-'\0,(t" FORM NoJ BY REGD. Posr wlrH ecr.oUe

IN THE ANDHRAPRADESH ADMINISTRATIJ4ITRIBUNAL:: AT l YPERllE4lqwEbiiisoA[iiE 6xreeuiii bAV or sepreraBER, rworHouEAND ANo FIFTEE

::PRESENT::HON'BLE SRI. MOTUPALLIVIJAYA KUMAR' MEMBER

(Constitutlng as a Bench U/s 5(6) of the Admlnlrtratlve Trlbunelt Act'

BETWEEN

1 . S. Parvathi, D/o. Krishnaiah, 32 years, 9G'Teacher,Uf .p.F-scn6ol, Hukumpeta (Main), Gopalapuram Mandal'

West Godavari Diskict.

2. S. Viiayalakshmi Kumari, D/o. Peddav-eeranna, aged- ;il;115 t;;t", s'c.r.r'a' p.P.School' Palantla (Special)'

Devarapaily Mandal, West Godavari District'

3.E. Suryachandra Rao, S/o. Pentaiah, aged about

Zg vears, S.G.T., M.P.P.School, Regulakunta (V),

Sanjeevdpuram Post, Gopalapuram Mandal'

West Godavari District.

4. Bhulsya Seviya, S/o' NageswarS !.a.o, 1Se{ab9ytSg yuit", S.G'T., M'P'P.School, Bhimolu' GopalaPuram

Mandal, West Godavari District'

5.K. Janakr-(umari, D/o. Lakshmaiah, aged about

30 vears, S.G.T., M'P.P School, GopqlaiqT'.Gopalapuram Mandal, West Godavari L'lstrlct'

6. N. Balachalam, S/o. Lakshminarayana'.aged about- :rit;";;, S.o.i., na.p.p.school, Bhimolu, Gopalapqam

UanOat, West Godaval'i Dishict'

7. K. Nagasatyavani, D/o. Mangaiah, a.ged about 31 years'

s.o.rl, M.P.P.School, Hukumpeta (H9I'. . . ,

Gopalapuram Mandal, West Godavari lJlstncl'

8. G. Parvathi, D/o. Chinnaveerabhadram, aged.about- C6 v""rs, s.C.f., M'P.P.School, Gopay3rgr.n (V)'

. Ooiatapuram Mandal, West Godavari District'

9. Mohd. Jahrussain, Sio. Khaja Miya, aged about 44 years'-

S.G.i., M.P.P.School, Narasannapalem, Gopalapuram

Mandal, West Godavari District.

10. G. Vijaya, D/o. Durgarao, aged about 3! Vea1s, S'G'T"- la. p.F.bCnool, Nad-igudem Vit tage; Sanjeevapuram Post'

Gopalapuram Mandal, West Godavari District'

11. E. Vanitha, D/o' Sampatharao, aged abott 31 Y3ars'e

^ T t\, P tr Sehool Hukumoeta Villaqe, Gopllapuram

www.ednforum.com

. ..,..

..4.,

S/o. Lakshmanarao, aged

ElEl" rr,r-i e. s.h@r, Gan-sorY Yil:s e

l#no.r: w;t Godavari Districl

I

1,l

' ". J fl, ti $,'rlrli Bi,::ru:::i"l::",1.:' "'*

GoPalaPuram Mandi

I I 31,'3lji1'"T I ll1i

"

i1ffi ts'5ft !f ,&:f '

ilffi i|'I'n'r"ni"r' west Godavari District

"*Y:,"S:Ssi[i,:BT:ii13i"""11?3ili;3Yf;"3!',?',"iit""lili, wi"t Godavari District'

16. S. Ramatulasi' D/o' Krishna' aged about 31 vea's

'" ; G.i ;M P Pf:!","j; Duii$[3ll#l3;in.,GoPalaPuram Manr

l T pu ne m r ndi'1f '.J* f ll l r'JleH"1?lH::X,T : iJ '"l

: "3,?T':3,":il",1 I.I;i w iii nool'"'i Distn ct

AND

' IE?E$:,:x#liliiilixfl,31i"THHi:ir"'.eHPJ:n':;,%o*1"JJf.1"0:"'*'

