PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS ANDZOA_ ESIA and ESMP_ 31... · The...
Transcript of PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS ANDZOA_ ESIA and ESMP_ 31... · The...
ROYAUME DU MAROC
PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED
ENVIRONMENTS”
DARED
EVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT & ESMP
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ........................................................................................................................ 5 2. INTRODUCTION AND APPROACH OF THE STUDY .................................................................................. 20
APPROACH OF THE STUDY ............................................................................................................... 20 2.1. GOALS OF THE ESIA ...................................................................................................................... 21 2.2.
3. POLITICAL, LEGAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE FRAMEWORK ........................................................................ 22 LEGAL FRAMEWORK ....................................................................................................................... 22 3.1. INSTITUTIONNEL FRAMEWORK ........................................................................................................... 26 3.2. NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY .................................................................................................... 26 3.3. INTERNATIONAL CONVENTIONS AND AGREEMENTS ................................................................................... 27 3.4. SAFEGUARD POLICIES OF THE GREEN CLIMATE FUND .............................................................................. 29 3.5. POSITION OF THE PROJECT WITH REGARDS TO EXISTING DEVELOPMENT STRATEGIES AND PROGRAMMES ................. 30 3.6.
3.6.1. LE PLAN MAROC VERT (GREEN MOROCCO PLAN): .............................................................................. 30 3.6.2. POLICY ON ARGAN DEVELOPMENT .................................................................................................. 31
4. DESCRIPTION OF THE PROJECT ......................................................................................................... 32 IMPLEMENTING AGENCY AND PILOTING ENTITY ....................................................................................... 32 4.1. OBJECTIVES OF THE PROJECT........................................................................................................... 34 4.2. DESCRIPTION OF THE PROJECT COMPONENTS ........................................................................................ 34 4.3.
4.3.1. COMPONENT 1: IMPLEMENTATION OF THE ARGANICULTURE ON 10 000 HA .................................................. 34 4.3.2. COMPONENT 2: STRUCTURATION ON UPSTREAM AND DOWNSTREAN ARGAN VALUE CHAIN ................................ 36 4.3.3. COMPONENT 3: CAPACITY BUILDING, KNOWLEDGE MANAGEMENT, CO-MANAGMENT OF NATURAL ARGAN FOREST AND
SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH PROMOTION............................................................................................................. 40 4.3.4. PROJECT TERRITORIAL DECLINATION .............................................................................................. 43
5. BASELINE SITUATION IN THE TERRITORIES OF INTERVENTION ............................................................. 45 INTRODUCTION............................................................................................................................. 45 5.1. CLIMATOLOGY ............................................................................................................................. 46 5.2. TEMPÉRATURE ............................................................................................................................. 46 5.3. PRECIPITATIONS ........................................................................................................................... 48 5.4. EVAPORATION ............................................................................................................................. 48 5.5. WIND ........................................................................................................................................ 49 5.6. HYDROLOGY ............................................................................................................................... 49 5.7.
5.7.1. SOUSS MASSA ......................................................................................................................... 49 5.7.2. GUELMIM BASIN ....................................................................................................................... 51 5.7.3. ESSAOUIRA BASIN..................................................................................................................... 51 MOBILIZATION OF SURFACE WATER .................................................................................................... 51 5.8.
5.8.1. EXISTING LARGE AND MEDIUM DAMS ............................................................................................... 51 5.8.2. EXISTING SMALL DAMS AND HILLSIDE LAKES ...................................................................................... 52 5.8.3. WATER WITHDRAWALS ................................................................................................................ 53 GROUNDWATER ........................................................................................................................... 53 5.9.
5.9.1. SOUSS MASSA BASIN ................................................................................................................. 53 5.9.2. GUELMIM BASIN ....................................................................................................................... 55 5.9.3. ESSAOUIRA ............................................................................................................................. 56 5.9.4. WATER DEMAND AT THE LEVEL OF THE ABHSMD ............................................................................... 56 5.9.5. SENSITIVITY OF UNDERGROUND WATER RESOURCES ........................................................................... 57 LAND USE AND VEGETATION INDEX ..................................................................................................... 58 5.1. CHARACTERIZATION OF THE CURRENT STATE OF EROSION IN WATERSHED ...................................................... 58 5.2. GEOLOGY ................................................................................................................................... 59 5.3. .NATURAL ENVIRONMENT AND BIODIVERSITY ......................................................................................... 61 5.4. SOCIO-ECONOMIC SITUATION OF REFERENCE ........................................................................................ 62 5.5.
5.5.1. POPULATION ........................................................................................................................... 62 5.5.2. POVERTY ............................................................................................................................... 65 EIGS NETWORK AND COOPERATIVES AT THE LEVEL OF THE REGION .............................................................. 66 5.6.
6. POTENTIAL ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACTS ............................................................................ 68 ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS ............................................................................................................... 68 6.1.
6.1.1. IMPACTS ON ARGANERAIE BIOSPHERE RESERVE (RBA) ........................................................................ 68 6.1.2. IMPACTS ON GROUND WATER AND SURFACE WATER RESOURCES ............................................................. 69
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
3
6.1.3. IMPACTS ON SOIL AND CARBON SEQUESTRATION ................................................................................ 71 6.1.4. IMPACTS ON BIODIVERSITY ........................................................................................................... 72 6.1.5. IMPACTS ON AIR ET TEMPERATURE ................................................................................................. 74 6.1.6. IMPACTS ON ARCHAEOLOGY AND CULTURAL HERITAGE ........................................................................ 75 6.1.7. IMPACTS FROM SOLID AND LIQUID WASTES....................................................................................... 75 6.1.8. NOISE AND VIBRATION ................................................................................................................ 76 POTENTIAL POSITIVE SOCIO-ECONOMIC IMPACTS ................................................................................... 77 6.2.
6.2.1. EMPLOYMENT CREATION ............................................................................................................. 77 6.2.2. NEW JOBS IN THE PRODUCTION OF ARGAN PLANTS : ............................................................................ 77 6.2.3. STABILISATION OF THE POPULATION AND LIMITATION OF THE PRESSION ON CITIES ......................................... 78 6.2.4. GENDER ISSUES ....................................................................................................................... 79 6.2.5. CAPACITY BUILDING .................................................................................................................. 80 6.2.6. SOCIO CULTURAL IMPACTS .......................................................................................................... 81 6.2.7. INVOLUNTARY RESETTLEMENT AND ADHERENCE OF POPULATION ............................................................. 81 6.2.8. RESTRICTION OF LAND USE AND LAND RIGHTS .................................................................................... 82 6.2.9. HEALTH AND SAFETY AND SECURITY ............................................................................................... 82
7. MITIGATION AND ENHANCEMENT MEASURES ...................................................................................... 84 ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS MITIGATION MEASURES .................................................................................. 84 7.1.
7.1.1. IMPACTS ON THE ARGANERAIE BIOSPHERE RESERVE ............................................................................ 84 7.1.2. IMPACTS ON SURFACE WATER AND GROUNDWATER RESOURCES .............................................................. 85 7.1.3. IMPACTS ON SOIL ...................................................................................................................... 86 7.1.4. IMPACTS ON BIODIVERSITY ........................................................................................................... 87 7.1.5. IMPACTS ON AIR ET TEMPERATURE ................................................................................................. 87 7.1.6. IMPACTS ON ARCHAEOLOGY AND CULTURAL HERITAGE ........................................................................ 88 7.1.7. IMPACTS FROM SOLID AND LIQUID WASTES....................................................................................... 89 7.1.8. NOISE AND VIBRATION ................................................................................................................ 89 SOCIO-ECONOMIC IMPACT MITIGATION MEASURES ................................................................................... 90 7.2.
7.2.1. EMPLOYMENT CREATION ............................................................................................................. 90 7.2.2. GENDER ISSUES ....................................................................................................................... 91 7.2.3. CAPACITY BUILDING .................................................................................................................. 92 7.2.4. SOCIO CULTURAL IMPACTS .......................................................................................................... 92 7.2.5. INVOLUNTARY RESETTLEMENT AND ADHERENCE OF POPULATION ............................................................. 93 7.2.6. HEALTH AND SAFETY AND SECURITY ............................................................................................... 94 MATRIX OF MITIGATION/COMPENSATION/ENHANCEMENT MEASURES .............................................................. 96 7.3.
8. ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL MANAGEMENT PLAN .......................................................................... 105 8.1.1. MATRIX OF MITIGATION/COMPENSATION/ENHANCEMENT MEASURES ........................................................ 105 8.1.2. ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL MANAGEMENT PLAN-ESMP .................................................................. 110 8.1.1. ESMP IMPLEMENTATION BUDGET ................................................................................................ 119
9. CONCLUSION ................................................................................................................................. 120 10. ANNEXES ................................................................................................................................... 121
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
4
LIST OF FIGURES
FIGURE 1 : THE ARGAN TREE PLANTING SITES .............................................................................................................................. 35 FIGURE 2 : DARED PROJECT AREA: COMMUNES CONCERNED BY THE PROJECT ............................................................................. 44 FIGURE 3 ADMINISTRATIVE SITUATION OF THE ACTION AREA OF THE ABHSMD ............................................................................... 45 FIGURE 4: WATERSHED SOUSS MASSA ........................................................................................................................................ 47 FIGURE 5 : ISOTHERMS ANNUAL AVERAGE (1931-2002) ................................................................................................................ 48 FIGURE 6 : WATERSHEDS OF THE STUDY AREA (ABHSMD) .......................................................................................................... 49 FIGURE 7 : MAIN SHEETS OF THE SOUSS MASSA WATERSHED WITH PIEZOMETRY CONTROL NETWORK (SOURCE ABHSMD) ............. 54 FIGURE 8: EROSION IN THE SOUSS MASSA BASIN ......................................................................................................................... 59 FIGURE 9 . ARGAN FOREST AND ARGAN BIOSPHERE ...................................................................................................................... 61 FIGURE 10 : POVERTY RATES OF THE CONCERNED COMMUNES ..................................................................................................... 65
LIST OF TABLES
TABLE 1 : INTERNATIONAL CONVENTIONS SIGNED AND RATIFIED BY MOROCCO (NON COMPREHENSIVE LIST) .................................. 27 TABLE 2: REGULATED POTENTIAL BY MEDIUM AND LARGE EXISTING DAMS....................................................................................... 52 TABLE 3 : SMALL DAMS AND HILLSIDE LAKES ................................................................................................................................. 53 TABLE 4: SURFACES AND CURRENT DEMANDS FOR WATER BY BASIN .............................................................................................. 56 TABLE 5 : SUMMARY OF HYDRAULIC BALANCES (MM3) OF SOUSS, CHTOUKA AND TIZNIT SHEETS .................................................... 58 TABLE 6 : AFFORESTATION RATE BY PROVINCE / PREFECTURE ...................................................................................................... 58 TABLE 7 : MATRIX OF RISKS AND SUGGESTED MITIGATION MEASURE .............................................................................................. 96 TABLE 8. ANALYSIS MATRIX OF THE ALIGNMENT OF THE PROJECT WITH ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL SAFEGUARD POLICIES AND
MEASURES ................................................................................................................................................................................. 98 TABLE 9 : ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL MANAGEMENT PLAN...................................................................................................... 106
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
5
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The project of arganiculture (argan growing) in degraded environment (DARED) consists of the integration of the
climate changes component in the whole implementation process of every development intervention in the oases
areas. Thus, this integration concerns all the components ranging from the development actors, to activities
aiming at the promotion of gender integration, and going through the implementation of structuring actions
resulting in the adaptation to climate change.
Although the project, in its background, is of environmental and social nature, given that it is related toclimate risk
integration and to improvement of adaptation to climate change practices in the argan area, it is necessary to
conduct an ESIA for a good anticipation of the residual negative impacts and for the enhancement of the positive
impacts.
Methodological approach
The environmental and social impact assessment was based on a process of consultation of stakeholders, and
representatives of direct beneficiaries of project. This consultation process aimed at:
Identifying and anticipating positive impacts and building measures to maximize them;
Identifying and analyzing potential negative impacts and mitigation measures to recommend;
Checking the compliance of planned activities with national laws and requirements in terms of environmental
and social safeguard policies;
Checking the compliance of the activities with the safeguard policies of the Green Climate Fund (GCF);
Giving the baseline situation in order to follow the evolution of monitoring indicators and mitigations measures
recommended, throughout the project;
Assessing the environmental and social impacts in accordance with the safeguard policies of GCF;
Establishing an environmental and social management plan for the project.
Nature of the project:
The DARED project consists of three components:
COMPONENT 1: IMPLEMENTATION OF THE ARGANICULTURE ON 10 000 HA
This component involves the planting of 10,000 ha, preceded by a pilot project on 500 ha during the first years. The
component also provides an extension on 2000 ha, of aromatic herbs and medicinal (PAM) as well as the supervision, the
technical assistance of the work and training and training and mentoring of the rights holders and beneficiaries. The first
component of the project aims four results:
- Result 1.1: Arganiculture on 10,000 ha implemented; - Result 1.2: intercropping Argan/ Medicinal and aromatic plants promoted and practiced; - Result 1.3:.Rainwater harvesting strengthened - Result 1.4: technical support provided and skills and knowledge of beneficiaries strengthened and developed.
RESULT 1.1: ARGANICULTURE ON 10,000 HA IMPLEMENTED
Activity 1.1.1: Plantation of argan trees on 10,000 ha:
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
6
o Planting selected argane seedlings at a density equivalent to that in semi-intensive orchard (180- 200 plants / ha) and intensive (300-400 plants / ha).
o Use of modern orchard management horticultural techniques;
The overall programme of 10,000 ha is implemented in 31 rural communes of the 8 targeted provinces.
RESULT 1.2: INTERCROPPED SEEDLING PROMOTED AND PRACTICED
Activity 1.2.1: Intercropping with medical and aromatic plants on 2000 ha
The project targets to promote an intercropping farming system based on planting argane trees with aromatic and medicinal plants (PAM). Generally, the PAM farming is widespread in Morocco with a large and diversified species (Basil, Thyme, Fennel, Mint, Verbena, Saffron, Fenugreek, etc ..).
RESULT 1.3: IMPROVING RAINWATER HARVESTING AND CONSERVATION OF WATER AND SOIL
The climate in Morocco is arid or semi-arid character and is marked by recurrent droughts; its rainfall regime is very irregular in time and space with a sequential alternating years of high runoff and then severe drought, which can last several years.
The current PDAIRE of the Project area revealed that the groundwater resources are in deficit; the only potential water resources available are surface water in medium, small dams and rainwater harvesting infrastructure. Other less known and uncertain resources, such as artificial insemination of clouds, and the exploration of deep groundwater. In the non-conventional water component, the identified options are the use of desalination of sea water and reuse of treated wastewater.
Capture and storage of runoff water and its harvesting for domestic, agriculture and environmental management. The capture techniques and rainwater harvesting could be a promising source given their wide area distribution covers remote areas with difficulty to reach and supply, particularly in the mountainous rural areas. Many technologies have been developed within this framework; collection in rainwater is used for irrigation (as supplemental irrigation) and for pastoral water points along the rangelands and in the municipalities engaged in farming (collective tanks on course the Ghdirs, hill lakes, etc ...) The studies undertaken by the ABH-MS has identified a significant need for rainwater harvesting.
RESULT 1.4: PLANTATION ACCOMPANIED
Activity 1.4.1: Supervision, technical assistance work
This assistance concerns the monitoring of the work and the finalization of site selection and planning for the duration of the
project among the identified potential.
The choice of priority areas will be done through a participatory approach with beneficiaries and based the date of
submission request for funding par stakeholders. Also, the implementation will be based on the follow criteria that includes:
- General geographical zoning - Specific criteria of the perimeter: - Commitments and responsibilities of beneficiaries - Adaptability to the argan plantations - Balance between the potential areas identified
COMPONENT 2: STRUCTURATION ON UPSTREAM AND DOWNSTREAN ARGAN VALUE
CHAIN
This component will lead to two results that are:
‐ Result 2.1: Professional organizations on the upstream of the sector of Argan structured and GIE created and accompanied
‐ Result 2.2: Valuing of argan products
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
7
RESULT 2.1: PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATIONS ON THE UPSTREAM OF THE ARGAN SECTOR STRUCTURED AND GIE CREATED AND
ACCOMPANIED
Activity 2.1.1: mobilization and supervision of the entitled persons and farmers and their professional organization
(OP).
The mobilization and the framing of the fruit producers constitutes the key to the success of the project. Indeed, it is
themselves which are organized to constitute their OP and themselves which influence its performance. A set of messages
must be transmitted, inter alia:
- The imperative to transform their organization into a viable OP (autonomous and efficient) able to mobilize the fruit producers for collective management to guarantying subsequently a consistent quality product on the level of identified perimeter;
- The importance of the organizations of second order for valorization and/or marketing. Other messages can be added according to regional specificities and specificities of the perimeters.
- Activity 2.1.2: Support cooperatives and GIE creation
The projected organization comprises two levels:
The creation of cooperatives to the upstream of the sector of the argan whose main object is the collection of the harvest of the fruits of argane within the limits of a zone identified within a perimeter of production;
The federation of the cooperatives in GIEs (interest groups) which give them supports in the conditioning of the product and their operation (organization, financing, administrative approaches, etc) and deal with the management of marketing.
RESULT 2.2: ARGAN'S PRODUCTS ARE VALUED
The main target in the short term for the interest groups created as a result of 2.1, is collecting the production of dried Argan
fruits, processing it fully or partially , depending on market demand, including pulping , packing and crushing, and selling the
product to argan oil processing cooperatives or companies.
In the medium term (after about five years of existence), these interest groups can expand into the production of argan oil
and possibly include other economic operators in the context of a community development effort covering its territory. Such a
development will involve the beneficiaries acting together as one team. They are expected to play a participatory and
dynamic role in improving the economic and social situation in their area and eventually for the overall Argan biosphere.
- Activity 2.2.1: Implementation of argan product collection units
The project will support the development of 11 centers for collecting and storing the Argan fruit. The unit size chosen as a
base model, is an interest group consisting of three (3) cooperatives. The overall collection and storage capacity totals 9,000
tons of dried Argan fruit, with an average of 3,000 tons per cooperative. A varying proportion of these quantities is
transformed to be sold as kernels and the rest is sold as is.
- Activity 2.2.2 : Installation of argan oil extraction pilot unit
In order to reduce the pressure on the natural resources of the biosphere, it is imperative to diversify the activities and to
increase the incomes of the local populations and to keep most of added value from these producing activities in at the
community level.
COMPONENT 3: CAPACITY BUILDING, KNOWLEDGE MANAGEMENT, CO-MANAGMENT OF
NATURAL ARGAN FOREST AND SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH PROMOTION
Three results are sought through the fourth component of the project. These results are :
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
8
‐ Result 3.1: Climate change management Capacities of institutional actor, elected representatives and professional organizations are reinforced and developed (RBA Co-managment).
‐ Result 3.2. Consolidating and promoting research on the Argan Tree. is consolidated and encouraged.
RESULT 3.1: REINFORCED AND DEVELOPING THE CAPACITIES OF INSTITUTIONAL ACTOR, ELECTED OFFICIALS AND PROFESSIONAL
ORGANIZATIONS IN THE FIELD OF CHANGE CLIMATE MANAGEMENT AND CONTRIBUTE ON CO-MANAGEMENT OF ARGAN NATURAL
FOREST
- Activity 3.1.1: Training of institutional actors and elected officials on the challenges of climate change to integrated local planning in the RBA and training on co-management of Argan Natural Forest
In areas of the Argan tree, information / training of actors for CC / RBA and CC adaptation is uneven. The project will
address the information and training gaps in selected sites that have not had the opportunity to benefit from major training or
knowledge transfer activities on adaptation to CC.
Populations have acquired expertise and adaptation techniques to CC because of their ancestral management experience in
facing scarcity and natural hazards. The consultation workshops confirmed that there is an awareness of aggravated risks
posed by climate change in all locations and areas affected by the project components. The said project aims to undertake
the following actions:
Development and implementation of a training program on climate change in RBA.
The project will issue a call for expressions of interest (EOI) with training organizations to develop a skills development plan
and implement it with all required participants. Overall, these modules must cover most sectors affected by climate change
related to the Argan tree. These modules should also address aspects of climate finance, conflict management and
mediation, biodiversity conservation, green economy, etc.
All selected modules are in line with the Green Climate Fund strategy:
Participation in events and scientific meetings and forums;
Organization of travel and Training;.
Training of Co-management on Argane Natural Forest.
- Activity 3.1.2 : Co-management of Natural Argan Forest
Many sub-activities will be implemented to reinforce management capacity and develop a mitigation approach to climate
change, namely
Capacity building: Reinforcement of capabilities and technical knowledge of beneficiaries and fruit producers Capacity building for collective management perimeters and the functioning of their OP Development of co-management agreements and sustainable use of natural forest and its regeneration Implementation of co-management agreements between stakeholders and actors;
RESULT 3.2: ARGAN RESEARCH IS CONSOLIDATED AND ENCOURAGED
Activity 3.2.1: Support for the implementation of the Argan National Center (CNA)
The establishment of the national center of excellence of the argan tree will channel the efforts of all scientific and
professional actors. This center will also promote Argan's cultural heritage and support for research excellence. Its strategic
objectives will address:
Preserve and interpret natural and cultural heritage of the RBA linked to the argane tree through the creation of the “Argane interpretive Center”
Design and implementation of a knowledge management platform on the Arganeraie and argane tree
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
9
Support scientific research on RBA and argan tree by supporting the implementation of joint programs and fund raising and fund management mechanisms;
Technological intelligence and expertise to support decision-makers and professionals, and all the stakeholders towards sustainable development.
Activity 3.2.2: Support for the concretization of the Argan Research-Innovation Federator Program
The project will support the realization of the "Joint Argane Research Program" mainly through:
• Call for research proposals mainly about the development of arganiculture
• Support scholarships for young researchers to fund research topics on the Argane / CC / RBA priority issues ;
• Support for the National Argane Researchers Network (RENARGANE)
BASELINE SITUATION:
The DARED project covers areas in three regions of Morocco (Sous-Massa, Guelmim and Essaouira). The project
area is characterized by a semi-arid to arid climate and high variability in precipitation. Indeed, the region has
experienced, during the last three years, heavy rains and floods causing several deaths and huge losses in terms of
infrastructure and property.
The project area is adjacent to the Arganaraie Biosphere Reserve and near a set of sites of biological and ecological
importance.
The direct beneficiary population is estimated at 26,000 inhabitants out of a total indirect population, which amounts to
345,000 inhabitants. The project area is located near the forest of argan, which spreads over an area of 830,000
hectares with a quite developed (about 300 cooperatives and 6,500 adherents) fabric of cooperatives for argan
products collection and valorization.
The argan sector is quite well organized with the presence of representations of all argan producers (RARBA).
Summary of potential impacts and mitigation and or enhancement measures
The Project will allow carbon sequestration of 2,091,201 T.eq.CO2 toward 2030, as compared to a 'without project’ scenario
(345,009 T.eq.CO2), broken down as following: the methodology to estimate the Carbone sequestration is part of NAMAs
methodology to estimate the Carbone sequestration1.
Action NAMA-
arganiculture
Emission (+) /
sequestration (-) in
T.eq.CO2
DARED
Emission (+) /
sequestration (-) in
T.eq.CO2
1 Etude stratégique d’atténuation des émissions des gaz à effet de serre dans le cadre du PMV –Elaboration d’une liste de NAMAs potentielles- rapport de
la mission II- page 14 à 28- 2014
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
10
43,000 ha
toward 2030
DARED Project
New argan orchards in association with crops -2 282 586,00 -530 833,95
Additional benefit related to the preservation of argan forest - 154 074,00 -154 074,00
Burning of shells 170,00 170,00
Diesel consumption for irrigation 280,00 280,00
“Without action" scenario consisting of the plantation of argan orchards in
the framework of the strategy implemented by ANDZOA
- 345 009,00 -80 234,65
Total balance -2 091 201,00 -604 223,30
OTHERS POTENTIAL IMPACT OF PROJECT :
- Argane area/household
The average area exploited by beneficial holders and per household is estimated at 2.6 hectares. It will be increased with
the project after completion to an average of 5 hectares / household.
- Argane production/ household (MT)
The production of the argan fruit will be increased on average of 5 tons / household after five years for project’s implantation.
It’s mean an additional production of 50 000 tons instead of 1.9 tons / household (baseline).
- Labor for kernel extraction (Hr)
The project will have a significant impact on employment promotion and emancipation of rural women. Indeed, at 800 hours
of work kernel a ton of fruit for an income 4.5 dollars per day per woman. The project will provide a double workday for
women five years after project completion. Ten years after starting the project, the volume of hours for kernel will be
increased by6000 hours.
- Impacts on arganeraie biosphere reserve (RBA)
The project aim to reduce the pressure on the argan biosphere reserve and increasing the resilience of the biosphere to fight
against the effects of climate change and contribute to reduce the soil erosion in the RBA and improve best practices. In fact,
the project will increase the average surface area per household to 5 hectares from the 2,5 hectares actually in the case of
business as usual. Also, if the worst case scenario of climate changes is felt, the argan region may become too dry and too
hot to continue hosting the argan tree. Vast expanses of argan orchards might then be unsuited for the tree.
- Impacts on biodiversity
The project aims to improve the biodiversity through planting Medicinal and Aromatic Plants on 2000 hectares and
developing the resilience of Argan tree in degraded environment. In fact, the first experience that was conducted in the
region demonstrate how arganiculture orchards contribute to preserving the biodiversity (photo bellow demonstrate the
impact of arganiculture in the degraded area).
- Capacity Building, social and cultural impact : o Capacity building in agriculture and sustainable collective management of planted areas for partners and
stakeholders
o Installing a school in the field dedicated to arganiculture
o Capacity building for research actors
o Strengthening links between regions where the project is carried out (exchanges, meetings at fairs, ...);
o Awareness about environmental protection and risks related to climate change;
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
11
Capacity building through training on topics such as health, hygiene and safety
ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL MANAGEMENT PLAN
The assessment of the environmental and social impact and the establishment of the ESMP have been conducted through a
screening of positive impacts and risks of negative impacts, as well as mitigation measures, in accordance with the
safeguard policies of the Green Climate Fund (GCF). Note that no major impact has been identified and that the component
3 of the project will rather benefit capacity building components that contribute to environmental protection and to achieving
the objectives of the GCF.
The risks and environmental and social negative impacts (minor risks) that have been identified are limited and will occur
temporarily during the project implementation phase.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
12
Environmental and Social Safeguard Principles
Element of compliance evaluation Potential risks to manage before, during project implementation
Corrective and preventive actions
PS1: Assessment and management of environmental and social risks and impacts
The project’s social and environmental classification is “B”. The project will not generate adverse environmental and social impacts and risks. Instead, institutional strengthening of government and community institutions, coupled with management plans for the sustainable use of natural resources for income-generating, will contribute to providing proper care for the natural resources base and to improving livelihoods in the province. Negative environmental and social impacts and risks are minor and can be prevented and/or mitigated. The project includes an ESIA identifying environmental and social risks and impacts.
