Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN)...
Transcript of Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN)...
![Page 1: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
David Soler (1), David Brusi (1), Manel Zamorano (1), Xavier Goula (2), Sara Figueras (2), Albert Macau (2), Andreu Martí (2) and Miquel Vilà (2)
Bologna, 12th - 15th June, 2012
(2) (1)
Session 9 – Seismic risk
![Page 2: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Index
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
7th EUREGEO, 2012
1. Introduction 2. Seismotectonic and geological setting 3. Geotechnical database processing 4. Seismic parameterization of soil and rock units 5. Site soil amplification 6. Seismic microzonation 7. Conclusions
1
![Page 3: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
1. Introduction
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
7th EUREGEO, 2012
· At a local level, a first approach to the potential effects of damaging earthquakes is the estimation of ground movements due to amplification of the seismic vibrations (“soil effect”).
· Soil dynamic parameters can be obtained by correlation from geological and geotechnical data, according to equivalences defined in national seismic normatives (e.g.: Spanish Seismic Building Code, NCSE-02). · In urban areas expanded and developed during the last decades, ground investigation reports are abundant and represent a valuable source of geolocated variables with seismic significance.
2
![Page 4: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
7th EUREGEO, 2012
· Basic level microzonation of the Girona urban area has been conducted by: i. statistical processing of a geological and geotechnical
database, ii. quantitative seismic characterization of the soil and
rock units, iii. site specific determination of soil coefficients
influencing the local seismic response, and iv. cartographic delineation of isoamplification zones
within the urban framework.
This work is included in the SISPyr project, program INTERREG IV A
3
![Page 5: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
7th EUREGEO, 2012
2. Seismotectonic and geological setting
· Eastern end of the Pyrenees and the Catalan Coastal Ranges
· Neogene grabens filled with sediments and basic volcanics · Plioquaternary NW-SE trending normal faults · Some of them are seismogenic sources
4
![Page 6: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
7th EUREGEO, 2012
Historical and instrumental seismicity
(www.igc.cat)
· Moderate periodical seismicity
· Estimated peak ground acceleration (PGA) for Girona: 0.070 g – 0.090 g (NCSE-02) 0.077 g-0.102 g (Secanell et al., 2008)
0.140 g (Mezcua et al., 2011)
· Low rates of strong events up to Mw=6.3-6.8 (475-year return period)
5
![Page 7: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Girona urban area Province capital 10 municipalities 150,000 inhabitants 50 km2
Girona Bescanó
Vilablareix
Fornells de la Selva
Sant Gregori
Sant Julià de Ramis
Sarrià de Ter
Quart
Aiguaviva
Urban land + 250 m
Urban land
Salt
6
![Page 8: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Local geology Local geology
Quaternary fluvial – alluvial plain deposits
Neogene overconsolidated detritic sediments
Simplificated from 1:25,000 IGC geological maps
Plioquaternary fault
![Page 9: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
7th EUREGEO, 2012
3. Geotechnical database processing · Database of geological and geotechnical investigation reports compiled by GEOCAMB (University of Girona).
· Typologies of prospection points included: - Boreholes (85% out of total)
- Dynamic probing tests (DPSH) - Excavations - Wells - Natural outcrops
8
![Page 10: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
7th EUREGEO, 2012
Structure of the database
· Selective extraction of geological and geotechnical variables of interest for seismic analysis
· One table of main hierarchical order
· None to several linked tables
9
![Page 11: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
7th EUREGEO, 2012
Prospection points
Cohesive material
(Qt2s)
SPT cores
Unaltered soil sample
Granular material
(Qt2i)
10
![Page 12: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
7th EUREGEO, 2012
Statistical synthesis of geotechnical parameters
· Carried out for each one of the lithostratigraphical soil units (Quaternary, Neogene and some altered rock units). · Summarized parameters: i) In situ tests: - Standard penetration test blow count, SPT-N - Dynamic Probing Super Heavy penetration test, DPSH-N ii) Laboratory tests on soil samples: - Unconfined shear strength, Qu - Granulometric percentages, especially fine content - Atterberg limits and Casagrande plasticity charts - Dry-wet density and natural humidity content
11
![Page 13: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
· NCSE-02 sets direct correlation of SPT-N and Qu with:
- Seismic soil class - Soil coefficient C - Shear wave velocities, Vs
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
7th EUREGEO, 2012
Inferred after code definitions about compactness of granular materials and consistency of cohesive materials, by comparison to values published in the geotechnical literature
12
![Page 14: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
· Synthesis of SPT-N data for soil units
Mainly soil class II-III
Mainly soil class III-IV
13
![Page 15: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
7th EUREGEO, 2012
· Synthesis of Qu data for cohesive soil units
Soil class III - IV
14
![Page 16: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
7th EUREGEO, 2012
4. Seismic parameterization of soil and rock units
· Soil coefficient C calculated by two parallel ways for each unit: - Based on SPT-N data - Based on Qu data
C(SPT-N) C(Qu)
15
![Page 17: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
7th EUREGEO, 2012
· A representative soil coefficient C(R) for all the units is derived from integrated consideration of:
- C(SPT-N) - C(Qu) - Granulometric percentages and fine content
(granular/cohesive/mixed geotechnical character) - Density, humidity, plasticity and other descriptive information
· Additionally, shear wave velocities Vs have been calculated for each individual SPT value by empirical equivalences (Kanai et
al., 1966), and then summarized by units.
