC
K P
OW
ELL
112
6,52
4.00
23
6
53
6.12
91,7
98.5
0
15
1,72
0.00
11
0,14
9.00
PA
RKER
SBU
RG, W
VSC
ALES
LAW
OFF
ICE
112
3,97
2.00
58
2,
137.
45
97,4
37.5
0
62
,001
.50
78,4
22.5
0
M
ARTI
NSB
URG
, WV
CHAR
LES
R HA
MIL
TON
112
2,32
3.50
18
6
65
7.65
113,
219.
00
106,
615.
50
112,
968.
00
CHAR
LEST
ON
, WV
HERB
ERT
L HI
VELY
112
1,56
9.50
24
5
49
6.20
90,1
06.5
0
10
1,40
5.00
76
,722
.50
CHAR
LEST
ON
, WV
COO
KE M
ICHA
EL P
111
9,24
9.00
40
4
29
5.17
157,
291.
95
128,
654.
00
108,
474.
50
BLU
EFIE
LD, W
VHU
GHA
RT L
AW O
FFIC
E1
119,
014.
00
136
875.
10
15
1,94
3.50
10
6,35
4.50
66
,267
.00
SISS
ON
VILL
E, W
VAD
KIN
S DR
ANN
ON
L-
-
-
29
,838
.00
6,50
1.50
4,
196.
00
HUGH
ART
KEVI
N W
119,
014.
00
136
875.
10
12
2,10
5.50
99
,853
.00
62,0
71.0
0
JA
MEL
LA L
LO
CKW
OO
D1
118,
362.
00
160
739.
76
72
,013
.00
4,43
3.00
-
BUCK
HAN
NO
N, W
VL
SCO
TT B
RISC
OE
111
6,29
2.00
23
8
48
8.62
132,
008.
00
121,
505.
00
137,
757.
00
HUN
TIN
GTO
N, W
V
FY2015 Annual Report Page 191 of 212
FY20
14FY
2013
FY20
12O
FFIC
E#
OF
ATTY
STO
TAL
$#
OF
CLAI
MS
AVER
AGE
TOTA
L $
TOTA
L $
TOTA
L $
LOCA
TIO
N
FY20
15
PUBL
IC D
EFEN
DER
SERV
ICES
TOP
100
HIG
HEST
CO
MPE
NSA
TED
APPO
INTE
D CO
UN
SEL
PAYE
E/AT
TORN
EY
JOHN
M T
HOM
PSO
N1
114,
666.
50
206
556.
63
88
,410
.50
90,3
39.5
0
52
,466
.00
HUN
TIN
GTO
N, W
VG
ERN
EST
SKAG
GS
111
4,08
9.00
82
1,
391.
33
209,
737.
00
223,
798.
50
119,
372.
50
FAYE
TTEV
ILLE
, WV
MO
RGAN
E L
AVO
YD JR
& A
SSO
CIAT
ES L
C2
113,
128.
50
96
1,17
8.42
47
,644
.00
46,0
00.5
0
45
,570
.50
LEW
ISBU
RG, W
VM
ILLE
R RA
NDY
K-
-
-
-
-
99
.00
MO
RGAN
E L
AVO
YD JR
91,3
95.5
0
77
1,
186.
95
47,4
53.0
0
46
,000
.50
45,4
71.5
0
PE
TTIJO
HN D
ENIS
E21
,733
.00
19
1,14
3.84
19
1.00
-
-
COLL
INS
LAW
FIR
M1
112,
649.
00
193
583.
67
72
,369
.50
80,5
57.5
0
28
,876
.50
KEYS
ER, W
VLA
W O
FFIC
E O
F RE
BECC
A S
JOHN
SON
111
1,15
2.00
19
6
56
7.10
62,8
45.0
0
66
,092
.00
13,2
92.5
0
CH
ARLE
STO
N, W
VCO
URT
RIG
HT L
AW O
FFIC
ES P
LLC
111
0,15
2.50
19
4
56
7.80
143,
515.
50
104,
835.
50
95,4
65.0
0
HU
RRIC
ANE,
WV
REDD
ING
R S
TEVE
N A
TTO
RNEY
AT
LAW
PLL
C1
109,
903.
50
69
1,59
2.80
10
0,67
9.62
21
,585
.00
1,95
0.00
M
ARTI
NSB
URG
, WV
STAR
CHER
& F
RUM
PLL
C2
109,
782.
00
223
492.
30
10
9,89
9.00
15
0,61
3.50
12
7,40
3.00
PA
RKER
SBU
RG, W
VFR
UM
G B
RADL
EY54
,917
.00
116
473.
42
49
,199
.50
76,3
57.0
0
64
,947
.50
STAR
CHER
HEA
THER
54,8
65.0
0
10
7
51
2.76
60,6
99.5
0
74
,256
.50
62,4
55.5
0
LA
W O
FFIC
E O
F FO
LICK
MAN
& T
URK
ETT
PLLC
210
9,38
6.00
13
1
83
5.01
137,
640.
00
177,
259.
95
79,5
75.0
0
FA
IRM
ON
T, W
VFO
LICK
MAN
PAM
ELA
33,2
72.5
0
34
97
8.60
36,3
58.5
0
31
,937
.50
30,0
27.0
0
RI
BEL
KATI
CA-
-
-
81
9.00
60,3
00.0
0
2,
365.
00
TURK
ETT
HOLL
Y76
,113
.50
97
784.
68
10
0,46
2.50
85
,022
.45
47,1
83.0
0
HA
SSAN
LAW
OFF
ICE
110
9,18
0.00
89
1,
226.
74
121,
387.
50
53,4
71.5
0
63
,407
.50
WEL
CH, W
VFR
ANCE
S C
WHI
TEM
AN1
108,
502.
00
113
960.
19
64
,135
.50
66,6
20.5
0
53
,669
.00
FAIR
MO
NT,
WV
DAN
FORD
RO
BYN
-
-
-
-
35
6.50
-
M
INU
TELL
I MIC
HELL
E-
-
-
-
-
95
2.50
WHI
TEM
AN F
RAN
CES
108,
502.
00
113
960.
19
64
,135
.50
66,2
64.0
0
52
,716
.50
KEIT
H W
HITE
110
8,38
8.50
27
6
39
2.71
108,
096.
50
141,
469.
50
45,3
95.5
0
SA
INT
MAR
YS, W
VM
OSE
S JO
SEPH
J1
107,
795.