- Difficulty in procurement of argan plants
- Adherence of the population
- Pollution
- Lack or insufficient irrigation of argan seedlings
Follow the environmental and social monitoring plan for the project
Project Risk management gives priority to anticipation and avoidance first, before seeking to minimize or compensate for the effects of unavoidable risks The project adopts an environmental and social management plan that identifies risks and provides for actions to be implemented to avoid, minimize or compensate for their effects. Environmental and social monitoring mechanism Complaints handling mechanism to implement
Identified risks associated with environmental and social aspects (ESIA); Social risks for the project components
Follow the environmental and social monitoring plan, globally or by project component
PS2: Labour and working conditions
The project will be in confrmity with the Labour Code /Morocco (code travail Maroc : bulletin officiel numéro 5210 du jeudi 6 mai 2004. Dahir n° 1-03-194 du 14 rejeb 1424 (11 septembre 2003) portant promulgation de la loi n° 65-99 relative au code du travail. 2004.) Morocco has ratified ILO core labour standards.
The probable risk of non-equity is the difference in salary between men and women workers and workers in the low access of women to jobs at companies employed by the project.
It is necessary to include clauses related to the compliance with ILO labour rights and national standards.
All activities planned in the framework of the project are in accordance with national and international laws
Limited institutional capacity for implementation of the ESMP (Environmental and Social Management Plan)
Development of a capacity building plan (information, training, etc.) to reinforce the capacities of institutions responsible for the implementation of the ESMP
None of the proposed actions will generate negative issues on these population groups. All project activities help strengthen the resilience of the population and improving their socio-economic conditions
During the implementation of the actions the vulnerable groups susceptible to be impacted during construction or operating phases are not identified yet.
ANDZOA shall engage a survey investigation to identify vulnerable and/or marginalized groups that may be impacted during construction or operating phases This measure will be included in the ESMP.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
13
Environmental and Social Safeguard Principles
Element of compliance evaluation Potential risks to manage before, during project implementation
Corrective and preventive actions
The organizations and contractors responsible for the implementation of the project are subject to the law which requires a minimum of social protection for workers
Exposure to pollution, risk of workplace accidents
Implement the measures of the ESMP
Organizations and enterprises in charge of implementing the project are subject to the law that prohibits child labor
No risk Raising awareness and integrating binding clauses in the contract documents
PS3: Resource efficiency and pollution prevention
Due to the small scale of the project and its small footprint, very low amounts of waste are produced. Also, the energy and other raw materials are low.
Deterioration of water quality of the Oueds (Rivers) along the segments affected by the construction of infrastructure.
Conventional mitigation measures reported in the ESMP will be implemented.
The project includes a component for the mobilization of rainwater for a better management of the resource "water". Energy requirements for the project are low.
No identified risk Sensitivity for better irrigation techniques
The Project reinforces resilience to climate change, and will not result in an increase in greenhouse gas emissions.
A temporary residual negative impact, with low intensity lies in low emissions of greenhouse gases during the construction of the structures.
Engage a climate check for the construction of the structures
PS4: Community health, safety and security
Apart from the risk of accidents that are controllable during the work phase, no project activity is generating negative impact on health.
risk of the spread of HIV spread in the community of workers during the construction phase and The risk of personal injury.
i) make workers aware of the disease ii) it is also necessary to take the measures recommended in the ESMP to avoid accidents. These measures must be integrated ias clauses (health, security, HIV aids awareness) in specific technical specifications contracted with the companies responsible for the work.
No action planned in this project, disagrees with the principles of human right. The project will be in line with the these human rights stipulated by the Moroccan new constitution that enshrines human rights as universally recognized and stipulates the protection of these rights, taking into account their universality and indivisibility. The Moroccan constitution adopted all rights provided for in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights enshrined the primacy of international conventions ratified by Morocco on national legislation and affirmed Morocco's commitment to harmonize these legislation with the provisions of these conventions.
The implementation of some activities can induce a deviation of rights such as deterioration of the living or non-securing the work site during the construction phase.
It is necessary to include environmental and social clauses (health, security, social issues, HIV aids awareness) in specific technical specifications contracted with the companies responsible for the work. This practice was initiated and implemented in the mega-project implemented under the compact millennium challenge account (MCC-USAID) and the Ministry of agriculture and fisheries in morocco. This model is well documented and can serve as an example. it has also been used for similar projects in the oasis of Tafilalet MCC project.
PS5: Land acquisition and involuntary resettlement
No population in the zone will be subject to resettlement due to the project activities.
For physical actions, and after the final selection of the sites by localization, the risk of expropriation - Involuntary
Possible measures to manage this risk are: i) search for an alternative site without involuntary resettlement, ii) stopping the activity
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
14
Environmental and Social Safeguard Principles
Element of compliance evaluation Potential risks to manage before, during project implementation
Corrective and preventive actions
resettlement of the population may occur.
The nature of the project involves an increase in local living standards through the expansion of the income sources of the beneficiaries
No identified risk Avoid any alternative involving expropriation or population displacement
PS6: Biodiversity conservation and sustainable management of living natural resources
Some planned actions aim a better water resources management that will improve the conservation of biological diversity in oasis zones.
For physical actions, and after the final selection of the sites, the risk of deterioration of biodiversity (specially relicts or/and endemic species)
It is necessary to initiate a study to inventory and characterization of plant and animal biodiversity (fauna and flora) in the area of influence of the activity. In cases where the impact proves to be significant, the activity site should be moved to another location or to cancelling the activity
The flood protection and water collection structures will enable the maintenance of benefits drawn from ecosystem.
Non-applying of good practice of irrigation and drainage can cause soil degradation by salinization. Another risk of non-conservation of water in the soil resulted from inadequate conservation practices.
Adoption (and training on) of practices of soil and water conservation:
- Leaching requirement to avoid salts accumulation in root zone
- Superficial minimum tillage,
- Mulching,
- Soil organic amendment
- etc.
PS7: Indigenous peoples
Principle not applicable to the project - -
PS8: Cultural heritage
Project activities do not generate negative impacts on the natural and cultural heritage (NCP). Indeed, in addition to the choice of the site which should prevent any site or heritage building, the NCP is protected by legal texts (Loi- 22-80 relative à la conservation des monuments historiques et des sites, des inscriptions, des objets d’art et d’antiquités, etc. )
NO RISKS _
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
15
Gender
Women and men will benefit from the same employment opportunities offered during the implementation phase. The ANDZOA and the
entity responsible for the implementation of the activity specifies that the chances for gender equality will be considered in the proposed
opportunities.
Component Positive impact Risks or negative impacts Mitigation measure
Component 1 : Conduct argan
growing (arganiculture) on 10 000
ha
Positive impact through
improving income for men
and women
- No risks
The construction work will
impact the employment of
both men and women
Risk of hiring men rather than
women due to the nature of
the work to be done ;
Risk relating to work
opportunity during the
construction phase
Specify the nature of the work,
the skills required while
highlighting equal chances for
job opportunities
Component 2 : Structuration of
upstream and downstream argan
value chain
Both genders will take
advantage of the work. This
component will contribute
to the employment of
women and thus mitigate
the risk of exclusion of
women from the project
This component will also
support wealth creation
initiatives (ICR) to the
benefit of young women.
Impact on other activities of
women because of their
occupation for the valuing of
the argan products.
During the implementation
phase, establish an
assessment of women's
activities in order to take them
into account in the planning of
the project and its activities
Component 3 : Capacity building,
knowledge management, Co-
managment of Natural Argan Forest
and scientific research promotion
positive impact on the
capacity building of all
stakeholders (men and
women)
- No risks
The following provides a summary of the main positive and negative social and environmental impacts of the project as
well as recommended mitigation and enhancement measures POSITIVE IMPACT COMMENTARY AND ENHANCEMENT MEASURES
Impacts on arganeraie biosphere reserve (RBA)
Reducing the pressure on the biosphere reserve;
Increasing the resilience of the biosphere in order to fight against the effects of climate change;
Contribution to the reduction of soil erosion risk in the biosphere reserve. Indeed, protection and rainwater catchment structures will protect both the argan growing area and a part of the biosphere reserve;
Reinforcing good protection practices of the Biosphere Reserve by the dissemination of
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
16
POSITIVE IMPACT COMMENTARY AND ENHANCEMENT MEASURES
good practices and the development of products derived from the argan tree;
Adding values to products derived from the argan tree in the argan biosphere beserve;
Strengthening the capacity of stakeholders in the area of the biosphere reserve;
Adding value to the products of the argan and searching for mitigation solutions to reduce the pressure on the reserve through the research center on the argan.
Impacts on ground water and surface water resources
The possible reconversion of a part of the intensive agriculture toward arganiculture (agran growing), will reduce the pression on water resources;
Mobilization of water resources for agriculture and aromatic or medicinal plants during the phase of plantation and value adding;
Water concentration in structures (basins, catchments) which improves the efficiency of the use of water;
Partial recharge of the aquifer by strengthening the collection of rainwater and the storing of flood waters;
Efficient management of water resources, contributing to the reduction of pressure on water resources, to the improvement of living conditions of the beneficiary population and to the improvement of the productivity of plantations;
Strengthening good practices about rational utilization of water for irrigation; good water use practices;
Good water saving practices;
Supporting applied research on optimizing the mobilization of water resources.
Impacts on soil and carbon sequestration
Protection of soil against erosion and improvement of soil fertility;
Carbon sequestration;
Dissemination of good practices for soil protection.
Impacts on biodiversity
Improving biodiversity through growing Medicinal and Aromatic Plants (PAM);
Domestication of the argan tree;
Improving biodiversity, especially the flora, as a result of water that will be captured;
Improving productivity through irrigation;
Positive impact on the diversification of domesticated crops and promotion of activities around the protection of biodiversity (beekeeping, etc.);
Positive impact on the population through thematic training and dissemination of good practices;
Encouragement of research (PhD students, researchers, etc ..) on the issues affecting the RBA and its biodiversity;
Support for dedicated entities (CNA) to promote the biodiversity of the RBA.
Impacts on air et temperature The planting of argan and PAM will contribute to reducing the temperature and to creating an ecosystem that will strength the Arganeraie Biosphere Reserve (RBA)
Contributing to the decrease in temperature around water catchment areas and flood protection structures
Impacts on Archaeology and Cultural Heritage
No negative impact, since the areas where the project will be implemented will not touch archaeological or cultural heritage sites.
Impacts from Solid and Liquid Wastes The mitigation measures planned for the construction phase will raise awareness on good practice in treatment and management of solid and liquid waste.
Noise and Vibration Activities under the project does not generate noise or vibration.
Impact on employment and income The direct beneficiary population is about 26,000 inhabitants; the indirect beneficiary population amounts to 350,000 inhabitants ;
Improved income for the population through the production of argan and its derivative products;
Creation of jobs during the implementation of the project;
Improvement of living standards of the beneficiary population;
Participating in the sustainable development of the region;
Preservation of social stability;
Strengthening the performance of arganiculture, owing to better water management;
Heritage preservation, owing to protection against floods;
Increase in irrigated agricultural area;
Retention of the local population;
Reducing migration flows towards other areas;
Protection of lives threatened by flooding phenomenon;
Sustaining and developing income generated by the argan.
Gender Issues / Questions sur le genre Positive impact through improving income for men and women;
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
17
POSITIVE IMPACT COMMENTARY AND ENHANCEMENT MEASURES
The construction work will impact the employment of both men and women;
This component will also support wealth creation initiatives (ICR) to the benefit of young women;
Positive impact on the capacity building of all stakeholders (men and women).
Capacity Building Capacity building in agriculture and sustainable collective management of planted areas;
Installing a school in the field dedicated to arganiculture;
Capacity building for the collective maintenance of CEP (rainwater catchment) and CES (SWC - Soil and Water Conservation) structures through the installation of a school in the dedicated field;
Capacity building for all stakeholders in the sector;
Capacity building for research actors (researchers, young PhD students, etc.).
Socio Cultural Impacts Strengthening links between regions where the project is carried out (exchanges, meetings at fairs, ...);
Awareness about environmental protection and risks related to climate change;
Conservation of CEP structures (terrassettes) as ingenious structures, heritage and local know-how;
Developping socio-cultural activities and increasing the presence at fairs and local products exhibitions.
Involuntary resettlement and adherence of population
No involuntary resettlement of the population will take place.
Health and Safety and security Capacity building through training on health, hygiene and safety;
Awareness and paradigm shift on the issue of health, safety and hygiene.
POTENTIAL NEGATIVE IMPACTS RISK OR POTENTIAL NEGATIVE IMPACT AND MITIGATION MEASURE
Impacts arganeraie biosphere reserve (RBA)
Risk : Impacts related to planting work, roads improvement, atmospheric emissions, waste management (mostly plants). Mitigation measure:
Despite the absence of risk, the project will consider the importance of the RBA, which must be preserved;
Finalize a requirements specification for works which will guarantee: ‐ considering the protection of the RBA; ‐ a good management of waste of plants; ‐ A rehabilitation of areas affected by the work; ‐ Low nuisance;
Conduct an awareness campaign for farmers / beneficiaries on the protection of RBA.
Impacts on surface water and groundwater resources
Risk: The pollution of waters during the construction of rainwater catchment and flood protection structures. Mitigation measure:
Consider the volume of water needed for the planting phase before the project starts;
Foresee the possiblity that the contractor be in charge of bringing water if needed;
Include environmental and social monitoring in the role of the technical assistant;
Avoid spillage of waste and products in oueds or alluvium;
Train site staff on food safety measures to comply with.
Impacts on soil and carbon sequestration
Risk : Risk of soil contamination during the construction of the EIGs (Economic Interest Groups) upgrading units. Mitigation measure :
Ensure a good management of tailings and waste produced by the workers;
Taking the necessary measures during the construction phase in order to avoid any risk of contamination (clear requirements specification on this matter).
Impacts on biodiversity Risk : Risk of plantations clearing due to construction works, especially those related to the implementation of access roads. Mitigation measure:
Restore and rehabilitate the areas affected by the work
Impacts on air et temperature Risk:
Generation of dust and atmospheric emissions associated with construction works: presence
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
18
POTENTIAL NEGATIVE IMPACTS RISK OR POTENTIAL NEGATIVE IMPACT AND MITIGATION MEASURE
of equipment and construction of access roads, especially in the dry period. Mitigation measure:
Optimizing the movement of the equipment;
Use of equipment that are in good condition;
Watering areas close to people.
Impacts from Solid and Liquid Waste Risk :
Poor management of waste resulting from argan plants;
Minor risk of pollution during the construction phase. Mitigation measure:
Ensuring a good management of plants waste;
Taking the necessary measures during the implementation phase;
Add the ESMP to the requirements specification.
Noise and Vibration Minor risk noise during the construction phase. Mitigation measure:
Including in the requirements specification, driving restrictions at night, limited speed and necessary safety instructions (signage, etc.)
Gender Issues Risk:
Risk of hiring men rather than women due to the nature of the work to be done. Mitigation measure:
Specify the nature of the work, the skills required, while highlighting equal chances for job opportunities.
During the implementation phase, establish an assessment of women's activities in order to take them into account in the planning of the project and its activities.
Involuntary resettlement and adherence of population
Risk :
Risk of unstable adherence of beneficiaries (possible opposition). Mitigation measure:
Always check the location of the action, although there is no anticipative displacement. In cases where detailed feasibility study finds that a displacement may occur, the site will be replaced. If there is no available replacement site, the action will be canceled.
Avoid any site that may cause population displacement or any dispute in the accurate identification process.
Reaffirming the commitment of the population before the project starts (to be done by ONCA and ANDZOA).
Health and Safety and security Risk: Risk of accident or illness during the construction phase. Mitigation measure:
Taking the necessary measures to prevent employment of children;
Take the necessary measures to ensure that site staff is insured, is trained on accident and has acquired good practices and tools for safe work;
Establishing a health/safety check for onsite employees beforehand;
The contractor must designate a local clinic in case of accident, with an insurance covering all staff risks.
Conclusion:
The DARED project is under the framework of NAMA and the declination of the Green Morocco Plan through the
development of arganiculture sector in the region of Souss-Massa, Essaouira and Guelmim. This project will contribute
to the reduction of pressure on the argan and to the improvement of income sources for beneficiaries.The project will
particularly contribute to carbon sequestration and comes as a response to climate change issues in the region by
contributing to the mitigation of the impacts of floods that characterize the region.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
19
The assessment of the environmental and social impact and the establishment of the ESMP have been conducted
through a screening of positive impacts and risks of negative impacts, as well as mitigation measures, in accordance
with the safeguard policies of the Green Climate Fund (GCF). Note that no major impact has been identified and that
the components 3 and 4 of the project are rather benefit enhancement and capacity building components that
contribute to the environmental protection and to achieving the objectives of GCF.
The risks and environmental and social negative impacts (minor risks) that have been identified are limited and will
occur temporarily, during the project implementation phase.
The implementation of the Environmental and Social Management Plan will require a budget of USD 600,000
(USD 200,000 for updating ESMP before starting the work and USD 400,000 for the environmental and social
assistance).
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
20
2. INTRODUCTION AND APPROACH OF THE STUDY
APPROACH OF THE STUDY 2.1.
As part of the fight against the effects of climate change, the Green Climate Fund, in collaboration with the
ANDZOA, has the intention to mobilize funds for the project of arganiculture in degraded environment.
The areas concerned are those of the Biosphere Reserve of the argan tree (RBA), which fall within the
administrative regions of Souss Massa Draa (prefectures of Agadir Ida Outanane and Inezgane - Ait Melloul and
provinces of Taroudant, Chtouka - Ait Baha Tiznit), of Marrakech-Safi (Province of Essaouira) and of Guelmim-
Oued Noun (provinces of Sidi Ifni and Guelmim).
The project includes three components, which are:
- Component 1 : argan growing (arganiculture) on 10 000 ha
- component 2: structuration on upstream and downstrean argan value chain
- Component 3 : capacity building, knowledge management, co-managment of natural argan forest and scientific research promotion
This study consists of the environmental and social impact assessment (ESIA) of the project. The methodological
approach adopted is to start with a scoping stage which recalled the context of the project, and then identify and
assess environmental and social impacts of the project. The aim is to propose mitigation and enhancement
actions to counter the negative impacts identified.
In general, the study must answer four key questions:
1) What are changes or positive or negative impacts that may be generated by the project?
2) Are these impacts or changes important and significant?
3) What are the mitigation-compensation measures for negative impacts and enhancement measures for positive impacts?
4) What are the modalities of environmental and social management and what are the needs for capacity building for operationalization and management of mitigation measures?
To conduct the study, the following steps were undertaken:
- Description of the legal and institutional framework;
- Description of the requirements of the Green Climate Fund;
- Description of the project ;
- Description of environmental and socio-economic conditions ;
- Interaction between environmental components and components of the project. This interaction enables the identification of potential impacts;
- - Identification and assessment of impacts, formulation of mitigation and compensation measures and estimating costs of such actions;
- Compliance of the project with the requirements of the Green Climate Fund
- Development of an Environmental and Social Management Plan.
In addition, to carry out the study, a series of meetings and consultations was held, namely:
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
21
- A scoping meeting with the Contracting authority was held before the start of the study. The objective of this step was to recall the context of the project and its characteristics. Also, this meeting helped identify the objectives and scope of the study, as well as major environmental and socio-economic issues that may be associated with the project. It was also an opportunity to identify the list of data to be collected.
- Several meetings with stakeholders were held. Especially, these include: ANDZOA Agadir, ONCA, ORMVA, ABHS, regional representation of the Haut-Commissariat des Eaux et Forêts et de Lutte contre la Désertification (HCEFLCD). The project context was recalled and discussions were centered on the context of the integration of the project, relating to the field of competence of each stakeholder. Also, the environmental and socio-economic challenges of the project were discussed and debated;
- Consultations with beneficiaries were held during the project design phase. Indeed, discussions were conducted with representatives of the Network of Associations of the Arganeraie Biosphere Reserve (RARBA) and with rights holders to present the project and its issues and hear their opinions and concerns. The participatory approach adopted at the early stages of the project is essential to ensure maximum adherence of the population and reflect the expectations and fears of the beneficiaries affected by the project.
Following the field mission, and on the basis of discussions with the various stakeholders, the project team has
developed this study. A mid-term meeting has been held, at ANDZOA, to present the first results of the study and
validate and / or discuss them.
GOALS OF THE ESIA 2.2.
The project of arganiculture (argan growing) in degraded environment (PDAED) consists of the integration of the
climate changes component in the whole implementation process of every development intervention in the arga
areas. Thus, this integration concerns all the components ranging from the development actors to activities
aiming the promotion of gender integration, going through the implementation of structuring actions resulting in
the adaptation to climate change.
Although the project, in its background, is of environmental and social nature, given its declination in climate risk
integration and improvement of adaptation to climate change practices in the argan area, it is necessary to
conduct an ESIA for a good anticipation of the residual negative impacts and for the enhancement of the positive
impacts.
This ESIA is carried out in accordance with the environmental and social safeguard policies and measures of the
Grean Climate Fund - GCF, as those generally adopted by the World Bank and the GEF. The basic objective is to
examine the alignment with the environmental and social policy of the GCF, to assess the positive and negative,
environmental and social impacts that are likely to be generated by the implementation of the four components of
the project. The ultimate goal is the definition of mitigation measures for negative impacts and significant risks
and the measures that maximize positive impacts.
This ESIA is carried out in accordance with national legislation including the 12-03 law relating to environmental
impact studies (EIS) and the 12-99 law on the National Charter for Environment and Sustainable Development.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
22
3. POLITICAL, LEGAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE FRAMEWORK
LEGAL FRAMEWORK 3.1.
This chapter presents the main legal documents relating to the protection of the environment, whose
development results from the rarefaction and the degradation of the quality of natural resources. In addition, there
will be a focus on the documents and sectors that are relevant to the project.
Law 11-03 relating to the protection and the development of the environment
Promulgated in May 2005, this law aims to make it more consistent, at the legal level, all the texts that affect the
environment. These instruments falling by nature within the competence of several administrations, the law is
designed to provide a reference frame posing the fundamental principles on the basis of which future texts
relating to the environment protection must be developed. This law deals, in its third chapter, with the need for
natural resources safeguarding and protection such as soil and sub-soil, fauna, flora, inland waters, air, littoral,
mountains, etc.
Framework law 99-12, on the National Charter of the environment and sustainable development
In the same philosophy of the law 11-03, recently 99-12 framework law on the National Charter for Environment
and Sustainable Development was enacted. This law aims legal protection of resources and ecosystems, makes
sustainable development a core value, defines the responsibilities and commitments of all parties and lays down
the measures of institutional, economic and financial accompanying it. The national strategy of sustainable
development, being finalized, constitutes a framework for the operationalization of this Charter. The ultimate
objective of this strategy is to find a common ground between economic and social actors and public authorities
to operationalize the green economy and define the role of each one within this new policy.
Law on the Environmental Impact Study and its implementing decrees
Promulgated in May 2003, the Study of Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is the key instrument as regards
environmental action. Morocco has developed since 2000 institutional and technical capacities for the
environmental assessment at national level. This ability constantly improving, is more appropriate and in line with
international practices in the field of EIA.
The application process of this law is operational and is strengthened by the adoption of implementing decrees
for the decentralization of the EIA review and for the mobilization and commitment of the concerned populations
in the context of public consultations. The 12-03 law was thus reinforced by the adoption of two implementing
decrees:
‐ Decree 2-04-563 of 4 November 2008 relating to the functions and functioning of the national
committee and regional committees of the EIA: This Decree fixes, in application of articles 2, 8
and 9 of law 12-03, the responsibilities and modalities of operation of the national Committee and
regional committees as well as the composition of these committees.
‐ Decree 2-04-564 of 4 November 2008 fixing the organizational modalities and conduct of the
public investigation relative to the subjected projects to EIA.
Law 2-03 fixed a list of projects obligatorily subjected to an EIA. However, it should be noted that the activities of
hydro-agricultural development projects are not part of the list of projects under the procedure of the
environmental impact study.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
23
Dahir of 4 March 1925 (8 chaâbane 1343) on the protection and the delimitation of argan forest
The order dated May 1, 1939 of the Directors of Water and Forest and Political Affairs regarding argan stands
has been promulgated under the Dahir of 4 March 1925 on the protection and delimitation of argan forests and
under the conditions of paragraph 2 of article 2 of the Dahir of 10 October 1917 on the conservation and
exploitation of forests.
Given that the Government's rights over forests of argan trees have been recognized by the delimitation
operations made under the conditions of the Dahir of January 3, 1916, it is important to ensure their protection
and conservation so that these plantations continue to play their physical role on hydrology and climatology of the
region and to provide present and future generations with the very significant resources that have traditionally
been drawing from them through grazing, fruit picking, culture, collection of dead wood, construction and service
wood supply.
ARTICLE 5 : The right of land use includes the right of ploughing and cultivation of areas already cultivated
during the delimitation or, with regards to those not yet cultivated but cultivable without danger to the forest, as
the Forest Departement may judge.
Any forest clearing, any cutting of important forest species is prohibited and shall be punished in accordance with
the last two paragraphs of Article 34 and Article 36 of the aforementioned Dahir of 10 October 1917.
ARTICLE 7 : Users have the right to use the necessary branches for their fences.
They first use the bushes of the undergrowth (jujube trees, tizra) and, in case of need only, argan branches argan
they take through pruning at the location and on trees that are designated by the forest officer.
ARTICLE 15 : Building a tent or any construction covered with flammable materials may be allowed closer than
100 meters from the argan forest by the forest service, which sets all the precautions to be observed.
Water Law 10-95 promulgated in August 16, 1995
It provides legal provisions for rationalizing the use of water, widespread access to water, interregional solidarity,
reduction of disparities between cities and rural areas to ensure water security of the whole territory of the
Kingdom. In particular, the law allowed the reorganization of previous texts and the establishment of a number of
principles, including:
‐ The public ownership of the water and the recognition of its economic value through the
implementation of a fee system
‐ The uniqueness of the resource in its qualitative and quantitative aspects and the watershed as
planning unit and resource management
‐ National and regional solidarity and the reduction of disparities between cities and rural areas to
ensure water security for the entire territory of Morocco
‐ a system of authorizations and concessions administrative and police, relating to the various uses of
water, including sanctions for non-compliance with the standards
‐ Regulation of polluting activities and combating pollution of waters
‐ Better agricultural valorization by improving conditions for the development and use of agricultural
water (Official Bulletin No. 4325 of 20/09/95)
‐ The establishment of the Higher Council for Water and Climate (CSEC)
One of the emblematic aspects of the Law 10-95 is the water resource management in the context of a
geographical unit, the hydraulic basin, which is an important innovation to design and implement a decentralized
water management. The law created the Hydraulic Basin Agencies (ABH), public institutions with legal personality
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
24
and financial autonomy, and administered by a board of directors. The board of directors includes representatives
of the Government (majority) and other sectors concerned by water and its management. ABH mission is to
assess, plan and manage water resources at the hydraulic basins level. They can provide loans, aids and
subsidies to anyone engaging in development or water resources conservation investments. Their resources
consist of fees recovered from the users and water users, loans, subsidies, donations, etc. Six ABH have been
implemented since June 2002, in addition to the pilot agency of the Oum Er Rbia basin instituted in 1996. The
elements which should affect the most the future development of the irrigation are the development and the
periodic actualization of the water resources integrated development plan at the level of the basins, and the
possibility of granting financial aids for the investments in the resources mobilization.
