Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
-
Upload
biljana-alampioska -
Category
Documents
-
view
216 -
download
0
Transcript of Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
1/52
University College London
School of Slavonic and East European Studies
Post-socialism: From Private to Public
Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
Dissertation submitted for theMA Central and South-East European Studies by
Student Number: 1039629
Candidate Number: RVYF2
This dissertation is my own work. Quotations from secondary literature are indicated by
the use of inverted commas and by reference to the author concerned. Literature used in
this essay is indicated in the reading list placed at the end. I have been made aware of the
UCL policy on plagiarism (http://www.ucl.ac.uk/current-students/study/plagiarism/) .
This dissertation is 11.804 words in length.
September 2011
http://www.ucl.ac.uk/current-students/study/plagiarism/http://www.ucl.ac.uk/current-students/study/plagiarism/ -
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
2/52
2
Table of Contents
1. Introduction 31.1Notes on Theory 61.2Notes on Research and Methodology 122. Socialism. The Private 142.1Overall Impression 142.2The context of the Albanian women in Tetovo 162.3Factors that put Albanian women in the Private 182.3.1 Family Values 182.3.2 Reproduction 202.3.3 Education 212.3.4 Employment 252.3.5 Religion 263. Post-Socialism. The Public 283.1In General 283.2Albanian Women and Post-Socialism 293.3Factors that put Albanian Women in the Public 313.3.1 Change of System and Womens Participation in Politics 313.3.2 Education and Employment 353.3.3 Traditions and Religion 383.3.4 Media 393.3.5 Albanian Immigration 404. Conclusion 41
Bibliography 44
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
3/52
3
1. IntroductionFor half a century half of the world experienced variations of a political system based on the
Marxist- Leninist communist ideology. It was a one-party system where generally the
Communist Party had the overall power. Its main goals and characteristics were establishment of
a society with no class divisions, state ownership as means of production and centrally planned
economy. However, one of its particular features that really caught my eye was the equality
between men and women and the need for women to be present and active not only in the
household, but in the labour market and politics as well. As Engels wrote, to emancipate woman
and make her the equal of the man is and remains an impossibility so long as the woman is shut
out from social production and restricted to private domestic labour.1
However, women in different countries experienced socialism and gender equality in a different
manner. Chinese communism certainly differed from the one of the Soviet Union or Yugoslavia.
As a result, it is nearly impossible to make analogies between the communist countries.
Moreover, it is almost equally difficult to make a comparison between countries that belonged to
the same bloc or federation, such as the countries of former Yugoslavia. Each community and
even each particular group of women have experienced socialism differently albeit group of the
same ethnic background or the same country. For example, Macedonian and Albanian women in
Macedonia share different experiences of socialism, but the same can be said for the Albanian
women from Macedonia, Kosovo and Albania who are of equal ethnic background but lived
under different variations of the system. Therefore, in order to provide a well-rounded and
1Women and communism: selections from the writings of Marx, Engels, Lenin and Stalin , p.11.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
4/52
4
detailed analysis of gender relations and role of women during and after state socialism, I
decided not only to focus on a specific country, but also on specific locality. This will enable me
to explore and discuss how particular conditions, economic development, national traditions and
political histories have affected the status of the women.
I focused my research on the Albanian women in the town of Tetovo, Macedonia and the region
that surrounds it, that is the nearby villages. I decided on this locality for two reasons. First of
all, this is a region of Macedonia where the Albanian population is mostly situated. In addition, it
is a town of two universities, both with instruction in Albanian language, as well as a town where
the Albanian political parties have their headquarters. In that sense Tetovo is the capital of the
Albanians in Macedonia. The second reason is of a rather personal nature. Being Tetovo native
and living there for the most of my life makes me an insider who has witnessed not only the
changes that have occurred in terms of the towns development, but also the turn of events for
the people, especially the Albanian women. Like many researchers I am interested in the other.
For me, a young Macedonian woman from Tetovo, there are two others. The first is the
Albanian woman, and the second is the period of socialism that I have heard so much about but
never really experienced. As a result much of my interest in this topic is due to a blend of
personal, historical and cultural experiences and observations.
My research question, as well as my analysis, is influenced by the notion of the private-public
dichotomy very much used by both feminists and anthropologists when defining male-female
relations. Namely, Gal and Kligman argue that women in post-socialism went back to the private
sphere and experienced re-traditionalization of their gender role. Although at first glance using
this dichotomy and Gal and Kligmans observation when analyzing the gender issues in the
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
5/52
5
communist- post-communist era might seem somewhat overused, it is exactly the private-public
divide that provides me with a different perspective on this topic. By choosing to study a specific
community, that is the Albanian women in Macedonia, more particularly the ones in the Tetovo
area, I would like to provide a different light to this dichotomy and show that the line between
public and private is constantly being renegotiated.2
In the context of my study I will challenge the understanding that women went from public to
private after socialism. The goal of my analysis is to present a case study of the opposite: a
community that was in private during socialism and went in public in the period after. What I
will argue is that unlike the most of the women that have experienced socialism, Albanian
women in Tetovo were not visibly present in the public sphere during socialist Macedonia and
consequently they did not go back to the private after the socialism ended. Albanian women
experienced a different shift, instead of going back, or staying in the private; they went from
private to public. By looking at their presence in the two spheres during the two political and
ideological systems I will seek to uncover whether, how and why the role of the Albanian
women has changed. In addition, I will try to offer an explanation of the factors that led to this
change and shift of spheres.
The heart of my research are interviews I have conducted with a particular group of Albanian
women that come from Tetovo and the nearby villages and who have lived in both periods of
socialism and post-socialism. All of the women I have interviewed are university graduates and
hold positions in the public administration, NGOs, private companies or schools. Most of the
2Feminism, the Public and the Private, ed. by Joan B. Landes, p.3.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
6/52
6
women are politically active on local level and some of them on national level as well. All but
the women active in the non-governmental sector are members of the two major Albanian
political parties.
The main discussion is split into two parts. In the first part I look at the general characteristics of
the socialist period in Yugoslavia, Macedonia and Tetovo and what that meant for the Albanian
community and the Albanian women. In addition, I point out several factors that have influenced
the presence of the Albanian women in the private. I focus on family values and traditions,
reproductive behaviour and religion in particular. Part two, addresses the period of post-
socialism and apart from describing its general characteristics in terms of the Albanian
community, it focuses in particular on the factors that have brought the Albanian women into the
public sphere. Here I emphasize the importance of education as the main tool for the process of
emancipation and progress of the Albanian women. Moreover, I analyze the political
participation, employment, media and change in values of the traditional Albanian family.
1.1 Notes on Theory
The Albanians in Western Macedonia are probably the least known part of the Albanian nation
in the Balkans.3 As a result, the Albanian women in Macedonia have been marginalized in terms
of academic attention. There is very little written about them and their position in the
Macedonian society. The prevalent discourse in terms of research and writing about Albanian
women in Macedonia is their traditional role within the family, position of submission to the
husband and high rate of fertility. The Macedonian Academy of Arts and Sciences addresses
3 The New Macedonian Question, ed. by James Pettifer, p. 137.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
7/52
7
exactly the latter especially in the period of socialism. Likewise, Petroska deals with
demographic changes in Macedonia and briefly explains the reasons behind the high
reproduction particularly among the Albanian rural women. She points out the problems with the
low level of education, traditional values and the non-presence of the Albanian woman in the
workforce. Studies of this kind, although rather brief, provide a starting point for analyzing the
reproduction behaviour among Albanian families in Macedonia. Apart from this, the Albanian
women as separate group in the Macedonian society have not been specifically addressed yet.