00
53
2,03
3.87
18
6,65
9.50
11
6,44
8.50
98
,020
.50
WHE
ELIN
G, W
VHI
LL JO
HNSO
N L
AW P
LLC
110
6,90
3.50
97
1,
102.
10
114,
320.
00
106,
992.
50
86,0
63.0
0
BE
LIN
GTO
N, W
VED
WAR
D RE
BRO
OK
III1
104,
820.
50
149
703.
49
97
,240
.00
84,2
74.0
0
71
,138
.00
CHAR
LEST
ON
, WV
SAAD
DIX
ON
LAW
OFF
ICE
PLLC
210
4,68
0.50
23
7
44
1.69
133,
089.
00
63,4
26.0
0
55
,204
.50
HUN
TIN
GTO
N, W
VLY
NCH
JEN
NIF
ER6,
317.
50
8
78
9.69
-
-
-
SA
AD A
BRAH
AM98
,363
.00
229
429.
53
13
3,08
9.00
63
,426
.00
55,2
04.5
0
W
ILLI
AMS
JOHN
E JR
110
4,60
8.00
14
5
72
1.43
86,0
75.0
0
12
1,63
2.00
63
,166
.50
PRIN
CETO
N, W
VN
EISW
ON
GER
& W
HITE
210
3,29
2.00
23
8
43
4.00
105,
777.
50
111,
174.
50
90,3
04.5
0
M
OU
NDS
VILL
E, W
VN
EISW
ON
GER
KEVI
N64
,130
.50
124
517.
18
51
,238
.50
40,3
79.5
0
46
,941
.00
WHI
TE D
AVID
39,1
61.5
0
11
4
34
3.52
54,5
39.0
0
70
,795
.00
43,3
63.5
0
W
ELLS
H D
ILLO
N1
103,
256.
50
173
596.
86
11
5,70
2.50
11
7,16
0.00
13
1,37
4.50
PA
RKER
SBU
RG, W
V
FY2015 Annual Report Page 192 of 212
FY20
14FY
2013
FY20
12O
FFIC
E#
OF
ATTY
STO
TAL
$#
OF
CLAI
MS
AVER
AGE
TOTA
L $
TOTA
L $
TOTA
L $
LOCA
TIO
N
FY20
15
PUBL
IC D
EFEN
DER
SERV
ICES
TOP
100
HIG
HEST
CO
MPE
NSA
TED
APPO
INTE
D CO
UN
SEL
PAYE
E/AT
TORN
EY
LUPA
RDU
S LA
W O
FFIC
E2
100,
090.
00
207
483.
53
10
9,41
9.50
11
9,67
0.00
12
5,33
2.50
PI
NEV
ILLE
, WV
BON
INSE
GNA
SAN
TE JR
2,44
5.50
1
2,44
5.50
-
62,3
56.0
0
53
,997
.00
LUPA
RDU
S TI
MO
THY
97,6
44.5
0
20
6
47
4.00
109,
419.
50
57,3
14.0
0
71
,335
.50
TRAC
IE L
GRE
ENE
199
,720
.50
172
579.
77
91
,933
.50
110,
660.
50
88,7
39.0
0
DA
LLAS
, TX
CORN
ETTE
LAW
PLL
C1
98,4
90.0
0
18
4
53
5.27
84,8
75.0
0
10
,949
.50
-
W
ESTO
N, W
VBE
LLO
MY
& T
URN
ER L
C3
98,3
54.5
0
26
3
37
3.97
123,
441.
00
106,
357.
00
68,3
53.0
0
HU
NTI
NG
TON
, WV
BART
RAM
SHA
WN
59,3
75.0
0
11
4
52
0.83
74,5
46.0
0
58
,755
.00
15,5
20.0
0
BE
LLO
MY
D SC
OTT
7,40
4.50
21
35
2.60
12,4
22.0
0
8,
182.
50
10,4
86.5
0
TU
RNER
RYA
N31
,575
.00
128
246.
68
36
,473
.00
39,4
19.5
0
42
,346
.50
MAR
K D
PAN
EPIN
TO1
97,7
45.0
0
34
2,
874.
85
69,7
84.0
0
40
,501
.00
16,2
95.5
0
W
HEEL
ING
, WV
MAG
ANN
LAW
OFF
ICE
PLLC
195
,475
.00
251
380.
38
69
,579
.50
107,
030.
00
123,
754.
00
BLU
EFIE
LD, W
VM
AGAN
N M
ICHA
EL95
,475
.00
251
380.
38
69
,579
.50
100,
453.
50
110,
699.
00
WIL
LIAM
SON
JAN
ET C
-
-
-
-
6,
576.
50
13,0
55.0
0
YO
UN
G W
ILLI
AM P
REN
TICE
194
,319
.00
12
7,85
9.92
10
7,92
5.00
11
5,58
2.50
16
2,74
7.00
M
ARTI
NSB
URG
, WV
HUN
TER
D SI
MM
ON
S1
94,1
91.0
0
35
6
26
4.58
70,5
21.1
0
87
,614
.00
89,0
97.5
0
BU
CKHA
NN
ON
, WV
ERIC
A BR
ANN
ON
GU
NN
ATT
AT
LAW
PLL
C1
93,2
79.5
0
22
8
40
9.12
63,6
73.0
0
24
,610
.50
20,3
23.5
0
SP
ENCE
R, W
VTR
ACY
WEE
SE1
91,9
76.5
0
24
3,
832.
35
46,4
54.5
0
96
,681
.00
53,1
59.0
0
SH
EPHE
RDST
OW
N, W
VAN
DREW
B C
HATT
IN1
91,4
71.5
0
95
96
2.86
63,7
59.0
0
70
,018
.50
35,2
36.0
0
CH
ARLE
STO
N, W
VLA
W F
IRM
OF
TERE
SA C
MO
NK
191
,040
.50
126
722.
54
13
,260
.50
-
-
WAL
TON
, WV
BRYA
N S
HIN
KLE
188
,639
.50
156
568.
20
58
,196
.50
52,1
91.5
0
4,
554.
00
BUCK
HAN
NO
N, W
VJO
HN C
LARK
AN
DERS
ON
187
,955
.50
163
539.