Among the contributions of Law 10-95, figure contribution to improving the environmental situation of water
resources, insofar as it establishes backup and prohibition perimeters and subjects the releases spills to
declarations, prior authorizations and fees. The Article 80 specifies that no agricultural project can be approved if
its planned achieving conditions can lead to degradation of water resources or cultivated soils. In more detail, the
law specifies:
‐ The development of management planning and allocation of water resources based on a wide
consultation between users and public authorities
‐ The protection of human health by regulating the exploitation, distribution and sale of food grade
water
‐ Regulation of activities that may pollute water resources, including the provision of sanctions and the
creation of a water police to repress any illegal use of water or any act likely to impair its quality
‐ The rational allocation of water resources in the drought period to mitigate the effects of the shortage
Since the publication of the Law 10-95, thirteen (13) implementing decrees were published. They focus on the
creation of the Tadla basin agency, composition and operation of the CSEC, integrated development master
plans of water resources, the National Water Plan, fees for water use , granting authorizations, the boundaries of
hydrological public domain and blackout and protection zones, water quality standards, the inventory of the water
pollution degree and the use of wastewater.
The Dahir 1-69-170 of 10 Jumada I 1389 (25 July 1969) on the protection and restoration of soils abrogates the
Dahir of 20 March 1951 on the protection and restoration of soils and the Dahir of 4 December 1954
supplementing it. he main measure of this Dahir is the establishment of zones called "defense perimeters and soil
restoration of national concern" will be subject to a local advertising in addition to the publication on the Official
Bulletin. Articles from 4 to 11 are regulations on the compensation awarded to interested parties when the
execution of infrastructure works cannot be followed by the creation of cereal benches or fruit plantations or
afforestation production.
The Dahir 1-97-01 12 of January 1997 promulgating law 42-95 on the control and the Organization of trade of
pesticide products for use in agriculture updates the sector organization by specifying the conditions under which
approvals and authorizations are granted and subjects the activity in this matter to an application for approval.
The provided penalties are revised upwards. two decrees are adopted for the implementation of this Dahir
namely: i) Decree 2-99-105 of 5 May 1999 on the approval of pesticide products for agricultural use, and ii)
Decree 2-99-106 of 5 May 1999 on the exercise of importation, manufacturing and marketing of agricultural
pesticides products. Recall that in Morocco, the import, trade, possession and use of pesticides substances are
subject to regulation since 1922.
Loi n° 9-94 sur la protection des obtentions végétales
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
25
Promulgated by Dahir n° 1-96-255 of 12 ramadan 1417 (21 January 1997), this law sets the conditions
and the extent of the protection
Indeed, the breeder's right is related to: a) the protected variety; b) any variety that is not clearly distinguishable
from the protected variety in accordance with Article 7 of this Law; c) any variety essentially derived from the
protected variety, where the latter is not itself an essentially derived variety and d) any variety whose production
requires the repeated use of the protected variety.
Law 33-94 on development of the bour areas promulgated by the Dahir 1-95-10 of 22 February 1995 and its
implementing decree (Decree No. 2-94-589 of 27 October 1995 taken for the implementation of the Law 33-94
relative to the bour perimeters development)
This law allows the Government to achieve internal and external equipment to the properties. This Law covers all
bour areas whether they are used in collective or private management. The Law allows for circumscribed
perimeter, to implement actions at different levels (farms, rural commune) involving both beneficiaries, local
elected representatives and technical departments. The law aims primarily to improve the perimeters by land
development. The pastoral value development areas also fall under this law even if the particular land status and
specific management methods make it more difficult to apply. This Law establishes development in bour
perimeters delineated by Decree in order to create the necessary conditions for the integrated development of
modern and efficient agriculture.
Law 34-94 promulgate by Dahir n° 1-95-152 of 11 August 1995 on the fragmentation of agricultural properties in
irrigated areas and areas in Bour
It aims to conserve a viable minimum area for a family. This law establishes the prohibition of any land
transaction that has the effect of generating area of land below the minimum threshold of 5 hectares set for
irrigation perimeters , and according to the agricultural potential of each area in the PMV (Articles 2 and 4).
Law 7-81 promulgated by the Dahir of 6 May 1982
This law is implemented by the Decree of 18 April 1983 on the expropriation for public utility and temporary
occupation. This law reinforces the concept of property rights, established by the Moroccan Constitution (Article
15). The implementation of this procedure is ensured by administrative courts (established in September 1993).
The Law offers much more guarantees for the expropriated, giving them the possibility to challenge the
lawfulness of the administrative procedure by the judge and ensure that the real presence of the provisional
compensation by his mandatory deposit to the Caisse de Dépôt et de Gestion, pending the final judgment.
Labor code : Law 65-99
The Law-65-99 lists the fundamental principles and rights of workers .
It particularly insists on the fact that according to the law and current regulations, it is forbidden to infringe trade
union freedoms and rights twithin the company and to attack freedom of work with regards to the employer and
the employees of the company.
It also prohibits any discrimination against employees. In particulary, any employee that became disabled for any
reason whatsoever, keeps his job and is assigned, after consulting the labor doctor or the commission of safety
and hygiene, to a job that corresponds to his disability after rehabilitation training, unless this is impossible given
the severity of the handicap and the nature of the work.
Legislation on the protection of historical and cultural heritage
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
26
The law 11-03 mentions (in Article 8) the national interest of the protection, conservation and enhancement of the
historical and cultural heritage and establishes laws and regulations that set the various measures to take in order
to achieve these goals.
INSTITUTIONNEL FRAMEWORK 3.2.
Institutionally, the main actors are:
The Ministry of Agriculture and Sea Fishing (Ministère de l’Agriculture et de la Pêche maritime-MAPM) ;
The Delegated Ministry attached to the Ministry of Energy, Mining, Water en Environment, in charge of Environment (Ministère délégué auprès du Ministre de l'énergie, des Mines, de l'Eau, et de l'Environnement, chargé de l’environnement);
The Delegated Ministry attached to the Ministry of Energy, Mining, Water en Environment, in charge of Water (Ministère délégué auprès du Ministre de l'énergie, des Mines, de l'Eau, et de l'Environnement, chargé de l’Eau);
The Ministry of Internal Affairs (ministère de l’Intérieur);
The High Commission for Waters and Forests and the Fight against Desertification (Haut-Commissariat aux Eaux et Forêts et à la Lutte Contre la Désertification-HCEFLCD);
The Agency for Agricultural Development (Agence pour le Développement Agricole-ADA);
The National Agency for Development of Oases and Argan Tree Zones (Agence Nationale pour le Développement des Zones Oasiennes et de l'Arganier-ANDZOA);
The Agency for Hydraulic Basins (Agences de Bassins Hydrauliques) administrated by the Delegated Ministry attached to the Ministry of Energy, Mining, Water en Environment, in charge of Water;
The National Office of Agricultural Conselling (Office National du Conseil Agricole-ONCA);
The Souss-Massa-Draa Regional Office for the Agricultural Development (Office Régional de la Mise en Valeur Agricole du Sous-Massa Draa -ORMVA SMD);
The Regional Directorate of Agriculture (Direction Régionale de l’Agriculture-DRA).
NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY 3.3.
Morocco has adopted a policy based on a comprehensive and integrated vision of making the environment a central
concern of socio-economic development. Several strategies, programs and important national plans have been
developed, including:
Green Morocco Plan (Plan Maroc Vert);
National Strategy for Environmental Protection and Sustainable Development (Stratégie Nationale pour la Protection de l’Environnement et le Développement Durable);
Program for biodiversity protection and valorization (Programme de protection et de valorisation de la biodiversité);
Conservation management programs of natural resources (Programmes de gestion conservatoire des ressources naturelles);
Program "Improvement of living conditions of populations" (Programme « Amélioration du cadre de vie des populations »);
National program of household waste (Programme national des déchets ménagers);
National Program for Air Quality Protection (Programme national de protection de la qualité de l'air);
National programme for the prevention of industrial pollution and risks (Programme national de prévention de la pollution industrielle et des risques);
National Water Plan (Plan National de l’Eau);
National Action Plan for the Environment (Plan d’Action National pour l’Environnement-PANE) ;
PNPI, PDAIRE, PNABV, INDH, etc.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
27
Sectorial policies relating to environment (Charte de l’Environnement) ;
The La stratégie de lutte contre la désertification et préservation de la biodiversité (stratégie de lutte contre la désertification et préservation de la biodiversité);
The Climate Plan (Plan Climat);
Development Strategy of oases and Argan zones (Stratégie de développement des zones oasiennes et de l’arganier).
INTERNATIONAL CONVENTIONS AND AGREEMENTS 3.4.
Morocco has signed and ratified the main international conventions on the environment. Those directly or indirectly
related to the purpose of the project are reported in the following table.
Table 1 : International Conventions Signed and Ratified by Morocco (Non comprehensive List)
Title Date of entry into force of the Convention
Entry into
force
in Morocco
Date of publication
Convention for the establishment of the European and Mediterranean Organization for the protection of the plants
18-4-951 27-10-1972 B.O. N° 3214 du 5-6-1974
International Plant Protection Convention 3-4-1952 12-10-1972 B.O. N° 3204
Du 27-03-74
Kyoto Protocol on the Climate Change Convention BO n°5122 du 3/7/2003
African Convention on the Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources
16-6-1969 14-12-1977 B O n° 3494
Du 17-10-1979
Convention for the World Heritage protection 16-11-1972
28-1-1976 B O n° 3371 Du 8-6-1977
Convention on international trade of endangered species of wild flora and fauna
1-7-1975 14-1-1976 B O n° 3553
Du 3-12-1980
Convention for the Protection of the Mediterranean Sea against Pollution and its Protocols
12-2-1978 15-2-1980 B O n° 3603 Du 18-11-1981
Convention on the conservation of wildlife and the natural environment of Europe. 1-6-1982
7-2001 BO n°5054 du 7-11-2002
Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and their Disposal
5-5-1992 27-3-1996 B O n° 4892 Du 19-4-2001
Convention on Climate Change 21-3-1994 27-3-1996 B.O. n°5000
Du 2-5-2002
Convention on Biological Diversity 29-12-1993 19-11-1995 BO n° 5758
Du 6-8-2009
UN Convention on the fight against desertification in countries seriously affected by drought or desertification in particular in Africa
5-2-1997 B O n° 4514 Du 4-9-1997
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
28
Protocol for the Prevention of Pollution of the Mediterranean Sea caused by transboundary movements of hazardous wastes and their disposal.
B O n° 4732 Du 7-10-1999
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
29
SAFEGUARD POLICIES OF THE GREEN CLIMATE FUND 3.5.
The Green Climate Fund (GCF) adopted the environmental and social policies of the International Finance
Corporation (World Bank Group). These policies aim to ensure that, in pursuing the mission to remedy the
harmful effects and risks caused by climate change, projects and support programs do not result in environmental
and social damage.
These safeguard policies enable institutions to identify and manage environmental and social risks of their
activities, through evaluating the potential environmental and social impacts and identifying and taking measures
to avoid, minimize, mitigate or compensate for these impacts.
Below, is introduced the safeguard policies of the GCF:
PS1: Assessment and management of environmental and social risks and impacts
a. Identify funding proposal’s environmental and social risks and impacts;
b. Adopt mitigation hierarchy: anticipate, avoid; minimize; compensate or offset;
c. Improve performance through an environmental and social management system;
d. Engagement with affected communities or other stakeholders throughout funding proposal cycle. This
includes communications and grievance mechanisms.
PS2: Labour and working conditions
a. Fair treatment, non-discrimination, equal opportunity;
b. Good worker–management relationship;
c. Comply with national employment and labour laws;
d. Protect workers, in particular those in vulnerable categories;
e. Promote safety and health;
f. Avoid use of forced labour or child labour.
PS3: Resource efficiency and pollution prevention
a. Avoid, minimize or reduce project-related pollution;
b. More sustainable use of resources, including energy and water;
c. Reduced project-related greenhouse gas emissions.
PS4: Community health, safety and security
a. To anticipate and avoid adverse impacts on the health and safety of the affected community;
b. To safeguard personnel and property in accordance with relevant human rights principles.
PS5: Land acquisition and involuntary resettlement
a. Avoid/minimize adverse social and economic impacts from land acquisition or restrictions on land use:
i) Avoid/minimize displacement;
ii) Provide alternative project designs;
iii) Avoid forced eviction.
b. Improve or restore livelihoods and standards of living;
c. Improve living conditions among displaced persons by providing:
i) Adequate housing;
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
30
ii) Security of tenure.
PS6: Biodiversity conservation and sustainable management of living natural resources
a. Protection and conservation of biodiversity;
b. Maintenance of benefits from ecosystem services;
c. Promotion of sustainable management of living natural resources;
d. Integration of conservation needs and development priorities.
PS7: Indigenous peoples
a. Ensure full respect for indigenous peoples
i) Human rights, dignity, aspirations;
ii) Livelihoods;
iii) Culture, knowledge, practices;
b. Avoid/minimize adverse impacts;
c. Sustainable and culturally appropriate development benefits and opportunities;
d. Free, prior and informed consent in certain circumstances.
PS8: Cultural heritage
a. Protection and preservation of cultural heritage;
b. Promotion of equitable sharing of cultural heritage benefits.
POSITION OF THE PROJECT WITH REGARDS TO EXISTING DEVELOPMENT STRATEGIES 3.6.AND PROGRAMMES
3.6.1. LE PLAN MAROC VERT (GREEN MOROCCO PLAN):
As part of the PMV, Morocco has redefined its objectives in a global context concerned about food security, climate
change, the rising prices of agricultural products, producer responsibility and the fight against poverty.
Thus, this agricultural strategy aims to accelerate growth, reduce poverty, ensure the long-term sustainability of the
sector and consolidate its integration into national and international markets.
Pillar I focuses on the development of productivist and modern agriculture and responding to market
rules based on private investment in high-value and high-productivity sectors.
Pillar II concerns the accompaniment of a solidarity agriculture and the fight against poverty particularly
in areas with fragile economy and, improving incomes of poor farmers through intensification,
diversification and the valorisation of local agricultural products.
The PMV is based on redesigning the sectoral framework and the improvement of cross-cutting factors, particularly in
regard to water policies, land and interprofessional organization.
The dimension of climate change is the subject of the seventh foundation of the PMV, which is the preservation of
natural resources for sustainable agriculture. The seventh foundation is based on:
The implementation of projects within the framework of improving the resilience of agriculture to future
climate change and the preservation of land and biodiversity;
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
31
Integration in PMV projects, technologies for adaptation to climate change through the dissemination of
selected and certified seeds, the use of water and soil conservation techniques, fertilization of crops and
good agricultural practices;
Supporting the development of the use of renewable energy, particularly solar, wind and biogas;
The establishment of the National Water Saving Irrigation Program (Programme National d’Économie
d’Eau en Irrigation) ;
Development of Cultivated Soil Fertility Maps, for better crop productivity at the national level;
The National Programme for Agricultural Lands Mapping (programme
national de Cartes de Vocation Agricole des Terres) for efficient use of agricultural land potential
3.6.2. POLICY ON ARGAN DEVELOPMENT
The National Agency for the Development of Oases and Argan tree Zones (ANDZOA) was craeted in 2010 under
the supervision of AFM. Its mission is to develop, in coordination with government authorities, elected deputy and
concerned organisme, a global development program of the areas of his intervention to ensure its
implementation, monitoring its monitoring-evaluation; and that, in the context of economic, social, cultural,
environmental and human sustainable development, in accordance with decided guidelines and strategies.
The oasis and Argan tree zones territory is vast and epresents nearly 40% of the national territory. This territory
has 5 administrative regions and 16 provinces and 388 municipalities. For areas of the argan tree, ANDZOA aims
to:
Ensure the argan tree areas preservation, protection and development including the implementation of
socio-economic projects;
Conduct Argan extension operations in accordance with forestry laws and regulations
Conduct or supervise the projects implementation for argan tree products valuation, marketing,
promotion and labeling, especially under contracts or agreements- program to be concluded with the
Agency;
Structure argan tree chains production and marketing in the partnership with different stakeholders
including the concerned people;
Encourage scientific research about argan tree protection and development and the its products
valuation.
To promote and develop the argan chain, a contract-program was signed in 2011, between the government and
the Argan Moroccan Federation Interprofessional (FIMARGANE). This contract- program plans, in 2020, to :
Rehabilitation of 200,000 hectares of natural argan tree;
Domestication of the argan tree and extension in modern ochard (arganiculture) on 5,000 Ha;
Promotion of the argane "Protected Geographical Indications " Label and f its products and derivatives
on the international market;
Increasing argan oil production to reach, in 2020, 10.000 tons / year (currently estimated at 4.000 tonnes
/ year);
Establishment argan Pillar I and Pillar II projects to integrate efficiently the mintenational market.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
32
4. DESCRIPTION OF THE PROJECT
IMPLEMENTING AGENCY AND PILOTING ENTITY 4.1.
The institutional structure of piloting, monitoring and implementation of the proposed project emanates from a
previous capitalization. With respect to the Project management, ANDZOA will host a Project Management Unit
(PMU). This unit will coordinate the monitoring and implementation of the project activities with the ADA and the
other partners. The PMU will adopt an integrated and multi-sectoral approach and will focus on the beneficiary’s
participation and active involvement at all levels of decision-making. This unit will be responsible, inter alia, of the
coordination of all the project activities, the regional monitoring Committee activities (CORES) and the provincial
local Committee (COLOP) organizations, the project results valorization and the communication strategy
implementation. The PMU will be composed of the following staff:
- National project coordinator,
- arboriculture/horticulture Specialist (argan-culture);
- Rural engineering specialist,
- Environment, Social and Gender specialist,
- Procurement and financial management specialist,
- Monitoring and evaluation specialist.
The analyses and discussions held during the preparation of the project agrees on the need for setting up an unit
of management by objectives.
The relevant arrangement envisages the following organization:
Steering Committee (COPIL)
The Steering Committee (COPIL), chaired by the Secretary General of the Ministry of Agriculture and Marine
Fisheries or the ANDZOA General Director gathers all the stakeholders: MAPM central directorates (DIAEA,
DSS, DF, DDFP , RFLD), ADA, ANDZOA, the HCEFLD, Water Department, Environment, Tourism, Handicraft
and social and solidarity economy, FIMARGANE ...).
The COPIL will meet at least twice per year and when necessary with as main missions:
- Review the project functioning and its activities progress
- Supervise, validate project activities and reports
- Identify strategic choices
- Ensure risk control
- Validate the annual programs (including the ESMP) and related budgets,
- Validate the progress reports and the obtained results ,
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
33
- Validate the adjustments and changes in the project activities,
- Ensure consistency of the project with the sector policies and government programs.
The Steering Committee recommendations focus on the orientation and strategies to be implemented to achieve
the project objectives in compliance with the Government and the GCF policy.
Regional Monitoring Committee (CORES)
The project will implement a regional monitoring committee (CORES), which will be implemented in two regions
(Marrakech-Safi and Souss Massa) and which will have the following roles:
- Ensure interactions between the regional and local levels, on the one hand, and the Steering Committee of
the project, on the other hand;
- Mobilise local institutional stakeholders
- Encourage interaction between local communities and development partners;
- Review and propose to COPIL the adjustments and changes in project activities;
- Ensure the project agreements implementation; and
- Capitalize on the learned experiences and lessons from the project interventions.
The CORES meetings will be held every six months on a rotating basis in each province. The CORES will be
composed of representatives of the departments and institutions operating at the level of the concerned regions.
Provincial Local Committee (COLOP) :
The project will also implement the Provincial Local Committee (COLOP) in the various provinces of the two
regions of the project. The COLOP will have the mission:
- Examine the problems impeding implementation of the programs,
- Follow the evaluation plan execution progress and the follow-up of the evaluation conclusions,
- Ensure the communication strategy implementation (Identification of the of dissemination means support,
exchange of information)
- perform the actions in favor of equal opportunities between women and men,
- Examine any proposed amendment submitted by the Management Unit.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
34
OBJECTIVES OF THE PROJECT 4.2.
The global objective of the project is to strengthen the resilience of rural communities and the biosphere reserve
of the argan (RBA) to climate change. The project aims to implement modern orchards of the argan tree (argani-
culture) on 10,000 hectares and build an institutional and organizational innovative environment favorable for this
purpose.
The project will also contribute to improve soil fertility and increase carbon storage in soil and biomass. It will
directly improve the living conditions of the local population, especially women; it will relieve of anthropogenic
pressure on the argan natural forest while improving production and productivity of the argan.
This project will also adopt water saving technologies coupled with the solar pumping system. This project will
also mitigate the negative impacts related to flooding and the protection of human lives in an environment
characterized by climate change.
DESCRIPTION OF THE PROJECT COMPONENTS 4.3.
The project is declined in tree components described briefly below:
4.3.1. COMPONENT 1: IMPLEMENTATION OF THE ARGANICULTURE ON 10 000 HA
This component involves the planting of 10,000 ha, preceded by a pilot project on 500 ha during the first years. The
component also provides an extension on 2000 ha, of aromatic herbs and medicinal (PAM) as well as the supervision, the
technical assistance of the work and training and training and mentoring of the rights holders and beneficiaries. The first
component of the project aims four results:
- Result 1.1: Arganiculture on 10,000 ha implemented; - Result 1.2: intercropping Argan/ Medicinal and aromatic plants promoted and practiced; - Result 1.3:.Rainwater harvesting strengthened - Result 1.4: technical support provided and skills and knowledge of beneficiaries strengthened and developed.
RESULT 1.1: ARGANICULTURE ON 10,000 HA IMPLEMENTED
Activity 1.1.1: Plantation of argan trees on 10,000 ha:
This activity is the domestication of argan trees on private land, through the following operations:
o Planting selected argane seedlings at a density equivalent to that in semi-intensive orchard (180- 200 plants / ha) and intensive (300-400 plants / ha).
o Use of modern orchard management horticultural techniques;
The overall program of 10,000 ha is implemented in 31 rural communes of the 8 targeted provinces.
The first leading pilot experience is conducted currently under Pilier II of the GMP in the Province of Tiznit with support from
the Agriculture Provincial Directorate of Tiznit in a partneship with Association Iklaln in Rasmouka rural commune; a 600 ha
project has been identified and a first phase of 25 ha is already established.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
35
Figure 1 : The argan tree planting Sites
RESULT 1.2: INTERCROPPED SEEDLING PROMOTED AND PRACTICED
Activity 1.2.1: Intercropping with medical and aromatic plants on 2000 ha
The project targets to promote an intercropping farming system based on planting argane trees with aromatic and medicinal plants (PAM). Generally, the PAM farming is widespread in Morocco with a large and diversified species (Basil, Thyme, Fennel, Mint, Verbena, Saffron, Fenugreek, etc ..). This operation should allow especially ensure:
Complementarity between the 'cultivated' and the 'spontaneous' particularly with regard to regularity of product offering.
Product quality (traceability);
the balance between supply and demand for PAM;
the valuation of the land in the targeted areas;
the preservation and protection of certain endangered plant species.
In the case of the Project, in addition the abovementioned elements the main objective is to ensure to the farmers / beneficiaries additional income while waiting for fruit production of the argane trees and have access to additional income.
Its worth mentioning that tests of Medicinal and Aromatic plants were conducted under a project by MAPM in the region Souss Massa (Project ASIMA) and the results are already available.
The first year of the project will cover an area of 100 ha in rural pilot site. Pilot plots will be developed to test the species that bests fit the area.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
36
Capitalizing on existing results, it is proposed to test three species of PAM by province (thyme, fennel and mint / lemon verbena). The final choice of species to plant will be at the end of the first year. These will be tested PAM planted in dividing strips beside the argan tree to encourage the development of an ecosystem in the area.
In light of the results of the pilot sites, there are plans to extend the culture of PAM over an area of 1,500 ha. According to the local surveys and meetings with local stakeholders, the PAM sector is booming. This could bring significant added value to contribute to the improvement of living standards of the vulnerable populations.
It should be noted that the PAM sector is organized and structured in such as way that the “production of biomass” (collection) and "transformation" and is characterized by the diversity of stakeholders and operators along the value (extraction, drying, distillation, packaging, cold storage, herbalism, pharmaceutical, extraction, preparation, etc.)
RESULT 1.3: IMPROVING RAINWATER HARVESTING AND CONSERVATION OF WATER AND SOIL
The climate in Morocco is arid or semi-arid character and is marked by recurrent droughts; its rainfall regime is very irregular in time and space with a sequential alternating years of high runoff and then severe drought, which can last several years.
The current PDAIRE of the Project area revealed that the groundwater resources are in deficit; the only potential water resources available are surface water in medium, small dams and rainwater harvesting infrastructure. Other less known and uncertain resources, such as artificial insemination of clouds, and the exploration of deep groundwater. In the non-conventional water component, the identified options are the use of desalination of sea water and reuse of treated wastewater.
Capture and storage of runoff water and its harvesting for domestic, agriculture and environmental management. The capture techniques and rainwater harvesting could be a promising source given their wide area distribution covers remote areas with difficulty to reach and supply, particularly in the mountainous rural areas. Many technologies have been developed within this framework; collection in rainwater is used for irrigation (as supplemental irrigation) and for pastoral water points along the rangelands and in the municipalities engaged in farming (collective tanks on course the Ghdirs, hill lakes, etc ...) The studies undertaken by the ABH-MS has identified a significant need for rainwater harvesting. It needs amounts to over 1 billion MAD over 3 years (2017-2019). Assuming the integration of activities of the First Draft and after the various meetings and consultation with the various stakeholders, a preliminary program has been identified and recommends the construction of 95 macro and micro ground catchment systems for rainwater harvesting with an average storage capacity of 600 m3 each. The average unit cost per system of 65 thousand US $. The overall amount s' amounted as mentioned on financing program with funding from 5% to be provided by the ABH.
RESULT 1.4: PLANTATION ACCOMPANIED
Activity 1.4.1: Supervision, technical assistance work
This assistance concerns the monitoring of the work and the finalization of site selection and planning for the duration of the
project among the identified potential.
The choice of priority areas will be done through a participatory approach with beneficiaries and based the date of
submission request for funding par stakeholders. Also, the implementation will be based on the follow criteria that includes:
- General geographical zoning - Specific criteria of the perimeter: - Commitments and responsibilities of beneficiaries - Adaptability to the argan plantations - Balance between the potential areas identified
4.3.2. COMPONENT 2: STRUCTURATION ON UPSTREAM AND DOWNSTREAN ARGAN VALUE CHAIN
This component will lead to two results that are:
‐ Result 2.1: Professional organizations on the upstream of the sector of Argan structured and GIE created and accompanied
‐ Result 2.2: Valuing of argan products
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
37
RESULT 2.1: PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATIONS ON THE UPSTREAM OF THE ARGAN SECTOR STRUCTURED AND GIE CREATED AND
ACCOMPANIED
The different evaluations of the current state of the argan space raise the weakness or absence (in the majority of the
ecosystem) of economically viable professional organization of fruit producers. The aforementioned evaluations also raise
the insufficiency amongst active economic actors in the aspect of marketing of argan nuts as regard to the recorded potential
of production.
In fact, the segment of agroindustrial and cosmetics companies monopolizes most of the added value generated by the
sector of the argan when that of fruit producers has remained on the sidelines of this dynamic sector and its recorded
development.
