Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

29
Profit Maximization from the Profit Maximization from the Islamic Perspective Islamic Perspective Presented by: Musliza Binti Musa G1236556 Siti Maisarah Binti Sewandi G1237154

description

Profit Maximization from the Islamic Perspective review from various authors and articles from Islamic Economy System.

Transcript of Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

Page 1: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

Profit Maximization from the Profit Maximization from the Islamic PerspectiveIslamic Perspective

Presented by:

Musliza Binti Musa G1236556

Siti Maisarah Binti Sewandi G1237154

Page 2: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

OutlineOutline

Introduction

A Review on the Islamic Perspective

Common Views of Contemporary Scholars

Authors’ Views and Reasoning on the

Islamic Perspective

Conclusion

Page 3: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

• The philosophical objective of an Islamic economic system is to fulfill the internal positions of satisfaction and motivations

• The operational objectives:– to spend wealth and materials to

accomplish aim (economic - based objective) – to achieve cooperation and harmony and to

maximize social interests (social - based objectives)

(Zaman, A., 2008)

IntroductionIntroduction

Page 4: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

• In an Islamic framework, it is accepted that a firm’s behavior must be guided by Islamic values and ethics

• The motivation of a firm in the Islamic framework is profit and public good. In mainstream economics, the firm’s motivation is solely to maximize profits. (Ali S.A)

IntroductionIntroduction

Page 5: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

• In Islam, the market is an institution that equilibrates the behaviors of consumers and firms to ensure greater welfare in this world, as well as the greatest reward in the hereafter through dealings involving profit maximization. (Samad, A., 2008)

IntroductionIntroduction

Page 6: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

A Review on theA Review on the Islamic Islamic PerspectivePerspectiveCentral Issues or Objectives• The real issues in relation to profit-maximization

from the Islamic social justice viewpoint :– fairness of the firms’ actions towards the

buyers in the product market– the equitability of the consumers towards the

sellers, especially labor, in the factor market; and

– the usage of profit from the activity

Page 7: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

A Review on theA Review on the Islamic Islamic PerspectivePerspective

• These objectives could be further explained through (Chaudry, M. S., 2003) :– Achievement of al-Falah– Fair and Equitable Distribution– Provision of Basic Human Needs– Establishment of Social Justice– Promotion of Brotherhood and Unity– Achievement of Moral and Material Development– Circulation of Wealth– Elimination of Exploitation

Page 8: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

A Review on theA Review on the Islamic Islamic PerspectivePerspective

1) Achievement of al-FalahSpiritual, moral and socio-economic success in

this world and in the world hereafter.In Islamic economics, profit is allowed but

maximization of profit is denounced by many Islamic economists.

It includes reward and sin which means Allah’s blessing and also His wrath (Al-Qasas: 77)

Page 9: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

A Review on theA Review on the Islamic Islamic PerspectivePerspective

2) Fair and Equitable Distribution(al-Hashr: 7)Wealth should not be allowed to be

concentrated in only a few hands but instead should be freely circulated among everyone

The Islamic firm would view profit from a more socially beneficial perspective.

Page 10: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

A Review on theA Review on the Islamic Islamic PerspectivePerspective

3) Provision of Human Basic NeedsIt is important that the society is provided with all

basic necessities to live like food, clothing and shelter.

A hadith narrated by Tirmizi: “The son of Adam has no better right than that he would have a house wherein he may live, and a piece of cloth whereby he may hide his nakedness, and a piece of bread and some water.”

Page 11: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

A Review on theA Review on the Islamic Islamic PerspectivePerspective

4) Establishment of Social Justice “He (Allah) placed therein firm hills rising above

it, and blessed it and measured therein its sustenance in four days, alike for (all) who ask” (Fussilat: 10)

“Never will you attain the good [reward] until you spend [in the way of Allah] from that which you love. And whatever you spend – indeed, Allah is knowing of it” (ali-Imran: 92)

Page 12: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

A Review on theA Review on the Islamic Islamic PerspectivePerspective

4) Establishment of Social Justice To make economic resources distribution fair

and just, an elaborate system of Zakah and Sadaqah has been established in the Islamic economic system.

Many restrictions have been put in place to bar an individual earning wealth through unfair, illegal and unjust measures.

Page 13: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

A Review on theA Review on the Islamic Islamic PerspectivePerspective

5) Promotion of Brotherhood and Unity"They ask you, [O Muhammad], what they

should spend. Say, "Whatever you spend of good is [to be] for parents and relatives and orphans and the needy and the traveler. And whatever you do of good - indeed, Allah is knowing of it." (al-Baqarah: 215)

Page 14: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

A Review on theA Review on the Islamic Islamic PerspectivePerspective

5) Promotion of Brotherhood and UnityIslam sets out the foundations of sympathy,

brotherhood (ikhwan), friendship and love among all the members of Ummah.

For a firm: it will automatically gear up its motive towards the interest of the Ummah rather than just focusing in achieving maximum profit.

Social accord will be attained and full cooperation will exist between all parties.

Page 15: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

A Review on theA Review on the Islamic Islamic PerspectivePerspective

6) Achievement of Moral and Material Development

It can be achieved particularly through Zakah.Through the paying out of Zakah particularly in

regards to firms who obtains profit, consumption and investment would be boosted. Through the multiplier effect, there will be a greater growth of national income.