. Ii"X3:I3:3*'i:::'ft 3ltffiLn District at Eluru

4. Ihe Mandal Educational Officer'' ' ' '* ilH,Jp'tirirn, w""t Godavari District'

S.The Mandal Educational Officer' ' '"' ffi;;;;t, west Godavari District'

6. rhe state or ^qq

y Sjf,jjiie l""T-:;:Hi jJ;':",,

PrinciPal Secretali.ii. i"".. a"riat, l'i )derabad

...APPLICANTS

..,RESPONDENTS

' Uoon motion this day made into"this"Tribunal bv MR' K' NARAYANA'

Advocate for the applica;l #;;'i;iounar ueing oiopinion that the records

'fi r*y,::"ili,'sliJi[1x5i["]*li'[n:r-nl"l'r::r:;r":ffii:?JI:be.called for and perused.

i contd. .. /

www.ednforum.com

to-

,\\-a3)

::3:;

That yor'--the afore.said Respondents do send for our use in AndhraPradesh Administrative rriuunar ii frvit,i'oJoi]r lnd singurar the said recordsand others with a, things toucrrrn! t'rr6l-a;;"'iily and perfecry as they havei",iJ^[1i""8]"',?:,":,1,,Hx,:"#,fl ,1,:f**Eir-::fS'*;-6ti,"i',,"d'ini"

This originar Apprication coming on today for orders as to admission andrnterrm relief, upon perusing the uipli""-tio,i, uio 1t" materiat papors filedrnerelv,th and upon hearing ihe ,rsd;;6;;Mn]'ii. nranevarue, Advocate forthe appricant and or G.p. ion 9-d-iooi e.iiu6)iiibrv (sER.) on beharr of therespondents, the Tribunat rnaoeir"rl rJioi;;;^,,.

:ORDER:

i

www.ednforum.com

\

O H.No.5358i20 i5

ln the recruitmenr concjucieci vide DSC 2008, the appiicants 'arere

appoiniecj as Seconciary Graoe Teachers ciurng riie years 2CC9 and 201,:

resOectively. However. ouring ine Vear 2Ai2 i"e to cenain ci'ciers issi,ec

regarciing the revision oi seiection oi the appiicants, Show Cause irciices ra;ei'e

issued to them as to why iheir seiection shouic roi be rerminared Srio','., Cause

Notices were chaiiengeci oV ihe appiicanis in O.Hs. 9279.9280 ar: 923+i2ii2

before this Tribunal anci ihis Tribunai siaveci the operaiion oi ihe Shoii Cause

Notices. The app icanis submii ihai ior the purpcse oi conciucirng ii'ansfer'

counseiling the respondenis issueci Ruies vicje G O.Ms.No.63. cjaiecj 3j 8 20i5.

As per Ruie 5 (1Xa) criteria ior iransfer uras prescribeci which is as foiiovvs

"(i) The ioiiowing caieqoi'ies oi i:eacjmasier Gr. ii Gazetiieci ,

Teacher in the Gcveirn':e;t iZP?;llPP shall be tr-ansferi"ed.

(a)Those Teachers v.,ho have compieieci 8 years service in anartia,rlar cahral and +ila l-.laaalmactarc /ar ll \^,h^ ha\,6Ps, srvu'q,

completed 5 years of in particuiar scnooi as on i"i August/(^. +L^ t--^a^-,,^^- at\,| F ,t A. +!.^ ^,J ^lt a-+^,.,^,,1, !.^ {Sl\lVr (l lq i,l Cll r5r(tr yaot ZV r J- r lJ Ll l<; U\.r( (Jrr UoLs ,f \JUtLJ r,,9 I

August) shail be comouisoriiy transferreci.

"Provided ihose who are going to reiire wiihin iwo (2) yearsfrcm 1d August cf the year shall not be shifted untij anduniess the.incumbent requests iol' such iransfer."