Concerned with this situation, the study initiated by the ANDZOA confirmed the need to structure territorially geographical
area of the argan in homogeneous production areas as the social and technical plan is in concern. Aforementioned study
suggested setting up models of organization of fruit producers to create perimeter including their federation into GIEs
(interest groups), while ensuring the technical, financial and economic viability of these new institutions.
It is accordingly that is registered the outputs of this result 2.1 which aims at the structuring of the actors especially those
operating in the upstream of the sector of argan this through the accompaniment of the professional organization of the fruit
producers.
These second-order organizations allowing both to operate at the level of argan and also to position themselves for the new
perimeters of arganiculture planned as part of the project in question (see component 1).
The support expected under this project to cooperatives and GIE organizing the upstream sector of the argan, besides
financial support, will focus on technical assistance, knowledge improvement (statistics and socio -economic ) concerning the
sector, the professional organization and the preservation of the environment.
Activity 2.1.1: mobilization and supervision of the entitled persons and farmers and their professional organization
(OP).
The mobilization and the framing of the fruit producers constitutes the key to the success of the project. Indeed, it is themselves which are organized to constitute their OP and themselves which influence its performance.
The mobilization in question will pass by their sensitizing and their information on all opportunities offered currently to make a success of their project, and especially, to integrate the sector of the argane in order to develop the production.
A set of messages must be transmitted, inter alia:
- The imperative to transform their organization into a viable OP (autonomous and efficient) able to mobilize the fruit producers for collective management to guarantying subsequently a consistent quality product on the level of identified perimeter;
- The importance of the organizations of second order for valorization and/or marketing. Other messages can be added according to regional specificities and specificities of the perimeters.
The project teams will define a communication and animation plan in light of the results of social diagnosis (D.S.). Simple communication media, and depending on the target groups, must accompany the awareness sessions.
Awareness and information of farmers and their OP in the Arganeraie.
This is a vast operation to launch across the whole geographical area of the argan in the shortest possible time in order to
raise the fruit producers’ awareness on the vital role their professional organizations can play; the latter will, indeed, likely
secure over the long term, the benefits they receive in the exploitation of the argan and enable them to derive substantial
profits that can improve their income and living conditions.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
38
Training and support to farmers and their OP
This proposed training for farmers and fruit producers and their OP aims to make these organizations more dynamic and to
equip them with management tools that allow the operation exploitation respecting all governing and regulatory
requirements. They must be: I) informed on their project and the context characterizing it, II) aware of the value of their
cooperative and how to manage it daily III) informed on the interest of a collective management system and the basic
guidelines of this process
In addition to training, the farmers and their organizations will be informed, trained and mentored on the possibilities of
adjustments and conversion of associations into cooperatives to prepare the creation of cooperative unions, or to integrate
the GIEs (interest groups) that will be created and processed in activity 2.1.2. These organizations of second order will be the
adequate models to deal with, later, the activities of valuing and marketing of the argan biosphere products.
This approach will thus ensure first, improving productivity and secondly, prepare for the development of products and
marketing. The farmers and fruit producers and their organizations will be initiated to promote partnerships between the
various actors operating in the sector.
Activity 2.1.2: Support cooperatives and GIE creation
The projected organization comprises two levels:
The creation of cooperatives to the upstream of the sector of the argan whose main object is the collection of the harvest of the fruits of argane within the limits of a zone identified within a perimeter of production;
The federation of the cooperatives in GIEs (interest groups) which give them supports in the conditioning of the product and their operation (organization, financing, administrative approaches, etc) and deal with the management of marketing.
Methodology for determining the number of cooperatives and
GIE : The determination of the number of cooperatives and GIE
to be created in the zones of action of the perimeters of
production is based on criteria of viability of these institutions as
well as human and space homogeneity and finally of efficiency
of the interventions.
Number of Cooperatives: Affiliates and members of
cooperatives will be necessarily the fruit producers of the argan.
To determine the number of cooperatives to create, it was taken into account criteria of viability based on the surface of the
perimeter and the volume of its production. The followed approach consisted of:
Fixing a level of production ensuring sustainable viability fruit collection to an argan cooperative; this level is set around 6,000 tons of dried fruit / year (one ton of fresh fruit provides 0.6 tons of dried fruit);
Beyond this level, the calculation of quotients surface/production will allow to take into account the importance of the surface and its space distribution\; the more important the surface is, the more heterogeneity on the level as of human groupings is large, which implies the creation of more cooperatives.
Number of de GIE : With the objective to strengthen the homogeneity and increase the cohesion and effectiveness in terms
of mastery of the marketing of raw materials and knowing that it will require a minimum of two (2) cooperatives to form a
GIE, the number of GIEs retained is 11 centered on the following production areas: Smimou, Tamanar, Tamri, Agadir,
OuledBerhil-Taliouine, Taroudant - Argana, Ouled Taima - Ighrem, Ait Baha, Anezi, Ifni and Tiznit.
technical package: The main mission of the GIE is to take address of the fruit market issues for its members with a specific
focus on quality and certification concerns. In the long term GIEs may develop argane oil extraction and marketing.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
39
It is noteworthy that the model of the GIE that was used in developing the business plan is a pilot model representing a
minimum production capacity considered, of 9000 tons of dried fruit, given that this model is destined to be resized according
to the production areas, the volumes of harvest of argane fruit and the subjective criteria of fruit producers interest groups.
The pilot diagram selected as bases for the study is composed of a GIE of fruit gathering, initially, composed of three
cooperatives of fruit producers. The number of cooperatives members may experience an evolution linked to the organization
of the fruit producers. In other words, the GIE can integrate any new cooperative created in its area of activity.
In the short term, the main mission of GIE, is collecting the production of Argan dried fruits, proceedings it fully or partially,
depending on market demand, to transformations, including pulping, packing and crushing, and selling the product to
operators of argan oils manufacturing or export sector.
In the medium term (after about five years of existence), GIE can expand its activities to the production of argan oil and
possibly include other economic operators in the context of a community development at the level of its entire action area.
Such a development will not be carried out unilaterally but in cooperation. They are expected to play a participatory and
dynamic role in improving the economic and social situation of the aforesaid project area and thus at all the levels of argan
supply chain.
For each of the identified production areas, it was retained to implement a maximum of one GIE and that, pursuant to well-
defined criteria, namely:
To have a critical argan fruits production with a certain economic interest for the fruit producers ;
Gather fruit producers groupings which can create cooperatives that will be integrated into the GIE;
Fit into existing administrative limits.
Within each cooperative member of the GIE, shall be created transformation farming centers which will act as collection
centers of argan fruit. The aforementioned centers are members of the cooperative, and their presidents will sit on its board
of directors and its general meetings.
The number of centers, their areas of action and their functioning are defined by the board of directors of the cooperative.
The main activities of these centers are::
To collect the production of the fruits of argan from the fruit producers ; the conditions, standards and purchase prices are fixed by the GIE and shared with the cooperatives;
Inform fruit producers about the activities and results of the cooperative.
It is to be announced that all the process of collection, transformation and marketing will be carried out by applying the
standards of traceability required for certification of the finished products. These standards will have to be applied as of the
first operations of collection. The architecture of the organization of the fruit producers in cooperatives and GIE is described
by the following diagram:
The technical assistance provided in the project will work according to this scheme. The aim is to set up, like what has been
committed in the framework of the Green Morocco Plan for the two sectors of the Olive and Date palm, the GIE
organizational model, which aims to establish a self-aggregation mechanism of solidarity development projects, viable and
sustainable economically, with a corporate vision for projects able to integrate and even compete in the market.
This support will concern women and young people to interest them and integrate them into the links of the value chain of the
sector. The aforementioned support will also address:
The implementation of a full and participatory approach for the professional organization of all farmers into cooperatives so that they can integrate the newly formed GIE.
The training and the mentoring of the GIE and the adherent cooperatives in areas of management, marketing, communication, accounting and access to financial services. To do this, information sessions and training and
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
40
demonstration tours inside and outside the country will be organized for the benefit of selected cooperatives and or GIEs (interest groups);
The training of the collection centers in the best practices with regards to storage, conditioning, packing and adoption of adequate practices and suitable value add processes..
The organization of work and the implementation and training of quality and its best global practices and standards, , throughout the production process and value added steps.;
The necessary training in developing opportunities and the marketing of the GIEs’ products.
The design, development and field roll out , in a participative manner, of a framework for dialog and coordination of the GIEs and professional organizations of the argan sector;
RESULT 2.2: ARGAN'S PRODUCTS ARE VALUED
The main target in the short term for the interest groups created as a result of 2.1, is collecting the production of dried Argan
fruits, processing it fully or partially , depending on market demand, including pulping , packing and crushing, and selling the
product to argan oil processing cooperatives or companies.
In the medium term (after about five years of existence), these interest groups can expand into the production of argan oil
and possibly include other economic operators in the context of a community development effort covering its territory. Such a
development will involve the beneficiaries acting together as one team. They are expected to play a participatory and
dynamic role in improving the economic and social situation in their area and eventually for the overall Argan biosphere.
Activity 2.2.1: Implementation of argan product collection units
The project will support the development of 11 centers for collecting and storing the Argan fruit. The unit size chosen as a
base model, is an interest group consisting of three (3) cooperatives. The overall collection and storage capacity totals 9,000
tons of dried Argan fruit, with an average of 3,000 tons per cooperative. A varying proportion of these quantities is
transformed to be sold as kernels and the rest is sold as is.
Activity 2.2.2 : Installation of argan oil extraction pilot unit
In order to reduce the pressure on the natural resources of the biosphere, it is imperative to diversify the activities and to
increase the incomes of the local populations and to keep most of added value from these producing activities in at the
community level.
In this perspective, it is important to support the development of argan oil products and its other byproducts through new trade and professional organizations in the form of new operating cooperatives and GIEs.
To implement this approach, the project will support the establishment of pilot Argan oil extraction mills. These units work with quality standards that meet the requirements of the national and international market by ensuring maximization of the added value in the country and best product quality. All tender specifications are indicated in the Argan Oil IGP. In light of the results of these pilot projects, tools and methods will be recommended to generalize best practices for the extraction process. The investment costs for this activity are shown in the financial summary. The funding contributions by the beneficiaries will reach up to 10 % in the form of land.(cost of land acquisition).
.
4.3.3. COMPONENT 3: CAPACITY BUILDING, KNOWLEDGE MANAGEMENT, CO-MANAGMENT OF NATURAL ARGAN
FOREST AND SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH PROMOTION
Three results are sought through the two component of the project. These results are :
‐ Result 3.1: Climate change management Capacities of institutional actor, elected representatives and professional organizations are reinforced and developed (RBA Co-managment).
‐ Result 3.2. Consolidating and promoting research on the Argan Tree. is consolidated and encouraged.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
41
RESULT 3.1: REINFORCED AND DEVELOPING THE CAPACITIES OF INSTITUTIONAL ACTOR, ELECTED OFFICIALS AND PROFESSIONAL
ORGANIZATIONS IN THE FIELD OF CHANGE CLIMATE MANAGEMENT AND CONTRIBUTE ON CO-MANAGEMENT OF ARGAN NATURAL
FOREST
Through this subcomponent, the project stakeholders (managers, partners and beneficiaries) can enhance their design
capabilities and project implementation and adaptation to climate change. Meetings and contacts made at the time of the
surveys, have identified the main gaps. On one hand, strengthening the participants' knowledge on adaptation methods to
climate change and their relationship to the Biosphere Reserve of the Argan tree (RBA). On the other hand,, building skills in
financial partnership management and conflict management In the field of adaptation to climate change / RBA. Capacity
building needs vary between the stakeholders: the beneficiaries find their livelihood directly impacted whereas the role of the
public officials requires them to manage and anticipate the effects of CC / RBA on this impacted populations.
- Activity 3.1.1: Training of institutional actors and elected officials on the challenges of climate change to integrated local planning in the RBA and training on co-management of Argan Natural Forest
In areas of the Argan tree, information / training of actors for CC / RBA and CC adaptation is uneven. The project will
address the information and training gaps in selected sites that have not had the opportunity to benefit from major training or
knowledge transfer activities on adaptation to CC.
Populations have acquired expertise and adaptation techniques to CC because of their ancestral management experience in
facing scarcity and natural hazards. The consultation workshops confirmed that there is an awareness of aggravated risks
posed by climate change in all locations and areas affected by the project components. The said project aims to undertake
the following actions:
Development and implementation of a training program on climate change in RBA.
The project will issue a call for expressions of interest (EOI) with training organizations to develop a skills development plan
and implement it with all required participants. Overall, these modules must cover most sectors affected by climate change
related to the Argan tree. These modules should also address aspects of climate finance, conflict management and
mediation, biodiversity conservation, green economy, etc.
All selected modules are in line with the Green Climate Fund strategy:
Participation in events and scientific meetings and forums: This action intends to support, according to an annual program prepared by the Project Unit, the costs of participation of technical officials at scientific meetings for climate change and local stakeholders awareness forums organized around the topics related to the argan tree and its preservation and development.
Organization of travel and Training: The project will support the logistics and costs and plan for continuous training and knowledge transfer of the project actors on topics of innovation and adaptation to climate change.
Training of Co-management on Argane Natural Forest :
The purpose of this activity is to initiate a public debate on the integration of climate change and biosphere reserves in
regional planning through the initiation of the process of developing a project charter / memorandum on RBA climate change
in the light of the new strategy 2016-2025 MAB (Lima 2016)
- Activity 3.1.2 : Co-management of Natural Argan Forest
Many sub-activities will be implemented to reinforce management capacity and develop a mitigation approach to climate
change, namely
Capacity building: Meetings held with local officials and representatives of the beneficiaries, to share the need to address key gaps in knowledge transfer and sharing: - Reinforcement of technical knowledge of beneficiaries and fruit producers.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
42
- Skills with regards to collective management of the perimeters and the operation of their OP Reinforcement of capabilities and technical knowledge of beneficiaries and fruit producers : The argan
development model requires capacity building in the following areas: - the plantation and culture of selected argan varieties according to a model of semi intensive orchard
seedlings; - Agronomic Training techniques, methods, and best practices ; - Intercropping of herbal and medicinal plants and sustainable farming training.
Capacity building for collective management perimeters and the functioning of their OP : Among the expected outfalls of the new plantations of 10 000 ha of argan, as planned and part of this program is to develop the organizations developing the project (generally an association, for each new websites / area) to create second tier professional organizations (cooperatives and GIEs) mobilizing farmers / beneficiaries and grouping them around a plan of action as regard to the management of their perimeter.
The second goal that DARED will reach is develop a co-management of natural argan forest and contribute to it protection
and regeneration by implantation by :
Development of co-management agreements and sustainable use of natural forest and its regeneration Implementation of co-management agreements between stakeholders and actors
After completing these critical steps in the project,, the integration of the OP will be strengthened throughout the
different levels in the argan value chain. This intervention will also reinforce marketing and value adding practices.
A comprehensive social diagnostic will be performed at the level of each identified perimeter to identify the existing
organization types and ensure their representativeness; ii) examine the functionality of the organizations dedicated to
the project; iii) to verify the information received by farmers for perimeter management; iv) master the specific
constraints and social aspects of each perimeter. The results of this survey will be used to better frame the activities of
capacities building of farmers and their OPA. This activity will contribute to
o Development of training modules for development and collective management of cooperatives and GIEs;
o Organization of informational workshops for collective management; Support for improving the governance of Arganiculture projects: i) preparation of action
plans ii) development of performance management capacities of OP iii) organization and performance monitoring
o Development of co-management agreements of sustainable use of Argane natural forest o Implementation of co-management agreements between beneficiaries and actors on Argan Natural
forest
The same support will be engaged in component 2 but for the Afyach harvesting cooperatives. It is imperative to coordinate
these actions in terms of content and messages development to be conveyed in order to have real impact and results;
RESULT 3.2: ARGAN RESEARCH IS CONSOLIDATED AND ENCOURAGED
Activity 3.2.1: Support for the implementation of the Argan National Center (CNA)
The establishment of the national center of excellence of the argan tree will channel the efforts of all scientific and
professional actors. This center will also promote Argan's cultural heritage and support for research excellence. Its strategic
objectives will address:
Preserve and interpret natural and cultural heritage of the RBA linked to the argane tree through the creation of the “Argane interpretive Center”
Design and implementation of a knowledge management platform on the Arganeraie and argane tree
Support scientific research on RBA and argan tree by supporting the implementation of joint programs and fund raising and fund management mechanisms;
Technological intelligence and expertise to support decision-makers and professionals, and all the stakeholders towards sustainable development.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
43
The project will contribute to the launch of this center by supporting the development of its content and strengthening the
capacities of its key actors. The first support axis are:
‐ Acquisition of specific equipment and staffing of the Argan Promotional center. The center is for the promotion of tangible and intangible heritage related to the Argan tree and its valuation in support of the local populations directly creating value in the Argan supply chain..
‐ Implementation of a knowledge management portal for the argan product and the argan tree. A tool that will be useful to facilitate access to knowledge for fruit producers.
‐ Creation of a knowledge sharing portal on the argane tree and its market
Activity 3.2.2: Support for the concretization of the Argan Research-Innovation Federator Program
The project will support the realization of the "Joint Argane Research Program" mainly through:
• Call for research proposals mainly about the development of arganiculture
• Support scholarships for young researchers to fund research topics on the Argane / CC / RBA priority issues ;
• Support for the National Argane Researchers Network (RENARGANE);
4.3.4. PROJECT TERRITORIAL DECLINATION
The sites affected by the project, fall under the area of the RBA in the Morocco affecting the the administrative
regions of Marrakech-Safi (province of Essaouira), Souss-Massa (prefectures of Agadir Ida Outanane and
Inezgane - Ait Melloul and provinces of Taroudant, Chtouka - Aït Baha and Tiznit) and Guelmim-Oued Noun
(provinces of Sidi Ifni and Guelmim). Within the eight provinces concerned, the 31 villages are directly affected by
the project components.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
44
Figure 2 : DARED project area: communes concerned by the project
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
45
5. BASELINE SITUATION IN THE TERRITORIES OF INTERVENTION
INTRODUCTION 5.1.
At the administrative level, the project affects the following prefectures and provinces:
Province of Essaouira
Prefecture of Agadir Ida Outanane ;
Prefecture of Inezgane Aït Melloul ;
Province of Chtouka Aït Baha ;
Province of Tiznit ;
Province of Sidi Ifni ;
Province of Taroudant ;
Province of Guelmim ;
These provinces are part of the action area of the hydraulics Basin Agency of Souss Massa Daraa (ABHSMD),
except for the province of Essaouira. The latter is in the action zone of Hydraulic Basin Agency of Tensift (ABHT).
The following figure shows the administrative situation of the action area of the ABHSMD.
Figure 3 Administrative situation of the action area of the ABHSMD
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
46
CLIMATOLOGY 5.2.
The study area includes the Souss Massa region, the province of Essaouira and the province of Guelmim.
- The Souss-Massa region is characterized by:
triangular coastal plain on the 30th north parallel, Opened on the west on the Atlantic Ocean, Closed on two sides: the north by the High Atlas, southeast and east by the Anti Atlas and
Siroua, Protected from the disturbances coming from north and the North-East, Submitted to disturbances arriving on the plain in a southwest flow, The area is however occasionally reached in winter by the invasions of polar air from higher
latitudes.
The climate of the Souss Massa region is predominantly arid but it varies from wet type, with cold winter
on the peaks of the High Occidental Atlas, to pre-Saharan, to fresh winter in the plains. The arid nature
is mitigated by the proximity of the ocean and the influence of the cold Canary Current, as well as the
protection against the South winds, ensured by the mountain barrier of the Anti-Atlas. The area includes
four hydrological units:
- Souss Basin; - Atlantic coastal basins; - Massa Basin; - Tiznit Sidi Ifni Basin.
Regarding Guelmim, it is characterized by severe aridity, due to the presence of the High Atlas chain
obstructing the rainy disturbances from the north. In spite of the latitude, the proximity of the Atlantic
Ocean mitigates the effect of the Saharan continentality for the part close to the ocean. The winds are
very common causing sand accumulations of different forms.
Within the wet season, rainfall occurs in two rainfall periods, the first fall with a peak in November and a
second in winter with a peak in February or in spring with a peak in March. The total rainy days is
around 30 days per year on average.
- Regarding Essaouira: The climate of the province of Essaouira is the arid type with significant dry period
of six to seven months. This aridity however shows a decreasing gradient from east to west. Towards
the east, the rain decreases and temperatures rise. In the west in the narrow coastal strip, around the
city of Essaouira, the influence of the cold Canary Current determines a microclimate with an average
temperature very homogeneous throughout the year.
The annual temperatures vary between 18 ° C and 23 ° C. The average annual rainfall is relatively low it
rarely exceeds 300 mm / year. Winds are frequent and violent and blow almost all year, on average 280
days / year.
TEMPÉRATURE 5.3.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
47
The annual average temperatures vary between 14 ° C, on the High Atlas in the north, and 20 ° C on the Anti-
Atlas in the south. The maximum daily temperature reaches 49 ° C and the minimum temperature drops to 3 ° C
below zero.
The thermal regime is much more diverse. The structure of space-time thermal field suffers a quad geographical
influence: proximity of the ocean, continentality, the mountains that surround the basin and the proximity of
Sahara
Figure 4: Watershed Souss Massa
Average maximum isotherms (1971-2000) average minimum isotherms (1971-2000)
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
48
PRECIPITATIONS 5.4.
Annual rainfall is highly variable. The annual average values vary from 600 mm in the north of the peaks of the
High Atlas, to 150 mm in the south, on the eastern part of the Anti-Atlas. The plain receives about 200 mm of rain.
The average of precipitation on sub-basins are the following :
- 280 mm on the Souss Basin;
- 265 mm in the Massa basin;
- 390 mm in the Tamraght basin;
- 370 mm in the Tamri basin;
- 180 mm on the plain of Tiznit.
Figure 5 : isotherms annual average (1931-2002)
Source : master plan study of rainwater harvesting in the Souss Massa Draa Basin
EVAPORATION 5.5.
The potential evapotranspiration (PET) is the global climatic request in soil saturation conditions, under the
combined effect of temperature, solar radiation, relative humidity (vapor pressure deficit), wind and pressure
atmospheric (sea level). The spatial distribution of this climate indicator is attributable to the direct or indirect
action of these factors.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
49
Evaporation reaches a peak in July to August and then decreases to a minimum for December-January. The
average annual evaporation varies between 1400 mm in the mountains and near the Atlantic coast and 2000 mm
in the plains.
WIND 5.6.
Generally the region is relatively windy. The "Chergui" hot Eastern wind can blow in summer and autumn. The
annual average wind speed is about 3 km / h in mountain and 5 km / h in plain.
HYDROLOGY 5.7.
5.7.1. SOUSS MASSA
The Oueds of Souss Massa basins are characterized by hydrological regimes known for their irregularities. These
regimes depend on irregular rainfall and often violent occurring after long periods of drought.
The area of action of ABHSMD includes several sub watersheds, as shown in the following figure:
Figure 6 : Watersheds of the study area (ABHSMD)
Souss Basin
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
50
The Souss Basin covers an area of 16,200 km2, is bordered by large reliefs; the High Atlas to the north, Antis
Atlas in the South, to the east by the junction of the two aforementioned chains and west by the Atlantic Ocean.
The average annual contribution of Souss at Aoulouz are 128.1 million m³. It is fed by tributaries of the High Atlas
and Anti-Atlas whose contribution is 290.9 million m³ (225.1 Mm³ as input of the right bank and 65.8 million m³ of
the left bank).
Massa Basin
Massa basin is drained by theoueds Amaghous and Assaka and the Oueds Sfa and Tekat that originate,
respectively from the Atlantic part of the anti-Atlas and the northern part of the basin.
The Oued Massa flows into the Atlantic Ocean, while the Oueds Sfa and Tekat are lost in the plain. The average
annual input of Oued Massa is estimated at 128 million m3 / year of which the run-off water blade is about 21 mm
/ year.
Adding also the existence of the dam Youssef Ben Tachfine (height 85 m, length 707 m and capacity of 303
million m3), which obstruct one of the arms of the Oued Massa, forming an artificial lake with a useful capacity of
304 million m3 for a basin area of 3800 ha.
This work regulates 88 million m3 / year, 85 million m3 are reserved to irrigate areas of Massa and Tassila and 3
million m3 for drinking water supply of Tiznit.
Tamri Tamraght Basin
The Tamri Tamraght Atlantic Basin is a coastal basin. It is drained by Oueds Tamri and Tamraght. The basins of
Tamri and Tamragh occupy the respective areas of 1899 km2 and 737 km2.
coastal basin
This basin is composed of two major watersheds:
1- The basin of the plain of Tiznit extends over an area of 1200 km². This unit consists of the
hydrographic system of the river Adoudou (820 km²) and an additional basin in the East whose
waters extend into the maïders in the north of Tiznit (380 km²). The total average annual contribution
of this basin reach 10.6 million m3 distributed as follows:
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
51
8.7 million m3 / from Oued Adoudou which has a high irregularity (15.3 mm3 in a humid year and 0.9 million m3 in dry years) ;
1.3 million m3 coming from N'baye under basin (120 km²);
0.6 million m3 coming from subbasin Içoh (83 km²).
2- The Coastal Basin of Ifni; having an area of km² 1600 with an average of 6.15 million m3, the
volume of annual runoff varies from a minimum of 0.11 million m3 for (1986-87) and a maximum of
19.6 million m3 (1984-1985) ; extending between the mouths of Oueds Adoudou and Assaka. It is
very rugged and marks the western limit of the Anti-Atlas. The Oued Ifni drains a mountainous basin
of 685 km² composed mainly of a granite base. Small coastal oueds drain an area of 915 km² to the
north and south of this basin.
In the agricultural domain, the spreading of the risings constitutes a privileged mode for the mobilization of water.
Thus, the flood waters of the oueds and chaabas crisscrossing the plain of Tiznit spread on the land "Feid" either
naturally or through small flood diversion dams. The spate of perimeters amount to an area of 3650 ha which is
practiced cereal crops and olives.
Currently, of the oued Adoudou Spate contributes to the supply of the water sheet by an estimated 20%
infiltration which brings about 0.5 Mm3 / year.
In the basins N'baye and Içoh, current derivation are estimated at 0.4 million m3 / year and 0.2 million m3 / year
The total volume of derivatives floodwaters currently in Tiznit basin is about 3.2 million m3 / year.
5.7.2. GUELMIM BASIN
The updated overall potential of this basin is 57 million m³ / year. The 88% of this potential come from Seyyad
basin that occupies the half north and northeast of Basin and comprises half of the Guelmim basin of an overall
area of 10 240 km².
5.7.3. ESSAOUIRA BASIN
The surface water resources are very irregular and unequally distributed, with the exception of the Oued Tensift
flowing in the north of the Province of Essaouira, the network is reduced to a few oueds, the largest of which is
the Oued Ksob. The latter originates in the Western High Atlas and is the main collector of water in the province.
This Oued is formed by the union of the Oued Igrounzar and Zeltene. Its watershed is about 1480 km² and its
average speed is estimated at 1.44 m3 / s (at the post Zerrar). Seasonal variations are very pronounced. Thus,
the flow of the driest month is 1.4% of the average flow. The flows are mainly concentrated between December
and March, with 67% of total flows. The mouth of the Oued Ksob is located south of the city of Essaouira and as
such presents potential flood risk.
