PROMISE and PERFORMANCE REPORT 2012-2015...

The Informed Voter Project Don’t just Vote. Select!

PROMISE and PERFORMANCE REPORT 2012-2015

Wards F/N, G/N, G/S, F/S

WAS YOUR CORPORATOR THE RIGHT CHOICE?

Don’t just Vote. Select!

Content Explanation Source

Attendance Total of General Body Meetings and Committee Meetings. Average attendance of 227 corporators = 77%

• www.Praja.org • RTI reply from BMC.

Corporator Fund Expenditure Status

Each corporator is entitled to two funds annually- (1) Corporator Fund, and (2) Development Fund.

• Entitlement- http://bit.ly/1PLOq2N • Corporator Fund Expenditure Data-

http://portal.mcgm.gov.in/irj/portal/anonymous/qlpurordcdetails. Average Expenditure of 227 corporators = 92.97%

• Development Fund info not included in this report.

Financial Year

Corporator Fund annual entitlement

Development Fund annual entitlement

2012-13 60 lakh 40 lakh

2013-14 60 lakh 40 lakh

2014-15 60 lakh 1 crore

Promise & Performance One-liners

Each corporator was asked the following questions in the interview conducted by MumbaiVotes- (1) Performance: Major work done in term so far (2) Promises: Plans for remaining part of term.

Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute video/audio interview with MumbaiVotes.

Contact Details Phone number provided. Find more on website. Affidavit filed for candidature

CONTENT BRIEF & DATA SOURCE


PRIMARY RESPONSIBILITIES OF CORPORATORS (CITY LEVEL ISSUES)

URBAN PLANNING EDUCATION ENVIRONMENT ROADS PUBLIC TRANSPORT

POVERTY ALLEVIATION HEALTH ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT WATER SUPPLY SLUM IMPROVEMENT

₹


MUMBAI = 227 WARDS = 227 CORPORATORS

RULING COALITION

NO

. OF

CO

RP

OR

ATO

RS

POLITICAL PARTIES

77

30

53

28

14 11 9

2 1 1 1 0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

SHS BJP INC MNS IND NCP SP ABS RPI(A)

BSKP BRKP


Questions Response

A plan will be made for more parking space Party did not respond.

Plan shall be made to give concession and encouragement for those co-operative societies who keep their building premises clean.

Party did not respond.

Graveyards will be made available with PNG gas (natural gas) to prevent excess use of wood and to stop pollution and bad smell.


In order to prevent diseases like Thalassemia, AIDS etc., blood testing services shall be provided at the Municipal Corporation's laboratory at very cheap rates.


All municipal schools will be repaired and have computer labs in the next three years. Party did not respond.

Bus services like 'Fort-ferry' shall be started in the many parts of Mumbai city and suburbs. Party did not respond.

Policy of developing 'Hawkers ground' shall be accepted. Party did not respond.

Project affected citizens of Mumbai due to different municipal projects shall be given houses or compensation as per 'Ready-reckoner' for which 15 years inhabitation shall be the eligibility.


SHIV SENA PARTY PERFORMANCE A questionnaire* consisting of projects and plans promised in the Shiv Sena 2012 MCGM Manifesto was first sent to the Shiv Sena spokesperson on April 26, 2015. Despite several follow-ups, this was the response we received-

* Few promises stated here. Questionnaire listed 117 promises extracted from SHS 2012 MCGM Manifesto.


PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT PARAMETERS

CORPORATOR’S CONTACT NUMBER LINK TO INTERVIEW

PROMISE: WORK TO BE DONE

PERFORMANCE: WORK DONE

ATTENDANCE

CORPORATOR FUNDS EXPENDITURE

QUALITATIVE Time Period: March 2012 – October 2015

QUANTITATIVE Time Period: March 2012 – March 2015


INTERVIEWS TAKEN IN 6 CLUSTERS

COVERED IN THIS REPORT: CLUSTER 2- Constituency Numbers 165-201 F/N: Antop Hill, GTB Nagar, King’s Circle, Matunga, Sion, Wadala G/N: Dadar, Dharavi, Mahim, Matunga G/S: Elphinstone Road, Lower Parel, Mahalaxmi, Parel, Prabhadevi, Worli F/S: Chinchpokli, Cotton Green, Currey Road, Dadar, Parel, Sewri