60
75
,138
.50
81,7
52.5
0
47
,409
.50
L EW
ISBU
RG, W
VLA
W F
IRM
OF
A JO
SEPH
MU
NO
Z1
87,4
64.0
0
11
0
79
5.13
87,3
52.0
0
85
,099
.50
53,1
68.5
0
PA
RKER
SBU
RG, W
VDA
VID
L O
RNDO
RFF
187
,033
.50
77
1,13
0.31
31
,049
.00
31,7
85.0
0
26
,061
.50
BUCK
HAN
NO
N, W
VSH
AW &
SHA
W L
C1
86,2
24.5
0
17
7
48
7.14
98,1
21.5
0
12
1,97
0.00
72
,724
.50
POIN
T PL
EASA
NT,
WV
SHAW
MIC
HAEL
86,2
24.5
0
17
7
48
7.14
98,1
21.5
0
91
,765
.00
63,1
41.5
0
TA
TTER
SON
R C
RAIG
-
-
-
-
30
,205
.00
9,58
3.00
SO
UTH
ERN
WV
LAW
CLI
NIC
185
,933
.50
130
661.
03
68
,061
.00
65,8
00.5
0
52
,636
.50
BECK
LEY,
WV
MCG
RAW
LAW
OFF
ICES
185
,890
.00
98
876.
43
40
,195
.00
42,5
16.0
0
91
,395
.00
PRO
SPER
ITY,
WV
BURL
ESO
N JO
HN T
-
-
-
2,16
3.00
69
8.50
-
M
CGRA
W W
ARRE
N II
85,8
90.0
0
98
87
6.43
38,0
32.0
0
41
,817
.50
91,3
95.0
0
LA
W O
FFIC
E O
F N
ICHO
LAS
FORR
EST
COLV
IN E
SQ P
LLC
185
,682
.50
102
840.
02
12
8,84
3.50
15
9,01
7.50
82
,907
.50
MAR
TIN
SBU
RG, W
VG
UN
NO
E LA
W O
FFIC
E2
85,4
48.5
0
17
0
50
2.64
57,4
14.0
0
67
,339
.50
66,3
93.0
0
HI
NTO
N, W
VFR
EEM
AN S
HERR
I49
,036
.00
104
471.
50
31
,912
.00
33,6
06.0
0
30
,690
.50
GUN
NO
E RI
CHAR
D36
,412
.50
66
551.
70
25
,502
.00
33,7
33.5
0
35
,702
.50
NES
SEL
LAW
FIR
M1
85,3
69.5
0
59
1,
446.
94
45,1
16.5
0
37
,621
.50
73,2
27.0
0
HU
NTI
NG
TON
, WV
FY2015 Annual Report Page 193 of 212
FY20
14FY
2013
FY20
12O
FFIC
E#
OF
ATTY
STO
TAL
$#
OF
CLAI
MS
AVER
AGE
TOTA
L $
TOTA
L $
TOTA
L $
LOCA
TIO
N
FY20
15
PUBL
IC D
EFEN
DER
SERV
ICES
TOP
100
HIG
HEST
CO
MPE
NSA
TED
APPO
INTE
D CO
UN
SEL
PAYE
E/AT
TORN
EY
L VI
CTO
R N
AVY
185
,288
.00
132
646.
12
66
,841
.00
69,5
96.0
0
50
,919
.00
BARB
OU
RSVI
LLE,
WV
BULL
MAN
& B
ULL
MAN
284
,372
.50
108
781.
23
10
6,00
6.00
49
,687
.50
76,4
46.0
0
CH
ARLE
STO
N, W
VBU
LLM
AN E
DWAR
D59
,985
.50
83
722.
72
56
,876
.50
44,0
57.0
0
59
,604
.00
BULL
MAN
SAN
DRA
24,3
87.0
0
25
97
5.48
49,1
29.5
0
5,
630.
50
16,8
42.0
0
TI
MO
THY
H PR
ENTI
CE1
83,7
80.5
0
13
0
64
4.47
82,2
54.7
0
69
,972
.50
44,5
96.5
0
EL
KIN
S, W
VPR
ITT
& P
RITT
PLL
C2
83,7
30.0
0
12
8
65
4.14
45,6
32.0
0
14
,978
.50
11,2
53.5
0
CH
ARLE
STO
N, W
VPR
ITT
CHRI
STO
PHER
33,6
11.0
0
52
64
6.37
29,1
43.0
0
14
,978
.50
7,22
4.50
PR
ITT
KELL
Y50
,119
.00
76
659.
46
16
,489
.00
-
4,
029.
00
LEFL
ER &
BO
GG
S PL
LC2
83,3
71.0
0
72
1,
157.
93
38,7
42.5
0
33
,825
.00
39,6
65.0
0
BE
CKLE
Y, W
VBO
GGS
LEFL
ER L
EIGH
42,8
98.0
0
31
1,
383.
81
17,8
79.0
0
17
,207
.00
20,6
23.5
0
LE
FLER
CHR
ISTO
PHER
40,4
73.0
0
41
98
7.15
20,8
63.5
0
16
,618
.00
19,0
41.5
0
KE
VIN
C D
UFF
Y1
81,0
70.5
0
19
4,
266.
87
21,7
38.0
0
16
,190
.50
28,4
47.5
0
CL
AY, W
VPU
LLIN
FO
WLE
R FL
ANAG
AN B
ROW
N &
PO
E PL
LC9
80,8
47.0
0
30
5
26
5.07
56,4
00.0
0
68
,295
.00
62,2
49.5
0
CH
ARLE
STO
N, W
VBU
RNS
DAN
IEL
12,2
57.5
0
30
40
8.58
4,76
6.50
-
-
BU
RTO
N A
SHLE
Y K
-
-
-
-
27
9.00
731.
00
CA
LHO
UN
JON
ATHA
N-
-
-
-
6,41
4.50
-
CHAP
MAN
MAR
Y BE
TH10
,333
.50
65
158.
98
6,
809.
50
8,20
6.50
4,
812.
50
GRAY
KEL
BY T
HOM
AS-
-
-
-
-
1,
943.
50
HARK
INS
JAN
E7,
552.
50
54
139.
86
10
,042
.50
12,6
72.0
0
15
,769
.00
JUST
ICE
ASHL
EY5,
101.
00
15
340.
07
2,
460.
00
3,72
7.50
7,
300.
00
LEM
LEY
COU
RTN
EY22
,295
.50
72
309.
66
15
,802
.00
1,43
2.50
-
LILL
Y EM
ILY
-
-
-
-
1,
038.
50
751.
50
M
CCU
LLO
CH C
OLL
EEN
1,55
9.50
9
173.
28
5,
036.
50
20,4
70.5
0
16
,286
.50
MU
LDO
ON
JAM
ES-
-
-
-
405.
00
-
ROBI
NSO
N K
EVIN
13,8
42.5
0
20
69
2.13
8,60
2.00
12
,939
.50
14,6
55.5
0
U
NDE
RWO
OD
JARE
D7,
405.
