Population and management assessment of the black-footed ...

8
Low Ecological Services P/L PO Box 3130, Alice Springs, NT 0871 Ph: (08) 89 555 222 Fax: (08) 89 555 722 Email: [email protected] Web: www.lowecol.com.au Population and management assessment of the black-footed tree-rat for the Jabiru power station development March 2021 Prepared for CDM Smith Australia Pty Ltd Environment, Planning and Economics Level 1, 48-50 Smith Street, Darwin NT 0800 Prepared by Low Ecological Services P/L March 2021

Transcript of Population and management assessment of the black-footed ...

Page 1: Population and management assessment of the black-footed ...

Low Ecological Services P/L

PO Box 3130, Alice Springs, NT 0871

Ph: (08) 89 555 222 Fax: (08) 89 555 722

Email: [email protected] Web: www.lowecol.com.au

Population and management assessment of the black-footed tree-rat for the Jabiru

power station development March 2021

Prepared for CDM Smith Australia Pty Ltd Environment, Planning and Economics

Level 1, 48-50 Smith Street, Darwin NT 0800

Prepared by Low Ecological Services P/L

March 2021

Page 2: Population and management assessment of the black-footed ...

Low Ecological Services P/L

Jabiru BFTR survey and management report March 2021 i

DOCUMENT CONTROL

Disclaimer

This document has been prepared by Low Ecological Services P/L for CDM Smith Australia Pty Ltd, on

behalf of the Northern Territory Government (NTG) Department of the Chief Minister and Cabinet.

Low Ecological Services has prepared this document using the skill and care expected from

professional scientists to provide factual and technical information and reasonable solutions to

identified risks. It does not constitute legal advice.

Acknowledgements

Low Ecological Services acknowledges the assistance of Tony Griffiths and the Flora and Fauna

Division, NTG Department of Environment, Parks and Water Security, for providing the survey design

and protocol, expertise and advice, equipment, and field supervision. We also acknowledge the

Djurrubu Rangers for providing logistical and technical information, and assistance on site. Justin Bott

from Connect Environmental assisted in the field and provided useful background information about

previous surveys of the site in 2020. Celeste Lymn from the Department of Agriculture, Water and

Environment helped with permits and assisted on site. Low Ecological Services staff involved in the

field work: Kate Stevens, Joe Rosewarne, Mac Moyses, Claire Treilibs, Xavier Tingle and Nicola

Hanrahan. This report was prepared by Claire Treilibs and reviewed by Bill Low.

Document Details

Name of Document: Population and management assessment of the black footed tree-rat for the Jabiru power station development

Authors: Claire Treilibs

Client: CDM Smith Australia Pty Ltd

Name of Project: Jabiru Lot 2303 black-footed tree-rat survey

Document Control

Approvals Name Signature Date

Originator: Low Ecological Services P/L 24/3/21

Reviewer: Bill Low 24/3/21

Administrator: CDM Smith Australia Pty Ltd

Approver: CDM Smith Australia Pty Ltd

Custodian: CDM Smith Australia Pty Ltd

Page 3: Population and management assessment of the black-footed ...

Low Ecological Services P/L

Jabiru BFTR survey and management report March 2021 ii

Table of Contents

Document control .................................................................................................................................... i

Executive summary ................................................................................................................................ iii

1 Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 1

1.1 Context .................................................................................................................................... 1

1.2 Scope of survey ....................................................................................................................... 1

2 Method ........................................................................................................................................... 1

2.1 Survey design .......................................................................................................................... 1

2.2 Data analysis ........................................................................................................................... 2

3 Results and discussion .................................................................................................................... 3

4 Conclusion and recommendations ................................................................................................. 4

5 References ...................................................................................................................................... 4

Page 4: Population and management assessment of the black-footed ...

Low Ecological Services P/L

Jabiru BFTR survey and management report March 2021 iii

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Low Ecological Services was commissioned by CDM Smith Australia Pty Ltd to undertake a population

survey of the threatened black-footed tree-rat, Mesembriomys gouldii, at the site of the proposed Jabiru

hybrid power station (Lot 2303, Jabiru). In September 2020, the black-footed tree-rat was detected at

14 of 20 camera traps within Lot 2303, but these data could not be used to determine the number of

individuals. Feasibly, the number could range from a single active and broad-ranging individual to many

animals. This current survey aimed to accurately determine the number of individual tree-rats within Lot

2303 as well as adjacent similar habitat, and test the extent of movement of individuals into and out of

the lot.