0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

AT

TEN

DA

NC

E (i

n %

) G/N Ward Corporators

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

AT

TEN

DA

NC

E (i

n %

)

F/N Ward Corporators

ATTENDANCE Below Average Above Average


0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

AT

TEN

DA

NC

E (i

n %

)

F/S Ward Corporators

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

AT

TEN

DA

NC

E (i

n %

)

G/S Ward Corporators

ATTENDANCE Below Average Above Average


0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

CO

RP

OR

ATO

R F

UN

D E

XP

END

ITU

RE

(in

%)

G/N Ward Corporators

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

CO

RP

OR

ATO

R F

UN

D E

XP

END

ITU

RE

(in

%)

F/N Ward Corporators

CORPORATOR FUND EXPENDITURE STATUS Below Average Above Average


0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

CO

RP

OR

ATO

R F

UN

D E

XP

END

ITU

RE

(in

%)

F/S Ward Corporators

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

CO

RP

OR

ATO

R F

UN

D E

XP

END

ITU

RE

(in

%)

G/S Ward Corporators

CORPORATOR FUND EXPENDITURE STATUS Below Average Above Average


CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.

Pranita Prakash Waghdhare

SHS

INFRASTRUCTURE: We have developed an open gym at Raghunath Chavan Garden.

INFRASTRUCTURE: The work of Sion Fort will be completed.

https://youtu.be/ehgtB3Ae4Og

9833401374/ 9769075207/ 8879997165

Lalita Kachru Yadav INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have done tarring of kaccha roads from Ambedkar Nagar to Jai Maharashtra Nagar.

INFRASTRUCTURE: I will undertake renovation of the BMC building in my constituency from either the inside or the outside.

https://youtu.be/kzneOyDMJ68

9323041863/ 9920209224/ 8879997166

Rajeshree Rajesh Shirvadkar

BJP INFRASTRUCTURE: I have undertaken the garden and subway project in Sion circle.

ECONOMIC AFFAIR: I will ensure that funds are granted to renovate dilapidated buildings.

https://youtu.be/y-2DIDM4fW8

9869852149/ 8879997167

Selvan R. Tamil BJP HEALTH & SANITATION: I have removed a lot of garbage bins and instead replaced it with garbage truck to clear out the waste and maintain cleanliness.

MISCELLANEOUS: I am working on issues of proper roads, hospital facilities and education to the poor kids.

https://youtu.be/NwbYPQvjmtU

9820058128/ 8879997168

Shraddha Shridhar Jadhav

SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: With the help of BMC engineers new roads were made.

HEALTH & SANITATION: I will solve the remaining water woes, and will work on chemical nullahs.

https://youtu.be/IdCVWe5AFPE

9821113757/ 8879997169

AREA: F/N Ward- Antop Hill, GTB Nagar, King’s Circle, Matunga, Sion, Wadala Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute video with MumbaiVotes



Trishna Chandrakant Vishwasrao

SHS

INFRASTRUCTURE: Haji Ismail municipal school was demolished to reconstruct a ground plus six structure.

INFRASTRUCTURE, HEALTH: I will set up a health centre for my ward.

https://youtu.be/T7wa5J0sfb4

9920326416/ 8879997170

Mahant Ramnaresh Choube

BJP INFRASTRUCTURE: I provided water facility in slum areas of Bandhu Nagar and Shanti Nagar that did not have water for two to four days.

INFRASTRUCTURE: I will construct proper roads and public toilets.

https://youtu.be/hkqL1qd_zgk

9867220565/ 9820825293/ 8879997171

Manojkumar Martandrao Sansare

IND *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9773339991/ 9821112220/ 8879997172

Alka Hemant Doke SHS ECONOMIC AFFAIR: I have brought in funds through the municipal corporation to speed up the frequent repair works required in the 50-55 year old Sahakar Nagar.