50
38
194.
88
1,
936.
50
-
-
UN
DERW
OO
D PO
E M
OLL
Y49
9.50
2
24
9.75
944.
50
70
9.50
-
N
OLA
N L
AW F
IRM
180
,790
.00
231
349.
74
10
1,42
0.00
91
,002
.50
46,0
17.0
0
LA
VALE
TTE,
WV
MU
LLEN
S &
MU
LLEN
S PL
LC3
80,5
35.0
0
20
5
39
2.85
99,8
04.0
0
95
,448
.50
6,35
0.00
PH
ILIP
PI, W
VM
OYE
DAV
ID13
,667
.00
29
471.
28
-
-
-
HELM
ICK
JUST
INA
78,1
05.0
0
19
7
39
6.47
99,8
04.0
0
95
,448
.50
6,35
0.00
HO
XIE
THO
MAS
2,43
0.00
8
303.
75
-
-
-
HOLD
REN
JASO
N D
180
,223
.00
94
853.
44
63
,557
.50
60,4
24.5
0
28
,842
.50
GAL
LIPO
LIS,
OH
RODG
ERS
JEFF
REY
S1
79,9
66.5
0
13
6
58
7.99
85,0
18.5
0
79
,258
.50
71,8
67.5
0
LE
WIS
BURG
, WV
JAM
ES T
CAR
EY1
79,4
26.5
0
11
8
67
3.11
70,9
46.5
0
11
6,69
3.50
93
,576
.50
WEI
RTO
N, W
V
FY2015 Annual Report Page 194 of 212
FY20
14FY
2013
FY20
12O
FFIC
E#
OF
ATTY
STO
TAL
$#
OF
CLAI
MS
AVER
AGE
TOTA
L $
TOTA
L $
TOTA
L $
LOCA
TIO
N
FY20
15
PUBL
IC D
EFEN
DER
SERV
ICES
TOP
100
HIG
HEST
CO
MPE
NSA
TED
APPO
INTE
D CO
UN
SEL
PAYE
E/AT
TORN
EY
SCO
TT A
SHO
UG
H1
79,3
95.5
0
13
3
59
6.96
76,8
75.0
0
85
,023
.50
68,9
87.0
0
FA
IRM
ON
T, W
VKE
TTER
ING
DEL
LIG
ATTI
LAW
OFF
ICES
PLL
C2
78,3
48.5
0
12
9
60
7.35
21,9
16.5
0
-
-
FA
IRM
ON
T, W
VDE
LLIG
ATTI
MAT
THEW
54,1
73.0
0
89
60
8.69
12,8
45.0
0
-
-
KE
TTER
ING
PAU
L24
,175
.50
40
604.
39
9,
071.
50
-
-
LAW
OFF
ICE
OF
WAR
D M
ORG
AN1
77,9
74.0
0
82
95
0.90
60,5
51.0
0
34
,197
.50
12,7
71.0
0
BL
UEF
IELD
, WV
SPEN
IA L
AW O
FFIC
E PL
LC1
77,4
07.5
0
87
88
9.74
61,0
49.0
0
16
,847
.00
-
BA
RBO
URS
VILL
E, W
VLA
W O
FFIC
E O
F RO
BBY
N L
ON
G L
C1
77,2
73.0
0
11
6
66
6.15
62,0
39.0
0
62
,418
.50
70,2
26.0
0
HA
MLI
N, W
VJA
SON
S L
ORD
176
,462
.50
83
921.
23
82
,947
.00
48,8
88.0
0
19
,545
.00
CHAR
LEST
ON
, WV
HAYD
EN &
HAR
T PL
LC3
75,6
50.0
0
10
2
74
1.67
90,6
48.0
0
49
,846
.50
46,4
37.5
0
BE
CKLE
Y, W
VEA
STER
AM
BER
37,7
24.5
0
57
66
1.83
52,4
52.5
0
33
,593
.00
34,0
88.0
0
HA
RT D
AVID
S24
,624
.00
29
849.
10
29
,175
.00
10,7
82.5
0
8,
495.
50
HAYD
EN G
ERAL
D13
,301
.50
16
831.
34
9,
020.
50
5,47
1.00
3,
854.
00
KIRK
PATR
ICK
LAW
OFF
ICE
PLLC
175
,407
.50
55
1,37
1.05
94
,380
.00
37,1
51.0
0
7,
391.
50
BECK
LEY,
WV
KIRK
PATR
ICK
DAVI
D75
,407
.50
55
1,37
1.05
48
,883
.50
16,9
30.5
0
7,
391.
50
TAYL
OR
ADAM
-
-
-
45,4
96.5
0
20
,220
.50
-
FY2015 Annual Report Page 195 of 212
Attorney Total TimeJacovetty, Gerald 972.0Skaggs, G. Ernest 876.2Ruth, Ryan 674.9Hughart, Kevin W. 663.5Chattin, Andrew 645.5Monk, Teresa 623.1Cooke, Michael 608.5Kelley, David 552.7Victor, Matthew 518.6Johnson, Rebecca 468.7Moffatt, Christopher 468.1Bonovitch, Robin 467.0Snead, Mary 463.4Alvarez, Jennifer 452.0Gentilozzi, Timothy 445.8Flanigan, Christina 430.4Pritt, Kelly 426.7Cooper, Jeremy 426.0Anderson, John 420.0Magann, Michael 412.9Redding, Robert 399.8Grindo, Daniel 394.3Courtright, Gregory 390.9Willett, Dennis 384.7Evans, Thomas H., III 371.9Ahlborn, Courtney 360.4Orndorff, David 358.3Rodgers, Jeffrey 347.1Escue, Bryan 346.1Morgan, Ward 341.4Hively, Herbert 341.2Dillon, Wells 328.8Cornette, Franklin 328.0Flinchum, R. Keith 320.0Keesee, Ryan 314.7Maier, Andrew 312.4Asbury, Michael 308.4Fittro, Jonathan 303.6Bond Wallace, Catherine 301.8Mancini, Steven 298.2Myers, Jessica 297.5Lord, Jason 297.3Hager, Natalie 296.9Hinkle, Bryan 296.1Hatfield, Karen 294.6French, Elizabeth 290.4Wheeler, Valentina 282.1
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESTOTAL BILLED TRAVEL TIME
FY2015 Annual Report Page 196 of 212
Attorney Total Time
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESTOTAL BILLED TRAVEL TIME
White, Keith 281.1Vance, Brian 280.4Simmons, Hunter 280.2Clyburn, Brent 272.5McGraw, Warren, II 271.4Oshoway, Franklin 267.6Nolan, Raymond 265.5Bayliss, Shawn 257.5Lockwood, Jamella 256.1Hawkins, James 256.0Miller, Christopher 252.7Nanners, Steven 237.3Harsh, Rhonda 229.8Rosinsky, Tim 228.5Morelli, Ann Marie 227.1Mazzei, Rocco 226.1McCoy, James 225.9Gregory, Justin 223.7Estep‐Morgan, Malorie 218.5Spenia, James 216.5Anderson, Eric 214.2Kurelac , Peter 213.4Kirkpatrick, David 210.6Long, Brenden 210.1Bullman, Edward 208.8Jurco, John 205.5Victor, Jennifer 205.2Shumate, Andrew 205.1Gunn, Erica 200.5Morgan, Dennie 199.8McQuade, Ruth 198.2Young, William 198.2Richardson, David 197.5Colvin, Nicholas 195.8Nelson, Jonie 193.7Crawley‐Woods, Ben 193.4Grunau, David 191.4Stewart, Paul 190.9Williams, Trena 189.9Armstrong, Daniel 189.5Long, Robby 185.6Manypenny‐Raines, April 183.9Pritt, Christopher 182.4Alberty, Michael 179.0Powell, Eric 179.0Cromley, Bryan 176.6Bell, Sidney 176.2