Earlier and also more recent studies have mainly focused on the integration of the Albanian
community in the Macedonian society, the co-existence between Macedonians and Albanians,
perspectives for interethnic dialogue, as well as ethnic identity and ethnic politics. Babuna
addresses the Albanian nationalism in Macedonia and Kosovo and argues that the Albanian
ethnic identity is more important than their religion. Similarly, Barary and Moser, when talking
about ethnic mobilization, emphasize the importance of the ethno-national identification, as well
as the fact that the norms and rules set by the Albanian culture and tradition are a lot more
important for the Albanian community than the official norms and regulations. Barary and
Moser talk explicitly about the position of the Albanians in the Macedonian society and their
very limited access to political, social and economic resources during socialism. On the other
hand, Starova points out the positive aspects of the communist state for the Albanians in
Macedonia, such as education in Albanian language, increased participation of the Albanians in
the political organizations, but also stressing the need for family planning and population policy
that will address the issue of high birth rate among the Albanians in Macedonia.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
8/52
8
When it comes to gender issues in Macedonia in general, Ilk Thiessen provides a valuable
ethnography on young professional women in Skopje. She explores how young Macedonian
urban women explore and define their identity in a period of change when Macedonia is leaving
the socialism behind and creates its own identity and nationhood. Thiessen is investigating the
intersection of gender and national identity.4 Similarly, my intention is to take the womens
point of view and womens experience in times of change and democratization, but instead on
young Macedonians, my focal point is on the middle-aged Albanian women.
Exploring modern masculinities among the Albanians in Macedonia, in the north-eastern town of
Kumanovo, Dimova emphasizes the importance of education for overcoming the backwardness
among Albanian women. My findings also point out that education is perceived as the main tool
for emancipating not only the Albanian women but women from other ethnic groups and
elevating them on a status equal to men. Dimovas research points out the importance of
preservation of the Albanian culture, heritage and lineage and the dilemma of tradition vs.
modernity among young Albanian women. Brunnbauer makes a link between education and
high fertility among Albanian women linking the two major issues that affect this particular
group. Finally Ristova acknowledges that the least examined feature of the socialist system
transformation is the womens political representation. Arguing that Macedonia became a
machocracy after communism she makes analysis of how the electoral systems in Macedonia
have effected womens representation in the parliament. However, she also concludes that there
is a change in the political culture among women in Macedonia including the ones of Albanian
background.
4 Ilk Thiessen, Waiting for Macedonia: Identity in a Changing World, p.17.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
9/52
9
There are a very scarce number of studies that address the issues of women in Macedonia and the
reason behind this is that the academic interest in post-socialist Macedonia has certainly been
overshadowed by the unfolding of the Yugoslav tragedy, the wars in Bosnia and Croatia as well
as the Kosovo crisis. In the period right after the dissolution of Yugoslavia, women have been
analyzed and portrayed mainly as refugees or victims of war and rape. They have received
almost no attention in terms of their political activity and their presence outside of the home. In
Macedonia, women have been set aside as well. The issues of the Albanians as one of the largest
minority group in Macedonia, the use of the Albanian language and symbols, as well as the
conflict of 2001 are the ones that received attention. Moreover, authors prefer to deal with the
question of building the Macedonian nationhood and the struggle for independence that includes
the name dispute with Greece.
On the other hand the literature on women and post-communism is of a much greater extent.
Mainly dealing with countries of the former SSSR, Eastern and Central Europe as well as some
of the countries of former Yugoslavia the emphasis is put on the way women experienced
politics during communism and how that has changed with the transition. Often addressed are
the emerging issues of re-traditionalization of the role of women, the surfacing of domestic
violence, womens access to political power, but also rape as tool of war where women are the
victims.
In addition, there is extensive literature on the public/private divide when it comes to womens
and gender issues. Anthropologists have generally found womens association with the domestic
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
10/52
10
sphere strong in all cultures.5
However, not all feminists agree with this statement and the
public/private dichotomy. Feminists often contest the fluidity of the division and challenge the
universality and applicability of it. Landes (1998), Rosaldo and Lamphere (1974), and Moore
(1988) all contribute in the analysis of this dichotomy and often challenge it.
The work that influences my study the most is the one of Gal and Kligman. Making an
intersection between the role of gender and the transformation of communist Europe they show
how gender has shaped the political and the economic change in the region. Their chapter on the
Dilemmas of Public and Private was particularly helpful in understanding the gender relations
before and after communism. Although the ethnographic component of their study is focused on
Eastern and Central Europe, the theory and argument behind it is a valuable background for any
studies concerning gender and socialism. As Dubisch notes in her research on gender and
masculinity in rural Greece, roles of women and man are strongly linked to the division of
private and public and this is a promising place to start with. Indeed, although my study does not
necessarily confirm the re-traditionalization of women, it definitely takes the private/public
dichotomy as the starting point.
Looking at society from the point of view of women thus leads us not simply to a different view
of women, but to a different view of society itself.6 Post-communism brought new changes and
challenges. The disappearance of a communist equality paradigm and the old -new
conservative ideology of State, Nation or Religion, in each post-communist country, were
crucially based on the strategy of retraditionalization of womens identities, their social roles,
5 Jill Dubisch, Gender and Power in Rural Greece, p.9.6 Ibid. p.5
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
11/52
11
and symbolic representations. Therefore many authors (usually female) look at socialism and
post-socialism exactly through the prism of gender and women. Ramet (1999), Corrin (1992,
1999), Johnson and Robinson (2007), Rueschemeyer and Wolchik (2009), and Matland and
Montgomery (2003) all provide gendered perspective of post-communism, thus offering
extensive literature on the topic. Transition toward neoliberal capitalism is accompanied by the
re-traditionalization of gender roles, both regarding the division of labour and sexuality. 7
However, at the turn of the millennium, as Milic argues, there is awakening of the existential
need for the voice of women to be heard.8Although from working women in socialism they
became wives and mothers in the period after there is less passivity among women 20 years
after the fall of communism.9
In the paragraphs that follow I will show in detail why and how
Albanian women went from passive to active during the transition and today. Unlike the rest of
the women they were wives and mothers during socialism, but nowadays they have turned into
working women and politicians because they have learnt how to be women in a system that
offered new conditions and new opportunities for them.
Trying to understand the reasons for womens participation in the public and political sphere
Paxton and Kunovich offered a good explanation. According to them there are three types of
factors: structural, political and ideological.10
Although a blend of the three gives the reason of
the presence of Albanian women in Macedonia in the public sphere, it seems the ideological
explanation to be of a greater importance. It is true that educational and professional
7Vesna Nikoli Ristanovi, Post-communism: Womens Lives in Transition, p.2.8Andjelka Milic, The womens movement in Serbia and Montenegro at the turn of the m illennium: a sociologicalstudy of women's groups, p.72.9 Chris Corrin, Superwomen and the Double Burden, p.167.10Pamela Paxton and Sheri Kunovich, Womens Political Representation: The Importance of Ideology, p.87.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
12/52
12
opportunities provide access to involvement in politics and that the electoral systems do have an
effect. However, Paxton and Kunovich argue the cultural norms can limit womens
opportunities to participate in politics.11
Following that logic it makes sense that the patriarchal
Balkan mentality12 present among most of the countries of former Yugoslavia, including the
Albanians in Macedonia affects the role of the women in the society. As I explain later on, the
Albanian family values, traditions and beliefs have had a major role in shaping the position of
the Albanian women in the society and they certainly have not had very positive effect. This was
especially the case before and during socialism. It is true that the traditional mentality has
changed due to reasons explained in detail later on. However, elements of the traditional and
patriarchal beliefs are still present and still affect the womens presence in the public sphere but
to a much lesser extent.
1.2Notes on Research and MethodologyAs someone born only few years before the collapse of Yugoslavia, it was impossible for me to
have any personal memories from that period. Everything I have known about communism
comes from the stories of my grandparents. What is unusual is that my two sets of grandparents
gave me two different perspectives, one for and one against socialism. This gave me the
motivation to do a research that involves looking into that time period in order to have my own
hands-on experience. Living in a town where the majority of the people are from nationality,
ethnicity and religion different from mine, I developed specific interest in that community. In
addition, scrutinizing the obvious and not so obvious changes happening in my town with both
11 Ibid. p.91.12 Chris Corrin, Superwomen and the double burden, p.160.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
13/52
13
the Albanian and Macedonian community provided a good base and a good starting point to
form my research.