INFRASTRUCTURE: I will make the footpath outside Dr. Ambedkar College functional by ridding it of encroached slums.

https://youtu.be/EGyqOrTbDOA

9223356680/ 8879997173

Nayna Manhar Sheth INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have bought toys worth Rs. 1 crore for kids in Five Gardens.

*No Reply* https://youtu.be/vinEs4MhXkw

9820157570/ 8879997174

AREA: F/N Ward- Antop Hill, GTB Nagar, King’s Circle, Matunga, Sion, Wadala Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute video with MumbaiVotes



Sabreddy Mallesh Bora

RPI (A) *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9820702882/ 8879997175

Ganga Kunal Mane SHS *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9324382293/ 8879997176

Rajendra Narayan Suryavanshi

SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have worked mostly on grounds, water supply, sanitation etc.

ECONOMIC AFFAIR: I'm planning to improve the condition of Hindu Cemetery.

https://youtu.be/7-uf5eEyY0c

9322376775/ 8879997177

Vakil Sagir Ahmed Shaikh

INC INFRASTRUCTURE, HEALTH: I got a 6-inch water line laid leading to good prssure water provision in Chamda Bazar, Bageecha, Kalyanwadi and Satyam- Shivam- Sundaram.

*No Reply*

https://youtu.be/dfkQ3zDJGc4

9321863301/ 8879997178

Jyotsna Harjivan Parmar

SP HEALTH & SANITATION: I have got gutters cleant.

*No Reply* https://youtu.be/Kmb8aO3KZ8o

9220409051/ 8879997179

Vishnu Ramchandra Gaikwad

IND *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9821932838/ 8879997180

AREA: G/N Ward- Dadar, Dharavi, Mahim, Matunga Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute video with MumbaiVotes



Shraddha Rajesh Patil MNS *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9969676729/ 8879997181

Virendra Vishnu Tandel

MNS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have got new roads constructed with footpaths.

INFRASTRUCTURE: I wish to improve the gardens in my ward so that there are facilities for elders and for children to play.

https://youtu.be/8Y-Eqh42_LM

9869172121/ 8879997182

Manish Dattaram Chavan

MNS ECONOMIC AFFAIR: I have brought funds for the maternity home.

INFRASTRUCTURE: I plan to construct a bridge to prevent accidents of Ruparel College students and staff who have to currently cross the road.

https://youtu.be/CHTuqPRxuao

9324318462/ 8879997183

Sudhir Krushna Jadhav MNS INFRASTRUCTURE, LAW AND ORDER: I have got all encroachments under Dadar station demolished to clear space for pedestrians.

OTHER: I plan to rid the area around Dadar station of hawkers to let commuters move and breathe freely.

https://youtu.be/1EFf27fPXJg

9833941730/ 8879997184

Sandeep Yashwant Sudhakar Deshpande

MNS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have started rain water harvesting at Shivaji Park through which approximately 14 lakh litres of water is saved per year.

OTHER LEGAL AFFAIRS: I plan to make one entire road a no-hawking zone.

https://youtu.be/KFO5JL4YFsw

9833089283/ 8879997185

AREA: G/N Ward- Dadar, Dharavi, Mahim, Matunga Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute video with MumbaiVotes



Seema Mahesh Shivalkar

MNS *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9821483978/ 8879997186

Santosh Balkrushna Dhuri

MNS INFRASTRUCTURE, HEALTH: I have made 6 roads in my ward and ensured water supply facility.

INFRASTRUCTURE, SANITATION: I plan to remove all public garbage bins and work on awareness of the public to segregate wet and dry waste.

https://youtu.be/7Bh8K7j11Y0

9892676401/ 8879997187

Hemangi Hareshwar Worlikar

SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I tried to complete the repairing work and proposed new sewer line.

INFRASTRUCTURE: I will repair and renovate Babsaheb Worlikar Udyan.

https://youtu.be/l_s5UdYKPAM

9869209974/ 8879997188

Mansi Madhukar Dalvi SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have widened narrow lanes in slums.

*No Reply* https://youtu.be/Qi7FW5AFZ80

8879997189

Hemlata Vinod Wange MNS *Denied Interview*

*Denied Interview* ----- 9669471805/ 8879997190

AREA: G/S Ward- Elphinstone Road, Lower Parel, Mahalaxmi, Parel, Prabhadevi, Worli Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute video with MumbaiVotes



Kishori Kishor Pednekar

SHS SANITATION: I have got the big bins removed from several spots to address the problem of strewn garbage.

