Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and...

109
Attorney-client privilege waived by vote of the Council on July 6 , 2010; document authorizied for public release. M!chael G. Colantuono MColantuono&?CLLAW. (213) 542- 5739 Colantuono & Levin, PC 11406 Pleasant Valley Road Penn Valley, CA 95946- 9001 Main: (530) 432- 7357 FAX: (530) 432- 7356 WW. CLLAW. CONFIDENTIAL BY FEDEX AND ELECTIONIC MAIL to larry. blazer acgov. org May 26 2010 Lawrence Blazer, Assistant District Attorney Alameda County District Attorney s Office 7677 Oakport Street , Suite 650 Oakland, CA 94621 Re: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Offcial Misconduct Dear Mr. Blazer: Introduction. As you and I discussed by telephone yesterday, Colantuono & Levin is acting as outside counsel for the City of Alameda and write to you to report potential Brown Act violations and other offcial misconduct by Alameda City Councilmember Lena Tam. Because some of these Brown Act violations occurred in relation to Tam s complaints about the performance of Alameda City Attorney Teresa Highsmith and to avoid any conflcts of interest the City Attorney and City Manager have asked us to provide independent advice in this matter and, if we find it appropriate, to report any violations directly to your office. Based on our review of the evidence available to us, we believe that Tam has engaged in numerous Ralph M. Brown Act , Governent Code sections 54950 et seq. (" the Brown Act" violations and other serious offcial misconduct , which warrant removal from office pursuant to a grand jury charge under Government Code sections 3060- 3075. We also conclude that Tam actions may warrant separate, criminal charges under the Brown Act. Accordingly, we provide this report and the enclosed evidence information. We describe below each of the suspected violations or acts of misconduct and the legal authority and evidence as to each. Attached exhibits to this report are the documents upon which our analysis is based and declarations of City Attorney Teresa Highsmith and Interim City Manager Ann Marie Gallant that attest to the genuineness of the exhibits and describe the relationships of various participants in the improper 98317.

description

Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits) - City of Alameda, California 5/26/2010

Transcript of Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and...

Page 1: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)

Attorney-client privilege waived by vote of the Council on July 6 , 2010;document authorizied for public release.

M!chael G. ColantuonoMColantuono&?CLLAW.(213) 542-5739

Colantuono & Levin, PC11406 Pleasant Valley Road

Penn Valley, CA 95946-9001Main: (530) 432-7357

FAX: (530) 432- 7356WW. CLLAW.

CONFIDENTIALBY FEDEX AND ELECTIONIC MAIL

to larry.blazer acgov.org

May 26 2010

Lawrence Blazer, Assistant District AttorneyAlameda County District Attorney s Office7677 Oakport Street, Suite 650Oakland, CA 94621

Re: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Offcial Misconduct

Dear Mr. Blazer:

Introduction. As you and I discussed by telephone yesterday, Colantuono & Levin isacting as outside counsel for the City of Alameda and write to you to report potential Brown Actviolations and other offcial misconduct by Alameda City Councilmember Lena Tam. Becausesome of these Brown Act violations occurred in relation to Tam s complaints about the

performance of Alameda City Attorney Teresa Highsmith and to avoid any conflcts of interestthe City Attorney and City Manager have asked us to provide independent advice in this matterand, if we find it appropriate, to report any violations directly to your office.

Based on our review of the evidence available to us, we believe that Tam has engaged innumerous Ralph M. Brown Act, Governent Code sections 54950 et seq. ("the Brown Act"violations and other serious offcial misconduct, which warrant removal from office pursuant to agrand jury charge under Government Code sections 3060-3075. We also conclude that Tamactions may warrant separate, criminal charges under the Brown Act. Accordingly, we providethis report and the enclosed evidence information. We describe below each of the suspectedviolations or acts of misconduct and the legal authority and evidence as to each. Attached exhibits to this report are the documents upon which our analysis is based and declarations ofCity Attorney Teresa Highsmith and Interim City Manager Ann Marie Gallant that attest to thegenuineness of the exhibits and describe the relationships of various participants in the improper

98317.

Page 2: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 3: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 4: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 5: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 6: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 7: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 8: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 9: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 10: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 11: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 12: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 13: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 14: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 15: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 16: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 17: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 18: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 19: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 20: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 21: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 22: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 23: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 24: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 25: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 26: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 27: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 28: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 29: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 30: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 31: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 32: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 33: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 34: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 35: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 36: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 37: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 38: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 39: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 40: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 41: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 42: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 43: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 44: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 45: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 46: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 47: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 48: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 49: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 50: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 51: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 52: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 53: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 54: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 55: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 56: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 57: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 58: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 59: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 60: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 61: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 62: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 63: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 64: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 65: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 66: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 67: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 68: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 69: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 70: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 71: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 72: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 73: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 74: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 75: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 76: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 77: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 78: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 79: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 80: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 81: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 82: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 83: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 84: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 85: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 86: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 87: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 88: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 89: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 90: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 91: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 92: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 93: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 94: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 95: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 96: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 97: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 98: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 99: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 100: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 101: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 102: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 103: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 104: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 105: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 106: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 107: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 108: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)
Page 109: Potential Brown Act Violations and Other Official Misconduct (2010-05-26 Colantouno Letter and Exhibits)