Private Equity: Passthrough...
Transcript of Private Equity: Passthrough...
Eric Sloan Deloitte Tax LLP
David Schnabel Debevoise & Plimpton LLP
Private Equity: Passthrough Investments
Practising Law Institute:
Tax Planning for Domestic & Foreign Partnerships,
LLCs, Joint Ventures & Other Strategic Alliances
Spring 2015
Lewis R. Steinberg
2
Agenda
• What is a Private Equity Fund?
• Investments in Passthroughs
− What are Passthrough Investments?
− How do Passthrough Investments Arise?
− How are Passthrough Investments Structured?
− Considerations in Evaluating Passthrough Investments
− Up-C Structure
− Exiting Passthrough Investments: Sales
− Exiting Passthrough Investments: IPOs
• Investments in Non-U.S. Companies
4
Basics of Private Equity
• What is a Private Equity Fund
• Difference from Hedge Funds
• Very active in M&A
5
Simplified Overview Structure
Sponsor
PE Fund
(Delaware)
Sponsor Commitment
20% Carried Interest
Investor Commitment
GP LP
Investors
6
Simplified Topside Structure
LP LP
PE Fund
(Delaware)
Sponsor
(Delaware)
GP LP LP
U.S. Taxable Investors U.S. Taxable
Investors Principals
U.S. Taxable Investors U.S. Taxable
Investors Non-U.S. Investors
U.S. Taxable Investors U.S. Taxable
Investors Tax-Exempt U.S. Investors
U.S. Taxable Investors U.S. Taxable
Investors Taxable and Super
Tax-Exempt U.S. Investors
U.S. Taxable Investors U.S. Taxable
Investors Sovereign Investors
8
What are Passthrough Investments?
• Portfolio company is a partnership or LLC
• Taxable income is taken into account at the fund investor level
• No portfolio company level federal income tax
9
How do Passthrough Investments Arise?
• Asset purchases (carve out or otherwise)
• LLC or partnership target
• S corporation target
• § 336(e)
• Joint ventures with strategics
11
Typical PE Investment in a Passthrough Investment
Blocker
(Delaware)
AIV 2
AIV 1
GP
Portfolio
Company
Sponsor
LP LP
U.S. Taxable Investors
U.S. Taxable Investors Principals
U.S. Taxable Investors
U.S. Taxable Investors
Non-Electing Investors
U.S. Taxable Investors U.S. Taxable
Investors Electing Investors
AIV 3
Sub-Partnership
12
AIVs in Relation to Main Fund
Blocker
(Delaware)
AIV 2
AIV 1
GP
Portfolio
Company
Sponsor
LP LP
U.S. Taxable Investors
U.S. Taxable Investors Principals
U.S. Taxable Investors
U.S. Taxable Investors
Non-Electing Investors
U.S. Taxable Investors U.S. Taxable
Investors Electing Investors
AIV 3
Sub-Partnership
Main Fund
Portfolio Companies
14
Considerations: Pros and Cons
Pros
• Potential to be paid for step-up upon exit
(e.g., TRA)
• One layer of tax (no tax for state pension
plans)
• Impact of tax distribution on preferred
return
• Treatment of management
Cons
• Complexity
• Requires additional decisions and
negotiation by sponsor
• Recapture income to the GP
• Potential loss of corporate NOL and ability
to monetize at exit
• Treatment of COD income
• State tax returns
• Add-on acquisitions where target is a
corporation
• Confusion and grumpiness by some LPs
15
• Complexity
• Requires additional decisions and negotiation by sponsor
• Recapture income to the GP
• Potential loss of corporate NOL and ability to monetize at exit
• Treatment of COD income
• State tax returns
• Add-on acquisitions where target is a corporation
• Confusion and grumpiness by some LPs
Considerations: Cons
16
• Difficult when buying from another PE firm that already has a blocker
• Treatment of the members of the GP
• Use of AIVs
• Treatment of foreign subsidiaries and FTCs
• Treatment of step up in computing tax distributions
• Use of multiple blockers where going to exit over time
• Type of business–large cap, middle market, real estate and energy
Other Considerations
18
Managing
Member
TRA
UP-C Structure – Simplified Ending Structure
AIV 1
PubCo
Portfolio
Company
Non-Managing
Member
AIV 2
TRA
Electing Investors
Non-Electing Investors
Public
20
Blocker
AIV 1
Portfolio
Company
AIV 2
Sponsor
GP GP LP LP
Partnership 1
Sale of Typical PE Investment in an Operating Partnership
Non-Electing Investors
Electing Investors
21
Sale of Typical PE Investment in an Operating Partnership (cont'd)
• Partnership 1 liquidates and distributes its interest in Portfolio Company to Blocker and Sponsor.
Blocker
AIV 1
Portfolio
Company
AIV 2
Sponsor
GP GP LP LP
Partnership 1
Electing Investors
Non-Electing Investors
22
Sale of Typical PE Investment in an Operating Partnership (cont'd)
Blocker
AIV 1
Portfolio
Company
AIV 2
Sponsor
GP GP LP LP
• Sponsor and AIV sell their interests in Portfolio Company; AIV2 sells its shares of Blocker (perhaps at a discounted purchase price).
• What if the buyer is another fund?
Electing Investors
Non-Electing Investors
24
• What is a tax receivable agreement?
─ What attributes are covered?
• What is needed?
─ § 754 election
─ § 743(b) adjustment to step up basis
─ Other tax attributes (e.g., NOLs, credits. etc.)
• Financial statement treatment
─ Liability for gross payments
─ Valuation allowance needed?
Tax Receivable Agreements
25
• Depends on nature of transaction that gave rise to ITR
─ Taxable purchase
─ Reorganization
─ Current distribution
• Installment sale
─ Principal and imputed interest
─ Basis recovery
─ Election out
• "With and Without" calculation
• When does the actual payment occur?
Characteristics of an ITR
26
• Common issues to consider
─ Ordering of multiple exchanges
─ Not enough taxable income
─ Permanent loss of ITR benefit
─ Law changes
─ What is the character of interest on the payment?
Characteristics of an ITR (cont’d)
28
Sponsor
(Cayman)
LP LP LP GP LP
U.S. Taxable Investors
U.S. Taxable Investors Principals
U.S. Taxable Investors
U.S. Taxable Investors
Taxable and Super Tax-Exempt
U.S. Investors
U.S. Taxable Investors
U.S. Taxable Investors
Tax-Exempt U.S. Investors
U.S. Taxable Investors
U.S. Taxable Investors
Non-U.S. Investors
U.S. Taxable Investors
U.S. Taxable Investors
Sovereign Investors
AIV
(Cayman)
Portfolio
Company
(Non-U.S.)
Investment in a Non-U.S. Corporation