Shamrock ottage, ross Lane, ayston Hill, Shrewsbury, SY3 0DF
Preprints Deborah Sweet for research integrity! Editorial .... SY3... · Noah Olsman,l Fangzhou...
6
Preprints are a boon for research integrity! Deborah Sweet VP of Editorial, Cell Press/Elsevier
Transcript of Preprints Deborah Sweet for research integrity! Editorial .... SY3... · Noah Olsman,l Fangzhou...
Preprints are a boon for research integrity!
Deborah SweetVP of Editorial, Cell Press/Elsevier
Record of form that precedes peer review
21 Nov 2017
19 Sep 2018
Countering criticism & adjusting claims5 Sep 2017
6 Sep 2017
12 Sep 2017
2 Aug 2017
Rapid communication of contradictory results
28 August 2017 August 2018
Rapid highlighting of data problems23 Nov 2015
1 Dec 2015
24 March 2016
12 May 2016
12 May 2016
22 Aug 2016
Think of all the things preprints can do….1. Record what a paper was like before peer review2. Allow authors to counter criticism/respond to discussion3. Speedy communication of contradictory results4. Highlighting problems with data/analysis5. Helping authors refine their paper before they formally submit6. Giving a home to negative results7. Validation and confirmation of results
Think about a paper you know that turned out to be problematic.
Would that situation have been different if the paper had been put out as a preprint first?