Because of the limited sources on the lives and position of the Albanian women in the
Macedonian society both before and after socialism I had to implement some qualitative methods
in my research. In order to better grasp and understand the situation I decided to be a little bit of
ethnographer and observer in my home town. My research consisted of spending 2 weeks in
Tetovo in July 2011. During these two weeks I conducted individual interviews with Albanian
women born between 1953 and 1970. I visited most of them at their workplace, since all of them
are employed mostly in the public sector, mainly educational institutions, but also NGOs and
private companies. Two of my interviewees are members of the Municipal Council. Since the
ones who were employed in schools and educational institutions had their summer holidays I met
and spoke with them in cafes or restaurants. I conducted all of my interviews in Macedonian,
although all the interviewees were ethnic Albanians. However, the language was not an issue
since they are somewhat part of the Albanian local elite, and all of them have excellent command
of Macedonian which is also the official language in the country. I did the translation of the
interviews into English and the analyses. The goal is to give a very specific, localized analysis of
the female Albanian community in Tetovo, Macedonia and their perception of the socialism and
post-socialism whilst exploring their role and their position in these political systems.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
14/52
14
2. Socialism. The Private2.1 Overall impressions
The Yugoslav state consisted of six republics and two provinces and was based on the principle
of brotherhood and unity which promised equal treatment and equal opportunities for everyone.
During 45 years of socialism, women in Yugoslavia became as free as men to work outside the
home.13 One of the main goals of the socialist system was to include large number of women
into the paid labour force. Despite the double and even the triple burden ,14 in terms of the given
possibilities to be active and present in the workforce and the local and national politics,
Yugoslavias socialist ideology was favourable to women.15 The state-socialist regime did
accomplish a high degree of social, economic, and political participation for women, but that
participation came at a high price.16
The role of a housewife and a mother never disappeared; it
was just extended with the role of a woman worker. Even then, the extensive maternity policies
made women inconvenient workers. Unemployment rates among women were always higher in
comparison to their male counterparts.
Additionally, very often the brotherhood and unity principle was just a rhetoric, rather than
action. No matter how hard the League of Communists tried to impose this principle and with
that the equality of men and women, marginalization of certain groups was unavoidable. Often
women from nationalities and women from certain areas did not have the opportunities to use the
13Garth Massey, Karen Hahn and Dusko Sekulic, Women, Men and the "Second Shift" in Socialist Yugoslavia,p.360.14 The triple burden includes (paid employment, housework and political/community responsibilities Massey,Hahn
and Sekulic, p. 364.15 Ibid. p.363.16Richard E. Matland and Kathleen A. Montgomery, Recruiting Women to National Legislatures: A GeneralFramework with Applications to Post-Communist Democracies in Womens Access to Political Power in Post-communist Europe ed. by Matland and Montgomery, pp.19-42 (p.36).
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
15/52
15
benefits from the ideology of gender equality. Although [o]n paper Yugoslav women seemed to
have made significant strides forward,17 the situation differed from republic to republic. The
formal guarantees issued to women18
often remained formal and only on paper. During
communism two structural problems in relation to gender equality appear. First of all, women
tended to be concentrated in certain professions and excluded from others, and next, women
remained underrepresented in leadership bodies.19
Women remained responsible for the
household labour, and womens political participation was encouraged but tightly controlled.20
When shifting the focus from Yugoslavia to Macedonia and its national minorities it is important
to note that the minorities, including the Albanian one were not very likely to join the League of
Communists.21
Their low interest in joining the party reflected in their attitudes towards the
beliefs of the socialist ideology. It is not surprising that the besides the efforts of the socialist
institutions, the traditional beliefs about the role of women were not in fact transformed not only
among the Albanian, but among all the other Yugoslav ethnic groups. Other factors not directly
connected with the state policies also shaped the role of women. When it comes to Albanian
women in Macedonia and in Tetovo, apart from the political system as a factor, there are indeed
other factors that conditioned the womens (non-)participation in the public sphere. It is exactly
these other factors that will be discussed in the following paragraphs.
17Sabrina P. Ramet, In Titos Time, in Gender Politics in the Western Balkans, ed. by Ramet, pp. 89-105 (p. 95).18 Ibid. p.94.19 Ibid. p.97.20Robert M. Kunovich, Ethnic Conflict, Group Polarization, and Gender Attitudes in Croatia,p.1091.21 Hugh Poulton, Who are the Macedonians?, p.122.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
16/52
16
2.2 The context of the Albanian women in Tetovo
Macedonia was one of the republics that were part of Yugoslavia. It was the most southern
republic where blend of people coming from different ethnic, national and religious backgrounds
lived together. The Albanian population was recognized as nationality, but not as its own nation.
According to the 1974 constitution Macedonia was a state of the Macedonian people and the
Albanian and Turkish minorities. In Macedonia, the most of the Albanian population lives in the
western and north-western part of the country. The Tetovo area, being situated in the valley of
Polog in the north-western part of Macedonia, has a majority of Albanian population. In his
overview of the Albanian population in Macedonia, Trifunovski explains that the first Albanian
settlers came in the Tetovo area in the second half of the 18th
century, in the period between 1780
and 1840. They came from the clans that lived in Northern Albania and usually settled in areas
already populated by the Orthodox Slavs.22
In 1939 the Tetovo area had 75,000 inhabitants, 82% of them had agriculture as their main
occupation and over 60% of the Tetovo population aged over 10 was illiterate.23
The size of the
population and especially of the Albanian population in Tetovo was constantly growing. It
increased in the city from 7,155 inhabitants in 1953, to 6,435 inhabitants in 1961 and 15,388
inhabitants in 1971. In the wider Tetovo area in 1953 there were 54,893 Albanians, in 1961 there
were 60,242 and in 1971 the population grew up to 87,715.24
The overall population of the
Tetovo area in the 1970s grew up to 132,000 and Tetovo became one of the most densely
22 Jovan Trifunoski,Albansko stanovnitvo u Socijalistikoj Republici Makedoniji: antropogeografska i etnografska
istraivanja23ivko Stefanovski,Poloka panorama, 1973, pp.5-6.24 Demographic Data from Trifunoski p.105.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
17/52
17
populated areas in Macedonia.25
However, the town and its surroundings remained
underdeveloped for a long time and this affected the status of women and the status of Albanian
women in the society in particular.
Before, during, and somewhat after socialism the position of the Albanian woman in Tetovo was
delicate and inferior, subordinated to biological imperatives, religious influences, as well as
traditional and patriarchal family understandings. Albanian women were perceived as backward
and traditional. Very few of them were educated and most of them did not participate in the paid
labour. It will be exaggeration to claim that Albanian women were isolated group within the
system. However, their participation outside of the household bubble was rather rare.
On the other hand, Macedonian women fully participated in the employment sector, as well as
the public and political institutions. The gender equality ideal seemed to have worked much
better for them than for the Albanian women. Marija Bakalova, a woman engineer, worker and
politician, in an interview found in the Stefanovski monography on Tetovo in 1973 states that
half of the workers employed in the factory Tetex are women. She finds paid employment as an
important progressive factor in materializing the political and legal equality of women. The
woman of that time is a mother, a housewife, a worker and an active participant in the society.
Namely, in 1973 in the textile factory Tetex, there were 15 women in the workers council and
one of them was a member of the Board of Directors.26
25 Stefanovski, p.1426 Ibid. pp.16-18
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
18/52
18
However, the symbolic distance that existed between the Albanian community and the
Macedonian/Yugoslav state kept the Albanian women in the private sphere. Therefore, it is not
unexpected that my respondents had negative attitudes towards communism. They did not
experience a double burden, but a double marginalization and discrimination. There are several
factors that managed to maintain the women in that position for long time. Firstly, they were
marginalized by the state by not being given equal opportunities for employment nor political
involvement, not only because they were women, but also because they were members of a
minority, and secondly they were marginalized within their own families, because their traditions
and patriarchal order would not let them be present and active out of the household.