MOBILIZATION OF SURFACE WATER 5.8.
5.8.1. EXISTING LARGE AND MEDIUM DAMS
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
52
The succession of overdrawn years caused in the whole of the dams a reduction in the contributions of
the Oueds. Regularized volumes were reduced as a result of hydrological changes. This impact is greater in the
works of large dimensions (regularized volume reduction of 7 million m3 / year for Aoulouz Mokhtar Soussi
complex and 5.4 million m3 / year for the dam Youssef ben Tachfine)
The revised regularized volumes pass thus from 379 m3/year initially evaluated to 364 m3/year in the
hydrological scenario “complete serie” (- 4%) and to 345 m3/year in the scenario “short serie” (- 9%).
Table 2: Regulated potential by medium and large existing dams
Dams :
Initial (Mm3/year)
Scenario Complete Serie Scenario Short serie
Revised (Mm3/an)
Deviation (%)
Revised (Mm3/an)
Deviation (%)
Aoulouz - Mokhtar Soussi 184 177.1 -4% 173.8 -6%
Youssfe Ben Tachfine 90 84.6 -6% 81.8 -9%
Abdelmoumen 69.5 67.4 -3% 54.9 -21%
Moulay Abdellah 27.5 27.1 -2% 27 -2%
Imi El Kheng 5.5 5.2 -5% 5 -9%
Ahl Souss 2.6 2.6 0% 2.6 0%
Total 379 364 -4% 345 -9%
5.8.2. EXISTING SMALL DAMS AND HILLSIDE LAKES
The PDAIRE area has nine hillside lakes and small dams that were commissioned between 1985 and 1992.
These works are used for domestic water supply, irrigation and watering livestock while contributing to the fight
against floods and flood control. The following table summarizes the main characteristics.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
53
Table 3 : Small dams and hillside lakes
Province / prefecture
Name Commissioning date
watershed (km²)
Annual throughp
ut (Mm3/year
)
Normal withholding capacity (Mm3/year
)
siltation Use2
T. morte
Ap. ann.
Agadir Ida Ou Tanane
Taguenza 1987 24.5 1.0 0.3 33.864 17 AED. AC. I
Agadir Ida Ou Tanane
Tildi 1991 15.5 0.6 0.0 20.955 6.2 AED. AC
Agadir Ida Ou Tanane
Tiguemi N'Ait Bihi
1992 7.5 0.4 0.1 15.967 3 AED. AC
Chtouka Ait baha Sfa 1985 14.8 0.3 0.5 62.368 3.25 PC. AC
Chtouka Ait baha Azgherkis 1991 8.3 0.3 0.1 6.833 4.37 AED. AC
Chtouka Ait baha Timicha 1989 5.6 0.1 0.1 1.333 2.97 AED. AC
Taroudant Assderm 1989 13.4 0.2 0.1 6 AED. AC
Taroudant Sellaoun 1992 25.5 0.2 0.2 13.5 AED. AC
Tiznit Anou Issafaren 1989 1.8 0.05 0.01 0.547 0.95 I. AED
5.8.3. WATER WITHDRAWALS
On the overall contributions in surface waters, a water harvesting of about 112 million m3 / year provide
essentially irrigation of mountain PMH perimeters.
GROUNDWATER 5.9.
5.9.1. SOUSS MASSA BASIN
The Souss Massa basin is soothes of groundwater of varying importance. Groundwater of the Souss, Chtouka
(1500km², about a third of the Souss plain) and Tiznit are the most important. They overcome other confined
groundwater but smaller Groundwater in the Souss Massa area are represented on the map below.
Groundwater reserves are estimated between 30 and 40 billion cubic meters, constitutes an important part of the
hydraulic potential of the region being 4105Mm3 and represents over 30% of mobilized water resources and
plays an important role in the socio-economic development in the region: drinking water supply in rural areas and
several towns, irrigation of 60,000 hectares of agricultural land.
2 AED : Alimentation en eau domestique. PC : Protection contre les crues. AC: Abreuvement du cheptel. I : Irrigation
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
54
Figure 7 : Main sheets of the Souss Massa watershed with piezometry control network (Source ABHSMD)
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
55
The potential renewable updated groundwater has 425 million m3 / year on average and is distributed as follows:
Souss Groundwater: 200
Chtouka Groundwater : 26
Tiznit Groundwater: 8,3
High-Atlas, right bank of Souss : 42
High-Atlas occidental : 20
the limestone Adoudounien of the anti Atlas: 85
Buttonholes of the Anti-Atlas: 44
Total : 425
However, higher amounts of water are being taken in an overexploitation plan: 696 million m3 / year across the whole basin of which 68 million m3 / year for AEPI and 628 million m3 / year for irrigation.
The groundwater of the Souss is generally of good quality. The electrical conductivity of water from the
groundwater increases from east to west with excessive values in the downstream portion of the groundwater
and in the region of oulad teima.
The waters of the sheet of Chtouka show significant variations in conductivity, it grows globally from upstream to
downstream and from North to South. salinity anomalies are observed in the southern part (irrigated sector Ait
Belfaa) and downstream of Chtouka and north of the line Aït Amira-Biougra. The sheet of Chtouka is significantly
polluted. This is due to the use of nitrogen fertilizers which cause pollution of groundwater by nitrates. In the plain
of Tiznit, the groundwater salinity increases from the South to the North towards the ocean.
5.9.2. GUELMIM BASIN
The Guelmim basin is part of the Western Antiatlas. It presents itself as a limited basin in the north by by the
Lakhsass plates, and the chain links of the massif of Ifni, in the south by the Jebel Taissa. The whole covers an
area of approximately 1240 Km.
The plain of Guelmim is occupied in the center by Jbel Tayert which separates the basins from the Oued Oum Al
Achar in north and the Oueds Seyad and Ouerguennoun in the south.
Water resources are in sharp decline in some areas of the plains due to prolonged and recurring cycles of
drought and especially due to degradation of natural resources (soil erosion, loss of forests, etc.) and a rural and
agricultural exodus that occurred in over half a century.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
56
5.9.3. ESSAOUIRA
The region is characterized by the presence of the sheet of-Meskala Kourimate extending over an area of around
1,600 km². It consists of two overlapping aquifer, one circulating in the limestone of the Eocene and the other in
dolomitic Cretaceous land. The recharging system is done by direct infiltration of rainwater and runoff on
outcropping areas. The flowing is towards Northwest to supply the Oued Ksob or constitute the transfer by lateral
anastomosis of the sheet of the synclinal of Essaouira.
Having the same structural characteristics as the Essaouira Basin, the productivity of catchment works also vary
depending on the degree of fracturing aquifers. The values of the operating flow rates vary from a few liters per
second to more than 60l/s.
The sheet of the coastline is represented by sheets of sandstones dune and coquillers limestones of Pliocene-
Quaternary extending along the coast on a wide strip of 20 km and 40 km of long. The aquifer Pliocene-
Quaternary developed along the Oued Ksob presents only a limited interest.
The depth of the sheet is 40 to 60 m. the productivity is very variable with flow rates ranging from 1 to over 30 l/s.
5.9.4. WATER DEMAND AT THE LEVEL OF THE ABHSMD
The PDAIRE of the ABHSMD revealed that the overall water demand is estimated at 1068 million m3 / year in
2007 and will increase to 1076 million m3 / year in 2030.
Agricultural demand is clearly dominant in 2007 (93%) but will decreased to represent only 80% of global demand
in 2030. On the other hand, the demand for drinking and industrial water will pass from 68 m3/year in 2007 (6%)
to 197 m3/year in 2030, that is to say 18% of the total demand.
The agricultural surfaces currently equipped total about 148,640 hectares, including 57,900 ha of private modern
perimeters and 32,730 ha of public perimeters. The perimeters of great hydraulics occupy approximately 60% of
equipped the surface. The 88% of the total surface currently equipped are located in the zone of action of the
ORMVA Souss Massa (130 740 ha) whereas the remaining equipped surfaces are distributed between the zones
of action of DPA of Agadir (4 660 ha), that of Tiznit (5 300 ha) and the ORMVA Ouarzazate (7 940 ha).
The current water demand requires water resources of about 994 million m3 / year, of which 412 million m3 / year
of surface water and 582 million m3 / year of groundwater.
Table 4: Surfaces and current demands for water by basin
Bassin Surface (ha)
Water demand eau (Mm3/year)
Massa 29 355 171
Souss 112 425 781
Tamri - Tamraght 1 560 18
Tiznit -Sidi Ifni 5 300 24
Total 148 640 994
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
57
The projections shows that the irrigated area will not expand, according to the principle of the cessation of
extensions already in force. The total surface to be irrigated until the end of the plan will be then 148'640 ha. The
projected corresponding demand for water will decrease greatly passing from 994 to 849 million m3 / year
5.9.5. SENSITIVITY OF UNDERGROUND WATER RESOURCES
The monitoring of changes of the water levels of almost all of the layers in the region shows a continuous decline
from 1971 reaching alarming values, sometimes exceeding 2 meters per year. his decrease is due to the
combined effects of drought and overexploitation.
At the level of the sheet of the Souss, it was noted in particular:
Between Aoulouz and Taroudant, declining groundwater levels is 15 m;
The area where the decline is most important is located between Taroudant and oulad teima, particularly in southern Souss; 80 m within the perimeters of Sebt El Guerdane oulad teima The rate of decline in this sector is around 2.5 m / year on average;
In the Issen sector, a decline of 5 m was observed between 1970 and 2005, locally it can reach 10 m.
The sheet of Chtouka shows a negative balance: its exploitation by overpumping has led to a very significant drop
in groundwater levels, especially in the north of the plain. e water deficit has increased from 19 million m³ in 1998
to 58 million m³ in 2003.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
58
Table 5 : Summary of hydraulic balances (Mm3) of Souss, Chtouka and Tiznit sheets
sheet 1972 1975 1976 1979 1985 1994 1996 1998 2002/03 2004
input 220 337 163 108 870 256 323
26 68 43 35
27.4 13.7 25 25
outputs 405 442 408 478 637 614 553
31 56 62 93
17.3 13.3 25.4 25.4
Balance -185 -105 -246 -370 233 -358 -230
-5 12 -19 -58
10 0.4 -0.4 -0.4
S : Souss ; C : Chtouka ; T : Tiznit
LAND USE AND VEGETATION INDEX 5.1.
The afforestation rate is variable and reaches 71% in the province of Agadir Ida Ou Tanane followed by
Inzegane Ait Melloul with 45%. The other provinces present rates surrounding 30%.
Table 6 : afforestation rate by Province / Prefecture
Province/ Prefecture afforestation rate (%)
Agadir-Ida-Ou-Tanane Inzegane-Ait Melloul Taroudant Tiznit Chtouka Aït Baha
71 45 33 28 30
This parameter is critical for slope stability and regulation of watersheds flows. The high pressure on forests,
following wood removals, land clearing for cultivation and overgrazing leads to a decrease in forest cover which is
estimated at some 1000 to 1500 ha per year in the argan trees.
CHARACTERIZATION OF THE CURRENT STATE OF EROSION IN WATERSHED 5.2.
The analysis of the erosion of Souss-Massa basin distinguishes very affected zone by water erosion. It is in the
south side of the High Atlas. his is due to the high altitude, steep slopes and the presence of soft outcrops. One
can consider that the catchment area of Issen is most representative with regard to the most spectacular forms of
erosion which arrive at the forms of badlands and generalized gullying.
A second zone less damaging corresponds to the septentrional side of the Anti-Atlas, where the forms of gullying
and scouring are related to the schistous outcrops.
The following figure shows the areas affected by the erosion phenomenon and its seriousness.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
59
Figure 8: Erosion in the Souss Massa basin
GEOLOGY 5.3.
Haut Atlas(High Atlas)
The High Atlas comprises a portion of old massif representing the highest area occupied by crystalline rocks
ante-Mesozoic. This massif constitutes the base of a cover of secondary age which levels in the south and the
west:
- In the south are the land of the Erguita Valley, located roughly between Taroudant and Tafingoult; - To the west, the Mesozoic cover is represented by the red Triassic age layers of the Argana
corridor, relayed mostly by limestone of Jurassic and Cretaceous reliefs of Ida Ou Tanane on the west.
On the Lithostratigraphic level:
- The Precambrian is composed of metamorphic rocks and granitoid. - The Paleozoic is represented primarily by Cambrian deposits (Paleozoic High AtlasThe Hercynian
deformation has manifested by folding, the establishment of Granite Tichka and significant metamorphism.
- The Permo-Triassic it: indicate the silty sandstone red series recognized in the corridor of Argana and its basic conglomerates of about ten meters thickness. It is formed by an alternation of sandstone and clay of more than 100 m thickness. This series is crowned by basaltic flows.
- The Jurassic: The Lower Lias: a sedimentary continuity seems to exist between the Upper Triassic and
Lower Lias. The base of lias is represented by red siltstones rich in evaporites on top of which intercalated the limestones bars. The basaltic flows at tholeiitic affinity are interspersed in this series at the Triassic-Lias limit.
The upper Lias consists of dolomites.
CT
CT
DP
CT
CT
CT
CT
CT
CT
CT
CT
DR
CT
CT
CT
CT
DP
CT
CT
CT
O C
E A
N
A
T L
A N
T I
Q U
E
50
Kilomètres
0 25
AgadirAgadirAgadirAgadirAgadirAgadirAgadirAgadirAgadir
TaroudantTaroudantTaroudantTaroudantTaroudantTaroudantTaroudantTaroudantTaroudant
Ouled BarhilOuled BarhilOuled BarhilOuled BarhilOuled BarhilOuled BarhilOuled BarhilOuled BarhilOuled Barhil
BASSIN DE TAMRI
TAMRAGHT
BASSIN DU SOUSS
BASSIN DE MASSA
O. I
Sse
n
O. I
Sse
n
O. I
Sse
n
O. I
Sse
n
O. I
Sse
n
O. I
Sse
n
O. I
Sse
n
O. I
Sse
n
O. I
Sse
n
O. OugarO. OugarO. OugarO. OugarO. OugarO. OugarO. OugarO. OugarO. Ougar
O. S
das
O. S
das
O. S
das
O. S
das
O. S
das
O. S
das
O. S
das
O. S
das
O. S
das
O. Arghane
O. Arghane
O. Arghane
O. Arghane
O. Arghane
O. Arghane
O. Arghane
O. Arghane
O. Arghane
O. A
ou
rga
O. A
ou
rga
O. A
ou
rga
O. A
ou
rga
O. A
ou
rga
O. A
ou
rga
O. A
ou
rga
O. A
ou
rga
O. A
ou
rga
O.
Wa
ar
O.
Wa
ar
O.
Wa
ar
O.
Wa
ar
O.
Wa
ar
O.
Wa
ar
O.
Wa
ar
O.
Wa
ar
O.
Wa
ar
O.
Mo
uh
an
nd
O.
Mo
uh
an
nd
O.
Mo
uh
an
nd
O.
Mo
uh
an
nd
O.
Mo
uh
an
nd
O.
Mo
uh
an
nd
O.
Mo
uh
an
nd
O.
Mo
uh
an
nd
O.
Mo
uh
an
nd
O. A
ouko
urte
O. A
ouko
urte
O. A
ouko
urte
O. A
ouko
urte
O. A
ouko
urte
O. A
ouko
urte
O. A
ouko
urte
O. A
ouko
urte
O. A
ouko
urteO. Tamraght
O. Tamraght
O. TamraghtO. Tamraght
O. TamraghtO. Tamraght
O. Tamraght
O. Tamraght
O. Tamraght
O. S o u s s
O. S o u s s
O. S o u s s
O. S o u s s
O. S o u s s
O. S o u s s
O. S o u s s
O. S o u s s
O. S o u s sO
. N
ok
he
ilO
. N
ok
he
ilO
. N
ok
he
ilO
. N
ok
he
ilO
. N
ok
he
ilO
. N
ok
he
ilO
. N
ok
he
ilO
. N
ok
he
il
O.
No
kh
eil
O. Ih
ou
rk
O. Ih
ou
rk
O. Ih
ou
rk
O. Ih
ou
rk
O. Ih
ou
rk
O. Ih
ou
rk
O. Ih
ou
rk
O. Ih
ou
rk
O. Ih
ou
rk
O.
Ait
Me
ss
ao
ud
O.
Ait
Me
ss
ao
ud
O.
Ait
Me
ss
ao
ud
O.
Ait
Me
ss
ao
ud
O.
Ait
Me
ss
ao
ud
O.
Ait
Me
ss
ao
ud
O.
Ait
Me
ss
ao
ud
O.
Ait
Me
ss
ao
ud
O.
Ait
Me
ss
ao
ud
O. M
assa
O. M
assa
O. M
assa
O. M
assa
O. M
assa
O. M
assa
O. M
assa
O. M
assa
O. M
assa
O. M
aghodis
O. M
aghodis
O. M
aghodis
O. M
aghodis
O. M
aghodis
O. M
aghodis
O. M
aghodis
O. M
aghodis
O. M
aghodis
O. Ih
adr
O. Ih
adr
O. Ih
adr
O. Ih
adr
O. Ih
adr
O. Ih
adr
O. Ih
adr
O. Ih
adr
O. Ih
adr
O. T
alo
us
tO
. Ta
lou
st
O. T
alo
us
tO
. Ta
lou
st
O. T
alo
us
tO
. Ta
lou
st
O. T
alo
us
tO
. Ta
lou
st
O. T
alo
us
t
O.
Izg
arn
O.
Izg
arn
O.
Izg
arn
O.
Izg
arn
O.
Izg
arn
O.
Izg
arn
O.
Izg
arn
O.
Izg
arn
O.
Izg
arn
O. OumnerighO. OumnerighO. OumnerighO. OumnerighO. OumnerighO. OumnerighO. OumnerighO. OumnerighO. Oumnerigh
O.
Mza
ou
rou
O.
Mza
ou
rou
O.
Mza
ou
rou
O.
Mza
ou
rou
O.
Mza
ou
rou
O.
Mza
ou
rou
O.
Mza
ou
rou
O.
Mza
ou
rou
O.
Mza
ou
rou
O.
Tfio
ut
O.
Tfio
ut
O.
Tfio
ut
O.
Tfio
ut
O.
Tfio
ut
O.
Tfio
ut
O.
Tfio
ut
O.
Tfio
ut
O.
Tfio
ut
Barrage AbdelmoumenBarrage AbdelmoumenBarrage AbdelmoumenBarrage AbdelmoumenBarrage AbdelmoumenBarrage AbdelmoumenBarrage AbdelmoumenBarrage AbdelmoumenBarrage AbdelmoumenBarrage My AbdallahBarrage My AbdallahBarrage My AbdallahBarrage My AbdallahBarrage My AbdallahBarrage My AbdallahBarrage My AbdallahBarrage My AbdallahBarrage My Abdallah
Barrage DkhilaBarrage DkhilaBarrage DkhilaBarrage DkhilaBarrage DkhilaBarrage DkhilaBarrage DkhilaBarrage DkhilaBarrage Dkhila
Barrage Imi LkhengBarrage Imi LkhengBarrage Imi LkhengBarrage Imi LkhengBarrage Imi LkhengBarrage Imi LkhengBarrage Imi LkhengBarrage Imi LkhengBarrage Imi Lkheng
Barrage AoulouzBarrage AoulouzBarrage AoulouzBarrage AoulouzBarrage AoulouzBarrage AoulouzBarrage AoulouzBarrage AoulouzBarrage Aoulouz
Barrage Youssef Ben TachfineBarrage Youssef Ben TachfineBarrage Youssef Ben TachfineBarrage Youssef Ben TachfineBarrage Youssef Ben TachfineBarrage Youssef Ben TachfineBarrage Youssef Ben TachfineBarrage Youssef Ben TachfineBarrage Youssef Ben Tachfine
Barrage Mokhtar SoussiBarrage Mokhtar SoussiBarrage Mokhtar SoussiBarrage Mokhtar SoussiBarrage Mokhtar SoussiBarrage Mokhtar SoussiBarrage Mokhtar SoussiBarrage Mokhtar SoussiBarrage Mokhtar Soussi
Ouled TeimaOuled TeimaOuled TeimaOuled TeimaOuled TeimaOuled TeimaOuled TeimaOuled TeimaOuled Teima
BiougraBiougraBiougraBiougraBiougraBiougraBiougraBiougraBiougra
Sebt GuerdaneSebt GuerdaneSebt GuerdaneSebt GuerdaneSebt GuerdaneSebt GuerdaneSebt GuerdaneSebt GuerdaneSebt Guerdane
TaliouineTaliouineTaliouineTaliouineTaliouineTaliouineTaliouineTaliouineTaliouine
Ait BahaAit BahaAit BahaAit BahaAit BahaAit BahaAit BahaAit BahaAit Baha
TiznitTiznitTiznitTiznitTiznitTiznitTiznitTiznitTiznit
Sidi IfniSidi IfniSidi IfniSidi IfniSidi IfniSidi IfniSidi IfniSidi IfniSidi Ifni
EROSIONEROSIONEROSIONEROSIONEROSIONEROSIONEROSIONEROSIONEROSION
Erosion
Erosion faible ou localisée
Erosion forte
Villes et centres
Bassins hydrologiques
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
60
The Middle Jurassic is composed of red sandstone of Amskroud, dolomite and limestone. - The Cretaceous outcrops the edge of the High Atlas in the north flank of the synclinal Cretaceous-
Eocene of the Souss. To the west, there is a complete Cretaceous marine series. eastward lagoonal facies mark increasingly the series, surmounted by Eocene deposits of lacustrine or continental facies. The power of Lower Cretaceous represented by the clays and calcareous marl decreases from west (300 m) to east (60 to 100 m). the Cenomanian is represented by gray marl with anhydrite, limestone and sandstone in small proportions. The Turonian is composed of dolomitic limestone at the base surmounted by limestone flint (limestone of the Kasbah of Agadir). Its power ranges from 50 m in the west to 10 m in the east. The Cretaceous is mainly marl and marl limestone, gypsum eastward. Its power is 400 m west, 1000 m at a pit subsidence at the height of the meridian 9 ° where it develops 300 m of phosphatic sandstone Maestrichtian, 300 m to the east and becomes 50 m at Aoulouz under a form of red sandstone and marl.
- Neogene-Paleogene: in the Agadir region, the Oligocene directly covers the Maastrichtian. The Eocene is well individualized to the east of the Souss Valley, where he overcomes the Maestrichtian in sedimentation continuity.
The Souss plain
the filling the formations of the Souss plain include sediment that have accumulated in the groove subsiding,
formed at the south of the High Atlas during the Neogene and Quaternary.
The continental Neogene is represented by powerful conglomerate deposits at the foot of the High Atlas. Further
to the south, there is a Fluviolacustrine formation essentially marly limestone, clay and sandstone with
interbedded conglomeratic. This is the "formation of the Souss" which has been assigned a Pliocene -
Villafrachien age.
In the subsiding basin of Souss the ancient Pliocene is represented by limestones, sandstones, unconsolidated
sands, coquinas and marl. It is crowned by Moghrebian coquillers sandstones. The series reaches a thickness of
600 m.
The Neogene Quaternary limit is difficult to determine, throughout the continental quaternary is often clay. It forms
the alluvial cones (early Quaternary), fossil beds of Souss (in grittiness) and more recent alluvial deposits (loams
and alluvial clay).
Structurally, the plain of Souss is a narrow rift zone wedged between the High Atlas and Anti Atlas, detrital
formations and calcareous clay of Pliocene-Quaternary filling cover a syncline Cretaceous-Eocene oriented east-
west. The northern flank of this synclinal widely outcrops discontinuously along the High Atlas. Its southern flank
is shown by a line of hills dominated by limestone of the Turonian in the center of the Souss valley.
Anti Atlas
On the left bank of the Oued Souss, the Precambrian terrains, part of the northern occidental Anti Atlas outcrops
buttonholes of dimensions and orientation variable. The wider are that of Ighrem, Timjicht Tangarfa surrounded
by buttonholes of smaller dimensions that are Wawfengha, Alma, Abdallah Ait and Tataout.
In the region of Taroudant Ighrem The bedrock consists of Paleoproterozoic land and quartzite associated with
the lower Neoproterozoic. They are covered in major unconformity by volcanic and volcano-clastic cover of the
upper Neoproterozoic and then sedimentary. This latter is mainly attributed to the carbonated Adoudounien and
the Cambrian.
- The Paleoproterozoic (P1) is formed of SCHITO-growackeuses grouped by series of more or less deformed granites during eburnean orogonese.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
61
- The Neoproterozoic is represented by the lower Precambrian II and Precambrian III. - Lower Precambrian II: consists of massive quartzites and limestones of nearly 1000 m thickness. It
is cut in numerous dykes and gabbroic diabase attributed to Precambrian II. - The upper Neoproterozoic (PII-PIII) is composed of conglomerate deposits associated to volcanic
acids tuffs. - Precambrian III: includes flows of basalt or Andesites surmounted by pelites and conglomerates.
The sedimentary cover is less developed than in the western part (Tiznit Basin). It is formed by:
- The basic series: represented by conglomerates, limestones and schists; - The lower limestone: composed of limestone and dolomite representing the bulk of the carbonate
plateau that characterizes this area; - The series Lie de Vin characterized by purplish schists deposited in bands around the main
synclinal structures; - The Cambrian is formed by the upper limestones (black limestones and dolomites of Tiout), who
enrich themselves upward in clay levels (schist and limestone series). The latter is surmounted by sandstone terminals, then by schists with Paradoxides.
.NATURAL ENVIRONMENT AND BIODIVERSITY 5.4.
This region is characterized by vegetation structures constituted by both the Mediterranean strain elements,
Saharan and tropical that cohabit depending on weather conditions. The region is an extensive hinge zone where
meet various phytogeographic elements making it a true botanical crossroads. The originality of the sector is the
presence of the endemic genus Argania, the gum of Morocco (Acacia gummifera), olive of Morocco
(Oleaeuropaeasubsp. Maroccana) a thermophilic flora composed of many delicious elements that from the
Physiognomic viewpoint reminds the infracanarien level and finally, the presence of many endemic (Genista ferox
ssp. microphylla, Bupleurumdumosum, Lavandula maroccana, Micromeriama crosiphon, Sideritis cossoniana,
Thymus leptobotrys, Micromeria arganietorum Dracaena draco subsp. ajgal, Hesperolaburnum platycarpum,
Hannonia hesperidum, Teucrium rock, etc...).
Figure 9 . Argan forest and argan biosphere
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
62
Moreover, the region has several Sites of Biological and Ecological Interest (SIBE). The following figures show
the distribution of the biosphere of the argan, the location of Sibes and their zones.
SOCIO-ECONOMIC SITUATION OF REFERENCE 5.5.
The project affects several provinces and prefectures, particularly through its main component which is the
completion of the arganiculture on 10 000 Ha. It includes the provinces of Essaouira, Agadir Ida Outanane,
Inezgane - Ait Melloul Taroudant, Chtouka - Ait Baha Tiznit, Sidi Ifni and Guelmim.
Within these provinces, the project target 31 towns with an average poverty rate of 10.5% and a rate of
vulnerability of 20,2%.
The direct beneficiary population of the project is estimated at 26 000 inhabitants and 10,000 households
5.5.1. POPULATION
In the territory of the concerned provinces, the project targets 31 municipalities with a total population of 345,211
inhabitants and 75,421 households, according to the General Census of Population and Housing 2014
(RGPH2014).
