Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

42
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA UNITED STATES ex rel. RIGSBY ) ) Relators and ) Counterclaim Defendants ) ) v. ) No. 1:10-mc-00164(HHK/JMF) ) STATE FARM MUTUAL ) Underlying Litigation: INSURANCE COMPANY, et al. ) ) Case No. 1:06cv0433 LTS-RHW Defendant and ) United States District Court Counterclaim Plaintiff ) Southern District of Mississippi Exhibit A Privilege Log of The Rendon Group, Inc. Part 3 Russell J. Gaspar, D.C. Bar No. 229781 Andrew Wible, D.C. Bar. No. 988391 COHEN MOHR, LLP Suite 504, 1055 Thomas Jefferson St., N.W. Washington, D.C. 20007 (202) 342-2550 (Telephone) (202) 342-6147 (Facsimile) [email protected] Case 1:10-mc-00164-HHK-JMF Document 14-3 Filed 04/13/10 Page 1 of 42

Transcript of Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Page 1: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

UNITED STATES ex rel. RIGSBY )

)

Relators and )

Counterclaim Defendants )

)

v. ) No. 1:10-mc-00164(HHK/JMF)

)

STATE FARM MUTUAL ) Underlying Litigation:

INSURANCE COMPANY, et al. )

) Case No. 1:06cv0433 LTS-RHW

Defendant and ) United States District Court

Counterclaim Plaintiff ) Southern District of Mississippi

Exhibit A

Privilege Log of The Rendon Group, Inc.

Part 3

Russell J. Gaspar, D.C. Bar No. 229781

Andrew Wible, D.C. Bar. No. 988391

COHEN MOHR, LLP

Suite 504, 1055 Thomas Jefferson St., N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20007

(202) 342-2550 (Telephone)

(202) 342-6147 (Facsimile)

[email protected]

Case 1:10-mc-00164-HHK-JMF Document 14-3 Filed 04/13/10 Page 1 of 42

Page 2: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 2

of 42

Page 3: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 3

of 42

Page 4: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 4

of 42

Page 5: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 5

of 42

Page 6: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 6

of 42

Page 7: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 7

of 42

Page 8: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 8

of 42

Page 9: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 9

of 42

Page 10: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 1

0 o

f 42

Page 11: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 1

1 o

f 42

Page 12: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 1

2 o

f 42

Page 13: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 1

3 o

f 42

Page 14: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 1

4 o

f 42

Page 15: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 1

5 o

f 42

Page 16: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 1

6 o

f 42

Page 17: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 1

7 o

f 42

Page 18: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 1

8 o

f 42

Page 19: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 1

9 o

f 42

Page 20: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 2

0 o

f 42

Page 21: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 2

1 o

f 42

Page 22: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 2

2 o

f 42

Page 23: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 2

3 o

f 42

Page 24: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 2

4 o

f 42

Page 25: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 2

5 o

f 42

Page 26: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 2

6 o

f 42

Page 27: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 2

7 o

f 42

Page 28: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 2

8 o

f 42

Page 29: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 2

9 o

f 42

Page 30: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 3

0 o

f 42

Page 31: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 3

1 o

f 42

Page 32: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 3

2 o

f 42

Page 33: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 3

3 o

f 42

Page 34: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 3

4 o

f 42

Page 35: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 3

5 o

f 42

Page 36: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 3

6 o

f 42

Page 37: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 3

7 o

f 42

Page 38: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 3

8 o

f 42

Page 39: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 3

9 o

f 42

Page 40: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 4

0 o

f 42

Page 41: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 4

1 o

f 42

Page 42: Privilege Log 3 for Rendon Group in Scruggs/State Farm Qui Tam

Case 1

:10-m

c-0

0164-H

HK

-JM

F D

ocum

ent 14-3

F

iled 0

4/1

3/1

0 P

age 4

2 o

f 42