2.3 Factors that put Albanian women in the private
2.3.1 Family Values
When migrating to the Tetovo area the Albanian settlers did not group into clans so the tribal
organization did not continue.27 Instead they lived in extended households that were typical for
Macedonia in the period before the Second World War. During socialism the extended
household was the primary form of organization for the Albanian families as well. Still apparent
were some of the leftovers of the traditional tribal mentality. Every Albanian family with the
course of time tried to have as many children as possible.28
Male children were especially
desired. The household felt stronger and happier when there were more members. Since
childhoodwomen are brought up with a sense of exclusive responsibility to their family.29 The
woman is a child-bearer, mother and housewife. Her role is to give birth to as many children as
27 Trifunoski, p. 126.28 Trifunoski, p. 97.29Platek, Monika, Hostages of Destiny: Gender Issues in Todays Poland, p.12.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
19/52
19
possible, especially boys and to preserve the Albanian culture. In other words it is the woman
that should preserve her traditional role. For Albanian women, especially those in the rural areas,
the households external environment is exclusively a male domain.30
On the other hand, male
children are brought up with the notion of being a real man, that is someone who is in charge of
both the private and the public.31
Consequently, during socialism the Albanian women are victims of the patriarchal society.32
The division of public and private takes its traditional form, although women do try to change it.
In 1985 in Tetovo to see a girl in a sweets shop or see a married woman on her own was
almost impossible. Traditionally, the boys could have gone out of the household but the
girls should have stayed at home so they could get married. If they went out of the home
no one would like to marry them.33
The males are smarter than females, and you know what they say of women: long on hair, short
on brains. That is the way people, especially the ones in the rural areas thought,34 another
respondent born in the town, but married in one of the close by villages told me.
Since the family is considered the one institution that provides continuity with the past,35 it was
through early marriages and the opportunity to give birth to more children that the patriarchal
family values were preserved. Additionally, the early marriages were also a result of the
30Bette Denich, Sex and Power in the Balkans in Woman, Culture and Society ed. by Rosaldo, Zimbalist andLamphere, pp.243-262 (p. 248).31Rozita Dimova, Modern Masculinities: Ethnicity, Education and Gender in Macedonia, p.306.32Women, State, and Party in Eastern Europe ed. by Sharon L. Wolchik and Alfred G. Meyer, p.141.33 Xh. K. interview with the author 11.07.201134 D.Xh. interview with the author 19.07.201135 Susan Gal and Gail Kligman, Politics of Gender after Socialism, p.68.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
20/52
20
unemployment of the women in the public sector. As a consequence, the women kept their old
role of demographic reproducer and a mother.36
2.3.2 Reproduction
One of the outcomes of the traditional family values and the women being responsible mainly in
and for the family and the household is the high birth rate. According to Trifunovski, Albanian
families both in the urban and rural Tetovo area had 5-7 children, and male children were
specifically desired. Both males and females married young, so women had more opportunities
to give birth. In 1971 the average family size was 8.7 members.37
My respondents explained that
the high birth was a consequence of the unemployment of the women in the public sector as well
as their very poor education. In the undeveloped Tetovo, Albanian families were mainly farmers
so they looked at the number of children as a possible workforce on the fields. The higher
number of children especially boys, the more people to work on the fields and improve the socio-
economic situation of the family.
Apart from filling family needs for labor [and] income,38 there are other social and structural
explanations for the high birth rate among Albanian women. In its publication on the Problems
with the Demographic Development in Socialist Republic of Macedonia, the Macedonian
Academy for Arts and Sciences particularly points out the problem of high fertility and high
birth rate characterizing the birth rate in the Tetovo area as irrational. The reasons behind the
high birth rate are the low level of education among women as well as the traditional and
36Problemi so demografskiot razvoj vo SR Makedonija ed. by Ksente Bogoev, p. 266.37 Trifunovski, p.148.38 Gal and Kligman, p. 21.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
21/52
21
patriarchal norms of behaviour within the family. The low level of education and unemployment
among Albanian women, as well as their subordinate role within the family made them nothing
more than birth-machines, as one of my respondents noted, not very happily though. In the later
1980s with the rise of the Albanian nationalism especially in Kosovo, the Macedonian
government perceived the high birth rate among the Albanians in Tetovo and in Macedonia as a
threat. The high levels of reproduction were seen as dangerous, out of control and polluting.39
A 1983 report of the League of Communists of Macedonia says: The high birth rate among the
Albanian nationalitycreates and will continue to create especially in the near future serious
difficulties in the sphere of healthcare, education and upbringing, housing policy, employment
and in other spheres of social work and life.40 As a consequence of the women in the private and
the men in the public, the issue of reproduction was highly politicized.
2.3.3 Education
Another politicized, but of a much greater importance for the Albanian women was the issue of
education. The socialist national policy promoted compulsory primary education and non-
discrimination on the basis of gender with the result that both sexes were to be equally
represented in education.41
This was one of the most positive things that the socialism made for
the Albanian women.42 However, Albanian girls did not continue schooling beyond primary
education. They stayed at home and bore with the everyday household activities and domestic
labour. It was exactly the lack of education that put the Albanian women into the private and did
39 Gal and Kligman, p. 23.40 Slavko Milosavlevski and Mire Tomovski,Albanians in the Republic of Macedonia 1945-1995: legislative,political documentation, statistics,p.182.
41 Massey, Hahn and Sekulic, p.363.
42 Xh. K. interview with the author 11.07.2011
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
22/52
22
not let them into the public sphere. The factors that influenced the lower level of education came
from two environments, first the family and next the system.
The material and the social status of the family, the distance of the school, the need for domestic
labour, the early marriage and the religious rather than state schooling affected the education of
the Albanian girls.43
The family saw the education as something that would make young women
behave improperly.Education makes a woman promiscuous44If the girl continues her
education she might marry someone she is not supposed to, she will not respect the traditions and
the family, a respondent who was the only girl that went to secondary school in 1967 in the
medical school in Tetovo told me. Furthermore she continued: I was on my own among all the
boys.45 If the family was educated, if the father was a teacher or a doctor they usually let the
girls go to school, otherwise girls had to fight for themselves. I was lucky that my father was a
teacher and my brothers also gave me their support.46 The selection of which girls went to
school and which did not depended on the education of the family, their socio-economic position
and their relation with the system. In that sense an elite formed, only some girls were able to
continue their education, attend secondary school and even university. However, those girls, now
my respondents did fight for the others and tried to challenge the traditional public/private
divide. In 8th grade my girl friends and I decided to run away if our parents did not let us go to
high school. We knew of two girls that already did that and we were ready to blackmail our
parents. Education was more important than anything.47
43 Bogoev, p. 120.44 Dimova, p.308.45 Xh. K. interview with the author 11.07.201146 D. Xh. Interview with the author 19.07.201147 Z. H. interview with the author 13.07.2011
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
23/52
23
However, apart from the family, the system also influenced the level of education. Although
primary education was mandatory and most of the time available in Albanian language, that was
not always the case with the secondary education. Sometimes there was a Macedonian male
teacher in an all-Albanian village. The problem was that firstly the students did not know the
language and secondly the traditional Albanian values would not let the parents have their
daughter in a classroom with a male teacher.48
Cases like this were extreme; however, they did
exist.