FY2015 Annual Report Page 197 of 212
Attorney Total Time
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESTOTAL BILLED TRAVEL TIME
Farnsworth, Michael 175.6Greene, Tracie 173.9Stephens, Richard 172.2Cain, Joshua 170.7Starcher, Heather 169.1Eachus, Michael 167.5Navy, Victor 166.4Neiswonger, Kevin 162.5Howard, Gregory 160.3Casteel, Chaelyn 160.0Wallace , Michael 158.7Rumora, Marsha 158.6Stedman, Jason 157.1Troisi, Joseph 157.0Collins, Agnieszka 155.1Olivero, Noel 154.7Chapman, Nate 153.6Harvey, Joseph 153.2Panepinto, Mark 150.8Cook, Steven 150.1VonDolteren, Margaret 150.0Holroyd, Rick 149.9Danford, John 148.1Brooks, John 147.7White, David 146.2Beckett, Allison 145.1Moses, Joseph 144.6Rice, William 142.6Hamilton, Charles 142.5Sirk, Timothy 141.6Davis, Greta 141.5Rees, James 140.4Sayre, Travis 140.3Gunnoe, Richard 139.8Harper, Seth 139.8Bowers, Jeffrey Stuart, II 138.5Hull, Savannah 137.7Warman, Cheryl L. 137.2Dinardi, Peter 137.0Clevenger, James 136.3Frum, G. Bradley 134.1Dalby, Nancy 133.2Graves, Matthew 133.1Danford, Robyn 132.1Kurelac, Patricia 130.7Bailey, Reggie 129.7Fair, Matthew 129.6
FY2015 Annual Report Page 198 of 212
Attorney Total Time
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESTOTAL BILLED TRAVEL TIME
Brunicardi‐Doss, Angela 129.4Douglass, Ernest 129.2Hoosier, Adrian 128.7Munoz, Joe 128.4Garlow, Richelle 127.5Gutmann, Richard 127.5Summers, William B 126.8Lupardus, Timothy 126.6Crane, Jennifer 125.6Davis, Stephen 125.0Scheetz, Christopher A 125.0Bragg, Steve 124.7Cary, Michael 124.4Garrett, Lary 122.3Ash, Gabrielle 121.9Mascio, David 121.0Baumgartel, Rolf 120.7Wilson, Lauren 119.1Cassell, Paul 118.1Noel, W. Chad 117.1Francis, Eric 115.9Moore, D. Kyle 115.8Pennington, William 115.8Freeman, Sherri 115.6Watson, Kevin John 115.2Wall, Randall 114.5Santer, Joseph 114.1McCullough, Judith 114.0Whiteman, Frances 112.2Nessel, Kerry 111.7Gossett, Randy 111.3LaCaria, Philip 110.5Saad, Abraham 110.0Morgan, E. Lavoyd, Jr. 109.9Hill Johnson, Karen 109.5Houck, G. Todd 107.8Anderson, David 107.5Carey, James 107.5Dean, William 106.8Goad, Jason 106.5Nogay, Cathryn 105.6Helgoe, Barron 105.3Collins, Peggy 105.1Duffy, Kevin 104.6Pancake, Jane Ann 103.1Corey, Daniel 102.6Nelson, Mary 101.7
FY2015 Annual Report Page 199 of 212
Attorney Total Time
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESTOTAL BILLED TRAVEL TIME
Clark, Tristan 101.6Keyser Fugate, Lora 101.6Tyson, David 101.0Hinerman, Holly 100.7Whitt, Michael 100.5Bailey, Brian 100.2Taylor, Adam 99.3Yanni, Matthew 98.3Harvey, Henry 96.7Treadway, John 96.7Snodgrass, Lora 95.9Tipton, Kevin 94.5Tichenor, Terri 94.4Walker, Lela 93.4Littlepage, Stephen 90.6Windom, Rodney 90.3Donadieu, Michael 89.7LaFon, Timothy 89.0Cowden, Allison 88.7Ball, Gregory 88.0Brooks, Patrick 87.8Moore, David K. 87.5Cline, Colin 87.0Hollandsworth, Richard 86.3Wilson, Christopher 86.2Brock, Matthew 85.9Scales‐Sherrin, Stephanie 85.9Rist, Thomas 85.2Craft, Justin 84.5Campbell, Brady 83.2Davis, G. Phillip 83.2Carlton, Robert 83.1Stewart, Joyce 83.1Pennington, Deanna 82.9Kohout, Edward 82.7Huffman, William 81.9Garrett, Karen 81.8Weese, Tracy 81.3Stout, Matthew 81.2Shough, Scott 79.7Blair, Jerry 77.4Hardy, Roy 77.3Sherman, Lawrence E., Jr. 77.2Prall, Thomas 76.8Williams, Paul 76.7Hausman, Linda 76.0Arbuckle, Douglas 75.6
FY2015 Annual Report Page 200 of 212
Attorney Total Time
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESTOTAL BILLED TRAVEL TIME
Prentice, Anne 75.3Williams, John E., Jr. 75.2Curry, Roger 75.0Faerber, Kristopher 75.0Woods, Jonny 74.7Fuda, Thomas 74.4Rumora, Ronald 74.4Hall, Dwight 73.7Shumaker, Brandon 73.5Baldwin, Shannon 73.4Torres, George 73.0Greenbaum, Steven 72.2Wolfe, B. Scott 71.4Matherly, Jeffrey 71.0Cooper, Christopher 70.6Harman, Marla 69.8Moorehead, Christopher 68.9Lester, William 68.4Prentice, Timothy 68.1Pritt, Alan 67.8Thompson, John M., Jr. 67.7Salmons, Ron 66.5Gordon, Margaret 66.1Delligatti, Matthew 66.0Easter, Amber 65.5Helmick, Justina 65.5Martin, Joshua 65.5Thompson, Michael D. 65.5Glover, David 65.3Biddle, Jacquelyn 65.2Mallett, Shane 65.0Allender, Megan 64.7Arnold, S. Andrew 64.3Minutelli, Michelle 64.2Hershberger, Justin 63.9Moore, Jared 63.8Bartram, Shawn 63.6Safcsak, Michael 62.8Scantlebury, Phillip 62.7Brancazio, Helen M 61.8Seay, Robert 61.2Windom, Scott 61.2Evans, Jenny M. 60.5Murphy, Stephen 59.8Ogle, Candace 59.5Kittle, Dennis 59.3Antolini, Kristen 59.2