To ensure appropriate survey design and techniques, the Flora and Fauna Division of the NT

Department of Environment, Parks and Water Security were consulted throughout the survey. The

Division provided the survey design and supervised the field program. One hundred and ninety-one

traps were set for five nights (191 x 5 = 955 trap nights) within the vegetated area of Lot 2303 and the

surrounding woodland. No black-footed tree-rats were trapped. Northern brown bandicoots, Isoodon

macrourus, were captured eight times; seven within Lot 2303 and one outside, with at least one

identifiable re-capture.

Given the substantial trapping effort, and the highly trap-able nature of tree-rats, expert opinion is that

the zero tree-rat result is a true absence of the species from Lot 2303 and surrounds. The tree-rats that

were detected in Lot 2303 in September 2020 (late dry season) now appear to be absent from the site.

One explanation is that the tree-rats have dispersed to surrounding areas that have now become more

suitable during the above average wet season conditions, for example with fruiting trees, ground cover

and hollow-bearing logs.

While the trapping data show no current resident population of black-footed tree-rats, the habitat within

Lot 2303 is in good condition and supports a population of northern brown bandicoot among other

fauna. We recommend spotters be used to check for animals ahead of the machinery when the

vegetation is cleared. The Djurrubu rangers would be well placed to take on this spotter role. Certain

staff members of the Djurrubu Rangers also have the skills to care for injured animals and are keen to

assist. We also recommend that the bottom of the boundary fence of Lot 2303 be lifted or folded along

the entire perimeter to allow fleeing animals to escape. We recommend vegetation be cleared

incrementally over a few days so that animals have an opportunity to relocate between clearing efforts,

and that the project area is cleared from west to east, in the direction away from the rubbish tip, so that

animals might move toward more intact habitat.

Page 5: Population and management assessment of the black-footed ...

Low Ecological Services P/L

Jabiru BFTR survey and management report March 2021 1

1 INTRODUCTION

Low Ecological Services was commissioned by CDM Smith Australia Pty Ltd to undertake a population

density survey of the threatened black-footed tree-rat, Mesembriomys gouldii, at the site of the proposed

Jabiru hybrid power station (Lot 2303, Jabiru). The black-footed tree-rat had recently been detected

within Lot 2303, and there is a risk that clearing of the vegetation for the power station development

could significantly impact a population of this threatened species. The findings from this population

survey will help to assess management options for the black-footed tree-rat.

The black-footed tree-rat is currently listed in Northern Territory and National legislation as Vulnerable

(NT Territory Parks and Wildlife Conservation Act) and Endangered (Environmental Protection and

Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999). Across northern Australia and Kakadu National Park, the species

has undergone a rapid and severe decline in recent decades along with a suite of other medium-sized

mammal species (Woinarski et al 2011).

1.1 Context

A survey using camera traps within Lot 2303 in September 2020 detected black-footed tree-rat at 14 of

20 camera locations (Connect Environmental 2021). This finding, combined with an absence of tree

rats from all but one of 35 camera traps locations in the broader Jabiru area sampled in

November/December 2020 (Connect Environmental 2021), suggested that Lot 2303 may provide

important habitat for a local subpopulation of this species.

However, the data from the September 2020 sample cannot be used to determine the number of

individuals using the habitat within Lot 2303. Feasibly, the number could range from a single active and

broad-ranging individual to many animals. This current study aimed to accurately determine the number

of individual tree-rats within Lot 2303 as well as adjacent similar habitat, and test the extent of movement

of individuals into and out of the lot.

Mammologists from the NTG Darwin Flora and Fauna division, Department of Environment, Parks and

Water Security, advised that live trapping was the most suitable technique for estimating the population

size and spatial use of tree-rats, and provided a survey design and trapping protocol to assess the

population. Data from captured and re-captured animals (marked using PIT tags) over sequential nights

could then be used to provide a robust estimate of population size. The movement of individual animals

would also help determine tree-rat habitat use within and adjacent to the project area, and appropriate

management options.

1.2 Scope of survey

The scope of this survey was to:

1. Determine the population size and spatial use of black-footed tree-rats within and adjacent to

Lot 2303, the development area for the Jabiru hybrid power station.

2. Assess management options for the black-footed tree-rat population occupying the

development area.

2 METHOD

2.1 Survey design

A trapping grid was designed to overlay the vegetated portion within Lot 2303 (n = 66) and a 200 m

buffer in the adjacent woodland (n = 150), with traps positioned 50 m apart (Figure 1). However,

difficulties laying traps in inundated areas on the western side, and hazardous areas around the landfill

Page 6: Population and management assessment of the black-footed ...