Higher education was even less available for Albanian girls. In Macedonia there was an absence
of higher education in Albanian language and the language was a barrier that had to be
overcome. The opening of the university in Prishtina in 1968 where the instruction was in
Albanian, brought new prospects for the education of Albanian women in Macedonia. For the
first time they were able to gain higher education in their native language. However, since the
university was in Kosovo, rather than Macedonia, families, especially male relatives were rather
resistant towards sending young girls to be on their own in Prishtina. One of my interviewees,
currently a member of the council of the municipality of Tetovo was among the first women who
continued their education at the University of Pristina. She said that although her family was
very supportive of her going to university when her relatives and uncles found out that she was
going to Prishtina on her own, they immediately reacted and tried to convince her father that
going to university was a bad idea. However, it was women like her that opened the doors for
other women to get out of the private and show their presence into the public, first through
education and then through employment. When I got married my mother-in-law thought that I
wasnt going to respect the family because I had university education. However, she managed to
48 Z.H. interview with the author 13.07.2011
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
24/52
24
renegotiate and balance between her university education and the values of the family. I
cleaned, I cooked, I went to work and I made sure my children, my nieces and nephews got the
proper education. One day our first-door neighbor, the wife of the hodza
49
told my mother-in-law
that she wants her sons to marry an educated woman. At that point I knew I started to make some
change. I started erasing the negative image created about educated women. It was very hard, but
worth it.50
I talked to another respondent who got her education in the 1980s and she told me that sometime
it seemed like the system and the state did not want the Albanian women to be educated.
This was especially the case in the 1980s and I experienced it. The first and the second
year of high school I had classes in Albanian language, however, in the third and the
fourth year all of the classes were entirely in Macedonian. That was just wrong. I wanted
to learn the language and the history, but not being able to study in the mother tongue
was a great disadvantage.51
Another somewhat concerning point about the education in Albanian language in the 1980s is
that the teachers were often inadequate. For example, in the academic year 1980/81 over 20% of
the teachers in the High School Kiril Pejchinovikj did not have the necessary qualification. In the
Medical School Center Nikola Stain, this was the case with half of the teachers.52
Therefore, both
the family and the system disadvantaged the Albanian women. Their intellectual capacity and
their educational and professional potentials were not used adequately.
49 Hodza is the name for the local Muslim priest50 D. Xh. interview with the author 19.07.201151 R. C. interview with the author 15.07.201152 Milosavlevski and Tomovski, p.159.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
25/52
25
2.3.4 Employment
That public and private are concepts ofinstability and mutability53 is somewhat pointed out by
the Albanian women who are present as employees in the public sector during the socialist
period. In this period women were mainly teachers and nurses. They were not present in any
other field of employment which is true not only for them as a group, but for all the women in
Macedonia and Yugoslavia. As it is widely known, women predominate[d] in lowly paid and
low-skilled work in the service, education and cultural sectors.54 So, the situation with the very
few Albanian women that had an employment was not any different.
Being poorly educated, swamped with family responsibilities and on top of that not being part of
the paid labour, Albanian women were cut off of the public sphere. However, the communist
government recognized that [t]he employment of the Albanian woman in the public sector is
the elementary precondition for her overall emancipation.55 Yet, the intention of the system to
involve the women in the workforce was weaker than the traditional value system of the
Albanian extended households. For example, in 1983 the textile factory Tetex from Tetovo
created employment opportunities for some of the Albanian women and girls by opening
branches of this plant in the nearby villages.56
Nevertheless, the limited opportunities for
employment in the public sector for the Albanian men, the low socio-economic position and the
number of children put the Albanian families in a position where they had to migrate and work
abroad. Namely, in the Tetovo area one third of the employed people worked abroad.57
53Leonore Davidoff, Regarding Some Old Husbands Tales: Public and Private in Feminist Theory inFeminism,the Public and the Private ed. by Landes, pp. 164-194 (p.165).54 Corrin, Superwomen and the double burden, p. 157.55 Bogoev, p.266.56 Milosavlevski and Tomovski, p.208.57 Bogoev, p.21.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
26/52
26
According to Trifunovski, the high birth rate allowed Albanian families to send their sons
abroad, usually in Western Europe. Migration was accepted as a solution for the
unemployment.
58
In the meantime, females stayed at home being prepared for the roles of
mothers and housewives.
2.3.5 Religion
Religious beliefs may also shape gender ideologies and regulate household tasks.59 This is true
for the Albanians in the Tetovo area. For them following the rule of the Islam is particularly
important and it is part of the family values. This is especially true for the rural areas where
many of the women were covered with veils.
When talking to my respondents, religion was one of the most sensitive topics. All of them are
religious to a certain extent and admitting that the religion had negative effect during the socialist
period was not easy.
During socialism religion was prohibited in the public. Namely, it was recognized as the private
affair of the individual and therefore it excluded any legitimate religious public activity.60 As a
result the Quran was not translated into Albanian language.61
The girls who wore veils could not
be admitted in schools because the veil was a symbol of religion. One of the most extreme forms
of prohibition of religion was the changing of personal names that had explicit religious
connotations.
58 Ibid. p. 21.59Elizabeth Miklya Legerski and Marie Cornwall, Working-Class Job Loss, Gender, and the Negotiation ofHousehold Labor,p. 450.60 Ramet, p. 91.61 This is a piece of information I got from one of the respondents (interview with Drita) but I cannot confirm it
since I couldnt find when was the first translation of the Quran published in Albanian and brought or published inMacedonia.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
27/52
27
On the other hand, the ordinary Albanian men and women did not know what the Quran said. It
was the hodzas who spread the religion and the traditional families followed their instructions.
They interpreted the holy book in a very traditional manner: the women should stay at home;
education is not needed for them. If women went to school they would have to unveil and if they
do that they will be less worthy the religion further preached.
Therefore, Muslim womens lives and the choices they face are influenced as much by
patriarchal social arrangements as they are by religious ideology.62 The limited freedom of
religious belief on one hand and the traditional role of women praised by the hodzas on the other,
made Albanian women in Tetovo attached to the household with very restricted possibilities for
education and employment and almost no opportunity for political and social engagement.
62 Camillia Fawzi El-Sohl and Judy Mabro, Introduction inMuslim Women's Choices : Religious Belief and SocialReality ed. by Fawzi El-Sohl and Mabro, pp.1-32 (p.1).
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
28/52
28
3. Part 2: Post-socialism. The Public3.1 In General
Post-socialism gave a new dimension of life to all Yugoslav people. For some the changes were
good, for others bad, but one thing was certain, the change was happening. All of a sudden there
was an entire transformation, shift from one-party to multi-party system. Only in Macedonia
more than dozen political parties emerged before the first democratic elections took place.
Womens lives transformed as well. The economic crisis, the increased unemployment and the
decline of standard of living that characterized the post-socialist period had an impact on the
change of gender identities and the increase of the culturally determined imbalance of power that
already existed between men and women.63
Women were pushed from public back to the private.
The opportunities for them to be politically active became limited.64
One of the main
characteristics of the early period of post-communism was the absence of women in politics.
Although a number of political parties were created, women did not have substantial roles in
their creation and the parties felt neither the need nor the pressure to involve women. Because
post-communist men gained decisive political and reproductive control over women, these
societies are often labelled as male democracies or new patriarchies or phallocracies.65
Unfortunately it was not only politics, but also employment that left women out. The exclusion
of women from paid employmentwas just another route by which women [were] expelled
63 Sanja opi, Wife Abuse in the Countries of Former Yugoslavia, p. 49.64Jana Gohrisch, Daphne Hahn, Gabriele Jhnert, Hildegard Maria Nickel, Iris Peinl and Katrin Schfgen, Genderin Transition in Gender and Transition in Eastern and Central Europe Proceedings ed. by Jhnert, Gohrisch, Hahn,Nickel, Peinl and Schfgen pp.11-20 (p.13).65 Ramet, p. 154.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
29/52
29
from the public sphere and forced once again into the private one- to economic dependence on
men and, in the end, to political passivity.66
However, it was not all dark and negative. Although there are not necessarily better opportunities
or life for women after communism, women are free to define their gender identities. There is
wide range of gender ideologies available both for men and women and they enable them to
construct their own identity that fits best their needs, values and beliefs.67
Also, there is more
freedom and flexibility for negotiating gender, power structures, divisions and boundaries. The
era of monopoly over gender was over. This enabled women to construct roles that fit their own
social, economic, political or any other purpose. The opportunity and choice to renegotiate
gender and power relations was finally open.68
3.2 Albanian women and Post-socialism
Albanian women had slightly different experience of the change and the transformation. Initially,
during socialism they were not an actual part of the public sphere, the paid labour and the
politics. Although there were few women delegates on local level, as well as one woman
delegate on national level, their presence was not very visible.69
In terms of education, few
women went beyond secondary school. For Albanian women in Tetovo and Macedonia it was
this new system that was going to be the starting point for making the social transformation.
