Political Participation: Election and Electoral Systems

19

description

Political Participation: Election and Electoral Systems

Transcript of Political Participation: Election and Electoral Systems

  • A country cannot be truly democratic until its citizens

    have the opportunity to

    choose their representatives

    through elections that are free

    and fair.U.S. Agency for International Development

    Only when elections are clean and fair, can citizens be real

    masters of their own destiny

    and expect holders of public

    office to act accountably and

    effectivelyBersih 2.0

    originated in the first post-apartheid elections in South Africa in 1994

  • free election

    Every adult

    citizen, with

    the exception

    of minors,

    aliens, insane

    and criminals,

    must have the

    right to vote.

    Every adult citizen

    must have an

    equal opportunity

    to vote and that

    each citizens vote must have the

    same weight as

    every other adult

    citizens.

    Voting must be

    secret.

    Citizens should have full freedom to

    form political parties, to contest in

    elections, and to nominate

    candidates of their choice.

    Candidates must have equal

    opportunities to publicise their names

    and policy positions so that voters

    can understand and choose among

    candidates and policies.

  • fair election

    Elections to be

    held at regular

    intervals within

    prescribed

    time limits.

    At the end of

    elections, votes

    must be counted

    accurately and in

    public and the

    results must be

    published as soon

    as possible.

    Voters to have

    equal access to

    polling places.

    All candidates be given equal

    financial support and equal free time

    on radio and television to make their

    views known to the voters.

    The electoral process to be

    administered and monitored by an

    impartial body composed of electoral

    specialists.

  • organizations to ensure elections to be

    free and fair

  • U.S. Agency of International Development (USAID)

    promoting 10 elements that are essential to fair elections and political processes

    Impartial electoral frameworks Credible electoral administration

    Effective oversight of electoral processesInformed and active citizens

    Representative and competitive multi-party systemsEffective governance by elected leaders and bodies

    Inclusion of women and disadvantaged groupsEffective transfer of political power

    Consensus-building for democratic reformSustainable local engagement

  • BERSIH 2.0The Coalition for Clean and Fair Elections

    Clean the electoral roll Reform postal ballot Use of indelible ink

    Minimum 21 days campaign period Free and fair access to media

    Strengthen public institutions Stop corruption

    Stop dirty politics

  • TYPES OF ELECTION

  • NORMAL

    ELECTION

    REALIGNING/CRITICAL ELECTION

    DEVIATING ELECTION

  • NORMAL ELECTION

    Is where the result expresses the balance of long

    term party loyalties in the electorate as a whole

    It also a presidential election in which the

    majority party continues its controls of

    presidency

    The voters have tended to vote according to

    their party identification & have not been cross

    pressured by short term variable

  • DEVIATING ELECTION

    Is where winning majority party loses the election

    due to short-term factors such as candidate

    appeal.

    short-term forces cause outcome that deviates

    from the current normal vote but without

    changing that normal-vote division

    The shift in voting is only temporary

  • REALIGNING/CRITICAL ELECTION

    The election that cause a significant shift in the

    way voters align themselves that is in who they

    vote for.

    It were also stands for dramatic change in the

    political system.

    In such election, the voters give up their old

    party loyalty & establish new durable party

    identities.

  • Electoral SystemDetermine the number of parties, by forming a

    stable government to represent the entire district by winning a plurality of the votes.

    First Past The Post (FPTP) System pushes interest groups and political factions

    to combine into two big parties.

    The candidate with the largest number of votes wins the seat.

    The party with the most seats forms the government.

  • Easy for the voter to understand, cheap

    and inexpensive

    Links maintained with

    constituencies

    One party usually wins outright and the government is therefore strong

    Parties have a chance to carry

    out their manifesto promises

    It has been proven to work

    effectively

    Advantages

    Parties coming consistently second

    or third are underrepresented

    Winning parties are overrepresented

    Winning governments

    usually only gain 40% of the total

    vote

    Voters in safe seats may not bother to

    vote

    The govt. may have less votes than its

    nearest rival

    Disadvantages

  • Majority Systems

    (The winning candidate achieves more than 50% of the vote)

    The Alternative Vote System (AV)

    Voters rank candidates in order of preference.

    Any candidate with 50%+ votes is elected.

    If no-one gets 50%, votes are redistributed

    This continues until someone wins

  • Supplementary Vote System (SVS) Voters have first and second choice. Candidates with 50%+ of votes are automatically

    elected. If no-one has 50%, all candidates are eliminated

    except for the top two. The votes of losing candidates are redistributed

    to second choices.

    The Second Ballot System Does not win 50% of the vote, a second ballot

    takes place a week or two later. Candidates with the least votes are eliminated.

  • Second or third parties are more

    fairly represented

    If voters do not get their first

    choice, they are quite likely to

    get their second

    MPs represent more members

    of their constituencies

    Constituency links are

    maintained

    Advantages

    Second or third parties can be

    over represented

    AV in particular is complicated for the voters

    Very small parties are not

    represented

    Second ballot system takes a

    long time to produce an

    outright result

    It is more expensive and

    time consuming

    Disadvantages

  • Proportional representation (PR)

    Based on multimember

    districts

    Each district sends several

    representatives to parliament

    Eg. Netherlands & Israel

    Countrys legislature accurately reflects public opinion and party strength

    Advantages

    Doing little to fight party splintering, so that they often lead to multiparty systems

    Disadvantages

  • Thank you