Pros and Cons of Increasing Local FoodNovember 18, 2011

By: Bob Harmon

PROS Increase Food Nutrition for Fresh

Produce

Reduce Energy Use

Partner with the Community

Lower Costs on Some Products

Reinvest in the Community

Make Food System More Sustainable

Reduce Food Miles

Reduce Carbon Footprint by Buying Local

Reduce new pollution from long distance transportation

Save fossil fuels by shortening travel distance

Reduce Energy Use

The average American food item travels 1,500 miles to consumer. 1

Reduce Food Miles

Reduce Energy Use

The Center for Sustainable Systems estimates that the U.S. Food System requires 7.3 units of (primarily) fossil fuel energy for each unit of food energy produced. 2

Any effort to reduce energy use will help to conserve fossil fuels, other energy, and will reduce pollution from energy use.

Local Food Nutrition Some nutrients are lost from fresh fruits

and vegetables after harvest.

Oxygen Light HeatVitamin A U U U

Vitamin C U U U

Folacin S U S

Mineral Salts S S S

S = Stable (no important destruction)

U = Unstable (significant destruction)

Conditions that Cause Loss of Nutrients

Local produce will often have more nutrients because it has not been as long since it was taken from the plant.

Harmons Local Vendor Partnerships

• Winder Dairy• Amano Chocolate• Caffe Ibis Coffee• Happy Monkey

Hummus• Lehi Roller Mills Flour• Stratton Farms Produce

• Creminelli• Pepperlane• Beehive• Prairie Grain Bread• Morgan Valley Lamb• Rockhill Creamery

Opportunity to partner with producers and farmers in our community.

• Jack Sprat Bread• Miller’s Honey• Cheese Bread

Mania• Laurie’s Buffalo

Gourmet Chips

Reinvesting in the Community

Buying local is supporting the community you live and work in

Money can be reinvested in local taxes and jobs

Creates jobs in the community

Supporting Local

Means doing business with more than 700 Utah companies representing $246 million in direct local support.

Based on the multiplier effect (Utah’s Own “every dollar spent on Utah products adds $4 to $6 to the local economy”) this totals approximately $984 million.

Cost Effectiveness

• Fair price buying from producer– We pay fair market value for the product

• Sustainable Partnerships– 15 stores buying from the Local Vendor– Gives vendors known retail location to sell

goods– Helps vendors to plan for the year’s production– Helps vendors save money through better

planning

• Save on transportation costs

• Investment at first, but the value outweigh

Benefits for Customers

Lasts Longer Tastes Better Higher Quality Better Value Support Local Economy Reduce Energy Use and New Pollution

CONS Limited quantity

Cost to set up Finances Distribution UPCs

Limited variety

Challenges in selling Local Foods

• Cost of Investment

• Buying local has some limitations in variety of products (can’t always find the exact type)

• Sometimes Local vendors will not have enough product for all 15 stores, so each store gets limited amount or only some stores get product.

• Financing Payments – payments are often expedited instead of term payments. Local vendors are often small and need quick payment to keep business going

• It takes a lot of resources for small companies to get started and to get their brand known.

Sources 1. Sustainable Table. “Fossil Fuel and Energy Use,”

(accessed November 3, 2011). 2. Center for Sustainable Systems, University of Michigan.

2010. “U.S. Food System Factsheet.” Pub. No. CSS01-06. 3. Extension Service, Oregon State University. October

2007. “What Counts? Nutrients in Fresh and Preserved Fruits and Vegetables.” SP 50-926.