Vs = 62 SPT-N0.6
16
![Page 18: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
![Page 19: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
7th EUREGEO, 2012
5. Site soil amplification (NCSE-02)
· Seismic calculus acceleration ac is:
ac = S · ρ · PGA S: Soil amplification factor ρ: non-dimensional risk coefficient (1.0-1.3 for normal-special importance buildings)
· Since PGA (Girona area) is 0.07-0.09, then S(PGA<0.1) = C / 1.25
· Soil coefficient C is a good indicator in estimation of soil effect:
Ci: Soil coefficient C ei: individual thickness
for all the soil class layers in the first 30 m from the surface
18
![Page 20: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
7th EUREGEO, 2012
· Database: great heterogeneity in the amount, precision and confidence of available data among the prospection points.
30 m
0 m 30 m?
- Borehole:
Pre-Quaternary substratum? Continuous/discontinuous core? Representativeness of the core? Dynamic probing log? (no core)
Quaternary
Neogene or Rock
SPT-N
SPT-N
SPT-N
- Lithology levels: Valid SPT-N data? (not refusal) Lab. resistance tests on unaltered soil samples?
Soil sample
Soil sample
19
![Page 21: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
7th EUREGEO, 2012
· Need of systematization in the process to obtain C 1,530 boreholes: many boreholes with few or poorly constrained data
· Standardized Ci calculation method by weighted contribution of Ci(SPT-N), Ci(Qu), C(R) (25 typological cases)
Ci
C1
C2
C3
Cn
.
.
.
ei
e1
e2
e3
en
.
.
.
i) After in situ penetration tests:
ii) After laboratory resistance tests:
iii) From extrapolation: C(R)
Ci(SPT-N) % C(R) Cases N1 to N8
Ci(Qu) % C(R) Cases M1 to M6
· Rock Cases R1 to R3 · Soil Cases S1 to S7 · Anthropogenic Case A1 20
![Page 22: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
7th EUREGEO, 2012
· Example of C and Iqc calculation for one borehole:
· Additionally, each Ci case is attributed to a quality (confidence) index, Iqci
Iqci: 1-4 (poor to very good Ci confidence) Iqc Iqci
21
![Page 23: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Iqc C
1,328 boreholes 22
![Page 24: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
· C coefficient isoamplification zones
6. Basic level seismic microzonation
Zone A-1 Rock cropping out or covered by a thin layer of Quaternary sediments. Zone A-2 Rock overlain by 5-20 meters of low seismic quality Quaternary sediments. Zone B i) Neogene sediments, ii) Quaternary alluviums up to 20 m thick overlying Neogene, iii) weathered Quaternary lava flow up to 15 m thick, over Quaternary and Neogene sediments. Zone C Local thick, soft Quaternary alluviums on Neogene.
![Page 25: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
7th EUREGEO, 2012
7. Conclusions
· Geotechnical databases: a valuable source of ground information for basic seismic analysis.
· Direct correlation of geotechnical and geological characteristics to soil dynamic parameters by means of published equivalences (seismic building codes).
· Weighted contribution of seismic parameters obtained by parallel, complementary ways allows to get standardized seismic data, instead of how much / how good available information comes out from the boreholes.
√
√
√
24
![Page 26: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
7th EUREGEO, 2012
7. Conclusions (continued) · This methodology reveals as a good complement in the determination of local seismic response from other direct techniques.
×
√ · Resulting microzonation sets a starting tool for more specific targets: field geophysical measurements, numerical simulations in selected emplacements, and performance of risk scenarios.
√
· Data compilation, filtering and processing is time consuming. · Geotechnical investigations are usually shallow. × · NCSE-02 only considers soil effect up to 30 m depth. ×
25
![Page 27: Presentació del PowerPoint · SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA . 7. th. EUREGEO, 2012 · At a local](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053119/60a0147e737a9e029b57ccb6/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Vi ringrazio per la vostra attenzione
http://www.igc.cat http://geocamb.udg.edu
SEISMIC MICROZONATION OF THE GIRONA URBAN AREA (CATALONIA, NE SPAIN) FROM STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF GEOTECHNICAL DATA
7th EUREGEO, 2012
26