66 Corrin, Superwomen and the double burden, p. 168.67Janet Elise Johnson and Jean C. Robinson, Living Gender inLiving Gender after Communism ed. by Johnsonand Robinson, pp.1-21 (p.2).68 Ibid, p.2.69 I managed to find only one woman that was a delegate on national level. There are no official statistics or
information on the number of Albanian women involved in the state communist institutions.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
30/52
30
Tetovo has changed significantly indeed. Most of the people that worked abroad during
socialism have invested back in the region. Even the look of the town has changed significantly.
From undeveloped area during socialism, now it is one of the most developed towns in the
country. New buildings appear every day. As a town of two universities, it attracts students
mainly from the Western part of Macedonia, Kosovo and Albania since the language of
instruction at the universities is mainly Albanian.
What is more striking is that the appearance and looks of the Albanian women changed
significantly as well. In the1990s the way I was able to distinguish between Albanian and any
other women was that most of the Albanian women wore veils. However, almost overnight this
has changed. The veils are almost gone, only some elderly women or young very religious ones
wear them. The veil is not a symbol of the Albanian woman anymore. With this act she shows
that she does not want to hide or cover, but that she is ready to be present in the public and voice
her opinion, educate herself and make decisions. What is more important is that even if she
wears the veil she can still continue her education.
Realizing the situation they were in and the possibilities that were offered, the Albanian women
in Tetovo firmly decided to escape from the time of baby machines and become actors and
creators of their own lives and affect the community and the society as a whole. The shift from
socialism to multi-party system has brought new definition of the public/private. Indeed, it
allowed Albanian women to go from private to public, yet still be involved in both spheres.
However, the move from private to public did not happen smoothly. It is far from true that
Albanian women and women in Tetovo and Macedonia in general enjoy equal rights as men.
Therefore, the renegotiating of the public/private divide is far from over. The only certain thing
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
31/52
31
is that Albanian women lived through different conditions during socialism and therefore their
way into the public is happening in a different manner. The border of the public/private is
shifting and it is yet to be shaped. What is essential is to look at the particular conditions that
allowed the Albanian women to enter the public sphere. Namely, the change of the system, the
availability to pursue higher education in Albanian language, the electoral system and the media
are the main factors that let the Albanian women out of the household. Changes in the influence
of tradition, mentality and religion are visible as well. Yet, although the change of the system,
the social and economic conditions, as well as the resistance of the individual and the collective
shapes the traditional beliefs concerning gender, it is very hard to completely change and modify
the core structure of the beliefs.70
The example of the Albanian women in Tetovo shows that
everything is adjustable and negotiable. At the end of the day, they did not abandon the private.
Instead they adjusted to the new conditions that they partially created in order to be women,
human beings and citizens.71
3.3 Factors that put Albanian women in the public
3.3.1 Change of system and womens participation in politics
If during socialism womens issues were not regarded as a separate question, after socialism
womens issues do not get any attention. National survival, protection and security are on the top
of the list. Womens problems have been ignored and women have been marginalized as political
subjects. They gained almost no attention by the newly formed political parties.72
Moreover,
70 Cecilia L. Ridgeway and Shelley J. Correl, Unpacking the Gender System: A Theoretical Perspective on GenderBeliefs and Social Relations,p. 528.71 Zuzana Kiczkova, Why Do We Need Feminist Theories, in Gender and Transition in Eastern and CentralEurope Proceedings ed. by Jhnert, Gohrisch, Hahn, Nickel, Peinl and Schfgen pp. 124-132 (p. 124).
72 Corrin, Superwomen and the double burden, p.173.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
32/52
32
although women from different ethnic groups have different needs and deal with different
problems, the specific position of the women that belong to certain ethnic groups is not reflected
in the programs and strategies of the ethno-dimensioned political parties.
73
So, it was true for
Macedonia, as it was for the other post-socialist countries that the transition to democracy was
accompanied by significant decline in womens political representation.74
Women were losers in the first democratic election. There was no formal obstacle to their
participation; however, they were not encouraged to participate as candidates.75
In Macedonia
5.4% of the candidates were women and even less were elected. On local level, in Tetovo during
the 1992 local elections, there was only one Albanian woman elected in the Municipality
council.76
Women in post-communist countries still live in a culture that perceives politics as
male domain. Therefore, women are still underrepresented in these 20-year old democracies.77
Yet, [o]pportunities for political access are greater in a democratic regime than an authoritarian
one.78 The first political action among women in Tetovo was taken with the formation of the
bloc of Albanian political parties, the Party for Democratic Prosperity and the National
Democratic Party. What women initially did is that they divided their membership between these
two parties. However, very soon they realized that they would not have any influence concerning
issues that target the Albanian women in rural and urban Tetovo, so they decided to act out of the
73Interetnicki dijalog od perspektiva na zenite, p. 35.
74 Melanie M. Hughes, Armed Conflict, International Linkages, and Womens Participation in DevelopingNations,p. 176.75 Corrin, Superwomen and the double burden p.174.76 Xh. K. interview with the author 11.07.201177Richard E. Matland, Womens Representation in Post- Communist Europe in Womens Access to PoliticalPower, ed by. Matland and Montgomery, pp.321-342 (p. 339).78 Kathleen A. Montgomery, Introduction in Womens Access to Political Power, ed by. Matland andMontgomery, pp. 1-18 (p. 3).
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
33/52
33
political parties. Women wanted freedom from traditional constraints,79 and as it is typical for
all the post-socialist countries in order to respond to their particular needs, organizations from
and for women emerge.
80
Albanian women acted in the same way, so in 1992 in Tetovo they
formed the Union of Albanian Women with one goal, emancipation and education of the
Albanian women. We went from village to village, from mosque to mosque informing fathers
and parents about the importance of education. We provided financial support for girls from the
mountain villages to continue their education in secondary school.81
Often the women part of the Union provided material means from their own savings in order to
achieve their goals. With the support of international organizations, the Union worked well for
several years cooperating with organizations from Albania, Kosovo and Macedonia. However,
after several years womens urge for political involvement was greater than the goals that they
were slowly achieving, so the Union stopped with its activism . Several womens organizations
came out of it and one of them, The Forum of Women is still working very successfully.
However, although women went back to the political parties they were unable to mobilize
effectively in order to push political parties to deal with the issue of womens representation in
political institutions.82
Finally, the courage to act in formal political arenas paid off. It was this
specific event that encouraged Albanian women to get involved in politics even more. Teuta
Arifis election as the first Albanian woman in the Macedonia parliament is a historic moment
for the Albanian women and it was characterized as such by all of my respondents no matter
which political party they came from.
79 Dimova, p. 312.80Gender and Identity in Central and Eastern Europe ed. by Chris Corrin, p. 30.81 Z. H. interview with the author 13.07.201182Richard E. Matland, Womens Representation in Post- Communist Europe in Womens Access to PoliticalPower, ed by. Matland and Montgomery, pp.321-342 (p. 324).
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
34/52
34
Finally, after 10 years of plural democracy there has been recognition among the political parties
that it is essential for their credibility to preselect and elect women in political institutions.83
Two
issues appear as vital when it comes to womens political involvement. First of all, all of the
Albanian political parties on local and national level adopted a strategy of creating Womens
Forum within the party that will deal with questions important for women. However, local
Albanian female politicians have mixed feelings about the Womens Forum. On one hand , it is
an arena where they can deal with issues that concern women only, but on the other hand, their
involvement in the decision-making process about issues that concern the economy or the
healthcare, or any other issue has been limited. This allows for a space for womens activities
not to be viewed as political precisely because they are womens activities and women are not
defined as political actors.84Again, although women are present in the public sphere, a private
is created within the public, and the traditional values that still persist one more time try to
prove that the public is a male-dominated arena and the women have nothing to do there.