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
63
Province or Préfecture
Commune Population 2014
Nb of householdss
2014
Size of householdsge
2014
Annual average growth rate
Essaouira Ida Ou Aazza 7 923 1 467 5,4 0,7%
Bizdad 7 959 1 604 5 -0,8%
Mzilate 4 209 782 5,4 -0,8%
Adaghas 2 825 519 5,4 -1,6%
Aglif 8 028 1 620 5 -1,1%
Agadir Ida Outanane Imouzzer 5 402 1 110 4,9 -1,6%
Tiqqi 8 773 1 716 5,1 -1,4%
Amskroud 9 351 2 031 4,6 -0,7%
Aqesri 4 128 907 4,6 -1,6%
Inezgane - Ait Melloul Temsia 40 780 9 096 4,5 4,5%
Taroudant Aoulouz (Mun.) 17 409 3 633 4,8 -0,6%
Tinzart 5 902 1 105 5,3 0,7%
Arazane 7 999 1 422 5,6 0,9%
Argana 4 804 978 4,9 -1,0%
Assads 4 650 968 4,8 -1,7%
Irherm (Mun.) 4 108 1 002 4,1 -1,2%
Imaouen 2 466 622 4 -2,3%
Ait Abdallah 2 086 643 3,2 -3,5%
Chtouka - Ait Baha Ida Ougnidif 2 149 678 3,2 -3,8%
Sidi Abdallah EL Bouchouari 8 128 1 764 4,6 -1,1%
Tiznit Tafraout (Mun.) 6 345 1 771 3,6 2,6%
Sidi Ahmed Ou Moussa 3 679 818 4,5 -1,4%
Tnine Aday 1 903 506 3,8 -3,6%
Arbaa Rasmouka 5 964 1 395 4,3 -2,3%
Reggada 13 284 2 948 4,5 -0,8%
Tnine Aglou 10 240 2 631 3,9 -3,5%
Sidi Ifni Mesti 2 931 636 4,6 -1,9%
Mirleft 8 162 2 004 4,1 1,5%
Tioughza 10 577 2 257 4,7 -1,5%
Lakhsas (Mun.) 4 729 1 121 4,2 1,2%
Guelmim Guelmim (Mun.) 118 318 25 667 4,6 2,1% Total 345 211 75 421 4,6 0,5%
Province of Essaouia : The five communes concerned with the project have a population of 30944
inhabitants concerned gathered in 5992 households having a mean size of 5.2 peoples. The population of
the communes follows a slight downward trend, with a rate of -0.6% per year (between 2004 and 2014).
Préfecture of Agadir – Ida Ou Tanane: The four municipalities involved in the project have a population of
27 654 inhabitants grouped into 5764 households with an average size of 4.8 persons. The population of the
concerned communes, all rural, follows a downward trend, evolving at a rate of -1.2% per year.
Prefecture of Inezgane-Ait Melloul : The commune concerned by the project (Temsia) has, according to
the 2014 RGPH, a population of 40 780 inhabitants grouped into 9096 households with an average size of
4.5 persons. This population follows an upward trend, with a rate of 4.5% per year between 2004 and 2014.
Province of Taroudant : The eight communities concerned by the project have a population of 49 424
inhabitants divided into 10,373 households with an average size of 4.8 persons. The population of the
concerned communes follows a slight downward trend, evolving at a rate of -0.7% per year.
Province of Chtouka – Ait Baha : The two communities concerned by the project have a population of 10
277 inhabitants grouped into 2442 households with an average size of 4.2 peoples. The population of the
concerned communes follows a downward trend, evolving at a rate of -1.7% per year.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
64
Province of Tiznit : The six communes concerned by the project have a population of 41 415 inhabitants
divided into 10,069 households with an average size of 4.1 peoples. The population of the concerned
communes follows a downward trend, evolving at a rate of -1.5% per year.
Préfecture of Sidi Ifni : The four communes concerned by the project have a population of 26 399
inhabitants grouped into 6018 households with an average size of 4.4 peoples. The population of the
concerned communes follows a slight downward trend, evolving at a rate of -0.2% per year.
Prefecture of Guelmim : The commune concerned by the project (Guelmim) has, according to the 2014
RGPH, a population of 118 318 inhabitants grouped in 25 667 households having an average size of 4.6
peoples. This population follows an upward trend, with a rate of 2.1% per year between 2004 and 2014.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
65
5.5.2. POVERTY
The 31 communities concerned by the project have an average poverty rate of 10.5% and a vulnerability rate of
20.2%. They are relatively poorer than the national average.
Figure 10 : Poverty Rates of the concerned communes
Province of Essaouia : With an overall poverty rate of about 20.7%, the concerned communes at the level
of Essaouira province are relatively poorer than the rest of the province, the poverty rate in the province is
16.1% ( 6.2% in urban and 18.8% in rural).
Préfecture of Agadir – Ida Ou Tanane : With an overall rate of about 15%, the concerned communes at the
level of prefecture of Agadir Ida Ou Tanane have relatively high poverty rates, knowing that the prefecture
poverty rate is 4.3% (1, 9% in urban and 13.5% in rural).
Préfecture of Inezgane-Ait Melloul : With 10.9% of poverty rate (in 2007), the commune of Temsia is
relatively poorer than the rest of the province, the provincial poverty rate is 3.6% (3% in urban and 12 1% in
rural areas). The commune's vulnerability rate is 14.3%.
Province of Taroudant : With an overall rate of about 14.7%, the concerned communes at the level of
Taroudant province have a relatively average poverty rate, given that the poverty rate in the province is
13.2% (5.7% in urban and 15.7% in rural).
Province of Chtouka – Ait Baha : With an average poverty rate of about 14.7%, the concerned
communities in the province of Chtouka-Ait Baha have a higher poverty rate than the provincial average of
8.4% (7.1% in urban and 8.5% in rural).
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
66
Province of Tiznit : With an overall rate of about 8%, the concerned communesat the level of Tiznit province
have a relatively average poverty rate, given that the poverty rate in the province of 9.7% (2.7% in urban and
12.5% in rural).
Prefecture of Sidi Ifni : With an overall rate of about 16.5%, the concerned communes at the level of Sidi
Ifni province have a poverty rate close to the provincial average of 17.2% (6.1% in urban and 20.7% in rural).
Prefectureof Guelmim : With 4.2% poverty rate (in 2007), the commune of Guelmim is relatively less poor
than the rest of the province, the provincial poverty rate of 7.2% (4.8% in urban and 12.9% in rural areas).
The commune's vulnerability rate is 17.1%.
EIGS NETWORK AND COOPERATIVES AT THE LEVEL OF THE REGION 5.6.
The sector of the argan knew an evolution that much more marked the organizational aspects and support to
producers. Since the first women's cooperative of production and marketing, in 1995 there was the creation of the
first group of women cooperatives producing Argan (UCFA) in 1999. The recognition of the argan tree as
Biosphere (RBA) also revitalized the cooperative sector with almost 300 cooperatives today. With a view to
reinforce the structuring of the sector a new phase was marked by the installation of the IGP Argane within the
framework of the law on the Characteristics of Origin and Quality (SDOQ). In order to consolidate the
professional organization of the sector a Moroccan Interprofessional Federation of Argan (FIMARGANE) was
created in 2011. It represents a new structure for strategic consultation and management which includes colleges
of the sector. It includes the National Federation of entitled personns of the argan tree, composed of 7 provincial
associations representing the producers of the raw materials that form the basis of the sector link.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
67
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
68
6. POTENTIAL ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACTS
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS 6.1.
6.1.1. IMPACTS ON ARGANERAIE BIOSPHERE RESERVE (RBA)
Arganeraie biosphere reserve (RBA) covers around 2.5 million hectares, of which argan trees covers 280,000
hectares. All the components of the project are located outside the biosphere reserve. The project has been
conceived in such a way as to develop argan growing beyond the limits of the biosphere. The components of the
project reinforces the preservation of the biosphere reserve through the development of argan growing in
degraded area, the promotion of good practices, and the capacity building of actors and local populations. Such
actions ensures a steady income for people who live in the area the biosphere and provides them with new
income sources. Thus, they would be less tempted to contribute to the degradation of the biosphere reserve.
The capacity building actions envisaged in component 3 would sensitize populations bordering the reserve to
better protect it. All actions go towards protecting the biosphere reserve.
Component Positive impacts Risks or negative impacts
Component 1
implementation of the
arganiculture on 10 000 ha
Reduce the pressure on the biosphere reserve;
Increasing the resilience of the biosphere to
fight against the effects of climate change;
Construction phase:
Impacts related to planting
work, roads improvement,
atmospheric emissions, waste
management (mostly plants)
Contribution to the reduction of soil erosion risk
in the biosphere reserve. Indeed, protection and
rainwater catchment structures will protect both
the argan growing area and a part of the
biosphere reserve
No major negative impacts: the
impacts are related to the
construction phase and will be
easily mitigated if good
practices are adopted. These
impacts are similar to those of
Component 1.
Component 2 :
Structuration on upstream
and downstrean argan value
chain
Reinforce good protection practices of the
Biosphere Reserve by the dissemination of
good practices and the development of
products derived from the argan tree:
Adding values to products derived from the
argan tree in the argan biosphere beserve.
No negative impact
Component 3 : capacity Strengthening the capacity of stakeholders in No negative impact
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
69
building, knowledge
management, co-
managment of natural argan
forest and scientific
research promotion
the area of the biosphere reserve;
Adding value to the products of the argan and
searching for mitigation solutions to reduce the
pressure on the reserve through the research
center on the argan
6.1.2. IMPACTS ON GROUND WATER AND SURFACE WATER RESOURCES
Water resources will be impacted positively by the project. The rainwater catchment and flood protection
structures will make it possible to store water to be reused in irrigation and familial livestock feeding.
The development of the argan growing (arganiculture) as a sector will enable the reconversion of some
perimeters practicing intensive agriculture (major consumer of water) toward the promotion of arganiculture
(agran growing), which is less greedy in water. This will reduce the pressure on the use of water which can be
used for irrigation in Souss-Massa perimeters. Indeed, in the short term, capacity-building and the dissemination
of good practices will make it possible to raise awareness on the role and importance of developing a profitable
sector of arganiculture and, therefore, will encourage perimeters that are suitable for intensive agriculture to
move towards arganiculture, in the long term. This orientation make it possible to strengthen the biosphere
reserve, reduce pressure on the forest of argan and reduce water consumption for irrigation, all together.
The rainwater catchment and flood protection structures will make it possible not only to mobilize water for
irrigation, but also to protect perimeters against flood. Thus, they protect human lives and infrastructures. In the
long term, these structures will enable harmonious development of economic activities and the reduction of risk of
flooding in the area.
All these elements give the possibility to reduce the over-exploitation of groundwater in the Souss-Massa basins.
However, negative impacts may occur during the construction phase. The mismanagement of the products used
during construction, construction waste and scraps, and a accidental spillage, etc. can affect the quality of surface
water and groundwater. Also, in case the work would require a temporary change of the flow of water, this could
negatively impact the population living downstream of the work site.
Therefore, there is a need to adopt a construction site with low environmental impact and to establish the
requirements and conditions to be met in order to avoid the negative impact of the project on water resources.
It should be noted that ABH (Agency of Hydraulic Basin), ORMVA-SM and DRA-SM have completed several
similar projects and that their experience has been proven in terms of the preservation of water resources during
the construction phase.
Component Positive impacts Risks or negative impacts
Component 1 : component 1:
implementation of the arganiculture
The possible reconversion of a
part of the intensive agriculture
The use of water for irrigation of
arganiculture could amplify the need for
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
70
on 10 000 ha toward arganiculture (agran
growing), will reduce the
pression on water resource
water for irrigation during the
implemention phase.
Additional needs in places where current
usage peaks
The water requirements for irrigation of
plants during the first 3 years are roughly
estimated at 25 million m3 / year
The mobilization of water
resources for agriculture and
aromatic or medicinal plants
during the phase of plantation
and value adding;
Water concentration in
structures (basins, catchment)
which improves the efficiency
of the use of water;
The partial recharge of the
aquifer by strengthening the
collection of rainwater and the
storing flood waters;
Efficient management of water
resources, contributing to the
reduction of pressure on water
resources, to the improvement
of living conditions of the
beneficiary population and to
the the improvement of the
productivity of plantations
The pollution of waters during the
construction of rainwater catchment and
flood protection structures
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan
value chain
Strengthening good practices
about rational utilization of
water for irrigation;Good water
use practices ;
No risks
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-
Good water saving practices;
Support applied research on
No risks or negative impacts
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
71
managment of natural argan forest
and scientific research promotion
optimizing the mobilization of
water resources.
6.1.3. IMPACTS ON SOIL AND CARBON SEQUESTRATION
Soil protection is one of the project objectives. Indeed, the planting of argan in degraded areas promotes soil
conservation and carbon sequestration. The project also helps improve the fertility of poor soils in target areas
giving the the argan tree grows in poor soils.
The project through the component of mobilization of water resources (carrying storm water collection structures
and protection against floods) enables both the mobilization of water resources and the protection ot soil against
erosion. A set of effective SWC techniques are practiced in the region and suggested in the documents of the
project in question.
The good practices of soil conservation through training provided by the Component 3 will have a positive impact
on soil protection.
However risks could appear during the construction phase. During the w construction of the structures, there
could be risks, especially in the vicinity of the site. The choice of the projects sites must be done wisely, in order
to minimize impacts on the soil. In addition, measures on preservation of soil and health / safety must be set up
and respected by public works companies..
Indeed, the implementation of such structures will require excavation of materials from the bed of the oued; this
could undermine the stability of soil and also cause damage to the vegetation around the site. Similarly, improper
handling of waste and dangerous products, although minimal, may contaminate the ground, if there is a failure to
compliance with adequate safety / health measures.
Thus, proper management of cuttings, products and waste should be ensured; quantities excavated will be
reused and / or disposed of in authorized areas; At the end of construction, site remediation will also be ensured.
Regarding of operation, it is necessary that the management technique avoid the risk of disrupting the dynamics
of water flow and that soil clogging risks in infiltration area be examined. In usual cases, frequent in the field,
these risks do not have a significant extent in the project area and the techniques adopted by the ABH and
ORMVA / DRA-SM is proof..
Component Positive impacts Risks or negative impacts
Component 1 : component 1:
implementation of the arganiculture
on 10 000 ha
Protection of soil against
erosion and improvement of
soil fertility;
Carbon sequestration
Risk of soil contamination by argan
plants waste and the waste produced
by the workers.
Soil protection against erosion; Risk of soil contamination during the
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
72
construction phase
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan
value chain
Dissemination of good
practices for soil protection
Risk of soil contamination during the
construction of the EIG upgrading units
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-
managment of natural argan forest
and scientific research promotion
Dissemination of good
practices for soil protection
No risks or negative impacts
6.1.4. IMPACTS ON BIODIVERSITY
The project will have a direct positive impact on biodiversity. Improved water availability will participate in the
maintenance of life in the project areas.
Thus the project will participate in the ecosystem preservation in general, and the local fauna and flora
preservation. It is recalled that the project area is located outside both RAMSAR areas.
During the implementation phase, possibly some impacts may occur but remain circumscribed in nearby
construction sites. Examples of these impacts may be those relating to the construction of access roads, the
clearing of plantations and also the poor management of waste and site scrap site.
Component Positive impacts Risks or negative impacts
Component 1 : component 1:
implementation of the arganiculture
on 10 000 ha
Imporving biodiversity through
growing Medicinal and
Aromatic Plants (PAM);
The domestication of the
argan tree
Risk localized during the phase of
planting work
Risk of plantations clearing due to
construction works, especially those
related to the implementation of access
roads
Improving biodiversity,
especially the flora, as a result
of water that will be captured
Improving productivity through
irrigation
Small risk during construction of
protection and rainwater catchment
structures
Component 2 : Structuration on Positive impact on the No negative impact
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
73
upstream and downstrean argan
value chain
diversification of domesticated
crops and promotion of
activities around the protection
of biodiversity (beekeeping,
etc ..)
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-
managment of natural argan forest
and scientific research promotion
positive impact on the
population through thematic
training and dissemination of
good practices
Encouragement of research
(PhD students, researchers,
etc ..) about the issues
affecting the RBA and its
biodiversity
Support to dedicated entities
(CNA) to promote biodiversity
of the RBA.
No negative impact
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
74
6.1.5. IMPACTS ON AIR ET TEMPERATURE
These impacts, generated during the implementation phase, are of low intensity, temporary and of low extent. Only the
emission of dust and noise generated by the works themselves are to master. Although sandy soils do not emit dust
during the work, their handling may trigger a drive by winds and sand encroachment. Stabilization measures should be
recommended.
Component Positive impacts Risks or negative impacts
Component 1 : component 1:
implementation of the arganiculture
on 10 000 ha
The planting of argan and
PAM will contribute to reducing
the temperature and creating
an ecosystem that will strength
the Arganeraie Biosphere
Reserve (RBA)
Carbon sequestration
Generation of dust and atmospheric
emissions associated with construction
works: presence of equipment and
construction of access roads, especially
in the dry period
Contributing to the decrease in
temperature around water
catchment areas and flood
protection structures;
- Generation of dust and atmospheric
emissions associated with
construction works: presence of
equipment and construction of
access roads, especially in the dry
period
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan
value chain
No impact Generation of dust and atmospheric
emissions associated with
construction works: presence of
equipment and construction of
access roads, especially in the dry
period
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-
managment of natural argan forest
and scientific research promotion
No impact No impact
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
75
6.1.6. IMPACTS ON ARCHAEOLOGY AND CULTURAL HERITAGE
The project will not affect any archaeological site or world heritage site, or other important sites (Graveyard, ....). The
project will not affect native or indigenous populations that do not even exist in Morocco.
Component Positive impacts Risks or negative impacts
Component 1 : component 1:
implementation of the
arganiculture on 10 000 ha
No impact Minimal risk of discovering archaeological
sites during the construction phase
Component 2 : Structuration
on upstream and downstrean
argan value chain
No impact No impact
Component 3 : capacity
building, knowledge
management, co-managment of
natural argan forest and
scientific research promotion
No impact No impact
6.1.7. IMPACTS FROM SOLID AND LIQUID WASTES
The activities of the project will generate waste during planting and construction / rehabilitation works of catchment and
protection structures, including empty specification materials (eg cement), wood and plastic wood, paper and waste
from construction sites. This could result in increased pressure on waste collection facilities and local sewerage.
Component Positive impacts Risks or negative impacts
Component 1 : component 1:
implementation of the
arganiculture on 10 000 ha
No impact Poor management of waste resulting from
argan plants
No impact Minimal risk of pollution during the
construction phase
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
76
Component 2 : Structuration
on upstream and downstrean
argan value chain
No impact No impact
Component 3 : capacity
building, knowledge
management, co-managment of
natural argan forest and
scientific research promotion
No impact No impact
6.1.8. NOISE AND VIBRATION
The various project sites are characterized by a quiet and noiseless environment . The activities in the project will not
generate any noise or vibration. The only impacts that could occur are minimal and covers the period of the
construction of protective structures. The noise that may be generated would be that of machines and vehicles.
Component Positive impacts Risks or negative impacts
Component 1: implementation
of the arganiculture on 10 000
ha
No impact Presence and movement of machines
No impact Minimal risk of noise during the
construction phase
Component 2 : Structuration
on upstream and downstrean
argan value chain
No impact Minimal risk of noise during the
construction phase
Component 3 : capacity
building, knowledge
management, co-managment of
natural argan forest and
No impact No impact
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
77
scientific research promotion
POTENTIAL POSITIVE SOCIO-ECONOMIC IMPACTS 6.2.
6.2.1. EMPLOYMENT CREATION
The project will have a positive impact on job creation during the implementation phase of the project and the
impact will last beyond the implementation phase of the lands improvement and inhancement actions planned in
components 3 and 4. Indeed, the project will impact a direct population of about 26 000 inhabitants and a total
direct and indirect population of about 425 000 inhabitants in the whole area.
The economic activity around the project sites will increase during the implementation phase . Local populations
may be asked to participate in the achievement of planting activites through companies that would carry out the
project activities. The sale of household consumer products, for people who will be in charge of carrying out the
work, will increase during the phase of implementation of the project activities.
Another advantage is selling products and building materials for rainwater the construction of catchment and flood
protection structures. At this stage it would be recommended the company give the priority to the use of local
building materials. This would create added value for the sale of these materials, locally.
Part of the expenditure of employees and consultants who will be in charge of technically participating in the
achievement of the project components will be injected into the local and regional economy.
During the upgrading phase, the project will:
- Improve the sources of income of the population by planting argan and aromatic and medicinal plants. This will allow beneficiaries to have a viable and sustainable source of income. The project will also create new income-generating activities for the population ;
- Create long-term jobs. Indeed, jobs relating to the valorization of argan plantations, jobs for the maintenance rainwater catchments and flood protection structures will be created. The creation of EIG will yield new jobs for their management.
6.2.2. NEW JOBS IN THE PRODUCTION OF ARGAN PLANTS :
The development of agriculture will strengthen revenue sources for nursery gardeners, who will have to produce more
plants that are certified for arganiculture .
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
78
6.2.3. STABILISATION OF THE POPULATION AND LIMITATION OF THE PRESSION ON CITIES
The project will strengthen the income sources for local people and hence, offer them opportunities to work sustainably
in the context of climate change. This will cause a change in the attitude of people who tend to leave their current
environment toward neighboring cities. This change will lead to an improvement in the living conditions of the local
population will yield indirect impacts on citiy jobs resulting from rural exodus.
Component Positive impacts Risks or negative impacts
Component 1 : component
1: implementation of the
arganiculture on 10 000 ha
- Improving income for the population
through the production of argan and its
derivative products: production of :
o 3,870 tons/year of fresh fruits
o 2,320 tons/year of dry fruits
o Argan oil
- Jobs creation
- Development of PAM : diversification of
income sources
- Diversification of income sources
Improving the living standards of the
beneficiary population;
Participating in the sustainable development
of the region
- Given the potential
and the demand, risk
of not satisfying the
whole population,
especially the
vulnerable
population
- Job creation during the construction of
structures, through local hiring, depending
on existing qualifications.
- Strengthening the efficiency of agriculture
owing to the better water management
- preserving social stability.
- Maintaining the irrigation of the current
agricultural area;
- Increase in irrigated agricultural area
- Retention of the local population;
- Reduction of migration towards other
areas.
- Minor risks related to
safety and health
during the
construction phase.
Component 2 : Structuration
on upstream and downstrean
argan value chain
- Sustaining and developing income
generated by the argan
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
79
Component 3 : capacity
building, knowledge
management, co-managment
of natural argan forest and
scientific research promotion
- Effectiveness in managing the production
of argan;
- Continuous improvement of the quality of
arganiculture.
6.2.4. GENDER ISSUES
Women and men will benefit from the same employment opportunities offered during the implementation phase. The
ANDZOA and the entity responsible for the implementation of the activity specifies that the chances for gender equality
will be considered in the proposed opportunities.
Component Positive impacts Risks or negative impacts
Component 1 : component 1:
implementation of the arganiculture
on 10 000 ha
- Positive impact through
improving income for men
and women
- No risks
- The construction work will
impact the employment of
both men and women
- - Risk of hiring men
rather than women due
to the nature of the
work to be done ;
- Risk relating to work
opportunity during the
construction phase
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan
value chain
- Both genders will take
advantage of the work. This
component will contribute to
the employment of women
and thus mitigate the risk of
exclusion of women from the
project
- This component will also
support wealth creation
initiatives (ICR) to the benefit
of young women.
Impact on other activities of
women because of their
occupation for the valorization of
the argan products.
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-
managment of natural argan forest
positive impact on the capacity
building of all stakeholders (men
and women)
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
80
and scientific research promotion
6.2.5. CAPACITY BUILDING
All the components of the project include capacity building of beneficiaries and stakeholders. Component 3 provides
capacity building for environmental and social aspects, and on safety and health and gender. …
Component Positive impacts Risks or negative impacts
Component 1 : component 1:
implementation of the arganiculture
on 10 000 ha
Capacity building in agriculture
and sustainable collective
management of planted areas
Installing a school in the field
dedicated to arganiculture
- No impact
Capacity building for the
collective maintenance of CEP
(rainwater catchment) and CES
(SWC - Soil and Water
Conservation) structures through
the installation of a school in the
dedicated field.
- No impact
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan
value chain
Training for OP and EIG, and
structuring rightful claimants
The valorization of argan
products
No impact
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-
managment of natural argan forest
and scientific research promotion
Capacity building for all
stakeholders in the sector.
Capacity building for research
actors(researchers, young PhD
students, etc ..).
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
81
6.2.6. SOCIO CULTURAL IMPACTS
The project enables the strengthening of management and argan valorization structures in the area, and, hence the
development of a structured network capable of accessing the market for argan products and PAM valorization
products. Components 3 and 4 will strenghen the socio-cultural impact and contribute to the promotion of local
products through the exhibitions that are regularly held in Morocco and abroad. .
Component Positive impacts Risks or negative impacts
Component 1 : component 1:
implementation of the arganiculture
on 10 000 ha
Strengthening links between
regions where the project is
carried out (exchanges,
meetings at fairs, ...);
- No impact
Awareness about environmental
protection and risks related to
climate change;
Conservation of CEP structures
(terrassettes) as ingenious
structures, heritage and local
know-how.
- No impact
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan
value chain
Developping socio-cultural
activities and increasing the
presence at fairs and local
products exhibitions
No impact
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-
managment of natural argan forest
and scientific research promotion
Developping socio-cultural
activities and increasing the
presence at fairs and local
products exhibitions
No impact
6.2.7. INVOLUNTARY RESETTLEMENT AND ADHERENCE OF POPULATION
No involuntary resettlement of the population will take place for all project components and activities. For components that require the mobilization of the land, this mobilization will be for the following activities:
Plantation of argan and PAM: host lands are those landowners and plantation will be done on behalf of the beneficiaries with their consent. In this context, during the detailed feasibility phase, the ANDZOA will ensure that all beneficiaries reaffirm their adherence through a commitment signed by the owners. In case of refusal, the
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
82
activity will be reassigned to people who express their willingness to expand the area they initially dedicated to the project.
For rainwater catchment structures: actions will be carried out on oueds and chaabas which are under the hydraulic public domain, according to Moroccan legislation. Regarding SWC structures (in particular the terraces) that already exist on the private property of beneficiaries, the Project will undertake their rehabilitation, which is highly demanded by the beneficiaries. However, the local population will be sensitized before the project starts in order to reach an agreement with them. The final technical choice for sites to hold rainwater catchment and flood protection structures will be made in such a way that no involuntary resetlement will occur. Before the construction work starts, ANDZOA and Hydraulic Basin Agency (execution partner) will mobilize the population to reaffirm their commitment and establish a record materializing the final agreement on the site to be chosen. In case of unwillingness or identification of a potential risk, the project will be moved to a site that is safe in this context. Note that the rest of the activities planned in the other components are enhancement activities. Therefore they present no risk of negative impact on the population.
Adherence of the population is a guarantee of the succes of the project, and awareness raising before the start of the project remains essential. This awareness raising, along with the detailed feasibility study will enable the adherence of the population and the implementation of the components of the project. This assistance must be supervised by ONCA given its experience in farm advisory.