INFRASTRUCTURE: I will make four gardens and two stadiums.

https://youtu.be/zRX4L3fw_pQ

9869019232/ 8879997191

Ratna Raghunath Mahale

NCP INFRASTRUCTURE: The major problems of water, gutter and meter, footpaths, nullahs, public toilets and surroundings were worked on.

MISCELLANEOUS: I will focus on social, education, health and women related issues.

https://youtu.be/mkalqQyb3dc

9869866978/ 8879997192

Sunil Mohan Ahir NCP *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9619342090/ 8879997193

Snehal Suryakant Ambekar

SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have provided drainage line for each building in the best manner possible minimizing problems for residents.

INFRASTRUCTURE, HEALTH: I have proposed setting up of a water pump at Jeevan Chowk which will be installed soon.

https://youtu.be/HkvusxyUv3k

9967836939/ 9004832059/ 8879997194

AREA: G/S Ward- Elphinstone Road, Lower Parel, Mahalaxmi, Parel, Prabhadevi, Worli Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute video with MumbaiVotes



Sunil Vishnu More INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have installed a drain pipe at Dadar station.

*No Reply* https://youtu.be/H0nqyCwa9ZQ

9322270542/ 8879997195

Pallavi Mahendra Mungekar

INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have renovated toilets, laid drainage lines and got chambers dug.

INFRASTRUCTURE: I will renovate Bhoiwada Cremation Ground, foot over-bridge near Fatima high school and Sewri crossroad drainage line.

https://youtu.be/IzBRtHr2NVY

9322822746/ 8879997196

Nandkishor Sakharam Vichare

SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have constructed two cement concrete and five tar roads.

INFRASTRUCTURE: I shall try my best to find space for children of Kamgar Basti to study as their houses are small.

https://youtu.be/0ya1HzGPpGU

9819513106/ 8879997197

Sanjay Gajanan Ambole

SHS INFRASTRUCTURE, HEALTH: I have majorly worked on fulfilling life's basic necessity of water.

SANITATION: After Diwali I plan to make mine a zero-garbage ward.

https://youtu.be/M2Ui-a37878

9221221772/ 9324666999/ 8879997198/ 98921143980

AREA: F/S Ward- Chinchpokli, Cotton Green, Currey Road, Dadar, Parel, Sewri Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute video with MumbaiVotes



Hemangi Hemantkumar Chemburkar

SHS OTHER LEGAL AFFAIR: We initiated an agitation for the water problem.

INFRASTRUCTURE: I will open gyms in Government colony, BEST colony and Haffkine Colony.

https://youtu.be/zRX4L3fw_pQ

7738384935/ 8879997199

Vaibhavi Vijay Chavan SHS HEALTH, INFRASTRUCTURE: I have solved water problems and reconstructed footpath.

INFRASTRUCTURE: I will open gym and will try to develop my slum area.

https://youtu.be/mkalqQyb3dc

9969963429/ 8879997200

Shweta Shyamsundar Rane

SHS *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9869160234/ 8879997201

AREA: F/S Ward- Chinchpokli, Cotton Green, Currey Road, Dadar, Parel, Sewri Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute video with MumbaiVotes


What this report won’t do… What can you do? Let them know that you are watching them!

SMS or call your corporator and let

them know- “I have read the

MumbaiVotes Report Card.”

Signup for regular updates for your

corporator’s promises & performance-

http://mumbaivotes.com/pages/newsletter/

You have the Right to Copy

(The MumbaiVotes ‘Copy Right’ Law)

- Share this report

- Share the videos

Make an issue about your issues-

Call/SMS your corporator and request

him/her to address your civic issues.

Like on Facebook: www.facebook.com/MumbaiVotes Follow us on Twitter: @mumbaivotes

PROMISE and PERFORMANCE REPORT 2012-2015...

Documents

Transcript of PROMISE and PERFORMANCE REPORT 2012-2015...