Sometimes we feel like puppets, we are told what to do and when to do it.
85
The second thing that allowed women to be politically represented and engaged is the quotas for
the underrepresented sex that is the women. Quotas have resulted in political parties paying
more attention to their women members. Even women from rural areas are being listed as
candidates.86 Moreover, the establishment of the Commission for Equal Opportunities among
men and women in 2004 has also had positive effect towards reaching gender balance. When
talking to the former president of the commission in Tetovo, she explained that it started as a
83 Paxton and Kunovich, p. 90.84 Dubisch, p.24.85 R.C. interview with the author86Daniela Dimitrievska, Quotas: The Case of Macedonia, p.4.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
35/52
35
pilot project supported by OSCE, but later on, it became an integral part of the Municipality of
Tetovo and it functions as any other commission. The issues that they work with are violence
against women, healthcare for women, family planning etc. However, their main project is
gender balanced budget for the municipality of Tetovo.87
Listening to the stories of my respondents explaining how they got involved in the public sphere
and politics one thing was rather surprising. Although they do get the full support from their
families to be politically active, their husbands are always involved in politics too. The women
might have a lower position within the party or the institutions than their husbands, but still the
husbands are always present. In this sense, it becomes even more difficult to explain the
public/private dichotomy. However, it is certain that no matter if alone or together with their
husbands, the Albanian women are present in the public.
3.3.2 Education and Employment
Education is the primary factor for the progress of the Albanian women, their entrance into the
public and the political sphere. Ethnic Albanian leaders see education as one of the keys to
improving their communitys status.88Dimovas research shows that Albanians view education
as principal mechanism for changing their social status by transforming their current backward
and traditional mentality. Socialism provided mandatory primary education in Albanian
language. However, secondary school and higher education were optional. Moreover, education
in Albanian language was not always the option.
87 E.M. interview with the author 20.07.2011
88Macedonias Ethnic Albanians: Bridging the Gulf; p. 18.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
36/52
36
With the change of the system the achievements in terms of education were changing slowly but
firmly. During 1990s the Albanian students received eight-grade primary education in their
mother tongue. In 1998 14% of them received high school education in Albanian and in terms of
education there was a quota system that allowed 16% of the students from the minorities to enter
university in 1998.89
After 2001 secondary education is fully available in Albanian language.
Moreover, since 2007 secondary education is mandatory for every citizen of Republic of
Macedonia and it is free of charge. This is yet another contribution towards proper education of
the Albanian girls and possibility for prospects in terms of employment.
However, the Albanian community and especially the Albanian women, with the Union of
Albanian Women being among them, were strong supporters of establishing a state university in
Albanian language that will give opportunities for the Albanian men and women to pursue
education in spheres other than school teachers. The struggle was long and followed by many
controversies. Between 1994 and 2004 the illegally established Tetovo University provided
parallel education in Albanian language.90
Apart from its illegality and contested quality of
education it did provide the Albanian young women with the necessary tool for their
emancipation, presence in the public sphere, opportunities for employment and possibilities for
political participation. The first official step in terms of higher education in Albanian language
was the establishment of the South-East European University in Tetovo in 2001. The university
provided education in three languages, namely Albanian, Macedonian and English with the
89 Poulton, p. 185.90 Zeqirija Rexhepi, Optestveno-politikite nastani kaj Albancite vo Makedonija 1990-2001, pp.114-115
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
37/52
37
majority of students being Albanian.91
It was considered a great accomplishment for the
Albanian community because it provided higher education in their mother tongue.92
Moreover,
the university in cooperation with the Dutch Embassy granted scholarships for young women in
order to motivate them to continue their schooling. The Tetovo University finally became part of
the state system in 2004. So the language barrier was removed at last and new horizons for
Albanian women in Tetovo were open. There was no more space for challenging the right of the
girls to liberate themselves from the traditional role imposed on them in the socialist period.
Albanian women from Tetovo were finally able to be present and seen in the public, outside of
their home, pursuing education which will eventually lead towards their presence in the
workforces and ultimately in politics and policy-making.
Education should decrease traditional gender attitudes for both women and men because it leads
to greater opportunities, and exposes individuals to diverse ideas.93 Moreover, education
provides resources for the Albanian women in Tetovo to get employed in different areas. Young
Albanian women study different subjects, thus their opportunities are much more open. Besides,
they do pursue education abroad as well, that brings a whole new set of prospects.
My respondents apart from education are employed in the spheres of law, medicine and
economics. Indeed, it was education that encouraged Albanian women to challenge the
traditional family and value patterns and move out of what was anticipated as their comfort zone
that is their household and family. However, their true visibility in the public is through presence
in the workforce and the political institutions. As one of my respondents noticed, the problem of
91Frosina Taevska, Remenski,Albancite i Makedoncite: etnikata interakcija vo Republika Makedonija, pred i pokonfliktot od 2001 godina,p. 312.92 Rexhepi, p.120.93 Kunovich , p. 1095.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
38/52
38
educating the Albanian women in their mother tongue is solved with the mandatory secondary
education and the two universities in Tetovo. The next step is career development.94 However,
the high level of unemployment in Macedonia affects not only Albanian women, but all of the
population and it is a problem yet to be solved.
3.3.3 Traditions and Religion
In a society where roles, responsibilities and aptitudes are commonly regarded as divided into
rather strict male and female categories, individuals may find it difficult to cross that divide even
where it runs counter personal preferences or individual circumstances.95 Although the
traditional roles and values among Albanian families in Tetovo are not completely erased, there
is a huge change when it comes to the traditional mentality. The social transformation, the
exposure to education, media and the new political system did affect the attitudes towards the
role of women. The family unit is still a very important role model for the future generations.96
The parents, knowing what they went through during the socialist period want to improve the
status of their children in the society and thus, though self-consciously, they change the
traditional beliefs and values.
When the woman is at home, she is not informed, she does not know how to use contraceptives
and she is not able to plan her family.97 However, the period of the high birth rate among
Albanian women is over. The extended households turn into nuclear families. If the families
94 Gj.B. interview with the author 16.07.201195Rebecca Kay, Experiences of Fatherhood in Contemporary Russia in Gender, Equality and Difference duringand after State Socialism ed. by Rebecca Kay, pp.125-145 (p.126).96Olga Tth, No Envy No Pity, in Gender Politics and Post-communism ed. Funk and Mueller, pp.213-222 (p.215).97 Z.H. interview with the autor 13.07.2011
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
39/52
39
once influenced the women to stay in the private, today they encourage them to be active in the
public. Moreover, the higher the level of education among Albanian women, the lower the
number of children they have.
98
The religious influence has changed as well. With the translation of the Quran the hodza does not
have the power in his hands. Men and women can educate and inform themselves. Now they
know that the Quran treats men and women equally and that education should be accessible for
everyone. Women practice religion, yet decide to be unveiled. Some more religious young
women decide to wear the veil, however, what is different is that most of the time this is their
own decision, and although covered, they can still be university educated. Moreover, with the
presence of the religion in the public, the hodzas also have more modern approach towards
religion and their interpretation of the role of women in the society has also changed.
3.3.4 Media
During socialism there was a media silence in terms of issues important for the Albanian
community and Albanian women. There were few hours of TV and radio programs in Albanian
and one newspaper, Flaka e Vlazrimit. However, with women being uneducated and many of
them illiterate, the medias influence would have been insignificant anyway. The absence of
media contributed towards maintaining the isolation of the Albanian women in the private.
However, the possibility for opening private media in the new system was a great opportunity
not only for diversity of the media in general, but for media with full content in Albanian
language. In this sense, the media became an important factor that can influence womens
98 Bogoev, p. 133.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
40/52
40
presence in the public sphere, although a respondent involved in the womens NGO sector said
that womens issues are not very interesting for the media and often they do not want to waste
their time.