Low Ecological Services P/L

Jabiru BFTR survey and management report March 2021 2

sites, resulted in a decision to remove the ‘rubbish tip block’ of 25 traps from the survey after the first

night (see Figure 1). The remaining 191 traps were set for five nights to ensure the recapture rates

would be sufficient for population estimates (191 x 5 = 955 trap nights).

Figure 1 Trapping grid over Lot 2303 and adjacent woodland

Small cage traps were baited with a mixture of peanut butter, oats and honey. Traps were baited and

set in the late afternoon and cleared at first light each morning. All traps were cleared by 8:30 am each

day to reduce heat stress on animals and were closed during the day to avoid animals entering the

traps. Traps were uniquely coded so that movement of uniquely identified individual animals could be

tracked.

Upon capture of a trapped tree-rat, LES staff were instructed in the Flora and Fauna Division protocol;

tree-rats would be processed immediately at each trap location, and each animal weighed (g), sexed

and a unique Passive Implant Transponder (PIT tag) inserted with a sterile applicator beneath the skin

on the back of the neck, and the details recorded with date, time and trap location. Once processed,

each animal would be released at the point of capture. Where trapped animals are recaptures, the PIT

tag ID and trap location would be recorded with a hand held reader and the animal released at the site

of capture. Data would be recorded to a suitable proforma and subsequently transferred to Excel in a

format that could be easily manipulated for analysis. If species other than black-footed tree-rat were

captured, the date, identity and location would be recorded. If other threatened mammal species were

captured, it was recommended that these were also PIT-tagged, providing this could be done within the

time available and permit conditions allowing. If unexpected adverse events occur, the protocol

described in the AEC permit approval were to be enacted.

2.2 Data analysis

Experienced members of the Flora and Fauna Division planned to use a closed capture-mark-recapture

population model to estimate population size. Capture data would have been summarised to create a

1T1S1R1Q1P1O1N1M1L1K1J1I1H1G1F1E1D1C1B1A

2T2S2R2Q2P2O2N2M2L2K2J2I2H2G2F2E2D2C2B2A

3T3S3R3Q3P3O3N3M3L3K3J3I3H3G3F3E3D3C3B3A

4T4S4R4Q4P4O4N4M4L4K4J4I4H4G4F4E4D4C4B4A

5T5S5R5Q5P5O5N5M5L5K5J5I5H5G5F5E5D5C5B5A

6T6S6R6Q6P6O6N6M6L6K6J6I6H6G6F6E6D6C6B6A

7T7S7R7Q7P7O7N7M7L7K7J7I7H7G7F7E7D7C7B7A

8T8S8R8Q8P8O8N8M8L8K8J8I8H8G8F8E8D8C8B8A

9T9S9R9Q9P9O9N9M9L9K9J9I9H9G9F9E9D9C9B9A

10T10S10R10Q10P10O10N10M10L10K10J10I10H10G10F10E10D10C10B10A

11T11S11R11Q

12T12S12R12Q

13T13S13R13Q

14T14S14R14Q

Source: Esri, Maxar, GeoEye, Earthstar Geographics, CNES/Airbus DS, USDA, USGS, AeroGRID, IGN,

and the GIS User Community

266800

266800

267200

267200

267600

267600

86

00

000

86

00

000

86

00

400

86

00

400

Low Ecological Services P/LPhone: (08) 89555 222

Web: [email protected]

Universal Transverse Mercator (UTM)

Map Grid of Australia (MGA) Zone 53

Horizontal Datum: GDA 1994

Vertical Datum: AHD (m)

Black-footed tree-ratpopulation survey

Trap grid designLow Ecological Services P/L 2021

0 50 100 150 200 250 Metres

¯

traps not set in inundated areas

traps set for one night then removed

traps set for five nights

Fence

Lot 2303Rubbish tip block

Page 7: Population and management assessment of the black-footed ...

Low Ecological Services P/L

Jabiru BFTR survey and management report March 2021 3

capture history of each individual over the five trap nights. Data would have been analysed in Program

MARK v9.0 to estimate capture probability (p) and the recapture probability (c) to estimate population

size (N).

3 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

No black-footed tree-rats were trapped over the 955 trap nights. Northern brown bandicoot, Isoodon

macrourus, were trapped in eight instances (examples Figure 2); seven within Lot 2303 and one outside

(trap 5A, see Figure 2). At least one bandicoot was re-captured, identified as the same individual from

an old eye injury and a missing tail, at traps 7N and 8N.

