Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the...

47
Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights An Overview of Current Events in Privacy Protections (or not) in Online Searches and Social Networking Sites

TAGS:

Transcript of Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the...

Page 1: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Privacy and Technology in the 21st Century

The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights

An Overview of Current Events in Privacy Protections (or not) in Online Searches and Social Networking Sites

Page 2: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Kia OraPhilip J. Greene

InternetNZ Senior Research Fellow in Cyberlaw

Victoria University School of LawWellington, New Zealand

Page 3: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

What is WHOIS??

Contact and related information concerning a domain name registration, namely:

Name of Registrar Name of Registrant, including address, phone

number and email Creation Date Expiration Date Administrative, Technical and Billing Contact info

Page 4: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

From InterNIC web site’s FAQs:

Will my name and contact information be publicly available?

Information about who is responsible for domain names is publicly available to allow rapid resolution of technical problems and to permit enforcement of consumer protection, trademark, and other laws. The registrar will make this information available to the public on a "Whois" site. It is however possible to register a domain in the name of a third party, as long as they agree to accept responsibility -- ask your registrar for further details.

Page 5: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Why Open Access to WHOIS??

1. Intellectual property owners need speedy and inexpensive access to domain and Web site owners

2. Law enforcement officials also need access, if web site offers/abets illegal content and/or activity, is a source of spyware, viruses, phishing, etc.

3. Consumers often use WHOIS for contact and identity purposes (to register a complaint; to investigate possible phishing; selection of a vendor, etc.)

Page 6: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.
Page 7: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.
Page 8: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.
Page 9: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

TradeMe.Co.Nz

Page 10: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Don’t Tread On Me?

Page 11: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

WHOIS to the Rescue

Page 12: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

What WHOIS Offers

Page 13: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.
Page 14: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Matter of First Impression?

Page 15: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Got a Secret?

Page 16: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Prove Your Qualifications to Teach

New Zealand Qualifications Authority Web site, found at NZQA.GOVT.NZ

Page 17: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Prove Your Qualifications

Page 18: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Or NOT!

WWW.NZQA.CO.NZ

Page 19: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Or Not

Page 20: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

What’s a Gripe Site?

Page 21: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Why NOT Open Access to WHOIS?

1. Invasion of privacy - registrant might not want identity revealed

2. Exposes e-mail addresses to spam, phishing, virus and other attacks

3. Is said to violate European Union’s 2002 Directive on privacy and electronic communications, as well as other national privacy/data rights laws.

Page 22: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

What is Status of WHOIS?

ICANN has just issued its Final Outcomes Report on the WHOIS Working Group 2007, please see: http://gnso.icann.org/drafts/icann-whois-wg-report-final-1-9.pdf

Grist for mill, discussion at next ICANN Meeting, Los Angeles, 31 October 2007

Page 23: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Scope of ICANN’s 2007 Review The WHOIS Working Group Outcomes Report (Report) was prepared in response to the GNSO Resolution of 28 March 2007, which created a WHOIS Working Group (WG) to examine three issues and to make recommendations concerning how current policies may be improved to address these issues:

#1. to examine the roles, responsibilities, and requirements of the operational point of contact (OPOC), and what happens if they are not fulfilled;

#2. to examine how legitimate interests will access unpublished registration data;

#3. to examine whether publication of registration contact information should be based on the type of registered name holder (legal vs. natural persons) or the Registrant’s use of a domain name.

Page 24: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Could it be…..

Just What IS a Natural Person?

Page 25: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.
Page 26: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Differentiating Between Natural and Legal Persons

From ICANN Report:

Working definition:

a natural person is a real living individual. a legal person is a company, business,

partnership, non-profit entity, association etc.

Page 27: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Other Possible ICANN Options?

The Special Circumstances Proposal

Special Circumstances model, also known as the Netherlands Model, because the rules are similar to those governing the .nl top-level domain:

"It allows individuals who demonstrate the existence of special circumstances to substitute contact details of the registrar for the data that would otherwise appear in published Whois." In other words, it allows some people to use the OPoC model if they qualify.

Page 28: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

The Special Circumstances Proposal So who qualifies? According to the ICANN report:

“The proposal envisages that full contact data of individuals would be held back from publication in the Whois only when this "would jeopardize a concrete and real interest in their personal safety or security that cannot be protected other than by suppressing that public access." This would seem to indicate that the vast majority of contact information would be published in the Whois, and that means of access to unpublished data would rarely be required.”