Component Positive impacts Risks or negative impacts
Component 1 : component 1:
implementation of the arganiculture
on 10 000 ha
No involuntary resettlement of the
population will take place
Risk of unstable adherence of
beneficiaries.
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan
value chain
No involuntary resettlement of the
population will take place
No involuntary resettlement of the
population will take place
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-
managment of natural argan forest
and scientific research promotion
No involuntary resettlement of the
population will take place
No involuntary resettlement of the
population will take place
6.2.8. RESTRICTION OF LAND USE AND LAND RIGHTS
The project components present no risk relating to land use and land use rights.
6.2.9. HEALTH AND SAFETY AND SECURITY
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
83
The construction rainwater catchment and flood protection structures can pose risks for people living or working near
construction sites, as well as those working on site. This work can be a particular threat to children and livestock during
transport of building materials. Local people, including those working on the site may not be aware of construction
risks. Children may be inadvertently recruited to work on construction sites.
Les camps de travailleurs de la construction peuvent également donner lieu à des risques pour la santé associés aux pratiques d'élimination des déchets, de l'assainissement, ….
Component Positive impacts Risks or negative impacts
Component 1 : component 1:
implementation of the arganiculture
on 10 000 ha
Risk of accident or illness during
the construction phase
Risk of accident or illness during
the construction phase
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan
value chain
Risk of accident or illness during
the construction phase
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-
managment of natural argan forest
and scientific research promotion
Risk of accident or illness during
the construction phase
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
84
7. MITIGATION AND ENHANCEMENT MEASURES
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS MITIGATION MEASURES 7.1.
7.1.1. IMPACTS ON THE ARGANERAIE BIOSPHERE RESERVE
Component Risks or negative
impacts
Mitigation measure
Component 1 : implementation of the
arganiculture on 10 000 ha
Construction phase:
Impacts related to planting
work, roads improvement,
atmospheric emissions,
waste management
(mostly plants)
Despite the absence of risk, the project
will consider the importance of the RBA,
which must be preserved
Finalize a requirements specification for
works which will guarantee:
- considering the protection of
the RBA.
- a good management of waste
of plants
- A rehabilitation of areas
affected by the work
- Low nuisance.
Conduct an awareness campaign for
farmers / beneficiaries on the protection
of RBA.
No major negative impacts:
the impacts are related to
the construction phase and
will be easily mitigated if
good practices are
adopted. These impacts
are similar to those of
Component 1.
Conduct an awareness campaign for
farmers / beneficiaries on the protection
of RBA.
Finalize a requirements specification for
works which will guarantee:
- considering the protection of
the RBA.
- a good management of waste
of plants
- A rehabilitation of areas
affected by the work
- Low nuisance.
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan value
chain
No negative impact
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
85
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-
managment of natural argan forest and
scientific research promotion
No negative impact
7.1.2. IMPACTS ON SURFACE WATER AND GROUNDWATER RESOURCES
Component Risks or negative impacts Mitigation measure
Component 1 : implementation of the
arganiculture on 10 000 ha
The use of water for irrigation of
arganiculture could amplify the
need for water for irrigation during
the implemention phase.
Additional needs in places where
current usage peaks
The water requirements for
irrigation of plants during the first
3 years are roughly estimated at
25 million m3 / year
Consider the volume of water
needed for the planting phase
before the project starts.
Foresee the possiblity that the
contractor be in charge of bringing
water if needed.
Include environmental and social
monitoring in the role of the
technical assistant
The pollution of waters during the
construction of rainwater
catchment and flood protection
structures
Avoid spillage of waste and
products in oueds or alluvium;
Train site staff on food safety
measures to comply with;
Include environmental and social
monitoring in the role of the
technical assistant
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan value
chain
Risk of contamination during the
construction of the value adding
units, if they are close to a
watercourse
Detailing the feasibility of the
project before its implementation
in order to estimate water needs
and provide an ESMP suitable for
the activities planned in
component 3
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
86
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-
managment of natural argan forest and
scientific research promotion
No risks or negative impacts
7.1.3. IMPACTS ON SOIL
Component Risks or negative impacts Mitigation measure
Component 1 : implementation of the
arganiculture on 10 000 ha
Risk of soil contamination by
argan plants waste and the
waste produced by the
workers.
Ensure a good management of
tailings and waste produced by
the workers
Risk of soil contamination during
the construction phase
Risk to be recorded during the
construction phase.
Taking the necessary measures
during the construction phase in
order to avoid any risk of
contamination (clear requirements
specification on this matter).
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan value
chain
Risk of soil contamination during
the construction of the EIG
upgrading units
Taking the necessary measures
during the construction phase in
order to avoid any risk of
contamination.
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-
managment of natural argan forest and
scientific research promotion
No risks or negative impacts
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
87
7.1.4. IMPACTS ON BIODIVERSITY
Component Risks or negative impacts Mitigation measure Component 1 : implementation of the arganiculture on 10 000 ha
Risk localized during the phase of planting work Risk of plantations clearing due to construction works, especially those related to the implementation of access roads
Restore and rehabilitate the areas affected by the work
Small risk during construction of protection and rainwater catchment structures
Rehabilitate areas affected by the work to a level at least equal to the baseline situation.
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan value
chain
No negative impact
Component 3 : capacity building, knowledge management, co-managment of natural argan forest and scientific research promotion
No negative impact
7.1.5. IMPACTS ON AIR ET TEMPERATURE
Component Risks or negative impacts Mitigation measure Component 1:: implementation of the arganiculture on 10 000 ha
Generation of dust and atmospheric emissions associated with construction works: presence of equipment and construction of access roads, especially in the dry period
Optimizing the movement of the equipment Use of equipment that are in good condition Watering areas close to people
- Generation of dust and atmospheric emissions associated with construction works: presence of equipment and construction of access roads, especially in the dry period
Risk to be considered during the construction phase. Optimizing the movement of the equipment Use of equipment that are in good condition Watering areas close to people
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan
value chain
Generation of dust and atmospheric emissions associated with construction works: presence of equipment
Optimizing the movement of the equipment Use of equipment that are in good condition Watering areas close to people
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
88
and construction of access roads, especially in the dry period
Component 3 : capacity building, knowledge management, co-managment of natural argan forest and scientific research promotion
7.1.6. IMPACTS ON ARCHAEOLOGY AND CULTURAL HERITAGE
Component Risks or negative impacts Mitigation measure
Component 1 : implementation of
the arganiculture on 10 000 ha
No impact
- Minimal risk of
discovering
archaeological sites
during the construction
phase
Upon discovery of archaeological sites,
alerting officials of the Ministry of Culture
and local authorities while following the
national procedure relating to sites
reporting. Stop work immediately.
Discuss with the other project partners
about the relocation to a new site while
following the same approach
(Consultation, support of the population,
site identification, prior assessment of the
environmental and social impact)
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan
value chain
No impact
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-
managment of natural argan forest
and scientific research promotion
No impact
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
89
7.1.7. IMPACTS FROM SOLID AND LIQUID WASTES
Component Risks or negative impacts Mitigation measure
Component 1 : implementation of
the arganiculture on 10 000 ha
Poor management of waste
resulting from argan plants
Ensuring a good management of plants
waste
Minimal risk of pollution during
the construction phase
Taking the necessary measure during
the implementation phase ;
Add the ESMP to the requirements
specification.
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan
value chain
No impact
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-
managment of natural argan forest
and scientific research promotion
No impact
7.1.8. NOISE AND VIBRATION
Component Risks or negative impacts Mitigation measure
Component 1 : implementation of the
arganiculture on 10 000 ha
Minor risk of noise during
the construction phase
Including in the requirements
specification, driving restrictions at
night, limited speed and
necessary safety instructions
(signage, etc .)
Component 2 : Structuration on upstream
and downstrean argan value chain
No impact
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
90
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-managment of
natural argan forest and scientific research
promotion
No impact
SOCIO-ECONOMIC IMPACT MITIGATION MEASURES 7.2.
7.2.1. EMPLOYMENT CREATION
Component Risks or negative impacts Mitigation measure
Component 1 : implementation of the
arganiculture on 10 000 ha
- Given the potential and the
demand, risk of not satisfying the
whole population, especially the
vulnerable population
In case of additional demand,
establishing eligibility criteria.
The ANDZOA has a proven
experience in partnership
management through calls for
proposals.
Maintaining a permanent
communication channel with
the local population.
- Minor risks related to safety and
health during the construction
phase.
Taking the necessary
measures to prevent
employment of children;
Take the necessary measures
to ensure that site staff is
insured, is trained on accident
and has acquired good
practices and tools for safe
work;
Establishing a health check for
onsite employees beforehand
The company must designate
a local clinic in case of
accident, with an insurance
covering all staff risks.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
91
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan value
chain
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-
managment of natural argan forest and
scientific research promotion
7.2.2. GENDER ISSUES
Component Risks or negative impacts Mitigation measure
Component 1 : implementation of the
arganiculture on 10 000 ha
- No risks
- Risk of hiring men
rather than women due
to the nature of the
work to be done ;
Risk relating to work opportunity
during the construction phase
Specify the nature of the work,
the skills required while
highlighting equal chances for
job opportunities
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan
value chain
Impact on other activities of
women because of their
occupation for the valorization of
the argan products.
During the implementation
phase, establish an assessment
of women's activities in order to
take them into account in the
planning of the project and its
activities
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-
managment of natural argan forest
and scientific research promotion
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
92
7.2.3. CAPACITY BUILDING
Component Risks or negative impacts Mitigation measure
Component 1 : implementation of the
arganiculture on 10 000 ha
- No impact *
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan
value chain
Minor risk of competition and
market access
Taken into account in the project
activities consisting of
accompanying EIG to access to
the market
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-
managment of natural argan forest
and scientific research promotion
No impact *
7.2.4. SOCIO CULTURAL IMPACTS
Component Risks or negative impacts Mitigation measure
Component 1 : implementation of the
arganiculture on 10 000 ha
- No impact -
- No impact -
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan
value chain
No impact -
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-
managment of natural argan forest
and scientific research promotion
No impact -
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
93
7.2.5. INVOLUNTARY RESETTLEMENT AND ADHERENCE OF POPULATION
Component Risks or negative impacts Mitigation measure
Component 1 : implementation of the
arganiculture on 10 000 ha
Risk of unstable adherence of
beneficiaries.
Risk of unstable adherence of
beneficiaries.
Avoid any site that may cause
population displacement or any
dispute in the accurate
identification process.
Reaffirming the commitment of
the population before the project
starts (to be done by ONCA and
ANDZOA).
No involuntary resettlement of the
population will take place
Risk of unstable adherence of
beneficiaries.
Avoid any site that may cause
population displacement or any
dispute in the accurate
identification process.
Reaffirming the commitment of
the population before the project
starts (to be done by ONCA and
ANDZOA).
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan
value chain
No involuntary resettlement of the
population will take place
Reaffirming the commitment of
the population before the project
starts (to be done by ONCA and
ANDZOA).
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-
managment of natural argan forest
and scientific research promotion
No involuntary resettlement of the
population will take place
Reaffirming the commitment of
the population before the project
starts (to be done by ONCA and
ANDZOA)..
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
94
7.2.6. HEALTH AND SAFETY AND SECURITY
Component Risks or negative impacts Mitigation measure
Component 1 : implementation of the
arganiculture on 10 000 ha
Risk of accident or illness during
the construction phase
Taking the necessary measures
to prevent employment of
children;
Take the necessary measures to
ensure that site staff is insured, is
trained on accident and has
acquired good practices and tools
for safe work;
Establishing a health/safety
check for onsite employees
beforehand;
The contractor must designate a
local clinic in case of accident,
with an insurance covering all
staff risks.
Risk of accident or illness during
the construction phase
Taking the necessary measures
to prevent employment of
children;
Take the necessary measures to
ensure that site staff is insured, is
trained on accident and has
acquired good practices and tools
for safe work;
Establishing a health/safety
check for onsite employees
beforehand;
The company must designate a
local clinic in case of accident,
with an insurance covering all
staff risks.
Component 2 : Structuration on
upstream and downstrean argan
value chain
Risk of accident or illness during
the construction phase
Taking the necessary measures
to prevent employment of
children;
Take the necessary measures to
ensure that site staff is insured, is
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
95
trained on accident and has
acquired good practices and tools
for safe work;
Establishing a health/safety
check for onsite employees
beforehand;
The company must designate a
local clinic in case of accident,
with an insurance covering all
staff risks.
Component 3 : capacity building,
knowledge management, co-
managment of natural argan forest
and scientific research promotion
Risk of accident or illness during
the construction phase
Taking the necessary measures
to prevent employment of
children;
Take the necessary measures to
ensure that site staff is insured, is
trained on accident and has
acquired good practices and tools
for safe work;
Establishing a health/safety
check for onsite employees
beforehand;
The company must designate a
local clinic in case of accident,
with an insurance covering all
staff risks.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
96
MATRIX OF MITIGATION/COMPENSATION/ENHANCEMENT MEASURES 7.3.
The project as designed confirms its positive impact on the environment and the population. Indeed, all planned
activities are generally bonus activities for the Arganeraie Biosphere Reserve, which ANDZOA and its partners will
maximize. Furthermore, it is recommended to update, in case of need, the environmental and social impact
assessment for all physical activities that the project plans.
Almost all of the negative impacts are related to the implementation phase. The table below summarizes the
mitigation measures for each identified impact.
Table 7 : Matrix of risks and suggested mitigation measure
Potential environmental and social impacts and risks
Suggested mitigation measure
Risk of harming the biosphere of the argan tree in case of poor management and performance of the work in areas close to the biosphere reserve. Deterioration of biodiversity due to the work and the presence of equipments and the construction site.
Conduct an awareness campaign among the different actors on the protection of
RBA;
Good organization of work and tailings management
Avoid clearing plantations and ensure saving wildlife that thrives in the
neighborhood of the site.
Rehabilitate the areas affected by the construction site
Add to the requirements specification for contractors, clauses relating to the
protection of RBA
Risk of altering archaeological sites
Upon discovery of archaeological sites, alerting officials of the Ministry of Culture and local authorities while following the national procedure relating to sites reporting. Stop work immediately.
Discuss with the other project partners about the relocation to a new site while following the same approach (Consultation, support of the population, site identification, prior assessment of the environmental and social impact)
Change of the flow of water, this could negatively impact the population living downstream of the work site
Encouraging work in dry weather. If necessary, trying to minimize the duration of the intervention
Deterioration of water quality of the Oueds (Rivers) along the segments affected by the project implementation
Avoid spillage of waste and products in oueds or alluvium;
Train site staff on food safety measures to comply with;
Include environmental and social monitoring in the role of the technical assistant
Ensure a good management of products used for the work
Ensure a good management of tailings and waste produced by the workers
Ensuring a good management of plants waste
Check the condition of vehicles and machinery to prevent leaks and spills of petroleum products and hydrocarbons
Implement a Hazardous Materials Management Plan and an action plan for spills
Ensure proper management of pollutants
Avoid materials releases into the oued or in the natural environment.
Prevent leaks and spills of petroleum products and hydrocarbons.
Risk of soil contamination by site waste
Collect waste water and site waste
Minimize waste accumulation
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
97
Disposing of waste in landfills authorized by the government
Providing a wastewater collection system
Always clean work areas, as well as the floor in case of dirt or deposits
• Build barricades around in polluting products storage tanks and prepare areas for the storage or handling of these products
Plan on one (or more if necessary) cleanup kit (emergency bag containing several absorbent sheets)
Restoring the work area
Risk of gender inequality During the implementation phase, establish an assessment of women's activities in order to take them into account in the planning of the project and its activities ;
Specify nature of the work, the skills required while highlighting equal chances for job opportunities.
Impact on air quality caused by the emission of greenhouse gases, dust and noise
Use of equipment that are in good condition
Limiting the speed of vehicles and equipments
Turning off the engine in case of non-operation
Covering the excess cuttings
Covering trucks carrying cuttings and materials that are likely to generate dust
Restoring the site
Risk of accidents, health and safety Impact on the health and safety of the population
Taking the necessary measures to prevent employment of children;
Take the necessary measures to ensure that site staff is insured, is trained on accident and has acquired good practices and tools for safe work;
Establishing a health check for onsite employees beforehand
The company must designate a local clinic in case of accident, with an insurance covering all staff risks ;
Establishing markup and temporary construction signage before starting the work
Checking the speed of construction vehicles, especially nearby houses.
Provide personal protective equipment for workers and site personnel.
Involuntary resettlement and adhrence of the population
Avoid any site that may cause population displacement or any dispute in the accurate identification process
Reaffirming the commitment of the population before the project starts (to be done by ONCA and ANDZOA).
Risk of discrimination for participation in events and fairs
The participation in trade fairs is to be organized in turn in order to involve every EIG (Economic Interest Group)
Pressure on water resources: need to irrigate plants during the first 3 years at a rate of 2500 m3 / ha / year, ie a total of 25 million m3 / year for the entire area of 10 000 ha
Water resources are already experiencing overexploitation, due to a significant demand for irrigation water. To compensate for this additional demand, the project includes rainwater catchment actions and, possibly, water points to construct upon authorization of ABH.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
98
Table 8. Analysis matrix of the alignment of the project with environmental and social safeguard policies and measures
Environmental and
Social Safeguard
Principles
Content and scope of principles Element of compliance evaluation Potential risks to manage before,
during project implementation
Corrective and preventive actions
PS1: Assessment
and management of
environmental and
social risks and
impacts
a) Identify funding proposal’s
environmental and social risks and
impacts;
The project includes an ESIA identifying
environmental and social risks and impacts
- Difficulty in procurement of
argan plants
- Adherence of the population
- Pollution
- Lack or insufficient irrigation of
argan seedlings
Follow the environmental and social
monitoring plan for the project
b) Adopt mitigation hierarchy: anticipate,
avoid; minimize; compensate or
offset;
Project Risk management gives priority to
anticipation and avoidance first, before seeking to
minimize or compensate for the effects of
unavoidable risks
c) Improve performance through an
environmental and social
management system;
The project adopts an environmental and social
management plan that identifies risks and provides
for actions to be implemented to avoid, minimize or
compensate for their effects.
d) Engagement with affected
communities or other stakeholders
throughout funding proposal cycle.
This includes communications and
grievance mechanisms.
Environmental and social monitoring mechanism
Complaints handling mechanism to implement
Identified risks associated with
environmental and social aspects
(ESIA);
Social risks for the project
components
Follow the environmental and social
monitoring plan, globally or by project
component
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
99
Environmental and
Social Safeguard
Principles
Content and scope of principles Element of compliance evaluation Potential risks to manage before,
during project implementation
Corrective and preventive actions
PS2: Labour and
working conditions
a) Fair treatment, non-discrimination,
equal opportunity;
b) Good worker–management
relationship;
The project will be in confrmity with the Labour
Code /Morocco (code travail Maroc : bulletin officiel
numéro 5210 du jeudi 6 mai 2004. Dahir n° 1-03-
194 du 14 rejeb 1424 (11 septembre 2003) portant
promulgation de la loi n° 65-99 relative au code du
travail. 2004.)
Morocco has ratified ILO core labour standards.
The probable risk of non-equity is
the difference in salary between
men and women workers and
workers in the low access of
women to jobs at companies
employed by the project.
It is necessary to include clauses
related to the compliance with ILO
labour rights and national standards.
c) Comply with national employment
and labour laws; All activities planned in the framework of the project
are in accordance with national and international
laws
Limited institutional capacity for
implementation of the ESMP
(Environmental and Social
Management Plan)
Development of a capacity building plan
(information, training, etc.) to reinforce
the capacities of institutions responsible
for the implementation of the ESMP
d) Protect workers, in particular those in
vulnerable categories; None of the proposed actions will generate
negative issues on these population groups. All
project activities help strengthen the resilience of
the population and improving their socio-economic
conditions
During the implementation of the
actions the vulnerable groups
susceptible to be affected during
construction or exploitation
sages are not identified yet.
ANDZOA shall engage a survey
investigation to identify vulnerable
and/or marginalized groups to be
affected during construction or
exploitation sages
This measure will be included in the
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
100
Environmental and
Social Safeguard
Principles
Content and scope of principles Element of compliance evaluation Potential risks to manage before,
during project implementation
Corrective and preventive actions
ESMP.
e) Promote safety and health; The organizations and contractors responsible for
the implementation of the project are subject to the
law which requires a minimum of social protection
for workers
Exposure to pollution, risk of
workplace accidents
Implement the measures of the ESMP
f) Avoid use of forced labour or child
labour. Organizations and enterprises in charge of
implementing the project are subject to the law that
prohibits child labor
No risk Raising awareness and integrating
binding clauses in the contract
documents
PS3: Resource
efficiency and
pollution
prevention
a) Avoid, minimize or reduce project-
related pollution;
Due to the small scale of the project and its small
footprint, very low amounts of waste are produced.
Also, the energy and other raw materials are low.
Deterioration of water quality of
the Oueds (Rivers) along the
segments affected by the
construction of infrastructure.
Conventional mitigation measures
reported in the ESMP will be
implemented.
b) More sustainable use of resources,
including energy and water; The project includes a component for the
mobilization of rainwater for a better management
of the resource "water".
Energy requirements for the project are low.
No identified risk Sensitivity for better irrigation
techniques
c) Reduced project-related greenhouse
gas emissions
The Project reinforces resilience to climate change,
and will not result in an increase in greenhouse gas
emissions.
A temporary residual negative
impact, with low intensity lies in
low emissions of greenhouse
gases during the construction of
Engage a climate check for the
construction of the structures
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
101
Environmental and
Social Safeguard
Principles
Content and scope of principles Element of compliance evaluation Potential risks to manage before,
during project implementation
Corrective and preventive actions
the structures.
PS4: Community
health, safety and
security
a) To anticipate and avoid adverse
impacts on the health and safety of
the affected community;
Apart from the risk of accidents that are controllable
during the work phase, no project activity is
generating negative impact on health.
Aids risk of HIV spread in the
community of workers during the
construction phase and The risk
of personal injury.
i) Sensitize workers about the disease
ii) it is also necessary to take the
measures recommended in the ESMP
to avoid accidents. These measures
must be integrated ias clauses (health,
security, HIV aids awareness) in
specific technical specifications
contracted with the companies
responsible for the work.
b) To safeguard personnel and property
in accordance with relevant human
rights principles.
No action planned in this project, disagrees with the
principles of human right.
The project will be in line with the these human
rights stipulated by the Moroccan new constitution
that enshrines human rights as universally
recognized and stipulates the protection of these
rights, taking into account their universality and
The implementation of some
activities can induce a deviation
of rights such as deterioration of
the living or non-securing the
work site during the construction
phase.
It is necessary to include environmental
and social clauses (health, security,
social issues, HIV aids awareness) in
specific technical specifications
contracted with the companies
responsible for the work.
This practice was initiated and
implemented in the mega-project
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
102
Environmental and
Social Safeguard
Principles
Content and scope of principles Element of compliance evaluation Potential risks to manage before,
during project implementation
Corrective and preventive actions
indivisibility.
The Moroccan constitution adopted all rights
provided for in the Universal Declaration of Human
Rights enshrined the primacy of international
conventions ratified by Morocco on national
legislation and affirmed Morocco's commitment to
harmonize these legislation with the provisions of
these conventions.
implemented under the compact
millennium challenge account (MCC-
USAID) and the Ministry of agriculture
and fisheries in morocco. This model is
well documented and can serve as an
example. it has also been used for
similar projects in the oasis of Tafilalet
mcc project.
PS5: Land
acquisition and
involuntary
resettlement
c) Avoid/minimize adverse social and
economic impacts from land
acquisition or restrictions on land use:
i) Avoid/minimize
displacement;
ii) Provide alternative
project designs;
iii) Avoid forced eviction.
No population in the zone will be subject to
resettlement due to the project activities.
For physical actions, and after
the final selection of the sites by
localization, the risk of
expropriation - Involuntary
resettlement of the population
may occur.
Possible measures to manage this risk
are: i) search for an alternative site
without involuntary resettlement, ii)
stopping the activity
d) Improve or restore livelihoods and
standards of living; The nature of the project involves an increase in
local living standards through the expansion of the
income sources of the beneficiaries
No identified risk Avoid any alternative involving
expropriation or population
displacement e) Improve living conditions among
displaced persons by providing:
i) Adequate housing;
ii) Security of tenure.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
103
Environmental and
Social Safeguard
Principles
Content and scope of principles Element of compliance evaluation Potential risks to manage before,
during project implementation
Corrective and preventive actions
PS6: Biodiversity
conservation and
sustainable
management of
living natural
resources
a) Protection and conservation of
biodiversity; Some planned actions aim a better water resources
management that will improve the conservation of
biological diversity in oasis zones.
For physical actions, and after
the final selection of the sites, the
risk of deterioration of
biodiversity (specially relicts
or/and endemic species)
It is necessary to initiate a study to
inventory and characterization of plant
and animal biodiversity (fauna and
flora) in the area of influence of the
activity. In cases where the impact
proves to be significant, the activity site
should be moved to another location or
to cancelling the activity
b) Maintenance of benefits from
ecosystem services;
c) Promotion of sustainable
management of living natural
resources;
d) Integration of conservation needs and
development priorities.
The flood protection and water collection structures
will enable the maintenance of benefits drawn from
ecosystem.
Non-applying of good practice of
irrigation and drainage can cause
soil degradation by salinization.
Another risk of non-conservation
of water in the soil resulted from
inadequate conservation
practices.
Adoption (and training on) of practices
of soil and water conservation:
- Leaching requirement to avoid salts accumulation in root zone
- Superficial minimum tillage,
- Mulching,
- Soil organic amendment
- etc.
PS7: Indigenous
peoples
a) Ensure full respect for indigenous
peoples
i) Human rights, dignity,
aspirations;
ii) Livelihoods;
Principle not applicable to the project - -
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
104
Environmental and
Social Safeguard
Principles
Content and scope of principles Element of compliance evaluation Potential risks to manage before,
during project implementation
Corrective and preventive actions
iii) Culture, knowledge,
practices;
b) Avoid/minimize adverse impacts;
c) Sustainable and culturally appropriate
development benefits and
opportunities;
d) Free, prior and informed consent in
certain circumstances.
PS8: Cultural
heritage
a) Protection and preservation of
cultural heritage;
b) Promotion of equitable sharing of
cultural heritage benefits.
Project activities do not generate negative impacts
on the natural and cultural heritage (NCP). Indeed,
in addition to the choice of the site which should
prevent any site or heritage building, the NCP is
protected by legal texts (Loi- 22-80 relative à la
conservation des monuments historiques et des
sites, des inscriptions, des objets d’art et
d’antiquités, etc. )
NO RISKS _
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS”
ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
ESIA "Establishing argan orchards in degraded environments" 105
8. ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL MANAGEMENT PLAN
This Environmental and Social Management Plan (ESMP) provides a logical framework within which the negative environmental and social impacts identified during the ESIA study can be mitigated and any beneficial environment effects can be enhanced.
Monitoring and management practices as well as monetary compensation are considered and cost estimates included as applicable. Responsibilities and time frames for the implementation of the various aspects of the ESMP will be identified.
The ESMP will be provided to prospective bidders for the construction contracts to ensure that environmental mitigation costs are factored into their costings. The Contractor(s) will also be required to prepare a separate and specific ESMP for their works in order to control construction impacts and ensure compliance with applicable environmental and health and safety legislation and standards.