99
3.3.5 Albanian Immigration
Albanians from Tetovo that went to work abroad after the Second World War have also had
influence in the emancipation of the Albanian women. Namely, the first generation that went
there was mainly uneducated and worked in construction or other manual labour. However, the
second and the third generation are now educated in the Western system and they influence their
relatives in Tetovo and encourage them to send their daughters to school. So, apart from
improving their economic situation, working abroad provided higher standard of living and
positive influence in terms of culture and education.100
People that worked abroad were more
likely to send their children to school and enable them to continue their education after the
mandatory secondary school. Although initially in creating my research I did not realize the
importance of the Albanian immigration as a factor that can contribute positively towards
womens development, in fact, many of my respondents pointed it out as an important aspect.
99 Xh. K. interview with the author 11.07.2011100 Trifunoski, p.178.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
41/52
41
4. ConclusionIn summary, this localized gender analysis of socialism/post-socialism gives possibilities for new
reflections on the public/private dichotomy. It does not only provide discussion of how women
experience socialism and post-socialism, but also how women from particular nationality in a
particular area experience an ideology and political system differently than others because of
specific social, economic and political conditions. Instead of making general assumptions, by
focusing on a particular community of women, I tried to challenge the attempt to universalize the
understanding of the public/private divide and show that there cannot be firm division between
the two spheres. Using this model provided a way of linking the cultural variations given to the
category woman to the organization of womens activities in a society.101
Moreover, what I demonstrated is that one understanding of the model may be particular for one
time period, and a different one might be typical for another. Albanian women in Tetovo did
follow the traditional divide before and during socialism. However, the change of the system
changed the traditional dichotomy. Albanian women indeed went from private to public in the
post-socialist period. In order to provide further analysis I looked into the factors that affected
this change. The political system, the education and the traditional family were the ones that kept
the women in the private, but they also let her out of it. Also, even during socialism, Albanian
women did not exclusively serve as housewives and mothers. Very few of them did have the
means and the courage to start redefining their traditional role and create space for further social
transformation.
101Moore Henrietta L. Moore, Feminism and Anthropology, p. 21.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
42/52
42
In the dawn of the changes, with the creation of the pluralist system,[i]n the 1990, the major
political parties only mentioned women in the context of family relations.102 In addition, not
only the state and the political parties, but also the ideological apparatus, the media, the
educational system, religion and family work[ed] together to reinforce and reproduce dominant
ideologies. However, there is a difference between the dominant ideology for Albanian women
in Tetovo during socialism, in the early post-socialist period and today. If tradition and the
private were features of the earlier, then it is education and participation that are features of the
latter.
Not having equal access to education and paid labour, it took Albanian women longer to enter
the sphere of politics. However, every group of women experiences a period where its
development is more prominent and its chances for success are higher. Now it is that period for
Albanian women in Tetovo and in Macedonia.103
Today there are six Albanian women in the Macedonian Parliament and nine Albanian women in
the Assembly of the Municipality of Tetovo. Through their participation in the paid labour,
NGOs and political parties, Albanian women in Tetovo made it clear that they cannot be kept in
isolation and that without their participation in the public life, local and national institutions the
country as a whole would not develop in the right direction. Further democratization of the
system, and the political parties, as well as higher participation and representation of women in
dominant positions will contribute towards emphasizing the qualities that women can bring to
the table. The Albanian women are in the public, but now it is the time to show what their
102Ristova, Karolina,Estabishing a Machocracy: Women and Elections in Macedonia (1990-1998) in WomensAccess to Political Power in Post-communist Europe, ed by. Matland and Montgomery pp.196-216 (p. 203).103 Z.H. interview with the author 13.07.2011
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
43/52
43
contribution to the well-being of the society can be. It seems to me that they might prove the
popular saying: The hand that rocks the cradle is the hand that rules the world.
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
44/52
44
Bibliography
(i) Babuna, Aydin, The Albanians of Kosovo and Macedonia: Ethnic Identity SupersedingReligion,Nationalities Papers 28 (2000) 67-92
(ii) Barany, Zoltan and Robert G. Moser, eds.,Ethnic Politics after Communism (Ithaca,London: Cornell University Press, 2005)
(iii) Bogoev, Ksente, ed.,Problemi so demografskiot razvoj vo SR Makedonija (Skopje:Makedonska Akademija na Naukite i Umetnostite, 1985)
(iv) Brunnbauer, Ulf, Fertility, Families and Ethnic Conflict: Macedonians and Albanians inthe Republic of Macedonia, 1944-2002,Nationalities Papers 32 (2004) 565-598
(v) Corrin, Chris, ed., Gender and Identity in Central and Eastern Europe (London: FrankCass, 1999)
(vi) Corrin, Chris., Superwomen and the Double Burden: Womens Experience of Change inCentral and Eastern Europe and the Former Soviet Union (London: Scarlet, 1992)
(vii) Davidoff, Leonore, Regarding Some Old Husbands Tales: Public and Private inFeminist Theory, inFeminism, the Public and the Private ed. by Joan B. Landes
(Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1998), pp.164-194 .
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
45/52
45
(viii) Denich, Bette, Sex and Power in the Balkans, in Woman, Culture and Society ed. byMichelle Zimbalist Rosaldo and Louse Lamphere (Stanford, CA: Stanford University
Press, 1974), pp.243-262.
(ix) Dimitrievska, Daniela, Quotas: The Case of Macedonia paper presented at TheImplementation of Quotas: European Experiences, International Institute for
Democracy and Electoral Assistance (IDEA)/CEE Network for Gender Issues
Conference Budapest, Hungary, 22-23 October 2004
(x) Dimova, Rozita, Modern Masculinities: Ethnicity, Education and Gender inMacedonia,Nationalities Papers 34 (2006) 305-320
(xi) Dubisch, Jill., Gender and Power in Rural Greece (Princeton, NJ: Princeton UniversityPress, 1986)
(xii) Fawzi, El-Sohl Camillia and Judy Mabro, eds.,Muslim Women's Choices: ReligiousBelief and Social Reality (Providence, RI: Berg, 1994)
(xiii) Funk, Nanette and Magda Mueller, eds., Gender Politics and Post-communism:Reflections from Eastern Europe and the Former Soviet Union (London: Routlegde,
1993)
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
46/52
46
(xiv) Gal, Susan and Gail Kligman, Politics of Gender after Socialism (Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press, 2000)
(xv) Gohrisch, Jana, Daphne Hahn, Gabriele Jhnert, Hildegard Maria Nickel, Iris Peinl andKatrin Schfgen, Gender in Transition in Gender and Transition in Eastern and Central
Europe Proceedings ed. By Gabriele Jhnert, Jana Gohrisch, Daphne Hahn, Hildegard
Maria Nickel, Iris Peinl and Katrin Schfgen (Berlin: Trafo-Verl.Weist, 2001), pp.11-20
(xvi) Hughes, Melanie M. Armed Conflict, International Linkages, and WomensParticipation in Developing Nations, Social Problems 56 (2009) 174-204
(xvii) Johnson, Janet Elise and Jean C. Robinson, Living Gender, inLiving Gender afterCommunism ed. by Janet Elise Johnson and Jean C. Robinson (Bloomington: Indiana
University Press, 2007), pp.1-21
(xviii) Kay, Rebecca, Experiences of Fatherhood in Contemporary Russia, in Gender, Equalityand Difference during and after State Socialism ed. by Rebecca Kay (Basingstoke:
Palgrave Macmillan, 2007), pp. 125-145
(xix) Kiczkova Zuzana, Why Do We Need Feminist Theories, in Gender and Transition inEastern and Central Europe Proceedings ed. By Gabriele Jhnert, Jana Gohrisch,
Daphne Hahn, Hildegard Maria Nickel, Iris Peinl and Katrin Schfgen (Berlin: Trafo-
Verl.Weist, 2001), pp. 124-132
-
7/28/2019 Post-socialism: From Private to Public Albanian Women in Tetovo, Macedonia
47/52
47
(xx) Kunovich, Robert M., Ethnic Conflict, Group Polarization, and Gender Attitudes inCroatia,Journal of Marriage and the Family, 66 (2004), 1089-1107
(xxi) Landes, Joan B., ed.,Feminism, the Public and the Priv