2. Now the applicants submit that the 2"d respondent, Commissioner has

i6sued ciarification in Rc.No.25lEstt-|i1i2015. daieo 12.9.201s. ln pursuance of

the said clarification, several items were meniioneci and ltem No.17 is ihe

.rblevant for the purpose of this case and ihe appiicanis are aggrieveci bv the

same which is as follows:

I

Ft- t-^-------

www.ednforum.com

6qR)/oj

St r.1o Clarification Sought

Eligibiliiy fcr trensfer and ' teachers against' Raiionalization of 2008 whom court cases are

pending with respect totheir appointmentsshould not be consideredfor transfer. How'ever,such teachers nraY betransferred and kePtunder surplus, if the said

i post is rendered surPlusi under Rationalization.i

: This O.rr., is fiieci ov the appiicants quesiioning the clarificaiion issued by

:ne 2"'i responrJeni dated 12I 2A15 to the Ruies issued in G O'Ms No'63, Cated

ii 8.20i5. The appiicanis conienci thai once ihe Ruies are issueci uncier Ariicle

sOg of rne constiruiion of inoia by vifiue of powers conferred under sections 78

ancr 06 of Ancl-b;ra Pradesh Edtlcalion Act the /d responderrt i'e'' Commissioner

nasncpowerloissueanYsucnciarificaiion.HefuriherSubmitsthai,infaci.iiis

rci a ctarifrcation. The ruie is sought io be amended bv issuing ihe clariiication'

zi -ihe Govenrment has issueci Ruies under erticie 309 oi the constitution oi

incia in oroei-io conciuci rransier counseiiing ior ihe Heacimasters and Teachers

rn rne State oi ancihra Praciesh.

5 rearo ooth sioes.

; aomiiieciiy. as couici be seen- from ihe ciariiicatiorr' ii is in ihe fortn oi

3menomenr of ihe Ruie in so far as item No.i7 siaieci above is concerned and ii

is weii seiiieci iaw ihai a Ruie cannot be amencieci by a Memo., that ioo, by

suborciinaie auihority. Hence, ihe Memo oatecj 12'g2-A15 is suspencied in so iar

a,c iiem No i 7 js concerned The 4ih and Sti' ReSpOndentS are direCted to

^^ii^-^i^ -a nar iiarn .h n, ." nor ihc nninis ihai ihev

; DSC teachers against, whom coud cases arependiiig - (D.E.O., West

I Godavarl)

www.ednforum.com

6r"n"" of G.O.iVis.No.63.

5

counseiiing scheduieci io be heici hereaiier

dateci 31 .8.20i5. penoing iut"iher orders'

Admit. issue notice io the responclenis' r'e:urnabie in four r"'eeks'

WTNESS THE HON'BLS SRI JUSTICE SAMUDRALA

GOVINDARAJULU,GHAIRMAN,ANDHRAPRADEShADMINI-9]RAT|VETRIBUNAL AT HYDERABAD.

lssued under my hand ancl the seal of the Tribunal' this the

tsth Day of September, 2015.

Note: 1. Copy of Original Application is enclosed herewith''--- 2 rnl',rec"ipt-ottnis'oroer be treated as receipt cf Rule Nisi in the

above mentioned O'A',

CopryTo:

1, The DisBict Educationa I fficer, West Godavari District at Eluru'

i. ttr. Commi""ioner and Dircctor of School Education'-'

Government of Andhra Pradesh, at Hyderabad'

3. The District Collector & Chairman,-' iranster Committee, West Godavari District at Eluru'

.

+,'ift. U*a"f Educational fficer, Gopalapuram Mand.al' West GodaY?ri Dis?le

;: Til; Iri;ffii Educational fficer, oeva:.apalty Mandat, west Godanri crsurcl

e. Tl'e Prlnctpal Secretary School Education Dcpartment,- State of Andhra Pradesh, A.P' Secretariat, Hyderabad'

7. One C.C. to MR. K. NAMYANA, ADVOCATE

8. Onc C.C tr thc GP FOR SCHOOL EDUCATION (SER')

1n

ed in the iransier

C/bY .i

)li"\

Sd/.T. VENKATESWARLU,

SECTION OFFICER

RKB R/by

i

www.ednforum.com