Unemployment will be minimized and resources would be fully and efficiently utilized

Page 16: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

A Review on theA Review on the Islamic Islamic PerspectivePerspective

6) Achievement of Moral and Material Development

“And whatever you give for interest to increase within the wealth of people will not increase with Allah . But what you give in zakah, desiring the countenance of Allah - those are the multipliers” (ar-Rum: 39)

The human soul and wealth are purified via Zakah and Sadaqah

Page 17: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

A Review on theA Review on the Islamic Islamic PerspectivePerspective

7) Circulation of Wealth "This is what you hoarded for yourselves, so

taste what you used to hoard" (at-Taubah: 34–35)

As with points 2 and 4, keeping wealth for one’s oneself is discouraged.

Allah threatens that there will be calamitous penalty for the persons responsible for this dreadful offense.

Page 18: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

A Review on theA Review on the Islamic Islamic PerspectivePerspective

8) Elimination of ExploitationFirstly is the abolition of interest or usury as it

is the worst form of human exploitation.For those who have only profit-maximization as

motivation, they would totally disregard this. Allah wages war against those who are involved

in this crime.

Page 19: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

A Review on theA Review on the Islamic Islamic PerspectivePerspective

8) Elimination of Exploitation2nd measure: Stop the exploitation of human in

relation to slavery.To maximize its profit, a firm might pay its

workers less than they are worth or pay the wages late or may not pay at all.

A hadith “Pay the labourer his wages before his sweat dries up” (Ibn Majah)

Page 20: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

Common Views of Contemporary Common Views of Contemporary ScholarsScholarsMajority of the Contemporary Scholars or the

Islamic Economists seem to agree that profit is allowed in the Islamic economic system

However, profit-maximization conflicts with the other objective of a firm in the Islamic economy which is the upholding of human welfare or public interest.

Page 21: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

Common Views of Contemporary Common Views of Contemporary ScholarsScholarsHasan (2002) states that the concept of

maximization in itself conflicts with the moral code of Islam.

Amin et al (2003) on the other hand is in view that profit maximization can still be applied in an Islamic framework to achieve the desired outcomes of an Islamic economy, provided that Islamic values are explicitly incorporated particularly in the measurement of the cost of production of an Islamic firm

Page 22: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

Common Views of Contemporary Common Views of Contemporary ScholarsScholarsHasan (2011) stated that scarcity, self-interest

and maximization can be incorporated in Islamic economics with advantage after interpretative modifications to meet the Shari’ah norms

Samad (2008), parties in the Islamic markets will combine twin objectives: • maximization of profits/utility, i.e. welfare in

this world• maximization of success in the world

hereafter, i.e. achievement of Paradise

Page 23: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

AuthorsAuthors’’ Views and Reasoning on Views and Reasoning on the Islamic Perspectivethe Islamic PerspectiveFrom our point view, this topic is relevant in

providing society’s benefits. Islam has its own prescriptions in order to tackle

this issue. This is because in Islam there are also economic activities and participation in business that have spiritual beliefs.

“Eat not up your property among yourselves in vanities; but let there be amongst you trade by mutual good-will” (an-Nisa’: 29)

Page 24: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

AuthorsAuthors’’ Views and Reasoning on Views and Reasoning on the Islamic Perspectivethe Islamic PerspectiveRasulullah (pbuh) made engaging in business

affairs an obligation, “Seeking earning is a duty for every Muslim” and “Some sins can be abolished only by working hard to get earnings”.

The elevation of participation in business activities bring important factors toward social stability, coherence and development and growth besides strengthening the spirituality and civilization of society.

Page 25: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

AuthorsAuthors’’ Views and Reasoning on Views and Reasoning on the Islamic Perspectivethe Islamic PerspectiveEntrepreneurial framework according to the

Islamic Worldview is not only profit-oriented for this world but it crosses the boundaries of the physical world to a dimension that cannot be seen with the normal human senses, namely the Hereafter (Hasan, Z., 2011).

The concept of profit (gains) and losses (loss) should be viewed in the medium and not just based on the theory of rational human reason alone.

Page 26: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

AuthorsAuthors’’ Views and Reasoning on Views and Reasoning on the Islamic Perspectivethe Islamic PerspectiveThus, without the guidance of revelation

resulted in man being ta’sub and fascinated to live in a world full of lies

Result in oppression, tyranny & the practice of riba'

Islamic guidance consists of a balance between individuals’ rights and their responsibilities towards others in opposition to self-interest and altruism (Dusuki, A. W., & Abdullah, N. I., 2007).

Page 27: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

ConclusionConclusion

We believe that profit maximization can still be applied in order to achieve the desired outcomes of an Islamic economy system.

Although the present economic environment and the values of mainstream economy may not completely imitate the ideal values of Islam, we do hope that the analysis of this paper provides valuable knowledge in supporting our Islamic economic framework.

Page 28: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

ConclusionConclusion

The government must undertake this responsibility to ensure that the goal is attained and coincide with the market of society.

We believe that economic and social justice values of the firm need to be in same discussion.

Islam via the concept of vicegerency visualizes shareholders’ financial resources plus society’s economic resources, holding their property in trust for the benefit of the whole society with ultimate goal to gain the blessing of Allah.

Page 29: Profit Maximization from Islamic Perspective

Q&A SessionQ&A Session