Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process...

19
Process Safety and Hyperloop Copyright © Ian Sutton. 2019. All Rights Reserved.

Transcript of Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process...

Page 1: Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process Safety Culture Hazard Identification / Risk Operational Readiness Compliance Operating

Process Safety and Hyperloop

Copyright © Ian Sutton. 2019. All Rights Reserved.

Page 2: Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process Safety Culture Hazard Identification / Risk Operational Readiness Compliance Operating

Objective

Copyright © Ian Sutton. 2019. All Rights Reserved.

2

Demonstrate that the principles of Process Safety can be applied to other industries and new technologies.

Hyperloop is an example.

Page 3: Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process Safety Culture Hazard Identification / Risk Operational Readiness Compliance Operating

Background

•Chemical Engineer

•Process Safety/Risk

•Author

•HARP Book (Climate Change)

Copyright © Ian Sutton. 2019. All Rights Reserved.

3

Page 4: Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process Safety Culture Hazard Identification / Risk Operational Readiness Compliance Operating

Start of Interest in Hyperloop

Copyright © Ian Sutton. 2019. All Rights Reserved.

4

Page 5: Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process Safety Culture Hazard Identification / Risk Operational Readiness Compliance Operating

Two Core Issues

• Real Estate Availability• Overhead

• Underground

• Energy Efficiency• Climate Change

• Resource Depletion

Copyright © Ian Sutton. 2019. All Rights Reserved.

5

Page 6: Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process Safety Culture Hazard Identification / Risk Operational Readiness Compliance Operating

What Is Hyperloop?

• Concept Still Being Developed

• Energy Efficiency• Low Pressure Tube

• Linear Induction Motor

• Mag-Lev Propulsion

• Airplane Speeds

• Freight/PassengerCopyright © Ian Sutton. 2019. All Rights Reserved.

6

Page 7: Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process Safety Culture Hazard Identification / Risk Operational Readiness Compliance Operating

No Track or Internal Moving Parts

Copyright © Ian Sutton. 2019. All Rights Reserved.

7

Page 8: Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process Safety Culture Hazard Identification / Risk Operational Readiness Compliance Operating

What Does It Replace?

Copyright © Ian Sutton. 2019. All Rights Reserved.

8

Page 9: Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process Safety Culture Hazard Identification / Risk Operational Readiness Compliance Operating

Previous Changes

Copyright © Ian Sutton. 2019. All Rights Reserved.

9

Page 10: Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process Safety Culture Hazard Identification / Risk Operational Readiness Compliance Operating

Four Questions

1. Does It Work?

2. Is It Safe?

3. Can It Make Money?

4. Is There Time?

Copyright © Ian Sutton. 2019. All Rights Reserved.

10

Page 11: Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process Safety Culture Hazard Identification / Risk Operational Readiness Compliance Operating

Preliminary Safety Analysis: Plus

•No on-board fuel

•No grade crossings

•Cannot fall from sky

Copyright © Ian Sutton. 2019. All Rights Reserved.

11

Page 12: Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process Safety Culture Hazard Identification / Risk Operational Readiness Compliance Operating

Preliminary Safety Analysis: Minus

•Module hits inside of tube

•Breach of tube

•Total power failure

•Emergency escape

Copyright © Ian Sutton. 2019. All Rights Reserved.

12

Page 13: Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process Safety Culture Hazard Identification / Risk Operational Readiness Compliance Operating

Project Status: Phase Gate

Copyright © Ian Sutton. 2019. All Rights Reserved.

13

Page 14: Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process Safety Culture Hazard Identification / Risk Operational Readiness Compliance Operating

Consider a Generic Safety Study/Case

Copyright © Ian Sutton. 2019. All Rights Reserved.

14

Page 15: Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process Safety Culture Hazard Identification / Risk Operational Readiness Compliance Operating

F-N Curves 15

Page 16: Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process Safety Culture Hazard Identification / Risk Operational Readiness Compliance Operating

Major Hazards Analysis

• Identify the major hazards

• Evaluate the safety consequences

• Determine likelihood/predicted frequency

• Determine overall risk (F-N curve)

• Compare to acceptable risk and other transportation modes

• Help make technical choices (e.g., wheels vs. mag-lev)Copyright © Ian Sutton. 2019. All Rights Reserved.

16

Page 17: Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process Safety Culture Hazard Identification / Risk Operational Readiness Compliance Operating

“Derailment”

Copyright © Ian Sutton. 2019. All Rights Reserved.

17

Page 18: Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process Safety Culture Hazard Identification / Risk Operational Readiness Compliance Operating

Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18

Process Safety Culture Hazard Identification

/ Risk

Operational Readiness

Compliance Operating Procedures Management of Change

Competence Safe Work Practices Conduct of Operations

Workforce Involvement Asset Integrity /

Reliability

Emergency Management

Stakeholder Outreach Contractor Management Incident Investigation

Knowledge Management Training / Performance Measurement and Metrics

Auditing Management Review

Page 19: Process Safety and Hyperloop - IChemE · Management Program: Process Safety Elements 18 Process Safety Culture Hazard Identification / Risk Operational Readiness Compliance Operating

Conclusions

• Process Risk / Safety methodologies can be used

•Will it work? Yes, but scale-up

• Is It Safe? Conditional

• Develop a Safety Case / Report

Copyright © Ian Sutton. 2019. All Rights Reserved.

19