Case study LocationsPotentials & scenarios

Definite Choice

Potentials

FoodMoney

Supplies

City

Outskirts

Dependence

Repetetiveness & Vulnerability

Winter

Summer

FoodMoney

Supplies

City

Outskirts

Dependence

Global connections

Downtown

Global connections

Downtown

Responds

Economical activity on the streets

Economical activity in buildings

IDP’S

Response process

Las Colinas

1.

2.

3.

Political Process

Local Government

Affected people

Central government

IDP’S

Response process

Las Colinas

1.

2.

3.

Scenarios

wee

k 9

wee

k 10

wee

k 10

wee

k 11

wee

k 13

wee

k 12

wee

k 14

wee

k 15

wee

k 16

Presentation Scenario 1Breakthrough Santa Tecla

wee

k 9

wee

k 10

wee

k 10

wee

k 11

wee

k 13

wee

k 12

wee

k 14

wee

k 15

wee

k 16

Presentation Scenario 2Breakthrough Downtown

wee

k 9

wee

k 10

wee

k 10

wee

k 11

wee

k 13

wee

k 12

wee

k 14

wee

k 15

wee

k 16

Presentation Scenario 3No Breakthroughs

wee

k 9

wee

k 10

wee

k 10

wee

k 11

wee

k 13

wee

k 12

wee

k 14

wee

k 15

wee

k 16

Presentation Scenario 4Two Breakthroughs

Plan overviewsObjectives, actions & needs

Case study locations

Objectives Actions Needs

Mejicanos

Map the contemporary conditions:To create a fi gure of the urban Vitality of sector Mon-treal we will investigate and map the three diff erent disciplines: the liveability, the urban conditions and the sustainability. The liveability, in three or four most vulnerable communities, the urban conditions and the sustainability on the scale of the whole section of Montreal

Determine the most vulnarable, disaster prone communities:- In which communities did disasters occur in the last ten years?- In which communities disasters are most likely to occur?

Tracing back incentives in the post-disaster proces:- Where/which/ by who: were post disaster responses implemented?- What were the objectives of the post disaster responses.

- interview with Victor.- interview with ‘geistion de Riesgos’.

- interview with Victor.- Interview with involved NGO’s.- Visit to diff erent projects.- Put up and distribute survey among communities.

discipline liveability:- Put up and distribute survey for inhabitants.- observation trips (help of GIS and Photographs) to dif-ferent communities in order to create analysis.- Interview with community workers (Victor and Hector).

discipline Urban conditions:- create analysis maps on the scale of Sector Montreal increasing in detail on the scale of communities (services, economy, networks, connectivity, infrastructure, etc.)- interview with offi cials about former development and future plans (Ricardo Barrera, Victor).

discipline Sustainability:- Interview with offi cials (protecion civil, desarollo urbano, comunidad, schools). -

1. Interview with Victor.

2. Observation trips to diff erent communities, in order to create analysis (possibility to team up in to groups, so two community workers needed).

3. Create a survey and distribute among diff erent communities.

4. Interview with department of Protection civll.

5. Visit projects and interview the NGO’s that imple-mented disaster responses (Procomes, Oxfam, Fundasal).

6. Interview with Ricardo Barrera on the future plans.

7. Interview in schools and communities on educa-tion programme.

(plan overview week 14 to 16)

Objectives Actions Needs

Santa Tecla (plan overview week 14 to 16)

Tracing back incentives in the post-disaster proces:exploration into the incentives that caused an eff ect on the liveability of the aff ected people, the urban conditions of Santa Tecla or the sustainability

Tracing back the fl ow of people:-where did the aff ected people in the emeregency camp came from (inside or outside of the city)?-where did the aff ected people left after the cafetalon closed (did they went back to their old place or have they been replaced)?

Current plans:-what are the plans for the future of Las Collinas (dif-ferent stakeholders)?-what are the plans for the future of the three provi-sional settlements (diff erent stakeholder)?

Evolutionairy mapCreating a graph of gathered data, in the disciplines that has there infl uences in the spatiality of Santa Tecla, focussing on the timeframe of the last 10 years.

Contemporary conditions:mapping the Urban Vitality on the scale of liveability, urban conditions and sustain-ability in transitional settlements.

- Visit provisional shelter settlements.- Interview aff ected people in transitional shelters.- Interview aff ected people in Las Collinas.- Interview with offi cials that worked in Cafetalon.

- Interview local government- Interview aff ected people in transitional shelters.- Interview aff ected people in Las Collinas.- Interview national Government.- Interview civil organization ConFena

- Visit provisional settlements.- Interview aff ected people in transitional settlements- create analysis maps, space syntax, observations, etc.

- all the actions above will contribute to the evolutionairy map.

- Visit provisional shelter settlements.- Interview aff ected people in transitional shelters.- Interview aff ected people in Las Collinas.- Interview with offi cials that worked in Cafetalon.- Interview NGO’s that worked in the post-disaster pro-cess

1. Appointment to visit provisional settlememts, and interview with aff ected people to create an understanding of the people fl ow(possibility to split up into two groups: one to observe and track, the other to interview inhabitants).

2. Interview with offi cial that worked in Cafetalon (Humberto de Paz), to create a list of facts about people, organizations and responses in order to map the process in more detail (Municipality, NGO archive?).

3. Interview with ConFena and current or old inhab-itants of Las Collinas.

4. Interview with NGO’s that helped in the response on the 2001 earthquake and landslide.

5. Interview with National Government in order to get an insight of the plans on Las Collinas.

6. Maps: munipality, GIS, OPAMSS etc.

Objectives Actions Needs

Downtown (AMSS)

Cultural-historic analysis:In relation to all case studies we investigate certain repetitive phenomona, for example: individualism, political ineffi ciency in collarboration and landowner-ship. Downtown contains key information about the history of detail. We aim to go in detail in certain time periods: 1986 earthquake and 1980-1992 the infl u-ence of civil war.

Occupation by population El Salvador:We aim to investigate the daily fl ow of people in and out DowntownInvestigating the occupation of street > buildingsIncoming migration and outgoing migration, includ-ing the informal settlements

Economic fl ow:We aim to investigate the quantity of market stalls and other economic activity. The typologies of street profi les.For now we focus on the scale of liveability, the impor-tance of the economic fl ow for an individual/family.

Interview with:- inhabitants/local formal/informal workers- landowners- offi cials/politicians

Map transport system: e.g. autobusses

- map typology of marketstalls- map product fl ow (Downtown + Latiendonna): investi-gate prices compara to other market- map the crowdedness of public space like streets, squares and parks

Data gathering:- Gather, read and analyze documentation regarding the history of Downtown in multiple aspects

Evolutionairy Map:- Apply information to the Evolutionairy Map. Analyze the key relations and continu research with results for a specifi c area of Downtown (AMSS).

Presentation:- Illustrate research in a presentation/animation for more effi cient communication through internet

1. Facts & fi gures about Downtown (AMSS), main focius on the period concerning the migration of the wealthy around th 30’s, the migration in the 70’s, the civil war 1980-1992, the earthquake of ‘86 and the last decade 2000-2009.

2. Documentation: (scientifi c/historic) books, publications, essays etc. on the topic of Downtown (AMSS).

3. Interview with landowners, politicians (national and local), architects and engineers, theorists and economists for diff erent visions and expertise.

4. Maps for analyzing, current but also historic and future plans. If possibile maps appliable for software programs: GIS and Space Syntax.

(plan overview week 14 to 16)