Page 29: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Intellectual Property v. Privacy, Pt. II - P2P File Sharing Litigation

Recording industry battles use of peer-to-peer (P2P) file-swapping software, such as Napster, KaZaa, LimeWire, Grokster, et al. Copyright infringement.

Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) initiated a two-pronged attack. Phase One, RIAA brought suit against these software providers to shut them down.

Page 30: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

RIAA v. Verizon, Pt. I

Phase Two, RIAA commenced the filing of law suits against the actual users doing the file-sharing (2002).

Only IP address of user’s computer known.

RIAA relied on streamlined subpoena process of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act to compel disclosure of users’ identities.

Page 31: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

RIAA v. Verizon, Pt. I

Verizon, an ISP, challenged RIAA’s practices.

In two decisions, issued in early 2003, the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, ruled in favour of the RIAA, approving of the use of DMCA subpoena process to compel disclosure. See, 240 F. Supp. 2d 24 and 257 F. Supp. 2d 244.

Page 32: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

RIAA Wins!

Page 33: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

RIAA v. Verizon, Part II Verizon appealed - U.S. Court of Appeals for D.C. reversed the

District Court decision, ruled in favour of Verizon. RIAA could no longer use streamlined subpoena process. Verizon not hosting the content, only an access provider.

As such, Verizon and other ISPs were protected by the Safe Harbour provisions of DMCA § 512(c).

RIAA must use DMCA’s Notice and Takedown provisions in tandem with subpoena process.

See: Recording Indus. Ass'n of Am., Inc. v. Verizon Internet Servs., 351 F.3d 1229, 1236 (D.C. Cir. 2003).

Page 34: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Verizon Prevails

Page 35: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

What About in Europe?

Page 36: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Part III – Privacy Issues and Online Behavioural Advertising, or

Don’t Google Your Old Girlfriend!!

Page 37: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

AutoDelete?

Page 38: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Microsoft/Ask.com Promise Search Privacy Reforms

Page 39: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

U.S. Government Role?

Page 40: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Is This Enough? A Good Start?

Page 41: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Or Just More Paralysis By Analysis?

Page 42: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.
Page 43: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.
Page 44: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.
Page 45: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.
Page 46: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Thank you again, Kia Ora!

Page 47: Privacy and Technology in the 21 st Century The Intersection of Privacy Protection and the Enforcement of Law and Intellectual Property and Consumer Rights.

Philip J. Greene

InternetNZ Senior Research Fellow in Cyberlaw

Victoria University School of Law

Wellington, NZ

[email protected]


Glenbrook intersection upgrade map - Roads and Maritime ... · Glenbrook intersection upgrade map Author: Roads and Maritime Services Subject: Glenbrook intersection upgrade map Keywords:

Glenbrook intersection upgrade map - Roads and Maritime ... · Glenbrook intersection upgrade map Author: Roads and Maritime Services Subject: Glenbrook intersection upgrade map Keywords:

Elaborating intersection and union types · 2020. 8. 4. · Elaborating intersection and union types 5 introduction and elimination rules for intersection to the (utterly standard)

Elaborating intersection and union types · 2020. 8. 4. · Elaborating intersection and union types 5 introduction and elimination rules for intersection to the (utterly standard)

Intersection Safety Implementation Plan Process · include Example Data Analysis Package and Straw Man Outline, Example Intersection Safety ... Intersection Safety Implementation

Intersection Safety Implementation Plan Process · include Example Data Analysis Package and Straw Man Outline, Example Intersection Safety ... Intersection Safety Implementation

Privacy attitudes and privacy behaviour: A review of …fws.commacafe.org › resources › Kokolakis_privacy_paradox.pdfnetwork.This inconsistency of privacy attitudes and privacy

Privacy attitudes and privacy behaviour: A review of …fws.commacafe.org › resources › Kokolakis_privacy_paradox.pdfnetwork.This inconsistency of privacy attitudes and privacy

Privacy and Privacy Rights

Privacy and Privacy Rights

PRIVACY AND RELATED ISSUES IN IT. Main points What is privacy? Privacy harms and benefits Privacy right Protecting privacy: Technology, markets,