ANDZOA and Partners will ultimately be responsible for ensuring that the ESMP is implemented on site via reviewing the Contractor’s ESMP and ensuring its implementation on site via audits.
8.1.1. MATRIX OF MITIGATION/COMPENSATION/ENHANCEMENT MEASURES
Almost all of the negative impacts are related to the implementation phase. The table below summarizes the
mitigation measures for each identified impact.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS”
ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
ESIA "Establishing argan orchards in degraded environments" 106
Table 9 : Environmental and Social Management Plan
Potential environmental and social impacts and risks
Suggested mitigation measure Phase Concerned environments
Monitoring Indicators
Frequency of the measures (*)
Responsibility Cost (equipment and staff)
Risk of harming the biosphere of the argan tree in case of poor management and performance of the work in areas close to the biosphere reserve. Deterioration of biodiversity due to the work and the presence of equipments and the construction site.
Conduct an awareness campaign among
the different actors on the protection of
RBA;
Good organization of work and tailings
management
Avoid clearing plantations and ensure
saving wildlife that thrives in the
neighborhood of the site.
Rehabilitate the areas affected by the
construction site
Add to the requirements specification for
contractors, clauses relating to the
protection of RBA
implementation Biological
environment
Methods and areas of storage of the construction site materials and hydrocarbons.
Site conditions
The whole construction period
ANDZOA / HCEFLCD / Contractors
Costs included in the implementation budget
Risk of altering archaeological sites
Upon discovery of archaeological sites, alerting officials of the Ministry of Culture and local authorities while following the national procedure relating to sites reporting. Stop work immediately.
Discuss with the other project partners about the relocation to a new site while following the same approach (Consultation, support of the population, site identification, prior assessment of the environmental and social impact)
implementation Physical environment
Number of sites discoverd and preserved
The whole construction period
ANDZOA / Ministère de la culture / Contractor
Costs included in the implementation budget
Change of the flow of water, this could negatively impact the population living
Encouraging work in dry weather. If necessary, trying to minimize the duration of the intervention
implementation Physical environment
Weather during construction works
The whole construction period
ANDZOA / ABH / Contractor
Costs included in the implementation budget
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS”
ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
ESIA "Establishing argan orchards in degraded environments" 107
Potential environmental and social impacts and risks
Suggested mitigation measure Phase Concerned environments
Monitoring Indicators
Frequency of the measures (*)
Responsibility Cost (equipment and staff)
downstream of the work site
Deterioration of water quality of the Oueds (Rivers) along the segments affected by the project implementation
Avoid spillage of waste and products in oueds or alluvium;
Train site staff on food safety measures to comply with;
Include environmental and social monitoring in the role of the technical assistant
Ensure a good management of products used for the work
Ensure a good management of tailings and waste produced by the workers
Ensuring a good management of plants waste
Check the condition of vehicles and machinery to prevent leaks and spills of petroleum products and hydrocarbons
Implement a Hazardous Materials Management Plan and an action plan for spills
Ensure proper management of pollutants
Avoid materials releases into the oued or in the natural environment.
Prevent leaks and spills of petroleum products and hydrocarbons.
implementation Physical environment
Site conditions.
• Observance of instructions about wastewater rejections on site.
Observance of good waste and yard waste management practices
Methods and areas of storage of the construction site materials and hydrocarbons
Availability of protective equipment at storage sites.
The whole construction period
ANDZOA / ABH / Contractor
Costs included in the implementation budget
Risk of soil contamination by site waste
Collect waste water and site waste
Minimize waste accumulation
Disposing of waste in landfills authorized by the government
Providing a wastewater collection system
Always clean work areas, as well as the floor in case of dirt or deposits
• Build barricades around in polluting products storage tanks and prepare areas for the storage or handling of these products
Plan on one (or more if necessary) cleanup kit (emergency bag containing several
implementation
Physical
environment
Presence of waste scattered around the site.
Presence of dustbins on the site.
Existence of a sealed enclosure for the storage of fuel.
Availability of a
The whole construction period
ANDZOA / Contractor Costs included in the implementation budget
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS”
ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
ESIA "Establishing argan orchards in degraded environments" 108
Potential environmental and social impacts and risks
Suggested mitigation measure Phase Concerned environments
Monitoring Indicators
Frequency of the measures (*)
Responsibility Cost (equipment and staff)
absorbent sheets)
Restoring the work area
unique place for handling contaminants.
Availability of an emergency intervention plan and the means of its implementation.
Risk of gender inequality During the implementation phase, establish an assessment of women's activities in order to take them into account in the planning of the project and its activities ;
Specify nature of the work, the skills required while highlighting equal chances for job opportunities.
implementation
Human environment
• Clarification regarding equal opportunities in job advertisements
Number of employed women
The whole construction period
ANDZOA / Contractor Costs included in the implementation budget
Impact on air quality caused by the emission of greenhouse gases, dust and noise
Use of equipment that are in good condition
Limiting the speed of vehicles and equipments
Turning off the engine in case of non-operation
Covering the excess cuttings
Covering trucks carrying cuttings and materials that are likely to generate dust
Restoring the site
implementation
Human and biological environment
Site conditions.
Compliance of vehicles with emissions standards (noise, exhaust gases).
Respect of working and resting hours of the population.
The whole construction period
ANDZOA / ABH / Contractor
Costs included in the implementation budget
Risk of accidents, health and safety Impact on the health and safety of the population
Taking the necessary measures to prevent employment of children;
Take the necessary measures to ensure that site staff is insured, is trained on accident and has acquired good practices and tools for safe work;
Establishing a health check for onsite employees beforehand
The company must designate a local clinic in case of accident, with an insurance covering all staff risks ;
Establishing markup and temporary
implementation
Human
environment
Presence of
markup (fence)
and construction
signage.
Compliance with
employment
regulations
Use of personal
protective
equipment
The whole
construction
period
ANDZOA / Contractor Costs included in
the
implementation
budget
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS”
ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
ESIA "Establishing argan orchards in degraded environments" 109
Potential environmental and social impacts and risks
Suggested mitigation measure Phase Concerned environments
Monitoring Indicators
Frequency of the measures (*)
Responsibility Cost (equipment and staff)
construction signage before starting the work
Checking the speed of construction vehicles, especially nearby houses.
Provide personal protective equipment for workers and site personnel.
Involuntary resettlement and adhrence of the population
Avoid any site that may cause population displacement or any dispute in the accurate identification process
Reaffirming the commitment of the population before the project starts (to be done by ONCA and ANDZOA).
Study Human
environment
Adherence of the
population
before the
work starts
ANDZOA / l’ONCA Costs included in
the
implementation
budget
Risk of discrimination for participation in events and fairs
Establish a requirements specification that qualifies EIGs (Economic Interest Groups) who could represent the EIGs concerned by the project, in consultation with RARBA and project stakeholders.
The participation in trade fairs is to be organized in turn in order to involve every EIG
operations Human
environment
Number of EIGs
participating in
trade fairs and
exhibitions
At the time of
fairs and
exhibitions
ANDZOA Costs included in
the operating
budget
Pressure on water resources: need to irrigate plants during the first 3 years at a rate of 2500 m3 / ha / year, ie a total of 25 million m3 / year for the entire area of 10 000 ha
Water resources are already experiencing
overexploitation, due to a significant
demand for irrigation water. To compensate
for this additional demand, the project
includes rainwater catchment actions and,
possibly, water points to construct upon
authorization of ABH.
operations Physical environment
Rainwater catchment projects
First 3 years following plantation
ANDZOA Costs included in the operating budget
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
110
8.1.2. ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL MANAGEMENT PLAN-ESMP
The ANDZOA take the responsibility to ensure compliance with environmental and social policy of the Green
Climate Fund. For this purpose, the responsible entity will manage the entire project and each sub-activity of the
project. It will provide the equipment, the necessary training from the beginning of the project and ensure that all
processes envisaged in the project (monitoring, evaluation, reporting, and governance) can detect environmental
and social risks so that they may be taken care of and managed accordingly.
The ANDZOA will designate a person with the competencies for the environmental and social monitoring and
surveillance of the project, as recommended in the studies and taking into account the requirements of the GCF.
Indeed, it must ensure the proper conduct of the project to minimize or to eliminate all the risks and negative impacts
of the project either on the biophysical or on the human environment.
The PMU of ANDZOA will be responsible for application of mitigation measures in the ESMP and ensuring
compliance with environmental and social policy of GCF. In addition, it must keep a close eye on the potential risks
that may arise during the implementation of the project.
The Environmental and social Risk Managment Plan will ensure that :
- adequate capacity building for risk management is provided at project start-up;
- activity forecasts are screened for potential risks and that associated disbursement is not approved where
these arise;
- project reporting processes have a particular focus on detection of environmental and social risks; the
project oversight and governance processes are designed to ensure that risks are avoided where possible
and appropriately mitigated in the unlikely event of these occurring; and
- Stakeholders are aware of a mechanism to raise concerns relating to risks with the project PMU and the
ANDZOA and ADA Steering Committee should concerns relating to risks not be adequately addressed by
the PMU.
For this, the ANDZOA will be responsible for monitoring the risks that have been identified or those that would be
identified for the project's sub-activities and will conduct the following activities:
1. Update the ESIA for each sub-activity of the DARED project:
That is, conduct an environmental and social study on the risks identified in the overall ESMP. Therefore, the
responsible entity will update the ESMP of each sub-activity, taking into account all the mitigations measures in
accordance with the principles of the GCF.
- Although the current ESIA has not identified any major risks in accordance with the ESP of the Fund, during
the identification the project implementation sites and in the event that the site presents a risk that can be in
contradiction with the ESP of the GCF, the responsible entity will change the site or will cancel the planned
activity.
- Also, all activities and sub-projects do not provide for involuntary displacements. The responsible entity make
sure, once the site is identified, to ensure compliance with the ESP of the GCF and, in the case where an
activity will require the involuntary displacement, to choose another site that does not require the triggering of
involuntary displacement. The Entity agrees to cancel sub-activities that could trigger an involuntary
displacement in the event that all the identified sites will present this condition.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
111
For each sub-project, an environmental and social impact assessment will be updated to identify environmental and
social risks. The Environmental and Social Management Plan will be updated accordingly. The entity (ADA and
ANDZOA) will ensure compliance with and respect of the environmental and social policies of the Green Climate
Fund and in the event that an activity or subproject will not respect one of the principles, it will be canceled or
replaced in coordination with the Green Climate Fund. Replacement costs that would be identified for sub-activities
and which are not provided for in the financial plan of the DARED will be supported by the ADA and the ANDZOA.
2. A project launch workshop
Once the ESIA is updated, a launch workshop will be organized in the presence of all stakeholders and actors and
the local population. This workshop will be an opportunity to present:
- the stages of implementation of the subproject;
- the mitigation measures for social and environmental risks;
- the frequency at which workshops will be held for information, for awareness and for complaints handling;
- the steps to follow for any complaint or request from population;
- the tools set up to ensure permanent contact and also the measures taken to mitigate the environmental and
social risks.
- an overview of the the environmental and social monitoring and surveillance plan;
- the work plan, the monitoring committee.
This workshop will be an opportunity to strengthen the support from the population, present the results and reaffirm
the appropriation of project activities by beneficiaries.
Following the workshop, a detailed report will be prepared and shared with all participants, actors and stakeholders
in the project.
3. Starting the Project and Sub-Activities
During the startup phase, the responsible entity directly commit, with partners (ORMVA, ABH, ...), to the procedures
to be used for the management of the Project. The PMU of the project will establish agreements with partners and
enterprises that will be mandated for the implementation of sub-activities. These agreements will stipulate the
obligation of the partners to respect the environmental and social policies of the GCF and, the Entity ADA- ANDZOA,
through the PMU will monitor the compliance with the ESP of the GCF.
- A procedural manual will be developed to support this process by focusing on the respect of ESP of the GCF.
- A training session will be organized by ANDZOA for the strengthening of stakeholders and partners capacity to
ensure compliance at the start-up of the project and sub-activities and the compliance with the ESP of the
GCF. This capacity will allow actors to be able to identify the environmental and social risks, the mitigation
measures, the monitoring of measures, the evaluation and the reporting.
In this regard, particular attention will be paid to ensure that the activities have no negative impact on all priority
biodiversity areas or ecosystem support areas, and that there are no negative impacts on local communities,
including vulnerable groups and indigenous peoples, involuntary displacement. Potential negative impacts will also
be anticipated.
4. Strengthening the capacity of local partners
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
112
During the implementation process of each activity of the project, the partners in such activities will be accompanied
for their capacity building. They will be able, after strengthening their capacity to detect and mitigate environmental and
social risks in accordance with the environmental and social policies of the GCF. This component will be considered by
the Project Management Unit through the environmental and social monitoring cell. This capacity building will also
allow local communities to know their rights and possible remedies they may have to raise issues related to potential
risks.
5. Quarterly forecasting and risk management
The monitoring of activities will be ensured by the PMU continuously throughout the duration of the project. Quarterly
monitoring reports will be prepared by the PMU and disseminated for the ADA and ANDZOA and shared with the
Green Climate Fund. These reports will describe the progress of the activities, the achievements, the measures taken,
the environmental and social monitoring.
The updating of the plan for monitoring environmental and social risks will be made on a quarterly basis by the PMU
and its partners. Each quarter, the PMU will ensure the implementation of the mitigations measures envisaged in the
risk management plan in compliance with the ESP principles of the GCF, but also will identify new environmental and
social risks and mitigations measures.
After the update, the risk management plan will be updated and the measures will be reviewed and consolidated
compared to those identified prior to the completion of the activity. Therefore, the risk management plan in compliance
with the environmental and social policies of the GCF will be updated throughout the entire period of implementation of
the activity and the measures will be presented and validated so that they are implemented. In the event that potential
risks appear and are not envisaged in the budget of risk management, ANDZOA will support them.
In order for funds to be disbursed, the PMU will need to submit detailed quarterly forecasts to the ANDZOA that are
built up from anticipated project activities. All Component and sub-Component Leaders will be expected to do the
same for the PMU.
In an effort to strengthen risk screening, and to ensure that no unintended negative impacts are caused or not
mitigated, all Component and sub-Component Leaders will be required to submit a basic environmental and social
risk table with their forecasts. These tables will need to be submitted to the PMU as part of the forecast approval
process.
In the lead up to project inception, the ANDZOA will modify the GCF’s ESP table for this purpose. All risks will be
included, but the table will be elaborated upon to create a set of clear and easy to understand activities that will need
to be cross checked.
This risk screening process will ensure compliance with the principles of the GCF ESP and National legislation.
Project activities that pose social or environmental risks that are not easily mitigated will not be approved during the
detailed quarterly forecasting process.
6. Quarterly forecast review and risk assessment
All quarterly forecasts, including risk assessments, will be reviewed by the PMU with support of the Gender and
Social Expert. These reviews will be tabled with recommendations to the PCC and NIE for approval.
Develop quarterly forecasts including
budgets (Who is responsible for the components and sub-activities ?)
Update the situation of the
environmental and social risks
originally identities and the mitigation measures for each sub-activity of the
project.
Submit the Environmental and Social Monitoring Plan to the PMU
which will submit it to the ADA-
ANDZOA and the Fund
Review the forecasts and the
risk assessment for sub-activities
Submit the management plan for environmental and social risks to
the Fund for approval, activity modification or
cancellation.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
113
7. Risk Management
Prior to the project start-up :
Environmental and social risks in connection with the ESP of the GCF are identified, reported the person
responsible for the environmental and social monitoring of the PMU. The mitigation measures of these risks are
established.
- Where minor risks that can easily be mitigated are detected, the PMU of DARED should be required to
develop a sub-Environmental and Social Risk Management Plan, commensurate with the severity of the risk
associated with the relevant sub-component activity. The PMU Entity will need to show that costs associated
with this can be provided within the project budget, and this will need to be approved by the ANDZOA and
ADA.
- In the contrary case, when the risks are significant, the ANDZOA will change the site of the sub-activity or
cancel it if the risk does not comply with ESP of the GCF.
During the implementation of the project:
The quarterly update allows for checking and updating risk and also identifying previously unidentified risks. These
risks are completed and submitted to the PMU in order to be reported to ANDZOA and ADA and then to GCF.
- If the risks are minimal: their mitigation measures are established, completed and monitored;
- If a potential risk is not in accordance with the ESP of the GCF, the ANDZOA and ADA will change the site
of the sub-activity or modify the sub-activity. In the case where the risk is significant, the sub-activity will be
stopped or replaced.
The mitigation measures are implemented, the monitoring is indicated by the PMU in the quarterly, semi-annual and
annual reports. The monitoring indicators are indicated in order to appreciate and check the implementation of
mitigation measures.
Roles and Responsibilities:
PMU, sub-Executing Entities and partners – risk screening, development of wetland rehabilitation plans. risk
screening oversight.
ANDZOA – capacity building, risk screening scrutiny and verification.
8. Reporting
Particular attention will be given to the monitoring of unanticipated environmental and social risks in the quarterly
reporting process. The PMU will be expected to scrutinize sub-Executing Entity reports for such risks, and to
provide the ADA and ANDZOA with their appraisals for verification. The ANDZOA will work closely alongside
the PMU to ensure that his staff have the capacity to undertake the required screening, and to provide the
necessary scrutiny.
Roles and Responsibilities:
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
114
PMU, sub-Executing Entities and partners – risk screening. Partners –
risk screening oversight.
ANDZOA– capacity building, risk screening scrutiny and verification.
9. Annual Reporting
Particular attention will be given to the monitoring of unanticipated environmental and social risks in the quarterly
reporting process. The PMU will be expected to scrutinize sub-Executing Entity reports for such risks, and to provide
the ANDZOA and ADA with their appraisals for verification.
The ANDZOA will work closely alongside the GCF to ensure that PMU staff have the capacity to undertake the
required screening, and to provide the necessary scrutiny.
Annual Project Implementation Reports will be prepared by the PMU and submitted to the ANDZOA in order to
monitor progress made since project start and in particular for the previous reporting period.
The Annual Project Implementation Reports shall include, but not be limited to, reporting on:
- progress made toward project objective and project outcomes – each with indicators, baseline data and end-of-project targets (cumulative);
- project outputs delivered per project outcome (annual); lessons
learned/good practice;
- expenditure reports; and
- risks and adaptive management, with a particular focus on environmental and social risks as identified in
the GCF ESP.
A report template for the Annual Project Implementation Report shall be prepared by the ANDZOA and the
ADA in consultation with the GCF Secretariat.
10. Periodic Monitoring through site visits
The ANDZOA will conduct visits to project sites based on a agreed schedule to assess first hand project progress.
11. Mid-term of project cycle
The project will undergo an independent Mid-Term Evaluation at the mid-point of project implementation. The Mid-
Term Evaluation will determine progress being made toward the achievement of outcomes and will identify course
correction if needed. It will focus on the effectiveness, efficiency and timeliness of project implementation; will
highlight issues requiring decisions and actions; and will present initial lessons learned about project design,
implementation and management. The mid-term evaluation will include a focus on environmental and social risks,
and ensure compliance with the GCF ESP.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
115
Findings of this review will be incorporated as recommendations for enhanced implementation during the final half
of the project’s term. The organization, Terms of Reference and timing of the Mid-Term Evaluation will be decided
after consultation between the parties to the project document. The Terms of Reference for this Mid-Term
Evaluation will be prepared by the ANDZOA and ADA based on guidance from the GCF.
Roles and Responsibilities:
Consultants – risk evaluation.
PMU, sub-Executing Entities and partners – risk management responses (in the unlikely event that these
should arise).
PMU – risk management oversight. ANDZOA– risk management verification.
12. End of Project
An independent Terminal Evaluation will take place three months prior to project closure and will be undertaken in
accordance with ANDZOA and ADA guidance. The Terminal Evaluation will focus on the delivery of the project's
results as initially planned (and as corrected after the mid-term evaluation, if any such correction took place). The
Terminal Evaluation will look at impact and sustainability of results, including the contribution to capacity
development and the achievement of global environmental benefits/goals. The Terminal Evaluation will include a
focus on environmental and social risks, and ensure compliance with the GCF ESP. It will provide
recommendations for follow-up activities and will require a management response from the GCF.
The Terminal Evaluation should also provide recommendations for follow-up activities and requires a management
response. During the last three months, the project team will prepare the Project Terminal Report. This
comprehensive report will summarize the results achieved (objectives, outcomes, outputs), risk management,
lessons learned, problems met and areas where results may not have been achieved. It will also lay out
recommendations for any further steps that may need to be taken to ensure sustainability and replicability of the
project's results.
13. Governance and Oversight
The PMU will report any unintended social and environmental risks that are detected through the project monitoring,
evaluation and reporting processes to the ANDZOA, together with a proposed risk management plan that shows
how these risks will be mitigated. In response to this, the ANDZOA and ADA with the GCF may propose the
redirection of project funds to risk management activities, or the withholding of the next tranche of payment until
satisfactory risk management actions are determined and agreed.
14. Grievance Procedures
During project inception workshops and the component launch workshops, stakeholders will be informed that any
concerns relating to the design or management of the project, including social and environmental risks, should be
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
116
raised with the subcontractors, partners. Where these are not adequately addressed, these may be escalated to
the project PMU and if necessary the ANDZOA and ADA.
15. The grievance mechanism
The ANDZOA will establish a grievance management system characterized by a grievance reception desk:
- Accessible to all (beneficiaries, neighboring population, others ...);
- Anyone can file a claim or a complaint;
- The treatment will be done in full transparency and the complainant will be informed.
To do this, a reception desk for complaints and grievances will be opened in the PMU that will be responsible for
monitoring the project. Also, the desk's branches will be opened in areas accessible to the public.
The desk will be distinct and recognizable in order to facilitate its identification by the public or anyone who wants to
file a claim.
The functioning of desk:
- A register for grievance recording. Each request is received, recorded in the register with a number. An
acknowledgment of receipt is given to the person filing the complaint;
- The claim is then sent to the PMU, which will meet periodically to decide on claims. The answer is given to
the complainant within a time limit not exceeding 15 days;
- In addition, the Web sites of the ADA and ANDZOA will be accessible to people who wish to file a
complaint. This request is sent to the PMU for processing.
The project managers will conduct briefing and public awareness sessions. During these sessions, responses to
complaints will be communicated. The data contained in this system will be compiled in order to produce a periodic
(semi-annual) management report and annual report dealing with the status of all received complaints. This report
includes:
• the number of received complaints;
• information about the beneficiary complainant (gender, age);
• the origin of grievances (province, area, perimeters, OPA);
• the type of complaint (written, oral);
• the number of complaints resolved;
• the nature of the complaint (company’s activities, training, technical assistance, environmental and social
impact, OPA, etc.);
• the average time to resolve the complaint;
• an appreciation and analysis of grievances and their management system.
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
117
16. Management Plan
Phase Activity Responsible Associated documentation
Before Strart UP Update the ESIA of each sub-
activity in line with the ESP of GCF
ANDZOA /
PARTNERS/
Bénéficiaires
ESMP sub-activities
updated
Start UP Update the ESMP of each activity
in line with the ESP of GCF
ANDZOA
PARTNERS
ESMP updated
Compilation of contracts. A
referring clause is included in
order that all activities executed in
the context of the program/project
financed by the Green Climate
Fund must be aligned with the
principles established in the
"Environmental and Social Policy
of the GCF“, which must be
included as an addendum to each
contract
ANDZOA Contract with each
executing entity
Workshop for partners and
beneficiaries for capability bulding
and manage the environnemental
and social risk in line with the ESP
of GCF
PMU of ANDDZOA Workshop report
Include follow-up for environmental
and social risks in the elaboration
of the Monitoring and Evaluation
Plan with the purpose of
evaluating the program level of
accomplishment with the principles
of the "Environmental and Social
Policy" of GCF
PMU of ANDDZOA Tracking Progress
Methodology
Recruitment of a person in charge
of the environmental and social
monitoring in the team of the
Project Management Unit
ANDZOA Designation of the person
responsible for the
environmental and social
monitoring of the DARED
Implementation Implement the mitigation
measures for environmental and
social risks identified
PMU / work firms,
Local Partners
Report on the monitoring of
mitigation measures
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
118
Update, on a quarterly basis,
environmental and social risks in
connection with the ESP of the
GCF
PMU / ANDZOA /
ADA
Environmental and Social
Management Plan for each
sub-activity is updated
Each executing entity must identify
the environmental and social risks
related to the execution of their
project and define those that
require a management or
mitigation mechanism . This will be
the starting base line for the
monitoring of the programme
Executing Entities
Environmental and Social
baseline data
Include in the annual plan those
mechanisms of management or
mitigation referring to
environmental/social risks or
impacts.
Executing
Entities
Annual Plan
In the semiannual reports the
executing entities must present
to the PCU a section
concerning the following items:
1) Identification of new
environmental or social impacts
or risks during the execution of
the project. 2) Legal backup or
necessary permits during the
execution of the project. 3)
Progress in the risk
management or mitigation
mechanisms as appropriate.
Executing Entities Technical and Financial
Report
On the project level each
executing entity must establish
mechanisms of internal
monitoring of environmental
and social risks or impacts as
well as required management
and mitigation mechanisms
Executing
Entities
Technical and Financial
Report
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
119
Monitoring The ANDZOA will review and
give technical support referring
to those identified impacts and
risks and the management and
mitigation mechanisms
proposed by the executing
entities..
ANDZOA
ANDZOA Convention
Review and monitoring
mechanisms for the identified
impacts and risks and
management and mechanisms
mitigation will be included
during the field visits, executed
and coordinated by the PMC,
assuring that no new impacts or
risks exist and the correct
compliance of the ES Policy of
the GCF.
PMU
Filed visit reports
8.1.1. ESMP IMPLEMENTATION BUDGET
The ESMP implementation budget is given in the following table.
Action Budget in USD
Updating the ESIA before the project starts 200,000.00
Implementation of the ESMP 400,000.00
TOTAL 600, 000.00
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
120
9. CONCLUSION
The DARED project is under the framework of NAMA and the declination of the Green Morocco Plan through the
development of arganiculture sector in the region of Souss-Massa, Essaouira and Guelmim. This project will contribute to
the reduction of pressure on the argan and to the improvement of income sources for beneficiaries.The project will
particularly contribute to carbon sequestration and comes as a response to climate change issues in the region by
contributing to the mitigation of the impacts of floods that characterize the region.
The assessment of the environmental and social impact and the establishment of the ESMP have been conducted through
a screening of positive impacts and risks of negative impacts, as well as mitigation measures, in accordance with the
safeguard policies of the Green Climate Fund (GCF). Note that no major impact has been identified and that the
components 3 and 4 of the project are rather benefit enhancement and capacity building components that contribute to the
environmental protection and to achieving the objectives of GCF.
The risks and environmental and social negative impacts (minor risks) that have been identified are limited and will occur
temporarily, during the project implementation phase.
The implementation of the Environmental and Social Management Plan will require a budget of USD 600,000
(USD 200,000 for updating ESMP before starting work and USD 400 000 for the environmental and social assistance).
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
121
10. ANNEXES
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
122
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
123
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
124
FEASABILITY STUDY OF THE PROJECT “ESTABLISHING ARGAN ORCHARDS IN DEGRADED ENVIRONMENTS” ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
125