FY2015 Annual Report Page 201 of 212
Attorney Total Time
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESTOTAL BILLED TRAVEL TIME
Bowser, Elmer 59.2Jarrell, Robert 59.2Pritt, Justin 58.2DeMoss, David 58.1Smith, Ashley 58.1Klatt, Wilbert 57.5Gadd, Eric 57.3Harmon‐Schamberger, Barbara 56.9Sinkkanen, Dreama 56.4Blevins, Michael 55.7Price, Tom 55.7Osborne, Raeann 54.8Winters, Joshua 54.5Boggs Lefler, Leigh 53.7Gain, Jason 53.6Love, Jay 53.6Prezioso, Christopher 52.7Dunlap, Robert 52.3Everett, Mark 52.0Logue, Sean 52.0Payne, Wilbert A. 51.5Rollo, Ed 50.7McIntyre‐Nicholson, Rachelle 49.8Hoffman, Travis 49.7Morrison, Paul V., II 49.7Wolfe, Steven 49.5Brown, Scott 49.4Radman, Scott 49.2Lash, Franklin 49.1Sills, Leah 48.4Stollings, Harley 47.9Chase, J. K. 46.7Laishley, John 46.5Nestor, William 46.3Pettijohn, Denise 46.0Harvey, Matthew 45.9Dixon, Sarah 45.6Sturm, Heidi 45.6Simmons, Berkeley 45.4Bullman, Sandra 44.8Weese, Heather 44.7Turkett, Holly 44.2Easton, Brent 44.1Rollo, Lance 43.3Burcham, Jeffrey 43.0Rohrig, Frederick M. Dean 42.7Bowser, Philip 42.5
FY2015 Annual Report Page 202 of 212
Attorney Total Time
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESTOTAL BILLED TRAVEL TIME
Wildman, Eric 42.2Smith, Harry 42.0Fuscardo, Dante 41.7Regula, Rae 41.6Tissue, Philip 41.4Callaghan, Julia 40.7Chapman, Cammie 40.6Haines, Meredith 40.3Hylton, Vickie 40.2Cook, Erica 40.0Parrott, Matthew 39.9Brill, Jonathan 39.6Nett, Cody 39.4Campbell, Robert 39.3Burton, DeAndra 38.8Forbes, W. Jesse 38.5Greiner, Cathy 38.3Morgan, Tony 38.1Redman, Trent 37.5Steed, Debra 37.4Kuhn, Kelley 37.3Hostler, Carl 37.1Skillman, David 37.1Funkhouser, John 37.0Masters, Ian 37.0Walker‐Gaskins, Chelsea 37.0Moye, David 36.8Karr, Thomas 36.7Garrett, Linda 36.5Souders, Melisha 36.4Doneghy, Brendan 36.3Glass, Jason 36.2Sikora, Jacqueline 36.0Pahl, Andrew 35.9Flanigan, Paige 35.8DeVore, Matthew 35.7Garvin, Julie 35.3Briscoe, L. Scott 35.0Hunter, Joseph 34.8Blyler, Howard 33.8Ours, John 33.8Robertson, Connor 33.7White, Thomas 33.6Tate, Rebecca 33.0Smith, Richard 32.8ReBrook , Edward, III 32.7Tyree, Scott 32.0
FY2015 Annual Report Page 203 of 212
Attorney Total Time
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESTOTAL BILLED TRAVEL TIME
Rozas, Ramon 31.5Boggs, Apryll 31.0Spadaro, Laura 30.4Beavers, Patricia 30.2Diehl, Elizabeth Layne 29.8Dolance, Jack 29.8Pratt, Lena Donna 29.7Ryan, Kourtney A. 29.3Iapalucci, Allison 29.1Erhard, Craig 28.9Wall, Maggie 28.7Bazzle, J. Parker, II 28.3Hudson, Blaire 28.0Gardner Estep, Elizabeth 27.9Huson, Allison 27.7Williams, Ashley 27.3White, Max 27.1Eagloski, N. Edward 26.4Brown‐Bailey, Colleen 26.1Sklavounakis, Jerry 26.1Kresch , Steven 25.7Flanigan, Ryan 25.6Lusk, Kyle 25.6Shockley, James Brian 25.1Batten, Dylan 24.9Bush, Frank 24.8Winter, Kurt 24.5Shaw, Michael 24.1Ciliberti, Anthony 24.0Green, Lisa 23.9Kratovil, James 23.8Marsh, Sam 23.8Heishman, James 23.7Lyons, Teresa 23.6Shepherd, Stephanie 23.5Gallagher, William 23.1Dorsey, William 22.7Evans, Wayne 22.6Orndorff, Joshua 22.6Bogarad, Sharon 22.4DiPiero, Timothy 22.4Morgan, Damon 22.3Maze, Leslie 22.2Riddell, Christian 22.2Yost, Brian 22.1Kettering, Paul 21.9Nelson, James 21.9
FY2015 Annual Report Page 204 of 212
Attorney Total Time
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESTOTAL BILLED TRAVEL TIME
McCoid, Robert G. 21.6Dyer, Thomas 20.9Noone, Robert 20.9Thompson, Lauren 20.9Giggenbach, Melissa 20.5Flannery, Carolyn 20.2Rokisky, Ryan 20.1Hatfield, Benjamin 18.8Bottner, Kirk 18.6Wright, Steven 18.6Saffer, Martin 18.4Turner, Ryan 18.3Salsbery, Harold 18.0Ashley, Anita 17.9Gall, Conrad 17.9Goddard, David 17.8Ellem, John 17.7Hawrot, Lisa 17.6Lynch, Jennifer 17.5Mauser, Bernard 17.5Lyall, Jerry 17.4Moye, Lisa 17.2Slavey, Tyler 17.1Crockett, Kimberley 16.8Sherman, Peter 16.6Haynie, Belinda 16.5Lefler, Derrick 16.2Handley, Tanya 16.0Lefler, Christopher 15.8Eritano, Rebecca 15.6Klie Kolenich, Erika 15.4Dawson, David 15.2Bailey, Dennis 14.4Dooley, Katherine 14.4Aucremanne, Joseph 14.3Buckner, Eric 14.0Tsoras, Theodore 14.0Roahrig, Randal 13.7Fast, Thomas 13.3Moran, Jane 13.3Estes, Lisa A. 13.2Justice, Ashley 13.2Payne, Michael 13.2Thompson, David 13.2Lemley, Courtney 13.0Barrat, Robert 12.8Chapman, Matthew 12.8