Figure 2 Examples of northern brown bandicoots captured at 7I (left) and 8N (right)

Figure 3 Trap locations of captured northern brown bandicoots in Lot 2303 and adjacent woodland

1T1S1R1Q1P1O1N1M1L1K1J1I1H1G1F1E1D1C1B1A

2T2S2R2Q2P2O2N2M2L2K2J2I2H2G2F2E2D2C2B2A

3T3S3R3Q3P3O3N3M3L3K3J3I3H3G3F3E3D3C3B3A

4T4S4R4Q4P4O4N4M4L4K4J4I4H4G4F4E4D4C4B4A

5T5S5R5Q5P5O5N5M5L5K5J5I5H5G5F5E5D5C5B5A

6T6S6R6Q6P6O6N6M6L6K6J6I6H6G6F6E6D6C6B6A

7T7S7R7Q7P7O7N7M7L7K7J7I7H7G7F7E7D7C7B7A

8T8S8R8Q8P8O8N8M8L8K8J8I8H8G8F8E8D8C8B8A

9T9S9R9Q9P9O9N9M9L9K9J9I9H9G9F9E9D9C9B9A

10T10S10R10Q10P10O10N10M10L10K10J10I10H10G10F10E10D10C10B10A

11T11S11R11Q

12T12S12R12Q

13T13S13R13Q

14T14S14R14Q

Source: Esri, Maxar, GeoEye, Earthstar Geographics, CNES/Airbus DS, USDA, USGS, AeroGRID, IGN,

and the GIS User Community

266800

266800

267200

267200

267600

267600

86

00

000

86

00

000

86

00

400

86

00

400

Low Ecological Services P/LPhone: (08) 89555 222

Web: [email protected]

Universal Transverse Mercator (UTM)

Map Grid of Australia (MGA) Zone 53

Horizontal Datum: GDA 1994

Vertical Datum: AHD (m)

Black-footed tree-ratpopulation survey

Non-target speciesLow Ecological Services P/L 2021

0 50 100 150 200 250 Metres

¯

traps not set in inundated areas

traps set for one night then removed

traps set for five nights

Fence

trapped_bandicoots_20mbuffer

Lot 2303Rubbish tip block

Page 8: Population and management assessment of the black-footed ...

Low Ecological Services P/L

Jabiru BFTR survey and management report March 2021 4

Given the substantial trapping effort, and the highly trap-able nature of tree-rats, there is a high degree

of confidence that the zero tree-rat result is a true absence of the species from Lot 2303 and surrounds

(T. Griffiths pers. comm. March 2021). The tree-rats detected in Lot 2303 in September 2020 (late dry

season) now appear to be absent from the site. One explanation is that the tree-rats have dispersed to

surrounding areas that have now become more suitable during the above average wet season

conditions, for example with fruiting trees, ground vegetation and hollow-bearing logs.

4 CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS

While the trapping data show no current resident population of black-footed tree-rats, the habitat within

Lot 2303 is in good condition and supports a population of northern brown bandicoot among other

fauna. We strongly recommend spotters be used to check for animals ahead of the machinery when

the vegetation is cleared. The Djurrubu rangers would be well placed to take on this spotter role. Certain

staff members of the Djurrubu Rangers also have the skills to care for injured animals and are keen to

assist (Shay Wrigglesworth has a Wildlife caring permit). We also recommend that the bottom of the

boundary fence of Lot 2303 be lifted or folded along the entire perimeter to allow fleeing animals to

escape. We recommend vegetation be cleared incrementally over a few days so that animals have an

opportunity to relocate between clearing efforts, and that the project area is cleared from west to east,

in the direction away from the rubbish tip, so that animals might move toward more intact habitat.

5 REFERENCES

Connect Environmental. (2021). Biodiversity assessment report, Lot 2302, Jabiru, NT. Darwin.

Woinarski, J.C.Z., Legge, S., Fitzsimons, J.A., Traill, B.J., Burbidge, A.A., Fisher, A., Firth, R.S.C., Gordon, I.J., Griffiths, A.D., Johnson, C.N., McKenzie, N.L., Palmer, C., Radford, I., Rankmore, B., Ritchie, E.G., Ward, S. and Ziembicki, M. (2011), The disappearing mammal fauna of northern Australia: context, cause, and response.

Conservation Letters, 4: 192-201. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1755-263X.2011.00164.x