PRIVACY AND RELATED ISSUES IN IT. Main points What is privacy? Privacy harms and benefits Privacy right Protecting privacy: Technology, markets,

Privacy Preserving Set Intersection · •Cryptographic methods •Example: Secure scalar product, asymmetric cryptography •Highly accurate •Provably secure •But, computationally

Privacy Preserving Set Intersection · •Cryptographic methods •Example: Secure scalar product, asymmetric cryptography •Highly accurate •Provably secure •But, computationally

Data Science at Intersection of Security and Privacy

Data Science at Intersection of Security and Privacy

1 Efficient Delegated Private Set Intersection on Outsourced …homepages.cs.ncl.ac.uk/changyu.dong/papers/TDSC.pdf · privacy-preserving data mining [3], like scenarios where mutu-ally

1 Efficient Delegated Private Set Intersection on Outsourced …homepages.cs.ncl.ac.uk/changyu.dong/papers/TDSC.pdf · privacy-preserving data mining [3], like scenarios where mutu-ally

intersection control and designII.ppt

intersection control and designII.ppt

Privacy - courses.cs.washington.edu · An interesting conundrum at the intersection of technology and policy ... Favorite sports team ... of the Fifth USENIX Workshop on Hot Topics

Privacy - courses.cs.washington.edu · An interesting conundrum at the intersection of technology and policy ... Favorite sports team ... of the Fifth USENIX Workshop on Hot Topics

[6-1 307pm] Privacy Webinar #2 - Intersection of ... Privacy Into Advertising and... · Recent Cases FTC v. Phillip A. Flora • FTC Complaint filed February 23, 2011 • Sent 5.5

[6-1 307pm] Privacy Webinar #2 - Intersection of ... Privacy Into Advertising and... · Recent Cases FTC v. Phillip A. Flora • FTC Complaint filed February 23, 2011 • Sent 5.5

Transtutors · Web viewIn today's modern world privacy is a atmost important commodity. Here the Set intersection protocol is a privacy protocol [7]. Private data should be shared

Transtutors · Web viewIn today's modern world privacy is a atmost important commodity. Here the Set intersection protocol is a privacy protocol [7]. Private data should be shared

Privacy, Accountability and Trust Privacy, Accountability and Trust Privacy, Accountability and Trust

Privacy, Accountability and Trust Privacy, Accountability and Trust Privacy, Accountability and Trust

SIMD Compression and the Intersection of Sorted … · SIMD Compression and the Intersection of Sorted Integers ... SIMD COMPRESSION AND THE INTERSECTION OF SORTED ... engine and

SIMD Compression and the Intersection of Sorted … · SIMD Compression and the Intersection of Sorted Integers ... SIMD COMPRESSION AND THE INTERSECTION OF SORTED ... engine and

Bhogal 1 The Intersection of Technology and Healthcare in ... of the biggest drawbacks about the intersection of technology and healthcare is the compromise of privacy. In recent years,

Bhogal 1 The Intersection of Technology and Healthcare in ... of the biggest drawbacks about the intersection of technology and healthcare is the compromise of privacy. In recent years,

Privacy issues and internet privacy

Privacy issues and internet privacy

Majestic - Final Report - Cycle Dayurbantransport.kar.gov.in/Better Access to Majestic Area-Final... · Road-TCM Road intersection and Shantala Intersection (towards Shantala Intersection).

Majestic - Final Report - Cycle Dayurbantransport.kar.gov.in/Better Access to Majestic Area-Final... · Road-TCM Road intersection and Shantala Intersection (towards Shantala Intersection).

Data Privacy and Dignitary Privacy: Google Spain, the ...€¦ · Google Spain, the Right to Be Forgotten, and the Construction of the Public Sphere1 Lying at the intersection of

Data Privacy and Dignitary Privacy: Google Spain, the ...€¦ · Google Spain, the Right to Be Forgotten, and the Construction of the Public Sphere1 Lying at the intersection of

Privacy Implications of Privacy Settings and Tagging in ...zannone/publication/... · Privacy Implications of Privacy Settings and Tagging in Facebook 1 Privacy Implications of Privacy

Privacy Implications of Privacy Settings and Tagging in ...zannone/publication/... · Privacy Implications of Privacy Settings and Tagging in Facebook 1 Privacy Implications of Privacy