FY2015 Annual Report Page 205 of 212
Attorney Total Time
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESTOTAL BILLED TRAVEL TIME
Moore, Harry 12.7Greer, Robert 12.5Boninsegna, Sante 12.3Clifton, J. L. 12.2Phillips, Todd 11.9Robinson, Kevin 11.5Hettrich, Jordan 11.4Ray, Amanda 11.4Butler, John 11.3Pellegrin, Mark 10.8Stanton, Shirley 10.8Geary, James Paul, II 10.7Taylor, Jennifer 10.7Saville, Royce 10.6Steele, Brandon 10.5Cogan, Timothy 10.4Holtzapfel, David 10.4Riffe, Richard 10.1McDermott, Shawn 9.8Bean, William 9.7Kramer, Ronald 9.6Plants, Mark 9.6Hart, David S. 9.5Burns, Daniel 9.2Kuenzel, Robert 9.2Woods, Jeff 9.0Workman, Elliott 9.0Starcher, Kenneth 8.9Blickenstaff, Brian 8.5Toor, Mark 8.5Sproles, Gregory 8.3Jewell, Jonathan 8.2Conway, Krista 8.0Gardner, Amanda 8.0Thorn, Matthew 8.0Chapman, Mary Beth 7.9Holtzapfel, Richard 7.8French, Michael 7.7Harrold, Samuel 7.7Mullins‐Taylor, Mindi 7.7Flanigan, William 7.4Riley, James 7.2Kusimo‐Frazier, Olubunmi 7.1Shafer, Amy 7.0Thorne, Steven 6.8Zimarowski, Thomas 6.6Robb, Richard 6.5
FY2015 Annual Report Page 206 of 212
Attorney Total Time
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESTOTAL BILLED TRAVEL TIME
Thompson, John M., Jr. 6.5Adams, William 6.4Bellomy, Donald 6.4Utt, Barbara 6.2Angotti, Mary Beth 6.1Orteza, Ailynn 6.1John, Proctor 6.0Longwell, William 6.0McClure, Allison 6.0Novobilski, Jerome 6.0Ross, Kristen 6.0Selario, Michael 6.0Sharley, Michael 6.0Barnhart, Christopher 5.7Bradley, James 5.6Fleegle, Krista 5.6Gunnoe, Sherri 5.6Stephens, Gloria 5.2HIll, David 5.1Atkinson, Natalie 5.0Bailess, Todd 5.0DeMarino, Shelly 5.0Hood, C. Christopher 5.0Stapleton, Matt 4.9Aman, Afton 4.7Cochran, Ashley 4.7Smith, Matthew 4.6Walters, Nathan 4.5Harkins, Jane 4.4Janutolo, Thomas 4.4Bouchillon, Neil R 4.3Harmon, Sarah 4.3Kupec, Thomas 4.3West, Charles 4.3Collins, David 4.2Hudnall, Mark 4.2Kennedy, Edward 4.2McCourt, William 4.2Peyton, Thomas 4.0Bias, Erin 3.8Mishoe, Benjamin 3.8Callaghan, Stephen 3.7Christopher, Braden 3.7Wright, Lacy 3.7Hall, Karen 3.6James, Nicholas 3.6Hamilton, Neal Jay 3.4
FY2015 Annual Report Page 207 of 212
Attorney Total Time
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESTOTAL BILLED TRAVEL TIME
Van Zant, Susan 3.4Hart, David 3.0Herndon, Stephen 3.0MacCallum, Judson 3.0Underwood, Jared 3.0Ashley, Lindsey 2.9Ribel, Katica 2.8Sal, Natalie 2.8Sutton, John 2.8Conley, Ginny 2.7Bowen, Jeff 2.6Selden, Stanley 2.6Mick, Rebecca E. 2.5Milleson, William 2.5Rusen, Michele 2.5Atkins, James 2.4Campbell, Adam 2.4Pardo, Georgiana 2.4Gilbert, David 2.2Bever, Darla 2.0Bucy, Winifred 2.0Carrico, Tim 2.0Childers, Sharon 2.0Conway, Glen 2.0Froble, Michael 2.0Henderson, Sherri 2.0Juba‐Plumley, Rosalee 2.0King, Wayne 2.0Lord, Erica 2.0Vital, Richard L. 2.0Koontz, Mark 1.8Qualls, Alvie E., II 1.8Stone, Robert C., Jr. 1.7Fragile, Matthew 1.6Forester, William 1.5Forman, Roger D. 1.5Hassan, Ron 1.5Judy, William 1.5OBrien, Jamie 1.4Pentony, Peter 1.4Hoosier, Michelle 1.3Lockwood, Ashley 1.3Miller, Rebecca 1.3Stroech, Christopher 1.3Folickman , Pamela 1.2Stalnaker, Charles 1.2Taylor, Chad 1.2
FY2015 Annual Report Page 208 of 212
Attorney Total Time
PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESTOTAL BILLED TRAVEL TIME
Camilletti, David 1.0Cohee, Bridget 1.0Judy, Rebecca 1.0Kirby, Todd 1.0Koreski, Samantha 1.0Slater, Elisabeth 1.0Wilmoth, David 1.0Conrad, Jamison 0.8Davisson, Benjamin 0.8Fraley, Lawrence 0.8Harman, Anne 0.7Hoxie, Thomas 0.7Gilliam, Candice 0.6Oglesby, Monica 0.6Varney, Cecil 0.6Clay, Paul 0.5Embree, Eric 0.5Fleshman, Martha 0.5Sluss, Stephen 0.5Underwood Poe, Molly 0.5Wilson, Kristen 0.5Furner, Dean 0.4Jecklin, David 0.4McGee, Thomas 0.4Taylor, Paul 0.4Zeigler, Sara 0.4Stapleton, John W. 0.2Rodriguez, Vanessa 0.1
56,809.4
FY2015 Annual Report Page 209 of 212
[Page left blank intentionally.]
FY2015 Annual Report Page 210 of 212
Appendix E
Historical Overview of Key Statistical Indicators
S
FY2015 Annual Report Page 211 of 212
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
SER
VICES
Historical O
verview of Key Statistical Indicators
APPOINTED COUNSEL
FY 2015
FY 2014
FY 2013
FY 2012
FY 2011
FY 2010
FY 2009
FY 2008
Am
ou
nt
Pai
d in
Cla
ims
$2
5,9
54
,89
7.2
4$
25
,53
0,7
68
.12
$2
5,2
32
,41
2.0
9$
21
,96
0,4
93
.86
$2
6,3
01
,22
5.6
0$
33
,32
7,7
43
.78
$2
0,5
13
,71
1.1
9$
22
,77
5,8
31
.90
Tota
l Cla
ims
Pai
d (
w/o S
up
p. &
Dir
ect)
33
,75
9.0
0
31
,81
7.0
0
32
,00
7.0
0
27
,40
2.0
0
32
,25
0.0
0
45
,28
3.0
0
23
,63
7.0
0
28
,13
1.0
0
Tota
l Ho
urs P
aid
48
6,7
26
.40
47
9,5
83
.90
47
5,5
03
.60
41
5,3
36
.00
50
2,9
34
.00
63
1,7
37
.00
38
4,5
64
.00
42
2,4
23
.00
Per
cen
t In C
ou
rt1
5.3
6%
14
.97
%1
5.2
4%
15
.09
%1
5.0
1%
15
.44
%1
6.4
6%
16
.76
%
Per
cen
t O
ut
of
Co
urt
84
.64
%8
5.0
3%
84
.76
%8
4.9
1%
84
.99
%8
4.5
6%
83
.54
%8
3.2
4%
Ave
rage C
ost P
er C
laim
$7
68
.83
$8
02
.43
$7
88
.34
$8
01
.42
$8
15
.54
$7
35
.99
$8
67
.86
$8
09
.63
Ave
rage T
ota
l Co
st P
er H
ou
r$
53
.33
$5
3.2
4$
53
.06
$5
2.8
7$
52
.30
$5
2.7
6$
53
.34
$5
3.9
2
PUBLIC DEFEN
DER
CORPORATIONS
FY 2015***
FY 2014
FY 2013
FY 2012
FY 2011
FY 2010
FY 2009
FY 2008
Dis
bu
rsm
ents f
or
Pu
blic D
ef. C
orp
s.$
17
,75
3,2
57
.00
$1
7,0
30
,81
7.0
0$
15
,37
6,3
20
.00
$1
9,6
95
,72
4.8
2$
18
,41
7,1
58
.00
$1
6,9
65
,24
3.4
2$
16
,92
6,0
70
.25
$1
3,6
56
,71
9.0
0
Tota
l Cas
es C
lose
d3
3,1
70
.00
33
,35
4.0
0
32
,74
0.0
0
41
,89
7.0
0
33
,54
4.0
0
30
,93
9.0
0
35
,35
4.0
0
32
,71
4.0
0
Tota
l Ho
urs (
w/o A
dm
in. T
ime)
18
8,5
08
.50
18
9,6
05
.10
18
4,0
78
.10
18
9,1
99
.90
18
5,3
22
.60
17
8,2
16
.80
18
0,6
47
.30
17
4,4
12
.50
Per
cen
t In C
ou
rt*
28
.72
%2
8.0
8%
27
.40
%2
7.4
3%
26
.71
%2
7.7
2%
28
.64
%2
8.6
9%
Per
cen
t O
ut
of
Co
urt
*7
1.2
8%
71
.29
%7
1.9
0%
71
.94
%7
2.7
7%
71
.92
%7
1.3
6%
71
.31
%
Ave
rage C
ost P
er C
lose
d C
ase*
*$
53
5.2
2$
51
0.6
1$
46
9.6
5$
47
0.1
0$
54
9.0
5$
54
8.3
4$
47
8.7
6$
41
7.4
6
Ave
rage T
ota
l Co
st P
er H
ou
r$
94
.18
$8
9.8
2$
83
.53
$1
04
.10
$9
9.3
8$
95
.19
$9
3.7
0$
78
.30
In
Ap
ril 2
01
4, t
he
on
line
vou
cher s
ub
mis
sio
n p
roce
ss b
ecam
e m
and
ato
ry.
Year
Savings Per Case
Total Savings
*Dru
g C
ou
rt is n
ot
con
sid
ered
as
it r
epre
sen
ts le
ss t
han
1% o
f ti
me
star
tin
g in F
Y 2
01
0.
20
15
$2
33
.61
$7
,74
8,7
99
.98
**A
vera
ge C
ost P
er C
lose
d C
ase
was r
ecal
cula
ted f
or
FY 2
01
1 t
o r
efle
ct a m
ore a
ccu
rate f
igu
re.
20
14
$2
91
.82
$9
,73
3,3
64
.28
20
13
$3
18
.69
$1
0,4
33
,91
0.6
0
20
12
$3
31
.32
$1
3,8
81
,31
4.0
4
Dif
fere
nce A
/C & P
DC C
ost p
er c
ase
tim
esP
DC C
lose
d C
ases
20
11
$2
66
.49
$8
,93
9,1
40
.56
20
10
$1
87
.65
$5
,80
5,7
03
.25
20
09
$3
89
.10
$1
3,7
56
,24
1.4
0
20
08
$3
92
.17
$1
2,8
29
,44
9.3
8
Summary of Cost Savings FY 2008‐‐2015
Savi
ngs c
alcu
late
d a
s:
***T
ota
l Dis
bu
rsem
ents f
or
PD
C e
xclu
des $
40
0,0
00 t
o 4
th P
DC f
or
star
tup e
xpen
ses. A
mo
un
t w
ill b
e in
clu
ded
in F
Y16 t
ota
ls
FY2015 Annual Report Page 212 of 212